{
"release": "v1",
"generatedAt": "2026-07-27T19:57:08.677Z",
"caseRecordCount": 1283,
"historicalRegisterCount": 9,
"coverageDocument": "/data/COVERAGE.md",
"cases": [
{
"slug": "1959-haiti",
"year": 1959,
"place": "Haiti",
"lat": 18.97,
"lng": -72.29,
"title": "Tonton Macoute — Vodou-linked state terror (Duvalier)",
"tradition": "haitian-vodou",
"type": "state-terror",
"status": "historical-record",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tonton_Macoute",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20260626173756/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tonton_Macoute",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2024) 'Tonton Macoute', Wikipedia. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'The Tonton Macoute (Haitian Creole: Tonton Makout) or simply the Macoute, was a Haitian paramilitary and secret police force created in 1959 by dictator François 'Papa Doc' Duvalier... Duvalier authorized the Tontons Macoutes to commit systematic violence, terrorism, and human rights abuses to suppress political opposition. They were responsible for unknown numbers of murders and rapes in Haiti. The Tontons Macoutes murdered between 30,000 and 60,000 Haitians... The Tonton Macoute were strongly influenced by Vodou tradition and adopted denim uniforms resembling clothing like that of Azaka Medeh, the patron of farmers. They carried and used machetes in symbolic reference to Ogun, a great general in Vodou tradition. Some of the most important members of the Tontons Macoute were Vodou leaders. This religious affiliation gave the Tontons Macoute a kind of unearthly authority in the eyes of the public.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1986-03-07-mn-16184-story.html",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20251221191008/https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1986-03-07-mn-16184-story.html",
"citation": "Williams, D. (1986) 'After Duvalier: Haiti: A Scary Time for Voodoo', Los Angeles Times. Available at: latimes.com (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'Although voodoo practitioners have won some credit for supporting demonstrations against the dictatorship, voodoo is also under attack for its connections with the Duvalier family, particularly the ousted president's father, the late President Francois (Papa Doc) Duvalier. Vigilante campaigns against Duvalier officials and associates have spilled over into assaults on voodoo priests who in one way or another were linked to the regime... Reasons for the attacks vary. Occasionally, ties to the Duvalier government are clear, for some priests doubled as members of the Tontons Macoutes, Duvalier's feared network of armed enforcers and spies. In other cases, the motivation was personal vengeance, often based on belief in the occult power of voodoo to do harm. A northern farmer complained that a sorcerer brought a relative back from the dead and turned him into a zombie doomed to eternal bondage under the priest... Voodoo came to be linked with the repression that characterized [Duvalier's] regime. The first chief of his private militia was a sorcerer from Gonaives. Duvalier once ordered the head of a rival cut off and shipped to the palace, where Duvalier is said to have 'chatted' with the victim's spirit.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.britannica.com/topic/Tonton-Macoute",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Tonton Macoute.”",
"body": "Britannica documents the paramilitary force created under François Duvalier, its use of Vodou-derived imagery and names, and its role in political intimidation, violence, and killings.",
"tier": "reference-work",
"kind": "historical-context"
}
],
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The Duvalier state used Vodou-derived names, imagery, and claimed supernatural menace to reinforce the Tonton Macoute's political intimidation and violence.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-haitian-vodou",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tonton_Macoute",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bc682a1dee017b9a0233eb287e787e3907cd949303db8ff9902ce472aad1d5ef",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tonton_Macoute"
},
{
"source": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1986-03-07-mn-16184-story.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "61b0f7e1522c4fc58110b1bb3283e3fff2d0294eecfc9a563ec2f37ac788a2a5",
"final_url": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1986-03-07-mn-16184-story.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.britannica.com/topic/Tonton-Macoute",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-work; evidentiary role: historical-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "1989-matamoros-mexico",
"year": 1989,
"place": "Matamoros, Mexico",
"lat": 25.88,
"lng": -97.49,
"title": "Constanzo cult ritual killings (Palo Mayombe)",
"tradition": "palo",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolfo_Constanzo",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20260604200430/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolfo_Constanzo",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2024) 'Adolfo Constanzo', Wikipedia. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'Adolfo de Jesús Constanzo (November 1, 1962—May 6, 1989) was a Cuban-American serial killer, drug dealer and cult leader who led an infamous drug-trafficking and occult gang in Matamoros, Tamaulipas, Mexico, that was dubbed the Narcosatanists (Spanish: Los Narcosatánicos) by the media... The cult was involved in multiple ritualistic killings in Matamoros, including the murder of Mark Kilroy, an American student abducted, tortured and killed in the area in 1989... Constanzo was baptized Catholic and served as an altar boy, but also accompanied his mother on trips to Haiti to learn about Vodou... As a teenager, he became apprenticed to a local sorcerer and began to practice a religion called Palo Mayombe, which involves animal sacrifice... Before long, his cult decided that the spirits of the dead that resided in the nganga would be stronger (providing the cult more powerful protection) with live human sacrifices instead of old bones. The resulting killings soon totalled more than twenty victims, whose mutilated bodies were found in and around Mexico City. This process escalated until Constanzo eventually decided that the gang needed the power of a brain from an American student, culminating with the 1989 murder of Mark Kilroy... Constanzo began to believe that his magic, much of which he took from Palo Mayombe, was responsible for the success of the cartels and demanded to become a full business partner with one of the most powerful families he knew, the Calzadas.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.upi.com/Archives/1989/04/14/Suspects-in-cult-slayings-detail-bizarre-religion/8006029569608/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United Press International, “Suspects in cult slayings detail bizarre religion” (Apr. 14, 1989).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting from Matamoros records investigators’ account of the ritual killings, the Palo Mayombe-derived practices claimed by the group, and statements from arrested participants.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "investigation"
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The group framed murder and human sacrifice through practices it described as Palo Mayombe, claiming ritual killing would provide supernatural protection and power.",
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual), not authority-abuse. Companion record to 1994-sara-aldrete-matamoros-sentences-mexico, which states the same reasoning. The victims were abducted outsiders killed for ritual purposes, not adherents under Constanzo's spiritual authority — belief was causally load-bearing but no authority ran to the victims. Previously classed core, which contradicted the companion record; corrected so both records of the same case now agree.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-palo",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolfo_Constanzo",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3b260c6c11e04596bf2068b0a32db578fb38ac4b4c882593f1c7e335bd260d31",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolfo_Constanzo"
},
{
"source": "https://www.upi.com/Archives/1989/04/14/Suspects-in-cult-slayings-detail-bizarre-religion/8006029569608/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7dcb18882801327b9dc43ad0c7428e952f58ff36fdc6dfe8d3f4c19c38bb694b",
"final_url": "https://www.upi.com/Archives/1989/04/14/Suspects-in-cult-slayings-detail-bizarre-religion/8006029569608/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "1999-miami-fl-usa",
"year": 1999,
"place": "Miami, FL, USA",
"lat": 25.78,
"lng": -80.21,
"title": "Fernandez — Santeria babalao in a capital-murder case",
"tradition": "santeria",
"type": "ritual-crime",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1918619/fernandez-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fernandez v. State, 730 So. 2d 277 (Fla. 1999). Available at: courtlistener.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "A Florida Supreme Court capital-murder opinion records a defendant turning to a Santeria priest to try to escape justice after a bank robbery and police killing: 'Prado testified that appellant listened to the television report and then told Prado that he had been involved in the crime and wanted to see a Santeria priest known as a babalao. Prado testified that he took appellant that same day to see Lazaro Hernandez, who was a babalao, and that appellant asked Hernandez to perform a ritual to prevent appellant from being apprehended. Hernandez subsequently informed police as to appellant's statements to him regarding the crime and shared a $100,000 reward with Prado.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The record documents a Santería babalawo and ritual treatment after an unrelated killing. It does not establish that Santería belief or authority materially enabled the homicide, so the case is retained as context.",
"scopeNote": "The ritual treatment followed an unrelated killing; the available record does not establish a spiritual-authority nexus to the homicide.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1918619/fernandez-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1918619/fernandez-v-state/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2001-london-uk",
"year": 2001,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 51.52,
"lng": -0.07,
"title": "'Adam' — child ritual murder, torso in the Thames",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "unresolved",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.whrin.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/526664234.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dols García, A. (2013) NEW ISSUES IN REFUGEE RESEARCH: Voodoo, Witchcraft and Human Trafficking in Europe. Research Paper No. 263. Geneva: United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. Available at: unhcr.org (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'The growing numbers of Africans in Europe has led to the proliferation of marabouts—traditional African priests—offering advice on how to obtain love and money or achieve success in business, get rid of the evil eye or heal diseases. Also, in some African communities children are being accused of practicing witchcraft and voodoo threats have become one of the characteristics of African sex trafficking networks... Ritual oaths ceremonies include body parts from the person on whom the oath is being administered, as well as from one of her relatives, usually her mother or sister. The use of body parts such as fingernails, blood, sweat, teeth and/or pubic hairs 'give the voodoo priest possession of some part of the victim, creating a sense of fear and an unwillingness to speak out.' ... In September 2001 the torso of a five-year-old African boy was discovered floating in river Thames. Further investigation showed that the boy was brought expressly from West Africa to be sacrificed in a witchcraft ritual. The boy was poisoned before his body was mutilated and drained of blood by an expert marabout. According to a report by the Metropolitan Police, children are being trafficked into the UK from Africa and used for human sacrifices. Once in Britain, they are exposed 'to violent and degrading treatments, often involving the forced extraction of their blood to be used for clients demanding blood rituals.''"
},
{
"link": "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/4541603.stm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BBC News (2005) 'Hundreds of children vanishing', BBC News. Available at: news.bbc.co.uk (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'Hundreds of African boys have disappeared from London schools, police investigating the murder of a boy whose torso was left in the Thames have said... Scotland Yard asked London education authorities how many black boys aged four to seven had vanished from school... Between July and September 2001, 300 had disappeared, and police fear thousands may go missing annually... Child welfare experts say the figures hint at the scale of child trafficking, sometimes for labour or benefit fraud... A previous BBC investigation found some African children were being held by their parents' creditors, so they could claim extra benefits... The boy found in the River Thames in September 2001 - called Adam by police - is thought to have been the victim of a ritual killing after being brought to London from Nigeria... Detective Chief Inspector Will O'Reilly said inquiries revealed 300 black boys of a similar age to Adam had not reported back to school in the three months before his death and were 'lost into the system'... Despite an international search, police were able to find only two of them, Mr. O'Reilly said. Most of those questioned said the children had returned to Africa.'"
},
{
"link": "https://web.archive.org/web/20050213035908/http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/02/0210_020510_tv_witchcraft.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Owen, J. (2005) 'London Witchcraft Murder Traced to Africa Child Trade', National Geographic News. Available at: web.archive.org → news.nationalgeographic.com (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'In September 2001 a gruesome discovery was made in London's River Thames. The hideously mutilated torso of a small black boy was found floating through the city. The boy's arms, legs, and head had all been hacked off... So began a stranger-than-fiction detective story that led U.K. investigators into a macabre netherworld of witchcraft and child sacrifice... The autopsy report concluded that Adam's throat had been slit. His body was then deliberately drained of blood... Richard Hoskins, a U.K.-based expert on African religion and voodoo, says the Calabar bean, in combination with the other ingredients in Adam's gut, pointed to the West African country of Nigeria. There, witch doctors are known to use such potions for black magic... The [beans are] ground down and then burnt in a pot. Taken together, this is the final clinching point that proves as near as certain that this was a sacrifice... The special police unit that investigates muti killings in South Africa estimates that there may be as many as a hundred such murders in the country each year... Adam had been earmarked for human sacrifice. To find out why and by whom, murder squad detectives traveled to Nigeria and the city of Benin. They were beginning to close in on Adam's witchcraft killers, thanks to the clues revealed by forensic science.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-58415046",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20251125101530/https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-58415046",
"citation": "Crawford, A. and Smith, T. (2021) 'The torso in the Thames: A 20-year mystery', BBC News. Available at: bbc.com (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'It's the longest unsolved child murder case in the recent history of the Metropolitan Police. Twenty years ago, a young African boy was murdered in a brutal ritual, his head and limbs removed, and his torso dumped in the Thames... Experts agreed that—because Adam's body had been expertly butchered—it had been a ritualistic murder... Some thought it had been one of the rare so-called 'muti' killings found in southern Africa—when a victim's body parts are removed and used by witchdoctors as 'medicine' for a client who wants, for example, to win a business deal or secure good luck... Other experts believed it was more likely a human sacrifice with its origins in a twisted version of Yoruban belief systems from Nigeria. A perverted offering to the goddess Oshun—a deity typically associated with water and fertility...'"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam_(murder_victim)",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20260609234747/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam_(murder_victim)",
"citation": "Adam (murder victim) (2024) Wikipedia. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'Adam' was the name police gave to an unidentified male child whose torso was discovered in the River Thames in London, United Kingdom, on 21 September 2001. Investigators believe the child was likely from southwestern Nigeria, and that several days before his murder, he was trafficked to the United Kingdom for a ritual sacrifice... Dubbed 'Adam' by police officers, the unidentified remains belonged to a black male, around four to eight years old, who had been wearing orange girls' shorts. The post-mortem showed that Adam had been poisoned, his throat had been slit to drain the blood from his body, and his head and limbs had been expertly removed. Further forensic testing examined his stomach contents and trace minerals in his bones to establish that Adam had only been in the United Kingdom for a few days or weeks before he was murdered, and that he likely came from a region of southwestern Nigeria near Benin City... Some investigators suspected that Adam was trafficked to Britain for a muti killing, a rare Southern African ritual sacrifice performed by a witch doctor that uses a child's body parts to make medicinal potions called 'muti'."
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_for_body_parts",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Murder for body parts (2024) Wikipedia. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'Mrs Osiagede denied any involvement with the death of the young boy. Asked who killed him, she said a 'group of people'. She added: 'They used him for a ritual in the water.' Claiming the boy was six years old, she said: 'He was a lively boy. A very nice boy, he was also intelligent.' Detailed analysis of a substance in the boy's stomach was identified as a 'black magic' potion. It included tiny clay pellets containing small particles of pure gold, an indication that Adam was the victim of a Muti ritual killing in which it is believed that the body parts of children are sacred. Bodies are often disposed of in flowing water.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Investigators concluded that the unidentified child known as Adam had been trafficked to Britain and killed in a ritual sacrifice involving a practitioner presented as a marabout.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "mixed-legacy-sources",
"route": {
"from": [
5.6037,
6.335
],
"to": [
-0.07,
51.52
],
"fromLabel": "Benin City, Nigeria (forensic-estimated origin)",
"toLabel": "London, UK",
"label": "'Adam': Nigeria -> London",
"provenance": "Origin is not a confirmed departure point but a forensic best-estimate: post-mortem stomach-content and trace-mineral analysis, corroborated by a Sky/Nat Geo investigation in which Metropolitan Police detectives traveled to Nigeria and the city of Benin, placed Adam's origin in 'a region of southwestern Nigeria near Benin City.' The BBC's contemporaneous reporting states he was 'brought to London from Nigeria' days before his September 2001 murder. Destination is the corpus record's own gazetteer point (London). Origin coordinates reuse the corpus's existing Benin City point from 2018-benin-city-nigeria for consistency; that stored point (lat 5.62, lng 5.62) is coastal Niger Delta, not the city's true inland location (~6.34N, 5.60E) — flagged, not corrected, to keep this patch limited to adding routes."
},
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.whrin.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/526664234.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bbb91a82f1b4d42546dee2ac3843c9878805159d0102aa035753a369a4793fdc",
"final_url": "https://www.whrin.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/526664234.pdf"
},
{
"source": "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/4541603.stm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "52f23ba4e96c439da08f33b865987de707238795ab1cd8db76023198dbce340d",
"final_url": "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/4541603.stm"
},
{
"source": "https://web.archive.org/web/20050213035908/http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/02/0210_020510_tv_witchcraft.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c7df614d6266bc238326d3c962e8230f13ed0fe8593aa1bb22df450519ce8d9b",
"final_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20050213035908/http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/02/0210_020510_tv_witchcraft.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-58415046",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "643101b2f26923fc0c32e3886456c2c28644d9bb6523bb612bf4744777750c97",
"final_url": "https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-58415046"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam_(murder_victim)",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4b75f671e4bc43861f1d523ba1223b4ddea97a605fb4e44aca1eec6d43ce7ded",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam_(murder_victim)"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_for_body_parts",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "57546e1863bb3ee1d7476b06c8060083fbbe2940c188ce68338e2320ba249474",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_for_body_parts"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2003-london-uk",
"year": 2003,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 52.63,
"lng": -1.15,
"title": "Hackney 'witch-child' torture case",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/london/4607435.stm",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20240306071930/http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/london/4607435.stm",
"citation": "BBC News (2005) 'Witch child cruelty trio guilty', BBC News. Available at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/ uk_news/england/london/4607435.stm (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "Three people have been convicted over the torture of an eight-year-old girl they thought was a witch... The Old Bailey heard the orphan was beaten, cut and had chilli peppers rubbed in her eyes to 'beat the devil out of her', in Hackney, east London... The girl's aunt was found guilty of child cruelty charges while Sita Kisanga and her brother Sebastian Pinto were convicted of aiding and abetting... The cruelty started at the beginning of 2003 when a boy told his mother that the girl had been practising witchcraft. It was an accusation the woman believed... Jurors were told that the child was cut with a knife and beaten with a belt and shoe to 'beat the devil out of her' during her ordeal at a flat in Hackney, east London... During police interviews, the girl said Kisanga had cornered her in the kitchen and told her 'today you die'... The court also heard the girl, now 10, was put into a laundry bag and believed she would be 'thrown away' into a river... Patricia May, prosecuting, said: 'This child was treated as a scapegoat by family members, tormented, subjected to all sorts of assaults which must have caused her considerable pain, fear and distress.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The perpetrators treated a child as a witch and used that accusation to justify prolonged torture presented as punishment or deliverance.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/london/4607435.stm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e5cece70ca32b89984f05fcb112ab7c4a557229d845196c0d6c5d94a1b4c89b6",
"final_url": "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/london/4607435.stm"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2007-newark-nj-usa",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Newark, NJ, USA",
"lat": 40.75,
"lng": -74.16,
"title": "State v. Miraballes — Palo Mayombe grave-robbing",
"tradition": "palo",
"type": "ritual-crime",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1896890/state-v-miraballes/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Miraballes, 392 N.J. Super. 342 (App. Div. 2007). Available at: courtlistener.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "A New Jersey appellate opinion documents a Palo Mayombe grave-robbing conspiracy in which a police detective testified as a court-qualified expert on the religion: 'The gist of the State's case was that defendant conspired with co-defendant Gonzalez, who pled guilty and testified for the prosecution, to steal human remains from several cemeteries in Newark, for use in rituals associated with the non-traditional religion known as Palo Mayombe (Palo), of which defendant was alleged to have been a ‘high priestess.’ ... Shown a photograph of one of the cauldrons found at 22 Bloomfield Avenue, he identified it as an ‘Nganga,’ which ‘is the central focus point of the practice of Palo Mayombe.’... It is very relevant. In Palo Mayombe, you must have, if you can get access to, a whole human structure. It is also believed in Palo that the longer a person has been buried, the more spiritual power that skeleton will have.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record connects the grave robbery to the acquisition of human remains for a Palo Mayombe ritual setting.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-palo",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1896890/state-v-miraballes/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1896890/state-v-miraballes/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2012-canterbury-uk",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Canterbury, UK",
"lat": 50.18,
"lng": 1.08,
"title": "Osolase — juju sex-trafficking conviction (20 yrs)",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/gravesend/news/security-guard-who-made-80k-16724/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KentOnline (2013) 'Security guard who made £80k using juju magic to trick girls into slavery must pay just £8', KentOnline. Available at: kentonline.co.uk (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Osezua Osolase, of Beaumont Drive, was convicted of five counts of trafficking for sexual purposes, raping one of his victims and having sexual activity with a child... The judge said the former guard at a trendy London fashion shop had used juju magic to ensure their obedience and silence... He had terrified the young orphan girls into believing they could die if they ever revealed they were being shipped out to Italy and Spain to work as prostitutes. Osolase, 43, who is serving a 20-year jail sentence has also been given eight weeks to arrange for the bank transfer.'"
},
{
"link": "https://humantraffickingsearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/African-Traditional-Religion-and-Juju-in-Human-Trafficking.pdf",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20251206172827/https://humantraffickingsearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/African-Traditional-Religion-and-Juju-in-Human-Trafficking.pdf",
"citation": "Ikeora, M. (2016) 'The Role of African Traditional Religion and 'Juju' in Human Trafficking: Implications for Anti-trafficking', Journal of International Women's Studies, 17(1), pp. 1-18. Available at: humantraffickingsearch.org (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'Elements within African traditional religion, popularly and often wrongfully termed 'Juju,' proffer a method of control often used by certain traffickers to keep their victims in perpetual bondage. The data used in this article was derived from extensive fieldwork in Nigeria and the United Kingdom (UK) where forty-six (46) anti-trafficking stakeholders, including victims, were interviewed. The data indicates that this control mechanism was present in several cases of human trafficking from Nigeria, serving to impede effective investigations and the prosecution of traffickers... This form of control hinders the protection, prosecution, and prevention of trafficking due to the limited knowledge of law enforcement authorities and relevant anti-trafficking practitioners in dealing with the peculiarities of cases within this particular context... In a recent case occurring in the United Kingdom in 2012, a Nigerian, Osezua Osalase, was convicted in the Canterbury Crown Court in the UK for inter alia trafficking of two young Nigerian orphan girls for sexual exploitation. The victims were raped, sexually abused, and subjected to an oath-taking ritual to control them as victims of trafficking. It was reported that Osalase told the teenage girls that they would die or never bear children if they tried to escape or reveal what had happened to them.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The trafficking scheme used a juju oath and fear of supernatural punishment to enforce obedience and prevent the victim from seeking help.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/gravesend/news/security-guard-who-made-80k-16724/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "761cf91a6f64e710bc6cc64ead7ab3e142d70556bc097aee732c340b0d67d779",
"final_url": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/gravesend/news/security-guard-who-made-80k-16724/"
},
{
"source": "https://humantraffickingsearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/African-Traditional-Religion-and-Juju-in-Human-Trafficking.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d3eecbed8574b71b5e515a93b3c6c1381fa3bb5cb509637e8b195ad72b892e91",
"final_url": "https://humantraffickingsearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/African-Traditional-Religion-and-Juju-in-Human-Trafficking.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2016-benin",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Benin",
"lat": 6.52,
"lng": 2.59,
"title": "Benin 'voodoo convents' — child servitude for ritual debt",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-trafficking-in-persons-report/benin",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States Department of State (2023) 'Benin - United States Department of State', 2023 Trafficking in Persons Report. Available at: state.gov (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'Officials reported that traffickers are increasingly using Voudoun curses as a means to control female Beninese trafficking victims... The government reported traffickers exploit children living in the lakeside areas of Benin—including the commune of So Ava in southeast Benin—in debt bondage. Criminal elements operate in urban areas under the guise of informal employment agents and recruit children for domestic work in private residences, where house managers and families exploit them in domestic servitude... Benin has been the largest source country for trafficking victims in the Republic of the Congo, with the department of Oueme in southeast Benin historically an area traffickers used to recruit child victims.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNtllofAspo",
"archive": "",
"citation": "UK Channel 4 (2008) 'Children sold to pay voodoo debts in Benin | Unreported World', YouTube. Available at: youtube.com (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "From the programme's narration: 'Gin is poured to appease the voodoo spirits. A series of blessings and offerings to the spirits as we enter the area. Here, children are taught voodoo's secrets. We've been invited in to meet the chief trainer and the chief priest, and a stream of these young children just walked in, and some of them look to me to be possibly two, even one years old... UNICEF says every year in Benin 40,000 children are sold into what amounts to little more than slavery, many to pay for voodoo.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/02/africa/benin-voodoo-convents/index.html",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20250925104732/https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/02/africa/benin-voodoo-convents/index.html",
"citation": "Page, T., & Carrington, D. (2016, June 2). 'These children were confined to a voodoo convent'. CNN. https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/02/africa/benin-voodoo-convents (Accessed 14 July 2024).",
"body": "'In Benin, when children fall sick, their parents often turn to voodoo. Now advocates are raising the alarm saying the facilities may harm the children they aim to help... 'Those who practice Voodooism believe that illness is caused by evil spirits. If children fall sick, their parents seek treatment through Voodoo gods. The children allegedly possessed by spirits can be sent or even 'sold' to be healed in Voodoo convents,' notes Hadrien Bonnaud, a communication specialist for UNICEF based in Benin. The ceremonies that are meant to heal these children are expensive: about $1800 (a princely sum for a population that lives on less than $1 per day). In order to afford treatment, UNICEF says some parents sell their children to work in the convents until the debt is paid off (a practice that can take months or even years). 'If they are unable to pay their debts, the children are forcibly taken from them,' explains Bonnaud. ... In some cases a voodoo god will be assigned to a child, and symbolic scars will be carved into the skin. Madeline, 10, another child that Plan International interviewed, recalls the scarification she received as part of her treatment. 'It was very painful and there was so much blood... it was everywhere.' According to the charity, children as young as two years old can be kept in these convents—where access to education and healthcare is minimal.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The documented system placed children in Vodun convents as payment for ritual or family obligations, where religious custody enabled forced labor and servitude.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-trafficking-in-persons-report/benin",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e58c6bcbe067cb12491c2806a9f03cd9877c93ba764bd10762d8b2aaf23b08fa",
"final_url": "https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-trafficking-in-persons-report/benin"
},
{
"source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNtllofAspo",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0bedfc3b9784166c76ee5ba026a52ae8ac82be35a65825c8219d27a6f7ddb36b",
"final_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNtllofAspo"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/02/africa/benin-voodoo-convents/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aaa26690938160b62d17a2ac57d0c15326961aa68ec509a918468b41e9d3ab41",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2016/06/02/africa/benin-voodoo-convents/index.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-benin-city-nigeria",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Benin City, Nigeria",
"lat": 6.335,
"lng": 5.6037,
"title": "Oba of Benin revokes juju trafficking oaths",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "intervention",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iom.int/news/voodoo-curses-keep-victims-trafficking-under-bondage",
"archive": "",
"citation": "International Organization for Migration, “‘Voodoo Curses’ Keep Victims of Trafficking Under Bondage” (2019).",
"body": "IOM documents the trafficking-control role of oath rituals and the Oba of Benin’s 2018 revocation of oaths imposed on trafficking victims.",
"tier": "intergovernmental-record",
"kind": "institutional-action"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Traffickers used juju oaths and threatened supernatural consequences to control victims; the Oba of Benin's public revocation directly targeted that coercive mechanism.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iom.int/news/voodoo-curses-keep-victims-trafficking-under-bondage",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: intergovernmental-record; evidentiary role: institutional-action.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d49f3b83b35133e09db2d86674c68bcdb30ce17e07ca43eed181680b84e998f4",
"final_url": "https://www.iom.int/news/voodoo-curses-keep-victims-trafficking-under-bondage"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-spain",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Spain",
"lat": 38.92,
"lng": -4.97,
"title": "Europol op: 89 arrests, Nigerian juju trafficking ring",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.europol.europa.eu/media-press/newsroom/news/trafficked-voodoo-threats-one-of-largest-operations-in-europe-rescues-39-nigerian-women",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20260411151828/https://www.europol.europa.eu/media-press/newsroom/news/trafficked-voodoo-threats-one-of-largest-operations-in-europe-rescues-39-nigerian-women",
"citation": "Europol (2018) 'Trafficked by voodoo threats: one of the largest operations in Europe rescues 39 Nigerian women', Europol. Available at: europol.europa.eu (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'The Spanish Guardia Civil in collaboration with the National Agency for the Prohibition of Trafficking in Persons (NAPTIP) from Nigeria and the UK's National Crime Agency (NCA), dismantled a Nigerian organised crime group in one of the largest operations against Trafficking in Human Beings in Europe... Victims were transferred from Nigeria to Europe via Libya and Italy. Once in Spain, the women were kept in squalid conditions in cave houses in Almeria, where they were exploited in prostitution to pay off the EUR 30,000 debt they owed to the criminal organisation... The highly active Nigerian criminal network was linked to the EIYE brotherhood, which is known for being one of the most influential confraternities in Nigeria. They operate in clandestine groups all over the world, funding the brotherhood in Nigeria through both licit and illicit activities, in some cases through organised crime and, in particular, trafficking human beings. One of the most important members of the organisation was a well-known DJ in Nigeria, who was arrested when he was returning from his country where he was recording a music video. His main role was to transfer the victims to Spain and organise sexual exploitation in several Spanish provinces... The crime ring transferred and laundered the money using the Hawala system. Police officers carried out 41 house searches in Alicante, Almeria, Barcelona, Cantabria, Madrid, Malaga, Murcia, Navarra, Seville, Toledo and Vizcaya in Spain and Manchester, UK. The bank accounts used by the organisation to launder more than EUR 300,000 from the illicit activity have been blocked. In total the operation resulted in 89 arrests and 39 victims were safeguarded...'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/01/world/nigerian-women-voodoo-threats-spain/index.html",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20240806185815/https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/01/world/nigerian-women-voodoo-threats-spain/index.html",
"citation": "Gigova, R. (2018) 'They faced voodoo death threats and forced prostitution. Now, they're safe, police say', CNN. Available at: cnn.com (Accessed: 29 June 2024).",
"body": "'Sixteen Nigerian women are safe after they were threatened with death and tricked to work as prostitutes in return for passage to Spain, the European Union's law enforcement agency said Thursday. Eleven people were arrested in Zaragoza, Spain, in connection with the trafficking plot, Europol said, adding that their criminal network operated mainly in Spain, Italy, Germany and Denmark... The women reflect a recent wave of Nigerians who have headed to Europe from Benin City, where poverty and traditional witchcraft suffocate opportunity. The journey can be fraught for women and girls, who face a particular risk of exploitation... Promised a better life in Spain, the 16 women were moved by land from Nigeria to Libya, then to Italy by sea, and from there into Spain, Europol said. Once on the Spanish territory they were handed over to a madam and forced into prostitution until they paid off their debt, the agency said... Voodoo threats leveled by traffickers: The women also were pressured under voodoo threats to pledge to pay for their transport and not to report their exploiters to police, Europol said. 'This method, used by criminal organizations with women from Western Africa, aims to control women under threat of death for them or their family members if they do not comply with that commitment,' the agency said. In some cases, traffickers can control their victims using phone contact alone, Europol said... The number of potential sex-trafficking victims arriving in Italy by sea has increased 600% since 2014, with the majority of victims arriving from Nigeria, a July report by the International Organization for Migration estimates. Eighty percent of all women and girls arriving from Nigeria to Europe are potential victims of trafficking for sexual exploitation, the group estimates, noting that exploitation of younger girls has been on the rise.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The trafficking network used juju oath rituals and threats of supernatural harm to compel sexual exploitation and silence victims.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"route": {
"from": [
5.6037,
6.335
],
"to": [
-4.97,
38.92
],
"fromLabel": "Benin City, Nigeria",
"toLabel": "Spain",
"label": "Nigeria -> Spain: Europol trafficking corridor",
"provenance": "Europol's own operation summary states victims were 'transferred from Nigeria to Europe via Libya and Italy' and, once in Spain, held in Almería; a companion AP report specifies the women were 'moved by land from Nigeria to Libya, then to Italy by sea, and from there into Spain,' and identifies Benin City as the point of origin for this wave of trafficking. The Libya/Italy transit legs are real but not drawn — this arc represents only the overall origin-to-destination corridor Europol itself describes, not each transit hop. Destination uses the record's own country-level gazetteer point (no city-level point exists on this record; Almería itself is not the record's coordinate). Origin reuses the corpus's existing Benin City point (see flag on the 2001-london-uk patch above)."
},
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The cited sources report charges or a pending proceeding. This record does not establish a finding of guilt or a final disposition.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.europol.europa.eu/media-press/newsroom/news/trafficked-voodoo-threats-one-of-largest-operations-in-europe-rescues-39-nigerian-women",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "014eeb898f3ce8d354cf29dcf5c52ff6c045cafe2882a4b8b475f02245a33fce",
"final_url": "https://www.europol.europa.eu/media-press/newsroom/news/trafficked-voodoo-threats-one-of-largest-operations-in-europe-rescues-39-nigerian-women"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/01/world/nigerian-women-voodoo-threats-spain/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "390ac3228bbd215150216a7bd1b2ec4a994774d948e077fb77c66b2435eede25",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/01/world/nigerian-women-voodoo-threats-spain/index.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-paris-france",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Paris, France",
"lat": 48.8566,
"lng": 2.3522,
"title": "Paris trial — voodoo-oath sex-trafficking network",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.france24.com/en/20180520-nigerian-victims-face-human-traffickers-paris-trial-testimony-forced-prostitution",
"archive": "https://web.archive.org/web/2024/https://www.france24.com/en/20180520-nigerian-victims-face-human-traffickers-paris-trial-testimony-forced-prostitution",
"citation": "Moitozo, M. (2018) 'Nigerian victims face their human traffickers at Paris trial', France 24, 20 May. Available at: france24.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Sixteen members of a mostly female network of Nigerian human traffickers operating forced prostitution rings in France went on trial last week in Paris... Before leaving Nigeria the women were taken to voodoo priests, some of whom used body scarification in a ritual to 'seal' the women's contracts with their traffickers. Other women were told they were haunted by 'bad spirits' and must pay their traffickers upwards of €70,000 for protection. ... Earlier this year Oba Ewuare ll, the traditional ruler of Nigeria's kingdom of Benin – where 90 percent of Nigerian sex trafficking originates... formally cursed those priests who take part... During a ceremony that all priests in the region were required to attend, he declared all people trafficked in his jurisdiction to be released from their voodoo bonds and placed a new curse on any priests continuing the practice.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The trafficking network used Vodou or juju oaths, ritual objects, and threatened harm to victims or their families as mechanisms of control.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"route": {
"from": [
5.6037,
6.335
],
"to": [
2.3522,
48.8566
],
"fromLabel": "Benin City, Nigeria",
"toLabel": "Paris, France",
"label": "Nigeria -> France: voodoo-oath trafficking network",
"provenance": "Source reporting on the Paris trial states the traffickers' victims underwent oath ceremonies with voodoo priests 'before leaving Nigeria' and explicitly ties the network to 'Nigeria's kingdom of Benin — where 90 percent of Nigerian sex trafficking originates,' the same jurisdiction whose Oba later revoked trafficking oaths (2018-benin-city-nigeria). The network is reported as running 'forced prostitution rings in France,' so Paris — the record's own gazetteer point, where the 16 defendants were tried — is treated as a genuine exploitation-side endpoint, not merely a courthouse. Destination coordinates reuse the record's own stored point (lat 48.85, lng 0.54); that point is imprecise for Paris proper (true Paris is ~48.86N, 2.35E) — flagged, not corrected. Origin reuses the corpus's existing Benin City point (see flag above)."
},
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.france24.com/en/20180520-nigerian-victims-face-human-traffickers-paris-trial-testimony-forced-prostitution",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "157fcf3eab23b63929a676ee18bb9dadf40a1a6e3607227494906687d31c1149",
"final_url": "https://www.france24.com/en/20180520-nigerian-victims-face-human-traffickers-paris-trial-testimony-forced-prostitution"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-birmingham-uk",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Birmingham, UK",
"lat": 53.57,
"lng": -1.91,
"title": "Iyamu — 1st Modern Slavery Act cross-border juju conviction",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wired-gov.net/wg/news.nsf/articles/London+nurse+jailed+for+14+years+in+landmark+slavery+case+05072018141500",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Crime Agency (2018) 'London nurse jailed for 14 years in landmark slavery case', National Crime Agency, 4 July. Available at: wired-gov.net (mirror of the original NCA press release, which is no longer online; Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Josephine Iyamu, 51, is the first British national to be convicted under the Modern Slavery Act for offences committed overseas. ... Using her status, Iyamu recruited vulnerable women from rural villages and promised them a better life in Europe. Before they left, she put her victims through a Juju ceremony - a humiliating ritual designed to exert control over them... The women believed serious harm would come to them or their families if they broke their oath to Iyamu or tried to escape... They detailed the horrendous conditions they endured whilst travelling over-land across Africa, and then by boat to Italy before flying to Germany using false ID documents provided to them by Iyamu's associates... Prior to Iyamu's trial, NAPTIP officers secured a video of a Juju priest conducting a revocation ceremony taking away the oath Iyamu's victims felt bound by... On Wednesday 4 July she was sentenced to 14 years in prison, 13 years for the slavery offences and one year for perverting the course of justice, to be served consecutively.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/first-ever-convicted-cross-border-sex-trafficker-has-sentence-increased",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Attorney General's Office (2018) 'First ever convicted cross-border sex-trafficker has sentence increased', GOV.UK. Available at: gov.uk (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Josephine Iyamu has had her sentence increased to 18 years after the Solicitor General's referral... From her south London home, Josephine Iyamu, now 51, organised the travel of 5 women from Nigeria to Germany for exploitation through prostitution for her own financial gain... The victims were all vulnerable young women who knew Iyamu could get them into Europe. In return for arranging their travel, Iyamu demanded they repay her up to £35,000 once they began working in Germany, and were told that breaking this promise would result in activation of a voodoo curse. After Iyamu's arrest in 2017, she plotted to stop the case against her through intimidation of the victims' families... Iyamu was originally sentenced at Birmingham Crown Court in July, where she was given 14 years imprisonment... Today, the Court of Appeal increased her sentence to 18 years imprisonment.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Iyamu used juju oath ceremonies and threats of supernatural punishment to bind trafficked women to debt and enforced sexual exploitation.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wired-gov.net/wg/news.nsf/articles/London+nurse+jailed+for+14+years+in+landmark+slavery+case+05072018141500",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a8ade5884b45d393c4cf5bf3e542a6d73df6db48b65cf6925d525f69bd1fb7aa",
"final_url": "https://www.wired-gov.net/wg/news.nsf/articles/London+nurse+jailed+for+14+years+in+landmark+slavery+case+05072018141500"
},
{
"source": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/first-ever-convicted-cross-border-sex-trafficker-has-sentence-increased",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e5c8c05ca404519a91e848b874bab78a3d9ce582fc17d1d74a695c4d4a3338dc",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/first-ever-convicted-cross-border-sex-trafficker-has-sentence-increased"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2021-mount-dora-fl-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Mount Dora, FL, USA",
"lat": 27.72,
"lng": -81.65,
"title": "Grave desecration for a Palo Mayombe shrine",
"tradition": "palo",
"type": "ritual-crime",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/miami/news/florida-men-arrested-desecrating-graves-stealing-human-remains-skulls/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News Miami (2021) '‘They Took His Skull’: 2 Florida Men Arrested For Desecrating Graves, Stealing Human Remains', CBS News Miami, 11 January. Available at: cbsnews.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "These are not only historical cases. In 2021: 'Two Florida men are now in jail for allegedly desecrating graves and stealing human remains, three of which belong to military veterans'... the men allegedly intended to 'use the human remains in their religious practice – Palo Mayombe, which is considered Santeria's ‘evil twin.’' When police searched the property, 'detectives found a shed with a religious shrine, and seven skulls, four of which both suspects admitted to taking from graves.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tampabay28.com/news/region-polk/2-polk-county-men-arrested-for-stealing-skulls-other-remains-of-4-veterans-from-florida-cemetery",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Leigh, H. and Trujillo, D. (2021) '2 Polk County men arrested for stealing skulls, other remains of 4 veterans from Florida cemetery', ABC Action News (WFTS). Available at: tampabay28.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "A second Florida case shows the logic laid bare. Two men who allegedly robbed veterans' graves in Lake County faced 'four counts of Disturbing the Contents of a Grave and four counts of Abuse of a Dead Human Body,' with one also charged with buying, selling, or trafficking in dead bodies. Police said the men 'use the human remains in their religious practice' and 'chose veterans' graves because their religion demands that the remains are from those who have 'done something heroic.''"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The grave desecration supplied human remains for a Palo Mayombe shrine and ritual practice.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-palo",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/miami/news/florida-men-arrested-desecrating-graves-stealing-human-remains-skulls/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7f21f3a023b5072a60b0e28b71839103f09cbf69381f5be7428dca98e127cb03",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/miami/news/florida-men-arrested-desecrating-graves-stealing-human-remains-skulls/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.tampabay28.com/news/region-polk/2-polk-county-men-arrested-for-stealing-skulls-other-remains-of-4-veterans-from-florida-cemetery",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24aaef621be56a5cc512ade5ce7f3ad99b9ca596dce13e7a612b9bd47962dbf1",
"final_url": "https://www.tampabay28.com/news/region-polk/2-polk-county-men-arrested-for-stealing-skulls-other-remains-of-4-veterans-from-florida-cemetery"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2023-lausanne-switzerland",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Lausanne, Switzerland",
"lat": 46.51,
"lng": 4.1,
"title": "Swiss court — juju sex-trafficking conviction",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/society/swiss-court-jails-nigerian-woman-for-sex-trafficking-using-voodoo-threats/48620320",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SWI swissinfo.ch (2023) 'Swiss court jails Nigerian woman for sex trafficking using voodoo threats', swissinfo.ch, 26 June. Available at: swissinfo.ch (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'A court has sentenced a Nigerian woman to four-and-a-half years in prison for trafficking young Nigerian women between 2014-18 and enslaving them in Switzerland as sex workers... Before leaving for Europe, they had been forced to undergo a ritual 'juju' ceremony. This voodoo practice involved the casting of a black magic spell and threats that they and their families could be harmed if they disobey.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The trafficker used a juju oath and the victim's fear of spiritual punishment to enforce debt, obedience, and sexual exploitation.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/society/swiss-court-jails-nigerian-woman-for-sex-trafficking-using-voodoo-threats/48620320",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c98431dc07b90777d0dab16a184f273b8dc7583d0e0003e2187843705e6544b2",
"final_url": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/society/swiss-court-jails-nigerian-woman-for-sex-trafficking-using-voodoo-threats/48620320"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2024-vredenburg-south-africa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Vredenburg, South Africa",
"lat": -32.9,
"lng": 18,
"title": "Joslin Smith — mother charged, muti trafficking of a child",
"tradition": "muti",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/crime/muti-killings-sa-joslin-joshlin-smith-missing-children/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Citizen (2024) 'Muti murders in SA: Has Joslin Smith fallen prey to 'occult economy'?', The Citizen, 11 March. Available at: citizen.co.za (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "In South Africa, the disappearance of six-year-old Joslin Smith led to human-trafficking charges against her own mother, allegedly for sale into muti (ritual body-part medicine): 'In a dramatic new development in the tragic case of the six-year-old, her mother, Racquel 'Kelly' Smith and her boyfriend Jacquin 'Boeta' Appollis have been charged with human trafficking and kidnapping. They appeared on Thursday, 7 March in the Vredenburg Magistrate's Court alongside their co-accused Steveno van Rhyn and Phumza Sigaqa, an alleged sangoma. The state alleges that her mother instructed Appollis and Van Rhyn to sell Joslin to a traditional healer for R20 000 to be used in muti.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The prosecution alleged that a child was trafficked for muti, making the claimed ritual use of the child the spiritual pretext at issue. The allegation must be read with the proceeding status shown on this record.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-muti",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The cited sources report charges or a pending proceeding. This record does not establish a finding of guilt or a final disposition.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/crime/muti-killings-sa-joslin-joshlin-smith-missing-children/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "75b1e805febeb0af054bf5950fa6046793b8cdc6d25ca155368590d49f32a032",
"final_url": "https://www.citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/crime/muti-killings-sa-joslin-joshlin-smith-missing-children/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2024-cit-soleil-haiti",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Cité Soleil, Haiti",
"lat": 17.86,
"lng": -71.24,
"title": "Massacre: 184 killed on a Vodou priest's witchcraft accusation",
"tradition": "haitian-vodou",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "documented-massacre",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/10/haiti-kidnapping-vodou-christianity-religion-politics/",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20260120163551/https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/10/haiti-kidnapping-vodou-christianity-religion-politics/",
"citation": "Hebblethwaite, B. (2021, November 10). 'Wilson Joseph, Bawon Samdi, and the meaning of Vodou in Haitian politics'. Foreign Policy. Retrieved from https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/10/haiti-kidnapping-vodou-christianity-religion-politics/ Accessed: 9 July 2024.",
"body": "'In a video statement released on Oct. 21, Wilson Joseph, the leader of the 400 Mawozo gang—dressed up as Bawon Samdi, Vodou's fearsome spirit of death—threatened to kill members of the Haitian government as well as 17 foreign hostages, including five children, in Haiti on a Christian mission trip. They remain his captives. He invoked a spell in the name of Bawon and explained that he had wept over his five 'soldiers' who were killed and whose open coffins he stood behind. Now the politicians will 'cry blood', he said, and vowed that he'd shoot 'those Americans' (referring to the missionaries, one of whom is Canadian) if his demands, including a $17 million ransom, were unmet. His participation in a Vodou ritual to bring justice to Moïse while threatening the 'stinking bourgeoisie' and the 'Siriyanolibanè' (Syrian and Lebanese descendants) puts on raw display Haitian essentialism and racism in that the ritual ties so-called authentic power, the power Chérizier envisions for himself, to the traditions of Haiti's Black majority.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/haiti-massacre-cite-soleil-port-au-prince-gang-violence-un-death-toll/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News/AFP (2024) '184 killed in Haiti, U.N. says, as gang leader allegedly orders massacre of elderly on voodoo priest's advice', CBS News, 9 December. Available at: cbsnews.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "In December 2024, a Vodou priest's witchcraft accusation triggered one of the worst massacres in recent Haitian history. Per the UN Human Rights Chief and Haiti's leading rights group: 'Just this past weekend, at least 184 people were killed in violence orchestrated by the leader of a powerful gang in the Haitian capital of Port-au-Prince, in the Cite Soleil area,' Volker Turk told reporters... RNDDH said Felix had sought advice from a voodoo priest who told him elderly people in the area had harmed his child, who died on Saturday, leading to members of his gang killing at least 100 people Friday and Saturday with machetes and knives.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/12/11/haitis-vodou-murders-why-did-a-gang-kill-nearly-200-people",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Shamim, S. (2024) 'Haiti's 'vodou' murders: Why did a gang kill nearly 200 people?', Al Jazeera, 11 December. Available at: aljazeera.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Al Jazeera independently corroborated the massacre and its ritual trigger: 'Felix had reportedly sought advice from a 'Vodou' priest who accused elderly people in the area of using witchcraft to harm the child. The gang's soldiers were responsible for identifying victims in their homes to take them to the chief's stronghold to be executed.' The gang leader, Jean Monel Felix, also goes by the moniker 'King Micanor'."
},
{
"link": "https://binuh.unmissions.org/sites/default/files/flash_report_20241223_wharf_jeremie_en.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BINUH & OHCHR (2024) 'Haiti Flash Report: killings by the Wharf Jérémie gang, Port-au-Prince, 6–7 December 2024', United Nations, 23 December. Available at: binuh.unmissions.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "The United Nations' own investigation into the December 2024 massacre is more damning than the wire coverage: it establishes that the gang leader had been serially executing Vodou priestesses for over fifteen years. 'BINUH and the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) established that the majority of the victims were elderly individuals accused of practicing Vodou and allegedly causing the illness of the gang leader's child.... In May 2008, he would have executed at least seven Vodou priestesses during a ceremony, justifying these murders as his desire to 'strengthen his mystical powers'. In 2012, 12 Vodou priestesses were also reportedly executed following accusations of witchcraft.... As a devout Vodou practitioner, the leader of the Wharf Jérémie gang personally knew those who regularly participated in ceremonies.' In his own audio, the gang leader declared: 'The victims are sorcerers (loup-garous)... In all Viv Ansanm bases, we will exterminate the sorcerers and cleanse the areas.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lapresse.ca/international/caraibes/2024-12-12/haiti/massacres-pour-une-question-de-vaudou.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Presse (2024) 'Haïti : Massacrés pour une question de vaudou', La Presse, 12 December, quoting Widlore Mérancourt (AyiboPost) and the RNDDH. Available at: lapresse.ca (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Haitian journalists explain the paradox at the heart of these killings — gang leaders both patronize Vodou and slaughter its practitioners. The editor-in-chief of AyiboPost, Widlore Mérancourt: 'Les chefs de gang s'affichent comme vaudouisants, ils sont prêts à faire appel aux prêtres et aux prêtresses quand ils en ont besoin. Mais ces mêmes individus sont aussi prêts à attaquer la communauté en toute impunité.' Haiti's leading rights group, the RNDDH, reported that 'des corps mutilés ont été brûlés dans les rues, notamment des jeunes qui ont été tués en tentant de sauver des résidants.' [English: Gang leaders present themselves as Vodou practitioners; they are ready to call on the priests and priestesses when they need them. But these same individuals are also ready to attack the community with total impunity... Mutilated bodies were burned in the streets, including young people who were killed while trying to save residents.]"
},
{
"link": "https://binuh.unmissions.org/sites/default/files/flash_report_20241223_wharf_jeremie_en.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United Nations Integrated Office in Haiti and Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, Flash Report: Massacre of at least 207 people in the Wharf Jérémie area of Cité Soleil (Dec. 23, 2024).",
"body": "The official UN investigation records at least 207 killings ordered by gang leader Monel Felix, also known as Micanor, after he blamed elderly people and Vodou practitioners for causing his child's illness through witchcraft. It identifies victims, methods, concealment and attacks on people trying to flee.",
"tier": "intergovernmental-investigation",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The gang leader accused elderly people and Vodou practitioners of causing his child's illness through witchcraft and used that accusation to order a massacre.",
"scopeNote": "INVERSE CATEGORY — PERSECUTION, NOT AUTHORITY ABUSE. The people killed here were Vodou practitioners accused of causing harm by supernatural means, and they were killed by crowds who held no spiritual authority over them. The archive's criterion requires that the victim was subject to the perpetrator's spiritual authority (N1); here the relationship runs the opposite way. The record is retained because accusation-driven killing is a real and lethal pattern this archive documents, but it is counted apart from authority abuse, and it must not be read as attributing the violence to Vodou — the practitioners were its targets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-haitian-vodou",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/10/haiti-kidnapping-vodou-christianity-religion-politics/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "51c2fc0befc26eac8651d026599190caa3aec1cefd7a911166783e4a038e0ec1",
"final_url": "https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/10/haiti-kidnapping-vodou-christianity-religion-politics/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/haiti-massacre-cite-soleil-port-au-prince-gang-violence-un-death-toll/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "27931e46bf99bf51780487fc3a126213ebefde2ba57ddb7cfb9abb1a74b48547",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/haiti-massacre-cite-soleil-port-au-prince-gang-violence-un-death-toll/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/12/11/haitis-vodou-murders-why-did-a-gang-kill-nearly-200-people",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7bb76d83400fb528cc88b73bf35ee9538c2e73761f0bcd2999c9aee3cfd1cc22",
"final_url": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/12/11/haitis-vodou-murders-why-did-a-gang-kill-nearly-200-people"
},
{
"source": "https://binuh.unmissions.org/sites/default/files/flash_report_20241223_wharf_jeremie_en.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a5050d429f56bd256bc0daae858df9a58d28156a88709b16f432ad6a157de9a5",
"final_url": "https://binuh.unmissions.org/sites/default/files/flash_report_20241223_wharf_jeremie_en.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lapresse.ca/international/caraibes/2024-12-12/haiti/massacres-pour-une-question-de-vaudou.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "73ff312ce85055c60a21f75a259bab9f981833ed4d9e316577241033ae9bc1ed",
"final_url": "https://www.lapresse.ca/international/caraibes/2024-12-12/haiti/massacres-pour-une-question-de-vaudou.php"
},
{
"source": "https://binuh.unmissions.org/sites/default/files/flash_report_20241223_wharf_jeremie_en.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: intergovernmental-investigation; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a5050d429f56bd256bc0daae858df9a58d28156a88709b16f432ad6a157de9a5",
"final_url": "https://binuh.unmissions.org/sites/default/files/flash_report_20241223_wharf_jeremie_en.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2024-jacmel-haiti",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Jacmel, Haiti",
"lat": 17.14,
"lng": -73.26,
"title": "Dana Jackson (US) dies at a manbo initiation retreat",
"tradition": "haitian-vodou",
"type": "death",
"status": "unresolved",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wsoctv.com/news/local/whats-truth-man-says-mom-mysteriously-died-vodou-retreat-haiti/FWWXSJTBBFBEBN3SNGXKAFWCMI/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "White, A. (2024) 'What's truth? Man says mom mysteriously died at Vodou retreat in Haiti', WSOC-TV (Channel 9, Charlotte). Available at: wsoctv.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "The risks of Vodou are not confined to Haitians or trafficking victims. In July 2024, Dana Jackson, 51, of Charlotte, North Carolina, traveled to Jacmel, Haiti to be initiated as a manbo (Vodou priestess), and died shortly after the initiation ritual; her family says they were given shifting and unverifiable accounts of how. Per her son, Timothy Jackson: 'My mom did not go to Haiti to not come back'... 'I was told that my mom got sick. Maybe a panic attack that was mentioned, of like a stroke and then a heart attack and some seizures'... 'Just trying to figure out what's the truth?' The Vodou organization that ran the retreat, Sosyete Nago, confirmed in a public statement that 'Her untimely passing in Jacmel, Haiti, on Monday, July 22, 2024, which came shortly after her initiation, was a profound shock to us all.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The death occurred shortly after a Vodou initiation conducted by the retreat organization. The cited record establishes the ritual setting and conflicting accounts, but does not establish a judicial finding about causation or abuse.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-haitian-vodou",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wsoctv.com/news/local/whats-truth-man-says-mom-mysteriously-died-vodou-retreat-haiti/FWWXSJTBBFBEBN3SNGXKAFWCMI/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "17a3b0dde1b83235c8054c05facaf3ea5f2d4f9d38a1a3caf4dc186dfc3e2401",
"final_url": "https://www.wsoctv.com/news/local/whats-truth-man-says-mom-mysteriously-died-vodou-retreat-haiti/FWWXSJTBBFBEBN3SNGXKAFWCMI/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2010-grand-anse-haiti",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Grand'Anse, Haiti",
"lat": 18.65,
"lng": -74.12,
"title": "2010 cholera lynchings: 45+ killed, mostly Vodou priests",
"tradition": "haitian-vodou",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "documented-killings",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.haitilibre.com/article-1975-haiti-social-lynchages-au-moins-45-morts-cholera-ou-guerre-de-religion.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "HaïtiLibre (2010) 'Haïti - Social : Lynchages, au moins 45 morts, choléra ou guerre de religion ?', HaïtiLibre, 23 December. Available at: haitilibre.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "The violence cuts both ways, and it is not new. During the 2010 cholera epidemic, dozens of people — mostly Vodou priests — were lynched after being accused of spreading the disease by sorcery. Per HaïtiLibre, quoting a government official: 'Nous avons dénombré 40 morts par lynchage dans Département de la Grand'Anse et 5 autres dans des communes du Plateau Central [...] les gens s'attaquent à des guérisseurs accusés de sorcellerie liée au choléra... Les victimes, la plupart des prêtres vodou, sont battues à coups de machette et de pierre avant d'être brûlées dans la rue.' [English: We counted 40 deaths by lynching in the Grand'Anse Department and 5 others in the Plateau Central [...] people are attacking healers accused of cholera-linked sorcery... The victims, most of them Vodou priests, are beaten with machetes and stones before being burned in the street.]"
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Cholera deaths were blamed on Vodou practitioners through witchcraft accusations, and those accusations were used to justify lynchings.",
"scopeNote": "INVERSE CATEGORY — PERSECUTION, NOT AUTHORITY ABUSE. The people killed here were Vodou practitioners accused of causing harm by supernatural means, and they were killed by crowds who held no spiritual authority over them. The archive's criterion requires that the victim was subject to the perpetrator's spiritual authority (N1); here the relationship runs the opposite way. The record is retained because accusation-driven killing is a real and lethal pattern this archive documents, but it is counted apart from authority abuse, and it must not be read as attributing the violence to Vodou — the practitioners were its targets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-haitian-vodou",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.haitilibre.com/article-1975-haiti-social-lynchages-au-moins-45-morts-cholera-ou-guerre-de-religion.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2a1c63d24c236f6435d302d58e145b9942c0f2ece9eee88405ec5de395f56417",
"final_url": "https://www.haitilibre.com/article-1975-haiti-social-lynchages-au-moins-45-morts-cholera-ou-guerre-de-religion.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2019-marseille-france",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Marseille, France",
"lat": 43.31,
"lng": 5.36,
"title": "Marseille: Supreme Vikings juju-oath trafficking convictions",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://amicaledunid.org/actualites/cp-proces-a-lencontre-de-15-membres-dune-confraternite-nigeriane-a-marseilledes-peines-exemplaires/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Amicale du Nid (2023) 'Procès à l'encontre de 15 membres d'une confraternité nigériane à Marseille : des peines exemplaires prononcées', amicaledunid.org, November. Available at: amicaledunid.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "At Marseille in November 2023, fifteen members of the Nigerian 'Supreme Vikings Confraternity' (Arrow Baga) cult were tried for gang rape and aggravated pimping enforced through juju witchcraft; six received ten years. Per the anti-trafficking NGO that supported the victims: 'l'emprise déployée par les membres de ce gang sur les victimes – caractérisée par les menaces de mort, les intimidations, les violences physiques et psychologiques, et rituel de sorcellerie (juju)... six prévenus ont été condamnés à 10 ans de réclusion criminelle pour agression sexuelle...et 8 ans pour proxénétisme aggravé.' [English: the hold this gang's members exerted over the victims — characterised by death threats, intimidation, physical and psychological violence, and a witchcraft ritual (juju)... six defendants were sentenced to 10 years for sexual assault... and 8 years for aggravated pimping.]"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The trafficking group used juju oath rituals and threatened supernatural consequences to compel prostitution and maintain control.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://amicaledunid.org/actualites/cp-proces-a-lencontre-de-15-membres-dune-confraternite-nigeriane-a-marseilledes-peines-exemplaires/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d2dfd447ab9aa281e5b1e822ccb906f4f32ea441164344c89fb64c80ecc7a391",
"final_url": "https://amicaledunid.org/actualites/cp-proces-a-lencontre-de-15-membres-dune-confraternite-nigeriane-a-marseilledes-peines-exemplaires/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2021-valladolid-spain",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Valladolid, Spain",
"lat": 41.65,
"lng": -4.72,
"title": "Spain Supreme Court upholds voodoo-oath trafficking (20 yrs)",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.diariodevalladolid.es/valladolid/260629/284248/penas-20-anos-grupo-nigeriano-prostituir-mujeres-rituales-vudu-valladolid-salamanca.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diario de Valladolid, 'Penas de hasta 20 años de cárcel a un grupo por prostituir a mujeres con rituales de vudú en Valladolid y Salamanca', Diario de Valladolid. Available at: diariodevalladolid.es (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Spain's Supreme Court upheld a Nigerian trafficking ring's convictions — the ringleader given 20 years — in a case where the coercion was explicitly voodoo. Per the reporting: 'Los acusados empleaban 'rituales de vudú -yuyu' mediante 'mezcla de fluidos corporales, cabello o pelo, sangre, procedente del sacrificio de un animal como una gallina' para imponer 'presión, sumisión y doblegamiento de la voluntad' en las víctimas, quienes temían que ellas o sus familias sufrieran 'males en su salud física o mental o, incluso, la muerte' si desobedecían.' [English: The accused used 'voodoo-yuyu rituals' involving 'a mixture of bodily fluids, hair, and blood from the sacrifice of an animal such as a hen' to impose 'pressure, submission and the breaking of the will' on the victims, who feared that they or their families would suffer 'physical or mental illness, or even death' if they disobeyed.]"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendants used rituals involving bodily material and animal blood to threaten illness or death and break victims' resistance to trafficking.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.diariodevalladolid.es/valladolid/260629/284248/penas-20-anos-grupo-nigeriano-prostituir-mujeres-rituales-vudu-valladolid-salamanca.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "96c0f029b8fe49119f227371e7dbdf59befe9c08fe1ac594a140a7894df17a7d",
"final_url": "https://www.diariodevalladolid.es/valladolid/260629/284248/penas-20-anos-grupo-nigeriano-prostituir-mujeres-rituales-vudu-valladolid-salamanca.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2017-bruges-belgium",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Bruges, Belgium",
"lat": 51.19,
"lng": 3.2,
"title": "Bruges: Nigerian voodoo-trafficking ring convicted",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2017/09/20/tot-9-jaar-cel-voor-nigeriaanse-prostitutiebende-/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "VRT NWS (2017) 'Tot 9 jaar cel voor Nigeriaanse prostitutiebende', vrt.be, 20 September. Available at: vrt.be (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "A Bruges court convicted the ringleaders of a Nigerian network that trafficked 25 young women into Belgium over four years, using voodoo to terrify them before departure. Per Belgium's public broadcaster: 'De twee kopstukken van de bende, waaronder een 25-jarige Nigeriaan, zijn nu door de rechter in Brugge veroordeeld tot 8 en 9 jaar cel... De jonge slachtoffers werden in hun thuisland eerst bang gemaakt met voodoopraktijken.' [English: The two ringleaders of the gang, including a 25-year-old Nigerian, have now been sentenced by the Bruges court to 8 and 9 years in prison... The young victims were first frightened in their home country with voodoo practices.]"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The trafficking network used Vodou or juju oaths and threatened supernatural retaliation to enforce exploitation and silence.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2017/09/20/tot-9-jaar-cel-voor-nigeriaanse-prostitutiebende-/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9d72bee0e8835ee520eb813601e4f4bf8e999aea9a0632982753e19be42c6eee",
"final_url": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2017/09/20/tot-9-jaar-cel-voor-nigeriaanse-prostitutiebende-/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2019-milan-italy",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Milan, Italy",
"lat": 45.47,
"lng": 9.18,
"title": "Milan: voodoo 'mental dependency' slavery conviction",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ansa.it/lombardia/notizie/2019/06/20/prostitute-per-riti-voodoo-3-condanne_501aee2f-b0ba-44ef-9ffa-4ff03f7c8f0e.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ANSA (2019) 'Prostitute per riti voodoo, 3 condanne', ANSA.it, 20 June. Available at: ansa.it (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "In Milan, an Italian court convicted a Nigerian 'maman' of reducing victims to slavery, in a case backed by a court-ordered anthropological assessment establishing that the ritual creates genuine psychological dependency. Per ANSA: 'il rito voodoo, in sostanza, è in grado di creare uno stato di 'dipendenza mentale'.' [English: the voodoo ritual, in substance, is capable of creating a state of 'mental dependency'.]"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The court found that Vodou threats created psychological dependency and fear that helped the trafficker maintain slavery-like control.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ansa.it/lombardia/notizie/2019/06/20/prostitute-per-riti-voodoo-3-condanne_501aee2f-b0ba-44ef-9ffa-4ff03f7c8f0e.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7661feb8512a89507a66e17b54f739d6cb25012251343ba87e3dc706fb01de48",
"final_url": "https://www.ansa.it/lombardia/notizie/2019/06/20/prostitute-per-riti-voodoo-3-condanne_501aee2f-b0ba-44ef-9ffa-4ff03f7c8f0e.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2021-cullinan-south-africa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Cullinan, South Africa",
"lat": -25.67,
"lng": 28.51,
"title": "Gabisile Shabane: child killed for muti (life terms)",
"tradition": "muti",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2021-10-28-life-sentences-for-trio-who-murdered-child-with-albinism-for-muti/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TimesLIVE (2021) 'Life sentences for trio who murdered child with albinism for muti', TimesLIVE (South Africa), 28 October. Available at: timeslive.co.za (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "The muti trade — the killing of people for body parts used in traditional 'medicine' — is one of the most heavily litigated forms of ritual crime in the world, and South Africa's courts document it in detail. Three people received life for the murder of 13-year-old Gabisile Shabane, who had albinism: they 'kidnapped Gabisile with the plan to kill her and harvest her body parts for muti they wanted to use to make potions they believed would make them rich. They were arrested just weeks after the kidnapping and killings. Gabisile's remains were found in a shallow grave in Cullinan.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-08-23-double-life-sentence-for-teacher-who-killed-teen-with-albinism-for-muti/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TimesLIVE (2019) 'Double life sentence for teacher who killed teen with albinism for muti', TimesLIVE (South Africa), 23 August. Available at: timeslive.co.za (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "A schoolteacher, Themba Thubane, received a double life sentence in the same case: 'Her killing was muti-related. The group kidnapped Gabisile Shabane, 13, and her 15-month-old cousin Nkosikhona Ngwenya. Both children were then killed and Gabisile's body was later found with body parts missing. The children had suffered a gruesome death at the hands of unscrupulous men who were blinded by greed and the love of money.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was abducted and killed so that body parts could be used in muti, making the promised ritual efficacy the motive and pretext for the killing.",
"scopeNote": "COMMISSIONING HEALER SEPARATELY CONVICTED — the part of this case that matters most for this corpus's criterion. Themba Thubane approached the traditional healer Thokozani Msibi seeking muti to help his business, and Msibi advised him to obtain a child with albinism, effectively directing the killing. Thubane was convicted in 2019 and received two life sentences plus five years; Msibi and co-accused were convicted in October 2021 before the High Court at Middelburg, Mpumalanga. This is the rarer and more important adjudication — not only the killer, but the healer whose claimed authority converted a man's business anxiety into a child's murder.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-muti",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2021-10-28-life-sentences-for-trio-who-murdered-child-with-albinism-for-muti/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e495dfa07e83d2574a6e8cd64fc62165efec18b8756d7b7832cdce08ddb40438",
"final_url": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2021-10-28-life-sentences-for-trio-who-murdered-child-with-albinism-for-muti/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-08-23-double-life-sentence-for-teacher-who-killed-teen-with-albinism-for-muti/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "be1561e1762a7e62f8140e264ee1f4131282de505e9fe0dedfa8b1bb6c01c731",
"final_url": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-08-23-double-life-sentence-for-teacher-who-killed-teen-with-albinism-for-muti/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2022-malawi",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Malawi",
"lat": -13.25,
"lng": 34.31,
"title": "Malawi albino ritual murder: 155-year sentences",
"tradition": "muti",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.africanews.com/2022/05/12/malawian-court-sentences-three-to-155-years-for-albino-murder/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Africanews (2022) 'Malawian court sentences three to 155 years for albino murder', Africanews, 12 May. Available at: africanews.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "The same belief drives a documented epidemic of albino killings across the region. A Malawian court sentenced three men, one the victim's uncle, for a ritual murder: 'Malawi, just like other countries in the sub-Sahara Africa[,] has been witnessing several cases of murder[,] gruesome attacks and killings of people with albinism, with the belief that the use of their body parts brings good luck and success. Victims are usually murdered and bodies mutilated and later sold to various witch doctors for special rituals.'"
},
{
"link": "https://media.malawilii.org/media/judgment/12577/source_file/r-v-khanga-nikisi-and-katupe-2022-mwhc-152-11-may-2022.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "High Court of Malawi, R v Khang'a, Nikisi and Katupe, Homicide Cause No. 2 of 2021, [2022] MWHC 152, sentencing judgment (May 11, 2022).",
"body": "The sentencing judgment records the murder of Saidi Dyton, extraction of human tissue and aggravated trafficking convictions. It identifies the false belief that body parts of people with albinism bring wealth or luck, and orders the three prison terms to run concurrently.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "sentencing-judgment"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"belief-motivated trafficking participants"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"deception and luring",
"belief that body parts bring wealth or luck",
"human-tissue trafficking"
],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Malawi, Mangochi",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-05-11",
"outcome": "Each defendant received 68.5 years for murder, 48.5 years for extracting human tissue and 38.5 years for aggravated trafficking. The terms run concurrently, making 68.5 years the controlling sentence."
}
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies deception and luring, belief that body parts bring wealth or luck, and human-tissue trafficking as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is belief-motivated trafficking participants.",
"scopeNote": "The three terms total 155.5 years arithmetically, but the High Court ordered them to run concurrently. Each defendant therefore serves the longest term: 68.5 years, calculated from the date of arrest.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-muti",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.africanews.com/2022/05/12/malawian-court-sentences-three-to-155-years-for-albino-murder/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a81107d9c699b0b93473b2480252f899a83eff35e336c4a4c5fcadc4d67d6024",
"final_url": "https://www.africanews.com/2022/05/12/malawian-court-sentences-three-to-155-years-for-albino-murder/"
},
{
"source": "https://media.malawilii.org/media/judgment/12577/source_file/r-v-khanga-nikisi-and-katupe-2022-mwhc-152-11-may-2022.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8dd2a45e13bf4a7aa7ad9c896a6c9fd1f87155bff9e2395235cc37ea051d252f",
"final_url": "https://media.malawilii.org/media/judgment/12577/source_file/r-v-khanga-nikisi-and-katupe-2022-mwhc-152-11-may-2022.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2020-limpopo-south-africa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Limpopo, South Africa",
"lat": -23.9,
"lng": 29.45,
"title": "Hlungwani ritual murder: 4 relatives, life",
"tradition": "muti",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ritualkillinginafrica.org/2020/11/19/south-africa-relatives-senctenced-to-life-for-ritual-murder/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ritual Killing in Africa (2020) 'South Africa: relatives sentenced to life for ritual murder', 19 November. Available at: ritualkillinginafrica.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "In Limpopo, four relatives were sentenced to life for the ritual murder of Hlayisani Hlungwani: 'The judge found that the four accused intentionally killed Hlungwani by cutting off her lips, breasts and private parts. During the ritual, the victim's mother-in-law, Mhlongo, burned herbs naked while calling Hlungwani['s] ancestors to accept her spirit.' A co-accused testified that 'he and Mahumani held the victim down while Chuma cut the body parts with a knife. The court remarked that the crime was barbaric, where the victim fought for her life with all her energy, screaming and kicking.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The killing was carried out to obtain human remains for a claimed ritual purpose, according to the cited conviction record.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-muti",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ritualkillinginafrica.org/2020/11/19/south-africa-relatives-senctenced-to-life-for-ritual-murder/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "97ea5009467e78e3fb0ab14b15eec8d5174aad81212e95b89f42a07b873ec788",
"final_url": "https://www.ritualkillinginafrica.org/2020/11/19/south-africa-relatives-senctenced-to-life-for-ritual-murder/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "1998-volta-region-ghana",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Volta Region, Ghana",
"lat": 6.59,
"lng": 0.47,
"title": "Trokosi ritual servitude of girls (~1,400)",
"tradition": "juju",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://awdf.org/trokosi-the-current-state-of-ritual-servitude-in-ghana/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "African Women's Development Fund. 'Trokosi: The current state of ritual servitude in Ghana', AWDF. Available at: awdf.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Ritual servitude of girls persists as a living institution. In Ghana's Volta Region, the trokosi system holds girls as 'wives of the gods' to atone for family offences: 'Tro means deity and kosi means slave or wife so Trokosi translates as slave or wife of the deity. The practice of Trokosi involves holding young girls in servitude to appease the deities whom their families have offended... Although the Trokosi system, alongside all traditional and cultural practices that violate the constitution of Ghana[,] was banned in 1998[,] the practice is still very much alive.' One study estimated the number of victims at roughly 1,400."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Trokosi assigned girls to shrines as atonement for alleged family wrongdoing, using ritual debt and priestly custody to impose servitude.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://awdf.org/trokosi-the-current-state-of-ritual-servitude-in-ghana/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6ec635d2e10423f02223154818d731968eb6762b44977198e8ea475e9ba009c8",
"final_url": "https://awdf.org/trokosi-the-current-state-of-ritual-servitude-in-ghana/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2004-kenner-la-usa",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Kenner, LA, USA",
"lat": 29.99,
"lng": -90.25,
"title": "Louisiana curse-removal fraud convictions",
"tradition": "fraud-us",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nola.com/news/psychic-arrested-in-2004-kenner-scam/article_1abd81bf-2b57-5769-8870-f28a0e801e42.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NOLA.com / The Times-Picayune, 'Psychic arrested in 2004 Kenner scam'. Available at: nola.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "New Orleans has the loudest 'voodoo' reputation in America and the thinnest actual record: a hard search of Louisiana's courts and press turns up no ritual killing or trafficking-by-coercion case that survives scrutiny. What it does turn up is curse-removal fraud — con-artistry that borrows spiritual vocabulary. A Kenner 'psychic' operating as 'Sister Gabrielle' took more than $51,000 from a victim after telling her 'she and her parents would die unless a curse on her was removed'; it was a repeat of a 1999 Baton Rouge curse-removal theft. (The lurid 'voodoo murders' of New Orleans legend — the 1911 Barnabet axe killings, the 2006 Bowen-Hall homicide — are, on inspection, press invention or mere geographic coincidence.)"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendants claimed that victims were cursed and demanded money for spiritual cleansing or curse removal.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-divination-fraud",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nola.com/news/psychic-arrested-in-2004-kenner-scam/article_1abd81bf-2b57-5769-8870-f28a0e801e42.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b6b36ef1fabbf7177c29ad6d98521e5f32318eaad33f90224a58b44f737f5759",
"final_url": "https://www.nola.com/news/psychic-arrested-in-2004-kenner-scam/article_1abd81bf-2b57-5769-8870-f28a0e801e42.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2026-miami-fl-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Miami, FL, USA",
"lat": 25.85,
"lng": -80.21,
"title": "Little River: Haitian-Vodou threat to traffic a victim",
"tradition": "haitian-vodou",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.local10.com/news/2026/02/06/miami-police-human-trafficker-threatened-to-kill-victim-with-haitian-vodou/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Local 10 / WPLG (2026) 'Miami police: Human trafficker threatened to kill victim with Haitian Vodou', WPLG Local 10, 6 February. Available at: local10.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "The Nigeria-to-Europe juju pattern has a Haitian-Vodou parallel on American soil. In February 2026, Miami police arrested a man in the Little River neighborhood for coercing a woman into prostitution with a Vodou threat captured on video: ''Want to die, like, I told you, I am going to Voodoo, I am going to sell you for money for Haiti, and I am going to trade you for money,' Herard told the victim during the recording of the video, according to police. Herard faced three charges: Human trafficking for commercial sexual activity via coercion, deriving support from the proceeds of prostitution, and battery.' A judge denied him bail on the trafficking charge."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The charged conduct used threatened Haitian Vodou consequences to frighten and control a trafficking victim. The allegation must be read with the proceeding status shown on this record.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-haitian-vodou",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The cited sources report charges or a pending proceeding. This record does not establish a finding of guilt or a final disposition.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.local10.com/news/2026/02/06/miami-police-human-trafficker-threatened-to-kill-victim-with-haitian-vodou/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9b815fa154231d033138ef982a012275c5738aeab75cb427a7ef5f334b2a010",
"final_url": "https://www.local10.com/news/2026/02/06/miami-police-human-trafficker-threatened-to-kill-victim-with-haitian-vodou/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2025-hialeah-fl-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Hialeah, FL, USA",
"lat": 25.81,
"lng": -80.28,
"title": "Santeria ritual precedes deadly Hialeah shooting",
"tradition": "santeria",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "charges",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.local10.com/news/local/2025/02/14/cops-say-santeria-ritual-preceded-deadly-hialeah-shooting/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Local 10 / WPLG (2025) 'Cops say Santeria ritual preceded deadly Hialeah shooting', WPLG Local 10, 14 February. Available at: local10.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Ritual gatherings themselves sometimes end in violence. In Hialeah, Florida, police reported that 'the victims had been at the home for a Santeria ritual being performed on Milton Cao. At some point, investigators said, an argument erupted between Cao, Novar, the boy, and his father. The dispute then spilled outside, where police confirmed that a gunshot rang out.' One man was killed and two others stabbed; two men were later charged with second-degree murder."
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The available record mentions a Santería ritual before the shooting but does not establish that the ritual, belief, or spiritual authority materially caused the homicide, so the case is retained as context.",
"scopeNote": "The ritual appears in the chronology, but the available record does not establish that belief or spiritual authority materially caused the shooting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The cited sources report charges or a pending proceeding. This record does not establish a finding of guilt or a final disposition.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.local10.com/news/local/2025/02/14/cops-say-santeria-ritual-preceded-deadly-hialeah-shooting/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "508ee12274ef150d608129d1374abfade7a4cc13fc8530dba2a45f8c9d07c019",
"final_url": "https://www.local10.com/news/local/2025/02/14/cops-say-santeria-ritual-preceded-deadly-hialeah-shooting/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2016-bridgeport-ct-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Bridgeport, CT, USA",
"lat": 41.18,
"lng": -73.19,
"title": "Palo altar w/ stolen human skulls found in heroin raid",
"tradition": "palo",
"type": "ritual-crime",
"status": "charges",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nbcconnecticut.com/news/local/skulls-bones-found-in-bridgeport-santeria-priests-apartment/2049580/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sawyer, J. (2016) 'Skulls, Bones Found in Bridgeport Santeria Priest's Apartment', NBC Connecticut, 3 February. Available at: nbcconnecticut.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "The same practice surfaces far from the traditional strongholds. In Bridgeport, Connecticut, a Palo altar built from stolen human remains was discovered during a drug raid: police 'arrested Felix 'Cuba' Delgado, 40, as part of a drug investigation' and 'searched Delgado's Hallet Street apartment after receiving information he was selling heroin and prescription pills', finding two human skulls and a long bone 'configured in a 'Palo Mayombe' type alter, which is a sub-culture within the Santeria religion. Delgado is the second Santeria priest in Connecticut accused of stealing human remains in Massachusetts.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Police found a Palo altar and stolen human remains during an unrelated narcotics investigation. The record does not establish that spiritual belief or authority enabled the drug offense, so the case is retained as context.",
"scopeNote": "The available record documents occult material found during an unrelated narcotics investigation, not spiritual authority used to cause the charged harm.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-palo",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The cited sources report charges or a pending proceeding. This record does not establish a finding of guilt or a final disposition.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nbcconnecticut.com/news/local/skulls-bones-found-in-bridgeport-santeria-priests-apartment/2049580/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2cece4b002f9f1bc91e57e62654a4cfdb9ab80518d1a8b5cc5ea1559a8974a69",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcconnecticut.com/news/local/skulls-bones-found-in-bridgeport-santeria-priests-apartment/2049580/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2013-new-york-ny-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "New York, NY, USA",
"lat": 40.72,
"lng": -74.02,
"title": "NYC psychic curse-removal fraud (5-15 yrs)",
"tradition": "fraud-us",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sylvia-mitchell-update-sorry-nyc-psychic-gets-5-to15-years-in-prison-for-conning-clients/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News / Associated Press, “NYC psychic gets 5 to 15 years in prison for conning clients” (Nov. 14, 2013).",
"body": "The contemporaneous report records Sylvia Mitchell’s grand-larceny conviction, five-to-fifteen-year sentence, restitution order, and evidence that clients paid to remove negative energy.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The fraud depended on claims that the victim faced a curse or harmful energy and had to pay the purported psychic to remove it.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-divination-fraud",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sylvia-mitchell-update-sorry-nyc-psychic-gets-5-to15-years-in-prison-for-conning-clients/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a228bebbd90118dddbc633aa059eb5fe1da60ec2b964dd6ffc49c58162d22bdf",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sylvia-mitchell-update-sorry-nyc-psychic-gets-5-to15-years-in-prison-for-conning-clients/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2024-washington-dc-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Washington, DC, USA",
"lat": 38.92,
"lng": -77.04,
"title": "DC 'psychic' $4M extortion scheme (10+ yrs)",
"tradition": "fraud-us",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/pr/purported-psychic-sentenced-more-10-years-prison-outrageous-4-million-extortion-scheme",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Columbia, “Purported Psychic Sentenced to More Than 10 Years in Prison” (July 18, 2024).",
"body": "The Justice Department records Gina Rita Russell’s extortion plea, 125-month sentence, restitution order, and separate use of claimed psychic powers in related fraudulent conduct.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The scheme used claimed psychic powers and supernatural threats as part of a broader pattern of fraud and extortion.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-divination-fraud",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/pr/purported-psychic-sentenced-more-10-years-prison-outrageous-4-million-extortion-scheme",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "810f5f092bbc3b89cfb4f8d696539f0d5ff5d8ccde3c14ed1a204088967e1229",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/pr/purported-psychic-sentenced-more-10-years-prison-outrageous-4-million-extortion-scheme"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-brockton-ma-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Brockton, MA, USA",
"lat": 42.08,
"lng": -71.03,
"title": "MA child-torture cases charged as 'voodoo ritual'",
"tradition": "haitian-vodou",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wbur.org/news/2018/02/12/hatian-voodoo-children-crimes",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WBUR (2018) ''We Are Being Targeted': Voodoo Believers Fear A Backlash After Crimes Against Children', WBUR (Boston), 12 February. Available at: wbur.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Finally, a caution that belongs on this page. Two 2018 Massachusetts cases were charged as 'voodoo' crimes — 'Two sisters in East Bridgewater were arrested last month after they tied down and burned a 5-year-old girl, permanently disfiguring her, in a 'voodoo ritual' meant to rid her of a demon', and a Brockton mother stabbed two of her children in what she called a ritual. But a Haitian Vodou priestess in Mattapan pushed back on the label: ''We are being targeted,' said Evans, a Haitian Vodou priestess in Mattapan.' The distinction matters: 'voodoo' as a slur applied to any crime by a Haitian defendant is exactly the kind of press reflex this survey works to avoid — the point is documented conduct, not ethnicity."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The charged abuse was described as a Vodou ritual intended to drive an alleged demon or evil presence from children. The allegation must be read with the proceeding status shown on this record.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-haitian-vodou",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The cited sources report charges or a pending proceeding. This record does not establish a finding of guilt or a final disposition.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wbur.org/news/2018/02/12/hatian-voodoo-children-crimes",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ae8f544e4099fda5e945f1d4d2ff973a956489fbdd9e03e6eed5bfefc1e7688b",
"final_url": "https://www.wbur.org/news/2018/02/12/hatian-voodoo-children-crimes"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2012-brooklyn-ny-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Brooklyn, NY, USA",
"lat": 40.64,
"lng": -73.94,
"title": "Nechemya Weberman: 103 years, 59 counts of sexual abuse (Satmar counselor)",
"tradition": "judaism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nechemya-weberman-nyc-orthodox-jewish-counselor-convicted-of-sex-abuse-sentenced-to-103-years-in-prison/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News (2013) 'Nechemya Weberman, NYC Orthodox Jewish counselor convicted of sex abuse, sentenced to 103 years in prison', CBS News. Available at: cbsnews.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'A prominent member of the ultra-Orthodox Jewish community in Brooklyn has been sentenced to 103 years in prison after being convicted last month on 59 counts of sexual abuse against a young girl he counseled for years... Nechemya Weberman pleaded not guilty to the charges against him and the case divided the insular Satmar community of which he and his teenage accuser were a part.' Weberman was an unlicensed religious counselor to whom the victim had been sent by her school for perceived lapses in religious observance."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Weberman's authority came from his role as an unlicensed religious counselor for girls accused of lapses in Satmar religious observance, creating private access and enforced deference.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nechemya-weberman-nyc-orthodox-jewish-counselor-convicted-of-sex-abuse-sentenced-to-103-years-in-prison/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "96d5d6afde3b5d6d31326bb6974029619e02e074b6418487591bcff4d329078f",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nechemya-weberman-nyc-orthodox-jewish-counselor-convicted-of-sex-abuse-sentenced-to-103-years-in-prison/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2022-woodridge-ny-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Woodridge, NY, USA",
"lat": 41.62,
"lng": -74.38,
"title": "Lev Tahor leaders convicted: kidnapping + child exploitation (forced child marriage)",
"tradition": "judaism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jns.org/three-lev-tahor-leaders-convicted-of-child-exploitation-kidnapping/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "JNS (2024) 'Three Lev Tahor leaders convicted of child exploitation, kidnapping', Jewish News Syndicate. Available at: jns.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Three leaders of the Guatemala-based Jewish extremist group Lev Tahor (“pure heart”)—Yoil Weingarten, Yakov Weingarten and Shmiel Weingarten—were convicted of child exploitation and kidnapping.' The US Justice Department stated: 'The defendants' conduct—which included forced child marriages, physical beatings and family separations—is unthinkable and has caused irreparable harm to children in their formative years.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/lev-tahor-cult-leader-sentenced-to-12-years-for-kidnapping-child-exploitation/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel (2022) 'Lev Tahor cult leader sentenced to 12 years for kidnapping, child exploitation', The Times of Israel. Available at: timesofisrael.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'A US federal court sentenced the leader of the extremist Jewish Lev Tahor cult to 12 years imprisonment on Thursday for six convictions including child sexual exploitation and kidnapping. Nachman Helbrans, 40, was convicted of the crimes by the federal Southern District of New York court in November... Around 2017, Helbrans had arranged for the girl, his niece, to be ‘married’ to an adult from the group.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/senior-leaders-lev-tahor-sect-sentenced-14-and-12-years-prison-kidnapping-and-sex",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York, “Senior Leaders of Lev Tahor Sect Sentenced to 14 and 12 Years in Prison” (July 10, 2024).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records the Weingarten brothers’ March 2024 jury convictions and July sentences, the kidnapping of two children, and the effort to return a fourteen-year-old to a religious child marriage with an adult.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"sect leaders",
"religious-marriage authorities"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"forced child marriage",
"family separation",
"religious authority",
"international concealment"
],
"organizations": [
"Lev Tahor"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York",
"stage": "jury verdicts and sentences",
"date": "2024-07-09",
"outcome": "Three senior leaders received sentences of fourteen, fourteen and twelve years after March 2024 jury convictions."
}
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies forced child marriage, family separation, religious authority, and international concealment as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is sect leaders and religious-marriage authorities.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jns.org/three-lev-tahor-leaders-convicted-of-child-exploitation-kidnapping/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bc9f31c3bb088c47aeec557f6ab1784d837d38570b1adf67148268b877c35c1b",
"final_url": "https://www.jns.org/world/three-lev-tahor-leaders-convicted-of-child-exploitation-kidnapping"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/lev-tahor-cult-leader-sentenced-to-12-years-for-kidnapping-child-exploitation/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b4cbbae597042f2d94a5b5a60afc4dc2795c63d67f65e9d93e05441eb9153dcd",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/lev-tahor-cult-leader-sentenced-to-12-years-for-kidnapping-child-exploitation/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/senior-leaders-lev-tahor-sect-sentenced-14-and-12-years-prison-kidnapping-and-sex",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8c865c3dbd71f1cedffd34edf97b5c9f80516bac0b71089854d5aa2083355138",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/senior-leaders-lev-tahor-sect-sentenced-14-and-12-years-prison-kidnapping-and-sex"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2017-sirsa-india",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Sirsa, India",
"lat": 29.52,
"lng": 75.02,
"title": "Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh: 20 years, rape of two followers (Dera Sacha Sauda)",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/8/28/gurmeet-ram-rahim-singh-sentenced-to-20-years-for-rape",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Al Jazeera (2017) 'Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh sentenced to 20 years for rape', Al Jazeera. Available at: aljazeera.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'A judge in northern India has sentenced the leader of a popular sect to 20 years in prison for raping two of his female followers. Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh was sentenced amid intense security on Monday at a prison in the town of Rohtak, where the 50-year-old sect leader has been held since his conviction last week... Singh was given two 10-year jail terms, which will run consecutively, for each offence.' Ram Rahim headed the Dera Sacha Sauda sect, claiming millions of followers; the victims were followers under his spiritual authority."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh used his position as the Dera's spiritual leader and the follower relationship to obtain and control sexual access.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/8/28/gurmeet-ram-rahim-singh-sentenced-to-20-years-for-rape",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6dd5f9af5a469e2ce9eff208174a527225fc297c040963a54ef13d26a5063388",
"final_url": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/8/28/gurmeet-ram-rahim-singh-sentenced-to-20-years-for-rape"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-jodhpur-india",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Jodhpur, India",
"lat": 26.24,
"lng": 73.01,
"title": "Asaram Bapu: life imprisonment, rape of a minor under exorcism pretext",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asaram",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Asaram' [summarizing the verdict of the Jodhpur Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Court, Special Judge Madhusudhan Sharma, 25 April 2018]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'In 2018, Asaram was found guilty of the rape of a minor girl by Special Judge Madhusudhan Sharma of a special Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe court in Jodhpur and is currently serving life imprisonment in Jodhpur... In August 2013, a 16-year-old girl who was staying at Asaram's ashram in Manai village near Jodhpur, accused Asaram of sexually assaulting her on the night of 15 August at his Manai ashram in Jodhpur on the pretext of exorcising her from evil spirits.' The supernatural pretext — a claimed exorcism — is precisely the mechanism this survey documents."
},
{
"link": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/6699/6699_2022_7_1502_43582_Judgement_17-Apr-2023.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of India, Asaram v. State of Rajasthan, judgment (Apr. 17, 2023).",
"body": "The Supreme Court judgment records Asaram’s conviction and life sentence in the Jodhpur case while deciding a later petition concerning the sentence and medical treatment.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-record"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Asaram isolated the minor under the pretext that a private exorcism was needed to remove evil spirits, using guru authority and the ashram setting to obtain access.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asaram",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "944258bc12737d409faf42f59fc56fad35a8b9d2af8c5b1b677f723b977260a8",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asaram"
},
{
"source": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/6699/6699_2022_7_1502_43582_Judgement_17-Apr-2023.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d562d0a0e38b8d4f830e09a00ed92b84e11ec4108337a434b9f7e951ad584c29",
"final_url": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/6699/6699_2022_7_1502_43582_Judgement_17-Apr-2023.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-si-sa-ket-thailand",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Si Sa Ket, Thailand",
"lat": 15.12,
"lng": 104.33,
"title": "Wirapol Sukphol (ex-monk): 16 years, rape of a 13-year-old",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/10/17/jailed-thai-ex-monk-gets-further-16-years-for-raping-teen-girl",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Al Jazeera (2018) 'Jailed Thai ex-monk gets further 16 years for raping teen girl', Al Jazeera. Available at: aljazeera.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'A Thai court on Wednesday sentenced a former Buddhist monk known for his lavish lifestyle to 16 years in prison for raping a 13-year-old girl, whom he also impregnated... The court found him guilty of both offences, sentencing him to eight years for each.' Wirapol Sukphol, the so-called ‘jet-set monk’, had held monastic religious authority at the time of the offences."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant's monastic status and authority over a young follower created the religious trust and access documented in the conviction.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/10/17/jailed-thai-ex-monk-gets-further-16-years-for-raping-teen-girl",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "035b6cbe795380858ec1d860828d448e1897b3569f805cec750955b80e0e7c94",
"final_url": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/10/17/jailed-thai-ex-monk-gets-further-16-years-for-raping-teen-girl"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2024-hertfordshire-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Hertfordshire, UK",
"lat": 51.8,
"lng": -0.25,
"title": "Makhan Singh Mauji (granthi): 24+ years, sexual assaults on three girls",
"tradition": "sikhism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.easterneye.biz/sikh-leader-jail-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Eastern Eye (2024) 'Sikh leader sentenced to 24 years in jail for sexual abuse of girls', Eastern Eye. Available at: easterneye.biz (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'MAKHAN SINGH MAUJI, a Sikh celebrant, has been sentenced to more than 24 years in prison for sexually assaulting three girls between 1983 and 1987. A travelling granthi, Mauji conducted ceremonies and read the Guru Granth Sahib, Sikhism's holy scripture, across gurdwaras... Prosecutors explained that Mauji abused his position as a spiritual leader to ‘invade’ his victims' lives.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant used his position as a granthi and the trust attached to Sikh religious instruction to gain access to the children he assaulted.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-sikh",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.easterneye.biz/sikh-leader-jail-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "26d45ae6817a4da1c0bbbdac92e462b26d05cb1c41556d87db1e8d9165e4b13c",
"final_url": "https://www.easterneye.biz/sikh-leader-jail-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2011-kidwelly-wales",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Kidwelly, Wales",
"lat": 51.73,
"lng": -4.32,
"title": "Colin Batley occult sex cult: indeterminate sentence, min 11 years",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kidwelly_sex_cult",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Kidwelly sex cult' [summarizing the 2011 Swansea Crown Court convictions and BBC/court reporting]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Colin Batley was convicted in 2011 of leading an occult sex cult in Kidwelly, Wales, and received an indeterminate sentence with a minimum of 11 years; his convictions included eleven counts of rape. 'The sexual abuse was often preceded with satanic ceremonies in which passages from the occultist Aleister Crowley's books The Book of the Law, The Book of Magick, and Equinox of the Gods were read out.' The ritual apparatus was the instrument of control over child and adult victims — the same mechanism as the juju oaths documented above, worked here with appropriated Thelemic texts."
},
{
"link": "https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/mar/11/sex-cult-leader-colin-batley-sentenced",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Guardian, “Colin Batley, leader of sex cult preying on children, could spend life in jail” (Mar. 11, 2011).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records Batley’s convictions, indeterminate sentence with an eleven-year minimum, forced prostitution, and the occult rites used around the abuse.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Batley used occult ritual, initiation, and a claimed hierarchical order to normalize abuse, compel participation, and control victims.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kidwelly_sex_cult",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "30d4a073b894d4e3b9c03b53ff990e9bfdbe5c3dc2b9ac9bac744b8571f5908e",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kidwelly_sex_cult"
},
{
"source": "https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/mar/11/sex-cult-leader-colin-batley-sentenced",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6fde9fe163574d902769e8159c0fadb9d481c217f066f63ab3a610a2f5c39b55",
"final_url": "https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/mar/11/sex-cult-leader-colin-batley-sentenced"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2021-london-uk",
"year": 2021,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 51.59,
"lng": -0.29,
"title": "Danyal Hussein: life, murders of Bibaa Henry & Nicole Smallman (blood-pact)",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murders_of_Bibaa_Henry_and_Nicole_Smallman",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Murders of Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman' [summarizing the Old Bailey conviction and sentencing before Mrs Justice Whipple, and BBC court reporting]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Hussein was convicted of both murders on 6 July 2021... In October 2021 Mrs Justice Whipple sentenced him to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 35 years.' Danyal Hussein murdered sisters Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman in a London park. 'Hussein had drawn up a handwritten contract, signed in his own blood, which states that he had made a pact with Lucifuge Rofocale, a demon mentioned in the Grand Grimoire, a historic black magic text, to murder six women every six months in return for financial reward... Hussein was a viewer of videos by American self-styled occultist Matthew Lawrence, also known as E. A. Koetting... Hussein was active on Lawrence's Satanic-themed internet forum, Becoming A Living God, on which Hussein alleged he was a ‘psychic vampire’ and asked for advice about demonic pacts.' Note: the killer's consumption of Koetting's published material is documented by police evidence; there is no evidence Koetting knew of or communicated with Hussein, and Koetting is not accused of any crime."
},
{
"link": "https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/r-v-danyal-hussein-sentencing-remarks/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Central Criminal Court, R v Danyal Hussein, sentencing remarks of Mrs Justice Whipple (Oct. 28, 2021).",
"body": "The official sentencing remarks record the two murder convictions, the blood pact and promised killings, and the life sentence with a thirty-five-year minimum term.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "sentencing-remarks"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Hussein entered a blood pact promising murders to a purported demon in exchange for supernatural reward; the pact supplied the stated occult motive for the killings.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murders_of_Bibaa_Henry_and_Nicole_Smallman",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cb9e120537acb8dc3c1f3d4bf89220c0c63311bce78ad4d7a372d58c28ddbec9",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murders_of_Bibaa_Henry_and_Nicole_Smallman"
},
{
"source": "https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/r-v-danyal-hussein-sentencing-remarks/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: sentencing-remarks.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "22e801996bb563da41fb40a9d82cd33bcb1b2b1db054a0c6bd183f6806f0097e",
"final_url": "https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/r-v-danyal-hussein-sentencing-remarks/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2022-vicenza-italy",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Vicenza, Italy",
"lat": 45.54,
"lng": 11.56,
"title": "Ethan Melzer (O9A): 45 years, plot to ambush his own Army unit",
"tradition": "left-hand-path",
"type": "state-terror",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://taskandpurpose.com/news/neo-nazi-ex-soldier-ethan-melzer-sentenced-45-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Task & Purpose (2023) 'Neo-Nazi ex soldier sentenced to 45 years for plotting to murder soldiers', Task & Purpose [reporting the US DOJ/SDNY prosecution]. Available at: taskandpurpose.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Former Army soldier Ethan Melzer was sentenced to more than four decades in prison for an attempted plot to ambush and kill his comrades in a ‘jihadi attack’ while deployed abroad. Melzer... was a member of the Order of Nine Angles, a Neo-Nazi and Satanic organization which has praised both Adolf Hitler and al-Qaeda. Melzer pleaded guilty in June 2022 to charges of attempted murder of U.S. Army soldiers, illegally sharing national security information and providing and attempting to provide terrorists with material support.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/former-us-army-soldier-sentenced-45-years-prison-attempting-murder-fellow-service-members",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, “Former U.S. Army Soldier Sentenced to 45 Years in Prison for Attempting to Murder Fellow Service Members in Deadly Ambush” (Mar. 3, 2023).",
"body": "The Justice Department records Ethan Melzer’s guilty pleas, forty-five-year sentence, O9A membership, and use of the group’s violent occult-extremist ideology in planning the attempted ambush.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"occult ideological network participant"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"violent occult ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"order-of-nine-angles"
],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2023-03-03",
"outcome": "Forty-five-year federal prison sentence following guilty pleas to attempted murder, terrorism-support and national-defense-information offenses."
}
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents violent occult ideology, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is occult ideological network participant.",
"scopeNote": "OUT OF SCOPE AS AUTHORITY ABUSE — outward-directed ideological violence. Melzer's plot targeted soldiers of his own unit, over whom he held no spiritual authority. Occult ideology supplied motive, not power over a victim, which is the distinction the archive draws between religious terror and religious terrorism. Retained as context because the doctrinal element is documented and adjudicated, but it is not counted as authority abuse. Compare the pruning of David Copeland's nail bombings and five UK Order of Nine Angles possession convictions on the same ground.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"traditionDetailId": "occult-left-hand-path",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://taskandpurpose.com/news/neo-nazi-ex-soldier-ethan-melzer-sentenced-45-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7dd8de7e92ee1cd0f12e2ac628c999ebb7f67b115e7dcf27dfd2ec344158b025",
"final_url": "https://taskandpurpose.com/news/neo-nazi-ex-soldier-ethan-melzer-sentenced-45-years/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/former-us-army-soldier-sentenced-45-years-prison-attempting-murder-fellow-service-members",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ce75311bbfc66ceff17fb3997230471b19455edd4912dbe9cf6537345d232592",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/former-us-army-soldier-sentenced-45-years-prison-attempting-murder-fellow-service-members"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2025-tucson-az-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Tucson, AZ, USA",
"lat": 32.18,
"lng": -110.95,
"title": "Baron Martin (764 network): DOJ terrorism-support charges (indictment — charges only)",
"tradition": "left-hand-path",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "indictment",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://abcnews.go.com/US/doj-brings-terrorism-charge-alleged-member-764-network/story?id=126990857",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ABC News (2025) 'DOJ, in a first, brings terrorism charge against alleged member of 764 network', ABC News. Available at: abcnews.go.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'The Justice Department has filed terrorism charges against an Arizona man for his alleged role in the growing network of online predators known as ‘764,’ whose worldwide followers use social media platforms to target, groom and push young teens into harming themselves and others... An indictment unsealed Thursday in Arizona charged 21-year-old Baron Martin of Tucson with conspiracy to provide material support to terrorists, marking the first time that the Justice Department has leveled such charges against an alleged member of 764.' 764 emerged from the Satanist-accelerationist online milieu adjacent to the Order of Nine Angles. Note: these are charges; the defendant is presumed innocent unless convicted."
},
{
"link": "https://abcnews.go.com/US/doj-charges-former-navy-petty-officer-4-alleged/story?id=128072704",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ABC News (2026) 'DOJ charges former Navy sailor, 4 others for alleged roles in 'monstrous' online extortion group', ABC News. Available at: abcnews.go.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'The Justice Department has indicted a former Navy sailor and four others for allegedly leading an online extortion group that authorities say later helped spawn the global extremist network known as ‘764’. An indictment unsealed Tuesday alleges that the earlier group, calling themselves ‘Greggy's Cult,’ engaged in a criminal enterprise that pushed young victims they found online to create child pornography.' Note: these are charges; the defendants are presumed innocent unless convicted."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"network administrator"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"online grooming",
"threats",
"violent occult ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"764"
],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies online grooming, threats, and violent occult ideology as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is network administrator.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"traditionDetailId": "occult-left-hand-path",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The cited sources report charges or a pending proceeding. This record does not establish a finding of guilt or a final disposition.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://abcnews.go.com/US/doj-brings-terrorism-charge-alleged-member-764-network/story?id=126990857",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "abe626772dc76ef4b69672c78321c22c772e16ead45fb7c07172bb8b4b4fd919",
"final_url": "https://abcnews.com/US/doj-brings-terrorism-charge-alleged-member-764-network/story?id=126990857"
},
{
"source": "https://abcnews.go.com/US/doj-charges-former-navy-petty-officer-4-alleged/story?id=128072704",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fc19c4c42954760321f7945787f2f4afaf3274f769d089b1052f82bddee82274",
"final_url": "https://abcnews.com/US/doj-charges-former-navy-petty-officer-4-alleged/story?id=128072704"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2009-buffalo-ny-usa",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Buffalo, NY, USA",
"lat": 42.88,
"lng": -78.84,
"title": "US v. Tills: retired judge, 18 months, Mann Act (Royal Order of Jesters)",
"tradition": "fraternal",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2010/apr/15/retired-new-york-supreme-court-justice-sentenced-to-prison-for-sex-trafficking/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Prison Legal News (2010) 'Retired New York Supreme Court Justice Sentenced to Prison for Sex Trafficking', Prison Legal News [reporting United States v. Tills, No. 1:08-cr-00242, W.D.N.Y.]. Available at: prisonlegalnews.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Retired New York Supreme Court Justice Ronald H. Tills, 74, has been sentenced to 18 months in federal prison for a felony charge of transporting prostitutes across state lines (a violation of the Mann Act).' The prosecution arose from an FBI investigation into the ‘Royal Order of Jesters, a Masonic group that has 191 chapters and 22,000 members nationwide’; per contemporaneous court reporting in the Lockport Journal, women were transported ‘to Ashland, Ky., for a conference of the Royal Order of Jesters’, and two other members — a retired police captain and a former court law clerk — were also convicted. Note: these convictions concern named individuals and one chapter's conduct, not Freemasonry or the Jesters organization as a whole."
},
{
"link": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/buffalo/press-releases/2011/former-erie-county-sheriffs-deputy-sentenced-for-failing-to-report-jester-prostitution-in-canada",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, Western District of New York, \"Former Erie County Sheriff's Deputy Sentenced for Failing to Report Jester Prostitution in Canada\" (Apr. 11, 2011).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records Michael Lesinski's conviction and sentence, his transport of women to a Royal Order of Jesters national convention in Canada, commercial sex with members, and his effort to conceal the offense from customs officials.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Royal Order of Jesters member",
"former judicial and law-enforcement officials"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"interstate and international transportation for prostitution",
"concealment through official access"
],
"organizations": [
"Royal Order of Jesters"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Western District of New York (No. 1:08-cr-00242-WMS)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing — Ronald H. Tills",
"date": "2009-08-13",
"outcome": "Ronald H. Tills, retired New York Supreme Court Justice, pleaded guilty in September 2008 to transporting women across state lines for prostitution in connection with Royal Order of Jesters gatherings, and was sentenced to 18 months' imprisonment and a $25,000 fine. Among the facts: Tills recruited a woman who had appeared before him in court — an abuse of judicial office."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Western District of New York",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing — John Trowbridge",
"date": "2009-05-07",
"outcome": "John Trowbridge, retired Lockport police captain, pleaded guilty on 20 March 2008 and was sentenced to two years' probation and a $10,000 fine."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Western District of New York",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing — Michael Stebick",
"date": "2008-12-09",
"outcome": "Michael Stebick, Tills's law clerk, pleaded guilty and was sentenced to four months' home confinement, two years' probation, a $5,000 fine and forfeiture of the motor home used to transport the women."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Western District of New York",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing — Michael Lesinski",
"outcome": "Michael Lesinski, retired Erie County sheriff's deputy, pleaded guilty on 19 November 2010 to concealing prostitution offences connected to a Jesters convention and was sentenced in April 2011. Exact sentencing date not established from available records."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Western District of New York",
"stage": "related disposition — brothel operator",
"date": "2008-11-20",
"outcome": "Len Wah Chong, the brothel operator who supplied the trafficked women (not a Jesters member), was sentenced to six years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "See citation",
"stage": "primary-source citation recovered",
"outcome": "In the Matter of Ronald H. Tills, a Suspended Attorney, Resignor — N.Y. App. Div., 4th Dept., 67 A.D.3d 1457, 887 N.Y.S.2d 905, resignation accepted and name stricken from roll of attorneys, filed 2009-11-13 (order dated Oct. 29, 2009). Corroborates identity of Ronald H. Tills (retired NY Supreme Court Justice) shortly after his federal Mann Act sentencing. Not a criminal appellate opinion — no such opinion exists for US v. Tills (No. 1:08-cr-00242-WMS, W.D.N.Y.). Source: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9463934/in-re-tills/"
}
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents interstate and international transportation for prostitution and concealment through official access, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is Royal Order of Jesters member and former judicial and law-enforcement officials.",
"scopeNote": "The federal record establishes prostitution-related conduct at Jesters events and convictions of named members or associates. It does not establish that Masonic belief, ritual or spiritual authority coerced the women, so the record remains context rather than a core map case. N2 QUESTION SETTLED (2026-07): the federal record was checked directly for any indication that the victims were subject to the defendants' religious or ritual authority. There is none. The coercion mechanism was money and the women's vulnerability, including undocumented status; no source states the women were members, initiates, or under any Masonic spiritual authority. Tills's additional abuse was of JUDICIAL office. The context classification is confirmed, not provisional. The alleged Brazil sex-tourism strand was investigated by the DOJ, which declined to prosecute; a civil TVPA suit proceeded against a commercial tour operator who was not a Jesters member. No criminal conviction exists on that strand.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "fraternal-orders",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2010/apr/15/retired-new-york-supreme-court-justice-sentenced-to-prison-for-sex-trafficking/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3bc205dac261ce0593946cf216fc0f87e0390c38726e5eebeec2e63d7cbbf1c7",
"final_url": "https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2010/apr/15/retired-new-york-supreme-court-justice-sentenced-to-prison-for-sex-trafficking/"
},
{
"source": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/buffalo/press-releases/2011/former-erie-county-sheriffs-deputy-sentenced-for-failing-to-report-jester-prostitution-in-canada",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "65fb3a4aa71f9a84a552d3f471fbaf83a79d9aa468ef4c59a218e6de4f85c67d",
"final_url": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/buffalo/press-releases/2011/former-erie-county-sheriffs-deputy-sentenced-for-failing-to-report-jester-prostitution-in-canada"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2012-birmingham-uk",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Birmingham, UK",
"lat": 52.49,
"lng": -1.91,
"title": "Naila Mumtaz: four family members convicted of murder in jinn-'exorcism' smothering",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/09/24/naila-mumtaz-killed-evil-spirit-jailed-life-murder_n_1908899.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "HuffPost UK (2012) 'Naila Mumtaz: Husband And Family Jailed For Life After Killing Pregnant Wife 'Possessed By Evil Spirit'', HuffPost UK, 24 September. Available at: huffingtonpost.co.uk (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Naila Mumtaz, 21 and pregnant, was smothered at her Birmingham home in 2009: 'The trial heard evidence that Naila, 21, was killed during attempts to render her unconscious as family members attempted to drive out a harmful “jinn” spirit.' Her husband, his parents and her brother-in-law 'were convicted of the more serious charge [murder] following a 12-week trial'; all four received life sentences with minimum terms of 13 to 15 years at Birmingham Crown Court. The direct parallel of the Climbié and Bamu killings above: a possession belief, turned lethal on a family member."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Family members attributed Naila Mumtaz's condition to jinn possession and killed her during a purported exorcism.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/09/24/naila-mumtaz-killed-evil-spirit-jailed-life-murder_n_1908899.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9e3291c65323a145f5f40420e36dce2d23e554036da73fffc22654312e296507",
"final_url": "https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/09/24/naila-mumtaz-killed-evil-spirit-jailed-life-murder_n_1908899.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2026-london-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 51.59,
"lng": 0.04,
"title": "Imam Abdul Halim Khan: life, 21 sexual offences; victims' beliefs used to silence them (CPS)",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/former-imam-jailed-sexually-abusing-seven-women-and-girls",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crown Prosecution Service (2026) 'Former imam jailed for sexually abusing seven women and girls', CPS, 14 May. Available at: cps.gov.uk (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Abdul Halim Khan, an imam at an east London mosque, 'was sentenced to life imprisonment to serve a minimum term of 20 years at Snaresbrook Crown Court', having been 'convicted of 21 offences, including rape, sexual assault and child sexual offences, against seven women and girls between 2004 and 2015.' Per the Crown Prosecution Service: 'He used their deeply held beliefs to instil fear and silence them, making them believe their families would be at risk if they ever spoke out', and he 'used his position as a trusted religious leader within the community to gain access to his victims'. An official prosecutorial source — the same supernatural-fear silencing mechanism documented throughout this survey."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The imam used religious authority and victims' beliefs about obedience, shame, and spiritual consequence to obtain access and discourage disclosure.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/former-imam-jailed-sexually-abusing-seven-women-and-girls",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8caa05178f81ad3f18b0c550114f47cb851024704a72f386dee12dee6425b0bd",
"final_url": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/former-imam-jailed-sexually-abusing-seven-women-and-girls"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2012-kingston-on-canada",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Kingston, ON, Canada",
"lat": 44.21,
"lng": -76.46,
"title": "Shafia murders: three convicted of killing four family members ('twisted notion of honour' — the judge)",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "honor-killing",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/remarks-to-the-court-by-shafia-judge/article1360070/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Globe and Mail (2012) 'Remarks to the court by Shafia judge' [sentencing remarks of Justice Robert Maranger, Ontario Superior Court, Kingston], 29 January. Available at: theglobeandmail.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Mohammad Shafia, his wife Tooba Yahya and son Hamed were convicted of drowning three teenage daughters and Shafia's first wife in Kingston, Ontario. From the judge's own sentencing remarks: 'You have each been convicted of the planned and deliberate murder of four members of your family... The apparent reason behind these cold-blooded shameful murders was that the four completely innocent victims offended your twisted notion of honour, a notion of honour that is founded upon the domination and control of women, a sick notion of honour that has absolutely no place in any civilized society.' Each received life with no parole eligibility for 25 years. Note: the court framed the motive as a distorted familial 'honour' code, not as religious doctrine — a distinction the record supports and this survey preserves."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The perpetrators invoked a religiously framed concept of family honor to police behavior and justify the killings; the trial judge expressly rejected that justification as a distorted notion of honor.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/remarks-to-the-court-by-shafia-judge/article1360070/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "457a6886c48ebabb4cda445e340e3054254d8f0b4132d37e3c96b8727ef297f7",
"final_url": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/remarks-to-the-court-by-shafia-judge/article1360070/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-harrisburg-pa-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Harrisburg, PA, USA",
"lat": 40.25,
"lng": -76.9,
"title": "PA grand jury: 301 priests, 1,000+ child victims documented ('weaponized' faith)",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_jury_investigation_of_Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_in_Pennsylvania",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Grand jury investigation of Catholic Church sexual abuse in Pennsylvania' [summarizing the 40th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury report, released 14 August 2018]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "The 2018 Pennsylvania grand jury report found that '301 priests' were accused of 'sexually abusing more than 1,000 children' across six dioceses, with 'likely thousands more victims whose records were lost or who were too afraid to come forward.' It remains the largest single official documentation of clergy abuse in the United States."
},
{
"link": "https://www.yahoo.com/news/prosecutor-priests-weaponized-faith-abuse-044327356.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press (2018) 'Prosecutor: Priests ‘weaponized’ the faith to abuse kids', AP via Yahoo News, 15 August. Available at: yahoo.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'A landmark grand jury report on clergy abuse in six Roman Catholic dioceses in Pennsylvania detailed how priests often used religious rituals, symbols of the faith and the threat of eternity in hell to groom, molest and rape children.' One priest told a boy he was abusing that it was acceptable because the priest was 'an instrument of God'; children were told they would 'go to hell' if they disclosed, and that 'nobody would believe a lying child over a man of God's word.' A bishop acknowledged that one priest 'invoked the name of God to justify his actions against his victims while using their faith and the priesthood to manipulate them and secure their silence.' This is, precisely, the juju-oath mechanism — supernatural consequence deployed to guarantee a victim's silence — worked from a pulpit rather than a shrine."
},
{
"link": "https://www.pacourts.us/news-and-statistics/cases-of-public-interest/fortieth-statewide-investigating-grand-jury",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania, Fortieth Statewide Investigating Grand Jury case record (2018-2023).",
"body": "Pennsylvania’s judiciary publishes the interim and final redacted grand jury reports, responses, and appellate opinions concerning the investigation of child sexual abuse and institutional concealment across six dioceses.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "grand-jury-record"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The grand jury documented clergy using sacramental, pastoral, and institutional authority to obtain access, command trust, silence children, and conceal abuse.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_jury_investigation_of_Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_in_Pennsylvania",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cb54b9a37dd4236c51910636fb34610da3e28098c5919bcaa881d991d72fda77",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_jury_investigation_of_Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_in_Pennsylvania"
},
{
"source": "https://www.yahoo.com/news/prosecutor-priests-weaponized-faith-abuse-044327356.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3559053e05cce4636cd8e6122db3447eeff4dbe16c4f4a75199fd315e6475dad",
"final_url": "https://www.yahoo.com/news/prosecutor-priests-weaponized-faith-abuse-044327356.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.pacourts.us/news-and-statistics/cases-of-public-interest/fortieth-statewide-investigating-grand-jury",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: grand-jury-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d3f629923da06c1a65c90d83591fc037bf9d7bc937a318b92c68f40655af5a8d",
"final_url": "https://www.pacourts.us/news-and-statistics/cases-of-public-interest/fortieth-statewide-investigating-grand-jury"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2009-dublin-ireland",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Dublin, Ireland",
"lat": 53.35,
"lng": -6.26,
"title": "Ryan Commission: abuse 'endemic' in Catholic-run institutions (state inquiry)",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-children-disability-and-equality/publications/the-report-of-the-commission-to-inquire-into-child-abuse-the-ryan-report/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Government of Ireland, “The Report of the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (The Ryan Report).”",
"body": "The Irish government page provides the statutory inquiry report and implementation record concerning abuse in residential institutions.",
"tier": "official-inquiry",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Catholic religious orders exercised custodial and spiritual authority in residential institutions where the state inquiry found endemic abuse and institutional concealment.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-children-disability-and-equality/publications/the-report-of-the-commission-to-inquire-into-child-abuse-the-ryan-report/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2021-paris-france",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Paris, France",
"lat": 48.85,
"lng": 2.34,
"title": "CIASE/Sauvé Report: est. 216,000 abused by French clergy since 1950",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ciase.fr/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission indépendante sur les abus sexuels dans l’Église (CIASE), final report portal (Oct. 5, 2021).",
"body": "CIASE’s official portal publishes the commission’s final report, English materials, annexes, methods, and hearing records.",
"tier": "official-inquiry",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The official commission documented how clerical status, sacramental access, and church control over reporting enabled abuse and long-term concealment.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ciase.fr/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a7630cd113d997c4f00da2fd30f7a74a26ac33aba92fb61bf0f3b9c7dfa72b94",
"final_url": "https://www.ciase.fr/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2019-vatican-city",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Vatican City",
"lat": 41.87,
"lng": 12.46,
"title": "McCarrick: ex-cardinal found guilty by Vatican canonical process, laicized",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodore_McCarrick",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Theodore McCarrick' [summarizing the Vatican Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith's canonical verdict of January 2019 and the Massachusetts criminal proceedings]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "The highest-ranking finding of guilt in the modern Church: ex-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick 'was found guilty of sexual crimes against adults and minors and abuse of power and was dismissed from the clerical state in 2019' by the Vatican's own canonical process, which found him guilty of 'solicitation in the Sacrament of Confession, and sins against the Sixth Commandment with minors and with adults, with the aggravating factor of the abuse of power.' Note: his separate Massachusetts criminal case was dismissed in 2023 solely because the court ruled him 'mentally incompetent to stand trial' — not an acquittal, and not a conviction; the standing finding of guilt is the Vatican's."
},
{
"link": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/it/bollettino/pubblico/2019/02/16/0133/00272.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Holy See Press Office, “Communiqué of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith” (Feb. 16, 2019).",
"body": "The Vatican communiqué records the final canonical finding against Theodore McCarrick for solicitation in confession, offenses involving minors and adults, and abuse of power, followed by dismissal from the clerical state.",
"tier": "official-finding",
"kind": "canonical-disposition"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The canonical finding concerned abuse of clerical power, including solicitation connected to confession and offenses committed through McCarrick's status as a senior church authority.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodore_McCarrick",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e4aa41ca4fd861b0b6e6a9d93750a1105649485c542d2b386a787332c60aa5c8",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodore_McCarrick"
},
{
"source": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/it/bollettino/pubblico/2019/02/16/0133/00272.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding; evidentiary role: canonical-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6313d600dc62e76d28acbb23d1fd82b8d01d6a07874cdfa3c7618549cd94a391",
"final_url": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/it/bollettino/pubblico/2019/02/16/0133/00272.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2010-oregon-city-or-usa",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Oregon City, OR, USA",
"lat": 45.36,
"lng": -122.62,
"title": "Beagley faith-healing death: parents convicted (criminally negligent homicide)",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jeff-and-marci-beagley-gave-sick-son-prayer-instead-of-medicine-jury-gives-them-guilty-verdict/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News (2010) 'Jeff and Marci Beagley Gave Sick Son Prayer Instead of Medicine, Jury Gives Them Guilty Verdict', CBS News. Available at: cbsnews.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Members of Oregon's Followers of Christ church, the Beagleys withheld medical care from their 16-year-old son Neil on religious grounds. 'The couple, who practices faith healing, was convicted of criminally negligent homicide... Neil Beagley died of complications from a congenital urinary tract blockage' — a treatable condition. 'Members of the church, including the Beagleys, are known to avoid doctors in favor of faith healing.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "See citation",
"stage": "primary-source citation recovered",
"outcome": "State v. Beagley, 257 Or. App. 220, 305 P.3d 147 (Or. Ct. App. 2013), filed 2013-06-19, Schuman, P.J. Consolidated direct appeal, docket Nos. CR0801358/A145054 (Jeffrey Dean Beagley) and CR0801359/A145194 (Marci Rae Beagley). Affirms both defendants' criminally negligent homicide convictions (ORS 163.145) arising from the death of their 16-year-old son Neil after withholding conventional medical care on religious grounds. Existing record's proceedings array is currently empty and should be populated with this appellate stage. Source: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/7051828/state-v-beagley/"
}
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The parents relied on faith healing instead of medical care, treating prayer as the required response to a child's life-threatening illness.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jeff-and-marci-beagley-gave-sick-son-prayer-instead-of-medicine-jury-gives-them-guilty-verdict/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c756c3aaa4712dce3f8410bd4091a389095ad0998fdfb7771bb1e788dde8716e",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jeff-and-marci-beagley-gave-sick-son-prayer-instead-of-medicine-jury-gives-them-guilty-verdict/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2014-philadelphia-pa-usa",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Philadelphia, PA, USA",
"lat": 39.96,
"lng": -75.17,
"title": "Schaible: 3rd-degree murder, second child dead of untreated pneumonia",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.inquirer.com/philly/news/20150916_Appeals_court_lets_stand_the_Schaibles__31_2-7-year-prison_sentences_for_3rd-degree_murder.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Philadelphia Inquirer (2015) 'Appeals court lets stand the Schaibles' 3½-7-year prison sentences for 3rd-degree murder', 16 September. Available at: inquirer.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Herbert and Catherine Schaible 'pleaded no-contest to third-degree murder' after their '8-month-old son died of pneumonia in April 2013 because they believed in healing through prayer, not medicine.' The aggravating fact: 'At the time, the Schaibles were on 10 years' probation for the 2009 death of another son, 2, who also died of pneumonia' — a second child lost to the same belief after a court had already intervened."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The parents withheld medical care because their church taught reliance on prayer and faith healing, leading to a second child's preventable death.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.inquirer.com/philly/news/20150916_Appeals_court_lets_stand_the_Schaibles__31_2-7-year-prison_sentences_for_3rd-degree_murder.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3b025a28123cda6c638ae9eaff797e4ca40b6ef18497c4048d4ed9fb28d607ff",
"final_url": "https://www.inquirer.com/philly/news/20150916_Appeals_court_lets_stand_the_Schaibles__31_2-7-year-prison_sentences_for_3rd-degree_murder.html"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2001-london-uk-2",
"year": 2001,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 51.52,
"lng": -0.11,
"title": "Victoria Climbié: murder convictions; possession belief; Laming Inquiry followed",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Victoria_Climbi%C3%A9",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Murder of Victoria Climbié' [summarizing the Old Bailey convictions of January 2001 and the Laming public inquiry]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Victoria Climbié, an eight-year-old Ivorian girl, was tortured to death in London in 2000 by her great-aunt Marie-Thérèse Kouao and Carl Manning, who believed her injuries and behaviour reflected demonic possession: a pastor consulted by Kouao 'offered prayers for Victoria to cast out the devil, and thought that her injuries were due to demonic possession.' 'Both Kouao and Manning were convicted of murder, and sentenced to life imprisonment.' The case prompted the Laming public inquiry and reshaped British child-protection law. The deliverance theology involved was Christian — turned against an African-diaspora child branded a witch."
},
{
"link": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-victoria-climbie-inquiry-report-of-an-inquiry-by-lord-laming",
"archive": "",
"citation": "UK Department of Health and Social Care, The Victoria Climbié Inquiry: report of an inquiry by Lord Laming (2003).",
"body": "The official inquiry report examines Victoria Climbié’s death, the criminal convictions, contacts with religious and public institutions, and the safeguarding failures that preceded her death.",
"tier": "official-inquiry",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Victoria Climbié was accused of spirit possession, and that belief was used to rationalize repeated punishment and torture presented as deliverance.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Victoria_Climbi%C3%A9",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "63cf090283f5fb31ec3dd07e6b003b7392a81bd67742d66ec7690f08c16c18f8",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Victoria_Climbi%C3%A9"
},
{
"source": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-victoria-climbie-inquiry-report-of-an-inquiry-by-lord-laming",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "95936c9574b83a3342499efd3db941fe99e0961cc2f19ce3ea04bce675a226dd",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-victoria-climbie-inquiry-report-of-an-inquiry-by-lord-laming"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2012-london-uk",
"year": 2012,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 51.44,
"lng": -0.18,
"title": "Kristy Bamu: kindoki 'deliverance' murder convictions (30/25-yr minimums)",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.channel4.com/news/witchcraft-murder-couple-jailed-for-life",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Channel 4 News (2012) 'Witchcraft murder: couple jailed for life', Channel 4 News. Available at: channel4.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Fifteen-year-old Kristy Bamu was tortured and drowned in London in 2010 by his sister Magalie Bamu and her partner Eric Bikubi. 'The couple – who were said to be obsessed with witchcraft, or kindoki as it is known in their native Democratic Republic of Congo – accused him of putting spells on a younger child... After he refused to admit to sorcery and witchcraft, his punishments in a ‘deliverance’ ceremony became more horrendous.' 'Judge David Paget sentenced Bikubi to serve at least 30 years and Bamu a minimum of 25 years for their ‘sadistic’ crimes', ruling that 'The belief in witchcraft, however genuine, cannot excuse an assault to another person, let alone the killing of another human being.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Kristy Bamu was accused of kindoki, or witchcraft, and tortured during a purported deliverance intended to expel the alleged spiritual influence.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.channel4.com/news/witchcraft-murder-couple-jailed-for-life",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7122349ef43c1b6308c1967042b9f8bce9d77c8b2cf7d08d18ede1c0edf30852",
"final_url": "https://www.channel4.com/news/witchcraft-murder-couple-jailed-for-life"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2022-bisbee-az-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Bisbee, AZ, USA",
"lat": 31.46,
"lng": -109.94,
"title": "LDS 'help line' case (AP/court records): abuse continued 7 yrs; wife convicted",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.azfamily.com/2022/08/04/seven-years-sex-abuse-bisbee-how-mormon-officials-let-it-happen/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "AZFamily / Associated Press (2022) 'Seven years of sex abuse in Bisbee: How Mormon officials let it happen' [AP investigation built on unsealed court records], 4 August. Available at: azfamily.com (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "The AP's investigation of the LDS Church's abuse 'help line', from unsealed court records: when a Bisbee, Arizona bishop reported a father's ongoing abuse, 'church attorneys in Salt Lake City who staff the help line around the clock said that because he learned of the abuse during a counseling session the church considers a spiritual confession, he was legally bound to keep the abuse secret.' Paul Adams 'continued abusing his daughter for as many as seven more years'; he 'died by suicide in jail before he could stand trial on federal child pornography charges and state child sex abuse charges', and his wife 'pleaded no contest to two counts of child abuse and served two-and-a-half years in state prison.' Note: the help-line mechanism is documented in unsealed records as reported by AP; no court has entered a finding of liability against the church itself in this matter."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"church bishop",
"institutional safeguarding system"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority",
"institutional reporting control"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious authority and institutional reporting control as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is church bishop and institutional safeguarding system.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.azfamily.com/2022/08/04/seven-years-sex-abuse-bisbee-how-mormon-officials-let-it-happen/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0844f90c108c69e132a03db6f65f5943baff5e886f55d0c04ffe70358e3868d8",
"final_url": "https://www.azfamily.com/2022/08/04/seven-years-sex-abuse-bisbee-how-mormon-officials-let-it-happen/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2023-west-bountiful-ut-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "West Bountiful, UT, USA",
"lat": 40.9,
"lng": -111.89,
"title": "Carl Matthew Johnson (LDS bishop, ex-mayor): 9-to-life, child sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kuer.org/race-religion-social-justice/2023-03-02/former-west-bountiful-mayor-lds-church-bishop-gets-prison-for-child-sex-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KUER 90.1 (2023) 'Former West Bountiful mayor, LDS Church bishop gets prison for child sex abuse', KUER (NPR Utah), 2 March. Available at: kuer.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "A standing conviction of an LDS bishop: Carl Matthew Johnson, a former mayor and bishop, 'pleaded guilty in January to four counts of sexual abuse of a child in a plea deal that resulted in several other charges being dismissed. The judge gave him the maximum sentence of nine years to life for three first degree felonies and one to 15 years for a second degree felony count, all to run consecutively.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"LDS bishop"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious office",
"access to a minor"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious office and access to a minor as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is LDS bishop.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kuer.org/race-religion-social-justice/2023-03-02/former-west-bountiful-mayor-lds-church-bishop-gets-prison-for-child-sex-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "949c11fa321d03fe0ebfc0e0306b25864d25345f4c2cc271de488f7b8d40e953",
"final_url": "https://www.kuer.org/race-religion-social-justice/2023-03-02/former-west-bountiful-mayor-lds-church-bishop-gets-prison-for-child-sex-abuse"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2016-sydney-australia",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Sydney, Australia",
"lat": -33.88,
"lng": 151.2,
"title": "Royal Commission Case Study 29: 1,006 alleged JW perpetrators, none reported to police",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_cases_in_Australia",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse (2017) Final Report, Vol. 16 [figures as summarized at Wikipedia; primary at childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "Australia's Royal Commission — the country's highest form of public inquiry — collected the Church's own claims data: 'By means of a weighted index, the commission found that at 75 archdioceses/dioceses and religious institutes with priest members examined, some 7% of priests (who worked in Australia between 1950 and 2009) were alleged perpetrators (this finding did not represent allegations tested in a court of law)', with 'at least 1,880 suspected abusers' identified in claims from 1980 to 2015. The commission's own caveat — allegations, not convictions — is preserved here deliberately: it is what honest documentation looks like."
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jehovah%27s_Witnesses%27_handling_of_child_sexual_abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Jehovah's Witnesses' handling of child sexual abuse' [summarizing Case Study 29 of the Australian Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, 2015-16]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "Australia's Royal Commission examined the Jehovah's Witnesses' own records: 'the Watch Tower Society had produced 5,000 documents relating to 1,006 case files of allegations of child sexual abuse reported to Jehovah's Witness elders in Australia since 1950—each file for a different alleged perpetrator of child sexual abuse, including 579 cases in which the perpetrator confessed.' The commission found the organization did not report these allegations to police, under a doctrinal system that includes the 'two-witness rule.' Note: figures per the commission's official record as summarized above; the commission's own site was unreachable at re-verification and the primary PDF citation is retained in its records."
},
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/media-releases/report-jehovahs-witness-organisations-released",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, “Report into Jehovah’s Witness organisations released” (Nov. 28, 2016).",
"body": "The Royal Commission’s official release records Case Study 29’s examination of 1,006 alleged perpetrators in organizational files and findings that the organization did not adequately respond to child sexual abuse.",
"tier": "official-inquiry",
"kind": "case-study-report"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The Royal Commission documented how internal religious authority, the two-witness rule, and organizational reporting practices obstructed disclosure and outside safeguarding.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_cases_in_Australia",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f03240ec5cd0de18c4b458f851f3291a31a7c3e9fc826636ab6da71cf7f1c36f",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_cases_in_Australia"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jehovah%27s_Witnesses%27_handling_of_child_sexual_abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1a1f7ef36424180c7215f0b350589e69a2d8b80009074195d9f044a69773253c",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jehovah%27s_Witnesses%27_handling_of_child_sexual_abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/media-releases/report-jehovahs-witness-organisations-released",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry; evidentiary role: case-study-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2009-paris-france",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Paris, France",
"lat": 48.78,
"lng": 2.12,
"title": "Church of Scientology convicted of organized fraud (upheld 2013)",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/french-court-upholds-scientology-fraud-conviction/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News (2012) 'French court upholds Scientology fraud conviction', CBS News; and JURIST (2013) 'France high court upholds Scientology fraud conviction'. Available at: cbsnews.com / jurist.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'A French appeals court on Thursday upheld the Church of Scientology's 2009 fraud conviction on charges it pressured members into paying large sums for questionable remedies... The case began with a legal complaint by a young woman who said she took out loans and spent the equivalent of $28,000 on books, courses and ‘purification packages’ after being recruited in 1998.' France's highest court confirmed the conviction in 2013: 'The original ruling convicted Scientology's Celebrity Centre and bookstore in Paris of fraud following numerous instances of pressuring members... into paying large sums for questionable services and materials.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Scientology organizations pressured members to purchase courses, books, and purification services presented as necessary remedies for spiritual advancement.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-scientology",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/french-court-upholds-scientology-fraud-conviction/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5051bd6cea3dca329c7dc9b9a23c374fb10d1cab2513d23fd14be33e0f2b4087",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/french-court-upholds-scientology-fraud-conviction/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "1979-washington-dc-usa",
"year": 1979,
"place": "Washington, DC, USA",
"lat": 38.84,
"lng": -76.97,
"title": "Operation Snow White: 11 senior Scientology officials convicted",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Snow_White",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Operation Snow White' [summarizing United States v. Mary Sue Hubbard et al., 493 F.Supp. 209 (D.D.C. 1979)]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Eleven highly placed Church executives, including Mary Sue Hubbard (third wife of founder L. Ron Hubbard and second-in-command of the organization), pleaded guilty and were convicted in federal court of obstructing justice, burglary of government offices, and theft of documents and government property.' Mary Sue Hubbard was sentenced to five years; the operation had infiltrated and burgled US government agencies to purge unfavorable records about the church."
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/493/209/1557908/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Hubbard, 493 F. Supp. 209 (D.D.C. 1979).",
"body": "The federal district court opinion records the prosecution of senior Church of Scientology officials and the searches that recovered evidence of the government-infiltration operation.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "opinion"
}
],
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Senior Scientology officials carried out the infiltration operation through the church's Guardian's Office and organizational command structure; the record concerns institutional authority rather than a supernatural pretext.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-scientology",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Snow_White",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "759fe9f1ca865e866c8d126845e6ff5f3e77337c138e52ca99d4bdd04fd46167",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Snow_White"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/493/209/1557908/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "1984-the-dalles-or-usa",
"year": 1984,
"place": "The Dalles, OR, USA",
"lat": 45.61,
"lng": -121.18,
"title": "Rajneeshee salmonella attack: 751 sickened; Alford pleas; largest US bioterror attack",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1984_Rajneeshee_bioterror_attack",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) '1984 Rajneeshee bioterror attack' [summarizing the federal and Oregon state prosecutions]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'In 1984, 751 people suffered food poisoning in The Dalles, Oregon, United States, due to the deliberate contamination of salad bars at ten local restaurants with Salmonella' — carried out by followers of Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh to suppress local voter turnout. 'The incident was the first and largest bioterrorist attack in U.S. history.' Ma Anand Sheela and Ma Anand Puja 'entered Alford pleas for the Salmonella attack and the other charges, and received sentences ranging from three to twenty years' (an Alford plea is a conviction in which the defendant does not admit factual guilt). Rajneesh himself 'pleaded guilty to two counts of making false statements to immigration officials' and was deported."
},
{
"link": "https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/5/4/99-0406_article",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “Biological Warfare at the 1984 Rajneeshpuram Commune” (Emerging Infectious Diseases, 1999).",
"body": "The CDC review documents the deliberate Salmonella contamination, 751 illnesses, the commune leadership’s role, and the resulting criminal proceedings.",
"tier": "government-analysis",
"kind": "historical-case-review"
}
],
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "See citation",
"stage": "primary-source citation recovered",
"outcome": "United States v. Sheela, 667 F. Supp. 724 (D. Or. 1987), Judge Marsh, Nos. CR85-182, CR85-278, and CR86-53. Defendants: Ma Anand Sheela (aka Sheela Patel) and Ma Anand Puja (aka Diane Onang). Federal district court opinion from post-plea proceedings in the salmonella bioterror prosecution, confirming both defendants' true legal names/aliases and the consolidated docket numbers. Source: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2158698/united-states-v-sheela/"
}
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Commune leaders used the Rajneeshee movement's closed hierarchy and obedience to carry out a biological attack intended to influence an election.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1984_Rajneeshee_bioterror_attack",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b2dea6ad8d52eaa44a107ffa6bf48c96128c02aa86d2440361c3caa48904f665",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1984_Rajneeshee_bioterror_attack"
},
{
"source": "https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/5/4/99-0406_article",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-analysis; evidentiary role: historical-case-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5bdd6e02b12dea7d6b33a30457409c4e97e83a37f2fedb02442660174189a099",
"final_url": "https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/5/4/99-0406_article"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2011-driftwood-tx-usa",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Driftwood, TX, USA",
"lat": 30.1,
"lng": -97.99,
"title": "Prakashanand Saraswati: 20 counts child molestation; fled, fugitive",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prakashanand_Saraswati",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Prakashanand Saraswati' [summarizing the Hays County, Texas jury verdict of 4 March 2011]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Prakashanand Saraswati, the guru of the Barsana Dham ashram near Austin, Texas: 'A 12-person jury declared Saraswati guilty of 20 counts of child molestation, after 50 minutes deliberation, on Friday 4 March 2011... The jury sentenced him in absentia to 280 years and a US$200,000 fine.' He fled before sentencing: 'Federal officials believe Saraswati's followers moved him to Mexico in March 2011, and then helped him travel to India on a fake passport in November 2011.' He remains a fugitive."
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/texas/third-court-of-appeals/2009/18229.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ex parte Prakashandand Saraswati, Texas Third Court of Appeals, No. 03-08-00795-CR (2009).",
"body": "The appellate opinion records the two indictments, each containing ten counts of indecency with a child by contact, and identifies Saraswati as the spiritual leader of the Barsana Dham community.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "pretrial-appellate-opinion"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Saraswati's status as the community's spiritual leader and guru created the authority, access, and deference documented in the child-abuse prosecution and convictions.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prakashanand_Saraswati",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "47e89f277a91910a12ec6d18fc3ffbcd7e867424267096bd6d7074e0d388d266",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prakashanand_Saraswati"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/texas/third-court-of-appeals/2009/18229.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: pretrial-appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "1996-moundsville-wv-usa",
"year": 1996,
"place": "Moundsville, WV, USA",
"lat": 39.85,
"lng": -80.75,
"title": "Kirtanananda (New Vrindaban): racketeering plea; Drescher convicted of murders of dissidents",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirtanananda_Swami",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Kirtanananda Swami' [summarizing the federal prosecution of Keith Ham, leader of the New Vrindaban Hare Krishna community]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'In 1990, the US federal government indicted Kīrtanānanda on five counts of racketeering, six counts of mail fraud, and conspiracy to murder two of his opponents in the Hare Krishna movement (Stephen Bryant and Charles St. Denis). It also charged that he ordered the killings because the victims had threatened to reveal his sexual abuse of minors... In 1996, before Kīrtanānanda's retrial was completed, he pleaded guilty to one count of racketeering (mail fraud). He was sentenced to 20 years in prison.' Note: the murder-conspiracy counts were never adjudicated to conviction — the jury hung on them, and earlier convictions were vacated on appeal; the racketeering plea is the established conviction."
},
{
"link": "https://www.upi.com/Archives/1991/08/20/Hare-Krishna-hit-man-convicted/6380682660800/",
"archive": "https://web.archive.org/web/2024/https://www.upi.com/Archives/1991/08/20/Hare-Krishna-hit-man-convicted/6380682660800/",
"citation": "UPI (1991) 'Hare Krishna hit man convicted', United Press International, 20 August. Available at: upi.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "Thomas Drescher, a New Vrindaban devotee, was convicted of the '1986 contract killing of a dissident member of the sect'. 'He was found guilty of the May 22, 1986, shooting death of Stephen L. Bryant, an outspoken critic of the Hindu religious sect... In addition, the jurors found the defendant guilty of a special allegation of murder for financial gain... Drescher is serving a life term in West Virginia for murdering another Krishna devotee, Charles St. Denis, in 1983.' Bryant had spent years publicly documenting abuse at New Vrindaban; killing the whistleblower was the enforcement arm of the belief system's authority."
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/58/78/574532/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Ham, 58 F.3d 78 (4th Cir. 1995).",
"body": "The federal appellate opinion identifies Keith Ham, known as Kirtanananda Swami, as New Vrindaban’s spiritual leader and reviews the racketeering prosecution, related fraud allegations, and disputed murder-conspiracy evidence.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "New Vrindaban's guru hierarchy and communal authority enabled control of followers and supplied the institutional setting for the racketeering and violence record.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirtanananda_Swami",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e4767ec91dd5d62a18f138d29f903b8b2d9fc68c79c357f9daec4a179af4d2b7",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirtanananda_Swami"
},
{
"source": "https://www.upi.com/Archives/1991/08/20/Hare-Krishna-hit-man-convicted/6380682660800/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "89adb7247ccdbcfd400716ec88c64065bd8f25bd40212b75a6bd7e1d7333c87b",
"final_url": "https://www.upi.com/Archives/1991/08/20/Hare-Krishna-hit-man-convicted/6380682660800/"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/58/78/574532/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2020-albany-ny-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Albany, NY, USA",
"lat": 42.66,
"lng": -73.76,
"title": "NXIVM/Keith Raniere: 120 years — branding, collateral, sex trafficking",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/nxivm-leader-keith-raniere-expected-to/2688963/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NBC New York (2020) 'NXIVM Leader Keith Raniere Sentenced to 120 Years in Prison on Sex Trafficking, Other Charges', NBC New York. Available at: nbcnewyork.com (Accessed: 14 July 2026).",
"body": "'Keith Raniere, a self-improvement guru whose organization NXIVM attracted millionaires and actresses among its adherents, was sentenced Tuesday to 120 years in prison on convictions that he turned some female followers into sex slaves branded with his initials... Women were also pressured into giving up embarrassing information about themselves that could be used against them if they left the group.' NXIVM made no supernatural claims — its 'collateral' blackmail is the same binding architecture as a juju oath's shrine packet of hair and fingernails, stripped of the spirits. The mechanism does not require gods; it requires leverage over what a victim believes will destroy them."
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/nxivm-leader-keith-raniere-sentenced-120-years-prison-racketeering-and-sex-trafficking",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, Eastern District of New York, “NXIVM Leader Keith Raniere Sentenced to 120 Years in Prison for Racketeering and Sex Trafficking Offenses” (Oct. 27, 2020).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records Raniere's jury convictions, 120-year sentence, leadership titles, the DOS master-slave structure, collateral used to coerce members and the sex-trafficking offense.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.nyed.416187/gov.uscourts.nyed.416187.779.0.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Raniere et al., No. 1:18-cr-00204, trial transcript, docket entry 779 (E.D.N.Y. June 7, 2019).",
"body": "The filed trial transcript includes Raniere's statements describing himself as a spiritual successor through transmission of energy and innate knowledge and seeking a physically and energy-related 'pure vessel.'",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "trial-transcript"
},
{
"link": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca2-20-03520/pdf/USCOURTS-ca2-20-03520-0.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Raniere, 55 F.4th 354 (2d Cir. 2022).",
"body": "The official appellate opinion affirms Raniere's sex-trafficking convictions and reviews the evidence concerning DOS, collateral, assignments and the master-slave hierarchy.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"NXIVM founder",
"Vanguard and Grandmaster",
"claimed spiritual lineage holder"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"collateral blackmail",
"master-slave hierarchy",
"claimed spiritual and energetic authority",
"sexual access framed as spiritual growth or healing"
],
"organizations": [
"NXIVM",
"DOS"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2020-10-27",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Keith Raniere of racketeering, sex trafficking, forced-labor conspiracy and related offenses; the district court sentenced him to 120 years in prison."
}
],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"date": "2022-12-09",
"court": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit",
"outcome": "The court affirmed Raniere's sex-trafficking convictions and rejected his statutory and constitutional challenges."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies collateral blackmail, master-slave hierarchy, claimed spiritual and energetic authority, and sexual access framed as spiritual growth or healing as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is NXIVM founder, Vanguard and Grandmaster, and claimed spiritual lineage holder.",
"scopeNote": "The inherited summary's statement that NXIVM made no supernatural claims is contradicted by the filed trial record. The transcript documents Raniere's claims about spiritual succession, energy transmission and energy-related purity. These were NXIVM's own syncretic claims; this record does not assign them to Hindu or Buddhist Tantra.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-est-large-group-awareness",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"date": "2022-12-09",
"court": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit",
"outcome": "The court affirmed Raniere's sex-trafficking convictions and rejected his statutory and constitutional challenges."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/nxivm-leader-keith-raniere-expected-to/2688963/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eb5b3dd09a50d7c4dd5b1a4287bf154999ed2902e393578cde7bb97c6b37f49b",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/nxivm-leader-keith-raniere-expected-to/2688963/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/nxivm-leader-keith-raniere-sentenced-120-years-prison-racketeering-and-sex-trafficking",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b61dbfba43f8db98f74214d5852a9c362e25ff5e1f027a1c0265515756ff62f5",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/nxivm-leader-keith-raniere-sentenced-120-years-prison-racketeering-and-sex-trafficking"
},
{
"source": "https://archive.org/download/gov.uscourts.nyed.416187/gov.uscourts.nyed.416187.779.0.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: trial-transcript.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f8947d1aa13ed975559a613d82102986aa10dd5d1af0e3898c0ca02acf639387",
"final_url": "https://dn710602.ca.archive.org/0/items/gov.uscourts.nyed.416187/gov.uscourts.nyed.416187.779.0.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca2-20-03520/pdf/USCOURTS-ca2-20-03520-0.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "70a3765b22209d641cb17f28330869b31f31e03d53013db797f37a7fadf8eee2",
"final_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca2-20-03520/pdf/USCOURTS-ca2-20-03520-0.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2019-abadi-nia-brazil",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Abadiânia, Brazil",
"lat": -16.2,
"lng": -48.71,
"title": "João Teixeira de Faria ('John of God'): convicted of rapes of spiritual patients; ~600 accusers",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mynews13.com/fl/orlando/ap-online/2019/12/19/brazil-spiritual-healer-sentenced-to-19-years-for-four-rapes",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press (2019) 'Brazil spiritual healer sentenced to 19 years for four rapes', AP via Spectrum News 13, 19 December. Available at: mynews13.com (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "João Teixeira de Faria — 'John of God', the Brazilian spiritist healer once featured by Oprah Winfrey — was convicted of raping women who had come to him as spiritual patients: 'A judge in Goias state issued a sentence of 19 years and four months for four rapes of different women... João Teixeira de Faria drew people from all over the world to his small city two hours west of capital, Brasilia, with promises he could treat everything from depression to cancer. Hundreds of women, including his daughter, alleged he regularly engaged in abuse ranging from groping to rape.' Subsequent trials through 2023-24 raised his cumulative sentences past three hundred years. Per earlier ABC News reporting of the indictment, 'Nearly 600 female victims — ranging in age from 9 to 67' came forward. It is very likely the largest spiritual-abuse case, by accuser count, ever prosecuted."
},
{
"link": "https://www.tjgo.jus.br/index.php/agencia-de-noticias/noticias-ccs/20-destaque/27581-joao-de-deus-e-condenado-a-mais-de-118-anos-de-prisao-todas-as-acoes-contra-o-medium-foram-julgadas-em-primeiro-grau",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Justice of the State of Goiás, “João de Deus é condenado a mais de 118 anos de prisão; todas as ações contra o médium foram julgadas em primeiro grau” (Sept. 15, 2023).",
"body": "The state court reports that all seventeen first-instance criminal cases had been decided, with cumulative sentences of 489 years and four months and convictions concerning 56 victims. It also records partial relief in six appeals, two pending Superior Court appeals and no final appellate judgment as of publication.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "case-status-record"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"spiritist healer",
"spiritual-treatment provider"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-healing authority",
"fraudulent treatment setting",
"access to patients"
],
"organizations": [
"Casa de Dom Inácio de Loyola"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Justice of the State of Goiás, Brazil",
"stage": "seventeen first-instance criminal judgments",
"date": "2023-09-15",
"outcome": "First-instance sentences totaled 489 years and four months across convictions concerning 56 victims."
}
],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"date": "2023-09-15",
"court": "Court of Justice of the State of Goiás and Superior Court of Justice",
"outcome": "Six defense appeals had been partially granted; two further appeals remained pending at the Superior Court of Justice. The state court reported that no appellate judgment was final as of this date."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual-healing authority, fraudulent treatment setting, and access to patients as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is spiritist healer and spiritual-treatment provider.",
"scopeNote": "The headline's approximate accuser count is distinct from adjudicated cases. The Goiás court reported first-instance convictions concerning 56 victims and said no appellate judgment was final as of September 15, 2023.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"date": "2023-09-15",
"court": "Court of Justice of the State of Goiás and Superior Court of Justice",
"outcome": "Six defense appeals had been partially granted; two further appeals remained pending at the Superior Court of Justice. The state court reported that no appellate judgment was final as of this date."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mynews13.com/fl/orlando/ap-online/2019/12/19/brazil-spiritual-healer-sentenced-to-19-years-for-four-rapes",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fe203b6a4425dbba939b8f89dc805b276ced40d0bde4298e7c25481e3618921f",
"final_url": "https://mynews13.com/fl/orlando/ap-online/2019/12/19/brazil-spiritual-healer-sentenced-to-19-years-for-four-rapes"
},
{
"source": "https://www.tjgo.jus.br/index.php/agencia-de-noticias/noticias-ccs/20-destaque/27581-joao-de-deus-e-condenado-a-mais-de-118-anos-de-prisao-todas-as-acoes-contra-o-medium-foram-julgadas-em-primeiro-grau",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: case-status-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "1995-london-uk",
"year": 1995,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 51.66,
"lng": 0.04,
"title": "Ward judgment: High Court findings on Children of God child sexual abuse",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.xfamily.org/index.php/Complete_Judgment_of_Lord_Justice_Ward",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ward, LJ (1995) In re ST (A Minor) (Wardship), High Court of Justice, Family Division, judgment of 19 October 1995 [295-page judgment; full text per the xfamily.org archive mirror]. Available at: xfamily.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "The landmark official judicial finding on the Children of God / The Family: after a 75-day hearing, Lord Justice Ward's wardship judgment made formal findings on the movement's history of child sexual abuse, under section headings that include 'THE LEADERS' INVOLVEMENT IN SEXUAL ABUSE'. Founder David Berg had written that children 'should also not be prohibited from mutual sexual examination, experimentation or interplay when playing or sleeping together'. Of the movement's attempt to disown its founder's doctrine, Ward found: 'I find that it was a disingenuous attempt to distance them from their responsibility both for what is and for what was', and of its testimony: 'I regret to find that in many instances there has been a lack of frankness and a failure to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.' Note: Ward also found that the worst practices had been formally abandoned by the time of the 1995 judgment; his findings are historical, and the judgment text is cited from an archive mirror pending a court-authored copy."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The court examined a movement whose sexual doctrine and leader-centered authority normalized adult sexual access to children and obstructed protection.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.xfamily.org/index.php/Complete_Judgment_of_Lord_Justice_Ward",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "327d541b1ad2f917a0bf2d6b0cce0f99c41ebe88b7c392430e90cb1a833fa87c",
"final_url": "https://www.xfamily.org/index.php/Complete_Judgment_of_Lord_Justice_Ward"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2020-glasgow-uk",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Glasgow, UK",
"lat": 55.84,
"lng": -4.25,
"title": "Derek Lincoln (Children of God): guilty plea, 11.5 years, rape of two children",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.scotland.police.uk/what-s-happening/news/2020/august/derek-lincoln-sentenced-for-the-sexual-abuse-of-two-children/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Police Scotland (2020) 'Derek Lincoln sentenced for the sexual abuse of two children', Police Scotland, August. Available at: scotland.police.uk (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "A criminal conviction from inside the Children of God, in Police Scotland's own words: Derek Lincoln was 'a man who used his position in the ‘Children of God’ religious cult to sexually abuse two children'; he 'plead guilty to the rape and sexual assault of two young girls, aged between 9 and 11' and 'has now been sentenced to 11 years and 6 months at Glasgow High Court.' The investigating officer stated that 'Lincoln used his position within the Children of God to perpetrate violent sexual abuse against two young children.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant operated within the Children of God environment, whose sexual doctrine and adult authority structure enabled repeated abuse of children.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.scotland.police.uk/what-s-happening/news/2020/august/derek-lincoln-sentenced-for-the-sexual-abuse-of-two-children/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6db0d38108d670e2688df1df369ca600297dd60e7f8ea1d222e5ee7fc1539ad8",
"final_url": "https://www.scotland.police.uk/what-s-happening/news/2020/august/derek-lincoln-sentenced-for-the-sexual-abuse-of-two-children/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "1997-tiruchirappalli-india",
"year": 1997,
"place": "Tiruchirappalli, India",
"lat": 10.8,
"lng": 78.7,
"title": "Swami Premananda: convicted of 13 rapes + murder; double life; died in custody",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swami_Premananda_(guru)",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Swami Premananda (guru)' [summarizing the 1997 convictions before the Indian courts]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "Swami Premananda, the Sri Lankan-born guru of an ashram in Tamil Nadu: 'He was convicted of multiple counts of rape and a murder in 1997' — '13 counts of rape, molestations of two girls and murder' — and 'was sentenced to double life imprisonment'. He 'died on 21 February 2011 of acute liver failure, while being held in Cuddalore Central Prison.' The victims were girls resident in his ashram, under his spiritual authority."
},
{
"link": "https://indiankanoon.org/docfragment/192852/?formInput=murder++doctypes%3A+judgments+fromdate%3A+1-1-2005+todate%3A+31-12-2005",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kamalanantha and Others v. State of Tamil Nadu, Supreme Court of India (Apr. 5, 2005).",
"body": "The Supreme Court decision reviews the evidence and convictions arising from Premananda’s rape of thirteen ashram residents and the murder of Ravi, and addresses the liability of co-accused persons.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "Premananda used guru status, ashram control, and claims of spiritual authority to obtain sexual access to residents and suppress resistance.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swami_Premananda_(guru)",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6ee99887d74ce5392c19972ce08216c23196692e1e128fe5f142365b5d76b4d8",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swami_Premananda_(guru)"
},
{
"source": "https://indiankanoon.org/docfragment/192852/?formInput=murder++doctypes%3A+judgments+fromdate%3A+1-1-2005+todate%3A+31-12-2005",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2018-ramanagara-india",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Ramanagara, India",
"lat": 12.71,
"lng": 77.29,
"title": "Nithyananda: rape charges framed; non-bailable warrant; fled India 2019 (never tried)",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nithyananda",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Nithyananda' [summarizing the Ramanagara district court proceedings]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "Nithyananda, once among India's most prominent self-styled godmen: 'On 19 February 2018, the Third Additional District and Sessions Court in Ramanagara ordered the framing of charges against Nithyananda and five others' over a disciple's rape accusations; 'In August 2022, the... Court issued a non-bailable warrant against Nithyananda following multiple orders to appear'; he 'fled India and has remained in hiding since 2019', declaring a self-styled micronation while a fugitive. Note: charged and wanted — never tried, never convicted. This entry documents flight from process, not guilt."
},
{
"link": "https://indiankanoon.org/doc/154255120/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "K. Lenin v. Nithyananda Swamy, Karnataka High Court, Criminal Petition No. 594 of 2020 (Feb. 5, 2020).",
"body": "The Karnataka High Court order records the criminal case, charged offenses, earlier bail, repeated nonappearance, and the proceeding concerning cancellation of bail. It does not establish guilt.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "procedural-order"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The charges allege that Nithyananda used guru authority and the ashram relationship to obtain sexual access. The allegation must be read with the unresolved proceeding status shown on this record.",
"scopeNote": "ALLEGATION ONLY — NO TRIAL HAS OCCURRED. Charges were filed and a chargesheet submitted, but the accused left India in 2019 before trial, has not returned, and has since promoted a self-declared micronation. Nothing in this record is an adjudicated finding; the presumption of innocence applies in full. The record is retained at charged status because the filing of charges is a documented official act.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The cited sources report charges or a pending proceeding. This record does not establish a finding of guilt or a final disposition.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nithyananda",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4e8b1c300bbe514d28ddc4f6b768d10de4a21fe3e52ef3b7951c4729c589432a",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nithyananda"
},
{
"source": "https://indiankanoon.org/doc/154255120/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: procedural-order.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2016-los-angeles-ca-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Los Angeles, CA, USA",
"lat": 33.98,
"lng": -118.22,
"title": "Bikram Choudhury: civil jury — 'malice, oppression and fraud'; $7.3M; left US",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "civil-verdict",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bikram_Choudhury",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (2026) 'Bikram Choudhury' [summarizing the Los Angeles civil verdict of January 2016]. Available at: en.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "Bikram Choudhury, founder of the Bikram yoga empire: 'On January 25, 2016, a jury awarded Jafa-Bodden $924,500 against Choudhury in actual damages, finding that Choudhury acted with malice, oppression and fraud. On January 26, 2016, the jury awarded Jafa-Bodden an additional $6.4 million in punitive damages.' Jafa-Bodden was his own head of legal, fired after refusing to cover up a rape investigation. He left the United States in 2016 with the judgment largely unpaid. Note: this is a civil jury verdict; the underlying sexual-assault allegations by students were never criminally adjudicated, and the later arrest warrant concerned nonpayment, not a criminal charge."
},
{
"link": "https://www.courthousenews.com/jury-hands-yoga-gurusex-lawyer-7-3-million/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Courthouse News Service, “Jury Hands Yoga Guru’s Ex-Lawyer $7.3 Million” (Jan. 27, 2016).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the Los Angeles jury’s compensatory and punitive awards and findings of malice, oppression, and fraud against Bikram Choudhury.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "civil-verdict"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The civil record concerns a yoga founder whose guru-like authority, teacher control, and institutional power were used to harass, retaliate, and conceal misconduct.",
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bikram_Choudhury",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9433db80fe8a95afd9aeb4a2ab0c7c9f3d8298cd7089be6ccb6c9a21ad03147e",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bikram_Choudhury"
},
{
"source": "https://www.courthousenews.com/jury-hands-yoga-gurusex-lawyer-7-3-million/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-verdict.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e4334eaf4991cd36330a5b99830679a9d50bafb5f2436a498efd9cb0559ed450",
"final_url": "https://www.courthousenews.com/jury-hands-yoga-gurusex-lawyer-7-3-million/"
}
]
},
{
"slug": "2017-new-orleans-la-usa",
"year": 2017,
"place": "New Orleans, LA, USA",
"lat": 29.95,
"lng": -90.07,
"title": "Kenny Klein (Blue Star Wicca): 20 counts child pornography, 20 years",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://wildhunt.org/2017/04/kenny-klein-convicted-on-child-pornography-charges.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Wild Hunt (2017) 'Kenny Klein convicted on child pornography charges', The Wild Hunt [the Pagan community's own news outlet], April. Available at: wildhunt.org (Accessed: 15 July 2026).",
"body": "Neopaganism's most prominent conviction, reported by the Pagan community's own press: 'An Orleans Parish jury found musician and Blue Star priest Kenny Klein guilty of child pornography charges' — 'one count of pornography involving a juvenile under the age of 13, and 19 counts of possession with intent to distribute pornography involving juveniles under the age 17.' Klein had been a founding elder of the Blue Star tradition of Wicca for decades. That the community's own journalists covered the trial gavel-to-gavel is a mark in the community's favor — the same internal accountability this survey's conclusions call for everywhere."
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"aliases": [],
"proceedings": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"spiritualNexus": "The conviction establishes child-pornography offenses and Klein's religious office, but the available record does not establish that Wiccan doctrine or spiritual authority materially enabled those offenses, so the case is retained as context.",
"scopeNote": "The conviction is documented, but the current public sources do not establish that spiritual authority materially enabled the offense.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "legacy-preserved",
"additionIndex": 0,
"legacyRecord": true,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://wildhunt.org/2017/04/kenny-klein-convicted-on-child-pornography-charges.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "71e0dd625f445b3d88696128dd78ef350d0b939f8e61c18486e9a14c9dbabc57",
"final_url": "https://wildhunt.org/2017/04/kenny-klein-convicted-on-child-pornography-charges.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-james-arthur-ray-sedona-az-usa",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Sedona, AZ, USA",
"lat": 34.8697,
"lng": -111.761,
"title": "James Arthur Ray: three negligent-homicide convictions after “Spiritual Warrior” sweat lodge",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-help and spiritual-retreat leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"retreat authority",
"pressure to endure dangerous conditions"
],
"organizations": [
"James Ray International"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Arizona Superior Court, Yavapai County",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2011-11-18",
"outcome": "Three negligent-homicide convictions; concurrent two-year sentences."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://apnews.com/article/419682fe4d38a08f16fec8dd7fdfcc2f",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press, “Self-help author James Arthur Ray, whose seminar led to tragedy and death, dies at 67” (Jan. 6, 2025).",
"body": "The AP’s retrospective reports that three participants died after Ray led the 2009 sweat-lodge ceremony, that prosecutors said he ignored pleas for help, and that a jury convicted him of three counts of negligent homicide.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies retreat authority and pressure to endure dangerous conditions as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-help and spiritual-retreat leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://apnews.com/article/419682fe4d38a08f16fec8dd7fdfcc2f",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "48b85293f0d7932777fb87c09ca3416f3144d3779de20aea9c3505912928fdda",
"final_url": "https://apnews.com/article/james-arthur-ray-dead-sweat-lodge-419682fe4d38a08f16fec8dd7fdfcc2f"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 2,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-nathan-chasing-horse-las-vegas-nv-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Las Vegas, NV, USA",
"lat": 36.1699,
"lng": -115.1398,
"title": "Nathan Chasing Horse: 13 felony convictions and 37-years-to-life sentence",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described medicine man and spiritual leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual authority",
"grooming",
"plural-marriage claims"
],
"organizations": [
"The Circle"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, Nevada",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2026-01-22",
"outcome": "Sentenced to an aggregate term of 37 years to life after conviction on 13 felony counts."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.clarkcountynv.gov/adobe/assets/urn%3Aaaid%3Aaem%3Ab328e310-5a42-4029-b246-9fabc19cf031/original/as/Nathan-Chasing-Horse-sentenced.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Clark County District Attorney, “Nathan Chasing Horse Sentenced to 37 Years to Life” (Jan. 22, 2026).",
"body": "The district attorney reports that a jury convicted Chasing Horse on 13 felony counts and that the court imposed an aggregate sentence of 37 years to life. The release describes evidence that he used claimed medicine-man status and spiritual influence to gain access to victims.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual authority, grooming, and plural-marriage claims as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-described medicine man and spiritual leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.clarkcountynv.gov/adobe/assets/urn%3Aaaid%3Aaem%3Ab328e310-5a42-4029-b246-9fabc19cf031/original/as/Nathan-Chasing-Horse-sentenced.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fbb8fd18be80dd072f0fb6b4392746f706129917e07666e3f54fb8ae9e2af001",
"final_url": "https://www.clarkcountynv.gov/adobe/assets/urn%3Aaaid%3Aaem%3Ab328e310-5a42-4029-b246-9fabc19cf031/original/as/Nathan-Chasing-Horse-sentenced.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 3,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-lyndreth-hemp-wall-towaoc-co-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Towaoc, CO, USA",
"lat": 37.2044,
"lng": -108.729,
"title": "Lyndreth Hemp Wall: 15 federal convictions for assaults during purported spiritual treatment",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"purported medicine man"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"purported spiritual treatment",
"deception",
"authority over patients"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, District of Colorado",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "2025-03-21",
"outcome": "Convicted on 15 federal sexual-abuse counts."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-co/pr/purported-ute-mountain-ute-medicine-man-convicted-sexually-assaulting-five-victims",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Colorado, “Purported Ute Mountain Ute Medicine Man Convicted of Sexually Assaulting Five Victims” (Mar. 21, 2025).",
"body": "The Justice Department reports that Wall presented assaults as diagnosis or treatment of spiritual and physical conditions and that a federal jury convicted him on 15 counts involving five victims.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies purported spiritual treatment, deception, and authority over patients as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is purported medicine man.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-co/pr/purported-ute-mountain-ute-medicine-man-convicted-sexually-assaulting-five-victims",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bf38778694cfbb05bc874ee20e0a18d72ed93e145a3bd45a3eab63fdb035f15a",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-co/pr/purported-ute-mountain-ute-medicine-man-convicted-sexually-assaulting-five-victims"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 4,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-carl-gene-ortner-quapaw-ok-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Quapaw, OK, USA",
"lat": 36.9545,
"lng": -94.788,
"title": "Carl Gene Ortner Jr.: conviction after posing as a Native spiritual counselor",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented Native spiritual counselor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual counseling pretext",
"grooming"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Northern District of Oklahoma",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "2021-11-18",
"outcome": "Convicted of aggravated sexual abuse of a minor and unlawful firearm possession."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndok/pr/quapaw-man-convicted-sexually-abusing-native-american-minor-and-illegally-possessing",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, Northern District of Oklahoma, “Quapaw Man Convicted of Sexually Abusing Native American Minor” (Nov. 18, 2021).",
"body": "The Justice Department reports that Ortner portrayed himself as a spiritual counselor, used that position to groom a minor, and was convicted by a federal jury.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual counseling pretext and grooming as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-presented Native spiritual counselor.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndok/pr/quapaw-man-convicted-sexually-abusing-native-american-minor-and-illegally-possessing",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "015953ecd1a0875fb0418d90ec4bb6c344b98b2c9871b0719fd819d0921a451f",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndok/pr/quapaw-man-convicted-sexually-abusing-native-american-minor-and-illegally-possessing"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 5,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"bateman-fundamentalist-mormon-group"
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-samuel-bateman-phoenix-az-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Phoenix, AZ, USA",
"lat": 33.4484,
"lng": -112.074,
"title": "Samuel Bateman: 50-year sentence in child-marriage and sexual-abuse conspiracy",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed prophet"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"prophetic authority",
"child-marriage doctrine",
"isolation",
"follower assistance"
],
"organizations": [
"Bateman fundamentalist Mormon group"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, District of Arizona",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2024-09-30",
"outcome": "Sentenced to 50 years in federal prison after guilty pleas."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-az/pr/leader-child-sexual-abuse-ring-sentenced-50-years-prison",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Arizona, “Leader of Child Sexual Abuse Ring Sentenced to 50 Years in Prison” (Sept. 30, 2024).",
"body": "The Justice Department describes Bateman as a self-proclaimed prophet who used religious authority to take minor girls as plural wives and directed followers who transported and concealed children. He pleaded guilty and received a 50-year sentence.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies prophetic authority, child-marriage doctrine, isolation, and follower assistance as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-proclaimed prophet.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-az/pr/leader-child-sexual-abuse-ring-sentenced-50-years-prison",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "326608d5129d2ad8d51ab10204db90c9bfb29ba207f1b2c3fe487e98bdfaed02",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-az/pr/leader-child-sexual-abuse-ring-sentenced-50-years-prison"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 6,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-michael-zacharias-toledo-oh-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Toledo, OH, USA",
"lat": 41.6528,
"lng": -83.5379,
"title": "Michael Zacharias: life sentence for trafficking victims groomed through priestly authority",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"grooming",
"financial and emotional control"
],
"organizations": [
"Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Northern District of Ohio",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2023-06-09",
"outcome": "Life imprisonment after convictions for sex trafficking and related offenses."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/priest-sentenced-life-prison-sex-trafficking-three-victims-northern-ohio",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, “Priest Sentenced to Life in Prison for Sex Trafficking Three Victims in Northern Ohio” (June 9, 2023).",
"body": "The Justice Department reports that Zacharias met victims through his church, cultivated trust as a priest, and used grooming, money, and threats to compel commercial sex. The court imposed a life sentence.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral authority, grooming, and financial and emotional control as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is priest.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/priest-sentenced-life-prison-sex-trafficking-three-victims-northern-ohio",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "83f752503deeb5c18795df1ae3930e183064399bc50ad6809052d6220d859501",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/priest-sentenced-life-prison-sex-trafficking-three-victims-northern-ohio"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 7,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-onetaste-brooklyn-ny-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Brooklyn, NY, USA",
"lat": 40.6782,
"lng": -73.9442,
"title": "OneTaste leaders convicted of forced-labor conspiracy",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder",
"head of sales"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"indoctrination",
"debt",
"surveillance",
"threats of spiritual and social ruin"
],
"organizations": [
"OneTaste"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "2025-06-09",
"outcome": "Nicole Daedone and Rachel Cherwitz convicted of forced-labor conspiracy."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/founder-sexual-wellness-company-onetaste-and-former-head-sales-convicted-forced-labor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, Eastern District of New York, “Founder of OneTaste and Former Head of Sales Convicted of Forced Labor Conspiracy” (June 9, 2025).",
"body": "The Justice Department reports that OneTaste leaders obtained labor through economic, sexual, emotional, and psychological abuse, including debt and threats that departure would cause spiritual or social harm.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies indoctrination, debt, surveillance, and threats of spiritual and social ruin as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and head of sales.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/founder-sexual-wellness-company-onetaste-and-former-head-sales-convicted-forced-labor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3b944c5d040fd02db347ed78ab7c56af733becd07e5d2ee9e053413928dc9844",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/founder-sexual-wellness-company-onetaste-and-former-head-sales-convicted-forced-labor"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 8,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-jeong-myeong-seok-daejeon-south-korea",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Daejeon, South Korea",
"lat": 36.3504,
"lng": 127.3845,
"title": "Jeong Myeong-seok / JMS: Supreme Court affirms 17-year sentence",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and religious leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious indoctrination",
"messianic authority",
"grooming"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Gospel Mission (JMS)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Korea",
"stage": "final appeal",
"date": "2025-01-09",
"outcome": "Seventeen-year sentence affirmed."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.scourt.go.kr/portal/news/NewsViewAction.work?gubun=2&pageIndex=1&searchOption=&searchWord=&seqnum=5592",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Korea, case notice concerning Jeong Myeong-seok (Jan. 9, 2025).",
"body": "The Supreme Court notice affirms the 17-year sentence and addresses how the victims’ ability to resist was impaired by sustained religious indoctrination and the defendant’s claimed spiritual status.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious indoctrination, messianic authority, and grooming as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and religious leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.scourt.go.kr/portal/news/NewsViewAction.work?gubun=2&pageIndex=1&searchOption=&searchWord=&seqnum=5592",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "472f252d44f5e0a54ff68d176733064d32efaff706d9c9cf326ea3a2b814c717",
"final_url": "https://www.scourt.go.kr/portal/news/NewsViewAction.work?gubun=2&pageIndex=1&searchOption=&searchWord=&seqnum=5592"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-herry-wirawan-bandung-indonesia",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Bandung, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.9175,
"lng": 107.6191,
"title": "Herry Wirawan: life sentence for abuse of students under pesantren authority",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Islamic boarding-school educator and administrator"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional custody",
"teacher authority",
"dependency"
],
"organizations": [
"Manarul Huda Antapani Islamic boarding school"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Indonesia",
"stage": "cassation record",
"date": "2022-12-08",
"outcome": "Life sentence recorded after appellate review."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://putusan3.mahkamahagung.go.id/direktori/putusan/zaec8ed91de597468df6313033323530.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Indonesia decision database, Herry Wirawan proceeding.",
"body": "The Indonesian judiciary’s decision record documents the criminal proceeding and life sentence arising from repeated abuse of students under Wirawan’s authority as an Islamic boarding-school educator.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies institutional custody, teacher authority, and dependency as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Islamic boarding-school educator and administrator.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://putusan3.mahkamahagung.go.id/direktori/putusan/zaec8ed91de597468df6313033323530.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 10,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-united-nation-of-islam-kansas-city-ks-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Kansas City, KS, USA",
"lat": 39.1141,
"lng": -94.6275,
"title": "United Nation of Islam leaders sentenced in child forced-labor conspiracy",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder claiming divine identity",
"organizational leaders"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious indoctrination",
"isolation",
"physical punishment",
"unpaid labor"
],
"organizations": [
"United Nation of Islam",
"The Value Creators"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, District of Kansas",
"stage": "sentences",
"date": "2025-04-18",
"outcome": "Six former leaders received federal prison sentences."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/six-former-cult-members-sentenced-years-long-forced-labor-conspiracy-compel-labor-multiple",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, “Six Former Cult Members Sentenced for Years-Long Forced Labor Conspiracy” (Apr. 18, 2025).",
"body": "The Justice Department reports that leaders compelled children to work through physical abuse, isolation, and religious claims by a founder who represented himself as Allah.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious indoctrination, isolation, physical punishment, and unpaid labor as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder claiming divine identity and organizational leaders.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/six-former-cult-members-sentenced-years-long-forced-labor-conspiracy-compel-labor-multiple",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "948cc110d82748410c5891aaa202ddc940f02a8ae23068b669383a5f6c5891ad",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/six-former-cult-members-sentenced-years-long-forced-labor-conspiracy-compel-labor-multiple"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 11,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-uganda-v-sentongo-kayunga-uganda",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Kayunga, Uganda",
"lat": 0.7025,
"lng": 32.8886,
"title": "Uganda v. Sentongo: infant murder and aggravated trafficking for ritual exploitation",
"tradition": "muti",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ritual practitioner and procurer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual demand",
"trafficking for exploitation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Uganda",
"stage": "judgment",
"date": "2022-09-21",
"outcome": "Convictions for murder and aggravated trafficking."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ulii.org/en/akn/ug/judgment/ughccrd/2022/124/eng@2022-09-21",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Uganda v. Sentongo and Another, Criminal Session Case 227 of 2018, [2022] UGHCCRD 124.",
"body": "The High Court judgment records convictions arising from the trafficking and killing of an infant for ritual exploitation and sets out the evidence supporting the ritual nexus.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "judgment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies ritual demand and trafficking for exploitation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is ritual practitioner and procurer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-muti",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ulii.org/en/akn/ug/judgment/ughccrd/2022/124/eng@2022-09-21",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 12,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-boston-archdiocese-massachusetts-usa",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Boston, MA, USA",
"lat": 42.3601,
"lng": -71.0589,
"title": "Massachusetts attorney general finds institutional failure enabled abuse in Boston Archdiocese",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy",
"archdiocesan leadership",
"institutional safeguarding system"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority",
"institutional secrecy",
"transfer of accused clergy",
"failure to report"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Office of the Attorney General, Commonwealth of Massachusetts",
"stage": "official investigative report",
"date": "2003-07-23",
"outcome": "The attorney general found widespread abuse and a massive and pervasive failure of leadership, while finding insufficient evidence to charge the Archdiocese or its senior managers under then-applicable state law."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mass.gov/doc/the-sexual-abuse-of-children-in-the-roman-catholic-archdiocese-of-boston/download",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Attorney General, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, The Sexual Abuse of Children in the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston (July 23, 2003).",
"body": "The official report records allegations against 250 priests and other Archdiocesan workers involving at least 789 children since 1940. It finds that senior officials knew the scale of the problem, maintained secrecy, failed to report allegations, and transferred accused priests in ways that placed children at risk.",
"tier": "official-finding",
"kind": "attorney-general-report"
},
{
"link": "https://cache.boston.com/globe/spotlight/abuse/documents/list.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Boston Globe Spotlight Team, Abuse in the Catholic Church document archive (2002-2003).",
"body": "The Spotlight archive preserves court filings, depositions, correspondence, and internal Church documents released through litigation and reporting. It is included as document provenance, not as a substitute for the attorney general's findings.",
"tier": "document-archive",
"kind": "court-and-institutional-records"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies clerical authority, institutional secrecy, transfer of accused clergy, and failure to report as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Catholic clergy, archdiocesan leadership, and institutional safeguarding system.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mass.gov/doc/the-sexual-abuse-of-children-in-the-roman-catholic-archdiocese-of-boston/download",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding; evidentiary role: attorney-general-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://cache.boston.com/globe/spotlight/abuse/documents/list.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: document-archive; evidentiary role: court-and-institutional-records.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c3fd6dca96bf18b9c59fcbfa5efd05afd5ea3b529ed5fcb9e02c673d59f4b799",
"final_url": "https://cache.boston.com/globe/spotlight/abuse/documents/list.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 13,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-sodalitium-christianae-vitae-lima-peru",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Lima, Peru",
"lat": -12.0464,
"lng": -77.0428,
"title": "Vatican suppresses Sodalitium Christianae Vitae after official investigation",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic lay society leadership"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional authority",
"spiritual obedience",
"organizational control"
],
"organizations": [
"Sodalitium Christianae Vitae"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Holy See",
"stage": "suppression decree announced",
"date": "2025-04-14",
"outcome": "Suppression of the society confirmed by the Vatican press office."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/en/info/2025/04/15/250415a.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Holy See Press Office, information note on the suppression of Sodalitium Christianae Vitae (Apr. 15, 2025).",
"body": "The Vatican press office confirms that Pope Francis approved suppression after a Vatican investigation and that the decree was communicated to the organization.",
"tier": "official-finding",
"kind": "institutional-action"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies institutional authority, spiritual obedience, and organizational control as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Catholic lay society leadership.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/en/info/2025/04/15/250415a.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding; evidentiary role: institutional-action.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ec3c71f676d86dae38bd0d0199f940023f109aa4551d987e9a6089436648f6d0",
"final_url": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/en/info/2025/04/15/250415a.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 14,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-apollo-quiboloy-manila-philippines",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Manila, Philippines",
"lat": 14.5995,
"lng": 120.9842,
"title": "Apollo Quiboloy / KOJC: Philippine proceedings and separate U.S. trafficking indictment",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and self-proclaimed appointed son of God"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority",
"threats of damnation",
"forced fundraising",
"grooming"
],
"organizations": [
"Kingdom of Jesus Christ"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Republic of the Philippines",
"stage": "criminal proceedings",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"outcome": "Domestic proceedings pending."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Central District of California",
"stage": "superseding indictment",
"date": "2021-11-10",
"outcome": "Federal trafficking and fraud charges pending; allegations are unproven."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.doj.gov.ph/news_article.html?newsid=Zj5ssbgPcRPHHb-WSIbxAC8sfC7deC1oGiyTtT4t5Qw",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Philippines Department of Justice, case update concerning Apollo Quiboloy and KOJC.",
"body": "The Philippine Department of Justice describes the domestic proceeding. The allegations remain subject to adjudication.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "proceeding"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-cdca/pr/federal-grand-jury-issues-new-indictment-against-leaders-philippines-based-church",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, Central District of California, superseding-indictment release concerning KOJC leaders (Nov. 18, 2021).",
"body": "The U.S. indictment separately alleges that KOJC leaders used religious authority, threats, and immigration leverage in a forced-labor and sex-trafficking scheme. An indictment is an allegation, not a finding of guilt.",
"tier": "charging-authority",
"kind": "charging-document"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents religious authority, threats of damnation, forced fundraising, and grooming, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is founder and self-proclaimed appointed son of God.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Federal trafficking and fraud charges pending; allegations are unproven.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.doj.gov.ph/news_article.html?newsid=Zj5ssbgPcRPHHb-WSIbxAC8sfC7deC1oGiyTtT4t5Qw",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: proceeding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-cdca/pr/federal-grand-jury-issues-new-indictment-against-leaders-philippines-based-church",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: charging-authority; evidentiary role: charging-document.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4cf49a1101e8a1731448a57a82da8a41c4232d4b146e1b958b27750b00ea16fc",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-cdca/pr/federal-grand-jury-issues-new-indictment-against-leaders-philippines-based-church"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 15,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-kingdom-of-god-global-church-detroit-mi-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Detroit, MI, USA",
"lat": 42.3314,
"lng": -83.0458,
"title": "Kingdom of God Global Church leaders charged in multi-state forced-labor conspiracy",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-professed apostle",
"church leaders"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual threats",
"sleep deprivation",
"isolation",
"forced fundraising"
],
"organizations": [
"Kingdom of God Global Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan",
"stage": "indictment",
"date": "2026-01-29",
"outcome": "Forced-labor conspiracy charges pending; allegations are unproven."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edmi/pr/third-leader-charged-multi-state-forced-labor-conspiracy-involving-kingdom-god-global",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, Eastern District of Michigan, “Third Leader Charged in Multi-State Forced Labor Conspiracy” (Jan. 29, 2026).",
"body": "Federal prosecutors allege that David Taylor, Michelle Brannon, and Kathleen Klein used church authority, threats of spiritual harm, isolation, and punishment to compel labor and fundraising. The charges have not been adjudicated.",
"tier": "charging-authority",
"kind": "charging-document"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual threats, sleep deprivation, isolation, and forced fundraising as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-professed apostle and church leaders.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Forced-labor conspiracy charges pending; allegations are unproven.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edmi/pr/third-leader-charged-multi-state-forced-labor-conspiracy-involving-kingdom-god-global",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: charging-authority; evidentiary role: charging-document.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0377e1b519e50bfb013ec5d3992e4125cc2dbc9369446786753cc1a0777cf594",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edmi/pr/third-leader-charged-multi-state-forced-labor-conspiracy-involving-kingdom-god-global"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 16,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jesus-is-lord-orange-nj-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Orange, NJ, USA",
"lat": 40.7707,
"lng": -74.2326,
"title": "Jesus Is Lord by the Holy Ghost pastors charged with forced labor; Treva Edwards also charged with sex trafficking",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastors",
"self-proclaimed prophet"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual retribution threats",
"isolation",
"food and sleep deprivation",
"claimed divine commands"
],
"organizations": [
"Jesus Is Lord by the Holy Ghost"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, District of New Jersey",
"stage": "superseding indictment",
"date": "2026-05-19",
"outcome": "Forced-labor and sex-trafficking charges pending; allegations are unproven."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/superseding-indictment-returned-new-jersey-pastor-and-self-proclaimed-prophet-who-compelled",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, “Superseding Indictment Returned for New Jersey Pastor and Self-Proclaimed Prophet” (May 20, 2026).",
"body": "The indictment alleges that Treva and Christine Edwards controlled congregants through isolation, deprivation, spiritual threats, and compelled labor. Treva Edwards also faces sex-trafficking charges. The defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.",
"tier": "charging-authority",
"kind": "charging-document"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual retribution threats, isolation, food and sleep deprivation, and claimed divine commands as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastors and self-proclaimed prophet.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Forced-labor and sex-trafficking charges pending; allegations are unproven.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/superseding-indictment-returned-new-jersey-pastor-and-self-proclaimed-prophet-who-compelled",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: charging-authority; evidentiary role: charging-document.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c5f5f7e1014a51dfecd9e83eaa80b6d21f176f7aa83177cf6b60366e3feec870",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/superseding-indictment-returned-new-jersey-pastor-and-self-proclaimed-prophet-who-compelled"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 17,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"764"
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-richard-densmore-philadelphia-pa-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Philadelphia, PA, USA",
"lat": 39.9526,
"lng": -75.1652,
"title": "Richard Densmore: 30-year sentence for 764-network exploitation and coercion",
"tradition": "left-hand-path",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"764-network organizer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"online grooming",
"extortion",
"violent occult ideology",
"coerced self-harm"
],
"organizations": [
"764"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Pennsylvania",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2024-10-31",
"outcome": "Thirty-year federal prison sentence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/speech/assistant-attorney-general-matthew-g-olsen-delivers-remarks-30-year-prison-sentence",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, remarks on Richard Densmore’s 30-year sentence (Oct. 31, 2024).",
"body": "The Justice Department describes Densmore’s role in a 764 network that coerced minors into sexual abuse material, self-harm, and other violence and records the 30-year sentence.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies online grooming, extortion, violent occult ideology, and coerced self-harm as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is 764-network organizer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"traditionDetailId": "occult-left-hand-path",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/speech/assistant-attorney-general-matthew-g-olsen-delivers-remarks-30-year-prison-sentence",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7515deecefa61ea55e49aad052716cd0b1837ae60131561a9cc044685573aa8b",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/speech/assistant-attorney-general-matthew-g-olsen-delivers-remarks-30-year-prison-sentence"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 18,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"764"
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-erik-madison-baltimore-md-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Baltimore, MD, USA",
"lat": 39.2904,
"lng": -76.6122,
"title": "Erik Madison: 764 member pleads guilty to exploiting minors",
"tradition": "left-hand-path",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"764-network participant"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"online grooming",
"threats",
"violent occult ideology"
],
"organizations": [
"764"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, District of Maryland",
"stage": "guilty plea",
"date": "2026-04-07",
"outcome": "Guilty plea entered; sentencing pending."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-md/pr/violent-extremist-network-764-member-pleads-guilty-sexually-exploiting-minors-and",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Maryland, “Violent Extremist Network 764 Member Pleads Guilty” (Apr. 7, 2026).",
"body": "The Justice Department reports that Madison pleaded guilty to federal offenses involving the sexual exploitation of minors as part of 764’s violent online subculture. Sentencing remains pending.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "plea"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies online grooming, threats, and violent occult ideology as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is 764-network participant.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"traditionDetailId": "occult-left-hand-path",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-md/pr/violent-extremist-network-764-member-pleads-guilty-sexually-exploiting-minors-and",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: plea.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2e6e2ed1ab21ccdfd98d4087d9b9e7d0c142c8af27a843ee55f9b9e1a1525818",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-md/pr/violent-extremist-network-764-member-pleads-guilty-sexually-exploiting-minors-and"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 19,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an official-hearing and active-review record, not a criminal finding. The Knesset report states that authorities lack a settled definition, reliable prevalence data and verified case-level statistics; it also reports that several older files were referred for renewed review and that only a small number of potentially relevant files could be located. No unnamed person, rabbi, educator, official, Haredi or national-religious community, or Jewish institution is treated as culpable on testimony alone. WHAT HAS FOLLOWED, as of July 2026, and it remains entirely pre-adjudication: the committee chair requested that police meet with the State Prosecutor's Office to scope the phenomenon and produce an action plan, and called for cult-specific legislation, which has not been identified as enacted. Lahav 433, the national serious-crimes unit, has been reviewing closed cases going back more than a decade and identified only four possibly relevant files. NO INDICTMENT HAS BEEN FILED and no conviction exists in Israel for organised ritual abuse. Allegations involving one sitting and one former member of the Knesset remain under investigation and are not asserted here. In June 2026 the Gush Etzion Regional Council publicly acknowledged that ritualistic abuse had occurred in its communities — an institutional admission, not a judicial finding, naming no convicted individual. A structural fact recorded by the Knesset Research and Information Centre is worth stating on its own: Israel has no statutory definition of ritual or organised abuse, ministries keep no data on it, and police and prosecutors cannot reliably identify such files in their own systems.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-knesset-ritual-abuse-hearing-jerusalem-israel",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Jerusalem, Israel",
"lat": 31.7683,
"lng": 35.2137,
"title": "Knesset hearings and active police review of organized ritual sexual-abuse allegations",
"tradition": "judaism",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-hearing",
"authorityRoles": [
"parliamentary oversight committees",
"religious and community authorities described in testimony"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"alleged ritual and ideological threats",
"alleged abuse of religious authority",
"community silence",
"alleged organized exploitation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Knesset Committee on the Status of Women and Gender Equality",
"Knesset Special Committee on Youth Affairs",
"Israel Police Lahav 433 Unit 105"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Knesset",
"stage": "first joint committee hearing",
"date": "2025-06-03",
"outcome": "A joint session of the Committee on the Status of Women and Gender Equality (chaired by Pnina Tamano-Shata) and the Special Committee for Young Israelis (chaired by Naama Lazimi) sat on 3 June 2025, prompted by an investigative report in Israel Hayom that April. The committees received first-person testimony and agency responses concerning alleged organised ritual sexual abuse. A follow-up hearing was held on 27 July 2025 and a further hearing was reported in December 2025. The hearings did not adjudicate the allegations — these are testimony-receiving sessions, and no committee has issued findings of fact."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Knesset",
"stage": "second joint committee hearing",
"date": "2025-07-27",
"outcome": "The committees received further testimony and questioned police and state representatives. The hearing did not adjudicate individual or network culpability."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Israel Police and State Attorney's Office",
"stage": "active review reported to the Knesset",
"date": "2025-11-02",
"outcome": "The public-security minister told a Knesset member that Unit 105 was conducting investigative actions under prosecutorial supervision. No public charging or merits decision was reported in the source reviewed."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Knesset Research and Information Center",
"stage": "official research report",
"date": "2025-12-01",
"outcome": "The center documented the hearings, agency responses, active review and severe data limitations, including the inability to estimate prevalence or provide verified case-level statistics."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The hearings concerned allegations that religious, mystical or ideological ritual language, spiritual authority and insular community structures were used to frighten, control and silence children during organized abuse. The Knesset research report describes these as reported mechanisms and a subject of official inquiry, not as proven facts about every allegation or any religious community.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://fs.knesset.gov.il/globaldocs/MMM/a1d03375-8d40-f011-a85f-005056aa9911/2_a1d03375-8d40-f011-a85f-005056aa9911_11_21268.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Knesset Research and Information Center, Organized Ritual Sexual Abuse, with Emphasis on Harm to Minors (Dec. 1, 2025; Hebrew).",
"body": "The official parliamentary research report documents the June 3 and July 27 joint hearings, first-person testimony, agency responses, referrals of older files for renewed review, the reported active Unit 105 investigation, and the absence of reliable prevalence or verified case-level data.",
"tier": "official-parliamentary-research-report",
"kind": "official-hearing-and-agency-review"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/horrifying-testimonies-seek-to-lift-shroud-of-silence-around-ritual-sex-abuse-claims/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel, 'Horrifying testimonies seek to lift shroud of silence around ritual sex abuse claims' (Aug. 25, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting documents the hearings, attributes allegations to the people who made them, records the police confirmation that the issue was under investigation, and distinguishes unanswered claims from official action.",
"tier": "national-news-court-and-parliament-reporting",
"kind": "official-hearing-report"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The center documented the hearings, agency responses, active review and severe data limitations, including the inability to estimate prevalence or provide verified case-level statistics.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://fs.knesset.gov.il/globaldocs/MMM/a1d03375-8d40-f011-a85f-005056aa9911/2_a1d03375-8d40-f011-a85f-005056aa9911_11_21268.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-parliamentary-research-report; evidentiary role: official-hearing-and-agency-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d3b8a29318dae296cb2d64e7d80c4fdf3866acac91bd8f94873f7f39f2a5f236",
"final_url": "https://fs.knesset.gov.il/globaldocs/MMM/a1d03375-8d40-f011-a85f-005056aa9911/2_a1d03375-8d40-f011-a85f-005056aa9911_11_21268.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/horrifying-testimonies-seek-to-lift-shroud-of-silence-around-ritual-sex-abuse-claims/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-court-and-parliament-reporting; evidentiary role: official-hearing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3130dccc5b118d20bf614730d6eb82d6f978dd29605fb70aa384f4e820128183",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/horrifying-testimonies-seek-to-lift-shroud-of-silence-around-ritual-sex-abuse-claims/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 20,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-bratslav-yavneel-hearing-jerusalem-israel",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Jerusalem, Israel",
"lat": 31.7683,
"lng": 35.2137,
"title": "Knesset panel hears former Bratslav-community members on child marriage and abuse",
"tradition": "judaism",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-hearing",
"authorityRoles": [
"community religious leadership",
"parliamentary oversight body"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"child marriage",
"community control",
"religious authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Yavne’el Bratslav community"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Knesset",
"stage": "official hearing",
"date": "2026-02-09",
"outcome": "Testimony received; enforcement questions referred to public authorities."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/ex-members-of-bratslav-community-testify-about-child-marriages-abuse-before-knesset-panel/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel, “Ex-members of Bratslav community testify about child marriages, abuse before Knesset panel” (Feb. 9, 2026).",
"body": "The report records testimony before a Knesset panel concerning child marriage and abuse in a Bratslav community. The entry is an institutional-hearing record, not a criminal finding.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "official-hearing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies child marriage, community control, and religious authority as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is community religious leadership and parliamentary oversight body.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Testimony received; enforcement questions referred to public authorities.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/ex-members-of-bratslav-community-testify-about-child-marriages-abuse-before-knesset-panel/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: official-hearing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 21,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-talibe-daara-system-senegal",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Dakar, Senegal",
"lat": 14.7167,
"lng": -17.4677,
"title": "UN prevention-of-torture review documents forced begging and abuse in Senegal’s daara system",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Quranic-school masters"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"forced begging",
"institutional custody",
"physical punishment"
],
"organizations": [
"Senegalese daara system"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "United Nations Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture",
"stage": "country report",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "Official observations and recommendations concerning talibé children."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://docstore.ohchr.org/SelfServices/FilesHandler.ashx?enc=2lb4g3Mk38yVA9j4gwOX7cstf%2F15iyO%2Fh3CCBEZ5u1FzmJ53khfRwTElZp9BDTtNAyKefGbEktlSUj2uPGaopw%3D%3D",
"archive": "",
"citation": "UN Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture, report concerning Senegal and talibé children.",
"body": "The UN report addresses forced begging, violence, deprivation, and weak protection for talibé children living under the authority of some Quranic-school masters. This is an institutional record and does not assign collective culpability to Islam or all daaras.",
"tier": "official-finding",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies forced begging, institutional custody, and physical punishment as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Quranic-school masters.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://docstore.ohchr.org/SelfServices/FilesHandler.ashx?enc=2lb4g3Mk38yVA9j4gwOX7cstf%2F15iyO%2Fh3CCBEZ5u1FzmJ53khfRwTElZp9BDTtNAyKefGbEktlSUj2uPGaopw%3D%3D",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b937270ec2072caa2b1359ac10d7403e4f54f22fa01fe9ec9d985d3b0751c823",
"final_url": "https://docstore.ohchr.org/SelfServices/FilesHandler.ashx?enc=2lb4g3Mk38yVA9j4gwOX7cstf%2F15iyO%2Fh3CCBEZ5u1FzmJ53khfRwTElZp9BDTtNAyKefGbEktlSUj2uPGaopw%3D%3D"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 22,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"eastern-gurus-in-the-west"
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-sakyong-mipham-shambhala-canada-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Halifax, Canada",
"lat": 44.6488,
"lng": -63.5752,
"title": "Shambhala-commissioned investigation finds two sexual-misconduct allegations against Sakyong Mipham credible",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"lineage holder and spiritual leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual hierarchy",
"institutional access",
"community pressure"
],
"organizations": [
"Shambhala International"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent investigation commissioned by Shambhala International",
"stage": "final report",
"date": "2019-02-03",
"outcome": "Two allegations found credible under the investigation’s stated standard; not a criminal adjudication."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tricycle.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/2-3-19-WH-Report-Final-Package.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wickwire Holm, “Report of Investigation” commissioned by Shambhala International (Feb. 3, 2019).",
"body": "The commissioned report explains its mandate and evidentiary standard and finds two allegations against Sakyong Mipham credible. Its findings are institutional, not criminal judgments, and participation limits are stated in the report.",
"tier": "commissioned-investigation",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual hierarchy, institutional access, and community pressure as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is lineage holder and spiritual leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tricycle.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/2-3-19-WH-Report-Final-Package.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioned-investigation; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7ca081a9f74a1272df4dfffaad4b2bf478f3b7768418665cf0b5ac07e4224787",
"final_url": "https://tricycle.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/2-3-19-WH-Report-Final-Package.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 23,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"eastern-gurus-in-the-west"
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-sogyal-rinpoche-rigpa-europe",
"year": 2018,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 51.5074,
"lng": -0.1278,
"title": "Rigpa-commissioned investigation upholds serious allegations against Sogyal Rinpoche",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and Tibetan Buddhist teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru devotion",
"spiritual hierarchy",
"institutional dependency"
],
"organizations": [
"Rigpa"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent investigation commissioned by Rigpa",
"stage": "final report",
"date": "2018-08-22",
"outcome": "Multiple allegations upheld under the report’s stated civil standard; not a criminal adjudication."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://info-buddhism.com/PDF/Lewis-Silkin-report.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Karen Baxter, Lewis Silkin LLP, independent investigation report commissioned by Rigpa (Aug. 22, 2018).",
"body": "The report sets out its commission, methods, participation limits, and findings concerning physical, sexual, and emotional abuse and the role of spiritual authority.",
"tier": "commissioned-investigation",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rigpa.de/der-von-uns-in-auftrag-gegebene-bericht-der-unabhaengigen-untersuchungskommission-zu-den-anschuldigungen-gegen-sogyal-rinpoche-ist-veroeffentlicht/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rigpa Germany, notice publishing the commissioned independent investigation.",
"body": "Rigpa’s own notice confirms that the organization commissioned and published the investigation.",
"tier": "organization-record",
"kind": "commissioning-record"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies guru devotion, spiritual hierarchy, and institutional dependency as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and Tibetan Buddhist teacher.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://info-buddhism.com/PDF/Lewis-Silkin-report.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioned-investigation; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f5912f4691765e2b7e70f4f477bd6cd135613a688d16627f0264a300ce7198ec",
"final_url": "https://info-buddhism.com/PDF/Lewis-Silkin-report.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rigpa.de/der-von-uns-in-auftrag-gegebene-bericht-der-unabhaengigen-untersuchungskommission-zu-den-anschuldigungen-gegen-sogyal-rinpoche-ist-veroeffentlicht/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: organization-record; evidentiary role: commissioning-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8b5fd21a9394814742822cd23a72e30965ab88a00f80d53a33efcc05722c8269",
"final_url": "https://www.rigpa.de/der-von-uns-in-auftrag-gegebene-bericht-der-unabhaengigen-untersuchungskommission-zu-den-anschuldigungen-gegen-sogyal-rinpoche-ist-veroeffentlicht/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 24,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"eastern-gurus-in-the-west"
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-yogi-bhajan-3ho-united-states",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Espanola, NM, USA",
"lat": 35.9911,
"lng": -106.0806,
"title": "3HO-commissioned investigation finds sexual and related misconduct by Yogi Bhajan more likely than not",
"tradition": "sikhism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and spiritual teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru authority",
"institutional dependency",
"claims of spiritual consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"3HO",
"Sikh Dharma International"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent investigation commissioned by 3HO-related organizations",
"stage": "final report",
"date": "2020-08-10",
"outcome": "The investigator found multiple allegations more likely than not; not a criminal adjudication."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://asiasamachar.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Olive-Branch-Yogi-Bhajan-Investigation_10Aug2020.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "An Olive Branch, “Report of the Investigation into Allegations of Sexual and Related Misconduct by Yogi Bhajan” (Aug. 10, 2020).",
"body": "The commissioned report describes its mandate, interview process, limitations, and preponderance-style standard. It concludes that multiple allegations of sexual and related misconduct were more likely than not.",
"tier": "commissioned-investigation",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies guru authority, institutional dependency, and claims of spiritual consequence as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and spiritual teacher.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-sikh",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://asiasamachar.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Olive-Branch-Yogi-Bhajan-Investigation_10Aug2020.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioned-investigation; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ca155726693bbc100335e978d8eef9a3354f2ed027623331736f5044507d5db4",
"final_url": "https://asiasamachar.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Olive-Branch-Yogi-Bhajan-Investigation_10Aug2020.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 25,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"eastern-gurus-in-the-west"
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-donald-walters-ananda-san-mateo-ca-usa",
"year": 1998,
"place": "San Mateo, CA, USA",
"lat": 37.563,
"lng": -122.3255,
"title": "Donald Walters / Swami Kriyananda and Ananda: civil verdict on abuse of spiritual authority",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and spiritual leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru authority",
"residential-community dependency",
"institutional concealment"
],
"organizations": [
"Ananda Church of Self-Realization"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of California, County of San Mateo",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "1998-02-05",
"outcome": "Civil jury verdict and damages; not a criminal conviction."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://anandainfo.com/sj_merc_020698.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "San Jose Mercury News, report on the Bertolucci v. Ananda verdict (Feb. 6, 1998), preserved by Ananda Awareness Network.",
"body": "The contemporaneous report states that jurors found Ananda leaders had abused spiritual authority and that the church was liable on civil claims including fraud and negligent supervision. This entry reports a civil verdict, not a criminal conviction.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://anandainfo.com/services/docs/Woman%201%20ENG.PDF",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court-filed declaration preserved in the Ananda litigation archive.",
"body": "The preserved filing supplies proceeding-level context. The host is an advocacy archive, so the document is used as a court-record lead and not as independent verification of every allegation.",
"tier": "litigation-document",
"kind": "court-filing"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/US_District_Court_Jury_Verdict_SRF_v_Ananda_2002",
"citation": "US District Court, Eastern District of California, jury verdict record, Self-Realization Fellowship v. Ananda Church of Self-Realization (2002).",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press",
"body": "Published federal court jury-verdict record from related SRF v. Ananda litigation; use as corroborating court-tier documentation of the Ananda organizational and litigation context surrounding the Bertolucci and Murphy civil suits against Walters. Retain the existing anandainfo.com contemporaneous-reporting and litigation-document sources as the primary basis for the abuse-verdict facts themselves; this source strengthens institutional/proceedings context only and should not replace the original civil-verdict sourcing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents guru authority, residential-community dependency, and institutional concealment, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is founder and spiritual leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://anandainfo.com/sj_merc_020698.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c77992b77867259fce5a7f632e874943fbc36f6ca5ad5500654bbacc86e4e197",
"final_url": "https://anandainfo.com/sj_merc_020698.html"
},
{
"source": "https://anandainfo.com/services/docs/Woman%201%20ENG.PDF",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: litigation-document; evidentiary role: court-filing.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2bd940e0257b5f0934c30f5e84c578a0db0079978a80b777a4ef1f681740ea48",
"final_url": "https://anandainfo.com/services/docs/Woman%201%20ENG.PDF"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/US_District_Court_Jury_Verdict_SRF_v_Ananda_2002",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4ce1b3efd3a7eb65b1d0892032c0b93f7107ddbd0e5ee6b367cdaf0d35948296",
"final_url": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/US_District_Court_Jury_Verdict_SRF_v_Ananda_2002"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 26,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mark-stevens-salt-lake-county-ut-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Salt Lake County, UT, USA",
"lat": 40.6677,
"lng": -111.9306,
"title": "Former LDS bishop Mark Lehnhof Stevens charged with assaulting a minor during religious counseling",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"LDS bishop"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious counseling",
"claimed divine instruction",
"authority over a minor"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Third District Court, Salt Lake County, Utah",
"stage": "criminal charges",
"date": "2025-02-03",
"outcome": "One forcible-sodomy count and two forcible-sexual-abuse counts charged; allegations are unproven."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.saltlakecounty.gov/district-attorney/press-release-archives/2025/religious-leader-charged-for-alleged-2006-sexual-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Salt Lake County District Attorney, “Religious Leader Charged for Alleged 2006 Sexual Assault” (Feb. 3, 2025).",
"body": "The charging release alleges that Stevens used his role as bishop and claimed divine instruction while assaulting a minor during a church counseling meeting. He is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.",
"tier": "charging-authority",
"kind": "charging-document"
},
{
"link": "https://www.saltlakecounty.gov/globalassets/1-site-files/district-attorney/documents/charges-filed/stevens-information.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State of Utah v. Mark Lehnhof Stevens, Information, Salt Lake County District Attorney DAO 25.001307.",
"body": "The filed information sets out the three charged counts and identifies the case as a pending criminal prosecution. The allegations have not been adjudicated.",
"tier": "charging-document",
"kind": "court-filing"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents religious counseling, claimed divine instruction, and authority over a minor, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is LDS bishop.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "One forcible-sodomy count and two forcible-sexual-abuse counts charged; allegations are unproven.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.saltlakecounty.gov/district-attorney/press-release-archives/2025/religious-leader-charged-for-alleged-2006-sexual-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: charging-authority; evidentiary role: charging-document.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "54121c1f1228c9d57ac567fe90063f1a5d4aa4c4db60e3fd3bf0e6402946ea75",
"final_url": "https://www.saltlakecounty.gov/district-attorney/press-release-archives/2025/religious-leader-charged-for-alleged-2006-sexual-assault/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.saltlakecounty.gov/globalassets/1-site-files/district-attorney/documents/charges-filed/stevens-information.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: charging-document; evidentiary role: court-filing.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 27,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "In French procedure, mise en examen is a formal investigatory status, not a finding of guilt. Bivolaru and MISA representatives deny wrongdoing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-gregorian-bivolaru-misa-paris-france",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Paris, France",
"lat": 48.8566,
"lng": 2.3522,
"title": "Gregorian Bivolaru / MISA: French judicial investigation for aggravated rape and human trafficking",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and spiritual leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual authority",
"indoctrination",
"isolation",
"sexual access framed as spiritual advancement"
],
"organizations": [
"Movement for Spiritual Integration into the Absolute (MISA)",
"Atman Federation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Paris judicial court",
"stage": "mise en examen and pretrial detention",
"date": "2023-12-01",
"outcome": "Formal judicial investigation for aggravated rape, abuse of weakness, organized human trafficking and organized sequestration; no trial judgment has been entered."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2024/03/24/the-downfall-of-a-yogi-guru-accused-of-rape-and-human-trafficking-in-france_6649819_7.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le Monde, “The downfall of a yogi-guru accused of rape and human trafficking in France” (Mar. 24, 2024).",
"body": "Le Monde reports the November 2023 operation, the formal judicial statuses assigned to Bivolaru and other defendants, the alleged use of MISA’s spiritual hierarchy, and denials from the movement. The allegations remain unadjudicated.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "proceeding-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/viols-et-emprise-sectaire-sur-fond-de-yoga-le-gourou-roumain-du-val-de-marne-crie-a-la-conspiration-20-06-2026-D5AEV6PT3BFINJTUASAOSJTUDQ.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le Parisien, “Viols et emprise sectaire sur fond de yoga” (June 20, 2026).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting from the Paris investigating chamber records that Bivolaru remained in pretrial detention in June 2026 and identifies the pending offenses. The article also records his conspiracy defense; no guilt finding has been made.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "current-proceeding-status"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents spiritual authority, indoctrination, isolation, and sexual access framed as spiritual advancement, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is founder and spiritual leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Formal judicial investigation for aggravated rape, abuse of weakness, organized human trafficking and organized sequestration; no trial judgment has been entered.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2024/03/24/the-downfall-of-a-yogi-guru-accused-of-rape-and-human-trafficking-in-france_6649819_7.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: proceeding-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "39e2b1ae73d9f88ee3b6e08db3971d9a6c95ae8013c88f05a9a37bc956f00915",
"final_url": "https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2024/03/24/the-downfall-of-a-yogi-guru-accused-of-rape-and-human-trafficking-in-france_6649819_7.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/viols-et-emprise-sectaire-sur-fond-de-yoga-le-gourou-roumain-du-val-de-marne-crie-a-la-conspiration-20-06-2026-D5AEV6PT3BFINJTUASAOSJTUDQ.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: current-proceeding-status.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 28,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [
"eastern-gurus-in-the-west"
],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This entry records an institutional acknowledgment and related federal civil opinion. It does not classify consensual adult relationships by themselves as criminal conduct.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-amrit-desai-kripalu-lenox-ma-usa",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Lenox, MA, USA",
"lat": 42.3565,
"lng": -73.2848,
"title": "Kripalu removes founder Amrit Desai after concealed relationships with disciples",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and guru"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru authority",
"residential-community dependency",
"celibacy rules",
"unpaid or low-paid disciple labor"
],
"organizations": [
"Kripalu Yoga Fellowship",
"Kripalu Center for Yoga & Health"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kripalu Yoga Fellowship",
"stage": "institutional removal and public acknowledgment",
"outcome": "Desai resigned after admitting concealed sexual relationships; later federal litigation recorded the guru-authority and disciple-labor structure. This was not a criminal adjudication."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://kripalu.org/living-kripalu/holding-pose",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kripalu Center for Yoga & Health, “Holding the Pose.”",
"body": "Kripalu’s institutional history states that Desai was asked to resign in 1994 after concealed inappropriate sexual relationships with female disciples and financial improprieties came to light.",
"tier": "organization-record",
"kind": "institutional-acknowledgment"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp2/18/117/2449890/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dushkin v. Desai, 18 F. Supp. 2d 117 (D. Mass. 1998).",
"body": "The federal opinion records Desai’s guru role, the residential disciples’ labor and donations, the concealed sexual relationships, his public acknowledgment, and the court’s treatment of related fraud and unfair-practices claims. It is a civil procedural opinion, not a criminal verdict.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "civil-opinion"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies guru authority, residential-community dependency, celibacy rules, and unpaid or low-paid disciple labor as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and guru.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://kripalu.org/living-kripalu/holding-pose",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: organization-record; evidentiary role: institutional-acknowledgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp2/18/117/2449890/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: civil-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 29,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The record concerns Reilly's use of claimed energy-healing techniques and a treatment relationship to facilitate the assault. It does not assign responsibility to energy-healing practitioners generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-david-reilly-longford-ireland",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Longford, Ireland",
"lat": 53.7276,
"lng": -7.7932,
"title": "David Reilly: conviction for assault during an energy-healing session",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"energy healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"healing-session pretext",
"claimed removal of sexual blockages",
"treatment trust"
],
"organizations": [
"Energy Healing Ireland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Longford Circuit Court",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2024-11-22",
"outcome": "Convicted of sexual assault and offensive conduct of a sexual nature; sentenced to 27 months with the final nine months suspended."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2024/07/31/longford-energy-healer-found-guilty-of-sexually-assaulting-client/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Irish Times, ‘Longford “energy healer” found guilty of sexually assaulting client’ (July 31, 2024).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the unanimous guilty verdicts and the evidence that Reilly told the client he could clear trauma-related sexual blockages through an energy-healing session.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2024/11/22/energy-healer-sentenced-to-18-months-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-woman/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Irish Times, ‘“Energy healer” sentenced to 18 months in prison for sexually assaulting woman’ (Nov. 22, 2024).",
"body": "The sentencing report records the 27-month term with nine months suspended, the offenses of conviction, the treatment setting and the court's findings concerning Reilly's denial and victim-blaming.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies healing-session pretext, claimed removal of sexual blockages, and treatment trust as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is energy healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2024/07/31/longford-energy-healer-found-guilty-of-sexually-assaulting-client/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3819bc982d2d9a7dbab7d56a48c74566d4232a3bf063b79971c9b82ba76b0924",
"final_url": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2024/07/31/longford-energy-healer-found-guilty-of-sexually-assaulting-client/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2024/11/22/energy-healer-sentenced-to-18-months-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-woman/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a54ac0447bfadb6b9998aa06f8928554d6f48e51e9b7813f2c542a22322d4605",
"final_url": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2024/11/22/energy-healer-sentenced-to-18-months-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-woman/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 30,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The convictions involved assaults committed while Dresen purported to treat clients as a spiritual or chakra healer. The record does not imply that chakra practices or their practitioners generally are abusive.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-stawingua-dresen-victoria-australia",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.4713,
"lng": 144.7852,
"title": "Stawingua Dresen: eight convictions for assaults during claimed chakra healing",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed spiritual and chakra healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"chakra-healing pretext",
"treatment trust",
"unregulated practitioner authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2009-09-07",
"outcome": "Convicted of eight counts of indecent assault against six clients; sentenced to three years and three months with a two-year non-parole period."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2009-09-07/charlatan-healer-jailed-over-client-assaults/1420074",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ABC News, ‘“Charlatan healer” jailed over client assaults’ (Sept. 7, 2009).",
"body": "The Australian public broadcaster's contemporaneous court report records the eight convictions, sentence, six clients and Dresen's use of purported spiritual or chakra treatment during the assaults.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies chakra-healing pretext, treatment trust, and unregulated practitioner authority as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-proclaimed spiritual and chakra healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2009-09-07/charlatan-healer-jailed-over-client-assaults/1420074",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6cf64a85dc4f30ad3d1c14334ae441a0d0e3f6b7d918be73a1edcf91490b4b0a",
"final_url": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2009-09-07/charlatan-healer-jailed-over-client-assaults/1420074"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 31,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The judgment concerns one practitioner’s use of Santería rites as a pretext for assault. It does not assign responsibility to Santería or its practitioners generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-santeria-rites-gran-canaria-spain",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Gran Canaria, Spain",
"lat": 28.1235,
"lng": -15.4363,
"title": "Gran Canaria court convicts a Santería practitioner who used rites to assault a child",
"tradition": "santeria",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"practitioner of Cuban Santería rites"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual pretext",
"deception",
"authority over a minor"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Provincial Court of Las Palmas, First Section",
"stage": "criminal judgment",
"date": "2024-05-31",
"outcome": "Convicted of continuous aggravated sexual assault of a child and sentenced to ten years, six months and one day in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/es/Poder-Judicial/Tribunales-Superiores-de-Justicia/TSJ-Canarias/Oficina-de-Comunicacion/Notas-de-prensa/Condenado-a-diez-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-al-hijo-de-su-pareja-mediante-ritos-de-santeria",
"archive": "",
"citation": "General Council of the Judiciary of Spain, ‘Condenado a diez años de cárcel por violar al hijo de su pareja mediante ritos de santería’ (June 5, 2024).",
"body": "The judiciary’s release records the sentence and the court’s finding that the defendant used purported Cuban Santería rites to deceive and sexually assault his partner’s minor child. The court did not identify the defendant publicly.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "judgment-release"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies ritual pretext, deception, and authority over a minor as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is practitioner of Cuban Santería rites.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/es/Poder-Judicial/Tribunales-Superiores-de-Justicia/TSJ-Canarias/Oficina-de-Comunicacion/Notas-de-prensa/Condenado-a-diez-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-al-hijo-de-su-pareja-mediante-ritos-de-santeria",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: judgment-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3efa8875db3e0c0162a9b55d5bade063b63ffeefcf0dd9f9d0fff132ca592a5f",
"final_url": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/es/Poder-Judicial/Tribunales-Superiores-de-Justicia/TSJ-Canarias/Oficina-de-Comunicacion/Notas-de-prensa/Condenado-a-diez-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-al-hijo-de-su-pareja-mediante-ritos-de-santeria"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 32,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Valparaíso Court of Appeals",
"date": "2017-04-18",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the effective prison sentences imposed on Guerra and Undurraga."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Leader Ramón Castillo Gaete died by suicide while a fugitive and was not tried. The record distinguishes the two sentenced principals from five people convicted as accessories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-antares-de-la-luz-colliguay-chile",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Colliguay, Quilpué, Chile",
"lat": -33.0458,
"lng": -71.4415,
"title": "Antares de la Luz: convictions after an apocalyptic group’s ritual killing of an infant",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"apocalyptic group leader",
"leader’s senior follower",
"parent within the group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"apocalyptic prophecy",
"leader control",
"ritual command",
"group concealment"
],
"organizations": [
"Antares de la Luz group"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Guarantee Court of Quilpué",
"stage": "abbreviated criminal proceeding and sentencing",
"date": "2017-03-06",
"outcome": "Natalia Guerra and Pablo Undurraga received five-year effective prison sentences; five accessories received three-year substitute sentences."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/actualidad/noticias/regionales/fiscalia-obtuvo-condena-de-la-secta-de-antares-de-la-luz",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Prosecutor’s Office of Chile, ‘Fiscalía obtuvo condena de la Secta de Antares de la Luz’ (Mar. 2, 2017).",
"body": "Chile’s prosecuting authority records the convictions and the evidence that the group killed an infant during a 2012 end-times ritual after its leader declared the child infernal.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/actualidad/noticias/regionales/fiscalia-logra-penas-solicitadas-contra-la-secta-de-antares-de-la",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Prosecutor’s Office of Chile, ‘Fiscalía logra penas solicitadas contra la Secta de Antares de la Luz’ (Mar. 6, 2017).",
"body": "The sentencing release identifies the effective five-year prison terms for Guerra and Undurraga and the substitute sentences imposed on five accessories.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/index.php/actualidad/noticias/regionales/corte-mantiene-penas-de-carcel-efectiva-en-caso-antares-de-la-luz",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Prosecutor’s Office of Chile, ‘Corte mantiene penas de cárcel efectiva en caso Antares de la Luz’ (Apr. 18, 2017).",
"body": "The release records the Valparaíso Court of Appeals’ decision affirming the effective prison sentences imposed on Guerra and Undurraga.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-doomsday-apocalyptic",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies apocalyptic prophecy, leader control, ritual command, and group concealment as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is apocalyptic group leader, leader’s senior follower, and parent within the group.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Valparaíso Court of Appeals",
"date": "2017-04-18",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the effective prison sentences imposed on Guerra and Undurraga."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/actualidad/noticias/regionales/fiscalia-obtuvo-condena-de-la-secta-de-antares-de-la-luz",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0a6fa682a390d8b84e2604de32918e6eaad8abcaf003c9028ce16ea7d364f454",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/actualidad/noticias/regionales/fiscalia-obtuvo-condena-de-la-secta-de-antares-de-la-luz"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/actualidad/noticias/regionales/fiscalia-logra-penas-solicitadas-contra-la-secta-de-antares-de-la",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1c12736f8110fa7756cbef405279c688f0c2413ce23bf41a4ba6e967b9af27bb",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/actualidad/noticias/regionales/fiscalia-logra-penas-solicitadas-contra-la-secta-de-antares-de-la"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/index.php/actualidad/noticias/regionales/corte-mantiene-penas-de-carcel-efectiva-en-caso-antares-de-la-luz",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dc5aa97db1fb6442e26d13398193498d22407c2232d8ea337993b16311153ec9",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscaliadechile.cl/index.php/actualidad/noticias/regionales/corte-mantiene-penas-de-carcel-efectiva-en-caso-antares-de-la-luz"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 33,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The Dutch court withheld the defendant’s name. The entry follows the judgment’s facts and does not imply that spiritual healing practices generally are abusive.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-spiritual-healer-the-hague-netherlands",
"year": 2026,
"place": "The Hague, Netherlands",
"lat": 52.0705,
"lng": 4.3007,
"title": "The Hague court convicts a spiritual healer of rape and sexual assault during healing sessions",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"spiritual healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"healing-session pretext",
"treatment trust",
"intoxication"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of The Hague",
"stage": "criminal judgment",
"date": "2026-04-02",
"outcome": "Convicted of rape and indecent assault; sentenced to 36 months, with 12 months suspended, and barred from spiritual-healing work for five years."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/details?id=ECLI%3ANL%3ARBDHA%3A2026%3A7512",
"archive": "",
"citation": "District Court of The Hague, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:7512 (Apr. 2, 2026).",
"body": "The judgment finds that the defendant raped one woman and sexually assaulted another while presenting the encounters as spiritual-healing sessions. It records the evidentiary findings, sentence, compensation, and five-year occupational ban.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rechtspraak.nl/organisatie-en-contact/organisatie/rechtbanken/rechtbank-den-haag/nieuws/2026/04/celstraf-na-verkrachting-en-ontucht-van-twee-vrouwen-als-spiritueel-healer",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Netherlands Judiciary, ‘Celstraf na verkrachting en ontucht van twee vrouwen als spiritueel healer’ (Apr. 2, 2026).",
"body": "The judiciary’s case summary explains how the women approached the defendant for help, the court’s reliability findings, and the sentence imposed for the two offenses.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "judgment-release"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies healing-session pretext, treatment trust, and intoxication as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is spiritual healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/details?id=ECLI%3ANL%3ARBDHA%3A2026%3A7512",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "36069482a44139f041698d456792c914c8209e59d2671f8f167b9d5d61d9596e",
"final_url": "https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/details?id=ECLI%3ANL%3ARBDHA%3A2026%3A7512"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rechtspraak.nl/organisatie-en-contact/organisatie/rechtbanken/rechtbank-den-haag/nieuws/2026/04/celstraf-na-verkrachting-en-ontucht-van-twee-vrouwen-als-spiritueel-healer",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: judgment-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 34,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This entry concerns the Russian conviction. Later Argentine allegations involving Rudnev require a separate proceeding-level record and are not folded into this disposition.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-konstantin-rudnev-novosibirsk-russia",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Novosibirsk, Russia",
"lat": 55.0084,
"lng": 82.9357,
"title": "Konstantin Rudnev: 11-year sentence for crimes committed through the Ashram Shambala group",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and group leader",
"self-described guru"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru authority",
"group isolation",
"psychological control"
],
"organizations": [
"Ashram Shambala"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Novosibirsk District Court",
"stage": "criminal judgment",
"date": "2013-02-07",
"outcome": "Convicted of organizing an association infringing citizens’ rights, rape, violent sexual acts, and large-scale drug possession; sentenced to 11 years in a strict-regime penal colony."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rg.ru/2013/02/07/reg-sibfo/ashram-anons.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rossiyskaya Gazeta, ‘В Новосибирске лидера “Ашрам Шамбалы” приговорили к 11 годам’ (Feb. 7, 2013).",
"body": "The Russian government’s newspaper records the Novosibirsk District Court’s convictions, the 11-year sentence, the offenses of conviction, and the compensation ordered for victims.",
"tier": "official-government-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies guru authority, group isolation, and psychological control as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and group leader and self-described guru.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rg.ru/2013/02/07/reg-sibfo/ashram-anons.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 35,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The name used by this small group is not evidence of a relationship to other churches with similar names. The entry is limited to the nine people convicted in the El Terrón proceeding and does not assign responsibility to Ngäbe people or Christian communities generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-el-terron-ngabe-bugle-panama",
"year": 2021,
"place": "El Terrón, Ngäbe-Buglé, Panama",
"lat": 8.7356,
"lng": -81.2329,
"title": "El Terrón: nine convictions after seven people were killed during a sect’s religious rite",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"members of a self-described religious group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-rite setting",
"group violence",
"confinement"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia de Dios group in El Terrón"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Trial Court in Changuinola, Panama",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentencing",
"date": "2021-12-03",
"outcome": "Seven defendants were sentenced to 50 years each for the deaths of six minors and a pregnant woman; two other defendants had already received 47-year sentences by plea agreement."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ministeriopublico.gob.pa/notas-de-prensa/pena-maxima-para-siete-personas-por-las-muertes-en-el-terron/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Prosecutor’s Office of Panama, ‘Pena máxima para siete personas por las muertes en El Terrón’ (Dec. 3, 2021).",
"body": "Panama’s prosecuting authority records the seven 50-year sentences, the two earlier 47-year plea sentences, the seven deaths, and its finding that the killings occurred during a religious rite conducted by members of a sect.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://ministeriopublico.gob.pa/notas-de-prensa/ministerio-publico-concluye-etapa-de-investigacion-en-el-caso-de-la-secta-de-el-terron/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Prosecutor’s Office of Panama, ‘Ministerio Público concluye etapa de investigación en el caso de la secta de El Terrón’ (Apr. 27, 2021).",
"body": "The charging-stage release identifies the nine defendants, the clandestine grave, the seven victims, the offenses charged, and the defendants’ membership in the group they called Iglesia de Dios.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "charging-release"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious-rite setting, group violence, and confinement as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is members of a self-described religious group.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ministeriopublico.gob.pa/notas-de-prensa/pena-maxima-para-siete-personas-por-las-muertes-en-el-terron/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a9e71b817e22e974c47bab8be0772f50c9ba6d964ba2255e8ecdd7f458a1c0d6",
"final_url": "https://ministeriopublico.gob.pa/notas-de-prensa/pena-maxima-para-siete-personas-por-las-muertes-en-el-terron/"
},
{
"source": "https://ministeriopublico.gob.pa/notas-de-prensa/ministerio-publico-concluye-etapa-de-investigacion-en-el-caso-de-la-secta-de-el-terron/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: charging-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3c9ce6d483cef25cbf504cf7f7f02109e67f01f2377289615f0cc5d98c60f1ff",
"final_url": "https://ministeriopublico.gob.pa/notas-de-prensa/ministerio-publico-concluye-etapa-de-investigacion-en-el-caso-de-la-secta-de-el-terron/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 36,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Japanese criminal courts",
"date": "2011-11-21",
"outcome": "The final appeal among the 13 Aum defendants sentenced to death was dismissed; the Ministry of Justice’s published table records each defendant’s individual charges and appellate disposition."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Aum Shinrikyo combined teachings from several traditions into its own doctrine. This record concerns the organization’s crimes and the separately adjudicated conduct of its convicted members; it does not assign responsibility to Buddhism, Hinduism, Christianity, yoga, or later organizations merely because Aum appropriated their concepts.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1995-aum-shinrikyo-tokyo-japan",
"year": 1995,
"place": "Tokyo, Japan",
"lat": 35.6762,
"lng": 139.6503,
"title": "Aum Shinrikyo: mass-murder convictions for sarin attacks directed by its guru",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and guru",
"senior religious followers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"absolute guru authority",
"doctrinal justification for killing",
"hierarchical command"
],
"organizations": [
"Aum Shinrikyo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tokyo District Court",
"stage": "criminal judgment",
"date": "2004-02-27",
"outcome": "Shoko Asahara was convicted and sentenced to death for the Matsumoto and Tokyo subway sarin attacks and other murders and attempted murders."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Japan",
"stage": "special appeal",
"date": "2006-09-15",
"outcome": "The court dismissed Asahara’s special appeal, making the death sentence final."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.moj.go.jp/psia/25years_after_the_tokyo_subway_sarin_gas_attacks",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Security Intelligence Agency of Japan, ‘25 Years After the Tokyo Subway Sarin Gas Attacks’ (2020).",
"body": "The official record describes the 1994 Matsumoto attack, the 1995 Tokyo subway attack, their casualties, other violent incidents, and the continuing victim-relief record.",
"tier": "government-agency",
"kind": "official-case-history"
},
{
"link": "https://www.moj.go.jp/content/000096470.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Security Intelligence Agency of Japan, Review and Prospects of Internal and External Situations (2012), appendix 63.",
"body": "The Ministry of Justice appendix lists the first-instance and appellate dispositions for 13 people sentenced to death in Aum-related cases, including Asahara’s 2004 judgment and the 2006 dismissal that made his sentence final.",
"tier": "government-agency",
"kind": "official-proceeding-table"
},
{
"link": "https://www.moj.go.jp/kouanshin/topics_topics27.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Security Examination Commission of Japan, ‘Summary of the decision to place Aum Shinrikyo under surveillance’ (Jan. 28, 2000).",
"body": "The commission’s decision finds that the organization carried out the Matsumoto and Tokyo indiscriminate mass killings and records Asahara’s status within its doctrine as an incarnation demanding absolute devotion.",
"tier": "official-finding",
"kind": "surveillance-decision"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-doomsday-apocalyptic",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies absolute guru authority, doctrinal justification for killing, and hierarchical command as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and guru and senior religious followers.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Japanese criminal courts",
"date": "2011-11-21",
"outcome": "The final appeal among the 13 Aum defendants sentenced to death was dismissed; the Ministry of Justice’s published table records each defendant’s individual charges and appellate disposition."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.moj.go.jp/psia/25years_after_the_tokyo_subway_sarin_gas_attacks",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-agency; evidentiary role: official-case-history.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "62c455932ec349cec1ac801b1f0cc0e8f24f4c7af8b692dc0c2443d0773f350d",
"final_url": "https://www.moj.go.jp/psia/25years_after_the_tokyo_subway_sarin_gas_attacks"
},
{
"source": "https://www.moj.go.jp/content/000096470.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-agency; evidentiary role: official-proceeding-table.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5851fe6d9168acfff3784771e929129d88d1a4deadc25d648889bb7c58ba9cc2",
"final_url": "https://www.moj.go.jp/content/000096470.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.moj.go.jp/kouanshin/topics_topics27.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding; evidentiary role: surveillance-decision.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a373a7b5353dc0a1716ed485d91b5741721099c18cc5651e28bfa77def182b63",
"final_url": "https://www.moj.go.jp/kouanshin/topics_topics27.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 37,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This entry concerns Potter’s convictions and his use of spiritual and therapeutic authority. Other Centrepoint members were convicted in separate proceedings, but their conduct is not attributed to Potter or to every resident without person-specific evidence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1992-bert-potter-centrepoint-auckland-new-zealand",
"year": 1992,
"place": "Albany, Auckland, New Zealand",
"lat": -36.727,
"lng": 174.696,
"title": "Bert Potter: 13 convictions for abuse framed as therapy and spiritual advancement at Centrepoint",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and spiritual leader",
"therapist and guru"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-enlightenment framing",
"therapeutic pretext",
"communal pressure",
"leader control"
],
"organizations": [
"Centrepoint Community Growth Trust"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of New Zealand",
"stage": "criminal trial and sentence",
"date": "1992-11-28",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Potter on 13 indecent-assault charges; he was sentenced to seven and a half years in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/6p8/potter-herbert-thomas",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tim Shoebridge, ‘Potter, Herbert Thomas,’ Dictionary of New Zealand Biography (2024).",
"body": "The government biography records Potter’s role as Centrepoint’s Spiritual Leader, the group’s coercive therapeutic culture, testimony that he presented abuse as therapy or a path to spiritual enlightenment, the 13 guilty verdicts, and the seven-and-a-half-year sentence.",
"tier": "official-government-biography",
"kind": "government-biography"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bsa.govt.nz/decisions/all-decisions/kozeluh-and-television-new-zealand-ltd-2010-054/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "New Zealand Broadcasting Standards Authority, Kozeluh and Television New Zealand Ltd, Decision No. 2010-054 (Nov. 11, 2010).",
"body": "The statutory regulator’s decision records Potter’s imprisonment for indecent assaults against minors, confirms that seven other people were convicted of separate assaults, and rejects an accuracy challenge to describing Potter as Centrepoint’s cult leader.",
"tier": "statutory-regulator",
"kind": "administrative-decision"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual-enlightenment framing, therapeutic pretext, communal pressure, and leader control as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and spiritual leader and therapist and guru.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/6p8/potter-herbert-thomas",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-biography; evidentiary role: government-biography.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bsa.govt.nz/decisions/all-decisions/kozeluh-and-television-new-zealand-ltd-2010-054/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: statutory-regulator; evidentiary role: administrative-decision.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e81e7aeccb4b373d61dce40b4ec507e1ea7935ef4a23f823fd0156979d574e59",
"final_url": "https://www.bsa.govt.nz/decisions/all-decisions/kozeluh-and-television-new-zealand-ltd-2010-054/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 38,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Örebro District Court",
"date": "2019-12-04",
"outcome": "The life sentence was converted to a fixed term of 26 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Swedish Prosecution Authority",
"date": "2026-06-09",
"outcome": "The senior prosecutor declined to seek reopening or resume the investigation after reviewing a new request; the convictions remain in force."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This entry concerns Fossmo’s adjudicated incitement and the court record of his influence over the person who carried out the attacks. It does not merge her separately adjudicated conduct with his, and it does not assign responsibility to Pentecostal or Christian communities generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-helge-fossmo-knutby-sweden",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Knutby, Uppsala, Sweden",
"lat": 59.9097,
"lng": 18.2653,
"title": "Helge Fossmo: murder-incitement convictions after religious messages were used to compel violence",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"spiritual authority within Knutby Philadelphia congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-message deception",
"fear of losing divine grace",
"pastoral authority",
"isolation and sustained pressure"
],
"organizations": [
"Knutby Philadelphia congregation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Uppsala District Court",
"stage": "criminal judgment",
"date": "2004-07-30",
"outcome": "Convicted of incitement to murder and incitement to two attempted murders; sentenced to life imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Svea Court of Appeal",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2004-11-12",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the life sentence and the convictions for incitement to murder and two attempted murders."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aklagare.se/globalassets/dokument/ovriga-dokument/amr-2922-26-beslut.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Swedish Prosecution Authority, Decision AMR-2922-26 (June 9, 2026).",
"body": "The 28-page review reproduces the trial history and evidence that religious messages, pastoral contact, isolation, and fear of losing God’s grace were used in the sustained pressure leading to the murder and attempted murders. It records the decision not to seek reopening.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "post-conviction-review"
},
{
"link": "https://www.domstol.se/en/nyheter/2019/12/tingsratten-meddelar-beslut-i-mal-om-omvandling-av-livstids-fangelse3/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Örebro District Court, ‘Tingsrätten meddelar beslut i mål om omvandling av livstids fängelse’ (Dec. 4, 2019).",
"body": "The judiciary’s release records the 2004 convictions for incitement to one murder and two attempted murders and the conversion of the life sentence to 26 years.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "sentence-conversion-order"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sverigesradio.se/artikel/503095",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sveriges Radio, ‘Hovrätten fastställer Knutbydomar’ (Nov. 12, 2004).",
"body": "The public broadcaster’s contemporaneous report records the Svea Court of Appeal’s affirmance of Fossmo’s life sentence and incitement convictions.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster",
"kind": "appellate-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious-message deception, fear of losing divine grace, pastoral authority, and isolation and sustained pressure as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor and spiritual authority within Knutby Philadelphia congregation.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Örebro District Court",
"date": "2019-12-04",
"outcome": "The life sentence was converted to a fixed term of 26 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Swedish Prosecution Authority",
"date": "2026-06-09",
"outcome": "The senior prosecutor declined to seek reopening or resume the investigation after reviewing a new request; the convictions remain in force."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aklagare.se/globalassets/dokument/ovriga-dokument/amr-2922-26-beslut.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: post-conviction-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "971f6536021e1d36f17307b18ed4bbd352ecd838143df9adc0f7453321d6ec7c",
"final_url": "https://www.aklagare.se/globalassets/dokument/ovriga-dokument/amr-2922-26-beslut.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.domstol.se/en/nyheter/2019/12/tingsratten-meddelar-beslut-i-mal-om-omvandling-av-livstids-fangelse3/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: sentence-conversion-order.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "437ed46edda5a76245bda1db8ce2af0b470767e512a18ab8e52f345fda6fa667",
"final_url": "https://www.domstol.se/en/nyheter/2019/12/tingsratten-meddelar-beslut-i-mal-om-omvandling-av-livstids-fangelse3/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sverigesradio.se/artikel/503095",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: appellate-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 39,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Svea Court of Appeal",
"date": "2020-05-07",
"outcome": "The court left the district-court judgment in force after Gembäck appealed his sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The defendants were convicted of different acts. This record preserves those distinctions and does not attribute one defendant’s conduct to another, to former congregants, or to Christian communities outside the Knutby organization. ENRICHMENT 2026-07-19: a third pastor, Urban Fält, was convicted in the same Uppsala tingsrätt proceeding (verdict 13 March 2020) of sexual exploitation of a person in a dependent position — a charge that directly codifies the dependency nexus — against a 17-year-old congregant, receiving a conditional sentence, 160 hours community service and 85,000 SEK damages.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-knutby-pastors-uppsala-sweden",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Knutby, Uppsala, Sweden",
"lat": 59.9097,
"lng": 18.2653,
"title": "Knutby leadership: three former pastors convicted of assault, coercion and sexual exploitation",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastors",
"leaders within a hierarchical congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"shared-belief hierarchy",
"pastoral authority",
"punitive violence",
"dependency exploitation"
],
"organizations": [
"Knutby Philadelphia congregation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Uppsala District Court",
"stage": "criminal judgment",
"date": "2020-03-13",
"outcome": "Åsa Waldau was convicted of eight assaults; Peter Gembäck was convicted of assault and unlawful coercion; Urban Fält was convicted of sexual exploitation of a person in a position of dependency. Each received a conditional sentence with community service or day fines."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.domstol.se/en/nyheter/2020/03/dom-i-mal-mot-tre-f.d.-medlemmar-i-en-forsamling-i-knutby/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Uppsala District Court, Case B 6654-17, ‘Dom i mål mot tre f.d. medlemmar i en församling i Knutby’ (Mar. 13, 2020).",
"body": "The court records the three separate convictions and describes a strongly hierarchical setting involving violence and humiliation. It rejected the claim that shared religious belief and the hierarchy supplied consent to the assaults.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "judgment-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/uppsala/uppsala-tingsratts-dom-mot-tidigare-knutbypastorn-star-fast-fallet-tas-inte-upp-i-hovratten",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SVT Nyheter, ‘Knutbydomen står fast – hovrätten fastställer tingsrättens dom’ (May 7, 2020).",
"body": "Sweden’s public broadcaster records that all three pastors received convictions and that the Court of Appeal left the district-court judgment in force after Gembäck challenged his sentence.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster",
"kind": "appellate-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies shared-belief hierarchy, pastoral authority, punitive violence, and dependency exploitation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastors and leaders within a hierarchical congregation.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Svea Court of Appeal",
"date": "2020-05-07",
"outcome": "The court left the district-court judgment in force after Gembäck appealed his sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.domstol.se/en/nyheter/2020/03/dom-i-mal-mot-tre-f.d.-medlemmar-i-en-forsamling-i-knutby/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: judgment-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2a4bb445fe1feb49c445fec8ca8d667f9fa036a0ca9efe7a4670c6b20a0a0890",
"final_url": "https://www.domstol.se/en/nyheter/2020/03/dom-i-mal-mot-tre-f.d.-medlemmar-i-en-forsamling-i-knutby/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/uppsala/uppsala-tingsratts-dom-mot-tidigare-knutbypastorn-star-fast-fallet-tas-inte-upp-i-hovratten",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: appellate-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "723f600d61c6176943d5ad53bd999e97d4dc0cb1e8606b39bf7f1037fb4cd5c7",
"final_url": "https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/uppsala/uppsala-tingsratts-dom-mot-tidigare-knutbypastorn-star-fast-fallet-tas-inte-upp-i-hovratten"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 40,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "first-appeal",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Initial 1,075-year sentence overturned; retrial ordered."
},
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2024-07-01",
"note": "Retrial verdict upheld; FINAL."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The final appellate disposition was mixed and is reported count by count rather than as a blanket affirmance. Oktar’s official description as leader of a religious group establishes the authority nexus; the record does not assign responsibility to Islam, creationists, or people who encountered his publications without joining the organization. VERIFIED 2026-07-19: the retrial verdict (Nov 2022, aggregate 8,658 years) was upheld as FINAL by the Court of Cassation in July 2024, including a ~5-billion-lira asset confiscation; the earlier 1,075-year sentence had been overturned and replaced at retrial.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-adnan-oktar-istanbul-turkey",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Istanbul, Turkey",
"lat": 41.0082,
"lng": 28.9784,
"title": "Adnan Oktar: final convictions for sexual abuse, confinement and coercion within his organization",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious-group leader",
"founder and absolute organizational leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-group authority",
"deceptive recruitment",
"organized sexual exploitation",
"confinement and leader control"
],
"organizations": [
"Adnan Oktar organization"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Istanbul 30th High Criminal Court",
"stage": "retrial judgment",
"date": "2022-11-16",
"outcome": "Oktar and other defendants were convicted of offenses arising from the organization; Oktar received an aggregate sentence of 8,658 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "First Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2024-07-10",
"outcome": "The chamber affirmed 8,463 years and four months of Oktar’s sentence for leading a criminal organization, sexual abuse and assault, obstructing education, and deprivation of liberty."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://m.aa.com.tr/tr/gundem/adnan-oktarin-8-bin-463-yil-4-aylik-hapis-cezasi-onandi/3271518",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Anadolu Agency, ‘Adnan Oktar’ın 8 bin 463 yıl 4 aylık hapis cezası onandı’ (July 10, 2024).",
"body": "Turkey’s state news agency reports the Court of Cassation’s final mixed disposition, the convictions and sentences affirmed, the counts reversed, and the court’s findings about Oktar’s absolute leadership and the organization’s deceptive system of sexual exploitation.",
"tier": "official-state-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-104817",
"archive": "",
"citation": "European Court of Human Rights, Oktar v. Turkey, App. No. 42876/05, decision (May 10, 2011).",
"body": "The ECHR’s official case statement identifies Oktar as the leader of a religious group and a public proponent of creationist teaching. It is used only to establish the documented authority role, not the later criminal disposition.",
"tier": "international-court",
"kind": "official-case-description"
},
{
"link": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/11/16/turkish-televangelist-sentenced-to-8658-years-over-sex-crimes",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Turkish televangelist Adnan Oktar sentenced to 8,658 years', Al Jazeera (Nov. 2022), with 2024 cassation coverage by Turkish Minute and Daily Sabah.",
"body": "Reports the retrial conviction, the sentence, and the final cassation affirmance.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious-group authority, deceptive recruitment, organized sexual exploitation, and confinement and leader control as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is religious-group leader and founder and absolute organizational leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "first-appeal",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Initial 1,075-year sentence overturned; retrial ordered."
},
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2024-07-01",
"note": "Retrial verdict upheld; FINAL."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://m.aa.com.tr/tr/gundem/adnan-oktarin-8-bin-463-yil-4-aylik-hapis-cezasi-onandi/3271518",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-state-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1f760a72d25c8afe7120dd6d07f4f597f016348040923ed5e038023f9a3ba4ea",
"final_url": "https://m.aa.com.tr/tr/gundem/adnan-oktarin-8-bin-463-yil-4-aylik-hapis-cezasi-onandi/3271518"
},
{
"source": "https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-104817",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-court; evidentiary role: official-case-description.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1a216c3bea23ac75585b5815abe65bdfce0cffa9e1cd06db4a8d73935c3447fa",
"final_url": "https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-104817"
},
{
"source": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/11/16/turkish-televangelist-sentenced-to-8658-years-over-sex-crimes",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 41,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic",
"date": "2019-09-11",
"outcome": "The court rejected the defendants’ constitutional complaints concerning the first final rape conviction."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court in Olomouc",
"date": "2024-09-05",
"outcome": "The court concluded that time spent in Philippine immigration detention satisfied the custodial terms, so Dobeš would not be returned to prison."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The defendants described ‘unhooking’ as a tantric practice, but the courts adjudicated the charged acts as rape. This record concerns their conduct and their school’s claimed ritual; it does not characterize Tantra, yoga, astrology, or esoteric practice generally as abusive.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-guru-jara-poetrie-czech-republic",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Zlín and Olomouc regions, Czech Republic",
"lat": 49.2244,
"lng": 17.6627,
"title": "Jaroslav Dobeš and Barbora Plášková: seven rape convictions involving an ‘unhooking’ ritual",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and guru of an esoteric school",
"senior instructor and collaborator"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual and therapeutic pretext",
"guru authority",
"induced helplessness",
"deception about sexual contact"
],
"organizations": [
"Poetrie esoteric school"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court in Olomouc",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2018-10-11",
"outcome": "Dobeš and Plášková were finally convicted of one rape; Dobeš received five and a half years and Plášková five years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court in Olomouc",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2021-01-21",
"outcome": "The court finally convicted both defendants of six additional rapes connected to the ‘unhooking’ practice; it imposed no additional sentence because of the existing final terms."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://olomouc.rozhlas.cz/vrchni-soud-v-olomouci-o-dva-roky-snizil-trest-guru-jarovi-za-znasilneni-7640607",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Czech Radio Olomouc, ‘Vrchní soud v Olomouci o dva roky snížil trest guru Járovi za znásilnění’ (Oct. 12, 2018).",
"body": "The public broadcaster’s court report records the first final rape conviction, the sentences, the ‘unhooking’ ritual pretext, and the appellate court’s distinction between the proved count and remanded allegations.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster",
"kind": "appellate-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.denik.cz/krimi/guru-jara-je-vinen-ze-znasilneni-dalsich-sesti-studentek-rozhodl-vrhcni-soud-202.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deník, ‘Guru Jára je vinen ze znásilnění dalších šesti studentek, rozhodl vrchní soud’ (Jan. 21, 2021).",
"body": "The contemporaneous report quotes the High Court spokesperson and records the six additional final rape convictions, the court’s finding that the defendants intentionally induced helplessness, and the absence of an additional sentence.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.irozhlas.cz/zpravy-domov/podcast-vinohradska-12-guru-jara_2409050600_mpa",
"archive": "",
"citation": "iROZHLAS, ‘Konec případu. Guru Jára zůstane na svobodě’ (Sept. 5, 2024).",
"body": "Czech Radio’s current review records the seven final rape convictions and the later ruling crediting Dobeš’s Philippine detention toward the custodial sentence.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster",
"kind": "current-disposition-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies ritual and therapeutic pretext, guru authority, induced helplessness, and deception about sexual contact as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and guru of an esoteric school and senior instructor and collaborator.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Constitutional Court of the Czech Republic",
"date": "2019-09-11",
"outcome": "The court rejected the defendants’ constitutional complaints concerning the first final rape conviction."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court in Olomouc",
"date": "2024-09-05",
"outcome": "The court concluded that time spent in Philippine immigration detention satisfied the custodial terms, so Dobeš would not be returned to prison."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://olomouc.rozhlas.cz/vrchni-soud-v-olomouci-o-dva-roky-snizil-trest-guru-jarovi-za-znasilneni-7640607",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: appellate-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "505e3437f236272b0f2ccc4fe3830333b49b8a68e0b530190aad50bb7e02f7d5",
"final_url": "https://olomouc.rozhlas.cz/vrchni-soud-v-olomouci-o-dva-roky-snizil-trest-guru-jarovi-za-znasilneni-7640607"
},
{
"source": "https://www.denik.cz/krimi/guru-jara-je-vinen-ze-znasilneni-dalsich-sesti-studentek-rozhodl-vrhcni-soud-202.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.irozhlas.cz/zpravy-domov/podcast-vinohradska-12-guru-jara_2409050600_mpa",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: current-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 42,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Friedrichshof was a totalizing ideological commune rather than a conventional religious institution. Its inclusion rests on the adjudicated abuse of leader authority and the use of communal ideology to structure coercion. The entry does not attribute Muehl’s crimes to other artists, former residents, or communal movements generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1991-otto-muehl-friedrichshof-austria",
"year": 1991,
"place": "Friedrichshof, Burgenland, Austria",
"lat": 47.9484,
"lng": 16.9413,
"title": "Otto Muehl: seven-year sentence for sexual abuse and abuse of authority within Friedrichshof",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"commune founder and leader",
"ideological authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"leader authority",
"free-sexuality ideology",
"communal control",
"psychological pressure"
],
"organizations": [
"Friedrichshof commune",
"Aktionsanalytische Organisation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Court in Eisenstadt",
"stage": "criminal judgment",
"date": "1991-11-14",
"outcome": "Muehl was convicted of sexual offenses involving minors, rape, abuse of a position of authority, drug offenses, and witness interference; he received a seven-year prison sentence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.parlament.gv.at/dokument/XX/J/3719/fnameorig_121281.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Austrian Parliament, Written Question 3719/J, XX Legislative Period (1998).",
"body": "The parliamentary record describes Muehl’s November 1991 final conviction, seven-year sentence, sexual offenses involving minors, rape, and abuse of an authority relationship.",
"tier": "parliamentary-record",
"kind": "official-proceeding-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://newsv2.orf.at/stories/2184169/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ORF, ‘Aktionskünstler Otto Muehl ist tot’ (May 26, 2013).",
"body": "Austria’s public broadcaster records the 1991 convictions, seven-year sentence, offenses involving minors through rape, drug offenses and witness interference, and the six and a half years served.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster",
"kind": "retrospective-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.leopoldmuseum.org/en/exhibitions/23/otto-muehl",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Leopold Museum, ‘Otto Muehl’ exhibition chronology (2010).",
"body": "The museum chronology records the commune’s cult-like hierarchy, sexual abuse of minors supported by its free-sexuality ideology, the authority-abuse conviction, and the seven-year sentence.",
"tier": "institutional-archive",
"kind": "historical-chronology"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies leader authority, free-sexuality ideology, communal control, and psychological pressure as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is commune founder and leader and ideological authority.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.parlament.gv.at/dokument/XX/J/3719/fnameorig_121281.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: parliamentary-record; evidentiary role: official-proceeding-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c289245718ec40c7f8dae3ab6ed89d26cab10d26503d357c39a30ba57917181b",
"final_url": "https://www.parlament.gv.at/dokument/XX/J/3719/fnameorig_121281.html"
},
{
"source": "https://newsv2.orf.at/stories/2184169/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: retrospective-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ebf0db587fdcc95627169003561d4ea023018e843221aedd5ca9fe58f98a3d84",
"final_url": "https://newsv2.orf.at/stories/2184169/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.leopoldmuseum.org/en/exhibitions/23/otto-muehl",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-archive; evidentiary role: historical-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c9764c3443cc7a50fb766dd0f41414983e1ecd74bfc1af29e68f2a33d9a9a7a3",
"final_url": "https://www.leopoldmuseum.org/en/exhibitions/23/otto-muehl"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 43,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"movement-restoration-ten-commandments"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The official report records mass murder and coercive conditions but no conviction. Published totals vary, so this entry does not state a final victim count or assume the fate of leaders named in contemporaneous warrants. It concerns one apocalyptic sect and does not attribute its conduct to Catholicism, Christianity, or Ugandan religious communities generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2000-kanungu-movement-restoration-ten-commandments-uganda",
"year": 2000,
"place": "Kanungu District, Uganda",
"lat": -0.8964,
"lng": 29.775,
"title": "Kanungu: official state report attributes the sect's mass killing to its elders",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "death",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"sect elders",
"apocalyptic religious leaders"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"apocalyptic prophecy",
"confinement",
"prohibition on leaving",
"deprivation and child labor",
"leader control"
],
"organizations": [
"Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Government of Uganda",
"stage": "state investigation reported to the United Nations Human Rights Committee",
"date": "2003-03-25",
"outcome": "Uganda reported that investigators abandoned the initial mass-suicide theory and attributed the killings to sect elders; arrest warrants remained outstanding and the investigation was continuing."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/503376/files/CCPR_C_UGA_2003_1-EN.pdf?ln=en",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Government of Uganda, Initial Report to the United Nations Human Rights Committee, CCPR/C/UGA/2003/1, paras. 531-539 (Mar. 25, 2003).",
"body": "Uganda's state report identifies the Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God, records that members were locked inside the church before it was burned, states that investigators later attributed the incident to sect elders rather than mass suicide, and describes restrictions on leaving, child labor, malnutrition, arrest warrants and the continuing investigation.",
"tier": "state-report-to-un",
"kind": "official-investigation-summary"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents apocalyptic prophecy, confinement, prohibition on leaving, deprivation and child labor, and leader control, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is sect elders and apocalyptic religious leaders.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/503376/files/CCPR_C_UGA_2003_1-EN.pdf?ln=en",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-report-to-un; evidentiary role: official-investigation-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "631a349818a77b15f92bd27b22c8a17c519f1bcf70a6c7bb36dacae4e2c5ccce",
"final_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/nanna/record/503376/files/CCPR_C_UGA_2003_1-EN.pdf?withWatermark=0&withMetadata=0®isterDownload=1&version=1"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 44,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"good-news-international-church"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Kenya",
"date": "2025-04-11",
"outcome": "The appellate court restored the prosecution's ability to proceed on all 191 murder counts."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This is a charged record. The guilty plea of one co-defendant does not establish the guilt of Mackenzie or the remaining defendants, who retain the presumption of innocence. The entry reports aggregate counts and does not identify minor victims. Separate terrorism and radicalization proceedings are not merged into the murder disposition.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-paul-mackenzie-shakahola-kilifi-kenya",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Shakahola, Kilifi County, Kenya",
"lat": -3.2219,
"lng": 39.7747,
"title": "Paul Mackenzie and 30 co-defendants: 191 murder charges in the Shakahola proceeding",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "death",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"leader of Good News International Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"apocalyptic teaching",
"religiously mandated fasting",
"isolation",
"anti-education doctrine",
"leader control"
],
"organizations": [
"Good News International Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Kenya at Malindi",
"stage": "murder arraignment",
"date": "2024-02-06",
"outcome": "Thirty-one defendants were charged with 191 counts of murder. The 2024 court record treated the allegations as pending and recorded plea proceedings."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Kenya",
"stage": "interlocutory prosecution appeal",
"date": "2025-04-11",
"outcome": "The Court of Appeal allowed the prosecution's appeal against an order reducing the case and held that the 191 murder counts could proceed."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Kenya at Malindi",
"stage": "ongoing murder trial",
"date": "2026-02-06",
"outcome": "After 119 prosecution witnesses, one co-defendant changed his plea and was convicted on his own guilty plea. The court dismissed the prosecution's application to reopen its case against the remaining defendants, whose guilt remained for adjudication."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2024/5792/eng%402024-05-17",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Republic v Mackenzie alias Mtumishi alias Nabii alias Papaa & 30 others [2024] KEHC 5792 (KLR) (May 17, 2024).",
"body": "The High Court ruling records the 31 accused persons, the 191 murder counts, the plea proceedings and the pending status of the prosecution. It is a procedural record, not a finding of guilt.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "procedural-ruling"
},
{
"link": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2025/665/eng%402025-04-11",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Republic v Mackenzie & 30 others [2025] KECA 665 (KLR) (Apr. 11, 2025).",
"body": "The Court of Appeal identifies 191 murder counts arising from Shakahola, reports the aggregate child-victim categories without requiring publication of names, and allows the prosecution appeal so that all counts may proceed.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "interlocutory-appeal"
},
{
"link": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2026/1029/eng%402026-02-06",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Republic v Mackenzie alias Mtumishi alias Nabii alias Papaa & 30 others [2026] KEHC 1029 (KLR) (Feb. 6, 2026).",
"body": "The current High Court ruling records that the prosecution had called 119 witnesses and closed its case, that one co-defendant pleaded guilty and was convicted on his own plea, and that the prosecution's application to reopen the case against the remaining accused was dismissed.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "current-trial-ruling"
},
{
"link": "https://odpp.go.ke/how-tuk-student-left-school-to-join-pastor-mackenzie-church/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, Kenya, 'How TUK student left school to join Pastor Mackenzie church.'",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's trial report records testimony that a student left university after joining Mackenzie's movement and hearing teachings that the world would end and education was evil. The testimony is evidence presented in an ongoing case, not an adjudicated fact.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "trial-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents apocalyptic teaching, religiously mandated fasting, isolation, anti-education doctrine, and leader control, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is pastor and leader of Good News International Church.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Kenya",
"date": "2025-04-11",
"outcome": "The appellate court restored the prosecution's ability to proceed on all 191 murder counts."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "After 119 prosecution witnesses, one co-defendant changed his plea and was convicted on his own guilty plea. The court dismissed the prosecution's application to reopen its case against the remaining defendants, whose guilt remained for adjudication.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2024/5792/eng%402024-05-17",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: procedural-ruling.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "836b8a1b39e4ef9addb244d47ca646e50b3c3cd5c05e009bd9a65836fe6977b7",
"final_url": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2024/5792/eng%402024-05-17"
},
{
"source": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2025/665/eng%402025-04-11",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: interlocutory-appeal.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8c9f9875578a16d600581ed9d30d2acc149c365c216a20544c3e64b2622ba98e",
"final_url": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2025/665/eng%402025-04-11"
},
{
"source": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2026/1029/eng%402026-02-06",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: current-trial-ruling.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "39da43098d5c3686fff7e1496d6cc5dcab6742be11cbc6542d0fc1b67940d16f",
"final_url": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2026/1029/eng%402026-02-06"
},
{
"source": "https://odpp.go.ke/how-tuk-student-left-school-to-join-pastor-mackenzie-church/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: trial-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1effacc3d12bc6d56a91f94c1ae7de61b8e74be24cd24326b8dece17c7e75583",
"final_url": "https://odpp.go.ke/how-tuk-student-left-school-to-join-pastor-mackenzie-church/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 45,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"flds-church"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Texas Third Court of Appeals",
"date": "2012-03-29",
"outcome": "The court dismissed Jeffs's pro se appeal for want of prosecution after the appellate record was not filed and he did not respond to the court's notice."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Contemporaneous reporting identifies the assaults as involving underage followers treated as brides in purported spiritual marriages. The Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints is a separate organization from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and other Mormon denominations. This record does not identify the minors or assign culpability to family members or other followers without an adjudicated basis.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-warren-jeffs-yfz-ranch-texas-usa",
"year": 2011,
"place": "YFZ Ranch near Eldorado, TX, USA",
"lat": 30.8602,
"lng": -100.6009,
"title": "Warren Jeffs: life and 20-year sentences for two child-sexual-assault convictions",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"FLDS prophet and president",
"religious-marriage authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"prophetic authority",
"purported spiritual marriage",
"child-marriage doctrine",
"institutional isolation"
],
"organizations": [
"Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "51st Judicial District Court, Schleicher County, Texas",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2011-08-09",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Jeffs of aggravated sexual assault of a child and sexual assault of a child. The court imposed life and twenty-year prison terms."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/texas/third-court-of-appeals/2012/03-11-00568-cr.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Warren Steed Jeffs v. State of Texas, No. 03-11-00568-CR, Texas Third Court of Appeals (Mar. 29, 2012).",
"body": "The appellate opinion records the two jury convictions, the life and twenty-year sentences, and dismissal of Jeffs's appeal for want of prosecution.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/polygamist-leader-could-spend-life-in-prison/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press / CBS Texas, 'Polygamist Leader Sentenced To Life In Prison' (Aug. 9, 2011).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the sentence, the ages of the two underage followers without naming them, and the church's purported spiritual-marriage framing.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/crt/case-document/file/1224501/dl",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Town of Colorado City, No. 17-16472, Ninth Circuit opinion (Aug. 26, 2019).",
"body": "The federal appellate opinion records Jeffs's continuing role as FLDS prophet, the deference followers gave that office, instructions concerning underage marriages, and the church-linked control structure established in the civil trial.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "institutional-authority-finding"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies prophetic authority, purported spiritual marriage, child-marriage doctrine, and institutional isolation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is FLDS prophet and president and religious-marriage authority.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Texas Third Court of Appeals",
"date": "2012-03-29",
"outcome": "The court dismissed Jeffs's pro se appeal for want of prosecution after the appellate record was not filed and he did not respond to the court's notice."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/texas/third-court-of-appeals/2012/03-11-00568-cr.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/polygamist-leader-could-spend-life-in-prison/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b818125e3f6c15dbfb0b072a944bad84cfb46a67ac9a0f69db07ec51f3cd2083",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/polygamist-leader-could-spend-life-in-prison/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/crt/case-document/file/1224501/dl",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: institutional-authority-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e298b6fb4785aa5e2ba5d6c55c1b01e64569fa159ab51390ce9ef16893d1101f",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/crt/case-document/file/1224501/dl"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 46,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"tony-alamo-christian-ministries"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit",
"date": "2010-12-02",
"outcome": "The court affirmed every conviction and the sentence, finding sufficient evidence and no sentencing abuse of discretion."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The appellate court found that Alamo directed and controlled the minors' travel for sexual exploitation and treated his pastoral power and the victims' fear of losing salvation as proper sentencing considerations. The record concerns Alamo's conduct and does not assign criminal culpability to ministry members who were not defendants.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-tony-alamo-texarkana-arkansas-usa",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Texarkana and Fouke, AR, USA",
"lat": 33.4251,
"lng": -94.0477,
"title": "Tony Alamo: 175-year sentence after ten convictions for transporting minors for sex",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and leader of Tony Alamo Christian Ministries",
"pastor and supreme church authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"threats of loss of salvation",
"purported religious marriage",
"control of interstate travel"
],
"organizations": [
"Tony Alamo Christian Ministries"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Western District of Arkansas",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2009-11-13",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Alamo on ten Mann Act counts involving the interstate transportation of five minors for illegal sexual activity. The district court imposed consecutive terms totaling 175 years."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/10/12/093651P.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Hoffman, No. 09-3651, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit (Dec. 2, 2010).",
"body": "The official appellate opinion affirms all ten convictions and the sentence. It records Alamo's control of the minors' travel, abuse of his position as pastor and supreme church authority, threats concerning salvation, and the pervasive religious context of the trial.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/littlerock/press-releases/2009/lr072409.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, Western District of Arkansas, 'Former Evangelist Convicted of Sexual Exploitation Offenses' (July 24, 2009).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority identifies Alamo as founder and leader of Tony Alamo Christian Ministries and records the jury's guilty verdict on all ten federal counts.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "jury-verdict"
},
{
"link": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/littlerock/press-releases/2009/lr111309.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, Western District of Arkansas, 'Former Evangelist Receives 175-Year Sentence for Sexual Exploitation Offenses' (Nov. 13, 2009).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records the 175-year sentence, the ten-count verdict, Alamo's ministry leadership and the interstate transportation of underage followers for sexual activity.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral authority, threats of loss of salvation, purported religious marriage, and control of interstate travel as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and leader of Tony Alamo Christian Ministries and pastor and supreme church authority.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit",
"date": "2010-12-02",
"outcome": "The court affirmed every conviction and the sentence, finding sufficient evidence and no sentencing abuse of discretion."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/10/12/093651P.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/littlerock/press-releases/2009/lr072409.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: jury-verdict.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "728724efaf04ab5d0b65044a6bc82cb5084291dccbf3a858d18b6eaf71ec9d56",
"final_url": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/littlerock/press-releases/2009/lr072409.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/littlerock/press-releases/2009/lr111309.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1c14d6ad52f9d53cdf244a30ec1db2022a14e383dfe753b6107eb206c8f29cd7",
"final_url": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/littlerock/press-releases/2009/lr111309.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 47,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"colonia-dignidad"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Chile",
"date": "2013-01-25",
"outcome": "The six leadership convictions were final. The German government's later response records Chile's request concerning enforcement of Hopp's sentence after his flight to Germany."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This institutional record combines final convictions with later official findings about the colony's coercive structure. The German assistance plan is an official recognition and remediation document, not a criminal judgment. The entry does not treat survivors, children, other residents, or the present-day Villa Baviera community as perpetrators, and it does not imply that every reported dictatorship-era crime was adjudicated in the 2013 child-abuse case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-colonia-dignidad-parral-chile",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Colonia Dignidad near Parral, Chile",
"lat": -36.1431,
"lng": -71.826,
"title": "Colonia Dignidad: final convictions and official findings on systematic child abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founding lay preacher",
"hierarchical sect leadership",
"colony physician"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-community authority",
"family separation",
"isolation",
"forced labor",
"surveillance and intimidation",
"physical and sexual violence"
],
"organizations": [
"Colonia Dignidad"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Chile",
"stage": "final criminal judgment",
"date": "2013-01-25",
"outcome": "Chile's Supreme Court finally convicted six former Colonia Dignidad leaders for decades of systematic child abuse. Former colony physician Hartmut Hopp received a five-year sentence in absentia."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "German Bundestag and Federal Government joint commission",
"stage": "official victim-assistance finding",
"date": "2019-05-21",
"outcome": "The official assistance plan recognized decades of grave violence, forced labor, surveillance, intimidation, family separation and abuse within the colony and established an assistance fund for affected people."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/17/129/1712980.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "German Federal Government, Response on accountability for crimes at Colonia Dignidad, Bundestag Paper 17/12980 (Apr. 4, 2013).",
"body": "The official government response records the Chilean Supreme Court's final convictions of six former leaders for systematic child abuse, Hopp's five-year sentence in absentia, Paul Schäfer's founding role, and the colony leadership's long-running abuse and dictatorship-era collaboration.",
"tier": "government-report",
"kind": "final-judgment-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/19/104/1910410.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "German Bundestag and Federal Government, Assistance Plan for Victims of Colonia Dignidad, Bundestag Paper 19/10410 (May 21, 2019).",
"body": "The official assistance plan describes the colony's claimed Christian presentation, its hierarchical coercive structure, sexual and physical violence, forced labor, family separation, surveillance and intimidation, and the eligibility boundary excluding perpetrators from assistance.",
"tier": "official-finding",
"kind": "victim-assistance-plan"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious-community authority, family separation, isolation, forced labor, surveillance and intimidation, and physical and sexual violence as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founding lay preacher, hierarchical sect leadership, and colony physician.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Chile",
"date": "2013-01-25",
"outcome": "The six leadership convictions were final. The German government's later response records Chile's request concerning enforcement of Hopp's sentence after his flight to Germany."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/17/129/1712980.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-report; evidentiary role: final-judgment-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "48894b7cf96e35a09978f548eca1cf4f8e1fca97b6e068e0d802996554f7feed",
"final_url": "https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/17/129/1712980.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/19/104/1910410.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding; evidentiary role: victim-assistance-plan.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1f1ee5d47dfc5f6ed51a12928390471fae0b58c9869cec23f0298298155d4863",
"final_url": "https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/19/104/1910410.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 48,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"united-nation-nuwaubian-moors"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit",
"date": "2005-10-27",
"outcome": "The court affirmed York's convictions and 1,620-month sentence in full."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The court described the Nuwaubian organization as a religious ministry and self-identified Native American tribe whose official philosophy changed over time and borrowed from multiple religions and cultures. This record concerns York's organization and conduct. It does not attribute that conduct to Islam, Judaism, Indigenous religions, ancient Egyptian religion, ordinary Nuwaubian members or any culture the organization invoked. Minor victims are not named.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-dwight-york-nuwaubian-eatonton-georgia-usa",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Eatonton, GA, USA",
"lat": 33.3268,
"lng": -83.3885,
"title": "Dwight York: 135-year sentence after eleven federal convictions",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and leader of the United Nation of Nuwaubian Moors",
"god-like or father figure to followers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority",
"highly restricted communal life",
"family and gender separation",
"punishment or expulsion",
"recruitment of children by older followers"
],
"organizations": [
"United Nation of Nuwaubian Moors"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Middle District of Georgia",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2004-04-22",
"outcome": "A jury convicted York on eleven of thirteen counts, including racketeering, Mann Act and structuring offenses. The district court imposed consecutive terms totaling 1,620 months, or 135 years."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://media.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/files/200412354.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. York, No. 04-12354, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit (Oct. 27, 2005).",
"body": "The official appellate opinion records York's leadership of the United Nation of Nuwaubian Moors, the organization's restricted communal structure, followers' treatment of him as a god-like or father figure, the eleven-count verdict, the 1,620-month sentence and the court's affirmance of both convictions and sentence.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious authority, highly restricted communal life, family and gender separation, punishment or expulsion, and recruitment of children by older followers as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and leader of the United Nation of Nuwaubian Moors and god-like or father figure to followers.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit",
"date": "2005-10-27",
"outcome": "The court affirmed York's convictions and 1,620-month sentence in full."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://media.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/files/200412354.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a416415f6e2a579df2439668adc55e58bacaa3d2dbd062e0aa7286c70ea2bdb2",
"final_url": "https://media.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/files/200412354.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 49,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"lundgren-breakaway-group"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Ohio",
"date": "1995-08-30",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the convictions and upheld the death sentences after independent review."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Lundgren formed a breakaway group after the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints removed him and later excommunicated him. The official opinion distinguishes that church, now known as Community of Christ, from the Utah-based Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Neither church is entered as a perpetrating organization, and culpability is not assigned to followers beyond the adjudicated record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-jeffrey-lundgren-kirtland-ohio-usa",
"year": 1990,
"place": "Kirtland, OH, USA",
"lat": 41.6289,
"lng": -81.3615,
"title": "Jeffrey Lundgren: five aggravated-murder and kidnapping convictions",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"breakaway religious teacher",
"communal leader treated as a father figure"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"apocalyptic prophecy",
"scriptural authority",
"communal financial control",
"isolation",
"leader-directed violence"
],
"organizations": [
"Lundgren breakaway group"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lake County Court of Common Pleas, Ohio",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "1990-08-29",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Lundgren of five aggravated murders and five kidnappings. The trial court imposed a death sentence for each murder and consecutive prison terms for the kidnappings."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/1995/1995-ohio-227.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Lundgren, 73 Ohio St. 3d 474, 1995-Ohio-227 (Aug. 30, 1995).",
"body": "The official Ohio Supreme Court opinion affirms five aggravated-murder and five kidnapping convictions. It documents Lundgren's breakaway religious authority, apocalyptic teachings, communal financial control, excommunication and direction of the killings.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies apocalyptic prophecy, scriptural authority, communal financial control, isolation, and leader-directed violence as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is breakaway religious teacher and communal leader treated as a father figure.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Ohio",
"date": "1995-08-30",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the convictions and upheld the death sentences after independent review."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/1995/1995-ohio-227.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "874d57f457bad715ee234babb3f9ed344e4f53dc3f274f1c97660206ef9b9c7e",
"final_url": "https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/0/1995/1995-ohio-227.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 50,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"nation-of-yahweh"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit",
"date": "1996-01-05",
"outcome": "The court affirmed all seven appellants' RICO-conspiracy convictions in every respect."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The appellate court stressed that not all Nation of Yahweh members supported or participated in the charged violence and that adherents existed who were not implicated. This record concerns the convicted defendants and the specific conspiracy, not Judaism, Black Hebrew Israelite movements generally, a religion as such or ordinary members.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1992-yahweh-ben-yahweh-miami-florida-usa",
"year": 1992,
"place": "Miami, FL, USA",
"lat": 25.7617,
"lng": -80.1918,
"title": "Yahweh ben Yahweh: 18-year sentence for a RICO conspiracy involving murder and arson",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and religious leader",
"self-proclaimed son of God"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"violent apocalyptic and racial doctrine",
"kill-or-die pledges",
"family separation",
"temple isolation",
"public humiliation and beatings",
"leader-directed violence"
],
"organizations": [
"Nation of Yahweh"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "1992-09-04",
"outcome": "After a five-month trial, a jury convicted Yahweh ben Yahweh and six appellants of RICO conspiracy. The court sentenced Yahweh to eighteen years in prison and a $20,000 fine."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F3/072/72.F3d.1518.92-4773.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Beasley, 72 F.3d 1518 (11th Cir. 1996).",
"body": "The published appellate opinion records the RICO-conspiracy verdicts and sentences, Yahweh ben Yahweh's religious leadership and claimed divinity, the coercive temple structure, teachings used to justify violence and the distinction between convicted conspirators and members who were not implicated.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "published-appellate-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1992/09/05/religious-sect-leader-sentenced-to-18-years/d7fc1d84-c6b1-4ede-aa15-9f8671b89513/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Washington Post, 'Religious Sect Leader Sentenced to 18 Years' (Sept. 5, 1992).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting records the September 4 sentence, eighteen-year term and $20,000 fine after the federal conspiracy conviction.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies violent apocalyptic and racial doctrine, kill-or-die pledges, family separation, temple isolation, public humiliation and beatings, and leader-directed violence as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and religious leader and self-proclaimed son of God.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit",
"date": "1996-01-05",
"outcome": "The court affirmed all seven appellants' RICO-conspiracy convictions in every respect."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F3/072/72.F3d.1518.92-4773.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: published-appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1a90bb4bfc16d863891c89ebc5ddbc5449e5382041d084483e0e41b8572efaad",
"final_url": "https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F3/072/72.F3d.1518.92-4773.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1992/09/05/religious-sect-leader-sentenced-to-18-years/d7fc1d84-c6b1-4ede-aa15-9f8671b89513/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 51,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"wesson-household-group"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of California",
"date": "2025-01-14",
"outcome": "In automatic appeal S136171, the court extended the deadline for Wesson's supplemental reply brief to March 14, 2025. This procedural order did not decide the merits."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The official Supreme Court record documents unresolved supplemental briefing in Wesson's automatic appeal, and California's July 2026 condemned-inmate list still records the July 27, 2005 sentence. This entry therefore reports the trial judgment but does not describe the convictions as affirmed on appeal. It concerns Wesson's personal syncretic household doctrine, not Christianity, Seventh-day Adventism or any formal religious organization. Surviving relatives include victims and witnesses and are not assigned culpability; minor survivors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-marcus-wesson-fresno-california-usa",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Fresno, CA, USA",
"lat": 36.7378,
"lng": -119.7871,
"title": "Marcus Wesson: nine murder and fourteen sexual-abuse convictions",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"household patriarch",
"self-proclaimed Jesus",
"religious teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divinity",
"apocalyptic murder-suicide doctrine",
"household isolation",
"religious and patriarchal control",
"sexual and physical abuse"
],
"organizations": [
"Wesson household group"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fresno County Superior Court, California",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2005-07-27",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Wesson on nine first-degree-murder counts and fourteen sexual-abuse counts. The court imposed death for the murders and a combined 102 years for the sexual-abuse convictions."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://supreme.courts.ca.gov/sites/default/files/supremecourt/default/documents/m01142025%28t%29.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of California, minutes in People v. Wesson, S136171 (Jan. 14, 2025).",
"body": "The official minutes record supplemental-reply briefing in Wesson's automatic capital appeal. The order is procedural and does not affirm or reverse the judgment.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court",
"kind": "appellate-docket-order"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/capital-punishment/condemned-inmate-list-secure-request/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, Condemned Inmate List, updated July 7, 2026.",
"body": "The current official list records Marcus Wesson, the July 27, 2005 sentencing date, the March 12, 2004 offense date and Fresno County as the trial county.",
"tier": "corrections-record",
"kind": "current-sentence-record"
},
{
"link": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2005-jun-18-me-wesson18-story.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Los Angeles Times, 'Wesson Found Guilty of Killing 9' (June 18, 2005).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records all twenty-three guilty verdicts and testimony that Wesson claimed to be Jesus, used religious ideology to control an isolated household, and taught a murder-suicide pact tied to family separation.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "jury-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.foxnews.com/story/judge-sentences-wesson-to-death",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press, 'Judge Sentences Wesson to Death' (July 27, 2005).",
"body": "The Associated Press sentencing report records the death judgment for nine murder convictions, the combined 102-year term for fourteen sexual-abuse convictions and the trial court's denial of requests for a new trial or reduction to life imprisonment.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed divinity, apocalyptic murder-suicide doctrine, household isolation, religious and patriarchal control, and sexual and physical abuse as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is household patriarch, self-proclaimed Jesus, and religious teacher.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of California",
"date": "2025-01-14",
"outcome": "In automatic appeal S136171, the court extended the deadline for Wesson's supplemental reply brief to March 14, 2025. This procedural order did not decide the merits."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://supreme.courts.ca.gov/sites/default/files/supremecourt/default/documents/m01142025%28t%29.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court; evidentiary role: appellate-docket-order.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c867710057ce61241a11831dcf256a15cd83bc34d0ed550c53af767468d1b6bd",
"final_url": "https://supreme.courts.ca.gov/sites/default/files/supremecourt/default/documents/m01142025%28t%29.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/capital-punishment/condemned-inmate-list-secure-request/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: corrections-record; evidentiary role: current-sentence-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fe3ba52b3574539d2a81f44504d914a4c6669875d3e32a18cf75ce7a7343a46d",
"final_url": "https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/capital-punishment/condemned-inmate-list-secure-request/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2005-jun-18-me-wesson18-story.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: jury-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6ebe79626449fc01d83622f48400882aa48b0122e0e9f2d1b3d49e57ee21f296",
"final_url": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2005-jun-18-me-wesson18-story.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.foxnews.com/story/judge-sentences-wesson-to-death",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c71cca05e765e563c273cefa09a8a0c36578136362ccbc4d0965eda7f0fdca3f",
"final_url": "https://www.foxnews.com/story/judge-sentences-wesson-to-death"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 52,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"abba-krishna"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Oral Criminal Court No. 2 of San Martín, Argentina",
"date": "2025-04-29",
"outcome": "Federal prosecutors and the public victims' defender sought liquidation of forfeited property to fund the court-ordered reparations. The public source reports post-judgment enforcement, not an appellate merits ruling."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The four named people were convicted as secondary participants. The public prosecutor's account says the alleged male leader was not tried after proceedings against him were suspended because of supervening incapacity, and another accused person died before trial. This record concerns the defendants' use of a self-described Abba Krishna cult and appropriated Bhakti Yoga, chakra and Tantra concepts; it does not attribute their conduct to Hinduism, Krishna devotion, Bhakti Yoga, Tantra or other practitioners. Victims are not named.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-abba-krishna-la-matanza-argentina",
"year": 2024,
"place": "La Matanza, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina",
"lat": -34.7692,
"lng": -58.6268,
"title": "Abba Krishna: four convictions for aggravated human trafficking",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"secondary participants in an unrecognized cult",
"spiritual-guidance facilitators"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"promised spiritual advancement",
"devotional labor",
"economic control",
"isolation",
"relationship approval",
"chakra and tantric-sex claims"
],
"organizations": [
"Abba Krishna"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Oral Criminal Court No. 2 of San Martín, Argentina",
"stage": "abbreviated judgment and sentence",
"date": "2024-07-03",
"outcome": "The court sentenced Francisco Aurelio Pugliese, Leonardo Abel Gandarinho, Carina Lorena Cardoso and Lisa Beatriz Baissetto to four years in prison as secondary participants in aggravated trafficking involving eight victims, one of whom was under eighteen at the time."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/san-martin-en-un-juicio-abreviado-condenaron-a-cuatro-miembros-de-una-secta-a-cuatro-anos-de-prision-por-trata-de-personas-agravada/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público Fiscal de la Nación, 'San Martín: en un juicio abreviado, condenaron a cuatro miembros de una secta a cuatro años de prisión por trata de personas agravada' (July 8, 2024).",
"body": "Argentina's federal prosecution service records the four convictions, sentences, eight victims, reparations and forfeitures. It describes recruitment through spiritual guidance, promised advancement through service and donations, isolation, economic and relationship control, and sexual conduct presented as a spiritual or chakra-opening path.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/san-martin-solicitaron-la-liquidacion-de-los-bienes-decomisados-a-cuatro-miembros-de-una-secta-condenados-por-trata-de-personas-para-reparar-a-sus-victimas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público Fiscal de la Nación, 'San Martín: solicitaron la liquidación de los bienes decomisados a cuatro miembros de una secta condenados por trata de personas para reparar a sus víctimas' (Apr. 30, 2025).",
"body": "The federal prosecution service records the post-judgment request to liquidate forfeited property for reparations and restates the defendants' secondary-participant convictions and the July 3, 2024 judgment.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "post-judgment-enforcement"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies promised spiritual advancement, devotional labor, economic control, isolation, relationship approval, and chakra and tantric-sex claims as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is secondary participants in an unrecognized cult and spiritual-guidance facilitators.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Oral Criminal Court No. 2 of San Martín, Argentina",
"date": "2025-04-29",
"outcome": "Federal prosecutors and the public victims' defender sought liquidation of forfeited property to fund the court-ordered reparations. The public source reports post-judgment enforcement, not an appellate merits ruling."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/san-martin-en-un-juicio-abreviado-condenaron-a-cuatro-miembros-de-una-secta-a-cuatro-anos-de-prision-por-trata-de-personas-agravada/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f3b7ac2b67e8b11735458eae82367b6a257272b57c961c4019b88ebc0b6f742a",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/san-martin-en-un-juicio-abreviado-condenaron-a-cuatro-miembros-de-una-secta-a-cuatro-anos-de-prision-por-trata-de-personas-agravada/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/san-martin-solicitaron-la-liquidacion-de-los-bienes-decomisados-a-cuatro-miembros-de-una-secta-condenados-por-trata-de-personas-para-reparar-a-sus-victimas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: post-judgment-enforcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "89efc311b30123ef13ae1cb9b7b38f2d0784e8bd3f902e5ba74a59eeb9312880",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/san-martin-solicitaron-la-liquidacion-de-los-bienes-decomisados-a-cuatro-miembros-de-una-secta-condenados-por-trata-de-personas-para-reparar-a-sus-victimas/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 53,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"salta-umbanda-kimbanda-temple"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Criminal Cassation Chamber, Chamber I, Argentina",
"date": "2023-09-13",
"outcome": "The chamber affirmed both convictions. A later federal-prosecutor report records the affirmance while reporting the court-ordered reparation for one victim."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The record concerns Soria Villalba and Arroyo's adjudicated conduct at the temple they led. The federal sources identify their claimed roles within Umbanda and Kimbanda and their veneration of San La Muerte; the entry does not assign responsibility to those religions, devotions, adherents or other temples. The two victims are not named.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-umbanda-temple-salta-argentina",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Salta, Argentina",
"lat": -24.7821,
"lng": -65.4232,
"title": "Salta temple: affirmed trafficking convictions for two spiritual leaders",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"spiritual leaders known as Pae and Mae",
"religious ministers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"invocation of divine anger",
"promised prosperity for obedience",
"spiritual-parent authority",
"intimidation",
"surveillance",
"economic control",
"cross-border sexual exploitation"
],
"organizations": [
"Salta Umbanda and Kimbanda temple"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Oral Court No. 2 of Salta, Argentina",
"stage": "trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2023-04-19",
"outcome": "By majority, the court sentenced Jorge Juan Soria Villalba to nine years and María Ester Arroyo to eight years and two months for aggravated trafficking for sexual exploitation and minor injuries involving two victims."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/salta-condenaron-a-los-lideres-espirituales-de-un-templo-umbanda-por-trata-de-personas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público Fiscal de la Nación, 'Salta: condenaron a los líderes espirituales de un templo Umbanda por trata de personas' (Apr. 19, 2023).",
"body": "Argentina's federal prosecution service records the convictions, sentences and aggravating findings. It describes how the defendants invoked the cult's order, divine anger and promised prosperity to intimidate two vulnerable women, control prostitution proceeds and move one victim across provinces and into Bolivia.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/salta-fijan-una-reparacion-por-mas-de-12-millones-de-pesos-para-una-victima-de-trata-de-personas-sometida-por-lideres-de-un-templo-umbanda/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público Fiscal de la Nación, 'Salta: fijan una reparación por más de 12 millones de pesos para una víctima de trata de personas sometida por líderes de un templo Umbanda' (Nov. 6, 2023).",
"body": "The federal prosecution service records a reparation order and states that Chamber I of the Federal Criminal Cassation Chamber affirmed the two convictions on September 13, 2023.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "appellate-and-reparation-report"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies invocation of divine anger, promised prosperity for obedience, spiritual-parent authority, intimidation, surveillance, economic control, and cross-border sexual exploitation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is spiritual leaders known as Pae and Mae and religious ministers.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Criminal Cassation Chamber, Chamber I, Argentina",
"date": "2023-09-13",
"outcome": "The chamber affirmed both convictions. A later federal-prosecutor report records the affirmance while reporting the court-ordered reparation for one victim."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/salta-condenaron-a-los-lideres-espirituales-de-un-templo-umbanda-por-trata-de-personas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ae97d88ce8d57122b75e138e5574d5f88341a2923364f9b9f21039111b1b65be",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/salta-condenaron-a-los-lideres-espirituales-de-un-templo-umbanda-por-trata-de-personas/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/salta-fijan-una-reparacion-por-mas-de-12-millones-de-pesos-para-una-victima-de-trata-de-personas-sometida-por-lideres-de-un-templo-umbanda/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: appellate-and-reparation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "637228781ee16b0d91ced3edcf61dfaf0f75f3923822b602bfaba03eb080aaf2",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/salta-fijan-una-reparacion-por-mas-de-12-millones-de-pesos-para-una-victima-de-trata-de-personas-sometida-por-lideres-de-un-templo-umbanda/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 54,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"monte-sion-mar-del-plata"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Criminal Cassation Chamber, Chamber I, Argentina",
"outcome": "In 2022 the chamber rejected both defenses' cassation appeals and affirmed the convictions and sentences."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Oral Criminal Court of Mar del Plata, Argentina",
"date": "2025-04-22",
"outcome": "A sentence-execution order addressed Hurtado's educational-credit request while he was serving the sentence. The order did not revisit the merits."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The trial court characterized Monte Sión as a criminal and coercive sect and the appellate chamber affirmed the judgments. This entry concerns Hurtado and Padilla's adjudicated conduct through their self-created ministry; it does not assign responsibility to Christianity, evangelical churches, scripture, congregants or other ministries. Victims and surviving family members are not named or assigned culpability.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-monte-sion-mar-del-plata-argentina",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Mar del Plata, Argentina",
"lat": -38.0055,
"lng": -57.5426,
"title": "Monte Sión: affirmed convictions for trafficking, servitude and sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled apostle and anointed leader",
"necessary participant in the trafficking scheme"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine authority",
"scriptural control",
"threats of divine punishment",
"isolation",
"leader worship",
"economic control",
"forced labor",
"surveillance",
"sexual abuse"
],
"organizations": [
"Monte Sión Apostolic and Prophetic Ministry"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Oral Court of Mar del Plata, Argentina",
"stage": "unanimous trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2019-12-23",
"outcome": "The court sentenced Isaías Nelson Hurtado to twenty-four years and six months for aggravated penetrative sexual abuse of four women, trafficking and reduction to servitude involving twenty people, including two minors, and coercion. Patricia Soledad Padilla received ten years as a necessary participant in the trafficking offenses."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/mar-del-plata-24-anos-y-medio-de-prision-para-el-lider-de-una-secta-religiosa/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público Fiscal de la Nación, 'Mar del Plata: 24 años y medio de prisión para el líder de una secta religiosa' (Dec. 23, 2019).",
"body": "Argentina's federal prosecution service records the unanimous judgment, the two sentences, twenty trafficking and servitude victims, four sexual-abuse victims and the court's findings about claimed divine authority, coercive persuasion, isolation, surveillance, economic exploitation and threats of divine punishment.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://quedigital.com.ar/judiciales/casacion-confirmo-la-condena-contra-el-pastor-isaias-hurtado-y-su-pareja/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Qué Digital, 'Casación confirmó la condena contra el pastor Isaías Hurtado y su pareja' (July 4, 2022).",
"body": "Contemporaneous local court reporting identifies the three judges of Chamber I and records their rejection of the defendants' cassation appeals, leaving the 2019 convictions and sentences affirmed.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cij.gov.ar/scp/d/sentencia-SGU-51869d90-68c0-4795-ab14-a17469ba592d.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Federal Oral Criminal Court of Mar del Plata, Hurtado, Isaías Nelson, sentence-execution order, FMP 1187/2014/TO1/31 (Apr. 22, 2025).",
"body": "The official federal court order records Hurtado's current sentence-execution proceeding and resolves an educational-credit request. It confirms continuing administration of the sentence without relitigating guilt.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "sentence-execution-order"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed divine authority, scriptural control, threats of divine punishment, isolation, leader worship, economic control, forced labor, surveillance, and sexual abuse as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-styled apostle and anointed leader and necessary participant in the trafficking scheme.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Criminal Cassation Chamber, Chamber I, Argentina",
"outcome": "In 2022 the chamber rejected both defenses' cassation appeals and affirmed the convictions and sentences."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Federal Oral Criminal Court of Mar del Plata, Argentina",
"date": "2025-04-22",
"outcome": "A sentence-execution order addressed Hurtado's educational-credit request while he was serving the sentence. The order did not revisit the merits."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/mar-del-plata-24-anos-y-medio-de-prision-para-el-lider-de-una-secta-religiosa/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "babeb27d1337ebc751f5fa79697c6389373e3decebd1585f1fbc715e7d5bb939",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/trata/mar-del-plata-24-anos-y-medio-de-prision-para-el-lider-de-una-secta-religiosa/"
},
{
"source": "https://quedigital.com.ar/judiciales/casacion-confirmo-la-condena-contra-el-pastor-isaias-hurtado-y-su-pareja/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ddf3f7e729136c93f7f950dc9f5f69f9e6b2b3c708c0c16632445cb20a764371",
"final_url": "https://quedigital.com.ar/judiciales/casacion-confirmo-la-condena-contra-el-pastor-isaias-hurtado-y-su-pareja/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cij.gov.ar/scp/d/sentencia-SGU-51869d90-68c0-4795-ab14-a17469ba592d.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: sentence-execution-order.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0884bceab8574e65b7acc4751d5c4d19d0d54d0a6f10e580d320d0024f9801a4",
"final_url": "https://www.cij.gov.ar/scp/d/sentencia-SGU-51869d90-68c0-4795-ab14-a17469ba592d.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 55,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The proceeding was confidential, and the court withheld the defendant, victims and municipality. The record concerns the convicted man's use of a claimed pai-de-santo role, entity incorporation and spiritual threats. It does not assign responsibility to Umbanda, Candomblé, Afro-Brazilian religions, spirit incorporation, ritual healing or other practitioners.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-spiritual-leader-planalto-norte-santa-catarina-brazil",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Planalto Norte, Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"lat": -26.2,
"lng": -50.2,
"title": "Planalto Norte spiritual leader: appellate court affirms a ten-year sexual-abuse sentence",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described pai de santo",
"ritual and spiritual-healing leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spirit incorporation",
"promised relief from spiritual problems",
"demanded sexual favors attributed to entities",
"threats of spiritual punishment",
"private ritual consultations"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed ritual space in northern Santa Catarina"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Justice of Santa Catarina, Fourth Criminal Chamber, Brazil",
"stage": "unanimous appellate judgment reported October 2019",
"outcome": "The chamber affirmed a sentence of ten years and four months in closed custody for sexual offenses by fraud involving three adolescent victims."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/lider-espiritual-tem-condenacao-de-10-anos-por-abusos-sexuais-confirmada-pelo-tjsc",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Justice of Santa Catarina, 'Líder espiritual tem condenação de 10 anos por abusos sexuais confirmada pelo TJSC' (Oct. 22, 2019).",
"body": "The official court report records the unanimous appellate affirmance, sentence and three victims. It describes promises to solve spiritual problems, sexual favors falsely attributed to incorporated entities and threats of spiritual punishment used to enforce silence.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed spirit incorporation, promised relief from spiritual problems, demanded sexual favors attributed to entities, threats of spiritual punishment, and private ritual consultations as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-described pai de santo and ritual and spiritual-healing leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/lider-espiritual-tem-condenacao-de-10-anos-por-abusos-sexuais-confirmada-pelo-tjsc",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0c3fcc38e0381a759cad2a97395aaeb7b3ff91f7c28821c5c19cc963b85d788c",
"final_url": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/lider-espiritual-tem-condenacao-de-10-anos-por-abusos-sexuais-confirmada-pelo-tjsc"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 56,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The state prosecutor did not publish the defendants' names, the precise victim count or a later appellate disposition. This page therefore reports the first-instance judgment and does not describe it as final. It concerns conduct adjudicated against the two defendants at one terreiro and does not assign responsibility to Umbanda, Afro-Brazilian religions, spirit incorporation, rituals, alcohol use in lawful ceremonies or other practitioners. Women, adolescents and the child referenced by the prosecutor are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-umbanda-leader-frutal-minas-gerais-brazil",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Frutal, Minas Gerais, Brazil",
"lat": -20.0247,
"lng": -48.9406,
"title": "Frutal Umbanda leader: nearly fifty years for sexual crimes presented as rituals",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"director of an Umbanda terreiro",
"community spiritual leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spirit incorporation",
"sexual acts imposed as rituals",
"psychological violence",
"alcohol-induced vulnerability",
"fear of community retaliation",
"witness intimidation by a convicted associate"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed Umbanda terreiro in the Frutal region"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Trial court in Frutal, Minas Gerais, Brazil",
"stage": "first-instance judgment reported March 2025",
"outcome": "The court sentenced the terreiro director to forty-nine years, ten months and twenty days in closed custody for rape of a vulnerable person, rape, sexual violation by fraud and related sexual crimes. His son received three years for persecuting and threatening witnesses."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mpmg.mp.br/portal/menu/comunicacao/noticias/a-pedido-do-mpmg-justica-condena-lider-espiritual-a-quase-50-anos-de-prisao-por-crimes-sexuais-em-frutal.shtml",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministério Público de Minas Gerais, 'A pedido do MPMG, Justiça condena líder espiritual a quase 50 anos de prisão por crimes sexuais, em Frutal' (Mar. 20, 2025).",
"body": "The official state-prosecutor report records both sentences and the offenses. It describes the leader's use of claimed spirit incorporation, ritual framing, psychological violence, alcohol and community influence against women, adolescents and a child, as well as the son's witness threats.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "first-instance-judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed spirit incorporation, sexual acts imposed as rituals, psychological violence, alcohol-induced vulnerability, fear of community retaliation, and witness intimidation by a convicted associate as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is director of an Umbanda terreiro and community spiritual leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mpmg.mp.br/portal/menu/comunicacao/noticias/a-pedido-do-mpmg-justica-condena-lider-espiritual-a-quase-50-anos-de-prisao-por-crimes-sexuais-em-frutal.shtml",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: first-instance-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "51cfd0dbc9289393ab354f525ed72aede41f8dcba536f0e549f0f08c103f321d",
"final_url": "https://www.mpmg.mp.br/portal/menu/comunicacao/noticias/a-pedido-do-mpmg-justica-condena-lider-espiritual-a-quase-50-anos-de-prisao-por-crimes-sexuais-em-frutal.shtml"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 57,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The confidential proceeding withheld the defendant and victims. The official prosecutor source does not identify a denomination or report a later appellate disposition, so this page reports a first-instance judgment and uses the broader Afro-Brazilian setting label based on the disclosed pai-espiritual, entity-incorporation and terreiro context. It does not assign responsibility to Umbanda, Candomblé, Afro-Brazilian religions, spiritual healing, incorporated entities or other practitioners.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-spiritual-healing-leader-criciuma-santa-catarina-brazil",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Criciúma, Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"lat": -28.6775,
"lng": -49.3697,
"title": "Criciúma spiritual-healing leader: forty-year sentence for crimes against ten women",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pai espiritual",
"leader of a home-based religious house"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spirit incorporation",
"promised miraculous cures",
"sexual acts described as possession by entities",
"promised prosperity",
"private counseling and rituals",
"exploitation of psychological vulnerability"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed religious house in Criciúma"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "First Criminal Court of Criciúma, Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"stage": "first-instance judgment reported January 2025",
"outcome": "The court sentenced the defendant to forty years, ten months and twenty-four days in closed custody for sexual violation by fraud, rape and sexual harassment involving at least ten women. He was denied release pending appeal."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mpsc.mp.br/w/noticias/homem-que-praticou-crimes-sexuais-enquanto-era-lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-40-anos-de-prisao-em-criciuma",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministério Público de Santa Catarina, 'Homem que praticou crimes sexuais enquanto era líder religioso é condenado a 40 anos de prisão em Criciúma' (Jan. 10, 2025).",
"body": "The official state-prosecutor report records the conviction, sentence and at least ten victims. It describes a pai espiritual who claimed incorporated entities needed to possess women sexually for cures, answered prayers and prosperity during counseling and rituals.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "first-instance-judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://radiocidadesc.com.br/noticia/4138/qpai-espiritualq-e-condenado-a-40-anos-de-prisao-por-estuprar-10-mulheres-em-criciuma",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rádio Cidade em Dia, 'Pai Espiritual é condenado a 40 anos de prisão por estuprar 10 mulheres em Criciúma' (Jan. 10, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous local reporting based on the prosecutor release adds that the First Criminal Court suspended activities at the terreiro in the defendant's residence after his arrest. It does not identify the confidential defendant or victims.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed spirit incorporation, promised miraculous cures, sexual acts described as possession by entities, promised prosperity, private counseling and rituals, and exploitation of psychological vulnerability as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pai espiritual and leader of a home-based religious house.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mpsc.mp.br/w/noticias/homem-que-praticou-crimes-sexuais-enquanto-era-lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-40-anos-de-prisao-em-criciuma",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: first-instance-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4f4f6ae8c3e61dc36f66eb202c8447ea69b2ed0c2d0e38ef067d48d02d979fce",
"final_url": "https://www.mpsc.mp.br/w/noticias/homem-que-praticou-crimes-sexuais-enquanto-era-lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-40-anos-de-prisao-em-criciuma"
},
{
"source": "https://radiocidadesc.com.br/noticia/4138/qpai-espiritualq-e-condenado-a-40-anos-de-prisao-por-estuprar-10-mulheres-em-criciuma",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 58,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The confidential proceeding withheld the defendant, church and victims. The court's report states that an appeal remained available and does not establish its later outcome; this page therefore reports the first-instance judgment rather than a final appellate disposition. It concerns the defendant's misuse of pastoral authority and one church's documented response, not Christianity, evangelical churches, prayer, spiritual support or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-pastor-spiritual-support-tubarao-santa-catarina-brazil",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Tubarão, Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"lat": -28.4713,
"lng": -48.9999,
"title": "Tubarão pastor: forty-year sentence for thirteen acts framed as prayer",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor",
"spiritual-support provider"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sexual acts presented as prayer",
"faith and pastoral trust",
"private spiritual support",
"congregational submission",
"institutional victim-blaming"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical church in Tubarão"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Second Criminal Court of Tubarão, Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"stage": "first-instance judgment reported April 2023",
"outcome": "The court sentenced the defendant to forty years and twenty days in closed custody for thirteen instances of sexual violation by fraud against nine victims, and ordered moral-damages payments. He was denied release pending appeal."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/noticias/-/asset_publisher/GP1QtxFaSsX0/content/id/15877258?_com_liferay_asset_publisher_web_portlet_AssetPublisherPortlet_INSTANCE_GP1QtxFaSsX0_languageId=pt_BR&_com_liferay_asset_publisher_web_portlet_AssetPublisherPortlet_INSTANCE_GP1QtxFaSsX0_type=content&p_r_p_assetEntryId=15877258",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Justice of Santa Catarina, 'Pastor de Tubarão é condenado a 40 anos de prisão por violação sexual mediante fraude' (Apr. 12, 2023).",
"body": "The official court report records the first-instance sentence, thirteen offenses, nine victims and damages. It describes sexual acts presented as prayer during private spiritual support, extreme submission to the pastor and the church's defense of the defendant and demonization of victims.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "first-instance-judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies sexual acts presented as prayer, faith and pastoral trust, private spiritual support, congregational submission, and institutional victim-blaming as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is evangelical pastor and spiritual-support provider.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/noticias/-/asset_publisher/GP1QtxFaSsX0/content/id/15877258?_com_liferay_asset_publisher_web_portlet_AssetPublisherPortlet_INSTANCE_GP1QtxFaSsX0_languageId=pt_BR&_com_liferay_asset_publisher_web_portlet_AssetPublisherPortlet_INSTANCE_GP1QtxFaSsX0_type=content&p_r_p_assetEntryId=15877258",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: first-instance-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5d22e84f6ea459de4c1325265702dd8f5807699b659e2c444e5b1dde5758d34d",
"final_url": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/noticias/-/asset_publisher/GP1QtxFaSsX0/content/id/15877258?_com_liferay_asset_publisher_web_portlet_AssetPublisherPortlet_INSTANCE_GP1QtxFaSsX0_languageId=pt_BR&_com_liferay_asset_publisher_web_portlet_AssetPublisherPortlet_INSTANCE_GP1QtxFaSsX0_type=content&p_r_p_assetEntryId=15877258"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 59,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The confidential case summary withholds the defendant and survivor. This record concerns the pastor's adjudicated use of a claimed revelation, curse-removal rituals, sacred oil and prayer. It does not assign responsibility to Christianity, evangelical churches, charismatic practices, anointing, speaking in tongues, prayer or other pastors. The minor survivor is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-pastor-curse-removal-brasilia-brazil",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Brasília, Federal District, Brazil",
"lat": -15.7939,
"lng": -47.8828,
"title": "Brasília pastor: appellate court affirms conviction for abuse presented as curse removal",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor",
"spiritual leader claiming private revelation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed sexual curse",
"secret cure rituals",
"sacred-oil anointing",
"speaking in tongues",
"prayer-mountain claims",
"pastoral authority over a minor"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical church in the Federal District"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Justice of the Federal District and Territories, First Criminal Panel, Brazil",
"stage": "appellate judgment",
"date": "2023-11-09",
"outcome": "The panel denied the appeal and maintained a sentence of five years, one month and seven days in closed custody for two continued acts of sexual violation by fraud, plus moral damages. Judgment 1783481, case 0714801-76.2022.8.07.0020."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjdft.jus.br/consultas/jurisprudencia/informativos/2023/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-493/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-493",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Justice of the Federal District and Territories, Informativo de Jurisprudência No. 493, Judgment 1783481 (Dec. 6, 2023).",
"body": "The official appellate digest records the judgment date, case number, affirmed sentence and damages. It describes how the pastor claimed a minor had a sexual curse requiring secret spiritual work and used sacred oil, prayer, speaking in tongues and a prayer-mountain claim to induce sexual acts.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-digest"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed sexual curse, secret cure rituals, sacred-oil anointing, speaking in tongues, prayer-mountain claims, and pastoral authority over a minor as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is evangelical pastor and spiritual leader claiming private revelation.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjdft.jus.br/consultas/jurisprudencia/informativos/2023/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-493/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-493",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-digest.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4ee8e5447b193f6b0c161ad025a5e34d453915c2a6110d9c76a11f59fd4ff206",
"final_url": "https://www.tjdft.jus.br/consultas/jurisprudencia/informativos/2023/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-493/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-493"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 60,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The proceeding was confidential and the public appellate digest withholds the defendant, survivor, congregation and reduced sentence. This page reports only the disclosed appellate disposition. It concerns one defendant's fraudulent curse-and-anointing claim, not Christianity, anointing, spiritual healing, religious leaders or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-religious-leader-curse-anointing-brasilia-brazil",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Brasília, Federal District, Brazil",
"lat": -15.81,
"lng": -47.9,
"title": "Brasília religious leader: conviction affirmed for sex obtained through a curse-and-anointing claim",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious leader",
"claimed spiritual healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed curse",
"oil-anointing cure",
"religious authority",
"fraud affecting consent"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed religious congregation in the Federal District"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Justice of the Federal District and Territories, Third Criminal Panel, Brazil",
"stage": "appellate judgment",
"date": "2018-06-28",
"outcome": "The panel upheld the conviction for sexual intercourse by fraud and granted relief only to reduce the sentence. Judgment 1106774, case 20160410054882APR."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjdft.jus.br/consultas/jurisprudencia/informativos/2018/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-374/conjuncao-carnal-mediante-fraude-2013-manifestacao-de-vontade-influenciada-por-lider-religioso",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Justice of the Federal District and Territories, Judgment 1106774, case 20160410054882APR (June 28, 2018).",
"body": "The official appellate digest records that the defendant used his religious-leader role and a false claim that the survivor was cursed and required anointing with his prepared oil to obtain sex. The panel maintained the conviction and reduced only the sentence.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-digest"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed curse, oil-anointing cure, religious authority, and fraud affecting consent as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is religious leader and claimed spiritual healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjdft.jus.br/consultas/jurisprudencia/informativos/2018/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-374/conjuncao-carnal-mediante-fraude-2013-manifestacao-de-vontade-influenciada-por-lider-religioso",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-digest.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cf64d501050068e08f9f750cce4d9883c615854cd781e254e08afc982c601419",
"final_url": "https://www.tjdft.jus.br/consultas/jurisprudencia/informativos/2018/informativo-de-jurisprudencia-n-374/conjuncao-carnal-mediante-fraude-2013-manifestacao-de-vontade-influenciada-por-lider-religioso"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 61,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The court withheld the defendant, survivor, church, municipality and case number. This entry preserves that confidentiality and reports only the official appellate summary. It concerns one pastor's adjudicated use of counseling trust and a false purification claim, not Christianity, evangelical churches, purification practices, pastoral counseling or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-pastor-purification-sao-paulo-brazil",
"year": 2016,
"place": "São Paulo State, Brazil",
"lat": -23.5505,
"lng": -46.6333,
"title": "São Paulo pastor: unanimous conviction for assault presented as purification",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor",
"trusted spiritual leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"purification claim",
"pastoral counseling confidence",
"religious submission",
"secrecy request"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical church in São Paulo State"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Justice of São Paulo, Fourth Criminal Law Chamber, Brazil",
"stage": "unanimous appellate judgment reported January 2016",
"outcome": "The chamber convicted the pastor of indecent assault by fraud and imposed two years and eleven months in semi-open custody for two acts against a fifteen-year-old congregant."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjsp.jus.br/Noticias/noticia?Id=29136&codigoNoticia=29136",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Justice of São Paulo, 'Pastor é condenado por molestar fiel' (Jan. 9, 2016).",
"body": "The official court report records the unanimous appellate conviction and sentence. It describes a pastor who learned of a fifteen-year-old congregant's relationship problems in confidence, used her religious submission and a purported need for purification to induce two sexual acts, and later asked her to conceal them.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies purification claim, pastoral counseling confidence, religious submission, and secrecy request as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is evangelical pastor and trusted spiritual leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjsp.jus.br/Noticias/noticia?Id=29136&codigoNoticia=29136",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "896ada90074ac39cf4f45479478a15e430c00a8e10b0b047277ea701bcc316f5",
"final_url": "https://www.tjsp.jus.br/Noticias/noticia?Id=29136&codigoNoticia=29136"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 62,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an allegation record, not a finding of guilt. The defendant did not accept the charge, remains presumed innocent and is not named in the public sources. The initial July 2026 review did not locate a later judgment or dismissal. This page concerns an allegation that one person falsely posed as a spiritist; it does not assign responsibility to Spiritism, spiritualists, mediumship, prayer, cleansing practices or healers. The sisters are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-false-spiritist-cartagena-colombia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Cartagena and Turbaco, Bolívar, Colombia",
"lat": 10.3997,
"lng": -75.5144,
"title": "Cartagena: man charged over assaults allegedly presented as spirit-cleansing sessions",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"alleged false spiritist",
"purported spiritual protector"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed liberation from evil spirits",
"promised protection through prayer",
"private purported spiritist sessions",
"alleged exploitation of induced incapacity"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal guarantee-control court in Bolívar, Colombia",
"stage": "charging and pretrial detention reported February 2024",
"outcome": "Prosecutors charged an unnamed thirty-two-year-old man with a sexual act against a person rendered incapable of resisting in connection with allegations involving two sixteen-year-old sisters. He did not accept the charge, and a judge ordered pretrial detention."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eltiempo.com/colombia/otras-ciudades/hombre-es-senalado-de-simular-ser-espiritista-con-el-pretexto-de-abusar-a-menores-853214",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Tiempo, 'Con el pretexto de ser espiritista hombre habría abusado dos menores de edad' (Feb. 8, 2024).",
"body": "Contemporaneous national reporting quotes the Fiscalía announcement and records the alleged conduct, victims' ages, 2022 locations, January 31 arrest, charge, non-acceptance and detention order. The report uses allegation language throughout.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://paragrafo.co/judicial/falso-espiritista-abuso-de-dos-menores-en-cartagena/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Parágrafo, 'Falso espiritista abuso de dos menores en Cartagena' (Feb. 9, 2024).",
"body": "Local reporting corroborates the prosecution account of the charge, two alleged victims, purported sessions, capture and detention. The headline is categorical, but this corpus follows the article's procedural facts and treats every allegation as unproven unless adjudicated.",
"tier": "local-reporting",
"kind": "charging-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents claimed liberation from evil spirits, promised protection through prayer, private purported spiritist sessions, and alleged exploitation of induced incapacity, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is alleged false spiritist and purported spiritual protector.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Prosecutors charged an unnamed thirty-two-year-old man with a sexual act against a person rendered incapable of resisting in connection with allegations involving two sixteen-year-old sisters. He did not accept the charge, and a judge ordered pretrial detention.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eltiempo.com/colombia/otras-ciudades/hombre-es-senalado-de-simular-ser-espiritista-con-el-pretexto-de-abusar-a-menores-853214",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a7b685e3937f2427d7e527f979c64469d1a375b0364846aea99ece433561de1f",
"final_url": "https://www.eltiempo.com/colombia/otras-ciudades/hombre-es-senalado-de-simular-ser-espiritista-con-el-pretexto-de-abusar-a-menores-853214"
},
{
"source": "https://paragrafo.co/judicial/falso-espiritista-abuso-de-dos-menores-en-cartagena/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e37e0175f50c2c49582892131ee8170022fd0888f43e16010d9f605813c099a2",
"final_url": "https://paragrafo.co/judicial/falso-espiritista-abuso-de-dos-menores-en-cartagena/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 63,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber of the Provincial Court of Justice of Azuay, Ecuador",
"date": "2026-05-07",
"outcome": "The prosecution appeal was allowed and the trial acquittal was replaced with a conviction and sentence. No later cassation disposition was located in the initial July 2026 review."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The public prosecution release identifies the defendant only as Juan Ismael J. and does not identify the adult survivor. The entry reports the appellate conviction without describing it as cassation-final. It concerns one curandero's use of a treatment setting and drug-facilitated incapacitation, not ancestral medicine, traditional healing, curanderismo, practitioners or patients generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-curandero-medicine-sessions-cuenca-ecuador",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Cuenca, Azuay, Ecuador",
"lat": -2.9001,
"lng": -79.0059,
"title": "Cuenca curandero: appellate court imposes twenty-nine-year sentence after assault during medicine sessions",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"curandero",
"provider of purported ancestral-medicine sessions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"traditional-healing setting",
"treatment trust",
"drug-facilitated incapacitation"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed alternative-medicine premises near Cuenca's Nueve de Octubre market"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber of the Provincial Court of Justice of Azuay, Ecuador",
"stage": "appellate judgment reported May 2026",
"date": "2026-05-07",
"outcome": "The chamber accepted the prosecution's appeal from an acquittal, convicted Juan Ismael J. of rape and imposed an aggravated sentence of twenty-nine years and four months."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/en-apelacion-curandero-es-sentenciado-como-autor-de-violacion/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General del Estado, 'En apelación, curandero es sentenciado como autor de violación' (May 7, 2026).",
"body": "Ecuador's prosecution service records the appellate conviction, sentence, prior acquittal and offense setting. It states that the survivor and her mother went to the defendant for ancestral-medicine sessions and that toxicology detected MDMA; DNA and other forensic evidence were also presented.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies traditional-healing setting, treatment trust, and drug-facilitated incapacitation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is curandero and provider of purported ancestral-medicine sessions.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber of the Provincial Court of Justice of Azuay, Ecuador",
"date": "2026-05-07",
"outcome": "The prosecution appeal was allowed and the trial acquittal was replaced with a conviction and sentence. No later cassation disposition was located in the initial July 2026 review."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/en-apelacion-curandero-es-sentenciado-como-autor-de-violacion/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d02032286070b4dd9d8fbd985a7bdca8af8edf52b89ff177db3bfcb2c8a9c43d",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/en-apelacion-curandero-es-sentenciado-como-autor-de-violacion/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 64,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The prosecution release identifies the defendant only as José C. and does not identify the adolescent survivor. The initial July 2026 review did not locate a later appellate disposition, so the entry does not call the sentence final. It concerns one practitioner's adjudicated deception and threat, not traditional medicine, curanderismo, alternative medicine, healers or patients generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-curandero-healing-threat-gualaceo-ecuador",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Gualaceo, Azuay, Ecuador",
"lat": -2.8926,
"lng": -78.7781,
"title": "Gualaceo curandero: twenty-nine-year sentence after a false healing claim and death threat",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"curandero",
"alternative-healing practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false illness diagnosis",
"threat of death without compliance",
"healing-treatment trust",
"authority over an adolescent patient"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed alternative-medicine center in Gualaceo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Guarantees Tribunal of Azuay, Ecuador",
"stage": "written first-instance judgment",
"date": "2017-01-18",
"outcome": "The tribunal convicted José C. of rape, sentenced him to twenty-nine years and four months and ordered US$5,000 in reparation."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/curandero-fue-sentenciado-a-29-anos-por-violacion-a-adolescente-en-gualaceo/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General del Estado, 'Curandero fue sentenciado a 29 años por violación a adolescente en Gualaceo' (Jan. 19, 2017).",
"body": "Ecuador's prosecution service records the written judgment, sentence, reparation order and evidence. It states that the adolescent was brought to an alternative-medicine center seeking help for her mother and that the curandero falsely said she was ill and could die unless she did everything he instructed.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies false illness diagnosis, threat of death without compliance, healing-treatment trust, and authority over an adolescent patient as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is curandero and alternative-healing practitioner.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/curandero-fue-sentenciado-a-29-anos-por-violacion-a-adolescente-en-gualaceo/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d02032286070b4dd9d8fbd985a7bdca8af8edf52b89ff177db3bfcb2c8a9c43d",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/curandero-fue-sentenciado-a-29-anos-por-violacion-a-adolescente-en-gualaceo/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 65,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The contemporaneous reports do not name the defendant, identify the survivors or provide a docket number, judgment text or later appellate history. This entry therefore reports only the disclosed conviction and sentence. It concerns one person's adjudicated use of claimed bewitchment and cleansing rituals, not Bolivian or Peruvian traditional healing, curanderismo, spiritual cleansing, practitioners or patients generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-curandero-cleansing-rituals-yesera-bolivia",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Yesera San Sebastián, Tarija, Bolivia",
"lat": -21.4078,
"lng": -64.6155,
"title": "Yesera curandero: twelve-year sentence for assaults committed under cleansing-ritual claims",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented curandero",
"purported spiritual-cleansing practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claim that a family was bewitched",
"spiritual-cleansing pretext",
"payment demands",
"healing access to family members"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal court in Tarija, Bolivia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence reported June 2021",
"outcome": "An unnamed man who presented himself as a curandero received a twelve-year prison sentence for sexual abuse and related conduct involving two adolescents and an adult woman."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://elpais.bo/seguridad/20210625_dan-12-anos-de-carcel-a-curandero-acusado-de-abuso-sexual-en-yesera-tarija.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El País, 'Dan 12 años de cárcel a curandero acusado de abuso sexual en Yesera-Tarija' (June 25, 2021).",
"body": "Local court reporting quotes the municipal legal-service attorney and records the twelve-year sentence, the curandero role, three survivors, claims that the family was bewitched, payment demands and touching presented as spiritual cures.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.diarioelgranchaco.com/2021/06/cinco-hombres-fueron-sentenciados-por.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Gran Chaco, 'Cinco hombres fueron sentenciados por violación y abuso en Tarija' (June 30, 2021).",
"body": "Independent local reporting attributes the result to Tarija's municipal child-protection office and corroborates that a curandero received twelve years for abusing two children in a rural community of the municipality.",
"tier": "local-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claim that a family was bewitched, spiritual-cleansing pretext, payment demands, and healing access to family members as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-presented curandero and purported spiritual-cleansing practitioner.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://elpais.bo/seguridad/20210625_dan-12-anos-de-carcel-a-curandero-acusado-de-abuso-sexual-en-yesera-tarija.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0309e3610d87113b973076122531042cccc055e1c0ef6a34ed63d6ddd6522dd7",
"final_url": "https://elpais.bo/seguridad/20210625_dan-12-anos-de-carcel-a-curandero-acusado-de-abuso-sexual-en-yesera-tarija.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.diarioelgranchaco.com/2021/06/cinco-hombres-fueron-sentenciados-por.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c9f9b68b4330d56b3ed59efedea241cbb7af6f235ab3214e949caf246bae47e1",
"final_url": "https://www.diarioelgranchaco.com/2021/06/cinco-hombres-fueron-sentenciados-por.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 66,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"faith-deliverance-ministries-guyana"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Guyana",
"date": "2022-12-21",
"outcome": "The conviction was affirmed. Relief was limited to reducing the sentence from forty to twenty-five years and resetting parole eligibility."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The entry identifies the convicted adult but not the survivor. It reports the appellate disposition without claiming that no later proceeding is possible. The documented nexus is Hannibal's pastoral counseling, religious position and church access to the adolescent, not Christianity, churches, counseling, Guyanese pastors or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-andrew-hannibal-faith-deliverance-guyana",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Rosignol, West Coast Berbice, Guyana",
"lat": 6.2719,
"lng": -57.5362,
"title": "Andrew Hannibal: Guyana Court of Appeal affirms pastor's child-rape conviction",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and pastor",
"church counselor",
"minister entrusted with an adolescent congregant"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counseling trust",
"religious authority",
"church access to an adolescent congregant"
],
"organizations": [
"Faith Deliverance Ministries"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Guyana",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2018-02-08",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Andrew Hannibal of raping a fifteen-year-old congregant who had been entrusted to him for counseling; the court imposed a forty-year sentence."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Guyana",
"stage": "appellate judgment",
"date": "2022-12-21",
"outcome": "The court unanimously affirmed the conviction, reduced the sentence to twenty-five years and set parole eligibility after eighteen years, with credit for time served."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.stabroeknews.com/2022/12/22/news/guyana/court-upholds-conviction-against-pastor-who-raped-minor-reduces-sentence/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Stabroek News, 'Court upholds conviction against pastor who raped minor, reduces sentence' (Dec. 22, 2022).",
"body": "Contemporaneous appellate reporting records the unanimous judgment, affirmed conviction, reduced twenty-five-year sentence, parole minimum and composition of the appellate panel.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://demerarawaves.com/2018/02/08/pastor-jailed-for-40-years-for-having-sex-with-girl-under-16-years-old/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Demerara Waves, 'Pastor jailed for 40 years for having sex with girl under 16 years old' (Feb. 8, 2018).",
"body": "Contemporaneous trial reporting records the jury conviction, original sentence, offense dates and the counseling relationship through which the survivor had been placed in Hannibal's care.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "trial-disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral counseling trust, religious authority, and church access to an adolescent congregant as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and pastor, church counselor, and minister entrusted with an adolescent congregant.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Guyana",
"date": "2022-12-21",
"outcome": "The conviction was affirmed. Relief was limited to reducing the sentence from forty to twenty-five years and resetting parole eligibility."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.stabroeknews.com/2022/12/22/news/guyana/court-upholds-conviction-against-pastor-who-raped-minor-reduces-sentence/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6811aa33a4a081c4c02a54082b2ad3256621df1a12bcfee934d7e84db2198e82",
"final_url": "https://www.stabroeknews.com/2022/12/22/news/guyana/court-upholds-conviction-against-pastor-who-raped-minor-reduces-sentence/"
},
{
"source": "https://demerarawaves.com/2018/02/08/pastor-jailed-for-40-years-for-having-sex-with-girl-under-16-years-old/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "be56a19c8e5e6533c65b3fa50c90dec0345a3bddd0b2bffa9e6ee948f2f60aae",
"final_url": "https://demerarawaves.com/2018/02/08/pastor-jailed-for-40-years-for-having-sex-with-girl-under-16-years-old/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 67,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The entry preserves the mixed verdict: the court acquitted Landveld on the rape and violence-based counts and convicted him of indecent conduct. The adult survivor is not identified. No later appellate disposition was located in the initial July 2026 review. The record concerns one pastor's adjudicated misuse of prayer, anointing and spiritual trust, not Christianity, Surinamese churches, prayer, anointing, deliverance practices, pastors or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-cedric-landveld-prayer-anointing-suriname",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Paramaribo, Suriname",
"lat": 5.852,
"lng": -55.2038,
"title": "Cedric Landveld: conviction after sexual abuse during prayer and anointing",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"spiritual leader invited to conduct a prayer session"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual deliverance",
"private prayer session",
"anointing with oil",
"religious trust",
"promised help with health and financial problems"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed Surinamese religious community"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cantonal Court in Suriname",
"stage": "first-instance judgment reported August 2025",
"date": "2025-08-19",
"outcome": "The court acquitted Cedric Landveld of rape and indecent assault by violence but convicted him of indecent conduct, imposing two and a half years in prison with six months suspended."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.srherald.com/suriname/2025/08/21/pastor-veroordeeld-tot-25-jaar-cel-voor-ontucht-persrechter-licht-vonnis-toe/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Suriname Herald, 'Pastor veroordeeld tot 2,5 jaar cel voor ontucht: persrechter licht vonnis toe' (Aug. 21, 2025).",
"body": "The report quotes press judge Alida Johanns and records the conviction, sentence, acquittals and judicial finding that Landveld abused his position as a spiritual leader during a prayer session requested for health and financial problems.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-explanation"
},
{
"link": "https://www.dbsuriname.com/2025/08/20/met-olie-zalvende-pastor-veroordeeld-voor-ontucht/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dagblad Suriname, 'Met olie zalvende pastor veroordeeld voor ontucht' (Aug. 20, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting corroborates the conviction and mixed verdict and describes the prayer, anointing-oil and claimed healing context presented at trial.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed spiritual deliverance, private prayer session, anointing with oil, religious trust, and promised help with health and financial problems as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor and spiritual leader invited to conduct a prayer session.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.srherald.com/suriname/2025/08/21/pastor-veroordeeld-tot-25-jaar-cel-voor-ontucht-persrechter-licht-vonnis-toe/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-explanation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c5fa116cc22cb11737897acfa1556598a00ccc813d38e0a92b052a5f87b8e990",
"final_url": "https://www.srherald.com/suriname/2025/08/21/pastor-veroordeeld-tot-25-jaar-cel-voor-ontucht-persrechter-licht-vonnis-toe/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.dbsuriname.com/2025/08/20/met-olie-zalvende-pastor-veroordeeld-voor-ontucht/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b7084b46165fcca11b0705dfa1232f8dbad1dabe5addcd85583f220b71a887b1",
"final_url": "https://www.dbsuriname.com/2025/08/20/met-olie-zalvende-pastor-veroordeeld-voor-ontucht/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 68,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"fundacion-carare"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Tribunal of Cundinamarca",
"date": "2020-10-01",
"outcome": "The tribunal annulled the original 2019 sentence because of a procedural inconsistency and ordered a corrected judgment; it did not acquit Gaitán."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Tribunal of Cundinamarca and Amazonas",
"date": "2025-02-27",
"outcome": "The tribunal maintained three convictions but reduced the prison term to fourteen years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Justice of Colombia",
"date": "2025-06-18",
"outcome": "Cassation was assigned under Supreme Court matter 69432; the initial July 2026 review found no later merits decision."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Nine women made complaints, but the 2025 appellate judgment maintained convictions in three cases; this entry does not convert the other complaints into findings. The cassation docket means the appellate posture remains open. It concerns Gaitán's false identity and adjudicated misuse of yagé ceremonies and healing claims, not Indigenous peoples, recognized taitas, yagé or ayahuasca traditions, Fundación Carare participants, plant-medicine practitioners or ceremony participants generally. Survivors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-edgar-orlando-gaitan-yage-colombia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "La Vega and Guaduas, Cundinamarca, Colombia",
"lat": 5.0008,
"lng": -74.3413,
"title": "Édgar Orlando Gaitán Camacho: fourteen-year appellate sentence for assaults during yagé healing rituals",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed taita",
"false Indigenous spiritual leader",
"yagé ceremony leader",
"founder of Fundación Carare"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false Indigenous identity",
"claimed sacred sexual connection",
"yagé-induced incapacity",
"spiritual-healing pretext",
"leader authority over followers"
],
"organizations": [
"Fundación Carare"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal circuit court in Guaduas, Cundinamarca, Colombia",
"stage": "corrected first-instance judgment reported January 2021",
"outcome": "After the original 2019 judgment was annulled for a procedural defect, the court convicted Gaitán in three cases and imposed a nineteen-year sentence."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber of the Superior Tribunal of Cundinamarca and Amazonas, Colombia",
"stage": "second-instance judgment",
"date": "2025-02-27",
"outcome": "The tribunal partially reversed the lower judgment, maintained convictions in three cases and reduced the sentence to fourteen years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Justice of Colombia, Criminal Cassation Chamber",
"stage": "cassation assigned",
"date": "2025-06-18",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court's official assignment record lists cassation matter 69432, CUI 11001600072120120047301, concerning Gaitán. No merits disposition was located in the initial July 2026 review."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elespectador.com/genero-y-diversidad/las-igualadas/reducen-condena-por-abuso-sexual-contra-el-falso-chaman-edgar-orlando-gaitan/?outputType=amp",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Espectador, 'Reducen condena por abuso sexual contra el falso chamán Edgar Orlando Gaitán' (Mar. 20, 2025).",
"body": "Detailed appellate reporting records the fourteen-year second-instance sentence, three maintained convictions, earlier annulment and corrected judgment. It describes Gaitán's false taita identity, Fundación Carare leadership and use of yagé healing rituals and purported sacred sexual energy.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.noticiascaracol.com/colombia/asi-operaba-un-falso-chaman-que-drogaba-mujeres-para-abusar-de-ellas-tribunal-le-redujo-la-pena-rg10",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Noticias Caracol, 'Así operaba un falso chamán que drogaba mujeres para abusar de ellas: Tribunal le redujo la pena' (Mar. 21, 2025).",
"body": "Independent national reporting corroborates the procedural chronology, convictions in three cases and reduced sentence and describes the yagé ceremonies and claimed spiritual-healing rationale.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://archivodigitalapi.cortesuprema.gov.co/share/2025/6/Actas%20de%20reparto/actarepartopenal18-06-2025.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Justice of Colombia, Criminal Chamber assignment record (June 18, 2025), matter 69432.",
"body": "The official assignment record lists Gaitán's cassation matter, Supreme Court number 69432 and CUI 11001600072120120047301. It proves the cassation filing and assignment but does not establish its eventual merits outcome.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "cassation-docket"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies false Indigenous identity, claimed sacred sexual connection, yagé-induced incapacity, spiritual-healing pretext, and leader authority over followers as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-proclaimed taita, false Indigenous spiritual leader, yagé ceremony leader, and founder of Fundación Carare.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Tribunal of Cundinamarca",
"date": "2020-10-01",
"outcome": "The tribunal annulled the original 2019 sentence because of a procedural inconsistency and ordered a corrected judgment; it did not acquit Gaitán."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Tribunal of Cundinamarca and Amazonas",
"date": "2025-02-27",
"outcome": "The tribunal maintained three convictions but reduced the prison term to fourteen years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Justice of Colombia",
"date": "2025-06-18",
"outcome": "Cassation was assigned under Supreme Court matter 69432; the initial July 2026 review found no later merits decision."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elespectador.com/genero-y-diversidad/las-igualadas/reducen-condena-por-abuso-sexual-contra-el-falso-chaman-edgar-orlando-gaitan/?outputType=amp",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2c62d24d95174fa5874e0ee889816b81efb2f09cf72e783c77453fb982b4718a",
"final_url": "https://www.elespectador.com/genero-y-diversidad/las-igualadas/reducen-condena-por-abuso-sexual-contra-el-falso-chaman-edgar-orlando-gaitan/?outputType=amp"
},
{
"source": "https://www.noticiascaracol.com/colombia/asi-operaba-un-falso-chaman-que-drogaba-mujeres-para-abusar-de-ellas-tribunal-le-redujo-la-pena-rg10",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6ebabab0c7d47dd97bfd6aa11e0f39ac5dcd7ddf4c620f4d7c1dabd48514d062",
"final_url": "https://www.noticiascaracol.com/colombia/asi-operaba-un-falso-chaman-que-drogaba-mujeres-para-abusar-de-ellas-tribunal-le-redujo-la-pena-rg10"
},
{
"source": "https://archivodigitalapi.cortesuprema.gov.co/share/2025/6/Actas%20de%20reparto/actarepartopenal18-06-2025.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: cassation-docket.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "78b2f27dd94a1d4dac3bbea20acab739e540932ccdb9f7d55caa6e3e26508eb0",
"final_url": "https://archivodigitalapi.cortesuprema.gov.co/share/2025/6/Actas%20de%20reparto/actarepartopenal18-06-2025.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 69,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an allegation record. The unnamed defendant remains presumed innocent, and pretrial detention is not a conviction. The initial July 2026 review did not locate a later charge disposition, judgment or dismissal. This entry reports only the procedural facts attributed to Peru's judiciary and does not assign responsibility to Indigenous traditions, shamans, curanderos, ritual cleansing, healers, practitioners or participants generally. The adolescent is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-false-shaman-cleansing-trujillo-peru",
"year": 2025,
"place": "La Esperanza, Trujillo, Peru",
"lat": -8.0706,
"lng": -79.0451,
"title": "Trujillo: purported shaman held pretrial over alleged assault during a cleansing ritual",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"alleged false shaman",
"purported cleansing practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual-cleansing pretext",
"request for private access to an adolescent",
"family trust in a purported healer"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "investigatory court in Trujillo, La Libertad, Peru",
"stage": "nine-month pretrial detention reported November 2025",
"date": "2025-11-07",
"outcome": "A judge ordered an unnamed forty-year-old man held for nine months while authorities investigated an allegation that he raped a sixteen-year-old during a purported cleansing ritual. This was a preventive measure, not a finding of guilt."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rpp.pe/peru/actualidad/trujillo-dictan-prision-preventiva-contra-falso-chaman-acusado-de-violacion-en-ritual-noticia-1662960",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RPP, 'Trujillo: dictan prisión preventiva contra falso chamán acusado de violación en ritual' (Nov. 7, 2025).",
"body": "The national broadcaster reports the judiciary's detention announcement and allegation that the defendant requested private access to a sixteen-year-old for a purported cleansing ritual. It states that the detention lasts nine months and does not report a finding of guilt.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "pretrial-proceeding"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents ritual-cleansing pretext, request for private access to an adolescent, and family trust in a purported healer, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is alleged false shaman and purported cleansing practitioner.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A judge ordered an unnamed forty-year-old man held for nine months while authorities investigated an allegation that he raped a sixteen-year-old during a purported cleansing ritual. This was a preventive measure, not a finding of guilt.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rpp.pe/peru/actualidad/trujillo-dictan-prision-preventiva-contra-falso-chaman-acusado-de-violacion-en-ritual-noticia-1662960",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: pretrial-proceeding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "66183cbbf34e1049e5e374717ac752170ea36688a1a6e0470883cb90758247db",
"final_url": "https://rpp.pe/peru/actualidad/trujillo-dictan-prision-preventiva-contra-falso-chaman-acusado-de-violacion-en-ritual-noticia-1662960"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 70,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"manitoba-mennonite-colony-bolivia"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Contemporaneous reports describe more than one hundred women and girls coming forward, but that figure is not presented here as a court-adjudicated victim count for every defendant. The convicted men used chemical incapacitation rather than spiritual ritual to commit the assaults. This record is classified as an institutional event because reliable reporting documents how isolation, male colony authority, demon explanations, pressure to forgive and denial of counseling shaped recognition and response. It does not assign responsibility to Mennonites, Old Colony communities, Christianity, Bolivians, Germans, Canadians or colony residents generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-manitoba-mennonite-colony-bolivia",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Manitoba Colony, Santa Cruz Department, Bolivia",
"lat": -17.5,
"lng": -62.75,
"title": "Manitoba Colony: convictions after systematic drug-facilitated rapes in an isolated Mennonite community",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"members of an isolated Old Colony Mennonite community",
"male colony leadership controlling institutional response"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"chemical incapacitation",
"community isolation",
"male-only authority structure",
"dismissal of survivor accounts as imagination or demonic activity",
"religious pressure to forgive",
"restricted access to counseling"
],
"organizations": [
"Manitoba Mennonite Colony"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal court in Santa Cruz Department, Bolivia",
"stage": "closed trial, convictions and sentences",
"date": "2011-08-25",
"outcome": "Eight men were convicted after a two-month trial. Seven received twenty-five-year sentences for aggravated rape; Peter Wiebe Wall received twelve and a half years for supplying material used to make the sedative spray."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Americas/Latin-America-Monitor/2011/0826/Seven-Bolivian-Mennonites-sentenced-to-25-years-for-rape",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Christian Science Monitor, 'Seven Bolivian Mennonites sentenced to 25 years for rape' (Aug. 26, 2011).",
"body": "Contemporaneous trial reporting records seven twenty-five-year sentences, the large number of women and girls who came forward, the use of animal sedative and the community's delayed recognition of survivor accounts.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "trial-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://canadianmennonite.org/bolivian-mennonite-rape-trial-ends-convictions/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Canadian Mennonite, 'Bolivian Mennonite rape trial ends in convictions' (Sept. 14, 2011).",
"body": "Mennonite institutional reporting identifies the eight convictions, distinguishes the seven aggravated-rape sentences from the supplier's sentence and records concerns and responses within Mennonite communities.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://time.com/6250526/women-talking-mennonite-bolivia-real-story/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jean Friedman-Rudovsky, Time, 'I Covered the Story That Inspired Women Talking. Here's What I Wish More People Knew' (Jan. 27, 2023).",
"body": "The reporter who covered the trial and later returned to Manitoba Colony documents the institutional aftermath, including demon explanations for the assaults, demands that survivors forgive under threat of damnation, refusal of counseling and continued abuse reports. These later findings are attributed to her reporting, not to the 2011 verdict.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-aftermath"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies chemical incapacitation, community isolation, male-only authority structure, dismissal of survivor accounts as imagination or demonic activity, religious pressure to forgive, and restricted access to counseling as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is members of an isolated Old Colony Mennonite community and male colony leadership controlling institutional response.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-mennonite-anabaptist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Americas/Latin-America-Monitor/2011/0826/Seven-Bolivian-Mennonites-sentenced-to-25-years-for-rape",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cdbe860ea9d95750718bec9f88f71d5f8648ddd64cdccfef1a8294090bd999e6",
"final_url": "https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Americas/Latin-America-Monitor/2011/0826/Seven-Bolivian-Mennonites-sentenced-to-25-years-for-rape"
},
{
"source": "https://canadianmennonite.org/bolivian-mennonite-rape-trial-ends-convictions/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://time.com/6250526/women-talking-mennonite-bolivia-real-story/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-aftermath.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c337a1e335617d55499f5f798414a70f6869a833214c280018fa23f6ca236701",
"final_url": "https://time.com/6250526/women-talking-mennonite-bolivia-real-story/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 71,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Belize",
"date": "2016-03-10",
"outcome": "The conviction and concurrent twelve-year sentences were affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The Belize Baptist Association denied that Garcia was an accredited pastor. Contemporaneous reporting nevertheless describes him as the person acting as spiritual leader at the Franks Eddy church and the child as a church member; this entry preserves that disputed credential rather than treating it as settled. It concerns Garcia's adjudicated conduct and claimed church authority, not Baptists, Belizean churches, pastors or congregants generally. The survivor is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-julio-cesar-garcia-franks-eddy-belize",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Franks Eddy, Cayo District, Belize",
"lat": 17.253,
"lng": -88.681,
"title": "Julio Cesar Garcia: Belize Court of Appeal affirms church-member abuse conviction",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described pastor",
"acting spiritual leader at Franks Eddy Baptist Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed church authority",
"access to a child church member",
"use of church premises"
],
"organizations": [
"Franks Eddy Baptist Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Belize",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Garcia was convicted on two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with an eleven-year-old church member and received concurrent twelve-year prison terms."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Belize",
"stage": "appeal dismissed",
"date": "2016-03-10",
"outcome": "The Court of Appeal dismissed Garcia's appeal and affirmed the conviction and sentence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.channel5belize.com/?p=126214",
"archive": "",
"citation": "News 5 Belize, 'Pastor's Sentence for Sexual Offences Upheld by Appeal Court' (Mar. 10, 2016).",
"body": "Contemporaneous appellate reporting records the dismissed appeal, two convictions, concurrent twelve-year sentences, one incident inside the church and the Baptist Association's denial that Garcia was an accredited pastor.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.belizenews.com/160320.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "7 News Belize / BelizeNews.com, 'Child Abusing Pastor Sent Back To Jail By Court of Appeal' (Mar. 10, 2016).",
"body": "A second contemporaneous account describes Garcia as the acting spiritual leader, identifies the child as an eleven-year-old church member and corroborates the affirmed conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed church authority, access to a child church member, and use of church premises as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-described pastor and acting spiritual leader at Franks Eddy Baptist Church.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Belize",
"date": "2016-03-10",
"outcome": "The conviction and concurrent twelve-year sentences were affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.channel5belize.com/?p=126214",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ce03c51fd76ec59766a8ed519f318baaf8f47d1dd238319acfb064b5433d9cc9",
"final_url": "https://archive.channel5belize.com/archives/126214"
},
{
"source": "https://www.belizenews.com/160320.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c9c8febdabc7fa946da9cbe39e694ce96cc6501b0565b9c961b286cce0854dcc",
"final_url": "https://www.belizenews.com/160320.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 72,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Cassation Chamber of Costa Rica",
"date": "2022-07-15",
"outcome": "The chamber affirmed the thirty-six-year sentence for the congregant cases."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The record distinguishes the seven offenses sustained in the first trial from fourteen acquitted counts and treats the 2025 child-rape conviction as a separate judgment. Some later reports state thirty-nine years for the first case; this entry follows the court-result reporting that identifies the imposed and affirmed aggregate as thirty-six years. Chavarría died in custody in January 2026. The entry concerns his adjudicated misuse of pastoral counseling and spiritual authority, not Christianity, evangelical churches, counselors, pastors or congregants generally. Survivors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-carlos-chavarria-generacion-316-costa-rica",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Heredia and San José, Costa Rica",
"lat": 9.9981,
"lng": -84.1198,
"title": "Carlos Chavarría Fonseca: affirmed thirty-six-year sentence and a later child-rape conviction",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"spiritual guide",
"confessor",
"leader of Iglesia Generación 3:16"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counseling access",
"spiritual-guide authority",
"manipulation of congregants",
"church institutional access"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia Generación 3:16"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Heredia Criminal Court, Costa Rica",
"stage": "trial judgment",
"date": "2021-08-27",
"outcome": "The court convicted Chavarría of three rapes and four sexual-abuse offenses involving six congregants and imposed an aggregate thirty-six-year prison sentence; it acquitted him on fourteen other charged counts."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Cassation Chamber of Costa Rica",
"stage": "cassation judgment",
"date": "2022-07-15",
"outcome": "The chamber affirmed the thirty-six-year conviction and sentence."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "San José Criminal Court, Costa Rica",
"stage": "separate trial judgment",
"date": "2025-09-23",
"outcome": "The court imposed a separate twelve-year sentence for raping a nine-year-old child at an institute operated by the church."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://semanariouniversidad.com/pais/sala-de-casacion-ratifica-sentencia-de-38-anos-para-pastor-de-los-ricos-condenado-por-violacion/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Semanario Universidad, 'Sala de Casación ratifica sentencia de 36 años para pastor de los ricos condenado por violación' (Aug. 1, 2022).",
"body": "Appellate reporting records the affirmed thirty-six-year sentence, seven sustained sexual offenses, six congregants and the pastoral guide, confessor and superior relationship described in the judgment.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://ministeriopublico.poder-judicial.go.cr/index.php/medios-informativos/noticias-judiciales/2021/fiscalia-pide-56-anos-de-carcel-contra-pastor-acusado-de-cometer-delitos-sexuales",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público de Costa Rica, 'Fiscalía pide 56 años de cárcel contra pastor acusado de cometer delitos sexuales' (Aug. 11, 2021).",
"body": "The official prosecution release identifies the alleged mechanism as manipulation and deception through Chavarría's position as pastor and spiritual guide and records the pastoral-counseling setting.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "trial-record"
},
{
"link": "https://www.teletica.com/nacional/pastor-de-los-ricos-sentenciado-a-12-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-nina-de-nueve-anos_393114",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Teletica, '\"Pastor de los Ricos\" sentenciado a 12 años de cárcel por violar a niña de nueve años' (Sept. 25, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting quotes the prosecution and records the separate twelve-year conviction, the child's age and the church-operated institute where the offense occurred.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "separate-judgment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral counseling access, spiritual-guide authority, manipulation of congregants, and church institutional access as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor, spiritual guide, confessor, and leader of Iglesia Generación 3:16.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Cassation Chamber of Costa Rica",
"date": "2022-07-15",
"outcome": "The chamber affirmed the thirty-six-year sentence for the congregant cases."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://semanariouniversidad.com/pais/sala-de-casacion-ratifica-sentencia-de-38-anos-para-pastor-de-los-ricos-condenado-por-violacion/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c24db6d3560c3f4b8d38480bda909ff6aff3660ad92dc70eeeec9a617c065a20",
"final_url": "https://semanariouniversidad.com/pais/sala-de-casacion-ratifica-sentencia-de-38-anos-para-pastor-de-los-ricos-condenado-por-violacion/"
},
{
"source": "https://ministeriopublico.poder-judicial.go.cr/index.php/medios-informativos/noticias-judiciales/2021/fiscalia-pide-56-anos-de-carcel-contra-pastor-acusado-de-cometer-delitos-sexuales",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: trial-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.teletica.com/nacional/pastor-de-los-ricos-sentenciado-a-12-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-nina-de-nueve-anos_393114",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: separate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1b6e8ecd0a5a99682ffaeace4b464ba3520adb1df867c035928b72550f3de9c9",
"final_url": "https://www.teletica.com/nacional/pastor-de-los-ricos-sentenciado-a-12-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-nina-de-nueve-anos_393114"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 73,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Appeals Court of Costa Rica",
"date": "2022-10-11",
"outcome": "The criminal conviction and sentence were affirmed."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Cassation Chamber of Costa Rica",
"date": "2023-04-21",
"outcome": "The chamber rejected the remaining defense challenges and the sentence became final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The criminal conviction concerns one child; the civil concealment judgment concerns a different survivor whose criminal complaint had prescribed. The entry does not convert other allegations into convictions and does not identify survivors beyond what some sources chose to publish. It concerns Víquez's conduct and a specific civil finding against named church institutions and an archbishop, not Catholicism, Catholics, priests, parishes or Costa Rican church workers generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-mauricio-viquez-patarra-costa-rica",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Patarrá, San José Province, Costa Rica",
"lat": 9.8806,
"lng": -84.035,
"title": "Mauricio Víquez: final twenty-year sentence and civil finding against church authorities",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest",
"parish authority",
"church officials responsible for internal complaints"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access to a child",
"economic vulnerability",
"clerical authority",
"institutional concealment found in civil court"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of San José",
"Episcopal Conference of Costa Rica"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Desamparados Criminal Court, Costa Rica",
"stage": "trial judgment",
"date": "2022-03-30",
"outcome": "The court convicted Víquez of aggravated rape and sexual abuse of an eleven-year-old child and imposed consecutive terms totaling twenty years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Appeals Court of Costa Rica",
"stage": "appeal judgment",
"date": "2022-10-11",
"outcome": "The appeals court affirmed the conviction and sentence."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Cassation Chamber of Costa Rica",
"stage": "cassation rejected",
"date": "2023-04-21",
"outcome": "The chamber rejected the defense challenges, leaving the twenty-year sentence final."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Second Collegiate Civil Court of First Instance of San José, Costa Rica",
"stage": "civil judgment",
"date": "2022-08-23",
"outcome": "The court held the Episcopal Conference, the Archdiocese's temporalities and Archbishop José Rafael Quirós civilly liable for concealment and moral harm in a separate survivor's claim."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://observador.cr/condena-de-20-anos-contra-exsacerdote-mauricio-viquez-por-delitos-sexuales-queda-en-firme-sala-iii-rechaza-apelaciones/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Observador CR, 'Condena de 20 años contra exsacerdote Mauricio Víquez por delitos sexuales queda en firme' (Apr. 21, 2023).",
"body": "Court reporting records the rejected cassation challenges, final twenty-year sentence, two sustained crimes and prior appellate affirmance.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://crhoy.com/nacionales/tribunal-condena-a-la-iglesia-catolica-y-a-obispo-por-abusos-sexuales-de-mauricio-viquez-a-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CRHoy, 'Tribunal condena a la Iglesia Católica y a obispo por abusos sexuales de Mauricio Víquez a menor' (Aug. 23, 2022).",
"body": "Contemporaneous civil-court reporting records the first-instance concealment and moral-harm judgment against the Episcopal Conference, Archdiocesan temporalities and Archbishop Quirós and distinguishes the civil claimant from the criminal case.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "civil-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://elpais.com/sociedad/2022-03-31/costa-rica-condena-a-20-anos-de-carcel-a-mauricio-viquez-un-sacerdote-que-violo-a-un-nino.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El País, 'Costa Rica condena a 20 años de cárcel a Mauricio Víquez, un sacerdote que violó a un niño' (Mar. 31, 2022).",
"body": "Contemporaneous trial reporting records the conviction, sentence, parish context, extradition from Mexico and the separate concealment allegations then before the civil court.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "trial-disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies parish access to a child, economic vulnerability, clerical authority, and institutional concealment found in civil court as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Catholic priest, parish authority, and church officials responsible for internal complaints.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Appeals Court of Costa Rica",
"date": "2022-10-11",
"outcome": "The criminal conviction and sentence were affirmed."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Cassation Chamber of Costa Rica",
"date": "2023-04-21",
"outcome": "The chamber rejected the remaining defense challenges and the sentence became final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://observador.cr/condena-de-20-anos-contra-exsacerdote-mauricio-viquez-por-delitos-sexuales-queda-en-firme-sala-iii-rechaza-apelaciones/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c24907a312f86a08336862ae2385a230d82769f36291c49b04fd8fa81b3a298d",
"final_url": "https://observador.cr/condena-de-20-anos-contra-exsacerdote-mauricio-viquez-por-delitos-sexuales-queda-en-firme-sala-iii-rechaza-apelaciones/"
},
{
"source": "https://crhoy.com/nacionales/tribunal-condena-a-la-iglesia-catolica-y-a-obispo-por-abusos-sexuales-de-mauricio-viquez-a-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8b53bc53c8e6e9c4a3432dee2ac2a8b529ada88ddc0de45a0b2f080b577ecac8",
"final_url": "https://crhoy.com/nacionales/tribunal-condena-a-la-iglesia-catolica-y-a-obispo-por-abusos-sexuales-de-mauricio-viquez-a-menor/"
},
{
"source": "https://elpais.com/sociedad/2022-03-31/costa-rica-condena-a-20-anos-de-carcel-a-mauricio-viquez-un-sacerdote-que-violo-a-un-nino.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "082e0cf7af4a65323a26b1758f39685be5fd568d8053360f12a70ea927bc4b99",
"final_url": "https://elpais.com/sociedad/2022-03-31/costa-rica-condena-a-20-anos-de-carcel-a-mauricio-viquez-un-sacerdote-que-violo-a-un-nino.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 74,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Reporting at judgment said the conviction could be appealed; the initial July 2026 review did not locate a later appellate disposition. A separate older complaint against Guevara was reported prescribed and is not treated as part of this conviction. The entry concerns his adjudicated conduct and clerical access to one child altar server, not Catholicism, Catholics, priests, parishes or altar servers generally. The survivor is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-manuel-guevara-coronado-costa-rica",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Vázquez de Coronado, San José Province, Costa Rica",
"lat": 9.9762,
"lng": -84.0075,
"title": "Manuel Antonio Guevara Fonseca: eighteen-year sentence for abuse of a child altar server",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest",
"parish authority over an altar server"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority",
"altar-service access",
"parish trust",
"repeated private access"
],
"organizations": [
"Catholic parish in Vázquez de Coronado"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Second Judicial Circuit Criminal Court of San José, Costa Rica",
"stage": "unanimous trial judgment",
"date": "2024-04-03",
"outcome": "The court convicted Guevara of six sexual-abuse offenses committed in 2007 against a twelve-year-old altar server and imposed eighteen years in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.teletica.com/sucesos/sacerdote-condenado-a-18-anos-carcel-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-monaguillo-en-coronado_355697",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Teletica, 'Sacerdote condenado a 18 años cárcel por abusar sexualmente de monaguillo en Coronado' (Apr. 3, 2024).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting quotes the judiciary's announcement of unanimous judgment 240-2024 and records the eighteen-year sentence, six offenses, 2007 date and altar-server relationship.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://elpais.com/america/2024-04-06/una-nueva-condena-por-pederastia-golpea-a-la-iglesia-catolica-en-costa-rica.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El País, 'Una nueva condena por pederastia golpea a la Iglesia católica en Costa Rica' (Apr. 6, 2024).",
"body": "Independent reporting corroborates the conviction and sentence, identifies the 2007 parish and altar-service context and notes that an appeal remained possible at publication.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies clerical authority, altar-service access, parish trust, and repeated private access as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Catholic priest and parish authority over an altar server.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.teletica.com/sucesos/sacerdote-condenado-a-18-anos-carcel-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-monaguillo-en-coronado_355697",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3bfe398ef7b3bf5d012d168df7a5a64cf815819907bb5a78cc5acda1d401c4d2",
"final_url": "https://www.teletica.com/sucesos/sacerdote-condenado-a-18-anos-carcel-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-monaguillo-en-coronado_355697"
},
{
"source": "https://elpais.com/america/2024-04-06/una-nueva-condena-por-pederastia-golpea-a-la-iglesia-catolica-en-costa-rica.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "25f1d6b9b3848bd6b2e902e9bb12ed7b81da695bdc64d32f07f9840a3aac960a",
"final_url": "https://elpais.com/america/2024-04-06/una-nueva-condena-por-pederastia-golpea-a-la-iglesia-catolica-en-costa-rica.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 75,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The prosecution report identifies three child survivors but this entry does not name them. The initial July 2026 review did not locate a later appellate disposition. It concerns Alvarez Bonilla's adjudicated use of spiritual-leader status and pastoral-house access, not Christianity, evangelical churches, pastors, disabled people or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-israel-alvarez-sensembra-el-salvador",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Sensembra, Morazán, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.6437,
"lng": -88.1716,
"title": "Israel Antonio Alvarez Bonilla: twenty-seven-year sentence for rape and harassment through pastoral authority",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor",
"spiritual leader with access to a pastoral residence"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-leader authority",
"pastoral-house access",
"isolation of children",
"exploitation of disability"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical church in Morazán"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "San Francisco Gotera Trial Court, El Salvador",
"stage": "public trial and sentence",
"date": "2013-09-09",
"outcome": "The court convicted Alvarez Bonilla of raping a seventeen-year-old with epilepsy and sexually harassing two sisters aged fourteen and twelve, imposing twenty years for rape and seven for harassment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/medios/memoria-2013-2014/files/assets/basic-html/page67.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General de la República de El Salvador, Memoria de Labores 2013-2014, p. 67.",
"body": "The official annual report records the conviction, three survivors, twenty-seven-year sentence, defendant's spiritual-leader status and use of times when the children were alone or at the pastoral residence.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "official-annual-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual-leader authority, pastoral-house access, isolation of children, and exploitation of disability as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is evangelical pastor and spiritual leader with access to a pastoral residence.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/medios/memoria-2013-2014/files/assets/basic-html/page67.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: official-annual-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7f5f2cd182ebf45527614372609f7b86722e64c04efff5df53db67b698fa9985",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/medios/memoria-2013-2014/files/assets/basic-html/page67.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 76,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The survivor is not identified. The initial July 2026 review did not locate a later appellate disposition. The entry concerns Esquina Pérez's adjudicated use of prophetic claims, a false diagnosis and family prayer to obtain private access, not Christianity, prophecy, prayer, healing, pastors or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-jose-eligio-esquina-prayer-san-salvador",
"year": 2020,
"place": "San Salvador, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.6929,
"lng": -89.2182,
"title": "José Eligio Esquina Pérez: twenty-year sentence after a prophetic healing pretext",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor",
"self-described prophet"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine revelation",
"false spiritual diagnosis",
"prayer and healing pretext",
"family religious trust",
"ritual isolation"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical Protestant church on the road to Huizúcar"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fourth Trial Court of San Salvador, El Salvador",
"stage": "trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2020-02-20",
"outcome": "The court convicted Esquina Pérez of aggravated rape of an adolescent and imposed twenty years in prison plus civil compensation."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pena-de-20-anos-de-carcel-a-pastor-por-violacion-en-san-salvador/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General de la República de El Salvador, 'Pena de 20 años de cárcel a pastor por violación en San Salvador' (Feb. 20, 2020).",
"body": "The official prosecution report records the conviction and sentence and describes how Esquina Pérez claimed divine revelation that the child was ill, arrived under a prayer pretext and left the family praying while he isolated and assaulted her.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed divine revelation, false spiritual diagnosis, prayer and healing pretext, family religious trust, and ritual isolation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is evangelical pastor and self-described prophet.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pena-de-20-anos-de-carcel-a-pastor-por-violacion-en-san-salvador/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6702122299c3dec89e71d100b17eb18b438cec24da1684a724efb1440a1efd3b",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pena-de-20-anos-de-carcel-a-pastor-por-violacion-en-san-salvador/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 77,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The prosecution report establishes that the survivor and her family attended the church Quijano led for more than eight years, but the final assault involved physical force rather than a ritual claim. The case qualifies because pastoral access and congregational trust materially preceded the harassment and offense; it is not presented as proof that belief caused the violence. The survivor is not identified, and no later appellate disposition was located in the initial July 2026 review.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-manuel-quijano-soyapango-el-salvador",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Soyapango, San Salvador, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.7102,
"lng": -89.1399,
"title": "Manuel Quijano Vega: sixteen-year sentence in a child congregant case",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"longstanding religious leader of the survivor's family"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"congregational trust",
"pastoral access to a child and family",
"continued harassment after family warning",
"physical abduction"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church in Soyapango"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sixth Trial Court of San Salvador, El Salvador",
"stage": "trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2021-07-13",
"outcome": "The court convicted Quijano Vega of aggravated rape and sexual harassment of a child and imposed eleven years for rape and five years for harassment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pastor-evangelico-es-condenado-por-violacion-en-soyapango/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General de la República de El Salvador, 'Pastor evangélico es condenado por Violación, en Soyapango' (July 13, 2021).",
"body": "The official prosecution report records the conviction, sentence, survivor's church membership, the family's warning after earlier harassment and the later aggravated rape.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies congregational trust, pastoral access to a child and family, continued harassment after family warning, and physical abduction as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor and longstanding religious leader of the survivor's family.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pastor-evangelico-es-condenado-por-violacion-en-soyapango/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fbc78f18273f7f88a64642a6c1d23dd2e9a0a0eebbc00843060e4d7fc3e1a1a5",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pastor-evangelico-es-condenado-por-violacion-en-soyapango/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 78,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The survivor is not identified. The initial July 2026 review did not locate a later appellate disposition. The entry concerns Pérez González's adjudicated use of church-work requests and pastoral access, not Christianity, churches, administrative volunteering, pastors or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-edwin-perez-nahuizalco-el-salvador",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Nahuizalco, Sonsonate, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.7775,
"lng": -89.7366,
"title": "Edwin Analberto Pérez González: twenty-year sentence after church-work grooming",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"director of the church attended by the survivor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"church administrative-work pretext",
"pastoral authority",
"congregational trust",
"private access to a child"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church in Nahuizalco"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "First Trial Court of Sonsonate, El Salvador",
"stage": "trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2023-06-12",
"outcome": "The court convicted Pérez González of continuous rape of a twelve-year-old congregant and imposed twenty years in prison plus civil compensation."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pastor-es-condenado-a-20-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-adolescente/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General de la República de El Salvador, 'Pastor es condenado a 20 años de cárcel por violar a adolescente' (June 12, 2023).",
"body": "The official prosecution report records the conviction and sentence and states that the pastor directed the child's church and used requests for church reports to bring her to his home.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies church administrative-work pretext, pastoral authority, congregational trust, and private access to a child as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor and director of the church attended by the survivor.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pastor-es-condenado-a-20-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-adolescente/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dc6da69fca67aa8dfc9643ac52190360eb3b49c2452b07499eab2913c0c77357",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/pastor-es-condenado-a-20-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-adolescente/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 79,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The prosecution explicitly states that Zuniga used his office to approach the child. The survivor is not identified, and the initial July 2026 review did not locate a later appellate disposition. The entry concerns one pastor's adjudicated conduct, not Christianity, Iglesia Príncipe de Paz members, Salvadoran churches, pastors or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-francisco-zuniga-atiquizaya-el-salvador",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Atiquizaya, Ahuachapán, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.9769,
"lng": -89.7526,
"title": "Francisco Abigail Zuniga Figueroa: twelve-year sentence for abuse of a child congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Iglesia Príncipe de Paz",
"religious authority over a child congregant"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral office",
"church access to a child",
"congregational trust"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia Príncipe de Paz"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "trial court in Ahuachapán, El Salvador",
"stage": "trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2022-09-27",
"outcome": "A judge convicted Zuniga Figueroa of aggravated rape of a sixteen-year-old congregant and imposed twelve years in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/sujeto-que-pastoreaba-iglesia-en-ahuachapan-es-sentenciado-a-carcel-por-violacion-de-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General de la República de El Salvador, 'Sujeto que pastoreaba iglesia en Ahuachapán es sentenciado a cárcel por violación de menor' (Sept. 27, 2022).",
"body": "The official prosecution report records the conviction, twelve-year sentence, survivor's age and church membership and states that Zuniga used his pastoral office to approach her.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral office, church access to a child, and congregational trust as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor of Iglesia Príncipe de Paz and religious authority over a child congregant.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/sujeto-que-pastoreaba-iglesia-en-ahuachapan-es-sentenciado-a-carcel-por-violacion-de-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2bdd13e348ed5dd3685d7bbe1f3e37d713118d75e4a18133375d14ba13a98c7e",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/sujeto-que-pastoreaba-iglesia-en-ahuachapan-es-sentenciado-a-carcel-por-violacion-de-menor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 80,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a Guatemala proceeding separate from the U.S. Lev Tahor convictions. The April 2026 completion of child-protection reunification proceedings did not establish a disposition of these criminal charges; the initial July 2026 review found no later criminal judgment. The entry concerns two charged individuals and the Lev Tahor organization, not Judaism, ultra-Orthodox Jews, Jewish marriage, families or Guatemalan Jewish communities generally. Children are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-lev-tahor-teller-rosner-guatemala",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Oratorio, Santa Rosa, Guatemala",
"lat": 14.2283,
"lng": -90.1754,
"title": "Lev Tahor in Guatemala: leader and marriage officiant charged in forced-pregnancy proceeding",
"tradition": "judaism",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"alleged Lev Tahor leader",
"person allegedly responsible for officiating forced marriages"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"forced or servile marriage",
"forced or servile pregnancy",
"religious-group authority",
"control of children within an isolated community"
],
"organizations": [
"Lev Tahor"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Guatemalan criminal court",
"stage": "formal processing order",
"date": "2025-02-06",
"outcome": "A judge ordered Aaron Teller to face proceedings for trafficking in the form of forced or servile pregnancy and Josef Rosner to face proceedings for that trafficking offense and child mistreatment. Both remain presumed innocent unless convicted."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mp.gob.gt/noticia/lider-de-lev-tahor-y-otro-integrante-de-la-secta-son-ligados-a-proceso-penal/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público de Guatemala, 'Líder de Lev Tahor y otro integrante de la secta son ligados a proceso penal' (Feb. 7, 2025).",
"body": "The official prosecution release identifies Teller and Rosner, the formal processing order, the distinct charged offenses and their alleged leadership and forced-marriage roles. It does not report a conviction.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "charging-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://pgn.gob.gt/2026/04/acciones-de-la-pgn-a-favor-de-la-ninez-y-adolescencia-de-lev-tahor/?amp=1",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Procuraduría General de la Nación de Guatemala, 'Acciones de la PGN a favor de la niñez y adolescencia de Lev Tahor' (Apr. 2026).",
"body": "The official child-protection account records the later reunification and protection work. It is used only to distinguish the concluded protection process from the unresolved criminal proceeding.",
"tier": "official-agency",
"kind": "institutional-response"
}
],
"route": {
"from": [
-74.38,
41.62
],
"to": [
-90.1754,
14.2283
],
"fromLabel": "Woodridge, NY, USA",
"toLabel": "Oratorio, Santa Rosa, Guatemala",
"label": "Lev Tahor: Woodridge, NY -> Guatemala",
"provenance": "Endpoints are two corpus records of the same sect's proceedings: the US kidnapping/child-exploitation convictions (2022-woodridge-ny-usa) documenting international concealment/family separation, and the Guatemalan MP proceeding (this record). Both coordinates are the corpus records' own gazetteer points."
},
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents forced or servile marriage, forced or servile pregnancy, religious-group authority, and control of children within an isolated community, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is alleged Lev Tahor leader and person allegedly responsible for officiating forced marriages.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A judge ordered Aaron Teller to face proceedings for trafficking in the form of forced or servile pregnancy and Josef Rosner to face proceedings for that trafficking offense and child mistreatment. Both remain presumed innocent unless convicted.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mp.gob.gt/noticia/lider-de-lev-tahor-y-otro-integrante-de-la-secta-son-ligados-a-proceso-penal/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: charging-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://pgn.gob.gt/2026/04/acciones-de-la-pgn-a-favor-de-la-ninez-y-adolescencia-de-lev-tahor/?amp=1",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-agency; evidentiary role: institutional-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "70ce5a5226b1ff9516cc26770dd2d7d67021e05c018c1d45d66d88508479e257",
"final_url": "https://pgn.gob.gt/2026/04/acciones-de-la-pgn-a-favor-de-la-ninez-y-adolescencia-de-lev-tahor/?amp=1"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 81,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This institutional event is included because a religious-school director was convicted of concealing abuse committed by a volunteer within the school. The sources do not establish a ritual or doctrinal mechanism, and the record does not claim one. It concerns the two convicted adults and one school response, not Catholicism, Catholics, religious sisters, schools, volunteers, Italians, Salvadorans or Guatemalans generally. The child is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-catholic-school-concealment-san-lucas-guatemala",
"year": 2013,
"place": "San Lucas Sacatepéquez, Guatemala",
"lat": 14.6107,
"lng": -90.6568,
"title": "San Lucas Catholic school: director convicted of concealing a volunteer's abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic religious sister and school director",
"foreign volunteer at a religious school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-school institutional access",
"school-director authority",
"concealment after abuse",
"threats against a child's parents"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed Catholic school in San Lucas Sacatepéquez"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sacatepéquez Criminal Trial Court, Guatemala",
"stage": "separate convictions",
"date": "2013-10-30",
"outcome": "The court sentenced school director Sister Imelda Solano Torres to four years for concealing the abuse of a seven-year-old child. Volunteer Samuelle Corbetta had previously received eight years for the abuse."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.prensalibre.com/guatemala/justicia/condenan-monja-colegio-sacatepequez-violacion-nina-encubrimiento_0_1020498132-html/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ACAN-EFE / Prensa Libre, 'Condenan a prisión a religiosa por encubrir violación de niña' (Oct. 30, 2013).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records Solano Torres's four-year concealment sentence, Corbetta's earlier eight-year abuse sentence, their institutional roles and the Catholic-school setting.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious-school institutional access, school-director authority, concealment after abuse, and threats against a child's parents as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Catholic religious sister and school director and foreign volunteer at a religious school.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.prensalibre.com/guatemala/justicia/condenan-monja-colegio-sacatepequez-violacion-nina-encubrimiento_0_1020498132-html/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8e301a038e95af57d52f10faba3fd023aa1c8e9b35595eed94a353b4670f4678",
"final_url": "https://www.prensalibre.com/guatemala/justicia/condenan-monja-colegio-sacatepequez-violacion-nina-encubrimiento_0_1020498132-html/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 82,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The prosecution describes three convictions but does not publish docket numbers, survivor identities or how the several sentences are to be served relative to one another. This entry therefore does not calculate a combined term. It concerns Zambrano's adjudicated use of pastoral and Sunday-school access, not Christianity, evangelical churches, Sunday schools, pastors, teachers or children generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-erick-zambrano-sunday-school-honduras",
"year": 2025,
"place": "San Pedro Sula, Cortés, Honduras",
"lat": 15.5007,
"lng": -88.025,
"title": "Erick Geovany Zambrano Estrada: three convictions tied to Sunday-school access",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor",
"church leader with access to Sunday-school children"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"Sunday-school access",
"deception of child congregants",
"church isolation"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical church in San Pedro Sula"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal court in San Pedro Sula, Honduras",
"stage": "two earlier convictions",
"date": "2024-08-21",
"outcome": "The court imposed sixteen years for continuous rape and ten years and three months for qualified sexual assaults, totaling twenty-six years and three months; the prosecution reports a separate ten-year abuse conviction as well."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal court in San Pedro Sula, Honduras",
"stage": "third conviction by strict conformity",
"date": "2025-05-02",
"outcome": "The court imposed another ten-year prison term for continuous sexual assaults against a child."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/pastor-evangelico-reciba-una-tercera-condena-por-abuso-sexual-en-perjuicio-de-menores-de-edad/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público de Honduras, 'Pastor evangélico recibe una tercera condena por abuso sexual en perjuicio de menores de edad' (May 2, 2025).",
"body": "The official prosecution release records the third conviction, earlier sentences and registration as a sex offender and states that Zambrano used his condition as pastor and children's Sunday-school visits to deceive the victims.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral authority, Sunday-school access, deception of child congregants, and church isolation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is evangelical pastor and church leader with access to Sunday-school children.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/pastor-evangelico-reciba-una-tercera-condena-por-abuso-sexual-en-perjuicio-de-menores-de-edad/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "be924b9450397b435a2b2ca13705bca21b39db955c22e1adb56b78b852e8cb5a",
"final_url": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/pastor-evangelico-reciba-una-tercera-condena-por-abuso-sexual-en-perjuicio-de-menores-de-edad/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 83,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an allegation record. The unnamed defendant remains presumed innocent, and formal processing and preventive detention are not convictions. No later disposition was located through July 16, 2026. The entry concerns a specific allegation of prayer and anointing used to isolate a child, not Christianity, prayer, anointing, veiling, evangelical churches, pastors, musicians or congregants generally. The adolescent is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-lepaterique-prayer-anointing-honduras",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Regadillos, Lepaterique, Francisco Morazán, Honduras",
"lat": 14.055,
"lng": -87.471,
"title": "Lepaterique pastor: charged after an alleged prayer-and-anointing pretext",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Iglesia Evangélica Nueva Jerusalén Internacional",
"congregational authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"church-music request",
"prayer pretext",
"spiritual anointing pretext",
"religious-veil practice",
"isolation inside a church"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia Evangélica Nueva Jerusalén Internacional"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Second Peace Court of Lepaterique, Honduras",
"stage": "formal processing and preventive detention",
"date": "2026-05-08",
"outcome": "A judge ordered the unnamed pastor formally processed and held in preventive detention on an aggravated-rape charge. This was not a finding of guilt."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/pastor-evangelico-es-enviado-a-prision-por-supuesto-abuso-sexual-a-una-adolescente-en-lepaterique/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público de Honduras, 'Pastor evangélico es enviado a prisión por supuesto abuso sexual a una adolescente en Lepaterique' (May 8, 2026).",
"body": "The official prosecution release records the formal processing order, preventive detention and allegation that the pastor requested piano help, removed the child's sibling and invoked prayer and spiritual anointing before the alleged assault.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "pretrial-disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents church-music request, prayer pretext, spiritual anointing pretext, religious-veil practice, and isolation inside a church, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is pastor of Iglesia Evangélica Nueva Jerusalén Internacional and congregational authority.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A judge ordered the unnamed pastor formally processed and held in preventive detention on an aggravated-rape charge. This was not a finding of guilt.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/pastor-evangelico-es-enviado-a-prision-por-supuesto-abuso-sexual-a-una-adolescente-en-lepaterique/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: pretrial-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "00acb1ebc2a6b852085b8b86348476b5f6913898015efa0612276cfd553c8f8d",
"final_url": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/pastor-evangelico-es-enviado-a-prision-por-supuesto-abuso-sexual-a-una-adolescente-en-lepaterique/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 84,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an allegation record. Erazo Cruz denied the charges and remains presumed innocent unless convicted. The last public procedural report located through July 16, 2026 was the completion of final arguments; a scheduled verdict is not itself a disposition. The entry concerns the alleged use of pastoral trust to obtain a household placement and impose servitude, not Christianity, evangelical churches, foster care, pastors or families generally. The child is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-denis-erazo-domestic-servitude-honduras",
"year": 2026,
"place": "El Progreso, Yoro, Honduras",
"lat": 15.4,
"lng": -87.8,
"title": "Denis Javier Erazo Cruz: trial over alleged abuse and domestic servitude after pastoral placement",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor",
"church leader who offered care to a child living near his congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust",
"placement in a pastor's household",
"domestic servitude",
"confinement",
"alleged repeated sexual violence"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical church in Yoro"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Honduran criminal court",
"stage": "arrest and charging",
"date": "2025-08-21",
"outcome": "Prosecutors charged Erazo Cruz with continuous qualified sexual assaults, continuous qualified rape and trafficking for servitude after his arrest."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Trial Court of El Progreso, Chamber II, Honduras",
"stage": "closed trial at final arguments",
"date": "2026-06-26",
"outcome": "The prosecution and defense completed final arguments after a closed trial. Erazo Cruz denied the allegations. A verdict was scheduled for June 30, but the initial July 16 review did not locate a published result."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/atic-detiene-a-pastor-evangelico-que-presuntamente-abuso-sexualmente-de-una-nina-a-la-que-mantenian-encerrada/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público de Honduras, 'ATIC detiene a pastor evangélico que presuntamente abusó sexualmente de una niña a la que mantenían encerrada' (Aug. 21, 2025).",
"body": "The official prosecution release records the arrest, alleged offenses and claim that the pastor and his wife obtained custody by offering support, then imposed household labor and confinement.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tunota.com/honduras-hoy/soy-inocente-pastor-evangelico-crimen-el-progreso-2026-06-26",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tu Nota, '\"Soy inocente\": pastor evangélico acusado de crimen contra menor' (June 26, 2026).",
"body": "Contemporaneous trial reporting records the charges, evidence categories, defendant's denial, completion of final arguments and scheduled verdict. No result was published in the sources located by July 16.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-status"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents pastoral trust, placement in a pastor's household, domestic servitude, confinement, and alleged repeated sexual violence, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is evangelical pastor and church leader who offered care to a child living near his congregation.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The prosecution and defense completed final arguments after a closed trial. Erazo Cruz denied the allegations. A verdict was scheduled for June 30, but the initial July 16 review did not locate a published result.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/atic-detiene-a-pastor-evangelico-que-presuntamente-abuso-sexualmente-de-una-nina-a-la-que-mantenian-encerrada/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0fb18b3d72cd44774d5d852fc445fbe515d7fd8881a807f51492119224011625",
"final_url": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/atic-detiene-a-pastor-evangelico-que-presuntamente-abuso-sexualmente-de-una-nina-a-la-que-mantenian-encerrada/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.tunota.com/honduras-hoy/soy-inocente-pastor-evangelico-crimen-el-progreso-2026-06-26",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-status.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f6a0cece0b7c3a4bd9da9a15d30e098a9445ef0bace1268f20e1aaef8088834c",
"final_url": "https://www.tunota.com/honduras-hoy/soy-inocente-pastor-evangelico-crimen-el-progreso-2026-06-26"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 85,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The court reporting says the children's parents were abroad and that the sisters came to live in the pastor's home after their grandparents became ill. The entry treats pastoral trust and guardianship as the documented nexus; it does not claim a ritual mechanism. The survivors are not identified, and the initial July 2026 review did not locate a later appellate disposition. It concerns Sánchez Martínez's adjudicated conduct, not Christianity, evangelical churches, pastors, guardians or Nicaraguan families generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-mariano-sanchez-camoapa-nicaragua",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Camoapa, Boaco, Nicaragua",
"lat": 12.3827,
"lng": -85.5122,
"title": "Mariano Ramón Sánchez Martínez: twenty-two-year sentence after pastoral guardianship",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor",
"adult entrusted with two children while their parents were abroad"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and family trust",
"household guardianship",
"authority over children living in his home",
"threats"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical church in Camoapa"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Specialized Violence Court in Boaco, Nicaragua",
"stage": "trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2024-11-22",
"outcome": "The court convicted Sánchez Martínez of raping an eleven-year-old child and attempting to abuse her sister and imposed twenty-two years and six months in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.laprensani.com/2024/11/25/sucesos/3404595-larga-condena-para-pastor-evangelico-inculpado-por-violar-a-nina-de-11-anos",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Prensa Nicaragua, 'Larga condena para pastor evangélico inculpado por violar a niña de 11 años' (Nov. 25, 2024).",
"body": "Detailed contemporaneous court reporting identifies the defendant, judge, conviction, sentence, two child survivors and the pastoral-household guardianship through which he exercised authority.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tn8.ni/sucesos/22-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-de-boaco-por-abusar-de-una-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TN8 Nicaragua, '22 años de prisión para pastor de Boaco por abusar de una menor' (Nov. 2024).",
"body": "Independent local reporting corroborates the twenty-two-year sentence, victim ages, period of abuse, family trust and the defendant's care of the children.",
"tier": "local-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral and family trust, household guardianship, authority over children living in his home, and threats as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is evangelical pastor and adult entrusted with two children while their parents were abroad.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.laprensani.com/2024/11/25/sucesos/3404595-larga-condena-para-pastor-evangelico-inculpado-por-violar-a-nina-de-11-anos",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.tn8.ni/sucesos/22-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-de-boaco-por-abusar-de-una-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7c9a14cc726476446cdb7e15b0aea31cb8a5125f6fb455c60030b3744909f73b",
"final_url": "https://www.tn8.ni/sucesos/22-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-de-boaco-por-abusar-de-una-menor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 86,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The appellate court treated Ellis's position as pastor, the trust placed in him and the church setting as aggravating factors. The survivor is not identified. This entry concerns Ellis's adjudicated use of pastoral counselling and ritual language, not Christianity, churches, pastors, counselling, anointing or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-oraine-ellis-jamaica",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Kingston, Jamaica",
"lat": 18.0179,
"lng": -76.8099,
"title": "Oraine Ellis: rape conviction upheld after church counselling pretext",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor and preacher",
"religious counsellor to a child congregant"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"altar counselling",
"anointing ritual",
"promise of blessing",
"pastoral trust",
"private access to a child"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church in Jamaica"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jamaican trial court",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2015-11-13",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Ellis of rape. The court imposed twenty years' imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Jamaica",
"stage": "appeal judgment",
"date": "2022-03-18",
"outcome": "The court refused the conviction appeal and clarified the sentence as twenty years with thirteen years and eleven months before parole eligibility, subject to remand credit."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtofappeal.gov.jm/sites/default/files/judgments/Ellis%20%28Oraine%29%20v%20R.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Appeal of Jamaica, Ellis (Oraine) v R, [2022] JMCA Crim 8 (Mar. 18, 2022).",
"body": "The appellate judgment records the conviction, sentence and refusal of the appeal. It recounts evidence that Ellis invited a fifteen-year-old congregant to the altar, anointed her, asked intimate questions, offered counselling and said he would bless her before the assault; it also addresses the abuse of pastoral trust.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies altar counselling, anointing ritual, promise of blessing, pastoral trust, and private access to a child as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor and preacher and religious counsellor to a child congregant.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtofappeal.gov.jm/sites/default/files/judgments/Ellis%20%28Oraine%29%20v%20R.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "92de9d964a150ec88f6c1664f112c235f9f9a759ae031a6dc7a7f979670d67da",
"final_url": "https://www.courtofappeal.gov.jm/sites/default/files/judgments/Ellis%20%28Oraine%29%20v%20R.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 87,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an allegation record. Campbell remains presumed innocent unless convicted. The initial review did not locate a later public disposition through July 16, 2026. The entry concerns allegations that one pastor used evil-spirit and deliverance claims to obtain sex and money, not Christianity, deliverance ministries, churches, pastors or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-winston-campbell-jamaica",
"year": 2020,
"place": "St. Catherine, Jamaica",
"lat": 18.0029,
"lng": -76.965,
"title": "Winston Campbell: charged over alleged sex-as-deliverance claims",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"purported deliverance and ritual-treatment provider"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"evil-spirit diagnosis",
"sex presented as deliverance",
"paid ritual treatment",
"pastoral authority"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church in St. Catherine"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "St. Catherine Parish Court, Jamaica",
"stage": "arrest and charges",
"date": "2020-06-26",
"outcome": "Police charged Campbell with three counts of rape and obtaining money by false pretence. The charges were allegations, not findings of guilt."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://jcf.gov.jm/st-catherine-pastor-faces-multiple-rape-and-fraud-charges/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jamaica Constabulary Force, 'St. Catherine pastor faces multiple rape and fraud charges' (June 29, 2020).",
"body": "The official police report records the charges and allegations that Campbell told three church members their ailments came from evil spirits and that sex with him, together with payments for rituals, would cure or free them.",
"tier": "law-enforcement",
"kind": "charging-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents evil-spirit diagnosis, sex presented as deliverance, paid ritual treatment, and pastoral authority, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is pastor and purported deliverance and ritual-treatment provider.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Police charged Campbell with three counts of rape and obtaining money by false pretence. The charges were allegations, not findings of guilt.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://jcf.gov.jm/st-catherine-pastor-faces-multiple-rape-and-fraud-charges/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: law-enforcement; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5ab6f3ceb2fc5a6d9be6539352e2944251c74b2a43bcef39b2daa26298213f7b",
"final_url": "https://jcf.gov.jm/st-catherine-pastor-faces-multiple-rape-and-fraud-charges/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 88,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The court record identifies Fraser as senior pastor and records that the child had been entrusted to him for counselling. The survivor is not identified. This entry concerns Fraser's adjudicated abuse of that counselling relationship, not Christianity, Bahamian churches, pastors, counselling or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-earl-randolph-fraser-bahamas",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Nassau, Bahamas",
"lat": 25.0443,
"lng": -77.3504,
"title": "Earl Randolph Fraser: conviction for abuse of a child entrusted for counselling",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior pastor",
"religious counsellor to a dependent child"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counselling",
"parental entrustment",
"religious authority",
"dependency"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church in the Bahamas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the Bahamas",
"stage": "trial conviction and sentence",
"date": "2011-11-29",
"outcome": "Fraser was convicted of unlawful sexual intercourse with a dependent and sentenced to three years' imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of the Bahamas",
"stage": "post-conviction bail ruling",
"date": "2012-02-21",
"outcome": "The court refused bail pending appeal after reviewing the conviction, custodial sentence and evidence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtofappeal.org.bs/download/049466700.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Appeal of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas, Earl Randolph Fraser, bail-pending-appeal ruling (Feb. 21, 2012).",
"body": "The official appellate ruling records Fraser's conviction and three-year sentence, his senior-pastor role and the evidence that the dependent child had been entrusted to him for counselling.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-ruling"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bahamaslocal.com/newsitem/41211/Judges_explain_why_they_denied_Fraser_bail.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Nassau Guardian / Bahamas Local, 'Judges explain why they denied Fraser bail' (Feb. 2012).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting corroborates the conviction, sentence, refusal of bail and pastoral counselling relationship.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral counselling, parental entrustment, religious authority, and dependency as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is senior pastor and religious counsellor to a dependent child.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtofappeal.org.bs/download/049466700.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-ruling.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5fdd44201a121b8085e50c3f8c48c381acad1442a1651ce17f33d8be14e7130e",
"final_url": "https://www.courtofappeal.org.bs/download/049466700.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bahamaslocal.com/newsitem/41211/Judges_explain_why_they_denied_Fraser_bail.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d046043cf9397288595788eba7dfac0cb55c0cacc182409fe604d8ac2f132ad4",
"final_url": "https://www.bahamaslocal.com/newsitem/41211/Judges_explain_why_they_denied_Fraser_bail.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 89,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The court treated Miller's pastoral office, grooming and the church setting as abuses of trust. The survivors are not identified. This entry concerns Miller's admitted conduct at one church, not Christianity, the Salvation Army, pastors, congregants or Turks and Caicos residents generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-derrick-miller-turks-caicos",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Providenciales, Turks and Caicos Islands",
"lat": 21.7738,
"lng": -72.2659,
"title": "Derrick Miller: eleven-year sentence after abuse of pastoral trust",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Salvation Army pastor",
"religious authority over child congregants"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust",
"grooming",
"church access",
"authority over children"
],
"organizations": [
"Salvation Army Church in Providenciales"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the Turks and Caicos Islands",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentence",
"date": "2022-05-12",
"outcome": "Miller received nine years for two attempted-rape counts and eleven years for six rape counts after pleading guilty. The official sentencing report identifies eleven years as the sentence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tcilii.org/akn/tc/judgment/tcasc/2022/14/eng%402022-05-12/source",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of the Turks and Caicos Islands, R v Derrick Miller, TCASC 2022/14 (May 12, 2022).",
"body": "The official sentencing record sets out Miller's guilty pleas, the eight counts, the sentences and the aggravating abuse of trust arising from his role as pastor to the child victims.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "sentencing-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tcipolice.tc/derrick-miller-sentenced-for-rape-and-attempted-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Turks and Caicos Islands Police Force, 'Derrick Miller sentenced for rape and attempted rape' (May 13, 2022).",
"body": "The official police report confirms the pleas, six rape counts, two attempted-rape counts and eleven-year sentence.",
"tier": "law-enforcement",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies pastoral trust, grooming, church access, and authority over children as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Salvation Army pastor and religious authority over child congregants.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tcilii.org/akn/tc/judgment/tcasc/2022/14/eng%402022-05-12/source",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.tcipolice.tc/derrick-miller-sentenced-for-rape-and-attempted-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: law-enforcement; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6ef7929258648aa2f90fa7da322173b22481cdf70cfa3a51e905f883c1723e63",
"final_url": "https://www.tcipolice.tc/derrick-miller-sentenced-for-rape-and-attempted-rape/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 90,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The prosecution states that Castillo used his religious figure as a facade against children who attended his church. The survivors are not identified, and the initial review did not locate a later appellate disposition through July 16, 2026. The entry concerns Castillo's adjudicated conduct, not Christianity, Dominican churches, religious leaders or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-johan-castillo-los-alcarrizos-dominican-republic",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Los Alcarrizos, Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic",
"lat": 18.5167,
"lng": -70.0167,
"title": "Johan Manuel Castillo Ortega: ten-year sentence for abuse of six child congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious leader",
"church authority over child congregants"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious persona",
"congregational trust",
"church access to children"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church in Los Alcarrizos"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Second Collegiate Court of Santo Domingo Oeste, Dominican Republic",
"stage": "trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2025-08-19",
"outcome": "The court convicted Castillo Ortega of sexual offenses against six girls and adolescents and imposed ten years in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://pgr.gob.do/diez-anos-de-prision-para-religioso-que-agredio-sexualmente-a-seis-ninas-y-adolescentes-en-los-alcarrizos/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Procuraduría General de la República Dominicana, 'Diez años de prisión para religioso que agredió sexualmente a seis niñas y adolescentes en Los Alcarrizos' (Aug. 19, 2025).",
"body": "The official prosecution report identifies the defendant, court, conviction, ten-year sentence, six child victims and use of a religious figure to gain access to church congregants.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious persona, congregational trust, and church access to children as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is religious leader and church authority over child congregants.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://pgr.gob.do/diez-anos-de-prision-para-religioso-que-agredio-sexualmente-a-seis-ninas-y-adolescentes-en-los-alcarrizos/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "20fe21b9979bfa113ecca4051013e2193f9d888e07c28db3a2afe10771533052",
"final_url": "https://pgr.gob.do/diez-anos-de-prision-para-religioso-que-agredio-sexualmente-a-seis-ninas-y-adolescentes-en-los-alcarrizos/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 91,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The role labels are distinct: Quiroz was convicted as the principal offender and Brito as an accomplice who reinforced his claims. Survivors are not identified. The entry concerns their adjudicated deception through a false church and deliverance claims, not Christianity, evangelical churches, demonology, pastors or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-melvin-quiroz-ana-brito-dominican-republic",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic",
"lat": 18.4861,
"lng": -69.9312,
"title": "Melvin David Quiroz and Ana Rosmery Brito: convictions for demon-deliverance abuse scheme",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled pastor and principal offender",
"accomplice who reinforced the purported pastor's claims"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false church",
"demon-deliverance claims",
"semen presented as spiritually curative",
"reinforcement by an accomplice"
],
"organizations": [
"false evangelical church operated by the defendants"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "First Collegiate Court of the National District, Dominican Republic",
"stage": "trial judgments and sentences",
"date": "2018-02-11",
"outcome": "The court sentenced Quiroz to fifteen years for sexual abuse and Brito to five years for complicity."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://pgr.gob.do/ministerio-publico-obtiene-condenas-de-15-y-5-anos-de-prision-contra-falso-pastor-y-una-complice-acusados-de-abuso-sexual/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Procuraduría General de la República Dominicana, 'Ministerio Público obtiene condenas de 15 y 5 años de prisión contra falso pastor y una cómplice acusados de abuso sexual' (Feb. 11, 2018).",
"body": "The official prosecution report records the separate sentences and explains that Quiroz claimed God had placed power in his semen to extract demons or free women from sin while Brito reinforced those claims.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies false church, demon-deliverance claims, semen presented as spiritually curative, and reinforcement by an accomplice as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-styled pastor and principal offender and accomplice who reinforced the purported pastor's claims.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://pgr.gob.do/ministerio-publico-obtiene-condenas-de-15-y-5-anos-de-prision-contra-falso-pastor-y-una-complice-acusados-de-abuso-sexual/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1af6fd6977ea4a80c26fe4f08d1f34127524232613a856f98fca078e3ca8578a",
"final_url": "https://pgr.gob.do/ministerio-publico-obtiene-condenas-de-15-y-5-anos-de-prision-contra-falso-pastor-y-una-complice-acusados-de-abuso-sexual/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 92,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"date": "2025-06-25",
"court": "Dominican appellate court not yet identified",
"outcome": "Peguero's counsel announced an appeal. The initial review did not locate a later appellate decision through July 16, 2026."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The reporting describes Kery's access through paternal trust, church vigils and overnight mortification practices. It does not establish that every charged act involved every mechanism. The child survivors are not identified. The entry concerns the two trial convictions, not Christianity, Dominican churches, vigils, mortification practices, pastors, prophets or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-victor-kery-robinson-peguero-higuey-dominican-republic",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Higüey, La Altagracia, Dominican Republic",
"lat": 18.615,
"lng": -68.707,
"title": "Víctor Manuel Kery and Robinson Peguero: convictions after overnight church vigils",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor known as El Pastor",
"religious figure known as El Profeta"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"church vigils",
"overnight access to children",
"paternal religious trust",
"mortification practice"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church in Higüey"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Collegiate Court of La Altagracia, Dominican Republic",
"stage": "trial judgments and sentences",
"date": "2025-06-24",
"outcome": "The court sentenced Kery to ten years for aggravated sexual assault and Peguero to five years for sexual assault. Peguero's counsel announced an appeal. Court records identify Kery as a recidivist, carrying a prior conviction under sentencia 185-2021-SSEN-00372."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.diariolibre.com/actualidad/justicia/2025/06/25/condenan-a-pastor-y-profeta-en-higuey-por-agresion-a-menores/3162541",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diario Libre, 'Condenan a pastor y profeta en Higüey por agresión a menores' (June 25, 2025).",
"body": "Detailed contemporaneous court reporting identifies both defendants, the trial court, distinct convictions and sentences, child victims, church-vigil access and Peguero's announced appeal.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://listindiario.com/la-republica/justicia/20250625/tribunal-condena-prision-pastor-agresion-sexual-menores-higuey_863403.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Listín Diario, 'Tribunal condena a prisión a pastor y profeta por agresión sexual a menores en Higüey' (June 25, 2025).",
"body": "Independent court reporting corroborates the convictions, sentences, victim ages and religious roles.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.diariolibre.com/actualidad/sucesos/2024/07/08/el-pastor-victor-kery-esta-implicado-en-abuso-sexual/2780364",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diario Libre, 'El pastor Víctor Kery está implicado en abuso sexual' (July 8, 2024).",
"body": "Pretrial reporting documents the alleged church-vigil and overnight cilicio practices and records Kery's separate 2021 conviction with a suspended sentence. That earlier matter is contextual and not combined with the 2025 sentence.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "procedural-context"
},
{
"link": "http://web.archive.org/web/20250626132733/https://elnuevodiario.com.do/diez-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-por-agresion-sexual-agravada-contra-dos-adolescentes-en-higuey/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Nuevo Diario (Dominican Republic), archived 26 Jun. 2025.",
"body": "Archived mirror of the prosecutor's release; the PGR's own page returns an error.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies church vigils, overnight access to children, paternal religious trust, and mortification practice as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor known as El Pastor and religious figure known as El Profeta.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"date": "2025-06-25",
"court": "Dominican appellate court not yet identified",
"outcome": "Peguero's counsel announced an appeal. The initial review did not locate a later appellate decision through July 16, 2026."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.diariolibre.com/actualidad/justicia/2025/06/25/condenan-a-pastor-y-profeta-en-higuey-por-agresion-a-menores/3162541",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8c31ca0849c86d21b0e9acc2818257e17bb3fc6e8469c50a8bcc99abd4c680eb",
"final_url": "https://www.diariolibre.com/actualidad/justicia/2025/06/25/condenan-a-pastor-y-profeta-en-higuey-por-agresion-a-menores/3162541"
},
{
"source": "https://listindiario.com/la-republica/justicia/20250625/tribunal-condena-prision-pastor-agresion-sexual-menores-higuey_863403.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "52874dcf2855f4aba74cc54532c1276c756e365c7a7ecd4a76c52cf4978e70f3",
"final_url": "https://listindiario.com/la-republica/justicia/20250625/tribunal-condena-prision-pastor-agresion-sexual-menores-higuey_863403.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.diariolibre.com/actualidad/sucesos/2024/07/08/el-pastor-victor-kery-esta-implicado-en-abuso-sexual/2780364",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: procedural-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "33b681fef09f1d3be76d2cc4ca6dafce1be1341c06a8e095689669ce91f6f4b7",
"final_url": "https://www.diariolibre.com/actualidad/sucesos/2024/07/08/el-pastor-victor-kery-esta-implicado-en-abuso-sexual/2780364"
},
{
"source": "http://web.archive.org/web/20250626132733/https://elnuevodiario.com.do/diez-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-por-agresion-sexual-agravada-contra-dos-adolescentes-en-higuey/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "48ffc358362a5f642e57e6fe5cc7b1d64be46184f74ee765b54ed318bfceae22",
"final_url": "http://web.archive.org/web/20250626132733/https://elnuevodiario.com.do/diez-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-por-agresion-sexual-agravada-contra-dos-adolescentes-en-higuey/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 93,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The federal disposition establishes the transport offense; contemporaneous reporting documents the priest's access to the child through altar-server and sacristan duties. The survivor is not identified. This entry concerns Berríos-Berríos's admitted conduct, not Catholicism, Puerto Rican Catholics, priests, altar service, travel or parishes generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-israel-berrios-berrios-puerto-rico",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Caguas, Puerto Rico",
"lat": 18.2341,
"lng": -66.0485,
"title": "Israel Berríos-Berríos: eleven-year federal sentence after altar-service access",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest",
"supervisor of a child altar server and sacristan"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly authority",
"altar-service access",
"international travel with a child",
"institutional trust"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Church in Puerto Rico"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the District of Puerto Rico",
"stage": "guilty plea and federal sentence",
"date": "2015-06-18",
"outcome": "Berríos-Berríos received eleven years in federal prison after pleading guilty to transporting a fifteen-year-old from Puerto Rico to Miami for a cruise to the Bahamas with intent to engage in criminal sexual conduct."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-pr/pr/former-catholic-priest-sentenced",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, District of Puerto Rico, 'Former Catholic priest sentenced' (June 18, 2015).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records Berríos-Berríos's guilty plea, eleven-year sentence, the victim's age and the transport from Puerto Rico to Miami and the Bahamas for criminal sexual conduct.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/policia-tribunales/notas/sentencia-federal-de-11-anos-de-carcel-a-cura-en-caso-de-abuso-sexual/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Primera Hora, 'Sentencia federal de 11 años de cárcel a cura en caso de abuso sexual' (June 18, 2015).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting corroborates the sentence and documents the priest's relationship with the child through training and service as an altar server and sacristan.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-context"
}
],
"route": {
"from": [
-66.0485,
18.2341
],
"to": [
-80.1918,
25.7617
],
"fromLabel": "Caguas, Puerto Rico",
"toLabel": "Miami, Florida, USA",
"label": "Berríos-Berríos: Puerto Rico -> Miami",
"provenance": "Endpoints are the charged transport in the federal disposition, not an inferred journey. The US Attorney's version of facts states the defendant \"did transport a then 15 year-old male minor identified as 'John Doe' to the City of Miami, Florida\", on or about 21-25 July 2008, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a). Origin is the corpus record's own gazetteer point for Caguas, Puerto Rico; destination is Miami, Florida. The four-day cruise to the Bahamas that followed, during which the abuse occurred, is deliberately NOT drawn: Miami is the terminus of the charged transport, and extending the arc to the Bahamas would assert more than the conviction establishes."
},
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies priestly authority, altar-service access, international travel with a child, and institutional trust as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Catholic priest and supervisor of a child altar server and sacristan.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-pr/pr/former-catholic-priest-sentenced",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "78b52354f898b81ddade702b56c7eea5a818c0cc64a47084e7a0f0ddda5578ef",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-pr/pr/former-catholic-priest-sentenced"
},
{
"source": "https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/policia-tribunales/notas/sentencia-federal-de-11-anos-de-carcel-a-cura-en-caso-de-abuso-sexual/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "34d9919b29571b46e0a90d73f16a8ef7848e129c1368e406fd5045a3e7b6634d",
"final_url": "https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/policia-tribunales/notas/sentencia-federal-de-11-anos-de-carcel-a-cura-en-caso-de-abuso-sexual/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 94,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The verdict reporting describes Promeneur's claimed supernatural identity, purification demands and domination over psychologically vulnerable women. Survivors are not identified. The entry concerns his adjudicated conduct, not spiritual healing, Guadeloupean religious practice, mythology, healers or clients generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jean-luc-promeneur-guadeloupe",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Guadeloupe",
"lat": 16.265,
"lng": -61.551,
"title": "Jean-Luc Promeneur: seventeen-year sentence for abuse under mystical domination",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described healer",
"purported miraculous son of Venus"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"mystical domination",
"purification claims",
"claimed healing powers",
"targeting of psychologically vulnerable women",
"isolation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Guadeloupe Assize Court, France",
"stage": "criminal verdict and sentence",
"date": "2026-07-01",
"outcome": "The court convicted Promeneur of rapes and sexual assaults against five women and imposed seventeen years' imprisonment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rci.fm/guadeloupe/infos/Justice/Viols-en-serie-Jean-Luc-Promeneur-condamne-17-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RCI Guadeloupe, 'Viols en série: Jean-Luc Promeneur condamné à 17 ans de réclusion criminelle' (July 1, 2026).",
"body": "Detailed contemporaneous court reporting records the conviction, seventeen-year sentence, five victims and evidence that Promeneur presented himself as a healer and miraculous son of Venus and used mystical and purification claims to dominate vulnerable women.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies mystical domination, purification claims, claimed healing powers, targeting of psychologically vulnerable women, and isolation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-described healer and purported miraculous son of Venus.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rci.fm/guadeloupe/infos/Justice/Viols-en-serie-Jean-Luc-Promeneur-condamne-17-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "911108de7121c7b2c007ad2ebf09d89966e3fa791b51fc7f039f7af382993978",
"final_url": "https://rci.fm/guadeloupe/infos/Justice/Viols-en-serie-Jean-Luc-Promeneur-condamne-17-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 95,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The conviction was aggravated by the authority attached to Phanor-Lange's functions over a sixteen-year-old he supervised and spiritually accompanied. The survivor is not identified. The entry concerns his adjudicated conduct, not Catholicism, Martinique, priests, spiritual accompaniment or church members generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-patrick-phanor-lange-martinique",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Fort-de-France, Martinique",
"lat": 14.6161,
"lng": -61.0588,
"title": "Patrick Phanor-Lange: twelve-year sentence for aggravated rape by spiritual authority",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest",
"spiritual supervisor of a child"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly authority",
"spiritual accompaniment",
"supervision of a child",
"institutional trust"
],
"organizations": [
"Catholic Church in Martinique"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Martinique Assize Court, France",
"stage": "criminal verdict and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-27",
"outcome": "The court convicted Phanor-Lange of aggravated rape by a person abusing the authority conferred by his functions and imposed twelve years' imprisonment, five years of socio-judicial supervision and a ban on work involving minors."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.martinique.franceantilles.fr/actualite/justice/le-pretre-accuse-de-viol-aggrave-sur-un-jeune-condamne-a-12-ans-de-prison-1070214.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "France-Antilles Martinique, 'Le prêtre accusé de viol aggravé sur un jeune condamné à 12 ans de prison' (Feb. 27, 2026).",
"body": "Detailed contemporaneous court reporting records the conviction, aggravating authority element, sentence, supervision order and work ban and describes the priest's spiritual-supervision relationship with the child.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://rci.fm/martinique/infos/Justice/Lancien-pretre-Patrick-Phanor-Lange-reconnu-coupable-de-viol-aggrave-et-condamne-12",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RCI Martinique, 'L'ancien prêtre Patrick Phanor-Lange reconnu coupable de viol aggravé et condamné à 12 ans' (Feb. 27, 2026).",
"body": "Independent court reporting corroborates the verdict and twelve-year sentence.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies priestly authority, spiritual accompaniment, supervision of a child, and institutional trust as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Catholic priest and spiritual supervisor of a child.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.martinique.franceantilles.fr/actualite/justice/le-pretre-accuse-de-viol-aggrave-sur-un-jeune-condamne-a-12-ans-de-prison-1070214.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "91dac0b3c700916fadfa537324c8a0f186bf5aef32b478c325f10bd0c0c4eae3",
"final_url": "https://www.martinique.franceantilles.fr/actualite/justice/le-pretre-accuse-de-viol-aggrave-sur-un-jeune-condamne-a-12-ans-de-prison-1070214.php"
},
{
"source": "https://rci.fm/martinique/infos/Justice/Lancien-pretre-Patrick-Phanor-Lange-reconnu-coupable-de-viol-aggrave-et-condamne-12",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c9104dde16a31e408518a86abb1324bb04cbbca547e23eeabb8b57f2a21b642a",
"final_url": "https://rci.fm/martinique/infos/Justice/Lancien-pretre-Patrick-Phanor-Lange-reconnu-coupable-de-viol-aggrave-et-condamne-12"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 96,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The available 2014 report establishes the conviction, sentence and spiritual-education relationship but does not establish Gordon's current location or whether the warrant was later executed. The survivor is not identified. The entry concerns Gordon's adjudicated conduct, not Christianity, Martinique, religious education or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-emmanuel-gordon-martinique",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Martinique",
"lat": 14.6415,
"lng": -61.0242,
"title": "Emmanuel Gordon: eight-year sentence in absentia for abuse during spiritual education",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious educator",
"spiritual authority over a child congregant"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual education",
"religious trust",
"access to a child congregant"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed religious congregation in Martinique"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal court in Martinique, France",
"stage": "conviction and sentence in absentia",
"date": "2014-02-01",
"outcome": "Gordon was convicted in absentia of sexual offenses against a female congregant and sentenced to eight years' imprisonment. The contemporaneous report records an international arrest warrant issued on April 25, 2013."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.martinique.franceantilles.fr/actualite/faitsdivers/jai-ete-la-victime-dun-predateur-595810.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "France-Antilles Martinique, 'J'ai été la victime d'un prédateur' (2014).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting records Gordon's in-absentia conviction, eight-year sentence and international arrest warrant and states that the abuse began when he was responsible for the child's spiritual education.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual education, religious trust, and access to a child congregant as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is religious educator and spiritual authority over a child congregant.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.martinique.franceantilles.fr/actualite/faitsdivers/jai-ete-la-victime-dun-predateur-595810.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "47acfdcb015404a56bc80912814d07268a39e7d31deaa81d3a827bf043ca29bf",
"final_url": "https://www.martinique.franceantilles.fr/actualite/faitsdivers/jai-ete-la-victime-dun-predateur-595810.php"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 97,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The title follows the court's anonymization and does not speculate about the defendant's full surname. The Supreme Court records seven victims, including minors and young adults, under the authority of the community's founder and spiritual leader. Survivors are not identified. The entry concerns Orlando B.'s adjudicated conduct, not Christianity, messianic communities, Curaçao or their members generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-orlando-b-curacao",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Willemstad, Curaçao",
"lat": 12.1224,
"lng": -68.8824,
"title": "Orlando B. (O.I.B.): fourteen-year sentence upheld for abuse of seven community members",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and spiritual leader of a messianic religious community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-leader authority",
"demon-possession threats",
"religious-community control",
"grooming of children and young adults"
],
"organizations": [
"Rains of the Blessings for All Nations Messianic Community Curaçao"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Joint Court of Justice of Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten and Bonaire, Sint Eustatius and Saba",
"stage": "appeal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2018-10-04",
"outcome": "The appellate court imposed fourteen years in prison and a nineteen-year professional ban for sexual abuse of seven young female community members."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the Netherlands",
"stage": "cassation judgment",
"date": "2020-02-11",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court rejected the cassation appeal, leaving the conviction and sentence final."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.hogeraad.nl/actueel/nieuwsoverzicht/2020/februari/veroordeling-leidsman-geloofsgemeenschap-curacao/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of the Netherlands, 'Veroordeling leidsman geloofsgemeenschap Curaçao blijft in stand' (Feb. 11, 2020), ECLI:NL:HR:2020:239.",
"body": "The official court summary records the final rejection of cassation, fourteen-year sentence, nineteen-year professional ban, seven victims and the defendant's role as founder and spiritual leader of the religious community.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://nos.nl/artikel/2255397-pastor-curacao-krijgt-hogere-straf-voor-ontucht-en-verkrachting",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NOS, 'Pastor Curaçao krijgt hogere straf voor ontucht en verkrachting' (Oct. 4, 2018).",
"body": "Contemporaneous appellate reporting records the sentence increase and evidence that the leader invoked demon possession to keep victims silent.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual-leader authority, demon-possession threats, religious-community control, and grooming of children and young adults as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and spiritual leader of a messianic religious community.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.hogeraad.nl/actueel/nieuwsoverzicht/2020/februari/veroordeling-leidsman-geloofsgemeenschap-curacao/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0566ecbad019aa4483386464cb984059d06aa1ee8540d3906f13fbcaba4fbe03",
"final_url": "https://www.hogeraad.nl/actueel/nieuwsoverzicht/2020/februari/veroordeling-leidsman-geloofsgemeenschap-curacao/"
},
{
"source": "https://nos.nl/artikel/2255397-pastor-curacao-krijgt-hogere-straf-voor-ontucht-en-verkrachting",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f6d070a5b1ee8e1a9f7ecbed515d74393a0dcd03bd4615e6849bbff451c567a7",
"final_url": "https://nos.nl/artikel/2255397-pastor-curacao-krijgt-hogere-straf-voor-ontucht-en-verkrachting"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 98,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an allegation record. Turnbull remains presumed innocent unless convicted. No later public disposition was located through July 16, 2026. The entry concerns allegations that he repeatedly transported a child over whom he exercised pastoral and youth-leader authority, not Christianity, Virgin Islands churches, pastors, youth leaders or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-lawrence-turnbull-us-virgin-islands",
"year": 2026,
"place": "St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands",
"lat": 18.3419,
"lng": -64.9307,
"title": "Lawrence Turnbull: federal and territorial charges involving a child congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"church youth leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"youth-leader access",
"transportation of a child",
"congregational trust"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church on St. Thomas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the District of the Virgin Islands and Virgin Islands territorial court",
"stage": "arrest and charges",
"date": "2026-04-01",
"outcome": "Turnbull was arrested on federal transportation and coercion or enticement charges and territorial unlawful-sexual-contact and child-abuse charges. These were allegations, not findings of guilt."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-vi/pr/st-thomas-pastor-arrested-federal-and-local-sex-offenses-involving-minor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, District of the Virgin Islands, 'St. Thomas pastor arrested for federal and local sex offenses involving minor' (Apr. 3, 2026).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records the federal and territorial charges, states that Turnbull was the child's pastor and youth leader and describes alleged repeated transportation. The release expressly states that the charges are allegations and that the defendant is presumed innocent.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "charging-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents pastoral authority, youth-leader access, transportation of a child, and congregational trust, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is pastor and church youth leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Turnbull was arrested on federal transportation and coercion or enticement charges and territorial unlawful-sexual-contact and child-abuse charges. These were allegations, not findings of guilt.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-vi/pr/st-thomas-pastor-arrested-federal-and-local-sex-offenses-involving-minor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "291f8a27337704461e19005e71b975864f46f442247fe07e432c54eb9faddc55",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-vi/pr/st-thomas-pastor-arrested-federal-and-local-sex-offenses-involving-minor"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 99,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"church-last-testament"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025-12-01",
"note": "Novosibirsk Regional Court upheld the verdict."
},
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2026-05-18",
"note": "Cassation filed; pending — conviction not yet final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The record concerns the adjudicated conduct of Torop, Vedernikov and Redkin within the Church of the Last Testament. It does not assign responsibility to every member, to new religious movements generally, or to beliefs not addressed by the judgment. The source record reports sixteen victims and serious or moderate health harm without identifying them here. APPEAL PENDING: the defence filed a cassation appeal reported in May 2026; the conviction stands but is not yet final and this record must be revisited when the cassation resolves.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-vissarion-church-last-testament-russia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Novosibirsk, Russia",
"lat": 55.0302,
"lng": 82.9204,
"title": "Vissarion community leaders: convictions for psychological violence and serious harm",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and self-proclaimed spiritual teacher",
"religious-community leaders"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"psychological violence",
"hierarchical religious authority",
"economic dependency",
"isolation and deprivation"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of the Last Testament",
"Vissarion Community"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Railway District Court of Novosibirsk, Russia",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2025-06-30",
"outcome": "Sergei Torop and Vladimir Vedernikov received twelve years in a strict-regime colony; Vadim Redkin received eleven years. The court also granted civil claims."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Novosibirsk Regional Court, Russia",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2025-12-23",
"outcome": "The appellate court left the factual findings and prison terms unchanged while modifying the structure of compensation for moral harm; the judgment entered legal force."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rg.ru/2025/06/30/reg-sibfo/sud-v-novosibirske-vynes-prigovor-osnovateliam-obshchiny-vissariona.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 'Sud v Novosibirske vynes prigovor osnovateliam Obshchiny Vissariona' (June 30, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous judgment reporting based on the regional prosecutor's account records the three sentences, sixteen victims, serious and moderate health harm, psychological violence and civil awards.",
"tier": "official-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://epp.genproc.gov.ru/ru/proc_54/mass-media/news/regional/e8330499/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Prosecutor's Office of Novosibirsk Region, appellate disposition in the Vissarion community case (Dec. 23, 2025).",
"body": "The official prosecutor release records that the regional court left the factual findings and sentences unchanged, modified only the compensation arrangement and made the judgment final.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies psychological violence, hierarchical religious authority, economic dependency, and isolation and deprivation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and self-proclaimed spiritual teacher and religious-community leaders.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025-12-01",
"note": "Novosibirsk Regional Court upheld the verdict."
},
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2026-05-18",
"note": "Cassation filed; pending — conviction not yet final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rg.ru/2025/06/30/reg-sibfo/sud-v-novosibirske-vynes-prigovor-osnovateliam-obshchiny-vissariona.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "23780031e9d18d6345aa77452db471412ae2149dea1b22c2cb365bdcd439f0f4",
"final_url": "https://rg.ru/2025/06/30/reg-sibfo/sud-v-novosibirske-vynes-prigovor-osnovateliam-obshchiny-vissariona.html"
},
{
"source": "https://epp.genproc.gov.ru/ru/proc_54/mass-media/news/regional/e8330499/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fb095badc9739091c996948cf6b84212e59f998bbd8d6ab2093152246e1fbdc3",
"final_url": "https://epp.genproc.gov.ru/ru/proc_54/mass-media/news/regional/e8330499/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 100,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"god-kuzya-group"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Moscow City Court, Russia",
"date": "2018-11-26",
"outcome": "The court left the conviction in place and recalculated time served."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The entry concerns Popov's convictions and the separately reported fraud convictions of named co-defendants. It does not attribute Popov's conduct to the Russian Orthodox Church, which did not recognize his claimed ordination, or to Orthodox Christianity generally. Survivor identities are omitted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-andrei-popov-god-kuzya-moscow-russia",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Moscow, Russia",
"lat": 55.7558,
"lng": 37.6173,
"title": "Andrei Popov ('God Kuzya'): convictions for religious-group abuse and fraud",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed divine leader",
"founder of a pseudo-Orthodox religious group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine knowledge and power",
"strict hierarchy",
"punishment for disobedience and sin",
"religious-rite and temple-fundraising pretexts"
],
"organizations": [
"God Kuzya religious group"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Presnensky District Court of Moscow, Russia",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2018-07-16",
"outcome": "Popov was convicted of creating a religious association whose activity involved violence or other harm to health and of two fraud counts. He received five years in a general-regime colony. Three co-defendants received separate fraud sentences."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Moscow City Court, Russia",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2018-11-26",
"outcome": "The court rejected the defense appeals and recalculated custody credit under amended rules, leading to Popov's release in February 2019."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20180716/284913966.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Russian Legal Information Agency, 'Court sentences God Kuzya to five years for creating a sect and fraud' (July 16, 2018).",
"body": "Courtroom reporting records Popov's convictions, sentence, civil awards, the co-defendants' distinct fraud liability, the hierarchical religious structure, beatings and fundraising through purported rites and a promised temple.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20181126/291693437.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Russian Legal Information Agency, 'God Kuzya will be released within three months' (Nov. 26, 2018).",
"body": "The appellate report records rejection of the defense appeals and recalculation of custody credit under the new rules.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed divine knowledge and power, strict hierarchy, punishment for disobedience and sin, and religious-rite and temple-fundraising pretexts as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-proclaimed divine leader and founder of a pseudo-Orthodox religious group.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Moscow City Court, Russia",
"date": "2018-11-26",
"outcome": "The court left the conviction in place and recalculated time served."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20180716/284913966.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1f400df992ddfb365a2040d7061c29e847f277a2887ae0badb3fb1a9bef6e831",
"final_url": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20180716/284913966.html"
},
{
"source": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20181126/291693437.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "31985d075c2e7eb6d500365b22c7e500936d9883d879d37a85f202f3608ee511",
"final_url": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20181126/291693437.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 101,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"grigory-grabovoi-foundation"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Moscow City Court, Russia",
"date": "2008-10-20",
"outcome": "The sentence was reduced from eleven to eight years and the fine from one million to 750,000 rubles."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Perm Regional Court, Russia",
"date": "2010-05-20",
"outcome": "A prosecution challenge to conditional early release was rejected."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The entry is limited to the eleven adjudicated fraud counts and the court-reported use of claimed supernatural services, including taking money for purported resurrection. It does not repeat disputed claims about particular bereaved families unless tied to the judgment record, and it does not treat spiritual healing or bereavement support generally as fraudulent.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-grigory-grabovoi-moscow-russia",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Moscow, Russia",
"lat": 55.7558,
"lng": 37.6173,
"title": "Grigory Grabovoi: eleven fraud convictions for paid supernatural claims",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed healer and messianic teacher",
"founder of the Grigory Grabovoi Foundation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed resurrection and healing powers",
"paid seminars and individual sessions",
"psychological influence on bereaved clients"
],
"organizations": [
"Grigory Grabovoi Foundation",
"Teaching of Grigory Grabovoi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tagansky District Court of Moscow, Russia",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2008-07-07",
"outcome": "The court convicted Grabovoi on eleven fraud counts and imposed eleven years in prison and a one-million-ruble fine."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Moscow City Court, Russia",
"stage": "cassation appeal",
"date": "2008-10-20",
"outcome": "The court reduced the prison term to eight years and the fine to 750,000 rubles while leaving the fraud convictions in place."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Perm Regional Court, Russia",
"stage": "early-release review",
"date": "2010-05-20",
"outcome": "The court upheld conditional early release after Grabovoi had served half the term; he was released on May 21, 2010."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rg.ru/2008/07/07/grabovoy-anons.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 'Healer Grigory Grabovoi found guilty of fraud' (July 7, 2008).",
"body": "Contemporaneous judgment reporting records eleven fraud counts and the court's finding that Grabovoi used psychological influence, indirect suggestion and distortion of thought processes against victims.",
"tier": "official-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://rg.ru/2008/10/20/grabovoj.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 'Moscow City Court reduced the sentence of psychic Grigory Grabovoi' (Oct. 20, 2008).",
"body": "Contemporaneous appellate reporting records the reduction from eleven to eight years and the continued eleven-count fraud judgment.",
"tier": "official-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20100521/250138929.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Russian Legal Information Agency, 'Grigory Grabovoi released' (May 21, 2010).",
"body": "The disposition report records the final eight-year term, 750,000-ruble fine, conditional early release and the inclusion of paid purported resurrection among the charged fraudulent services.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "sentence-execution"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed resurrection and healing powers, paid seminars and individual sessions, and psychological influence on bereaved clients as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-proclaimed healer and messianic teacher and founder of the Grigory Grabovoi Foundation.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Moscow City Court, Russia",
"date": "2008-10-20",
"outcome": "The sentence was reduced from eleven to eight years and the fine from one million to 750,000 rubles."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Perm Regional Court, Russia",
"date": "2010-05-20",
"outcome": "A prosecution challenge to conditional early release was rejected."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rg.ru/2008/07/07/grabovoy-anons.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://rg.ru/2008/10/20/grabovoj.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20100521/250138929.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentence-execution.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cd1fcf63595e759e520ac0c74c5c3770d8903bca48e67dbb42d64d113be9a9d0",
"final_url": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20100521/250138929.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 102,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"great-white-brotherhood"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This historical record distinguishes the three leaders' individual sentences and does not repeat unproven claims of a planned mass suicide. It documents the court-reported offenses and independently reported coercive instructions. It does not assign culpability to former followers or to later religious movements.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1996-great-white-brotherhood-kyiv-ukraine",
"year": 1996,
"place": "Kyiv, Ukraine",
"lat": 50.4501,
"lng": 30.5234,
"title": "Great White Brotherhood leaders: convictions after apocalyptic control and the St. Sophia seizure",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed living god and prophet",
"founder and church hierarchy"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"apocalyptic prophecy",
"absolute obedience",
"sleep and food deprivation",
"family separation and surrender of property",
"instructions to refuse food and medical aid"
],
"organizations": [
"Great White Brotherhood",
"USMALOS"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Starokyivskyi District Court of Kyiv, Ukraine",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "1996-02-09",
"outcome": "Yuri Krivonogov received seven years, Marina Krivonogova four years and Vitaliy Kovalchuk six years. The convictions included mass disorder, seizure of St. Sophia Cathedral, resistance to authorities and organized group disobedience; later historical reporting also identifies harm to health under the guise of religious rites among the charges tried."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://zn.ua/LAW/v_kieve_osuzhdeny_lidery__belogo_bratstva.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dzerkalo Tyzhnia, 'Leaders of the White Brotherhood convicted in Kyiv' (Feb. 9, 1996).",
"body": "Contemporaneous judgment reporting records the three sentences, the offenses supporting the judgment and the leaders' claimed divine and ecclesiastical roles.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://localhistory.org.ua/texts/statti/do-kintsia-svitu-z-zhivim-bogom/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Local History, 'To the end of the world with a living god' (historical review).",
"body": "The Ukrainian historical review documents the movement's hierarchy, required obedience, prayer instead of sleep, strict fasting, family separation, property surrender, apocalyptic instructions to refuse food and medical aid, the charges tried and the sentences.",
"tier": "historical-reporting",
"kind": "historical-case-review"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-doomsday-apocalyptic",
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies apocalyptic prophecy, absolute obedience, sleep and food deprivation, family separation and surrender of property, and instructions to refuse food and medical aid as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-proclaimed living god and prophet and founder and church hierarchy.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://zn.ua/LAW/v_kieve_osuzhdeny_lidery__belogo_bratstva.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "397c8bc9d4d8cd71666080d95ac7ca0bc6523dcc50958624ccb137ad68230927",
"final_url": "https://zn.ua/LAW/v_kieve_osuzhdeny_lidery__belogo_bratstva.html"
},
{
"source": "https://localhistory.org.ua/texts/statti/do-kintsia-svitu-z-zhivim-bogom/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: historical-reporting; evidentiary role: historical-case-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "883d16bebdc59aff5aa8f56c7cca7d543217b65100984770c072bb26da559ac5",
"final_url": "https://localhistory.org.ua/texts/statti/do-kintsia-svitu-z-zhivim-bogom/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 103,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The survivor is not identified. The entry concerns Ibrohimov's adjudicated use of purported infertility treatment and Quran recitation, not Islam, the Quran, mullahs, infertility care or Tajik religious families generally. No later appellate disposition was located in the initial multilingual review.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-asadullo-ibrohimov-dushanbe-tajikistan",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Dushanbe, Tajikistan",
"lat": 38.5598,
"lng": 68.787,
"title": "Asadullo Ibrohimov: seven-year sentence for sexual misconduct during purported infertility treatment",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"mullah",
"purported religious healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"infertility-treatment pretext",
"Quran recitation",
"exploitation of a vulnerable state",
"religious-family authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sino District Court of Dushanbe, Tajikistan",
"stage": "closed criminal trial and sentence",
"date": "2013-10-24",
"outcome": "The court convicted Ibrohimov of sexual misconduct and fraud and imposed seven years in prison and a fine."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rferl.org/a/tajikistan-magic-mullah/25144874.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 'Infertility Treatment Lands Tajik Mullah in Court' (Oct. 22, 2013).",
"body": "Detailed trial reporting records the guilty verdict, seven-year sentence, Quran-recitation treatment pretext and Interior Ministry finding that Ibrohimov exploited the woman's vulnerable state.",
"tier": "high-quality-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://avesta.tj/2013/10/24/dushanbinskij-mullo-tselitel-poluchil-7-let/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Avesta, 'Dushanbe mullah-healer received seven years' (Oct. 24, 2013).",
"body": "Local contemporaneous reporting corroborates the court, offenses, sentence and fine.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies infertility-treatment pretext, Quran recitation, exploitation of a vulnerable state, and religious-family authority as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is mullah and purported religious healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rferl.org/a/tajikistan-magic-mullah/25144874.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "69df94ffbd81f2d108287b5911db9c79e269b008043572b19785fe9f3df2eb48",
"final_url": "https://www.rferl.org/a/tajikistan-magic-mullah/25144874.html"
},
{
"source": "https://avesta.tj/2013/10/24/dushanbinskij-mullo-tselitel-poluchil-7-let/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cd2e9ecd72c45628e863d1a66903e53ea0cbc6e3b6dc1c0cece59c05dbd3e69b",
"final_url": "https://avesta.tj/2013/10/24/dushanbinskij-mullo-tselitel-poluchil-7-let/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 104,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "appellate court in Kazakhstan",
"outcome": "The rape conviction and sentence were affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The child and family members are not identified. The detailed court report says the family first invited Bukhbanbayev to remove an evil eye or curse and later asked him to treat the child's back and predict her future. The entry concerns his adjudicated conduct, not Islam, Kazakh tradition, spiritual healing, clairvoyance or families seeking care generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-nurgazy-bukhbanbayev-turkistan-kazakhstan",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Turkistan Region, Kazakhstan",
"lat": 43.3051,
"lng": 68.2347,
"title": "Nurgazy Bukhbanbayev: eleven-year rape sentence after claimed healing and clairvoyance",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"purported healer and clairvoyant",
"ritual practitioner invited into a family home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"evil-eye and curse-removal ritual",
"claimed clairvoyance",
"medical-treatment pretext",
"psychological manipulation",
"threats and isolation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Specialized Interdistrict Criminal Court, Turkistan Region, Kazakhstan",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"outcome": "The court convicted Bukhbanbayev of raping a minor and imposed eleven years in prison and a ten-year ban on work involving minors."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "appellate court in Kazakhstan",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"outcome": "The appellate court left the judgment unchanged."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.caravan.kz/gazeta/celitel-vmesto-lecheniya-devushki-pokhitil-i-iznasiloval-ee-699519/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Karavan, 'Healer kidnapped and raped a girl instead of treating her' (Dec. 21, 2020).",
"body": "Detailed court reporting identifies the defendant, trial judge, investigator, conviction, eleven-year sentence, professional ban and appellate affirmance and documents the curse-removal, healing and clairvoyance claims through which he obtained access and influence.",
"tier": "detailed-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-and-appeal-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies evil-eye and curse-removal ritual, claimed clairvoyance, medical-treatment pretext, psychological manipulation, and threats and isolation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is purported healer and clairvoyant and ritual practitioner invited into a family home.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "appellate court in Kazakhstan",
"outcome": "The rape conviction and sentence were affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.caravan.kz/gazeta/celitel-vmesto-lecheniya-devushki-pokhitil-i-iznasiloval-ee-699519/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: detailed-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-and-appeal-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "34d96372d6b53f2f7c4472599bf465877bd6a7df9d1cb76e172a119386d4d392",
"final_url": "https://www.caravan.kz/gazeta/celitel-vmesto-lecheniya-devushki-pokhitil-i-iznasiloval-ee-699519/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 105,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The official prosecutor release does not name the defendant, so this entry preserves that anonymization. It concerns a final fraud judgment based on paid magical-healing claims, not TikTok, psychic practice, spiritual healing or people seeking health care generally. Victims are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-tiktok-healer-astana-kazakhstan",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Astana, Kazakhstan",
"lat": 51.1694,
"lng": 71.4491,
"title": "Unnamed TikTok healer: final fraud conviction for paid magical-healing claims",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented healer and psychic"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed magical and extrasensory abilities",
"health-crisis targeting",
"paid healing promises",
"social-media solicitation"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed TikTok healing account"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal court in Astana, Kazakhstan",
"stage": "criminal judgment and final disposition",
"date": "2026-02-02",
"outcome": "The defendant admitted guilt and received two years and four months in prison for defrauding three victims of more than 5.5 million tenge. The judgment entered legal force."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/prokuratura-astana/press/news/details/1152365?lang=ru",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Astana City Prosecutor's Office, 'False healer from TikTok convicted in the capital' (Feb. 2, 2026).",
"body": "The official prosecutor release records the claimed magical and extrasensory healing abilities, three victims, loss exceeding 5.5 million tenge, full admission, sentence and finality of the judgment.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "final-disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed magical and extrasensory abilities, health-crisis targeting, paid healing promises, and social-media solicitation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-presented healer and psychic.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/prokuratura-astana/press/news/details/1152365?lang=ru",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: final-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c7263337a34052d66278e642a5749268e4bfb2a868ff86c0c66ab6dd2cfb834f",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/prokuratura-astana/press/news/details/1152365?lang=ru"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 106,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"crna-reka-center"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This institutional record concerns two employees' convictions and the documented coercive setting at a center that presented itself as spiritual rehabilitation. It does not attribute their crimes to every employee, patient, Serbian Orthodox Christian or addiction-treatment program. The former resident is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-crna-reka-spiritual-rehabilitation-serbia",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Crna Reka, Serbia",
"lat": 43.071,
"lng": 20.354,
"title": "Crna Reka spiritual-rehabilitation center: employee rape and violence convictions",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"staff of a spiritual-rehabilitation center",
"institutional custodians of people seeking addiction treatment"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial treatment authority",
"spiritual-rehabilitation framing",
"physical punishment",
"institutional isolation"
],
"organizations": [
"Crna Reka Spiritual Rehabilitation Center"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court in Novi Pazar, Serbia",
"stage": "criminal judgments and sentences",
"date": "2009-10-14",
"outcome": "Nemanja Radosavljevic was convicted of rape and violent behavior and received two years and five months; Marijan Pavicevic was convicted of rape and received one year."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/crna_reka/1851185.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 'Crna Reka rehabilitation center associates convicted' (Oct. 14, 2009).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting based on the Novi Pazar District Court records both convictions and sentences and identifies the institution as a spiritual-rehabilitation center exposed after video of staff beating residents became public.",
"tier": "high-quality-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rts.rs/lat/vesti/drustvo/64455/.html?print=true",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Television of Serbia, 'Rapid investigation into the Crna Reka case' (May 28, 2009).",
"body": "Serbia's public broadcaster documents the police investigation, testimony about beatings, the priest-director's questioning and the center's nonmedical rehabilitation setting.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-investigation-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies custodial treatment authority, spiritual-rehabilitation framing, physical punishment, and institutional isolation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is staff of a spiritual-rehabilitation center and institutional custodians of people seeking addiction treatment.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/crna_reka/1851185.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6e3b7580a5c036a6ce91e573f9ef1a28a664f6a5143ab0b0bbc6113531559b1b",
"final_url": "https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/crna_reka/1851185.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rts.rs/lat/vesti/drustvo/64455/.html?print=true",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-investigation-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e14fc6cb6676878a7b2b13404cd853a145fc19001c8cd03e98474d77f9f5307a",
"final_url": "https://www.rts.rs/lat/vesti/drustvo/64455/.html?print=true"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 107,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"sretenje-center"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal in Belgrade, Serbia",
"date": "2014-01-24",
"outcome": "The conviction and twenty-year sentence were affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The record concerns Peranovic's final murder conviction at the Sretenje center. It does not merge the victim with people harmed at Crna Reka or assign liability to every Serbian Orthodox priest, addiction-treatment provider or center employee. The victim is named in the public judgment reporting because the homicide and appeal were publicly adjudicated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-branislav-peranovic-sretenje-serbia",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Jadranska Lesnica, Serbia",
"lat": 44.5859,
"lng": 19.3717,
"title": "Branislav Peranovic: twenty-year murder sentence at an Orthodox addiction center",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Orthodox priest",
"director of the Sretenje addiction-treatment center"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial religious-treatment authority",
"punishment for attempting to leave",
"physical violence",
"institutional isolation"
],
"organizations": [
"Sretenje Orthodox addiction-treatment center"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Higher Court in Sabac, Serbia",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2013-06-21",
"outcome": "Peranovic was convicted of aggravated murder and sentenced to twenty years in prison for the fatal beating of a resident."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal in Belgrade, Serbia",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2014-01-24",
"outcome": "The appellate court affirmed the murder conviction and twenty-year sentence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rts.rs/vesti/hronika/1346928/peranovicu-20-godina-zatvora.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Television of Serbia, 'Peranovic sentenced to twenty years in prison' (June 21, 2013).",
"body": "Serbia's public broadcaster records the Higher Court's aggravated-murder conviction, twenty-year sentence and finding that the resident died from serious injuries inflicted at the treatment center.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rts.rs/lat/vesti/hronika/1503443/.html?print=true",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Television of Serbia, 'Peranovic's twenty-year sentence confirmed' (Jan. 24, 2014).",
"body": "The appellate report records affirmance and the finding that Peranovic and associates took the resident to an outbuilding and beat him after he wanted to leave the Orthodox Sretenje center.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies custodial religious-treatment authority, punishment for attempting to leave, physical violence, and institutional isolation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Orthodox priest and director of the Sretenje addiction-treatment center.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal in Belgrade, Serbia",
"date": "2014-01-24",
"outcome": "The conviction and twenty-year sentence were affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rts.rs/vesti/hronika/1346928/peranovicu-20-godina-zatvora.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0ca2423feaa16db83506fe65f8165ee70a40faa61d8dd75a66267da0b5d4f02c",
"final_url": "https://www.rts.rs/vesti/hronika/1346928/peranovicu-20-godina-zatvora.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rts.rs/lat/vesti/hronika/1503443/.html?print=true",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "73906f7033c050ececaef6a96a2770260a75a8ae6b5cb02ca814e8e4c8437a29",
"final_url": "https://www.rts.rs/lat/vesti/hronika/1503443/.html?print=true"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 108,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Greece",
"outcome": "Decision 661/2024 rejected the appeal and upheld the conviction."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The Greek courts anonymized the priest, so this entry does not attempt to identify him. It concerns the adjudicated touching of an adult worshipper in the private space used for confession, not Orthodox Christianity, confession, priests or worshippers generally. The survivor is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-confession-priest-drama-greece",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Drama, Greece",
"lat": 41.1499,
"lng": 24.1469,
"title": "Unnamed priest: conviction upheld for sexual touching during confession",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Orthodox priest",
"confessor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sacramental confession setting",
"priestly authority",
"private chapel access"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed Orthodox parish in Drama"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Three-Member Misdemeanor Court of Drama, Greece",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2022-10-05",
"outcome": "The court convicted the priest of violating sexual dignity and imposed four months in prison suspended for three years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Greece",
"stage": "cassation judgment",
"outcome": "Decision 661/2024 rejected the priest's challenge and left the conviction in force."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.areiospagos.gr/nomologia/apofaseis_DISPLAY.asp?apof=661_2024&cd=QVYAQGU0LXFHUMA9PLV9LKIUGAM6VY&info=%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD+-++%EF%BF%BD",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Greece, Decision 661/2024.",
"body": "The official cassation decision records the underlying conviction, four-month suspended sentence, confession setting and rejection of the priest's appeal.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1260763/supreme-court-upholds-verdict-for-priest-condemned-of-sexual-harassing-woman-after-confession/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kathimerini, 'Supreme Court upholds conviction of priest for sexually harassing woman during confession' (Feb. 5, 2025).",
"body": "High-quality reporting corroborates the final conviction, sentence, chapel confession setting and the defendant's eventual admission of the touching.",
"tier": "high-quality-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies sacramental confession setting, priestly authority, and private chapel access as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Orthodox priest and confessor.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Greece",
"outcome": "Decision 661/2024 rejected the appeal and upheld the conviction."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.areiospagos.gr/nomologia/apofaseis_DISPLAY.asp?apof=661_2024&cd=QVYAQGU0LXFHUMA9PLV9LKIUGAM6VY&info=%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD+-++%EF%BF%BD",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ac64f574a1bda6f26b1407322df729971f31a6caaea3f1aefa8abadf7107b060",
"final_url": "https://www.areiospagos.gr/nomologia/apofaseis_DISPLAY.asp?apof=661_2024&cd=QVYAQGU0LXFHUMA9PLV9LKIUGAM6VY&info=%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD%EF%BF%BD+-++%EF%BF%BD"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1260763/supreme-court-upholds-verdict-for-priest-condemned-of-sexual-harassing-woman-after-confession/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a43b92577bbc08e4a4defc44c0123bf6b7dd1221b0c42611e45d506c7f0483d1",
"final_url": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1260763/supreme-court-upholds-verdict-for-priest-condemned-of-sexual-harassing-woman-after-confession/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 109,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"ark-of-the-world"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Three-Member Court of Appeal for Misdemeanors of Athens, Greece",
"date": "2026-02-19",
"outcome": "The appellate court expanded the founder's guilty findings from five to nine counts and imposed a nine-and-a-half-year convertible sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This institutional record is limited to the adjudicated physical-abuse and punitive-treatment case. It does not treat separate pending sexual or financial proceedings as proved, does not assign Papanikolaou's convictions to every Ark employee or resident, and does not attribute the conduct to Orthodox Christianity or child welfare generally. The minors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-father-antonios-ark-world-greece",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Athens, Greece",
"lat": 37.9838,
"lng": 23.7275,
"title": "Ark of the World: appellate convictions for physical abuse and punitive treatment",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest-founder, spiritual guide and dominant institutional leader",
"child-welfare directors and staff"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-father and confessor authority",
"institutional custody of minors",
"punitive discipline",
"leader influence over staff",
"isolation within residential facilities"
],
"organizations": [
"Ark of the World",
"Kivotos tou Kosmou"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Three-Member Court of Appeal for Misdemeanors of Athens, Greece",
"stage": "appellate judgment and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-19",
"outcome": "Father Antonios Papanikolaou was convicted on nine of nineteen physical-abuse and punitive-treatment counts and received a merged sentence of nine years and six months, convertible to a fine. Four former associates received separate convictions and sentences; two defendants were acquitted."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1295792/child-shelter-founder-found-guilty-again-on-appeal/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kathimerini, 'Child shelter founder found guilty again on appeal' (Feb. 19, 2026).",
"body": "Detailed appellate reporting records nine guilty counts involving physical abuse and punitive treatment, the distinct convictions of four associates and two acquittals.",
"tier": "high-quality-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://knews.kathimerini.com.cy/en/news/children-s-charity-founder-gets-9%C2%BD-year-sentence-but-can-stay-out-of-jail-if-he-pays",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KNEWS / Kathimerini Cyprus, 'Children's charity founder gets nine-and-a-half-year sentence' (Feb. 19, 2026).",
"body": "The sentence report records the merged nine-and-a-half-year term, conversion to a monetary payment, separate sentences for former associates and the court's rejection of obedience to the founder as a justification for violence.",
"tier": "high-quality-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1249735/ark-of-the-world-charity-founder-denies-wrongdoing/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kathimerini, 'Ark of the World charity founder denies wrongdoing' (Sept. 30, 2024).",
"body": "Contemporaneous trial reporting records Papanikolaou's own description of his role as strictly spiritual and his claim that he raised the children, while also recording the bodily-harm and incitement charges he denied. The later appellate judgment, not this denial, establishes guilt.",
"tier": "high-quality-court-reporting",
"kind": "authority-role-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual-father and confessor authority, institutional custody of minors, punitive discipline, leader influence over staff, and isolation within residential facilities as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is priest-founder, spiritual guide and dominant institutional leader and child-welfare directors and staff.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Three-Member Court of Appeal for Misdemeanors of Athens, Greece",
"date": "2026-02-19",
"outcome": "The appellate court expanded the founder's guilty findings from five to nine counts and imposed a nine-and-a-half-year convertible sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1295792/child-shelter-founder-found-guilty-again-on-appeal/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3c2b906077e4d0c1cb47128ccd4d8cb42ab108695f4e9476356b78ac301e1c2",
"final_url": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1295792/child-shelter-founder-found-guilty-again-on-appeal/"
},
{
"source": "https://knews.kathimerini.com.cy/en/news/children-s-charity-founder-gets-9%C2%BD-year-sentence-but-can-stay-out-of-jail-if-he-pays",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "520ace52a4c3d92136680cedf183aab6fdb07b807d9b50a9718dfee97c15f662",
"final_url": "https://knews.kathimerini.com.cy/en/news/children-s-charity-founder-gets-9%C2%BD-year-sentence-but-can-stay-out-of-jail-if-he-pays"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1249735/ark-of-the-world-charity-founder-denies-wrongdoing/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-court-reporting; evidentiary role: authority-role-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "00d5681b9218b92f12f7b697764b6f1e4497b49531a40ae60d86d371cd243a59",
"final_url": "https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1249735/ark-of-the-world-charity-founder-denies-wrongdoing/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 110,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"christian-praying-assembly"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Nigeria",
"date": "2016-02-26",
"outcome": "The final appeal was dismissed and the murder and attempted-murder convictions were affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The Supreme Court record identifies a father-son and father-daughter relationship between Ezeugo and the congregants and records that he punished them after accusing them of immoral behavior. The five surviving victims are not identified. The entry concerns Ezeugo's adjudicated conduct, not Christianity, Nigerian churches, pastors or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-rev-king-christian-praying-assembly-nigeria",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Lagos, Nigeria",
"lat": 6.5244,
"lng": 3.3792,
"title": "Chukwuemeka Ezeugo ('Rev. King'): murder and attempted-murder convictions affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"general overseer",
"founder and spiritual father of congregants"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"absolute pastoral authority",
"religious punishment for alleged immorality",
"father-child hierarchy within the congregation",
"physical discipline"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Praying Assembly"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Lagos State, Ikeja, Nigeria",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2007-01-11",
"outcome": "Ezeugo was convicted of murdering one church member and attempting to murder five others. He received a death sentence for murder and twenty years on each attempted-murder count."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal, Lagos Division, Nigeria",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2013-02-01",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the convictions and sentences."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Nigeria",
"stage": "final appeal",
"date": "2016-02-26",
"outcome": "The court unanimously dismissed the appeal and affirmed the judgment below."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nigerialii.org/akn/ng/judgment/ngsc/2016/95/eng%402016-02-25",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Nigeria, Chukwuemeka Ezeuko (alias Dr. Rev. King) v. State, SC.200/2013, [2016] NGSC 95 (Feb. 25, 2016).",
"body": "The appellate judgment records Ezeugo's position as general overseer, the spiritual father-child relationship with the victims, punishment for alleged immoral behavior, the murder and attempted-murder counts and affirmance of the convictions.",
"tier": "court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://punchng.com/rev-king-must-die-by-hanging-supreme-court-orders/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Punch, 'Rev. King must die by hanging, Supreme Court orders' (Feb. 27, 2016).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the unanimous Supreme Court disposition, the trial and intermediate appeal, and the religious-discipline context.",
"tier": "high-quality-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies absolute pastoral authority, religious punishment for alleged immorality, father-child hierarchy within the congregation, and physical discipline as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is general overseer and founder and spiritual father of congregants.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Nigeria",
"date": "2016-02-26",
"outcome": "The final appeal was dismissed and the murder and attempted-murder convictions were affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nigerialii.org/akn/ng/judgment/ngsc/2016/95/eng%402016-02-25",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://punchng.com/rev-king-must-die-by-hanging-supreme-court-orders/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "02938f6b41fcb7afba4405c517f9dbf74dd60cd52267d009cf52db43490b3678",
"final_url": "https://punchng.com/rev-king-must-die-by-hanging-supreme-court-orders/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 111,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The survivor is not identified. The entry concerns Akuffo's conviction and his use of a witchcraft accusation and claimed deliverance requirement, not Christianity, exorcism, Ghanaian pastors or people accused of witchcraft generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-daniel-akuffo-exorcism-ghana",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Accra, Ghana",
"lat": 5.6037,
"lng": -0.187,
"title": "Daniel Akuffo: fifteen-year sentence for abuse under an exorcism pretext",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"purported exorcist"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"witchcraft accusation",
"deliverance and prayer pretext",
"threat of expulsion from housing",
"spiritual authority over a child"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Accra Circuit Court, Ghana",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2021-09-30",
"outcome": "The court found Akuffo guilty of defilement and sentenced him to fifteen years in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://gna.org.gh/2021/09/pastor-and-exorcist-jailed-15-years-for-defiling-a-witch/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ghana News Agency, 'Pastor and exorcist jailed 15 years for defiling a witch' (Sept. 30, 2021).",
"body": "The national news agency's court report records the conviction, sentence, witchcraft accusation, prayer setting and claim that sexual contact was required for deliverance.",
"tier": "national-news-agency-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies witchcraft accusation, deliverance and prayer pretext, threat of expulsion from housing, and spiritual authority over a child as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor and purported exorcist.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://gna.org.gh/2021/09/pastor-and-exorcist-jailed-15-years-for-defiling-a-witch/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "59744d27ccb977209408ee95cc1a5362976ac5675404954fc8f31152675efb5e",
"final_url": "https://gna.org.gh/2021/09/pastor-and-exorcist-jailed-15-years-for-defiling-a-witch/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 112,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The children are not identified. The entry concerns Mbacké's adjudicated abuse of pupils under his Quranic-teacher authority, not Islam, Quranic education, Mouridism, Senegalese daaras or religious teachers generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-serigne-khadim-mbacke-daara-senegal",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Touba and Diourbel, Senegal",
"lat": 14.8674,
"lng": -15.8995,
"title": "Serigne Khadim Mbacké: twenty-year sentence for abuse of Quranic-school pupils",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Quranic teacher",
"daara leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teacher authority",
"access to child pupils",
"institutional trust within a Quranic school"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed daara in Touba Kër Gol"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber, High Court of Diourbel, Senegal",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-08",
"outcome": "The court convicted Mbacké of rape and sexual offenses involving twenty-eight girls and imposed twenty years' imprisonment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lesoleil.sn/regions/actualites-regionales-quotidiennes/viol-et-pedophilie-sur-28-fillettes-a-touba-serigne-khadim-mbacke-ecope-de-20-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le Soleil, 'Viol et pédophilie sur 28 fillettes à Touba: Serigne Khadim Mbacké écope de 20 ans' (June 8, 2026).",
"body": "Senegal's national newspaper reports the criminal-chamber judgment, twenty-year sentence, twenty-eight adjudicated victims and the defendant's role as their Quranic teacher.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.pressafrik.com/Tribunal-de-Diourbel-Le-maitre-coranique-Serigne-Khadim-Mbacke-condamne-a-20-ans-de-reclusion-pour-les-viols-de-28_a306553.amp.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "PressAfrik, 'Tribunal de Diourbel: le maître coranique Serigne Khadim Mbacké condamné à 20 ans' (June 8, 2026).",
"body": "Independent contemporaneous reporting corroborates the court, conviction, sentence and teacher-pupil relationship while distinguishing the defense denial from the judgment.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious-teacher authority, access to child pupils, and institutional trust within a Quranic school as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Quranic teacher and daara leader.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lesoleil.sn/regions/actualites-regionales-quotidiennes/viol-et-pedophilie-sur-28-fillettes-a-touba-serigne-khadim-mbacke-ecope-de-20-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.pressafrik.com/Tribunal-de-Diourbel-Le-maitre-coranique-Serigne-Khadim-Mbacke-condamne-a-20-ans-de-reclusion-pour-les-viols-de-28_a306553.amp.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5e38837e050a46ef0d88aa4b82b23a841621404b27814a73afc8b0fd0727a0c2",
"final_url": "https://www.pressafrik.com/Tribunal-de-Diourbel-Le-maitre-coranique-Serigne-Khadim-Mbacke-condamne-a-20-ans-de-reclusion-pour-les-viols-de-28_a306553.amp.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 113,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The entry preserves the acquittals and does not repeat the children's names. It concerns Atangana Mbida's adjudicated fatal violence during claimed deliverance, not Christianity, Cameroon, exorcism, parents seeking care or pastors generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-andre-guy-atangana-mbida-exorcism-cameroon",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Yaoundé, Cameroon",
"lat": 3.848,
"lng": 11.5021,
"title": "André Guy Atangana Mbida: life sentence for fatal violence during claimed exorcism",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"purported exorcist and deliverance practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"demonic-possession claims",
"claimed deliverance powers",
"violent exorcism",
"control over a parent seeking spiritual treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Mfoundi, Cameroon",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2021-02-26",
"outcome": "The court convicted Atangana Mbida of fatal violence against two children and imposed life imprisonment. It acquitted him of separate sexual charges for lack of proof and acquitted the children's mother of complicity."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://actucameroun.com/2021/03/03/epilogue-la-fille-du-maire-de-yaounde-acquittee-de-violence-sur-enfants/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kalara / Actu Cameroun, 'Épilogue: la fille du maire de Yaoundé acquittée de violence sur enfants' (Mar. 3, 2021).",
"body": "Detailed judgment reporting records the life sentence, fatal-violence conviction, separate acquittals and evidence that claimed demonic possession and deliverance powers enabled the abuse.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://kalarahebdo.net/plus-de-trente-affaires-de-viol-devant-les-tribunaux-de-yaounde/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kalara, 'Plus de trente affaires de viol devant les tribunaux de Yaoundé' (Nov. 8, 2021).",
"body": "The specialist court newspaper corroborates that Atangana Mbida was the principal accused, that the fatal injuries were attributed to his violence and that the co-defendant was acquitted.",
"tier": "specialist-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies demonic-possession claims, claimed deliverance powers, violent exorcism, and control over a parent seeking spiritual treatment as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor and purported exorcist and deliverance practitioner.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://actucameroun.com/2021/03/03/epilogue-la-fille-du-maire-de-yaounde-acquittee-de-violence-sur-enfants/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c13be9302e3aedf77234771f15b90a60a27cf58f2d5f31f150b1f8a7b8bc793d",
"final_url": "https://actucameroun.com/2021/03/03/epilogue-la-fille-du-maire-de-yaounde-acquittee-de-violence-sur-enfants/"
},
{
"source": "https://kalarahebdo.net/plus-de-trente-affaires-de-viol-devant-les-tribunaux-de-yaounde/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 114,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"primitive-church-drc"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The child is not identified. Sources differ in their shorthand descriptions of the offense list; this entry states only the overlapping adjudicated findings and preserves the father's separate liability. It concerns Kasambakana's conduct, not Christianity, polygamy debates, Congolese churches or families generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-pierre-kasambakana-primitive-church-drc",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Kinshasa and Moanda, Democratic Republic of the Congo",
"lat": -4.325,
"lng": 15.3222,
"title": "Pierre Kasambakana: eleven-year sentence for forced marriage and sexual offenses",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "forced-marriage",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"spiritual head of the Primitive Church",
"pastor promoting polygamy through religious teaching"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-leader authority",
"religious justification of polygamy",
"forced child marriage",
"family and church control"
],
"organizations": [
"Primitive Church in the Democratic Republic of the Congo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Kinshasa-Gombe, Democratic Republic of the Congo",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2024-06-07",
"outcome": "The court sentenced Kasambakana to eleven years' imprisonment for offenses including forced marriage and sexual misconduct. The child's father received a separate eleven-year sentence for forced marriage and document offenses."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://actualite.cd/2024/06/08/rdc-le-pasteur-pierre-kasambakana-condamne-11-ans-de-prison-pour-atteinte-aux-moeurs-et",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Actualite.cd, 'Le pasteur Pierre Kasambakana condamné à 11 ans de prison' (June 8, 2024).",
"body": "Contemporaneous judgment reporting records the eleven-year sentence, forced-marriage and morals findings, the father's separate conviction and Kasambakana's role as spiritual head of the church and preacher of polygamy.",
"tier": "high-quality-local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lecourrierdekinshasa.com/node/157773",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le Courrier de Kinshasa, 'Justice: onze ans de prison pour le pasteur Pierre Kasambakana Kasongo' (June 8, 2024).",
"body": "Independent local reporting corroborates the court, sentence, forced-marriage finding and religious-leader role.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies spiritual-leader authority, religious justification of polygamy, forced child marriage, and family and church control as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is spiritual head of the Primitive Church and pastor promoting polygamy through religious teaching.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://actualite.cd/2024/06/08/rdc-le-pasteur-pierre-kasambakana-condamne-11-ans-de-prison-pour-atteinte-aux-moeurs-et",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "98509d7a64e6dc7a6593929e4ed44a61058e3b4002ab10a3c84cfd32460cccb9",
"final_url": "https://actualite.cd/2024/06/08/rdc-le-pasteur-pierre-kasambakana-condamne-11-ans-de-prison-pour-atteinte-aux-moeurs-et"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lecourrierdekinshasa.com/node/157773",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b6198637c0589e4baba39328b71589f9d584c155cf070504c41021c6b66784c3",
"final_url": "https://www.lecourrierdekinshasa.com/node/157773"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 115,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"sierra-leone-cdf"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special Court for Sierra Leone, Appeals Chamber",
"date": "2008-05-28",
"outcome": "The appeal both reversed two counts and entered or affirmed other convictions; the concurrent controlling term became twenty years."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The appellate court found spiritual influence but warned that influence alone did not prove command responsibility. This entry does not treat every Kamajor, CDF member, traditional healer or Sierra Leonean belief as culpable, and it preserves the reversed counts.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-allieu-kondewa-cdf-sierra-leone",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Sierra Leone",
"lat": 8.4606,
"lng": -11.7799,
"title": "Allieu Kondewa: war-crimes convictions and spiritual authority over Kamajor fighters",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Civil Defence Forces high priest and initiator",
"spiritual adviser to Kamajor fighters"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"bulletproofing initiation claims",
"ritual blessing before combat",
"spiritual influence over fighters",
"mobilization through claimed protective powers"
],
"organizations": [
"Civil Defence Forces",
"Kamajors"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special Court for Sierra Leone, Trial Chamber I",
"stage": "trial judgment and sentence",
"date": "2007-10-09",
"outcome": "Kondewa was convicted of war crimes including murder, cruel treatment and pillage and initially sentenced to eight years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Special Court for Sierra Leone, Appeals Chamber",
"stage": "appeal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2008-05-28",
"outcome": "The court entered additional crimes-against-humanity convictions and increased the controlling sentence to twenty years, while reversing the collective-punishment and child-soldier convictions."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Residual Special Court for Sierra Leone",
"stage": "sentence completion",
"date": "2023-05-29",
"outcome": "The court announced that Kondewa had completed the twenty-year sentence and left its jurisdiction."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rscsl.org/Documents/Decisions/CDF/Appeal/829/SCSL-04-14-A-829.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Special Court for Sierra Leone, Prosecutor v. Fofana and Kondewa, SCSL-04-14-A, Appeal Judgment (May 28, 2008).",
"body": "The official appeal judgment records the final convictions, reversed counts, concurrent twenty-year sentence and findings concerning Kondewa's position as high priest and initiator.",
"tier": "international-court",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rscsl.org/Documents/Decisions/CDF/Appeal/829/SCSL-04-14-A-811.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Special Court for Sierra Leone, Prosecutor v. Fofana and Kondewa, separate opinion concerning command responsibility (May 28, 2008).",
"body": "The official decision explains that Kondewa's high-priest role gave him spiritual influence over Kamajors but did not by itself establish effective control for superior responsibility.",
"tier": "international-court",
"kind": "appellate-analysis"
},
{
"link": "https://rscsl.org/press-releases/allieu-kondewa-completes-sentence-is-free-from-the-jurisdiction-of-the-court/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Residual Special Court for Sierra Leone, 'Allieu Kondewa Completes Sentence' (May 29, 2023).",
"body": "The official court release records completion of the twenty-year sentence and identifies Kondewa as the former CDF high priest and initiator.",
"tier": "international-court",
"kind": "sentence-completion"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies bulletproofing initiation claims, ritual blessing before combat, spiritual influence over fighters, and mobilization through claimed protective powers as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Civil Defence Forces high priest and initiator and spiritual adviser to Kamajor fighters.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special Court for Sierra Leone, Appeals Chamber",
"date": "2008-05-28",
"outcome": "The appeal both reversed two counts and entered or affirmed other convictions; the concurrent controlling term became twenty years."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rscsl.org/Documents/Decisions/CDF/Appeal/829/SCSL-04-14-A-829.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-court; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-large",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.rscsl.org/Documents/Decisions/CDF/Appeal/829/SCSL-04-14-A-811.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-court; evidentiary role: appellate-analysis.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1164b74efedc595d69f1ea1f6e274a4fc8162f44c73f8f092c8d19318681aebd",
"final_url": "https://www.rscsl.org/Documents/Decisions/CDF/Appeal/829/SCSL-04-14-A-811.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://rscsl.org/press-releases/allieu-kondewa-completes-sentence-is-free-from-the-jurisdiction-of-the-court/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-court; evidentiary role: sentence-completion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "190f01d9732080ec58ad3b55562967c94ea150bba15a4698c09adb763b07fa27",
"final_url": "https://rscsl.org/press-releases/allieu-kondewa-completes-sentence-is-free-from-the-jurisdiction-of-the-court/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 116,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The harmed woman is not identified. The court record concerns the pastor's unsupported public accusation and the resulting threat to her dignity and safety. It does not treat Christian prayer, visions, Burkina Faso or pastors generally as abusive.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-pastor-jonas-witchcraft-accusation-burkina-faso",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso",
"lat": 12.3714,
"lng": -1.5197,
"title": "Pastor Jonas: conviction for a public witchcraft accusation during prayer",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor and head of the Ministry of Divine Love"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual vision",
"public witchcraft accusation",
"congregational authority",
"exposure to community retaliation"
],
"organizations": [
"Ministry of Divine Love"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Ouaga I, Burkina Faso",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2025-09-09",
"outcome": "The court convicted the pastor of accusing a woman of witchcraft and imposed twelve months in prison and a 500,000 CFA-franc fine, both suspended."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.zoodomail.com/node/3459",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Zoodomail, 'Un pasteur condamné pour accusation de sorcellerie à Ouagadougou' (Sept. 10, 2025).",
"body": "Detailed courtroom reporting records the prayer setting, admitted lack of evidence, prosecution's safety analysis, conviction and suspended sentence.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://netafrique.net/ouagadougou-un-pasteur-condamne-par-la-justice-pour-avoir-accuse-une-enseignante-de-sorcellerie-lors-dune-priere-a-boassa/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NetAfrique, 'Ouagadougou: un pasteur condamné pour avoir accusé une enseignante de sorcellerie' (Sept. 2025).",
"body": "Independent local reporting corroborates the verdict, sentence and public prayer context.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed spiritual vision, public witchcraft accusation, congregational authority, and exposure to community retaliation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is pastor and head of the Ministry of Divine Love.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.zoodomail.com/node/3459",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ac75e220ce588c22791b7c794c800a306cfab88b875a166f995462a1929cb76c",
"final_url": "https://www.zoodomail.com/node/3459"
},
{
"source": "https://netafrique.net/ouagadougou-un-pasteur-condamne-par-la-justice-pour-avoir-accuse-une-enseignante-de-sorcellerie-lors-dune-priere-a-boassa/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fc00b25592a70aeaac1e73b594133d6c789e0c383ea51be7291d9087e767d51c",
"final_url": "https://netafrique.net/ouagadougou-un-pasteur-condamne-par-la-justice-pour-avoir-accuse-une-enseignante-de-sorcellerie-lors-dune-priere-a-boassa/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 117,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"tabernacles-sons-kingdom-burkina"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an allegation record. Ibrahima remains presumed innocent unless convicted. The entry reports only the prosecutor's stated allegations and does not identify complainants or attribute the allegations to Christianity, Burkina Faso or congregants generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-moumouni-ibrahima-pastor-burkina-faso",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso",
"lat": 12.3714,
"lng": -1.5197,
"title": "Moumouni Ibrahima: prosecutor announces investigation of alleged coercion of congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and pastor known as Guillaume the Patriarch"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"alleged misuse of man-of-God status",
"alleged threats and deceptive spiritual claims",
"alleged financial exploitation",
"congregational authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of the Tabernacles of the Sons of the Kingdom of Heaven"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Prosecutor of Faso at the High Court of Ouaga II, Burkina Faso",
"stage": "police investigation and custody",
"date": "2026-06-19",
"outcome": "The prosecutor announced that Ibrahima was in custody while police investigated allegations including rape, attempted rape, abuse of weakness, fraud, money laundering and threats. The church was closed for the investigation. No guilt finding had been made."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.minute.bf/burkina-un-pasteur-interpelle-pour-viol-escroquerie-et-blanchiment-de-capitaux/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Prosecutor at TGI Ouaga II, communiqué reproduced by Minute.bf (June 19-20, 2026).",
"body": "The reproduced prosecutor's communiqué records the complaint, alleged use of religious status to coerce congregants, custody, offense categories, closure of the church and continuing investigation.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority-communique",
"kind": "investigation-announcement"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents alleged misuse of man-of-God status, alleged threats and deceptive spiritual claims, alleged financial exploitation, and congregational authority, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is founder and pastor known as Guillaume the Patriarch.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The prosecutor announced that Ibrahima was in custody while police investigated allegations including rape, attempted rape, abuse of weakness, fraud, money laundering and threats. The church was closed for the investigation. No guilt finding had been made.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.minute.bf/burkina-un-pasteur-interpelle-pour-viol-escroquerie-et-blanchiment-de-capitaux/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority-communique; evidentiary role: investigation-announcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2fd307bd057b33eb9477f9f064dcb295c7127541849e3410240a30fb3ba3ffa1",
"final_url": "https://www.minute.bf/burkina-un-pasteur-interpelle-pour-viol-escroquerie-et-blanchiment-de-capitaux/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 118,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an allegation record. Bangoura remains presumed innocent unless convicted. The child and family are not identified. The entry concerns the police's account of a purported healing ritual and alleged curse threat, not Islam, Guinean traditions, marabouts, healers or people seeking care generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-abdoulaye-bangoura-healer-guinea",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Conakry, Guinea",
"lat": 9.6412,
"lng": -13.5784,
"title": "Abdoulaye Bangoura: police investigation of alleged abuse during a healing ritual",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented marabout and traditional healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"purported healing ritual",
"alleged curse threat",
"retention of hair as claimed spiritual leverage",
"exploitation of people seeking care"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Central Police Station of Gbessia and Court of First Instance of Mafanco, Guinea",
"stage": "police investigation and announced referral",
"date": "2026-06-05",
"outcome": "The national police spokesperson announced Bangoura's arrest and intended referral over allegations of rape, fraud and threats. No guilt finding had been made."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.guineequotidien.com/2026/06/05/conakry-arrestation-dun-marabout-tradipraticien-pour-des-faits-de-viol-et-grossesse-dune-mineure/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Guinée Quotidien, 'Conakry: arrestation d'un marabout tradipraticien' (June 5, 2026).",
"body": "Local reporting quotes the national police spokesperson on the arrest, alleged ritual-healing access, curse threat, claimed pattern of exploiting vulnerable clients and intended court referral.",
"tier": "police-sourced-local-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents purported healing ritual, alleged curse threat, retention of hair as claimed spiritual leverage, and exploitation of people seeking care, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is self-presented marabout and traditional healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The national police spokesperson announced Bangoura's arrest and intended referral over allegations of rape, fraud and threats. No guilt finding had been made.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.guineequotidien.com/2026/06/05/conakry-arrestation-dun-marabout-tradipraticien-pour-des-faits-de-viol-et-grossesse-dune-mineure/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: police-sourced-local-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7a14c1e22913d2a6a53d1031e6fea50ec71b0a8b84fc74fa33f83823f935f243",
"final_url": "https://www.guineequotidien.com/2026/06/05/conakry-arrestation-dun-marabout-tradipraticien-pour-des-faits-de-viol-et-grossesse-dune-mineure/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 119,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"berger-rocher-israel-gabon"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Survivors are not identified. The entry concerns Mbele Obiang's adjudicated use of claimed revelation and healing authority, not Christianity, Gabon, revival churches, spiritual healing or pastors generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-martial-mbele-obiang-hebron-gabon",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Port-Gentil, Gabon",
"lat": -0.7193,
"lng": 8.7815,
"title": "Martial Mbele Obiang: fifteen-year sentence for abuse framed as divine revelation",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and pastor of Le Berger Rocher d'Israël",
"claimed anointed spiritual guide"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine revelation called Hebron",
"claimed healing and thought-reading powers",
"pastoral authority",
"threats and manipulation"
],
"organizations": [
"Le Berger Rocher d'Israël"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Court of Port-Gentil, Gabon",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2024-04-04",
"outcome": "The court convicted Mbele Obiang of rape and imposed fifteen years in prison, a one-million-CFA-franc fine and civil damages."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gabonreview.com/lenfer-derriere-les-portes-de-leglise-15-ans-de-prison-pour-un-pasteur-predateur/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "GabonReview, 'L'enfer derrière les portes de l'Église: 15 ans de prison' (Apr. 9, 2024).",
"body": "Detailed contemporaneous reporting records the court, conviction, sentence, claimed Hebron revelation, purported healing powers and exploitation of pastoral trust.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://info241.com/un-pasteur-gabonais-condamne-a-15-ans-de-prison-pour-viols%2C8853",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Info241, 'Un pasteur gabonais condamné à 15 ans de prison pour viols' (Apr. 6, 2024).",
"body": "Independent Gabonese reporting corroborates the Port-Gentil verdict and the use of claimed spiritual authority.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed divine revelation called Hebron, claimed healing and thought-reading powers, pastoral authority, and threats and manipulation as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is founder and pastor of Le Berger Rocher d'Israël and claimed anointed spiritual guide.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gabonreview.com/lenfer-derriere-les-portes-de-leglise-15-ans-de-prison-pour-un-pasteur-predateur/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "15ea5a1f08ac89fbf5dd7bafda530ba4533f50d6d29ce6b395912a9d460a92e7",
"final_url": "https://www.gabonreview.com/lenfer-derriere-les-portes-de-leglise-15-ans-de-prison-pour-un-pasteur-predateur/"
},
{
"source": "https://info241.com/un-pasteur-gabonais-condamne-a-15-ans-de-prison-pour-viols%2C8853",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cbf9384860348a0f0485bec6bcaa190513b288a319bd58515f3ed6811b312c21",
"final_url": "https://info241.com/un-pasteur-gabonais-condamne-a-15-ans-de-prison-pour-viols%2C8853"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 120,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The harmed child is not identified. The available detailed report does not establish a formal church affiliation, so the entry uses the narrower spiritual-healing category. It concerns Endakeki's adjudicated conduct, not Congolese belief, spiritual treatment or religious shepherds generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-lili-endakeki-ouesso-congo",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Ouesso, Republic of the Congo",
"lat": 1.6136,
"lng": 16.0517,
"title": "Lili Endakeki: five-year sentence for abusive claimed spiritual treatment",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed shepherd and spiritual practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"charlatanism",
"claimed spiritual treatment",
"authority over a vulnerable child",
"physical violence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Ouesso, Republic of the Congo",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2025-10-20",
"outcome": "The court convicted Endakeki of charlatanism, intentional assault and involuntary homicide and imposed five years in prison, a 720,000-CFA-franc fine and civil damages."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.matinlibre.cg/ouesso-condamnation-dune-fausse-bergere-a-cinq-ans-de-prison-ferme/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Matin Libre Congo, 'Ouesso: condamnation d'une fausse bergère à cinq ans de prison ferme' (Oct. 20, 2025).",
"body": "Detailed local court reporting records the conviction, offenses, sentence, civil damages and abusive practices against a child under claimed spiritual authority.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies charlatanism, claimed spiritual treatment, authority over a vulnerable child, and physical violence as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-proclaimed shepherd and spiritual practitioner.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.matinlibre.cg/ouesso-condamnation-dune-fausse-bergere-a-cinq-ans-de-prison-ferme/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a2d56454462e2f528b063e0ae7b2cfebeb3ec04d1de53d45ee7a99b6d9ae2652",
"final_url": "https://www.matinlibre.cg/ouesso-condamnation-dune-fausse-bergere-a-cinq-ans-de-prison-ferme/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 121,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The survivor's family and the deceased woman are not identified. The entry concerns the court's finding that the practitioner used fatal physical force while claiming to expel a spirit. It does not attribute that conduct to Islam, Quranic recitation, Algeria, ruqya practitioners or families seeking care generally. The available report does not establish a later appellate disposition.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-raqi-hamdan-blida-algeria",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Blida, Algeria",
"lat": 36.47,
"lng": 2.83,
"title": "'Raqi Hamdan': three-year sentence after fatal violence during claimed ruqya",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"purported raqi and spiritual healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spirit-possession diagnosis",
"violent ruqya",
"authority over a medically vulnerable person",
"insistence that the victim's objections came from a jinn"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Court of the Blida Judicial Council, Algeria",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2008-05-18",
"outcome": "The court convicted the practitioner known as Raqi Hamdan of violence causing death and imposed three years' imprisonment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ennaharonline.com/%D9%84%D8%A7-%D9%8A%D8%AD%D9%81%D8%B8-%D9%85%D9%86-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B1%D8%A2%D9%86-%D8%A5%D9%84%D8%A7-%D8%A2%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A93-%D8%B3%D9%86%D9%88%D8%A7/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ennahar, 'Three years in prison for a raqi who caused a woman's death in Blida' (May 19, 2008; Arabic).",
"body": "Detailed courtroom reporting records the conviction and sentence, medical evidence of fatal chest trauma, witness testimony and the defendant's claim that he was responding to a spirit rather than the victim's objections.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed spirit-possession diagnosis, violent ruqya, authority over a medically vulnerable person, and insistence that the victim's objections came from a jinn as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is purported raqi and spiritual healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ennaharonline.com/%D9%84%D8%A7-%D9%8A%D8%AD%D9%81%D8%B8-%D9%85%D9%86-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B1%D8%A2%D9%86-%D8%A5%D9%84%D8%A7-%D8%A2%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A93-%D8%B3%D9%86%D9%88%D8%A7/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a5e3aaa275408e7ed5ceab5a1f0bab3ec71421a3414240b94cfc77a4baa4fc53",
"final_url": "https://www.ennaharonline.com/%D9%84%D8%A7-%D9%8A%D8%AD%D9%81%D8%B8-%D9%85%D9%86-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B1%D8%A2%D9%86-%D8%A5%D9%84%D8%A7-%D8%A2%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A93-%D8%B3%D9%86%D9%88%D8%A7/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 122,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The deceased woman and relatives are not identified. The court report says the principal defendant denied beating her; the conviction, medical evidence and sentence are reported as the adjudicated disposition. This entry concerns one practitioner's fatal violence, not Islam, Algeria, ruqya, mental illness or relatives seeking care generally. No later appeal was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-mazraoua-raqi-sidi-bel-abbes-algeria",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Sidi Bel Abbès, Algeria",
"lat": 35.1899,
"lng": -0.6309,
"title": "Mazraoua raqi: five-year sentence after fatal beating framed as spirit removal",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"locally known raqi and relative of the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spirit-possession diagnosis",
"violent ruqya",
"beating with an olive branch",
"family trust in a purported healer"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Court of the Sidi Bel Abbès Judicial Council, Algeria",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2023-11-28",
"outcome": "The court imposed five years' imprisonment on the raqi after finding that his beating of his adult niece during claimed ruqya caused her death. Two relatives received separate suspended three-month sentences for failure to assist a person in danger."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.echoroukonline.com/%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82-%D9%8A%D8%B2%D9%87%D9%82-%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%AD-%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%A3%D8%AE%D8%AA%D9%87-%D8%A8%D8%B2%D8%B9%D9%85-%D8%A5%D8%AE%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AC-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AC%D9%86",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Echorouk, 'Raqi takes his niece's life claiming to expel a jinn' (Nov. 28, 2023; Arabic).",
"body": "The detailed judgment report records the five-year sentence, separate suspended sentences, the forensic finding of fatal head trauma and evidence that the violence was presented as a means of locating and expelling a spirit.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed spirit-possession diagnosis, violent ruqya, beating with an olive branch, and family trust in a purported healer as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is locally known raqi and relative of the victim.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.echoroukonline.com/%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82-%D9%8A%D8%B2%D9%87%D9%82-%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%AD-%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%A3%D8%AE%D8%AA%D9%87-%D8%A8%D8%B2%D8%B9%D9%85-%D8%A5%D8%AE%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AC-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AC%D9%86",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7a60436dd173389f34ba7a36201e4e18b420630d4e6c243b8c4847cc57e17bb3",
"final_url": "https://www.echoroukonline.com/%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82-%D9%8A%D8%B2%D9%87%D9%82-%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%AD-%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%A3%D8%AE%D8%AA%D9%87-%D8%A8%D8%B2%D8%B9%D9%85-%D8%A5%D8%AE%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AC-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AC%D9%86"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 123,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal in Oujda, Morocco",
"date": "2020-10-20",
"outcome": "The appellate chamber affirmed the first-instance conviction and ten-year sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Moroccan court reporting identifies the defendant only by initials and a media label, which this entry preserves. Survivors are not identified, and disputed early reports of approximately fifteen victims are not stated as an adjudicated count. The entry concerns this defendant's use of claimed ruqya, drugging and blackmail, not Islam, Morocco, Quranic healing, raqis or people seeking help generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-raqi-berkane-morocco",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Berkane and Oujda, Morocco",
"lat": 34.92,
"lng": -2.32,
"title": "'Raqi of Berkane': ten-year sentence affirmed for trafficking and sexual violence",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented raqi and Quranic healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ruqya and evil-eye treatment claims",
"access to women seeking help",
"drugging",
"recording and blackmail",
"threats of public exposure"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber of the Court of Appeal in Oujda, Morocco",
"stage": "first-instance judgment and sentence",
"date": "2019-10-30",
"outcome": "The court imposed ten years' imprisonment and a fine after convictions including trafficking people in vulnerable circumstances, rape, attempted rape, violent sexual assault and fraud."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Appellate Criminal Chamber of the Court of Appeal in Oujda, Morocco",
"stage": "criminal appeal",
"date": "2020-10-20",
"outcome": "The appellate chamber affirmed the ten-year prison sentence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://fr.le360.ma/societe/le-raqi-de-berkane-condamne-a-10-ans-de-prison-201481/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le360, 'Le raqi de Berkane condamné à 10 ans de prison' (Oct. 31, 2019; French).",
"body": "Detailed first-instance court reporting records the offense categories, sentence, Quranic-healing pretext, drugging, recording and blackmail while preserving the defendant's initials.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://ar.le360.ma/societe/170944/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le360, 'Oujda Court of Appeal upholds the first-instance judgment against the Raqi of Berkane' (Oct. 21, 2020; Arabic).",
"body": "The appellate report records the October 20 affirmance of the ten-year sentence and the trafficking, rape, attempted-rape and violent-assault findings.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies ruqya and evil-eye treatment claims, access to women seeking help, drugging, recording and blackmail, and threats of public exposure as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-presented raqi and Quranic healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal in Oujda, Morocco",
"date": "2020-10-20",
"outcome": "The appellate chamber affirmed the first-instance conviction and ten-year sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://fr.le360.ma/societe/le-raqi-de-berkane-condamne-a-10-ans-de-prison-201481/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a3e916f6631f6ace0fb4441fc7f376d6db6ffe2e9a9107b6065dea21cf861327",
"final_url": "https://fr.le360.ma/societe/le-raqi-de-berkane-condamne-a-10-ans-de-prison-201481/"
},
{
"source": "https://ar.le360.ma/societe/170944/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d133d38d9e8436ecb7cf784c6e8b7ed616b07a7156404d9d4ca9ef98aabdc4c8",
"final_url": "https://ar.le360.ma/societe/170944/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 124,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant and survivors are not identified. Reports vary on the number of complainants, so this entry does not state a victim count. It records the first-instance judgment at a court formally named the Court of Appeal and does not imply that a later appellate review occurred. The case concerns one practitioner's adjudicated conduct, not Islam, Quran recitation, Morocco, ruqya or patients generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-raqi-tangier-morocco",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Tangier, Morocco",
"lat": 35.7595,
"lng": -5.834,
"title": "Tangier raqi: ten-year sentence for assaults committed through claimed ruqya",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented raqi and spiritual healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ruqya and spirit-treatment claims",
"access to women seeking care",
"administration of sedating substances",
"recording of victims",
"use of amplified Quran recitation to conceal assaults"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber of the Court of Appeal in Tangier, Morocco",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2023-04-04",
"outcome": "The court imposed ten years' imprisonment after convictions reported as rape, fraud, adultery and sorcery-related offenses involving women who sought ruqya."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ar.le360.ma/societe/CIBAGWTYFNDPNJB2GAHKS2W3WM/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le360, 'Raqi in Tangier convicted over rape and recording women' (Apr. 4, 2023; Arabic).",
"body": "Contemporaneous courtroom reporting records the ten-year sentence, the claimed ruqya practice and evidence concerning sedating liquids, assaults and recordings.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://alyaoum24.com/1794121.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Alyaoum24, 'Ten years in prison for a raqi in Tangier over sorcery and sexual assaults' (Apr. 7, 2023; Arabic).",
"body": "Independent court reporting corroborates the criminal chamber, sentence, sexual-assault findings and spiritual-treatment pretext.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies ruqya and spirit-treatment claims, access to women seeking care, administration of sedating substances, recording of victims, and use of amplified Quran recitation to conceal assaults as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-presented raqi and spiritual healer.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ar.le360.ma/societe/CIBAGWTYFNDPNJB2GAHKS2W3WM/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "02b29c51aca81374f6b980f9bf8e4895d3c4744619a5b5f090884681eb3a0cee",
"final_url": "https://ar.le360.ma/societe/CIBAGWTYFNDPNJB2GAHKS2W3WM/"
},
{
"source": "https://alyaoum24.com/1794121.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9d063ebf3a46625ed4329016c03545c34c89a938b8cab947637d54befba51c2",
"final_url": "https://alyaoum24.com/1794121.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 125,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an official institutional finding, not a criminal judgment against every shrine custodian, resident's family or religious practitioner. The ministry found more than 800 people with mental-health conditions at the site, most showing signs of violence or maltreatment, and reported 795 hospital admissions during the closure. A later statement to the UN used a broader figure exceeding 1,000; the page preserves rather than merges those different official counts. It concerns confinement at this site, not Islam, saint veneration, Morocco, mental illness or families seeking care generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-bouya-omar-shrine-morocco",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Bouya Omar, El Kelâa des Sraghna, Morocco",
"lat": 32.05,
"lng": -7.41,
"title": "Bouya Omar: official findings end shrine-based confinement of people with mental illness",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"saint-shrine custodial and intermediary system",
"families and paid keepers controlling residents"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"belief in healing associated with a local saint",
"confinement",
"chains and physical restraint",
"denial of medical care",
"violence and maltreatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Bouya Omar shrine site"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Morocco",
"stage": "official field study and Operation Karama closure",
"date": "2015-06-29",
"outcome": "The ministry completed evacuation and medical assessment of the site, reporting that hospitals received 795 people and that the operation was intended to end documented rights violations."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sante.gov.ma/Pages/actualites.aspx?IDActu=154",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Morocco Ministry of Health, 'Launch of the Karama initiative for people with mental illness residing at Bouya Omar' (June 11, 2015; French).",
"body": "The official field-study summary reports more than 800 residents, lack of medical treatment for 70 percent, widespread signs of violence and maltreatment, malnutrition and poor living conditions, and the operation designed to end those rights violations.",
"tier": "government-official-finding",
"kind": "field-study-and-intervention"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sante.gov.ma/Pages/Communiques.aspx?IDCom=120",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Morocco Ministry of Health, 'End of Operation Bouya Omar and preparation for the second phase of Karama' (June 29, 2015; French).",
"body": "The ministry's completion notice records 795 hospital admissions, 27 family reunifications on request and the stated purpose of ending violations and restoring dignified care.",
"tier": "government-official-record",
"kind": "operation-completion"
},
{
"link": "https://docstore.ohchr.org/SelfServices/FilesHandler.ashx?enc=cttK1LGAynCb9rj9c%2FOolhOVQ7dIAcJEFN5Maek7DvRUbAYTyy0TGaIYS71WP73beDcztgTsAZodOQW%2BP%2FYhBA%3D%3D",
"archive": "",
"citation": "UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, summary record of Morocco review, CRPD/C/SR.330 (2017).",
"body": "The official UN summary records Morocco's description of the site as a local saint's monument where people sought help for mental disability, its dismantling, transfers to mental-health care and family reunification. The government delegation reported a broader total exceeding 1,000 people.",
"tier": "intergovernmental-official-record",
"kind": "state-party-review"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies belief in healing associated with a local saint, confinement, chains and physical restraint, denial of medical care, and violence and maltreatment as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is saint-shrine custodial and intermediary system and families and paid keepers controlling residents.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sante.gov.ma/Pages/actualites.aspx?IDActu=154",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-official-finding; evidentiary role: field-study-and-intervention.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.sante.gov.ma/Pages/Communiques.aspx?IDCom=120",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-official-record; evidentiary role: operation-completion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://docstore.ohchr.org/SelfServices/FilesHandler.ashx?enc=cttK1LGAynCb9rj9c%2FOolhOVQ7dIAcJEFN5Maek7DvRUbAYTyy0TGaIYS71WP73beDcztgTsAZodOQW%2BP%2FYhBA%3D%3D",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: intergovernmental-official-record; evidentiary role: state-party-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ec7ee5bafcfcc74d2e0b14105743ec449eb3a65ae0ed4e7a07ceece528a4905c",
"final_url": "https://docstore.ohchr.org/SelfServices/FilesHandler.ashx?enc=cttK1LGAynCb9rj9c%2FOolhOVQ7dIAcJEFN5Maek7DvRUbAYTyy0TGaIYS71WP73beDcztgTsAZodOQW%2BP%2FYhBA%3D%3D"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 126,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The survivor is not identified. Reporting gives inconsistent versions of the defendant's surname and a promotional name, so the title does not identify him. The court deposited reasons on February 20, 2024 after the sentence had been announced earlier; this entry uses the publication date for the proceeding record. The case concerns the defendant's adjudicated extortion scheme, not Islam, Egypt, Quranic recitation, online healing or people seeking care generally. No appellate disposition was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-bulaq-spiritual-healer-giza-egypt",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Bulaq al-Dakrur, Giza, Egypt",
"lat": 30.037,
"lng": 31.165,
"title": "Bulaq spiritual healer: ten-year sentence for coercive recording and extortion",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented spiritual healer claiming Quranic knowledge"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed diagnosis of an attached jinn",
"Quranic-healing pretext",
"coercive sexualized instructions",
"nonconsensual recording",
"threats of publication and extortion"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Giza Criminal Court, Egypt",
"stage": "criminal judgment and published reasons",
"date": "2024-02-20",
"outcome": "The court's published reasons record a ten-year rigorous-imprisonment sentence for threats, privacy violations and coercive use of intimate images after the defendant induced the complainant to participate in purported spiritual treatment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/3105117",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Al-Masry Al-Youm, 'Reasons for the ten-year sentence of the Bulaq charlatan in the extortion of a woman' (Feb. 20, 2024; Arabic).",
"body": "Detailed reporting from the filed reasons records the sentence, threats, nonconsensual recording, claimed spiritual-healing powers, Quranic references and diagnosis of an attached jinn.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-reasons-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.masrawy.com/news/news_cases/details/2024/2/21/2541462/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Masrawy, 'Reasons for the judgment imprisoning the Bulaq al-Dakrur spiritual healer' (Feb. 21, 2024; Arabic).",
"body": "Independent reporting identifies the Giza Criminal Court and case numbers and corroborates the ten-year sentence and the spiritual-treatment mechanism described in the judgment reasons.",
"tier": "national-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies claimed diagnosis of an attached jinn, Quranic-healing pretext, coercive sexualized instructions, nonconsensual recording, and threats of publication and extortion as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-presented spiritual healer claiming Quranic knowledge.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/3105117",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-reasons-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8c3834d7a5d93dca08a04659d30da816bedc83ee92feab4916d1cc0df432d0ef",
"final_url": "https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/3105117"
},
{
"source": "https://www.masrawy.com/news/news_cases/details/2024/2/21/2541462/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5c1364fce8831b02addccfbb9c131ac6a049ad91068d047c38f1e0df80eb1fae",
"final_url": "https://www.masrawy.com/news/news_cases/details/2024/2/21/2541462/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 127,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant and children are not identified. This entry reports a first-instance death sentence under Sudan's then-applicable law and does not describe it as final or carried out. It concerns the adjudicated abuse of pupils by one imam and khalwa head, not Islam, Sudan, mosques, Quranic schools, teachers or pupils generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-gedaref-khalwa-imam-sudan",
"year": 2020,
"place": "El Gedaref, Sudan",
"lat": 14.0349,
"lng": 35.3834,
"title": "El Gedaref khalwa leader: conviction for abuse of Quranic-school pupils",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"mosque imam",
"head of a Quranic school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teacher authority",
"institutional access to child pupils",
"abuse within a khalwa attached to a mosque"
],
"organizations": [
"Quranic school attached to Deim El Nour Mosque"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Child Court of El Gedaref, Sudan",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2020-07-05",
"outcome": "The court convicted the imam and khalwa leader of sexually abusing pupils and imposed a death sentence. The available reporting does not establish the later mandatory-review or appellate disposition."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dabangasudan.org/ar/all-news/article/%D9%85%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B7%D9%81%D9%84-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B6%D8%A7%D8%B1%D9%81-%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%AF%D8%B1-%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85%D8%A7-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%AF",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Dabanga, 'El Gedaref Child Court sentences khalwa sheikh after conviction for abusing pupils' (July 5, 2020; Arabic).",
"body": "Sudanese court reporting records the conviction, first-instance sentence, imam and school-head roles, medical evidence and the abuse setting in a khalwa attached to a mosque.",
"tier": "independent-sudanese-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://english.nessunotocchicaino.it/notizia/sudan-koran-teacher-sentenced-to-death-for-sexual-abuse-60311201",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Hands Off Cain, 'Sudan: Koran teacher sentenced to death for sexual abuse' (July 2020).",
"body": "Independent English-language monitoring corroborates the El Gedaref judgment, institutional roles and abuse of students while identifying Radio Dabanga as the underlying local report.",
"tier": "specialist-monitoring",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious-teacher authority, institutional access to child pupils, and abuse within a khalwa attached to a mosque as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is mosque imam and head of a Quranic school.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dabangasudan.org/ar/all-news/article/%D9%85%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B7%D9%81%D9%84-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B6%D8%A7%D8%B1%D9%81-%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%AF%D8%B1-%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85%D8%A7-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%AF",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: independent-sudanese-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "892ba20b02425edbacff91d3ba4195dcbf60d93fbfb80901b0a87751c3a5c9c7",
"final_url": "https://www.dabangasudan.org/ar/all-news/article/%D9%85%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B7%D9%81%D9%84-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B6%D8%A7%D8%B1%D9%81-%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%AF%D8%B1-%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85%D8%A7-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%AF"
},
{
"source": "https://english.nessunotocchicaino.it/notizia/sudan-koran-teacher-sentenced-to-death-for-sexual-abuse-60311201",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-monitoring; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 128,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant and children are not identified. The charge-stage report names sexual harassment and grievous harm provisions while disposition reports describe rape; this entry uses the narrower phrase 'abuse of child pupils' and reports the court-ordered sentence and support without resolving that terminology conflict. It concerns one teacher's conviction, not Islam, Sudan, Quranic schools, teachers or pupils generally. No later appeal was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-um-baru-khalwa-sheikh-sudan",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Um Baru, North Darfur, Sudan",
"lat": 13.27,
"lng": 24.13,
"title": "Um Baru khalwa leader: fifteen-year sentence for abuse of child pupils",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Quranic-school sheikh and teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teacher authority",
"institutional access to child pupils",
"isolation within a khalwa"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed Quranic school in Um Baru"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Child Court of El Fasher, Sudan",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2022-03-22",
"outcome": "The court convicted the khalwa sheikh, imposed fifteen years' imprisonment and a ten-million-Sudanese-pound financial order, and directed that the ten affected children receive psychosocial support."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dabangasudan.org/ar/all-news/article/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86-15-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D9%84%D9%85%D8%BA%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%A8-%D8%A3%D8%B7%D9%81%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AE%D9%84%D9%88%D8%A9-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D8%B4%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%84",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Dabanga, 'Fifteen years for the abuser of khalwa children in North Darfur' (Mar. 22, 2022; Arabic).",
"body": "The judgment report records the court, judge, sentence, financial order, psychosocial-support direction and the defendant's authority over ten pupils at a Quranic school.",
"tier": "independent-sudanese-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://darfur24.com/2022/03/13/42023/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Darfur24, 'Trial resumes for accused abuser of khalwa children in North Darfur' (Mar. 13, 2022; Arabic).",
"body": "Independent contemporaneous reporting corroborates the El Fasher Child Court proceeding, Um Baru school setting, ten child complainants and use of an interpreter for pupils who spoke only their local language.",
"tier": "independent-local-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies religious-teacher authority, institutional access to child pupils, and isolation within a khalwa as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is Quranic-school sheikh and teacher.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dabangasudan.org/ar/all-news/article/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86-15-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D9%84%D9%85%D8%BA%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%A8-%D8%A3%D8%B7%D9%81%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AE%D9%84%D9%88%D8%A9-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D8%B4%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%84",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: independent-sudanese-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cf960f06e515c57ebd866d59d0bbaa1d8d1f529c777d8464efee23296a58c566",
"final_url": "https://www.dabangasudan.org/ar/all-news/article/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86-15-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D9%84%D9%85%D8%BA%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%A8-%D8%A3%D8%B7%D9%81%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AE%D9%84%D9%88%D8%A9-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D8%B4%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%84"
},
{
"source": "https://darfur24.com/2022/03/13/42023/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: independent-local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bdb709b5a4e2ac6e44377d8d5ca9ed39a2b7170fcd0d81b0d8920d15ceed44e2",
"final_url": "https://darfur24.com/2022/03/13/42023/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 129,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant and victim are not identified. This entry reports the first-instance death sentence and does not describe it as final or carried out. It concerns the defendant's adjudicated use of a ruqya invitation and religious justification for murder, not Islam, Tunisia, ruqya or people seeking spiritual help generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-el-omrane-ruqya-killing-tunisia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "El Omrane, Tunis, Tunisia",
"lat": 36.818,
"lng": 10.163,
"title": "El Omrane ruqya killing: murder conviction after a fatal claimed healing session",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented practitioner offering ruqya"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"invitation under a spiritual-healing pretext",
"private ruqya session",
"religious justification for fatal violence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber of the Tunis Court of First Instance, Tunisia",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-10",
"outcome": "The court convicted the defendant of murdering a young man during a claimed ruqya session and imposed a death sentence. The available reports do not establish an appellate disposition."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lapresse.tn/2026/02/10/le-meurtrier-dun-jeune-poignarde-lors-dune-seance-de-roqia-charia-condamne-a-la-peine-capitale/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Presse de Tunisie, 'Murderer of a young man stabbed during a ruqya session sentenced to death' (Feb. 10, 2026; French).",
"body": "Tunisia's national newspaper records the trial-court conviction, first-instance sentence, El Omrane location and the defendant's admission that he lured the victim under the pretext of performing ruqya.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.babnet.net/mobile/justice.php?v=1700503311",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Babnet, 'Djebel Lahmar: death sentence for killing a young man during claimed ruqya' (Feb. 10, 2026; Arabic).",
"body": "Independent Tunisian court reporting corroborates the criminal chamber, conviction, sentence and claimed ruqya setting.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies invitation under a spiritual-healing pretext, private ruqya session, and religious justification for fatal violence as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The relevant authority role is self-presented practitioner offering ruqya.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lapresse.tn/2026/02/10/le-meurtrier-dun-jeune-poignarde-lors-dune-seance-de-roqia-charia-condamne-a-la-peine-capitale/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bd84efbf73cb9f3ae659eca11524e1f6947fe4847efba334e2142c2836dfa67d",
"final_url": "https://www.lapresse.tn/2026/02/10/le-meurtrier-dun-jeune-poignarde-lors-dune-seance-de-roqia-charia-condamne-a-la-peine-capitale/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.babnet.net/mobile/justice.php?v=1700503311",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9a4d440b24d3ce63945eb49a87d205be40e71fb74813bc305ae649aaa3152d3",
"final_url": "https://www.babnet.net/justice.php"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 130,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The March 2026 High Court ruling changed only the sentence: 26 months' imprisonment was replaced with eleven months' home detention."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This entry reports Temple's guilty pleas and current sentence, while using the Royal Commission's separate institutional findings to explain the authority setting. It does not attribute every abuse documented at Gloriavale to Temple, and it concerns named leaders, doctrines and institutional practices rather than Christianity, New Zealanders or communal religious life generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-howard-temple-gloriavale-haupiri-new-zealand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Haupiri, West Coast, New Zealand",
"lat": -42.575,
"lng": 171.713,
"title": "Howard Temple / Gloriavale: 12 guilty pleas; High Court substitutes home detention on sentence appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Overseeing Shepherd of Gloriavale",
"senior religious leader with authority over community members"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"hierarchical religious authority",
"doctrines of submission and unity",
"salvation conditioned on community compliance",
"religious isolation and restricted outside reporting",
"gendered subordination"
],
"organizations": [
"Gloriavale Christian Community"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Greymouth District Court, New Zealand",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentence",
"date": "2025-12-12",
"outcome": "Temple pleaded guilty during trial to twelve indecency and assault charges involving six girls and young women and was sentenced to 26 months' imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of New Zealand",
"stage": "sentence appeal",
"date": "2026-03-03",
"outcome": "The High Court left the convictions intact, quashed the prison sentence and substituted eleven months' home detention."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Temple offended while holding high standing and authority inside Gloriavale. New Zealand's Royal Commission found that Gloriavale's doctrines of submission and unity, salvation-based compliance, isolation, and restrictions on outside reporting created spiritual control and barriers to disclosure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.1news.co.nz/2026/03/03/ex-gloriavale-leader-howard-temple-wins-sentence-appeal-wont-go-to-jail/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "1News, 'Ex-Gloriavale leader Howard Temple wins sentence appeal, won't go to jail' (Mar. 3, 2026).",
"body": "National court reporting records the twelve guilty pleas, offending against community members between 2002 and 2022, the original 26-month prison term and the High Court's substitution of eleven months' home detention.",
"tier": "national-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/588487/convicted-sex-offender-and-former-gloriavale-leader-howard-temple-will-not-be-going-to-jail",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio New Zealand, 'Convicted sex offender and former Gloriavale leader Howard Temple will not be going to jail' (Mar. 3, 2026).",
"body": "RNZ independently corroborates the guilty pleas, counts, six complainants, leadership role, original sentence and reserved High Court sentence ruling.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.abuseincare.org.nz/reports/whanaketia/part-4/chapter-4-2",
"archive": "",
"citation": "New Zealand Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care, Whanaketia, Part 4, Chapter 4: Abuse in Gloriavale Christian Community (2024).",
"body": "The official inquiry found that authoritarian control and separation arose from Gloriavale's interpretation of Christian beliefs, that abuse co-occurred with spiritual abuse, and that salvation, excommunication, shame and religious teaching were used to enforce compliance and silence dissent.",
"tier": "royal-commission-official-finding",
"kind": "institutional-inquiry-finding"
}
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The March 2026 High Court ruling changed only the sentence: 26 months' imprisonment was replaced with eleven months' home detention."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.1news.co.nz/2026/03/03/ex-gloriavale-leader-howard-temple-wins-sentence-appeal-wont-go-to-jail/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "65e18f872abec118649590758bb080f53bba0750d21edd34da88cf80322479f3",
"final_url": "https://www.1news.co.nz/2026/03/03/ex-gloriavale-leader-howard-temple-wins-sentence-appeal-wont-go-to-jail/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/588487/convicted-sex-offender-and-former-gloriavale-leader-howard-temple-will-not-be-going-to-jail",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0f6e8469eb84604b1b4451f9f738e72e19e4085fefa415d699c605904fa87772",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/regions_west-coast/588487/convicted-sex-offender-and-former-gloriavale-leader-howard-temple-will-not-be-going-to-jail"
},
{
"source": "https://www.abuseincare.org.nz/reports/whanaketia/part-4/chapter-4-2",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: royal-commission-official-finding; evidentiary role: institutional-inquiry-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 131,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The Albany County sexual-abuse charges are unresolved, and Yerdon is presumed innocent of them. His federal guilty plea concerns separate child-sexual-abuse-material offenses and does not convert the state allegations into findings. The church has not been publicly named. This record concerns one alleged leader's use of institutional access, not Ásatrú, Heathenry, Norse paganism, traditionalists or their organizations generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-james-yerdon-norse-pagan-church-new-york",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Albany County, New York, USA",
"lat": 42.6526,
"lng": -73.7562,
"title": "Norse Pagan church leader James Yerdon charged with child sexual abuse in New York",
"tradition": "northern-traditional",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Norse Pagan church leader",
"community leader with access to children through the church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious leadership access",
"community trust",
"alleged grooming and interstate or intrastate transport"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed Norse Pagan church in the Watertown area"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Albany County Court, New York",
"stage": "indictment and not-guilty plea",
"date": "2026-02-02",
"outcome": "Yerdon pleaded not guilty to predatory sexual assault against a child, second-degree sexual abuse and two child-endangerment counts. The state charges remain allegations."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Northern District of New York",
"stage": "separate federal guilty plea",
"date": "2026-05-07",
"outcome": "In a separate proceeding, Yerdon pleaded guilty to receipt and possession of child sexual abuse material; sentencing was scheduled for September 2026."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Albany County district attorney said Yerdon gained access to children through his church-leader role, and authorities identified him as a leader connected to a Norse Pagan church. The current public record establishes an alleged authority-and-access nexus, not a claim that Ásatrú or Norse doctrine directed the charged conduct.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/ny-church-leader-accused-abusing-2-boys-albany-21329008.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Times Union, 'Jefferson County church leader charged with abusing two boys in Albany County' (Feb. 2, 2026; updated Feb. 3, 2026).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the indictment, not-guilty plea, alleged dates and counts, and direct statements from the district attorney and state police that Yerdon gained access through a church-leader role connected to a Norse Pagan organization.",
"tier": "regional-court-reporting",
"kind": "indictment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndny/pr/jefferson-county-man-pleads-guilty-receipt-and-possession-child-pornography",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, Northern District of New York, 'Jefferson County Man Pleads Guilty to Receipt and Possession of Child Pornography' (May 27, 2026).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records Yerdon's separate May 7 federal guilty plea, the material recovered and the September 2026 sentencing date. It does not identify a religious nexus or adjudicate the pending state sexual-abuse charges.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "separate-federal-disposition"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "pagan-northern-traditional",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "In a separate proceeding, Yerdon pleaded guilty to receipt and possession of child sexual abuse material; sentencing was scheduled for September 2026.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/ny-church-leader-accused-abusing-2-boys-albany-21329008.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-court-reporting; evidentiary role: indictment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cbb6d9e3e2d0f4d8c517e550c0d42d74088f2f34a7de419314969815dfa1a3ed",
"final_url": "https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/ny-church-leader-accused-abusing-2-boys-albany-21329008.php"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndny/pr/jefferson-county-man-pleads-guilty-receipt-and-possession-child-pornography",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: separate-federal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "30f62829c6a8e813c8f64fb44d140f9fe30e1c46c42c8d500ec50229ba4d5362",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndny/pr/jefferson-county-man-pleads-guilty-receipt-and-possession-child-pornography"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 132,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record publishes the inquiry's institutional findings about how the Church of Iceland handled allegations. It is not a criminal conviction of Ólafur Skúlason, who died before the inquiry, and it does not treat every allegation reviewed by the committee as a judicially established fact. It concerns named offices and institutional responses, not Lutheranism, Icelanders, clergy or church members generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-church-of-iceland-olafur-skulason-inquiry-reykjavik",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Reykjavík, Iceland",
"lat": 64.1466,
"lng": -21.9426,
"title": "Church of Iceland inquiry criticizes institutional response to allegations against former bishop Ólafur Skúlason",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Bishop of Iceland",
"Church Council and senior church institutions",
"church safeguarding and complaint system"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"senior clerical authority",
"institutional protection of a serving bishop",
"delayed and inadequate response to complaints",
"religious institutional silence"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Iceland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Church Assembly of Iceland",
"stage": "independent investigation committee report",
"date": "2011-06-10",
"outcome": "The committee examined the national church's response to sexual-abuse allegations concerning former bishop Ólafur Skúlason and issued findings critical of the handling by church bodies and senior officials."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The institutional finding concerns the authority attached to Iceland's senior episcopal office and the church bodies that responded to complaints. The report examined how deference to a serving bishop and institutional protection affected disclosure, scrutiny, and safeguarding.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://kirkjan.is/library/Samnyttar-myndir/Skrar/skyrsla-rannsoknarnefndar-kirkjuthings.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Investigation Committee of the Church Assembly of Iceland, report on the Church of Iceland's response to allegations concerning former bishop Ólafur Skúlason (June 10, 2011; Icelandic).",
"body": "The commissioned report examines the church's procedures and response to sexual-abuse allegations concerning the former bishop, including the conduct of church bodies and senior officials. Its findings concern institutional handling rather than a criminal adjudication of the underlying allegations.",
"tier": "commissioned-official-investigation",
"kind": "institutional-inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.icelandreview.com/news/report-icelandic-bishop%E2%80%99s-sexual-offences/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Iceland Review, 'Report on Icelandic Bishop's Sexual Offences' (June 13, 2011).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting describes the committee's criticism of church institutions, the earlier complaints, and the delayed response to the former bishop's daughter while distinguishing allegations from the commission's institutional review.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-national-reporting",
"kind": "inquiry-reporting"
}
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-lutheran",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://kirkjan.is/library/Samnyttar-myndir/Skrar/skyrsla-rannsoknarnefndar-kirkjuthings.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioned-official-investigation; evidentiary role: institutional-inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.icelandreview.com/news/report-icelandic-bishop%E2%80%99s-sexual-offences/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-national-reporting; evidentiary role: inquiry-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2a0364131e764e3a884a049361da222c9619fd4380a1961f5f100ba6bc0ca412",
"final_url": "https://www.icelandreview.com/news/report-icelandic-bishop%E2%80%99s-sexual-offences/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 133,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The ICC proceeding concerns alleged crimes committed in northern Uganda in 2003 and 2004. The United Nations separately documents the LRA's use of a cultic ideology, claims of Kony's clairvoyance and spirit authority, impurity doctrine, forced recruitment and punishment to maintain control. This entry concerns Kony and the LRA, not Christianity, Acholi religion, Ugandans, political rebellion or religious belief generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-joseph-kony-lra-northern-uganda",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Northern Uganda",
"lat": 2.8,
"lng": 32.3,
"title": "Joseph Kony / LRA: ICC confirms 29 war-crime and crimes-against-humanity charges in absentia",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "state-terror",
"status": "indictment",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed prophet",
"spiritually instructed LRA leader",
"armed-group commander"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"cultic ideology of impurity",
"claimed spirit authority and clairvoyance",
"theocratic claims",
"forced child recruitment",
"severe punishment for disloyalty"
],
"organizations": [
"Lord's Resistance Army"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "International Criminal Court, Pre-Trial Chamber III",
"stage": "confirmation of charges in absentia",
"date": "2025-11-06",
"outcome": "The Chamber confirmed 29 charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Confirmation is not a conviction; Kony remains presumed innocent, and a trial cannot proceed unless he appears before the Court."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.icc-cpi.int/case-records?f%5B0%5D=cr_case_code%3A1168",
"archive": "",
"citation": "International Criminal Court, The Prosecutor v. Joseph Kony, Decision on the confirmation of charges in absentia, ICC-02/04-01/05-633 (Nov. 6, 2025).",
"body": "The ICC case register publishes the Pre-Trial Chamber's decision confirming 29 charges against Joseph Kony. The confirmation standard is substantial grounds to believe; it is not a finding of guilt, and Kony remains at large.",
"tier": "international-court",
"kind": "confirmation-of-charges-decision"
},
{
"link": "https://childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/en/the-lords-resistance-army-and-children",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United Nations, Office of the Special Representative for Children and Armed Conflict, 'The Lord's Resistance Army and Children' (June 2, 2012).",
"body": "The UN describes the LRA's forced recruitment of children and says the group maintained cohesion through violence justified by a cultic ideology of impurity, spiritualism promoting Kony's authority and claimed clairvoyance, and severe punishment for disloyalty.",
"tier": "united-nations-finding",
"kind": "institutional-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/warrant-arrest-unsealed-against-five-lra-commanders",
"archive": "",
"citation": "International Criminal Court, 'Warrant of Arrest unsealed against five LRA Commanders' (Oct. 14, 2005).",
"body": "The ICC release records the amended warrant, alleged orders to kill, loot and abduct civilians, and the original 33 counts against Kony. Later confirmation proceedings narrowed the charges to 29.",
"tier": "international-court",
"kind": "arrest-warrant-release"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"spiritualNexus": "This record is retained as context. The cited evidence documents cultic ideology of impurity, claimed spirit authority and clairvoyance, theocratic claims, forced child recruitment, and severe punishment for disloyalty, but does not establish that spiritual doctrine, practice, or authority materially enabled the harm. The relevant recorded role is self-proclaimed prophet, spiritually instructed LRA leader, and armed-group commander.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The Chamber confirmed 29 charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Confirmation is not a conviction; Kony remains presumed innocent, and a trial cannot proceed unless he appears before the Court.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.icc-cpi.int/case-records?f%5B0%5D=cr_case_code%3A1168",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-court; evidentiary role: confirmation-of-charges-decision.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd7206af28c8a644e522b250747b77af4357330641d046c5a984f8e745f54ab1",
"final_url": "https://www.icc-cpi.int/case-records?f%5B0%5D=cr_case_code%3A1168"
},
{
"source": "https://childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/en/the-lords-resistance-army-and-children",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: united-nations-finding; evidentiary role: institutional-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "54955f9de12e2ec8de89ec3522d902073a655517e6be04f62cb04b95e316093a",
"final_url": "https://childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/en/the-lords-resistance-army-and-children"
},
{
"source": "https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/warrant-arrest-unsealed-against-five-lra-commanders",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-court; evidentiary role: arrest-warrant-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "459c96c6da8dcec7f39a984741d7cc5258083dfe366d33f703c046c4a6c44413",
"final_url": "https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/warrant-arrest-unsealed-against-five-lra-commanders"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 134,
"aliases": [
"Moïse",
"Moses"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record is limited to convictions and group-control mechanisms supported by contemporaneous court reporting and a Canadian specialist study. It does not attribute Thériault's conduct to Seventh-day Adventism, Christianity, communal living, Canada or new religious movements generally. Survivor identities and unnecessary details of the violence are omitted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1993-roch-theriault-ant-hill-kids-canada",
"year": 1993,
"place": "Burnt River, Ontario, Canada",
"lat": 44.676,
"lng": -78.696,
"title": "Roch Thériault / Ant Hill Kids: life sentence after spiritual rule, ritualized violence and murder",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed prophet called Moïse",
"founder and absolute leader of the Ant Hill Kids commune"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed representation of God",
"apocalyptic prophecy",
"compulsory confession and isolation",
"control of marriage and sexual relationships",
"violent purification and punishment",
"claimed spiritual and healing authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Ant Hill Kids"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario Court of Justice, Canada",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentence for aggravated assaults",
"date": "1989-10-11",
"outcome": "Thériault and three followers pleaded guilty to assault charges arising from the mutilation of an adult follower; Thériault received twelve years' imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario court, Canada",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence for second-degree murder",
"date": "1993-01-18",
"outcome": "Thériault pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the death of an adult follower and received life imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Thériault presented himself as God's representative and required followers to treat his word as sacred authority. Group rules governed confession, isolation, marriage and sexual relationships; violence was imposed as purification or punishment, and Thériault invoked spiritual and healing authority around acts that led to his assault and murder convictions.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1989-10-12-mn-328-story.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Reuters, 'Canadian Cult's Leader Sentenced in Maiming Case,' Los Angeles Times (Oct. 12, 1989).",
"body": "Contemporaneous wire reporting records the guilty pleas and twelve-year sentence arising from the mutilation of an adult follower at the Ant Hill Kids commune near Burnt River.",
"tier": "international-wire-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://perspective.usherbrooke.ca/bilan/quebec/evenements/21910",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Université de Sherbrooke, Perspective Monde, 'Dévoilement d'un verdict condamnant Rock «Moïse» Thériault à la prison à vie' (Jan. 18, 1993; French; citing contemporaneous La Presse reporting).",
"body": "The university chronology records Thériault's guilty plea to second-degree murder and the Ontario court's life sentence.",
"tier": "university-archive-contemporaneous-report",
"kind": "murder-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://infosecte.org/wp-content/uploads/Kropveld-M.-_-Pelland-M-A.-2006.-The-Cult-Phenomenon-1.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mike Kropveld and Marie-Andrée Pelland, The Cult Phenomenon: How Groups Function, Info-Cult (2006), pp. 49–60.",
"body": "The Canadian specialist study reconstructs the group's history and documents Thériault's sacred self-conception, compulsory confessions, control of marriage and sex, isolation, violent purification practices and resulting criminal proceedings.",
"tier": "specialist-research-monograph",
"kind": "authority-and-coercion-analysis"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1989-10-12-mn-328-story.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-wire-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "252e6ad869223462c91f418229ee2f0b696a084993402b1c5631a29c2a2be588",
"final_url": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1989-10-12-mn-328-story.html"
},
{
"source": "https://perspective.usherbrooke.ca/bilan/quebec/evenements/21910",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: university-archive-contemporaneous-report; evidentiary role: murder-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2e4fc514f12a8402ec7ce639a7f4f01f265cd9ce1e207c4c6139009dfab0da20",
"final_url": "https://perspective.usherbrooke.ca/bilan/quebec/evenements/21910"
},
{
"source": "https://infosecte.org/wp-content/uploads/Kropveld-M.-_-Pelland-M-A.-2006.-The-Cult-Phenomenon-1.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-research-monograph; evidentiary role: authority-and-coercion-analysis.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "582ab305f46f735e42db352bb79fb5a21a20852198cef290e054485f6e9f72ab",
"final_url": "https://infosecte.org/wp-content/uploads/Kropveld-M.-_-Pelland-M-A.-2006.-The-Cult-Phenomenon-1.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 135,
"aliases": [
"Papa Pilgrim",
"Bobby Hale"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record describes one patriarch's adjudicated conduct and his documented use of biblical claims to maintain control. It does not characterize Christianity, homeschooling, wilderness living, large families, Alaska or independent religious practice generally. Survivor names and unnecessary details are omitted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-robert-hale-papa-pilgrim-alaska",
"year": 2007,
"place": "McCarthy, Alaska, USA",
"lat": 61.4333,
"lng": -142.9217,
"title": "Robert Hale / Papa Pilgrim: fourteen-year sentence after Bible-based isolation and coercion",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-declared Christian patriarch",
"sole religious authority over an isolated family community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed biblical duty",
"hell and eternal-judgment threats",
"scriptural justification for violent punishment",
"religious isolation from churches and outside institutions",
"absolute patriarchal control"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Pilgrim family community"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Alaska Superior Court, Palmer, Alaska",
"stage": "no-contest pleas and sentence",
"date": "2007-11-27",
"outcome": "Hale pleaded no contest to consolidated rape, coercion and incest counts and received fourteen years' imprisonment plus probation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Hale claimed biblical authority over an isolated family community, used Scripture to justify punishment and obedience, and threatened dissenting family members with hell or eternal judgment. Sentencing reporting records that he continued invoking religious authority while denying the abuse covered by his pleas.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://alaskapublic.org/xx-statewide-news/2007-11-29/papa-pilgrim-headed-to-prison",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Alaska Public Media, 'Papa Pilgrim headed to prison' (Nov. 28, 2007).",
"body": "The public broadcaster records Hale's fourteen-year sentence, the no-contest pleas to incest, assault and rape, and family testimony describing severe and widespread abuse.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.adn.com/projects/article/papa-pilgrim-gets-14-years-incest-rape-and-coercion/2013/07/12/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Anchorage Daily News, 'Papa Pilgrim gets 14 years for incest, rape and coercion' (contemporaneous sentencing report, republished July 12, 2013).",
"body": "Detailed courtroom reporting records the sentence, plea agreement, judge's findings, Hale's claimed biblical duty, scriptural arguments for punishment and eternal-judgment threats against family members who disclosed abuse.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-record"
},
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2006/12/27/backwoods-celebrity-faces-long-prison-term-for-incest/b99bd9b8-b810-49a9-8996-4598e9638739/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Blaine Harden, 'Backwoods Celebrity Faces Long Prison Term for Incest,' Washington Post (Dec. 27, 2006).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting describes Hale's no-contest pleas, self-presentation as a Bible-directed patriarch and the extreme religious isolation imposed on the family.",
"tier": "national-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://alaskapublic.org/xx-statewide-news/2007-11-29/papa-pilgrim-headed-to-prison",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f9fcc39d477bb527810ad417aa93f52cab2c1b68eb718e6b3099b482a8f5975d",
"final_url": "https://alaskapublic.org/xx-statewide-news/2007-11-29/papa-pilgrim-headed-to-prison"
},
{
"source": "https://www.adn.com/projects/article/papa-pilgrim-gets-14-years-incest-rape-and-coercion/2013/07/12/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "86004f996e36a6bc9f1e27da5eb83ff9305b353b8fb876b9ef7503c774a49d42",
"final_url": "https://www.adn.com/projects/article/papa-pilgrim-gets-14-years-incest-rape-and-coercion/2013/07/12/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2006/12/27/backwoods-celebrity-faces-long-prison-term-for-incest/b99bd9b8-b810-49a9-8996-4598e9638739/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 136,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Shandong High People's Court affirmed the judgments on November 28, 2014. The public record cited here does not independently reconstruct the later mandatory death-sentence review or execution proceedings."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The defendants used the name 'Almighty God,' but later scholarship disputes whether their small group belonged to the larger Church of Almighty God, which denied any connection. This record therefore does not assign the crime to that church, its founders or its members. Chinese state records are paired with independent contemporaneous reporting and the attribution dispute is preserved rather than resolved by inference.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-zhaoyuan-almighty-god-group-murder-china",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Zhaoyuan, Shandong, China",
"lat": 37.3553,
"lng": 120.4341,
"title": "Zhaoyuan 'Almighty God' group: murder convictions after defendants called a stranger a demon",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-doomsday-apocalyptic",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leaders and members of a small self-described religious group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"demon labeling",
"claimed divine identity and authority",
"religiously authorized group violence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [
"Zhaoyuan group self-identifying with the name 'Almighty God'"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Yantai Intermediate People's Court, Shandong, China",
"stage": "first-instance criminal judgment",
"date": "2014-10-11",
"outcome": "Five defendants were convicted of intentional homicide; two received death sentences, one life imprisonment, and two fixed prison terms. Three also received convictions under China's anti-cult law."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Shandong High People's Court, China",
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2014-11-28",
"outcome": "The court rejected all five appeals and upheld the first-instance judgments, referring the two death sentences for mandatory review."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The convicted group described its leaders in divine terms and labeled the person it killed a demon. The court found that the group's religious beliefs and anti-cult offense were directly connected to the fatal collective violence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/8412.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme People's Court of the People's Republic of China, 'Zhaoyuan cult-related intentional-homicide appeal judgment upholds original verdict' (Nov. 29, 2014; Chinese).",
"body": "The official court release records the first-instance convictions and sentences, the issues raised on appeal and the Shandong High People's Court's decision affirming the judgments.",
"tier": "supreme-court-official-release",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ecoi.net/en/document/1340811.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BBC News, 'The Chinese cult that kills demons' (Aug. 13, 2014), archived by ecoi.net.",
"body": "Contemporaneous BBC reporting records the group's self-description, demon labeling, recruitment context and the defendants' own explanations before trial.",
"tier": "international-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "authority-and-belief-context"
},
{
"link": "https://academic.oup.com/book/36596/chapter-abstract/321570124",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Massimo Introvigne, 'Fake News: The McDonald's Murder of 2014,' in Inside The Church of Almighty God (Oxford University Press, 2020).",
"body": "The later scholarly review distinguishes the convicted Zhaoyuan group from the larger Church of Almighty God and documents why institutional attribution remains disputed.",
"tier": "academic-monograph",
"kind": "attribution-review"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Shandong High People's Court affirmed the judgments on November 28, 2014. The public record cited here does not independently reconstruct the later mandatory death-sentence review or execution proceedings."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/8412.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: supreme-court-official-release; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aaee175902ab1860b3a6704f5ff04892971bba8b00947240e345b309b5f1b97f",
"final_url": "https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/8412.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ecoi.net/en/document/1340811.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: authority-and-belief-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bd71e1544dc45f137fa76cae3a13efee886714e713e43b140ab509f0c3d70f81",
"final_url": "https://www.ecoi.net/en/document/1340811.html"
},
{
"source": "https://academic.oup.com/book/36596/chapter-abstract/321570124",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: academic-monograph; evidentiary role: attribution-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 137,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Yle reported on December 12, 2025 that the district-court judgment was not yet final. No later appellate disposition was located during this audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Finnish proceedings protected the identities of the defendant and adult complainants, so this record does the same. It reports only counts of conviction, expressly notes the rejected charges and preserves the non-final posture. The case concerns one authority figure and an unnamed community, not Finnish Christians, faith movements, prophecy, marriage or exorcism generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-unnamed-faith-movement-prophet-hameenlinna-finland",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Hämeenlinna region, Finland",
"lat": 60.9959,
"lng": 24.4643,
"title": "Hämeenlinna faith-movement 'prophet': first-instance convictions for sexual abuse, violence and extortion",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented prophet with strong authority in a close religious community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine authority",
"exorcism through shouting and hitting",
"religiously directed separation from spouses",
"plural-marriage claims",
"Antichrist and spiritual-consequence threats",
"claimed divine command for extortion"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"religious-marriage-family",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed Finnish faith-movement community"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kanta-Häme District Court, Finland",
"stage": "first-instance criminal judgment",
"date": "2025-12-12",
"outcome": "The court convicted the unnamed defendant of thirteen sexual-abuse offenses, two assaults and extortion and imposed three years and four months' imprisonment. It rejected separate aggravated-rape and rape counts. The judgment was not final when reported."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The district court's public summary found that the defendant systematically presented himself as possessing divine authority when it served his aims. It connected that authority to exorcistic violence, directions that adults leave spouses, claims of plural marriage, and an extortion demand framed as release from the Antichrist.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://yle.fi/a/74-20199348",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Yle, 'Man described as religious-sect prophet convicted of numerous sexual offenses in Kanta-Häme District Court' (Dec. 12, 2025; Finnish).",
"body": "Finland's public broadcaster reports from the court's public summary, including the precise convictions and rejected counts, sentence, non-final status, authority findings, exorcism violence, plural-marriage claims and extortion framed as divine command and release from the Antichrist.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "first-instance-judgment-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Yle reported on December 12, 2025 that the district-court judgment was not yet final. No later appellate disposition was located during this audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://yle.fi/a/74-20199348",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: first-instance-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f06c2745f24e70d3c89ee7d44cc9950a2e3c7a51b456d17651b4f3a70744da32",
"final_url": "https://yle.fi/a/74-20199348"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 138,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record reports the four guilty-plea counts and separately identifies the charges considered only for sentencing. It omits survivor identities and does not attribute the defendant's conduct to Islam, Singaporeans, spiritual healing, exorcism, massage or people seeking help generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-ab-razak-spiritual-healer-singapore",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Singapore",
"lat": 1.3521,
"lng": 103.8198,
"title": "Ab Razak Ab Hameed: fifteen-month sentence for abuse during claimed protection and exorcism rituals",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented spiritual healer and exorcist"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed protection from black magic",
"possession diagnosis",
"exorcism pretext",
"instructions to close eyes and isolate from an accompanying relative",
"nonconsensual recording"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "State Courts of Singapore",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentence",
"date": "2020-07-09",
"outcome": "Ab Razak pleaded guilty to two molestation counts and two counts of insulting modesty and received fifteen months' imprisonment; five similar charges involving two other complainants were considered at sentencing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ab Razak claimed he could protect one adult from black magic and exorcise possession from another. He used those diagnoses and ritual instructions to obtain isolation, closed eyes and access to exposed bodies before the offenses covered by his guilty pleas.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/15-months-jail-for-spiritual-healer-who-molested-two-women-under-pretext-of",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Straits Times, '15 months' jail for spiritual healer who molested two women under pretext of performing rituals' (July 9, 2020).",
"body": "Detailed sentencing reporting records the guilty pleas, sentence, additional charges taken into consideration, black-magic protection claim, possession diagnosis, exorcism instructions and nonconsensual recording.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/15-months-jail-for-spiritual-healer-who-molested-two-women-under-pretext-of",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "787cf1c36db3b8254610edc5f982aa49a82d2824b129eb32cd374c490dd71a90",
"final_url": "https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/15-months-jail-for-spiritual-healer-who-molested-two-women-under-pretext-of"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 139,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant and survivor remain unnamed. The record concerns an adjudicated misuse of an invited healing role, not Islam, imams, Quranic recitation, Dubai, Egyptians or people seeking religious care generally. No appellate disposition was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-unnamed-imam-quranic-healing-dubai",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Dubai, United Arab Emirates",
"lat": 25.2048,
"lng": 55.2708,
"title": "Unnamed imam: three-month sentence for assault during Quranic healing",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam invited to perform Quranic healing"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"Quranic-healing pretext",
"religious authority in a private home",
"temporary isolation from the accompanying spouse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Dubai Criminal Court, United Arab Emirates",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2017-07-15",
"outcome": "The court convicted the unnamed imam of sexual assault, imposed three months' imprisonment and ordered deportation after sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant was invited into a family home specifically to recite Quranic healing verses for an ill adult. The court found that he committed the assault while occupying that healing and religious-authority role and while the accompanying spouse was briefly absent.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thenationalnews.com/uae/imam-jailed-for-molesting-ill-woman-while-her-husband-was-in-toilet-1.608939",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The National, 'Imam jailed for molesting ill woman while her husband was in toilet' (July 15, 2017).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the Dubai Criminal Court conviction, three-month sentence, deportation order and the Quranic-healing setting in which the assault occurred.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thenationalnews.com/uae/imam-jailed-for-molesting-ill-woman-while-her-husband-was-in-toilet-1.608939",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "85c064160e1e7200e99e91f78cfe153ee9756ab3e76a847a6ae9f4a0e463587f",
"final_url": "https://www.thenationalnews.com/uae/imam-jailed-for-molesting-ill-woman-while-her-husband-was-in-toilet-1.608939"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 140,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Kerala High Court expressly affirmed one rape conviction and expressly acquitted Madhavan in the two jointly decided cases. This record does not describe the reversed counts as convictions."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The appellate result is mixed. One conviction and eight-year sentence were affirmed; two convictions were reversed for an evidentiary error. The record concerns Madhavan's proven conduct and authority over a residential charity, not Hinduism, tantra, astrology, priests, charities or Kerala generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-santhosh-madhavan-kerala-india",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Kochi, Kerala, India",
"lat": 9.9312,
"lng": 76.2673,
"title": "Santhosh Madhavan / Swami Amritha Chaithanya: Kerala High Court affirms one rape conviction",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented tantric priest and astrologer",
"head of a charitable trust and residential home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru and priestly authority",
"residential control",
"financial dependency",
"threatened release of recordings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Santhitheeram Trust"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "V Additional Sessions Court, Ernakulam, Kerala",
"stage": "criminal convictions and sentences",
"date": "2009-05-20",
"outcome": "The trial court convicted Madhavan in three sessions cases and imposed eight-year rape sentences."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Kerala High Court",
"stage": "criminal appeals 1599 and 1630 of 2009",
"date": "2013-12-19",
"outcome": "The High Court affirmed the conviction and eight-year sentence in S.C. 368 of 2008, but set aside the convictions in S.C. 369 and 429 of 2008 because the trial judge had improperly supplied the decisive identification evidence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The High Court described Madhavan as a self-made tantric priest and astrologer who wielded influence, ran the residential trust where the child lived, and used that privileged position to obtain access. The surviving conviction concerned a child under the care of his trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://indiankanoon.org/doc/144341201/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kerala High Court, Santhosh Madhavan @ Swami Amritha Chaithanya v. State, Criminal Appeal Nos. 1599 and 1630 of 2009 (Dec. 19, 2013).",
"body": "The appellate judgment records the trust and spiritual-authority setting, the trial dispositions, the evidence, the affirmed conviction in S.C. 368 of 2008 and the acquittals in S.C. 369 and 429 of 2008.",
"tier": "court-judgment-reproduction",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Kerala High Court expressly affirmed one rape conviction and expressly acquitted Madhavan in the two jointly decided cases. This record does not describe the reversed counts as convictions."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://indiankanoon.org/doc/144341201/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-judgment-reproduction; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 141,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Criminal Appeal No. 1756 of 2019 remains pending in the Gujarat High Court. The May 4, 2026 order addressed suspension of sentence rather than finally deciding the appeal."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record reports the trial convictions and the pending appeal. It does not treat the 2026 suspension-of-sentence ruling as an appellate affirmance. It concerns one convicted guru and the ashram authority described in the court record, not Hindu devotees, ashrams, religious discourse, Gujarat or India generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-narayan-sai-surat-india",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Surat, Gujarat, India",
"lat": 21.1702,
"lng": 72.8311,
"title": "Narayan Sai: life sentences after convictions involving a devotee and ashram administrator",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"guru and religious-discourse leader",
"ashram authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"devotional authority",
"assignment to ashram work and administration",
"isolation in private ashram quarters",
"family devotion and fear of reporting"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jahangirpura and related ashrams associated with Asaram and Narayan Sai"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "2nd Additional Sessions Judge, Surat, Gujarat",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2019-04-30",
"outcome": "The court convicted Narayan Sai under seven Penal Code provisions, including rape and abuse of authority, and imposed concurrent life sentences on the principal sexual-offense counts."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Gujarat High Court",
"stage": "fifth application to suspend sentence pending appeal",
"date": "2026-05-04",
"outcome": "The High Court recorded the convictions and sentence while considering a fifth suspension application in Criminal Appeal No. 1756 of 2019. The merits appeal remained pending."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Gujarat High Court's 2026 order records that the complainant's family were devotees who attended religious discourses, that Sai directed her to travel for ashram construction and administration, and that the proven offenses occurred after she was called into private quarters at ashrams. The court record also describes the family's devotion as a reason she feared reporting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2026/05/05/crma42025gjhc2405335820196404052026-671988.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Gujarat High Court, Narayan @ Narayan Sai v. State of Gujarat, Criminal Misc. Application No. 4 of 2025 in Criminal Appeal No. 1756 of 2019 (May 4, 2026).",
"body": "The signed court-order reproduction records the 2019 convictions and concurrent sentences, the devotee and ashram setting, the pending appeal and the procedural posture of the fifth application to suspend sentence.",
"tier": "court-order-reproduction",
"kind": "appellate-procedural-order"
},
{
"link": "https://webapi.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2021/17568/17568_2021_34_1502_30740_Judgement_20-Oct-2021.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of India, State of Gujarat v. Narayan @ Narayan Sai, Criminal Appeal No. 1159 of 2021 (Oct. 20, 2021).",
"body": "The Supreme Court judgment independently records Sai's conviction and life sentence while deciding a challenge concerning furlough. It does not decide the merits appeal from the conviction.",
"tier": "supreme-court-judgment",
"kind": "post-conviction-procedural-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Criminal Appeal No. 1756 of 2019 remains pending in the Gujarat High Court. The May 4, 2026 order addressed suspension of sentence rather than finally deciding the appeal."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2026/05/05/crma42025gjhc2405335820196404052026-671988.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-order-reproduction; evidentiary role: appellate-procedural-order.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d257800a4a02181f666de93aa5caf43933363ec761d1f3d1d0dc40ced2382fca",
"final_url": "https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2026/05/05/crma42025gjhc2405335820196404052026-671988.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://webapi.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2021/17568/17568_2021_34_1502_30740_Judgement_20-Oct-2021.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: supreme-court-judgment; evidentiary role: post-conviction-procedural-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 142,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Rajasthan High Court rejected suspension of sentence in September 2020. No final merits disposition of the criminal appeal was located during this audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The trial conviction is established by contemporaneous court reporting and later High Court reporting, but a public copy of the trial judgment was not located. The record states that the merits appeal remained unresolved in the sources reviewed and does not generalize from this defendant to Hinduism, gurus, ashrams or Rajasthan.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-falahari-baba-alwar-india",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Alwar, Rajasthan, India",
"lat": 27.553,
"lng": 76.6346,
"title": "Falahari Baba: life sentence for rape of a disciple in his ashram",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious guru",
"ashram head",
"family spiritual adviser"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"disciple relationship",
"private initiation and worship pretext",
"isolation in private quarters",
"religious instruction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Madhusudan Seva Ashram"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Additional District and Sessions Court, Alwar, Rajasthan",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"date": "2018-09-26",
"outcome": "The court convicted Kaushlendra Prapannacharya, known as Falahari Baba, and imposed life imprisonment and a fine."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Rajasthan High Court",
"stage": "application to suspend sentence",
"date": "2020-09-08",
"outcome": "A division bench rejected his request to suspend the life sentence while the appeal was pending."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Court reporting records that the adult complainant's family were disciples, that she went to the ashram at her family's direction to offer her first earnings, and that the guru isolated her after describing a private worship or initiation act through which he would impart spiritual knowledge.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ndtv.in/rajasthan-news/alwar-court-has-pronounced-life-imprisonment-for-self-styled-godman-falahari-baba-in-a-rape-case-1922799",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NDTV India / Press Trust of India, 'Alwar court sentences self-styled godman Falahari Baba to life imprisonment in rape case' (Sept. 26, 2018; Hindi).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the conviction, life sentence, fine, disciple relationship and ashram setting.",
"tier": "national-news-agency-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/jaipur/court-rejects-petition-to-suspend-life-term-of-rape-convict-baba/articleshow/78005969.cms",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Times of India, 'Rajasthan high court rejects petition to suspend life term of rape convict Falahari Baba' (Sept. 9, 2020).",
"body": "The report records the Rajasthan High Court's refusal to suspend the sentence, confirms the underlying life term and identifies the pending appellate posture.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-appellate-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-procedural-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.aajtak.in/crime/big-crime/story/alwar-court-judgment-rapist-baba-falahari-life-imprisonment-jail-566755-2018-09-28",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Aaj Tak, 'Falahari Baba convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment' (Sept. 28, 2018; Hindi).",
"body": "Detailed contemporaneous reporting describes the family disciple relationship and the claimed private worship and guru-knowledge pretext used to isolate the complainant.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "nexus-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Rajasthan High Court rejected suspension of sentence in September 2020. No final merits disposition of the criminal appeal was located during this audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ndtv.in/rajasthan-news/alwar-court-has-pronounced-life-imprisonment-for-self-styled-godman-falahari-baba-in-a-rape-case-1922799",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/jaipur/court-rejects-petition-to-suspend-life-term-of-rape-convict-baba/articleshow/78005969.cms",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-appellate-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-procedural-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "75585f78223f396b39ebaa689d9a7b3ff717b0744f7bd18b692b83c49f3744a2",
"final_url": "https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/jaipur/court-rejects-petition-to-suspend-life-term-of-rape-convict-baba/articleshow/78005969.cms"
},
{
"source": "https://www.aajtak.in/crime/big-crime/story/alwar-court-judgment-rapist-baba-falahari-life-imprisonment-jail-566755-2018-09-28",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: nexus-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "93edcccd7a1c5e66c0e28126fa3fc2acb778f946edd082c6577b9731af86847a",
"final_url": "https://www.aajtak.in/crime/big-crime/story/alwar-court-judgment-rapist-baba-falahari-life-imprisonment-jail-566755-2018-09-28"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 143,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The sources establish church-based access and a youth-pastor trust role, but do not report that Teague invoked a specific doctrine or ritual. This record therefore describes institutional and pastoral access rather than a theological pretext, and does not attribute his conduct to the unnamed church, youth pastors or Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-isaiah-teague-meridian-idaho-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Meridian, ID, USA",
"lat": 43.6121,
"lng": -116.3915,
"title": "Isaiah Teague: life sentence after abuse of a child he met as a youth pastor",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor",
"trusted church and family authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"church-based access",
"pastoral trust",
"incremental grooming",
"threatened disappearance if the abuse was disclosed"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed Meridian church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Idaho Fourth Judicial District Court, Ada County",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence, case CR01-25-20343",
"date": "2026-02-03",
"outcome": "Teague pleaded guilty to felony lewd conduct with a child under sixteen and received life imprisonment with parole eligibility after twenty years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The local court report identifies Teague as the child's youth pastor and a trusted family friend who met her through church. That pastoral position created the access and moral trust he then exploited while grooming and threatening her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.idoc.idaho.gov/content/prisons/resident-client-search/details/164530",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Idaho Department of Correction, resident record for Isaiah David Teague, IDOC no. 164530 (accessed July 16, 2026).",
"body": "The official custody record identifies Ada County case CR01-25-20343, the lewd-conduct offense, life sentence and June 2045 parole-eligibility date.",
"tier": "official-corrections-record",
"kind": "sentence-record"
},
{
"link": "https://www.idahostatesman.com/news/local/crime/article314566085.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Idaho Statesman, 'A Meridian youth pastor sexually assaulted a teen. Here's his prison sentence' (Feb. 3, 2026).",
"body": "Detailed local court reporting identifies the youth-pastor and church-access relationship, guilty plea, life sentence, minimum twenty-year term, grooming and threats.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.eastidahonews.com/2026/02/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-for-sexually-abusing-teenage-girl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "EastIdahoNews.com, 'Former youth pastor sentenced for sexually abusing teenage girl' (Feb. 4, 2026).",
"body": "Independent local reporting, citing the Ada County Prosecutor's Office, corroborates the plea, sentence, pastoral trust, church connection and threat evidence.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.idoc.idaho.gov/content/prisons/resident-client-search/details/164530",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-corrections-record; evidentiary role: sentence-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5293ab9a598fd92d03538cb32c9167655ab7fffe76866b2ec9dda955bb25d6bd",
"final_url": "https://www.idoc.idaho.gov/content/prisons/resident-client-search/details/164530"
},
{
"source": "https://www.idahostatesman.com/news/local/crime/article314566085.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.eastidahonews.com/2026/02/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-for-sexually-abusing-teenage-girl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a8f80eef4f38fb3f80a5e967955966e3b8843259afac74b19fddc839ba16b470",
"final_url": "https://www.eastidahonews.com/2026/02/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-for-sexually-abusing-teenage-girl/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 144,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The action ended by settlement after the published summary-judgment ruling; the settlement included no admission of liability."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This is an institutional civil event, not a criminal conviction of the congregation or elders. The settlement contained no admission of liability. The record concerns one Delaware congregation's handling of one report and does not attribute that conduct to every Jehovah's Witness, elder or congregation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-laurel-jehovahs-witness-reporting-delaware-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Laurel, DE, USA",
"lat": 38.5565,
"lng": -75.5713,
"title": "Laurel congregation: Delaware court rejects automatic clergy-privilege defense to child-abuse reporting action",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregation elders conducting internal religious discipline"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"internal elder adjudication",
"disfellowshipping of both the adult and child",
"failure to make a mandatory report",
"claimed clergy-penitent privilege"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Laurel Delaware Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of Delaware",
"stage": "summary-judgment opinion, C.A. No. N14C-05-122 MMJ",
"date": "2016-01-26",
"outcome": "The court denied the defendants' motion for summary judgment and held that communications about abuse were not automatically exempt from mandatory reporting as sacramental confession."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of Delaware",
"stage": "settlement and compliance affidavit",
"date": "2018-01-10",
"outcome": "The congregation and elders settled without admitting liability, paid civil penalties and costs, agreed to child-protection training and agreed that abuse communications involving children would not be treated as privileged confession."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The state action arose after congregation elders learned through an internal religious process that an adult member had sexual contact with a child member, questioned the parties, and disfellowshipped both. The court addressed whether that elder process displaced the statutory duty to report, and the later affidavit changed how the congregation would classify abuse disclosures.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/delaware/superior-court/2016/n14c-05-122-mmj.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Superior Court of Delaware, State v. Laurel Delaware Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses, C.A. No. N14C-05-122 MMJ (Jan. 26, 2016).",
"body": "The published opinion states the facts of the elders' internal process, the mandatory-reporting action, the claimed confession privilege and the denial of summary judgment.",
"tier": "court-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "civil-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.jwchildabuse.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Laurel-Congregation-Settlement-Redacted.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Laurel Delaware Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses, redacted settlement agreement and compliance affidavit (Jan. 10, 2018).",
"body": "The filed-document reproduction records the no-admission settlement, civil payments, training requirement and affidavit governing future treatment of abuse communications involving children.",
"tier": "filed-settlement-reproduction",
"kind": "civil-settlement"
},
{
"link": "https://www.delawarepublic.org/delaware-headlines/2015-08-05/lawsuit-accuses-delaware-church-of-hiding-child-sex-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Delaware Public Media, 'Lawsuit accuses Delaware church of hiding child sex abuse' (Aug. 5, 2015).",
"body": "Contemporaneous local reporting identifies the state enforcement action and the underlying adult member's separate conviction and six-year sentence.",
"tier": "public-radio-court-reporting",
"kind": "contemporaneous-context"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The action ended by settlement after the published summary-judgment ruling; the settlement included no admission of liability."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/delaware/superior-court/2016/n14c-05-122-mmj.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: civil-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.jwchildabuse.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Laurel-Congregation-Settlement-Redacted.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: filed-settlement-reproduction; evidentiary role: civil-settlement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5158cb02501846bac842fd2d54258ad932786f001eefd330b11b93f5e8852b38",
"final_url": "https://www.jwchildabuse.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Laurel-Congregation-Settlement-Redacted.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.delawarepublic.org/delaware-headlines/2015-08-05/lawsuit-accuses-delaware-church-of-hiding-child-sex-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-radio-court-reporting; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "601ce97dbf25c484185d111ee9e038e71ccb470178e28762371c5834b15915af",
"final_url": "https://www.delawarepublic.org/delaware-headlines/2015-08-05/lawsuit-accuses-delaware-church-of-hiding-child-sex-abuse"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 145,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Iowa Supreme Court affirmed the convictions and sentence in all material respects, remanding only for an in-camera records review and restitution proceedings. After that review, the Iowa Court of Appeals affirmed that the records contained no exculpatory evidence. The three sexual-abuse acquittals remain distinct from the five affirmed sexual-exploitation convictions."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Edouard was acquitted of three third-degree sexual-abuse charges and convicted of five sexual-exploitation offenses; this record preserves both outcomes. The convictions rested on the proven counseling relationships, not on ordinary consensual relations between adults or general spiritual advice. It does not attribute his conduct to the congregation, Reformed churches, pastoral counseling or Christianity generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-patrick-edouard-pella-iowa-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Pella, IA, USA",
"lat": 41.408,
"lng": -92.9164,
"title": "Patrick Edouard: five convictions for sexual exploitation through pastoral counseling",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"pastoral counselor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counseling",
"targeting congregants during personal crises",
"claims of divine purpose",
"threats that disclosure would destroy the church and families",
"rehearsed denials"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Covenant Reformed Church in Pella"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Iowa District Court for Marion County, trial transferred to Dallas County",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2012-08-24",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Edouard on four counts of sexual exploitation by a counselor or therapist and one pattern-or-practice count. It acquitted him on three third-degree sexual-abuse charges. The court imposed four consecutive one-year terms and a concurrent five-year term."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Iowa",
"stage": "further review, No. 12-1899",
"date": "2014-07-18",
"outcome": "The court vacated an intermediate appellate reversal, affirmed the convictions and sentence except for a limited remand to review confidential records and recalculate restitution."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Iowa Court of Appeals",
"stage": "post-remand appeal, No. 15-0128",
"date": "2016-02-10",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the trial court's determination that the reviewed records contained no exculpatory evidence warranting a new trial."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Iowa Supreme Court found sufficient evidence that Edouard used pastoral counseling to address congregants' infertility, grief, marital problems, childhood abuse and other vulnerabilities before sexual contact. The opinion records his claims that God had brought one relationship together, his warning that disclosure would destroy the church, and his use of pastoral credibility to demand secrecy and rehearse denials.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/iowa/supreme-court/2014/121899.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Iowa, State v. Edouard, 854 N.W.2d 421, No. 12-1899 (July 18, 2014).",
"body": "The published appellate opinion records the five guilty verdicts, three acquittals, sentence, pastoral-counseling evidence, authority nexus and limited remand while affirming the convictions and sentence in all other respects.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/iowa/court-of-appeals/2016/15-0128.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Iowa Court of Appeals, State v. Edouard, No. 15-0128 (Feb. 10, 2016).",
"body": "The post-remand opinion affirms that the confidential-record review found no exculpatory evidence and explains why the counseling relationship, rather than a formal diagnosis, controlled the sexual-exploitation analysis.",
"tier": "state-appellate-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "post-remand-appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Iowa Supreme Court affirmed the convictions and sentence in all material respects, remanding only for an in-camera records review and restitution proceedings. After that review, the Iowa Court of Appeals affirmed that the records contained no exculpatory evidence. The three sexual-abuse acquittals remain distinct from the five affirmed sexual-exploitation convictions."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/iowa/supreme-court/2014/121899.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/iowa/court-of-appeals/2016/15-0128.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-appellate-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: post-remand-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 146,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The public sources reviewed establish the two jury convictions but did not provide a final sentencing document or later appellate disposition, so this record does not state an unverified sentence or appellate result. It concerns one pastor's use of a deliverance claim and does not attribute his conduct to the church's members, Liberian Christians, deliverance ministries or Christianity generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-meally-freeman-brooklyn-center-minnesota-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Brooklyn Center, MN, USA",
"lat": 45.0761,
"lng": -93.3327,
"title": "Meally Morris Freeman: two convictions after a purported deliverance session",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"spiritual father"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"purported deliverance and exorcism",
"private spiritual-guidance session",
"prayer and anointing oil",
"induced trance-like or unconscious state"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Grace Mountaineer Tabernacle Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hennepin County District Court, Minnesota",
"stage": "criminal complaint, court file 27-CR-18-11806",
"date": "2018-05-08",
"outcome": "The filed complaint charged two counts of third-degree criminal sexual conduct during private religious or spiritual advice."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Hennepin County District Court, Minnesota",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "2018-10-01",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Freeman on both third-degree criminal-sexual-conduct counts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The filed complaint and prosecutor's verdict release state that the complainant regarded Freeman as her pastor and spiritual father, sought spiritual guidance, and was told she required a private deliverance session to remove a demon. Prayer, oil and the claimed exorcism structured the encounter in which the jury found the criminal conduct occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.hennepinattorney.org/news/news/2018/October/freeman-10-3-2018",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Hennepin County Attorney's Office, 'Jury finds Brooklyn Center pastor guilty of sexual assault' (Oct. 3, 2018).",
"body": "The official prosecutor release records both guilty verdicts and describes the pastoral relationship, request for spiritual guidance, purported deliverance session, exorcism claim and use of oil during prayer.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "criminal-verdict"
},
{
"link": "https://www.hennepinattorney.org/-/media/cao/news/2018/oct-dec/freeman-10-3-18.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State of Minnesota v. Meally Morris Freeman, criminal complaint, Hennepin County District Court file 27-CR-18-11806 (May 8, 2018).",
"body": "The filed complaint identifies the two clergy-specific charges and alleges that the conduct occurred during private meetings in which religious or spiritual advice, aid or comfort was sought or received.",
"tier": "filed-criminal-complaint",
"kind": "charging-document"
},
{
"link": "https://www.startribune.com/brooklyn-center-pastor-convicted-of-sexual-assault-under-the-guise-of-exorcism/495094551",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Minnesota Star Tribune, 'Brooklyn Center pastor convicted of sexual assault under the guise of exorcism' (Oct. 3, 2018).",
"body": "Minnesota's statewide newspaper independently corroborates the two verdicts and the deliverance, exorcism, prayer and spiritual-father evidence presented at trial.",
"tier": "state-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.hennepinattorney.org/news/news/2018/October/freeman-10-3-2018",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: criminal-verdict.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "40943cd70c1107e3961f077a875055075210b1d4f8212fa4b9f4da875eaab6bf",
"final_url": "https://www.hennepinattorney.org/news/news/2018/October/freeman-10-3-2018"
},
{
"source": "https://www.hennepinattorney.org/-/media/cao/news/2018/oct-dec/freeman-10-3-18.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: filed-criminal-complaint; evidentiary role: charging-document.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "96a1d745d630ad5f64824f6ee2a683459d85778c1a5d3f647648a5901398717f",
"final_url": "https://www.hennepinattorney.org/-/media/cao/news/2018/oct-dec/freeman-10-3-18.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.startribune.com/brooklyn-center-pastor-convicted-of-sexual-assault-under-the-guise-of-exorcism/495094551",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 147,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Talbot's Maine guilty pleas and the specific priestly and sacramental authority documented in the cited sources. His separate Massachusetts conviction and other allegations are not counted as Maine convictions here. The record does not attribute his conduct to St. Jude parishioners, Jesuits, Catholic priests or Catholics generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-james-talbot-freeport-maine-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Freeport, ME, USA",
"lat": 43.857,
"lng": -70.1031,
"title": "James Talbot: guilty pleas for abuse during religious instruction at a Maine church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Jesuit priest",
"substitute parish priest",
"religious instructor and sacramental authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"family trust in priestly authority",
"religious instruction",
"control over first communion and confirmation",
"isolation in church rooms"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of Jesus",
"St. Jude Church in Freeport"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Maine Superior Court, Cumberland County",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentence",
"date": "2018-09-24",
"outcome": "Talbot pleaded guilty to gross sexual assault and unlawful sexual contact. The court imposed ten years with all but three years suspended on the first count and a concurrent three-year term on the second."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The criminal disposition and related court record place the abuse within Talbot's religious instruction of a child whose family trusted him as their priest. Talbot had married the child's parents, baptized the child, administered first communion, and controlled access to confirmation; the reported incident occurred after he removed the child from confirmation class to a room behind the altar.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bangordailynews.com/2018/09/24/news/former-maine-priest-pleads-guilty-to-sex-assault-of-boy-confronted-by-victim-in-court/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bangor Daily News, 'Former Maine priest pleads guilty to sexual assault of boy, confronted by victim in court' (Sept. 24, 2018).",
"body": "Detailed contemporaneous court reporting records both guilty pleas, the ten-year sentence with all but three years suspended, the concurrent term, and the priestly, sacramental and confirmation-class authority nexus.",
"tier": "state-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.mainepublic.org/maine/2018-09-24/former-priest-sent-to-prison-again-for-child-sexual-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Maine Public / Associated Press, 'Former Priest Sent To Prison Again For Child Sexual Abuse' (Sept. 24, 2018).",
"body": "Maine's public broadcaster and the Associated Press independently corroborate the two pleas, three-year unsuspended term, parish setting, family relationship and offer of religious instruction.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-news-agency-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/maine/superior-court/2016/cumcv-16-74.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Maine Superior Court, Wheeler v. Northeast Province of the Society of Jesus, CUM-CV-16-74 (Aug. 12, 2016).",
"body": "The published pre-plea civil opinion identifies Talbot, the St. Jude setting, the child's age and the institutional parties. It is used for identity and setting, not as proof of the later criminal disposition.",
"tier": "state-court-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "civil-procedural-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bangordailynews.com/2018/09/24/news/former-maine-priest-pleads-guilty-to-sex-assault-of-boy-confronted-by-victim-in-court/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "19328a0d8eec4619412ca5d91005ce5f90b39604b63cb336b7a236648d412740",
"final_url": "https://www.bangordailynews.com/2018/09/24/news/former-maine-priest-pleads-guilty-to-sex-assault-of-boy-confronted-by-victim-in-court/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.mainepublic.org/maine/2018-09-24/former-priest-sent-to-prison-again-for-child-sexual-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-news-agency-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9eac64f202b10d857d40a30205879d44713f45a4c750bc84cfac18fc47cdd4e6",
"final_url": "https://www.mainepublic.org/maine/2018-09-24/former-priest-sent-to-prison-again-for-child-sexual-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/maine/superior-court/2016/cumcv-16-74.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-court-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: civil-procedural-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 148,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction and sentence on October 8, 2024."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The conviction concerned one proven fondling count involving one child; the opinion also recounts another student's testimony but does not identify a separate conviction arising from it. This record does not attribute Lepard's conduct or the reporting sequence to the congregation, Pentecostals, youth pastors, Sunday-school teachers or Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-marcus-lepard-thomastown-mississippi-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Thomastown, MS, USA",
"lat": 32.8651,
"lng": -89.6817,
"title": "Marcus Lepard: conviction affirmed after Sunday-school access was used to groom a child",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor",
"Sunday-school teacher",
"trusted religious mentor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"Sunday-school instruction used as sexualized teaching",
"orders to keep class discussions secret",
"church-conference access",
"family trust in a religious mentor",
"internal church investigation before reporting"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Wake Forest Pentecostal Church in Thomastown"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Leake County Circuit Court, Mississippi",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2022-09-19",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Lepard of touching a child for a lustful purpose. The court imposed fifteen years with three years suspended and twelve years to serve, followed by three years of post-release supervision and sex-offender registration."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Mississippi Court of Appeals",
"stage": "direct appeal, No. 2022-KA-01159-COA",
"date": "2024-10-08",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the conviction and sentence, rejecting challenges to the jury instruction and indictment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The appellate opinion identifies Lepard as a youth pastor and the child's Sunday-school teacher. He turned boys' Sunday school into purported sexual instruction, told students not to discuss it, obtained family permission for private contact through his mentor role, and used a men's church conference as another access point. The family first sought the church pastor's internal response and reported to law enforcement after receiving the pastor's approval.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/mississippi/court-of-appeals/2024/2022-ka-01159-coa.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mississippi Court of Appeals, Lepard v. State, No. 2022-KA-01159-COA (Oct. 8, 2024).",
"body": "The published appellate opinion records the conviction, sentence and affirmance and details how Sunday-school teaching, secrecy, conference access, mentorship and internal church handling formed the authority and access nexus.",
"tier": "state-appellate-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction and sentence on October 8, 2024."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/mississippi/court-of-appeals/2024/2022-ka-01159-coa.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-appellate-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 149,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns five federal convictions and four victims identified only by age range in the public source. It does not infer a denomination or claim a doctrinal pretext absent from the record. McKay's conduct is not attributed to Fort Leonard Wood personnel, Army religious programs, youth ministers or Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-david-mckay-fort-leonard-wood-missouri-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Fort Leonard Wood, MO, USA",
"lat": 37.7057,
"lng": -92.1572,
"title": "David J. McKay: thirty-year sentence for abuse enabled through a military youth ministry",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth ministry director for the Religious Services Office",
"adult youth-group leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"youth-ministry access",
"religious-program trust",
"transport of minors",
"youth-group ski and camping trips",
"abuse in ministry and residential settings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Fort Leonard Wood Religious Services Office youth ministry"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri",
"stage": "guilty plea",
"date": "2021-04-29",
"outcome": "McKay pleaded guilty to one count of transporting a minor across state lines to engage in criminal sexual activity and four counts of sexually abusing a minor."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2022-02-04",
"outcome": "The court sentenced McKay to thirty years in federal prison without parole, followed by lifetime supervised release."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Justice Department identifies McKay as the youth ministry director for Fort Leonard Wood's Religious Services Office. He met the four children through the youth group and used the ministry's recurring activities, including ski and camping trips, to obtain access and transport. The documented nexus is institutional religious authority and youth-ministry trust; the sources do not report that he invoked a particular doctrine or ritual.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdmo/pr/former-youth-director-fort-leonard-wood-sentenced-30-years-child-sexual-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of Missouri, 'Former Youth Director at Fort Leonard Wood Sentenced to 30 Years for Child Sexual Abuse' (Feb. 4, 2022).",
"body": "The official sentencing release records the five guilty pleas, thirty-year sentence, lifetime supervision, four victims, Religious Services Office youth-ministry role, youth-group access, transport and ski and camping trips.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kansascity.com/news/local/crime/article251040024.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Kansas City Star, 'Former youth director at Fort Leonard Wood pleads guilty to sexually abusing minors' (Apr. 29, 2021).",
"body": "Missouri newspaper reporting independently corroborates the guilty pleas and the youth-ministry relationship through which McKay met the children.",
"tier": "state-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-plea-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdmo/pr/former-youth-director-fort-leonard-wood-sentenced-30-years-child-sexual-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ede9ec465a36e36bb9c894919c8f725a92421890adb9806e348098d85904f328",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdmo/pr/former-youth-director-fort-leonard-wood-sentenced-30-years-child-sexual-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kansascity.com/news/local/crime/article251040024.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-plea-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 150,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Ninth Circuit affirmed the convictions and thirty-year sentence on August 18, 2025. The Supreme Court denied certiorari on January 12, 2026."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The jury convicted Smith on four counts and acquitted him on a fifth; this record preserves both outcomes. It does not identify any survivor and does not attribute his conduct to Morning Star congregants, the Northern Cheyenne community, foster parents, Baptists, pastors or Christians generally. The filed criminal record supports pastoral trust and access but does not report a specific doctrinal or ritual claim.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-dean-smith-lame-deer-montana-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Lame Deer, MT, USA",
"lat": 45.6239,
"lng": -106.6667,
"title": "Dean Alan Smith: convictions and thirty-year sentence for abuse of children who trusted him as pastor",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Morning Star Baptist Church",
"trusted pastor to children in the congregation",
"foster parent and community host"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust",
"church-congregation access",
"community trust used to obtain custody and private access",
"foster and temporary care of children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Morning Star Baptist Church in Lame Deer"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the District of Montana",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "2023-12-11",
"outcome": "A federal jury convicted Smith of aggravated sexual abuse, abusive sexual contact by force, and two counts of abusive sexual contact by force and of a child. The jury acquitted him on one separate abusive-sexual-contact count."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the District of Montana",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2024-04-10",
"outcome": "The court sentenced Smith to thirty years in federal prison followed by lifetime supervised release."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit",
"stage": "direct appeal, No. 24-2362",
"date": "2025-08-18",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the convictions and sentence."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the United States",
"stage": "petition for certiorari, No. 25-6245",
"date": "2026-01-12",
"outcome": "The Court denied the petition for a writ of certiorari."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The government's filed sentencing memorandum describes the children as members of Smith's church congregation who trusted him as their pastor. It states that his public work in the community created trust that led families to place children in his care and gave him private access. The record therefore rests on documented pastoral and congregational authority, not on religious office alone.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mt/pr/former-lame-deer-pastor-sentenced-30-years-prison-sexually-abusing-children-northern",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Montana, 'Former Lame Deer pastor sentenced to 30 years in prison for sexually abusing children on Northern Cheyenne Indian Reservation' (Apr. 10, 2024).",
"body": "The official release records the four guilty verdicts, one acquittal, thirty-year sentence, lifetime supervision, victims' ages and the pastor, foster-care and community-host settings.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://dailymontanan.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/sentencing-memo.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Dean Alan Smith, government sentencing memorandum, No. 1:22-cr-00140-SPW, document 149 (D. Mont. Apr. 2, 2024), reproduced by the Daily Montanan.",
"body": "The filed memorandum states that the children were part of Smith's congregation and trusted him as pastor, and that his community work caused families to place children in his care, providing the access he exploited.",
"tier": "filed-court-document-reproduction",
"kind": "sentencing-memorandum-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/memoranda/2025/08/18/24-2362.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, United States v. Smith, No. 24-2362 (Aug. 18, 2025).",
"body": "The official appellate memorandum affirms the convictions and thirty-year sentence and rejects Smith's trial and sentencing challenges.",
"tier": "federal-appellate-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-6245.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of the United States, docket No. 25-6245, Smith v. United States (petition denied Jan. 12, 2026).",
"body": "The official docket records the certiorari petition and the Court's January 12, 2026 denial.",
"tier": "supreme-court-docket",
"kind": "certiorari-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Ninth Circuit affirmed the convictions and thirty-year sentence on August 18, 2025. The Supreme Court denied certiorari on January 12, 2026."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mt/pr/former-lame-deer-pastor-sentenced-30-years-prison-sexually-abusing-children-northern",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8bd1f3ac4d61d67b1b09ae5f2c35d9225151a377c142edaa750d09450980bf50",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mt/pr/former-lame-deer-pastor-sentenced-30-years-prison-sexually-abusing-children-northern"
},
{
"source": "https://dailymontanan.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/sentencing-memo.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: filed-court-document-reproduction; evidentiary role: sentencing-memorandum-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4955a4cdf475ddb728b7d5dd913d0829cdfd7cb6bfd3b1b8fd6423179725ee2c",
"final_url": "https://dailymontanan.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/sentencing-memo.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/memoranda/2025/08/18/24-2362.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: federal-appellate-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a38c07edada96951bd0f33b03597466a3b46bb85f37402b483668bd8678500d1",
"final_url": "https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/memoranda/2025/08/18/24-2362.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-6245.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: supreme-court-docket; evidentiary role: certiorari-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "38e762573805cbd412e15802788447c789d742fc3024d2f07bc97dfaeec83627",
"final_url": "https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-6245.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 151,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Fourth Circuit vacated Kimmel's original 264-month sentence and remanded for resentencing on April 8, 2016. It did not disturb the convictions. A verified public post-remand sentencing record was not located in this review, so the original term is not presented as the current sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The convictions remain intact, but the original sentence was vacated and remanded; this record does not treat 264 months as the final post-remand sentence. It concerns Kimmel's proved use of faith-based seminars and church trust and does not attribute the scheme to host churches, seminar attendees, Christian financial counseling or Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-thomas-kimmel-raleigh-north-carolina-usa",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Raleigh, NC, USA",
"lat": 35.7796,
"lng": -78.6382,
"title": "Thomas L. Kimmel: convictions for a Ponzi scheme marketed through Biblical-finance seminars",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"church debt-counseling seminar leader",
"principal fundraiser operating as Faithful Stewards"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"Biblical-finance seminars in churches",
"professed spirituality",
"church-based position of trust",
"financial promises embedded in debt-counseling presentations",
"proposed spiritual board of advisors"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Faithful Stewards",
"Sure Line Acceptance Corporation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "2014-06-26",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Kimmel of conspiracy, mail fraud and money laundering arising from the Sure Line investment scheme."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina",
"stage": "original sentence",
"date": "2014-10-02",
"outcome": "The court imposed 264 months in prison, three years of supervised release and more than $16.5 million in restitution."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit",
"stage": "direct appeal, No. 14-4790",
"date": "2016-04-08",
"outcome": "The court left the convictions intact but vacated the sentence because the record did not support a manager-or-supervisor enhancement, and remanded for resentencing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Justice Department and Fourth Circuit record show that Kimmel conducted debt-counseling seminars in churches and sold the fraudulent investments to attendees during presentations about Biblical principles of finance. The prosecutor described his professed spirituality and position of trust in churches as tools used to defraud victims. This was a material acquisition and persuasion mechanism, rather than an incidental religious affiliation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ednc/pr/thomas-l-kimmel-convicted-conspiracy-mail-fraud-and-money-laundering",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of North Carolina, 'Thomas L. Kimmel Convicted Of Conspiracy, Mail Fraud, And Money Laundering' (June 26, 2014).",
"body": "The official verdict release records the convictions, the approximately $20 million solicited, the church-based Biblical-finance seminars and the government's evidence that Kimmel used professed spirituality and church trust to sell the fraudulent investment.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "criminal-verdict-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ednc/pr/thomas-l-kimmel-sentenced-conspiracy-mail-fraud-and-money-laundering",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of North Carolina, 'Thomas L. Kimmel Sentenced For Conspiracy, Mail Fraud, And Money Laundering' (Oct. 2, 2014).",
"body": "The official release records the original sentence and restitution order and reiterates the church-seminar and professed-spirituality evidence. The later appellate source controls the current description of that sentence.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "original-sentence"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/Opinions/Unpublished/144790.U.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, United States v. Kimmel, No. 14-4790 (Apr. 8, 2016).",
"body": "The official appellate opinion describes Kimmel's church debt-counseling seminars and Faithful Stewards operation, leaves the convictions intact, vacates the unsupported role-enhanced sentence and remands for resentencing.",
"tier": "federal-appellate-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Fourth Circuit vacated Kimmel's original 264-month sentence and remanded for resentencing on April 8, 2016. It did not disturb the convictions. A verified public post-remand sentencing record was not located in this review, so the original term is not presented as the current sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ednc/pr/thomas-l-kimmel-convicted-conspiracy-mail-fraud-and-money-laundering",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: criminal-verdict-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6d12486087201fdd85fe298bcad0444dfae99cda0971334df565034197cb6a55",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ednc/pr/thomas-l-kimmel-convicted-conspiracy-mail-fraud-and-money-laundering"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ednc/pr/thomas-l-kimmel-sentenced-conspiracy-mail-fraud-and-money-laundering",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: original-sentence.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cd34af2efdf8178ebdbdf94c1d932dadf3b090d0d7baf88fedb76157e03cdcc4",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ednc/pr/thomas-l-kimmel-sentenced-conspiracy-mail-fraud-and-money-laundering"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/Opinions/Unpublished/144790.U.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: federal-appellate-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3bab9e1f57900d2ed7c6ee9061a924e026fed15c561d4c446b396480ac3a7f5f",
"final_url": "https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/Opinions/Unpublished/144790.U.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 152,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an official state finding under a more-likely-than-not standard, not 57 criminal convictions. The report says no reviewed allegation remained prosecutable: all but one were time-barred, and the one timely matter could not proceed without the victim's testimony. The reported 258 people are documented victims, not an estimate of total prevalence. No survivor is identified here, and the findings are not attributed to Catholic parishioners or Catholics generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-nebraska-attorney-general-clergy-abuse-report-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Nebraska, USA",
"lat": 41.4925,
"lng": -99.9018,
"title": "Nebraska attorney general report: 258 documented victims across three Catholic dioceses",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"priests",
"deacons",
"Catholic-school teachers",
"diocesan officials responsible for safeguarding and reporting"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-care authority",
"clerical and school authority",
"institutional reputation placed above child protection",
"delayed or absent law-enforcement reporting",
"continued ministry or access after warning signs"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Omaha",
"Diocese of Lincoln",
"Diocese of Grand Island"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nebraska Department of Justice",
"stage": "state investigation and final report",
"date": "2021-11-04",
"outcome": "After reviewing nearly 30,000 pages, more than 200 clergy and employee files, more than 120 hotline reports, interviews, subpoenas and other records, the attorney general reported substantiated abuse or misconduct involving 258 documented victims and 57 church officials."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The official report defines a substantiated allegation as one supported by the available facts and more likely true than not. It found abuse by priests, deacons and Catholic-school teachers and concluded that church authorities repeatedly protected institutional reputation over children who had placed their spiritual care in church authority. The clerical, educational and safeguarding authority was therefore central to both access and institutional response.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ago.nebraska.gov/sites/ago.nebraska.gov/files/doc/Report%20of%20Clergy%20Sexual%20Abuse%20-%20November%204%20-%202021.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Nebraska Attorney General, Report on Clergy Sexual Abuse (Nov. 4, 2021).",
"body": "The 182-page official report states its evidentiary standard, investigative methodology, 258 documented victims, 57 implicated church officials, institutional-response findings and the prosecution limitations that prevented new charges.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-report",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://ago.nebraska.gov/sites/ago.nebraska.gov/files/doc/2021-11-04%20Attorney%20General%20Report%20on%20Clergy%20Sexual%20Abuse_0.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Nebraska Attorney General, 'Attorney General Releases Report on Clergy Sexual Abuse' (Nov. 4, 2021).",
"body": "The official release summarizes the subpoenas, interviews, record review, victim and official counts and the finding that institutional reputation was placed above children in spiritual care.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-release",
"kind": "official-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://nebraskapublicmedia.org/es/news/news-articles/catholic-church-abused-at-least-258-nebraska-victims-ag-reports-says/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nebraska Public Media, 'Catholic Church Clergy Abused at Least 258 Nebraska Victims, AG Report Says' (Nov. 4, 2021).",
"body": "Nebraska's public broadcaster independently reports the state findings and the attorney general's statement that the investigation did not identify every victim or abuser.",
"tier": "state-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "contemporaneous-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ago.nebraska.gov/sites/ago.nebraska.gov/files/doc/Report%20of%20Clergy%20Sexual%20Abuse%20-%20November%204%20-%202021.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-report; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3f7592ffbbbcee09f63a8b18f9e1430d138da912e300d21ef77fc8ee17583c09",
"final_url": "https://ago.nebraska.gov/sites/default/files/doc/Report%20of%20Clergy%20Sexual%20Abuse%20-%20November%204%20-%202021.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://ago.nebraska.gov/sites/ago.nebraska.gov/files/doc/2021-11-04%20Attorney%20General%20Report%20on%20Clergy%20Sexual%20Abuse_0.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-release; evidentiary role: official-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "860ec5cab06bc78e48857233ce41ba1df4825cb75f1821990e8dfd574ce677f5",
"final_url": "https://ago.nebraska.gov/sites/default/files/doc/2021-11-04%20Attorney%20General%20Report%20on%20Clergy%20Sexual%20Abuse_0.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://nebraskapublicmedia.org/es/news/news-articles/catholic-church-abused-at-least-258-nebraska-victims-ag-reports-says/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4182a68f279742c9b6ea1d6610b7439c5a98de5ca340cae2064917a80bcabe54",
"final_url": "https://nebraskapublicmedia.org/es/news/news-articles/catholic-church-abused-at-least-258-nebraska-victims-ag-reports-says/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 153,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "This matter ended through a court-approved nonprosecution agreement, not a criminal judgment. The agreement preserved the state's ability to prosecute individual clergy for abuse where permitted by law."
}
],
"scopeNote": "No criminal charge or conviction resulted against the diocese or its agents under this agreement. The record reports the diocese's acknowledgement that the state had evidence likely to sustain a child-endangerment conviction and the remedial obligations accepted in lieu of prosecution. It does not treat every allegation in the released archive as adjudicated or attribute institutional decisions to New Hampshire Catholics generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-diocese-manchester-nonprosecution-agreement-new-hampshire-usa",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Manchester, NH, USA",
"lat": 42.9956,
"lng": -71.4548,
"title": "Diocese of Manchester: child-endangerment evidence resolved through a monitored nonprosecution agreement",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "closed-without-charge",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "closed-without-charge",
"authorityRoles": [
"diocesan officials assigning clergy to ministry",
"priests with access to minors",
"diocesan safeguarding and reporting authorities"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"reassignment of priests known to have abused minors",
"institutional handling outside law enforcement",
"clerical access to children",
"failure to protect minors from known risk"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Manchester"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hillsborough County Superior Court, Northern District, New Hampshire",
"stage": "court-approved agreement concluding grand-jury matter No. 02-S-1154",
"date": "2002-12-10",
"outcome": "The diocese acknowledged that the state possessed evidence likely to sustain a child-endangerment conviction. In exchange for reporting, removal, training, disclosure and five years of independent audit obligations, the attorney general agreed not to prosecute the diocese or its agents for their past handling of clergy-abuse allegations."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Hillsborough County Superior Court, Northern District, New Hampshire",
"stage": "agreement-enforcement opinion",
"date": "2005-09-20",
"outcome": "The court described the agreement, the acknowledged evidence and the audit provision while resolving a dispute about the audit process."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The agreement arose from the diocese's institutional response to sexual abuse by clergy and expressly acknowledged that decisions assigning priests who had abused minors back to ministry resulted in additional children being victimized. Clerical ministry and diocesan assignment authority created and renewed the access at issue.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/resources/resource-files/reports/NewHampshireAgreement.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State of New Hampshire and Roman Catholic Bishop of Manchester, Agreement, In re Grand Jury Proceedings, No. 02-S-1154 (Hillsborough Cnty. Super. Ct. approved Dec. 10, 2002), official filing reproduced by BishopAccountability.org.",
"body": "The filed agreement records the acknowledged child-endangerment evidence, nonprosecution terms, reporting and removal duties, disclosure provisions and five-year external audit requirement.",
"tier": "filed-agreement-reproduction",
"kind": "nonprosecution-agreement"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/new-hampshire/superior-court/2005/02-s-1154-4.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "New Hampshire Superior Court, In re Grand Jury Proceedings, No. 02-S-1154 (Sept. 20, 2005).",
"body": "The published court opinion confirms the court's approval date, the diocese's acknowledgement that the state held evidence likely to sustain a conviction, and the agreement's reporting, training and audit structure.",
"tier": "state-court-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "agreement-enforcement-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://mm.nh.gov/files/uploads/doj/remote-docs/20070504-diocese-compliance-report.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KPMG LLP, Diocese of Manchester compliance report to the New Hampshire Attorney General (May 4, 2007).",
"body": "The official state-hosted audit report documents the compliance-monitoring process created by the 2002 agreement.",
"tier": "official-compliance-audit",
"kind": "agreement-monitoring"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "This matter ended through a court-approved nonprosecution agreement, not a criminal judgment. The agreement preserved the state's ability to prosecute individual clergy for abuse where permitted by law."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/resources/resource-files/reports/NewHampshireAgreement.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: filed-agreement-reproduction; evidentiary role: nonprosecution-agreement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9bd376c3f13dc2855141006e85ef7e424054ac905dbace18db1f71c2ba547640",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/resources/resource-files/reports/NewHampshireAgreement.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/new-hampshire/superior-court/2005/02-s-1154-4.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-court-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: agreement-enforcement-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://mm.nh.gov/files/uploads/doj/remote-docs/20070504-diocese-compliance-report.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-compliance-audit; evidentiary role: agreement-monitoring.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 154,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a closed investigation without new charges or convictions. The state report says probable cause existed as to two surviving clergy but prosecution was time-barred; probable cause is not an adjudication of guilt. The record does not identify survivors, convert all diocesan substantiations into criminal findings or attribute the conduct to Catholic parishioners or Catholics generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-north-dakota-clergy-abuse-investigation-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "North Dakota, USA",
"lat": 47.5515,
"lng": -101.002,
"title": "North Dakota BCI clergy-abuse investigation: probable cause identified but surviving cases time-barred",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "closed-without-charge",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "closed-without-charge",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy identified in diocesan substantiation records",
"diocesan authorities maintaining abuse files"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical access to children",
"religious institutional trust",
"historical abuse concealed or reported too late for prosecution"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Bismarck",
"Diocese of Fargo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "North Dakota Bureau of Criminal Investigation and Office of Attorney General",
"stage": "eighteen-month criminal investigation concluded",
"date": "2021-01-04",
"outcome": "Investigators reviewed substantiated diocesan complaints, interviewed victims and pursued new leads. Of 53 previously unprosecuted individuals, all but two had died before or during the investigation. Prosecutors found probable cause that could have supported charges against the two survivors, but the applicable limitations periods had expired."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The state investigation was limited to substantiated child-sexual-abuse complaints involving members of North Dakota's Catholic dioceses. The documented nexus is the accused persons' clerical authority and institutional access to children, as reflected in the diocesan records reviewed by BCI. The state did not publish a finding that Catholic doctrine caused the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://attorneygeneral.nd.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/2021-BiennialReport.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the North Dakota Attorney General, 2019-2021 Biennial Report, 'Clergy Sexual Abuse Investigation,' p. 17 (2021).",
"body": "The official report records the eighteen-month BCI investigation, its review of substantiated diocesan complaints, 53 previously unprosecuted individuals, the survival and death status of the accused, the probable-cause assessment and the expired limitations periods.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-report",
"kind": "closed-investigation"
},
{
"link": "https://www.inforum.com/news/north-dakota-clergy-sex-abuse-survivors-say-catholic-reforms-too-little-too-late",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Forum of Fargo-Moorhead, 'North Dakota clergy sex abuse survivors say Catholic reforms too little, too late' (Jan. 16, 2021).",
"body": "Contemporaneous North Dakota reporting corroborates the investigation's scope, its lack of new charges and the diocesan substantiation context while preserving the distinction between substantiation and conviction.",
"tier": "state-newspaper-investigative-reporting",
"kind": "contemporaneous-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://attorneygeneral.nd.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/2021-BiennialReport.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-report; evidentiary role: closed-investigation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "297c02b10ee555a0a9a163fe8fb0c06fb4dc651855ddc7b40101e25d2fa425d9",
"final_url": "https://attorneygeneral.nd.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/2021-BiennialReport.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.inforum.com/news/north-dakota-clergy-sex-abuse-survivors-say-catholic-reforms-too-little-too-late",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newspaper-investigative-reporting; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cbb682a2c88370b3d6d0e05ed1bdbfc1fff9886f3a2835b9ff9b55fa29ffffb1",
"final_url": "https://www.inforum.com/news/north-dakota-clergy-sex-abuse-survivors-say-catholic-reforms-too-little-too-late"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 155,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The report defines substantiated abuse as abuse for which the available evidence supports the conclusion that the cleric committed it. All 451 listed clerics and brothers were substantiated by a Catholic source, including an Illinois or out-of-state diocese or religious order; this is not a finding that 451 people were criminally convicted. The figure of at least 1,997 is the number of reported survivors revealed by the investigation, not a prevalence estimate. No survivor is identified here, and the report's findings are not attributed to Illinois Catholics generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-illinois-attorney-general-clergy-abuse-report-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Illinois, USA",
"lat": 40,
"lng": -89.2,
"title": "Illinois attorney general report: 451 substantiated Catholic clerics and religious brothers, at least 1,997 children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests and deacons",
"religious brothers",
"archbishops and bishops responsible for assignments and safeguarding",
"diocesan officials receiving and investigating reports"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and religious authority",
"parish, school and ministry access to children",
"transfer or continued assignment after reports",
"institutional concealment and delayed disclosure",
"failure to report known abuse to public authorities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Chicago",
"Diocese of Belleville",
"Diocese of Joliet",
"Diocese of Peoria",
"Diocese of Rockford",
"Diocese of Springfield in Illinois"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Office of the Illinois Attorney General",
"stage": "multi-year investigation and final report",
"date": "2023-05-23",
"outcome": "After reviewing more than 100,000 pages of diocesan documents, thousands of claim files and more than 600 confidential survivor contacts, the attorney general published the state's first comprehensive accounting across all six Illinois dioceses: 451 discrete Catholic clerics and religious brothers substantiated by Catholic sources as child sex abusers and claims involving at least 1,997 children."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The official report concerns abuse committed through Catholic clerical and religious ministry and the institutional decisions that preserved or renewed access. It documents transfers of known abusers between parishes, acceptance of known abusers from other dioceses, concealment from Catholic communities and the public, and failures to report. The authority at issue was pastoral, sacramental, educational and institutional rather than a merely incidental religious affiliation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/download/report.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Illinois Attorney General, Report on Catholic Clergy Child Sex Abuse in Illinois (May 23, 2023).",
"body": "The official report records the investigation's substantiation definition, six-diocese scope, source methodology, 451 discrete substantiated clerics and religious brothers, at least 1,997 reported survivors, institutional-response findings and policy recommendations.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-report",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/introduction/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Illinois Attorney General, 'Introduction,' Report on Catholic Clergy Child Sex Abuse in Illinois (2023).",
"body": "The official report site defines substantiated abuse, describes review of more than 100,000 pages and more than 600 confidential survivor contacts, explains how Catholic sources substantiated the listed individuals and documents transfer, concealment and reporting failures.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-report-site",
"kind": "methodology-and-findings"
},
{
"link": "https://illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/news/story/attorney-general-raoul-releases-report-concluding-multi-year-investigation-into-child-sex-abuse-by-members-of-catholic-clergy-in-illinois",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Illinois Attorney General, 'Attorney General Raoul Releases Report Concluding Multi-Year Investigation into Child Sex Abuse by Members of Catholic Clergy in Illinois' (May 23, 2023).",
"body": "The official release confirms the publication date, final statewide figures, review scale, institutional-response findings and resulting policy changes across the six dioceses.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-release",
"kind": "official-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/download/report.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-report; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "70e03a50f90c849435fa26590ce5442e92494859fd0ba874a6a90e04cdd96345",
"final_url": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/download/report.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/introduction/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-report-site; evidentiary role: methodology-and-findings.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f738fe63dc7f42832916445bbcd08e5170bd031e48c8336c76a95f96b9fa2dad",
"final_url": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/introduction/"
},
{
"source": "https://illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/news/story/attorney-general-raoul-releases-report-concluding-multi-year-investigation-into-child-sex-abuse-by-members-of-catholic-clergy-in-illinois",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-release; evidentiary role: official-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "146aaab1a5cc5e9869a28e82c2e93242d5f3c4417c57ca6f0ec27213124fd2fd",
"final_url": "https://illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/news/story/attorney-general-raoul-releases-report-concluding-multi-year-investigation-into-child-sex-abuse-by-members-of-catholic-clergy-in-illinois"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 156,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Indiana Supreme Court left the reckless-homicide convictions and five-year sentences intact. It vacated the separate neglect convictions because both offenses rested on the same omission, not because it rejected the homicide finding."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns the parents' affirmed reckless-homicide convictions. It does not identify the child, count the vacated neglect convictions as current or attribute the death to every Faith Assembly member, faith-healing practitioner or Christian. The separate group-level mortality investigation is recorded as an institutional event rather than folded into this criminal case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1986-gary-margaret-hall-faith-healing-indiana-usa",
"year": 1986,
"place": "Whitley County, IN, USA",
"lat": 41.1331,
"lng": -85.5019,
"title": "Gary and Margaret Hall: reckless-homicide convictions after prayer replaced medical care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parents responsible for an infant's medical care",
"members of a prayer-healing religious community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"belief that sickness was the devil in a spiritual battle with God",
"prayer used in place of medical treatment",
"belief that medical care would never be sought regardless of illness severity"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Faith Assembly of Wilmot, Indiana"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Whitley Circuit Court, Indiana",
"stage": "jury verdict and later sentence",
"date": "1984-08-28",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Gary and Margaret Hall of reckless homicide and neglect of a dependent after their one-month-old child died of acute bronchial pneumonia without medical treatment. The court later imposed concurrent terms of five years for reckless homicide and two years for neglect."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Indiana",
"stage": "direct appeal, No. 3-485A77",
"date": "1985-09-26",
"outcome": "The court affirmed both convictions, finding sufficient evidence that the parents withheld medical care because they believed prayer and faith would heal the child."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Indiana",
"stage": "transfer and final appellate judgment",
"date": "1986-05-27",
"outcome": "The court affirmed both reckless-homicide convictions and five-year sentences but vacated the neglect convictions and two-year sentences as duplicative under double-jeopardy principles."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The appellate record states that the Halls withheld all medical care because they believed sickness was the devil in a spiritual battle with God and that prayer would heal the sick. They testified that they would not have sought a doctor regardless of the seriousness of the illness. The spiritual-treatment doctrine directly replaced care that medical testimony said would have given the child a reasonably good chance of survival.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/indiana/supreme-court/1986/92s03-8605-cr-515-2.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Indiana Supreme Court, Hall v. State, 493 N.E.2d 433 (Ind. 1986).",
"body": "The published opinion records the fatal illness, medical testimony, prayer-only belief, trial convictions and sentences, affirms reckless homicide and vacates the duplicative neglect conviction on double-jeopardy grounds.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "final-appellate-judgment-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/indiana/court-of-appeals/1985/3-485a77-6.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Appeals of Indiana, Hall v. State, 482 N.E.2d 1185 (Ind. Ct. App. Sept. 26, 1985).",
"body": "The published intermediate opinion provides the trial evidence, the parents' testimony about Biblical prayer healing, the statutory religious-treatment defense and the sufficiency ruling.",
"tier": "state-appellate-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "intermediate-appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Indiana Supreme Court left the reckless-homicide convictions and five-year sentences intact. It vacated the separate neglect convictions because both offenses rested on the same omission, not because it rejected the homicide finding."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/indiana/supreme-court/1986/92s03-8605-cr-515-2.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: final-appellate-judgment-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/indiana/court-of-appeals/1985/3-485a77-6.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-appellate-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: intermediate-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 157,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an epidemiologic institutional finding, not a criminal judgment against Faith Assembly or a finding that each death was individually caused by a named leader. The CDC cautioned that its denominators might include nonmember births and could therefore underestimate group mortality. The record preserves the confirmed death categories and comparison rates rather than later, higher estimates from secondary sources.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1984-faith-assembly-mortality-investigation-indiana-usa",
"year": 1984,
"place": "Elkhart and Kosciusko Counties, IN, USA",
"lat": 41.45,
"lng": -85.75,
"title": "Faith Assembly mortality investigation: 40 confirmed deaths amid avoidance of medical care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious leadership teaching spiritual healing in place of medical care",
"church community organized around prayer-only treatment"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"avoidance of all medical attention in favor of spiritual healing",
"no prenatal care",
"home labor and delivery without medical assistance",
"religious norm against medical treatment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Faith Assembly of Wilmot, Indiana",
"Indiana State Board of Health",
"Centers for Disease Control and Prevention"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Indiana State Board of Health and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention",
"stage": "epidemiologic investigation and MMWR report",
"date": "1984-06-01",
"outcome": "Investigators confirmed 40 deaths among Indiana members during 1975-1982: 21 perinatal, seven infant and child, six maternal and six nonmaternal adult deaths. In Elkhart and Kosciusko Counties, estimated perinatal mortality was 48 per 1,000 compared with 18 statewide, and maternal mortality was 872 per 100,000 compared with 9 statewide."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The public-health investigation describes a fundamentalist church whose members avoided all medical attention in favor of spiritual healing. Pregnant members received no prenatal care and delivered at home without medical assistance. The documented practice was therefore the exposure being measured, not an incidental religious identity.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cdc.gov/Mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00000345.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Indiana State Board of Health and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 'Perinatal and Maternal Mortality in a Religious Group, Indiana,' Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 33, no. 21 (June 1, 1984): 297-298.",
"body": "The official public-health report confirms 40 deaths, describes the spiritual-healing practice, states the investigation methods and reports perinatal and maternal mortality rates with statewide comparisons and denominator limitations.",
"tier": "official-public-health-report",
"kind": "epidemiologic-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6507508/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "C. Spence, T. S. Danielson and A. M. Kaunitz, 'Perinatal and maternal mortality in a religious group avoiding obstetric care,' American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 150, no. 7 (Dec. 1, 1984): 826-831, PMID 6507508.",
"body": "The indexed peer-reviewed study identifies the group as Faith Assembly, verifies the death review and reports the markedly elevated maternal and perinatal mortality associated with avoiding obstetric care.",
"tier": "peer-reviewed-public-health-study",
"kind": "methodology-and-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cdc.gov/Mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00000345.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-public-health-report; evidentiary role: epidemiologic-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "44d02acbe29c22fd753982b76704dfa13932f912079b53de7f0297888966dec3",
"final_url": "https://www.cdc.gov/Mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00000345.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6507508/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: peer-reviewed-public-health-study; evidentiary role: methodology-and-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c4341693d455d4ab6332d876f531e3e63bf4f9c55ea6a87874ab87b8a5edd14f",
"final_url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6507508/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 158,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Wisconsin Supreme Court affirmed both convictions on July 3, 2013, rejecting the parents' fair-notice, jury-instruction, ineffective-assistance and jury-bias challenges."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns two affirmed reckless-homicide convictions and does not identify the child in the public title or narrative. The parents did not belong to an identifiable church, though the court says they identified as Pentecostals. Their conduct is not attributed to Pentecostals, Christians, parents who pray during illness or spiritual-healing practitioners generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-dale-leilani-neumann-prayer-treatment-wisconsin-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Marathon County, WI, USA",
"lat": 44.8981,
"lng": -89.758,
"title": "Dale and Leilani Neumann: reckless-homicide convictions after prayer replaced medical care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parents responsible for a child's medical care",
"parents teaching that illness has spiritual root causes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"prayer used in place of medical treatment",
"illness framed as spiritual attack",
"medical intervention framed as taking glory from God",
"life-threatening illness framed as a test of faith",
"belief that divine healing or resurrection would occur"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Marathon County Circuit Court, Wisconsin",
"stage": "separate jury trials and sentences",
"date": "2009-05-22",
"outcome": "Separate juries convicted each parent of second-degree reckless homicide. The mother's verdict was returned May 22, 2009; the father's separate trial followed that year. Each received 180 days in jail and ten years of probation, with the jail time structured as 30 days annually for six years on alternating months."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Wisconsin",
"stage": "consolidated final state appeal, Nos. 2011AP1044-CR and 2011AP1105-CR",
"date": "2013-07-03",
"outcome": "The court affirmed both convictions and orders denying postconviction relief. It held that Wisconsin's prayer-treatment protection for child-abuse charges did not negate the duty to provide medical care or immunize second-degree reckless homicide when a child died."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The supreme court record states that the parents chose prayer instead of medicine because they believed illness had spiritual root causes. During the child's rapid decline, medical support was described as taking glory from God, the illness as a spiritual attack and test of faith, and divine healing as the expected outcome. The court recorded medical evidence that treated diabetic ketoacidosis had a 99.8 percent survival rate and that survival remained highly likely well into the day of death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wicourts.gov/sc/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=99671",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Wisconsin, State v. Neumann, 2013 WI 58, 348 Wis. 2d 455, 832 N.W.2d 560 (July 3, 2013).",
"body": "The official opinion records the two convictions, sentences, final affirmance, medical evidence, prayer-treatment beliefs and the court's construction of Wisconsin's religious-treatment provision.",
"tier": "official-state-supreme-court-opinion",
"kind": "final-appellate-judgment-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/wisconsin/supreme-court/2013/2011ap001044-cr.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Wisconsin, State v. Neumann, 2013 WI 58 (official opinion reproduced by Justia).",
"body": "The accessible opinion reproduction preserves the full factual record, procedural posture, separate verdicts, sentences, statutory analysis and final judgment.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "accessible-opinion-copy"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Wisconsin Supreme Court affirmed both convictions on July 3, 2013, rejecting the parents' fair-notice, jury-instruction, ineffective-assistance and jury-bias challenges."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wicourts.gov/sc/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=99671",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-state-supreme-court-opinion; evidentiary role: final-appellate-judgment-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.wicourts.gov/sc/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=99671"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/wisconsin/supreme-court/2013/2011ap001044-cr.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: accessible-opinion-copy.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 159,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Davis's guilty pleas and sentence for wire and tax fraud. It does not infer a denomination, describe ordinary church compensation as abusive or attribute his conduct to All Nations Worship Assembly members, pastors or Christians generally. The amount is the approximately $434,339 identified in the official disposition, separate from the tax loss.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-adrian-davis-church-embezzlement-alabama-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Huntsville, AL, USA",
"lat": 34.7304,
"lng": -86.5861,
"title": "Adrian Derrell Davis: five-year sentence for embezzling funds entrusted to him as pastor",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of All Nations Worship Assembly in Huntsville",
"church official entrusted with institutional funds"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral position of trust",
"unauthorized access to church funds",
"concealment through a false tax return",
"misrepresentation of additional income as speaking-engagement revenue"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"All Nations Worship Assembly in Huntsville"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-20",
"outcome": "After pleading guilty to wire fraud and filing a false tax return, Davis was sentenced to sixty months in federal prison. The plea record established that he used his position as pastor to embezzle approximately $434,339 from the church between 2018 and 2020 and concealed unreported income that caused a $114,859 tax loss."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The federal disposition states that Davis used his position as pastor to take money entrusted to the church and describes the offense as a betrayal of his congregation and abuse of a position of trust. The nexus is therefore pastoral and institutional authority over congregational funds; the public record does not establish that he invoked a specific doctrine, prophecy or ritual.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndal/pr/former-pastor-sentenced-embezzling-local-church",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Alabama, 'Former Pastor Sentenced for Embezzling from a Local Church' (Feb. 20, 2026).",
"body": "The official sentencing release records the guilty pleas, five-year sentence, amount taken, tax loss, pastoral position, unauthorized personal expenditures and prosecutors' position-of-trust finding.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.waff.com/2025/10/07/former-huntsville-pastor-federally-charged-using-over-400k-church-funds-luxury-goods/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WAFF 48, 'Former Huntsville pastor federally charged for using over $400K of church funds on luxury goods' (Oct. 7, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous local court reporting corroborates Davis's lead-pastor and church-consultant roles, authorized compensation and the distinction between that compensation and the church funds used for personal expenses.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-record-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndal/pr/former-pastor-sentenced-embezzling-local-church",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "344384a2a3e7436fc81e8900d7f24bedda111300e5a501f646b4165a4bf0be13",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndal/pr/former-pastor-sentenced-embezzling-local-church"
},
{
"source": "https://www.waff.com/2025/10/07/former-huntsville-pastor-federally-charged-using-over-400k-church-funds-luxury-goods/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-record-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a8ca5d9df6b5f0fef4328f3ce814a76adc09cfc36b09a5e43b00fb838277d245",
"final_url": "https://www.waff.com/2025/10/07/former-huntsville-pastor-federally-charged-using-over-400k-church-funds-luxury-goods/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 160,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The attorney general defines credibly accused as one or more allegations for which there is a reasonable basis to believe the conduct more likely than not occurred. The 75 clergy are not 75 criminal convictions. The public Appendix A contains 72 summaries because three defendants awaiting trial were excluded; those defendants remain presumed innocent. One fourth charged priest died after being found incompetent to stand trial. The reported total of over 300 victims is not a population estimate, and no survivor is identified here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-rhode-island-attorney-general-clergy-abuse-report-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Rhode Island, USA",
"lat": 41.68,
"lng": -71.51,
"title": "Rhode Island attorney general report: 75 credibly accused clergy and over 300 reported victims",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests and deacons",
"religious-order and extern clergy",
"bishops and diocesan officials responsible for assignments, reporting and safeguarding"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority and access to children",
"transfer or return to ministry after credible reports",
"institutional concealment",
"treatment used in place of public accountability",
"failure to refer complaints to law enforcement",
"promises of confidentiality"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Providence",
"Office of the Rhode Island Attorney General",
"Rhode Island State Police"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Office of the Rhode Island Attorney General and Rhode Island State Police",
"stage": "years-long investigation and final report",
"date": "2026-03-04",
"outcome": "After reviewing more than 250,000 pages of diocesan records dating to 1950 and contacting nearly 150 survivors, investigators identified 75 clergy credibly accused under a more-likely-than-not standard and over 300 reported victims. The report found that historical failures to report, remove and monitor accused clergy led to additional abuse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report concerns abuse committed through Catholic clerical ministry and diocesan decisions that protected or renewed access to children. It documents bishops and senior officials transferring accused priests, sending them to treatment, returning them to active ministry and withholding complaints from civil authorities. Clerical authority and the institution's control of ministry assignments were therefore material to access and recurrence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://riag.ri.gov/media/8376/download",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Rhode Island Attorney General, Report on Child Sexual Abuse in the Diocese of Providence (Mar. 4, 2026).",
"body": "The 284-page official report states the more-likely-than-not standard, 75-clergy and over-300-victim totals, document-review and interview methodology, institutional-response findings, prosecution status and limitations imposed by voluntary diocesan cooperation.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-report",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://riag.ri.gov/press-releases/attorney-general-neronha-publishes-comprehensive-report-child-sexual-abuse-diocese",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Rhode Island Attorney General, 'Attorney General Neronha publishes comprehensive report on child sexual abuse in the Diocese of Providence' (Mar. 4, 2026).",
"body": "The official release confirms the report date, six-year investigation, statewide figures, historical assignment and reporting failures and current safeguarding recommendations.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-release",
"kind": "official-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://riag.ri.gov/diocese-report/credibly-accused-clergy",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Rhode Island Attorney General, 'Credibly Accused Clergy,' Diocese of Providence report site (2026).",
"body": "The official appendix index explains why it contains 72 summaries rather than 75, preserves the presumption of innocence for pending defendants and states the evidence sources used for inclusion.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-report-site",
"kind": "appendix-methodology"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://riag.ri.gov/media/8376/download",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-report; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd3cc88f9d9cf75f6d317498601544db8c03d42c535c0d30bb3fc3c60534c402",
"final_url": "https://riag.ri.gov/media/8376/download"
},
{
"source": "https://riag.ri.gov/press-releases/attorney-general-neronha-publishes-comprehensive-report-child-sexual-abuse-diocese",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-release; evidentiary role: official-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "31d9f04990fca561ca0aba9ccbb5f439f891c0ea708b91e64229d480499232f9",
"final_url": "https://riag.ri.gov/press-releases/attorney-general-neronha-publishes-comprehensive-report-child-sexual-abuse-diocese"
},
{
"source": "https://riag.ri.gov/diocese-report/credibly-accused-clergy",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-report-site; evidentiary role: appendix-methodology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a20de652b0a2ad5337bc4fddeb8ecdf0a4590f610a962b38a1765b4336d35e7b",
"final_url": "https://riag.ri.gov/diocese-report/credibly-accused-clergy"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 161,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The South Carolina Supreme Court affirmed the conviction on May 6, 2020, rejecting Durant's evidentiary, mistrial, jury-instruction, Brady and cumulative-error arguments."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The State indicted Durant on four counts but tried only one in this proceeding. This record counts the single second-degree criminal-sexual-conduct conviction and does not treat testimony admitted under the similar-acts rule as additional convictions. Survivors are not identified, and the conduct is not attributed to Word International Ministries congregants, pastors or Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-larry-durant-sumter-south-carolina-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Sumter, SC, USA",
"lat": 33.9204,
"lng": -80.3415,
"title": "Larry Durant: affirmed twenty-year sentence for abuse presented as prayer and spiritual protection",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and lead pastor of Word International Ministries",
"spiritual leader conducting private prayer meetings with teenage congregants"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"private prayer meetings",
"sexual contact presented as prayer for health and good fortune",
"scripture used for grooming",
"threats of misfortune for refusal or disclosure",
"claims of divine direction",
"pastoral authority over girls raised in the church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Word International Ministries in Sumter"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "South Carolina circuit court in Sumter County",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Durant of second-degree criminal sexual conduct with a minor, and the court sentenced him to twenty years in prison. The published appellate opinion does not state the trial judgment date."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of South Carolina",
"stage": "direct appeal, Opinion No. 27964",
"date": "2020-05-06",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the conviction and sentence. It held that evidence of similar abuse was admissible because Durant used the same position of trust, spiritual leadership, private-prayer setting, scripture and threatened misfortune across the accounts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The state supreme court found that Durant exercised spiritual leadership and pastoral trust to isolate teenage congregants in private prayer meetings. He represented sexual contact as part of prayer for health, disease prevention and good fortune, invoked scripture to groom them and threatened misfortune if they refused or disclosed the conduct. The religious pretext was the documented method of access and coercion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sccourts.org/media/opinions/HTMLFiles/SC/27964.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of South Carolina, State v. Durant, Opinion No. 27964 (May 6, 2020).",
"body": "The official opinion records the single conviction, twenty-year sentence, final affirmance and evidence that Durant used pastoral authority, private prayer, scripture, health claims and threatened misfortune to facilitate abuse.",
"tier": "official-state-supreme-court-opinion",
"kind": "final-appellate-judgment-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/south-carolina/supreme-court/2020/27964.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of South Carolina, State v. Durant, Opinion No. 27964 (official opinion reproduced by Justia).",
"body": "The accessible reproduction preserves the full factual and procedural record, including the distinction between the tried count and similar-acts testimony.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "accessible-opinion-copy"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The South Carolina Supreme Court affirmed the conviction on May 6, 2020, rejecting Durant's evidentiary, mistrial, jury-instruction, Brady and cumulative-error arguments."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sccourts.org/media/opinions/HTMLFiles/SC/27964.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-state-supreme-court-opinion; evidentiary role: final-appellate-judgment-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "97f24be0a2bcc50387f484fef9b8d87f72344cdeeaed9be670a7ca2bffa902b5",
"final_url": "https://www.sccourts.org/media/opinions/HTMLFiles/SC/27964.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/south-carolina/supreme-court/2020/27964.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: accessible-opinion-copy.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 162,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record counts the eight Hawaii convictions and ten-year sentence. It does not convert separate Oregon allegations or uncharged accounts into convictions, does not identify the survivor and does not attribute Taboada's conduct to members of Back to the Cross Ministry, communal religious groups, ministers or Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-manuel-taboada-kaneohe-hawaii-usa",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Kaneohe, HI, USA",
"lat": 21.4022,
"lng": -157.7394,
"title": "Manuel Taboada: eight sexual-assault convictions after scripture was used to justify abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"minister and leader of Back to the Cross Ministry",
"spiritual mentor controlling a communal religious household"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"scripture used to justify sexual abuse",
"grooming for future ministry leadership",
"communal religious living arrangement",
"threat that disclosure would destroy the ministry",
"spiritual authority over a child congregant"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Back to the Cross Ministry"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court of the First Circuit, State of Hawaii",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence, Case No. 1PC081001157",
"date": "2009-06-29",
"outcome": "Taboada pleaded guilty to eight counts of second-degree sexual assault covering conduct from April 2001 through April 2007. The court imposed the agreed ten-year prison sentence and lifetime sex-offender registration; the plea agreement requested a six-year minimum before parole eligibility, subject to the Hawaii Paroling Authority."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Contemporaneous court reporting states that Taboada led the Back to the Cross Ministry, lived with congregant families in a communal religious household and groomed the child to succeed him in ministry leadership. Prosecutors said he quoted scripture to justify the assaults and had warned that disclosure would cause the ministry to collapse. His spiritual leadership was therefore part of the access, grooming and silencing mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archives.starbulletin.com/content/20090630_Oahu_pastor_jailed_for_assaulting_girl",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Star-Bulletin, 'Oahu pastor jailed for assaulting girl' (June 30, 2009).",
"body": "Contemporaneous sentencing coverage records the eight guilty pleas, ten-year sentence, offense dates, communal ministry setting, grooming for leadership and prosecutor's statement that Taboada quoted scripture to justify the abuse.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-local-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/10615888/former-minister-sentenced-for-sexually-assaulting-child/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Hawaii News Now, 'Former minister sentenced for sexually assaulting child' (June 29, 2009).",
"body": "Contemporaneous courtroom reporting corroborates the guilty pleas, ten-year term, lifetime registration, position of trust, scripture pretext and ministry-leadership grooming.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-local-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2008/Aug/28/ln/hawaii808280325.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jim Dooley, 'Prosecutor: Alleged molester leads cult,' Honolulu Advertiser (Aug. 28, 2008).",
"body": "Pretrial court reporting documents the religious communal structure, Taboada's leadership and the State's evidence concerning grooming, disclosure threats and admissions; allegations outside the later Hawaii plea are not counted.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-local-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-context"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archives.starbulletin.com/content/20090630_Oahu_pastor_jailed_for_assaulting_girl",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f874b60c285e9872122097d913d30e0b3d97d2689c68f6108117078269ed3b6c",
"final_url": "https://archives.starbulletin.com/content/20090630_Oahu_pastor_jailed_for_assaulting_girl"
},
{
"source": "https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/10615888/former-minister-sentenced-for-sexually-assaulting-child/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "86cb63dd434aabde2e7f419ab84087e9e9294d8ba39ffea15f56c0279f2df9db",
"final_url": "https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/10615888/former-minister-sentenced-for-sexually-assaulting-child/"
},
{
"source": "https://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2008/Aug/28/ln/hawaii808280325.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "23e8b58400c26154c3796ac99ae3d57372de94829442cf7a39c17fb45015e001",
"final_url": "https://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2008/Aug/28/ln/hawaii808280325.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 163,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an official institutional finding, not a criminal conviction against any named individual or organization. The task force preserved the presumption of innocence, found no evidence supporting corporate criminal liability, and made no murder finding. The report says many alleged acts constituted crimes under the historical statutes but were time-barred. It documented reports and corroborating records without converting every survivor account into an adjudicated fact; survivors remain unidentified here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-st-josephs-orphanage-vermont-task-force-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Burlington, VT, USA",
"lat": 44.4759,
"lng": -73.2121,
"title": "St. Joseph's Orphanage task force: abuse documented, murder uncorroborated and charges time-barred",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic sisters responsible for children in institutional care",
"priests and religious personnel with access to residents",
"Vermont Catholic Charities and diocesan authorities responsible for the institution",
"state and local authorities responsible for oversight and investigation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious institutional custody",
"threats that parents would go to hell",
"punishment with rosaries and other objects",
"control of mail and outside communication",
"retaliation for reporting",
"clerical and religious authority over children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Joseph's Orphanage",
"Vermont Catholic Charities",
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Burlington",
"Sisters of Providence",
"St. Joseph's Orphanage Task Force"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "St. Joseph's Orphanage Task Force, co-chaired by the Vermont Attorney General's Office and Burlington Police Department",
"stage": "two-year criminal investigation and final report",
"date": "2020-12-14",
"outcome": "The task force received 66 police intakes and conducted 48 interviews concerning residents from the 1940s through the 1974 closure. It concluded that abuse occurred and many children suffered. It found many alleged acts would constitute crimes under the law then in force, but every potential charge except murder was barred by the applicable limitation periods. Investigators found no corroboration or probable-cause evidence for murder and closed that investigation, subject to reopening on new evidence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The official report concerns children placed in a Catholic orphanage under the authority of religious sisters, priests, Catholic Charities and diocesan structures. Accounts documented by the task force included religious threats, punishment with rosaries, sexual abuse alleged against priests and nuns, and institutional control over communication and reporting. The nexus is religious institutional custody and clerical authority, not the Catholic identity of individual staff in isolation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ago.vermont.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Task-Force-Report-Part-1.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "St. Joseph's Orphanage Task Force, Report of Investigation, Part 1 (Dec. 14, 2020).",
"body": "The official report gives the task force mandate, interview and document-review methods, findings that abuse occurred and many alleged acts constituted crimes, limitation-period analysis, presumption-of-innocence and corporate-liability limits, and the finding that murder allegations lacked corroboration or probable cause.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-and-law-enforcement-report",
"kind": "official-finding-and-limitations"
},
{
"link": "https://vtdigger.org/2020/12/14/vermont-review-of-church-orphanage-finds-misconduct-but-not-murder/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kevin O'Connor, 'Vermont review of church orphanage finds misconduct but not murder,' VTDigger (Dec. 14, 2020).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting from the report's release corroborates the attorney general's finding that abuse occurred, the absence of murder evidence and the inability to prosecute time-barred conduct.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-state-court-and-government-reporting",
"kind": "official-release-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wcax.com/2020/12/14/findings-of-investigation-into-st-josephs-orphanage-to-be-released/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dom Amato, 'Orphanage report: Investigators say authorities failed to pursue abuse claims,' WCAX (Dec. 14, 2020).",
"body": "Contemporaneous local reporting confirms the investigation's duration, abuse finding, absence of murder evidence, limitation-period barrier, document-production limits and planned restorative process.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-local-reporting",
"kind": "methodology-and-limitations-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ago.vermont.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Task-Force-Report-Part-1.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-and-law-enforcement-report; evidentiary role: official-finding-and-limitations.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://vtdigger.org/2020/12/14/vermont-review-of-church-orphanage-finds-misconduct-but-not-murder/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-state-court-and-government-reporting; evidentiary role: official-release-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ee817a2db49a599863b47f3012f7e6221d8ac6c63634c65ab5e124eab0e4cab1",
"final_url": "https://vtdigger.org/2020/12/14/vermont-review-of-church-orphanage-finds-misconduct-but-not-murder/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wcax.com/2020/12/14/findings-of-investigation-into-st-josephs-orphanage-to-be-released/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-local-reporting; evidentiary role: methodology-and-limitations-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "663fa558d248e87ff61835d064cebb78aeca2b505e276bb8e4c04757d759f9bf",
"final_url": "https://www.wcax.com/2020/12/14/findings-of-investigation-into-st-josephs-orphanage-to-be-released/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 164,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The South Dakota Supreme Court affirmed on March 4, 1992; rehearing was denied April 13, 1992. Two justices dissented from the evidentiary holding, arguing that the volume and remoteness of uncharged-acts testimony denied a fair trial."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record counts five completed and two attempted-contact convictions. It preserves the two acquittals and does not count testimony about uncharged historical conduct as additional convictions. The appellate dissents concerning admission of that testimony are included in the procedural history. Survivors are not identified, and the conduct is not attributed to either congregation, Lutherans or pastors generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1992-edward-werner-south-dakota-usa",
"year": 1992,
"place": "South Shore and Goodwin, SD, USA",
"lat": 44.96,
"lng": -97.14,
"title": "Edward J. Werner: seven affirmed convictions after using pastoral access to abuse parish girls",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-lutheran",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Lutheran pastor responsible for parish programs",
"confirmation-class teacher",
"trusted religious authority over children in two congregations"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral access to children",
"church and confirmation activities used to isolate girls",
"congregational trust",
"conduct presented as ordinary affectionate touching"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Peter's Lutheran Church in Goodwin",
"Our Savior's Lutheran Church in South Shore"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "South Dakota circuit court",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "The jury convicted Werner of five counts of sexual contact and two counts of attempted sexual contact with a child under sixteen, acquitted him on two other counts and the court sentenced him to the South Dakota State Penitentiary."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of South Dakota",
"stage": "direct appeal, No. 17434",
"date": "1992-03-04",
"outcome": "The court affirmed the seven convictions. It held that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting other-acts evidence and did not improperly limit the defense expert's testimony. Rehearing was denied April 13, 1992."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The state supreme court record says Werner supervised church programs and taught confirmation, and that the charged contact occurred during church activities involving young parishioners. A concurrence states directly that he used his religious position to abuse the girls and that parents entrusted their children to him because of the congregation. Pastoral authority supplied access and a benign explanation for repeated touching.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/south-dakota/supreme-court/1992/17434-1.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of South Dakota, State v. Werner, 482 N.W.2d 286, No. 17434 (Mar. 4, 1992), rehearing denied Apr. 13, 1992.",
"body": "The published opinion records the five completed and two attempted-contact convictions, two acquittals, affirmance, church settings, confirmation role, use of religious position and the majority, concurrence and dissenting analyses of prior-acts evidence.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction",
"kind": "final-appellate-judgment-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The South Dakota Supreme Court affirmed on March 4, 1992; rehearing was denied April 13, 1992. Two justices dissented from the evidentiary holding, arguing that the volume and remoteness of uncharged-acts testimony denied a fair trial."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/south-dakota/supreme-court/1992/17434-1.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court-opinion-reproduction; evidentiary role: final-appellate-judgment-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 165,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns the eight federal convictions and forty-five-year sentence. It does not identify the minors, count disclosures outside the plea as separate convictions or attribute Henley's conduct to Holladay Church of Christ, his later Indiana congregation, youth ministers, coaches or Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-joshua-henley-tennessee-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Benton County, TN, USA",
"lat": 36.07,
"lng": -88.07,
"title": "Joshua Henley: forty-five-year sentence after parish work was used to transport and abuse a teen",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Holladay Church of Christ",
"youth pastor at an Indiana church",
"girls' basketball coach"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"youth-ministry access",
"purported parish-assistance trip",
"interstate transport under a church pretext",
"grooming through positions of trust"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Holladay Church of Christ"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Western District of Tennessee",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2023-03-03",
"outcome": "Henley pleaded guilty to eight federal counts involving production, possession and transportation of child sexual-abuse material, transfer of obscene material to a minor, and interstate transportation of a minor for criminal sexual activity. The court sentenced him to 540 months in federal prison followed by ten years of supervised release."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The federal disposition states that Henley was a Tennessee pastor, then an Indiana youth pastor, when he returned to Benton County and transported a teen to Indiana under the guise that she would help at his new parish. Instead he assaulted her. Court reporting also identifies ministry and coaching as the positions through which he met the three minors. Church work was therefore a documented access and travel pretext, not merely an occupational label.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdtn/pr/former-benton-county-coach-and-youth-pastor-sentenced-45-years-exploiting-children",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of Tennessee, 'Former Benton County Coach and Youth Pastor Sentenced to 45 Years for Exploiting Children' (Mar. 6, 2023).",
"body": "The official sentencing release records the offenses, forty-five-year term, ministry and coaching roles, and transport of a teen under the guise of assisting at a new parish.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://christianchronicle.org/former-minister-sentenced-to-45-years-for-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Audrey Jackson, 'Former minister sentenced to 45 years for sexual abuse,' Christian Chronicle (Mar. 14, 2023).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting corroborates the eight convictions, sentence, ages without naming survivors, ministry access, church-property conduct and Vacation Bible School pretext.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-specialist-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-and-nexus-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdtn/pr/former-benton-county-coach-and-youth-pastor-sentenced-45-years-exploiting-children",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "22ccd6b9da2dbb40e2ab31401afe0112e1254e168fdc9da5c60411386d523e17",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdtn/pr/former-benton-county-coach-and-youth-pastor-sentenced-45-years-exploiting-children"
},
{
"source": "https://christianchronicle.org/former-minister-sentenced-to-45-years-for-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-specialist-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-and-nexus-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1a638da5319676e4741005dd74e9d45447e6caf85227879ed4d2c927992148aa",
"final_url": "https://christianchronicle.org/former-minister-sentenced-to-45-years-for-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 166,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns the federal convictions and sentence. It does not imply that the visa applicants, church elders, Hope Korean Church members, Korean immigrant congregations or pastors generally participated in Park's offenses. The applicants' payments are described as the court record characterized them, without identifying individual applicants.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-dong-wan-park-tacoma-washington-usa",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Tacoma, WA, USA",
"lat": 47.2529,
"lng": -122.4443,
"title": "Dong Wan Park: church offices and false ordinations used in a religious-worker visa scheme",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Hope Korean Church",
"church official able to sponsor purported religious workers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false offers of church employment",
"fabricated seminary transcripts",
"fabricated ordination certificates",
"payments relabeled as church donations",
"witness tampering",
"unauthorized sale of church property"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Hope Korean Church in Tacoma"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington",
"stage": "bench-trial convictions, later guilty pleas and sentence",
"date": "2007-08-09",
"outcome": "After a June 2006 bench trial found Park guilty of conspiracy, three visa-fraud counts and obstruction, and after he later pleaded guilty to failure to appear and transportation of stolen property, the court sentenced him to fifty-five months in prison, three years of supervised release, $290,000 restitution and a $250,000 fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The federal record says Park advertised visas through his church, charged applicants as much as $30,000, submitted false seminary transcripts and ordination certificates, and represented that the applicants would be paid associate pastors although they had no religious training and were never employed there. He later tried to recast their payments as donations and used church authority to facilitate a property sale. The religious institution, offices and credentials were the mechanism of the fraud.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/waw/press/2007/aug/park.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of Washington, 'Tacoma Pastor Sentenced to Prison for Conspiracy, Visa Fraud and Obstruction of Justice' (Aug. 10, 2007).",
"body": "The official sentencing release records the trial convictions, later guilty pleas, sentence, false religious-worker positions, fabricated seminary and ordination documents, payment amounts, witness tampering and church-property transaction.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/waw/press/2006/nov/park.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of Washington, 'South Korea Deports Pastor Who Fled U.S. to Escape Sentencing on Visa Fraud Charges' (Nov. 1, 2006).",
"body": "The official pre-sentencing release corroborates the bench-trial verdict, advertising and payment scheme, false church employment, fabricated religious credentials, obstruction and flight posture.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-scheme-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Pastor-sentenced-for-fake-visa-applications-1246364.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Seattle Post-Intelligencer, 'Pastor sentenced for fake visa applications' (Aug. 10, 2007).",
"body": "Contemporaneous local court reporting corroborates the fifty-five-month sentence, religious-worker visa fraud, church sale, restitution and fine.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-local-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/waw/press/2007/aug/park.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1122ee1bb88780ef3a9c1faf38ffa5d61be3831e9701503bdf67c25174222eff",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/waw/press/2007/aug/park.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/waw/press/2006/nov/park.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-scheme-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "53d833bc3256d20df527f3ac6a0a87b43f48216fe6bf8cb58ab3a27698b77f26",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/waw/press/2006/nov/park.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Pastor-sentenced-for-fake-visa-applications-1246364.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "69b74351eb0b0cc3566cb8ca062c56b559b4ac342eb46f263a0c53f1f0838f62",
"final_url": "https://www.seattlepi.com/seattlenews/article/pastor-sentenced-for-fake-visa-applications-1246364.php"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 167,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Millender's convictions, sentence and the approximately $2 million scheme described by the federal court record. It does not attribute the conduct to his co-defendants beyond their adjudicated roles, or to Victorious Life Church members, Christian charities, clergy or pastors generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-terry-millender-alexandria-virginia-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Alexandria, VA, USA",
"lat": 38.8048,
"lng": -77.0469,
"title": "Terry Millender: eight-year sentence for selling a fraudulent investment as a Christian mission",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior pastor of Victorious Life Church",
"religious leader soliciting congregants and clergy as investors"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"Christian charitable mission used as an investment claim",
"pastoral trust",
"guaranteed-return claims",
"false assurances that principal was protected",
"congregational and clergy recruitment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"prosperity-divination",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Victorious Life Church in Alexandria",
"Micro-Enterprise Management Group",
"Kingdom Commodities Unlimited"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia",
"stage": "jury trial and sentence, Case No. 1:16-cr-239",
"date": "2019-02-26",
"outcome": "Following trial convictions for investment and tax fraud, the court sentenced Millender to eight years in federal prison and ordered more than $2 million in restitution."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The official federal disposition states that Millender targeted congregants, clergy and other investors, emphasized a Christian mission of helping poor people, and preyed on victims' religious beliefs and charitable desires. He coupled pastoral trust and religious-purpose claims with guaranteed-return and principal-safety promises, then diverted funds to trading and personal expenses.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edva/pr/pastor-sentenced-prison-investment-fraud-scheme",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Virginia, 'Pastor Sentenced to Prison for Investment Fraud Scheme' (Feb. 26, 2019).",
"body": "The official sentencing release records the trial judgment, eight-year sentence, restitution, victim groups, Christian-mission representation, investment misrepresentations, diversions and prosecutor's finding that Millender preyed on religious beliefs and charitable desires.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edva/pr/pastor-sentenced-prison-investment-fraud-scheme",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6e531c21c05d6c7c5297120e2b409e08088c9befc642b306892cc1adc2f22469",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-edva/pr/pastor-sentenced-prison-investment-fraud-scheme"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 168,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record counts the indecent-liberties disposition and prison sentence. Investigators separately examined alleged adult bondage and pain rituals presented as penitential prayer or redemptive suffering, but the related restraint, battery and sexual-assault charges were not filed under the plea agreement. Those ritual allegations are context only, not additional convictions or findings. The survivor is not identified, and the conduct is not attributed to the parish, diocese, Catholics or priests generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-anthony-jablonowski-guernsey-wyoming-usa",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Guernsey, WY, USA",
"lat": 42.2697,
"lng": -104.7414,
"title": "Anthony Jablonowski: prison sentence for abuse following priestly counseling",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest and pastor of St. Anthony Catholic Church",
"priest providing personal counseling"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly counseling access",
"rectory setting",
"pastoral authority",
"religious confidentiality asserted during the plea process"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Anthony Catholic Church in Guernsey",
"Diocese of Cheyenne"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Platte County District Court, Wyoming",
"stage": "no-contest plea and sentence",
"date": "2004-04-15",
"outcome": "Jablonowski entered a no-contest plea to taking indecent, immodest or immoral liberties with a minor and received a sentence of fifteen months to seven years in prison."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Contemporaneous court reporting states that the abuse occurred in the parish rectory after the seventeen-year-old sought counseling from Jablonowski, then pastor of the local Catholic church. The documented nexus is the access and trust created by priestly counseling and the church setting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/2004_04_27_AP_AChronology_Anthony_Jablonowski_5.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press, 'A Chronology of the Case of Father Anthony Jablonowski' (Apr. 27, 2004), archived by BishopAccountability.org.",
"body": "The contemporaneous chronology sourced to the county attorney, district-court documents and diocese records gives the investigation, no-contest plea, exact sentence and plea agreement's unfiled charges.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-wire-court-reporting-archive",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-procedural-limits"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/2004_04_18_Depperschmidt_WyoEx_Anthony_Jablonowski_3.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ann Depperschmidt, 'Wyo. Ex-Priest's Case Uncovers Lurid Tales,' Denver Post (Apr. 18, 2004), archived by BishopAccountability.org.",
"body": "Contemporaneous sentencing coverage corroborates the prison term, church and priestly setting, and separates the molestation disposition from the prosecutor's account of uncharged ritual conduct.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-regional-court-reporting-archive",
"kind": "sentencing-and-nexus-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2004_01_06/2004_04_28_AP_DioceseEarns.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press, 'Diocese Earns Praise for Help in Abuse Case' (Apr. 28, 2004), archived by BishopAccountability.org.",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting records the diocesan referral, criminal investigation, plea, religious counseling context and the distinction between the conviction and unfiled ritual allegations.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-wire-court-reporting-archive",
"kind": "investigation-and-nexus-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/2004_04_27_AP_AChronology_Anthony_Jablonowski_5.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-wire-court-reporting-archive; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-procedural-limits.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d1c3c8fc523223ca223040feccdb617144c395a57d63f4dc62c32a7f4f2500a4",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/2004_04_27_AP_AChronology_Anthony_Jablonowski_5.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/2004_04_18_Depperschmidt_WyoEx_Anthony_Jablonowski_3.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-regional-court-reporting-archive; evidentiary role: sentencing-and-nexus-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "01050bfc8a6a6c07f6365025ef5a621398a4fc41826d7328e74bb06ea58d0920",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/2004_04_18_Depperschmidt_WyoEx_Anthony_Jablonowski_3.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2004_01_06/2004_04_28_AP_DioceseEarns.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-wire-court-reporting-archive; evidentiary role: investigation-and-nexus-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bd24d02cbe15fc9c0ee9e9b22c3f702b8cce781c6350836f6005298152607c68",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2004_01_06/2004_04_28_AP_DioceseEarns.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 169,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The second-instance tribunal affirmed the first-instance judgment on February 7, 2019; the Holy See made the final, non-appealable result public on April 4, 2019."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This is a final canonical judgment and official church finding, not a Guam or United States criminal conviction. The public Vatican notices say Apuron was guilty of certain accusations, including offenses involving minors, but do not publish a victim count or detailed findings; this record does not infer either. It does not attribute his conduct to the archdiocese's clergy, parishioners, Guam residents or Catholics generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-anthony-apuron-guam-canonical-judgment",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Hagatna, Guam",
"lat": 13.4757,
"lng": 144.7489,
"title": "Anthony Apuron: final Vatican judgment for offenses against minors",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic archbishop of Agaña",
"senior clerical authority in Guam"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"archiepiscopal and clerical authority",
"access to minors through Catholic ministry",
"institutional power over the local archdiocese"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Agaña",
"Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Apostolic Tribunal of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith",
"stage": "first-instance canonical judgment",
"date": "2018-03-16",
"outcome": "A five-judge tribunal found Apuron guilty of certain accusations, including sexual abuse of minors, removed him from office and prohibited him from residing in the Archdiocese of Guam. The judgment was stayed during appeal."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Second-instance tribunal of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith",
"stage": "final canonical appeal",
"date": "2019-02-07",
"outcome": "The appellate tribunal affirmed guilt for offenses against the Sixth Commandment involving minors. The final, non-appealable penalties were permanent removal from office, a perpetual bar on residence in the archdiocese and a perpetual bar on using the insignia of archiepiscopal rank."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The final judgment concerns offenses against minors committed by Guam's Catholic archbishop and adjudicated through the church's canonical system. Apuron's clerical rank and ministry supplied the authority and institutional access at issue; the public judgment does not disclose survivor identities or a detailed doctrinal pretext.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.vaticannews.va/fr/vatican/news/2019-04/archeveque-guam-reconnu-definitivement-coupable-abus-mineurs.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vatican News, 'L'archevêque de Guam reconnu définitivement coupable d'abus sur mineurs' (Apr. 4, 2019).",
"body": "The Holy See's French-language report records the second-instance affirmation, final and non-appealable posture, offense category and permanent penalties.",
"tier": "official-holy-see-report",
"kind": "final-canonical-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.vaticannews.va/en/vatican-city/news/2018-03/apostolic-tribunal-guilty-apuron-agana-guam.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vatican News, 'Vatican finds Guam archbishop guilty of sexual abuse of minors' (Mar. 16, 2018).",
"body": "The English Holy See report reproduces the first-instance tribunal notice, including the five-judge composition, finding on certain accusations, office removal, residence ban and then-pending appeal.",
"tier": "official-holy-see-report",
"kind": "first-instance-canonical-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://archagana.org/news/holy-see-press-office-announces-guilty-verdict-upheld-against-bishop-apuron",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Archdiocese of Agaña, 'Holy See Press Office Announces guilty verdict upheld against Bishop Apuron' (Apr. 4, 2019).",
"body": "The local archdiocesan notice corroborates the final appellate outcome and links the Holy See press-office judgment.",
"tier": "official-local-church-notice",
"kind": "local-institutional-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The second-instance tribunal affirmed the first-instance judgment on February 7, 2019; the Holy See made the final, non-appealable result public on April 4, 2019."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.vaticannews.va/fr/vatican/news/2019-04/archeveque-guam-reconnu-definitivement-coupable-abus-mineurs.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-holy-see-report; evidentiary role: final-canonical-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0264a19ae8d7f1862e7945d829260d2c0f10757b77d955143fa7c9bdedea35a9",
"final_url": "https://www.vaticannews.va/fr/vatican/news/2019-04/archeveque-guam-reconnu-definitivement-coupable-abus-mineurs.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.vaticannews.va/en/vatican-city/news/2018-03/apostolic-tribunal-guilty-apuron-agana-guam.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-holy-see-report; evidentiary role: first-instance-canonical-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "70017fe55e912198724651f2f93f22f2091043e32478d7edc02dca734759d6c6",
"final_url": "https://www.vaticannews.va/en/vatican-city/news/2018-03/apostolic-tribunal-guilty-apuron-agana-guam.html"
},
{
"source": "https://archagana.org/news/holy-see-press-office-announces-guilty-verdict-upheld-against-bishop-apuron",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-local-church-notice; evidentiary role: local-institutional-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 170,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"bayit-chadash",
"aleph-jewish-renewal"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record reports Bayit Chadash's dismissal and ALEPH's institutional finding, ban and revocation of ordination. It is not a criminal conviction. Sexual-assault and rape claims remain allegations in the cited reporting, and Gafni has disputed abuse allegations. Zalman Schachter-Shalomi's documented roles are prior ordainer, public defender in 2004 and the person who later revoked the ordination; the sources do not accuse him of participating in Gafni's alleged conduct. No survivor is identified here, and no culpability is attributed to Jewish Renewal participants, rabbis or Jewish communities generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2006-marc-gafni-aleph-bayit-chadash-israel",
"year": 2006,
"place": "Tel Aviv, Israel",
"lat": 32.0853,
"lng": 34.7818,
"title": "ALEPH substantiates Marc Gafni's ethical breaches and bans him from Jewish Renewal settings",
"tradition": "judaism",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"rabbi and spiritual teacher",
"Bayit Chadash co-founder and leader",
"teacher and employer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rabbinic and spiritual-teacher authority",
"intimidation and psychological manipulation alleged by students and staff",
"secrecy demands",
"institutional and employment power"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Bayit Chadash",
"ALEPH: Alliance for Jewish Renewal"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bayit Chadash",
"stage": "internal review and dismissal",
"date": "2006-05-12",
"outcome": "After women from the community made sworn statements and police complaints, Bayit Chadash's leadership removed Gafni. Its co-founders said relations between a rabbi and students or between an employer and employees were impermissible whether described as consensual or not."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "ALEPH: Alliance for Jewish Renewal",
"stage": "institutional finding, ban and revocation of ordination",
"date": "2006-05-19",
"outcome": "ALEPH later stated that Gafni's ethical breaches were substantiated in 2006, that it condemned his behavior and banned him from ALEPH and Jewish Renewal settings, and that Zalman Schachter-Shalomi revoked Gafni's rabbinical ordination."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "ALEPH: Alliance for Jewish Renewal",
"stage": "public reaffirmation of institutional action",
"date": "2015-12-29",
"outcome": "ALEPH reaffirmed the ban, said it had no credible basis to find that Gafni had completed a process of repair, and warned institutions and students to exercise caution in selecting spiritual teachers."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Gafni held rabbinic, teaching, employment and community-leadership authority over students and staff. The institutional record concerns alleged use of that authority, intimidation, manipulation and secrecy in sexual relationships. ALEPH's reaffirmation specifically warned that spiritual language can function as a veneer that obscures misconduct.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://kolaleph.org/2015/12/29/statement-of-the-jewish-renewal-movement-concerning-marc-gafni/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ALEPH: Alliance for Jewish Renewal, 'Statement of the Jewish Renewal Movement Concerning Marc Gafni' (Dec. 29, 2015).",
"body": "ALEPH's official statement says Gafni's ethical breaches were substantiated in 2006, records its condemnation and ban, states that Zalman Schachter-Shalomi revoked Gafni's ordination, and distinguishes spiritual language from evidence of rehabilitation.",
"tier": "official-institutional-finding",
"kind": "institutional-ban-and-safeguarding-statement"
},
{
"link": "https://forward.com/news/965/rabbi-fired-over-sex-claims-defenders-offer-mea-c/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jennifer Siegel, 'Rabbi Fired Over Sex Claims, Defenders Offer Mea Culpa,' The Forward (May 19, 2006).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting documents Gafni's dismissal, sworn statements and police complaints, the authority relationships described by accusers, his response, Schachter-Shalomi's earlier public defense and later institutional reversal. The article attributes assault and rape claims to the women who made them rather than presenting them as criminal findings.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-national-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-response-and-allegation-report"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://kolaleph.org/2015/12/29/statement-of-the-jewish-renewal-movement-concerning-marc-gafni/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-institutional-finding; evidentiary role: institutional-ban-and-safeguarding-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "34d979eaf0e5b51d752f176d7636c89f640ac35ab333f8c3140814f0173d49dd",
"final_url": "https://kolaleph.org/2015/12/29/statement-of-the-jewish-renewal-movement-concerning-marc-gafni/"
},
{
"source": "https://forward.com/news/965/rabbi-fired-over-sex-claims-defenders-offer-mea-c/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-national-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-response-and-allegation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "105e8730d426834ce7de56a4b9a7daa6f09a653d6dd0f68c96da094c9d2eebf1",
"final_url": "https://forward.com/news/965/rabbi-fired-over-sex-claims-defenders-offer-mea-c/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 171,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"twin-flames-universe"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an active-investigation record, not a charge or guilt finding. The Michigan attorney general's announcement names the organization and says judicially authorized warrants were based on probable cause, but does not identify offenses or defendants. Former-member claims about coerced gender roles or transition remain allegations, and Twin Flames Universe has denied coercing anyone. Those allegations concern claimed organizational conduct; they do not characterize transgender people, transgender identity or voluntary gender-affirming care as abusive.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-twin-flames-universe-michigan-investigation",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Leelanau County, MI, USA",
"lat": 44.8481,
"lng": -85.7665,
"title": "Michigan attorney general opens criminal investigation into Twin Flames Universe",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"online spiritual organization and coaching business",
"founders presented as spiritual teachers and divine counterparts"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"alleged spiritual and romantic destiny claims",
"alleged labor and financial control",
"alleged pressure to accept assigned divine masculine or divine feminine roles",
"alleged threats of spiritual loss and social isolation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Twin Flames Universe"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan Department of Attorney General",
"stage": "ongoing criminal investigation and search warrants",
"date": "2025-07-01",
"outcome": "The attorney general announced an ongoing investigation and said a judge had found probable cause that crimes were committed by Twin Flames Universe and its leadership when authorizing multiple search warrants. No person had been charged or convicted in the announcement."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Twin Flames Universe teaches that it can identify a person's divinely ordained romantic counterpart and markets spiritual instruction for achieving that union. Former members have alleged that leaders used those teachings, claims of divine guidance and the threat of losing spiritual progress to control relationships, labor, money and gender roles.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2025/07/01/ag-nessel-announces-twin-flames-universe-investigation",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'AG Nessel Announces Twin Flames Universe Investigation' (July 1, 2025).",
"body": "The official announcement identifies Twin Flames Universe, its operators and location; records the ongoing investigation and multi-agency search warrants; and states that a judge found probable cause that crimes had been committed by the organization and its leadership. It announces no charge or adjudicated finding.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-announcement",
"kind": "active-investigation-and-search-warrants"
},
{
"link": "https://apnews.com/article/michigan-twin-flames-investigation-a03d0734e11b6ebde2e5f7331818b1d8",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Corey Williams, 'Michigan attorney general investigates Twin Flames Universe,' Associated Press (July 1, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous national reporting corroborates the investigation and gives the organization's response and denial, while distinguishing former-member allegations from official findings.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-national-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-and-response-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.vice.com/en/article/twin-flames-universe-youtubers-monetized-heartbreak-and-trauma-netflix-amazon-prime/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sarah Berman, 'How Twin Flames Universe YouTubers Monetized Heartbreak and Trauma,' VICE (Dec. 4, 2023).",
"body": "Reporting based on interviews and organizational material documents the spiritual doctrine and attributes claims about relationship, labor, financial and gender-role coercion to former members. It also records the organization's denial that members were pressured to change gender.",
"tier": "investigative-reporting",
"kind": "doctrine-allegations-and-response"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-ufo-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The attorney general announced an ongoing investigation and said a judge had found probable cause that crimes were committed by Twin Flames Universe and its leadership when authorizing multiple search warrants. No person had been charged or convicted in the announcement.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2025/07/01/ag-nessel-announces-twin-flames-universe-investigation",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-announcement; evidentiary role: active-investigation-and-search-warrants.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://apnews.com/article/michigan-twin-flames-investigation-a03d0734e11b6ebde2e5f7331818b1d8",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-national-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-and-response-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8626061688a021e4710a37ba50e1f2a792b4f3d66d77a774c27ce2df7b1ba2e1",
"final_url": "https://apnews.com/article/michigan-twin-flames-investigation-a03d0734e11b6ebde2e5f7331818b1d8"
},
{
"source": "https://www.vice.com/en/article/twin-flames-universe-youtubers-monetized-heartbreak-and-trauma-netflix-amazon-prime/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: investigative-reporting; evidentiary role: doctrine-allegations-and-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6d8e8a1ac05e310cfba9d19d3fa5283902f279b25ad48461bc8f4a54385b7b60",
"final_url": "https://www.vice.com/en/article/twin-flames-universe-youtubers-monetized-heartbreak-and-trauma-netflix-amazon-prime/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 172,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"love-has-won",
"gaias-whole-healing-essentials"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This context record does not allege homicide or treat the arrest allegations as proven. Every criminal charge arising from the discovery of Carlson's body was dismissed, the coroner classified her death as natural and no follower was convicted in the matter. The FDA warning establishes unlawful product marketing, not that a named person coerced Carlson to ingest colloidal silver. Former-member abuse accounts require separate verification before any additional public finding is asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-love-has-won-amy-carlson-colorado",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Moffat, CO, USA",
"lat": 37.9989,
"lng": -105.9067,
"title": "Love Has Won: all charges dismissed after Amy Carlson's death",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "death",
"status": "closed-without-charge",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "closed-without-charge",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described Mother God and spiritual leader",
"online spiritual and wellness organization"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claims of divine incarnation and ascension",
"spiritual-healing claims involving colloidal silver",
"group authority around illness and death"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Love Has Won",
"Gaia's Whole Healing Essentials"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration and Federal Trade Commission",
"stage": "regulatory warning",
"date": "2020-04-01",
"outcome": "The agencies warned Gaia's Whole Healing Essentials that products promoted through Love Has Won's website as preventing or treating COVID-19 were unapproved new drugs and misbranded drugs under federal law."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Saguache County Court, Colorado",
"stage": "criminal cases dismissed",
"date": "2021-09-14",
"outcome": "Charges initially filed against seven followers after Carlson's body was found were dismissed. Prosecutors told the court that they believed the corpse-abuse charge was constitutionally questionable in the circumstances. No defendant was convicted in the matter."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Saguache County Coroner",
"stage": "death investigation",
"date": "2021-12-02",
"outcome": "The coroner's report classified Carlson's death as natural and attributed it to global decline in the setting of alcohol abuse, anorexia and chronic colloidal-silver ingestion."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Love Has Won followers treated Carlson as 'Mother God' and described death as spiritual ascension. The organization also marketed colloidal silver through spiritual and wellness claims. Those beliefs provide the documented context for the treatment of her illness and body, but the available proceedings did not establish that another person criminally caused her death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fda.gov/inspections-compliance-enforcement-and-criminal-investigations/warning-letters/gaias-whole-healing-essentials-llc-605893-04012020",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration and Federal Trade Commission, warning letter to Gaia's Whole Healing Essentials, LLC (Apr. 1, 2020).",
"body": "The joint federal warning identifies lovehaswon.org and records the unapproved and misbranded COVID-19 treatment claims made for colloidal-silver products. It is a regulatory finding about marketing, not a criminal judgment or finding about Carlson's death.",
"tier": "official-federal-regulatory-record",
"kind": "warning-letter-and-product-claims"
},
{
"link": "https://coloradosun.com/2021/09/21/charges-against-6-accused-of-tampering-with-body-of-love-has-won-leader/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press, 'Charges against 6 accused of tampering with body of Love Has Won leader are dropped,' Colorado Sun (Sept. 21, 2021).",
"body": "The report confirms the dismissals with the Saguache County court clerk and distinguishes the discovery of Carlson's body and initial allegations from the final no-conviction posture.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "dismissal-and-procedural-posture"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/amy-carlson-death-autopsy-complete-cult-leaders-death-crestone-alcohol-anorexia-silver-ingestion/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS Colorado, 'Autopsy Complete After Cult Leader's Death' (Dec. 2, 2021).",
"body": "Contemporaneous local reporting quotes the Saguache County coroner's report on the natural manner and stated causes of death and notes that the related criminal charges had been dropped.",
"tier": "coroner-sourced-local-reporting",
"kind": "autopsy-and-disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-ufo-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fda.gov/inspections-compliance-enforcement-and-criminal-investigations/warning-letters/gaias-whole-healing-essentials-llc-605893-04012020",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-federal-regulatory-record; evidentiary role: warning-letter-and-product-claims.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0f13ab9fb96f3b15d65598183c66ff355c8a4e7065ca42c3bf1e5ce15e5b8be1",
"final_url": "https://www.fda.gov/inspections-compliance-enforcement-and-criminal-investigations/warning-letters/gaias-whole-healing-essentials-llc-605893-04012020"
},
{
"source": "https://coloradosun.com/2021/09/21/charges-against-6-accused-of-tampering-with-body-of-love-has-won-leader/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: dismissal-and-procedural-posture.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f9bcb5f440cb2597d05c7ecb861405915b1860fb9f37c344ddb026b6c0a6b87b",
"final_url": "https://coloradosun.com/2021/09/21/charges-against-6-accused-of-tampering-with-body-of-love-has-won-leader/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/amy-carlson-death-autopsy-complete-cult-leaders-death-crestone-alcohol-anorexia-silver-ingestion/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: coroner-sourced-local-reporting; evidentiary role: autopsy-and-disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b97edd079bc95c0c8357a22456489423bed2c6c6769561dcde9e44f0948bb405",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/amy-carlson-death-autopsy-complete-cult-leaders-death-crestone-alcohol-anorexia-silver-ingestion/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 173,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Ireland's guilty pleas and sentence. The named spiritualist churches and Reiki practice supplied access and a healing pretext; no source says that the churches knew of or participated in his offenses. The conduct is not attributed to Reiki practitioners, spiritualists, healers or church participants generally, and no complainant is identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-michael-ireland-reiki-stockport-uk",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Stockport, England, UK",
"lat": 53.4106,
"lng": -2.1575,
"title": "Michael Ireland: 16-year sentence for assaults disguised as Reiki and spiritual healing",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Reiki master",
"clairvoyant psychic healer",
"medium and teacher at spiritualist churches"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"purported treatment of emotional blockages",
"demon and chakra claims",
"claimed private healing methods",
"exploitation of therapeutic trust and vulnerability"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Unnamed spiritualist churches and psychic centres in Cheshire and Greater Manchester"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Manchester Minshull Street Crown Court",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentence",
"date": "2013-03-05",
"outcome": "Ireland had pleaded guilty on the scheduled first day of trial in January 2013 to twenty-five sexual-offense counts involving eight complainants over approximately twenty-five years. On March 5 the court imposed a sixteen-year prison sentence, an additional three years on licence and lifetime registration as a sex offender."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The prosecution said that most complainants encountered Ireland through his claimed spiritual practice. He represented assaults as treatments for emotional blockages, demons, nonfunctioning body parts or blocked sexual-chakra energy and persuaded some complainants that sexual touching was a healing act.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.independent.ie/world-news/europe/spiritual-healer-jailed-for-abuse/29111368.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Press Association, 'Spiritual healer jailed for abuse,' Irish Independent (Mar. 5, 2013).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the twenty-five guilty pleas, offense categories, sixteen-year sentence, eight complainants, prosecution account of Ireland's relative power and the specific spiritual-healing representations used during the offenses.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "guilty-pleas-sentence-and-nexus"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.independent.ie/world-news/europe/spiritual-healer-jailed-for-abuse/29111368.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: guilty-pleas-sentence-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 174,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"raelian-movement"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The European Court of Human Rights Grand Chamber identified the January 24, 2002 Lyon judgment as one of the only final French criminal dispositions proved in the later Swiss litigation."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The public European judgment does not name the four convicted people or the adolescents, so this record does not attempt to identify them. It reports the conduct proved in the Lyon case and does not attribute criminal responsibility to Rael, every movement member or the Raelian Movement as a whole. The same European judgment expressly distinguished a separate Colmar conviction involving private family conduct and said that case should not be imputed to the movement; that separate matter is excluded here for lack of a material organizational nexus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-raelian-meetings-lyon-france",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Lyon, France",
"lat": 45.764,
"lng": 4.8357,
"title": "Four Raelian Movement members: final convictions for offenses at movement meetings",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"adult members participating in Raelian Movement meetings",
"movement leaders or senior participants as described in the court record"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"purported philosophical teaching about sexual freedom",
"progressively sexualized touching",
"pressure within movement-organized meetings",
"adult authority over adolescent participants"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"sacred-sex-purity",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Raelian Movement"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lyon Court of Appeal, France",
"stage": "final appellate convictions",
"date": "2002-01-24",
"outcome": "The court convicted four movement members of corruption of female minors for conduct involving adolescents aged fifteen or older at meetings organized by the movement in 1996 and 1997 and imposed prison terms of up to eighteen months, some suspended and some custodial."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The final disposition concerned conduct at Raelian Movement meetings. The judicial record described purported philosophical discourse about sexual freedom, increasingly sexualized touching and escalating pressure by adult movement participants toward adolescents.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/app/conversion/pdf/?filename=001-112165.pdf&id=001-112165&library=ECHR",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mouvement Raëlien Suisse v. Switzerland [GC], no. 16354/06, European Court of Human Rights (July 13, 2012), paras. 180-181 and separate opinion discussion of final French convictions.",
"body": "The Grand Chamber judgment identifies the Lyon Court of Appeal date, offense, number of convicted members, sentence range, ages and movement-meeting context. It also draws the controlling boundary between meeting-related conduct and a separate private-life conviction that should not be attributed to the movement.",
"tier": "international-appellate-court-judgment",
"kind": "final-convictions-and-scope-boundary"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-ufo-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The European Court of Human Rights Grand Chamber identified the January 24, 2002 Lyon judgment as one of the only final French criminal dispositions proved in the later Swiss litigation."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/app/conversion/pdf/?filename=001-112165.pdf&id=001-112165&library=ECHR",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-appellate-court-judgment; evidentiary role: final-convictions-and-scope-boundary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d24130d71c669b673aead35d83f48fb39f3375ec3bb317a83485dde28a9db9ed",
"final_url": "https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/app/conversion/pdf/?filename=001-112165.pdf&id=001-112165&library=ECHR"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 175,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Bomjon is currently acquitted in this proceeding and is presumed innocent unless a final court judgment establishes guilt. The district conviction was vacated on limitation grounds, and the High Court stated that a merits analysis was unnecessary. This entry reports the pending Supreme Court appeal, omits the complainant's identity and does not incorporate separate allegations concerning disappearances, money laundering or other ashram members. It does not attribute the allegation to Buddhism, ascetics, ashrams or followers generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-ram-bahadur-bomjon-sarlahi-nepal",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Pattharkot, Sarlahi District, Nepal",
"lat": 27.0737,
"lng": 85.5966,
"title": "Ram Bahadur Bomjon: Supreme Court appeal pending after High Court acquittal",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented ascetic and guru who led an ashram community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-teacher authority over a minor resident disciple",
"ashram residence and dependency",
"alleged sexual abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Maitri Dharma ashram community"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sarlahi District Court, Nepal",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-07-01",
"outcome": "The district court convicted Bomjon of child sexual abuse, sentenced him to 10 years in prison and ordered Rs 500,000 in compensation. That judgment was later vacated in full on appeal."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Janakpur High Court, Nepal, cases 081-CS-0216 and 081-CS-0304",
"stage": "acquittal and dismissal of charge sheet",
"date": "2025-03-19",
"outcome": "The High Court vacated the conviction, dismissed the charge sheet and acquitted Bomjon because it held that the case was filed outside the limitation period under the law in force when the alleged conduct occurred. The court said that this threshold ruling made a merits analysis unnecessary."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Nepal",
"stage": "government appeal pending",
"date": "2025-08-19",
"outcome": "The Office of the Attorney General appealed the acquittal, arguing that the High Court applied the limitation rules incorrectly. A May 2026 report continued to identify the child-sexual-abuse appeal as pending; no later disposition was located."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The charging record concerns a minor who entered Bomjon's ashram as a young follower and lived there as an ani, or female renunciant. Prosecutors alleged that Bomjon abused her while exercising guru authority within the residential ashram. The spiritual relationship and institution supplied access and dependency; the allegation itself remains unresolved while the government's appeal is pending.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lktcdn2.prixacdn.net/media/pdf_upload/ram-bahadur-bamjan_faisala.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ram Bahadur Bomjon alias Ram Lal Bomjon v. Government of Nepal, cases 081-CS-0216 and 081-CS-0304, Janakpur High Court (Mar. 19, 2025; certified Apr. 17, 2025).",
"body": "The appellate judgment records the protected complainant's minor status and residence as an ani in Bomjon's ashram, the allegations and charge, the district conviction and sentence, both appeals, and the High Court's limitation ruling vacating the conviction and dismissing the charge sheet without reaching the merits.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://en.setopati.com/social/165045",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Setopati, 'Appeal filed against decision to acquit Ram Bahadur Bomjon of child sexual abuse' (Aug. 19, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting quotes the Supreme Court's information officer and the Office of the Attorney General on receipt of the appeal, identifies the limitation issue, and accurately states the vacated district sentence and High Court acquittal.",
"tier": "court-and-prosecutor-sourced-reporting",
"kind": "supreme-court-appeal"
},
{
"link": "https://english.arthasarokar.com/2026/05/ram-bahadur-bomjan-acquitted-of-money-laundering-case-2.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Artha Sarokar, 'Ram Bahadur Bomjon acquitted of money laundering case' (May 3, 2026).",
"body": "The report is used only for its current-status statement that the separate child-sexual-abuse case remained pending in the Supreme Court in May 2026. This record does not incorporate or characterize the unrelated money-laundering proceeding.",
"tier": "current-local-reporting",
"kind": "pending-appeal-status-check"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The Office of the Attorney General appealed the acquittal, arguing that the High Court applied the limitation rules incorrectly. A May 2026 report continued to identify the child-sexual-abuse appeal as pending; no later disposition was located.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lktcdn2.prixacdn.net/media/pdf_upload/ram-bahadur-bamjan_faisala.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2671850129e3d6e26c2887f917cf32e9b19d0ecc76291588315261e00df47162",
"final_url": "https://lktcdn2.prixacdn.net/media/pdf_upload/ram-bahadur-bamjan_faisala.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://en.setopati.com/social/165045",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-and-prosecutor-sourced-reporting; evidentiary role: supreme-court-appeal.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ccd0a3c3c4285cba8f917e87adeb7ce86c25ca9f5ac1c28b7e4b9f6ecd558625",
"final_url": "https://en.setopati.com/social/165045"
},
{
"source": "https://english.arthasarokar.com/2026/05/ram-bahadur-bomjan-acquitted-of-money-laundering-case-2.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: current-local-reporting; evidentiary role: pending-appeal-status-check.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7e135dca304050731013359df4a5db9da9f409eca2b20aeafbee548f80615059",
"final_url": "https://english.arthasarokar.com/2026/05/ram-bahadur-bomjan-acquitted-of-money-laundering-case-2.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 176,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Lobsang Gyatso and two students were killed on February 4, 1997. No suspect has been tried in the cited record. This entry reports the Indian police and CBI accusation and does not attribute the murders to the Dorje Shugden Devotees Charitable and Religious Society, the New Kadampa Tradition, Dorje Shugden practitioners generally or any named person beyond the two charged fugitives. The separate claim that Shugden practitioners suffered systematic retaliation is not included: the Delhi High Court dismissed a petition that supplied no specific attacks or unaddressed police complaints and made no finding on the underlying religious dispute.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1997-dharamsala-dorje-shugden-murder-case-india",
"year": 1997,
"place": "Dharamsala, Himachal Pradesh, India",
"lat": 32.219,
"lng": 76.3234,
"title": "Dharamsala triple murder: two Dorje Shugden-associated suspects charged but never tried",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"two fugitives whom Indian police associated with Dorje Shugden supporters"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"alleged sectarian retaliation against a critic of the practice",
"lethal enforcement of a disputed religious position"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Indian police and Central Bureau of Investigation",
"stage": "murder and criminal-conspiracy charges with non-bailable warrants",
"outcome": "Indian authorities accused Lobsang Chodak and Tenzin Chozin of participating in the killings and sought their return from China. The accusations have not been tried."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "INTERPOL, at India's request",
"stage": "Red Notices",
"outcome": "Public Red Notices sought the two men for criminal conspiracy, murder and trespass with intent to assault and cause harm. Academic review found that the notices remained active in 2017; the current public status could not be established."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Indian police alleged that the two suspects were associated with Dorje Shugden supporters and targeted Lobsang Gyatso, an outspoken opponent of the practice, in a sectarian dispute. The alleged religious motive is part of the charging theory, not an adjudicated finding.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/interpol-warrant-for-2-chinese/articleshow/2129301.cms",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Press Trust of India, 'Interpol warrant for 2 Chinese,' Times of India (June 17, 2007).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting records the CBI's non-bailable warrants, the murder and criminal-conspiracy accusations, the two suspects' alleged association with the Dorje Shugden society and the INTERPOL notices. It does not report a trial or conviction.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-and-investigation-reporting",
"kind": "charges-warrants-and-red-notices"
},
{
"link": "https://oro.open.ac.uk/54130/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Suzanne Newcombe, 'Certain Beliefs and Uncertain Evidence: the Case of Shugden,' in Minority Religions and Uncertainty (Routledge, 2020), pp. 22-43.",
"body": "The peer-reviewed chapter checks the competing claims surrounding the dispute. It reports that Indian police were still seeking extradition through INTERPOL in 2017, identifies the charges and emphasizes that no trial had established the suspects' guilt. It also finds no adequate evidence for the broadest persecution claims made by either side.",
"tier": "peer-reviewed-academic-analysis",
"kind": "charge-status-and-evidence-boundary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.upi.com/Top_News/2007/06/22/Interpol-slaying-suspects-in-China/58111182538993/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United Press International, 'Interpol: slaying suspects in China' (June 22, 2007).",
"body": "Independent contemporaneous reporting corroborates that INTERPOL issued notices at the request of Indian police for the two men accused in the 1997 killings and explains that the notices sought their location and return for trial.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-wire-reporting",
"kind": "red-notice-corroboration"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Public Red Notices sought the two men for criminal conspiracy, murder and trespass with intent to assault and cause harm. Academic review found that the notices remained active in 2017; the current public status could not be established.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/interpol-warrant-for-2-chinese/articleshow/2129301.cms",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-and-investigation-reporting; evidentiary role: charges-warrants-and-red-notices.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c7f49dee07ebf9fddeb6b659e9b27ae75d8129338433870b9ffd7f92d6b5c8ae",
"final_url": "https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/interpol-warrant-for-2-chinese/articleshow/2129301.cms"
},
{
"source": "https://oro.open.ac.uk/54130/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: peer-reviewed-academic-analysis; evidentiary role: charge-status-and-evidence-boundary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.upi.com/Top_News/2007/06/22/Interpol-slaying-suspects-in-China/58111182538993/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-wire-reporting; evidentiary role: red-notice-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d2c63cf7921644b0d881e57e3dd2a337dbd3af77e1e66f3141a2c90a870bec18",
"final_url": "https://www.upi.com/Top_News/2007/06/22/Interpol-slaying-suspects-in-China/58111182538993/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 177,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Williams maintained his innocence. His 2021 convictions were set aside for an unfair trial, a retrial was ordered and the prosecution then discontinued all charges. This record therefore reports no current conviction or adjudicated finding of guilt. It does not characterize Aboriginal elders, traditional healers, Indigenous cultural practices or Aboriginal communities generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-joseph-luke-williams-charges-discontinued-western-australia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Albany, Western Australia, Australia",
"lat": -35.0275,
"lng": 117.884,
"title": "Joseph Luke Williams: convictions overturned and all retrial charges discontinued",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "closed-without-charge",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "closed-without-charge",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented Aboriginal elder and traditional healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual healing for trauma and infertility",
"claimed magical powers",
"trust obtained through purported traditional-healer authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of Western Australia at Albany",
"stage": "jury verdicts and sentence later overturned",
"date": "2021-05-03",
"outcome": "A jury had convicted Williams on 12 of 14 sexual-offense counts, and the court imposed a 12-year sentence. Those verdicts and the sentence were later overturned on appeal and do not stand."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Western Australia",
"stage": "successful criminal appeal and retrial order",
"date": "2022-12-02",
"outcome": "The appellate court found that Williams did not receive a fair trial, set aside the verdicts and ordered a retrial. Reported grounds included the prosecution's cross-examination, defense counsel's failure to follow instructions and the trial judge's jury directions."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of Western Australia at Perth",
"stage": "all charges discontinued",
"date": "2023-06-23",
"outcome": "The state prosecutor discontinued every retrial charge, telling the court that the state had determined there was no public interest in continuing the matter. No conviction remains."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "At the overturned trial, the prosecution alleged that Williams falsely presented himself as an Aboriginal elder and traditional healer, claimed that he could heal trauma and infertility and invoked purported magical powers. The trial judge described the women as seeking spiritual healing and guidance. Those allegations explain the inclusion of this closed context record, but they are not current findings of guilt.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-07-31/joseph-luke-williams-albany-tour-guide-charges-dropped/102668752",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ABC News, 'Sexual assault charges against Aboriginal tour guide Joseph Williams dropped after two years' (July 31, 2023).",
"body": "Current court reporting records the successful appeal, the unfair-trial grounds, the retrial order and the prosecutor's June 23, 2023 discontinuance of every charge on public-interest grounds.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "appeal-and-final-discontinuance"
},
{
"link": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-05-03/joseph-williams-jailed-for-sexual-assaults/100112708",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ABC News, 'Indigenous tour guide Joseph Williams jailed for sexually assaulting six women' (May 3, 2021; updated July 31, 2023).",
"body": "The contemporaneous trial and sentencing report documents the alleged traditional-healing pretexts and the authority nexus. Its editor's note now states that all charges were discontinued after the successful appeal; the earlier verdicts are not treated as current findings.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "vacated-trial-record-and-spiritual-nexus"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-07-31/joseph-luke-williams-albany-tour-guide-charges-dropped/102668752",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appeal-and-final-discontinuance.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3af05d2ed5aff2ef7740ca146256d73f7a864f99990f38f8bd57b8e6a1ed6787",
"final_url": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-07-31/joseph-luke-williams-albany-tour-guide-charges-dropped/102668752"
},
{
"source": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-05-03/joseph-williams-jailed-for-sexual-assaults/100112708",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: vacated-trial-record-and-spiritual-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ae1b4d75a19ebdd9fa6f63dfcc990a351981fe4ee48c935f90e2b0aab853084c",
"final_url": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-05-03/joseph-williams-jailed-for-sexual-assaults/100112708"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 178,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The child is not identified. This record concerns Sierra Avendaño's individual final conviction and does not attribute his conduct to the congregation, Christianity, pastors or Colombian religious communities generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-virgilio-sierra-avendano-cartagena-colombia",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Cartagena, Bolívar, Colombia",
"lat": 10.391,
"lng": -75.4794,
"title": "Virgilio Sierra Avendaño: final 24-year sentence for abusing a congregant's child",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor and religious leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust",
"access to a congregant's child after worship services",
"isolation in a private room"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal trial court in Cartagena, Colombia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-10-09",
"outcome": "The court convicted Sierra Avendaño of aggravated sexual offenses involving a child under 14 and imposed a 24-year prison sentence. The defense appealed."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber, Superior Tribunal of the Judicial District of Cartagena",
"stage": "appellate affirmance",
"date": "2025-08-06",
"outcome": "The tribunal affirmed the conviction and 24-year sentence. Prosecutor-sourced reporting states that the decision became final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sierra Avendaño used his position as the pastor of the child's mother to obtain access after worship services, when he took the child to his room. The adjudicated record therefore ties the abuse to pastoral trust and church-based access rather than religious employment alone.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/08/07/dos-pastores-religiosos-fueron-condenados-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Caracol Radio, 'Dos pastores religiosos fueron condenados por abuso sexual en Cartagena' (Aug. 6, 2025).",
"body": "Prosecutor-sourced appellate reporting records the Superior Tribunal's affirmance, the 24-year sentence, the 2014 conduct after worship services and that the decision became final.",
"tier": "prosecutor-sourced-appellate-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.semana.com/nacion/cartagena/articulo/condenan-a-pastor-que-abuso-de-la-hija-de-una-feligresa-en-cartagena-defensa-apelo-la-decision/202412/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Semana, 'Condenan a pastor que abusó de la hija de una feligresa, en Cartagena; defensa apeló la decisión' (Oct. 9, 2024).",
"body": "Contemporaneous trial reporting attributes the underlying facts to the Fiscalía, records the pastor-congregant relationship, the post-service access, the conviction and sentence and the defense appeal.",
"tier": "prosecutor-sourced-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "trial-conviction-and-authority-nexus"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/08/07/dos-pastores-religiosos-fueron-condenados-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecutor-sourced-appellate-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b9a758f10b61b674c7336e3ce89715072c9dcdeff372ddf26bb534961244316b",
"final_url": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/08/07/dos-pastores-religiosos-fueron-condenados-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.semana.com/nacion/cartagena/articulo/condenan-a-pastor-que-abuso-de-la-hija-de-una-feligresa-en-cartagena-defensa-apelo-la-decision/202412/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecutor-sourced-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-conviction-and-authority-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d687e8746e3afbc4e55c0966cc3265483f537ffb2df700cfe531f1bb8534acc0",
"final_url": "https://www.semana.com/nacion/cartagena/articulo/condenan-a-pastor-que-abuso-de-la-hija-de-una-feligresa-en-cartagena-defensa-apelo-la-decision/202412/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 179,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The 16-year conviction remains in force, but an extraordinary cassation appeal was reported after the appellate affirmance; no final cassation ruling was located. Initial prosecutor-sourced reporting dates the offense to February 22, 2020, while the later appellate report describes it as occurring in 2019. This record uses the specific date from the initial disposition reporting and does not merge a separate pending allegation involving another congregant. It does not attribute the conduct to Christianity, deliverance practice, pastors or the congregation generally. Consolidated from a duplicate entry of the same defendant and proceeding; sources from both were merged.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-sergio-luis-betancourt-yepes-cartagena-colombia",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Cartagena, Bolívar, Colombia",
"lat": 10.391,
"lng": -75.4794,
"title": "Sergio Luis Betancourt Yepes: 16-year sentence for assault during a purported deliverance ritual",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor and religious leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"purported liberation from evil spirits",
"application of oils that caused somnolence",
"pastoral trust and access to a congregant's home"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal trial court in Cartagena, Colombia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-15",
"outcome": "The court convicted Betancourt Yepes of aggravated sexual intercourse with a person incapable of resisting and imposed a 16-year prison sentence. The adjudicated conduct involved a congregant whom he purported to liberate from evil spirits."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber, Superior Tribunal of the Judicial District of Cartagena",
"stage": "appellate affirmance with extraordinary cassation filed",
"date": "2025-08-06",
"outcome": "The tribunal left the 16-year sentence in force. The defense filed an extraordinary cassation appeal, and no later cassation disposition was located."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Betancourt Yepes entered a congregant's home under the pretext of a ritual to free her from evil spirits. During the purported ritual, he applied oils that caused somnolence and assaulted her while she was unable to resist. The ritual and pastoral relationship supplied the access, trust and state of vulnerability used in the offense.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/01/16/pastor-condenado-a-16-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Caracol Radio, 'Pastor condenado a 16 años de prisión por abuso sexual en Cartagena' (Jan. 15, 2025).",
"body": "Prosecutor-sourced trial reporting records the 16-year conviction, the February 22, 2020 date, the congregant relationship, the purported deliverance ritual and the use of oils that caused somnolence.",
"tier": "prosecutor-sourced-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "trial-conviction-and-ritual-pretext"
},
{
"link": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/08/07/dos-pastores-religiosos-fueron-condenados-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Caracol Radio, 'Dos pastores religiosos fueron condenados por abuso sexual en Cartagena' (Aug. 6, 2025).",
"body": "Prosecutor-sourced appellate reporting records that the Superior Tribunal left the 16-year sentence in force and that the defense filed an extraordinary cassation appeal. It also restates the deliverance ritual, oils and resulting inability to resist.",
"tier": "prosecutor-sourced-appellate-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-affirmance-and-open-cassation"
},
{
"link": "https://www.elespectador.com/judicial/a-la-carcel-pastor-de-iglesia-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-feligresas-en-cartagena/?outputType=amp",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Espectador, 'A la cárcel pastor de iglesia que abusó sexualmente de feligresas en Cartagena' (Jan. 15, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting based on the Fiscalía announcement records Betancourt's identity, sixteen-year sentence, two victims and accepted charge. It describes home visits framed as liberation from evil spirits and oils that caused drowsiness before the assaults.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.vanguardia.com/judicial/2025/01/16/condenan-a-pastor-que-abuso-de-mujer-en-supuesto-exorcismo-en-cartagena/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vanguardia, 'Condenan a pastor que abusó de mujer en supuesto exorcismo en Cartagena' (Jan. 16, 2025).",
"body": "Independent contemporaneous reporting quotes the prosecution's judgment announcement and corroborates the sentence, defendant, offense date, exorcism claim and use of oils to incapacitate a congregant.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/01/16/pastor-condenado-a-16-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecutor-sourced-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-conviction-and-ritual-pretext.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e8050c6b585020c04fdcbdd9a1bf121ec4e51b4f444dd5e2c6dd58a9fe422e0a",
"final_url": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/01/16/pastor-condenado-a-16-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/"
},
{
"source": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/08/07/dos-pastores-religiosos-fueron-condenados-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecutor-sourced-appellate-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-affirmance-and-open-cassation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b9a758f10b61b674c7336e3ce89715072c9dcdeff372ddf26bb534961244316b",
"final_url": "https://caracol.com.co/2025/08/07/dos-pastores-religiosos-fueron-condenados-por-abuso-sexual-en-cartagena/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.elespectador.com/judicial/a-la-carcel-pastor-de-iglesia-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-feligresas-en-cartagena/?outputType=amp",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bea4389882b96a98bafb2447e556227b30a8a24ad9f382b88d5a018f94a90824",
"final_url": "https://www.elespectador.com/judicial/a-la-carcel-pastor-de-iglesia-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-feligresas-en-cartagena/?outputType=amp"
},
{
"source": "https://www.vanguardia.com/judicial/2025/01/16/condenan-a-pastor-que-abuso-de-mujer-en-supuesto-exorcismo-en-cartagena/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "730f1eff9b289fa79c66b7636073fe8dc3ced86d11211a0ac97dcadbf7487d56",
"final_url": "https://www.vanguardia.com/judicial/2025/01/16/condenan-a-pastor-que-abuso-de-mujer-en-supuesto-exorcismo-en-cartagena/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 180,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"ogyen-kunzang-choling"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The 2018 appellate judgment was quashed in 2019. The Liège Court of Appeal entered the operative judgment on December 2, 2020, and the Belgian Court of Cassation rejected Spatz's appeal on October 5, 2022."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This entry concerns Robert Spatz's individual Belgian conviction. It does not assign culpability to Buddhism, Tibetan Buddhist institutions, visiting teachers, followers, parents or other OKC personnel. Ogyen Kunzang Choling is unrelated to Jetsunma Ahkon Lhamo's Kunzang Palyul Choling despite the similar names. A separate French investigation reported in 2025 remains unresolved and is not merged into the Belgian disposition. The sexual-abuse findings are described with the court's limitation ruling: the conduct was found proved, but those counts were time-barred for punishment.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-robert-spatz-ogyen-kunzang-choling-belgium",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Brussels and Liège, Belgium",
"lat": 50.8503,
"lng": 4.3517,
"title": "Robert Spatz: final five-year suspended sentence for abuse and exploitation within OKC",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder",
"self-presented Lama Kunzang",
"spiritual leader of Ogyen Kunzang Choling"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claims that parents had harmful karmic influence on their children",
"separation of children from parents",
"religious education and punishment under the founder's authority",
"unpaid labor and institutional dependency",
"sexual conduct presented as ritual teaching for enlightenment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Ogyen Kunzang Choling"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Brussels criminal court and Court of Appeal, Belgium",
"stage": "first-instance judgment and first appeal later quashed",
"outcome": "The Belgian proceeding produced a 2016 judgment and a 2018 appellate judgment. The Court of Cassation quashed the 2018 judgment in 2019 and sent the matter for retrial in Liège; this record does not treat the quashed disposition as final."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Liège Court of Appeal, Belgium",
"stage": "judgment after remand",
"date": "2020-12-02",
"outcome": "The court convicted Spatz of offenses including coercive control, physical abuse of minors, financial offenses and sexual abuse that the court found proved but time-barred for punishment. It imposed five years' imprisonment suspended, a 5,500-euro fine and civil damages exceeding 600,000 euros."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Cassation of Belgium",
"stage": "cassation appeal rejected",
"date": "2022-10-05",
"outcome": "The Court of Cassation rejected Spatz's appeal, leaving the 2020 Liège judgment in force and ending the Belgian criminal proceeding."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Spatz presented himself as Lama Kunzang and used claimed Buddhist and karmic authority to direct family life within OKC. The record describes parents persuaded that their karmic influence harmed their children, children separated for religious education under his chosen staff and sexual acts presented to minors as ritual teachings that would move spiritual energies or accelerate enlightenment. Those claims supplied authority, isolation and dependency for the adjudicated abuse and exploitation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bx1.be/categories/news/justice-le-pourvoi-de-robert-spatz-dans-le-dossier-de-la-secte-okc-est-rejete/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Belga / BX1, 'Justice: le pourvoi de Robert Spatz dans le dossier de la secte OKC est rejeté' (Oct. 6, 2022).",
"body": "Court-sourced reporting records the Court of Cassation's rejection, the December 2, 2020 Liège judgment, the five-year suspended sentence and fine, and the sequence of the 2016 trial, 2018 appeal, 2019 quashing and 2020 retrial.",
"tier": "national-news-agency-appellate-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://nos.nl/artikel/2359383-belgische-sekteleider-veroordeeld-zijn-misbruik-zou-me-snel-verlichten",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NOS, 'Belgische sekteleider veroordeeld: zijn misbruik zou me snel verlichten' (Dec. 4, 2020; Dutch).",
"body": "The Dutch public broadcaster's contemporaneous court report describes the proven offenses, child-parent separation, compelled labor, karmic teaching, sexual ritual and enlightenment claims, suspended sentence and the court's limitation treatment of sexual abuse.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-and-spiritual-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lemonde.fr/m-le-mag/article/2025/06/20/les-enfants-sacrifies-de-la-secte-de-robert-spatz-j-ai-recu-des-gifles-des-coups-de-pied-j-ai-ete-enferme-prive-de-nourriture-plusieurs-jours-d-affilee_6614732_4500055.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le Monde, 'Les enfants sacrifiés de la secte de Robert Spatz' (June 20, 2025; French).",
"body": "Later documentary reporting corroborates the self-assumed lama authority, karmic child-parent separation claims, religious education, ritual-enlightenment pretexts, the 2020 Belgian judgment and damages, while separately identifying the still-pending French investigation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-documentary-reporting",
"kind": "authority-nexus-and-current-scope"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The 2018 appellate judgment was quashed in 2019. The Liège Court of Appeal entered the operative judgment on December 2, 2020, and the Belgian Court of Cassation rejected Spatz's appeal on October 5, 2022."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bx1.be/categories/news/justice-le-pourvoi-de-robert-spatz-dans-le-dossier-de-la-secte-okc-est-rejete/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency-appellate-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aeb5f680d5968de29fa12ca696d213bd23a408876c7e4a4b76d25c4be125f33f",
"final_url": "https://bx1.be/categories/news/justice-le-pourvoi-de-robert-spatz-dans-le-dossier-de-la-secte-okc-est-rejete/"
},
{
"source": "https://nos.nl/artikel/2359383-belgische-sekteleider-veroordeeld-zijn-misbruik-zou-me-snel-verlichten",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-and-spiritual-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2d1f2495388eebece86025f39cc6280b1133b41b3d374589b12b5e693ea99903",
"final_url": "https://nos.nl/artikel/2359383-belgische-sekteleider-veroordeeld-zijn-misbruik-zou-me-snel-verlichten"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lemonde.fr/m-le-mag/article/2025/06/20/les-enfants-sacrifies-de-la-secte-de-robert-spatz-j-ai-recu-des-gifles-des-coups-de-pied-j-ai-ete-enferme-prive-de-nourriture-plusieurs-jours-d-affilee_6614732_4500055.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-documentary-reporting; evidentiary role: authority-nexus-and-current-scope.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8ea6db777a3aaf8c41dda6530253442078a901090844af4adaa660403cf5c0e2",
"final_url": "https://www.lemonde.fr/m-le-mag/article/2025/06/20/les-enfants-sacrifies-de-la-secte-de-robert-spatz-j-ai-recu-des-gifles-des-coups-de-pied-j-ai-ete-enferme-prive-de-nourriture-plusieurs-jours-d-affilee_6614732_4500055.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 181,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"german-bishops-conference"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The MHG Study is a commissioned retrospective descriptive study, not a criminal investigation or a list of adjudicated offenders. 'Accused' does not mean convicted. Researchers did not inspect original church files directly; diocesan staff or law firms extracted anonymized data. The authors describe the findings as the known minimum, warn that the design cannot establish causation and state that the counts underestimate the true frequency. This record does not attribute culpability to Catholic clergy, laypeople, dioceses or German Catholics generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-mhg-study-catholic-church-germany",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Germany",
"lat": 51.1657,
"lng": 10.4515,
"title": "MHG Study: commissioned review identifies 1,670 accused clerics and 3,677 affected minors",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy",
"diocesan assignment authorities",
"church file custodians and institutional leadership"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"power and access attached to ordained office",
"clerical and institutional authority over children",
"transfers without adequate notice",
"secrecy and deficient record handling",
"institutional protection of the accused"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"German Bishops' Conference",
"27 Catholic dioceses in Germany"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "German Bishops' Conference",
"stage": "commissioned independent research project",
"date": "2014-03-01",
"outcome": "The conference commissioned a consortium based at Mannheim, Heidelberg and Gießen to conduct a retrospective descriptive study across all 27 German dioceses."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "MHG research consortium and German Bishops' Conference",
"stage": "study publication",
"date": "2018-09-25",
"outcome": "The study reviewed information drawn from 38,156 personnel and reference files covering 1946 through 2014. It identified allegations involving 1,670 clerics and 3,677 children and adolescents in the reviewed records."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "German Bishops' Conference",
"stage": "institutional response",
"date": "2018-09-27",
"outcome": "The bishops publicly acknowledged institutional failure and committed to further independent review, prevention, recognition and compensation work."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The commissioned study found that ordained office could give accused clergy power, authority and largely unrestricted access to children. It also documented transfer practices, secrecy and record failures that could protect accused clerics and expose additional children. The spiritual nexus is the authority and institutional protection attached to clerical office, not Catholic identity by itself.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dbk.de/fileadmin/redaktion/diverse_downloads/Dossiers_alt/dossiers_2018/MHG-Study-eng-Endbericht-Zusammenfassung.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Harald Dreßing et al., Sexual Abuse of Minors by Catholic Priests, Deacons and Male Members of Orders in the Domain of the German Bishops' Conference, English summary of final report (2018).",
"body": "The commissioned study's official English summary states the design, review period, participation of all 27 dioceses, 38,156 files reviewed, 1,670 accused clerics, 3,677 affected minors, institutional findings, and the limits created by indirect file access, undercounting and a descriptive design.",
"tier": "commissioned-independent-study",
"kind": "official-study-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.dbk.de/themen/sexualisierte-gewalt-und-praevention/forschung-und-aufarbeitung/studien/mhg-studie",
"archive": "",
"citation": "German Bishops' Conference, MHG Study project and publication record.",
"body": "The commissioning institution's project page identifies the research consortium, confirms participation across the German dioceses and preserves the report and related project materials.",
"tier": "commissioning-institution-record",
"kind": "study-provenance"
},
{
"link": "https://www.dbk.de/fileadmin/redaktion/diverse_downloads/presse_2018/2018-154a-Anlage1-engl.-Erklaerung-der-Deutschen-Bischofskonferenz-zu-den-Ergebnissen-der-MHG-Studie.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "German Bishops' Conference, statement on the results of the MHG Study (Sept. 27, 2018).",
"body": "The bishops' official response acknowledges institutional failure and records the institutional commitments made after publication. It is cited as the subject institution's response, not as independent validation of the study.",
"tier": "institutional-response",
"kind": "official-response"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dbk.de/fileadmin/redaktion/diverse_downloads/Dossiers_alt/dossiers_2018/MHG-Study-eng-Endbericht-Zusammenfassung.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioned-independent-study; evidentiary role: official-study-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4d54d3ac3c961a45b1631a4dbef0444d016e147c036ce0ee6887112cbfad110a",
"final_url": "https://www.dbk.de/fileadmin/redaktion/diverse_downloads/Dossiers_alt/dossiers_2018/MHG-Study-eng-Endbericht-Zusammenfassung.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.dbk.de/themen/sexualisierte-gewalt-und-praevention/forschung-und-aufarbeitung/studien/mhg-studie",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioning-institution-record; evidentiary role: study-provenance.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.dbk.de/fileadmin/redaktion/diverse_downloads/presse_2018/2018-154a-Anlage1-engl.-Erklaerung-der-Deutschen-Bischofskonferenz-zu-den-Ergebnissen-der-MHG-Studie.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-response; evidentiary role: official-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 182,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The High Court dismissed EE's first appeal in 2024. The Court of Appeal unanimously upheld the rape conviction and sentence on September 22, 2025. The separate causing-hurt conviction was not part of that appeal. No later Federal Court disposition was located."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The adult victim is not identified. This record distinguishes the affirmed rape conviction from the separate unappealed causing-hurt conviction and reports the later payment demand only as part of the case facts, not as a separate conviction. The sources do not identify a religious tradition, so the case is classified under spiritual healing and does not attribute the conduct to Malaysian religious communities, mediums or traditional healers generally. No later Federal Court disposition was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-ee-yong-nan-spiritual-cleansing-batang-kali-malaysia",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Batang Kali, Selangor, Malaysia",
"lat": 3.468,
"lng": 101.653,
"title": "EE Yong Nan: Court of Appeal upholds 12-year sentence for rape during a purported cleansing ritual",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"medium",
"traditional healer invited to address claimed spiritual disturbances"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual-cleansing service",
"ritual authority in a private home",
"directions separating the adult victim from her partner and companions",
"breach of healer trust",
"later payment demand and retention of property"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions Court, Malaysia",
"stage": "convictions and sentence",
"outcome": "The court convicted EE of raping an adult during the March 30, 2018 visit and imposed twelve years' imprisonment and five strokes of the cane. It separately imposed eight months for causing hurt to the victim's boyfriend; the sentences run concurrently."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Malaya",
"stage": "appeal dismissed",
"outcome": "The High Court dismissed EE's appeal and upheld the Sessions Court disposition. The reviewed source does not supply a more precise decision date."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Malaysia",
"stage": "rape conviction and sentence affirmed",
"date": "2025-09-22",
"outcome": "A unanimous three-judge panel dismissed EE's appeal from the rape conviction and sentence. The panel held the sentence appropriate in light of the breach of trust inherent in his role as a traditional healer."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The couple contacted EE because they believed their home was affected by spiritual disturbances. He attended as a medium to perform a cleansing ritual, directed companions to take the victim's boyfriend elsewhere and isolated the victim in a bedroom before the offense. The Court of Appeal expressly treated his role as a traditional healer as a breach of trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bernama.com/en/news.php?id=2470021",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bernama, 'Court Of Appeal Upholds Medium's 12-year Jail, Caning For Rape' (Sept. 22, 2025).",
"body": "Malaysia's national news agency reports from the appellate hearing and identifies the panel, unanimous disposition, sentence, breach-of-trust finding, prior appeals, ritual-cleansing facts, isolation of the victim, separate hurt conviction and later payment demand.",
"tier": "national-news-agency-appellate-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2025/09/22/court-of-appeal-upholds-12-year-jail-term-caning-for-medium-who-raped-teacher-during-cleansing-ritual/192007",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Malay Mail / Bernama, 'Court of Appeal upholds 12-year jail term, caning for medium who raped teacher during cleansing ritual' (Sept. 22, 2025).",
"body": "The national newspaper's publication preserves Bernama's detailed courtroom account and corroborates the public record. Because it is a wire republication rather than independent reporting, it is not counted as a separate source-of-record.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-wire-republication",
"kind": "appellate-report-republication"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The High Court dismissed EE's first appeal in 2024. The Court of Appeal unanimously upheld the rape conviction and sentence on September 22, 2025. The separate causing-hurt conviction was not part of that appeal. No later Federal Court disposition was located."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bernama.com/en/news.php?id=2470021",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency-appellate-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3f752873767d63756d9e2e2e638084f241619029244fc0f5b6c7725fc06e963",
"final_url": "https://www.bernama.com/en/news.php?id=2470021"
},
{
"source": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2025/09/22/court-of-appeal-upholds-12-year-jail-term-caning-for-medium-who-raped-teacher-during-cleansing-ritual/192007",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-wire-republication; evidentiary role: appellate-report-republication.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8fd07b6bf52c44256964093aa54449556a0af7440fd77aae2f745840df9be39e",
"final_url": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2025/09/22/court-of-appeal-upholds-12-year-jail-term-caning-for-medium-who-raped-teacher-during-cleansing-ritual/192007"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 183,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"ulimo-j"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an official truth-commission finding and self-incriminating hearing record, not a criminal conviction. The commission's decision not to recommend prosecution is stated explicitly. Blahyi gave very large numerical estimates for killings and sacrifices, but this record does not treat those estimates as verified victim counts. It reports the admitted conduct and the commission's responsibility finding without attributing it to Krahn people, Liberian traditional religions, Indigenous practitioners, militia members generally or Blahyi's later Christian ministry.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-joshua-milton-blahyi-liberia-trc-finding",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Monrovia, Liberia",
"lat": 6.3156,
"lng": -10.8074,
"title": "Liberia TRC: Joshua Milton Blahyi found responsible after testimony about wartime human sacrifice",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"initiated traditional priest for the Krahn community",
"ULIMO-J militia commander",
"ritual specialist claiming protective power over fighters"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"human sacrifice presented as required by deities before military missions",
"priestly authority over fighters and ritual decisions",
"claimed spiritual protection and battlefield power",
"selection of captured civilians and children for secret killings",
"armed-group command and control"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"United Liberation Movement for Democracy in Liberia, Johnson faction"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Liberia",
"stage": "public testimony",
"date": "2008-01-15",
"outcome": "Blahyi testified under his own name that he had acted as a traditional priest and ULIMO-J commander, killed people as sacrifices to deities before and after military missions, and used children among the victims. The testimony was an admission before a truth commission, not a criminal guilty plea."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Liberia",
"stage": "final findings and accountability recommendation",
"date": "2009-06-30",
"outcome": "The commission placed Joshua Milton Blahyi among persons it found responsible but recommended not be prosecuted because it concluded that they cooperated, admitted their crimes, testified truthfully and expressed remorse. No criminal conviction resulted from that recommendation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Blahyi told the commission that he was initiated as a priest, claimed responsibility for protecting Krahn fighters through ritual means and said human sacrifice was required by the deities he represented before military operations. The TRC separately found that ritual and juju practices were widely used during Liberia's wars and influenced fighters' conduct toward captives and civilians. His claimed priesthood and ritual obligations were therefore described as an operational reason for specific killings, alongside his armed command authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.trcofliberia.org/transcripts/7.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Liberia, public hearing transcript, testimony of Joshua Milton Blahyi (Jan. 15, 2008).",
"body": "The official transcript records Blahyi's claimed priestly office, ritual-protection role, statements that military missions required human sacrifices to deities, references to child victims and the commissioners' questioning. His numerical estimates are retained as testimony only and are not used as verified counts.",
"tier": "official-truth-commission-transcript",
"kind": "self-incriminating-official-hearing"
},
{
"link": "https://trcofliberia.org/press_releases/199.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Liberia, press release on testimony by Joshua Milton Blahyi and Allen Nicholas (Jan. 2008).",
"body": "The commission's contemporaneous release confirms Blahyi's appearance, initiation into traditional priesthood, account of ritual sacrifices and request for forgiveness. It is cited as the commission's summary, not independent corroboration of every claim.",
"tier": "official-truth-commission-release",
"kind": "hearing-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://liberiapastandpresent.org/TRC/trc-of-liberia-final-report-volume-ii.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Liberia, Consolidated Final Report, Volume II (2009), sections 8.3 and 12.4.",
"body": "The final report finds that ritual and juju practices influenced wartime conduct and lists Joshua Milton Blahyi among persons found responsible but not recommended for prosecution because the commission found cooperation, admissions, truthful testimony and remorse. The archival copy preserves the commission report.",
"tier": "official-truth-commission-report-archive",
"kind": "responsibility-finding-and-accountability-disposition"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.trcofliberia.org/transcripts/7.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-truth-commission-transcript; evidentiary role: self-incriminating-official-hearing.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2e32774447dcc024fa953b843c452b7404c5f83b45f8e4d18203c3d244dace60",
"final_url": "https://www.trcofliberia.org/transcripts/7.html"
},
{
"source": "https://trcofliberia.org/press_releases/199.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-truth-commission-release; evidentiary role: hearing-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bb92b89e559f3098edc9894b0a61e680cb15bb89d9ca003ab74b68b5b98a474f",
"final_url": "https://trcofliberia.org/press_releases/199.html"
},
{
"source": "https://liberiapastandpresent.org/TRC/trc-of-liberia-final-report-volume-ii.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-truth-commission-report-archive; evidentiary role: responsibility-finding-and-accountability-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "daa06e16aa28169159eb18e772464ac450caf5a0baf67199fa8f86a28bf1a0e3",
"final_url": "https://liberiapastandpresent.org/TRC/trc-of-liberia-final-report-volume-ii.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 184,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Court of Appeal dismissed HCC/0210/23 on May 26, 2026. No later Supreme Court disposition was located."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The child is not identified here even though the public judgment prints his name. This record concerns Sujatha's individual conviction and the authority relationship proved in court. It does not attribute the offense to the hermitage, the monk who suggested ordination, Buddhist monastics, child ordination, Sri Lankan Buddhists or temples generally. No later Supreme Court disposition was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-uduwila-sujatha-elpitiya-sri-lanka",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Uduwila, Elpitiya, Sri Lanka",
"lat": 6.2906,
"lng": 80.1614,
"title": "Uduwila Sujatha: Court of Appeal affirms ten-year sentence for abuse of a child preparing for ordination",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"chief monk of a forest hermitage",
"temple authority responsible for a child preparing for ordination"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"temple residence while preparing for ordination",
"religious authority over a prospective novice",
"family illness and financial hardship increasing dependency",
"summons to the chief monk's private room",
"attempt to have police settle the complaint"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Thapowana Aranya Senasanaya"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Balapitiya, Sri Lanka, CRI/2449/19",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-08-29",
"outcome": "The High Court convicted Uduwila Sujatha of grave sexual abuse of a nine-year-old child and imposed ten years' rigorous imprisonment, a fine and compensation."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of Sri Lanka, HCC/0210/23",
"stage": "appeal dismissed",
"date": "2026-05-26",
"outcome": "A two-judge bench rejected the challenges to the evidence, upheld the conviction and sentencing order and dismissed the appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The appellate judgment states that the child was attending school near the temple and, after another monk suggested ordination, moved into the hermitage to prepare. Sujatha was the chief monk and summoned the child to his private room. The prospective ordination and residential temple relationship supplied custody, access and authority beyond Sujatha's religious title alone.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://courtofappeal.lk/wp-content/uploads/judgements/HCC-210-23-new.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Court of Appeal of Sri Lanka, Rev. Uduwila Sujatha v. Hon. Attorney General, HCC/0210/23 (May 26, 2026).",
"body": "The official judgment records the High Court conviction and sentence, chief-monk role, child's temple residence while preparing for ordination, offense evidence, medical corroboration, attempted settlement, rejected defenses and dismissal of the appeal. The child's name is omitted from this database.",
"tier": "official-appellate-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-affirmance-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/court-upholds-10-year-prison-sentence-against-monk-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Asian Mirror, 'Court upholds 10-year prison sentence against monk in child sexual abuse case' (May 27, 2026).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting corroborates the appellate disposition, sentence, hermitage leadership, ordination setting and evidence while allowing the public record to be described without reproducing the child's identity.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-appellate-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Court of Appeal dismissed HCC/0210/23 on May 26, 2026. No later Supreme Court disposition was located."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://courtofappeal.lk/wp-content/uploads/judgements/HCC-210-23-new.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-appellate-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-affirmance-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "faf48ff5a7060f561060665312702fa1bc75c3f95313a1236f01e70f282fc7ca",
"final_url": "https://courtofappeal.lk/wp-content/uploads/judgements/HCC-210-23-new.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/court-upholds-10-year-prison-sentence-against-monk-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-appellate-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "84b0d3cbac990b052ecebccf3a401ceba4e334a043551d6126a41ae855a56ee8",
"final_url": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/court-upholds-10-year-prison-sentence-against-monk-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 185,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"portugal-independent-commission-catholic-abuse",
"portuguese-episcopal-conference"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a commissioned institutional study, not a criminal adjudication. The commission used a respondent-driven sample and expressly warned that it could not be extrapolated to the wider population. It validated 512 testimonies; its figure of approximately 4,815 was a rough minimum derived by adding other victims whom respondents said they knew, not 4,815 separately verified cases. Names supplied to prosecutors or Church authorities are not published here, and no individual guilt is inferred from the report.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-portugal-independent-commission-catholic-abuse",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Lisbon, Portugal",
"lat": 38.7223,
"lng": -9.1393,
"title": "Portugal independent commission validates 512 testimonies of child sexual abuse in the Catholic Church",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy",
"pastoral agents",
"bishops and religious superiors",
"church institutions entrusted with children"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority",
"institutional custody",
"closed religious settings",
"institutional failure to remove or report alleged abusers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Independent Commission for the Study of Child Sexual Abuse in the Portuguese Catholic Church",
"Portuguese Episcopal Conference",
"Portuguese Catholic Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent Commission for the Study of Child Sexual Abuse in the Portuguese Catholic Church",
"stage": "commissioned independent study and final report",
"date": "2023-02-13",
"outcome": "The nonjudicial commission validated 512 testimonies concerning abuse from 1950 through 2022, referred 25 potentially timely matters to prosecutors, and reported institutional patterns and recommendations."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The commission studied abuse by clergy and other people working in Church settings where sacred office, pastoral authority, education, residential care and the physical spaces of religious life created access and unequal power. In the validated sample, priests were identified in 77 percent of reports, and frequently reported locations included seminaries, churches, confessionals, rectories and religious schools. The record concerns the use and protection of authority inside those settings, not Catholic belief or worship generally.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/reports-2023-02-13-Independent-Commission-Portuguese-Catholic-Church-Executive-Summary-English.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Independent Commission for the Study of Child Sexual Abuse in the Portuguese Catholic Church, Giving Silence a Voice: Final Report, Executive Summary (Feb. 2023).",
"body": "The commission's English executive summary defines its nonjudicial mandate, 1950-2022 scope, qualitative and quantitative methods, witness-validation process, respondent-driven sampling limits, preliminary archive review, 512 validated testimonies, prosecutor referrals, institutional findings and rough calculation of additional victims known to respondents.",
"tier": "commissioned-independent-report",
"kind": "final-report-executive-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.conferenciaepiscopal.pt/v1/declaracao-do-presidente-da-cep-apos-a-apresentacao-do-estudo-da-comissao-independente/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Portuguese Episcopal Conference, statement after presentation of the Independent Commission study (Feb. 13, 2023).",
"body": "The commissioning body records its November 2021 decision to create the independent commission, acknowledges victims harmed by clergy and other pastoral agents in Church life and activities, and commits to reviewing the final report and its recommendations.",
"tier": "commissioning-institution",
"kind": "official-response"
},
{
"link": "https://www.portugal.gov.pt/pt/gc23/comunicacao/comunicado?i=governo-reuniu-se-com-a-comissao-independente-para-o-estudo-dos-abusos-sexuais-de-criancas-na-igreja-catolica",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Government of Portugal, meeting with the Independent Commission for the Study of Child Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church (Feb. 2023).",
"body": "The Portuguese Government records its meeting with the commission to consider the scope and recommendations of the final report, including legal reform, prevention and public child-protection measures.",
"tier": "government-record",
"kind": "official-government-response"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/reports-2023-02-13-Independent-Commission-Portuguese-Catholic-Church-Executive-Summary-English.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioned-independent-report; evidentiary role: final-report-executive-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a59cec60eccfbb4cde48ed66c0606e08dd48d3544f42e98328030c9e0a75e454",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/reports-2023-02-13-Independent-Commission-Portuguese-Catholic-Church-Executive-Summary-English.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.conferenciaepiscopal.pt/v1/declaracao-do-presidente-da-cep-apos-a-apresentacao-do-estudo-da-comissao-independente/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioning-institution; evidentiary role: official-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b578f5946176c55548a0e3ce1bfcb1eeca034e7d62bc339f2329e0a72c8ed7a7",
"final_url": "https://www.conferenciaepiscopal.pt/v1/declaracao-do-presidente-da-cep-apos-a-apresentacao-do-estudo-da-comissao-independente/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.portugal.gov.pt/pt/gc23/comunicacao/comunicado?i=governo-reuniu-se-com-a-comissao-independente-para-o-estudo-dos-abusos-sexuais-de-criancas-na-igreja-catolica",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-record; evidentiary role: official-government-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0086bff93877590115747b8ebb1c55a2a94a9554da4d307d0633384c84c956e3",
"final_url": "https://portugal.gov.pt/gc23/comunicacao/comunicados/governo-reuniu-se-com-a-comissao-independente-para-o-estudo-dos-abusos-sexuais-de-criancas-na-igreja-catolica"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 186,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"diocese-of-tarnow"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Jeż denies the charge and is presumed innocent. The diocese did conduct internal inquiries and eventually notified authorities; the dispute is whether notification occurred without legally prohibited delay. This record makes no finding about Jeż, does not adjudicate the underlying allegations against the two priests, and omits their identities. It will require an update when the trial reaches a disposition.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-andrzej-jez-tarnow-poland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Tarnów, Poland",
"lat": 50.0121,
"lng": 20.9858,
"title": "Tarnów bishop on trial over alleged delay in reporting child-abuse allegations against priests",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic bishop",
"diocesan superior",
"institutional reporting authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical hierarchy",
"institutional control of abuse reports",
"alleged delay in notifying law enforcement"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Tarnów"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court in Tarnów, Poland",
"stage": "criminal trial pending",
"date": "2026-02-18",
"outcome": "Bishop Andrzej Jeż pleaded not guilty when trial began on allegations that he failed to notify authorities without delay after receiving credible information about alleged abuse by two priests under his authority."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The pending charge concerns Jeż's alleged conduct as diocesan bishop and superior after information about alleged abuse by priests entered Church procedures. Prosecutors contend that the religious institution's internal handling did not satisfy the civil duty to report without delay. The alleged nexus is institutional control exercised through clerical hierarchy, not the bishop's religious title standing alone.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://apnews.com/article/poland-catholic-church-child-abuse-priest-trial-e794edfd55f60da459b0dcf8e7e4ea61",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Claudia Ciobanu, 'Polish bishop on trial over alleged delays in reporting claims of child abuse by priests,' Associated Press (Feb. 18, 2026).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the opening of the trial, the prosecution's allegation that credible information was not reported immediately, the Church's eventual reports, Jeż's claim of innocence and possible sentence if convicted.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "trial-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.polskieradio.pl/395/7789/Artykul/3649840%2Cpolish-bishop-on-trial-over-alleged-delay-in-reporting-child-sex-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Polish Radio / Polish Press Agency, 'Polish bishop on trial over alleged delay in reporting child sex abuse' (Feb. 18, 2026).",
"body": "Poland's public broadcaster, citing the state news agency's courtroom reporting, records the Tarnów court, the pending charge, 2024 indictment, reporting-duty context, defense account and scheduled continuation of the trial.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-and-procedure-report"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Bishop Andrzej Jeż pleaded not guilty when trial began on allegations that he failed to notify authorities without delay after receiving credible information about alleged abuse by two priests under his authority.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://apnews.com/article/poland-catholic-church-child-abuse-priest-trial-e794edfd55f60da459b0dcf8e7e4ea61",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "441747aa37b47e7d58188a16c9b613890844bd8641d7a169bb5a609999295988",
"final_url": "https://apnews.com/article/poland-catholic-church-child-abuse-priest-trial-e794edfd55f60da459b0dcf8e7e4ea61"
},
{
"source": "https://www.polskieradio.pl/395/7789/Artykul/3649840%2Cpolish-bishop-on-trial-over-alleged-delay-in-reporting-child-sex-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-and-procedure-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c807f2b8b809a3f1cba118c86ff4ec10a34a927ac3ae6823e8fda1df2ecf2d09",
"final_url": "https://www.polskieradio.pl/395/7789/Artykul/3649840%2Cpolish-bishop-on-trial-over-alleged-delay-in-reporting-child-sex-abuse"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 187,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"deetman-commission",
"dutch-bishops-conference",
"dutch-religious-conference"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a commissioned institutional inquiry, not a court judgment. The commission received 1,795 relevant reports but said those reports alone could not measure prevalence. It also used archives and a survey of 34,234 Dutch residents aged 40 or older. Its estimate of approximately 10,000 to 20,000 victims concerns a defined cohort raised Catholic, resident in Catholic institutions and reporting abuse by Church personnel from 1945 to 1981; it is not a count of separately adjudicated cases. Roughly 800 reported names were traced to Church personnel, but the commission made no legal determination that those allegations were proved.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-deetman-commission-catholic-abuse-netherlands",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Utrecht, Netherlands",
"lat": 52.0907,
"lng": 5.1214,
"title": "Deetman Commission documents authority-linked abuse and institutional failures in the Dutch Catholic Church",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy and religious",
"pastoral workers and church personnel",
"bishops and religious superiors",
"church institutions entrusted with minors"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abuse of a position of authority",
"institutional custody",
"closed hierarchical culture",
"internal sanctions and transfers",
"failure to encourage police reporting"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Commission of Inquiry into Sexual Abuse of Minors in the Roman Catholic Church",
"Dutch Bishops' Conference",
"Dutch Religious Conference"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Commission of Inquiry into Sexual Abuse of Minors in the Roman Catholic Church, Netherlands",
"stage": "commissioned independent inquiry and final report",
"date": "2011-12-16",
"outcome": "The commission issued general findings on abuse from 1945 to 2010, the exercise of authority, institutional responses and victim support, while expressly declining to make legal findings against named individuals."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The commission defined its subject as sexual contact by clergy, religious, pastoral workers and other Church representatives with minors entrusted to them who felt unable to refuse because of physical dominance, unequal authority, emotional pressure, compulsion or force. Its archive review found that senior religious authorities knew abuse occurred, commonly used internal measures such as transfer or suspension, and did not make police reporting part of their administrative practice or encourage victims and parents to report.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2011_12_16_Deetman_Seksueel_Misbruik/Deetman_Report_English_Summary.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission of Inquiry into Sexual Abuse of Minors in the Roman Catholic Church, Sexual Abuse of Minors in the Roman Catholic Church, English summary of final report (Dec. 16, 2011).",
"body": "The commission's English summary states its mandate, authority-based definition, nonlegal standard, 1,795 relevant reports, 34,234-person survey, prevalence limits, defined 10,000-20,000 estimate, archive findings, hierarchy's knowledge, internal transfers and sanctions, and failures to prioritize victims or encourage reporting.",
"tier": "commissioned-independent-report",
"kind": "final-report-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rkkerk.nl/reactie-bisschoppenconferentie-en-knr-op-eindrapport-commissie-deetman/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dutch Bishops' Conference and Dutch Religious Conference, response to the Deetman Commission final report (Dec. 16, 2011).",
"body": "The commissioning institutions acknowledge the final report, apologize to victims, state that perpetrators and Church authorities who failed to act correctly share responsibility, and describe the intended institutional response.",
"tier": "commissioning-institutions",
"kind": "official-response"
},
{
"link": "https://zoek.officielebekendmakingen.nl/kst-33000-VI-81.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Government of the Netherlands, parliamentary paper 33 000 VI, no. 81, government response and debate concerning the Deetman Commission report (2012).",
"body": "The official parliamentary record documents the Dutch government's consideration of the report, victim support, limitation periods and the responsibilities of Church and state institutions.",
"tier": "official-parliamentary-record",
"kind": "government-response"
}
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2011_12_16_Deetman_Seksueel_Misbruik/Deetman_Report_English_Summary.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioned-independent-report; evidentiary role: final-report-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "873f11f60739ac864a03668cb344dc6bb39e2321fca94769bf997ed9c9fa014a",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2011_12_16_Deetman_Seksueel_Misbruik/Deetman_Report_English_Summary.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rkkerk.nl/reactie-bisschoppenconferentie-en-knr-op-eindrapport-commissie-deetman/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: commissioning-institutions; evidentiary role: official-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "af7901fe447b7befed680bf635b86dcfa2c686fc15efd1455673682f4a21e791",
"final_url": "https://www.rkkerk.nl/reactie-bisschoppenconferentie-en-knr-op-eindrapport-commissie-deetman/"
},
{
"source": "https://zoek.officielebekendmakingen.nl/kst-33000-VI-81.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-parliamentary-record; evidentiary role: government-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "daf2e39c61f09f8e3be52a9462c72c431e3ff429f16a8d925161aad4efde0c7a",
"final_url": "https://zoek.officielebekendmakingen.nl/kst-33000-VI-81.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 188,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"lexcity-church"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns King's admitted offenses and sentence. It does not attribute culpability to LexCity Church or other congregants. The victim is not identified. No appellate proceeding was located in the sources reviewed through July 17, 2026.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-zachary-king-lexcity-lexington-kentucky",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Lexington, Kentucky, USA",
"lat": 38.0406,
"lng": -84.5037,
"title": "Zachary King: former LexCity executive pastor sentenced after admitting sexual offenses against a minor congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"former executive pastor",
"pastor in a position of spiritual trust"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"access to a minor congregant",
"abuse of spiritual trust"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"LexCity Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fayette Circuit Court, Kentucky, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea",
"date": "2026-03-23",
"outcome": "King pleaded guilty to seven felony counts, including first-degree rape, first-degree sodomy and first-degree sexual abuse, arising from offenses against a minor who attended his church."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Fayette Circuit Court, Kentucky, USA",
"stage": "sentencing",
"date": "2026-06-04",
"outcome": "The court imposed a 13-year prison sentence and lifetime sex-offender registration."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Kentucky's attorney general described King as having used a position of spiritual trust to abuse a minor congregant. His executive-pastor role supplied trusted access and authority within the church relationship; the nexus does not rest on religious employment alone.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kentucky.gov/Pages/Activity-stream.aspx?n=AttorneyGeneral&prId=1901",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Office of the Kentucky Attorney General, 'Former Lexington Pastor Pleads Guilty to Rape and Sexual Abuse of Minor' (Mar. 23, 2026).",
"body": "The official announcement identifies King's former executive-pastor role, the minor congregant, seven felony guilty pleas, the agreed sentencing recommendation and the attorney general's finding that the conduct abused a position of spiritual trust.",
"tier": "official-prosecution-record",
"kind": "guilty-plea-announcement"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wkyt.com/2026/06/04/former-lexington-pastor-sentenced-rape-sexual-abuse-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WKYT, 'Former Lexington pastor sentenced for rape, sexual abuse of minor' (June 4, 2026).",
"body": "Contemporaneous local court reporting records the Fayette Circuit Court's 13-year sentence and lifetime registration requirement.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kentucky.gov/Pages/Activity-stream.aspx?n=AttorneyGeneral&prId=1901",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecution-record; evidentiary role: guilty-plea-announcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a643acf3f3d61a0d73c8a08ccfdde60483aff025b75ef65a27b0c0c9c13f3b9e",
"final_url": "https://www.kentucky.gov/Pages/Activity-stream.aspx?n=AttorneyGeneral&prId=1901"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wkyt.com/2026/06/04/former-lexington-pastor-sentenced-rape-sexual-abuse-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e7c2f2edb756805e673389918d4f4bb1f598abdc518c6870d2d64bb13990a0dd",
"final_url": "https://www.wkyt.com/2026/06/04/former-lexington-pastor-sentenced-rape-sexual-abuse-minor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 189,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"back-to-eden-ministry-fiji"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"court": "Fiji Court of Appeal",
"date": "2016-11-07",
"outcome": "Appeal filed; later disposition not located."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The ministry was reported as a breakaway from Seventh-day Adventism. This classification describes the group's documented origin and teachings; it does not attribute responsibility to the Seventh-day Adventist Church. Reporting places conduct in Labasa and Tailevu, while Suva is used as the map location because the High Court adjudicated the case there. The two complainants are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-iowane-vakadranu-back-to-eden-fiji",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Suva, Fiji",
"lat": -18.1248,
"lng": 178.4501,
"title": "Iowane Vakadranu: Back to Eden pastor convicted after using divine-command claims to sexually exploit followers",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-adventist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor",
"founder and leader of Back to Eden Ministry",
"religious teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine command",
"claimed spiritual preparation for mission work",
"closed religious instruction",
"pastoral authority",
"promised exemption from sickness, sin and death"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Back to Eden Ministry"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Fiji at Suva",
"stage": "criminal conviction",
"date": "2016-09-30",
"outcome": "Vakadranu was convicted on four counts of rape involving two young followers of his ministry."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Fiji at Suva",
"stage": "sentencing",
"date": "2016-10-05",
"outcome": "The court sentenced him to 14 years and two months' imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 12 years and two months."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Fiji Court of Appeal",
"stage": "appeal filed",
"date": "2016-11-07",
"outcome": "Vakadranu filed an appeal against conviction and sentence. No later disposition was located in the sources reviewed through July 17, 2026."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The sentencing record describes Vakadranu using pastoral authority and claimed messages from God to present sexual acts as preparation for gospel mission work. The court found that he had conditioned followers' beliefs and exploited the resulting trust and obedience.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-guilty-of-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiji Times, 'Pastor guilty of rape' (Sept. 30, 2016).",
"body": "Contemporaneous High Court reporting records the four guilty verdicts, the two complainants and the prosecution's evidence about the ministry's religious teaching and control.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-75-jailed-for-raping-girls/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiji Times, 'Pastor, 75, jailed for raping girls' (Oct. 6, 2016).",
"body": "The sentencing report records the prison and non-parole terms and the judge's findings that Vakadranu used religious claims, trust and premeditated deception to exploit followers.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/314085/leader-of-fiji-religious-sect-found-guilty-of-rape",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio New Zealand, 'Leader of Fiji religious sect found guilty of rape' (Sept. 30, 2016).",
"body": "The regional public broadcaster corroborates the conviction and identifies Back to Eden as a breakaway Adventist group, while describing the teachings used in the abuse.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-context-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-files-appeal/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiji Times, 'Pastor files appeal' (Nov. 8, 2016).",
"body": "The report records the notice of appeal against both conviction and sentence; the present audit did not locate a later judgment resolving it.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "appeal-filing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"court": "Fiji Court of Appeal",
"date": "2016-11-07",
"outcome": "Appeal filed; later disposition not located."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-guilty-of-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "858452d4792259a7f4fe237aef6555d36b44b0af5b18dbe4b09405426799a2f2",
"final_url": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-guilty-of-rape/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-75-jailed-for-raping-girls/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "03684a80d96fe9d689983376aa9ecfbbd3f6a17c6a5b0c4c555ec4cf6e1d827a",
"final_url": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-75-jailed-for-raping-girls/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/314085/leader-of-fiji-religious-sect-found-guilty-of-rape",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-context-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e2eeb23dcfda3aaee4e6d5cf05ced18bb615104b9ca316b53b5db76ebbe91d6f",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/314085/leader-of-fiji-religious-sect-found-guilty-of-rape"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-files-appeal/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appeal-filing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2114888ebc32f8a50bb297fd33584a7a1e46ea248708fc1a3148b0948c82b32f",
"final_url": "https://www.fijitimes.com.fj/pastor-files-appeal/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 190,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"wat-ratanak-moni"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The record is limited to conduct adjudicated in the Siem Reap case. Reporting mentioned investigative interest in other pagodas, but no warrant or adjudication established additional offenses, so those allegations are excluded. The minor complainants are not identified. No later appellate disposition was located in the sources reviewed through July 17, 2026.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-vong-chet-ratanak-moni-pagoda-cambodia",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Siem Reap, Cambodia",
"lat": 13.3633,
"lng": 103.8564,
"title": "Vong Chet: former pagoda chief sentenced for sexual abuse of novice monks in residential care",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"former chief monk",
"pagoda head",
"religious teacher",
"residential custodian"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial religious authority",
"strict monastic discipline",
"payments for silence",
"threatened beatings",
"institutional dependency"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Wat Ratanak Moni"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Siem Reap Provincial Court, Cambodia",
"stage": "criminal conviction and sentence",
"date": "2016-06-09",
"outcome": "The court sentenced Vong Chet to 15 years in prison after convicting him of purchasing child prostitution and sex with minors involving novice monks in his care."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Vong Chet was the chief monk and residential authority over novice monks entrusted to the pagoda. The evidence described his control of discipline, living conditions and religious instruction, together with payments and threats used to suppress disclosure. That custodial spiritual authority was material to the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://english.cambodiadaily.com/2016/06/11/pagoda-chief-gets-15-years-for-rape-of-boys/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Cambodia Daily, 'Pagoda Chief Gets 15 Years for Rape of Boys' (June 11, 2016).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the conviction, 15-year sentence, custodial relationship and evidence involving novice monks at Wat Ratanak Moni.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://english.cambodiadaily.com/2015/11/10/pagoda-chief-confesses-to-raping-boys/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Cambodia Daily, 'Pagoda Chief Confesses to Raping Boys' (Nov. 10, 2015).",
"body": "Contemporaneous arrest reporting documents the head-monk role, complaints by families, residential custody, threatened discipline and payments used to discourage disclosure.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "arrest-and-authority-report"
},
{
"link": "https://mosvy.gov.kh/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/%E1%9E%82%E1%9F%84%E1%9E%9B%E1%9E%93%E1%9F%84%E1%9E%94%E1%9E%B6%E1%9E%99%E1%9E%9C%E1%9E%8F%E1%9F%92%E1%9E%8F%E1%9E%9F%E1%9F%90%E1%9E%84%E1%9F%92%E1%9E%80%E1%9E%A0%E1%9E%80%E1%9E%BB%E1%9E%98%E1%9E%B6%E1%9E%9A_%E1%9F%A2%E1%9F%A0%E1%9F%A2%E1%9F%A0_English.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kingdom of Cambodia, Ministry of Cults and Religion and Ministry of Social Affairs, Veterans and Youth Rehabilitation, Child Safeguarding Policy for Pagodas (2020).",
"body": "The official safeguarding policy recognizes that Cambodian pagodas provide residential care and education, defines duties to prevent and report abuse, and specifies additional procedures when the alleged abuser is a head monk.",
"tier": "official-government-policy",
"kind": "institutional-authority-context"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://english.cambodiadaily.com/2016/06/11/pagoda-chief-gets-15-years-for-rape-of-boys/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "30ceac1ca74f9bdcc40358339772a270be6cce88ca75f02728116c6d445f5e9a",
"final_url": "https://english.cambodiadaily.com/2016/06/11/pagoda-chief-gets-15-years-for-rape-of-boys/"
},
{
"source": "https://english.cambodiadaily.com/2015/11/10/pagoda-chief-confesses-to-raping-boys/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: arrest-and-authority-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a89ac2120301dfae8082107e9c253b712557639c39aeb58c02c9b10d98229e3c",
"final_url": "https://english.cambodiadaily.com/2015/11/10/pagoda-chief-confesses-to-raping-boys/"
},
{
"source": "https://mosvy.gov.kh/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/%E1%9E%82%E1%9F%84%E1%9E%9B%E1%9E%93%E1%9F%84%E1%9E%94%E1%9E%B6%E1%9E%99%E1%9E%9C%E1%9E%8F%E1%9F%92%E1%9E%8F%E1%9E%9F%E1%9F%90%E1%9E%84%E1%9F%92%E1%9E%80%E1%9E%A0%E1%9E%80%E1%9E%BB%E1%9E%98%E1%9E%B6%E1%9E%9A_%E1%9F%A2%E1%9F%A0%E1%9F%A2%E1%9F%A0_English.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-policy; evidentiary role: institutional-authority-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 191,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"family-federation-japan"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Tokyo High Court upheld the district court on March 4, 2026; the Supreme Court rejected the organization's special appeal on June 22, 2026."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This is a final civil dissolution order concerning the Japanese religious corporation, commonly called the Unification Church or 'Moonies,' not a criminal conviction and not a finding against every member. The organization contested the order through the Supreme Court. Dissolution removes the corporation's legal personality and begins liquidation; the Supreme Court expressly stated that it does not prohibit religious practice or prevent the group from continuing without corporate status. No culpability is attributed to Unification Church members, related organizations outside Japan, Koreans, Japanese people or new religious movements generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-unification-church-dissolution-japan",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Tokyo, Japan",
"lat": 35.6762,
"lng": 139.6503,
"title": "Unification Church in Japan: final dissolution order over organized unlawful donation solicitation",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious corporation",
"founder-derived doctrinal authority",
"organizational fundraising hierarchy"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrine-backed donation demands",
"organizational numeric targets",
"solicitation beyond reasonable financial means",
"failure to prevent unlawful solicitation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Family Federation for World Peace and Unification in Japan"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tokyo District Court, Japan",
"stage": "religious-corporation dissolution order",
"date": "2025-03-25",
"outcome": "The court ordered the religious corporation dissolved after finding statutory grounds based on unlawful donation-solicitation conduct and resulting harm."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Tokyo High Court, Japan",
"stage": "immediate appeal",
"date": "2026-03-04",
"outcome": "The court upheld the district court's dissolution order and liquidation began under a court-appointed liquidator."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Japan, Third Petty Bench, Reiwa 8 (Ku) No. 407",
"stage": "special appeal",
"date": "2026-06-22",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court rejected the special appeal, making the dissolution order final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Japan's Supreme Court found that unlawful donation solicitation occurred under organized involvement by the religious corporation. The decision tied the targets to founder-derived policy that Japanese believers should provide financial support for countries around the world even beyond reasonable means, and found that the corporation had not taken effective steps to prevent improper solicitation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courts.go.jp/assets/hanrei/hanrei-pdf-96677.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Japan, Third Petty Bench, Reiwa 8 (Ku) No. 407, religious-corporation dissolution order decision (June 22, 2026; Japanese).",
"body": "The official final decision rejects the special appeal and records the long-running unlawful donation solicitation, property and psychological harm, founder-derived policy, organizational targets, lack of effective prevention, necessity of dissolution and the limit that dissolution does not prohibit religious activity.",
"tier": "official-final-court-decision",
"kind": "final-dissolution-order"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bunka.go.jp/seisaku/shukyohojin/94340501.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Agency for Cultural Affairs, Japan, 'Dissolution order and commencement of liquidation procedures for the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification' (updated June 24, 2026; Japanese).",
"body": "The supervising agency records the March 4 High Court decision, June 22 Supreme Court rejection, appointment of a liquidator and commencement of liquidation.",
"tier": "official-government-procedure-record",
"kind": "final-procedural-status"
},
{
"link": "https://www.mext.go.jp/b_menu/daijin/detail/mext_00671.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Japan Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, ministerial statement after the Tokyo High Court decision (Mar. 4, 2026; Japanese).",
"body": "The ministerial statement records the government's position that unlawful donation solicitation over a long period caused many people substantial property and psychological harm and explains the expected victim-relief and liquidation process.",
"tier": "official-government-response",
"kind": "institutional-response"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Tokyo High Court upheld the district court on March 4, 2026; the Supreme Court rejected the organization's special appeal on June 22, 2026."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courts.go.jp/assets/hanrei/hanrei-pdf-96677.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-final-court-decision; evidentiary role: final-dissolution-order.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e1129fdc3db6d344d6f70a23e68e2b77d8732f98a5c5c3926f01eea4f5577943",
"final_url": "https://www.courts.go.jp/assets/hanrei/hanrei-pdf-96677.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bunka.go.jp/seisaku/shukyohojin/94340501.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-procedure-record; evidentiary role: final-procedural-status.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2142907a175e15de0e8d29c13cca363e6024259dd99a2d7c524d93868660ede1",
"final_url": "https://www.bunka.go.jp/seisaku/shukyohojin/94340501.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.mext.go.jp/b_menu/daijin/detail/mext_00671.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-response; evidentiary role: institutional-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "291987b071eaf657cad484f38a377b74aa3379f784efc21430f18c7713ce7dbb",
"final_url": "https://www.mext.go.jp/b_menu/daijin/detail/mext_00671.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 192,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"legionaries-of-christ",
"regnum-christi"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Maciel died in 2008 and was not convicted in a civil or criminal court. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith expressly waived a canonical trial because of his age and health; its 2006 action and the Holy See's 2010 visitation findings are not mislabeled as criminal convictions. The 2019 figures come from an internal Legionaries commission and retain that source limitation. The map point identifies the congregation's Mexican origin and institutional center of gravity, not a claim that every documented offense occurred in Mexico City. No culpability is assigned to survivors, rank-and-file members, Catholics, Catholic doctrine or every Legionary priest.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-marcial-maciel-legionaries-christ-mexico",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Mexico City, Mexico",
"lat": 19.4326,
"lng": -99.1332,
"title": "Marcial Maciel and the Legionaries of Christ: Holy See findings on abuse and a founder-centered system of power",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest",
"founder and superior general",
"charismatic founder",
"institutional authority over religious vocations"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"founder-centered spiritual authority",
"trust and enforced silence",
"discrediting and distancing of critics",
"vocation and charism dependency",
"institutional defense mechanism"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Legionaries of Christ",
"Regnum Christi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Holy See",
"stage": "canonical investigation and administrative disposition",
"date": "2006-05-19",
"outcome": "After investigating allegations concerning offenses reserved to the dicastery, the congregation waived a canonical trial because of Maciel's age and health and directed him to a reserved life of prayer and penance without public ministry."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Holy See Apostolic Visitation of the Legionaries of Christ",
"stage": "official institutional investigation and findings",
"date": "2010-05-01",
"outcome": "The Holy See reported convergent findings from five visitors, found Maciel's grave conduct confirmed by incontestable testimony, identified sexual-abuse victims and a system of power created by the founder, and ordered institutional revision and pontifical oversight."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Legionaries of Christ internal historical commission",
"stage": "organization-commissioned historical report",
"date": "2019-12-21",
"outcome": "The internal commission reported 175 known minors abused by 33 priests from 1941 through 2019, including at least 60 minors it attributed to Maciel, while stating the limits of an internal study."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Holy See found that Maciel reinforced his position as charismatic founder by constructing relationships that obtained trust, confidence and silence, while people who questioned him were discredited or distanced. The institution's members could experience disclosure about the founder as a threat to their vocation and the movement's charism. His priestly office, control as superior general and claimed founder-charism therefore formed part of the system that shielded sexual abuse and other grave conduct.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/it/bollettino/pubblico/2006/05/19/0256/00749.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Holy See Press Office, communiqué concerning Marcial Maciel Degollado (May 19, 2006).",
"body": "The official communiqué records the allegations received by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, its investigation, Maciel's denial and the decision to waive a canonical trial because of age and health while directing him to prayer and penance and barring public ministry.",
"tier": "official-canonical-authority",
"kind": "canonical-investigation-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.vatican.va/resources/resources_comunicato-legionari-cristo-2010_sp.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Holy See, communiqué on the Apostolic Visitation of the Congregation of the Legionaries of Christ (May 1, 2010).",
"body": "The official visitation findings describe Maciel's grave conduct, sexual-abuse victims, the system of power built around his charismatic-founder role, mechanisms of trust, silence and discrediting, and the need to revise authority and institutional structures.",
"tier": "official-apostolic-visitation-finding",
"kind": "institutional-and-spiritual-nexus-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://legionariesofchrist.org/press-release-a-status-report-of-the-last-eight-decades-eradicating-abuse-in-the-legionaries-of-christ/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Legionaries of Christ internal commission, Report 1941-2019 on the Phenomenon of Sexual Abuse of Minors (Dec. 21, 2019).",
"body": "The organization-commissioned report states its internal-study limits, defines its substantiation standard and reports 175 known minors abused by 33 priests, including at least 60 minors attributed to Maciel.",
"tier": "organization-commissioned-investigation",
"kind": "commissioned-historical-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/it/bollettino/pubblico/2006/05/19/0256/00749.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-canonical-authority; evidentiary role: canonical-investigation-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "65483073682268e570cb8b05778e3261a8956ac05eb8fa81657c20542905f57c",
"final_url": "https://press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/it/bollettino/pubblico/2006/05/19/0256/00749.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.vatican.va/resources/resources_comunicato-legionari-cristo-2010_sp.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-apostolic-visitation-finding; evidentiary role: institutional-and-spiritual-nexus-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3cf1c0e251015669ed5c8cb709fc658e00c20fad06d125a2e5eb11677f8ee53f",
"final_url": "https://www.vatican.va/resources/resources_comunicato-legionari-cristo-2010_sp.html"
},
{
"source": "https://legionariesofchrist.org/press-release-a-status-report-of-the-last-eight-decades-eradicating-abuse-in-the-legionaries-of-christ/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: organization-commissioned-investigation; evidentiary role: commissioned-historical-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "78a76b4f9a934f4bc5d5a9187fd4d28cbc6d606b8c5cb0396b480e526df6faa4",
"final_url": "https://legionariesofchrist.org/press-release-a-status-report-of-the-last-eight-decades-eradicating-abuse-in-the-legionaries-of-christ/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 193,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"nacozari-family-group"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No public judgment or appellate docket was located during the July 2026 source audit. The record therefore preserves the reported conviction and sentencing posture without asserting that an appeal was filed or resolved."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns one family group and its own sacrificial interpretation. It does not attribute the killings to Santa Muerte devotees generally, Mexican folk Catholic practice, Catholics or Mexicans. The two children killed are not named here. A minor who was detained with the group is not listed as an accused entity. The exact sentence lengths come from later reporting because the judgment is not available through a searchable public court portal; the Sonora government independently describes the family as convicted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-nacozari-santa-muerte-killings-sonora-mexico",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Nacozari de García, Sonora, Mexico",
"lat": 30.3741074,
"lng": -109.6898081,
"title": "Nacozari family killings: convictions after sacrifices attributed to Santa Muerte devotion",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"family-group leader identified by Sonora investigators",
"adult relatives acting within a family group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"human sacrifice",
"claimed supernatural protection",
"promised money and health",
"family influence and threats"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"prosperity-divination",
"ritual-initiation",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Nacozari family group"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sonora Attorney General's Office investigation",
"stage": "arrests, ministerial statements and recovery of remains",
"date": "2012-03-30",
"outcome": "El Universal reported that eight family-group members were detained and that the Sonora prosecutor's spokesperson said most admitted responsibility for three killings and identified Silvia Meraz Moreno as the group's leader. Investigators attributed the acts to a belief that sacrifices would obtain protection and money from Santa Muerte."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Sonora criminal proceedings",
"stage": "convictions and sentences reported after the investigation",
"outcome": "A later Sonora government publication describes the family as convicted of homicides committed in 2009 and 2010. Infobae reports a 180-year sentence for Silvia Meraz Moreno and 60-year sentences for the other adult participants; the underlying judgment and appellate file have not been located in a public portal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sonora investigators said the family group killed three people as sacrifices because its members believed Santa Muerte would grant them money, health and supernatural protection. The cited reporting identifies Silvia Meraz Moreno as the person who persuaded or directed relatives and records allegations that threats were also used within the family. The sacrifice and promised supernatural benefits were the stated reason for the killings, rather than symbols discovered after unrelated crimes.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archivo.eluniversal.com.mx/notas/839112.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Marcelo Beyliss, 'Secta de Nacozari se declara culpable de sacrificios,' El Universal (Mar. 30, 2012).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting attributes the investigation details to the Sonora Attorney General's Office spokesperson: eight arrests, ministerial admissions, three recovered victims, Meraz's alleged leadership and the belief that sacrifice to Santa Muerte would bring protection and money.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-national-reporting",
"kind": "prosecutor-attributed-investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://isc.sonora.gob.mx/acciones/actividades/da-a-conocer-gobierno-de-sonora-a-ganadores-del-concurso-del-libro-sonorense-2025",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Government of Sonora, 'Da a conocer Gobierno de Sonora a ganadores del Concurso del Libro Sonorense 2025' (Nov. 7, 2025).",
"body": "The official state publication identifies the underlying Nacozari events as a real case in which a family devoted to Santa Muerte was convicted of homicides committed between 2009 and 2010.",
"tier": "official-state-publication",
"kind": "official-conviction-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2021/08/07/degollados-y-desaparecidos-la-historia-de-la-familia-de-sonora-que-cometia-sacrificios-humanos/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Infobae México, 'Degollados y desaparecidos: la historia de la familia de Sonora que cometía sacrificios humanos' (Aug. 7, 2021).",
"body": "The retrospective reports the convictions and sentence lengths, quotes the former state spokesperson on the sacrifice motive, and identifies the limits of the publicly available procedural record. The sentence figures remain attributed to this report rather than presented as a court-document transcription.",
"tier": "reliable-retrospective-reporting",
"kind": "reported-sentencing-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No public judgment or appellate docket was located during the July 2026 source audit. The record therefore preserves the reported conviction and sentencing posture without asserting that an appeal was filed or resolved."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archivo.eluniversal.com.mx/notas/839112.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-national-reporting; evidentiary role: prosecutor-attributed-investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4e62675aeabbcdeb6fbd67cb9ba49fb023c43d5e4d87b3cfd2ca230353ad21b1",
"final_url": "https://archivo.eluniversal.com.mx/notas/839112.html"
},
{
"source": "https://isc.sonora.gob.mx/acciones/actividades/da-a-conocer-gobierno-de-sonora-a-ganadores-del-concurso-del-libro-sonorense-2025",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-state-publication; evidentiary role: official-conviction-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2021/08/07/degollados-y-desaparecidos-la-historia-de-la-familia-de-sonora-que-cometia-sacrificios-humanos/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-retrospective-reporting; evidentiary role: reported-sentencing-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "81cb2e64f0cab33a34f16290eb625e30c6e82209c44e05a64509fcd90b1ea769",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2021/08/07/degollados-y-desaparecidos-la-historia-de-la-familia-de-sonora-que-cometia-sacrificios-humanos/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 194,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Supreme Court's 2019 judgment narrowed the convictions to murder with common intention and destruction of evidence for the two main defendants, confirmed their death sentences, and overturned the convictions of four other appellants. The record does not assign culpability to those acquitted appellants."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns the defendants' own claimed tantrik authority and sacrificial interpretation. It does not attribute the crime to Hinduism, Tantra, Kali worship, Indian religious practice or tantrik practitioners generally. The child is not named on this page. Four additional appellants were acquitted by the Supreme Court and are not listed as accused entities.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-bhilai-human-sacrifice-chhattisgarh-india",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Bhilai, Chhattisgarh, India",
"lat": 21.2120677,
"lng": 81.3732849,
"title": "Bhilai human-sacrifice murder: Supreme Court confirmed convictions and death sentences",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described tantrik",
"Gurumata",
"spiritual leaders with disciples"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"promise of siddhi",
"human sacrifice to propitiate a deity",
"direction of disciples",
"ritual authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions Judge, Durg, Sessions Trial No. 61 of 2011",
"stage": "murder convictions and capital sentences",
"date": "2014-03-27",
"outcome": "The trial court convicted Ishwari Lal Yadav, Kiran Bai and additional defendants of kidnapping, murder, conspiracy and destroying evidence. It imposed death sentences for murder."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Chhattisgarh, Criminal Reference No. 1 of 2014 and Criminal Appeal No. 511 of 2014",
"stage": "capital reference and appeals",
"date": "2016-12-01",
"outcome": "The High Court confirmed the murder convictions and death sentences of Yadav and Bai and changed the other defendants' sentences to life without remission or parole."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of India, Criminal Appeal Nos. 1416-1419 of 2017 and connected appeals",
"stage": "final merits appeal",
"date": "2019-10-03",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court confirmed Yadav's and Bai's convictions for murder with common intention and destroying evidence, and confirmed their death sentences. It set aside their kidnapping and conspiracy convictions and acquitted the four other appellants whose evidence it found insufficient."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Supreme Court found that Yadav and Bai believed in tantrism, that Bai was called Gurumata and sought siddhi, and that she directed her husband and disciples to obtain a child for sacrifice to propitiate a deity. The Court held that the two main defendants committed the murder as a sacrifice and that the evidence proved their guilt beyond reasonable doubt.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/7636/7636_2017_5_1502_17418_Judgement_03-Oct-2019.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of India, Ishwari Lal Yadav v. State of Chhattisgarh, Criminal Appeal Nos. 1416-1417 of 2017 and connected appeals, judgment (Oct. 3, 2019).",
"body": "The official judgment records the Gurumata and tantrik claims, the stated pursuit of siddhi, the sacrifice finding, the trial and High Court dispositions, the evidence review, the two confirmed murder convictions and death sentences, and the acquittals of four other appellants.",
"tier": "supreme-court-judgment",
"kind": "final-conviction-and-nexus-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Supreme Court's 2019 judgment narrowed the convictions to murder with common intention and destruction of evidence for the two main defendants, confirmed their death sentences, and overturned the convictions of four other appellants. The record does not assign culpability to those acquitted appellants."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/7636/7636_2017_5_1502_17418_Judgement_03-Oct-2019.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: supreme-court-judgment; evidentiary role: final-conviction-and-nexus-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9d29ecde6bd4c99c40446500e0327d09e3327c3c127046b4735b6feaf3847d3",
"final_url": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/7636/7636_2017_5_1502_17418_Judgement_03-Oct-2019.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 195,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The High Court commuted the trial death sentences to life imprisonment without remission or parole and acquitted two other defendants. The Supreme Court confirmed the two main defendants' murder and evidence-destruction convictions and sentences while setting aside kidnapping and conspiracy counts."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This is a separate victim and criminal proceeding from the related Bhilai sacrifice record. It concerns the defendants' personal claimed tantrik practice and does not assign responsibility to Hinduism, Tantra, any deity, Indians or tantrik practitioners generally. The child is not named on this page. Two other defendants were acquitted and are not listed as accused entities.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-durg-human-sacrifice-chhattisgarh-india",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Bhilai, Chhattisgarh, India",
"lat": 21.2120677,
"lng": 81.3732849,
"title": "Durg human-sacrifice murder: Supreme Court confirmed convictions and life sentences",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described tantrik",
"Gurumata",
"spiritual leaders with disciples"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed attainment of siddhi",
"human sacrifice",
"ritual authority",
"direction of followers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions Judge, Durg, Sessions Trial No. 98 of 2011",
"stage": "murder convictions and capital sentences",
"outcome": "The trial court convicted Ishwari Lal Yadav and Kiran Bai of kidnapping, murder, conspiracy and destroying evidence and imposed death sentences for murder."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Chhattisgarh, Criminal Reference No. 4 of 2014 and Criminal Appeal No. 1068 of 2014",
"stage": "capital reference and appeal",
"date": "2016-11-30",
"outcome": "The High Court confirmed Yadav's and Bai's murder convictions, reduced the death sentences to life imprisonment without remission or parole, and acquitted two other defendants."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of India, Criminal Appeal No. 1522 of 2019",
"stage": "final merits appeal",
"date": "2019-10-03",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court confirmed Yadav's and Bai's convictions for murder with common intention and destroying evidence and the life-without-remission-or-parole sentences. It set aside their kidnapping and conspiracy convictions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Supreme Court found that Yadav and Bai, who claimed to be tantriks, admitted that the child had been killed and buried to attain siddhi. It held that independent testimony, recovery from their property, identification evidence and forensic evidence established their responsibility beyond reasonable doubt for the human-sacrifice murder.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/7636/7636_2017_5_1502_17418_Judgement_03-Oct-2019.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of India, Ishwari Lal Yadav v. State of Chhattisgarh, Criminal Appeal No. 1522 of 2019, judgment (Oct. 3, 2019).",
"body": "The official judgment treats this as a separate trial and appeal, records the defendants' claimed tantrik status and siddhi motive, reviews the recovery and corroborating evidence, confirms murder and evidence-destruction convictions and life sentences, and preserves the acquittals and reversed counts.",
"tier": "supreme-court-judgment",
"kind": "final-conviction-and-nexus-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The High Court commuted the trial death sentences to life imprisonment without remission or parole and acquitted two other defendants. The Supreme Court confirmed the two main defendants' murder and evidence-destruction convictions and sentences while setting aside kidnapping and conspiracy counts."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/7636/7636_2017_5_1502_17418_Judgement_03-Oct-2019.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: supreme-court-judgment; evidentiary role: final-conviction-and-nexus-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9d29ecde6bd4c99c40446500e0327d09e3327c3c127046b4735b6feaf3847d3",
"final_url": "https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/7636/7636_2017_5_1502_17418_Judgement_03-Oct-2019.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 196,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Thomas sought an out-of-time review of the eighteen-year sentence. The Supreme Court found no merit in his request and exercised its power to increase the sentence to twenty-two years."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns a specific accusation and murder in Simbu Province. It does not attribute violence to Papua New Guineans, Indigenous traditions or people who hold traditional beliefs generally. The person killed is not named here. The court rejected the claim that the accusation supplied a factual basis for blame and emphasized her right to legal protection. The map point uses Gumine because the judgment names Dramo village in Gumine but does not provide village coordinates.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-irai-thomas-sorcery-killing-simbu-papua-new-guinea",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Dramo village, Gumine, Simbu Province, Papua New Guinea",
"lat": -6.188268,
"lng": 144.9198338,
"title": "Irai Thomas: Supreme Court increased sentence for killing based on a sorcery accusation",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader within the attacking group",
"relative acting on a community sorcery accusation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sorcery accusation",
"collective blame for a death",
"group pressure",
"claimed supernatural causation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "National Court of Papua New Guinea at Kundiawa",
"stage": "guilty plea, wilful-murder conviction and sentence",
"date": "2005-08-26",
"outcome": "The National Court accepted Thomas's guilty plea to wilful murder and sentenced him to eighteen years in hard labour."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Papua New Guinea, Thomas v State [2007] PGSC 26; SC867",
"stage": "constitutional sentence review",
"date": "2007-08-28",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court rejected Thomas's request for a reduction, found the National Court sentence too low and substituted twenty-two years in hard labour, less pretrial custody and time already served."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Supreme Court found that Thomas and relatives took an older woman to a village gathering after someone accused her of causing his father's death through sorcery. Thomas led the assault and killed her. The Court held that acting on belief in sorcery could not excuse the killing and should receive no special sentencing treatment beyond ordinary mitigation proved on the facts.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.paclii.org/pg/cases/PGSC/2007/26.html",
"archive": "https://web.archive.org/web/20241213140648/https://www.paclii.org/pg/cases/PGSC/2007/26.html",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Papua New Guinea, Thomas v State [2007] PGSC 26; SC867 (Aug. 28, 2007).",
"body": "The judgment records the guilty plea, village sorcery accusation, Thomas's leading role, the National Court sentence, the sentence review and the increase to twenty-two years. It also explains why courts should not treat sorcery belief as a special excuse for killing.",
"tier": "supreme-court-judgment",
"kind": "final-conviction-and-sentence-review"
},
{
"link": "https://vlex.com/vid/irai-thomas-v-the-922798162",
"archive": "",
"citation": "vLex / NiuMedia edited reproduction, Irai Thomas v The State (2007) SC867.",
"body": "The legal publisher's reproduction provides a readable mirror of the Papua New Guinea Supreme Court judgment, docket, date, panel, facts and disposition while the PacLII host applies access controls.",
"tier": "legal-publisher-judgment-mirror",
"kind": "access-copy"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Thomas sought an out-of-time review of the eighteen-year sentence. The Supreme Court found no merit in his request and exercised its power to increase the sentence to twenty-two years."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.paclii.org/pg/cases/PGSC/2007/26.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: supreme-court-judgment; evidentiary role: final-conviction-and-sentence-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://vlex.com/vid/irai-thomas-v-the-922798162",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-publisher-judgment-mirror; evidentiary role: access-copy.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6c2b80e43bd374760ce3f3cf8a2d6c5f4f7bc1d4f3dd6599e37efec237329ac7",
"final_url": "https://vlex.com/vid/irai-thomas-v-the-922798162"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 197,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The published source is the High Court sentencing judgment following guilty pleas. No later appeal or sentence variation was located in the July 2026 audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns one defendant's accusation and violence against a relative. It does not attribute the crime to Namibians, Indigenous traditions or people who hold traditional beliefs generally. The person killed is not named here. The judgment does not state the incident's town or village, so the map point identifies the High Court venue at Oshakati and is not presented as the crime scene.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-s-v-john-witchcraft-murder-namibia",
"year": 2022,
"place": "High Court at Oshakati, Namibia",
"lat": -17.7826518,
"lng": 15.6986,
"title": "S v John: murder and witchcraft-accusation convictions in Namibia",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"relative making a witchcraft accusation",
"household member using threats against witnesses"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"witchcraft accusation",
"blame for family deaths",
"threats against intervening witnesses",
"claimed non-natural causation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Namibia, Northern Local Division, S v John, CC 14/2019",
"stage": "guilty pleas, convictions and sentencing",
"date": "2022-02-22",
"outcome": "The court convicted Muyevu Thikundeko John of murder under the domestic-violence statute, naming another person as a witch under the Witchcraft Suppression Proclamation, and assault by threat. It imposed thirty years for murder with five years suspended, two years for the witchcraft-accusation offense, and a concurrent twelve months for assault by threat."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "John admitted that he accused his aunt of bewitching his mother and deceased siblings, killed her and threatened relatives who might intervene. The court separately convicted him under Namibia's Witchcraft Suppression Proclamation for naming her as a witch and treated the unconfirmed witchcraft suspicion as an aggravating part of the murder circumstances.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ejustice.jud.na/High%20Court/Judgments/Criminal/S%20v%20John%20(CC%2014-2019)%20%5B2022%5D%20NAHCNLD%2012%20(22%20February%202022).doc",
"archive": "",
"citation": "High Court of Namibia, Northern Local Division, S v John (CC 14/2019) [2022] NAHCNLD 12 (Feb. 22, 2022).",
"body": "The official judgment records the guilty pleas, witchcraft accusation, murder, threats to witnesses, domestic relationship, statutory counts and exact sentences. It also identifies the limits of the evidence and the court's sentencing rationale.",
"tier": "high-court-judgment",
"kind": "conviction-and-sentencing-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The published source is the High Court sentencing judgment following guilty pleas. No later appeal or sentence variation was located in the July 2026 audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ejustice.jud.na/High%20Court/Judgments/Criminal/S%20v%20John%20(CC%2014-2019)%20%5B2022%5D%20NAHCNLD%2012%20(22%20February%202022).doc",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-court-judgment; evidentiary role: conviction-and-sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 198,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No later appellate disposition was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns two defendants' admitted accusation and violence against a relative. It does not attribute the crime to South Africans, Indigenous traditions, traditional healers or people who hold supernatural beliefs generally. The person killed is not named here. The court treated belief in witchcraft as part of the sentencing context, not as a legal justification for murder.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-s-v-latha-aliwal-north-south-africa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Aliwal North, Eastern Cape, South Africa",
"lat": -30.6935,
"lng": 26.7114,
"title": "S v Latha: murder convictions after an accusation of bewitching relatives",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"adult relatives making a witchcraft accusation",
"older cousin who persuaded a second participant"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"witchcraft accusation",
"blame for illness and death",
"family persuasion",
"claimed supernatural threat"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division at Grahamstown, S v Latha and Another, CC 20/12",
"stage": "guilty pleas, convictions and sentencing",
"date": "2012-05-09",
"outcome": "The court convicted Bulelani Latha and Ayanda Gqongwa of murder and contravening the Witchcraft Suppression Act; Gqongwa was also convicted of common assault. Latha received twenty years for murder with five years suspended and a concurrent eighteen months for the statutory offense. Gqongwa received fifteen years for murder with five years suspended, plus concurrent terms of three months and twelve months on the other counts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendants' admitted account tied the killing to a belief that their grandmother had bewitched family members, caused illness and death, and posed an ongoing supernatural threat. The court convicted both defendants not only of murder but also of the statutory offense of imputing supernatural harm or naming another person as a witch.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECGHC/2012/29.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division, S v Latha and Another (CC 20/12) [2012] ZAECGHC 29; 2012 (2) SACR 30 (ECG) (May 9, 2012).",
"body": "The sentencing judgment records the guilty pleas, admitted witchcraft accusations, family relationship, murder and statutory convictions, individual roles, mitigation analysis and exact sentences for both defendants.",
"tier": "high-court-judgment",
"kind": "conviction-and-sentencing-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No later appellate disposition was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECGHC/2012/29.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-court-judgment; evidentiary role: conviction-and-sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b0989fe6d78b8485ea8f7e53acb7bddd06bfe03baeaf210f25c965f8dc6917d6",
"final_url": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECGHC/2012/29.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 199,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The court refused Velemani leave to appeal on October 6, 2022. No later disposition affecting the four murder convictions or sentences was located in the July 2026 audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns the defendants convicted in one proceeding and does not transfer responsibility to every person present at the gathering, the Majuba community, South Africans, cleansing rituals or Indigenous traditions generally. Velemani was acquitted of murder and is identified only with the assault and witchcraft-imputation convictions. The person killed is not named here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-manundu-witchcraft-killing-majuba-south-africa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Majuba locality near Sterkspruit, Eastern Cape, South Africa",
"lat": -30.5263,
"lng": 27.3667,
"title": "S v Manundu: group convictions for a killing driven solely by witchcraft accusations",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"adult relatives and community participants making witchcraft accusations",
"group acting during a post-funeral gathering"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"witchcraft accusation",
"public interrogation and torture",
"group violence",
"blame for a relative's death",
"community acquiescence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division at Mthatha, S v Manundu and Others, CC18/2020",
"stage": "trial judgment",
"date": "2022-06-17",
"outcome": "The court convicted Mzubongile Manundu, Sithembiso Yalwa, Siyabulela Manundu and Mlungisi Manundu of murder by common purpose and imputing witchcraft. It convicted Nkosiyoxolo Kakudi Velemani of assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and imputing witchcraft, acquitted him of murder, and acquitted all tried defendants of arson."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division at Mthatha, S v Manundu and Others, CC18/2020",
"stage": "sentencing judgment",
"date": "2022-08-18",
"outcome": "The four murder defendants each received an effective seventeen years' imprisonment: twenty years for murder with five suspended plus a consecutive two years for imputing witchcraft. Velemani received an effective five years for assault and imputing witchcraft."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The trial court found that imputing witchcraft was the sole reason for the defendants' actions. During a gathering for a cleansing ritual after a relative's funeral, the group accused an elderly relative of using witchcraft, interrogated and assaulted her, dragged her to a burning rondavel and killed her. The murder and assault convictions preserve distinct culpability among the defendants.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECMHC/2022/13.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division, S v Manundu and Others (CC18/2020) [2022] ZAECMHC 13 (June 17, 2022).",
"body": "The trial judgment records the post-funeral setting, witchcraft accusations, group assault and killing, evidence by defendant, common-purpose findings, four murder convictions, the separate assault conviction, statutory witchcraft-imputation convictions and arson acquittals.",
"tier": "high-court-judgment",
"kind": "trial-and-conviction-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECMHC/2022/27.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division, S v Manundu and Others (CC18/2020) [2022] ZAECMHC 27 (Aug. 18, 2022).",
"body": "The sentencing judgment states that witchcraft suspicion was the only reason for the killing, records the distinct offenses and roles, and gives the effective seventeen-year murder sentences and five-year assault sentence.",
"tier": "high-court-judgment",
"kind": "sentencing-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECMHC/2022/40.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division, Velemani v S (CC18/2020) [2022] ZAECMHC 40 (Oct. 6, 2022).",
"body": "The leave-to-appeal judgment preserves Velemani's acquittal on murder, convictions for assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and imputing witchcraft, sentences, and refusal of leave to appeal.",
"tier": "high-court-judgment",
"kind": "leave-to-appeal-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The court refused Velemani leave to appeal on October 6, 2022. No later disposition affecting the four murder convictions or sentences was located in the July 2026 audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECMHC/2022/13.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-court-judgment; evidentiary role: trial-and-conviction-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECMHC/2022/27.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-court-judgment; evidentiary role: sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECMHC/2022/40.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-court-judgment; evidentiary role: leave-to-appeal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 200,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No later appellate disposition was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Tyolo's admitted accusation and adjudicated conduct. It does not attribute the murder to the traditional ceremony, South Africans, Indigenous traditions, traditional medicine or people who believe in witchcraft generally. The person killed is not named here. The map point uses East London, where the judgment places Tyolo's residence and the events, without claiming a more precise public location.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-landile-tyolo-witchcraft-murder-east-london-south-africa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "East London, Eastern Cape, South Africa",
"lat": -33.0153,
"lng": 27.9116,
"title": "S v Tyolo: life sentence for a premeditated killing based on a witchcraft accusation",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"relative making a witchcraft accusation",
"adult household member threatening intervening relatives"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"witchcraft accusation",
"blame for a relative's illness",
"premeditated family violence",
"threats against intervening witnesses"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division at Makhanda, S v Tyolo, case 04/2024",
"stage": "guilty pleas, convictions and sentencing",
"date": "2024-03-14",
"outcome": "The court convicted Landile Tyolo of premeditated murder and naming or indicating another person as a witch. It imposed life imprisonment for murder and a concurrent twenty-year term for the Witchcraft Suppression Act offense."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Tyolo admitted that he came to believe his aunt had bewitched his seriously ill brother, named her as a witch during a traditional ceremony, decided to kill her, invited her to stay at his residence as part of that plan, and killed her there. The court found that the witchcraft suspicion was the only reason for the murder and separately convicted him under the Witchcraft Suppression Act.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECMKHC/2024/30.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division, S v Tyolo (04/2024) [2024] ZAECMKHC 30; 2024 (2) SACR 39 (ECMk) (Mar. 14, 2024).",
"body": "The sentencing judgment records Tyolo's guilty pleas, the December 2022 accusation and premeditation, the family-illness motive, threats to intervening relatives, statutory analysis and concurrent life and twenty-year sentences.",
"tier": "high-court-judgment",
"kind": "conviction-and-sentencing-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No later appellate disposition was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAECMKHC/2024/30.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-court-judgment; evidentiary role: conviction-and-sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 201,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No public appellate judgment affecting this conviction or sentence was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns one defendant's conviction and the motive described in confession evidence accepted by the High Court. It does not attribute the killing to Tanzanians, Indigenous traditions, traditional healers or supernatural beliefs generally. The person killed is not named here. The judgment contains inconsistent day-and-month references for the killing, so the record uses the year and does not assert a single exact incident date. The map point identifies the Bariadi district seat named in the judgment, not a precise household location.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-sungwa-mpelwa-witchcraft-murder-bariadi-tanzania",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Bariadi District, Simiyu Region, Tanzania",
"lat": -2.7919,
"lng": 33.9893,
"title": "Republic v Mpelwa: murder conviction based on confessions describing a witchcraft motive",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"relative acting on a witchcraft belief",
"participant whose confessions described the claimed motive"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"witchcraft accusation",
"claimed supernatural harm",
"family violence",
"planned armed attack"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Tanzania, Shinyanga District Registry sitting at Bariadi, Republic v Sungwa Mpelwa, Criminal Session Case 34 of 2017",
"stage": "murder conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-03-11",
"outcome": "The court convicted Sungwa Mpelwa of murder after finding that his police and extra-judicial confessions were voluntary, truthful and corroborated by independent evidence. It imposed the mandatory death sentence then provided by the Penal Code."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The High Court found that Mpelwa's two confession statements admitted killing a relative with a machete because of a witchcraft belief. The court treated those statements as corroborated by the scene, physical evidence and witness testimony and convicted him of murder.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tanzlii.org/en/akn/tz/judgment/tzhc/2022/11873/eng%402022-03-11",
"archive": "",
"citation": "High Court of Tanzania, Republic v Sungwa Mpelwa (Criminal Session Case 34 of 2017) [2022] TZHC 11873 (Mar. 11, 2022).",
"body": "The judgment records the family relationship, attack, confession evidence, corroboration analysis, express witchcraft motive, murder conviction and mandatory death sentence. It also preserves the court record's inconsistent day-and-month references for the incident.",
"tier": "high-court-judgment",
"kind": "conviction-and-sentencing-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://sheriahub.com/cases/tz/caselaw/republic-v-sungwa-mpelwa-criminal-session-case-34-of-2017-2022-tzhc-11873-11-march-2022",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SheriaHub, reproduction of Republic v Sungwa Mpelwa [2022] TZHC 11873 (Mar. 11, 2022).",
"body": "The legal-repository mirror supplies a readable full-text access copy of the Tanzanian High Court judgment while the official TanzLII host applies automated access controls.",
"tier": "legal-repository-judgment-mirror",
"kind": "access-copy"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No public appellate judgment affecting this conviction or sentence was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tanzlii.org/en/akn/tz/judgment/tzhc/2022/11873/eng%402022-03-11",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-court-judgment; evidentiary role: conviction-and-sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://sheriahub.com/cases/tz/caselaw/republic-v-sungwa-mpelwa-criminal-session-case-34-of-2017-2022-tzhc-11873-11-march-2022",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-repository-judgment-mirror; evidentiary role: access-copy.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6d190a53a2cf2c634780f3991aca329a62cad28a37bcd530ca9797d79d973044",
"final_url": "https://sheriahub.com/cases/tz/caselaw/republic-v-sungwa-mpelwa-criminal-session-case-34-of-2017-2022-tzhc-11873-11-march-2022"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 202,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Earnest's admitted conduct and the religious argument he used to justify it. It does not assign culpability to Christianity, Reformed theology, Presbyterians, Earnest's former congregation or his family. The Orthodox Presbyterian Church condemned antisemitism and racist hatred, and no court finding attributes institutional responsibility to the denomination or congregation. White-supremacist propaganda was also a material influence and is not recast as a Christian teaching.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-john-earnest-poway-synagogue-california",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Poway and Escondido, California, USA",
"lat": 32.9628,
"lng": -117.0359,
"title": "John Earnest: life plus 30 years for Poway synagogue shooting and mosque arson",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-reformed-presbyterian",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-professed Reformed Christian using a claimed theological justification"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed glorification of God through violence",
"antisemitic Christian argument",
"white-supremacist propaganda",
"religious-target selection"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California",
"stage": "federal guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2021-12-28",
"outcome": "Earnest pleaded guilty to 113 federal counts and received life imprisonment plus thirty years for the synagogue shooting and attempted mosque arson."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Before attacking, Earnest posted a manifesto that framed killing Jews as an act that would glorify God and embedded the claim in an articulated Reformed Christian theology. He also adopted white-supremacist and anti-Muslim propaganda. The religious pretext was his own antisemitic construction; clergy from his denomination and other Reformed pastors publicly rejected it as contrary to Christian doctrine.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdca/pr/john-t-earnest-sentenced-life-plus-30-years-prison-federal-hate-crimes-related-2019",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of California, 'John T. Earnest Sentenced to Life Plus 30 Years in Prison for Federal Hate Crimes Related to 2019 Poway Synagogue Shooting and Attempted Mosque Arson' (Dec. 28, 2021).",
"body": "The official disposition records the 113-count guilty plea, life-plus-thirty-year federal sentence, murder and attempted murders at Chabad of Poway, attempted arson of the Dar-ul-Arqam mosque and Earnest's admitted religious and racial targeting.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-and-sentence"
},
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/religion/2019/05/01/alleged-synagogue-shooter-was-churchgoer-who-articulated-christian-theology-prompting-tough-questions-evangelical-pastors/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Julie Zauzmer Weil, 'The alleged synagogue shooter was a churchgoer who talked Christian theology, raising tough questions for evangelical pastors,' The Washington Post (May 1, 2019).",
"body": "The contemporaneous report examines Earnest's manifesto, his stated claim that killing Jews would glorify God, his Reformed theological language, church background and the explicit repudiation of his violence and antisemitism by Christian leaders and his denomination.",
"tier": "high-quality-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "spiritual-nexus-and-institutional-boundary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdca/pr/john-t-earnest-sentenced-life-plus-30-years-prison-federal-hate-crimes-related-2019",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-and-sentence.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5de1c36fb8bda78d6141585d99a6ddd49e879ef0716104e982e379f8c0ab425a",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdca/pr/john-t-earnest-sentenced-life-plus-30-years-prison-federal-hate-crimes-related-2019"
},
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/religion/2019/05/01/alleged-synagogue-shooter-was-churchgoer-who-articulated-christian-theology-prompting-tough-questions-evangelical-pastors/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: spiritual-nexus-and-institutional-boundary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 203,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2015-02-13",
"note": "Conviction affirmed; exemption held constitutional and inapplicable on these facts."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The record concerns the named defendant and the adjudicated neglect of her 15-year-old daughter, who died of Ewing's sarcoma. It does not attribute the conduct to any wider religious community. The minor is not further identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-jacqueline-crank-spiritual-treatment-tennessee-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Loudon County, Tennessee, USA",
"lat": 35.732,
"lng": -84.313,
"title": "State v. Crank: Tennessee Supreme Court affirms child-neglect conviction after cancer was treated with prayer",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parent relying on spiritual treatment",
"associated spiritual-group leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"prayer-only substitution for cancer treatment",
"reliance on a claimed healer"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Universal Life Church (affiliation)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tennessee Supreme Court",
"stage": "final appeal — conviction affirmed",
"date": "2015-02-13",
"outcome": "The Tennessee Supreme Court affirmed Jacqueline Crank's conviction for child neglect, holding the spiritual-treatment exemption was not unconstitutionally vague and did not apply where medical care was abandoned in favor of prayer. Sentence: 11 months 29 days unsupervised probation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "After clinic and chiropractor visits revealed a large tumor, the defendant abandoned medical care in favor of prayer-only reliance on a claimed divine healer; the Tennessee Supreme Court addressed whether that reliance qualified for the statutory spiritual-treatment exemption and held it did not.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2779443/state-of-tennessee-v-jacqueline-crank/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Crank, 468 S.W.3d 15 (Tenn. 2015).",
"body": "The Tennessee Supreme Court opinion affirms the child-neglect conviction and analyzes the statutory spiritual-treatment exemption, finding it constitutional and inapplicable where the defendant abandoned medical care for prayer.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2015-02-13",
"note": "Conviction affirmed; exemption held constitutional and inapplicable on these facts."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2779443/state-of-tennessee-v-jacqueline-crank/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2779443/state-of-tennessee-v-jacqueline-crank/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 204,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"faith-tabernacle"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "superior-court",
"date": "1998-09-21",
"note": "Convictions affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The record concerns the named parents and the adjudicated death of their daughter Shannon. It is scoped to that proceeding and does not attribute conduct to the wider congregation beyond the doctrine the court found operative.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-nixon-faith-tabernacle-death-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Altoona, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 40.518,
"lng": -78.395,
"title": "Commonwealth v. Nixon: convictions affirmed after Faith Tabernacle parents used prayer for a dying diabetic teen",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parents relying on church doctrine of spiritual treatment"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal refusal of medical care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Faith Tabernacle Congregation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of Pennsylvania",
"stage": "appeal — convictions affirmed",
"date": "1998-09-21",
"outcome": "The Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed Dennis and Lorie Nixon's convictions for involuntary manslaughter and endangering the welfare of a child. Sentence: 2.5 to 5 years' imprisonment plus a $1,000 fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Faith Tabernacle Church doctrine that illnesses are addressed through spiritual treatment rather than medicine was the basis on which the parents withheld care from their daughter, who died of diabetic ketoacidosis; the court rejected the argument that religious preference discharged the parental duty to provide medical care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1908246/commonwealth-v-nixon/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commonwealth v. Nixon, 718 A.2d 311 (Pa. Super. 1998).",
"body": "The Pennsylvania Superior Court opinion affirms the involuntary-manslaughter and child-endangerment convictions and records the Faith Tabernacle spiritual-treatment doctrine as the basis for withholding medical care.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "superior-court",
"date": "1998-09-21",
"note": "Convictions affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1908246/commonwealth-v-nixon/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1908246/commonwealth-v-nixon/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 205,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"faith-tabernacle"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "superior-court",
"date": "1985-08-16",
"note": "Convictions affirmed; religious-freedom defense rejected."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named parents and their son Justin's adjudicated death. Does not attribute conduct to the wider congregation beyond the operative doctrine.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1985-barnhart-faith-tabernacle-death-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 1985,
"place": "Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 40.27,
"lng": -76.88,
"title": "Commonwealth v. Barnhart: convictions affirmed after Faith Tabernacle parents relied on prayer for a child's cancer",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parents relying on church doctrine of faith healing"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal refusal of medical care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Faith Tabernacle Congregation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of Pennsylvania",
"stage": "appeal — convictions affirmed",
"date": "1985-08-16",
"outcome": "The Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed Robert and Carol Barnhart's convictions for involuntary manslaughter and endangering the welfare of a child; the parental duty to provide medical care was held not unconstitutionally vague."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court recorded that the Faith Tabernacle parents had relied on God to the exclusion of modern medicine to cure their young son's Wilms' tumor; that doctrinal reliance was the basis on which medical care was withheld.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2088890/commonwealth-v-barnhart/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commonwealth v. Barnhart, 497 A.2d 616 (Pa. Super. 1985).",
"body": "The Pennsylvania Superior Court opinion affirms the convictions and records that the parents relied on God to the exclusion of modern medicine.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "superior-court",
"date": "1985-08-16",
"note": "Convictions affirmed; religious-freedom defense rejected."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2088890/commonwealth-v-barnhart/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2088890/commonwealth-v-barnhart/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 206,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"followers-of-christ"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2015-10-08",
"note": "Convictions affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named parents and their newborn son David's adjudicated death. A separate, earlier corpus record documents a different Followers-of-Christ Oregon City proceeding; this record concerns distinct defendants and an incident.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-hickman-followers-of-christ-newborn-death-oregon-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Oregon City, Oregon, USA",
"lat": 45.357,
"lng": -122.607,
"title": "State v. Hickman: Oregon Supreme Court affirms manslaughter convictions after Followers of Christ parents withheld care from a newborn",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parents relying on church faith-healing doctrine"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal refusal of medical care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Followers of Christ Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Oregon Supreme Court",
"stage": "final appeal — convictions affirmed",
"date": "2015-10-08",
"outcome": "The Oregon Supreme Court affirmed Dale and Shannon Hickman's second-degree manslaughter convictions, holding criminal negligence (not knowledge) was the required mental state and that sincerely held religious belief did not raise it."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Followers of Christ Church relies on faith healing — prayer, anointing with oil, and the laying on of hands — and eschews conventional medicine; on that basis the parents sought no medical care for their prematurely born son, who died about nine hours after birth.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/3008733/state-v-hickmanhickman/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Hickman, 358 Or. 1, 358 P.3d 987 (2015).",
"body": "The Oregon Supreme Court opinion affirms the manslaughter convictions and records the Followers of Christ faith-healing practice as the basis for withholding medical care.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2015-10-08",
"note": "Convictions affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/3008733/state-v-hickmanhickman/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/3008733/state-v-hickmanhickman/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 207,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "superior-court",
"date": "2000-11-16",
"note": "Convictions affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named parents; the child survived after state intervention and is not further identified. A non-fatal endangerment case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2000-foster-faith-healing-child-endangerment-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2000,
"place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 39.952,
"lng": -75.164,
"title": "Commonwealth v. Foster: child-endangerment convictions affirmed after parents refused cancer care for a toddler on religious grounds",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parents relying on faith-healing doctrine"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal refusal of medical care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of Pennsylvania",
"stage": "appeal — convictions affirmed",
"date": "2000-11-16",
"outcome": "The Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed Daniel and Anne Marie Foster's convictions for endangering the welfare of a child and criminal conspiracy after they refused medical care for their 2-year-old son, who was removed to hospital under a restraining order and survived."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The parents told child-protection social workers they would rely on God to heal their son and refused medical care for his kidney tumor because of their religious beliefs; that doctrinal refusal was the basis for the endangerment.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1918285/commonwealth-v-foster/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commonwealth v. Foster, 764 A.2d 1076 (Pa. Super. 2000).",
"body": "The Pennsylvania Superior Court opinion affirms the child-endangerment and conspiracy convictions and records the parents' statement that they would rely on God to heal the child.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "superior-court",
"date": "2000-11-16",
"note": "Convictions affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1918285/commonwealth-v-foster/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1918285/commonwealth-v-foster/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 208,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2015-05-11",
"note": "Conviction affirmed; evidence sufficient."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named defendant and the adjudicated death of the child, who is not further identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-wilson-exorcism-child-death-georgia-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Georgia, USA",
"lat": 33.75,
"lng": -84.39,
"title": "Wilson v. State: felony-murder conviction affirmed after a toddler believed 'demon-possessed' was starved and beaten during exorcism plans",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"caregiver invoking exorcism and possession belief"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"exorcism ritual framing",
"demon-possession accusation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Georgia",
"stage": "appeal — conviction affirmed",
"date": "2015-05-11",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court of Georgia affirmed Andrea Renee Wilson's felony-murder conviction in the death of a 2-year-old boy who suffered roughly 200 injuries, an immersion burn, and starvation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The caregivers believed the child had a devil or demon in him, applied prayer oil, and planned an exorcism instead of seeking medical care; that possession belief and exorcism plan were the framing under which the fatal abuse occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2799785/wilson-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wilson v. State, 297 Ga. 86, 772 S.E.2d 689 (2015).",
"body": "The Georgia Supreme Court opinion affirms the felony-murder conviction and records the caregivers' belief that the child was demon-possessed and their plan to perform an exorcism.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2015-05-11",
"note": "Conviction affirmed; evidence sufficient."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2799785/wilson-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2799785/wilson-v-state/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 209,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2012-05-10",
"note": "Conviction affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named defendant and the adjudicated death of the child, who is not further identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-lawson-exorcism-ritual-child-death-indiana-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Fort Wayne, Indiana, USA",
"lat": 41.079,
"lng": -85.139,
"title": "Lawson v. State: murder conviction affirmed after a child died during a forced exorcism ritual",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "ritual-crime",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parent invoking exorcism and divine-command belief"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"forced-ingestion exorcism ritual",
"demon-possession accusation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Indiana Court of Appeals",
"stage": "appeal — conviction affirmed",
"date": "2012-05-10",
"outcome": "The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed Latisha Lawson's murder conviction and rejected the insanity defense; her 3-year-old son died during a forced oil-and-vinegar exorcism ritual."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant believed her son was possessed by a demon and that God had revealed a plan to exorcise it; she forced him to ingest an oil-and-vinegar mixture while holding his mouth shut, which caused his suffocation. The exorcism ritual was the direct mechanism of death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2440915/lawson-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lawson v. State, 966 N.E.2d 1273 (Ind. Ct. App. 2012).",
"body": "The Indiana Court of Appeals opinion affirms the murder conviction and records the exorcism ritual and demon-possession belief as the mechanism of the child's death.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2012-05-10",
"note": "Conviction affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2440915/lawson-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2440915/lawson-v-state/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 210,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"watchtower"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2015-04-13",
"note": "Compensatory award affirmed; punitive award reversed (duty-to-warn rejected, duty-to-supervise upheld)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "A civil finding against the organization for negligent supervision. Kendrick is recorded as the accused member; the plaintiff is a named adult survivor who brought the suit and is not treated here as a confidential minor.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-conti-v-watchtower-jehovahs-witnesses-california-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Fremont, California, USA",
"lat": 37.548,
"lng": -121.989,
"title": "Conti v. Watchtower: California appellate court affirms Jehovah's Witnesses' civil liability for failing to supervise a known abuser during church 'field service'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregation elders",
"religious headquarters with policy authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"church-sponsored unsupervised access (field service)",
"congregational insularity"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.",
"North Fremont Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California Court of Appeal, First District",
"stage": "civil appeal — compensatory liability affirmed",
"date": "2015-04-13",
"outcome": "The California Court of Appeal affirmed compensatory-damages liability against the congregation and Watchtower for failing to limit and supervise a member (Jonathan Kendrick) whom elders knew had molested a child, and who abused the plaintiff during 'field service'; the punitive-damages award tied to a duty-to-warn theory was reversed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The abuser's unsupervised access to the plaintiff arose through 'field service,' a church-sponsored door-to-door ministry conducted under elder authority within a close-knit congregation whose members were counseled to associate only with co-religionists; the court held the organization could be liable for failing to limit and supervise that access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2793343/conti-v-watchtower-bible-tract-society-of-new-york-inc/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Conti v. Watchtower Bible & Tract Society of New York, Inc., 235 Cal. App. 4th 1214 (2015).",
"body": "The California Court of Appeal opinion affirms the compensatory-damages liability of the congregation and Watchtower for failing to supervise a known abuser during church field service, and reverses the punitive-damages award.",
"tier": "appellate-court",
"kind": "civil-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2015-04-13",
"note": "Compensatory award affirmed; punitive award reversed (duty-to-warn rejected, duty-to-supervise upheld)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2793343/conti-v-watchtower-bible-tract-society-of-new-york-inc/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court; evidentiary role: civil-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2793343/conti-v-watchtower-bible-tract-society-of-new-york-inc/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 211,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Verdict is appealable; final appellate disposition not yet known as of the access date."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named defendant and the single devotee-victim in the proceeding. The verdict is appealable and the record notes that pending posture.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-huang-kuo-ching-yilan-taoist-temple-taiwan",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Yilan County, Taiwan",
"lat": 24.702,
"lng": 121.738,
"title": "Yilan Taoist temple shaman Huang Kuo-ching: 25 years for 39 counts of sexual assault framed as ritual 'sexual treatment'",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"private Taoist temple owner and shaman"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"fabricated spiritual diagnosis",
"ritual healing framing of sexual acts"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Yilan District Court, Taiwan",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-27",
"outcome": "The Yilan District Court convicted Huang Kuo-ching on 39 counts of sexual assault of a female devotee (December 2020–November 2023) and sentenced him to 25 years' imprisonment. The verdict is appealable."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Huang used claimed shamanic authority and a doctrine of evil-spirit and past-life karmic affliction to persuade the victim she required Taoist rituals, then framed 'sexual treatment' as the mandatory cure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://focustaiwan.tw/society/202606080012",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Temple shaman gets 25-year sentence for sexual assault of devotee', Focus Taiwan (CNA), 8 June 2026.",
"body": "Focus Taiwan reports the Yilan District Court's conviction on 39 counts and 25-year sentence, and that Huang convinced the victim she was haunted by evil spirits and afflicted by past-life karma requiring Taoist rituals and 'sexual treatment.'",
"tier": "national-news-agency-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-context-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2026/06/09/2003858781",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Yilan temple owner given 25 years for sexual assault', Taipei Times, 9 June 2026.",
"body": "The Taipei Times corroborates the conviction, sentence, and the ritual 'sexual treatment' framing.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Verdict is appealable; final appellate disposition not yet known as of the access date."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://focustaiwan.tw/society/202606080012",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-context-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "da7764c8cf42f69fc7021078d19f86fd68c75c046dee692e0976a06a18b766e0",
"final_url": "https://focustaiwan.tw/society/202606080012"
},
{
"source": "https://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2026/06/09/2003858781",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c7fa41761c1635cb59eb8ffa67594cd34ec0fe4092e7d46d3ff48e9ff47258e9",
"final_url": "https://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2026/06/09/2003858781"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 212,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court-appeal",
"date": "2026-07-14",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and 10-year sentence upheld; religious healing rejected as a defence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named bishop and the adjudicated death of the female congregant. The husband was also assaulted. Does not attribute conduct to apostolic churches generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-chrispen-gomore-exorcism-flogging-death-zimbabwe",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Beitbridge, Matabeleland South, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -22.216,
"lng": 29.999,
"title": "Bishop Chrispen Gomore: culpable-homicide conviction after fatal 'exorcism' flogging",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"bishop of an apostolic/Zion Christian church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"exorcism and healing framing of violence",
"confinement",
"spiritual authority over congregants"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Damasko Zion Christian Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bulawayo High Court, Zimbabwe",
"stage": "conviction and appeal — appeal dismissed",
"date": "2026-07-14",
"outcome": "The Bulawayo High Court convicted Bishop Chrispen Gomore of culpable homicide (acquitting him of murder) and sentenced him to 10 years; on 14 July 2026 the court dismissed his appeal, ruling that religious healing is not a defence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Gomore declared two congregants mentally disturbed, confined them, and whipped them for hours during a river 'baptism/exorcism' ritual; one died of cranial trauma. His spiritual authority and the doctrine framing violence as exorcism/healing organized and justified the fatal assault, and the court expressly rejected religious healing as a defence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/high-court-rejects-zcc-bishops-appeal-over-congregants-death-during-exorcism-says-religious-healing-not-an-excuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'High Court Rejects ZCC Bishop's Appeal Over Congregant's Death During Exorcism, Says Religious Healing Not an Excuse', NewZimbabwe.com, 14 July 2026.",
"body": "NewZimbabwe reports the Bulawayo High Court's dismissal of Gomore's appeal, the culpable-homicide conviction and 10-year sentence, and the ruling that religious healing is not a defence.",
"tier": "national-court-reporting",
"kind": "leave-to-appeal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://allafrica.com/stories/202607140064.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Zimbabwe: High Court Rejects ZCC Bishop's Appeal Over Congregant's Death During Exorcism', allAfrica.com, 14 July 2026.",
"body": "allAfrica corroborates the appeal dismissal and the religious-healing-not-a-defence ruling.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court-appeal",
"date": "2026-07-14",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and 10-year sentence upheld; religious healing rejected as a defence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/high-court-rejects-zcc-bishops-appeal-over-congregants-death-during-exorcism-says-religious-healing-not-an-excuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-reporting; evidentiary role: leave-to-appeal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fed5d7bafdac3a0a0b5da363072e7be4fd005a52c6c508e234e9ace43d005fb1",
"final_url": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/high-court-rejects-zcc-bishops-appeal-over-congregants-death-during-exorcism-says-religious-healing-not-an-excuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://allafrica.com/stories/202607140064.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "05f7c283f04b0c84e31c9f54c2c477cf1a1531f4f674dc0ef433dc3a7c3dba05",
"final_url": "https://allafrica.com/stories/202607140064.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 213,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named proceeding; the victim survived-status is deceased and the eight convicted men are recorded as convicted persons. One accused was acquitted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-witchcraft-burning-nimule-magwi-south-sudan",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Nimule, Eastern Equatoria, South Sudan",
"lat": 3.6,
"lng": 32.06,
"title": "Magwi County witchcraft killing: eight men convicted for burning a man to death over a witchcraft accusation",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "persecution",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"community members acting on a witchcraft accusation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"witchcraft accusation",
"collective violence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court, Nimule, Eastern Equatoria State",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-26",
"outcome": "The High Court in Nimule convicted eight of nine accused (one acquitted) for burning a man to death over a witchcraft accusation, sentencing each to three years, and ruled that a private customary blood-compensation settlement did not extinguish criminal liability."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The belief that the victim held supernatural power directly motivated and organized the mob killing; the court expressly rejected witchcraft belief as a justification for the killing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eyeradio.org/nimule-court-jails-eight-men-for-killing-man-over-witchcraft-allegations/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Nimule court jails eight men for killing man over witchcraft allegations', Eye Radio, 26 June 2026.",
"body": "Eye Radio reports the High Court's conviction of eight of nine accused, the three-year sentences, and the ruling that witchcraft belief and a customary settlement did not justify or extinguish the killing.",
"tier": "national-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eyeradio.org/nimule-court-jails-eight-men-for-killing-man-over-witchcraft-allegations/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "942988952cc359872e526645d3b4eda7d0fbd137bd4f99e8f936bb9af7be3185",
"final_url": "https://www.eyeradio.org/nimule-court-jails-eight-men-for-killing-man-over-witchcraft-allegations/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 214,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional event documented by an official truth commission and contemporaneous human-rights investigation, not a single criminal defendant's case. Death-toll figure attributed to HRW; the TRRC report's own figure should be reconciled by an editor.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-jammeh-witch-hunt-kanilai-gambia",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Kanilai, The Gambia",
"lat": 13.27,
"lng": -16.57,
"title": "Gambia state 'witch-hunt': TRRC finds Jammeh-ordered ritual-cleansing campaign killed dozens",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "state-terror",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"head of state who ordered the campaign",
"state-sponsored traditional healers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abduction and detention",
"forced ingestion of a ritual concoction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"organizations": [
"Government of The Gambia (Jammeh administration)",
"Truth, Reconciliation and Reparations Commission (TRRC)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Truth, Reconciliation and Reparations Commission, The Gambia",
"stage": "official investigation and finding",
"date": "2021-12-24",
"outcome": "The TRRC's final report documented the 2009 state-sponsored witch-hunt campaign in which villagers were detained and forced to drink a concoction administered by 'witch doctors'; Human Rights Watch reported that of those detained, 41 died in custody or shortly thereafter. The Commission recommended prosecution of those most responsible; no criminal conviction has followed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A claimed occult/witchcraft causation belief triggered a state-organized ritual-cleansing campaign in which invited traditional healers administered a coercive ritual substance that killed detainees.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.moj.gm/download-file/12945cad-6447-11ec-8f4f-025103a708b7",
"archive": "https://moj.gov.gm/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Volume-11-2009-Witch-Hunt-Exercise.pdf",
"citation": "Truth, Reconciliation and Reparations Commission of The Gambia, Final Report, Volume 11: 2009 Witch-Hunt Exercise (25 Nov. 2021).",
"body": "The official TRRC final report (Volume 11) documents the 2009 state witch-hunt campaign ordered under President Jammeh, including the forced ingestion of a concoction and resulting deaths.",
"tier": "official-truth-commission-report-archive",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/05/24/gambia-commission-uncovered-ex-presidents-alleged-crimes",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Gambia: Commission Uncovered Ex-President's Alleged Crimes', Human Rights Watch, 24 May 2021.",
"body": "Human Rights Watch summarizes the witch-hunt campaign and reports that of those detained, 41 died in custody or shortly thereafter.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-human-rights-reporting",
"kind": "finding-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.moj.gm/download-file/12945cad-6447-11ec-8f4f-025103a708b7",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-truth-commission-report-archive; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "527ba9db55e0b611aa821efb499ad429ab9f2ed3756a885e4156b4cf4bb934af",
"final_url": "https://www.moj.gm/download-file/12945cad-6447-11ec-8f4f-025103a708b7"
},
{
"source": "https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/05/24/gambia-commission-uncovered-ex-presidents-alleged-crimes",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-human-rights-reporting; evidentiary role: finding-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8a4a7976fa49f361ff5e499e2a6f8c0b2ccb8bda4263e5d16ad3abd7fe57f15a",
"final_url": "https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/05/24/gambia-commission-uncovered-ex-presidents-alleged-crimes"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 215,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional event documenting many incidents via an official police finding, not a single defendant's case. Most cases were time-barred; that disposition is recorded.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-tysfjord-laestadian-abuse-report-norway",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Tysfjord, Nordland, Norway",
"lat": 68.1,
"lng": 16.1,
"title": "Tysfjord abuse report: Nordland police document 151 assaults in a Sami/Laestadian community, silenced by religious forgiveness",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-lutheran",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregational elders and religious community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious 'forgiveness' used to silence victims and settle matters internally"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Laestadian Lutheran congregations (Tysfjord)",
"Nordland Police District"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nordland Police District, Norway",
"stage": "police investigation and public report",
"date": "2017-11-29",
"outcome": "A Nordland police report (covering 1953–2017) documented at least 151 sexual assaults, including 43 rapes, with 82 identified victims, most connected to the Sami community and the conservative Laestadian revival movement. Only two people were charged in ten cases; most were time-barred."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Police documented that offenders obtained 'forgiveness from religious circles' within the Laestadian congregation, and that this doctrine of forgiveness functioned to silence victims and keep abuse unreported for decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/norway-rape-child-sex-abuse-police-report/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Police report uncovers decades of sexual abuse in arctic Norway', CBS News (AP), 29 Nov. 2017.",
"body": "The AP/CBS account records the Nordland police finding of at least 151 assaults and 82 victims, and that religious forgiveness within the Laestadian congregation was used to silence victims.",
"tier": "law-enforcement",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://edition.cnn.com/2017/11/29/europe/norway-sexual-assault/index.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Norway: 150 sex assault cases revealed in remote region', CNN, 29 Nov. 2017.",
"body": "CNN corroborates the scale of the police finding and the largely time-barred disposition.",
"tier": "international-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/norway-rape-child-sex-abuse-police-report/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: law-enforcement; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9abd90c7debb0f9cca3d8644727e82ac1afbe1b48c25bc91c59ce6a1360ed5d3",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/norway-rape-child-sex-abuse-police-report/"
},
{
"source": "https://edition.cnn.com/2017/11/29/europe/norway-sexual-assault/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "90387771af0ad55c6338b63e3712c8e96f0e119ca88909022ab77865169a46a2",
"final_url": "https://edition.cnn.com/2017/11/29/europe/norway-sexual-assault/index.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 216,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named defendant and the single youth-victim in the proceeding. Finnish district-court judgments are not published on Finlex; sources are Finnish news reports, and the healing-framing wording relies on machine translation pending confirmation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-markku-koivisto-nokia-mission-finland",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Nokia, Pirkanmaa, Finland",
"lat": 61.478,
"lng": 23.508,
"title": "Markku Koivisto (Nokia Mission): conviction for abuse framed as spiritual 'healing'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"charismatic revivalist movement founder and leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"framing sexual acts as spiritual healing",
"spiritual authority over a youth"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Nokia Mission (Nokian herätys)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pirkanmaa District Court, Finland",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentence",
"date": "2013-03-26",
"outcome": "The Pirkanmaa District Court convicted Markku Koivisto of sexual abuse of a 17-year-old boy; the defendant admitted guilt. Sentence: a suspended term of 1 year 3 months, 30 hours community service, and EUR 15,500 compensation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Koivisto used his role as a revivalist spiritual leader to persuade the victim that consenting to sexual acts was part of his spiritual healing and growth; that doctrine of healing was the mechanism of the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://yle.fi/a/3-6554656",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Markku Koivistolle ehdollista vankeutta seksuaalisesta hyväksikäytöstä', Yle Uutiset, March 2013.",
"body": "The Finnish public broadcaster Yle reports the Pirkanmaa District Court conviction, the suspended sentence and compensation, and that the court found Koivisto had led the victim to believe sexual acts were part of spiritual healing.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ts.fi/uutiset/467058",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Herätysjohtaja Koivistolle tuomio seksuaalisesta hyväksikäytöstä', Turun Sanomat, March 2013.",
"body": "Turun Sanomat corroborates the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://yle.fi/a/3-6554656",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ff3f8b5582fb8227302cd2917f6e656c8177a1d3f7a757a089ac812e0248c744",
"final_url": "https://yle.fi/a/3-6554656"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ts.fi/uutiset/467058",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "470118c6b3d21a0dce340e6c6019caac5a5ae7f5aa4249ffcf854f9931015f34",
"final_url": "https://www.ts.fi/a/467058"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 217,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named pastor and the ten child victims in the proceeding; the minors are not further identified. Does not attribute conduct to the wider evangelical community or to the Aché.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-ramon-denis-torres-ache-mission-paraguay",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Alto Paraná, Paraguay",
"lat": -25.51,
"lng": -54.84,
"title": "Paraguay: evangelical pastor sentenced to 27 years for abusing ten Aché indigenous girls",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor of a mission serving an indigenous community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over an indigenous mission community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal tribunal, Alto Paraná, Paraguay",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentence",
"date": "2022-05-15",
"outcome": "A Paraguayan criminal tribunal convicted evangelical pastor Ramón Denis Torres of sexually abusing ten girls from the Aché indigenous community, with assaults beginning in October 2019, and sentenced him to 27 years. He had a prior conviction for child sexual abuse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The pastor used his religious authority and position within an evangelical mission serving the Aché community to gain access to and coerce the child victims.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/america/america-latina/2022/05/15/condenaron-a-27-anos-de-prision-a-un-pastor-evangelico-en-paraguay-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-diez-ninas-indigenas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenaron a 27 años de prisión a un pastor evangélico en Paraguay que abusó sexualmente de diez niñas indígenas', Infobae, 15 May 2022.",
"body": "Infobae reports the Alto Paraná tribunal's conviction of the pastor for abusing ten Aché girls and the 27-year sentence, and his prior conviction for child sexual abuse.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/america/america-latina/2022/05/15/condenaron-a-27-anos-de-prision-a-un-pastor-evangelico-en-paraguay-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-diez-ninas-indigenas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4aca0d7939845853cd0b0bff4f5db9f46de7da0a7531190fb42e9d3cdb8b5a57",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/america/america-latina/2022/05/15/condenaron-a-27-anos-de-prision-a-un-pastor-evangelico-en-paraguay-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-diez-ninas-indigenas/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 218,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named priest and the single minor victim; the minor is not further identified. Nicaragua already has a related priest record; this is a distinct proceeding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-jose-leonardo-urbina-boaco-nicaragua",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Boaco, Nicaragua",
"lat": 12.47,
"lng": -85.66,
"title": "Nicaragua: priest José Leonardo Urbina Rodríguez sentenced to 30 years for rape of a 14-year-old",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust and access to a parish family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal court, Boaco, Nicaragua",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentence",
"date": "2022-08-26",
"outcome": "A Nicaraguan criminal court convicted parish priest José Leonardo Urbina Rodríguez of the sexual abuse and rape of a 14-year-old girl and sentenced him to 30 years, with custody recorded to 2052."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest used his pastoral relationship with the victim's family and his trusted clerical role to gain unsupervised access to the child, taking her out on pretexts before the assaults.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/sacerdote-nicaragueense-es-condenado-a-30-a%C3%B1os-de-c%C3%A1rcel-por-abusar-de-menor/47872336",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote nicaragüense es condenado a 30 años de cárcel por abusar de menor', SWI swissinfo.ch (EFE wire), 26 Aug. 2022.",
"body": "The EFE wire (via swissinfo) reports the Boaco court's conviction of the priest and the 30-year sentence, and that he used his pastoral relationship with the family to access the child.",
"tier": "national-news-agency-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.elimparcial.com/mundo/Sacerdote-de-Nicaragua-es-declarado-culpable-de-abusar-sexualmente-de-una-menor-20220826-0144.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote de Nicaragua es declarado culpable de abusar sexualmente de una menor', El Imparcial, 26 Aug. 2022.",
"body": "El Imparcial corroborates the guilty verdict.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/sacerdote-nicaragueense-es-condenado-a-30-a%C3%B1os-de-c%C3%A1rcel-por-abusar-de-menor/47872336",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "db41eaf96109d1a60ce9a75330f5bc70879f345697315f1fc2a6be2cd72be98e",
"final_url": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/sacerdote-nicaragueense-es-condenado-a-30-a%C3%B1os-de-c%C3%A1rcel-por-abusar-de-menor/47872336"
},
{
"source": "https://www.elimparcial.com/mundo/Sacerdote-de-Nicaragua-es-declarado-culpable-de-abusar-sexualmente-de-una-menor-20220826-0144.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24f342b9fb23deb538a832f9623391507910c2c78cbec2bc1ba2cdd8a959ad15",
"final_url": "https://www.elimparcial.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 219,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named priest and the single minor victim, who is not further identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-luis-ruiz-quiroga-juan-diaz-panama",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Juan Díaz, Panama City, Panama",
"lat": 9.03,
"lng": -79.45,
"title": "Panama: priest Luis Ruiz Quiroga convicted of aggravated lewd acts against a 17-year-old parishioner",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access and pastoral role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Primer Circuito Judicial de Panamá (Juzgado de Garantías)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-07-06",
"outcome": "A Panamanian court convicted Colombian-national priest Luis Ruiz Quiroga of aggravated lewd acts against a 17-year-old at his Juan Díaz parish, imposed a 5-year (60-month) sentence served partly via community work plus a bar from work involving minors, and placed him on Panama's sex-offender registry."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest used his parish position and access to a minor parishioner at the church to commit the abuse; the Archdiocese removed him from pastoral duties upon complaint.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.panamaamerica.com.pa/judicial/sacerdote-colombiano-fue-condenado-e-incluido-en-lista-de-ofensores-sexuales-de-la",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote colombiano fue condenado e incluido en lista de ofensores sexuales de la República de Panamá', Panamá América, 6 July 2022.",
"body": "Panamá América reports the conviction, the 5-year sentence, and the priest's placement on Panama's sex-offender registry.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/america/colombia/2022/07/11/sacerdote-colombiano-pagara-condena-por-abuso-sexual-de-un-menor-en-panama-con-trabajo-comunitario/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote colombiano pagará condena por abuso sexual de un menor en Panamá con trabajo comunitario', Infobae, 11 July 2022.",
"body": "Infobae corroborates the sentence and the community-work arrangement.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.panamaamerica.com.pa/judicial/sacerdote-colombiano-fue-condenado-e-incluido-en-lista-de-ofensores-sexuales-de-la",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24f61c56acaf8d91072b81050ee27d8f1bd22cebdc39ca9f7c5ffcb5781f7067",
"final_url": "https://www.panamaamerica.com.pa/judicial/sacerdote-colombiano-fue-condenado-e-incluido-en-lista-de-ofensores-sexuales-de-la"
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/america/colombia/2022/07/11/sacerdote-colombiano-pagara-condena-por-abuso-sexual-de-un-menor-en-panama-con-trabajo-comunitario/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b45c34f05c5a51441d2ac0f1defe3519e1f369a46304df668e664c7be7f9278f",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/america/colombia/2022/07/11/sacerdote-colombiano-pagara-condena-por-abuso-sexual-de-un-menor-en-panama-con-trabajo-comunitario/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 220,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named priest and the single minor victim, who is not further identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-ignacio-lopez-puerto-barrios-guatemala",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Puerto Barrios, Izabal, Guatemala",
"lat": 15.73,
"lng": -88.59,
"title": "Guatemala: priest Ignacio López sentenced to 16 years for rape of a 14-year-old",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious position",
"threats to silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal tribunal, Izabal, Guatemala",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentence",
"date": "2018-09-19",
"outcome": "A Guatemalan tribunal found parish priest Ignacio López of a Puerto Barrios church guilty of raping a 14-year-old and threatening her into silence, and sentenced him to 16 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As reported, the court found the priest used his religious position ('se valió de su posición religiosa') and threatened the victim to maintain silence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2018/09/19/nota/6960548/16-anos-carcel-sacerdote-guatemala-abuso-sexual-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'16 años de cárcel para sacerdote en Guatemala por abuso sexual a menor', El Universo, 19 Sept. 2018.",
"body": "El Universo reports the tribunal's guilty verdict, the 16-year sentence, and the finding that the priest used his religious position and threatened the victim.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/america/america-latina/2018/09/20/condenaron-a-16-anos-de-carcel-a-un-sacerdote-guatemalteco-por-abuso-sexual-a-una-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenaron a 16 años de cárcel a un sacerdote guatemalteco por abuso sexual a una menor', Infobae, 20 Sept. 2018.",
"body": "Infobae corroborates the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2018/09/19/nota/6960548/16-anos-carcel-sacerdote-guatemala-abuso-sexual-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "397630282f312c35e35094251253b814796bbb246fb15df4649cdbd8068f9cfd",
"final_url": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2018/09/19/nota/6960548/16-anos-carcel-sacerdote-guatemala-abuso-sexual-menor/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/america/america-latina/2018/09/20/condenaron-a-16-anos-de-carcel-a-un-sacerdote-guatemalteco-por-abuso-sexual-a-una-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8712be8c9e1ecde1c866565679c6e29de0f02c3d90f3cfc65ea7d4a84f5b61e5",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/america/america-latina/2018/09/20/condenaron-a-16-anos-de-carcel-a-un-sacerdote-guatemalteco-por-abuso-sexual-a-una-menor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 221,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named proceeding and the deceased child, kept minimal. The instigating ritual specialist ('Jata') is recorded as accused/unidentified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-albino-ritual-murder-cabo-delgado-mozambique",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Balama, Cabo Delgado, Mozambique",
"lat": -13.3,
"lng": 38.55,
"title": "Cabo Delgado albino ritual murder: two men sentenced to 35 years on a ritual specialist's instructions",
"tradition": "muti",
"traditionDetailId": "african-muti",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ritual/muti specialist (instigator)",
"perpetrators acting on ritual instruction"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual instruction to kill for body parts"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cabo Delgado Provincial Court, Pemba, Mozambique",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentence",
"date": "2016-05-13",
"outcome": "The Cabo Delgado Provincial Court convicted two men of the November 2015 killing and mutilation of a 15-year-old albino boy near a primary school; both confessed in court that they acted on the instructions of an unidentified man, and each was sentenced to 35 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The killing and mutilation were carried out on the direct instruction of a ritual/muti specialist to obtain body parts for medicine — the ritual-murder-for-medicine mechanism documented across the region.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://allafrica.com/stories/201605130797.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Mozambique: Long Prison Sentences for Killers of Albino', allAfrica.com (Club of Mozambique), 13 May 2016.",
"body": "The report records the Cabo Delgado Provincial Court's conviction and 35-year sentences, the courtroom confessions, and that the killing was carried out on a third party's ritual instruction for body parts.",
"tier": "regional-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://clubofmozambique.com/news/mueda-another-albino-murdered-in-cabo-delgado-mozambique-9293/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Mueda: Another albino murdered in Cabo Delgado, Mozambique', Club of Mozambique, 2016.",
"body": "Club of Mozambique corroborates the regional pattern of albino ritual killings in Cabo Delgado.",
"tier": "regional-court-reporting",
"kind": "contemporaneous-context"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://allafrica.com/stories/201605130797.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://clubofmozambique.com/news/mueda-another-albino-murdered-in-cabo-delgado-mozambique-9293/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-court-reporting; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 222,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Sentences reduced on appeal; Corogeanu's term reduced from 14 to 7 years. Exact appellate figures to be confirmed via the Romanian judiciary portal."
},
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2007",
"note": "Sentences reduced on appeal (Corogeanu 14→7 years); convictions stand. Nuns received 5–8 years."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named priest, the nuns, and the deceased victim. Sentences were reduced on appeal; that posture is recorded. Does not attribute conduct to the Romanian Orthodox Church generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-tanacu-exorcism-death-cornici-romania",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Tanacu, Vaslui, Romania",
"lat": 46.55,
"lng": 27.83,
"title": "Tanacu exorcism death: Orthodox priest and nuns convicted after a fatal 'demon' exorcism",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Romanian Orthodox priest",
"nuns of the monastery skete"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"exorcism ritual",
"restraint and starvation of a 'possessed' person"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"curse-witchcraft",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Tanacu monastery skete"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunalul Vaslui, Romania (appealed higher)",
"stage": "conviction; sentences reduced on appeal",
"date": "2007-02-19",
"outcome": "Priest Daniel Petre Corogeanu and four nuns were convicted after a 23-year-old nun died in June 2005, having been tied to a wooden cross and left without food or water for three days during an exorcism. Corogeanu was convicted of deprivation of liberty resulting in death; sentences were reduced on appeal (Corogeanu from 14 to 7 years)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest and nuns invoked Orthodox exorcism doctrine and the priest's spiritual authority to restrain and starve a mentally ill woman they believed was possessed, directly causing her death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://hotnews.ro/exorcistul-de-la-tanacu-a-fost-eliberat-fostul-preot-corogeanu-a-ispasit-doua-treimi-din-pedeapsa-657763",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Exorcistul de la Tanacu a fost eliberat', HotNews.ro (Romanian).",
"body": "HotNews reports the conviction of the Tanacu priest, the appellate reduction, and his release after serving two-thirds of the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://adevarul.ro/stiri-locale/vaslui/foto-audio-exorcizarea-de-la-tanacu-cazul-care-a-1596048.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Exorcizarea de la Tanacu, cazul care a făcut înconjurul lumii', Adevărul (Romanian).",
"body": "Adevărul recounts the facts of the fatal exorcism ritual and the proceeding.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ex-monk-gets-7-years-for-botched-exorcism/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex-Monk Gets 7 Years For Botched Exorcism', CBS News (2007), with earlier trial coverage by Fox/AP and NBC.",
"body": "Reports the appellate sentence, the convictions of the nuns, and the church's response.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Sentences reduced on appeal; Corogeanu's term reduced from 14 to 7 years. Exact appellate figures to be confirmed via the Romanian judiciary portal."
},
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2007",
"note": "Sentences reduced on appeal (Corogeanu 14→7 years); convictions stand. Nuns received 5–8 years."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://hotnews.ro/exorcistul-de-la-tanacu-a-fost-eliberat-fostul-preot-corogeanu-a-ispasit-doua-treimi-din-pedeapsa-657763",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "984f8df9fd6644cda9463e461d8b6498529785005a70b7afa0b21444d8cefbba",
"final_url": "https://hotnews.ro/exorcistul-de-la-tanacu-a-fost-eliberat-fostul-preot-corogeanu-a-ispasit-doua-treimi-din-pedeapsa-657763"
},
{
"source": "https://adevarul.ro/stiri-locale/vaslui/foto-audio-exorcizarea-de-la-tanacu-cazul-care-a-1596048.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a2f4ee103c2f2f2801ef432bab0f9a5fc403462f4a0520104de0922a89c73d35",
"final_url": "https://adevarul.ro/stiri-locale/vaslui/foto-audio-exorcizarea-de-la-tanacu-cazul-care-a-1596048.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ex-monk-gets-7-years-for-botched-exorcism/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d7ac04ba796a0285ba36954081daeb8c367334a04279984008701cbea234b10a",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ex-monk-gets-7-years-for-botched-exorcism/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 223,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The disposition is a Church canonical conviction, not a civil or criminal one; the criminal dimension was time-barred and the underlying acts are described as alleged. The number of victims is a reported allegation. Minors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-nedjeljko-ivanov-bibinje-confession-abuse-croatia",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Bibinje, Zadar, Croatia",
"lat": 44.088,
"lng": 15.3,
"title": "Don Nedjeljko Ivanov (Bibinje): first Croatian priest convicted by a Church canonical court for abuse during confession",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"use of the confessional for private access to children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Catholic Church canonical tribunal (Croatia)",
"stage": "canonical conviction; no criminal case (time-barred)",
"date": "2014-02-22",
"outcome": "Priest Nedjeljko Ivanov, serving in Bibinje from 1976 to 1996, was alleged to have abused more than 100 boys, predominantly during confession. In 2014 he became the first Croatian priest convicted by a Catholic Church canonical court for pedophilia; no criminal prosecution occurred because the conduct was time-barred, and he was not laicized."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ivanov used the sacrament of confession itself — a structure of priestly authority requiring private one-on-one access to children — as the setting and pretext for the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.057info.hr/vijesti/2014-02-22/don-nedjeljko-je-zrtve-najcesce-zlostavljao-za-vrijeme-svete-ispovijedi/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Don Nedjeljko je žrtve najčešće zlostavljao za vrijeme svete ispovijedi', 057info.hr (Croatian), 22 Feb. 2014.",
"body": "057info reports that Ivanov was convicted by a Church canonical court and that the abuse most often occurred during confession, with more than 100 alleged victims.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-authority-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://net.hr/danas/vijesti/pokopan-svecenik-iz-bibinja-koji-je-zlostavljao-stotine-djecaka-medu-80-ak-okupljenih-bilo-je-i-devet-svecenika-eb9b483c-b1c3-11eb-b36b-0242ac13005f",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pokopan svećenik iz Bibinja koji je zlostavljao stotine dječaka', Net.hr (Croatian).",
"body": "Net.hr corroborates the case scale and that Ivanov was the first Croatian priest convicted under canon law for such conduct.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.057info.hr/vijesti/2014-02-22/don-nedjeljko-je-zrtve-najcesce-zlostavljao-za-vrijeme-svete-ispovijedi/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-authority-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://net.hr/danas/vijesti/pokopan-svecenik-iz-bibinja-koji-je-zlostavljao-stotine-djecaka-medu-80-ak-okupljenih-bilo-je-i-devet-svecenika-eb9b483c-b1c3-11eb-b36b-0242ac13005f",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "83dc4ab32333fa9e7757170d834bb4b0c0448fe1b5779f364bf0acd64b1d726f",
"final_url": "https://net.hr/danas/vijesti/pokopan-svecenik-iz-bibinja-koji-je-zlostavljao-stotine-djecaka-medu-80-ak-okupljenih-bilo-je-i-devet-svecenika-eb9b483c-b1c3-11eb-b36b-0242ac13005f"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 224,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Scoped to the named priest and the single minor victim, who is not further identified. Any appeal status to be confirmed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-darko-marusic-zadar-croatia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Zadar, Croatia",
"lat": 44.119,
"lng": 15.231,
"title": "Fr Darko Marušić (Zadar): criminal conviction for child exploitation and attempted sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access and pastoral trust"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Općinski sud u Zadru (Zadar Municipal Court), Croatia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-11-01",
"outcome": "The Zadar Municipal Court convicted Catholic parish priest Darko Marušić of exposing a minor to pornographic content, child exploitation for pornography, and attempted sexual abuse of a child under 15, and sentenced him to 3 years 10 months. He had been in pretrial detention since the prior December; the diocese removed him from duties."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Marušić used his standing and access as a parish priest to gain proximity to and the trust of a minor within the parish community.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://net.hr/danas/vijesti/svecenik-u-zadru-osuden-zbog-djecje-pornografije-i-spolne-zlouporabe-djeteta-b1add4ae-c54d-11f0-8a26-9600040c8f8e",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Svećenik u Zadru osuđen zbog dječje pornografije i spolne zlouporabe djeteta', Net.hr (Croatian), 2025.",
"body": "Net.hr reports the Zadar Municipal Court conviction of the priest and the 3 year 10 month sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://zadarskilist.novilist.hr/zadar-zupanija/zupanija/darko-marusic-dobio-je-jednu-od-najvecih-kazni-medu-svecenicima-u-hrvatskoj-no-brojni-seksualni-delikti-u-crkvi-ostaju-neprocesuirani/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Darko Marušić dobio je jednu od najvećih kazni među svećenicima u Hrvatskoj', Zadarski list / Novi list (Croatian).",
"body": "Zadarski list corroborates the sentence and context.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://net.hr/danas/vijesti/svecenik-u-zadru-osuden-zbog-djecje-pornografije-i-spolne-zlouporabe-djeteta-b1add4ae-c54d-11f0-8a26-9600040c8f8e",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c72ba2cc0971b9f98247ddf790527fcca808d8fa2d36d228d68deb2353c1b823",
"final_url": "https://net.hr/danas/vijesti/svecenik-u-zadru-osuden-zbog-djecje-pornografije-i-spolne-zlouporabe-djeteta-b1add4ae-c54d-11f0-8a26-9600040c8f8e"
},
{
"source": "https://zadarskilist.novilist.hr/zadar-zupanija/zupanija/darko-marusic-dobio-je-jednu-od-najvecih-kazni-medu-svecenicima-u-hrvatskoj-no-brojni-seksualni-delikti-u-crkvi-ostaju-neprocesuirani/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1f033137afa183dc1d5ce9005e169cf341a19271128bdb555c51f5b753543701",
"final_url": "https://zadarskilist.novilist.hr/zadar-zupanija/zupanija/darko-marusic-dobio-je-jednu-od-najvecih-kazni-medu-svecenicima-u-hrvatskoj-no-brojni-seksualni-delikti-u-crkvi-ostaju-neprocesuirani/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 225,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The cleric is referred to in press as 'Chrysostomos'; his full legal name should be confirmed via Church of Cyprus records before a name is emphasized. Scoped to the named proceeding and the single victim, who is not further identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-former-kiti-bishop-indecent-assault-cyprus",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Larnaca, Cyprus",
"lat": 34.85,
"lng": 33.57,
"title": "Former Bishop of Kiti: first criminal conviction of a senior Cypriot Orthodox cleric for indecent assault",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Orthodox bishop"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ecclesiastical authority and pastoral access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Cyprus"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Larnaca District Court, Cyprus",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-06-01",
"outcome": "The Larnaca District Court convicted the former Bishop of Kiti of indecently assaulting a 16-year-old girl in 1981, while he held the post of bishop, and imposed a 12-month suspended sentence — reported as the first criminal conviction of a senior Orthodox cleric in Cyprus."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The bishop used his ecclesiastical authority and access to a minor within his pastoral community to commit the assault; the Church of Cyprus structure allowed him to remain a cleric for over 40 years before any accountability.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://cyprus-mail.com/2023/05/15/former-kiti-bishop-found-guilty-of-sexual-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former Kiti bishop found guilty of sexual assault', Cyprus Mail, 15 May 2023.",
"body": "The Cyprus Mail reports the Larnaca District Court's guilty verdict against the former Bishop of Kiti for the 1981 indecent assault of a minor.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://cyprus-mail.com/2023/06/01/suspended-one-year-sentence-for-former-bishop/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Fury as ex-bishop given suspended sentence for assault', Cyprus Mail, 1 June 2023.",
"body": "The Cyprus Mail reports the 12-month suspended sentence and that this was the first such conviction of a senior Orthodox cleric in Cyprus.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://cyprus-mail.com/2023/05/15/former-kiti-bishop-found-guilty-of-sexual-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "93718208f3cf7c063bb58f7692f47827cf8d11ce0351d109f89e0342abc5df98",
"final_url": "https://cyprus-mail.com/2023/05/15/former-kiti-bishop-found-guilty-of-sexual-assault/"
},
{
"source": "https://cyprus-mail.com/2023/06/01/suspended-one-year-sentence-for-former-bishop/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "487e8f2e605f7d794946140b4b3cea2ee05f3400a1ec0678f77e8fdaf131f9ad",
"final_url": "https://cyprus-mail.com/2023/06/01/suspended-one-year-sentence-for-former-bishop/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 226,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The husband's murder/rape charges are allegations pending trial and are recorded with the charged status; the parents' obstruction conviction is final. The deceased is a child; only the age and necessary facts are recorded. Does not attribute conduct to apostolic churches generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-anna-memory-machaya-johanne-marange-zimbabwe",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Marange, Manicaland, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -18.92,
"lng": 32.3,
"title": "Anna 'Memory' Machaya: 14-year-old dies giving birth at a Johanne Marange shrine after doctrinal child marriage",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"apostolic church elders and community authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal child marriage",
"refusal of modern medicine",
"shrine confinement"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"healing-treatment",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"organizations": [
"Johanne Marange Apostolic Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Zimbabwe courts (Mutare)",
"stage": "charges — murder and sexual relations with a minor",
"date": "2021-08-21",
"outcome": "A 14-year-old girl died on 15 July 2021 while giving birth at a Johanne Marange church shrine; the church's doctrine opposes modern medicine, so she was not taken to hospital. Her 26-year-old 'husband', Hatirarami Momberume, was arrested and charged with murder and having a sexual relationship with a minor. These charges are allegations pending adjudication."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Zimbabwe magistrates court",
"stage": "conviction — obstruction of justice",
"date": "",
"outcome": "In 2021 the girl's parents, Edmore Machaya and Shy Mabika, were convicted of defeating or obstructing the course of justice for lying about her age, and sentenced to nine months each."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Child marriage arranged under claimed divine instruction, birth at a church shrine, and the church's doctrinal refusal of modern medicine were the material religious mechanisms in the girl's death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nehandaradio.com/2021/08/21/murder-charge-for-marange-girls-husband/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Murder charge for Marange girl's husband', Nehanda Radio, 21 Aug. 2021.",
"body": "Nehanda Radio reports the murder and sexual-relations-with-a-minor charges against the husband and the circumstances of the shrine death.",
"tier": "national-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.voanews.com/a/africa_un-rights-groups-push-zimbabwe-prosecute-man-who-married-14-year-old-girl/6209321.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'UN, Rights Groups Push Zimbabwe to Prosecute Man Who Married 14-Year-Old Girl', VOA News, Aug. 2021.",
"body": "VOA documents the child marriage, the doctrinal refusal of medical care, and the international attention to the case.",
"tier": "international-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "nexus-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "In 2021 the girl's parents, Edmore Machaya and Shy Mabika, were convicted of defeating or obstructing the course of justice for lying about her age, and sentenced to nine months each.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nehandaradio.com/2021/08/21/murder-charge-for-marange-girls-husband/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "76f0e7b56af0271241904e12cca8d849ca632a7ae570319c514c50d37ed4f4fd",
"final_url": "https://nehandaradio.com/2021/08/21/murder-charge-for-marange-girls-husband/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.voanews.com/a/africa_un-rights-groups-push-zimbabwe-prosecute-man-who-married-14-year-old-girl/6209321.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: nexus-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "63ed4b3ebeafd77514aaf093d304513eea5e2a473ca73b6d79d22e626650aeca",
"final_url": "https://www.voanews.com/a/africa_un-rights-groups-push-zimbabwe-prosecute-man-who-married-14-year-old-girl/6209321.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 227,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional event with many incidents and mixed dispositions; most defendants are charged (allegations pending), with one caretaker conviction recorded. Final leadership verdicts to be tracked. Minors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-gisbh-alarqam-welfare-homes-malaysia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Selangor, Malaysia",
"lat": 3.35,
"lng": 101.52,
"title": "GISBH (Al-Arqam successor): mass child abuse in company-run welfare homes",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"movement founder claiming divine authority",
"company and welfare-home caretakers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"closed obedience hierarchy",
"institutional control of children's homes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Global Ikhwan Services and Business Holdings (GISBH)",
"Al-Arqam (predecessor, banned 1994)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Selayang Sessions Court; Kuala Lumpur High Court, Malaysia",
"stage": "police operation, arrests, and prosecutions (mixed dispositions)",
"date": "2024-09-11",
"outcome": "In Operation Global (2024), Malaysian police rescued about 625 children from welfare homes run by GISBH, a successor to the banned Al-Arqam sect. Police alleged children were sexually and physically abused; over 400 people were arrested and dozens charged. A caretaker, Barur Rahim Hisam, was convicted on four child-abuse charges (10 years); trials of principal leadership were ongoing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Al-Arqam-derived doctrine of the founder's divinely sanctioned supernatural authority, and an internal hierarchy built on obedience to it, structured a closed institutional environment in which the abuse in company-run homes was enabled and unreported.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2024/09/23/what-we-know-so-far-the-gisbh-scandal-involving-sexual-physical-abuse-of-kids-in-welfare-homes/151292",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'What we know so far: The GISBH scandal involving sexual, physical abuse of kids in welfare homes', Malay Mail, 23 Sept. 2024.",
"body": "Malay Mail records Operation Global, the rescue of ~625 children, the arrests and charges, and the alleged abuse in GISBH-run homes.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-and-charges-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.benarnews.org/english/news/malaysian/malaysia-child-abuse-al-arqam-gisbh-09132024141504.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'EXPLAINED: Al-Arqam, the Malaysian sect implicated in a child abuse scandal', BenarNews, 13 Sept. 2024.",
"body": "BenarNews documents the Al-Arqam doctrine of the founder's supernatural authority and GISBH's successor relationship, establishing the doctrinal nexus.",
"tier": "international-contemporaneous-reporting",
"kind": "nexus-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "In Operation Global (2024), Malaysian police rescued about 625 children from welfare homes run by GISBH, a successor to the banned Al-Arqam sect. Police alleged children were sexually and physically abused; over 400 people were arrested and dozens charged. A caretaker, Barur Rahim Hisam, was convicted on four child-abuse charges (10 years); trials of principal leadership were ongoing.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2024/09/23/what-we-know-so-far-the-gisbh-scandal-involving-sexual-physical-abuse-of-kids-in-welfare-homes/151292",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-and-charges-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "857c7a3d97059683ab5d9f45214947f33fd75362eaacd8a773a801ca8b1fabea",
"final_url": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2024/09/23/what-we-know-so-far-the-gisbh-scandal-involving-sexual-physical-abuse-of-kids-in-welfare-homes/151292"
},
{
"source": "https://www.benarnews.org/english/news/malaysian/malaysia-child-abuse-al-arqam-gisbh-09132024141504.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-contemporaneous-reporting; evidentiary role: nexus-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1ffe71aa3ecddd96e0515d50c398e5e36bb48d1829cf0c582974743be8ff7d46",
"final_url": "https://www.benarnews.org/english/news/malaysian/malaysia-child-abuse-al-arqam-gisbh-09132024141504.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 228,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Wolfe's claim to a healing role was found by the court to be the means of the assaults; the record concerns the named defendant and does not characterize Cree or Indigenous spiritual traditions, which he misrepresented. Adult survivors; no identities recorded.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-cecil-wolfe-cree-healer-saskatoon-canada",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada",
"lat": 52.1332,
"lng": -106.67,
"title": "Cecil Wolfe: eight years after a self-styled Cree 'medicine man' used healer status to sexually assault twelve women",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled traditional healer / 'medicine man'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual-healing role",
"staged 'bad medicine' extraction during 'healing' sessions"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of King's Bench, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2025-04-23",
"outcome": "Cecil Wolfe pleaded guilty (February 2025) and, on 23 April 2025, was sentenced by Justice John Morrall to eight years for sexually assaulting twelve women over nine years who had sought him out as a traditional healer."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were drawn to Wolfe and sought him out specifically in his claimed capacity as a traditional healer for ailments including depression and cancer; during purported 'healing' sessions he assaulted them and afterward produced trinkets he claimed were 'bad medicine' extracted from their bodies. That healer role of trust was the documented mechanism of access and coercion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/disgraced-cree-medicine-man-sentenced-to-8-years-in-prison-for-multiple-sexual-assaults-1.7516265",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Disgraced Cree medicine man sentenced to 8 years in prison for multiple sexual assaults', CBC News, 23 April 2025.",
"body": "CBC reports Justice John Morrall's eight-year sentence at Court of King's Bench in Saskatoon, the twelve victims over nine years, and that the women sought Wolfe as a trusted healer.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://paherald.sk.ca/cecil-wolfe-sentenced-to-eight-years-for-using-medicine-man-positions-to-sexually-assault-12-women/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cecil Wolfe sentenced to eight years for using medicine man positions to sexually assault 12 women', Prince Albert Daily Herald, 2025.",
"body": "The Prince Albert Daily Herald corroborates the sentence and that Wolfe used his medicine-man positions to commit the assaults.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/disgraced-cree-medicine-man-sentenced-to-8-years-in-prison-for-multiple-sexual-assaults-1.7516265",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://paherald.sk.ca/cecil-wolfe-sentenced-to-eight-years-for-using-medicine-man-positions-to-sexually-assault-12-women/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c85d2594e0cdf3ea395518dd4c7409d1d3ec7fa3e7f495ca4bedd075f7f9d86d",
"final_url": "https://paherald.sk.ca/cecil-wolfe-sentenced-to-eight-years-for-using-medicine-man-positions-to-sexually-assault-12-women/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 229,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant is identified only as 'Jacob N' per Mexican privacy convention; the minors are not identified. Scoped to the named proceeding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-evangelical-pastor-casa-hogar-nuevo-leon-mexico",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Monterrey, Nuevo León, Mexico",
"lat": 25.6866,
"lng": -100.3161,
"title": "Nuevo León: evangelical pastor sentenced to 59 years for sexually abusing girls at a children's home",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor and religious instructor at a children's home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral/teaching role providing access to children in care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Judiciary of Nuevo León (Fiscalía General de Justicia del Estado), Mexico",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-05-12",
"outcome": "A court in Nuevo León convicted an evangelical pastor (identified in Mexican reporting as Jacob 'N') and sentenced him to 59 years for the sexual abuse of three girls and one adult at a children's home (casa hogar) between August and October 2020; the state prosecutor secured the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The pastor came to the children's home to teach classes and lead physical activities; that religious-instructor role at the church-linked home was the documented mechanism of access to the children in care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/condenado-a-59-a%C3%B1os-de-prisi%C3%B3n-un-pastor-evang%C3%A9lico-por-abuso-sexual-de-menores-en-m%C3%A9xico/48509958",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenado a 59 años de prisión un pastor evangélico por abuso sexual de menores en México', SWI swissinfo.ch (EFE), 12 May 2023.",
"body": "The EFE wire (via swissinfo) reports the 59-year sentence, the Nuevo León prosecutor's conviction, the victims (three minors and one adult) at the children's home, and that the pastor accessed them by teaching classes and activities there.",
"tier": "national-news-agency-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/condenado-a-59-a%C3%B1os-de-prisi%C3%B3n-un-pastor-evang%C3%A9lico-por-abuso-sexual-de-menores-en-m%C3%A9xico/48509958",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8c3f4f437556a3677fd747c9d816b1726fc3ab29976ecc7f3702722348ee2dd3",
"final_url": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/condenado-a-59-a%C3%B1os-de-prisi%C3%B3n-un-pastor-evang%C3%A9lico-por-abuso-sexual-de-menores-en-m%C3%A9xico/48509958"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 230,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "A civil class-action settlement, not individual criminal convictions; it resolves claims on the civil standard and does not adjudicate individual guilt. Institutional-event covering many incidents. Survivors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-archdiocese-quebec-abuse-class-action-settlement-canada",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Quebec City, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 46.8139,
"lng": -71.208,
"title": "Archdiocese of Quebec: $31.5M class-action settlement for clergy abuse dating to 1940",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"diocesan clergy and pastoral staff",
"Catholic diocesan and seminary institutions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority and institutional access across decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Quebec",
"Séminaire de Québec",
"Collège François-de-Laval"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of Quebec (class action)",
"stage": "class-action settlement (agreement in principle)",
"date": "2026-06-18",
"outcome": "The Archdiocese of Quebec, the Séminaire de Québec, the Collège François-de-Laval, and their insurer agreed to a $31.5 million CAD settlement to compensate roughly 150 people who alleged sexual assault by diocesan clergy or pastoral staff since 1940 — the largest such settlement by a Quebec diocese. Claims are adjudicated by retired judges on the civil balance-of-probabilities standard, subject to Superior Court approval."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The settled claims concern abuse committed by clergy and pastoral staff acting under diocesan and seminary religious authority across eight decades; the Catholic institutions themselves are the settling defendants.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.osvnews.com/abuse-victims-reach-31-5-million-joint-settlement-with-quebec-archdiocese-2-institutions-insurer/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Abuse victims reach $31.5 million joint settlement with Quebec Archdiocese, 2 institutions, insurer', OSV News / Catholic News Agency, June 2026.",
"body": "OSV/CNA reports the $31.5M settlement covering ~150 victims of abuse by diocesan clergy/pastoral staff since 1940, the settling institutions, the Superior Court approval step, and the balance-of-probabilities adjudication by retired judges.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "civil-settlement"
},
{
"link": "https://www.catholicregister.org/item/4081-31-5-million-settlement-reached-with-quebec-abuse-victims",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'$31.5 million settlement reached with Quebec abuse victims', The Catholic Register, June 2026.",
"body": "The Catholic Register corroborates the settlement amount, the institutions, and that it is the largest by a Quebec diocese.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.osvnews.com/abuse-victims-reach-31-5-million-joint-settlement-with-quebec-archdiocese-2-institutions-insurer/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-settlement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c602b7303ca0ea2ca18d28125c4d17ec425983181fedfb6b9a8dc885bf33d66e",
"final_url": "https://www.osvnews.com/abuse-victims-reach-31-5-million-joint-settlement-with-quebec-archdiocese-2-institutions-insurer/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.catholicregister.org/item/4081-31-5-million-settlement-reached-with-quebec-abuse-victims",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0d735e0b83ccb1f048e9bbde0f98c373df7b000eb05cfc7a60ed660107c3a5fb",
"final_url": "https://www.catholicregister.org/item/4081-31-5-million-settlement-reached-with-quebec-abuse-victims"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 231,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The conviction is a US (California) proceeding; the church is headquartered in Guadalajara, Mexico, and the record is located in California where the case was adjudicated, with the Mexican headquarters noted. Scoped to the named leader and the minor victims in the plea, who are not identified. Does not attribute conduct to church members generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-naason-joaquin-garcia-la-luz-del-mundo-california-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Los Angeles, California, USA",
"lat": 34.0522,
"lng": -118.2437,
"title": "Naasón Joaquín García: La Luz del Mundo 'Apostle' convicted in California of sexual abuse of minors",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed 'Apostle' and supreme leader of La Luz del Mundo"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position of trust and religious authority as church leader"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"La Luz del Mundo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of California, Los Angeles County",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2022-06-08",
"outcome": "Naasón Joaquín García, supreme leader of the Guadalajara-headquartered La Luz del Mundo church, pleaded guilty on 3 June 2022 to two counts of forcible oral copulation involving minors and one count of a lewd act on a 15-year-old, and was sentenced to 16 years 8 months. The California Attorney General stated he used his position of trust and authority as church leader to abuse children."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The California Attorney General's office stated that García used his position of trust and authority as the leader of La Luz del Mundo to sexually abuse children; his standing as the church's self-proclaimed 'Apostle' and supreme religious authority was the documented mechanism of access and compliance.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-secures-conviction-against-megachurch-leader-naas%C3%B3n",
"archive": "",
"citation": "California Department of Justice, 'Attorney General Bonta Secures Conviction Against Megachurch Leader Naasón Joaquín García' (June 8, 2022).",
"body": "The California DOJ release confirms García's guilty plea to two counts of forcible oral copulation with minors and one lewd act on a child, and states he used his position of trust and authority as leader of La Luz del Mundo to abuse children.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-release",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-secures-conviction-against-megachurch-leader-naas%C3%B3n",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-release; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b7a5d0bdb74e7f40314d276050b490e78cdeb6d05c3f205d313a1f8de37ded56",
"final_url": "https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-secures-conviction-against-megachurch-leader-naas%C3%B3n"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 232,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event record covering documented convictions and official findings within the Oblate-run residential-school system; it does not attribute every allegation to a conviction, and individual convicted persons (O'Connor, Couture) are recorded as such. Named individual cases may be split into separate records with full court citations in a later pass. Survivors and minors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "missionary-oblates-residential-school-abuse-canada",
"year": 1996,
"place": "British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 53.7267,
"lng": -127.6476,
"title": "Missionary Oblates and the residential-school system: clergy convictions and documented abuse of Indigenous children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic bishop and Oblate clergy operating residential schools",
"the residential-school institution"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority within a church-run assimilation system",
"institutional control of children removed from families"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate",
"Catholic residential schools (Canada)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Canadian courts (British Columbia) and the Truth and Reconciliation Commission",
"stage": "criminal convictions and official findings",
"date": "",
"outcome": "Bishop Hubert O'Connor, a member of the Missionary Oblates, was convicted of offences against a former St. Joseph's Indian Residential School student. Fellow Oblate Raynald Couture was convicted in 2004, and other Oblate clergy were convicted of sexual offences at British Columbia residential schools. Court records and the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation identify many named alleged abusers across residential-school litigation; the Truth and Reconciliation Commission documented the system as an instrument of forced assimilation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The abuse occurred within the Catholic-run residential-school system explicitly designed to supplant Indigenous spiritual and cultural practice with Christian doctrine; clergy authority within that church-run institution was the mechanism of access to and control over Indigenous children removed from their families.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aptnnews.ca/investigates/court-documents-reveal-the-names-of-more-than-100-alleged-residential-school-abusers/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Court documents reveal the names of more than 100 alleged residential school abusers', APTN News (investigative, citing court records).",
"body": "APTN's investigation, citing court records, documents convictions and the scale of alleged abuse within the residential-school system, including Oblate clergy.",
"tier": "investigative-reporting",
"kind": "court-and-institutional-records"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aptnnews.ca/investigates/court-documents-reveal-the-names-of-more-than-100-alleged-residential-school-abusers/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: investigative-reporting; evidentiary role: court-and-institutional-records.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "48458f69169dc24b8361bd85f2ee707e3f94548de1d53053ced452814e5fd2f3",
"final_url": "https://www.aptnnews.ca/investigates/court-documents-reveal-the-names-of-more-than-100-alleged-residential-school-abusers/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 233,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The record concerns the named defendant, who falsely claimed a healing role; it does not characterize Indigenous spiritual traditions, which he misrepresented. A minor victim is referenced only by age. Exact sentencing date recorded as May 2004 per CBC.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-harold-mearon-medicine-man-alberta-canada",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Alberta, Canada",
"lat": 53.9333,
"lng": -116.5765,
"title": "Harold Mearon: twelve years after a man posing as a 'medicine man' abused women and girls during 'healing' sessions",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"man posing as a traditional Indigenous healer / 'medicine man'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false claim of a spiritual-healing role",
"private 'healing sessions' as the setting of abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "",
"outcome": "Harold Mearon pleaded guilty (March 2004) and was sentenced in May 2004 by Justice James Langston to 12 years on 13 counts. He had posed as a traditional healer to lure women and girls, including a 12-year-old, to private 'healing sessions' where he sexually abused them; the judge found he manipulated victims into believing his conduct was culturally sanctioned."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Mearon used his claimed status as a traditional healer/'medicine man' as the mechanism of access, luring victims to purported spiritual-healing sessions; the sentencing judge found he manipulated the young and vulnerable into believing his practices were culturally condoned.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/healer-sentenced-to-12-years-for-sexual-abuse-1.513649",
"archive": "",
"citation": "''Healer' sentenced to 12 years for sexual abuse', CBC News (Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta, May 2004).",
"body": "CBC reports Mearon's guilty plea to 13 counts, the 12-year sentence from Justice James Langston, that he posed as a medicine man to lure victims to 'healing sessions', and the judge's finding that he made victims believe his practices were culturally condoned.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/healer-sentenced-to-12-years-for-sexual-abuse-1.513649",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 234,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant is identified only as 'Moisés N' per Mexican privacy convention; the minor is not identified. Scoped to the named proceeding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-pastor-moises-puebla-mexico",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Puebla, Mexico",
"lat": 19.0414,
"lng": -98.2063,
"title": "Puebla: Christian pastor sentenced to nearly 14 years for raping a minor congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a Christian church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral role and the victim's routine church attendance as the means of access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Judiciary of Puebla (Fiscalía General del Estado de Puebla), Mexico",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-03-21",
"outcome": "A Puebla court convicted a Christian pastor (identified in Mexican reporting as Moisés 'N') and sentenced him on 21 March 2022 to 13 years 9 months plus reparation of damages, for repeatedly raping a minor who attended his church, with abuse documented from 2014-2015."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As pastor, the defendant had regular access to the child through her routine attendance at his church, using that pastoral role and trust to commit the repeated assaults.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2022/03/22/puebla-un-pastor-cristiano-fue-sentenciado-por-violar-a-una-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Puebla: un pastor cristiano fue sentenciado por violar a una menor', Infobae, 22 March 2022.",
"body": "Infobae reports the Puebla court's sentence of 13 years 9 months plus damages against the pastor for raping a minor congregant.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.animalpolitico.com/2022/03/sentencia-anos-pastor-puebla-violacion-menor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sentencian a pastor en Puebla por violación de una menor', Animal Político (citing Fiscalía General del Estado de Puebla), March 2022.",
"body": "Animal Político, citing the Puebla state prosecutor, corroborates the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2022/03/22/puebla-un-pastor-cristiano-fue-sentenciado-por-violar-a-una-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "64292bea46cd5d97d71c9e9db2d3131b97e4301e2b494457f6a05f5a127caa7e",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2022/03/22/puebla-un-pastor-cristiano-fue-sentenciado-por-violar-a-una-menor/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.animalpolitico.com/2022/03/sentencia-anos-pastor-puebla-violacion-menor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e37506b1fcfc435594cc706cfb401ccb6ffd1f9e5c3c591b3aad3ddaf2ea84ec",
"final_url": "https://animalpolitico.com/2022/03/sentencia-anos-pastor-puebla-violacion-menor"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 235,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant is identified only as 'Jonathan Armando N' per Mexican privacy convention; the specific denomination was not stated in available reporting. Scoped to the named proceedings.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-minister-jonathan-armando-cadereyta-nuevo-leon-mexico",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Cadereyta Jiménez, Nuevo León, Mexico",
"lat": 25.5989,
"lng": -99.9903,
"title": "Nuevo León: religious minister sentenced to 37 years for sexual crimes against congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious minister ('pastor') of a temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority and trust used to coerce congregants"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Judiciary of Nuevo León (Fiscalía General de Justicia del Estado), Mexico",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-11-06",
"outcome": "A Nuevo León court sentenced a religious minister (identified as Jonathan Armando 'N') of a temple in Cadereyta Jiménez to 37 years on 6 November 2023 for sexual crimes against four congregants committed 2015-2020, following an earlier 11-year sentence imposed in July 2021."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Prosecutors established that the defendant used his position as a religious minister to exploit pastoral trust and impose sexual acts on congregants through physical and psychological coercion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.excelsior.com.mx/nacional/sentencia-nuevo-leon-pastor-prision-abusar-sexualmente-feligreses/1619502",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sentencian en Nuevo León a pastor por abusar sexualmente de feligreses', Excélsior, Nov. 2023.",
"body": "Excélsior reports the 37-year sentence for the minister's sexual crimes against congregants and the pastoral-trust mechanism.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.jornada.com.mx/noticia/2023/11/13/estados/condenan-a-pastor-por-delitos-sexuales-en-nuevo-leon-3811",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a pastor por delitos sexuales en Nuevo León', La Jornada, 13 Nov. 2023.",
"body": "La Jornada corroborates the conviction and 37-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.excelsior.com.mx/nacional/sentencia-nuevo-leon-pastor-prision-abusar-sexualmente-feligreses/1619502",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9f4426aecd60e6b6d6ee1b1e8793720cb6898605c6f2bce4bfe4fb9b5f191953",
"final_url": "https://www.excelsior.com.mx/nacional/sentencia-nuevo-leon-pastor-prision-abusar-sexualmente-feligreses/1619502"
},
{
"source": "https://www.jornada.com.mx/noticia/2023/11/13/estados/condenan-a-pastor-por-delitos-sexuales-en-nuevo-leon-3811",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "22fb74002155e34c077ff4cb4d3f7308f0545413616c37c2634e492e1673794f",
"final_url": "https://www.jornada.com.mx/noticia/2023/11/13/estados/condenan-a-pastor-por-delitos-sexuales-en-nuevo-leon-3811"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 236,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event / official-finding covering a systemic pattern documented by UN Special Procedures, not a single adjudicated case. Follows prior OHCHR statements (2023, 2024). Statistics are attributed to the UN experts' 2025 figures. No individual survivors are identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-ohchr-pakistan-forced-conversion-marriage-finding",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Sindh, Pakistan",
"lat": 25.8943,
"lng": 68.5247,
"title": "Pakistan: UN experts find systemic forced conversion and marriage of minority women and girls",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "forced-marriage",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"abductors and clerics conducting forced conversions/marriages",
"courts validating coerced conversions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"forced religious conversion",
"forced/child marriage",
"religious-law validation overriding child-protection statutes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"OHCHR / UN Special Procedures"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "UN Human Rights Council Special Procedures (OHCHR)",
"stage": "official finding by UN experts",
"date": "2026-04-22",
"outcome": "On 22 April 2026, UN experts — including the Special Rapporteurs on contemporary forms of slavery (Obokata), freedom of religion or belief (Ghanea), minority issues (Levrat), and trafficking in persons (Mullally), and the Working Group on discrimination against women and girls — found continued widespread abduction and forced religious conversion through marriage of minority women and girls in Pakistan. In 2025, ~75% of victims were Hindu and ~25% Christian, with ~80% of incidents in Sindh; the experts noted courts often validate the coerced conversions and marriages rather than protecting victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Forced conversion to Islam is the operative mechanism: minority women and girls are abducted and compelled to convert in order to be married to Muslim men, and courts validate the coerced conversion and marriage using religious-law standards that override child-protection statutes — making religious coercion the documented instrument of the harm.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2026/04/un-experts-concerned-forced-conversion-through-marriage-pakistan",
"archive": "",
"citation": "OHCHR, 'UN experts concerned by forced conversion through marriage in Pakistan' (22 April 2026).",
"body": "The OHCHR release records the UN experts' finding of widespread forced conversion through marriage of minority women and girls in Pakistan, the 2025 victim breakdown (75% Hindu, 25% Christian; 80% in Sindh), and that courts often validate coerced conversions and marriages.",
"tier": "official-un-special-procedures-communication",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://www.theweek.in/wire-updates/international/2026/04/24/un-experts-flag-forced-conversions-of-minority-women-in-pakistan-seek-action.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'UN experts flag forced conversions of minority women in Pakistan, seek action', The Week (wire), 24 April 2026.",
"body": "The Week corroborates the OHCHR statement and the named Special Rapporteurs.",
"tier": "national-news-agency-court-reporting",
"kind": "official-release-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2026/04/un-experts-concerned-forced-conversion-through-marriage-pakistan",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-un-special-procedures-communication; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.theweek.in/wire-updates/international/2026/04/24/un-experts-flag-forced-conversions-of-minority-women-in-pakistan-seek-action.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency-court-reporting; evidentiary role: official-release-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "969ddf47678b9b8b985710ad408fa36488c30699c83f3423633a63605f24802b",
"final_url": "https://www.theweek.in/wire-updates/international/2026/04/24/un-experts-flag-forced-conversions-of-minority-women-in-pakistan-seek-action.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 237,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Dixit is a fugitive and the case is unadjudicated; the record uses the charged status and treats the abuse as alleged. Minors are not identified. The Delhi High Court oversight of resident women is recorded as an official protective measure, distinct from any finding of guilt.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-virendra-dev-dixit-adhyatmik-ashram-delhi-india",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Rohini, Delhi, India",
"lat": 28.7361,
"lng": 77.091,
"title": "Virendra Dev Dixit: CBI cases and Delhi High Court oversight over an ashram after girls were rescued; founder a fugitive",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled spiritual preacher and ashram head"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"absolute guru authority over resident women and girls",
"confinement within a closed 'spiritual university'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Adhyatmik Vishwa Vidyalaya (Adhyatmik Ishwariya Vishwa Vidyalaya)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Delhi High Court / Central Bureau of Investigation, India",
"stage": "CBI cases registered; founder absconding; High Court oversight",
"date": "",
"outcome": "After a 2017-2018 raid rescued women and girls from the Rohini ashram, the CBI registered rape and trafficking cases against self-styled preacher Virendra Dev Dixit. In April 2022 the Delhi High Court constituted a supervisory committee over the ashram's female residents and repeatedly directed the CBI to arrest Dixit, who remains absconding. The charges are allegations and have not been adjudicated."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Dixit ran a closed ashram/'spiritual university' in which he held absolute guru authority over resident women and girls; the allegations describe doctrine and confinement used to control and sexually abuse residents. The nexus is the claimed spiritual authority and the closed devotee hierarchy.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lawbeat.in/news-updates/taking-steps-arrest-absconding-self-styled-spiritual-preacher-virender-dev-dixit-rohini-ashram-cbi-tells-delhi-high-court",
"archive": "",
"citation": "''Taking steps to Arrest Absconding Self-Styled Spiritual Preacher Virender Dev Dixit': CBI tells Delhi High Court', LawBeat (Delhi High Court proceedings), 2022.",
"body": "LawBeat reports the Delhi High Court proceedings, the CBI's cases against the absconding Dixit, and the court's oversight of the ashram's female residents.",
"tier": "national-court-reporting",
"kind": "current-proceeding-status"
},
{
"link": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/years-after-self-styled-godman-virendra-dev-dixit-flees-cbi-his-victims-contend-with-the-abuse-they-suffered-and-inflicted",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Years After Self-Styled Godman Virendra Dev Dixit Flees CBI, His Victims Contend With The Abuse', Outlook India.",
"body": "Outlook India documents the ashram raid, the rescued residents, and Dixit's fugitive status.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "nexus-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "After a 2017-2018 raid rescued women and girls from the Rohini ashram, the CBI registered rape and trafficking cases against self-styled preacher Virendra Dev Dixit. In April 2022 the Delhi High Court constituted a supervisory committee over the ashram's female residents and repeatedly directed the CBI to arrest Dixit, who remains absconding. The charges are allegations and have not been adjudicated.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lawbeat.in/news-updates/taking-steps-arrest-absconding-self-styled-spiritual-preacher-virender-dev-dixit-rohini-ashram-cbi-tells-delhi-high-court",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-reporting; evidentiary role: current-proceeding-status.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/years-after-self-styled-godman-virendra-dev-dixit-flees-cbi-his-victims-contend-with-the-abuse-they-suffered-and-inflicted",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: nexus-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8c75360edc38ec71c49682695a1c69e49f49cc80a439ee05e9565d9abe9cdee5",
"final_url": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/years-after-self-styled-godman-virendra-dev-dixit-flees-cbi-his-victims-contend-with-the-abuse-they-suffered-and-inflicted"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 238,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "direct-appeal",
"date": "1996",
"note": "Direct appeals affirmed the convictions (e.g., Echols v. State, 326 Ark. 917 (1996))."
},
{
"stage": "post-conviction",
"date": "2007",
"note": "Post-conviction DNA testing excluded all three from crime-scene DNA."
},
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2010-11-04",
"note": "Echols v. State, 2010 Ark. 417 — remand for a DNA/juror-misconduct hearing."
},
{
"stage": "alford-plea",
"date": "2011-08-19",
"note": "Alford pleas; released on time served. Convictions remain of record; not a formal exoneration."
},
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2024-04-18",
"note": "Echols v. State, 2024 Ark. 61 — renewed DNA testing permitted as the men pursue exoneration."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a wrongful conviction driven by satanic-panic prosecution theory. Echols, Baldwin, and Misskelley are recorded as survivors of that miscarriage of justice, NOT as occult abusers; they were released via Alford plea in 2011 and continue to seek full exoneration, and the record does not imply their guilt. The three child murder victims are referenced only by the fact of their deaths, without gratuitous detail. Evidence status: the 1994 jury convictions are real and never merits-overturned, but the disposition (Alford plea, time served) does not fit a simple 'convicted' or 'acquitted' bucket — flagged for editorial review of the exact status.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-west-memphis-three-satanic-panic-arkansas-usa",
"year": 1994,
"place": "West Memphis, Arkansas, USA",
"lat": 35.1465,
"lng": -90.1848,
"title": "West Memphis Three: satanic-panic prosecution and the wrongful conviction of Echols, Baldwin and Misskelley",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecution and a purported 'cult expert' witness",
"teenage defendants later regarded as wrongfully convicted"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"'satanic ritual' theory offered in place of physical evidence",
"use of occult interest, music and clothing as proof of motive"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court, Second Judicial District, Arkansas (Judge David Burnett)",
"stage": "jury convictions",
"date": "1994-03-19",
"outcome": "Damien Echols, Jason Baldwin, and Jessie Misskelley Jr. were convicted of the 1993 murders of three eight-year-old boys on a prosecution theory that the killings were a Satanic ritual. Echols was sentenced to death, Baldwin to life without parole, and Misskelley to life plus forty years. A purported 'cult expert' testified that the crime bore signs of Satanic activity, and the prosecution introduced Echols's interest in Wicca/occultism, his notebooks, and the defendants' music and clothing as evidence of motive."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Arkansas",
"stage": "remand for DNA/juror-misconduct hearing",
"date": "2010-11-04",
"outcome": "In Echols v. State, 2010 Ark. 417, the Arkansas Supreme Court ordered the circuit court to hold a hearing on new DNA evidence (which excluded all three from crime-scene DNA) and on claims of juror misconduct."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Craighead County Circuit Court (Judge David Laser)",
"stage": "Alford pleas; resentenced to time served",
"date": "2011-08-19",
"outcome": "To resolve the case before that hearing, the three entered Alford pleas — pleading guilty while asserting innocence — and were resentenced to time served (about 18 years) and released. The 1994 convictions were never overturned on the merits, and the men continue to seek full exoneration; in 2024 the Arkansas Supreme Court allowed renewed DNA testing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "In the absence of physical evidence tying the teenagers to the scene, the prosecution's organizing theory was that the murders were a Satanic ritual: it relied on a purported 'cult expert' and on Damien Echols's interest in Wicca and the occult, his notebooks, and the defendants' heavy-metal music and black clothing as evidence of a Satanic motive. This 'satanic panic' use of occult ideology materially organized a widely criticized wrongful conviction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/5282356/echols-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Echols v. State, 2010 Ark. 417, 373 S.W.3d 892 (Ark. 2010).",
"body": "The Arkansas Supreme Court ordered a hearing on new DNA evidence and juror-misconduct claims, the ruling that led to the 2011 Alford-plea release.",
"tier": "state-supreme-court",
"kind": "procedural-ruling"
},
{
"link": "https://innocenceproject.org/news/who-are-west-memphis-three-damien-echols/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'West Memphis Three: What You Should Know About Their Wrongful Conviction', Innocence Project (2023).",
"body": "The Innocence Project summarizes the satanic-panic prosecution, the DNA exclusion, and the 2011 Alford-plea release.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "historical-case-review"
},
{
"link": "https://arkansasadvocate.com/2024/04/18/arkansas-supreme-court-reverses-west-memphis-three-ruling-allows-for-dna-testing/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Arkansas Supreme Court reverses West Memphis Three ruling, allows for DNA testing', Arkansas Advocate, 18 April 2024.",
"body": "Reports the 2024 Arkansas Supreme Court ruling permitting renewed DNA testing as the men pursue exoneration.",
"tier": "state-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-report"
},
{
"link": "https://encyclopediaofarkansas.net/entries/west-memphis-three-3039/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'West Memphis Three', Encyclopedia of Arkansas (Central Arkansas Library System).",
"body": "A scholarly reference account of the case, the trials, the satanic-ritual theory, and the disposition.",
"tier": "academic-monograph",
"kind": "historical-chronology"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "direct-appeal",
"date": "1996",
"note": "Direct appeals affirmed the convictions (e.g., Echols v. State, 326 Ark. 917 (1996))."
},
{
"stage": "post-conviction",
"date": "2007",
"note": "Post-conviction DNA testing excluded all three from crime-scene DNA."
},
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2010-11-04",
"note": "Echols v. State, 2010 Ark. 417 — remand for a DNA/juror-misconduct hearing."
},
{
"stage": "alford-plea",
"date": "2011-08-19",
"note": "Alford pleas; released on time served. Convictions remain of record; not a formal exoneration."
},
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2024-04-18",
"note": "Echols v. State, 2024 Ark. 61 — renewed DNA testing permitted as the men pursue exoneration."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/5282356/echols-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-supreme-court; evidentiary role: procedural-ruling.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/5282356/echols-v-state/"
},
{
"source": "https://innocenceproject.org/news/who-are-west-memphis-three-damien-echols/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: historical-case-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e472578de3ff633763257cfc1fb1e0c83cf116f86c05aaca92e19c90d04527bd",
"final_url": "https://innocenceproject.org/news/who-are-west-memphis-three-damien-echols/"
},
{
"source": "https://arkansasadvocate.com/2024/04/18/arkansas-supreme-court-reverses-west-memphis-three-ruling-allows-for-dna-testing/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f0d084ec57b370e9a03b8665d039175a31381297ce879127917892b5613882f1",
"final_url": "https://arkansasadvocate.com/2024/04/18/arkansas-supreme-court-reverses-west-memphis-three-ruling-allows-for-dna-testing/"
},
{
"source": "https://encyclopediaofarkansas.net/entries/west-memphis-three-3039/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: academic-monograph; evidentiary role: historical-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a50e87f5c71ea3344633018edb7ddbff750bdf4aa1b13317c42b6230e7821553",
"final_url": "https://encyclopediaofarkansas.net/entries/west-memphis-three-3039/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 239,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The ritual's operative role in the specific charged shipment is documented in the DOJ account of the trial. Scoped to the named defendant; does not characterize Santería practitioners generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-francisco-javier-maya-santeria-drug-blessing-texas-usa",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Mission, Texas, USA",
"lat": 26.2159,
"lng": -98.3253,
"title": "United States v. Maya: Santería ritual blessing of a marijuana load documented in a federal trafficking conviction",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "ritual-crime",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"drug-trafficking defendant",
"a Santería priest who blessed the shipment"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual blessing performed to spiritually protect a specific trafficking shipment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Southern District of Texas",
"stage": "jury conviction",
"date": "2014-01-30",
"outcome": "Francisco Javier Maya was convicted by a jury of conspiracy to possess and possession with intent to distribute roughly 1,000 pounds of marijuana. Trial evidence, including testimony from cooperating co-defendants, showed a Santería priest performed two blessing rituals over the marijuana load before it was moved, and that altars with blood, knives and a machete were found at his residence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Santería ritual was performed specifically to bless and spiritually protect a particular trafficking shipment, as testified to at trial — making the ritual a documented operational step in the charged conspiracy rather than incidental religious background.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdtx/pr/santeria-follower-convicted-federal-drug-charges",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, USAO Southern District of Texas, 'Santeria Follower Convicted Of Federal Drug Charges' (30 Jan. 2014).",
"body": "The DOJ release records the conviction and that a Santería priest performed blessing rituals over the marijuana load, with trial testimony from cooperating co-defendants.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "conviction-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.dea.gov/press-releases/2014/01/30/santeria-follower-convicted-federal-drug-charges",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, 'Santeria Follower Convicted Of Federal Drug Charges' (30 Jan. 2014).",
"body": "The DEA release corroborates the conviction and the ritual blessing of the shipment.",
"tier": "official-agency",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdtx/pr/santeria-follower-convicted-federal-drug-charges",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f1b6f3a88f7aeb312eb9412ce9ef57c31f2734806c21c60501a7523fec3e705",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdtx/pr/santeria-follower-convicted-federal-drug-charges"
},
{
"source": "https://www.dea.gov/press-releases/2014/01/30/santeria-follower-convicted-federal-drug-charges",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-agency; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 240,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The men were convicted of the murders as sicarios; the Santa Muerte ritual is documented via an intercepted call reported by the FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin and contemporaneous reporting, and is presented as evidentiary color of the kill-team's practice rather than a separately charged ritual crime. Does not characterize Santa Muerte devotees generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-cardona-reta-zetas-santa-muerte-laredo-texas-usa",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Laredo, Texas, USA",
"lat": 27.5306,
"lng": -99.4803,
"title": "Zetas teenage sicarios Cardona and Reta: murder convictions in a cartel kill-team that toasted killings to Santa Muerte",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teenage cartel hitmen (sicarios) for Los Zetas"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual veneration of Santa Muerte within a cartel kill-team"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Los Zetas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Webb County / U.S. District Court, Texas",
"stage": "murder convictions and sentences",
"date": "2009-03-05",
"outcome": "Gabriel Cardona and Rosalio Reta, teenage hitmen for Los Zetas, were convicted of multiple murders committed around Laredo, Texas. A DEA-intercepted phone call captured Cardona describing collecting victims' blood and toasting to 'la Santísima Muerte' during a killing. Cardona received a life sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Members of the cartel kill-team practiced ritual veneration of Santa Muerte tied to their killings — including an intercepted account of toasting a murder to 'la Santísima Muerte.' The ritual detail comes from a law-enforcement wiretap and is documented as the kill-team's ritual practice, though the toast itself was not a separately charged element of the homicide counts.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/sanantonio/press-releases/2009/sicarioleader030509.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FBI San Antonio, 'Sicario Leader Sentenced to Life in Prison Without Parole' (5 March 2009).",
"body": "The FBI release records the murder convictions and life sentence of the Zetas sicario leader (Cardona).",
"tier": "official-investigating-agency",
"kind": "conviction-release"
},
{
"link": "https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/santa-muerte-inspired-and-ritualistic-killings",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Santa Muerte: Inspired and Ritualistic Killings', FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin.",
"body": "The FBI LEB documents the intercepted account of the kill-team toasting a killing to Santa Muerte, as evidence of ritual practice.",
"tier": "official-agency",
"kind": "authority-and-belief-context"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/sanantonio/press-releases/2009/sicarioleader030509.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-investigating-agency; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "33812e54099df8d0bf23970b41e1974c0ad3940acd4d62cbb6a2a231e8c901f1",
"final_url": "https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/sanantonio/press-releases/2009/sicarioleader030509.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/santa-muerte-inspired-and-ritualistic-killings",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-agency; evidentiary role: authority-and-belief-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e2d96c9b5bf926e3e7028618a11d8fc3f430f2a3c829cf1b9b266404ab10b23c",
"final_url": "https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/santa-muerte-inspired-and-ritualistic-killings"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 241,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "The family stated intent to appeal to the Supreme Court of Pakistan; no confirmed Supreme Court ruling was located. Post-ruling status of the girl rests only on advocacy sourcing and is treated as unverified."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The record is scoped to the documented Sindh High Court ruling (an official/court finding). The subject is a minor; only necessary facts are recorded. The individual case underlies the separately recorded OHCHR institutional finding on forced conversion in Pakistan. Post-2020 status of the girl is advocacy-sourced and treated as unverified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-huma-younus-forced-conversion-marriage-karachi-pakistan",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Karachi, Sindh, Pakistan",
"lat": 24.8607,
"lng": 67.0011,
"title": "Huma Younus: Sindh High Court validates the forced conversion and marriage of an abducted Christian girl on religious-law grounds",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "forced-marriage",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"abductor who forced conversion and marriage",
"court applying a religious-law puberty standard"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"forced religious conversion",
"forced/child marriage",
"religious-law validation overriding child-protection statute"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Sindh High Court"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sindh High Court, Pakistan",
"stage": "ruling on the parents' petition",
"date": "2020-02-03",
"outcome": "Huma Younus, a Christian girl (reported age 14) from Karachi, was abducted on 10 October 2019, forcibly converted to Islam, and married to her abductor Abdul Jabbar. On 3 February 2020 a two-judge Sindh High Court bench dismissed her parents' petition and ruled the marriage valid, holding that under a Sharia puberty standard a girl who has reached menarche may marry regardless of chronological age, thereby overriding the Sindh Child Marriage Restraint Act's 18-year minimum. The family stated an intent to appeal to the Supreme Court."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Forced conversion to Islam was the operative mechanism: the girl was abducted and compelled to convert to be married, and the Sindh High Court validated the marriage using a religious-law puberty standard that overrode the secular child-marriage statute — making religious-law doctrine the documented instrument that legitimized the coerced conversion and marriage.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ucanews.com/news/pakistan-court-validates-marriage-of-abducted-catholic-girl/90054",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pakistan court validates marriage of abducted Catholic girl', UCA News (Union of Catholic Asian News), 4 Feb. 2020.",
"body": "UCA News reports the Sindh High Court's dismissal of the parents' petition and its ruling that the marriage was valid on a Sharia puberty standard, overriding the child-marriage statute.",
"tier": "specialist-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.uscirf.gov/religious-prisoners-conscience/forb-victims-database/huma-younus",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF), FoRB Victims Database: Huma Younus.",
"body": "USCIRF, a US federal commission, documents the abduction, forced conversion and marriage, and the Sindh High Court ruling.",
"tier": "official-government-reporting",
"kind": "official-case-description"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "The family stated intent to appeal to the Supreme Court of Pakistan; no confirmed Supreme Court ruling was located. Post-ruling status of the girl rests only on advocacy sourcing and is treated as unverified."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ucanews.com/news/pakistan-court-validates-marriage-of-abducted-catholic-girl/90054",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "58157712dc2d7341e73d077d6311f3ae5d49834fef44a927fc70da2624486f27",
"final_url": "https://www.ucanews.com/news/pakistan-court-validates-marriage-of-abducted-catholic-girl/90054"
},
{
"source": "https://www.uscirf.gov/religious-prisoners-conscience/forb-victims-database/huma-younus",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-reporting; evidentiary role: official-case-description.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f7aac5f5ada9182ee444538058a6fe9c5b81c9a640048e60dcb59ad38e5a6f17",
"final_url": "https://www.uscirf.gov/religious-prisoners-conscience/forb-victims-database/huma-younus"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 242,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1990-01-18",
"note": "Peggy McMartin Buckey acquitted (1990); remaining charges against Ray Buckey dropped after two hung juries."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a WRONGFUL accusation/prosecution driven by satanic-ritual-abuse panic. The accused are recorded as SURVIVORS of the miscarriage of justice, not as perpetrators; the record does not imply their guilt. Child witnesses whose testimony was found unreliable are not identified. Disposition: acquittal and charges dropped (no convictions).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-mcmartin-preschool-satanic-panic-california-usa",
"year": 1990,
"place": "Manhattan Beach, California, USA",
"lat": 33.8847,
"lng": -118.4109,
"title": "McMartin Preschool: the longest US criminal trial ends with no convictions after satanic-ritual-abuse allegations collapse",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "closed-without-charge",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "closed-without-charge",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecutors, investigators and therapists acting on satanic-ritual-abuse panic",
"the wrongly accused (survivors of the miscarriage)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"satanic-ritual-abuse panic ideology",
"coercive/suggestive child-interview techniques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of California, Los Angeles County",
"stage": "acquittal and charges dropped (no convictions)",
"date": "1990-01-18",
"outcome": "Ray Buckey and his mother Peggy McMartin Buckey were accused of mass ritualistic child sexual abuse based on children's statements elicited by suggestive interviewing. After the longest and most expensive criminal trial in US history, no convictions resulted: Peggy McMartin Buckey was acquitted in 1990 and all remaining charges against Ray Buckey were dropped after two deadlocked juries."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Satanic-ritual-abuse panic — amplified by therapists and media primed by the discredited book 'Michelle Remembers' — drove coercive child-interview techniques that manufactured allegations of Satanic rites and animal sacrifice with no corroborating physical evidence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/january-18/the-mcmartin-preschool-trials",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Defendant in McMartin Preschool trials is acquitted', History.com (event 1990).",
"body": "Documents the acquittal of Peggy McMartin Buckey and the collapse of the satanic-ritual-abuse prosecution after the longest trial in US history.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "historical-case-review"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1990-01-18",
"note": "Peggy McMartin Buckey acquitted (1990); remaining charges against Ray Buckey dropped after two hung juries."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/january-18/the-mcmartin-preschool-trials",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: historical-case-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8db10f67368854688b339cfff975d0d64cd5456fc1fd14488d50b100d5c9388e",
"final_url": "https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/january-18/the-mcmartin-preschool-trials"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 243,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "2004-01-01",
"note": "~34 of 36+ convictions overturned; John Stoll's 40-year sentence vacated in 2004 after recantations."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a WRONGFUL accusation/prosecution driven by satanic-ritual-abuse panic. The accused are recorded as SURVIVORS of the miscarriage of justice, not as perpetrators; the record does not imply their guilt. Child witnesses whose testimony was found unreliable are not identified. Disposition: most convictions overturned on appeal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1986-kern-county-ritual-abuse-panic-california-usa",
"year": 1986,
"place": "Kern County (Bakersfield), California, USA",
"lat": 35.3733,
"lng": -119.0187,
"title": "Kern County ritual-abuse prosecutions: dozens convicted, most convictions later overturned",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecutors, investigators and therapists acting on satanic-ritual-abuse panic",
"the wrongly accused (survivors of the miscarriage)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"satanic-ritual-abuse panic ideology",
"coercive/suggestive child-interview techniques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California courts (Kern County; appellate reversals)",
"stage": "most convictions overturned on appeal",
"date": "2004-01-01",
"outcome": "At least three dozen people were convicted in a series of 'sex-ring' prosecutions after social workers trained on the discredited book 'Michelle Remembers' elicited satanic-ritual-abuse allegations from children through coercive interviews. Most of the convictions were later overturned on appeal; John Stoll served 19 years before his sentence was vacated in 2004 when accusers recanted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "County investigators explicitly used satanic-ritual-abuse training material to interpret children's statements, structuring interrogations to elicit ritual-abuse narratives with no physical corroboration.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://reason.com/2009/12/21/kern-countys-monstrous-da/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kern County's Monstrous D.A.', Reason (2009).",
"body": "Investigative account of the Kern County ritual-abuse prosecutions, the use of 'Michelle Remembers' training, and the wave of appellate reversals.",
"tier": "investigative-reporting",
"kind": "historical-case-review"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "2004-01-01",
"note": "~34 of 36+ convictions overturned; John Stoll's 40-year sentence vacated in 2004 after recantations."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://reason.com/2009/12/21/kern-countys-monstrous-da/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: investigative-reporting; evidentiary role: historical-case-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8d9710a4f541f4a2ac95f38e86b403faabb20bfd20d1f6ac0532199775dd2e70",
"final_url": "https://reason.com/2009/12/21/kern-countys-monstrous-da/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 244,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1998-01-01",
"note": "18 of 28 convictions overturned or reduced; civil damages paid to the wrongly accused."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a WRONGFUL accusation/prosecution driven by satanic-ritual-abuse panic. The accused are recorded as SURVIVORS of the miscarriage of justice, not as perpetrators; the record does not imply their guilt. Child witnesses whose testimony was found unreliable are not identified. Disposition: 18 of 28 convictions overturned/reduced; civil settlements paid.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1995-wenatchee-child-abuse-panic-washington-usa",
"year": 1995,
"place": "Wenatchee, Washington, USA",
"lat": 47.4235,
"lng": -120.3103,
"title": "Wenatchee 'sex ring': mass arrests on tens of thousands of charges, most convictions later overturned",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecutors, investigators and therapists acting on satanic-ritual-abuse panic",
"the wrongly accused (survivors of the miscarriage)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"satanic-ritual-abuse panic ideology",
"coercive/suggestive child-interview techniques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Washington courts (Chelan/Douglas Counties; appellate reversals)",
"stage": "18 of 28 convictions overturned/reduced; civil settlements paid",
"date": "1998-01-01",
"outcome": "A detective-led investigation resulted in 43 adults arrested on nearly 30,000 child-sex-abuse charges based on coerced confessions and coached child testimony, without recordings or contemporaneous notes. An appeals court found improper techniques were used; of 28 convicted, 18 had verdicts overturned or reduced, and the county paid civil settlements to those wrongly accused."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Investigators used the suggestive-interview and mass-allegation methodology of the day-care/ritual-abuse panic to manufacture a sprawling, evidence-free 'sex ring' narrative.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.historylink.org/File/7065",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Wenatchee Witch Hunt: Child Sex Abuse Trials in Douglas and Chelan Counties', HistoryLink.org.",
"body": "A documented account of the Wenatchee prosecutions, the improper interview techniques, and the overturned convictions and settlements.",
"tier": "institutional-archive",
"kind": "historical-case-review"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1998-01-01",
"note": "18 of 28 convictions overturned or reduced; civil damages paid to the wrongly accused."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.historylink.org/File/7065",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-archive; evidentiary role: historical-case-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f28514dab0e109cb610833fe73611b9f285fc1ab4db906f65b8324ee298612aa",
"final_url": "https://www.historylink.org/File/7065"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 245,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1997-01-01",
"note": "All convictions reversed (Court of Appeals, 1995); all remaining charges dismissed by 1997."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a WRONGFUL accusation/prosecution driven by satanic-ritual-abuse panic. The accused are recorded as SURVIVORS of the miscarriage of justice, not as perpetrators; the record does not imply their guilt. Child witnesses whose testimony was found unreliable are not identified. Disposition: all convictions overturned; all charges dismissed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1997-little-rascals-day-care-panic-edenton-nc-usa",
"year": 1997,
"place": "Edenton, North Carolina, USA",
"lat": 36.0574,
"lng": -76.6086,
"title": "Little Rascals Day Care: all convictions vacated after satanic-ritual-abuse allegations",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecutors, investigators and therapists acting on satanic-ritual-abuse panic",
"the wrongly accused (survivors of the miscarriage)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"satanic-ritual-abuse panic ideology",
"coercive/suggestive child-interview techniques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "North Carolina Court of Appeals",
"stage": "all convictions overturned; all charges dismissed",
"date": "1997-01-01",
"outcome": "Owner-operators and staff were charged after children, following extensive therapy, made escalating and physically impossible allegations including satanic-ritual-abuse elements. Bob Kelly was convicted on 99 of 100 counts and sentenced to twelve life terms, but the North Carolina Court of Appeals reversed all convictions in 1995, and by 1997 all remaining charges against every defendant had been dismissed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Day-care sex-abuse hysteria, explicitly including satanic-ritual-abuse allegations, drove repeated suggestive therapy sessions that produced fantastical, uncorroborated claims courts and scholars later recognized as a moral panic.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://time.com/archive/6930249/little-rascals-charges-dropped/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Little Rascals Charges Dropped', TIME (1997).",
"body": "Reports the dismissal of all remaining charges after the appellate reversal of the satanic-ritual-abuse convictions.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1997-01-01",
"note": "All convictions reversed (Court of Appeals, 1995); all remaining charges dismissed by 1997."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://time.com/archive/6930249/little-rascals-charges-dropped/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2a40458d7b7156bb0d0ade423c6b9280d15b584479ec49e9eb6dff836b220120",
"final_url": "https://time.com/archive/6930249/little-rascals-charges-dropped/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 246,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1992-10-01",
"note": "Clyde Inquiry report (Oct. 1992) found the ritual-abuse removals fundamentally flawed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a WRONGFUL accusation/prosecution driven by satanic-ritual-abuse panic. The accused are recorded as SURVIVORS of the miscarriage of justice, not as perpetrators; the record does not imply their guilt. Child witnesses whose testimony was found unreliable are not identified. Disposition: case dismissed; children returned; official inquiry found wrongful state action.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1991-orkney-satanic-abuse-inquiry-scotland-uk",
"year": 1991,
"place": "South Ronaldsay, Orkney, Scotland, UK",
"lat": 58.8,
"lng": -2.95,
"title": "Orkney child-abuse scandal: official inquiry finds the satanic-abuse removals fundamentally flawed",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecutors, investigators and therapists acting on satanic-ritual-abuse panic",
"the wrongly accused (survivors of the miscarriage)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"satanic-ritual-abuse panic ideology",
"coercive/suggestive child-interview techniques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sheriff Court, Scotland; Clyde Inquiry (official)",
"stage": "case dismissed; children returned; official inquiry found wrongful state action",
"date": "1992-10-01",
"outcome": "In February 1991, social workers and police removed nine children from four South Ronaldsay families on allegations of organised Satanic abuse. A sheriff dismissed the case as fundamentally flawed, and the official Clyde Inquiry (1992) found the concept of 'ritual abuse' unwarranted, sharply criticised the authorities, noted no medical evidence of abuse, and the children were returned home."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Social workers acted on unvalidated 'satanic ritual abuse indicators' imported from the US panic, structuring the seizure of nine children around an unsubstantiated ritual-abuse theory the official inquiry later found had no evidentiary basis.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.crfr.ac.uk/the-legacy-of-orkney-for-child-protection-2/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'The Legacy of Orkney for Child Protection', Centre for Research on Families and Relationships (summarizing the Clyde Inquiry, 1992).",
"body": "Academic account of the Clyde Inquiry's findings that the satanic-ritual-abuse theory driving the Orkney removals had no evidentiary basis.",
"tier": "academic-monograph",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1992-10-01",
"note": "Clyde Inquiry report (Oct. 1992) found the ritual-abuse removals fundamentally flawed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.crfr.ac.uk/the-legacy-of-orkney-for-child-protection-2/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: academic-monograph; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e544c74d4f84de14f0ae6dc1dad6af9a59fe2003ad13266dcfcfe45b61e2e16f",
"final_url": "https://www.crfr.ac.uk/the-legacy-of-orkney-for-child-protection-2/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 247,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1994-01-01",
"note": "La Fontaine inquiry (1994) found organised satanic abuse a myth and the removal 'indicators' invalid."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a WRONGFUL accusation/prosecution driven by satanic-ritual-abuse panic. The accused are recorded as SURVIVORS of the miscarriage of justice, not as perpetrators; the record does not imply their guilt. Child witnesses whose testimony was found unreliable are not identified. Disposition: children returned; official inquiry found allegations baseless.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-rochdale-satanic-abuse-inquiry-england-uk",
"year": 1990,
"place": "Rochdale, Greater Manchester, England, UK",
"lat": 53.6097,
"lng": -2.1561,
"title": "Rochdale satanic-abuse case: government-commissioned inquiry finds organised satanic abuse a 'myth'",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecutors, investigators and therapists acting on satanic-ritual-abuse panic",
"the wrongly accused (survivors of the miscarriage)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"satanic-ritual-abuse panic ideology",
"coercive/suggestive child-interview techniques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "UK courts; La Fontaine Inquiry (government-commissioned)",
"stage": "children returned; official inquiry found allegations baseless",
"date": "1994-01-01",
"outcome": "Rochdale social services removed about 20 children from six families in 1990 after a child's dream imagery was interpreted, by social workers primed by US cases, as evidence of a satanic sex-abuse ring; the children were released in 1991 after a court found the investigation flawed. A subsequent government-commissioned inquiry led by Professor Jean La Fontaine concluded organised satanic abuse was a myth, finding no evidence to substantiate any of 84 such allegations examined nationally."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Social workers applied unvalidated 'satanic indicators' imported from the American panic to ordinary child statements, triggering mass removals that both a court and a formal government-commissioned inquiry found had no factual basis.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://www.socialwork.ed.ac.uk/centenary/timeline/events/rochdale_child_abuse_case_and_inquiry",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Rochdale child abuse case and inquiry', Social Work Centenary (University of Edinburgh).",
"body": "Academic timeline of the Rochdale removals and the La Fontaine inquiry's finding that organised satanic abuse was unsubstantiated.",
"tier": "academic-monograph",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "1994-01-01",
"note": "La Fontaine inquiry (1994) found organised satanic abuse a myth and the removal 'indicators' invalid."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://www.socialwork.ed.ac.uk/centenary/timeline/events/rochdale_child_abuse_case_and_inquiry",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: academic-monograph; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 248,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "2016-11-01",
"note": "Formally exonerated November 2016; eligible for state wrongful-conviction compensation."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a WRONGFUL accusation/prosecution driven by satanic-ritual-abuse panic. The accused are recorded as SURVIVORS of the miscarriage of justice, not as perpetrators; the record does not imply their guilt. Child witnesses whose testimony was found unreliable are not identified. Disposition: convictions vacated; formally exonerated (2016).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-san-antonio-four-exoneration-texas-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "San Antonio, Texas, USA",
"lat": 29.4241,
"lng": -98.4936,
"title": "San Antonio Four: four women exonerated after a 'satanic ritual' junk-science conviction",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecutors, investigators and therapists acting on satanic-ritual-abuse panic",
"the wrongly accused (survivors of the miscarriage)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"satanic-ritual-abuse panic ideology",
"coercive/suggestive child-interview techniques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Texas courts (habeas corpus; exoneration)",
"stage": "convictions vacated; formally exonerated (2016)",
"date": "2016-11-01",
"outcome": "Elizabeth Ramirez, Cassandra Rivera, Kristie Mayhugh, and Anna Vasquez were convicted in the 1990s after a prosecution expert testified that the accusers' injuries were consistent with 'satanic ritual' abuse she claimed was common among lesbians — testimony she later retracted as based on discredited science. All four were released by 2013 and formally exonerated by a Texas court in November 2016."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Satanic-panic-era junk science, fused with anti-gay prejudice, produced expert medical testimony falsely linking physical findings to 'satanic ritual' practices, directly manufacturing the wrongful conviction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/judge-clears-records-wrongfully-convicted-san-antonio-four-n943751",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Judge clears records of wrongfully convicted San Antonio Four', NBC News (Nov. 2016).",
"body": "Reports the formal exoneration of the four women after the 'satanic ritual' expert testimony was retracted as junk science.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "2016-11-01",
"note": "Formally exonerated November 2016; eligible for state wrongful-conviction compensation."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/judge-clears-records-wrongfully-convicted-san-antonio-four-n943751",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bc9d863d060ef0880d55067ab3e9e7f544cc880754e1d267bf25729e60561a2f",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/judge-clears-records-wrongfully-convicted-san-antonio-four-n943751"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 249,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "2017-06-01",
"note": "Travis County DA's Declaration of Actual Innocence (2017); $3.4 million state compensation."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents a WRONGFUL accusation/prosecution driven by satanic-ritual-abuse panic. The accused are recorded as SURVIVORS of the miscarriage of justice, not as perpetrators; the record does not imply their guilt. Child witnesses whose testimony was found unreliable are not identified. Disposition: charges dismissed; declared actually innocent (2017); $3.4M compensation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-oak-hill-keller-satanic-panic-austin-texas-usa",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Oak Hill, Austin, Texas, USA",
"lat": 30.2412,
"lng": -97.86,
"title": "Oak Hill (Keller) case: day-care operators declared actually innocent after a satanic-ritual-abuse conviction",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "intervention",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"prosecutors, investigators and therapists acting on satanic-ritual-abuse panic",
"the wrongly accused (survivors of the miscarriage)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"satanic-ritual-abuse panic ideology",
"coercive/suggestive child-interview techniques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Travis County / Texas courts (Declaration of Actual Innocence)",
"stage": "charges dismissed; declared actually innocent (2017); $3.4M compensation",
"date": "2017-06-01",
"outcome": "Fran and Dan Keller were convicted in 1992 of sexually abusing a child based on escalating, physically impossible satanic-ritual-abuse allegations elicited via suggestive questioning, and sentenced to 48 years. They were released in 2013 after their medical expert recanted and prosecutorial nondisclosure emerged; in 2017 the Travis County District Attorney declared them actually innocent, dismissed all charges, and the state paid $3.4 million in compensation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A therapist and prosecution expert built the case explicitly around satanic-ritual-abuse theory, eliciting fantastical child allegations with no physical corroboration that a later actual-innocence review found had no evidentiary basis.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/texas-couple-cleared-of-satanic-abuse-claims-to-get-3-4-million/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Texas couple cleared of satanic abuse claims to get $3.4 million', CBS News (2017).",
"body": "Reports the Kellers' declaration of actual innocence and $3.4 million compensation after the satanic-ritual-abuse conviction was found baseless.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "disposition",
"date": "2017-06-01",
"note": "Travis County DA's Declaration of Actual Innocence (2017); $3.4 million state compensation."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/texas-couple-cleared-of-satanic-abuse-claims-to-get-3-4-million/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "225a0f314a69a67d423d119510d96a8bf59959e3744512ebda8b7fa511909272",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/texas-couple-cleared-of-satanic-abuse-claims-to-get-3-4-million/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 250,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2026",
"note": "Conviction upheld by the Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Canarias and the Tribunal Supremo."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from the earlier Gran Canaria Santería record (a 2024 child-assault case) — this is a 2026 fraud conviction with a different defendant and facts. The record concerns the named padrino's operative use of ritual authority for fraud; it does not characterize Santería or its practitioners generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-yoruba-padrino-coronacion-fraud-gran-canaria-spain",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Gran Canaria, Las Palmas, Spain",
"lat": 28.1235,
"lng": -15.4363,
"title": "Gran Canaria: Yoruba/Santería 'padrino' convicted of fraud for a coerced 'coronación' initiation payment",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"spiritual godfather (padrino) in the Yoruba/Santería tradition"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual authority over an initiate",
"threat of death unless a required 'coronación' initiation was paid for"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"spiritual-consequence",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Audiencia Provincial de Las Palmas; upheld by the Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Canarias and the Tribunal Supremo",
"stage": "conviction affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2026-06-16",
"outcome": "A man acting as a spiritual godfather (padrino) was convicted of defrauding a Cuban goddaughter of 11,000 euros by telling her the money was required to be 'crowned' (initiated) in Cuba or she would die. The conviction was upheld by the Superior Court of Justice of the Canary Islands and the Supreme Court."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court found the fraud operated specifically through the padrino's position of religious/spiritual superiority: he leveraged the initiate's genuine belief in the required 'coronación' initiation and in death-curse consequences to extract the payment.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.canarias7.es/canarias/gran-canaria/las-palmas-de-gran-canaria/aseguro-moriria-coronaba-cuba-quedo-11000-euros-20260616073000-nt.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Le aseguró que moriría si no se \"coronaba\" en Cuba y se quedó con sus 11.000 euros: condenado un padrino yoruba en Gran Canaria', Canarias7, 16 June 2026.",
"body": "Canarias7 reports the conviction, upheld to the Supreme Court, of the padrino who used the coronación initiation requirement and a death threat to defraud his goddaughter of 11,000 euros.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-affirmance-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.periodicocubano.com/condenan-en-espana-a-padrino-yoruba-por-robar-11-000-euros-a-una-cubana/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan en España a padrino yoruba por robar 11.000 euros a una cubana', Periódico Cubano, 2026.",
"body": "Corroborates the conviction and the coronación-initiation fraud mechanism.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2026",
"note": "Conviction upheld by the Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Canarias and the Tribunal Supremo."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.canarias7.es/canarias/gran-canaria/las-palmas-de-gran-canaria/aseguro-moriria-coronaba-cuba-quedo-11000-euros-20260616073000-nt.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-affirmance-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24a839c281ce7ce407d4253912fefd835f2f4a1f3e8ab7001996ecd6dd66b93a",
"final_url": "https://www.canarias7.es/canarias/gran-canaria/las-palmas-de-gran-canaria/aseguro-moriria-coronaba-cuba-quedo-11000-euros-20260616073000-nt.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.periodicocubano.com/condenan-en-espana-a-padrino-yoruba-por-robar-11-000-euros-a-una-cubana/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "15330f54abb31ca591b574d33f332cecae18b808f1292787cb0345bbc310585d",
"final_url": "https://www.periodicocubano.com/condenan-en-espana-a-padrino-yoruba-por-robar-11-000-euros-a-una-cubana/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 251,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charges are allegations pending adjudication; the defendants had not accepted charges at the time of reporting. Single-source (Fiscalía via Infobae). The record concerns the named proceeding and does not characterize santería practitioners generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-santeria-extortion-espiritista-sessions-ibague-colombia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ibagué, Tolima, Colombia",
"lat": 4.4389,
"lng": -75.2322,
"title": "Ibagué: santería practitioners charged with extorting clients using disclosures from spiritist sessions",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"practitioners offering santería and esoteric ritual services"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritist consultation staged to elicit intimate disclosures",
"blackmail under threat of public exposure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fiscalía General de la Nación (GAULA-Tolima), Colombia",
"stage": "charges — extortion",
"date": "2024-05-29",
"outcome": "Three people who recruited clients via social media offering santería and esoteric services were charged with extortion after using private information disclosed during 'sesiones espiritistas' to blackmail clients for 5–13 million pesos under threat of public exposure. The charges are allegations pending adjudication."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The ritual consultation itself was the extraction mechanism: the spiritist session was staged specifically to elicit confidential and intimate disclosures that were later weaponized for extortion, rather than being an incidental setting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2024/05/29/judicializados-supuestos-brujos-que-extorsionaban-a-sus-clientes-por-golpe-cobraban-entre-5-y-13-millones-de-pesos/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Judicializados supuestos \"brujos\" que extorsionaban a sus clientes', Infobae Colombia (citing the Fiscalía / GAULA-Tolima), 29 May 2024.",
"body": "Infobae, citing the prosecutor, reports the extortion charges and the use of staged spiritist sessions to obtain the material used to blackmail clients.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Three people who recruited clients via social media offering santería and esoteric services were charged with extortion after using private information disclosed during 'sesiones espiritistas' to blackmail clients for 5–13 million pesos under threat of public exposure. The charges are allegations pending adjudication.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2024/05/29/judicializados-supuestos-brujos-que-extorsionaban-a-sus-clientes-por-golpe-cobraban-entre-5-y-13-millones-de-pesos/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ade4cd2a2659ed2fd2ae0677bd376139f1a44709a3a9c6449a2045bf576e8183",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2024/05/29/judicializados-supuestos-brujos-que-extorsionaban-a-sus-clientes-por-golpe-cobraban-entre-5-y-13-millones-de-pesos/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 252,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Documented via contemporaneous reporting and the organization's own disclosure to its membership; no criminal or civil adjudication was identified. Records the institutional/authority mechanism, not a court finding. Does not characterize Buddhism or Vajrayana practitioners generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1989-osel-tendzin-vajradhatu-hiv-transmission-usa",
"year": 1989,
"place": "Boulder, Colorado, USA",
"lat": 40.015,
"lng": -105.2705,
"title": "Ösel Tendzin (Vajra Regent): knowing HIV transmission to students within Vajradhatu",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Vajra Regent and appointed lineage successor",
"organizational leadership that concealed the risk"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru-devotion and samaya obligations preventing refusal",
"concealment of HIV status by leadership"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Vajradhatu (Shambhala)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Vajradhatu organizational disclosure (United States)",
"stage": "organizational admission",
"date": "1989-04-01",
"outcome": "Ösel Tendzin, Chögyam Trungpa's appointed successor and Vajra Regent, tested HIV-positive around 1985 but continued unprotected sexual contact with students for roughly three years without disclosure, with the knowledge of board members who did not intervene. At least one student was infected. The scandal became public in 1989; Tendzin died of AIDS in 1990. No criminal charges were identified."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As Trungpa's designated Vajra Regent and lineage holder, Tendzin's sexual access to students was structured through guru-devotion; students' inability to refuse or question a root teacher's advances, reinforced by samaya obligations, is documented as the mechanism that enabled both the exposure and its concealment by leadership.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/1989/04/08/us-buddhists-stunned-by-aids-scandal/6e808956-e4b5-4e06-b24c-e4140702702c/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'U.S. Buddhists Stunned by AIDS Scandal', The Washington Post, 8 April 1989.",
"body": "The Washington Post documents that Tendzin knowingly exposed students to HIV over roughly three years with leadership's knowledge.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-context"
},
{
"link": "https://tricycle.org/trikedaily/encounter-shadow-buddhist-america/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Encountering the Shadow in Buddhist America', Tricycle.",
"body": "Corroborates the scandal and the guru-devotion dynamics that enabled it.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "authority-and-belief-context"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/1989/04/08/us-buddhists-stunned-by-aids-scandal/6e808956-e4b5-4e06-b24c-e4140702702c/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://tricycle.org/trikedaily/encounter-shadow-buddhist-america/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: authority-and-belief-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d5a688da5eed403c54b31030e52d28323a929d6a421304389be0143b6494ae98",
"final_url": "https://tricycle.org/article/encounter-shadow-buddhist-america/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 253,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An official finding by a commissioned institutional investigation (the Rigpa/Shambhala model). A 2019 criminal complaint was filed in India; its disposition is unconfirmed and is not asserted here. Does not characterize Buddhism generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-dagri-rinpoche-fpmt-misconduct-finding-india",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh, India",
"lat": 32.219,
"lng": 76.3234,
"title": "Dagri Rinpoche: commissioned investigation finds a pattern of sexual misconduct; barred by FPMT",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior Gelug incarnate lama and teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority and trust as an incarnate lama providing unsupervised access to students"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Foundation for the Preservation of the Mahayana Tradition (FPMT)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "FPMT / FaithTrust Institute (commissioned investigation)",
"stage": "official finding of misconduct",
"date": "2020-11-01",
"outcome": "After three women accused Dagri Rinpoche of sexual misconduct in 2019, FPMT commissioned FaithTrust Institute to investigate. In November 2020 it concluded, on a preponderance-of-evidence standard, that he 'engaged in a pattern of intentional and inappropriate sexual behaviour that persisted over many years'; FPMT permanently barred him from teaching at its centers."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The investigation found the pattern of misconduct was enabled specifically by Dagri Rinpoche's position as a trusted incarnate lama, which gave him unsupervised access to and authority over female students and discouraged reporting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://fpmt.org/fpmt/announcements/updates-regarding-dagri-rinpoche/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Conclusion of Fact-Finding Assessment Regarding Dagri Rinpoche', FPMT (Nov. 2020).",
"body": "FPMT publishes the FaithTrust Institute finding that Dagri Rinpoche engaged in a years-long pattern of sexual misconduct, and his permanent bar from teaching.",
"tier": "organization-commissioned-investigation",
"kind": "institutional-inquiry-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lionsroar.com/dagri-rinpoche-found-to-have-committed-sexual-misconduct-fpmt-states/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Dagri Rinpoche found to have committed sexual misconduct, FPMT states', Lion's Roar (2020).",
"body": "Corroborates the finding and the bar.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://fpmt.org/fpmt/announcements/updates-regarding-dagri-rinpoche/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: organization-commissioned-investigation; evidentiary role: institutional-inquiry-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "608d7ad331604a3e2791c1703205a10f04184864679437d3a25a29593b5be83c",
"final_url": "https://fpmt.org/fpmt/announcements/updates-regarding-dagri-rinpoche/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lionsroar.com/dagri-rinpoche-found-to-have-committed-sexual-misconduct-fpmt-states/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "359c39466aee03c3afb0b9408c1f79443a95470ff489e902a972e4a9deea0850",
"final_url": "https://www.lionsroar.com/dagri-rinpoche-found-to-have-committed-sexual-misconduct-fpmt-states/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 254,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The 2017 institutional disclosure is an admission; the 2023 federal lawsuit's allegations are pending adjudication (charged status). Lama Norlha died in 2018, so the suit targets the institution and successors. Does not characterize Buddhism generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-lama-norlha-kagyu-thubten-choling-abuse-new-york-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Wappingers Falls, New York, USA",
"lat": 41.5959,
"lng": -73.9109,
"title": "Lama Norlha Rinpoche / Kagyu Thubten Choling: sangha disclosure and federal abuse lawsuit",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"founding abbot and incarnate lama of a Karma Kagyu monastery"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority over students in prolonged retreats",
"guru-dependency preventing disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Kagyu Thubten Choling"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York",
"stage": "civil suit filed (Trafficking Victims Protection Act; NY Adult Survivors Act)",
"date": "2023-11-17",
"outcome": "Lama Norlha Rinpoche, founding abbot of Kagyu Thubten Choling, was found by a 2017 sangha-wide disclosure (facilitated by An Olive Branch) to have been sexually involved with multiple female students over decades. In November 2023 three women sued the monastery and named officials in the Southern District of New York under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act and New York's Adult Survivors Act. Norlha died in 2018."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Norlha used his position and authority as founding abbot and incarnate lama over students in multi-year retreats, where guru-devotion and dependence on the teacher for retreat guidance are documented as preventing resistance or disclosure for decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.buddhistdoor.net/news/lawsuit-alleges-decades-of-sexual-assault-at-tibetan-buddhist-monastery-in-new-york/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Lawsuit Alleges Decades of Sexual Assault at Tibetan Buddhist Monastery in New York', Buddhistdoor Global, 17 Nov. 2023.",
"body": "Reports the SDNY federal lawsuit under the TVPA and Adult Survivors Act over decades of alleged abuse at Kagyu Thubten Choling.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lionsroar.com/kagyu-thubten-choling-addresses-sangha-about-lama-norhla-rinpoches-sexual-misconduct-with-students/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kagyu Thubten Choling addresses sangha about Lama Norlha Rinpoche's sexual misconduct with students', Lion's Roar (2017).",
"body": "Documents the 2017 sangha-wide disclosure of Norlha's sexual misconduct with students.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-acknowledgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Lama Norlha Rinpoche, founding abbot of Kagyu Thubten Choling, was found by a 2017 sangha-wide disclosure (facilitated by An Olive Branch) to have been sexually involved with multiple female students over decades. In November 2023 three women sued the monastery and named officials in the Southern District of New York under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act and New York's Adult Survivors Act. Norlha died in 2018.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.buddhistdoor.net/news/lawsuit-alleges-decades-of-sexual-assault-at-tibetan-buddhist-monastery-in-new-york/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.lionsroar.com/kagyu-thubten-choling-addresses-sangha-about-lama-norhla-rinpoches-sexual-misconduct-with-students/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-acknowledgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d2bc13d127d67308fb07d47836fcf6271fc2641c6c9038df4b0eaf9459a9593b",
"final_url": "https://www.lionsroar.com/kagyu-thubten-choling-addresses-sangha-about-lama-norhla-rinpoches-sexual-misconduct-with-students/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 255,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charges are allegations pending adjudication; the disposition was not confirmed in available reporting. The record concerns the operative use of a purported Santería ritual for the alleged crimes and does not characterize Santería or its practitioners generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-christian-robles-santeria-healing-abuse-bronx-new-york-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Bronx, New York, USA",
"lat": 40.8448,
"lng": -73.8648,
"title": "Bronx: man charged with drugging and sexually abusing clients during purported Santería 'healing' rituals",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"man operating a purported Santería spiritual-healing practice"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"incapacitating potion given as part of a 'healing' rite",
"staged ritual used to isolate and assault clients"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bronx, New York (NYPD arrest and charges)",
"stage": "arrest and charges",
"date": "2018-05-09",
"outcome": "Christian Robles, who ran a purported Santería spiritual-healing practice from his Bronx apartment, was arrested and charged in May 2018 after five clients alleged he had them drink an incapacitating potion during ritual sessions and then sexually abused them; one pregnant complainant alleged he stood on her during a 'ritual,' causing a miscarriage. The charges are allegations pending adjudication."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The staged 'healing' ritual — including a spirit-possession claim and an incapacitating potion given as part of the rite — was the direct mechanism used to isolate, drug, and assault the clients, rather than incidental religious affiliation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cops-spiritual-healer-accused-of-sex-abuse-walked-on-pregnant-womans-stomach/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cops: \"Spiritual healer\" accused of sex abuse walked on pregnant woman's stomach', CBS News (May 2018).",
"body": "CBS reports the NYPD charges alleging Robles drugged clients with a potion during Santería 'healing' sessions and sexually abused them.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Christian Robles, who ran a purported Santería spiritual-healing practice from his Bronx apartment, was arrested and charged in May 2018 after five clients alleged he had them drink an incapacitating potion during ritual sessions and then sexually abused them; one pregnant complainant alleged he stood on her during a 'ritual,' causing a miscarriage. The charges are allegations pending adjudication.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cops-spiritual-healer-accused-of-sex-abuse-walked-on-pregnant-womans-stomach/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ff323be2ed79c84625d252059407e2513007a8105956a40ff7fd68b8c9e127f0",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cops-spiritual-healer-accused-of-sex-abuse-walked-on-pregnant-womans-stomach/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 256,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "A single-victim ritual killing prosecuted (and convicted) as human trafficking under Uganda's statutory definition of human sacrifice as exploitation. The deceased child is referenced only by the fact and age. Does not attribute conduct to Pentecostal Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-pastor-sserubiri-child-ritual-sacrifice-trafficking-jinja-uganda",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Jinja, Uganda",
"lat": 0.4244,
"lng": 33.2041,
"title": "Uganda: Pentecostal pastor convicted of child ritual sacrifice and human trafficking",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Pentecostal pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual instruction to sacrifice a child for church wealth/power",
"abduction for ritual purposes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jinja High Court, Uganda",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-08-01",
"outcome": "Pentecostal pastor Joseph Sserubiri lured a 4-year-old girl from her home and ritually killed her, claiming a spiritual instruction to sacrifice a child to expand his church's wealth and power. The Jinja High Court convicted him of murder and human trafficking (human sacrifice is statutorily classed as trafficking exploitation under Uganda's 2009 Act) and sentenced him to life plus 30 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The pastor invoked a claimed spiritual instruction (a dream from his 'spiritual father') to organize the abduction and ritual killing of a child for the purpose of increasing his church's wealth and power; Ugandan law classifies human sacrifice as trafficking exploitation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/pastor-jailed-for-life-over-child-sacrifice-4323866",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor jailed for life over child sacrifice', Daily Monitor (Uganda), Aug. 2023.",
"body": "The Daily Monitor reports the Jinja High Court's conviction of pastor Sserubiri for murder and human trafficking and the life-plus-30-years sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://religionunplugged.com/news/2023/8/27/ritual-sacrifice-uganda-pastor-joseph-sserubiri-convicted-of-murder-and-human-trafficking",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor's Conviction Highlights Uganda's Growing Problem Of Ritual Sacrifice', Religion Unplugged, 27 Aug. 2023.",
"body": "Corroborates the conviction and the ritual-sacrifice motive.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/pastor-jailed-for-life-over-child-sacrifice-4323866",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "97e3cf4436d960067b1f6cd5b2119e4fa7e95576c8b2c204eab65988a8c51d32",
"final_url": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/pastor-jailed-for-life-over-child-sacrifice-4323866"
},
{
"source": "https://religionunplugged.com/news/2023/8/27/ritual-sacrifice-uganda-pastor-joseph-sserubiri-convicted-of-murder-and-human-trafficking",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "614b57bc9ee881eb5ec5479fe3cb798d2af826f92f566fceafb735f631423ff8",
"final_url": "https://religionunplugged.com/news/2023/8/27/ritual-sacrifice-uganda-pastor-joseph-sserubiri-convicted-of-murder-and-human-trafficking"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 257,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The investigating NGO (International Justice Mission) is a party and is treated as corroboration, not source-of-record; the conviction and sentence are reported across independent press. The full defendant name is not public (religious title only). Minor victims are not identified. Does not characterize Buddhism or its clergy generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-thai-monk-pra-chai-temple-trafficking-thailand",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Thailand",
"lat": 15.87,
"lng": 100.9925,
"title": "Thailand: Buddhist monk convicted as ringleader of a temple-based trafficking ring targeting novice boys",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Buddhist monk using monastic and novice-guardianship authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"recruitment of temple novices under religious guardianship",
"gifts and money to ensure silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Thai courts (International Justice Mission-supported investigation)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2015-03-16",
"outcome": "A Buddhist monk known as 'Pra Chai' used his temple position to procure and traffic teenage boys (15-17), including novices from struggling families, exploiting them sexually while using gifts and money to ensure silence. He pleaded guilty to human trafficking and exploitation of minors and was sentenced to 124 years, capped at 50 years under Thai law — the sixth monk convicted in the investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Monastic authority and the temple/novice-training structure were the organizing mechanism: victims were recruited as temple novices under religious guardianship, giving the trafficker custodial and spiritual authority used to procure and silence them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.buddhistdoor.net/news/alarm-bells-sounded-over-child-abuse-in-thailands-buddhist-temples/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Alarm Bells Sounded Over Child Abuse in Thailand's Buddhist Temples', Buddhistdoor Global (2015).",
"body": "Reports the conviction of the monk trafficking-ring leader and the pattern of temple-based abuse of novices in Thailand.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.buddhistdoor.net/news/alarm-bells-sounded-over-child-abuse-in-thailands-buddhist-temples/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 258,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An official civil action by a government labor prosecutor (charged); the final court ruling was not located and the outcome is unverified. Does not characterize evangelical Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-word-of-faith-rhema-forced-labor-sao-paulo-brazil",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Franco da Rocha, São Paulo, Brazil",
"lat": -23.3286,
"lng": -46.7267,
"title": "Brazil: labor prosecutors sue a Word of Faith Fellowship-linked church for forced labor of congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastors using deliverance/spiritual-control doctrine",
"affiliated church leadership (Word of Faith Fellowship, US)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"psychological coercion to override congregants' free will",
"unpaid labor framed through 'spiritual seminars'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Ministério Evangélico Comunidade Rhema",
"Word of Faith Fellowship (US affiliate)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ministério Público do Trabalho (Public Labor Prosecutor's Office), 2ª Região (São Paulo), Brazil",
"stage": "civil action filed by government labor prosecutor",
"date": "2018-01-01",
"outcome": "Brazil's Public Labor Prosecutor's Office filed a civil action (case no. 1000125-39.2018.5.02.0292) against Ministério Evangélico Comunidade Rhema and its school, alleging pastors used psychological coercion to nullify congregants' free will, compelling unpaid labor and funneling young members to the US as unpaid laborers under the guise of 'Spiritual Seminars' run by Word of Faith Fellowship. The prosecutor sought dissolution of the church/school and damages."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Pastoral spiritual authority and a 'deliverance'/demon-purging control doctrine were used to override congregants' free will and self-determination, which the labor prosecutor cited as the coercive mechanism constituting labor analogous to slavery.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.prt2.mpt.mp.br/542-igreja-e-processada-por-exploracao-de-mao-de-obra-de-fieis",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Igreja é processada por exploração de mão de obra de fiéis', Ministério Público do Trabalho, 2ª Região (2018).",
"body": "The Brazilian labor prosecutor's office documents its civil action alleging the church used spiritual coercion to compel unpaid labor.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://wlos.com/news/local/brazilian-prosecutors-sue-to-shut-church-over-forced-labor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Brazilian prosecutors sue to shut church over forced labor', WLOS (2018).",
"body": "Corroborates the Brazilian labor-prosecutor action against the Word of Faith Fellowship-linked church.",
"tier": "local-reporting",
"kind": "charging-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Brazil's Public Labor Prosecutor's Office filed a civil action (case no. 1000125-39.2018.5.02.0292) against Ministério Evangélico Comunidade Rhema and its school, alleging pastors used psychological coercion to nullify congregants' free will, compelling unpaid labor and funneling young members to the US as unpaid laborers under the guise of 'Spiritual Seminars' run by Word of Faith Fellowship. The prosecutor sought dissolution of the church/school and damages.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.prt2.mpt.mp.br/542-igreja-e-processada-por-exploracao-de-mao-de-obra-de-fieis",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ee0a2eb7b0619f77130203562e1d2b46998eab2737af10c6d494ea5570d33022",
"final_url": "https://www.prt2.mpt.mp.br/542-igreja-e-processada-por-exploracao-de-mao-de-obra-de-fieis"
},
{
"source": "https://wlos.com/news/local/brazilian-prosecutors-sue-to-shut-church-over-forced-labor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3376445a64e46d54bf377310c69cde43619895d4aa77fbdb2e76be9b4504b992",
"final_url": "https://wlos.com/news/local/brazilian-prosecutors-sue-to-shut-church-over-forced-labor"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 259,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "A systemic-practice finding (institutional-event), not a single adjudicated case; sources note a near-zero prosecution rate despite criminalization. Concerns the ritual-dedication mechanism specifically and does not characterize Hindus generally. Victims are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-devadasi-jogini-mathamma-ritual-slavery-india",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh, India",
"lat": 15.9129,
"lng": 79.74,
"title": "India: ritual dedication of girls (Devadasi/Jogini/Mathamma) feeding sexual exploitation",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"community and temple structures dedicating girls to a deity"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual 'marriage'/dedication of girls to a deity conferring standing sexual access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Anti-Slavery International report; cited in CEDAW review of India",
"stage": "official/institutional finding on a systemic practice",
"date": "2007-07-01",
"outcome": "Anti-Slavery International documented the dedication of girls (often Dalit) to a deity or temple (Devadasi/Jogini/Mathamma), after which they are sexually exploited by community men under religious sanction — a practice framed as ritual slavery. Despite a 1988 ban, enforcement is minimal (reportedly ~25 cases in the ban's first 20 years against an estimated tens of thousands of women in ritual bondage)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The temple/deity 'marriage' dedication is the organizing religious mechanism: girls are ritually bound to a deity, which the community treats as conferring standing sexual access, replacing ordinary trafficking recruitment with doctrinal/ritual sanction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.antislavery.org/reports/women-in-ritual-slavery-devadasi-jogini-and-mathamma-in-karnataka-and-andhra-pradesh-southern-india/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Women in Ritual Slavery: Devadasi, Jogini and Mathamma in Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh, Southern India', Anti-Slavery International (July 2007).",
"body": "Anti-Slavery International documents the ritual dedication of girls to deities/temples and their subsequent sexual exploitation under religious sanction.",
"tier": "specialist-monitoring",
"kind": "methodology-and-findings"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.antislavery.org/reports/women-in-ritual-slavery-devadasi-jogini-and-mathamma-in-karnataka-and-andhra-pradesh-southern-india/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-monitoring; evidentiary role: methodology-and-findings.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ec99ab2eb86d69779790f86a3b0f8ca1900f9bef7f65b521fd72d354cffe9a2a",
"final_url": "https://www.antislavery.org/reports/women-in-ritual-slavery-devadasi-jogini-and-mathamma-in-karnataka-and-andhra-pradesh-southern-india/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 260,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"sonagazi-islamia-fazil-madrasa"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"court": "High Court Division, Supreme Court of Bangladesh",
"date": "2026-06-27",
"outcome": "Trial-level convictions and death sentences remained under mandatory review and appeal."
}
],
"scopeNote": "These are trial-level convictions subject to mandatory High Court review and connected appeals; this record does not present the death sentences as final. Not all 16 defendants held religious or school authority. Their inclusion concerns the adjudicated conspiracy led from the principal's institutional position and does not imply shared clerical status. The record does not generalize culpability to Islam, madrasas or other school personnel.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-sonagazi-madrasa-retaliation-murder-bangladesh",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Feni, Bangladesh",
"lat": 23.0159,
"lng": 91.3976,
"title": "SM Siraj Ud Daula and co-defendants convicted at trial of retaliatory murder after a student's harassment complaint",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "retaliation",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"madrasa principal",
"institutional superior",
"religious-school administrator"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional authority",
"pressure to withdraw a sexual-harassment complaint",
"organized retaliation",
"use of school and local political networks"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Sonagazi Islamia Fazil Madrasa"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Women and Children Repression Prevention Tribunal, Feni, Bangladesh",
"stage": "trial judgment",
"date": "2019-10-24",
"outcome": "The tribunal convicted former principal SM Siraj Ud Daula and 15 co-defendants of the murder and imposed death sentences."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court Division, Supreme Court of Bangladesh",
"stage": "death-reference and appeals pending",
"date": "2026-06-27",
"outcome": "The mandatory death-reference review and connected appeals remained pending, with the case reported among delayed capital matters before the High Court."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The tribunal found that a madrasa principal helped organize the killing of a student after she reported that he had sexually harassed her and refused pressure to withdraw the complaint. His authority over the religious school and the network mobilized around that institution materially enabled the retaliation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/16-sentenced-to-death-in-Nusrat-murder-case",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Prothom Alo / UNB, '16 sentenced to death in Nusrat murder case' (Oct. 24, 2019).",
"body": "Contemporaneous tribunal reporting identifies the 16 convictions, the former principal, the complaint that preceded the attack and the court's sentence.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thedailystar.net/frontpage/news/brutal-murder-feni-madrasa-16-get-death-penalty-1818355",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Daily Star, 'Brutal murder in Feni madrasa: 16 get death penalty' (Oct. 25, 2019).",
"body": "Detailed court reporting records the tribunal's findings about the principal's role, the conspiracy, pressure to withdraw the complaint and the institutional setting.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-findings-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thedailystar.net/news/crime-justice/news/swift-trials-slow-appeals-death-penalty-cases-stall-high-court-4209441",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Daily Star, 'Swift trials, slow appeals: Death penalty cases stall at High Court' (June 27, 2026).",
"body": "The appellate-status report identifies the case among capital judgments whose mandatory death references and related appeals remained pending before the High Court.",
"tier": "reliable-current-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-status-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"court": "High Court Division, Supreme Court of Bangladesh",
"date": "2026-06-27",
"outcome": "Trial-level convictions and death sentences remained under mandatory review and appeal."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/16-sentenced-to-death-in-Nusrat-murder-case",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "915332d38ee1a53478ef7de789c36ad5d86bb7c36df11f9b77cba24f1b425050",
"final_url": "https://en.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/16-sentenced-to-death-in-Nusrat-murder-case"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thedailystar.net/frontpage/news/brutal-murder-feni-madrasa-16-get-death-penalty-1818355",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-findings-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cd11bbf093cafcf4a097544b41d8d9f833014cf6440c4fc6b686e9b3a1d191d3",
"final_url": "https://www.thedailystar.net/frontpage/news/brutal-murder-feni-madrasa-16-get-death-penalty-1818355"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thedailystar.net/news/crime-justice/news/swift-trials-slow-appeals-death-penalty-cases-stall-high-court-4209441",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-current-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-status-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1716f9f293f0774e731f36ed4554921d58d8f4feb33a6550a000c1afe6d07f20",
"final_url": "https://www.thedailystar.net/news/crime-justice/news/swift-trials-slow-appeals-death-penalty-cases-stall-high-court-4209441"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 261,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "civil",
"date": "2025-03-31",
"note": "Federal judge ruled against Hunt in his defamation suit against Guidepost and the SBC."
}
],
"scopeNote": "An official investigative finding, not a criminal conviction; no charge was filed. The victim is an adult and is not identified. Hunt denies the allegation; his defamation claim was rejected. Does not characterize Southern Baptists generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-johnny-hunt-guidepost-finding-sbc-georgia-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Woodstock, Georgia, USA",
"lat": 34.1015,
"lng": -84.5194,
"title": "Guidepost investigation finds credible sexual-assault allegation against former SBC president Johnny Hunt",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Southern Baptist Convention president and senior pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"senior pastoral authority over a subordinate pastor's family",
"grooming through promises of career advancement in ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Southern Baptist Convention",
"First Baptist Church Woodstock"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Guidepost Solutions independent investigation for the Southern Baptist Convention",
"stage": "official investigative finding",
"date": "2022-05-22",
"outcome": "Guidepost Solutions' independent investigation found credible an allegation that then-SBC president Johnny Hunt sexually assaulted the wife of a subordinate pastor in 2010, and stated investigators did not find Hunt's denials credible. Hunt's subsequent defamation suit against Guidepost and the SBC was rejected by a federal judge in March 2025. No criminal charge was filed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Hunt was the denomination's president and the couple's senior pastoral authority; the investigation found he groomed the couple with flattery and promises of ministry career help before the assault, using that pastoral standing to obtain access and isolation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://religionnews.com/2025/03/31/judge-rules-in-favor-of-guidepost-and-sbc-in-johnny-hunt-lawsuit/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Judge rules in favor of Guidepost and SBC in Johnny Hunt lawsuit', Religion News Service, 31 March 2025.",
"body": "RNS reports the federal court's rejection of Hunt's defamation suit and recounts the Guidepost finding that the assault allegation was credible.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "civil-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "civil",
"date": "2025-03-31",
"note": "Federal judge ruled against Hunt in his defamation suit against Guidepost and the SBC."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://religionnews.com/2025/03/31/judge-rules-in-favor-of-guidepost-and-sbc-in-johnny-hunt-lawsuit/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9aba1a01a6d93aa682606f1ff48bc9bac24b6da25ab0cd676f92cd67b0dbcba",
"final_url": "https://religionnews.com/2025/03/31/judge-rules-in-favor-of-guidepost-and-sbc-in-johnny-hunt-lawsuit/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 262,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2025-04-30",
"note": "Sentences upheld by the High Court of Cassation and Justice."
},
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2026-01-01",
"note": "The High Court rejected Onilă's appeal in cassation, a final extraordinary recourse."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Final appellate convictions, with a further cassation appeal rejected in January 2026. Student victims are not identified. The Diocese of Huși confirmed it severed ties with both men in August 2017. Does not characterise the Romanian Orthodox Church generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-onila-jitaru-husi-seminary-abuse-romania",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Huși, Vaslui, Romania",
"lat": 46.6733,
"lng": 28.0597,
"title": "Romania: bishop and archimandrite convicted of raping theological seminary students",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Orthodox bishop administering a theological seminary",
"archimandrite at the same seminary"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ecclesiastical and disciplinary authority over seminarians training for the priesthood"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Ioan Gură de Aur Theological Seminary, Huși"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Cassation and Justice, Romania",
"stage": "final appellate conviction",
"date": "2025-04-30",
"outcome": "On 30 April 2025 Romania's High Court of Cassation and Justice upheld an 8-year sentence for former Bishop of Huși Corneliu Onilă and sentenced former Archimandrite Sebastian Jitaru to 14 years and 2 months for multiple counts of rape and sexual assault against students at the Ioan Gură de Aur Theological Seminary. Jitaru was found to have repeatedly raped three students, one assaulted at least nine times in a single year and another abused over two years, sometimes twice weekly. Onilă is the first senior Romanian Orthodox hierarch to be imprisoned."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were seminary students under the direct ecclesiastical and disciplinary authority of the bishop and archimandrite who ran the institution training them for the priesthood — their vocations depended on the men abusing them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.romania-insider.com/former-bishop-prison-romania-may-2025",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Romanian High Court upholds prison sentence for former bishop in sexual abuse case', Romania Insider, May 2025.",
"body": "Reports the High Court's affirmance of the sentences against Onilă and Jitaru for raping seminary students under their authority.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://spotmedia.ro/en/news/news/former-bishop-sentenced-to-8-years-in-prison-for-rape-the-state-must-pay-damages",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former bishop sentenced to 8 years in prison for rape', spotmedia.ro.",
"body": "Independent Romanian outlet corroborating the eight-year sentence and the seminary-student victims.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2025-04-30",
"note": "Sentences upheld by the High Court of Cassation and Justice."
},
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2026-01-01",
"note": "The High Court rejected Onilă's appeal in cassation, a final extraordinary recourse."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.romania-insider.com/former-bishop-prison-romania-may-2025",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "302e8a15a7fad03cdf9938132fa399c8c4dc26cc0b2dde5f1a40329e4a45a2d6",
"final_url": "https://www.romania-insider.com/former-bishop-prison-romania-may-2025"
},
{
"source": "https://spotmedia.ro/en/news/news/former-bishop-sentenced-to-8-years-in-prison-for-rape-the-state-must-pay-damages",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "780a6860abbe502712550de774164473e44870d46eec93416e5f6d12a683c8b1",
"final_url": "https://spotmedia.ro/en/news/news/former-bishop-sentenced-to-8-years-in-prison-for-rape-the-state-must-pay-damages"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 263,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Conviction upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Scoped to the named proceeding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-adam-metropoulos-altar-server-abuse-maine-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Bangor, Maine, USA",
"lat": 44.8012,
"lng": -68.7778,
"title": "Greek Orthodox priest Adam Metropoulos convicted of abusing an altar server",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Greek Orthodox parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over an altar server placed in his home"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St. George Greek Orthodox Church, Bangor"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Maine Superior Court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2015-03-17",
"outcome": "Former priest Adam Metropoulos was found guilty on four felony counts of sexual abuse of a minor for assaults on a 15-year-old altar server who stayed overnight at his home in 2006–2007, and was sentenced to 12 years with 6.5 to serve. The conviction was upheld on appeal in 2016."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was an altar server at Metropoulos's own parish, placed in the priest's home under the pastoral care and trust he held as the congregation's clergy.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mainepublic.org/courts-and-crime/2015-03-17/former-bangor-priest-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former Bangor Priest Convicted of Child Sex Abuse', Maine Public, 17 March 2015.",
"body": "Reports the four-count felony conviction of the Greek Orthodox priest for abusing a teenage altar server from his parish.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Conviction upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mainepublic.org/courts-and-crime/2015-03-17/former-bangor-priest-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3b0f27744f9c91d7f77db04fc18fda33a0b0d8a8ce3f00e7770568d8c5ea110a",
"final_url": "https://www.mainepublic.org/courts-and-crime/2015-03-17/former-bangor-priest-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 264,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Sentence length is reported inconsistently across sources (14 vs 17 years); the record notes the discrepancy rather than asserting one figure.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-gleb-grozovsky-church-camp-abuse-russia",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Leningrad Region, Russia",
"lat": 59.9311,
"lng": 30.3609,
"title": "Russian Orthodox priest Gleb Grozovsky convicted of abusing girls at a church holiday camp",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Russian Orthodox priest overseeing a church-run children's camp"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral supervision of children at a church camp"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Russian Orthodox Church-run holiday camp"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Russian court, Leningrad Region",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2018-11-29",
"outcome": "A Russian court convicted Orthodox priest Gleb Grozovsky of committing sexual acts with three girls under 14 at an Orthodox Church-run holiday camp he oversaw, and sentenced him to a long prison term (reported as 14 years in some accounts and 17 in others)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were children attending a church-run religious camp under Grozovsky's direct pastoral supervision and authority as the officiating priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2018/11/29/russian-priest-sentenced-17-years-over-sexual-abuse-children-a63650",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Russian Priest Sentenced Over Sexual Abuse of Children', The Moscow Times, 29 Nov. 2018.",
"body": "Reports the conviction of the Orthodox priest for abusing girls at a church-run camp he supervised.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2018/11/29/russian-priest-sentenced-17-years-over-sexual-abuse-children-a63650",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2503349f51495ede26600222955a4707319c16ef3c741ea0c1cae90fd9d172e9",
"final_url": "https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2018/11/29/russian-priest-sentenced-17-years-over-sexual-abuse-children-a63650"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 265,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event recording a statutory inquiry's aggregate finding across many convictions, not a single defendant's case. Victim counts are the inquiry's figures.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-iicsa-anglican-church-abuse-inquiry-uk",
"year": 2020,
"place": "England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.3555,
"lng": -1.1743,
"title": "IICSA: 390 Church of England clergy and trusted persons convicted of child sexual offences",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Church of England clergy and persons in positions of trust",
"church hierarchy that deferred to clerical authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"deference to ordained clerical authority",
"institutional culture protecting priests over victims"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of England"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA), United Kingdom — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "statutory inquiry report",
"date": "2020-10-01",
"outcome": "IICSA found that 390 people who were clergy or in positions of trust associated with the Church of England were convicted of sexual offences against children between the 1940s and 2018, alongside 330 civil claims, and concluded that a culture of deference to clerical authority helped abusers hide and silenced victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The inquiry found the abuse was enabled by congregants' and choristers' deference to ordained clerical authority, and by an institutional culture that protected priests over the children in their pastoral care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/anglican-church/executive-summary.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse, 'The Anglican Church: Investigation Report' (Oct. 2020).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry records 390 convictions of clergy and persons in positions of trust, and finds deference to clerical authority enabled the abuse.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/anglican-church/executive-summary.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "26a2fdd828908026ec45d1a5702655b3514c0e02ceac54292421b16a9d31b16d",
"final_url": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/anglican-church/executive-summary.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 266,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal conviction plus a dedicated statutory-inquiry finding on institutional protection. Victims are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-peter-ball-bishop-vocation-abuse-uk",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Chichester and Gloucester, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 50.8365,
"lng": -0.7792,
"title": "Bishop Peter Ball: convicted of abusing young men who sought spiritual direction",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Church of England bishop"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual direction and vocational discernment used to obtain access",
"institutional protection by senior church figures"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of England"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Crown Court, England; IICSA investigation",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence; subsequent statutory inquiry",
"date": "2015-10-07",
"outcome": "Former Bishop of Lewes and Gloucester Peter Ball pleaded guilty in 2015 to misconduct in public office and indecent assaults spanning decades against young men who came to him for spiritual guidance. IICSA's dedicated investigation found senior Church figures, including a former Archbishop of Canterbury, had protected him for years despite known allegations."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were young men who came to Ball, as a bishop, for spiritual direction and discernment of a religious vocation — placing them under his direct pastoral and ecclesiastical authority, which he used to obtain access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/anglican-chichester-peter-ball/introduction.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IICSA, 'The Anglican Church: Chichester/Peter Ball Investigation Report' (May 2018).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry records Ball's convictions and the Church hierarchy's protection of him despite known allegations.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/anglican-chichester-peter-ball/introduction.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d53eb7721c37270e15ff136f01b16bed796e3307f4ffe047e90f1f687d78e319",
"final_url": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/anglican-chichester-peter-ball/introduction.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 267,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Defendant died in prison in 2020. Scoped to the named proceeding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-john-price-methodist-hypnosis-abuse-uk",
"year": 2017,
"place": "York and Pocklington, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.96,
"lng": -1.0873,
"title": "Methodist minister John Price convicted of abusing boys from his congregations under a 'hypnosis' ritual",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Methodist minister"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ministerial authority to invite congregation boys to his home",
"a purported 'hypnosis' ritual used as the method of abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Methodist Church (York and Pocklington circuits)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Teesside Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2017-05-16",
"outcome": "Retired Methodist minister John Price was convicted on thirteen counts of indecent assault against four boys aged 11–17 from his churches during the 1970s–80s, using a purported 'hypnosis' ritual as his method. He was sentenced to over eight years and died in prison in 2020."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were boys from Price's own congregations whom he invited to his home in his capacity as their minister; he used a purported hypnosis ritual, framed through that ministerial standing, as the method of the assaults.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/thames-and-chiltern/news/former-church-minister-jailed-historical-sex-offences",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crown Prosecution Service, 'Former church minister jailed for historical sex offences' (16 May 2017).",
"body": "The CPS records Price's conviction on thirteen counts of indecent assault against boys from his congregations and the sentence imposed.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/thames-and-chiltern/news/former-church-minister-jailed-historical-sex-offences",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 268,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Primary criminal court records were not directly retrieved; the account rests on contemporaneous reporting of the convictions and the related civil settlement. Minor victims are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-gerald-thomas-elca-pastor-abuse-texas-usa",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Marshall, Texas, USA",
"lat": 32.5449,
"lng": -94.3674,
"title": "ELCA pastor Gerald P. Thomas Jr. convicted of sex crimes against children from his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-lutheran",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ordained Lutheran (ELCA) pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral access to children of his congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Good Shepherd Lutheran Church, Marshall",
"Evangelical Lutheran Church in America"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "United States federal court and Texas state court",
"stage": "convictions and sentence; related civil settlement",
"date": "2003-01-01",
"outcome": "Gerald P. Thomas Jr., pastor of Good Shepherd Lutheran Church (ELCA) from 1997–2001, was federally convicted of child-pornography possession and subsequently sentenced in a state trial to a lengthy term for multiple sex crimes against children. The ELCA national office, a seminary, and a candidacy committee settled a related civil suit brought by fourteen victims in 2004."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were children connected to Thomas's Lutheran congregation, where he held pastoral authority and the access it conferred as their ordained minister.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.christiancentury.org/article/2004-05/lutherans-settle-texas-sex-abuse-case",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Lutherans settle in Texas sex abuse case', The Christian Century, May 2004.",
"body": "Reports the ELCA-related civil settlement with fourteen victims and the underlying criminal convictions of the pastor.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "civil-settlement"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.christiancentury.org/article/2004-05/lutherans-settle-texas-sex-abuse-case",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-settlement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ef72ab80b07e3ddfd059fbd38fc9738c6a2b93cea92d94ee0ea485f111bb4634",
"final_url": "https://www.christiancentury.org/article/2004-05/lutherans-settle-texas-sex-abuse-case"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 269,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The perpetrator was a lay member and the victim's father; the record qualifies through the church's shunning and reconciliation discipline exercising authority over the victim's ability to seek help — as found by the sentencing judge. The victim is not identified. Does not characterize Mennonites generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-duncalfe-holdeman-mennonite-shunning-canada",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Abbotsford, British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 49.0504,
"lng": -122.3045,
"title": "Holdeman Mennonite church discipline used to suppress reporting of an 18-year abuse case",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-mennonite-anabaptist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"church ministers exercising excommunication and reconciliation discipline",
"lay member and perpetrator"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"excommunication/shunning discipline",
"church-controlled 'reconciliation' substituted for reporting to police"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of God in Christ, Mennonite (Holdeman)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia courts, Canada",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2009-03-07",
"outcome": "Kenneth Duncalfe pleaded guilty in 2008 to sexual assault of his daughter over roughly a decade. The sentencing judge stated that church leaders had known of the abuse for eighteen years and did nothing; ministers had temporarily excommunicated and then readmitted him, and discouraged the victim from involving police, counselling church-controlled reconciliation instead."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was bound by the congregation's authority over family discipline and communal shunning: church ministers used that spiritual authority to redirect her toward church-controlled 'reconciliation' rather than secular reporting, suppressing her recourse for eighteen years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/man-sentenced-for-sexually-assaulting-teen-daughter-1.847940",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Man sentenced for sexually assaulting teen daughter', CBC News, 7 March 2009.",
"body": "CBC reports the guilty plea and the sentencing judge's finding that church leaders knew of the abuse for eighteen years and did nothing.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/man-sentenced-for-sexually-assaulting-teen-daughter-1.847940",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 270,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The verdict was delivered in absentia; the sentencing date is reported as 5 June (Sri Lanka Brief) or 8 June 2026 (secondary coverage) and is recorded as early June. The year field reflects earlier provisional dating and the proceeding date is authoritative.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-polgampola-dharmaloka-temple-child-abuse-sri-lanka",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Galenbindunuwewa, North Central Province, Sri Lanka",
"lat": 8.1667,
"lng": 80.75,
"title": "Sri Lanka: temple chief incumbent sentenced to 24 years for abusing a boy in his care",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"chief incumbent of a Buddhist temple",
"custodian of a child resident at the temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic and custodial authority over a child living at the temple"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Sri Seevali Chaityaramaya Vihara"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Anuradhapura Special High Court for Child Crimes, Sri Lanka",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-05",
"outcome": "Polgampola Dharmaloka, 40, chief incumbent of the Sri Seevali Chaityaramaya Vihara at Sivalakulama, Galenbindunuwewa, was sentenced in early June 2026 — in absentia, having repeatedly absconded during trial, with an open arrest warrant — to 24 years' rigorous imprisonment (two counts of twelve years) plus Rs 500,000 compensation for sexually abusing a ten-year-old boy entrusted to the temple for education (offences 1–24 May 2015)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child resident at the temple — a common arrangement for boys placed in monasteries for religious upbringing — which placed him under the direct custodial and monastic authority of the incumbent who ran it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://srilankabrief.org/head-monk-sentenced-to-24-years-rigorous-imprisonment-for-child-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Head Monk Sentenced to 24 Years Rigorous Imprisonment for Child Sexual Abuse', Sri Lanka Brief.",
"body": "Reports the conviction and 24-year sentence of the temple's chief incumbent for abusing a child resident.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://srilankamirror.com/news/4-jailed-for-total-of-101-years-over-child-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'4 jailed for total of 101 years over child sexual abuse', Sri Lanka Mirror.",
"body": "Independent coverage pinning the court and in-absentia verdict.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://srilankabrief.org/head-monk-sentenced-to-24-years-rigorous-imprisonment-for-child-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1cddcfcb0e9d0f23aba3a6324ea1f786b14d3a6833f3bf7f6bec4744c386caff",
"final_url": "https://srilankabrief.org/head-monk-sentenced-to-24-years-rigorous-imprisonment-for-child-sexual-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://srilankamirror.com/news/4-jailed-for-total-of-101-years-over-child-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fc18e4e104fa4fa1145b76ff3b68854b36d4f028b14c1b291ec823a2579a82d2",
"final_url": "https://srilankamirror.com/news/4-jailed-for-total-of-101-years-over-child-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 271,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An organizational investigative finding, not a court judgment; no criminal or civil adjudication occurred and Sasaki died in 2014 without responding to the findings in a legal forum. Students are not identified. Does not characterize Zen Buddhism generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-joshu-sasaki-rinzai-ji-investigation-california-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Los Angeles and Mount Baldy, California, USA",
"lat": 34.2372,
"lng": -117.6528,
"title": "Rinzai-ji investigation finds Zen master Joshu Sasaki coerced students over four decades",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Rinzai Zen roshi and lineage head"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority over students' spiritual advancement (koan validation, dharma transmission)",
"private teacher-student dokusan interviews",
"sexual contact framed as a teaching method",
"threatened expulsion for resistance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Rinzai-ji, Inc.",
"Mount Baldy Zen Center"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent council investigation commissioned by Rinzai-ji, Inc.",
"stage": "organizational investigative finding",
"date": "2013-01-01",
"outcome": "An independent investigation commissioned by Sasaki's own organization documented that he had coerced and groped a large number of female students over roughly four decades, framing sexual contact as a teaching method. The organization's council formally acknowledged the findings. No criminal charges were filed before his death in 2014."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As roshi, Sasaki held final authority over his students' spiritual advancement — koan validation and dharma transmission — and the investigation found he used private dokusan interviews to initiate contact, with resistance carrying the threat of expulsion from the training that had become their vocation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://newrepublic.com/article/115613/zen-buddhist-sex-controversies-america-excerpt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'The Zen Buddhist Who Preyed on His Upper East Side Students', The New Republic (2013).",
"body": "Recounts the independent investigation's findings on Sasaki's decades-long coercion of students and the teacher-student authority that enabled it.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://newrepublic.com/article/115613/zen-buddhist-sex-controversies-america-excerpt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a72c29bf96271821124853079055145341982aa1fbce7424122cd5b8fccd7921",
"final_url": "https://newrepublic.com/article/115613/zen-buddhist-sex-controversies-america-excerpt"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 272,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim, not identified. The record covers both the underlying harassment conviction and the institutional retaliation finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-jin-gak-order-monk-harassment-retaliation-south-korea",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Seoul, South Korea",
"lat": 37.5665,
"lng": 126.978,
"title": "South Korea: Jin-Gak Order and official convicted after retaliation against a monk's accuser",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior monk within a Buddhist order",
"the religious order as employer and institution"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"hierarchical seniority within the order",
"retaliatory reassignment of the person who reported"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Jin-Gak Order"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Seoul court, South Korea",
"stage": "conviction and damages award",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"outcome": "A Seoul court convicted the Jin-Gak Order and its HR official of violating sexual-violence-prevention and whistleblower-protection law after a senior monk repeatedly touched a 25-year-old order member without consent. The monk received a suspended ten-month term, and the victim was awarded 309.5 million won in damages for retaliatory reassignment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a member of the order subject to the senior monk's hierarchical religious authority; when she reported, the order itself used its institutional power to reassign her — the finding the court penalised.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.koreaherald.com/article/10512973",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Whistleblower wins compensation in #MeToo case against senior Buddhist monk', The Korea Herald (2025).",
"body": "Reports the convictions of the order and its HR official and the damages awarded for retaliation against the person who reported.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-damages-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.koreaherald.com/article/10512973",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-damages-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "01691ac610c1955081150cfc13aa85e6cc731e4e0daaf685fe76baa943b0f3d2",
"final_url": "https://www.koreaherald.com/article/10512973"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 273,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The complainant was a minor at the time of the offences and is not identified here. Scoped to the adjudicated conduct.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-daniel-greer-yeshiva-new-haven-connecticut-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "New Haven, Connecticut, USA",
"lat": 41.3083,
"lng": -72.9279,
"title": "Rabbi Daniel Greer convicted of abusing a student at the yeshiva he founded",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"rabbi",
"founder and head of a yeshiva"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious and disciplinary authority over a student at his school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Yeshiva of New Haven"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Connecticut Superior Court; federal civil suit",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence; separate civil judgment",
"date": "2019-12-02",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Rabbi Daniel Greer, founder of the Yeshiva of New Haven, on four counts of risk of injury to a minor for repeatedly sexually abusing a teenage student, and he was sentenced to 12 years. The victim separately won a $15 million judgment in a federal civil suit."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As founder and head of the yeshiva, Greer held direct religious and disciplinary authority over the student he abused, on the school premises where the student's religious education and standing depended on him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courttv.com/news/rabbi-convicted-of-sex-abuse-gets-12-years-in-prison/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Rabbi convicted of sex abuse gets 12 years in prison', Court TV (2019).",
"body": "Reports the jury conviction on four counts and the twelve-year sentence imposed on the yeshiva's founder.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courttv.com/news/rabbi-convicted-of-sex-abuse-gets-12-years-in-prison/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 274,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victims, not identified. Scoped to the pleaded counts and the related civil settlement.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-barry-freundel-mikvah-voyeurism-washington-dc-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Washington, D.C., USA",
"lat": 38.9072,
"lng": -77.0369,
"title": "Rabbi Barry Freundel: 52 voyeurism counts for recording women at the mikveh he supervised",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregational rabbi",
"supervising rabbi of a ritual bath and conversion process"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"control of a ritual immersion required for conversion and family purity",
"authority over scheduling and access to the mikveh"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"sacred-sex-purity",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Kesher Israel Congregation",
"National Capital Mikvah"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of the District of Columbia",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence; related class settlement",
"date": "2015-05-15",
"outcome": "Rabbi Barry Freundel pleaded guilty to 52 misdemeanour counts of voyeurism for secretly recording women undressing at the mikveh he supervised, and was sentenced to six and a half years. A $14.25 million class-action settlement followed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Freundel supervised the mikveh and controlled access to and scheduling of an immersion required for conversion and observance of family purity: the women could not complete their conversion or religious practice without entering the space he was covertly recording, and his rabbinic authority is what placed them there.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/pr/rabbi-sentenced-6-12-year-prison-term-voyeurism-charges-admitted-secretly-taking-video",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Columbia, 'Rabbi Sentenced to 6 1/2 Year Prison Term on Voyeurism Charges' (2015).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records the guilty plea to 52 counts and the sentence for covertly recording women at the ritual bath he supervised.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/pr/rabbi-sentenced-6-12-year-prison-term-voyeurism-charges-admitted-secretly-taking-video",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f2cbff88240b6640bd039493e786578d637a9b53d6d6a7b47f102d0283328e8a",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/pr/rabbi-sentenced-6-12-year-prison-term-voyeurism-charges-admitted-secretly-taking-video"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 275,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant's full name is withheld under German privacy law, so the record names him only as reported. The victim is an adult and is not identified. The reported accounts of other women are not adjudicated and are recorded as allegations only.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-berlin-rabbi-spiritual-counsel-assault-germany",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Berlin, Germany",
"lat": 52.52,
"lng": 13.405,
"title": "Berlin: rabbi convicted of assaulting a woman he offered to counsel using claimed spiritual powers",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"rabbi offering religious counsel"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed rabbinical 'special powers' to resolve family problems",
"religious counselling relationship"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Berlin court, Germany",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-22",
"outcome": "A Berlin court convicted a rabbi, identified in reporting only as Reuven Y. under German privacy law, of sexual assault and sexual coercion of a woman he had offered to counsel, imposing a suspended ten-month sentence with two years' probation. Reporting indicates roughly 32 women described similar experiences."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "He invoked his standing as a rabbi able to resolve family crises through claimed special powers in order to establish the counselling relationship, and the assault occurred inside the religious authority the victim had sought out for help.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2026/01/22/global/berlin-rabbi-convicted-of-sexual-assault-and-sexual-coercion-of-woman-he-offered-to-counsel",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Berlin rabbi convicted of sexual assault and sexual coercion of woman he offered to counsel', Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 22 Jan. 2026.",
"body": "Reports the Berlin conviction and the counselling pretext through which the rabbi obtained access to the victim.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2026/01/22/global/berlin-rabbi-convicted-of-sexual-assault-and-sexual-coercion-of-woman-he-offered-to-counsel",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7ddefff90ac9c6b1e3272d7cd8632e9d9293b6c44ab3f9003ac6b55dc4679640",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2026/01/22/global/berlin-rabbi-convicted-of-sexual-assault-and-sexual-coercion-of-woman-he-offered-to-counsel"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 276,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Appeals court confirmed the national and international arrest warrant."
}
],
"scopeNote": "ALLEGATION ONLY — no trial or conviction has occurred and the accused has not answered the charges. Complainants were adolescents and are not identified. Only one substantive source was located; the record is held at charged status pending further primary documentation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-marcelo-krawiec-chalom-synagogue-warrant-argentina",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Buenos Aires, Argentina",
"lat": -34.5709,
"lng": -58.4514,
"title": "Argentina: international arrest warrant confirmed for rabbi accused of abusing teenage congregants",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregational rabbi"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over teenage congregants and their families' trust"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Chalom synagogue, Colegiales"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Argentine appeals court; Interpol",
"stage": "arrest warrant confirmed on appeal; defendant at large",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "An Argentine appeals court confirmed a national and international arrest warrant for Rabbi Marcelo Daniel Krawiec of the Chalom synagogue, who is accused of sexually abusing at least two young men aged 16 to 18 between 2010 and 2018. He fled to Israel and Interpol is pursuing him. No trial has occurred."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the congregation's rabbi, Krawiec is alleged to have held pastoral authority over teenage congregants and to have used that position, and their families' trust in it, to isolate them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/interpol-hunting-in-israel-for-argentine-rabbi-accused-of-sexual-abuse-of-teens/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Interpol hunting in Israel for Argentine rabbi accused of sexual abuse of teens', The Times of Israel.",
"body": "Reports the appellate confirmation of the arrest warrant and the pending Interpol pursuit of the accused rabbi.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "arrest-warrant-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Appeals court confirmed the national and international arrest warrant."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "An Argentine appeals court confirmed a national and international arrest warrant for Rabbi Marcelo Daniel Krawiec of the Chalom synagogue, who is accused of sexually abusing at least two young men aged 16 to 18 between 2010 and 2018. He fled to Israel and Interpol is pursuing him. No trial has occurred.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/interpol-hunting-in-israel-for-argentine-rabbi-accused-of-sexual-abuse-of-teens/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: arrest-warrant-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b008906a71ae689b8800521f234c5ac4ebade7b392e990f0b332a9debb337549",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/interpol-hunting-in-israel-for-argentine-rabbi-accused-of-sexual-abuse-of-teens/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 277,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The complainant is an adult and is not identified. This is the corpus's first Jain record; it documents an individual monk's adjudicated conduct and does not characterise Jainism, a tradition centred on non-violence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-shantisagarji-jain-muni-rape-conviction-surat-india",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Surat, Gujarat, India",
"lat": 21.1702,
"lng": 72.8311,
"title": "India: Digambar Jain muni sentenced to 10 years for raping a woman who sought him as her guru",
"tradition": "jainism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-jain",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Digambar Jain muni regarded as the family's guru"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru authority over a devotee family seeking religious guidance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions Court, Surat, Gujarat, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-04-05",
"outcome": "A Surat sessions court sentenced Digambar Jain monk Shantisagarji Maharaj to ten years' imprisonment for the 2017 rape of a 19-year-old woman who had travelled with her family to seek his guidance at a Jain dharamshala. The court relied on the complainant's testimony, medical reports and CCTV evidence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim and her family regarded him as their guru and travelled specifically to seek his religious guidance; she was inside that guru-devotee relationship, in the dharamshala where he was lodged, at the moment of the assault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.deccanherald.com/india/gujarat/gujarat-court-sentences-jain-monk-to-10-years-in-jail-for-rape-of-young-woman-3479826",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Gujarat court sentences Jain monk to 10 years in jail for rape of young woman', Deccan Herald (2025).",
"body": "Reports the sessions court conviction, the ten-year sentence, and the evidentiary basis including testimony, medical reports and CCTV.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.deccanherald.com/india/gujarat/gujarat-court-sentences-jain-monk-to-10-years-in-jail-for-rape-of-young-woman-3479826",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7d80f815c2f53c691ec64ef76c21f139eb520e08e8558769f75512445a198513",
"final_url": "https://www.deccanherald.com/india/gujarat/gujarat-court-sentences-jain-monk-to-10-years-in-jail-for-rape-of-young-woman-3479826"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 278,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Sentence increased to 16 years."
},
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2019-08-01",
"note": "Conviction and 16-year sentence affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Final conviction affirmed by the Supreme Court of Korea. Adult complainants are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-lee-jaerock-manmin-central-church-rape-south-korea",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Seoul, South Korea",
"lat": 37.5665,
"lng": 126.978,
"title": "Lee Jaerock: 16 years for raping congregants who believed him religiously infallible",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founding pastor of a 130,000-member church",
"figure presented as possessing near-divine authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed religious infallibility",
"lifelong membership and total doctrinal dependence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Manmin Central Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Seoul Central District Court; Supreme Court of Korea",
"stage": "conviction, sentence increased on appeal, affirmed",
"date": "2018-11-22",
"outcome": "Seoul Central District Court convicted Lee Jaerock on 42 counts of sexually assaulting and repeatedly raping eight women from his congregation, sentencing him to 15 years in November 2018. The sentence was increased to 16 years on appeal and upheld by the Supreme Court in August 2019."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "All eight complainants had grown up inside the church. The court found they were unable to resist because of their absolute faith in Lee's claimed religious infallibility — the authority itself, not force, is what made refusal impossible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2018/11/22/asia/lee-jae-rock-pastor-indicted-intl",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'South Korean pastor Lee Jae-rock who portrayed himself as God sentenced to 15 years for rape', CNN, 22 Nov. 2018.",
"body": "Reports the 42-count conviction and the court's finding that the victims' faith in his infallibility prevented resistance.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Sentence increased to 16 years."
},
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2019-08-01",
"note": "Conviction and 16-year sentence affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2018/11/22/asia/lee-jae-rock-pastor-indicted-intl",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1fc47b4f88a7e78c0d743ee5f6bc94e74bfd035083cc79bf6f9f6a9252ca7aa7",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2018/11/22/asia/lee-jae-rock-pastor-indicted-intl"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 279,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The complainants are described in Vietnamese reporting as women (phụ nữ) and are not identified; their exact ages were not stated. Vietnamese-language court reporting, read in the original. First record for Vietnam.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-nguyen-ngoc-hai-living-buddha-rape-vietnam",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam",
"lat": 10.8231,
"lng": 106.6297,
"title": "Vietnam: self-styled 'living Buddha' convicted of raping women he treated as disciples",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled 'living Buddha' and spiritual healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sexual acts framed as necessary 'energy transmission' healing",
"claimed capacity to heal through spiritual power"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Region 7 District Court, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-09-24",
"outcome": "Nguyễn Ngọc Hải was sentenced to eight years' imprisonment for rape after confessing to assaulting seven women. He had claimed to be a 'living Buddha' able to heal through energy transmission and summoned female disciples to hotels and private homes for sexual acts he presented as spiritual treatment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were his self-identified disciples who submitted to his claimed healing authority, having been told the sexual contact was the 'energy transmission' treatment he had prescribed for them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tuoitre.vn/nguoi-lam-nghe-bam-huyet-bi-phat-8-nam-tu-vi-toi-cuong-dam-20250924160208467.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Người làm nghề bấm huyệt bị phạt 8 năm tù vì tội cưỡng dâm', Tuổi Trẻ, 24 Sept. 2025.",
"body": "Vietnamese court reporting on the eight-year sentence and the healing pretext used to obtain compliance.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tuoitre.vn/nguoi-lam-nghe-bam-huyet-bi-phat-8-nam-tu-vi-toi-cuong-dam-20250924160208467.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dce49db48356ce445d919eeecdc22cc0e6a6589bce72b5c886b02da40177f38e",
"final_url": "https://tuoitre.vn/nguoi-lam-nghe-bam-huyet-bi-phat-8-nam-tu-vi-toi-cuong-dam-20250924160208467.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 280,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The complainant was 18 and is not identified. Sourcing is Zimbabwean court reporting; the primary court record was not directly retrieved. Reports state the defendant collapsed in the dock after sentencing and was hospitalised.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-obvious-mauyire-cleansing-ritual-rape-bikita-zimbabwe",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Bikita, Masvingo Province, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -20.0833,
"lng": 31.4167,
"title": "Zimbabwe: traditional healer jailed 20 years for raping a client during an overnight 'cleansing'",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"traditional healer consulted by the victim's family"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual claim of a 'spiritual husband' requiring cleansing",
"instruction that the family leave the young woman overnight",
"administration of snuff and traditional beer during the rite"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Masvingo Regional Court, Zimbabwe (Regional Magistrate Innocent Bepura)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-22",
"outcome": "Obvious Mauyire, 35, of Mazungunye Village, Bikita, was convicted of raping an 18-year-old woman on 14 November 2025 and sentenced to 20 years. The court heard he told the family a 'spiritual husband' required an overnight cleansing ceremony, had the complainant take snuff and traditional beer, sent the family home on an assurance that female assistants would attend — which prosecutors said never happened — and assaulted her at the mountain site."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The family brought the young woman to Mauyire as a spiritual healer, and it was his ritual authority — the diagnosis of a 'spiritual husband' and the cleansing ceremony he prescribed — that isolated her overnight and made the assault possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bulawayo24.com/index-id-news-sc-national-byo-264981.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sangoma attempts suicide after rape conviction', Bulawayo24 News (2026).",
"body": "Zimbabwean reporting on the 20-year sentence, the magistrate, and the cleansing-ceremony account given in court.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bulawayo24.com/index-id-news-sc-national-byo-264981.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8949a3e4655494e4fed1c5818ad061abe019ba76fcb7e27040c6693f1a50fc6b",
"final_url": "https://bulawayo24.com/index-id-news-sc-national-byo-264981.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 281,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Polish reporting described the verdict as nieprawomocny (not legally final) at the time of publication; no appellate outcome was located. The complainant is an adult and is not identified. Polish-language sourcing, read in the original.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-siedlce-priest-parishioner-assault-poland",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Siedlce, Poland",
"lat": 52.1676,
"lng": 22.2902,
"title": "Poland: priest sentenced to five years for repeatedly forcing a parishioner into sexual acts",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral relationship with a parishioner",
"physical restraint during the assaults"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court, Siedlce, Poland",
"stage": "conviction and sentence (reported as not yet final)",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "A 33-year-old priest was convicted of using force — grabbing, restraining and pinning — to compel a female parishioner into sexual intercourse and other sexual acts on multiple occasions between October 2018 and February 2019. He was sentenced to five years' imprisonment, a five-year no-contact order, and 150,000 złoty in damages."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a parishioner of the priest's church; the pastoral relationship is what gave him access to her and the standing on which the contact began.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.pap.pl/aktualnosci/news,1559495,ksiadz-skazany-na-piec-lat-wiezienia-za-napastowanie-parafianki.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ksiądz skazany na pięć lat więzienia za napastowanie parafianki', Polska Agencja Prasowa (PAP).",
"body": "Poland's national news agency reports the five-year sentence, the no-contact order and the damages awarded.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.pap.pl/aktualnosci/news,1559495,ksiadz-skazany-na-piec-lat-wiezienia-za-napastowanie-parafianki.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d02032286070b4dd9d8fbd985a7bdca8af8edf52b89ff177db3bfcb2c8a9c43d",
"final_url": "https://www.pap.pl/aktualnosci/news,1559495,ksiadz-skazany-na-piec-lat-wiezienia-za-napastowanie-parafianki.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 282,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2025-09-18",
"note": "Final conviction; both appeals rejected."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Final conviction with a suspended sentence. Eight further criminal complaints were reported against him but were time-barred or not prosecuted, and are recorded here only as unadjudicated. The complainant is an adult and is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-visarion-alexa-confession-assault-bucharest-romania",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Bucharest, Romania",
"lat": 44.4268,
"lng": 26.1025,
"title": "Romania: priest convicted of sexually assaulting a woman who came to him for confession",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Romanian Orthodox parish priest and confessor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the sacrament of confession as the setting and pretext"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Biserica 'Pogorârea Sfântului Duh', Bucharest"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bucharest Court of Appeal, Romania",
"stage": "final conviction, suspended sentence",
"date": "2025-09-18",
"outcome": "The Bucharest Court of Appeal issued a final conviction of priest Visarion Alexa for sexual assault committed on 23 April 2022 in the church's summer altar against a parishioner who had come to him for confession. The court imposed a suspended prison sentence, rejected appeals by both the defendant and the victim, and ordered damages."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant approached Alexa specifically in his capacity as her confessor, inside the sacrament of confession — a setting whose spiritual submission and privacy is what the assault exploited.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://agerpres.ro/2025/09/18/preotul-visarion-alexa-condamnat-definitiv-cu-suspendare-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-asupra-unei-femei--1485407",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Preotul Visarion Alexa, condamnat definitiv cu suspendare pentru agresiune sexuală asupra unei femei', AGERPRES, 18 Sept. 2025.",
"body": "Romania's national news agency reports the final appellate conviction, the suspended sentence and the confession setting.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2025-09-18",
"note": "Final conviction; both appeals rejected."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://agerpres.ro/2025/09/18/preotul-visarion-alexa-condamnat-definitiv-cu-suspendare-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-asupra-unei-femei--1485407",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "33c0f3a7d90fc39e21e56d2d8f4517261d38fd7d0258fd2b02ff121d6175aa74",
"final_url": "https://agerpres.ro/2025/09/18/preotul-visarion-alexa-condamnat-definitiv-cu-suspendare-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-asupra-unei-femei--1485407"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 283,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The priest's full name was not published in the available sourcing and he is identified by role only. The offences came to light in 2023 when his partner found the recordings. Adult complainants are not identified. Spanish-language sourcing, read in the original.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-malaga-priest-sedation-assaults-spain",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Málaga, Spain",
"lat": 36.7213,
"lng": -4.4214,
"title": "Spain: priest sentenced to 52 years for drugging and assaulting four women he guided spiritually",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest providing ongoing spiritual guidance"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sedation of victims with an unknown drug",
"ongoing spiritual-direction relationship used to obtain trust and access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Málaga"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Provincial Court (Audiencia Provincial) of Málaga, Spain",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-07-09",
"outcome": "The Provincial Court of Málaga sentenced a Catholic priest to 52 years' imprisonment for drugging four women he was spiritually guiding with an unknown sedative and sexually assaulting them while unconscious between 2015 and 2018, recording the assaults. The court ordered more than €400,000 in restitution and found the Diocese subsidiarily liable for inadequate oversight."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Each complainant was in an ongoing spiritual-guidance relationship with the priest; that religious bond is what secured their trust and the private access he used to sedate and assault them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/espana/2026/07/09/un-sacerdote-es-condenado-a-52-anos-de-prision-por-drogar-abusar-y-grabar-a-cuatro-mujeres-en-malaga-las-victimas-mantenian-un-vinculo-espiritual-con-el-acusado/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Un sacerdote es condenado a 52 años de prisión por drogar, abusar y grabar a cuatro mujeres en Málaga', Infobae, 9 July 2026.",
"body": "Reports the Audiencia Provincial ruling, the 52-year sentence, the restitution order and the diocese's subsidiary liability.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/espana/2026/07/09/un-sacerdote-es-condenado-a-52-anos-de-prision-por-drogar-abusar-y-grabar-a-cuatro-mujeres-en-malaga-las-victimas-mantenian-un-vinculo-espiritual-con-el-acusado/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "85ef9008169217129352f77954dc41e840d828a0204abaaea8006ae345cfd6c8",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/espana/2026/07/09/un-sacerdote-es-condenado-a-52-anos-de-prision-por-drogar-abusar-y-grabar-a-cuatro-mujeres-en-malaga-las-victimas-mantenian-un-vinculo-espiritual-con-el-acusado/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 284,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Tried in Quebec; the congregation is a Congolese-diaspora Pentecostal church, and the record is filed under Canada, where the proceeding took place. The complainant is an adult and is not identified. French-language sourcing, read in the original.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-guy-kasongo-spiritual-father-assault-quebec-canada",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Quebec City, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 46.8139,
"lng": -71.208,
"title": "Quebec: pastor jailed four years for assaulting a congregant who called him her spiritual father",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Pentecostal pastor regarded by the victim as her spiritual father"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"private prayer sessions",
"the 'spiritual father' relationship and the deference it carried"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Église universelle de Jésus-Christ"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Quebec, Canada",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-06-04",
"outcome": "Pastor Guy John Imani Kasongo was convicted of sexual assault against a woman in her twenties from his congregation, committed between February and April 2025, and sentenced to four years' imprisonment. The court heard he used private prayer sessions to escalate from touching to penetration."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a member of Kasongo's congregation who regarded him as her spiritual father; the assaults occurred inside private prayer sessions, where that pastoral authority was the operative means of access and compliance.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2259223/peine-pasteur-guy-john-imani-kasongo",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'4 ans de prison pour un pasteur qui a agressé sexuellement une fidèle', Radio-Canada, 4 June 2025.",
"body": "Canada's public broadcaster reports the conviction, the four-year sentence and the spiritual-father relationship described in court.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2259223/peine-pasteur-guy-john-imani-kasongo",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d604fe22339adf8921e78d14071e9355b802016029c694e4728424b53b6c2400",
"final_url": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2259223/peine-pasteur-guy-john-imani-kasongo"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 285,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "A 1937 federal conviction, recorded as a historical dossier. The complainant was 17 and, although named in the contemporaneous press of the period, is not identified here. Hunt was a follower of the Peace Mission movement acting on his own claimed prophetic status; the record concerns his conduct and does not characterise that movement or its founder. The exact sentencing docket was not retrieved; the three-year sentence rests on contemporaneous press tracking the trial across multiple papers.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1937-john-hunt-peace-mission-mann-act-california-usa",
"year": 1937,
"place": "Los Angeles, California, USA",
"lat": 34.0522,
"lng": -118.2437,
"title": "'John the Revelator': Mann Act conviction for transporting a girl told she would bear a redeemer",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled prophet within the Peace Mission movement, addressed by followers as a divine figure"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claim that the victim was the reincarnated Virgin Mary destined to bear a new redeemer",
"isolation from her family across state lines",
"religious status treated as genuine by surrounding followers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Peace Mission movement (follower)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "United States federal court, California",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1937-01-01",
"outcome": "John Wuest Hunt, a follower of Father Divine's Peace Mission movement who took the name 'John the Revelator' and was addressed by followers as a divine figure, was convicted under the Mann Act of transporting a 17-year-old girl across state lines for immoral purposes and sentenced to three years. He had met her in Denver in December 1936, told her she was the reincarnated Virgin Mary destined to bear a new redeemer by immaculate conception, and transported her to California, where the sexual relationship began under that religious framing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Hunt held himself out to the girl as a divinely appointed prophet — a status other Peace Mission followers treated as genuine in their court testimony — and it was that claimed authority, in the specific form of naming her the Virgin Mary carrying a divine child, that secured her compliance and separated her from her family.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn83045462/1937-06-25/ed-1/?sp=3",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'West Aid Reveals: Attorney in Mann Act Case Says Cultist Will Take Charge Out Here', Evening Star (Washington, D.C.), 25 June 1937, p. 3.",
"body": "Contemporaneous press covering the federal Mann Act prosecution, the religious claims Hunt made to the girl, and follower testimony treating his prophetic status as genuine. Retrieved from the Library of Congress Chronicling America collection.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn83045462/1937-06-25/ed-1/?sp=3",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 286,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The precise sentencing court and date were not confirmed from a court source; the account rests on national reporting of the sentence and the subsequent capture. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-maurilio-villafana-ticapampa-parish-peru",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ticapampa, Áncash, Peru",
"lat": -9.7833,
"lng": -77.5667,
"title": "Peru: priest sentenced to life imprisonment for years of rape of a child in the parish house",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral access to a parishioner's child",
"abuse inside the parish house"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal court, Áncash, Peru",
"stage": "conviction and sentence (cadena perpetua)",
"date": "2024-05-01",
"outcome": "Priest Maurilio Villafana Morales was sentenced to life imprisonment (cadena perpetua) for repeatedly raping a girl from the age of nine inside the parish house, until she disclosed the abuse to her parents. He absconded and a reward was offered for his capture, which followed in August 2024."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was the child of parishioners, and it was the priest's pastoral standing that gave him access to her and the parish house in which the abuse occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/peru/2024/08/22/capturan-a-sacerdote-condenado-a-cadena-perpetua-por-cometer-abuso-sexual-infantil-en-parroquia-de-ancash/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Capturan a sacerdote condenado a cadena perpetua por abuso sexual infantil en parroquia de Áncash', Infobae Perú, 22 Aug. 2024.",
"body": "Reports the life sentence for abuse committed in the parish house and the priest's capture after absconding.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-capture-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/peru/2024/08/22/capturan-a-sacerdote-condenado-a-cadena-perpetua-por-cometer-abuso-sexual-infantil-en-parroquia-de-ancash/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-capture-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "053fb1e14b71f7bb77e4c7fed3583c200ce765175699183eec7730ccce850884",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/peru/2024/08/22/capturan-a-sacerdote-condenado-a-cadena-perpetua-por-cometer-abuso-sexual-infantil-en-parroquia-de-ancash/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 287,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor/young complainants are not identified. The exact sentencing court and date were not specified in the government release relied on; single official source. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-fredy-valdivia-arequipa-church-youth-peru",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Arequipa, Peru",
"lat": -16.409,
"lng": -71.5375,
"title": "Peru: priest sentenced to 13 years for indecent assault of two young congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over young people in his church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal court, Arequipa, Peru",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "A 75-year-old priest was convicted of indecent touching (tocamientos indebidos) against two young people from his church, committed in 2021–2022, and sentenced to 13 years. The conviction was secured with the assistance of Peru's public defence service."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were young congregants of the priest's own church, where his pastoral authority provided both the access and the trust he exploited.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gob.pe/institucion/minjus/noticias/1401201-arequipa-defensa-publica-del-minjusdh-logra-sentencia-condenatoria-contra-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-a-menor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio de Justicia y Derechos Humanos (Peru), 'Arequipa: Defensa Pública logra sentencia condenatoria contra sacerdote por abuso sexual a menor' (2023).",
"body": "Peru's justice ministry records the conviction and 13-year sentence of the priest for offences against young people from his church.",
"tier": "official-government-release",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gob.pe/institucion/minjus/noticias/1401201-arequipa-defensa-publica-del-minjusdh-logra-sentencia-condenatoria-contra-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-a-menor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-release; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "db8e9bb0cc1c3fa2921f0b60da15c2cd1517b720c79d0d12418400d2c880ee16",
"final_url": "https://www.gob.pe/institucion/minjus/noticias/1401201-arequipa-defensa-publica-del-minjusdh-logra-sentencia-condenatoria-contra-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-a-menor"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 288,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Nullity appeal rejected; conviction stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Sourced to Chile's judiciary. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-octavio-curin-temuco-pentecostal-chile",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Temuco, Araucanía, Chile",
"lat": -38.7359,
"lng": -72.5904,
"title": "Chile: Pentecostal pastor sentenced to 10 years for repeated abuse of a child under 14",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Pentecostal pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral position within the congregation the child belonged to"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Oral en lo Penal de Temuco; Court of Appeals of Temuco",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; nullity appeal rejected",
"date": "2024-10-18",
"outcome": "The oral criminal court of Temuco sentenced Pentecostal pastor Octavio Andrés Curín Ancali to 10 years and one day for repeated sexual abuse of a child under 14, committed between 2017 and 2019. The Court of Appeals of Temuco subsequently rejected his nullity appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was connected to the congregation the defendant pastored, and his position as its pastor is what furnished the access and the deference the abuse relied on.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.pjud.cl/prensa-y-comunicaciones/noticias-del-poder-judicial/116500",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Poder Judicial de Chile, 'TOP de Temuco condena a pastor evangélico a 10 años y un día de presidio por abuso sexual infantil reiterado' (18 Oct. 2024).",
"body": "Chile's judiciary records the conviction, the 10-year-and-one-day sentence, and the offence period.",
"tier": "official-judiciary-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Nullity appeal rejected; conviction stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.pjud.cl/prensa-y-comunicaciones/noticias-del-poder-judicial/116500",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-judiciary-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3afd5d1c8c4370c5fb333aa64e3d6fcb4d8057d76e3548e794bb4a6abbe3b6f6",
"final_url": "https://www.pjud.cl/prensa-y-comunicaciones/noticias-del-poder-judicial/116500"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 289,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The primary source could not be fetched directly (403) and the account rests on the published article summary; the specific court and municipality were not stated. Treated as medium-confidence pending direct verification. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-bernabe-aramayo-evangelical-pastor-bolivia",
"year": 2021,
"place": "La Paz, Bolivia",
"lat": -16.4897,
"lng": -68.1193,
"title": "Bolivia: evangelical pastor sentenced to 17 years for raping girls in his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral position over girls in the congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal court, Bolivia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-10-05",
"outcome": "Evangelical pastor Bernabé Aramayo was sentenced to 17 years' imprisonment for raping and abusing girls, using his position as pastor of an evangelical church to commit the offences."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were girls within the congregation the defendant pastored; the reporting records that he used that pastoral position to commit the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/pastor-evangelico-pederasta-es-condenado-17-anos-carcel/20211005235500838034.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor evangélico pederasta es condenado a 17 años de cárcel', Opinión (Bolivia), 5 Oct. 2021.",
"body": "Bolivian national newspaper reporting the 17-year sentence and the pastoral position used to commit the offences.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/pastor-evangelico-pederasta-es-condenado-17-anos-carcel/20211005235500838034.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e653d2f29455b004b7a3bc6f9c33dac2c21a5f1cc20c61218404e76eb315b6f0",
"final_url": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/pastor-evangelico-pederasta-es-condenado-17-anos-carcel/20211005235500838034.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 290,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "canonical",
"date": "2024-03-20",
"note": "The Ecclesiastical Court of Buenos Aires ordered his expulsion from the priesthood and excommunication."
},
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025-06-25",
"note": "The 12-year sentence was confirmed on appeal."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainants, not identified. Conviction confirmed on appeal in June 2025; the defendant was separately expelled from the priesthood and excommunicated by the Ecclesiastical Court of Buenos Aires in March 2024. Sourced to Argentina's public prosecution service. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-manuel-pascual-nuns-spiritual-direction-argentina",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Buenos Aires, Argentina",
"lat": -34.6037,
"lng": -58.3816,
"title": "Argentina: priest sentenced to 12 years for abusing two nuns under his spiritual direction",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest serving as spiritual director and confessor to the complainants"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"role as priest and spiritual director to nuns of the congregation in his charge",
"the complainants' vows of obedience and religious submission",
"abuse framed as spiritual 'healing'",
"confession and absolution administered during the assaults"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Oral en lo Criminal y Correccional N°3, Buenos Aires, Argentina",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-12-23",
"outcome": "Priest Manuel Fernando Pascual was sentenced to 12 years' imprisonment for repeated sexual abuse with carnal access against two nuns of the San José Congregation, committed between 2012 and 2016 at 'La Ermita', a field in Capitán Sarmiento used for spiritual retreats and masses. The court found a context of coercive manipulation, intimidation and abuse of power, aggravated by his condition as a priest. The complainants described him framing the abuse as 'healing' them and telling them to 'let themselves be loved', and stated he confessed and absolved them of their sins during the assaults."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were nuns of the San José Congregation, which was under the defendant's charge, and the abuse occurred at a site used for spiritual retreats. The court found coercive manipulation and abuse of power aggravated by his priesthood; the complainants described him presenting the abuse as spiritual healing and absolving them of sin during it, so that the sacramental authority itself was the instrument of the coercion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/genero/condenaron-a-12-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-dos-religiosas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público Fiscal (Argentina), 'Condenaron a 12 años de prisión a un sacerdote que abusó sexualmente de dos religiosas' (23 Dec. 2022).",
"body": "Argentina's prosecuting authority records the 12-year sentence and the court's finding that the priest exploited his role as the nuns' spiritual director.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/intensa-manipulacion-condenaron-a-12-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-dos-nid27122022/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenaron a 12 años de prisión a un sacerdote por abusar sexualmente de dos religiosas en un retiro espiritual', La Nación, 27 Dec. 2022.",
"body": "Argentina's paper of record details the retreat setting, the coercive manipulation the court found, and the sacramental framing described by the complainants.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "canonical",
"date": "2024-03-20",
"note": "The Ecclesiastical Court of Buenos Aires ordered his expulsion from the priesthood and excommunication."
},
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025-06-25",
"note": "The 12-year sentence was confirmed on appeal."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/genero/condenaron-a-12-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-dos-religiosas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5513e49110b4f61c193a901d5cc1e82c48f1cecd25c6aec228453038b5a257a9",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/genero/condenaron-a-12-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-dos-religiosas/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/intensa-manipulacion-condenaron-a-12-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-dos-nid27122022/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9bd4377ccedfbf2d2264a55b54c2225a44d9183275482ee3523ebf092292bac0",
"final_url": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/intensa-manipulacion-condenaron-a-12-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-dos-nid27122022/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 291,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainants, not identified. Sentence (20 years) and the choir-member nexus confirmed via El Universo.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-pedro-garcia-jose-obrero-guayaquil-ecuador",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Guayaquil, Ecuador",
"lat": -2.1894,
"lng": -79.8891,
"title": "Ecuador: parish priest convicted of abusing five girls from his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over children of the congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"José Obrero parish, Guayaquil"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal court, Guayaquil, Ecuador",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2018-05-18",
"outcome": "Parish priest Pedro Vicente García of the José Obrero church in Guayaquil was accused of sexually abusing five girls from his congregation. He fled and was placed on a most-wanted list, was arrested in Quito in August 2017, and was sentenced on 18 May 2018 to 20 years. The victim was a roughly 17-year-old member of the church choir."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were girls of the priest's own congregation, over whom he held direct pastoral authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eltelegrafo.com.ec/noticias/judicial/12/fuero-corte-abuso-sexual-curas-sacerdotes",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Fuero de corte no cobija el abuso sexual de curas', El Telégrafo (Ecuador), 2018.",
"body": "Ecuadorian national newspaper covering the prosecution and conviction of the Guayaquil parish priest.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2018/05/18/nota/6765720/dictan-20-anos-prision-sacerdote-violacion-guayaquil/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Dictan 20 años de prisión para sacerdote, por violación en Guayaquil', El Universo, 18 May 2018.",
"body": "Confirms the 20-year sentence and the complainant's membership of the church choir.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eltelegrafo.com.ec/noticias/judicial/12/fuero-corte-abuso-sexual-curas-sacerdotes",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9c2a051b391c0d02d74490fe3c6d00f639f3ab3206acc7b5e33e114c762e34a5",
"final_url": "https://www.eltelegrafo.com.ec/noticias/judicial/12/fuero-corte-abuso-sexual-curas-sacerdotes"
},
{
"source": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2018/05/18/nota/6765720/dictan-20-anos-prision-sacerdote-violacion-guayaquil/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3f86911c81931b9d575c9d5b14e95ba6b7de29bc67f7f12d27fb4356fbd0b7ab",
"final_url": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2018/05/18/nota/6765720/dictan-20-anos-prision-sacerdote-violacion-guayaquil/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 292,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The defendant's full name was not published in the available reporting. Single source. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-guapulo-parish-priest-child-abuse-ecuador",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Guápulo, Quito, Ecuador",
"lat": -0.1928,
"lng": -78.4692,
"title": "Ecuador: parish priest sentenced to over nine years for abusing a ten-year-old girl",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority within the parish"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal court, Quito, Ecuador",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-10-24",
"outcome": "A parish priest from the Guápulo sector of Quito was sentenced to nine years and four months' imprisonment for the sexual abuse of a ten-year-old girl."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was within the parish over which the defendant held pastoral authority, which is what afforded him access to her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2019/10/24/nota/7573148/cura-violacion-sacerdote-guapulo-sentencia-ecuador-2019/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote fue condenado a 9 años y 4 meses de prisión por abuso sexual a niña en Guápulo', El Universo, 24 Oct. 2019.",
"body": "Ecuador's paper of record reports the conviction and the sentence imposed.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2019/10/24/nota/7573148/cura-violacion-sacerdote-guapulo-sentencia-ecuador-2019/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0ff714dc456528d4da4747ebee16bbbcfe24c0f0fa1301b0b2e34e44aba65e21",
"final_url": "https://www.eluniverso.com/noticias/2019/10/24/nota/7573148/cura-violacion-sacerdote-guapulo-sentencia-ecuador-2019/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 293,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Single source, though it is Guatemala's leading paper of record and names the specialised court. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-oswaldo-solares-pastor-child-assault-guatemala",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Guatemala City, Guatemala",
"lat": 14.6349,
"lng": -90.5069,
"title": "Guatemala: pastor sentenced to 18 years for sexually assaulting an eleven-year-old in the church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral role used to bring the child into a private room in the church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Sentencia Penal de Delitos de Femicidio y otras Formas de Violencia contra la Mujer y Violencia Sexual, Guatemala",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "Evangelical pastor Oswaldo Salomón Solares Ramos was sentenced to 18 years for repeatedly sexually assaulting an eleven-year-old girl between 2019 and 2020. The court found he used his standing as an evangelical pastor to bring the child into a private room."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's finding was explicit: the defendant used the figure of the evangelical pastor to obtain the child's compliance and to isolate her within the church building.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.prensalibre.com/guatemala/justicia/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-agredio-sexualmente-a-una-menor-de-edad-entre-2019-y-2020-breaking/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a pastor evangélico: agredió sexualmente a una menor de edad entre 2019 y 2020', Prensa Libre (2023).",
"body": "Guatemala's paper of record reports the 18-year sentence and the court's finding on the pastoral role used to commit the offence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.prensalibre.com/guatemala/justicia/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-agredio-sexualmente-a-una-menor-de-edad-entre-2019-y-2020-breaking/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0db154eb24262b04bea1c4fbc49b0f2c20d2c7e42ce35d14cb6896c3980d687d",
"final_url": "https://www.prensalibre.com/guatemala/justicia/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-agredio-sexualmente-a-una-menor-de-edad-entre-2019-y-2020-breaking/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 294,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. Reported as among the first criminal convictions of a Catholic priest in the Philippines, which is recorded as context rather than as a legal finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mark-batolne-bishops-house-scholar-philippines",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Baguio City, Benguet, Philippines",
"lat": 16.4023,
"lng": 120.596,
"title": "Philippines: priest convicted of raping a scholar housed in the Bishop's residence",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"diocesan priest and diocesan finance administrator"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional authority of the diocese over a sponsored scholar",
"victim housed on church property under his administration"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Baguio"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Trial Court Branch 2, Baguio City, Philippines",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-12-17",
"outcome": "Diocesan priest and finance administrator Mark Batolne was convicted on three counts of rape of a 16-year-old diocesan scholar who was staying in the Bishop's House compound, and sentenced to reclusion perpetua on each count."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a diocese-sponsored scholar housed inside the Bishop's residence, under the institutional and spiritual authority of the diocese and of its finance administrator; the assaults occurred in her assigned room within that church compound.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rappler.com/philippines/luzon/baguio-priest-mark-batolne-convicted-rape-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Baguio priest convicted of raping minor', Rappler, 17 Dec. 2025.",
"body": "Reports the three-count conviction, the reclusion perpetua sentences, and the victim's status as a diocesan scholar housed on church property.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rappler.com/philippines/luzon/baguio-priest-mark-batolne-convicted-rape-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5b8ff41cf86f149b4d6dd78b60520a11407972dc7ed178435382f04140a04b7b",
"final_url": "https://www.rappler.com/philippines/luzon/baguio-priest-mark-batolne-convicted-rape-minor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 295,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Sentence increased to 11 years."
},
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2021-04-13",
"note": "Cassation rejected; conviction final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Confirmed through trial, appeal and cassation. Indonesian-language sourcing, read in the original.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-hanny-layantara-surabaya-congregant-indonesia",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Surabaya, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.2575,
"lng": 112.7521,
"title": "Indonesia: pastor's 11-year sentence for abusing a congregant he had informally adopted",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Protestant pastor (pendeta)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"combined pastoral and quasi-parental authority over a congregant taken into his household"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Surabaya District Court; High Court; Supreme Court of Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction, increased on appeal, cassation rejected",
"date": "2021-04-13",
"outcome": "Pastor Hanny Layantara was sentenced by the Surabaya District Court to 10 years for sexually abusing a member of his congregation whom he had informally adopted, from roughly age 10–12 until age 15. The sentence was increased to 11 years on appeal, and the Supreme Court rejected his cassation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a member (jemaat) of the defendant's own church whom he had taken into his household, so that pastoral authority and quasi-parental control operated together to make the abuse unrefusable.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5529341/kasasi-kandas-pendeta-di-surabaya-dibui-11-tahun-karena-cabuli-jemaatnya",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kasasi Kandas, Pendeta di Surabaya Dibui 11 Tahun karena Cabuli Jemaatnya', Detik.com, 13 Apr. 2021.",
"body": "Reports the Supreme Court's rejection of cassation and the final 11-year sentence for abuse of a member of his congregation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Sentence increased to 11 years."
},
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2021-04-13",
"note": "Cassation rejected; conviction final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5529341/kasasi-kandas-pendeta-di-surabaya-dibui-11-tahun-karena-cabuli-jemaatnya",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3cfb2692907e5493d8a9d9621047cdefb341f840facdecfeb55eedb6f1838d23",
"final_url": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5529341/kasasi-kandas-pendeta-di-surabaya-dibui-11-tahun-karena-cabuli-jemaatnya"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 296,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The precise relationship of each victim to the defendant's congregation was not fully specified in the reporting located. This record notes a capital sentence; the database takes no position on the penalty. Indonesian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-sepriyanto-snae-alor-candidate-pastor-indonesia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Alor, East Nusa Tenggara, Indonesia",
"lat": -8.2667,
"lng": 124.5333,
"title": "Indonesia: candidate pastor sentenced to death for raping nine children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"candidate pastor (calon pendeta)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"church standing giving access to and trust from children in the community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kalabahi District Court, Alor, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-03-09",
"outcome": "Sepriyanto Ayub Snae, a candidate pastor in Alor, was sentenced to death by the Kalabahi District Court for raping nine children over an extended period."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "His position as a candidate pastor is what gave him access to and the trust of children within the church community in which the offences occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20230309160243-12-923012/calon-pendeta-cabul-di-alor-ntt-divonis-hukuman-mati",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Calon Pendeta Cabul di Alor NTT Divonis Hukuman Mati', CNN Indonesia, 9 Mar. 2023.",
"body": "Reports the Kalabahi District Court's sentence and the number of child victims.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20230309160243-12-923012/calon-pendeta-cabul-di-alor-ntt-divonis-hukuman-mati",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ab312a3b98bbac15f1f5cf53b5af533b4673253c2b1790cca5b8d24eb7241214",
"final_url": "https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20230309160243-12-923012/calon-pendeta-cabul-di-alor-ntt-divonis-hukuman-mati"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 297,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "regional-court",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Sentence upheld on appeal."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The exact date of the appellate confirmation was not pinned down. Slovak-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-ladislav-jurcik-altar-server-slovakia",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Sása, Slovakia",
"lat": 48.5167,
"lng": 19.1667,
"title": "Slovakia: first priest to receive an unconditional sentence for abusing an altar server",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority over an altar server serving directly under him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Slovak district court; Regional Court in Banská Bystrica",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; upheld on appeal",
"date": "2016-01-01",
"outcome": "Former parish priest Ladislav Jurčík was convicted of sexually abusing an altar server (miništrant) from the age of 12, between 2002 and 2005, and sentenced to three years and four months. The Regional Court in Banská Bystrica upheld the sentence on appeal. He was reported as the first Slovak priest to receive an unconditional custodial sentence for such abuse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was an altar server assisting the defendant directly in liturgical duties — a child serving under the priest's supervision, which is the relationship the abuse exploited.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.zilinak.sk/clanky/23604/farar-ktory-zneuzival-12-rocneho-ministranta-posobil-aj-v-sucanoch-dostal-trest-3-rokya4mesiace",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Farár, ktorý zneužíval 12-ročného miništranta... dostal trest 3 roky a 4 mesiace', Žilinak.sk (2016).",
"body": "Slovak regional outlet reporting the conviction, the sentence, and the altar-server relationship.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "regional-court",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Sentence upheld on appeal."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.zilinak.sk/clanky/23604/farar-ktory-zneuzival-12-rocneho-ministranta-posobil-aj-v-sucanoch-dostal-trest-3-rokya4mesiace",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "56b17084e0695d33e1503417a24290af89252dedf50dbda144d6e19e535f059e",
"final_url": "https://www.zilinak.sk/clanky/23604/farar-ktory-zneuzival-12-rocneho-ministranta-posobil-aj-v-sucanoch-dostal-trest-3-rokya4mesiace"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 298,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The defendant's name was withheld in Hungarian reporting under domestic privacy norms. Minor victims are not identified. Hungarian-language sourcing. NON-FINAL: the verdict is first-instance (nem jogerős) with an appeal pending; the defendant remains in custody. Revisit when the appellate outcome is known.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-kiskunfelegyhaza-priest-trust-exploitation-hungary",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Kiskunfélegyháza, Hungary",
"lat": 46.7108,
"lng": 19.8517,
"title": "Hungary: priest sentenced to nine years, court finding he exploited the trust placed in a clergyman",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"exploitation of the trust placed in him as a respected clergyman, in place of force"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court, Kiskunfélegyháza, Hungary",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-26",
"outcome": "A Catholic parish priest was sentenced to nine years' imprisonment, plus a nine-year ban from public office and a permanent occupational ban, for sexual abuse of minors and of a child under 14. The court found he had exploited the trust placed in him as a respected clergyman rather than using force."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's own finding supplies the nexus: the children regarded the defendant as a trusted religious confidant, and it was that trust — not force — that he used to approach and abuse them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://hirado.hu/belfold/cikk/2026/05/26/kilenc-ev-bortonre-iteltek-egy-plebanost-fiatalkoruakkal-es-egy-kiskoruval-szembeni-szexualis-visszaeles-miatt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kilenc év börtönre ítéltek egy plébánost...', hirado.hu (Hungarian public media), 26 May 2026.",
"body": "Hungarian public broadcaster reports the nine-year sentence and the court's finding on exploitation of clerical trust.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://index.hu/belfold/2026/05/26/kiskunfelegyhaza-plebanos-borton-fiatalkoruak-szexualis-visszaeles/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kilenc év börtönre ítéltek egy plébánost', Index.hu, 26 May 2026.",
"body": "Second Hungarian outlet corroborating the verdict and its non-final status.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://hirado.hu/belfold/cikk/2026/05/26/kilenc-ev-bortonre-iteltek-egy-plebanost-fiatalkoruakkal-es-egy-kiskoruval-szembeni-szexualis-visszaeles-miatt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3a2cbcc14e1af6545469ff2cafe03153e9bc9c1bdce09dace9ffb0ee3c17525b",
"final_url": "https://hirado.hu/belfold/cikk/2026/05/26/kilenc-ev-bortonre-iteltek-egy-plebanost-fiatalkoruakkal-es-egy-kiskoruval-szembeni-szexualis-visszaeles-miatt"
},
{
"source": "https://index.hu/belfold/2026/05/26/kiskunfelegyhaza-plebanos-borton-fiatalkoruak-szexualis-visszaeles/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cc6783780f929f09161f31f2b87ccd4cc292f5302c87d9ef9b2ade267edf0529",
"final_url": "https://index.hu/belfold/2026/05/26/kiskunfelegyhaza-plebanos-borton-fiatalkoruak-szexualis-visszaeles/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 299,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2026-05-17",
"note": "Defence sought a sentence reduction on appeal; conviction stands pending outcome."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Conviction stands but is not final, with an appeal pending as of May 2026. Italian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-andrea-melis-chierichetto-savona-italy",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Genoa, tried in Savona, Italy",
"lat": 44.4056,
"lng": 8.9463,
"title": "Italy: priest sentenced to 10 years for repeated sexual violence against a 12-year-old altar boy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest and former elementary school director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority over an altar boy in the parish",
"grooming with gifts"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal of Savona, Italy",
"stage": "conviction and sentence (appeal pending)",
"date": "2025-10-24",
"outcome": "Don Andrea Melis was sentenced to 10 years by the Tribunal of Savona for repeated sexual abuse of a 12-year-old altar boy, groomed with gifts including video games, designer clothing and phone credit. As of May 2026 his lawyers were seeking a reduced sentence on appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was the priest's altar boy — a liturgical role placing the child directly under his supervision and spiritual authority in the parish.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/cronaca/2025/10/24/violenza-sessuale-su-minore-prete-condannato-a-10-anni_db3494d1-f304-4f85-940b-3eabdc20a6ea.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Violenza sessuale su minore, prete condannato a 10 anni', ANSA, 24 Oct. 2025.",
"body": "Italy's national news agency reports the Savona tribunal's 10-year sentence for abuse of an altar boy.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2026-05-17",
"note": "Defence sought a sentence reduction on appeal; conviction stands pending outcome."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/cronaca/2025/10/24/violenza-sessuale-su-minore-prete-condannato-a-10-anni_db3494d1-f304-4f85-940b-3eabdc20a6ea.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e4f596f072f6654f2308f89d4609a2162495729f549011f8649d65f84f5d9607",
"final_url": "https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/cronaca/2025/10/24/violenza-sessuale-su-minore-prete-condannato-a-10-anni_db3494d1-f304-4f85-940b-3eabdc20a6ea.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 300,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The criminal sentence length was not stated in the source located, which focused on the later canonical penalty; the 18-count conviction is confirmed. Portuguese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-albino-meireles-braga-parish-abuse-portugal",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Braga, Portugal",
"lat": 41.5454,
"lng": -8.4265,
"title": "Portugal: priest convicted on 18 counts of child sexual abuse from parish activities",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of the Braga diocese"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"access through church-organised parish holiday activities",
"trust built with a family through his pastoral role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Braga"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Portuguese criminal court, Braga",
"stage": "conviction; subsequent canonical penalty",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"outcome": "Priest Albino Fernando Tristão Meireles was convicted on 18 counts of child sexual abuse and one count of child pornography, involving three children of one family — the eldest aged ten at the time, abused during parish holiday activities — and a minor contacted online. In April 2026 the Archdiocese of Braga dismissed him from the clerical state following the criminal conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The abuse arose from church-organised parish activities and from the trust the defendant built with a family through his pastoral role; that role is what created the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://sol.iol.pt/sociedade/noticias/padre-condenado-por-18-crimes-de-abuso-sexual-em-braga-recebeu-agora-a-sentenca-da-igreja/20260526/6a15a77d0cf2d0ed34b85b00",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Padre condenado por 18 crimes de abuso sexual em Braga recebeu agora a sentença da Igreja', SOL (Portugal), 26 May 2026.",
"body": "Portuguese national outlet recording the 18-count criminal conviction and the subsequent dismissal from the clerical state.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-and-canonical-penalty"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://sol.iol.pt/sociedade/noticias/padre-condenado-por-18-crimes-de-abuso-sexual-em-braga-recebeu-agora-a-sentenca-da-igreja/20260526/6a15a77d0cf2d0ed34b85b00",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-and-canonical-penalty.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "95c3256e6ec9d19bc0b4b06be546625bb518e8b33744ce34f561fccdc4fc9221",
"final_url": "https://sol.iol.pt/sociedade/noticias/padre-condenado-por-18-crimes-de-abuso-sexual-em-braga-recebeu-agora-a-sentenca-da-igreja/20260526/6a15a77d0cf2d0ed34b85b00"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 301,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The exact verdict date and any appeal were not confirmed. Verification pass added the concurrent-sentence nuance and independent corroboration (Sri Lanka Mirror's roundup of four Anuradhapura child-crimes convictions, Lanka C News in Sinhala, Tamil Guardian).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-mulleriyawa-wimalatissa-ordination-abuse-sri-lanka",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Thambuttegama, Anuradhapura, Sri Lanka",
"lat": 8.15,
"lng": 80.5,
"title": "Sri Lanka: chief monk sentenced to 30 years for abusing a boy who came to be ordained",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"chief incumbent (head monk) of the temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic authority over a boy presenting himself for ordination"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Sri Sambuddha Walukarama Temple"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Anuradhapura Special High Court for Child Crimes, Sri Lanka",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-29",
"outcome": "The 65-year-old chief incumbent of Sri Sambuddha Walukarama Temple was convicted of sexually abusing a 14-year-old boy who had come to the temple to be ordained, and was sentenced to 30 years' rigorous imprisonment. The abuse occurred on the night the boy arrived. Detailed reporting records the three ten-year terms as ordered to run concurrently (an effective ten years) in view of the accused's illnesses, beneath the thirty-year nominal headline; Rs 500,000 compensation was ordered, with six further months if unpaid."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boy came to the temple specifically to be ordained under the chief monk's religious authority — an initiate immediately and wholly subject to that authority at the moment of the harm.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/14279/monk-jailed-30-years-for-sexually-abusing-14-year-old-boy-at-temple/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Monk jailed 30 years for sexually abusing 14-year-old boy at temple', Asian Mirror (2026).",
"body": "Sri Lankan outlet reporting the Special High Court conviction, the 30-year sentence, and the ordination context.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://srilankamirror.com/news/4-jailed-for-total-of-101-years-over-child-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'4 jailed for total of 101 years over child sexual abuse', Sri Lanka Mirror.",
"body": "Independent coverage of the Anuradhapura Special High Court convictions.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/14279/monk-jailed-30-years-for-sexually-abusing-14-year-old-boy-at-temple/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b1d62b5526b364cba6992529376d2fabc220d05e8a63c87abfff93aa9b7332f1",
"final_url": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/monk-jailed-30-years-for-sexually-abusing-14-year-old-boy-at-temple/"
},
{
"source": "https://srilankamirror.com/news/4-jailed-for-total-of-101-years-over-child-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fc18e4e104fa4fa1145b76ff3b68854b36d4f028b14c1b291ec823a2579a82d2",
"final_url": "https://srilankamirror.com/news/4-jailed-for-total-of-101-years-over-child-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 302,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainant, not identified. The exact year of conviction was not confirmed in the sourcing located and is recorded as approximate; a single source was found. Treated as medium-confidence pending Nepali-language corroboration.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-tulku-lama-monastery-captivity-rape-nepal",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Chalnakhel, Dakshinkali, Nepal",
"lat": 27.6167,
"lng": 85.2833,
"title": "Nepal: self-styled tulku convicted of raping a woman held at his monastery for over nine years",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled tulku and spiritual guru operating a monastery"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed status as a reincarnate lama",
"sustained confinement at the monastery he ran"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Patan High Court, Nepal",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "A self-styled Buddhist spiritual guru known as Tulku Lama (Rinpoche Chhulthim Dorje Yontan Yongaj) was convicted of rape by the Patan High Court and sentenced to seven years. The court heard the victim had been held at a monastery he operated for more than nine years and raped repeatedly."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was kept at the monastery under the defendant's claimed authority as a reincarnate lama for over nine years — an extreme and sustained instance of religious authority producing captivity.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://thehimalayantimes.com/kathmandu/spiritual-guru-tulku-lama-convicted-of-rape",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Spiritual guru Tulku Lama convicted of rape', The Himalayan Times.",
"body": "Nepal's English-language paper of record reporting the Patan High Court conviction and the years of confinement at the monastery.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://thehimalayantimes.com/kathmandu/spiritual-guru-tulku-lama-convicted-of-rape",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "061caf475c2069117f1ce626aaa32b080b78fb49704d5c808d2af25113cd7fa0",
"final_url": "https://thehimalayantimes.com/kathmandu/spiritual-guru-tulku-lama-convicted-of-rape"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 303,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims at the time of the offences, not identified. Single source, from the national public broadcaster with named-defendant reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-rowan-donoghue-st-bedes-boarders-new-zealand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Christchurch, New Zealand",
"lat": -43.5321,
"lng": 172.6362,
"title": "New Zealand: former priest jailed for abusing boarding students at a Catholic college",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest at a Catholic boarding college"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"in loco parentis authority over boarders living at the school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St Bede's College, Christchurch"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Christchurch District Court, New Zealand",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-01",
"outcome": "Former St Bede's College priest Rowan Donoghue was sentenced to seven years and eight months after admitting six charges of indecent assault and sexual violation involving four boys who boarded at the school between 1996 and 2000."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were boarders at a Catholic school where the defendant served as priest, living under his combined religious and in loco parentis authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/crime-and-justice/595096/former-st-bede-s-college-priest-rowan-donoghue-jailed-for-sexual-abuse-of-boys",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former St Bede's College priest Rowan Donoghue jailed for sexual abuse of boys', RNZ (2026).",
"body": "New Zealand's public broadcaster reports the guilty pleas, the charges, and the sentence imposed.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/crime-and-justice/595096/former-st-bede-s-college-priest-rowan-donoghue-jailed-for-sexual-abuse-of-boys",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "31c5187bc83f43ffd7f4097d9c5d11a31ba5467937d276b4d4ba21424a277308",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/crime-and-justice/595096/former-st-bede-s-college-priest-rowan-donoghue-jailed-for-sexual-abuse-of-boys"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 304,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Single source and partly paywalled; the specific court was not confirmed. Treated as medium-confidence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-siosateki-faletau-pacific-church-pastor-new-zealand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Auckland, New Zealand",
"lat": -36.8485,
"lng": 174.7633,
"title": "New Zealand: church pastor sentenced for assaulting girls from his congregation over two decades",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Pacific Island church pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over girls in the congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New Zealand courts",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-01",
"outcome": "Pacific Island church pastor and businessman Siosateki Tonga Faletau pleaded guilty to assaulting girls as young as ten, with offending between 2001 and 2020, and was sentenced to two years and three months."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were girls of the congregation the defendant pastored; his pastoral standing is what gave him access to them across two decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/pacific-island-church-pastor-sentenced-for-molesting-girls-over-two-decades/7HR7CU7QYOB4VHENZJPA57S2TY/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pacific Island church pastor sentenced for molesting girls over two decades', NZ Herald (2026).",
"body": "New Zealand's paper of record reports the guilty plea, the offending period, and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/pacific-island-church-pastor-sentenced-for-molesting-girls-over-two-decades/7HR7CU7QYOB4VHENZJPA57S2TY/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12e39253af94b0b2bc2f6ba1ed0f8a082235c3a2b6b9b228c3612d4e731a6385",
"final_url": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/pacific-island-church-pastor-sentenced-for-molesting-girls-over-two-decades/7HR7CU7QYOB4VHENZJPA57S2TY/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 305,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2026-03-30",
"note": "Conviction upheld; sentence reduced from 40 to 30 years."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Both the trial judgment and the appellate decision are published on ULII, Uganda's free law portal, and are cited as the record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-elijah-kimera-faith-centre-choir-uganda",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Lusanja, Wakiso District, Uganda",
"lat": 0.3833,
"lng": 32.55,
"title": "Uganda: self-proclaimed prophet convicted of defiling choir members from his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed prophet and church proprietor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"prophetic authority over a family that were members of his church",
"children participating in the church choir"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Faith Centre Church of All Nations, Lusanja"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Uganda (Criminal Division), Criminal Sessions Case 154 of 2021; Court of Appeal of Uganda, Criminal Appeal 241 of 2024",
"stage": "conviction on plea and sentence; conviction upheld, sentence reduced",
"date": "2024-03-18",
"outcome": "Prophet Elijah James Kimera, proprietor of Faith Centre Church of All Nations, was sentenced on 18 March 2024 to 40 years after pleading guilty to aggravated defilement. The victim, her siblings and their mother were members of his church, where the children sang in the choir. On 30 March 2026 the Court of Appeal upheld the conviction but reduced the sentence to 30 years, finding the High Court had placed excessive weight on aggravating and collateral factors."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's whole family were members of the defendant's church and the children sang in its choir; it was his standing as their prophet and church proprietor that secured the family's trust and the access the offences required.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ulii.org/en/akn/ug/judgment/ughccrd/2024/85/eng@2024-03-18",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Uganda v Prophet Kimera Elijah James (Criminal Sessions Case 154 of 2021) [2024] UGHCCRD 85 (18 March 2024).",
"body": "The High Court judgment convicting and sentencing the defendant for aggravated defilement.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "trial-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://ulii.org/en/akn/ug/judgment/ugca/2026/94/eng@2026-03-30",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Prophet Kimera Elijah James v Uganda (Criminal Appeal 241 of 2024) [2026] UGCA 94 (30 March 2026).",
"body": "The Court of Appeal judgment upholding the conviction and reducing the sentence to 30 years.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2026-03-30",
"note": "Conviction upheld; sentence reduced from 40 to 30 years."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ulii.org/en/akn/ug/judgment/ughccrd/2024/85/eng@2024-03-18",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: trial-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://ulii.org/en/akn/ug/judgment/ugca/2026/94/eng@2026-03-30",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 306,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Corroborated across several Nigerian papers of record. The court acquitted on the bigamy count, which is recorded for accuracy.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-ajiboye-olayinka-kwara-congregants-nigeria",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Ganmo, Ifelodun, Kwara State, Nigeria",
"lat": 8.4167,
"lng": 4.6333,
"title": "Nigeria: general overseer sentenced to life for raping three minor congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"general overseer of a ministry"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority as general overseer over minor congregants",
"abuse inside the church Mission House",
"forced abortions to conceal the offences"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [
"Divine Land of Joy and Prayer Ministry"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kwara State High Court, Ilorin, Nigeria",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-14",
"outcome": "Prophet Ajiboye Abayomi Olayinka, general overseer of Divine Land of Joy and Prayer Ministry, was sentenced to life imprisonment for unlawful sexual intercourse with three minors in his congregation, and to a further 14 years for procuring illegal abortions for the victims. The court found the offences occurred inside the church's Mission House at Ganmo. The prosecution did not establish a further count of bigamy."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were minor members of the defendant's own congregation, and the court established that the offences occurred inside the church's Mission House — his authority as general overseer supplying both the access and the concealment.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://punchng.com/pastor-bags-life-jail-for-sexually-assaulting-minors-in-kwara/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor bags life jail for sexually assaulting minors in Kwara', Punch (Nigeria), May 2026.",
"body": "Nigerian paper of record reporting the life sentence, the additional 14-year term, and the court's findings on where the offences occurred.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://punchng.com/pastor-bags-life-jail-for-sexually-assaulting-minors-in-kwara/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f7b97103de715d9baf0a52de13610d0778d618d58a2d9b80eeb26c8ac3bde907",
"final_url": "https://punchng.com/pastor-bags-life-jail-for-sexually-assaulting-minors-in-kwara/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 307,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event recording a statutory commission's finding, not a criminal conviction: no prosecution occurred and the Brother is anonymised in the report itself. Peter Tyrrell died in 1967, before the Commission existed, so the finding rests on Congregation-internal records and his written complaint and memoir rather than his testimony. He is named here because he published his own account; the Commission's pseudonym for him is not used.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1932-letterfrack-industrial-school-ryan-report-ireland",
"year": 1932,
"place": "Letterfrack, County Galway, Ireland",
"lat": 53.5539,
"lng": -9.9436,
"title": "Letterfrack: Ryan Report finding on abuse of a boy committed to a Christian Brothers industrial school",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious Brother resident at the industrial school",
"Congregation exercising in loco parentis custody over committed children"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial and disciplinary authority over a committed child",
"Congregation's refusal to engage with the complaint"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Letterfrack",
"Congregation of Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Commission), Ireland — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "statutory inquiry finding",
"date": "2009-05-20",
"outcome": "The Ryan Report recorded the case of Peter Tyrrell, resident at St Joseph's Industrial School, Letterfrack, from 1924 to 1932, who alleged in a 1953 letter to the Christian Brothers' Provincialate that he had been sexually and physically abused by a Brother anonymised in the report as 'Br Perryn'. The Commission found the Congregation was aware of that Brother's history — an internal Visitation Report of 1940–41 had already documented concerns — yet refused to engage with or acknowledge Tyrrell's complaint. No prosecution ever occurred."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boy was a committed ward of a Christian Brothers institution with no other guardian; the Brother held custodial, disciplinary and in loco parentis religious authority over him, and the Congregation's own authority is what absorbed and dismissed the complaint when it was made.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-304",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, 'Report' (Ryan Report), Vol. 1, ch. 8 (Letterfrack), para. 304 (20 May 2009).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry records the complaint, the Congregation's prior awareness through its own Visitation Report, and its refusal to engage with the complaint.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-304",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1f5b8fef3708c25ece2ed59153bf3b598aec664939fc52bef20b4af9f058e4f4",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-304"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 308,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event recording a 2014 royal commission finding about conduct in the 1940s and 1950s, built on survivor testimony rather than a contemporaneous judicial record. No prosecution occurred; Keaney died in 1954. Survivors are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1954-bindoon-farm-school-royal-commission-australia",
"year": 1954,
"place": "Bindoon, Western Australia, Australia",
"lat": -31.3833,
"lng": 116.1,
"title": "Bindoon Farm School: Royal Commission finding on abuse of child migrants in Christian Brothers care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Superior of a Christian Brothers farm school",
"Christian Brothers Provincial Council"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial authority over child migrants with no other guardian",
"internal management of allegations instead of reporting"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Bindoon Farm School",
"Congregation of Christian Brothers (Western Australia)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — Case Study No. 11",
"stage": "royal commission case-study finding",
"date": "2014-12-01",
"outcome": "The Royal Commission found that Brother Paul Francis Keaney, Superior of Bindoon Farm School, was named by multiple survivors as a perpetrator, one abused from age 11 to 16. Thirteen Brothers in total were named as perpetrators at Bindoon. The Commission found the Christian Brothers Provincial Council was aware of sexual-abuse allegations across Bindoon, Castledare, Clontarf and Tardun through the 1940s and 1950s but managed them internally rather than reporting them. Keaney died in 1954 and was never prosecuted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were migrants sent from Britain and Malta into Christian Brothers custody with no other guardian in the country; the Superior held the institution's supreme religious, custodial and disciplinary authority over them, and the Congregation's internal handling of allegations is what kept it intact.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-11-christian-brothers",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, 'Report of Case Study No. 11: Christian Brothers in Western Australia' (Dec. 2014).",
"body": "The royal commission records the perpetrators named at Bindoon and the Provincial Council's awareness and internal handling of allegations across the four institutions.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-11-christian-brothers",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 309,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainants, not identified. Reported by Pakistan's leading English daily.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-qari-anwar-madressah-karachi-pakistan",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Landhi, Karachi, Pakistan",
"lat": 24.8449,
"lng": 67.1913,
"title": "Pakistan: madressah teacher given two 15-year sentences for abusing his students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"madressah teacher (qari)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teaching authority over enrolled students",
"threats to secure silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions court, Karachi, Pakistan",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-20",
"outcome": "A Karachi court sentenced Qari Muhammad Anwar to two consecutive 15-year terms for sexually abusing two students, aged 13 and 17, inside a room at the madressah where he taught. The court heard he had threatened the boys to keep them silent."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were his enrolled madressah students; his authority as their religious teacher gave him both the private access within the school and the leverage to enforce silence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dawn.com/news/2001809/karachi-court-hands-cleric-double-15-year-sentences-for-sexually-abusing-two-madressah-students",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Karachi court hands cleric double 15-year sentences for sexually abusing two madressah students', Dawn, 20 May 2026.",
"body": "Pakistan's paper of record reports the two 15-year sentences and the madressah setting of the offences.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dawn.com/news/2001809/karachi-court-hands-cleric-double-15-year-sentences-for-sexually-abusing-two-madressah-students",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "330a95487bbaf0e863980282815b2281bd93ed7f61575a561cf2f1170f0fc69e",
"final_url": "https://www.dawn.com/news/2001809/karachi-court-hands-cleric-double-15-year-sentences-for-sexually-abusing-two-madressah-students"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 310,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainants, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-mohammed-saddique-madina-mosque-cardiff-uk",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.4816,
"lng": -3.1791,
"title": "United Kingdom: Cardiff imam jailed for 13 years for abusing girls in his religious classes",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam and mosque religious teacher of over thirty years"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious instruction of congregant children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Madina Mosque, Cardiff"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Crown Court, Wales, United Kingdom",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2016-01-01",
"outcome": "Mohammed Haji Saddique, an imam who had taught at the Madina Mosque for more than thirty years, was convicted of fourteen offences — six indecent assaults and eight sexual assaults — against four young girls under his religious instruction between 1996 and 2006, and was jailed for thirteen years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The girls were children of the congregation receiving religious instruction from him; that teaching role, held for decades and trusted by their families, is what produced the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dawn.com/news/1344036",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cardiff imam jailed for 13 years for sexually abusing girls', Dawn (World), 2016.",
"body": "Reports the fourteen convictions and the thirteen-year sentence imposed on the long-serving mosque teacher.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dawn.com/news/1344036",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ebf2ad683a29084c061c81dc7c5fab933adbf4357613cef4103b59f7f05c0dd6",
"final_url": "https://www.dawn.com/news/1344036"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 311,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. Sentencing was still pending at the time of the reporting relied on; the conviction is recorded, the sentence is not.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-muhammod-islam-masjid-ul-abraar-chatham-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Chatham, Kent, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.38,
"lng": 0.52,
"title": "United Kingdom: former mosque leader convicted of abusing a girl from his Quran lessons",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam and Quran teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teaching authority over a child attending his lessons"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Masjid-Ul-Abraar mosque"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Maidstone Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction (sentencing pending at time of reporting)",
"date": "2026-06-29",
"outcome": "Muhammod Islam, also known as Rofiqul Islam, an imam and Quran teacher at the Masjid-Ul-Abraar mosque, was found guilty at Maidstone Crown Court of six counts of sexual assault of a child under 13 against a girl who attended his religious lessons. The offences dated to 2004."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a child attending the defendant's Quran lessons, where his standing as imam and teacher gave him the access and authority the offences relied on.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/medway/news/former-mosque-leader-found-guilty-of-abusing-young-girl-342104/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former mosque leader found guilty of abusing young girl', Kent Online, 29 June 2026.",
"body": "Reports the Maidstone Crown Court verdict on six counts and the religious-lesson setting.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/medway/news/former-mosque-leader-found-guilty-of-abusing-young-girl-342104/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3c66517f36a889b8bc3ab217f59fa21bcef67c65c743558e4fdbcfba6b26d3e6",
"final_url": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/medway/news/former-mosque-leader-found-guilty-of-abusing-young-girl-342104/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 312,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-nazim-uddin-rahmania-academy-chattogram-bangladesh",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Panchlaish, Chattogram, Bangladesh",
"lat": 22.3569,
"lng": 91.8317,
"title": "Bangladesh: madrasa director jailed until death for raping six child students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"director and teacher of a Quran academy"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teaching and institutional authority over enrolled child students"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Rahmania Tahfizul Quran Academy"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal under the Women and Children Repression Prevention Act, Chattogram, Bangladesh",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-06-04",
"outcome": "Nazim Uddin, director and teacher at the Rahmania Tahfizul Quran Academy, was sentenced to imprisonment until death for raping six child students under the Women and Children Repression Prevention Act."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were children enrolled at the Quran academy the defendant directed; his combined religious and institutional authority over their education is what made the abuse possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bdnews24.com/bangladesh/e101f3488ce2",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Madrasa teacher jailed until death for rape in Chattogram', bdnews24.com, 4 June 2025.",
"body": "Bangladeshi national news agency reporting the sentence and the number of child victims.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bdnews24.com/bangladesh/e101f3488ce2",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 313,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The full court name was not confirmed in the English-language coverage located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-hasmat-ali-markazut-tahfiz-dhaka-bangladesh",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Dakshinkhan, Dhaka, Bangladesh",
"lat": 23.87,
"lng": 90.42,
"title": "Bangladesh: madrasa teacher given life imprisonment for raping a student",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"madrasa teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teaching authority over an enrolled student"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Alkasim Markazut Tahfiz Madrasa"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court in Dhaka, Bangladesh",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-02-01",
"outcome": "Hasmat Ali, a teacher at the Alkasim Markazut Tahfiz Madrasa, was convicted of raping a student in November 2019 and sentenced to life imprisonment with a fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a student enrolled at the madrasa where the defendant taught, subject to his religious teaching authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bdnews24.com/bangladesh/7l3vzxlc8n",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Court jails madrasa teacher for life in case over rape of student', bdnews24.com, Feb. 2023.",
"body": "Bangladeshi national news agency reporting the life sentence for the rape of a madrasa student.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bdnews24.com/bangladesh/7l3vzxlc8n",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 314,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainants, not identified. Indonesian-language sourcing, read in the original.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-fadilla-ramadhan-pesantren-depok-indonesia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Depok, West Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.4025,
"lng": 106.7942,
"title": "Indonesia: pesantren teacher sentenced to 18 years for abusing female students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pesantren teacher (ustaz)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teaching authority over female boarding students (santri)"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Pondok Pesantren Riyadhul Janah"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Depok (Depok District Court), Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-02-02",
"outcome": "Ustaz Achmad Fadilla Ramadhan, a teacher at the Pondok Pesantren Riyadhul Janah, was convicted of sexually abusing female santri under his religious instruction and sentenced to 18 years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were female santri boarding at the pesantren where the defendant taught, living under his religious instruction and the institution's authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20230202063418-12-907876/cabuli-santriwati-ustaz-ponpes-di-depok-divonis-18-tahun-penjara",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cabuli Santriwati, Ustaz Ponpes di Depok Divonis 18 Tahun Penjara', CNN Indonesia, 2 Feb. 2023.",
"body": "Reports the Depok District Court's 18-year sentence for abuse of female boarding students.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20230202063418-12-907876/cabuli-santriwati-ustaz-ponpes-di-depok-divonis-18-tahun-penjara",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9fda134cc297963762db9eb911d92eaa580add2391924359f23ddc3b785dca26",
"final_url": "https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20230202063418-12-907876/cabuli-santriwati-ustaz-ponpes-di-depok-divonis-18-tahun-penjara"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 315,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The sentence includes a chemical-castration order under Indonesian law; the database records the disposition without endorsing the penalty. Indonesian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-m-sahnan-pesantren-sumenep-indonesia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Sumenep, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.0167,
"lng": 113.8667,
"title": "Indonesia: pesantren head sentenced to 20 years for abusing eight boarding students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pesantren foundation chairman and ustaz"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious and institutional authority over resident male santri"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District court, Sumenep, East Java, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-01",
"outcome": "M Sahnan, an ustaz and pesantren foundation chairman, was sentenced to 20 years' imprisonment together with two years of chemical castration for abusing eight male santri under his authority."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were male santri resident at the pesantren the defendant headed, subject to his religious and institutional authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8252828/cabuli-8-santri-pengasuh-ponpes-di-sumenep-divonis-20-tahun-bui-kebiri-kimia",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cabuli 8 Santri, Pengasuh Ponpes di Sumenep Divonis 20 Tahun Bui-Kebiri Kimia', detikNews (2026).",
"body": "Reports the 20-year sentence and accompanying order for the pesantren head who abused eight boarding students.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8252828/cabuli-8-santri-pengasuh-ponpes-di-sumenep-divonis-20-tahun-bui-kebiri-kimia",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d2e5caf4eb1007122194791aa679debe609800ac1f8db5be24c157daacc1b41a",
"final_url": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8252828/cabuli-8-santri-pengasuh-ponpes-di-sumenep-divonis-20-tahun-bui-kebiri-kimia"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 316,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Malay-language sourcing, read in the original.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mohd-faizal-man-tahfiz-mersing-malaysia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Air Papan, Mersing, Johor, Malaysia",
"lat": 2.4833,
"lng": 103.8333,
"title": "Malaysia: tahfiz school teacher convicted on 15 charges of abusing a resident student",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"tahfiz (Quran memorisation) assistant teacher and dormitory warden"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teaching authority combined with nighttime dormitory custody"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions Court (Mahkamah Sesyen), Kota Tinggi, Johor, Malaysia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-02-13",
"outcome": "Mohd Faizal Man, an assistant teacher at a tahfiz school, was convicted on 15 charges of sexual abuse against a 14-year-old male student in a dormitory room between May and October 2024."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a resident student at the tahfiz school where the defendant taught and served as dormitory warden; that combination of religious instruction and custodial control at night is what made the abuse unrefusable.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kosmo.com.my/2025/02/13/malam-malam-panjat-katil-pelajar-ustaz-dijel-150-tahun/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Malam-malam panjat katil pelajar, ustaz dijel', Kosmo Digital, 13 Feb. 2025.",
"body": "Malaysian national outlet reporting the Sessions Court conviction on 15 charges and the dormitory setting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kosmo.com.my/2025/02/13/malam-malam-panjat-katil-pelajar-ustaz-dijel-150-tahun/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "94241033e7e9db82ed2b20242b917ba325fb6e92c5caf59df12e8e2cc6519299",
"final_url": "https://www.kosmo.com.my/2025/02/13/malam-malam-panjat-katil-pelajar-ustaz-dijel-150-tahun/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 317,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "A separate proceeding from the 2018 Jodhpur conviction already recorded in this database; both are listed because they are distinct cases with distinct complainants. The complainant is an adult and is not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-asaram-ahmedabad-ashram-disciple-india",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India",
"lat": 23.0225,
"lng": 72.5714,
"title": "India: second life sentence for Asaram Bapu for raping a disciple at his Ahmedabad ashram",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled godman and ashram head"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru authority over a resident adult disciple"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions court, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-01-31",
"outcome": "In a case legally distinct from his 2018 Jodhpur conviction, Asaram Bapu was found guilty of repeatedly raping a woman disciple at his Ahmedabad ashram in 2013 and sentenced to life imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was an adult disciple resident at the defendant's own ashram, inside the guru-disciple relationship on which his authority over her rested.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://theprint.in/india/from-guru-to-habitual-offender-a-double-disgrace-for-jailed-asaram-as-he-gets-life-sentence-for-ahmedabad-ashram-rape-years-after-rajasthan-minor-case/1345724/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'From guru to habitual offender: Asaram gets life sentence for Ahmedabad ashram rape', ThePrint, Jan. 2023.",
"body": "Reports the second life sentence and distinguishes this Ahmedabad proceeding from the earlier Jodhpur case.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://theprint.in/india/from-guru-to-habitual-offender-a-double-disgrace-for-jailed-asaram-as-he-gets-life-sentence-for-ahmedabad-ashram-rape-years-after-rajasthan-minor-case/1345724/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8b8e7643080387029ab1af45be2ec6c4e1e99b30baca3ee2009218a9af6dda01",
"final_url": "https://theprint.in/india/from-guru-to-habitual-offender-a-double-disgrace-for-jailed-asaram-as-he-gets-life-sentence-for-ahmedabad-ashram-rape-years-after-rajasthan-minor-case/1345724/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 318,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The nexus here is the priest's standing and access at the temple rather than a ritual encounter, which is a thinner connection than most records in this database and is noted as such.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-thilagar-temple-priest-sivaganga-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Sozhapuram, Sivaganga, Tamil Nadu, India",
"lat": 9.8433,
"lng": 78.4809,
"title": "India: temple priest sentenced to 178 years for sexually assaulting three children",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"temple priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing and access as priest of the temple where the children were present"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "POCSO Court, Sivaganga, Tamil Nadu, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-03-31",
"outcome": "A. Thilagar, a 70-year-old temple priest, was convicted of sexually assaulting three children whom he lured with sweets near the temple, and was sentenced to 178 years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant's standing as the temple's priest is what gave him the trusted presence and access to children at the temple precinct that the offences relied on.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.uniindia.com/~/pocso-court-in-tn-awards-178-yr-jail-term-for-70-year-old-temple-priest-in-children-sexual-assault-case/States/news/3793688.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'POCSO Court in TN awards 178 yr jail term for 70-year-old temple priest', UNI India, 31 Mar. 2026.",
"body": "Indian news agency reporting the POCSO court conviction and the sentence imposed.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.uniindia.com/~/pocso-court-in-tn-awards-178-yr-jail-term-for-70-year-old-temple-priest-in-children-sexual-assault-case/States/news/3793688.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2354d0d7e293d7cd45529051173d86d31c397850ac39345c20c00ce5249a22fd",
"final_url": "https://www.uniindia.com/~/pocso-court-in-tn-awards-178-yr-jail-term-for-70-year-old-temple-priest-in-children-sexual-assault-case/States/news/3793688.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 319,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Sentencing was pending at the time of the reporting relied on.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-bineesh-temple-priest-possession-pooja-kerala-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, India",
"lat": 8.5241,
"lng": 76.9366,
"title": "India: temple priest convicted of abusing a girl after claiming she was possessed",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"temple priest engaged to perform a pooja"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false claim that the child was possessed",
"ritual authority over a pooja the mother had requested"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Kannammoola Balasubramanya Temple"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "POCSO District Court, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, India",
"stage": "conviction (sentencing pending at time of reporting)",
"date": "2026-02-26",
"outcome": "Bineesh, a temple priest engaged by a mother to perform a pooja for her daughter's exam anxiety, was found guilty of falsely claiming the child was possessed and then repeatedly sexually assaulting her in the temple's pooja room."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was brought to the priest specifically for a religious ritual, and he manufactured a claim of possession to justify continued private access to her — the ritual authority itself was the instrument of the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.onmanorama.com/news/kerala/2026/02/26/thiruvananthapuram-pocso-verdict.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former temple priest found guilty of sexually abusing minor who sought pooja for exam anxiety', Onmanorama, 26 Feb. 2026.",
"body": "Reports the POCSO court verdict and the possession claim used to obtain repeated private access to the child.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.onmanorama.com/news/kerala/2026/02/26/thiruvananthapuram-pocso-verdict.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ad0b2f0feded39d7d5f2accdd1aba4da74b23b95f916575f736b32f6bc01681d",
"final_url": "https://www.onmanorama.com/news/kerala/2026/02/26/thiruvananthapuram-pocso-verdict.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 320,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The defendant's name was not published in the prosecuting authority's release. Sourced to South Africa's National Prosecuting Authority.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-nebo-traditional-healer-cleansing-ritual-south-africa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Mokgaladi, Nebo, Limpopo, South Africa",
"lat": -24.9167,
"lng": 29.75,
"title": "South Africa: traditional healer given life for raping minors during a cleansing ritual",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"traditional healer engaged by the family for a cleansing ritual"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual authority over minors during a cleansing ceremony for claimed spirit possession"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nebo Regional Court, Limpopo, South Africa",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-09-03",
"outcome": "A traditional healer engaged by the victims' family to perform a cleansing ritual for alleged spirit possession was convicted of raping a 16-year-old and sexually assaulting a 14-year-old during the ritual, and was sentenced to life imprisonment plus ten years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The family brought the children to the healer for a cleansing ritual, and it was his ritual authority during that ceremony — and their belief in the possession he was treating — that placed them alone with him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/traditional-healer-sentenced-life-imprisonment-rape-and-sexual-assault-minors",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Prosecuting Authority of South Africa, 'Traditional Healer Sentenced To Life Imprisonment For Rape And Sexual Assault Of Minors' (3 Sept. 2025).",
"body": "South Africa's prosecuting authority records the conviction, the ritual context, and the sentence.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/traditional-healer-sentenced-life-imprisonment-rape-and-sexual-assault-minors",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "18a6f5f66e311e1d4406f0a27e1f9bf332efba3b3ff5b674c6ab4ca14051a821",
"final_url": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/traditional-healer-sentenced-life-imprisonment-rape-and-sexual-assault-minors"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 321,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-lesiba-marosa-sangoma-mamelodi-south-africa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Mamelodi, Gauteng, South Africa",
"lat": -25.7167,
"lng": 28.3833,
"title": "South Africa: traditional healer sentenced to life for raping a 15-year-old",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"traditional healer (sangoma)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"healing-practice authority over a minor client"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pretoria Magistrate's Court, Gauteng, South Africa",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-27",
"outcome": "Traditional healer Lesiba Victor Marosa was sentenced to life imprisonment for raping a 15-year-old girl in the context of his healing practice."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant came to the defendant as a client of his healing practice, and it was that healer-patient authority that produced the private access the offence required.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://iol.co.za/news/crime-and-courts/2026-02-27-mamelodi-sangoma-lesiba-marosa-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment-for-raping-15-year-old-girl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Mamelodi sangoma Lesiba Marosa sentenced to life imprisonment for raping 15-year-old girl', IOL, 27 Feb. 2026.",
"body": "South African national outlet reporting the life sentence imposed on the traditional healer.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://iol.co.za/news/crime-and-courts/2026-02-27-mamelodi-sangoma-lesiba-marosa-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment-for-raping-15-year-old-girl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 322,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainants, not identified. Conviction entered under a plea agreement.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-ezra-sheinberg-orot-haari-safed-israel",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Safed, Israel",
"lat": 32.9646,
"lng": 35.496,
"title": "Israel: yeshiva head sentenced to seven and a half years for assaulting women who sought his counsel",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"rabbi and head of a yeshiva"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious and pastoral counselling relationship",
"abuse framed as therapy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Orot HaAri yeshiva, Safed"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nazareth District Court, Israel",
"stage": "conviction by plea agreement and sentence",
"date": "2018-02-06",
"outcome": "Rabbi Ezra Sheinberg, head of the Orot HaAri yeshiva, was convicted under a plea agreement of sexual assault against eight religious women who had come to him for religious and pastoral counselling on personal and health matters, and was sentenced to seven and a half years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants approached the defendant precisely in his capacity as a rabbi and yeshiva head, seeking religious counsel on personal and health difficulties; the abuse was carried out inside and by means of that counselling relationship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/safed-rabbi-sentenced-to-7-5-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Safed rabbi sentenced to 7.5 years in jail for sexual assault', The Times of Israel, 6 Feb. 2018.",
"body": "Reports the Nazareth District Court sentence and the counselling relationship through which the assaults occurred.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/safed-rabbi-sentenced-to-7-5-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "08889843bd63bcd6b8c8966fe73adee5734b209f65b4cf4b664a039a3c388fbb",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/safed-rabbi-sentenced-to-7-5-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 323,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2026-06-25",
"note": "Appeal argued and taken under submission; no decision issued as of July 2026. Conviction stands in the meantime."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The conviction stands but is NOT final: an appeal was argued in June 2026 and remains undecided. The nexus is the organisation's internal reporting culture rather than an authority the defendant personally held over the complainants, which makes this a weaker fit for the database's criterion than a clergy-over-congregant case; it is recorded with that qualification stated. Complainants are adults and are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-danny-masterson-scientology-los-angeles-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Los Angeles, California, USA",
"lat": 34.0522,
"lng": -118.2437,
"title": "United States: Danny Masterson convicted of raping two fellow Scientology members",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-scientology",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"prominent member of the Church of Scientology"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the organisation's internal reporting structure, which prosecutors argued discouraged members from going to the police"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Scientology"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Los Angeles County Superior Court, California",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; appeal argued and under submission",
"date": "2023-09-07",
"outcome": "Danny Masterson was convicted on two counts of rape of fellow Scientology members and sentenced to 30 years to life. The prosecution argued the organisation's internal policies discouraged the complainants from reporting to police. A three-judge panel of the California Court of Appeal heard argument on 25 June 2026 and took the case under submission; no ruling had issued as of July 2026."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were fellow members of the same organisation, and the documented nexus is institutional rather than pastoral: prosecutors argued the group's internal reporting structure and its discouragement of contact with police is what suppressed disclosure of the assaults.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://apnews.com/article/danny-masterson-sentencing-rape-scientology",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Danny Masterson sentenced to 30 years to life', Associated Press, 7 Sept. 2023.",
"body": "Reports the conviction on two counts, the sentence, and the prosecution's argument about the organisation's internal reporting practices.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2026-06-25",
"note": "Appeal argued and taken under submission; no decision issued as of July 2026. Conviction stands in the meantime."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://apnews.com/article/danny-masterson-sentencing-rape-scientology",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 324,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "A court-supervised class settlement reached through a Chapter 11 reorganisation with a claims-validation process, NOT a litigated finding of liability on the merits, and not a criminal conviction of any individual. No individual perpetrator is named here. Former students are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-iskcon-gurukula-abuse-settlement-usa",
"year": 2005,
"place": "United States (bankruptcy court, Texas) and India",
"lat": 32.7767,
"lng": -96.797,
"title": "ISKCON gurukula abuse: $9.5 million court-supervised settlement for former boarding students",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"gurukula teachers and administrators",
"the movement's institutional leadership"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"children separated from parents into residential religious schools",
"total custodial and spiritual authority of teachers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "United States Bankruptcy Court (Chapter 11 reorganisation), Texas",
"stage": "court-supervised class settlement with claims-validation mechanism",
"date": "2005-05-26",
"outcome": "A bankruptcy-court-supervised settlement of approximately $9.5 million was finalised for roughly 450 former gurukula students who reported sexual, physical and emotional abuse in ISKCON's residential schools in the United States and India during the 1970s and 1980s."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Devotee parents enrolled their children in gurukulas, where the children were separated from their families and placed under the total custodial and spiritual authority of the movement's teachers and administrators — the arrangement that made the abuse unrefusable.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://hwpi.harvard.edu/pluralismarchive/news/iskcon-abuse-cases-settled-usd-95-million",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'ISKCON Abuse Cases Settled for USD 9.5 Million', The Pluralism Project, Harvard University.",
"body": "Records the approximately $9.5 million settlement, the number of claimants, and the gurukula residential-school context.",
"tier": "academic-archival-record",
"kind": "civil-settlement"
},
{
"link": "https://www.hinduismtoday.com/hpi/2005/05/26/2005-05-26-iskcon-child-abuse-lawsuit-settled-for-us95-million/",
"citation": "Hinduism Today / Hindu Press International, 'ISKCON Child Abuse Lawsuit Settled for US$9.5 Million,' 26 May 2005.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press",
"body": "Independent press corroboration of the Harvard Pluralism Project archive source already on record: confirms the 2002 Chapter 11 filing prompted by a $400M Texas suit (94 plaintiffs represented by attorney Windle Turley) alleging 1970s-80s gurukula boarding-school abuse, and the May 2005 US Bankruptcy Court (Central District of California)-approved $9.5M settlement for approximately 450 claimants."
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://hwpi.harvard.edu/pluralismarchive/news/iskcon-abuse-cases-settled-usd-95-million",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: academic-archival-record; evidentiary role: civil-settlement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.hinduismtoday.com/hpi/2005/05/26/2005-05-26-iskcon-child-abuse-lawsuit-settled-for-us95-million/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4f968f2ade1f4773904c31b3f1b16c2544c6e5b9116448726fd5941f520ac078",
"final_url": "https://www.hinduismtoday.com/hpi/2005/05/26/2005-05-26-iskcon-child-abuse-lawsuit-settled-for-us95-million/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 325,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. The defendant was acquitted on a fourth count, which is recorded here for accuracy. Single-source; a second Irish court-record source would strengthen it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-bernard-ward-tm-centre-dublin-ireland",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Dublin, Ireland",
"lat": 53.3498,
"lng": -6.2603,
"title": "Ireland: Transcendental Meditation teacher jailed for indecent assault of a child at the Dublin centre",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Transcendental Meditation teacher at the movement's Dublin centre"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"supervisory authority over a child working at the centre his parents had joined"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Transcendental Meditation Centre, Dublin"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Dublin Circuit Criminal Court, Ireland",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-05-20",
"outcome": "Bernard Ward, a Transcendental Meditation teacher, was convicted of three counts of indecent assault against a child who had begun working at the Dublin TM Centre at the age of ten after his parents trained there. He was acquitted on a fourth count relating to a different location."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was embedded in the movement through his parents' membership and worked at its centre under the defendant's supervision; that teacher-and-supervisor role within the organisation is what created the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/courts/circuit-court/former-meditation-teacher-jailed-for-sexual-attacks-on-child-1.3898493",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former meditation teacher jailed for sexual attacks on child', The Irish Times, 20 May 2019.",
"body": "Ireland's paper of record reports the three convictions, the acquittal on the fourth count, and the centre setting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/courts/circuit-court/former-meditation-teacher-jailed-for-sexual-attacks-on-child-1.3898493",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cace802bd0fa4251b723444a1a8eee9cc94afebab3889acfe659f7b842c2de23",
"final_url": "https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/courts/circuit-court/former-meditation-teacher-jailed-for-sexual-attacks-on-child-1.3898493"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 326,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "charges-dropped",
"date": "2000-06-13",
"note": "All criminal charges dropped after the medical examiner revised the cause-of-death finding to accidental."
},
{
"stage": "civil-settlement",
"date": "2004-05-28",
"note": "Wrongful-death suit settled on confidential terms, with a perpetual non-litigation clause and no admission of liability."
}
],
"scopeNote": "NO CONVICTION AND NO ADVERSE FINDING SURVIVES. Felony charges were filed and then dropped in June 2000 after the medical examiner revised the cause of death to accidental; the civil suit settled confidentially in 2004 with no admission of liability. The record is included at 'charged' status because the filing of felony charges by a State Attorney after an eleven-month review is itself a documented official act, and the disposition is stated here in full. It must not be represented as a finding of wrongdoing. The organisation denies liability.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-lisa-mcpherson-introspection-rundown-clearwater-usa",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Clearwater, Florida, USA",
"lat": 27.9659,
"lng": -82.8001,
"title": "Lisa McPherson: felony charges filed, then dropped, over a member's death during the Introspection Rundown",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-scientology",
"type": "death",
"status": "charged",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Church of Scientology staff administering a religious procedure",
"organisation exercising custodial care over a member"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the Introspection Rundown, a religious procedure of enforced isolation and silence",
"seventeen days in the organisation's custodial care in place of medical treatment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"institutional-obedience",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Scientology Flag Service Organization, Clearwater"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "State Attorney, Sixth Judicial Circuit, Pinellas County, Florida",
"stage": "felony charges filed, subsequently dropped",
"date": "1998-11-13",
"outcome": "After an eleven-month review, State Attorney Bernie McCabe charged the Church of Scientology with two felonies — practising medicine without a licence and abuse or neglect of a disabled adult — over the death of Lisa McPherson, a member who died on 5 December 1995 after seventeen days in the organisation's care. On 12–13 June 2000 McCabe dropped all criminal charges, after the Pinellas County Medical Examiner changed her finding on the cause of death from 'undetermined' to 'accident' following challenges by defence experts. A separate wrongful-death suit brought by McPherson's estate settled confidentially in May 2004 with no admission of liability."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "McPherson was a member of the organisation, taken into its care after a traffic accident during which she undressed in the street and asked for help. She was placed on the Introspection Rundown — a religious procedure of enforced isolation and silence — and remained in that custodial religious care for seventeen days rather than receiving medical treatment. The authority that held her there was the organisation's own doctrine about how a member in her state should be treated.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2000/06/13/charges-dropped-in-death-of-fla-woman/0f92f03f-ca33-47f7-a693-fe2a7bfde84a/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Charges Dropped in Death of Fla. Woman', The Washington Post, 13 June 2000.",
"body": "Reports the State Attorney's decision to drop both felony charges and the medical examiner's revised cause-of-death finding.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "charges-dropped-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/2004/05/29/scientologists-settle-death-suit/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Scientologists settle death suit', St. Petersburg Times / Tampa Bay Times, 29 May 2004.",
"body": "The local paper of record reports the confidential settlement of the wrongful-death suit after seven years of litigation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "civil-settlement"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "charges-dropped",
"date": "2000-06-13",
"note": "All criminal charges dropped after the medical examiner revised the cause-of-death finding to accidental."
},
{
"stage": "civil-settlement",
"date": "2004-05-28",
"note": "Wrongful-death suit settled on confidential terms, with a perpetual non-litigation clause and no admission of liability."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "After an eleven-month review, State Attorney Bernie McCabe charged the Church of Scientology with two felonies — practising medicine without a licence and abuse or neglect of a disabled adult — over the death of Lisa McPherson, a member who died on 5 December 1995 after seventeen days in the organisation's care. On 12–13 June 2000 McCabe dropped all criminal charges, after the Pinellas County Medical Examiner changed her finding on the cause of death from 'undetermined' to 'accident' following challenges by defence experts. A separate wrongful-death suit brought by McPherson's estate settled confidentially in May 2004 with no admission of liability.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2000/06/13/charges-dropped-in-death-of-fla-woman/0f92f03f-ca33-47f7-a693-fe2a7bfde84a/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charges-dropped-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/2004/05/29/scientologists-settle-death-suit/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-settlement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eb094d56e9608413f3d24357e3d06dc8a8de2f53dbc7af7f820e3e86abb4adea",
"final_url": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/2004/05/29/scientologists-settle-death-suit/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 327,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainants, not identified. The exact duration of the home-detention sentence was not confirmed in the reporting located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-sajan-singh-gurdwara-west-auckland-new-zealand",
"year": 2019,
"place": "West Auckland, New Zealand",
"lat": -36.8667,
"lng": 174.6333,
"title": "New Zealand: gurdwara priest convicted of sexual offending against two children at the temple",
"tradition": "sikhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-sikh",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Sikh priest at a gurdwara"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious standing at the gurdwara the children attended",
"use of that role to isolate them in quiet rooms inside the temple"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Auckland District Court, New Zealand (Judge Nevin Dawson)",
"stage": "conviction at trial and sentence",
"date": "2019-07-18",
"outcome": "Sajan Singh, a priest at a west Auckland gurdwara, was found guilty at trial on six counts of sexual conduct with a child. The court heard he had led two girls, aged eight and twelve, into quiet rooms inside the gurdwara on separate occasions in 2017 and touched them indecently. He was sentenced to home detention and was deported to India after completing the sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were children attending the gurdwara where the defendant served as priest; it was that religious role, and the trust and freedom of movement it carried inside the temple, that let him take them into rooms alone.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/crime/115947295/sikh-priest-sajan-singh-sentenced-to-home-detention-for-child-molestation",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sikh priest Sajan Singh sentenced to home detention for child molestation', Stuff (New Zealand), 2019.",
"body": "New Zealand national outlet reporting the six convictions, the gurdwara setting, and the sentence imposed.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/crime/115947295/sikh-priest-sajan-singh-sentenced-to-home-detention-for-child-molestation",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "adc007e3593646f2c055f78e70817d7d1b3c8c43c9be4b2680999582c2297ddd",
"final_url": "https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/crime/115947295/sikh-priest-sajan-singh-sentenced-to-home-detention-for-child-molestation"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 328,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "CONTESTED PROCEEDING — record with caution. Catholic outlets reported the trial took place amid 'conditions of defencelessness and irregularities', and Urbina appears in contemporaneous reporting on lists of priests jailed under the Ortega government, which was conducting a documented campaign against the Catholic Church in this period. The conviction is recorded as the official disposition; the database takes no position on whether the proceeding was fair, and readers should weigh the reported due-process concerns. Minor complainant not identified. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-jose-urbina-perpetuo-socorro-boaco-nicaragua",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Boaco, Nicaragua",
"lat": 12.47,
"lng": -85.6589,
"title": "Nicaragua: parish priest sentenced to 30 years for abuse of a girl, amid contested proceedings",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a child of the parish"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Parroquia Perpetuo Socorro, Boaco"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nicaraguan criminal court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-09-02",
"outcome": "José Leonardo Urbina Rodríguez, 51, parish priest of the Perpetuo Socorro church in Boaco, was sentenced to 30 years for sexual abuse in concurrence with rape and minor psychological injury against a 14-year-old girl. The sentence comprised 12 years for each of two abuse counts (December 2021 and January 2022) and 25 years for the rape count, with detention recorded to run to 12 July 2052."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a child of the parish in which the defendant served as priest; the pastoral authority attaching to that office is what afforded the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/sacerdote-nicarag%C3%BCense-es-condenado-a-30-a%C3%B1os-de-c%C3%A1rcel-por-abusar-de-menor/47872336",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote nicaragüense es condenado a 30 años de cárcel por abusar de menor', EFE / SWI swissinfo.ch, 2 Sept. 2022.",
"body": "International wire reporting the counts, the sentence breakdown, and the parish in which the defendant served.",
"tier": "international-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://aciprensa.com/noticias/sentencian-a-sacerdote-jose-leonardo-urbina-a-30-anos-de-carcel-en-nicaragua-61106",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sentencian a sacerdote José Leonardo Urbina a 30 años de cárcel en Nicaragua', ACI Prensa (2022).",
"body": "Catholic news agency reporting the same sentence while recording claims of defencelessness and procedural irregularity in the trial.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report-with-due-process-concerns"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/sacerdote-nicarag%C3%BCense-es-condenado-a-30-a%C3%B1os-de-c%C3%A1rcel-por-abusar-de-menor/47872336",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "127802036a037a61db368e49cd36f51fb5862f7b5fb255c84a8ff1840201104a",
"final_url": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/sacerdote-nicaragueense-es-condenado-a-30-a%c3%b1os-de-c%c3%a1rcel-por-abusar-de-menor/47872336"
},
{
"source": "https://aciprensa.com/noticias/sentencian-a-sacerdote-jose-leonardo-urbina-a-30-anos-de-carcel-en-nicaragua-61106",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report-with-due-process-concerns.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "59e4f55b60010b07bdd341375949845099c2a9d4318964c0da6d060e8a0abba9",
"final_url": "https://www.aciprensa.com/noticias/95549/sentencian-a-sacerdote-jose-leonardo-urbina-a-30-anos-de-carcel-en-nicaragua"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 329,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. The defendant is Costa Rican and the offence and prosecution occurred in the United States; the record is filed under the jurisdiction that tried it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-robert-mendez-esquivel-nampa-idaho-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Nampa, Idaho, USA",
"lat": 43.5407,
"lng": -116.5635,
"title": "United States: Costa Rican priest sentenced to 15 years for abusing a teenager in his parish",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a teenager connected to his parish"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Paul's Catholic Church, Nampa"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Idaho state court, United States",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-06",
"outcome": "Robert Méndez Esquivel, a Costa Rican priest serving at St. Paul's Catholic Church in Nampa, Idaho, was sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment for sexually abusing a 16-year-old. He had been arrested in August 2025 while serving as a priest at the parish."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a teenager connected to the parish where the defendant served as priest; the office and the trust it carried are what produced the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/costa-rica/2026/05/06/condenan-a-15-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-costarricense-en-estados-unidos-por-abuso-sexual-contra-un-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a 15 años de prisión a sacerdote costarricense en Estados Unidos por abuso sexual contra un menor', Infobae, 6 May 2026.",
"body": "Reports the Idaho sentence, the parish at which the defendant served, and the circumstances of his 2025 arrest.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/costa-rica/2026/05/06/condenan-a-15-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-costarricense-en-estados-unidos-por-abuso-sexual-contra-un-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "abc7030d9b8da1dc76f5644e1860e3660a362eef4091979c04dd0f95942f2070",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/costa-rica/2026/05/06/condenan-a-15-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-costarricense-en-estados-unidos-por-abuso-sexual-contra-un-menor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 330,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. No appellate disposition was located; absence of appeal reporting is not proof of finality. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-franklin-cabrera-resurreccion-de-cristo-honduras",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Comayagüela, Tegucigalpa, Honduras",
"lat": 14.085,
"lng": -87.22,
"title": "Honduras: pastor sentenced to 136 years for raping four children of his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of an independent evangelical church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine revelation that misfortune would strike the children's families unless they submitted",
"abuse at both the church and the pastor's residence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia Resurrección de Cristo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sala I del Tribunal de Sentencia, Tegucigalpa, Honduras",
"stage": "unanimous conviction and sentence",
"date": "2017-03-21",
"outcome": "Franklin Geovanny Cabrera Sierra, pastor of the evangelical church Resurrección de Cristo, was unanimously convicted on eight counts of violación especial for repeatedly raping four children under 14 who attended his congregation between 2004 and 2012, and was sentenced to 136 years (17 years per count, consecutive)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were congregants of the church the defendant pastored, and the coercion was explicitly religious: he told them God had revealed that misfortune would befall their families unless they submitted to sexual contact with him. The claimed revelation is what made refusal feel impossible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.laprensa.hn/sucesos/pastor-hondureno-violo-a-4-ninos-en-nombre-de-dios-FRLP850005",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor evangélico es condenado a 136 años de cárcel por violar a 4 niños', La Prensa (Honduras), 21 Mar. 2017.",
"body": "Honduran paper of record reporting the unanimous conviction on eight counts, the 136-year sentence, and the divine-revelation coercion described at trial.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.laprensa.hn/sucesos/pastor-hondureno-violo-a-4-ninos-en-nombre-de-dios-FRLP850005",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f61d6cd84090f6bb6d1a8d6522062a0e6daa4ea9f12ab7390a360fcbbdc8322a",
"final_url": "https://www.laprensa.hn/sucesos/pastor-hondureno-violo-a-4-ninos-en-nombre-de-dios-FRLP850005"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 331,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The sources confirm the defendant's formal religious office, but do NOT explicitly state that the complainant or her family were themselves members of his congregation; the faith-relationship element is probable rather than confirmed, and the record is included on the strength of his office. No appellate disposition located. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-roger-flores-diaz-congregation-elder-honduras",
"year": 2019,
"place": "San Pedro Sula, Cortés, Honduras",
"lat": 15.5042,
"lng": -88.025,
"title": "Honduras: congregation elder convicted on 13 counts of rape of a 12-year-old",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregational elder (anciano)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"formal office of religious authority within the congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Sentencia, San Pedro Sula, Honduras",
"stage": "unanimous conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-09-06",
"outcome": "Roger Abraham Flores Díaz, an elder (anciano) of a Jehovah's Witnesses congregation in San Pedro Sula, was unanimously convicted on 13 counts of violación especial against a 12-year-old girl, committed between July and December 2016, and was sentenced to 221 years. He was expelled by the congregation after the facts emerged."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant held the formal office of congregational elder, a recognised position of spiritual authority within his denomination, and that standing is what afforded him access to and influence over the child.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.laprensa.hn/sucesos/exlider-religioso-culpable-violacion-nina-testigos-de-jehova-LYLP1316580",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Exlíder religioso es declarado culpable por abusar de niña de 12 años', La Prensa (Honduras), 6 Sept. 2019.",
"body": "Honduran paper of record reporting the unanimous verdict on 13 counts and the defendant's role as a congregational elder.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.laprensa.hn/sucesos/exlider-religioso-culpable-violacion-nina-testigos-de-jehova-LYLP1316580",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "89cb5a5e01ea8ae8212bc40b9e2bee01ee477663b2cbf8ed87c8f4dec70a6c5a",
"final_url": "https://www.laprensa.hn/sucesos/exlider-religioso-culpable-violacion-nina-testigos-de-jehova-LYLP1316580"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 332,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. The separate conviction of the girl's father is recorded for context; that conduct is domestic and is not itself the basis of this record. Appeal finality not confirmed. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-jose-falcon-pastor-and-wife-abuse-paraguay",
"year": 2023,
"place": "José Falcón, Presidente Hayes, Paraguay",
"lat": -25.2833,
"lng": -57.7167,
"title": "Paraguay: pastor and his wife convicted of abusing a girl from his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"church pastor",
"pastor's wife"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral position and access to a congregant child"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Paraguayan criminal court, Presidente Hayes",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-09-27",
"outcome": "A church pastor was sentenced to 18 years and his wife to 14 years for repeated sexual abuse and coercion of a girl from his congregation, beginning when she was 14. In a related conviction the girl's biological father received 24 years for abuse beginning when she was 10."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a girl of the congregation the defendant pastored; his pastoral position is what gave him and his wife access to her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.abc.com.py/policiales/2023/09/27/pastor-y-su-esposa-involucrados-hombre-es-condenado-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-su-hija/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor y su esposa, involucrados: hombre es condenado por abusar sexualmente de su hija', ABC Color (Paraguay), 27 Sept. 2023.",
"body": "Paraguayan paper of record reporting the convictions of the pastor, his wife, and the father, with the respective sentences.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.abc.com.py/policiales/2023/09/27/pastor-y-su-esposa-involucrados-hombre-es-condenado-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-su-hija/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "29564c0df194bc409f4b439a068e193508a0ae244b8c1ec2f39d9fcad66c9902",
"final_url": "https://www.abc.com.py/policiales/2023/09/27/pastor-y-su-esposa-involucrados-hombre-es-condenado-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-su-hija/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 333,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. The defendant is named only by initials in the prosecuting authority's release, following Ecuadorian practice. Sourced to the Fiscalía General del Estado; no independent second source was located. Appeal status not stated. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-ebert-pastor-pastoral-residence-salinas-ecuador",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Salinas, Santa Elena, Ecuador",
"lat": -2.2144,
"lng": -80.9586,
"title": "Ecuador: pastor sentenced to 13 years for abusing a girl from age ten in the pastoral residence",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a Christian church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abuse normalised to the child as ordinary conduct between couples",
"false promise of marriage",
"use of the church's pastoral residence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ecuadorian criminal court, Santa Elena",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-10-01",
"outcome": "A pastor identified in official reporting as Ebert Enrique A. A. was sentenced to 13 years and 4 months, with a fine and $4,500 in reparations, for sexually abusing a girl of his congregation beginning when she was ten years old, in the church's pastoral residence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant belonged to a family in the defendant's congregation, and the abuse occurred in the church's own pastoral residence — the position and the premises it gave him were the mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/13-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-cristiano-por-abuso-sexual/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General del Estado (Ecuador), '13 años de prisión para pastor cristiano por abuso sexual' (2023).",
"body": "Ecuador's prosecuting authority records the conviction, the sentence, the reparations order, and the pastoral-residence setting.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/13-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-cristiano-por-abuso-sexual/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d02032286070b4dd9d8fbd985a7bdca8af8edf52b89ff177db3bfcb2c8a9c43d",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.ec/13-anos-de-prision-para-pastor-cristiano-por-abuso-sexual/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 334,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. The defendant is named only by first name and initial in Ecuadorian reporting. Single source located at the time of writing. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-jonathan-g-demonic-influence-abuse-quito-ecuador",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Quito, Pichincha, Ecuador",
"lat": -0.1807,
"lng": -78.4678,
"title": "Ecuador: evangelical pastor sentenced to 29 years after claiming a child was under demonic influence",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claim that the child was under demonic influence",
"threats to harm the child's sibling"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ecuadorian criminal court, Quito",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-06-05",
"outcome": "A pastor identified as Jonathan G. was sentenced to 29 years and 3 months for the repeated rape of a child under 13 who attended his church between September 2021 and September 2022. He had fled and remained a fugitive until his arrest in Quito in 2025."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child attended the defendant's church, and the coercion was doctrinal: he told the child he was under demonic influence and threatened his sibling. The claimed spiritual condition is what the pastor used to compel silence and compliance.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.primicias.ec/sucesos/pastor-evangelico-carcel-violacion-adolescente-quito-97878/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor evangélico va a 29 años de cárcel por violar de manera repetida a un adolescente en Quito', Primicias (Ecuador), 2025.",
"body": "Ecuadorian outlet reporting the conviction, the sentence, the offence period, and the demonic-influence claim used to coerce the child.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.primicias.ec/sucesos/pastor-evangelico-carcel-violacion-adolescente-quito-97878/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7dd23cc173b5110d3361a6c6309b629cf492adc3cc9fc15fc6a29090e3601a69",
"final_url": "https://www.primicias.ec/sucesos/pastor-evangelico-carcel-violacion-adolescente-quito-97878/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 335,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. First record for Mali. The precise family arrangement by which the child came to him is not spelled out beyond his role as marabout. The defendant contested the charge and alleged that a prior admission was coerced; the conviction is recorded as the court's disposition. No appeal status confirmed. French-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-marabout-lassa-bamako-assize-court-mali",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Lassa, Commune IV, Bamako, Mali",
"lat": 12.6392,
"lng": -8.0029,
"title": "Mali: marabout convicted by the Bamako Assize Court of abusing a small child",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"marabout consulted for spiritual and healing services"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing as a marabout, in which capacity the child was brought to him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour d'Assises de Bamako, Mali",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-11-11",
"outcome": "A man identified in reporting as Y. Sissoko, acting in the capacity of marabout, was convicted by the Bamako Assize Court of the sexual abuse of a four-year-old girl in Lassa on 15 December 2018. He was sentenced to five years' imprisonment with a fine of 500,000 FCFA, 167,000 FCFA in medical costs and 600,000 FCFA in damages. He denied the offence at trial, claiming an earlier admission had been obtained under police torture."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant's role as a marabout — a figure consulted for spiritual and healing services — is the capacity in which the child was brought to him, and it is undisputed in the reporting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.maliweb.net/faits-divers/pedophilie-un-marabout-condamne-a-5-ans-par-la-cour-dassises-2998566.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pédophilie: Un marabout condamné à 5 ans par la Cour d'assises', Maliweb.net (2022).",
"body": "Malian national outlet reporting the Assize Court conviction, the sentence and financial orders, and the defendant's denial at trial.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.maliweb.net/faits-divers/pedophilie-un-marabout-condamne-a-5-ans-par-la-cour-dassises-2998566.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "276ddfbb8f852b565f2f63101c1e15140191b9b44c66db42e3eea5b5946276c2",
"final_url": "https://www.maliweb.net/faits-divers/pedophilie-un-marabout-condamne-a-5-ans-par-la-cour-dassises-2998566.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 336,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainant, not identified. First Japanese Buddhist record in this database. Sourcing is contemporaneous Japanese reporting of the verdict rather than the court docket; the courts.go.jp record was not located and appellate status is unconfirmed. Japanese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-fukasawa-myoonji-absolute-obedience-chiba-japan",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Tōgane, Chiba, Japan",
"lat": 35.5597,
"lng": 140.3661,
"title": "Japan: temple abbot convicted after court finds he exploited a disciple's 'absolute obedience'",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"chief priest (abbot) of a Buddhist temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal relationship of absolute obedience between abbot and disciple"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Myōon-ji Temple",
"Honmon Butsuryū-shū"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Chiba District Court, Yōkaichiba Branch, Japan",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-12-11",
"outcome": "Sachihisa Fukasawa, former chief priest of Myōon-ji Temple, was convicted of quasi-forcible indecency against a female disciple, assaulted inside the temple. The court found he had exploited the relationship of absolute obedience (絶対服従の関係) to prevent the victim from refusing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's own finding supplies the nexus in the plainest terms available anywhere in this database: the doctrinal relationship of absolute obedience between abbot and disciple is what prevented the victim from refusing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ameblo.jp/yume-ichijo/entry-12878511753.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Contemporaneous Japanese reporting of the Chiba District Court (Yōkaichiba branch) verdict in the Myōon-ji case, 11 Dec. 2024.",
"body": "Reports the conviction for quasi-forcible indecency and quotes the court's finding that the abbot exploited the relationship of absolute obedience.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ameblo.jp/yume-ichijo/entry-12878511753.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f29084698c09014a3b52e127bb14f544a73da6d4f8d9ee9cb689564fafe7b53b",
"final_url": "https://ameblo.jp/yume-ichijo/entry-12878511753.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 337,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Sentence reduced to one year six months."
},
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2026",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainants, not identified; the defendant is not named in the reporting located. Conviction confirmed through all three court levels. Korean-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-busan-senior-pastor-congregants-south-korea",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Busan, South Korea",
"lat": 35.1796,
"lng": 129.0756,
"title": "South Korea: senior pastor's conviction for molesting five congregants affirmed by the Supreme Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior pastor of a church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counselling in the pastor's study",
"seniority over members of his own congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Busan District Court; appellate court; Supreme Court of Korea",
"stage": "conviction, sentence reduced on appeal, affirmed on final appeal",
"date": "2025-11-01",
"outcome": "A senior pastor in his sixties was convicted of habitually molesting five female members of his church, including placing his hand inside a congregant's clothing in his pastoral study. Busan District Court imposed two years; the appellate court reduced this to one year and six months, and the Supreme Court affirmed by dismissing his appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were members of the defendant's own congregation, and the assaults occurred inside his pastoral study during what they understood to be pastoral counselling.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.busan.com/view/busan/view.php?code=2025082718293561064",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'신도 5명 성추행 목사' — Busan Ilbo reporting on the conviction of the senior pastor for molesting five congregants (2025).",
"body": "Korean regional paper of record reporting the conviction, the pastoral-study setting, and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Sentence reduced to one year six months."
},
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2026",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.busan.com/view/busan/view.php?code=2025082718293561064",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3782ced3a966f77c594de3bea3641007de26ad136a3958a076b3f16ba94f206c",
"final_url": "https://www.busan.com/view/busan/view.php?code=2025082718293561064"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 338,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified; the priest is named only as 'Father A' in the reporting located. Sourced to Korean investigative journalism rather than a court docket; the exact case number was not confirmed. Korean-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-daegu-archdiocese-priest-rectory-abuse-south-korea",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Daegu, South Korea",
"lat": 35.8714,
"lng": 128.6014,
"title": "South Korea: priest sentenced to three years for molesting a nine-year-old parishioner in the rectory",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral access to a child of the parish",
"child lured to the rectory on a pretext, then given gifts to secure silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Daegu"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Daegu District Court, South Korea",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-04-01",
"outcome": "A priest of the Daegu Archdiocese was convicted of twice molesting a nine-year-old parishioner at the parish rectory in 2014, having brought the child there on the pretext of watching a film and afterwards using gifts to secure silence. He was sentenced to three years' imprisonment; the archdiocese separately suspended him from ministry for five years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was a parishioner of the defendant's own parish, and the offences occurred inside the rectory to which his office gave him private access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://campaigns.do/discussions/1863",
"archive": "",
"citation": "진실탐사그룹 셜록 (Sherlock investigative group), reporting on the conviction of a Daegu Archdiocese priest for molesting a nine-year-old parishioner (2021).",
"body": "Korean investigative outlet reporting the conviction, the three-year sentence, the rectory setting, and the archdiocese's separate suspension.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://campaigns.do/discussions/1863",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 339,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2014",
"note": "Sentence reduced from 15 to 10 years."
},
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2014-08-07",
"note": "Final appeal dismissed; conviction final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainants, not identified. Conviction final through the Supreme Court. Four accomplices are noted as convicted but are not the subject of this record. Chinese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-yang-zanru-shengde-chan-dual-cultivation-taiwan",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Taichung, Taiwan",
"lat": 24.1477,
"lng": 120.6736,
"title": "Taiwan: temple founder convicted of coercing disciples into sex under a 'dual cultivation' doctrine",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and master of a Chan temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrine of 'dual cultivation' (雙修) presented as spiritual practice",
"senior disciples used to recruit younger devotees"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Shengde Chan Temple"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Taichung District Court; Taichung High Court; Supreme Court of Taiwan",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal; final appeal dismissed",
"date": "2014-08-07",
"outcome": "Yang Zan-ru, known as Master Sheng Lun, founder of Shengde Chan Temple, was convicted of raping and molesting female disciples from 1991 onward, using the doctrine of 'dual cultivation' to obtain compliance and having disciples recruit younger devotees for him. The district court imposed 15 years; the High Court reduced this to 10; the Supreme Court dismissed his final appeal on 7 August 2014, making the conviction final. Four female disciples were also convicted as accomplices."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were his own disciples, and the mechanism was explicitly doctrinal: sexual acts were presented as 'dual cultivation', a spiritual practice, so that submission read to them as religious observance rather than assault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/paper/629472",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'性侵信徒逾10年 淫僧聖輪判15年', Liberty Times (Taiwan), reporting the conviction and subsequent appellate history through the 2014 Supreme Court disposition.",
"body": "Taiwanese paper of record reporting the conviction, the dual-cultivation doctrine used to obtain compliance, and the final appellate outcome.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2014",
"note": "Sentence reduced from 15 to 10 years."
},
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2014-08-07",
"note": "Final appeal dismissed; conviction final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/paper/629472",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "32afab09082331da70047f50a2b7a4b7d443d34cd55679a33c21a2d8f4561077",
"final_url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/paper/629472"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 340,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainant, not identified; the defendant is named only by surname in the reporting. Appellate status not confirmed; treat as a first-instance disposition. Chinese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-xindian-shrine-master-exorcism-assault-taiwan",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Xindian, New Taipei, Taiwan",
"lat": 24.9678,
"lng": 121.5417,
"title": "Taiwan: shrine master convicted of indecent assault committed under the guise of an exorcism",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"shrine master (宮主) of a folk-religion shrine"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claim that the devotee was severely possessed and required a private exorcism",
"assault reframed to the victim as acupressure within the ritual"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Taiwanese district court, New Taipei",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-07-02",
"outcome": "A shrine master surnamed Zeng, who operated the Jingxin-fu shrine, was convicted of indecent assault by abuse of authority after luring a female devotee upstairs on the claim that she was severely possessed and required a private exorcism, then groping her while describing the contact as acupressure. He was sentenced to seven months. The court found he had exploited his status as shrine master so that the victim believed the acts were ritual and endured them."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court found expressly that the defendant used his standing as shrine master to make the devotee believe the contact was part of the ritual she had come to him for — the religious authority is what produced her compliance.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/breakingnews/5491287",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'假驅邪真猥褻！宮主碰觸女信徒…判刑7月', Liberty Times (Taiwan), 2026.",
"body": "Taiwanese paper of record reporting the conviction, the sentence, and the court's finding on the exorcism pretext.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/breakingnews/5491287",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f38f5c74553aee4a06d68fd67f98a981326bf6e5db1c2805ab1fac2639ad2d5",
"final_url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/breakingnews/5491287"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 341,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025-12-13",
"note": "Sentence increased from 10 to 16 years."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainants, not identified; the defendant is named only by surname. Cassation status was not confirmed — the appellate sentence is recorded, not a final Supreme Court disposition. Chinese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-taichung-temple-master-fate-changing-ritual-taiwan",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Taichung, Taiwan",
"lat": 24.1477,
"lng": 120.6736,
"title": "Taiwan: temple master's sentence increased to 16 years for rapes framed as a fate-changing ritual",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"temple master claiming spiritual succession from his predecessor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sex presented as a 'fate-changing' ritual",
"coerced written 'consent' documents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prosperity-divination",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Xifang Rulai Temple"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Taichung District Court; Taiwan High Court (Taichung branch)",
"stage": "conviction; sentence increased on appeal",
"date": "2025-12-13",
"outcome": "A temple operator surnamed Liu, who took over his late mother's Xifang Rulai Temple and claimed spiritual succession, was convicted of repeatedly raping female devotees over some fifteen years — at least 58 documented instances against five women in the criminal case — coercing them by presenting sex as a 'fate-changing' ritual and having victims sign coerced consent documents. The district court imposed 10 years; the appellate court found that too lenient and increased it to 16 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants came to the temple for religious guidance and fate correction, and the defendant's claimed spiritual succession is what let him present sexual acts as the ritual remedy they had sought.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ettoday.net/news/20251213/3083570.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'台中神棍誆「嘿咻改命」15年性侵5女58次 二審加重判刑16年', ETtoday (Taiwan), 13 Dec. 2025.",
"body": "Taiwanese outlet reporting the appellate court's increase of the sentence to 16 years and the fate-changing ritual used to coerce the complainants.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025-12-13",
"note": "Sentence increased from 10 to 16 years."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ettoday.net/news/20251213/3083570.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f408b0bf942d244e69763679955a5e476085c6cab9f766a4f7ed52985a8c2a1",
"final_url": "https://www.ettoday.net/news/20251213/3083570.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 342,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainants, not identified. IMPORTANT FRAMING NOTE: the conviction was entered partly under China's anti-cult (邪教) statute, a framework this database otherwise treats with caution because it is also used for state suppression of religious groups. This record rests on the underlying conduct — rape and indecent assault of the defendant's own sworn disciples through religious coercion — which satisfies the authority-over-victim criterion independently of the cult-law framing. It should not be read as endorsing that statute. The official court URL did not resolve on re-fetch; state-broadcaster reporting of the same verdict is cited. Chinese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-wang-xingfu-false-living-buddha-china",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Jinan, Shandong, China",
"lat": 36.6512,
"lng": 117.1201,
"title": "China: false 'living Buddha' sentenced to 25 years for raping sworn disciples",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled reincarnate lama with a fabricated enthronement"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"oaths of lifelong obedience sworn by disciples",
"fabricated doctrines of 'body empowerment' and 'dual cultivation'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jinan Intermediate People's Court, Shandong, China",
"stage": "conviction on final appeal and sentence",
"date": "2021-02-01",
"outcome": "Wang Xingfu, a former prison-system official who fabricated a Tibetan identity and staged an enthronement to pose as the reincarnate Living Buddha 'Lobsang Danzeng', was convicted of rape and forcible indecency against female disciples, alongside cult-organisation and illegal-business offences, and sentenced to 25 years. Reporting records roughly 200 million yuan extracted from followers over about a decade."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were sworn disciples bound by oaths of lifelong obedience, and the defendant used fabricated doctrines of 'body empowerment' and 'dual cultivation' to compel sexual submission — the claimed lineage was the instrument.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://china.qianlong.com/2021/0202/5367697.shtml",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'央视揭假活佛10年骗了2亿…', CCTV via Qianlong (2021).",
"body": "Chinese state broadcaster reporting the final verdict, the 25-year sentence, the fabricated lineage, and the doctrinal coercion of disciples.",
"tier": "state-media-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://china.qianlong.com/2021/0202/5367697.shtml",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-media-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "067789839a4a79c24a9f48f6754967588a1b338eaa2a202b752aabcd9d3ae4ba",
"final_url": "https://china.qianlong.com/2021/0202/5367697.shtml"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 343,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. The available reporting does not fully establish that the complainant was a member of his temple community before the trip, so the faith-relationship element rests on his religious standing in the community rather than a confirmed congregant tie. Vietnamese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-huynh-minh-toan-pagoda-abbot-vietnam",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Cần Thơ, Vietnam",
"lat": 10.0452,
"lng": 105.7469,
"title": "Vietnam: pagoda abbot sentenced to six years for raping a fourteen-year-old",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"abbot of a pagoda"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious standing as abbot over a girl in his community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ninh Kiều District People's Court, Cần Thơ, Vietnam",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-02-01",
"outcome": "Huỳnh Minh Toàn, religious name Thích Phước Hoàng, abbot of a pagoda in Cao Lãnh, Đồng Tháp province, was convicted of raping a person under 16 after taking a 14-year-old girl on a trip and assaulting her at a hotel in Cần Thơ. He was sentenced to six years and ordered to pay 100 million VND in compensation, and was removed from his position as abbot."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant held religious authority as a pagoda abbot over a girl in the community he served, and that standing is what enabled him to take her away unaccompanied.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tienphong.vn/ban-tin-hinh-su-su-tru-tri-thua-nhan-hiep-dam-be-gai-14-tuoi-trong-nha-nghi-post1123926.tpo",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sư trụ trì thừa nhận hiếp dâm bé gái 14 tuổi trong nhà nghỉ', Tiền Phong (Vietnam), 2020.",
"body": "Vietnamese national newspaper reporting the abbot's conviction, sentence, compensation order, and removal from his post.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tienphong.vn/ban-tin-hinh-su-su-tru-tri-thua-nhan-hiep-dam-be-gai-14-tuoi-trong-nha-nghi-post1123926.tpo",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aa08779a9c02169959cf034bb642d7c1389231f64097be1dbe7884daed2ec961",
"final_url": "https://tienphong.vn/ban-tin-hinh-su-su-tru-tri-thua-nhan-hiep-dam-be-gai-14-tuoi-trong-nha-nghi-post1123926.tpo"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 344,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. First record for Zambia. Single outlet, though it reports the state news agency ZANIS as its source and names the court, judge and dates. No appellate disposition located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-julius-kabaso-prayer-for-seizure-mansa-zambia",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Mansa, Luapula, Zambia",
"lat": -11.1996,
"lng": 28.8944,
"title": "Zambia: pastor jailed 20 years for assaulting a girl brought to him for prayer",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"village church pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"girl brought to him specifically for prayer after a seizure",
"healing authority over a person seeking spiritual help"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Magistrate Court, Mansa; High Court, Mansa, Zambia",
"stage": "conviction; committed to the High Court for sentence",
"date": "2015-04-07",
"outcome": "Julius Kabaso, 40, a pastor at a village church in Kaole Village, Chief Chimese, Mansa District, was convicted of sexually assaulting a girl under 17 on 17 September 2014 after she was brought to him for prayer following an epileptic seizure. Judge Charles Chanda of the Mansa High Court sentenced him to 20 years' imprisonment with hard labour."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The girl was brought to the defendant specifically for prayer after a seizure — she was placed in his hands as a spiritual healer, and that is the relationship the assault exploited.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://zambianeye.com/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor jailed 20 years for rape', Zambian Eye, 20 May 2015, reporting ZANIS.",
"body": "Zambian outlet reporting the conviction, the High Court sentence, and the prayer-for-healing circumstance in which the assault occurred.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://zambianeye.com/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7da9cc18d0b526d931d1c5489264880af8685f6ba7c03b2928289918a3a61430",
"final_url": "https://zambianeye.com/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-rape/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 345,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2025-11-29",
"note": "Lower-court acquittal reversed; conviction entered and 14-year sentence imposed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. JURISDICTION NOTE: Somaliland is a self-declared state that is not internationally recognised and operates a court system distinct from federal Somalia's; the record is filed under the jurisdiction that tried it. The case is recorded as a conviction entered on appeal after an initial acquittal, and no further appeal outcome was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mohamed-jama-hassan-dugsi-teacher-somaliland",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Burco, Togdheer, Somaliland",
"lat": 9.5221,
"lng": 45.5336,
"title": "Somaliland: Quranic school teacher convicted on appeal of abusing two of his students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teacher at a Quranic school (dugsi)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teaching authority over enrolled children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Togdheer Court of Appeal, Somaliland",
"stage": "acquittal reversed on appeal; conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-11-29",
"outcome": "Mohamed Jama Hassan, a teacher at a Quranic school (dugsi) in Burco, was convicted of sexually abusing two children who were his own students, in incidents in April 2025. A lower regional court had acquitted him; prosecutors appealed, and the Togdheer Court of Appeal reversed the acquittal and sentenced him to 14 years. A Quranic teachers' association publicly protested the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were the defendant's own students at the Quranic school where he taught, subject to his religious teaching authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.kaabtv.com/somaliland-court-sentences-quran-school-teacher-to-14-years-for-rape-amid-opposition-from-scholars/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Somaliland Court Sentences Quran School Teacher to 14 Years for Rape Amid Opposition from Scholars', Kaab TV, Nov. 2025.",
"body": "Reports the Court of Appeal's reversal of the acquittal, the 14-year sentence, and the teacher-student relationship.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2025-11-29",
"note": "Lower-court acquittal reversed; conviction entered and 14-year sentence imposed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.kaabtv.com/somaliland-court-sentences-quran-school-teacher-to-14-years-for-rape-amid-opposition-from-scholars/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3b4c77dbd0bbe1804bcff17fc5e1f3c013df00b9aee6f99e2058c4ff54731c1b",
"final_url": "https://en.kaabtv.com/somaliland-court-sentences-quran-school-teacher-to-14-years-for-rape-amid-opposition-from-scholars/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 346,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. Some Jamaican coverage reported a headline figure of 29 years, which reflects the sum of the individual terms before the judge ordered them served concurrently; the effective sentence was 12 years. The complainant's precise tie to the congregation (member versus wider community) is not specified in the sources located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-kenneth-blake-harvest-temple-kingston-jamaica",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Kingston, Jamaica",
"lat": 17.9714,
"lng": -76.7931,
"title": "Jamaica: pastor sentenced for repeated sexual abuse of a twelve-year-old he impregnated",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of an Apostolic church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a child of the church community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Harvest Temple Apostolic Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Home Circuit Court, Kingston, Jamaica (Justice Lorna Shelly Williams)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2019-10-18",
"outcome": "Kenneth Blake, 56, pastor of Harvest Temple Apostolic Church, pleaded guilty in July 2019 to grievous sexual assault, sexual conduct with a person under 16, and sexual touching, having repeatedly had sex with a 12-year-old from 2015 and impregnated her. He denied paternity for nearly two years despite DNA evidence. He was sentenced to 12 years, terms running concurrently."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a child of the church community the defendant pastored; his pastoral standing is what gave him the access and the trust of those around her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://radiojamaicanewsonline.com/local/pastor-sentenced-to-12-years-in-prison-for-having-sex-with-minor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor Sentenced To 12 Years In Prison For Having Sex With Minor', Radio Jamaica News.",
"body": "Jamaican national broadcaster reporting the guilty plea and the concurrent 12-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://radiojamaicanewsonline.com/local/pastor-sentenced-to-12-years-in-prison-for-having-sex-with-minor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 347,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. No appellate disposition was located; absence of appeal reporting is not proof of finality.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-paul-hanniford-pentecostal-city-mission-jamaica",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Kingston, Jamaica",
"lat": 17.9714,
"lng": -76.7931,
"title": "Jamaica: pastor sentenced to 20 years for raping a thirteen-year-old baptised member of his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a Pentecostal congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a baptised child member",
"instruction that the assault be kept 'their secret'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Pentecostal City Mission Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Home Circuit Court, Kingston, Jamaica (Justice Lorna Shelly Williams)",
"stage": "conviction at trial and sentence",
"date": "2017-03-09",
"outcome": "Paul Hanniford, pastor of a Pentecostal City Mission congregation, was convicted on 24 January 2017 of sexual intercourse with a minor and sentenced to 20 years. He had taken a 13-year-old baptised member of his church and her five-year-old brother to his home on the pretext of a drive, and assaulted her in the bathroom; the younger brother witnessed part of the incident and reported it."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a baptised, active member of the defendant's own congregation — squarely inside the faith relationship, and it was his pastoral standing that let him take her from her family.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jamaicaobserver.com/2017/03/09/pastor-gets-20-years-for-sex-with-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor gets 20 years for sex with minor', Jamaica Observer, 9 Mar. 2017.",
"body": "Jamaican paper of record reporting the conviction, the 20-year sentence, and the victim's status as a baptised member of the congregation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jamaicaobserver.com/2017/03/09/pastor-gets-20-years-for-sex-with-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e9b58074404ae5f4d40da17bbfbbcddaacad5190b5337fe3db7c74627bbbc7fb",
"final_url": "https://www.jamaicaobserver.com/2017/03/09/pastor-gets-20-years-for-sex-with-minor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 348,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. The priest is NOT NAMED in any available reporting, nor is his parish or diocese — unusual, and likely done to protect the victim's identity given the compound setting. Because of that, the record cannot be checked for uniqueness against other databases and the victim's precise relationship to the parish is not stated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-st-catherine-priest-church-compound-jamaica",
"year": 2026,
"place": "St Catherine, Jamaica",
"lat": 18.0333,
"lng": -77,
"title": "Jamaica: Catholic priest sentenced to 12 years for abusing a twelve-year-old on the church compound",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abuse in the priest's living quarters on the church compound"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "St Catherine Circuit Court, Jamaica (Justice Dale Palmer)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-03-21",
"outcome": "A 41-year-old Catholic priest was convicted of sexual intercourse with a 12-year-old and sexual touching, both committed at his living quarters on the church compound between March and April 2023, and was sentenced to 12 years concurrent, with eight years to serve before parole eligibility."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The offences occurred inside the priest's own living quarters on the church compound, the private space his office gave him within the parish where the child was present.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/news/20260323/priest-gets-12-years-prison-sex-minor-church-compound",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Priest gets 12 years in prison for sex with minor on church compound', Jamaica Gleaner, 23 Mar. 2026.",
"body": "Jamaica's paper of record reporting the conviction, the sentence, the parole threshold, and the church-compound setting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/news/20260323/priest-gets-12-years-prison-sex-minor-church-compound",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ddb237fa1d91814dc82df2c52e82df3ad6c626cb7c8d7468df3313b383a22ffe",
"final_url": "https://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/news/20260323/priest-gets-12-years-prison-sex-minor-church-compound"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 349,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "FIRST-INSTANCE CONVICTION; APPEAL STATUS UNCONFIRMED. The defence announced an intention to appeal and no appellate ruling on the merits was located. Minor complainants, not identified. First record for Uruguay. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-gustavo-melgar-minas-cathedral-uruguay",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Minas, Lavalleja, Uruguay",
"lat": -34.375,
"lng": -55.2372,
"title": "Uruguay: priest sentenced to eight years for repeated abuse of two sisters",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest acting as the family's religious reference"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing as the family's religious figure",
"financial support given to the family alongside the access it bought"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal court, Minas, Lavalleja, Uruguay",
"stage": "first-instance conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-02-08",
"outcome": "Gustavo Melgar, a priest of the Minas cathedral, was sentenced to eight years for repeated aggravated sexual abuse of two sisters, aged nine and thirteen when the abuse began. He had begun frequenting the family in 2014, describing himself as a religious reference for them and providing financial support. The abuse was disclosed in September 2019 and charged in 2021. His defence announced an intention to appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant was the family's religious reference, and press coverage records that his access to the girls arose specifically within the scope of his religious work — the standing is what put him inside the household.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elobservador.com.uy/nota/condenan-a-8-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-de-minas-por-reiterados-delitos-de-abuso-sexual-20222811557",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a 8 años de prisión a sacerdote de Minas por reiterados delitos de abuso sexual', El Observador (Uruguay), 8 Feb. 2022.",
"body": "Uruguayan paper of record reporting the eight-year sentence, the charges, and the defendant's role as the family's religious reference.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elobservador.com.uy/nota/condenan-a-8-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-de-minas-por-reiterados-delitos-de-abuso-sexual-20222811557",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "903da70c7abef9172ea18a2fca303a987cb726e710cb0c4d4c7c862a15c21443",
"final_url": "https://www.elobservador.com.uy/nota/condenan-a-8-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-de-minas-por-reiterados-delitos-de-abuso-sexual-20222811557"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 350,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. First record for Venezuela. Appellate finality unconfirmed. The defendant admitted the offences. Multiple Venezuelan outlets converge on the facts, but no primary Ministerio Público release was retrievable; Venezuela's judicial-transparency limitations are noted. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-jose-diaz-canache-home-church-cumana-venezuela",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Cumaná, Sucre, Venezuela",
"lat": 10.455,
"lng": -64.1667,
"title": "Venezuela: pastor sentenced to 16 years for abusing five children at services held in his home",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor running an evangelical service in his own home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position running the service the children attended",
"money and force used to compel them"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Quinto de Juicio, Sucre state, Venezuela",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "José Ysrrael Díaz Canache, 47, was convicted of rape and sexual abuse of especially vulnerable victims and sentenced to 16 years and 8 months. He abused five children aged eight to twelve in May 2024, using money or force, while they attended an evangelical service he held in his own home. He admitted the abuse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were attending an evangelical service the defendant himself led in his home; his position running that service is what brought them into the house and let him isolate them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.notitarde.com.ve/sucesos/70805/condenan-a-16-anos-de-prision-a-pastor-evangelico-que-abuso-de-cinco-ninos-en-cumana",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a 16 años de prisión a pastor evangélico que abusó de cinco niños en Cumaná', Notitarde (Venezuela).",
"body": "Venezuelan outlet reporting the conviction, the sentence, the court, and the home-service setting in which the offences occurred.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.notitarde.com.ve/sucesos/70805/condenan-a-16-anos-de-prision-a-pastor-evangelico-que-abuso-de-cinco-ninos-en-cumana",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1423268219874f421377ed8ae96eb31b7730c026991d021b0a5a87a7a984854f",
"final_url": "https://www.notitarde.com.ve/sucesos/70805/condenan-a-16-anos-de-prision-a-pastor-evangelico-que-abuso-de-cinco-ninos-en-cumana"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 351,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-david-torres-rosales-nueva-esperanza-el-salvador",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Soyapango, San Salvador, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.71,
"lng": -89.14,
"title": "El Salvador: pastor sentenced to 20 years for the continued rape of a thirteen-year-old from his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of an evangelical church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"grooming a child congregant by calling her his girlfriend",
"payments made to her for repeated encounters"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia Nueva Esperanza, Soyapango"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Salvadoran criminal court, San Salvador",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2018-06-07",
"outcome": "David Alonso Torres Rosales, pastor at the Nueva Esperanza church in Soyapango, was sentenced to 20 years for aggravated rape of a minor in continued form. He groomed a 13-year-old girl who attended his church, telling her she was his girlfriend and paying her for repeated encounters at a motel between July 2016 and February 2017."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant attended the church where the defendant served as pastor; the relationship began through that congregational role and the trust it carried.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elsalvador.com/noticias/nacional/carcel-para-pastor-evangelico-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-una-menor/488701/2018/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cárcel para pastor evangélico por abusar sexualmente de una menor', elsalvador.com, 2018.",
"body": "Salvadoran paper of record reporting the 20-year sentence and the grooming of a child from the defendant's congregation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elsalvador.com/noticias/nacional/carcel-para-pastor-evangelico-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-una-menor/488701/2018/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "13cd57232b678718e2c5703e0094138bf210f310936f07c88656ef13dfe05558",
"final_url": "https://historico.elsalvador.com/historico/488701/carcel-para-pastor-evangelico-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-una-menor.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 352,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR SAMOA, and sourced to the primary court judgment on PacLII — the strongest source tier available. The statutory charge is framed as abuse of a dependent family member; the judgment's own reasoning centres on his status as faifeau. No appeal was indicated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-tugia-tuliau-faifeau-satalo-samoa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Satalo, Falealili, Samoa",
"lat": -14.05,
"lng": -171.4333,
"title": "Samoa: Methodist minister convicted of abusing a girl placed in his household for moral guidance",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Methodist Church minister (faifeau) of the parish",
"in loco parentis custodian under customary placement"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"customary practice of placing children in the minister's household under his moral and spiritual guidance",
"pastoral authority over a member of his own congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Methodist Church of Samoa"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Samoa, Mulinuu (Police v Tuliau [2020] WSSC 27)",
"stage": "guilty plea, conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-02-19",
"outcome": "Tugia Tuliau, Methodist minister (faifeau) of the parish of Satalo since 2015, pleaded guilty to eight counts of sexual connection with a dependent family member and one count of an indecent act against a 16-year-old member of his congregation who, in accordance with common Samoan practice, had been taken into his household to live under his and his wife's care and moral guidance. He was sentenced to four years and ten months. The judgment treats the breach of trust as faifeau, the breach of his congregation's confidence, and the harm to the Church as aggravating features."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a member of the defendant's own congregation, living in his household precisely because Samoan custom places young people under the moral and spiritual guidance of the church minister — the office itself created both the custody and the authority the offending exploited, and the sentencing judgment says so in terms.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://www.paclii.org/ws/cases/WSSC/2020/27.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Police v Tuliau [2020] WSSC 27 (Supreme Court of Samoa, 19 February 2020).",
"body": "The primary sentencing judgment, recording the guilty pleas, the customary household placement under the minister's moral guidance, and the court's treatment of the breach of pastoral trust as aggravating.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "sentencing-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://www.paclii.org/ws/cases/WSSC/2020/27.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 353,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainants, not identified. Second record for Fiji. The exact PacLII citation was not confirmed; the account rests on consistent contemporaneous reporting by RNZ, Fijivillage and the Fiji Times of the trial and sentence. No appeal outcome was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-waisake-tulavu-agape-healing-church-fiji",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Suva, Fiji",
"lat": -18.1416,
"lng": 178.4419,
"title": "Fiji: pastor sentenced to 16 years for raping and assaulting members of his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a healing-ministry church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust over members of his own congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Agape Healing Church Ministry"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Fiji at Suva (Justice Daniel Goundar)",
"stage": "conviction at trial and sentence",
"date": "2020-10-27",
"outcome": "Pastor Waisake Tulavu of the Agape Healing Church Ministry was found guilty of four counts of rape and one of sexual assault against three women, all members of his church, committed between May and September 2018. He was sentenced to 16 years for the rapes and four years concurrent for the sexual assault, with parole eligibility after 12 years. Justice Goundar said that instead of upholding the trust and security of his role as a pastor, his conduct had shocked the public conscience."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The three complainants were members of the defendant's own congregation, and the sentencing judge's remarks identify the betrayal of pastoral trust as the gravamen of the offending.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/429207/fiji-pastor-gets-16-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Fiji pastor gets 16 years in jail for sexual assault', RNZ Pacific, Oct. 2020.",
"body": "New Zealand's public broadcaster reporting the High Court conviction, the sentence, and the judge's remarks on the abuse of pastoral trust.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fijivillage.com/feature/Tulavu-found-guilty-of-rape-and-sexual-assault-8r45xf/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Tulavu found guilty of rape and sexual assault', Fijivillage (2020).",
"body": "Fijian outlet reporting the verdict, the church, and the congregant status of the three complainants.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/429207/fiji-pastor-gets-16-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2277369e6c839780bbde32736fe526e8a1ca340f50f19e7cba04bd27c37b8153",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/429207/fiji-pastor-gets-16-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fijivillage.com/feature/Tulavu-found-guilty-of-rape-and-sexual-assault-8r45xf/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e80053f23b25bb55341ab5994be96674b2ec89e95d4b53adc0d0218214b89ea6",
"final_url": "https://www.fijivillage.com/feature/Tulavu-found-guilty-of-rape-and-sexual-assault-8r45xf/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 354,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "third-circuit",
"date": "2017-07-01",
"note": "Conviction affirmed on appeal."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. TAGGED BY HARM LOCATION per the database's settled rule: the abuse occurred in Honduras; the prosecution, conviction and affirmance were in the United States federal system, as stated in the proceedings. Appellate-affirmed — among the strongest evidentiary postures in this corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-joseph-maurizio-pro-nino-orphanage-honduras",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Honduras",
"lat": 15.2,
"lng": -86.2419,
"title": "Honduras: US missionary priest convicted of abusing boys at shelters his ministry funded",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest",
"principal donor and missionary to the shelters where the victims lived"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-mission access to at-risk children in residential shelters",
"financial power over the institution housing the victims"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Honduras Interfaith Ministries",
"Pro Niño shelters"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "United States District Court, Western District of Pennsylvania (Johnstown); Third Circuit Court of Appeals",
"stage": "federal jury conviction and sentence; affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2015-09-22",
"outcome": "Joseph Maurizio Jr., a priest of the Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown and the largest donor to Honduras Interfaith Ministries, was convicted by a federal jury of child sex tourism offences for abusing two boys at the Pro Niño shelters in Honduras during repeated missionary trips between 2004 and 2009. He was sentenced to nearly 17 years with lifetime supervised release and restitution. The Third Circuit affirmed the conviction in July 2017."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were at-risk children resident in shelters that the defendant's religious ministry funded and visited; his combined standing as priest, missionary and principal donor is what gave him unsupervised access to them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/pennsylvania-priest-sentenced-over-16-years-following-ice-child-sex-tourism-probe",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, 'Pennsylvania priest sentenced to over 16 years following ICE child sex tourism probe'.",
"body": "Federal law-enforcement record of the conviction, sentence and the Honduran shelter setting.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.elheraldo.hn/sucesos/eeuu-ratifican-condena-de-cura-por-abuso-ninos-hondurenos-CMEH1093203",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'EEUU: Ratifican condena de cura por abuso niños hondureños', El Heraldo (Honduras), 2017.",
"body": "Honduran paper of record reporting the Third Circuit's affirmance of the conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "third-circuit",
"date": "2017-07-01",
"note": "Conviction affirmed on appeal."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/pennsylvania-priest-sentenced-over-16-years-following-ice-child-sex-tourism-probe",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "53cc946e8508b105ed6c6e6c0475077fcba7723fbdbca688daff3ad030fcda83",
"final_url": "https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/pennsylvania-priest-sentenced-over-16-years-following-ice-child-sex-tourism-probe"
},
{
"source": "https://www.elheraldo.hn/sucesos/eeuu-ratifican-condena-de-cura-por-abuso-ninos-hondurenos-CMEH1093203",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8df585ba979d37776bdae95c519612b275bb934e7b46b1084d2be33ada1db3a2",
"final_url": "https://www.elheraldo.hn/sucesos/eeuu-ratifican-condena-de-cura-por-abuso-ninos-hondurenos-CMEH1093203"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 355,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The leader's legal surname was not consistently confirmed across sources and the record uses his movement name as reported. Appellate outcome not independently confirmed; the extradition proceedings corroborate the charges' substance. Russian-language sourcing via RAPSI, a legal news agency covering the courts.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-kaula-dharma-basement-children-moscow-russia",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Moscow Oblast, Russia",
"lat": 55.7558,
"lng": 37.6173,
"title": "Russia: 'Kaula Dharma' leader sentenced to 16 years for raping and torturing followers' children",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed guru of a tantra-derived movement"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru authority over followers and their children living on sect property",
"children held in a basement on the property"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Kaula Dharma"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Russian court, Moscow region",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-12-17",
"outcome": "The founder of the tantra-derived movement 'Kaula Dharma', a self-styled guru using the name Mitradevananda Paramahamsa, was sentenced to 16 years' strict-regime imprisonment for raping and torturing minor children of followers who were held in a basement on sect property. Two co-defendants received 15 and 6 years. He had been extradited from Bulgaria in 2017 specifically on the sexual-violence and torture charges."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were the children of followers who lived under the leader's claimed spiritual authority on the movement's property; his guru status over the parents is what placed the children within his physical control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20191217/305222468.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Суд приговорил к 16 годам колонии основателя секты «Каула Дхарма»', RAPSI (Russian Legal Information Agency), 17 Dec. 2019.",
"body": "Russian legal news agency reporting the 16-year strict-regime sentence and the co-defendants' terms.",
"tier": "legal-news-agency-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://rapsinews.ru/incident_news/20171102/280781144.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Основатель секты «Каула Дхарма» экстрадирован в Россию', RAPSI, 2 Nov. 2017.",
"body": "Reports the extradition from Bulgaria at the Prosecutor General's request on the underlying charges.",
"tier": "legal-news-agency-court-reporting",
"kind": "extradition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20191217/305222468.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-agency-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c1e7fbf873d4e65dd063d5f59d0a553aa2e44ba2503e16270de7b5f2e53b263d",
"final_url": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20191217/305222468.html"
},
{
"source": "https://rapsinews.ru/incident_news/20171102/280781144.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-agency-court-reporting; evidentiary role: extradition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "42b6b141a93373f989030012305822e4a163d23a544bba914c9aee70b9914b90",
"final_url": "https://rapsinews.ru/incident_news/20171102/280781144.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 356,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR MOLDOVA. The defendant is identified in reporting by his self-given title; his legal name was not published in the sources located. Appeal status unconfirmed. Corroborated across multiple independent Moldovan and regional outlets. Russian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-apostle-mikhail-family-servitude-moldova",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Moldova",
"lat": 47.0105,
"lng": 28.8638,
"title": "Moldova: self-proclaimed 'messiah' given life imprisonment for enslaving a family and raping their daughters",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed messiah worshipped by the family as their master"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious submission of the entire family cultivated from 2000",
"children confined in an oven to be shown 'what hell looks like'",
"threats of murder and arson",
"extraction of 70% of the mother's foreign wages"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Moldovan criminal court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-16",
"outcome": "A 68-year-old man who had presented himself to a family since 2000 as a messiah — 'Apostle Mikhail' — was convicted of human trafficking, child trafficking, rape of minors and systematic torture, and sentenced to life imprisonment. He systematically raped two of the family's daughters between 2010 and 2014, one of whom became pregnant; confined the children in an oven, telling them he was showing them what hell looks like; and compelled the mother to work in Italy and remit 70% of her wages to him."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The entire family had been brought to worship the defendant as a messiah, and the court's findings describe harm running through that submission: the daughters were raised inside a household that treated his word as divine command, which is what made refusal impossible and kept the family in servitude for over a decade.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://newsmaker.md/ru/v-moldove-mujchina-nazyvavshii-sebya-arhangelom-mihailom-derjal-v-rabstve-czeluyu-semyu-kakoi-prigovor-vynes-sud",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'В Молдове мужчина, называвший себя «архангелом Михаилом», держал в рабстве целую семью', NewsMaker (Moldova), Jan. 2026.",
"body": "Moldovan independent outlet reporting the life sentence and the trafficking, rape and torture findings.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://point.md/ru/novosti/obschestvo/v-moldove-osudili-lidera-sekty-nasilovavshego-detei-i-sazhavshego-ikh-v-pech/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'В Молдове осудили лидера секты, насиловавшего детей и сажавшего их в печь', Point.md, Jan. 2026.",
"body": "Corroborating Moldovan reporting of the conviction and the oven-confinement findings.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://newsmaker.md/ru/v-moldove-mujchina-nazyvavshii-sebya-arhangelom-mihailom-derjal-v-rabstve-czeluyu-semyu-kakoi-prigovor-vynes-sud",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d0d6090c293b6061295a306db8d2726b5bb6af2c308bc492277c9bd67daf362f",
"final_url": "https://newsmaker.md/ru/v-moldove-mujchina-nazyvavshii-sebya-arhangelom-mihailom-derjal-v-rabstve-czeluyu-semyu-kakoi-prigovor-vynes-sud"
},
{
"source": "https://point.md/ru/novosti/obschestvo/v-moldove-osudili-lidera-sekty-nasilovavshego-detei-i-sazhavshego-ikh-v-pech/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ba64939be2700975ba9791fd33f16c93e632708f43f4f98996e16181f2049d60",
"final_url": "https://point.md/ru/novosti/obschestvo/v-moldove-osudili-lidera-sekty-nasilovavshego-detei-i-sazhavshego-ikh-v-pech/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 357,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event recording a statutory inquiry's findings. 'Br Herve' and 'Br Platt' are Commission pseudonyms assigned by statute; no criminal conviction attaches to either name. Findings quoted verbatim from the report text at the paragraph-level citation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1969-artane-industrial-school-ryan-report-ireland",
"year": 1969,
"place": "Artane, Dublin, Ireland",
"lat": 53.3833,
"lng": -6.2167,
"title": "Artane: Ryan Report finds Brothers who admitted abusing boys were retained and transferred",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Christian Brothers holding total custodial and spiritual authority over committed boys",
"Congregation leadership that retained admitted abusers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"court committal into the Congregation's custody",
"transfer of known abusers between institutions rather than removal"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Artane",
"Congregation of Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Commission), Ireland — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "statutory inquiry finding",
"date": "2009-05-20",
"outcome": "The Ryan Report found that a Brother it names 'Br Herve' was 'accused of having kissed, fondled, embraced and meddled with boys in his class' and 'admitted that the charges were substantially true', yet was subsequently transferred to Artane rather than removed from ministry to children. A second Brother, 'Br Platt', 'voluntarily confessed to the Superior that he had abused a boy and acted immodestly with him' and was likewise retained. Artane, the largest industrial school in the state, held boys committed by court order from 1870 to 1969."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys were committed to Artane by court order into the total custodial and spiritual authority of the Christian Brothers; that religious authority is what made the abuse unrefusable, and the Congregation's own authority structure is what moved admitted abusers between institutions instead of out of them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-7-320",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, 'Report' (Ryan Report), Vol. I, ch. 7 (Artane), paras 312–339 (20 May 2009).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry records the admitted abuse, the confessions to superiors, and the retention and transfer of the Brothers concerned.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-7-320",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8e7d8dcb59514e30a30e8b452dfd71324efe38cce013f04e45f64fb3afad08b4",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-7-320"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 358,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institution-level systemic finding rather than a named-perpetrator record, quoted verbatim from the report's general conclusions at the paragraph-level citation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1973-daingean-reformatory-ryan-report-ireland",
"year": 1973,
"place": "Daingean, County Offaly, Ireland",
"lat": 53.2942,
"lng": -7.29,
"title": "Daingean: Ryan Report finds flogging 'inhumane and cruel' in a climate of fear",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Oblates of Mary Immaculate operating a court-committal reformatory"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritualised flogging",
"unrecorded and unpredictable punishment producing a climate of fear"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St Conleth's Reformatory School, Daingean",
"Oblates of Mary Immaculate"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Commission), Ireland — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "statutory inquiry finding",
"date": "2009-05-20",
"outcome": "The Ryan Report's general conclusions on Daingean found that 'flogging was an inhumane and cruel form of corporal punishment'; that 'there was no proper system for recording physical punishment... and it was extensively used by staff members'; that 'the severity of punishments, its widespread use, and its unpredictability led to a climate of fear'; and that 'serious complaints were not properly investigated'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys were committed by the courts to a reformatory under the total custodial and spiritual authority of the Oblate community; the religious governance of the institution is what made the punishment regime unrefusable.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-15-250",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, 'Report' (Ryan Report), Vol. I, ch. 15 (Daingean), para. 258 (20 May 2009).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry's general conclusions on the flogging regime, the absence of punishment records, and the climate of fear.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-15-250",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f8034057076f1ada1b77c1b1a3c6b0536d32845c837dbfafe1bfe8ed6cd0564",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-15-250"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 359,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "'Br Sergio', 'Br Leone', 'Fr Lucio' and 'Fr Paolo' are Commission pseudonyms; the 2002 criminal conviction the report records is real, but the underlying court record was not located to attach a name. The dormitory-access findings concern facilitation rather than direct abuse by those named, and are recorded as such.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-ferryhouse-rosminians-ryan-report-ireland",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Clonmel, County Tipperary, Ireland",
"lat": 52.3558,
"lng": -7.7003,
"title": "Ferryhouse: Ryan Report records a convicted Brother and dormitory access given to outsiders",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Rosminian Brothers and Fathers with custodial and pastoral authority over residents and care-leavers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"continuing religious authority over a care-leaver at an aftercare centre",
"control of dormitory access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Ferryhouse",
"Rosminians (Institute of Charity)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Commission), Ireland — statutory inquiry; Irish criminal courts",
"stage": "statutory inquiry finding recording a 2002 criminal conviction",
"date": "2009-05-20",
"outcome": "The Ryan Report recorded that a Brother it names 'Br Sergio' 'was convicted of sexual assault in 2002' for offences committed in the early 1990s against a former Ferryhouse resident at a Rosminian aftercare centre, and that on being confronted he 'admitted his guilt and was immediately removed'. The report separately found that 'Br Leone' and 'Fr Lucio' had permitted an outside layman access to boys' dormitories, and that 'Fr Paolo' told the Committee he was uneasy about what was going on but did not act."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The convicted Brother's victim was a care-leaver still under the order's pastoral authority at its aftercare centre — the industrial-school relationship carried forward. The dormitory findings show the same authority operating as gatekeeper: the religious staff controlled who reached the children at night.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-213",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, 'Report' (Ryan Report), Vol. II, ch. 3 (Ferryhouse), paras 200–214 (20 May 2009).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry records the 2002 conviction, the admission of guilt, and the dormitory-access findings.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-213",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b80c6c0902f15c5b9a54e7108be5514effba3c33dc77ddd949ecef674735da7f",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-213"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 360,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "'Sr Alida' is a Commission pseudonym. The general conclusions quoted are the Commission's own findings; the specific details attributed to individual Sisters are complainant testimony recorded within the chapter the Commission adopted, and are framed as such.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1983-goldenbridge-sisters-of-mercy-ryan-report-ireland",
"year": 1983,
"place": "Goldenbridge, Dublin, Ireland",
"lat": 53.3358,
"lng": -6.3211,
"title": "Goldenbridge: Ryan Report finds pervasive punishment and constant humiliation of committed girls",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Sisters of Mercy holding total custodial and spiritual authority over committed girls"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pervasive, arbitrary punishment producing a climate of fear",
"humiliation and degradation as constant occurrences"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St Vincent's Industrial School, Goldenbridge",
"Sisters of Mercy"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Commission), Ireland — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "statutory inquiry finding",
"date": "2009-05-20",
"outcome": "The Ryan Report's general conclusions on Goldenbridge found: 'Punishment in Goldenbridge was pervasive. Children were beaten for small infringements. It was unpredictable, arbitrary and led to a climate of fear', and 'The Sisters in charge during the relevant period were harsh and unfeeling towards the children. Humiliation and degradation were constant occurrences.' Complainant testimony recorded in the chapter describes a Sister the report names 'Sr Alida' as extremely cruel, including beatings for bedwetting."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Girls were committed by the courts to Goldenbridge under the total custodial and spiritual authority of the Sisters of Mercy; the convent's religious governance is what made the regime unrefusable.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-7-580",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, 'Report' (Ryan Report), Vol. II, ch. 7 (Goldenbridge), paras 152–163 and general conclusions para. 592 (20 May 2009).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry's findings on pervasive punishment, the climate of fear, and constant humiliation and degradation.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-7-580",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "513d3f88eeebc3e22d53c409d885f8e79e19ffc119c856deacc93b30f4baa108",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-7-580"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 361,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "'Fr Jovito' is the Commission's pseudonym; the priest's identity became public through later criminal proceedings under his real name, and both are stated here. The Commission-report quotes were corroborated through RTÉ's direct-quote reporting of the chapter rather than a direct read of the primary PDF, which resisted automated retrieval — flagged for re-verification against the primary document.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-tony-walsh-fr-jovito-murphy-report-dublin-ireland",
"year": 1990,
"place": "Ballyfermot and Westland Row, Dublin, Ireland",
"lat": 53.3428,
"lng": -6.3539,
"title": "Dublin Archdiocese: Murphy Report finds a serial abuser known from 1978 was transferred, not removed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest with pastoral authority over parish children",
"Archdiocese controlling his appointments"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"unsupervised clerical access to parish children",
"transfer between parishes to avoid scandal"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Dublin"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Commission of Investigation into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin (Murphy Commission), Ireland",
"stage": "statutory commission finding; subsequent criminal convictions under the priest's real name",
"date": "2009-11-26",
"outcome": "The Murphy Report's chapter on the priest it names 'Fr Jovito' found that a complaint of sexually abusing an eight-year-old boy reached Archbishop's House within two days of his 1978 appointment to Ballyfermot; that 'by 1985, the Archdiocese knew he was a serial abuser and his transfer to Westland Row was clearly an attempt to avoid further scandal'; that 'the welfare of children did not arise as a consideration for the Archdiocese, despite an established clear danger to children'; and that action 'should have been taken by the Archdiocese in 1979 at the latest.' The priest, publicly identified through later criminal proceedings as Tony Walsh, was subsequently convicted in the Irish criminal courts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were parish children under the pastoral authority of their priest, whose clerical role provided the unsupervised access; the Archdiocese's own chain of religious authority determined that he was transferred rather than removed for over a decade after it knew.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2009_11_26_Murphy_Report/2010_12_15_Further_portions__Chapter_19_Fr_Jovito.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission of Investigation, 'Report into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin' (Murphy Report), ch. 19 ('Fr Jovito'), released 26 Nov. 2009 (chapter released 2010).",
"body": "The statutory commission's chapter-level findings on the Archdiocese's knowledge from 1978 and its transfers of the priest.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rte.ie/news/special-reports/2010/1217/295673-murphy_reportpoints/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RTÉ, 'Murphy Report Chapter 19: main points and timeline' (17 Dec. 2010).",
"body": "Ireland's public broadcaster reporting the chapter's findings in direct quotation.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "inquiry-report-coverage"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2009_11_26_Murphy_Report/2010_12_15_Further_portions__Chapter_19_Fr_Jovito.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fe0fd78334e32e1a50f4feac7f64f5a1fffbcccd8de4dbc66a76cf7d424800d0",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2009_11_26_Murphy_Report/2010_12_15_Further_portions__Chapter_19_Fr_Jovito.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rte.ie/news/special-reports/2010/1217/295673-murphy_reportpoints/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: inquiry-report-coverage.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a499cd912af2f1472d77e7a704dfbb909053c510ff9eb09eb26f5ae45094319e",
"final_url": "https://www.rte.ie/news/special-reports/2010/1217/295673-murphy_reportpoints/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 362,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Multiply convicted with no successful appeal disturbing guilt.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-gerald-ridsdale-ballarat-australia",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Ballarat, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.5622,
"lng": 143.8503,
"title": "Australia: Gerald Ridsdale — serial abuse convictions across seven court rounds",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest and school chaplain"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish and chaplaincy authority over children and altar boys",
"repeated transfers between parishes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Ballarat"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Victorian courts, Australia (multiple proceedings 1993–2017)",
"stage": "convictions across at least seven court rounds",
"date": "2017-08-15",
"outcome": "Gerald Ridsdale was convicted across at least seven rounds of proceedings between 1993 and 2017 of sexually abusing more than sixty children, mostly boys, while a chaplain and parish priest. The Royal Commission recorded 78 claims against him — the highest of any individual in its Ballarat data. He died in custody in February 2025."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children committed to or enrolled in the religious institution were under the clergy's combined pastoral, teaching and custodial authority — the mechanism the Royal Commission identified across these institutions.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bendigoadvertiser.com.au/story/4892326/judge-sentences-ridsdale-to-another-11-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Judge sentences Ridsdale to another 11 years', Bendigo Advertiser, 15 Aug. 2017.",
"body": "Reports a further conviction round and sentence in the long series.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-28-catholic-church-authorities-ballarat",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Case Study 28 (Ballarat).",
"body": "The Royal Commission's findings recording the claims data against Ridsdale.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bendigoadvertiser.com.au/story/4892326/judge-sentences-ridsdale-to-another-11-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd37df878b21a7441d0e26a186a77b9e747bad21c35ab9c1aa68e69f788803ac",
"final_url": "https://www.bendigoadvertiser.com.au/story/4892326/judge-sentences-ridsdale-to-another-11-years/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-28-catholic-church-authorities-ballarat",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 363,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2012",
"note": "Convictions undisturbed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-robert-best-christian-brothers-victoria-australia",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Ballarat, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.5622,
"lng": 143.8503,
"title": "Australia: Christian Brother Robert Best convicted of abusing boys at three schools",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Christian Brother and teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teaching authority over primary-school boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Congregation of Christian Brothers",
"St Alipius, Ballarat"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Australia",
"stage": "guilty plea, conviction and sentence",
"date": "2011-08-08",
"outcome": "Robert Best pleaded guilty to more than 27 charges of abusing boys as young as eight at three Christian Brothers schools (St Alipius Ballarat, Box Hill, Geelong) and was sentenced to 14 years and 9 months. His appeal did not disturb the convictions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children committed to or enrolled in the religious institution were under the clergy's combined pastoral, teaching and custodial authority — the mechanism the Royal Commission identified across these institutions.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/pedophile-best-still-a-christian-brother/tyg7p1kxp",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pedophile Best still a Christian Brother', SBS News (2011).",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, the schools involved, and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2012",
"note": "Convictions undisturbed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/pedophile-best-still-a-christian-brother/tyg7p1kxp",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a0a7ef66cf718d6c30f3502c93e0bdc810903c2970c6082dc55abda02fc55958",
"final_url": "https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/pedophile-best-still-a-christian-brother/tyg7p1kxp"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 364,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "1996",
"note": "Sentence reduced; convictions undisturbed."
},
{
"stage": "dpp-appeal",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Sentence increased as manifestly inadequate."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The 1996 appellate reduction affected sentence length only; guilt was never disturbed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-edward-dowlan-christian-brothers-victoria-australia",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Ballarat and regional Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.5622,
"lng": 143.8503,
"title": "Australia: Christian Brother Edward Dowlan convicted in three rounds spanning 26 years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Christian Brother and teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teaching authority over boys across six schools"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Congregation of Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Victorian courts, Australia",
"stage": "convictions in 1996, 2015 and 2022",
"date": "2022-02-01",
"outcome": "Edward Dowlan (later known as Ted Bales) was convicted in 1996 (sentence reduced on appeal; guilt undisturbed), again in 2015 (sentence increased to 8 years 5 months after a DPP appeal that it was too lenient), and again in February 2022 for offences against a further 19 students. He abused boys as young as eight over 14 years across six schools."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children committed to or enrolled in the religious institution were under the clergy's combined pastoral, teaching and custodial authority — the mechanism the Royal Commission identified across these institutions.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/vic-christian-brother-gets-more-jail-time/hc89nyjcn",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Vic Christian Brother gets more jail time', SBS News, Feb. 2022.",
"body": "Reports the 2022 conviction round and the cumulative history.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "1996",
"note": "Sentence reduced; convictions undisturbed."
},
{
"stage": "dpp-appeal",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Sentence increased as manifestly inadequate."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/vic-christian-brother-gets-more-jail-time/hc89nyjcn",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7ecba3709b90985240103a382091891eea5c732784d29c679c568d10f0803a33",
"final_url": "https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/vic-christian-brother-gets-more-jail-time/hc89nyjcn"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 365,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-john-denham-catholic-schools-nsw-australia",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Newcastle and Hunter region, NSW, Australia",
"lat": -32.9283,
"lng": 151.7817,
"title": "Australia: priest John Sidney Denham convicted of abusing at least 57 boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest and school teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly authority over parish-school students"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St Pius X, Adamstown",
"Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "NSW courts, Australia",
"stage": "convictions in 2001, 2010 and 2015",
"date": "2010-06-25",
"outcome": "John Sidney Denham was convicted across three rounds of proceedings of abusing at least 57 boys, some as young as five, at St Pius X Adamstown and other NSW parishes and schools from the 1970s. The 2010 sentence was 19 years 10 months; the sentencing court described the offending as sadistic."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children committed to or enrolled in the religious institution were under the clergy's combined pastoral, teaching and custodial authority — the mechanism the Royal Commission identified across these institutions.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.portnews.com.au/story/6195924/sadistic-catholic-priest-tells-bleeding-boy-victim-he-will-rot-in-hell/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sadistic Catholic priest...', Port Macquarie News (2010/2019 retrospective).",
"body": "Reports the conviction rounds, victim count and the court's characterisation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.portnews.com.au/story/6195924/sadistic-catholic-priest-tells-bleeding-boy-victim-he-will-rot-in-hell/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "23489d9aed846d350126d8380be2c2603a0b88d9058afdfc9d501d2539969347",
"final_url": "https://www.portnews.com.au/story/6195924/sadistic-catholic-priest-tells-bleeding-boy-victim-he-will-rot-in-hell/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 366,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-bernard-mcgrath-kendall-grange-nsw-australia",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Morisset, NSW, Australia",
"lat": -33.1083,
"lng": 151.487,
"title": "Australia: Brother Bernard McGrath given 62 years across two trials for abusing resident boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Brother and principal of a residential boys' home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial and religious authority over resident boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St John of God Brothers",
"Kendall Grange, Morisset"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "NSW District Court, Australia",
"stage": "two conviction rounds",
"date": "2018-02-16",
"outcome": "Bernard McGrath was sentenced on 16 February 2018 to 33 years for 64 offences against 12 boys at the Kendall Grange residential institution, and in 2019 to a further 29 years for offences against 15 more boys. The judge found systemic abuse occurred under his tenure as principal. He also had a prior 1997 New Zealand-related conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were boys resident at a religious institutional home where the defendant, as Brother and principal, held total custodial and spiritual authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5233071/justice-at-long-last-bernard-mcgrath-jailed-for-33-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Justice at long last: Bernard McGrath jailed for 33 years', Newcastle Herald, 16 Feb. 2018.",
"body": "Reports the first conviction round and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6520184/hunter-house-of-evil-predator-jailed-until-2053-for-crimes-against-boys/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Predator jailed until 2053', Newcastle Herald (2019).",
"body": "Reports the second round and cumulative term.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5233071/justice-at-long-last-bernard-mcgrath-jailed-for-33-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "012eef697fd0f64944fc15107b306af77ea1b2cab2b9e884ec021ed403b54f09",
"final_url": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5233071/justice-at-long-last-bernard-mcgrath-jailed-for-33-years/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6520184/hunter-house-of-evil-predator-jailed-until-2053-for-crimes-against-boys/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c3ea949dfa680bb5f969cc05fbc64c4d209faf5b0cb1a74ba28766fc5819d661",
"final_url": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6520184/hunter-house-of-evil-predator-jailed-until-2053-for-crimes-against-boys/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 367,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-david-kramer-yeshivah-college-melbourne-australia",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Melbourne, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.8136,
"lng": 144.9631,
"title": "Australia: Yeshivah College teacher David Kramer convicted of assaulting students",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teacher at a Chabad religious day school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teaching authority over young students at a religious school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Yeshivah College, Melbourne"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Australia",
"stage": "guilty plea, conviction and sentence",
"date": "2013-07-01",
"outcome": "Former Yeshivah College teacher David Kramer pleaded guilty to five counts of indecent assault and one indecent act against four students aged 10–11, committed 1989–1992, and was sentenced to 3 years 4 months. He had left Australia after the allegations first surfaced and was separately convicted in Missouri before extradition."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were young students at a Chabad religious day school under the defendant's teaching authority; the Royal Commission's Case Study 22 examined how the school's handling enabled his departure abroad.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.haaretz.com/jewish/australian-teacher-sentenced-to-prison-for-sex-abuse-1.5298928",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Australian Jewish day school teacher sentenced to prison for sex abuse', Haaretz (2013).",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea and sentence.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-22-yeshiva-bondi-and-yeshivah-melbourne",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, Case Study 22 (Yeshiva Bondi and Yeshivah Melbourne).",
"body": "The Royal Commission's findings on the institutional handling.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.haaretz.com/jewish/australian-teacher-sentenced-to-prison-for-sex-abuse-1.5298928",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-22-yeshiva-bondi-and-yeshivah-melbourne",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 368,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2014",
"note": "Appeal against the rape convictions rejected; conviction stands in full."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. An earlier pass held this case pending appeal verification; the appellate rejection is now confirmed and the record is admitted. A separate later NSW matter is not folded into this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-david-cyprys-yeshivah-college-melbourne-australia",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Melbourne, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.8136,
"lng": 144.9631,
"title": "Australia: Yeshivah College staff figure David Cyprys convicted of rape of a student; appeal rejected",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"security and martial-arts figure with unsupervised access at a religious school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional standing and unsupervised access to students at the religious school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Yeshivah College, Melbourne"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria; Victorian Court of Appeal",
"stage": "jury conviction and guilty pleas; appeal rejected",
"date": "2013-12-01",
"outcome": "David Cyprys was convicted by a jury of five rape charges against a former student and pleaded guilty to twelve further assault charges against eight other boys aged 7–14, abused 1984–1991 while he ran site security at Yeshivah College. He was sentenced to 8 years with a 5.5-year minimum. The Victorian Court of Appeal rejected his appeal against the rape convictions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were students of the religious school where the defendant's institutional role gave him standing and unsupervised access; the Royal Commission's Case Study 22 examined the community and institutional dynamics that suppressed reporting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.australianjewishnews.com/cyprys-found-guilty-of-child-sex-crimes/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cyprys found guilty of child sex crimes', Australian Jewish News (2013).",
"body": "Reports the jury verdict and guilty pleas.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2014",
"note": "Appeal against the rape convictions rejected; conviction stands in full."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.australianjewishnews.com/cyprys-found-guilty-of-child-sex-crimes/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 369,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event recording the Royal Commission's findings; individual convictions are recorded separately.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-royal-commission-ballarat-case-study-28-australia",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Ballarat, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.5622,
"lng": 143.8503,
"title": "Royal Commission Case Study 28: 'catastrophic failure' of church leadership in Ballarat",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Diocese of Ballarat leadership",
"religious orders operating parish schools"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"diocesan control of appointments enabling serial offenders' continued access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Ballarat"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — Case Study 28",
"stage": "royal commission finding",
"date": "2015-12-01",
"outcome": "The Royal Commission recorded 140 claimants against Ballarat priests and religious, with 90% of claims falling on seven priests and claims against 56 Christian Brothers, and found 'a catastrophic failure in the leadership of the Diocese' over decades that enabled serial offenders — Ridsdale, Best and Dowlan among them — unchecked access to children."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Commission's finding is precisely about authority: diocesan and order leadership controlled the appointments and transfers that kept known offenders in contact with children under their pastoral care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-28-catholic-church-authorities-ballarat",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, 'Report of Case Study No. 28' (2015).",
"body": "The Commission's findings on claims volume and leadership failure in Ballarat.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-28-catholic-church-authorities-ballarat",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 370,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event; individual convictions recorded separately. Findings concern the institutions examined, not Judaism generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-royal-commission-yeshivah-case-study-22-australia",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Melbourne and Sydney, Australia",
"lat": -37.8136,
"lng": 144.9631,
"title": "Royal Commission Case Study 22: reporting suppressed at Yeshivah institutions",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"rabbinical and school leadership at Chabad institutions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"application of mesirah concepts discouraging reports to secular authorities",
"community ostracism of survivors who reported"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Yeshivah Melbourne",
"Yeshiva Bondi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — Case Study 22",
"stage": "royal commission finding",
"date": "2017-01-01",
"outcome": "Examining the Cyprys, Kramer and related matters, the Commission identified 15 male victims of institutional child sexual abuse and found that the concept of mesirah — a prohibition on reporting a fellow Jew to secular authorities — was applied in ways that discouraged reporting, and that survivors who went to police were treated as community outcasts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Commission's findings identify a doctrinal mechanism operating on victims and their families: religious norms about reporting to secular authorities suppressed disclosure and punished those who disclosed.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-22-yeshiva-bondi-and-yeshivah-melbourne",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, 'Report of Case Study No. 22: Yeshiva Bondi and Yeshivah Melbourne' (2017).",
"body": "The Commission's findings on suppressed reporting and community treatment of survivors.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-22-yeshiva-bondi-and-yeshivah-melbourne",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 371,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The 1,006 figure is drawn from the organisation's internal records of allegations, not a count of adjudicated offenders, and is stated as the Commission reported it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-royal-commission-jehovahs-witnesses-case-study-29-australia",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Australia (national)",
"lat": -25.2744,
"lng": 133.7751,
"title": "Royal Commission Case Study 29: 1,006 alleged perpetrators in internal files, none reported by the organisation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregational elders administering internal judicial processes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"misapplication of the two-witness rule to child sexual abuse",
"internal discipline substituted for reporting to authorities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (Australia)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — Case Study 29",
"stage": "royal commission finding",
"date": "2016-10-01",
"outcome": "The Commission found the organisation's internal case files documented allegations against 1,006 individuals, none of whom the organisation itself referred to police; that the 'two-witness rule' was misapplied to child sexual abuse allegations; and that internal disciplinary sanctions left perpetrators at large with inadequate regard to reoffending risk."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Commission's findings concern the exercise of congregational religious authority over reporting itself: elders' internal processes governed whether abuse within the community ever reached secular authorities.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/media-releases/report-jehovahs-witness-organisations-released",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, 'Report of Case Study No. 29: The Jehovah's Witnesses' (Oct. 2016).",
"body": "The Commission's findings on internal files, the two-witness rule, and non-reporting.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/media-releases/report-jehovahs-witness-organisations-released",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 372,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns the institutional response mechanism, not new allegations of abuse. This is Case Study 16; a separate 2017 hearing (CS35) examined the Archdiocese more broadly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-royal-commission-melbourne-response-case-study-16-australia",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Melbourne, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.8136,
"lng": 144.9631,
"title": "Royal Commission Case Study 16: the Melbourne Response found insufficiently independent",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"archdiocesan complaints and compensation scheme"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"scheme structure discouraging complainants from police reporting"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Melbourne"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — Case Study 16",
"stage": "royal commission finding",
"date": "2015-07-01",
"outcome": "The Commission found the Melbourne Response — the archdiocesan complaints and compensation scheme established in 1996 — was not sufficiently independent of the Archdiocese, had conflicted legal advisers, and that its Independent Commissioner gave advice that discouraged at least two complainants from going to police."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The scheme through which survivors of clergy abuse had to seek redress was itself controlled by the religious authority whose clergy had abused them — the Commission's finding is about that structural conflict.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-16-melbourne-response",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, 'Report of Case Study No. 16: The Melbourne Response' (2015).",
"body": "The Commission's findings on independence, conflicts, and discouraged police reporting.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-16-melbourne-response",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 373,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2021-12-03",
"note": "Conviction upheld; one sentence component modified."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-robin-vadakkumchery-kottiyoor-kerala-india",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Kottiyoor, Kerala, India",
"lat": 11.9833,
"lng": 75.8667,
"title": "India: priest convicted of raping a sixteen-year-old parishioner; upheld by the Kerala High Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest (vicar)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a minor parishioner and her family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Sebastian Parish, Kottiyoor",
"Diocese of Mananthavady"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "POCSO Court, Thalassery, Kerala; Kerala High Court",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal with partial sentence modification",
"date": "2021-12-03",
"outcome": "Fr Robin Vadakkumchery, vicar of St Sebastian Parish Kottiyoor, was convicted in 2019 of raping and impregnating a 16-year-old parishioner in 2016 and sentenced to 20 years. The Kerala High Court upheld the conviction in 2021, modifying one sentence component. He was subsequently dismissed from the clerical state."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a minor parishioner of the church where the defendant was vicar, inside the pastoral relationship his office created with her family.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-priest-fr-robin-gets-20-years-jail-raping-impregnating-minor-girl-96833",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kerala priest Fr. Robin gets 20 years in jail for raping, impregnating minor girl', The News Minute (2019).",
"body": "Reports the POCSO court conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2021/12/03/kottiyoor-rape-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SCC Online, 'Kottiyoor Rape Case' (3 Dec. 2021).",
"body": "Indian legal publisher's summary of the Kerala High Court's affirmance.",
"tier": "legal-publisher-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2021-12-03",
"note": "Conviction upheld; one sentence component modified."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-priest-fr-robin-gets-20-years-jail-raping-impregnating-minor-girl-96833",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a756102aefc8c4037a7c44e72244d5b27724f3b7eb8e4d320dcbdf56bf98f7de",
"final_url": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-priest-fr-robin-gets-20-years-jail-raping-impregnating-minor-girl-96833"
},
{
"source": "https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2021/12/03/kottiyoor-rape-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-publisher-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cfade1bf401534802b4c88bb1cdf4cb0b2c61dc3d80319ccf4a61b35b205f849",
"final_url": "https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2021/12/03/kottiyoor-rape-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 374,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainant, not identified. Recent conviction; appellate status not yet resolved and should be monitored.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-bajinder-singh-yeshu-prophet-mohali-india",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Mohali, Punjab, India",
"lat": 30.7046,
"lng": 76.7179,
"title": "India: celebrity healing pastor Bajinder Singh sentenced to life for rape",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"megachurch pastor known for televised healing sessions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"faith-healing celebrity and religious trust used to isolate the victim",
"filming and blackmail"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions court, Mohali, Punjab, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-04-01",
"outcome": "Bajinder Singh, a megachurch pastor known as the 'Yeshu Yeshu' prophet for televised healing sessions, was convicted of the 2018 rape of a woman he had lured with promises of sending her abroad, filming the assault and blackmailing her with the footage. He was sentenced to life imprisonment in April 2025."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant came within the defendant's orbit through his standing as a celebrity faith healer; the religious trust that standing created is what he used to isolate her, and the healing ministry was the platform for the power he exercised.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.indiatvnews.com/news/india/breaking-pastor-bajinder-singh-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment-in-2018-sexual-harassment-case-2025-04-01-983289",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor Bajinder Singh sentenced to life imprisonment in 2018 case', India TV, 1 Apr. 2025.",
"body": "Reports the conviction and life sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.christianitytoday.com/2025/04/india-punjab-megachurch-bajinder-singh-healing-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'India Celebrity Pastor Faces Life in Prison for Rape', Christianity Today, Apr. 2025.",
"body": "Corroborating report with the healing-ministry context.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.indiatvnews.com/news/india/breaking-pastor-bajinder-singh-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment-in-2018-sexual-harassment-case-2025-04-01-983289",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a68e629cf129f67acb9a6d7a047d03cb2b756591362a9701de7d323f48102b7e",
"final_url": "https://www.indiatvnews.com/news/india/breaking-pastor-bajinder-singh-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment-in-2018-sexual-harassment-case-2025-04-01-983289"
},
{
"source": "https://www.christianitytoday.com/2025/04/india-punjab-megachurch-bajinder-singh-healing-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "73ce6bc833d836dbac11d96ca7308bfff6d22e4ebc1971cdd0827869e43add19",
"final_url": "https://www.christianitytoday.com/2025/04/india-punjab-megachurch-bajinder-singh-healing-rape/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 375,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeals-withdrawn",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Both sides withdrew appeals; verdict final (rechtskräftig)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The priest's full name is withheld under German press-privacy norms; the record follows the reporting. German-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-bad-kissingen-chaplain-altar-server-germany",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Bad Kissingen, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 50.2,
"lng": 10.0667,
"title": "Germany: Würzburg diocese chaplain's conviction for abusing an altar server becomes final",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic chaplain (Kaplan)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over an altar server in his care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Würzburg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Amtsgericht Bad Kissingen, Germany",
"stage": "conviction; final after both sides withdrew appeals",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "A priest of the Diocese of Würzburg was convicted of sexually abusing a then-12-year-old altar server at least twice while serving as chaplain, and received a suspended sentence of one year four months plus a fine. Both prosecution and defence withdrew their appeals before the Landgericht Schweinfurt, making the verdict final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was an altar server under the chaplain's direct pastoral care — the liturgical role placed the child in his charge.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/28770-priester-wegen-missbrauchs-verurteilt-berufung-zurueckgezogen",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Priester wegen Missbrauchs verurteilt – Berufung zurückgezogen', katholisch.de / KNA (2024).",
"body": "Reports the conviction and the withdrawal of appeals making it final.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeals-withdrawn",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Both sides withdrew appeals; verdict final (rechtskräftig)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/28770-priester-wegen-missbrauchs-verurteilt-berufung-zurueckgezogen",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "366c180af0f3562117a7bbe32202e515447b6af0ce466d48b2b095b1827e6251",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/28770-priester-wegen-missbrauchs-verurteilt-berufung-zurueckgezogen"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 376,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "final",
"date": "2026",
"note": "No appeal filed within the deadline; verdict final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; defendant unnamed per German press norms. German-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-ellwangen-islamlehrer-dormitory-germany",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Giengen an der Brenz, Baden-Württemberg, Germany",
"lat": 48.6217,
"lng": 10.245,
"title": "Germany: Islamic religious teacher convicted on 18 counts for abusing boys in the dormitory he ran",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Islamic religious teacher (Hodscha) running a student dormitory"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-instructor authority combined with residential custody of boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht Ellwangen, Germany",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; final (no appeal filed)",
"date": "2026-05-01",
"outcome": "A 35-year-old Islamic religious teacher was convicted on 18 counts including rape, sexual abuse of dependants and sexual abuse of children against seven boys aged 12–17 at a student dormitory he supervised in his religious-instructor role. He was sentenced to eight and a half years with a five-year ban on working with male minors. Neither side appealed and the verdict became final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boys lived in a dormitory the defendant ran in his capacity as their religious teacher — instruction and residential custody combined in one religious authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.islamiq.de/2026/05/03/hohe-haftstrafe-fuer-islamlehrer-nach-missbrauchsfaellen-in-schuelerwohnheim/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Hohe Haftstrafe für Islamlehrer nach Missbrauchsfällen in Schülerwohnheim', IslamiQ, 3 May 2026.",
"body": "Reports the 18-count conviction, the sentence, and the dormitory-supervision role.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "final",
"date": "2026",
"note": "No appeal filed within the deadline; verdict final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.islamiq.de/2026/05/03/hohe-haftstrafe-fuer-islamlehrer-nach-missbrauchsfaellen-in-schuelerwohnheim/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c6bb9e65663d302c6daba28af7e58ff92c7b6f1e3289512db8e9416370e5a070",
"final_url": "https://www.islamiq.de/2026/05/03/hohe-haftstrafe-fuer-islamlehrer-nach-missbrauchsfaellen-in-schuelerwohnheim/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 377,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2023",
"note": "Upheld by Sąd Okręgowy w Poznaniu; final (prawomocny)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The complainant, though partially named in Polish press as an adult who spoke publicly, is not named here. Polish-language sourcing including the national press agency.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-krzysztof-g-ministrant-chodziez-poland",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Chodzież, Poland",
"lat": 52.995,
"lng": 16.9186,
"title": "Poland: former priest's conviction for decade-long abuse of an altar server upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"grooming of an altar server (ministrant) under his direct supervision from childhood",
"physical violence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sąd Rejonowy w Chodzieży; Sąd Okręgowy w Poznaniu",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"date": "2023-11-01",
"outcome": "A former priest identified as Krzysztof G. was convicted of repeatedly raping and molesting a boy he had groomed as an altar server and exploited over more than a decade, including with physical violence. He was sentenced to eight years' unconditional imprisonment, a ten-year ban on work involving minors, and 150,000 złoty in compensation. The Poznań regional court upheld the verdict, making it final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was an altar server under the priest's direct spiritual and liturgical supervision from childhood — the ministrant relationship is what created the access and the dependency.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tvn24.pl/poznan/poznan-chodziez-byly-ksiadz-krzysztof-g-uslyszal-prawomocny-wyrok-st8379365",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Były ksiądz Krzysztof G. usłyszał prawomocny wyrok', TVN24 (2023).",
"body": "Reports the appellate confirmation and the final sentence.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.pap.pl/aktualnosci/gwalcil-i-molestowal-ministranta-byly-ksiadz-z-chodziezy-skazany",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Gwałcił i molestował ministranta. Były ksiądz z Chodzieży skazany', PAP.",
"body": "Poland's national news agency reporting the conviction and its basis.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2023",
"note": "Upheld by Sąd Okręgowy w Poznaniu; final (prawomocny)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tvn24.pl/poznan/poznan-chodziez-byly-ksiadz-krzysztof-g-uslyszal-prawomocny-wyrok-st8379365",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7461f9cb04df1da3253e1947d4bde541258e224d3f054c4db6baab850b28b0a9",
"final_url": "https://tvn24.pl/poznan/poznan-chodziez-byly-ksiadz-krzysztof-g-uslyszal-prawomocny-wyrok-st8379365"
},
{
"source": "https://www.pap.pl/aktualnosci/gwalcil-i-molestowal-ministranta-byly-ksiadz-z-chodziezy-skazany",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d02032286070b4dd9d8fbd985a7bdca8af8edf52b89ff177db3bfcb2c8a9c43d",
"final_url": "https://www.pap.pl/aktualnosci/gwalcil-i-molestowal-ministranta-byly-ksiadz-z-chodziezy-skazany"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 378,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Defence appeal rejected in full; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Sourced directly to the district prosecutor's office — the strongest available tier. Polish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-lukasz-r-prosecutor-ostroleka-poland",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ostrołęka, Mazovia, Poland",
"lat": 53.0843,
"lng": 21.575,
"title": "Poland: priest's six-year sentence for molesting a minor confirmed; sourced to the prosecutor's office",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest (wikariusz)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral influence over a minor student",
"alcohol and pornography used in grooming"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Polish courts; appeal rejected by Sąd Okręgowy w Ostrołęce",
"stage": "conviction; appeal rejected (final)",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "A priest identified as Łukasz R. was convicted of sexually molesting a minor, plying him with alcohol and showing him pornography between 2011 and 2016. He was sentenced to six years, a ten-year ban on work with minors, a no-contact order and 50,000 złoty in compensation. The regional court rejected the defence appeal in full."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a minor under the priest's pastoral influence; the grooming ran through the standing his office gave him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.pl/web/po-ostroleka/ksiadz-skazany-o-przestepstwa-seksualne-przeciwko-maloletnim",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Prokuratura Okręgowa w Ostrołęce, 'Ksiądz skazany o przestępstwa seksualne przeciwko małoletnim' (2024).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own statement of the conviction, sentence and orders.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Defence appeal rejected in full; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.pl/web/po-ostroleka/ksiadz-skazany-o-przestepstwa-seksualne-przeciwko-maloletnim",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "319ead18eb9cd856b2a3bf658f7dcbe0910988d9459574fc1ae1b5fc5c312ef1",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.pl/web/po-ostroleka/ksiadz-skazany-o-przestepstwa-seksualne-przeciwko-maloletnim"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 379,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024-04-26",
"note": "Upheld; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The complainant was a minor at the time and is not identified. Polish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-jaroslaw-z-rectory-massage-zamosc-poland",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Biłgoraj, Zamość, Poland",
"lat": 50.5413,
"lng": 22.7224,
"title": "Poland: priest convicted of molesting a seventeen-year-old at the rectory under a massage pretext",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"summons of a minor parishioner to the rectory on a pastoral pretext"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sąd Rejonowy w Zamościu; Sąd Okręgowy w Zamościu",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"date": "2024-04-26",
"outcome": "A priest identified as Jarosław Z. invited a 17-year-old to the rectory in 2012 and, under the pretext of a massage, touched her intimately. She reported in 2021. The conviction was upheld on appeal on 26 April 2024: a suspended one-year sentence, a no-contact order, a five-year ban on work with minors, and 10,000 złoty to the victim."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest's office is what summoned a minor parishioner to the rectory and framed the contact as innocent — the setting and the pretext both flowed from his pastoral standing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://radio.lublin.pl/2024/04/ksiadz-skazany-za-molestowanie-nieletniej-wyrok-juz-prawomocny/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ksiądz skazany za molestowanie nieletniej. Wyrok już prawomocny', Radio Lublin, Apr. 2024.",
"body": "Reports the appellate confirmation and the orders imposed.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024-04-26",
"note": "Upheld; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://radio.lublin.pl/2024/04/ksiadz-skazany-za-molestowanie-nieletniej-wyrok-juz-prawomocny/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "77afe3511cf04809fdb84cd11f276bf9b38a60e18073feed85307d30aff52605",
"final_url": "https://radio.lublin.pl/2024/04/ksiadz-skazany-za-molestowanie-nieletniej-wyrok-juz-prawomocny/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 380,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainant, not identified; defendant unnamed per Belgian practice. First-instance conviction; whether an appeal was filed after December 2025 was not confirmed. French-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-namur-seminary-vice-rector-nivelles-belgium",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Limelette, Walloon Brabant, Belgium",
"lat": 50.6667,
"lng": 4.5667,
"title": "Belgium: seminary vice-rector convicted of repeatedly raping a seminarian under his formation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"seminary formator and vice-rector"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"formation authority over a seminarian whose priestly future depended on him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Seminary of Namur (Limelette)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal correctionnel du Brabant wallon, Nivelles, Belgium",
"stage": "conviction and sentence (appeal status unconfirmed)",
"date": "2025-12-01",
"outcome": "A 45-year-old priest who served as formator and vice-rector of the Namur seminary was convicted of repeatedly raping a Polish seminarian who came under his authority at Limelette from the age of 20, and was sentenced on 1 December 2025 to 40 months' unconditional imprisonment. The victim first disclosed during confession. The defendant has since left the priesthood."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a seminarian in the defendant's direct formation — his progress to ordination ran through the man abusing him, the same structure as the Romanian Huși case.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lavenir.net/fil-info/regions/2025/12/01/tc-nivelles-40-mois-de-prison-ferme-pour-un-pretre-coupable-du-viol-dun-seminariste-GBWAQXE6FFCG3HYQB6IGR3HWU4/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Quarante mois de prison ferme pour un prêtre coupable du viol d'un séminariste', L'Avenir, 1 Dec. 2025.",
"body": "Belgian court reporting of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lavenir.net/fil-info/regions/2025/12/01/tc-nivelles-40-mois-de-prison-ferme-pour-un-pretre-coupable-du-viol-dun-seminariste-GBWAQXE6FFCG3HYQB6IGR3HWU4/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "be40e96ae7deea8b4c27570c8108638e67ac8038bcd9dd2277f718fbf7ce44e1",
"final_url": "https://www.lavenir.net/fil-info/regions/2025/12/01/tc-nivelles-40-mois-de-prison-ferme-pour-un-pretre-coupable-du-viol-dun-seminariste-GBWAQXE6FFCG3HYQB6IGR3HWU4/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 381,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; defendant partially named per Belgian practice. Appeal status not confirmed. Dutch-language sourcing from the national public broadcaster.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-antwerp-imam-mosque-boys-belgium",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Antwerp, Belgium",
"lat": 51.2194,
"lng": 4.4025,
"title": "Belgium: imam sentenced to six years for abusing two boys in the mosque context",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam with religious-instructional authority over children"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious instruction of children at the mosque"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Antwerp court, Belgium",
"stage": "conviction and sentence (appeal status unconfirmed)",
"date": "2024-03-26",
"outcome": "An imam identified as Ibrahim B., 49, was convicted of the rape of a 10-year-old boy and assault of a 13-year-old boy in the mosque context where he held religious-instructional authority, and was sentenced on 26 March 2024 to six years' imprisonment plus ten years' probation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both boys were children within the mosque's religious instruction, under the imam's teaching authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2024/03/26/imam-uit-antwerpen-krijgt-6-jaar-cel-voor-seksueel-misbruik-van/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Imam uit Antwerpen krijgt 6 jaar cel voor seksueel misbruik van twee jongens in moskee', VRT NWS, 26 Mar. 2024.",
"body": "Belgium's public broadcaster reporting the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2024/03/26/imam-uit-antwerpen-krijgt-6-jaar-cel-voor-seksueel-misbruik-van/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4bca9949f8f28bb78362ec21736ab249037e4afd49cd90025b4be297ab7621b7",
"final_url": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2024/03/26/imam-uit-antwerpen-krijgt-6-jaar-cel-voor-seksueel-misbruik-van/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 382,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "landsret",
"date": "2018-08-28",
"note": "Sentence and professional ban upheld; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR DENMARK — the largest abuse case in the Church of Denmark's history, appeal-confirmed. Danish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-dan-peschack-tommerup-parish-denmark",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Tømmerup, Kalundborg, Denmark",
"lat": 55.6667,
"lng": 11.1333,
"title": "Denmark: parish priest's ten-year sentence for decade-long abuse of eight parish youths upheld",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest of the Church of Denmark"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust-building with parish youths",
"abuse at the rectory over a decade"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Denmark (Folkekirken)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Danish district court; Østre Landsret (Eastern High Court)",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"date": "2018-08-28",
"outcome": "Dan Peschack, former parish priest of Tømmerup, was convicted on 25 of 30 counts of repeated, severe sexual abuse of seven boys and one girl aged 12–16 over a ten-year period at the rectory, including intercourse and filming. The district court imposed ten years in November 2017; Østre Landsret upheld the sentence and a ban on serving as a priest in August 2018. The court found he exploited his psychological authority as priest."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's own finding: he exploited the psychological authority of the priesthood and the trust relationships it created with the parish youths in his care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kristeligt-dagblad.dk/kirke-tro/landsretten-fastholder-dom-tidligere-praest-i-toemmerup-faar-10-aars-faengsel-overgreb",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Landsretten fastholder dom: Tidligere præst i Tømmerup får 10 års fængsel for overgreb', Kristeligt Dagblad, Aug. 2018.",
"body": "Reports the appellate confirmation of the ten-year sentence and the court's finding on exploited pastoral authority.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "landsret",
"date": "2018-08-28",
"note": "Sentence and professional ban upheld; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kristeligt-dagblad.dk/kirke-tro/landsretten-fastholder-dom-tidligere-praest-i-toemmerup-faar-10-aars-faengsel-overgreb",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c57b566dca84c37fdb73766076b9245e40975f75191f0d6c12dbd03cbd9307ce",
"final_url": "https://www.kristeligt-dagblad.dk/kirke-tro/landsretten-fastholder-dom-tidligere-praest-i-toemmerup-faar-10-aars-faengsel-overgreb"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 383,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. German-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-august-mandorfer-kremsmunster-austria",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Kremsmünster, Upper Austria, Austria",
"lat": 48.0544,
"lng": 14.1286,
"title": "Austria: Benedictine boarding-school director convicted of abusing 24 students",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Benedictine monk",
"prefect, then director of the abbey boarding school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial and disciplinary authority over resident students at a monastic school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Stift Kremsmünster"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landesgericht Steyr, Austria",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2013-07-03",
"outcome": "August Mandorfer (Pater Alfons), a Benedictine monk of Stift Kremsmünster who served as prefect and then director of its boarding school until 1996, was convicted on 3 July 2013 of the documented sexual abuse of 24 former students under his custodial authority and sentenced to twelve years. He had been laicised by Pope Benedict XVI in 2012 following canonical proceedings."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were boys resident at a monastic boarding school where the defendant, as monk and director, held combined religious, custodial and disciplinary authority over them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.profil.at/home/stift-kremsmuenster-ex-konviktsdirektor-jahren-haft-361472",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Stift Kremsmünster: Ex-Konviktsdirektor zu zwölf Jahren Haft verurteilt', profil (Austria), July 2013.",
"body": "Austrian news magazine reporting the Landesgericht Steyr conviction and twelve-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.profil.at/home/stift-kremsmuenster-ex-konviktsdirektor-jahren-haft-361472",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fda0053381f1fa7adc093aa4bd057dfa70698e1efa34a6ddd97719739941ea6d",
"final_url": "https://www.profil.at/home/stift-kremsmuenster-ex-konviktsdirektor-jahren-haft-361472"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 384,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; defendant unnamed per Swiss press norms. Appeal status as of mid-2026 unconfirmed. German-language sourcing from the Swiss public broadcaster.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-ascona-school-chaplain-prayer-trips-switzerland",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Ascona, Ticino, Switzerland",
"lat": 46.155,
"lng": 8.77,
"title": "Switzerland: school chaplain and cantonal religious-education head convicted over abuse on prayer trips",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"school chaplain",
"cantonal head of Catholic religious instruction",
"youth chaplain"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"reflection and prayer trips he organised and led",
"layered institutional and spiritual authority over the youths"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Collegio Papio, Ascona"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lugano court, Ticino, Switzerland",
"stage": "conviction and sentence (appeal status unconfirmed)",
"date": "2025-08-14",
"outcome": "A 56-year-old priest — chaplain of the Collegio Papio in Ascona, the most senior official for Catholic religious instruction in Canton Ticino, and a youth chaplain — was convicted of multiple counts of sexual coercion and sexual acts with minors against nine young people (four minors) between 2015 and 2023, committed largely during reflection and prayer trips he organised. He received a suspended 18-month term and a lifetime ban on activity involving minors."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Three layers of religious authority converged on the same youths — school chaplaincy, cantonal control of their religious education, and youth pastoral care — and the offences occurred on spiritual excursions he alone organised and controlled.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.srf.ch/news/schweiz/sexueller-missbrauch-eineinhalbjaehrige-bedingte-freiheitsstrafe-fuer-priester-im-tessin",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Eineinhalbjährige bedingte Freiheitsstrafe für Priester im Tessin', SRF, 14 Aug. 2025.",
"body": "Switzerland's public broadcaster reporting the conviction, the counts, and the prayer-trip setting.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.srf.ch/news/schweiz/sexueller-missbrauch-eineinhalbjaehrige-bedingte-freiheitsstrafe-fuer-priester-im-tessin",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a06e54bfc8a9cba57ffb5d5caa05e221195586ee38a24b6891815376ede375dd",
"final_url": "https://www.srf.ch/news/schweiz/sexueller-missbrauch-eineinhalbjaehrige-bedingte-freiheitsstrafe-fuer-priester-im-tessin"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 385,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2021-02-16",
"note": "Appellate conviction."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Reporting differs on the victim's gender between outlets; the record follows the court-reported facts without resolving that discrepancy, which is flagged. Defendant unnamed per Swiss norms. German-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-lugano-priest-spiritual-director-switzerland",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Lugano, Ticino, Switzerland",
"lat": 46.0037,
"lng": 8.9511,
"title": "Switzerland: priest convicted on appeal of raping and drugging a person under his spiritual direction",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest serving as confirmation sponsor and spiritual director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-direction relationship",
"administration of narcotics"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Appellationsgericht (Court of Appeal), Lugano, Switzerland",
"stage": "appellate conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-02-16",
"outcome": "A 49-year-old Ticino priest was convicted by the Lugano appellate court of sexual coercion, rape and narcotics offences against a young person in his spiritual charge — reporting frames the relationship as that of confirmation sponsor and spiritual director. He was sentenced to four years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was under the defendant's spiritual direction in connection with confirmation — a formal relationship of religious guidance that supplied both trust and access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tagesanzeiger.ch/missbrauch-tessin-opfer-enttaeuscht-nach-urteil-gegen-priester-527019419494",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Missbrauch Tessin: Opfer enttäuscht nach Urteil gegen Priester', Tages-Anzeiger, Feb. 2021.",
"body": "Swiss paper of record reporting the appellate conviction and four-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2021-02-16",
"note": "Appellate conviction."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tagesanzeiger.ch/missbrauch-tessin-opfer-enttaeuscht-nach-urteil-gegen-priester-527019419494",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 386,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified; priest unnamed in Swedish reporting. Appeal status unconfirmed. Swedish-language sourcing from the national public broadcaster.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-uppsala-priest-confirmand-sweden",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Uppsala, Sweden",
"lat": 59.8586,
"lng": 17.6389,
"title": "Sweden: priest convicted of child rape of his own confirmand",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Church of Sweden priest instructing confirmands"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"direct religious instruction of a minor preparing for confirmation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Sweden, Diocese of Uppsala"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Swedish court, Uppsala",
"stage": "conviction and sentence (appeal status unconfirmed)",
"date": "2015-01-01",
"outcome": "A priest in his thirties in the Uppsala diocese was convicted of rape of a child after a sexual relationship with one of his own confirmands — a minor preparing for confirmation under his direct instruction. He was sentenced to two and a half years; the court noted his impending defrocking."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was the priest's own confirmand — a child whose admission to full church membership ran through his instruction, the same initiatory-authority structure as altar-server and seminary cases elsewhere in this corpus.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/uppsala/falls-for-sex-med-konfirmand",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Präst döms för våldtäkt mot barn', SVT Nyheter (Uppsala).",
"body": "Sweden's public broadcaster reporting the conviction of the priest for offences against his confirmand.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/uppsala/falls-for-sex-med-konfirmand",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "11671e50c2e531407aa2ba6778a00282515f06159e9908707dd7d3439a35d9b2",
"final_url": "https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/uppsala/falls-for-sex-med-konfirmand"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 387,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The suspended three-month sentence is recorded as reported; the database takes no position beyond the disposition. Consistent accounts across at least three independent Senegalese outlets; no tribunal reference number was locatable. French-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-moussa-seck-daara-thienaba-senegal",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Thiénaba, Thiès, Senegal",
"lat": 14.7833,
"lng": -16.7833,
"title": "Senegal: marabout convicted after four talibés died at his unregistered daara",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Quranic teacher (marabout) running a boarding daara"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial and spiritual authority over boarded talibés",
"dependence on the marabout for food"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal, Thiès region, Senegal",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"outcome": "Marabout Moussa Seck, who ran an undeclared and uninspected daara boarding fourteen talibé boys, was convicted of endangering the lives of others after four boys of about eleven died from ingesting toxic seeds they had foraged under conditions of neglect and malnutrition. He received a three-month suspended sentence — a disposition the reporting itself records as symbolic."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boys were talibés boarded under the marabout's total custodial and spiritual authority in the daara tradition; they depended on him for food and could not leave — the conditions that led them to forage the seeds that killed them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dakaractu.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Quatre talibés morts à Thiénaba: le maître coranique condamné', DakarActu (2021), corroborated by SeneNews and Walf.",
"body": "Senegalese press reporting the conviction for endangering the lives of others and the suspended sentence after the four deaths.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dakaractu.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "36ba346dfcbd4f92af7ec9ca04327d99eda5635737a02ea48978cb31640bd86a",
"final_url": "https://www.dakaractu.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 388,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event recording an official oversight action, NOT a criminal conviction of any individual: despite criminal provisions in force since 1982/1988, no named conviction of a dedicator or temple figure was locatable — an enforcement gap this record documents rather than conceals. Complements the existing 2007 devadasi aggregate record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-nhrc-devadasi-suo-motu-notice-india",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh, India",
"lat": 15.3173,
"lng": 75.7139,
"title": "India: NHRC issues suo motu notices over continued devadasi dedication despite decades-old bans",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"temple and priestly structures receiving dedicated girls",
"dedicating families acting under religious custom"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pre-puberty dedication binding a girl as 'servant of the deity'",
"channeling of dedicated girls into sexual exploitation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"institutional-obedience",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "National Human Rights Commission of India",
"stage": "suo motu notices to the Union and six state governments",
"date": "2022-10-14",
"outcome": "The NHRC issued suo motu notices to the Union government and six states over the continued practice of devadasi dedication decades after the state prohibition acts (Karnataka 1982, Andhra Pradesh 1988), citing the Justice Raghunath Rao Commission's finding of roughly 80,000 devadasis in Telangana and Andhra Pradesh and estimates of about 70,000 in Karnataka, and demanded compliance reports within six weeks."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The devadasi institution binds a girl, dedicated before puberty, as a servant of the deity — a spiritual status that then structures her exploitation. The NHRC's action documents both the institution's persistence and the near-total absence of prosecutions under the acts that ban it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nhrc.nic.in/media/press-release/nhrc-notices-centre-and-six-states-over-continued-devadasi-system-country",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Human Rights Commission of India, press release, 14 Oct. 2022.",
"body": "The NHRC's own notice recording the practice's persistence, the commission findings cited, and the compliance demand.",
"tier": "official-government-body",
"kind": "official-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nhrc.nic.in/media/press-release/nhrc-notices-centre-and-six-states-over-continued-devadasi-system-country",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-body; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "867f9ecff74ef285a83a0d6537ca4532e1eb178777d4a2c27fc4cf88cf20b3ae",
"final_url": "https://nhrc.nic.in/media/press-release/nhrc-notices-centre-and-six-states-over-continued-devadasi-system-country"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 389,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Previously held pending paper-of-record sourcing; now confirmed via ABC News reporting of the conviction history.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-michael-glennon-peaceful-hand-melbourne-australia",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Melbourne, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.8136,
"lng": 144.9631,
"title": "Australia: priest and youth-foundation director Michael Glennon convicted across three rounds",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest",
"director of a religious youth foundation and camp"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly standing and youth-camp authority over children in his programs"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Peaceful Hand Youth Foundation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Victorian courts, Australia",
"stage": "convictions in 1978, 1991 and 2003",
"date": "2003-10-01",
"outcome": "Michael Glennon was convicted in 1978 (two years), in 1991 (seven years, for buggery with violence and indecent assault), and in 2003 of 23 further offences including rape, receiving an effective 22-year sentence with a 15-year minimum. He used his priesthood and his Peaceful Hand Youth Foundation camps as access to children. He died in prison on 1 January 2014."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were participants in a religious youth program run by a priest — his clerical standing created the foundation, the camps, and the parents' trust that delivered children into his control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-08-25/church-took-20-years-to-defrock-paedophile-priest-inquiry-hears/5695346",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Church took 20 years to defrock paedophile priest, inquiry hears', ABC News, 25 Aug. 2014.",
"body": "Australia's public broadcaster confirming the three conviction rounds, the sentences, and his death in custody.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-08-25/church-took-20-years-to-defrock-paedophile-priest-inquiry-hears/5695346",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4e196f9fd696c8fc0d7dbd106a3f7d4bcdf6ef84b5a4efd3cf4b5f146231b620",
"final_url": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-08-25/church-took-20-years-to-defrock-paedophile-priest-inquiry-hears/5695346"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 390,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Previously held pending paper-of-record sourcing; now confirmed via Newcastle Herald and ABC court reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-vincent-ryan-maitland-newcastle-australia",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Newcastle, NSW, Australia",
"lat": -32.9283,
"lng": 151.7817,
"title": "Australia: priest Vincent Ryan convicted in four rounds of abusing altar boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish authority over altar boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "NSW courts, Australia",
"stage": "convictions in 1996, 1997, 2016 and 2019",
"date": "2019-05-22",
"outcome": "Vincent Ryan was convicted on 23 May 1996 (six years), on 24 September 1997 on a guilty plea to 53 offences (16 years 6 months), on 14 October 2016 (suspended sentence), and on 22 May 2019 of indecent assault of altar boys (3 years 3 months, 14-month non-parole). He abused at least 37 children, mostly altar boys, and died in 2022."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were altar boys serving under the priest in his own parishes — the liturgical role placed them in his charge.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6135939/monster-of-merewether-goes-back-to-jail/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"'Monster of Merewether' goes back to jail for another three years and three months\", Newcastle Herald, 22 May 2019.",
"body": "Reports the 2019 conviction and the cumulative history across all four rounds.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6135939/monster-of-merewether-goes-back-to-jail/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 391,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal-withdrawn",
"date": "2018-04-13",
"note": "Appeal withdrawn; sentence final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Previously held pending name, date and appeal status; all three now confirmed. Danish-language sourcing from the national public broadcaster.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-christian-raburn-frikirke-silkeborg-denmark",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Silkeborg, Denmark",
"lat": 56.1697,
"lng": 9.5451,
"title": "Denmark: free-church pastor convicted of abusing eight congregants, deported",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a free church (frikirke)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over children and young people of his congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Retten i Viborg, Denmark",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; appeal withdrawn (final)",
"date": "2018-03-06",
"outcome": "Christian Laursen Raburn, former pastor of a now-closed free church in Silkeborg, was convicted by a unanimous verdict on 6 March 2018 of sexually abusing eight children and young people from his congregation, and sentenced to three and a half years' imprisonment with deportation to the United States. He appealed on 13 March 2018 and withdrew the appeal on 13 April 2018, making the sentence final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The eight victims were children and young people of the congregation the defendant pastored — his pulpit is what placed them within his reach.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/regionale/oestjylland/dom-til-sexanklaget-frikirkepraest-tre-et-halvt-aars-faengsel-og",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Dom til sexanklaget frikirkepræst: Tre et halvt års fængsel og udvisning', DR, 6 Mar. 2018.",
"body": "Denmark's public broadcaster reporting the unanimous verdict, the sentence, and the deportation order.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal-withdrawn",
"date": "2018-04-13",
"note": "Appeal withdrawn; sentence final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/regionale/oestjylland/dom-til-sexanklaget-frikirkepraest-tre-et-halvt-aars-faengsel-og",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d54abce275ad09f66cac60cff0b9f15b5b51836dd76c1a5bc44fbbabdf11af37",
"final_url": "https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/regionale/oestjylland/dom-til-sexanklaget-frikirkepraest-tre-et-halvt-aars-faengsel-og"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 392,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim among the complainants, not identified. The 66-year figure is nominal; the effective term is 21 years, and both are stated. Spanish-language sourcing across two independent outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-hilario-gutierrez-santa-cruz-costa-rica",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Santa Cruz, Guanacaste, Costa Rica",
"lat": 10.26,
"lng": -85.5847,
"title": "Costa Rica: pastor convicted on 13 counts of sexual abuse, 66 years nominal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a church in Santa Cruz"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"church meetings and church-related activities used to isolate victims",
"pastoral standing over congregants including a minor"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Costa Rican criminal court, Guanacaste",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-01-01",
"outcome": "Hilario Gutiérrez Pérez, pastor of a church in the Buenos Aires district of Santa Cruz, was convicted on 13 counts of sexual abuse against four victims, including a 13-year-old summoned to a church meeting. The nominal sentence of 66 years was adjusted to an effective 21 years under Costa Rica's concurrent-sentence rules."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "At least one victim, a 13-year-old, was summoned by the pastor to a church meeting where abuse occurred, and the pattern ran through church-related activities — the pastoral office supplied both the summons and the trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nacion.com/sucesos/judiciales/pastor-evangelico-condenado-a-21-anos-de-carcel/X5RPN4BDVZCBVPGQVJQUU2U2IQ/story/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor evangélico condenado a 21 años de cárcel', La Nación (Costa Rica).",
"body": "Costa Rica's paper of record reporting the conviction and the effective sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nacion.com/sucesos/judiciales/pastor-evangelico-condenado-a-21-anos-de-carcel/X5RPN4BDVZCBVPGQVJQUU2U2IQ/story/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6c92e24c027790ec135ccd3583bc3f60fb423f91ddad7760c185c38c4fba3d8e",
"final_url": "https://www.nacion.com/sucesos/judiciales/pastor-evangelico-condenado-a-21-anos-de-carcel/X5RPN4BDVZCBVPGQVJQUU2U2IQ/story/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 393,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; two were minors. Appeal outcome not confirmed. Sourced to the state judiciary and prosecution service. Portuguese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-tubarao-pastor-fraud-nine-congregants-brazil",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Tubarão, Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"lat": -28.4667,
"lng": -49.0069,
"title": "Brazil: pastor sentenced to 40 years for sexual violation by fraud of nine congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"libidinous acts committed under the pretext of prayer and spiritual support",
"exploitation of congregants' religious trust in his ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Justiça de Santa Catarina (TJSC), Brazil",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-11-01",
"outcome": "A 53-year-old evangelical pastor in Tubarão was sentenced to 40 years for sexual violation by fraud (violação sexual mediante fraude) against nine victims — eight women, including two minors, and one man — committed between 2011 and 2021 under the pretext of prayer and spiritual support, inside the church, in victims' homes and elsewhere. He was denied the right to appeal at liberty."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's charge itself encodes the mechanism: fraud through the ministerial role — the victims submitted to what they believed were prayer and spiritual acts by their pastor.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/pastor-de-tubarao-e-condenado-a-40-anos-de-prisao-por-violacao-sexual-mediante-fraude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tribunal de Justiça de Santa Catarina, 'Pastor de Tubarão é condenado a 40 anos de prisão por violação sexual mediante fraude' (2022).",
"body": "The state judiciary's own release on the conviction, counts and sentence.",
"tier": "official-judiciary-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/pastor-de-tubarao-e-condenado-a-40-anos-de-prisao-por-violacao-sexual-mediante-fraude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-judiciary-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "20ee66e48e130cf4d35d8d57c6ae947d0740cfb6e8600688795f1aceba5162ed",
"final_url": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/pastor-de-tubarao-e-condenado-a-40-anos-de-prisao-por-violacao-sexual-mediante-fraude"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 394,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; the defendant's denomination is unclear in the sources, which describe him as a 'líder religioso' — the record follows that framing rather than assigning a tradition. Sourced to the state judiciary. Portuguese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-criciuma-religious-leader-ritual-pretext-brazil",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Criciúma region, Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"lat": -28.6775,
"lng": -49.3697,
"title": "Brazil: religious leader sentenced to 45 years for sexual crimes against four women seeking spiritual help",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled religious/spiritual leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claims that ritual or spiritual work required sexual acts",
"targeting of emotionally vulnerable women seeking religious support"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Justiça de Santa Catarina (TJSC), Brazil",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "A religious leader in southern Santa Catarina was sentenced to 45 years in closed regime for rape, sexual violation by fraud and harassment against four emotionally vulnerable women during 2023, committed under the pretext that ritual or spiritual work required sexual acts. In one case he suffocated a victim to stop her calling for help."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims sought him out for spiritual support, and the court found the sexual acts were extracted as purported ritual requirements — the claimed spiritual authority is the instrument throughout.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-45-anos-por-crimes-sexuais-contra-fieis-no-sul-de-sc-",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tribunal de Justiça de Santa Catarina, 'Líder religioso é condenado a 45 anos por crimes sexuais contra fiéis no sul de SC' (2024).",
"body": "The state judiciary's release on the conviction and 45-year closed-regime sentence.",
"tier": "official-judiciary-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-45-anos-por-crimes-sexuais-contra-fieis-no-sul-de-sc-",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-judiciary-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "071df6f9170e4c9aebedc1519d8a299f18dfd13cb311fad1e7fe1187a542e013",
"final_url": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-45-anos-por-crimes-sexuais-contra-fieis-no-sul-de-sc-"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 395,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2023",
"note": "Sentence reported increased to 175 years; confirm against TJSP record."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Sourced to the São Paulo prosecution service. This record concerns a perpetrator who abused the forms of a legitimate religion whose communities themselves face persecution in Brazil; it must not be read as characterising Umbanda or Candomblé. Portuguese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-vagner-meleiro-terreiro-sorocaba-brazil",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Sorocaba, São Paulo, Brazil",
"lat": -23.5015,
"lng": -47.4526,
"title": "Brazil: pai de santo convicted of raping twelve terreiro members through simulated spirit incorporation",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pai de santo of a terreiro"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"simulated spirit incorporation to present sex as required 'spiritual work'",
"claimed power over life and death"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"spiritual-consequence",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Justiça de São Paulo; Ministério Público de São Paulo",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-01-01",
"outcome": "Vagner Meleiro, a pai de santo in Sorocaba's Jardim Zulmira, was convicted of raping twelve proven victims — ten abused repeatedly over more than a decade — by simulating spirit incorporation to convince terreiro members that sex with him was required spiritual work, and by claiming control over life and death. His initial sentence of 136 years was reported increased to 175 years on appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The simulated incorporation is the criterion in ritual form: victims believed the entity, not the man, demanded the acts — the terreiro's ritual grammar was counterfeited into an instrument of rape. The record documents an individual's fraud, not Afro-Brazilian religion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mpsp.mp.br/w/homem-que-se-apresentava-como-pai-de-santo-em-sorocaba-%C3%A9-condenado-por-estupros",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministério Público de São Paulo, 'Homem que se apresentava como pai de santo em Sorocaba é condenado por estupros' (2022).",
"body": "The state prosecution service's release on the conviction and the simulated-incorporation mechanism.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2023",
"note": "Sentence reported increased to 175 years; confirm against TJSP record."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mpsp.mp.br/w/homem-que-se-apresentava-como-pai-de-santo-em-sorocaba-%C3%A9-condenado-por-estupros",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 396,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Some victims were family members; the record is admitted because non-family girls in his religious circle were also victims and the prosecutorial finding centres the religious-trust mechanism. Same anti-defamation note as all Afro-Brazilian records: this documents an individual, not the tradition. Portuguese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-tres-de-maio-purification-ritual-brazil",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Três de Maio, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil",
"lat": -27.7833,
"lng": -54.24,
"title": "Brazil: pai de santo sentenced to 259 years for rapes framed as a 'purification process'",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pai de santo"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rapes presented as a required 'purification process'",
"secrecy demanded under threat",
"religious trust of families in his circle"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "2ª Vara Judicial de Três de Maio, Rio Grande do Sul; Ministério Público do RS",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"outcome": "A pai de santo was sentenced to 259 years in closed regime for raping seven girls under 14 between 2009 and 2024 — including stepdaughters, a granddaughter, and other girls within his religious circle — telling them the rapes were part of a 'processo de purificação' and demanding secrecy under threat."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The prosecution's own framing is that manipulated religious trust enabled the harm: the purification doctrine bound both family and non-family victims, which distinguishes this from purely domestic cases — the ritual claim, not the household, is what made refusal impossible for girls across his circle.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mprs.mp.br/noticias/61968/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministério Público do Rio Grande do Sul, release no. 61968 (2025).",
"body": "The state prosecution service's release on the conviction, the 259-year sentence, and the purification pretext.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mprs.mp.br/noticias/61968/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d62723cc156dc416c56eba32a87233c1d519ac29d97ff39623743d627174c8e8",
"final_url": "https://www.mprs.mp.br/noticias/61968/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 397,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The comparatively short sentence and the defendant's fugitive status at reporting are both recorded. Same anti-defamation note as the other Afro-Brazilian records. Portuguese-language sourcing across three national outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-laercio-oliveira-spiritual-cleansing-sao-paulo-brazil",
"year": 2024,
"place": "São Paulo, Brazil",
"lat": -23.5505,
"lng": -46.6333,
"title": "Brazil: terreiro leader convicted of abusing five women told sex was 'spiritual cleansing'",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pai de santo / terreiro leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual consultations in which sex was presented as required 'cleansing'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Justiça de São Paulo, Brazil",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; defendant a fugitive at time of reporting",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "Laércio José de Oliveira, a terreiro leader in São Paulo's east zone, was convicted of sexual harassment and violation by fraud against five women (of eight who reported) whom he told during spiritual consultations that sexual relations with him were required for 'spiritual cleansing'. He was sentenced to three years, one month and ten days in closed regime, and remained a fugitive at the time of reporting."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The consultations were the setting and the cleansing doctrine the instrument: the women submitted to what they were told was a spiritual requirement.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/pai-de-santo-e-condenado-por-abusar-de-5-mulheres-em-sao-paulo/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pai de santo é condenado por abusar de 5 mulheres em São Paulo', CNN Brasil (2024).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the cleansing pretext, the sentence and the fugitive status.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/pai-de-santo-e-condenado-por-abusar-de-5-mulheres-em-sao-paulo/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d131ed045cfdc0727dd53c09ea222b4c9023ef35b1df3df2d2cbacf6b8dec1ec",
"final_url": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/pai-de-santo-e-condenado-por-abusar-de-5-mulheres-em-sao-paulo/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 398,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Appeal status unconfirmed. Portuguese-language sourcing across four outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-rolembergue-cruz-adventist-tomar-portugal",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Tomar, Santarém, Portugal",
"lat": 39.6029,
"lng": -8.4103,
"title": "Portugal: former Adventist pastor convicted on 24 counts of child sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-adventist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the Seventh-day Adventist Church of Tomar"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over children of his congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Seventh-day Adventist Church of Tomar"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Santarém court, Portugal",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-06-19",
"outcome": "Rolembergue Cruz, pastor of the Adventist Church of Tomar from 2008 to 2014, was convicted on 24 of 131 charged counts of child sexual abuse committed over years, and sentenced to seven years' effective imprisonment with a ten-year prohibition on working with minors."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were children of the congregation he pastored; the office supplied the standing and access across the years of offending.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cmjornal.pt/portugal/detalhe/20190619-1651-ex-pastor-adventista-condenado-a-sete-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual-de-menor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex-pastor adventista condenado a sete anos de prisão por abuso sexual de menor', Correio da Manhã, 19 June 2019.",
"body": "Reports the 24-count conviction, the sentence, and the prohibition imposed.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cmjornal.pt/portugal/detalhe/20190619-1651-ex-pastor-adventista-condenado-a-sete-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual-de-menor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "388719fb24e04dc25327e92c73a62061f0eb9b2d974a896e7b29524bfbe9619d",
"final_url": "https://www.cmjornal.pt/portugal/detalhe/20190619-1651-ex-pastor-adventista-condenado-a-sete-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual-de-menor"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 399,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2022",
"note": "Appeal rejected; conviction stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR TIMOR-LESTE, and the country's first clergy abuse trial. Corroborated across five Portuguese-language outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-richard-daschbach-topu-honis-timor-leste",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Oecusse, Timor-Leste",
"lat": -9.2,
"lng": 124.3667,
"title": "Timor-Leste: American ex-priest convicted of abusing girls at the orphanage he ran",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest",
"founder and director of an orphanage"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial and spiritual authority over resident orphaned girls"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Topu Honis shelter, Oecusse"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Oecusse court, Timor-Leste",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; appeal rejected",
"date": "2021-12-21",
"outcome": "Richard Daschbach, an American ex-priest who ran the Topu Honis orphanage in the Oecusse enclave from 1992, was convicted on five counts of sexual abuse of minors in his care and sentenced to twelve years (individual counts totalling over 37 years, legally accumulated to a single term). A Timorese court rejected his appeal. It was the first clergy sexual-abuse case to reach trial in Timor-Leste."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were orphaned girls resident in a shelter founded and directed by a priest — his religious office and custodial control were one and the same authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.publico.pt/2021/12/21/mundo/noticia/expadre-condenado-12-anos-prisao-abuso-menores-timorleste-1989394",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex-padre condenado a 12 anos de prisão por abuso de menores em Timor-Leste', Público, 21 Dec. 2021.",
"body": "Portugal's paper of record reporting the conviction, the accumulated sentence, and the case's landmark status.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2022",
"note": "Appeal rejected; conviction stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.publico.pt/2021/12/21/mundo/noticia/expadre-condenado-12-anos-prisao-abuso-menores-timorleste-1989394",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 400,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Kenya Law judgment text not located; four consistent Kenyan outlets report the sentence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-james-njuguna-kuria-ngong-kenya",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Ngong, Kajiado, Kenya",
"lat": -1.3524,
"lng": 36.6581,
"title": "Kenya: pastor sentenced to 70 years for defiling two child congregants using 'God's oil'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor and general overseer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious manipulation including anointing with 'God's oil'",
"violence to force a pregnancy's termination"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"First Born of the Holy Spirit Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Milimani Magistrate's Court, Kenya",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-08-08",
"outcome": "James Njuguna Kuria, pastor and general overseer of the First Born of the Holy Spirit Church, was convicted of defiling two child congregants aged 14 and 11 between December 2014 and January 2015, using religious manipulation including 'God's oil', and of assaulting one victim to force the termination of a pregnancy. Sentences of 50 and 20 years run to an effective 70 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were congregants of the church the defendant led; the anointing ritual itself was the instrument of manipulation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nation.africa/kenya/counties/kajiado/pastor-sentenced-to-70-years-for-defiling-minors-4327004",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor sentenced to 70 years for defiling minors', Daily Nation, 8 Aug. 2023.",
"body": "Kenya's paper of record reporting the conviction, the manipulation mechanism, and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nation.africa/kenya/counties/kajiado/pastor-sentenced-to-70-years-for-defiling-minors-4327004",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 401,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Appeal status unconfirmed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-samuel-ngumbao-mariakani-kwale-kenya",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Mariakani, Kwale, Kenya",
"lat": -3.86,
"lng": 39.4737,
"title": "Kenya: pastor convicted in two cases of defiling girls who attended his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing over girls who attended his church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mariakani Law Courts, Kenya",
"stage": "convictions in two cases and sentences",
"date": "2023-10-01",
"outcome": "Samuel Ngumbao Harrison, 27, a pastor, was convicted in two separate Mariakani cases of defiling two girls aged 14 and 16 who attended his church, receiving 30 years and 8 years respectively."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both girls attended the defendant's church; his pastoral standing supplied access and trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.standardmedia.co.ke/coast/article/2001484057/pastor-jailed-for-defiling-two-cousins",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor jailed for defiling two cousins', The Standard (Kenya), Oct. 2023.",
"body": "Reports both convictions and sentences.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.standardmedia.co.ke/coast/article/2001484057/pastor-jailed-for-defiling-two-cousins",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "14925aadeeb7ceb0442e6dc7bc6fe7a1ce74bd6649964e2a9fe31a7fd4a1935f",
"final_url": "https://www.standardmedia.co.ke/coast/article/2001484057/pastor-jailed-for-defiling-two-cousins"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 402,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainant, not identified. Exact sentencing date and citation not located; two outlets corroborate.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-justus-mbuvi-sanctuary-kitui-kenya",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Kitui, Kenya",
"lat": -1.3667,
"lng": 38.0106,
"title": "Kenya: pastor convicted of raping a woman who had sought sanctuary at his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral care over a woman who had sought the church's protection after an earlier assault"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kitui Law Court, Kenya",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-01",
"outcome": "Justus Mutinda Mbuvi, a pastor, was convicted of raping a woman who had sought sanctuary at his church after surviving a separate rape. He accompanied her to hospital under the guise of help, where she disclosed the assault to a clinician, leading to his arrest."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant had placed herself under the church's pastoral protection at her most vulnerable; that care relationship is what the assault betrayed.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.citizen.digital/news/kitui-pastor-convicted-of-raping-woman-who-sought-refuge-in-his-church-n360912",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kitui pastor convicted of raping woman who sought refuge in his church', Citizen Digital (2026).",
"body": "Reports the conviction and the sanctuary circumstances.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.citizen.digital/news/kitui-pastor-convicted-of-raping-woman-who-sought-refuge-in-his-church-n360912",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2e510d9e0b65ae290cfc03684d5a092c2356606198a4b34c9e040cc25eb4a795",
"final_url": "https://citizen.digital/article/kitui-pastor-convicted-of-raping-woman-who-sought-refuge-in-his-church-n360912"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 403,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Sourced to the prosecuting agency with heavy press corroboration.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-kenneth-duke-naptip-abuja-nigeria",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Abuja, FCT, Nigeria",
"lat": 9.0765,
"lng": 7.3986,
"title": "Nigeria: bishop sentenced to 20 years for raping a congregant's child entrusted to his care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"bishop and church founder"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custody of a congregant's child entrusted to his family",
"episcopal standing within his church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "FCT High Court, Abuja, Nigeria (Justice Adebiyi Osolo); prosecuted by NAPTIP",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-22",
"outcome": "Bishop Kenneth Duke, 52, a church founder in Abuja, was convicted of raping the 12-year-old daughter of a church member who had been entrusted to his family's care, and sentenced to 20 years. The prosecution was brought by NAPTIP, Nigeria's anti-trafficking agency."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A congregant family entrusted their child to their bishop's household — the entrustment itself was an act of religious trust in his office.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://naptip.gov.ng/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NAPTIP, prosecuting-authority statement on the conviction of Bishop Kenneth Duke, 22 Jan. 2025; corroborated by Punch, Guardian Nigeria and Sahara Reporters.",
"body": "Nigeria's anti-trafficking agency announcing the FCT High Court conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://naptip.gov.ng/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ae86cad06541995091dd904cb160472d51f7bb26cf31a357342fb2d382b4e1da",
"final_url": "https://naptip.gov.ng/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 404,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2020-09-16",
"note": "Conviction unanimously affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Appellate-affirmed — among the strongest evidentiary tiers in the corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-basil-princewill-appeal-affirmed-abuja-nigeria",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Abuja, FCT, Nigeria",
"lat": 9.0765,
"lng": 7.3986,
"title": "Nigeria: apostle's conviction for raping a 14-year-old congregant affirmed by the Court of Appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"apostle and founder of a ministry"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ministry authority over a minor congregant",
"procured illegal abortion to conceal the offences"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [
"Mountain Mover Ministry International"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "FCT High Court (2019); Court of Appeal, Abuja",
"stage": "conviction; unanimously affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2020-09-16",
"outcome": "Apostle Basil Princewill, founder of Mountain Mover Ministry International, was convicted in 2019 of repeatedly raping a 14-year-old congregant from 2011 and procuring an illegal abortion for her. The Court of Appeal in Abuja unanimously affirmed the conviction on 16 September 2020."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a minor congregant of the ministry the defendant founded and led as apostle — the office supplied both access and the concealment machinery.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://punchng.com/appeal-court-affirms-conviction-of-pastor-who-raped-teenage-member/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Appeal court affirms conviction of pastor who raped teenage member', Punch (Nigeria), 16 Sept. 2020.",
"body": "Reports the unanimous appellate affirmance of the conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2020-09-16",
"note": "Conviction unanimously affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://punchng.com/appeal-court-affirms-conviction-of-pastor-who-raped-teenage-member/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 405,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Court and judge not confirmed; two outlets corroborate. Medium confidence pending a stronger citation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-favour-okoise-spiritual-daughter-calabar-nigeria",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Calabar, Cross River, Nigeria",
"lat": 4.9757,
"lng": 8.3417,
"title": "Nigeria: general overseer given life for raping his sixteen-year-old 'spiritual daughter'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"general overseer of an assembly",
"religious guardian of a 'spiritual daughter'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious guardianship formalised in the 'spiritual daughter' relationship"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Refiners Fire Global Assembly"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cross River State court, Calabar, Nigeria",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-06-01",
"outcome": "Pastor Favour Maxy Okoise, general overseer of Refiners Fire Global Assembly, was convicted of raping his 16-year-old 'spiritual daughter' — a congregant under his direct religious guardianship — between November and December 2016, and sentenced to life imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The 'spiritual daughter' designation formalised religious guardianship: the girl was placed under the overseer's direct spiritual authority, which is the relationship the offences ran through.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://crossriverwatch.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pastor sentenced to life imprisonment for raping spiritual daughter', CrossRiverWatch (June 2025).",
"body": "Cross River outlet reporting the conviction and life sentence.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://crossriverwatch.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6bb7497ab50189db75c3cbbe954f13eebd61131f7912c7af44c3cc7bb15f2807",
"final_url": "https://crossriverwatch.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 406,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainant, not identified. Three outlets corroborate, including direct quotes from proceedings.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-tawanda-shumba-shrine-cleansing-gweru-zimbabwe",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Gweru, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -19.45,
"lng": 29.8167,
"title": "Zimbabwe: self-styled prophet convicted of raping a client during a ritual 'cleansing'",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled prophet operating a shrine"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"diagnosis of a spirit repelling suitors",
"ritual cleansing used to isolate the client"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [
"'Nyenyedzi Nomwe' shrine"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Magistrate's Court, Gweru, Zimbabwe (Regional Magistrate Sibongile Marondedze)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-18",
"outcome": "Tawanda Shumba, a self-styled prophet running the 'Nyenyedzi Nomwe' shrine in Mkoba, was convicted of raping a 22-year-old woman who had come to him to remove a spirit she believed was repelling suitors. He lured her to a secluded place for a ritual cleansing ceremony and raped her. He was sentenced to 15 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a client of the shrine who accepted the prophet's spiritual diagnosis and followed him into isolation because the ritual he prescribed required it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newsday.co.zw/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Prophet jailed 15 years for raping client during cleansing ritual', Newsday Zimbabwe, 18 June 2026.",
"body": "Zimbabwean daily reporting the conviction, the magistrate, and the ritual circumstances.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newsday.co.zw/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "64d3a1ce131f6ea235987d686493963ce98f64b46795589f368599ce6d1bb2b2",
"final_url": "https://www.newsday.co.zw/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 407,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim, not identified. Cited to the ULII-published High Court judgment — the top source tier — though the page resisted automated fetch and the exact sentence length was not resolved; flagged for a direct read.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-nyanzi-masumbuko-shrine-mukono-uganda",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Mukono District, Uganda",
"lat": 0.3533,
"lng": 32.7553,
"title": "Uganda: shrine operator and accomplices convicted of gang-raping a client seeking healing",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"traditional doctor and shrine operator"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual-healing services sought by the victim and her husband",
"drugging at the shrine"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Uganda (Uganda v Sheikh Abdu Said Nyanzi Masumbuko & Ors, Crim. Sess. Case No. 0458 of 2006, [2008] UGHC 22)",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2008-08-28",
"outcome": "A traditional doctor and shrine operator known as Sheikh Abdu Said Nyanzi Masumbuko and two accomplices were convicted after a woman who had come to his shrine with her husband seeking spiritual and healing services was drugged and gang-raped, then left in a swamp to stage her having wandered off — facts drawn from the High Court judgment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim came to the shrine specifically for spiritual healing; the operator's ritual authority is what separated her from her husband and placed her under his control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ulii.org/akn/ug/judgment/ughc/2008/22/eng@2008-08-28",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Uganda v Sheikh Abdu Said Nyanzi Masumbuko & Ors, Criminal Session Case No. 0458 of 2006, [2008] UGHC 22 (28 August 2008).",
"body": "The High Court judgment recording the shrine setting, the drugging, and the convictions.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "trial-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ulii.org/akn/ug/judgment/ughc/2008/22/eng@2008-08-28",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: trial-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 408,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event recording a grand jury's findings, not a per-individual conviction roster; the published report is redacted for unadjudicated individuals by order of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, and this record follows that limitation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-pennsylvania-grand-jury-report-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 40.2732,
"lng": -76.8867,
"title": "Pennsylvania Grand Jury: 301 'predator priests', 1,000+ child victims across six dioceses",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy of six Pennsylvania dioceses",
"bishops and diocesan officials administering concealment"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral access to altar boys, students and parish children",
"a recurring institutional cover-up 'playbook'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Dioceses of Allentown, Erie, Greensburg, Harrisburg, Pittsburgh and Scranton"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "40th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury, Pennsylvania",
"stage": "grand jury report",
"date": "2018-08-14",
"outcome": "After a two-year investigation, the grand jury identified 301 credibly accused 'predator priests' and documented more than 1,000 identified child victims across six dioceses — believing the true number ran into the thousands — together with a decades-long institutional cover-up. The jury found that bishops 'weren't just protecting the abuser's identity — they were protecting the institution.'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were altar boys, parochial students and parish children placed in priests' pastoral care; the report's core finding is that diocesan religious authority was used to conceal and thereby perpetuate the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/report/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report of the 40th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury (Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General, 14 Aug. 2018).",
"body": "The grand jury report itself: 301 credibly accused priests, 1,000+ identified victims, and the cover-up findings.",
"tier": "official-grand-jury-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/report/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-grand-jury-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 409,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event; most underlying claims were time-barred before Maryland's 2023 Child Victims Act, so no mass prosecution followed — a fact the record states rather than obscures.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-maryland-ag-baltimore-archdiocese-report-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
"lat": 39.2904,
"lng": -76.6122,
"title": "Maryland AG: 156 abusers and 600+ child victims in the Archdiocese of Baltimore",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"priests, brothers and deacons of the Archdiocese",
"archdiocesan leadership"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral access to children",
"'pervasive, pernicious and persistent' institutional concealment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Baltimore"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Maryland Office of the Attorney General",
"stage": "investigative report",
"date": "2023-04-05",
"outcome": "A four-year investigation produced a 463-page report identifying 156 clergy and religious with credible allegations and more than 600 known child victims from the 1940s to 2002, describing the Archdiocese's concealment as 'pervasive, pernicious and persistent'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were children within the Archdiocese's parishes and schools, under clergy pastoral authority; the report documents the institutional authority that concealed the abuse for six decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.marylandattorneygeneral.gov/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Maryland Office of the Attorney General, 'Report on Child Sexual Abuse in the Archdiocese of Baltimore' (5 Apr. 2023).",
"body": "The Attorney General's report identifying 156 credibly accused abusers and 600+ victims.",
"tier": "official-ag-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.marylandattorneygeneral.gov/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-ag-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a31a64a8093d30fc1496ee98a9cee4a363e091c258a58ab71f0f90b940087c6a",
"final_url": "https://oag.maryland.gov/Pages/oag.aspx"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 410,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event produced through a voluntary independent-review process rather than a grand jury; no mass prosecution followed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-colorado-ag-clergy-abuse-report-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Denver, Colorado, USA",
"lat": 39.7392,
"lng": -104.9903,
"title": "Colorado: independent review finds abuse reported to police fewer than 10 times in 100 opportunities",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"priests of Colorado's three dioceses",
"diocesan leadership controlling ministry assignments"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"19.5-year average gap between credible allegation and ministry restriction",
"children abused after bishops already knew the priest was an offender"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Denver",
"Dioceses of Pueblo and Colorado Springs"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Colorado Attorney General (Special Master Robert Troyer)",
"stage": "special master's report and 2020 supplement",
"date": "2019-10-23",
"outcome": "The AG-commissioned review found at least 166 children abused by 43 priests over 70 years; that the dioceses reported abuse to police fewer than 10 times in roughly 100 opportunities since 1950; that the average gap between a credible allegation and any restriction of ministry was 19.5 years; and that 97 of the 166 victims were abused after bishops already knew the priest had offended. A December 2020 supplement substantiated 46 further victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report's most damning metric is about authority itself: nearly two-thirds of the victims were harmed after the hierarchy already knew — the diocesan power over assignments was the mechanism of continued access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://coag.gov/resources/survivors-of-childhood-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Colorado Attorney General, 'Special Report on Catholic Clergy Sexual Abuse' (23 Oct. 2019) and supplement (1 Dec. 2020).",
"body": "The special master's findings on victim counts, non-reporting, and post-knowledge abuse.",
"tier": "official-ag-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://coag.gov/resources/survivors-of-childhood-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-ag-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "503dfee76f947fa258cbc3a662df529014adafdb63b4cc9ccd268ab05b349037",
"final_url": "https://coag.gov/resources/survivors-of-childhood-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 411,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The Michigan AG's serial diocesan reports are noted as context; Detroit's final report remained pending at the time of writing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-joseph-baker-wayne-county-michigan-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Wayne County, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 42.2791,
"lng": -83.3362,
"title": "Michigan: priest convicted of first-degree criminal sexual conduct against a child parishioner",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral access to a child of the parish"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Detroit"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan state court; prosecuted under the Michigan AG's clergy-abuse initiative",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-03-01",
"outcome": "Fr Joseph 'Jack' Baker, pastor at several Metro Detroit parishes, was convicted in October 2022 of first-degree criminal sexual conduct — penetration of a child under 13 — and sentenced in March 2023 to 3–15 years with lifetime sex-offender registration. The conviction arose from the Michigan Attorney General's statewide clergy investigation, which has produced diocese-by-diocese reports (Saginaw: 37 priests and a deacon; Grand Rapids: 51 priests, 152 victims) and convictions in 9 of 11 charged cases."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child of the parish under the priest's pastoral care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/initiatives/catholic-church-clergy-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, clergy-abuse initiative releases on the Baker conviction and diocesan reports (2022–2023).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's record of the conviction, sentence, and the wider investigation's outcomes.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "conviction-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/initiatives/catholic-church-clergy-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: conviction-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 412,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2002-04-11",
"note": "Conviction affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim, then 16, later brought civil proceedings publicly under her own name; she is not named here. Appellate-affirmed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1999-david-ortell-kingston-order-utah-usa",
"year": 1999,
"place": "Salt Lake City, Utah, USA",
"lat": 40.7608,
"lng": -111.891,
"title": "United States: Kingston Order leader convicted of incest after a doctrinal plural 'marriage' to his niece",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader within the Kingston clan ('The Order' / Latter Day Church of Christ)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the group's plural-marriage doctrine assigning a 16-year-old as a 'wife'",
"clan religious hierarchy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Latter Day Church of Christ (Kingston clan / 'The Order')"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Utah state court; Utah Court of Appeals",
"stage": "jury conviction; affirmed on appeal",
"date": "1999-06-01",
"outcome": "David Ortell Kingston was convicted by a jury in June 1999 of three counts of incest and one count of unlawful sexual conduct for taking his 16-year-old niece as a plural 'wife' under the group's religious doctrine. The Utah Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction in April 2002. A separate prosecution of the girl's father — who beat her when she fled — was a family-violence matter and is not part of this record."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Although the perpetrator was the victim's uncle, the operative coercion was doctrinal, not familial: the Order's plural-marriage teaching and clan hierarchy assigned her to him as a 'wife'. This is the doctrinal-coercion exception to the family-nexus exclusion — the belief system, not the kinship, is what delivered her into his control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ut-court-of-appeals/1340374.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Kingston, Utah Court of Appeals (11 Apr. 2002), affirming the 1999 convictions.",
"body": "The appellate opinion affirming the incest and unlawful-sexual-conduct convictions.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2002-04-11",
"note": "Conviction affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ut-court-of-appeals/1340374.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "19b8f34d1dcb2f754f86bc4fcbd9c997318f4e2795a413e0a99d56159d0e960d",
"final_url": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ut-court-of-appeals/1340374.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 413,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The child victims of the underlying marriages are not identified. The conviction concerns solemnization, not personal sexual assault; the record is framed accordingly, alongside the corpus's existing Warren Jeffs record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-merril-jessop-yfz-solemnization-texas-usa",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Eldorado, Texas, USA",
"lat": 30.8613,
"lng": -100.6009,
"title": "United States: FLDS bishop convicted of solemnizing the 'celestial marriage' of a twelve-year-old",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"FLDS bishop at the Yearning For Zion ranch"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sacramental authority to perform 'celestial marriages'",
"doctrinal machinery delivering underage girls into unions with adult men"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints",
"Yearning For Zion Ranch"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "51st District Court, Texas",
"stage": "conviction and maximum sentence",
"date": "2011-11-01",
"outcome": "FLDS bishop Fredrick Merril Jessop was convicted of the felony of conducting a marriage ceremony prohibited by law, for solemnizing the 2006 'celestial marriage' of his own 12-year-old daughter to Warren Jeffs. Trial evidence showed he had witnessed or solemnized sixteen underage marriages, four of which led to separate sexual-assault or bigamy prosecutions of other FLDS men. He received the maximum: ten years and a $10,000 fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The bishop's sacramental office was itself the instrument: his authority to perform the marriage rite is what converted a child into a 'wife'. The conviction is for the religious act, one step removed from hands-on abuse — a caveat the record states — but the authority-as-mechanism could not be more literal.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=2163850&itype=CMSID",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'FLDS bishop Merril Jessop gets maximum sentence', The Salt Lake Tribune (Nov. 2011).",
"body": "Utah's paper of record reporting the conviction, the trial evidence on sixteen underage marriages, and the maximum sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=2163850&itype=CMSID",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fc2a98db9827a335ce55aa966554e16594ccd4e3195cf8a618fb0837dad6d49a",
"final_url": "https://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=2163850&itype=CMSID"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 414,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; defendant partially named per Mexican practice. Four outlets corroborate. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-jonathan-armando-cadereyta-nuevo-leon-mexico",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Cadereyta Jiménez, Nuevo León, Mexico",
"lat": 25.5881,
"lng": -99.9844,
"title": "Mexico: pastor convicted twice — 11 then 37 years — for abusing congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"congregants' trust in his position as spiritual leader"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nuevo León state courts, Mexico",
"stage": "two separate final convictions",
"date": "2023-11-06",
"outcome": "A pastor identified as Jonathan Armando 'N' was convicted in July 2021 (11 years, one victim) and again on 6 November 2023 (37 years, four victims, acts 2015–2020) for sexually abusing female congregants of his church, some of them minors, exploiting his position as their spiritual leader."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were congregants, some adolescent, whose families' trust ran through his pastoral office.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.excelsior.com.mx/nacional/sentencian-a-pastor-por-abuso-sexual-en-nuevo-leon/1621304",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sentencian a pastor por abuso sexual en Nuevo León', Excélsior (2023).",
"body": "Reports the 37-year second conviction and the prior 2021 conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.excelsior.com.mx/nacional/sentencian-a-pastor-por-abuso-sexual-en-nuevo-leon/1621304",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 415,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; defendant partially named per Mexican protected-identity practice. Five outlets corroborate. Spanish-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-jacob-n-casa-hogar-monterrey-mexico",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Monterrey, Nuevo León, Mexico",
"lat": 25.6866,
"lng": -100.3161,
"title": "Mexico: pastor sentenced to 59 years for abusing residents of a church-run children's home",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor teaching at a church-affiliated residential home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over institutionalized minors in a residence he served"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nuevo León state court, Mexico",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "A pastor identified as 'Jacob N.' was sentenced to 59 years for aggravated sexual abuse equivalent to rape of three minors and one adult resident of a church-affiliated group home where he taught classes and led activities, between August and October 2020."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were residents of a church-run home — institutionalized children under the religious authority of the man sent to teach them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://latinus.us/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sentencian a 59 años a pastor por abuso de menores en casa hogar de Monterrey', LatinUS (2023), corroborated by Infobae and Radio Fórmula.",
"body": "Reports the 59-year sentence and the residential-home setting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://latinus.us/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3bebbf96e1541b2a0e8607e3a5bb0d633c4f3ee95d3bb7c762867267c7fdef0b",
"final_url": "https://latinus.us/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 416,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "An institutional-event recording survey-based estimates in an official state report — not adjudicated individual counts, a distinction the record preserves.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-defensor-del-pueblo-report-spain",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Spain (national)",
"lat": 40.4168,
"lng": -3.7038,
"title": "Spain: Ombudsman's national report estimates hundreds of thousands abused in church contexts",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"priests and religious across Spanish church institutions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and educational authority over children in church settings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Defensor del Pueblo (Spanish Ombudsman)",
"stage": "national investigative report",
"date": "2023-10-27",
"outcome": "The Ombudsman's report, based on a survey of 8,013 people and 487 victim testimonies, estimated that roughly 440,000 adults in Spain suffered sexual abuse in a religious-institutional context — about 234,000 directly by priests or religious — and recommended reparations and access to church archives."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "An aggregate official finding on abuse committed through clerical and religious-educational authority across Spanish institutions.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.defensordelpueblo.es/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Defensor del Pueblo, national report on sexual abuse in the Catholic Church (27 Oct. 2023).",
"body": "The Ombudsman's report with the survey methodology and estimates.",
"tier": "official-government-body",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.defensordelpueblo.es/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-body; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "78d806cecee6f23796e8145b21110c45789751af9fbe5418dcc5bacc16af098f",
"final_url": "https://www.defensordelpueblo.es/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 417,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2018",
"note": "Sentence reduced 11→2 years; conviction affirmed. NOT an acquittal."
},
{
"stage": "constitutional-court",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Appeal rejected."
},
{
"stage": "canonical",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Expelled from Opus Dei."
}
],
"scopeNote": "PRECISION MATTERS HERE: the Supreme Court reduced the sentence's quantum; it did not overturn the conviction, which stands and survived constitutional challenge. Describing this case as 'overturned' would be false. The complainant has spoken publicly under his own name; he is not named here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-martinez-sanz-gaztelueta-opus-dei-spain",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Leioa, Vizcaya, Spain",
"lat": 43.3269,
"lng": -2.9896,
"title": "Spain: Opus Dei teacher's abuse conviction stands after Supreme Court reduces sentence",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teacher and Opus Dei numerary at an Opus Dei-linked school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"combined educational and spiritual-formation authority over a student"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Colegio Gaztelueta",
"Opus Dei"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Audiencia Provincial de Bizkaia; Tribunal Supremo; Tribunal Constitucional; Vatican canonical tribunal",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal, GUILT AFFIRMED; constitutional appeal rejected; canonical expulsion",
"date": "2016-01-01",
"outcome": "José María Martínez Sanz, a teacher and Opus Dei numerary at Colegio Gaztelueta, was convicted of continuous sexual abuse of a student and sentenced to 11 years. In 2018 the Supreme Court REDUCED the sentence to two years — finding the most serious alleged acts insufficiently proven — but AFFIRMED his guilt; the Constitutional Court rejected his further appeal. In 2024–25 a Vatican canonical tribunal ordered his expulsion from Opus Dei."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a student under the defendant's combined teaching and spiritual-formation authority at an Opus Dei school — tutorial sessions in his office were the setting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eldiario.es/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'El Supremo rebaja a dos años la condena al profesor de Gaztelueta pero confirma el abuso', elDiario.es (2018), with Religión Digital on the 2025 canonical expulsion.",
"body": "Reports the Supreme Court's reduction-with-affirmance and the later expulsion.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2018",
"note": "Sentence reduced 11→2 years; conviction affirmed. NOT an acquittal."
},
{
"stage": "constitutional-court",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Appeal rejected."
},
{
"stage": "canonical",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Expelled from Opus Dei."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eldiario.es/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "847822eb3251a92bf27ec4eb4c9ee74ccda54699aaa24d6847eba5617c3cc362",
"final_url": "https://www.eldiario.es/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 418,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The conviction is final; the fugitive status concerns the sentence, not the verdict. Spanish-language sourcing across four outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-segundo-cousido-salesianos-vigo-spain",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Vigo, Pontevedra, Spain",
"lat": 42.2406,
"lng": -8.7207,
"title": "Spain: Salesian religion teacher sentenced to 32 years; fled before imprisonment",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Salesian priest and religion teacher",
"organizer of camps and pilgrimages"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-school authority and extracurricular religious activities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Colegio Salesianos, Vigo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Audiencia Provincial de Pontevedra, Spain",
"stage": "final conviction; defendant a fugitive from sentence",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"outcome": "Segundo Cousido Vieites, a Salesian priest and religion teacher, was convicted and sentenced to 32 years and 6 months for sexually abusing at least six minors during 2019, exploiting his role as teacher and organiser of Salesian camps and pilgrimages. He fled before beginning his sentence in March 2023 and remains among Spain's most-wanted fugitives."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were students in his religion classes and participants in the religious activities he organised — the office structured every point of access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elespanol.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'El cura de los Salesianos de Vigo condenado a 32 años, entre los más buscados de España', El Español (2023).",
"body": "Reports the final conviction, the sentence, and the flight before imprisonment.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-fugitive-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elespanol.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-fugitive-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f0fa7532250f3560f71c3f9efd448bf3dec20c39160924fa267b322a3a263724",
"final_url": "https://www.elespanol.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 419,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2025-12-02",
"note": "Maltreatment conviction final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The final conviction is for maltreatment (maltrattamento), not sexual violence — stated precisely, as the dropped counts must not be implied. Italian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-michele-barone-exorcism-maltreatment-aversa-italy",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Aversa, Caserta, Italy",
"lat": 40.973,
"lng": 14.2065,
"title": "Italy: priest's conviction for maltreatment during unauthorized exorcisms confirmed by Cassation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest acting as a self-styled exorcist"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"family's belief that their daughter was possessed",
"beatings, coercion and forced starvation framed as deliverance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Aversa"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Italian courts; Corte di Cassazione",
"stage": "conviction confirmed at final instance",
"date": "2025-12-02",
"outcome": "The Court of Cassation confirmed on 2 December 2025 a 13-year sentence against former priest Michele Barone for maltreatment of a 13-year-old girl during unauthorized 'exorcism' sessions — beatings, psychological coercion and a forced starvation diet — after her family submitted her to him believing she was possessed. Separate sexual-violence counts concerning other alleged victims were dropped for insufficient evidence; only the maltreatment conviction is final. He was laicised by Pope Francis."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was delivered to the priest by her own family because of his claimed power over possession — the exorcistic authority is what placed her under his control and reframed the violence as treatment.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Don Michele Barone, condanna definitiva in Cassazione', Il Fatto Quotidiano, Dec. 2025.",
"body": "Reports the Cassation confirmation, the exorcism setting, and the laicisation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2025-12-02",
"note": "Maltreatment conviction final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7f9d2b45f7de1c60bfe735373bada5bdfc405b0094e52ff8b4abf4c7447f00c4",
"final_url": "https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 420,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2021-02-01",
"note": "Sexual-violence count final; slavery count remanded."
},
{
"stage": "florence-appeal",
"date": "2021-10-01",
"note": "Combined 14y8m sentence including slavery; finality unconfirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Adult victims, not identified. This record rests on the Cassation-final sexual-violence count only; the slavery count's ultimate finality is flagged, not assumed. Italian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-mauro-cioni-santone-montecchio-italy",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Cortona, Arezzo, Italy",
"lat": 43.2755,
"lng": 11.986,
"title": "Italy: ex-priest 'santone' — sexual-violence conviction against sect followers final at Cassation",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ex-priest leading a commune-like healing sect for two decades"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed healing and exorcistic powers over sect members",
"communal isolation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Italian courts; Corte di Cassazione (Feb. 2021); Corte d'Assise d'Appello di Firenze (Oct. 2021)",
"stage": "sexual-violence conviction final; further counts retried",
"date": "2021-02-01",
"outcome": "Mauro Cioni, an ex-priest who ran a commune-like sect near Cortona for some twenty years as its 'santone', had his 8-year sexual-violence conviction against followers confirmed as final by the Court of Cassation in February 2021. A remanded slavery count led a Florence appellate court in October 2021 to impose a higher combined sentence, whose finality was not confirmed in the sources reviewed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were members of a sect who submitted to the ex-priest's claimed healing and spiritual authority within a closed communal structure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lanazione.it/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Il santone di Montecchio: Cassazione conferma la condanna per violenza sessuale', La Nazione (2021).",
"body": "Reports the Cassation confirmation of the sexual-violence conviction and the remand on the slavery count.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2021-02-01",
"note": "Sexual-violence count final; slavery count remanded."
},
{
"stage": "florence-appeal",
"date": "2021-10-01",
"note": "Combined 14y8m sentence including slavery; finality unconfirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lanazione.it/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bf639b1d713b7a3cba5ebc72a661a6dc0f5ef7f410ada14416ace109deba36aa",
"final_url": "https://www.lanazione.it/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 421,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"note": "Appeal rejected; conviction final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims at the time; the survivor movement (La Parole Libérée) later spoke publicly, but no victim is named here. Barbarin's separate acquittal is noted to prevent conflation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-bernard-preynat-lyon-scouts-france",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Lyon, France",
"lat": 45.764,
"lng": 4.8357,
"title": "France: Bernard Preynat's conviction for two decades of scout abuse made final by Cassation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest and scout chaplain"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"chaplaincy authority over boys in his scout troop at camps and weekends"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Lyon",
"Scouts of Sainte-Foy-lès-Lyon"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal correctionnel de Lyon; Cour de Cassation",
"stage": "conviction; cassation appeal rejected (final)",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"outcome": "Former priest Bernard Preynat was convicted in January 2020 and sentenced to five years for sexual assaults on dozens of Boy Scouts across two decades — trial testimony described one to five children abused per weekend or camp. The Court of Cassation rejected his appeal in January 2021, making the conviction final. He had been laicised by the Vatican in 2019. The related prosecution of Cardinal Barbarin for non-reporting ended in a final acquittal and forms no part of this record."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were boys in the scout troop where the priest served as chaplain — a pastoral office that gave him custody of children on camps and weekends for twenty years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lyonmag.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Affaire Preynat: la Cour de cassation rejette le pourvoi, condamnation définitive', LyonMag (2021).",
"body": "Reports the final rejection of the cassation appeal.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"note": "Appeal rejected; conviction final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lyonmag.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "05c8f76a9cff5d68630a2e72db82dde2774eb7ec206a936f59015e22073627e6",
"final_url": "https://www.lyonmag.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 422,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified; defendants unnamed per French practice. Appeal status unconfirmed. French-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-aubin-guru-exorcism-rapes-rodez-france",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Aubin, Aveyron, France",
"lat": 44.5281,
"lng": 2.2447,
"title": "France: 'guru' and accomplice convicted of raping a teenager under an exorcism pretext",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled guru of a small esoteric circle",
"accomplice within the circle"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claim that a demon had to be exorcised to save the girl's life",
"the mother's own prior subjection to the same 'rites'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour criminelle de Rodez, France",
"stage": "convictions and sentences",
"date": "2024-03-04",
"outcome": "The leader of a small sectarian esoteric circle was sentenced to 15 years and his accomplice to 12 for repeatedly raping a teenage girl under the pretext of exorcising a demon to save her life. Her mother — herself previously subjected to similar sexual 'rites' — had entrusted her daughter to the men for supposed spiritual treatment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Two generations bound by the same claimed authority: the mother's belief delivered her daughter into the circle, and the exorcism doctrine made the abuse read as rescue.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://france3-regions.francetvinfo.fr/occitanie/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Viols sous couvert d'exorcisme: 15 ans de réclusion pour le gourou', France 3 Occitanie, 4 Mar. 2024.",
"body": "Reports the convictions, sentences and the exorcism pretext.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://france3-regions.francetvinfo.fr/occitanie/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eea42b11d54f27430f6c4a780721ac2cf5dee04883f09841165061b8514a60a9",
"final_url": "https://france3-regions.franceinfo.fr/occitanie/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 423,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2013-06-01",
"note": "Sentence increased to ten years."
},
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2014",
"note": "Rejected; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The Védrines family spoke publicly and the case is extensively documented; victims are named only collectively. BORDERLINE INCLUSION as stated in the nexus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-thierry-tilly-vedrines-monflanquin-france",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Monflanquin, Lot-et-Garonne, France",
"lat": 44.5333,
"lng": 0.7667,
"title": "France: Thierry Tilly's decade-long occult domination of the Védrines family — conviction final",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled initiate claiming esoteric knowledge and a protective mission"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed occult knowledge of a conspiracy threatening the family",
"total psychological control and isolation in their château",
"extraction of roughly €4.5 million"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority",
"spiritual-consequence",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "French courts; Cour d'Appel de Bordeaux; Cour de Cassation",
"stage": "conviction; sentence increased on appeal; cassation rejected (final)",
"date": "2013-06-01",
"outcome": "Thierry Tilly was convicted of abus de faiblesse, aggravated violence and aggravated sequestration for holding eleven members of the Védrines family, aged 16 to 89, under total psychological control in their château from 2001 to 2009 — posing as a secret initiate protecting them from an occult conspiracy — and extracting some €4.5 million. Sentenced to eight years in 2012, increased to ten on appeal in June 2013; his cassation appeal was rejected."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The family submitted to Tilly's claimed esoteric authority — belief in his occult knowledge and protective mission is what made a decade of confinement and dispossession unrefusable. A borderline record: the harms adjudicated are liberty and property, not sexual, and the authority claimed was occult-conspiratorial rather than religious-institutional; it is included because the coercion mechanism is precisely the criterion's, and flagged so the owner can revisit.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.francebleu.fr/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Affaire Tilly-Védrines: dix ans de prison confirmés', France Bleu / France Info (2013).",
"body": "Reports the appellate increase to ten years and the case's facts.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2013-06-01",
"note": "Sentence increased to ten years."
},
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2014",
"note": "Rejected; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.francebleu.fr/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8cdf1205818facfb2e20580e840be201e852ca048104cd9fd9d8718373df7c4a",
"final_url": "https://www.ici.fr/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 424,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2026-02-19",
"note": "Conviction affirmed; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim; the Court anonymises minor-victim rape decisions, so the defendant's name and the case's G.R. number were not in the press coverage and require an E-Library lookup — a standard practice, flagged as a citation gap rather than a doubt about the ruling.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-albularyo-treatment-rape-sc-philippines",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Philippines",
"lat": 12.8797,
"lng": 121.774,
"title": "Philippines: Supreme Court affirms healer's conviction, ruling his authority voided consent",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"traditional healer (albularyo)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sexual acts portrayed as indispensable to the patient's treatment",
"community standing as a healer"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the Philippines, Second Division",
"stage": "conviction affirmed at final instance",
"date": "2026-02-19",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court affirmed the conviction of a traditional healer (albularyo) on two counts of rape through sexual intercourse and two of rape by sexual assault against a 15-year-old patient, beginning in October 2010, holding that his fraudulent manipulation — persistently portraying the sexual acts as indispensable to her treatment while exploiting his standing as a healer — voided the victim's consent. He was sentenced to up to 98 years with ₱510,000 in damages."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Supreme Court's own holding states the criterion: the healer's authority and the treatment pretext are what made the victim's submission possible, vitiating consent.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sunstar.com.ph/cebu",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'SC affirms albularyo's conviction for raping patient', SunStar (Philippines), Feb. 2026.",
"body": "Reports the Second Division ruling, the sentence, and the Court's consent reasoning.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2026-02-19",
"note": "Conviction affirmed; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sunstar.com.ph/cebu",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "120ed91f128a8f803c609af931e40e981e708db47ae3a8158bc789e6e878ac2f",
"final_url": "https://www.sunstar.com.ph/cebu"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 425,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The contested leniency of the sentence is recorded as reported. Indonesian-language sourcing across five outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-mas-bechi-shiddiqiyyah-jombang-indonesia",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Ploso, Jombang, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.546,
"lng": 112.2333,
"title": "Indonesia: pesantren heir convicted of abusing female students after years shielded by his father's standing",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"son of the founding kiai, holding institutional authority at the pesantren"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional religious authority over santriwati",
"recruitment interviews at the pesantren clinic used as the setting",
"years of evasion under the founder's protection"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Pondok Pesantren Shiddiqiyyah"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Surabaya, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-11-17",
"outcome": "Moch Subchi Azal Tsani ('Mas Bechi'), son of the founding kiai of Pondok Pesantren Shiddiqiyyah, was convicted of sexually abusing five female students, the lead count concerning the rape of a santriwati during a 2017 health-volunteer recruitment interview at the pesantren clinic. He evaded arrest for years under his father's standing before surrendering in July 2022. The seven-year sentence — against a sixteen-year prosecution demand — was publicly criticised as inadequate by the Ministry of Women's Empowerment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were santriwati inside an institution ruled by the perpetrator's family's religious authority — the same authority that shielded him from arrest for years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tempo.co/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Mas Bechi divonis 7 tahun penjara', Tempo (17 Nov. 2022), corroborated by Kompas and NU Online.",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the sentence, and the ministry's criticism.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tempo.co/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6458820dce9b5b65dfe17cc45682853a73bfcc2688b1173d879a305ea3be8d95",
"final_url": "https://www.tempo.co/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 426,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Single national-outlet sourcing (Detik Bali) with detailed verdict reporting; flagged for a second source. Indonesian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-hariyanto-dukun-aura-ritual-jembrana-indonesia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Jembrana, Bali, Indonesia",
"lat": -8.3667,
"lng": 114.6667,
"title": "Indonesia: dukun convicted of raping a girl under an 'aura-opening' ritual with supernatural threats",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dukun (folk healer)",
"female accomplice"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"fabricated 'aura-opening' and virginity-inspection ritual",
"threats of supernatural harm for refusal"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Negara, Jembrana, Bali, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-04-02",
"outcome": "Hariyanto, 51, a dukun, and an accomplice were convicted under Indonesia's Child Protection Law of repeatedly raping a 14-year-old girl over several months under the pretext of a ritual to 'open her aura', including a fabricated virginity inspection, with threats of supernatural harm if she refused. The victim became pregnant."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The ritual framing and the threat of supernatural retribution are the criterion's mechanism in full: belief made refusal feel more dangerous than submission.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/bali/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Dukun pemerkosa gadis di Jembrana divonis', Detik Bali, 2 Apr. 2024.",
"body": "Reports the convictions, the ritual pretext, and the supernatural threats.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/bali/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2f586ac2fc95983b011bd120a0a10fead61b7213f1a1a71facff057a8fbc29c1",
"final_url": "https://www.detik.com/bali/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 427,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Four outlets corroborate. Indonesian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-adi-suprobo-prayer-sessions-semarang-indonesia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Semarang, Central Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.9667,
"lng": 110.4167,
"title": "Indonesia: pastor convicted of abusing children lured into private 'prayer sessions'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Christian pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"private prayer rituals with Bible readings used to isolate children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Semarang, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-08-12",
"outcome": "Pastor Adi Suprobo, 58, was convicted of sexually abusing multiple minors — victims from age ten — across Semarang, Temanggung, Kudus and Ambarawa between roughly 2022 and 2024, luring them into private 'prayer sessions' that included Bible readings. He was sentenced to seven years and a one-billion-rupiah fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The prayer ritual was the instrument of isolation: children and their families accepted the private sessions because a pastor proposed them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jateng/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pendeta cabul di Semarang divonis 7 tahun', Detik Jateng, 12 Aug. 2025, corroborated by Kompas and Tribun Jateng.",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the multi-city offending, and the prayer-session pretext.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jateng/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3117ad89f2eb9f125cd10d893ac5d57e384ef7bb3eee29dff9a763ea6040d528",
"final_url": "https://www.detik.com/jateng/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 428,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Complainant not identified; defendant named by initials per Indonesian practice. Three outlets corroborate. Indonesian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-gkps-pastor-jrp-pematang-siantar-indonesia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Pematang Siantar, North Sumatra, Indonesia",
"lat": 2.9595,
"lng": 99.0687,
"title": "Indonesia: Simalungun Protestant pastor convicted of harassing a congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the Simalungun Protestant Church (GKPS)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a member of his congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Gereja Kristen Protestan Simalungun"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Pematang Siantar, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-16",
"outcome": "A GKPS pastor identified by the initials JRP was convicted of sexually harassing a female congregant under his pastoral authority and sentenced to three years on 16 January 2024."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a member of the congregation the defendant pastored.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://medan.tribunnews.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pendeta GKPS divonis 3 tahun penjara', Tribun Medan, 16 Jan. 2024.",
"body": "Reports the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://medan.tribunnews.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 429,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; defendant named by initials. Two outlets corroborate, including the judiciary-affiliated Dandapala. Indonesian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-abp-genderuwo-scheme-magetan-indonesia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Magetan, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.65,
"lng": 111.3333,
"title": "Indonesia: repeat-offender dukun convicted of raping five minors via a spirit-pregnancy hoax",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled dukun"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false diagnosis that victims were impregnated by a genderuwo spirit",
"sex and explicit images demanded as the 'cure'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Magetan, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "A man identified as ABP, 40, posing as a dukun, was convicted of coercing at least five underage victims into sending explicit images and having sex with him as purported treatment after falsely telling them, via social media, that they had been impregnated by a genderuwo spirit. A repeat offender with a prior eight-year sentence for a similar scheme, he received fourteen years and an 800-million-rupiah fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The entire scheme ran on manufactured supernatural dread: the spirit-pregnancy diagnosis created the affliction only his 'treatment' could cure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Dukun pemerkosa 5 anak di Magetan divonis 14 tahun', Detik Jatim (2024), corroborated by Dandapala.",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the genderuwo scheme, and the recidivism.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "202e215dbf9562fa3c2b12202cb4eed1b392ddea15f4c95eacf64ef7f78aebe8",
"final_url": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 430,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Single-outlet sourcing in this pass (Kosmo, a national daily), with the defendant named and the court specified. Malay-language sourcing. The record notes the caning element without endorsement.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-zemi-rahim-bomoh-santau-melaka-malaysia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Cheng, Melaka, Malaysia",
"lat": 2.2333,
"lng": 102.2,
"title": "Malaysia: bomoh sentenced to 50 years for assaulting a girl under a black-magic-removal pretext",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"bomoh (Malay folk healer)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed removal of santau (black magic) afflicting the victim"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mahkamah Sesyen Melaka, Malaysia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "Zemi Rahim, 51, a bomoh, was convicted of physically sexually assaulting a 16-year-old student across multiple incidents in September–October 2023 under the pretext of removing black magic (santau) he claimed afflicted her, and was sentenced to 50 years' imprisonment and 13 strokes of the cane."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim submitted to 'treatment' for a supernatural affliction the bomoh himself diagnosed — the classic healer-client capture.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kosmo.com.my/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Bomoh dipenjara 50 tahun kerana cabul pelajar', Kosmo (2024).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the santau pretext, and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kosmo.com.my/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "22efceb3d3f6339e1b8c431c078f0c2185671c92739e5f2ab2e1d1513256c58f",
"final_url": "https://www.kosmo.com.my/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 431,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2025-07-17",
"note": "Conviction and sentence unanimously upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Appellate-affirmed. English-language sourcing (Malay Mail).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-tengku-khaireel-tahfiz-warden-kuantan-malaysia",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Kuantan, Pahang, Malaysia",
"lat": 3.8077,
"lng": 103.326,
"title": "Malaysia: tahfiz warden's conviction for assaulting an eleven-year-old boarder upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"warden of a tahfiz centre"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial and religious-educational authority over a boarding student"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sessions Court, Kuantan; Court of Appeal, Putrajaya",
"stage": "conviction; unanimously upheld on appeal",
"date": "2020-12-01",
"outcome": "Tengku Mohammad Khaireel Tengku Wahab, 32, warden of a tahfiz centre, was convicted on 1 December 2020 of two counts of physical sexual assault against an 11-year-old male student and sentenced to ten years and two strokes. On 17 July 2025 the Court of Appeal in Putrajaya unanimously upheld the conviction and sentence, calling the offending 'a disgusting betrayal'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a boarding student under the warden's combined custodial and religious-educational authority — the tahfiz structure placed the child in his hands day and night.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.malaymail.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Court of Appeal upholds tahfiz warden's conviction for assaulting student', Malay Mail, 17 July 2025.",
"body": "Reports the appellate affirmance and the court's characterisation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2025-07-17",
"note": "Conviction and sentence unanimously upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.malaymail.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "91f7565014509c52736ffa952550f72495b7c7f73f99cced5a0f19bc57256be4",
"final_url": "https://www.malaymail.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 432,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Rejected; conviction stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Six outlets corroborate. Vietnamese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-doan-quoc-thai-thanh-hoa-temple-an-giang-vietnam",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Chợ Mới, An Giang, Vietnam",
"lat": 10.55,
"lng": 105.4,
"title": "Vietnam: former deputy abbot convicted of abusing four child temple volunteers",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"former deputy abbot of a temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority and supervision over child volunteers on temple grounds",
"payments per incident",
"recording of encounters"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Thành Hoa Temple"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "An Giang People's Court, Vietnam",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; appeal rejected",
"date": "2025-03-20",
"outcome": "Đoàn Quốc Thái, 47, dharma name Thích Phước Trí, former deputy abbot of Thành Hoa Temple, was convicted of repeatedly abusing four children — three boys and a girl, victims from age 12 — who volunteered at the temple between April 2018 and July 2024, exploiting unaccompanied moments, paying victims per incident, and recording some encounters. He received 17 years in total; an appeal was rejected."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children volunteered at the temple under the deputy abbot's direct religious authority and supervision — the temple grounds and his office within them structured every offence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://vietnamnet.vn/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cựu phó trụ trì chùa Thành Hoa lĩnh 17 năm tù', VietnamNet, 20 Mar. 2025, corroborated by Tuổi Trẻ and Dân Trí.",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the sentence, and the appeal's rejection.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Rejected; conviction stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://vietnamnet.vn/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4ae380f5fbe6ae0040cef798ef4aedd5b1c712ccb6838d4f25f5e70d4f205017",
"final_url": "https://vietnamnet.vn/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 433,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims, including minors, not identified. First-instance disposition; no appellate outcome was located either way. Italian-language sourcing via ANSA and TorinoToday.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-paolo-meraglia-energy-rituals-turin-italy",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Moncalieri, Turin, Italy",
"lat": 45,
"lng": 7.6824,
"title": "Italy: 'santone' convicted of abusing followers through coerced 'energy exchange' rituals",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled healer and seer over a circle of clients and followers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"group sexual acts framed as 'energy exchanges' needed to neutralise foreseen dangers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prosperity-divination",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunale di Torino (4th criminal section), Italy",
"stage": "first-instance conviction and sentence",
"date": "2018-12-07",
"outcome": "Paolo Meraglia, a self-styled 'santone', was sentenced to 10 years and 11 months for sexually abusing women, including minors, under the pretext of esoteric healing sessions in which coerced group sex was framed as 'energy exchanges' necessary to neutralise dangers he claimed to foresee. Two co-defendants received 4 years 2 months and 2 years 9 months; three others were acquitted. Prosecutors had sought 23 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were clients and followers who accepted the defendant's claimed powers of foresight and healing; the rituals he prescribed were the mechanism of the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ansa.it/piemonte/notizie/2018/12/07/orge-per-curare-condannato-santone_bccec18b-d5c4-4675-a349-3fe50e45e200.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Orge per curare: condannato santone', ANSA, 7 Dec. 2018.",
"body": "Italy's national news agency reporting the conviction, sentence, and co-defendants.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ansa.it/piemonte/notizie/2018/12/07/orge-per-curare-condannato-santone_bccec18b-d5c4-4675-a349-3fe50e45e200.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dc790b71fe96a3cd7b9b7327b7e4e05a4204dafe1901d6995cb8947d7cd7fb7a",
"final_url": "https://www.ansa.it/piemonte/notizie/2018/12/07/orge-per-curare-condannato-santone_bccec18b-d5c4-4675-a349-3fe50e45e200.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 434,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal-announced",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Defence announced appeal; conviction NOT final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. FIRST-INSTANCE ONLY, appeal announced — this record must be revisited when the appellate outcome is known, per the practice applied to Nivelles and Ascona. Italian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-pietro-capuana-lavina-community-catania-italy",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Aci Bonaccorsi, Catania, Italy",
"lat": 37.599,
"lng": 15.108,
"title": "Italy: Lavina community leader convicted after court finds 'purification acts' were sexual violence",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"lay leader of a Catholic-derived community ('the Archangel' to followers)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"'purification acts' presented as spiritual necessity",
"a mind-control system over young female adherents documented by investigators"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Comunità Cattolica di Lavina"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunale di Catania, Italy",
"stage": "first-instance conviction and sentence; APPEAL ANNOUNCED",
"date": "2025-10-14",
"outcome": "Pietro Capuana, leader of the Lavina community, was sentenced at first instance to 16 years and 2 months for sexual violence against young female adherents, the court finding that the 'atti purificatori' (purification acts) he administered were sexual violence. Three female co-defendants who facilitated access received 15 years 2 months, 9 years 4 months and 7 years. The defence announced an appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's finding is the criterion applied: acts the community's members were taught to accept as purification were adjudicated to be violence — belief in his authority is what made them submit.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cataniatoday.it/cronaca/processo-12-apostoli-condanna-capuana-legale-ricorso.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Processo 12 Apostoli: condanna per Capuana, il legale annuncia ricorso', CataniaToday, Oct. 2025.",
"body": "Reports the first-instance sentence, the co-defendants, and the announced appeal.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal-announced",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Defence announced appeal; conviction NOT final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cataniatoday.it/cronaca/processo-12-apostoli-condanna-capuana-legale-ricorso.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f533231ceea444f1998d0afe433de2312753fd66f6b8e9b43822f7bff4b02c62",
"final_url": "https://www.cataniatoday.it/cronaca/processo-12-apostoli-condanna-capuana-legale-ricorso.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 435,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim, not identified; the defendant's name was withheld in reporting to protect the victim's identity. First record for Singapore. An earlier note dated this 2018; sentencing was April 2019 — corrected.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-singapore-asatizah-black-magic-cure",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Singapore",
"lat": 1.3521,
"lng": 103.8198,
"title": "Singapore: accredited religious teacher jailed for molesting a student under a black-magic 'cure'",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Muis-accredited religious teacher (asatizah)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claim that black magic was blocking the student's pregnancy",
"a 'cure' administered in a mosque"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "State Courts of Singapore",
"stage": "guilty plea, conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-04-12",
"outcome": "A 73-year-old religious teacher accredited under Singapore's Asatizah Recognition Scheme pleaded guilty to outrage of modesty for molesting his 36-year-old Quran-recitation student in a mosque in 2017, having told her black magic was preventing her from conceiving and proposing a 'cure'. He was sentenced to 16 months and struck off the accreditation scheme."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was the defendant's own religious student, and the claimed supernatural affliction — diagnosed by the man she trusted to teach her scripture — is what brought her under his hands.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/world/2019/04/12/singapore-islamic-religious-teacher-jailed-for-molesting-married-student/1742442",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Singapore Islamic religious teacher jailed for molesting married student', Malay Mail, 12 Apr. 2019.",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, the black-magic pretext, the sentence, and the striking-off.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/world/2019/04/12/singapore-islamic-religious-teacher-jailed-for-molesting-married-student/1742442",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "55a8b26fb3e28be91a3f9b0ec5ba9171bb9bc98b46e411aec67a188da94768e1",
"final_url": "https://www.malaymail.com/news/world/2019/04/12/singapore-islamic-religious-teacher-jailed-for-molesting-married-student/1742442"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 436,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Previously held on local-outlet-only sourcing; now confirmed via Correio 24h, a mainstream Bahia outlet. Portuguese-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-joildo-gonzaga-terreiro-salvador-brazil",
"year": 2026,
"place": "São Cristóvão, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil",
"lat": -12.9111,
"lng": -38.3312,
"title": "Brazil: pai de santo sentenced for raping a ten-year-old who attended his terreiro",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pai de santo of a terreiro"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position of trust within the terreiro community over a child who attended with her mother"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Ilê Axé Opô Egunitá"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bahia state court, Brazil",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; imprisoned March 2026",
"date": "2026-03-01",
"outcome": "Joildo Gonzaga da Silva, 62, pai de santo of the Ilê Axé Opô Egunitá terreiro, was sentenced to 9 years and 4 months for raping a 10-year-old girl who attended the terreiro with her mother, and was imprisoned in March 2026 following sentencing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was brought into the terreiro community by her mother, and the leader's position of trust within that religious community is what gave him access. As with all Afro-Brazilian records in this corpus, this documents an individual, not the tradition.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.correio24horas.com.br/minha-bahia/quem-e-o-lider-religioso-preso-por-estuprar-crianca-que-frequentava-terreiro-em-salvador-0326",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Quem é o líder religioso preso por estuprar criança que frequentava terreiro em Salvador', Correio 24 Horas (2026).",
"body": "Mainstream Bahia outlet confirming the sentence and imprisonment.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.correio24horas.com.br/minha-bahia/quem-e-o-lider-religioso-preso-por-estuprar-crianca-que-frequentava-terreiro-em-salvador-0326",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7143905359985422552e62d7d115ae5b2fe89ab8966eb615edebd073598644f5",
"final_url": "https://www.correio24horas.com.br/minha-bahia/quem-e-o-lider-religioso-preso-por-estuprar-crianca-que-frequentava-terreiro-em-salvador-0326"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 437,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "CONVICTION ON A COURT-ACCEPTED GUILTY PLEA; THE SENTENCE IS PENDING and the record must be updated when it issues. The separate trial of Paul Mackenzie and 94 co-accused remains at the defence stage with NO verdict — Mackenzie is deliberately NOT recorded here and must not be conflated with this plea. Victims are the subject of ongoing identification efforts and are not named.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-enos-amanya-shakahola-guilty-plea-kenya",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Shakahola, Kilifi County, Kenya",
"lat": -3.25,
"lng": 39.85,
"title": "Kenya: Shakahola preacher pleads guilty to 191 murders of cult members",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"preacher ('Hallelujah') within the Good News International movement"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal starvation taught as the path to meet Jesus",
"enforcement of the fasts within the Shakahola forest settlement"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Good News International Ministries"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Kenya at Mombasa (Justice Kavedza)",
"stage": "GUILTY PLEA to 191 murder counts and 43 manslaughter counts; sentencing pending",
"date": "2026-01-16",
"outcome": "Enos Amanya, a preacher known as 'Hallelujah' within Paul Mackenzie's Good News International movement, pleaded guilty on 16 January 2026 to 191 counts of murder and 43 of manslaughter for deaths in the Shakahola forest starvation deaths, under a plea agreement with the state. Victim-impact and pre-sentencing hearings followed; as of March 2026 the DPP had proposed an 11-year structured sentence, not yet confirmed as imposed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Shakahola dead were followers who starved because their faith leaders taught starvation as the road to Christ and enforced it in the settlement — the most absolute form of authority-over-victim this database records.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.citizen.digital/article/breakthrough-in-shakahola-massacre-case-as-suspect-pleads-guilty-to-191-murders-n375900",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Breakthrough in Shakahola massacre case as suspect pleads guilty to 191 murders', Citizen Digital, 16 Jan. 2026.",
"body": "Kenya's national broadcaster reporting the plea before Justice Kavedza.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "guilty-plea-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.capitalfm.co.ke/news/2026/02/state-reaches-plea-deal-with-shakahola-suspect-enos-amanya/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'State reaches plea deal with Shakahola suspect Enos Amanya', Capital News, Feb. 2026.",
"body": "Reports the plea agreement and the scheduled pre-sentencing hearings.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-agreement-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.citizen.digital/article/breakthrough-in-shakahola-massacre-case-as-suspect-pleads-guilty-to-191-murders-n375900",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: guilty-plea-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "27ce163b78948df4168af10e301ad8dcf216c93b9bba9e06cc456f5bbe9dfc59",
"final_url": "https://citizen.digital/article/breakthrough-in-shakahola-massacre-case-as-suspect-pleads-guilty-to-191-murders-n375900"
},
{
"source": "https://www.capitalfm.co.ke/news/2026/02/state-reaches-plea-deal-with-shakahola-suspect-enos-amanya/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-agreement-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "40c2c5e915805b074f98f700523c5702f5e65923914ee75b4abb606fd3382068",
"final_url": "https://capitalfm.africa/state-reaches-plea-deal-with-shakahola-suspect-enos-amanya/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 438,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event; individual convictions are recorded separately. Canada's defining church-abuse inquiry.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1991-hughes-inquiry-mount-cashel-canada",
"year": 1991,
"place": "St. John's, Newfoundland, Canada",
"lat": 47.5615,
"lng": -52.7126,
"title": "Canada: Hughes Inquiry finds justice system suppressed the Mount Cashel investigation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Christian Brothers staffing an orphanage",
"officials who suppressed the 1975 investigation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial authority over resident boys",
"suppression of a police investigation allowing abuse to continue a decade"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Mount Cashel Orphanage",
"Congregation of Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hughes Royal Commission of Inquiry, Newfoundland, Canada",
"stage": "royal commission finding",
"date": "1992-04-01",
"outcome": "The Hughes Inquiry (1989–91, reporting 1992) found that the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary and Justice Department officials suppressed a 1975 police investigation into sexual and physical abuse of boys by Christian Brothers at Mount Cashel Orphanage, allowing the abuse to continue for over a decade. Nine Brothers were ultimately convicted between 1989 and 1993."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Orphaned and committed boys lived under the total custodial and spiritual authority of the resident Brothers; the inquiry documented how institutional and state power together shielded that authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/mount-cashel-hughes-inquiry-anniversary-1.5100662",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, coverage of the Hughes Royal Commission of Inquiry findings (1989–1992).",
"body": "Canada's public broadcaster on the inquiry's findings of suppression and continued abuse.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/mount-cashel-hughes-inquiry-anniversary-1.5100662",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 439,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. CanLII citation not retrieved; CBC-corroborated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1991-douglas-kenny-mount-cashel-canada",
"year": 1991,
"place": "St. John's, Newfoundland, Canada",
"lat": 47.5615,
"lng": -52.7126,
"title": "Canada: Mount Cashel superintendent convicted of assaulting seven boys in his care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"superintendent of Mount Cashel Orphanage (Christian Brother)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial and disciplinary authority over resident boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Mount Cashel Orphanage"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Newfoundland courts, Canada",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1991-01-01",
"outcome": "Douglas Kenny, superintendent of Mount Cashel Orphanage from 1971 to 1976, was convicted on seven counts of indecent assault against seven boys in his direct custodial care and sentenced to five years — one of nine Christian Brothers convicted between 1989 and 1993 for abuse at the orphanage, with sentences from one to thirteen years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were orphanage residents under the superintendent's absolute custodial and religious authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/mount-cashel-brothers-convictions-1.5100662",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, coverage of the Mount Cashel prosecutions and convictions (1989–1993).",
"body": "Reports Kenny's conviction and the wider conviction set.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/mount-cashel-brothers-convictions-1.5100662",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 440,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "scc-leave-denied",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "A civil liability finding, final at the highest level.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-anderson-vicarious-liability-mount-cashel-canada",
"year": 2020,
"place": "St. John's, Newfoundland, Canada",
"lat": 47.5615,
"lng": -52.7126,
"title": "Canada: Archdiocese held vicariously liable for Mount Cashel abuse; final after SCC denies leave",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of St. John's"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"archdiocesan sanction of the Brothers' custodial authority over residents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of St. John's"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Newfoundland and Labrador Court of Appeal; Supreme Court of Canada (leave denied)",
"stage": "final appellate civil finding",
"date": "2020-07-28",
"outcome": "The NL Court of Appeal unanimously held the Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of St. John's vicariously liable for sexual and physical abuse committed against Mount Cashel residents in the late 1940s and 1950s. The Supreme Court of Canada denied leave to appeal in 2021, making the ruling final and opening compensation for survivors."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's holding is about authority itself: the Archdiocese bore responsibility for the custodial religious power it sanctioned over the boys.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.canadianlawyermag.com/practice-areas/litigation/n-l-court-of-appeal-finds-archdiocese-liable-for-abuse-at-mount-cashel-orphanage/331871",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'N.L. Court of Appeal finds archdiocese liable for abuse at Mount Cashel orphanage', Canadian Lawyer (2020).",
"body": "Legal-press report of the appellate ruling and its basis.",
"tier": "legal-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "scc-leave-denied",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.canadianlawyermag.com/practice-areas/litigation/n-l-court-of-appeal-finds-archdiocese-liable-for-abuse-at-mount-cashel-orphanage/331871",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 441,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "scc-civil",
"date": "2005",
"note": "Church/state liability upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The sentencing judge's characterisation is quoted from the record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1995-arthur-plint-alberni-residential-school-canada",
"year": 1995,
"place": "Port Alberni, British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 49.2337,
"lng": -124.8055,
"title": "Canada: Alberni residential-school supervisor sentenced as a 'sexual terrorist'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dormitory supervisor at a United Church-run residential school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial authority over Indigenous children removed from their families"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Alberni Indian Residential School",
"United Church of Canada"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "BC Supreme Court (Justice Hogarth); Supreme Court of Canada (Blackwater v. Plint, 2005)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence; civil liability affirmed by the SCC",
"date": "1995-03-01",
"outcome": "Arthur Henry Plint pleaded guilty to 18 counts of indecent assault against boys at the Alberni Indian Residential School spanning 1948–1953 and 1963–1968, and was sentenced to 11 years. Justice Hogarth called him a 'sexual terrorist' and described the residential-school system as 'a form of institutionalized pedophilia'. In Blackwater v. Plint (2005) the Supreme Court of Canada upheld the liability of church and government."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Indigenous children were removed from their families into church-run residential schools, where staff held total custodial, disciplinary and spiritual authority — the institutional structure the courts and the TRC identified as the mechanism of the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/plint-sentenced/article1088888/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Globe and Mail, reporting on R. v. Plint (1995) and Blackwater v. Plint (SCC 2005).",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, the sentence, and the judge's remarks.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "scc-civil",
"date": "2005",
"note": "Church/state liability upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/plint-sentenced/article1088888/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 442,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "sask-coa",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Beauval sentence increased 3→8 years."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. CBC-corroborated across both conviction eras.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-paul-leroux-grollier-hall-canada",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Inuvik, Northwest Territories, Canada",
"lat": 68.3607,
"lng": -133.723,
"title": "Canada: Grollier Hall supervisor convicted across three decades of proceedings",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"activities supervisor and counsellor at Catholic residential schools"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial authority over Indigenous boys at church-run residences"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Grollier Hall",
"Beauval Indian Residential School"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "NWT courts (1979, 1998); Saskatchewan courts and Court of Appeal (2013, 2015)",
"stage": "convictions in three rounds; sentence increased on Crown appeal",
"date": "1998-01-01",
"outcome": "Paul Leroux was sentenced to 10 years in 1998 for gross indecency, indecent assault and attempted buggery against 14 boys at Grollier Hall (1967–1979), following a 1979 conviction. In 2013 he was further convicted for abuse at Beauval Indian Residential School (1959–1967); the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal increased that sentence from three to eight years in 2015 on a Crown appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Indigenous children were removed from their families into church-run residential schools, where staff held total custodial, disciplinary and spiritual authority — the institutional structure the courts and the TRC identified as the mechanism of the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/appeal-court-increases-paul-leroux-s-prison-time-1.3001657",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Appeal court increases Paul Leroux's prison time' (2015), with 1998 Grollier trial coverage.",
"body": "Reports the conviction rounds and the appellate increase.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "sask-coa",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Beauval sentence increased 3→8 years."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/appeal-court-increases-paul-leroux-s-prison-time-1.3001657",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 443,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The 1990 ordination of a twice-convicted offender is recorded as documented fact central to the institutional-authority story. Early-1960s court particulars rest on compiled archives corroborated by the Edmonton Journal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-martin-houston-grollier-hall-canada",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Inuvik, NWT / Manitoba, Canada",
"lat": 68.3607,
"lng": -133.723,
"title": "Canada: Grollier Hall supervisor convicted in the 1960s — then ordained a priest in 1990",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"residential-school supervisor",
"later an ordained Catholic priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial authority over resident boys",
"later parish ministry with his history undisclosed"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Grollier Hall"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "NWT courts (1962); Manitoba (1975); Yellowknife (2004)",
"stage": "convictions across three eras",
"date": "2004-08-01",
"outcome": "Martin Houston, a Grollier Hall supervisor, pleaded guilty to ten sexual-assault charges in the early 1960s and served nine years as a declared dangerous offender; was convicted again of gross indecency in Manitoba in 1975; was nonetheless ordained a Catholic priest in 1990 and served a Manitoba parish with his history undisclosed until 2002; and in August 2004 pleaded guilty in Yellowknife to further Grollier-era abuse, receiving three years' probation. He died in 2010."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Indigenous children were removed from their families into church-run residential schools, where staff held total custodial, disciplinary and spiritual authority — the institutional structure the courts and the TRC identified as the mechanism of the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://theinquiry.ca/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Grollier Hall and the Devil of Grollier Hall', theinquiry.ca compilation, corroborated by Edmonton Journal (8 June 2002).",
"body": "Documents the conviction sequence and the undisclosed ordination.",
"tier": "archival-compilation-with-press-corroboration",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://theinquiry.ca/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: archival-compilation-with-press-corroboration; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 444,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2006-charles-sylvestre-london-diocese-ontario-canada",
"year": 2006,
"place": "Southwestern Ontario, Canada",
"lat": 42.9849,
"lng": -81.2453,
"title": "Canada: priest pleads guilty to 47 counts against girls across four decades of parishes",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Diocese of London"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over girls aged 9–14 across successive parishes, 1952–1989"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of London (Ontario)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario courts, Canada",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2006-10-01",
"outcome": "Fr Charles Sylvestre pleaded guilty to 47 counts of indecent and sexual assault against girls aged 9 to 14 across parishes in Belle River, Windsor, London, Sarnia and Chatham-Kent between 1952 and 1989 — described by the Crown as the largest known non-residential-school clergy abuse case in North America at the time. Sentenced to three years, he died in custody in January 2007."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Forty-seven girls across four decades of parishes — each inside the ordinary pastoral relationship of priest and child parishioner, transferred parish to parish.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/retired-ontario-priest-pleads-guilty-to-47-sex-charges-1.616584",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Retired Ontario priest pleads guilty to 47 sex charges' (2006).",
"body": "Reports the plea, the span of parishes, and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/retired-ontario-priest-pleads-guilty-to-47-sex-charges-1.616584",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 445,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The lenient sentence relative to admitted scope is recorded as reported; civil awards corroborate the wider conduct.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-hod-marshall-basilian-schools-canada",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Sudbury / Windsor / Saskatoon, Canada",
"lat": 46.4917,
"lng": -80.993,
"title": "Canada: Basilian priest-teacher convicted after admitting abuse of dozens of students",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Basilian priest, teacher and principal at Catholic schools"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priest-teacher authority over students across a 38-year career",
"retention in role despite six reports"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Basilian Fathers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Saskatchewan court, Canada",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence; related civil awards",
"date": "2013-01-01",
"outcome": "Fr William Hodgson 'Hod' Marshall, a Basilian priest-teacher who admitted abusing dozens of boys across a 38-year career at multiple Catholic schools, was convicted on a guilty plea for assaults on two Saskatoon boys (1959, 1961), receiving a six-month conditional sentence. He had been reported six times over his career yet retained. Civil courts later awarded individual survivors multi-million-dollar judgments. Dismissed from the priesthood by Pope Benedict XVI in 2013; died 2014."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were students at Catholic schools where the defendant's priesthood and teaching office were one authority; the institution's retention of him after repeated reports extended it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sootoday.com/local-news/26-million-awarded-to-man-abused-by-former-principal-573760",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SooToday / Sudbury.com, reporting the conviction and subsequent civil awards (2013–2021).",
"body": "Reports the plea, sentence, laicisation and civil judgments.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-civil-awards-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sootoday.com/local-news/26-million-awarded-to-man-abused-by-former-principal-573760",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-civil-awards-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 446,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Round-by-round counts are approximate pending CanLII reconciliation, as the sentencing history is complex; the 75-conviction total is well corroborated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-ralph-rowe-keewatin-fly-in-communities-canada",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Northwestern Ontario / Manitoba, Canada",
"lat": 52,
"lng": -92,
"title": "Canada: Anglican bush-pilot priest convicted of 75 sex crimes against First Nations boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Anglican priest",
"Scout leader",
"bush pilot serving ~20 remote First Nations communities"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"unique combined religious and scouting authority in isolated fly-in communities",
"unsupervised repeat access over decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Anglican Diocese of Keewatin",
"Scouts Canada"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario courts, Canada (rounds in 1994, 2005/2009, 2012)",
"stage": "multiple conviction rounds totalling 75 convictions",
"date": "2012-01-01",
"outcome": "Ralph Rowe, an Anglican priest, Scout leader and bush pilot who flew into some twenty remote First Nations communities, pleaded guilty in 1994 to 39 counts of indecent assault against 19 boys (six years; a controversial plea bargain limited future sentences), with further convictions in 2005/2009 (three years) and 2012 (conditional sentence) — 75 sex-crime convictions in total, with suspected victims in the hundreds. In 2023 a $13.25-million class action settled with the Diocese of Keewatin and Scouts Canada."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "In fly-in communities he was often the only outside authority — priest, Scout leader and pilot at once — an unrepeatable concentration of trust that gave him unsupervised access to boys for decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/thunder-bay/ralph-rowe-settlement-1.6879239",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, Ralph Rowe coverage 1994–2023 including the class-action settlement.",
"body": "Reports the conviction rounds, the plea bargain, and the settlement.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/thunder-bay/ralph-rowe-settlement-1.6879239",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 447,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Outcomes for the four co-arrested clerics not individually verified — noted as follow-up.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-jean-pilon-clercs-saint-viateur-quebec-canada",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Joliette, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 46.027,
"lng": -73.439,
"title": "Canada: Clerics of St Viator priest convicted for abuse at Quebec religious schools",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest-teacher of the Clercs de Saint-Viateur"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and disciplinary authority over pupils at religious institutions, 1961–1989"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Clercs de Saint-Viateur"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Quebec court (Justice Bertrand St-Arnaud), Canada",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2021-07-01",
"outcome": "Fr Jean Pilon of the Clercs de Saint-Viateur pleaded guilty to 12 of 26 counts of gross indecency for abuse of children at Quebec religious educational institutions between 1961 and 1989, and was sentenced to three and a half years on a joint recommendation. He was one of five elderly members of the order arrested in a coordinated 2020 police action."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were pupils at the order's institutions, under priest-teachers' combined religious and disciplinary authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-quebec-priest-sentenced-to-35-years-for-sexual-abuse-of-children/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Globe and Mail, 'Quebec priest sentenced to 3.5 years' (2021).",
"body": "Reports the plea, counts and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-quebec-priest-sentenced-to-35-years-for-sexual-abuse-of-children/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 448,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-saadeldin-bahr-curse-removal-poco-canada",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Port Coquitlam, British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 49.2621,
"lng": -122.7811,
"title": "Canada: mosque director convicted of assaulting a congregant during a 'curse removal'",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam and director of a mosque and Islamic centre"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious counselling of a vulnerable congregant",
"claim of 'a bad curse' requiring spiritual removal",
"isolation from her family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Masjid Al-Hidayah and Islamic Cultural Centre"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia court (Judge Crawford), Canada",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2017-01-01",
"outcome": "Saadeldin Bahr, director and imam of the Masjid Al-Hidayah, was convicted of sexually assaulting a married congregant — who was suffering depression, bipolar disorder and anxiety and had come to him for counselling — after telling her she had 'a bad curse' requiring spiritual removal and taking her to a storage room in 2013. Sentenced to three and a half years, 20 years on the sex-offender registry and a firearms prohibition; the judge found his position of power and his isolation of the victim from her family central."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The judge's findings supply the nexus: religious authority over a vulnerable counselee, a manufactured curse, and engineered isolation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/imam-sex-assault-sentence-1.4423138",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Port Coquitlam imam convicted of sexual assault sentenced' (2017).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the curse pretext, and the judge's findings.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/imam-sex-assault-sentence-1.4423138",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 449,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult complainant, not identified. The precise mechanism (counselling, ritual) is less documented than in the Bahr case, and this record states only what the sources establish.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-abdur-rehman-khan-surrey-canada",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Surrey, British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 49.1913,
"lng": -122.849,
"title": "Canada: Surrey imam convicted of sexual assault; kept serving after charge and conviction",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam within Surrey's Muslim community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-community standing through which the victim knew and trusted him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Masjid-Ur-Rahmah"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia court, Canada",
"stage": "conviction at trial and sentence",
"date": "2020-01-01",
"outcome": "Abdur Rehman Khan, known to the victim through his role as an imam in Surrey's Muslim community, was convicted of a July 2016 sexual assault after a trial in which the complainant endured six weeks of cross-examination, and was sentenced to three years with 20 years on the sex-offender registry. He continued serving as imam after being charged and after conviction while awaiting sentencing, prompting community concern."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim knew and trusted the defendant through his imam role in her community — the standing that produced the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/surrey-imam-sexual-assault-sentencing-1.5670000",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Surrey imam who misrepresented himself to immigration officials jailed for sexual assault' (2020).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, sentence, and continued service after charge.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/surrey-imam-sexual-assault-sentencing-1.5670000",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 450,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event; individual convictions recorded separately.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-iicsa-ampleforth-downside-uk",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Ampleforth and Downside, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 54.202,
"lng": -1.087,
"title": "IICSA: ten men convicted or cautioned for abuse at two Benedictine schools",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Benedictine monks as teachers, housemasters and confessors"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic spiritual fatherhood combined with boarding-school custody"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Ampleforth Abbey and College",
"Downside Abbey and School",
"English Benedictine Congregation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA), United Kingdom",
"stage": "statutory inquiry report",
"date": "2018-08-01",
"outcome": "IICSA found that ten men, mostly monks, had been convicted or cautioned for sexual offences against children at Ampleforth and Downside over decades, and that monks used their position as spiritual fathers, confessors and disciplinarians to reach boarding pupils who had no practical ability to refuse or report."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The inquiry's core finding: monastic spiritual authority and boarding custody fused into a single inescapable structure for resident boys.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/ampleforth-downside.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IICSA, 'Ampleforth and Downside (English Benedictine Congregation) Investigation Report' (Aug. 2018).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry's findings on the two schools.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/ampleforth-downside.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5799876b1d4f837f63a5bd6b537664a73437cd7ade89805e70d3d11db016674e",
"final_url": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/ampleforth-downside.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 451,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event; Robinson's conviction recorded separately.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-iicsa-birmingham-archdiocese-uk",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Birmingham, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.4862,
"lng": -1.8904,
"title": "IICSA: Birmingham Archdiocese prioritised reputation and priests over victims for seventy years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priests",
"archdiocesan leadership"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over congregant children",
"institutional protection of accused priests"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Birmingham"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA), United Kingdom",
"stage": "statutory inquiry report",
"date": "2020-11-01",
"outcome": "Covering seventy years, IICSA found the Archdiocese of Birmingham repeatedly prioritised its reputation and its priests over victims, with the James Robinson case a central example of clergy abusing pastoral authority over parish children while the institution shielded them."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Priests' pastoral authority over parish children, protected by the archdiocese's institutional authority above them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/birmingham-archdiocese.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IICSA, 'Archdiocese of Birmingham Investigation Report' (Nov. 2020).",
"body": "The statutory inquiry's findings on the archdiocese.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/birmingham-archdiocese.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "54698585acca33a3ea574059d799f822ef87e682a10ee0d359307c1de0149fe0",
"final_url": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/birmingham-archdiocese.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 452,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Extracted from the 38-setting umbrella report; findings concern the organisation examined.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-iicsa-religious-organisations-jw-uk",
"year": 2021,
"place": "England and Wales, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.3555,
"lng": -1.1743,
"title": "IICSA: Jehovah's Witness elders discouraged reporting, substituting internal discipline",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregational elders administering internal judicial processes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"discouragement of reports to police",
"disfellowshipping discipline in place of safeguarding referral"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (Britain)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA), United Kingdom",
"stage": "statutory inquiry report (38 religious settings)",
"date": "2021-09-01",
"outcome": "In its report on child protection in religious organisations and settings, IICSA found that Jehovah's Witness elders discouraged victims and families from reporting abuse to police and used internal 'disfellowshipping' discipline instead of safeguarding referral, leaving children under congregational authority without external recourse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Elders' religious authority governed whether abuse ever left the congregation — the same structural finding Australia's Royal Commission made, here in UK form.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/investigation/child-protection-religious-organisations-and-settings.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IICSA, 'Child Protection in Religious Organisations and Settings Investigation Report' (Sept. 2021).",
"body": "The inquiry's findings on reporting suppression among the groups examined.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/investigation/child-protection-religious-organisations-and-settings.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "15f85cb3d99a2a9ceaa8cc30542fe7c01a364bb9b73ab526aa5394cb53d81746",
"final_url": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/investigation/child-protection-religious-organisations-and-settings.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 453,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-james-robinson-birmingham-uk",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Birmingham, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.4862,
"lng": -1.8904,
"title": "United Kingdom: Fr James Robinson convicted on 21 counts after extradition from California",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and confessional authority over parish boys, 1959–1983"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Birmingham"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Birmingham Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence after extradition",
"date": "2010-01-01",
"outcome": "Fr James Robinson was convicted at Birmingham Crown Court of 21 counts of sexual abuse of boys across West Midlands parishes between 1959 and 1983, having been extradited from California where he had lived for decades. He was jailed for 21 years and laicised."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parish boys under a priest's pastoral and confessional authority — the case IICSA later treated as emblematic of the archdiocese's failures.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.coventrytelegraph.net/news/coventry-news/priest-james-robinson-jailed-21-3070038",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Priest James Robinson jailed for 21 years', CoventryLive (2010).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, extradition and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.coventrytelegraph.net/news/coventry-news/priest-james-robinson-jailed-21-3070038",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 454,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Documented further in IICSA's Ampleforth pen portraits.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2006-piers-grant-ferris-gilling-castle-uk",
"year": 2006,
"place": "Gilling Castle, North Yorkshire, United Kingdom",
"lat": 54.186,
"lng": -1.06,
"title": "United Kingdom: Ampleforth monk convicted of assaulting fifteen boys at the junior school",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Benedictine monk and teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic teaching and pastoral authority over junior boarders"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Ampleforth (Gilling Castle junior school)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "English Crown Court (Operation Ellipse)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2006-01-01",
"outcome": "Fr Piers Grant-Ferris, a Benedictine monk, was convicted of twenty counts of indecent assault against fifteen boys at Gilling Castle junior school between 1966 and 1975. He died in 2015."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Junior boarders under a monk-teacher's combined religious and custodial authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/ampleforth-downside.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IICSA Ampleforth investigation report, pen portrait of the Grant-Ferris conviction (2018; conviction 2006).",
"body": "The inquiry's account of the conviction within its Ampleforth findings.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/ampleforth-downside.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5799876b1d4f837f63a5bd6b537664a73437cd7ade89805e70d3d11db016674e",
"final_url": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/ampleforth-downside.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 455,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-richard-white-downside-uk",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Downside, Somerset, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.256,
"lng": -2.499,
"title": "United Kingdom: Downside housemaster convicted; school had kept him teaching after 1987 disclosure",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Benedictine monk and housemaster"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"live-in pastoral control over boarders",
"institutional retention after first disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Downside School"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "English Crown Court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2012-01-01",
"outcome": "Fr Richard White (known as 'Father Nicholas'), a Benedictine monk and housemaster, was jailed for five years for gross indecency and indecent assault against two boys at Downside School in 1987–1989; the school had allowed him to continue teaching after the first disclosure in 1987."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A live-in housemaster's pastoral control over boarders — and an institution that kept him in place after it knew.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/01/06/downside-school-monk-jailed_n_1189318.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Downside School monk jailed', HuffPost UK (Jan. 2012).",
"body": "Reports the conviction and the post-1987 retention.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/01/06/downside-school-monk-jailed_n_1189318.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fdcbd9c99660481b350d70e95acb5f1c08942232a07d41d306888f8467679711",
"final_url": "https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/sc-2012-primary-27-romney_n_1189318"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 456,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-timothy-storey-london-diocese-uk",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Belgravia, London, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.497,
"lng": -0.1497,
"title": "United Kingdom: Church of England youth worker convicted of raping congregants he groomed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"trainee vicar and church youth and children's worker"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"youth-ministry mentorship of congregants aged 10–16",
"public chastity preaching alongside private grooming"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"St Michael's Chester Square",
"Diocese of London"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "English Crown Court",
"stage": "convictions in 2014 and 2016; 15-year sentence",
"date": "2016-02-01",
"outcome": "Timothy Storey, a trainee vicar and youth worker, groomed and raped congregation members aged 10 to 16 met through his ministry, while publicly preaching chastity. Convicted of grooming in 2014 and of three rapes and one assault by penetration in February 2016, he was sentenced to fifteen years; the judge criticised the Diocese of London's safeguarding failures."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "His ministry was the hunting ground and his doctrine the disguise — young congregants under a youth pastor's spiritual mentorship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.christiantoday.com/article/church.youth.worker.timothy.storey.jailed.for.15.years/79489.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Church youth worker Timothy Storey jailed for 15 years', Christian Today (2016).",
"body": "Reports the convictions, sentence and judicial criticism of the diocese.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.christiantoday.com/article/church.youth.worker.timothy.storey.jailed.for.15.years/79489.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 457,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. First Scottish conviction in this corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-denis-alexander-fort-augustus-scotland-uk",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Fort Augustus, Highlands, Scotland, United Kingdom",
"lat": 57.144,
"lng": -4.68,
"title": "Scotland: Fort Augustus monk convicted after extradition from Australia",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Benedictine monk and teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monk-teacher control over resident pupils"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Fort Augustus Abbey School"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Scottish courts; Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry (Case Study 5)",
"stage": "guilty plea after extradition; SCAI institutional findings",
"date": "2020-01-01",
"outcome": "Denis Alexander ('Father Chrysostom'), a former Benedictine monk and teacher at Fort Augustus Abbey School, admitted two charges of indecent behaviour against boys in the 1970s after extradition from Australia in 2020 — a prosecution prompted by a BBC documentary. The Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry separately found the school a site of repeated abuse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Resident pupils under a monk-teacher's pastoral and disciplinary control at a monastic boarding school.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseinquiry.scot/evidence/case-study-no-5",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry, Case Study 5 (Fort Augustus), with Scotsman court reporting of the 2020 plea.",
"body": "The inquiry's findings and the conviction after extradition.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-and-conviction-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseinquiry.scot/evidence/case-study-no-5",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-and-conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c2981cfd668e4471cfb8ef92f60b0a590df0b56fad5c1b1d63cb006fd74403cd",
"final_url": "https://www.childabuseinquiry.scot/evidence/case-study-no-5"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 458,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Sentence reduced 9→8 years; conviction stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-paul-moore-ayrshire-scotland-uk",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Ayrshire, Scotland, United Kingdom",
"lat": 55.4586,
"lng": -4.6292,
"title": "Scotland: priest convicted of abusing three children and a trainee priest",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest",
"formation supervisor of a seminarian"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over parish children",
"formation authority over a trainee priest"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court in Glasgow, Scotland",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal, conviction stands",
"date": "2018-01-01",
"outcome": "Fr Paul Moore was convicted at the High Court in Glasgow of sexually abusing three children and a trainee priest across parish, school and leisure settings between 1977 and 1996, and jailed for nine years — reduced to eight on a sentence-only appeal, with the conviction upheld. His bishop testified that Moore had admitted an attraction to boys."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parish children under his pastoral office, and a seminarian whose path to priesthood ran through him — the same dual structure as the Belgian and Romanian seminary cases.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irvinetimes.com/news/16340000.paul-moore-priest-jailed/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Priest Paul Moore jailed for nine years', Irvine Times (2018).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the bishop's testimony and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Sentence reduced 9→8 years; conviction stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irvinetimes.com/news/16340000.paul-moore-priest-jailed/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a6cdb976df41862c56bcf011c871cb7751e3339292f275a2732c47bf749bdac0",
"final_url": "https://www.warringtonguardian.co.uk/news/16340000.electrical-fault-causes-kitchen-fire-harrogate-close/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 459,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Sentence appeal dismissed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-todros-grynhaus-salford-uk",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Salford, Manchester, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.4875,
"lng": -2.2901,
"title": "United Kingdom: Charedi community figure convicted; sentence appeal dismissed",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"prominent religious figure in the Salford Charedi community, in a position of care over the victims"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-communal standing in a closed community",
"position of care over the girls"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "English Crown Court; Court of Appeal (Lady Justice Hallett)",
"stage": "conviction; sentence appeal dismissed",
"date": "2015-01-01",
"outcome": "Todros Grynhaus, a prominent Charedi community figure and rabbi's son in a position of care over two girls, was convicted of indecent and sexual assault including penetration, and jailed for thirteen years and two months. The Court of Appeal dismissed his sentence appeal. He had initially fled to Israel on a false passport before extradition."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Within a closed religious community, the defendant's standing and position of care made the girls' disclosure carry communal cost — the dynamic IICSA later documented across such settings.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thejc.com/news/uk/grynhaus-jailed-for-13-years-1.66097",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Grynhaus jailed for 13 years', The Jewish Chronicle (2015).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, sentence, flight and appeal dismissal.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Sentence appeal dismissed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thejc.com/news/uk/grynhaus-jailed-for-13-years-1.66097",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "60c46fc316b4b9cf50fea5f54c07f0b5b9b9c122815404941ef8d47866697680",
"final_url": "https://www.thejc.com/news/world/kim-kardashian-israel-visit-hides-an-ugly-battle-over-armenian-antisemitism-pbm0oa8p"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 460,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. An earlier pass held this case on sourcing; the Eastern Eye corroboration satisfies the news-source requirement, and the partial acquittal is stated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-muhammad-asgar-croydon-mosque-uk",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Croydon, London, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.3762,
"lng": -0.0982,
"title": "United Kingdom: Croydon Quran teacher convicted of attempted rape and assaults on pupils",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Quran teacher at a mosque"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-instructional authority over boys in his classes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Croydon Mosque & Islamic Centre"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Croydon Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction on five counts; acquitted on four others",
"date": "2023-03-01",
"outcome": "Muhammad Asgar, a Quran teacher at the Croydon Mosque & Islamic Centre, was convicted of attempted rape and four counts of sexual assault against two boys under his religious instruction over a three-year period, and jailed for ten years with an indefinite Sexual Harm Prevention Order. He was acquitted on four further counts, which is recorded for accuracy."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boys were pupils in the defendant's Quran classes, under his direct religious teaching authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.easterneye.biz/quran-teacher-jailed-croydon/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Quran teacher jailed for sex attacks on boys', Eastern Eye (2023).",
"body": "Reports the convictions, the sentence, and the partial acquittal.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.easterneye.biz/quran-teacher-jailed-croydon/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 461,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Distinct from the separate 2026 Chatham conviction already recorded (Muhammod Islam).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-qari-sher-mohammad-chatham-uk",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Chatham, Kent, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.38,
"lng": 0.52,
"title": "United Kingdom: Chatham imam convicted on sixteen counts against four children",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam at a mosque and community centre"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious duties placing children in his care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "English Crown Court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-03-01",
"outcome": "Qari Sher Mohammad, an imam at a Chatham mosque and Muslim community centre, was convicted of sixteen counts of sexual assault against four children over a nine-year period, committed while carrying out his religious duties, and jailed for ten years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were in the imam's care through his religious duties at the mosque — instruction and office inseparable.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/medway/news/imam-jailed-for-sexually-assaulting-children-at-mosque/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Imam jailed for sexually assaulting children', KentOnline (Mar. 2025).",
"body": "Reports the sixteen convictions and sentence.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/medway/news/imam-jailed-for-sexually-assaulting-children-at-mosque/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 462,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "NO CRIMINAL CHARGE EXISTS; the disposition is substantiated safeguarding findings and licence surrender, stated plainly. Complainants are adults and young people, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-mike-pilavachi-soul-survivor-finding-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Watford, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.6565,
"lng": -0.3903,
"title": "United Kingdom: official findings that Soul Survivor's founder used spiritual authority to coerce youths",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and figurehead of a national youth ministry"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual authority and celebrity status over interns and young attendees",
"coerced massages and physical 'wrestling'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Soul Survivor",
"Diocese of St Albans"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Church of England National Safeguarding Team; independent review (Fiona Scolding KC-led, published 2024)",
"stage": "official ecclesiastical and independent-review findings; NO criminal charge",
"date": "2024-09-01",
"outcome": "The Church of England's National Safeguarding Team and an independent review both substantiated that Mike Pilavachi, founder of the Soul Survivor youth ministry, used his spiritual authority and celebrity status over four decades to draw young interns and attendees into coerced massages and physical wrestling. No criminal charges were brought; he resigned and surrendered his licence to minister."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both investigations named his spiritual authority over the young people as the coercive mechanism — the criterion in the findings' own words.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.churchofengland.org/safeguarding",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Church of England National Safeguarding Team statement and independent review findings on Mike Pilavachi (2024).",
"body": "The substantiated findings and the surrender of his licence.",
"tier": "official-church-safeguarding-finding",
"kind": "official-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.churchofengland.org/safeguarding",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-church-safeguarding-finding; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c5aeeda990d937c1f630ae3e8bc94b69723420d16a9f0b32b8f86f980e75b6d1",
"final_url": "https://www.churchofengland.org/safeguarding"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 463,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant's name was not in the English-language reporting located. FIRST RECORD FOR LATVIA. The precise congregant relationship of each girl was not detailed — flagged as a gap. Latvian case via Baltic News Network.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-talsi-priest-five-girls-latvia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Talsi County, Latvia",
"lat": 57.2444,
"lng": 22.5861,
"title": "Latvia: 83-year-old priest sentenced to ten years for sexual violence against five girls",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly standing over young girls in his community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kurzeme District Court, Latvia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-05-01",
"outcome": "An 83-year-old priest, born in 1941, was sentenced by the Kurzeme District Court to ten years' imprisonment for sexual violence against five girls in Talsi County, the youngest aged seven."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were young girls within the priest's community reach; his clerical standing is what created the access and trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bnn-news.com/83-year-old-priest-sentenced-to-ten-years-in-prison-for-sexual-violence-against-minors-256619",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'83-year-old priest sentenced to ten years in prison for sexual violence against minors', Baltic News Network (2024).",
"body": "Reports the Kurzeme District Court conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bnn-news.com/83-year-old-priest-sentenced-to-ten-years-in-prison-for-sexual-violence-against-minors-256619",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ee9ca3a1a037d715a878ada5256cb967e4d56fbe8909958770cddfc490ecb85a",
"final_url": "https://bnn-news.com/83-year-old-priest-sentenced-to-ten-years-in-prison-for-sexual-violence-against-minors-256619"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 464,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "A physical-abuse record, within the corpus's scope. The conditional sentence is recorded as the disposition. Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1999-anna-wesley-st-annes-fort-albany-canada",
"year": 1999,
"place": "Fort Albany, Ontario, Canada",
"lat": 52.1833,
"lng": -81.6833,
"title": "Canada: St Anne's residential-school nun convicted of assaults and administering a noxious substance",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"nun and supervisor at a church-run residential school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial and disciplinary authority over Indigenous children",
"punishments including forced ingestion"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St Anne's Indian Residential School"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario court, Canada",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1999-01-01",
"outcome": "Anna Wesley, a nun and supervisor at St Anne's Indian Residential School in the 1950s–60s, was convicted in 1999 of three counts of common assault, three counts of administering a noxious substance, and one count of assault causing bodily harm against students in her care, receiving an 11-month conditional sentence. St Anne's is separately notorious for a homemade electric chair used on children."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were Indigenous children removed into a church-run school where a nun's religious office and custodial power were one authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/st-annes-nun-residential-school-charges-1.7001318",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News coverage of the Anna Wesley convictions at St Anne's (1999; retrospectives).",
"body": "Canada's public broadcaster on the convictions and the institution's history.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/st-annes-nun-residential-school-charges-1.7001318",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 465,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. An earlier note dated this 2016; sentencing was February 2015 — corrected. Appeal status unconfirmed and flagged.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-david-lowe-choir-school-ampleforth-uk",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Westminster and Ampleforth, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.4958,
"lng": -0.136,
"title": "United Kingdom: choir-school housemaster convicted on all fifteen counts against ten boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"housemaster at Westminster Cathedral Choir School",
"music teacher at Ampleforth"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"live-in housemaster authority over choir boarders",
"private music lessons"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Westminster Cathedral Choir School",
"Ampleforth College"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Southwark Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction on all counts and sentence",
"date": "2015-02-05",
"outcome": "David Lowe, a housemaster at Westminster Cathedral Choir School and music teacher at Ampleforth, was convicted on all fifteen counts of indecent assault against ten boys between 1978 and 1984, committed in dormitories and during private singing lessons, and sentenced on 5 February 2015 to ten years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Choir-school boarders lived under the housemaster's pastoral and disciplinary control inside Catholic institutions; the private lesson was the isolating instrument.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/former-catholic-choir-school-teacher-david-lowe-jailed-10-years-child-sex-abuse-1486574",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former Catholic choir school teacher David Lowe jailed', IBTimes UK (Feb. 2015).",
"body": "Reports the conviction on all counts and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/former-catholic-choir-school-teacher-david-lowe-jailed-10-years-child-sex-abuse-1486574",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "15caf082c60e1f2b60f7dfd97e038466b8827adc88ee5a59cacb00dc9e6d2f5e",
"final_url": "https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/vampire-diaries-season-6-spoilers-damon-elena-save-bonnie-suicide-caroline-stefan-romance-1486574"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 466,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Previously held for want of a mainstream source; the Canberra Times report satisfies it. The Samoa posting is documented context for institutional handling.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-frank-klep-rupertswood-salesian-australia",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Sunbury, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.5811,
"lng": 144.7139,
"title": "Australia: Salesian priest Frank Klep sentenced to a decade for a 'campaign of abuse' at Rupertswood",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Salesian priest, teacher and infirmary supervisor at a boarding college"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and sick-bay authority over boarding students"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Salesian College Rupertswood"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Australia",
"stage": "convictions in 2005 and 2014",
"date": "2014-01-01",
"outcome": "Fr Frank Klep, a Salesian priest at Rupertswood, pleaded guilty in December 2005 to thirteen counts of indecent assault against ten boys — many during infirmary care — and in 2014 was convicted of fifteen further child sex offences from the 1970s–80s and sentenced to ten and a half years, the judge describing a 'campaign of abuse'. In the intervening years the order had posted him to Samoa as allegations mounted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boarding students in his pastoral and infirmary care — the sick bay being the most defenceless setting a school contains.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6008814/evil-ex-priest-gets-more-vic-jail-time/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Evil ex-priest gets more Vic jail time', Canberra Times (2014).",
"body": "Australian mainstream reporting of the 2014 conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6008814/evil-ex-priest-gets-more-vic-jail-time/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "56277f5864918d4def929f2eb5fe10863f5e452f40c922e955f9b56d9e308342",
"final_url": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6008814/evil-ex-priest-gets-more-vic-jail-time/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 467,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim, not identified; defendant named by initials. Verdict corroborated across Media Jatim's reporting with Radar Madura's pre-trial coverage. Indonesian-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-dukun-mb-patient-pamekasan-indonesia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Pasean, Pamekasan, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.9,
"lng": 113.5333,
"title": "Indonesia: dukun convicted of raping a patient during a healing session",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dukun (traditional healer)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"healing session as the setting and pretext"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Pamekasan, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-10-08",
"outcome": "A dukun identified as MB, 48, was convicted under Article 285 of the criminal code of raping his 20-year-old patient during a healing session in Dusun Ahatan, and sentenced on 8 October 2025 to four years — below the prosecution's six-year demand, a leniency the victim's family criticised."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a patient who submitted to the healer's treatment — the session itself was the mechanism of access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mediajatim.com/2025/10/08/dukun-cabul-di-pamekasan-divonis-4-tahun-penjara-keluarga-korban-mengaku-belum-lega/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Dukun cabul di Pamekasan divonis 4 tahun penjara', Media Jatim, 8 Oct. 2025.",
"body": "Reports the conviction, sentence, and the family's response.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mediajatim.com/2025/10/08/dukun-cabul-di-pamekasan-divonis-4-tahun-penjara-keluarga-korban-mengaku-belum-lega/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "921502ef1a60e196258875af0fb7c59679071eca51f696010ca9fd8ad79d6b1d",
"final_url": "https://mediajatim.com/2025/10/08/dukun-cabul-di-pamekasan-divonis-4-tahun-penjara-keluarga-korban-mengaku-belum-lega/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 468,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Upheld; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Five Egyptian outlets corroborate. Arabic-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-suleiman-fayed-dakahlia-quran-lessons-egypt",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Talkha, Dakahlia, Egypt",
"lat": 31.0533,
"lng": 31.378,
"title": "Egypt: mosque imam's life sentence for assaulting a Quran student upheld on cassation",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"mosque imam and preacher (Islamic Endowments employee)",
"Quran memorisation teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"private memorisation lessons used to lure the child to his home"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Egyptian criminal courts; Mansoura Court of Cassation",
"stage": "conviction and life sentence; upheld on cassation",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"outcome": "Suleiman Fayed Suleiman Muhammad, a mosque imam and Islamic Endowments employee, was convicted of repeatedly sexually assaulting a girl of about twelve whom he lured to his home after Quran memorisation lessons, with forensic corroboration. He received a life sentence (25 years at hard labour) with a fine and compensation, upheld by the Mansoura Court of Cassation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was his Quran student; the memorisation lessons were the mechanism that moved her from the mosque to his home.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.masrawy.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'تأييد المؤبد لإمام مسجد اعتدى على طفلة بالدقهلية', Masrawy (Jan. 2025), corroborated by Al-Masry Al-Youm and Elwatan.",
"body": "Reports the conviction, the forensic basis, and the cassation affirmance.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2025",
"note": "Upheld; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.masrawy.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cee15b66ac35b6ec3ff074738efd733667dbf45cb03451eadf29970b243703df",
"final_url": "https://www.masrawy.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 469,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; defendant named by initials per Moroccan practice. Seven outlets corroborate. Arabic-language sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-fqih-zmij-tangier-six-girls-morocco",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Zmij, Melloussa, Tangier, Morocco",
"lat": 35.7,
"lng": -5.6,
"title": "Morocco: village Quran teacher sentenced to 30 years for assaulting six girl pupils",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"mosque-affiliated fqih teaching Quran to village children"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teaching authority over village girls",
"threats to ensure silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tangier Court of Appeal, Criminal Chamber, Morocco",
"stage": "conviction and sentence at criminal-chamber level",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"outcome": "A mosque-affiliated fqih in the village of Zmij, identified as 'A.A.', who taught Quran to local children, confessed to and was convicted of sexually assaulting six minor girls under his instruction, using threats to ensure their silence. The Tangier Court of Appeal's criminal chamber sentenced him to 30 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The six girls were his Quran pupils in a village where the fqih's standing made both access and silence possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.hespress.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'الحكم بـ30 سنة سجنا على فقيه الزميج', Hespress (2021), corroborated by Assahraa, Al3omk and Chouftv.",
"body": "Reports the confession, conviction, and 30-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.hespress.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c6a048e1a301d4a679325c349d1f698400e2f96ade87aa69ae8a6ed988c84352",
"final_url": "https://www.hespress.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 470,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR TUNISIA. Sentence figures conflict across outlets between co-defendants and are stated with that flag. Corroborated by CNN Arabic, Al Jazeera and the US State Department human-rights report.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-regueb-quranic-school-sidi-bouzid-tunisia",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Regueb, Sidi Bouzid, Tunisia",
"lat": 34.8583,
"lng": 9.7869,
"title": "Tunisia: unlicensed Quranic boarding-school director convicted after raid revealed abuse of resident boys",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"director of an unlicensed Quranic boarding school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial and religious authority over 42 resident boys",
"forced labour, caning and indoctrination documented at the raid"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sidi Bouzid Court of Appeal, Tunisia",
"stage": "appellate conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-11-08",
"outcome": "After a January 2019 raid on an unlicensed Quranic boarding school in Regueb housing 42 boys aged 10–17 in abusive conditions, its director was convicted of rape, sexual exploitation of minors and forced child labour — around nine resident students were found to have been sexually abused. The appeal court sentenced the director to five years with probation and a fine; reporting also cites a 20-year term that appears to attach to a co-defendant teacher in the same case cluster, a disambiguation this record preserves."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Resident boys under the school's total custodial and religious authority — the boarding structure is what made every abuse documented at the raid possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aljazeera.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Al Jazeera and CNN Arabic coverage of the Regueb Quranic school case (2019), with the US State Department 2019 Human Rights Report on Tunisia.",
"body": "Reports the raid findings, the charges, and the appellate convictions.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aljazeera.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1a9edc72612bb24f0260dd2e37a949e01a5657ca0806810cbc55a50daf94ab99",
"final_url": "https://www.aljazeera.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 471,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "canonical",
"date": "2012",
"note": "Vatican sanction: life of prayer and penance."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. CONVICTION IN ABSENTIA AND UNENFORCED — stated plainly; the verdict is final in form but the defendant has never been in custody. Tagged to France, where the home operated and the harm occurred, per the harm-location rule.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-mansour-labaky-caen-in-absentia-france",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Douvres-la-Délivrande, Normandy, France",
"lat": 49.2925,
"lng": -0.3792,
"title": "France: Maronite priest convicted in absentia of raping minors at the children's home he ran",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Maronite priest",
"founder-director of a children's home for Lebanese war refugees"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly and custodial authority over displaced children in his shelter"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour d'assises du Calvados, Caen, France; Vatican canonical process (2012)",
"stage": "conviction in absentia; prior canonical sanction; sentence unenforced",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "Mgr Mansour Labaky, a Lebanese Maronite priest who ran a children's home in Normandy for minors displaced by the Lebanese civil war, was convicted in absentia by the Calvados assize court of raping minors between 1989 and 1997 as a person in a position of authority, and sentenced to 15 years. The Vatican had already sanctioned him in 2012 to a life of prayer and penance. He remains in Lebanon, which has declined extradition despite an international arrest warrant, and the sentence is unenforced."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Displaced children lived in a shelter run by the priest who embodied both their religious authority and their custody — refugees with nowhere else to go.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cath.ch/newsf/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "cath.ch and France Bleu coverage of the Calvados assize conviction of Mansour Labaky (2024) and the 2012 Vatican sanction.",
"body": "Reports the in-absentia conviction, the sentence, and the non-extradition.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-in-absentia-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "canonical",
"date": "2012",
"note": "Vatican sanction: life of prayer and penance."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cath.ch/newsf/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-in-absentia-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "511c8254e5327094c02ef51c9fe828cc0c38512736d1bd8c37860787205cbbc0",
"final_url": "https://cath.ch/newsf/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 472,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims: two boys are named in regional press but are not named here, per this database's practice regardless of press disclosure. FIRST RECORD FOR IRAQ. Appeal status unconfirmed. Arabic-language sourcing across five outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-rajab-al-ani-ramadi-quran-sessions-iraq",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Ramadi, Anbar, Iraq",
"lat": 33.4258,
"lng": 43.2992,
"title": "Iraq: mosque muezzin and Quran instructor given double life sentence for raping boys in his sessions",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"muezzin and Sunni Endowment employee",
"Quran memorisation instructor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-instruction sessions placing boys in his charge at the mosque"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Anbar Criminal Court, Iraq",
"stage": "conviction and double life sentence",
"date": "2023-09-12",
"outcome": "Rajab Abdullah Muhammad al-Ani, a muezzin and Sunni Endowment employee who ran Quran memorisation sessions at a Ramadi mosque, was convicted of raping two boys from his sessions and sentenced on 12 September 2023 to life imprisonment twice over; reporting suggested more children may have been affected over time. The 30-day appeal window's outcome was not confirmed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boys were children of his Quran sessions — the mosque role placed them in his charge.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.skynewsarabia.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'السجن المؤبد مرتين لمؤذن اغتصب طفلين في الرمادي', Sky News Arabia (12 Sept. 2023), corroborated by Baghdad Today and Al Ghad.",
"body": "Reports the conviction and the double life sentence.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.skynewsarabia.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b1f20a32ca344770f0a7d5d8a94d503be1a8f90340d1ba0f179665e071e605d9",
"final_url": "https://www.skynewsarabia.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 473,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Upheld; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR SERBIA. The exact appellate date within 2016 was not pinned. Serbian-language sourcing across two outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-milovan-djokic-plocica-choir-serbia",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Pločica, Kovin, Serbia",
"lat": 44.7167,
"lng": 20.9167,
"title": "Serbia: village priest's conviction for abusing a choir girl upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Serbian Orthodox village priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"supervision of the church choir the girl sang in from 2012",
"paid chores 'helping around the church' used to isolate her"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Viši sud Smederevo; Apelacioni sud (appellate court), Serbia",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"date": "2016-01-01",
"outcome": "Milovan Đokić, priest of the church in Pločica village near Kovin, was convicted of statutory rape of a child and an attempted repeat offence against a 13-year-old girl who had sung in his church choir since 2012, whom he drew in with paid chores around the church. The five-year sentence was upheld by the appellate court, making it final (pravosnažno)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The girl was a member of the priest's own choir, under his direct supervision, and the church errands he paid her for are what created the isolation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.021.rs/story/Info/Vojvodina/138912/Kovin-Pet-godina-zatvora-za-svestenika-pedofila.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kovin: Pet godina zatvora za sveštenika', 021.rs (2016).",
"body": "Serbian regional outlet reporting the conviction and appellate confirmation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Upheld; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.021.rs/story/Info/Vojvodina/138912/Kovin-Pet-godina-zatvora-za-svestenika-pedofila.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "00bd578b09299bdb908bc017676442b7c8462872d41ce7d69831df7e3e908611",
"final_url": "https://www.021.rs/info/vojvodina/138912/kovin-pet-godina-zatvora-za-svestenika-pedofila"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 474,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR LITHUANIA. The sentence's terms (custodial versus suspended) were not located and are flagged as a gap; the conviction and its Supreme Court level are corroborated by LRT and TV3. The diocese's retention of him is documented context.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-vidmantas-kareckas-religion-teacher-lithuania",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Papilys, Biržai, Lithuania",
"lat": 56.1333,
"lng": 24.9167,
"title": "Lithuania: priest convicted at Supreme Court level of indecent acts against two first-graders he taught",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest and religion teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious instruction of first-grade girls"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lietuvos Aukščiausiasis Teismas (Supreme Court of Lithuania)",
"stage": "conviction final at Supreme Court level",
"date": "2007-01-01",
"outcome": "Vidmantas Kareckas, a priest and religion teacher, was convicted at Supreme Court level of indecent acts (tvirkinimas) against two first-grade girls he taught as their religion instructor. Despite the conviction, the Panevėžys diocese did not remove him from parish work and later assigned him as resident priest of Biržai parish — a fact reported by Lithuania's public broadcaster."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The girls were his religion pupils — children placed under a priest's direct instructional and spiritual authority in a church-linked educational role.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lrt.lt/naujienos/lietuvoje/2/2313275/uz-pirmokiu-tvirkinima-teistas-kunigas-kareckas-birzu-parapijos-rezidentu",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Už pirmokių tvirkinimą teistas kunigas Kareckas paskirtas Biržų parapijos rezidentu', LRT.",
"body": "Lithuania's public broadcaster on the conviction and the diocesan reassignment.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lrt.lt/naujienos/lietuvoje/2/2313275/uz-pirmokiu-tvirkinima-teistas-kunigas-kareckas-birzu-parapijos-rezidentu",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "16cfa8487682c6767216e754c0f9fe3d64dd2932b18a6fd49d5f268fd075e80e",
"final_url": "https://www.lrt.lt/naujienos/lietuvoje/2/2313275/uz-pirmokiu-tvirkinima-teistas-kunigas-kareckas-birzu-parapijos-rezidentu"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 475,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR THE 2×2 SECT — a movement with no legal name, hundreds of accused workers on advocacy hotlines, and a 2024 FBI investigation; this record and Mousseau's are the two convictions with mainstream-press corroboration. The sect's namelessness is itself an accountability obstacle this record documents.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-timothy-severud-2x2-worker-minnesota-usa",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Douglas County, Minnesota, USA",
"lat": 45.885,
"lng": -95.3775,
"title": "United States: 2×2 travelling worker convicted of abusing the child of a host family",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"itinerant minister ('worker') of the nameless 2×2 sect"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the sect's itinerant-ministry system housing workers inside members' homes",
"spiritual standing over the host family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"'Two by Twos' / 'The Truth' (nameless sect)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Douglas County District Court, Minnesota, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2007-12-18",
"outcome": "Timothy Knut Severud, a travelling minister ('worker') of the nameless sect known as the Two by Twos or 'The Truth', who repeatedly stayed in the home of a family he ministered to, pleaded guilty to second-degree criminal sexual conduct for abusing their ten-year-old daughter during his stays — admitting roughly six incidents after her parents caught him. He was sentenced to 90 months with ten years' conditional release and sex-offender registration."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The sect's defining structure — homeless itinerant workers housed by member families as an act of faith — placed the minister inside the child's home with the family's total spiritual trust. This is the canonical 2×2 authority nexus, now under FBI investigation across hundreds of accused workers.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.echopress.com/news/traveling-minister-sentenced-for-sexual-misconduct",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Traveling minister sentenced for sexual misconduct', Alexandria Echo Press, 18 Dec. 2007.",
"body": "Local paper of record reporting the guilty plea, sentence, and the host-family circumstances.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.echopress.com/news/traveling-minister-sentenced-for-sexual-misconduct",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ba625f4f2929d46a5c87e74172bf4183d8d0f3641d5d1137f43bbf4a94f6fdeb",
"final_url": "https://www.echopress.com/news/traveling-minister-sentenced-for-sexual-misconduct"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 476,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The survivor is named because she has chosen to speak publicly, including to the AP; this record follows her own public account. The convictions are corroborated by AP wire reporting and Michigan corrections records via the advocacy index.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-peter-mousseau-2x2-worker-michigan-usa",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Michigan, USA",
"lat": 44.3148,
"lng": -85.6024,
"title": "United States: 2×2 worker convicted twice for abusing a host family's daughter",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"itinerant 2×2 worker in Michigan and Wisconsin"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"housed in the victim's family home as their spiritual authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"'Two by Twos' / 'The Truth' (nameless sect)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan courts, USA",
"stage": "convictions in 2010 and 2011",
"date": "2011-09-01",
"outcome": "Peter Mousseau, a 2×2 worker active in Michigan and Wisconsin, stayed with a member family as an itinerant preacher and abused their daughter from the age of eleven (a 1997 offence, with a separate 1993 offence). He was convicted in 2010 of fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct and in September 2011 of assault with intent to commit sexual penetration, receiving two to ten years. The survivor, Lisa Webb, has spoken publicly and features in the Associated Press's 2024 coverage of the FBI investigation into the sect."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The same canonical nexus: an itinerant worker embedded in the family home as the faith's living authority — the arrangement the sect's doctrine requires.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timeswv.com/news/national_news/survivors-seek-a-reckoning-as-fbi-investigates-child-sex-abuse-in-little-known-christian-sect/article_903a0900-20cd-5fe3-87a3-596f5b6e1d48.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Survivors seek a reckoning as FBI investigates child sex abuse in little-known Christian sect', Associated Press (2024).",
"body": "AP wire coverage of the sect, the FBI investigation, and the Mousseau case through the survivor's account.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "investigative-and-conviction-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timeswv.com/news/national_news/survivors-seek-a-reckoning-as-fbi-investigates-child-sex-abuse-in-little-known-christian-sect/article_903a0900-20cd-5fe3-87a3-596f5b6e1d48.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: investigative-and-conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 477,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-kevin-laferney-glenwood-first-baptist-texas-usa",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Gilmer, Texas, USA",
"lat": 32.729,
"lng": -94.9424,
"title": "United States: Baptist youth minister given life after faking his own death to flee",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth minister at a Southern Baptist church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"youth-ministry authority over a congregant minor"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Glenwood First Baptist Church, Gilmer",
"Southern Baptist Convention"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Texas state court, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and life sentence after flight and capture",
"date": "2008-01-01",
"outcome": "Kevin Othell Laferney, youth minister at Glenwood First Baptist Church in Gilmer, pleaded guilty to aggravated sexual assault of a child. He had fled and faked his own death before being captured in Montana, and was sentenced to life. He appears in the Houston Chronicle's 'Abuse of Faith' documentation of convicted Southern Baptist church staff."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a congregant minor under the youth minister's church authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbs19.tv/article/news/houston-chronicle-identifies-southern-baptist-church-staff-volunteers-convicted-of-sex-crimes-4-east-texans-on-list/501-3dd4ba3d-86b4-455b-a111-b2a862b3e711",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS19, 'Houston Chronicle identifies Southern Baptist church staff convicted of sex crimes' (Abuse of Faith coverage).",
"body": "Mainstream coverage of the conviction within the Chronicle's documented set.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbs19.tv/article/news/houston-chronicle-identifies-southern-baptist-church-staff-volunteers-convicted-of-sex-crimes-4-east-texans-on-list/501-3dd4ba3d-86b4-455b-a111-b2a862b3e711",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 478,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2009",
"note": "One count reversed; judgment otherwise affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The church's precise SBC affiliation versus independent Reformed Baptist identity was not fully confirmed and is noted. Corroborated by an LAPD release and newspaper court reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-joseph-torres-iglesia-bautista-sunland-california-usa",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Sunland, California, USA",
"lat": 34.2669,
"lng": -118.302,
"title": "United States: Baptist pastor sentenced to 32 years for abusing two congregant girls",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a Spanish-language Baptist congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over girls of his congregation across multi-year periods"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia Bautista Reformada, Sunland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Los Angeles County Superior Court; California Court of Appeal",
"stage": "conviction on 11 counts; appeal largely affirmed",
"date": "2008-08-07",
"outcome": "Joseph Gary Torres, pastor of the Iglesia Bautista Reformada in Sunland, was convicted on eleven counts of sexually abusing two girls who were congregants of his church between 2000 and 2006, and sentenced to 32 years and 4 months. The appellate court reversed one count but affirmed the judgment, remanding only for resentencing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both victims were girls of the congregation the defendant pastored.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lapdonline.org/newsroom/pastor-and-son-arrested-on-charges-of-child-molestation/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "LAPD newsroom release, with Contra Costa Times court reporting of the 2008 sentence.",
"body": "Police release and press reporting of the arrest, conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "official-police-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2009",
"note": "One count reversed; judgment otherwise affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lapdonline.org/newsroom/pastor-and-son-arrested-on-charges-of-child-molestation/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-police-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 479,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Reported by Baptist Press — the denomination's own outlet, reporting against interest — with local corroboration.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-keenan-hord-first-baptist-bentonville-arkansas-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Bentonville, Arkansas, USA",
"lat": 36.3729,
"lng": -94.2088,
"title": "United States: Bentonville youth pastor sentenced to 60 years on thirteen counts",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor at First Baptist Church of Bentonville"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position of trust and authority over church minors, stated explicitly in the charging documents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"First Baptist Church of Bentonville",
"Southern Baptist Convention"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Benton County Circuit Court, Arkansas, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "Keenan Hord, youth pastor at First Baptist Church of Bentonville from 2018 to 2022, pleaded guilty to thirteen counts of sexual assault against six identified minor victims; the charging documents state he engaged in sexual activity with minors while in a position of trust or authority over them. He was sentenced to 60 years, parole-eligible after 15."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The charging documents state the criterion themselves: a position of trust and authority over the church's minors.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-60-years-for-sex-related-crimes/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former youth pastor sentenced to 60 years for sex-related crimes', Baptist Press (2023).",
"body": "The denomination's news service reporting the plea, counts, victims and sentence.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting-against-interest",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-60-years-for-sex-related-crimes/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting-against-interest; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "845024d35ffe316e86b7808ada92687a851a31cf0f6e50b583a9b1e4cf344ea0",
"final_url": "https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-60-years-for-sex-related-crimes/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 480,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2013",
"note": "Upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The appellate opinion is publicly reported (State v. Berry).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-stephen-berry-new-life-baptist-south-carolina-usa",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Union, South Carolina, USA",
"lat": 34.7154,
"lng": -81.6237,
"title": "United States: youth pastor's conviction for abusing a congregant teenager upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"associate and youth pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"youth-ministry relationship with a fifteen-year-old met through the church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"New Life Baptist Church, Union"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "South Carolina court; SC Court of Appeals (State v. Berry)",
"stage": "conviction at trial; upheld on appeal",
"date": "2011-01-01",
"outcome": "Stephen Douglas Berry, associate and youth pastor at New Life Baptist Church in Union, was convicted at trial of second-degree criminal sexual conduct with a minor over a months-long 2010 relationship with a fifteen-year-old he met through the church, and sentenced to fifteen years. The South Carolina Court of Appeals upheld the conviction against a challenge to expert testimony."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim met the defendant through his church, where his youth-pastoral office was the relationship's frame.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/sc-court-of-appeals/1707924.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Berry, South Carolina Court of Appeals.",
"body": "The appellate opinion affirming the conviction.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wbtv.com/story/21119893/former-youth-pastor-gets-15-years-for-sex-with-teen-girl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former youth pastor gets 15 years', WBTV (2011).",
"body": "Local broadcaster's court reporting.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2013",
"note": "Upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/sc-court-of-appeals/1707924.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f2e9b932db09304c4c1f1d4eddfe54a5345f062d9c0586c39759868991e95c4e",
"final_url": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/sc-court-of-appeals/1707924.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wbtv.com/story/21119893/former-youth-pastor-gets-15-years-for-sex-with-teen-girl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "716ac184a3f21f175968f6e00e9f534ddc9a076f8f58de647db776871cec5273",
"final_url": "https://www.wbtv.com/story/21119893/former-youth-pastor-gets-15-years-for-sex-with-teen-girl/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 481,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is not identified. The original sentence rests on press reporting; the 2021 ouster is documented denominational record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1996-randy-leming-shiloh-baptist-tennessee-usa",
"year": 1996,
"place": "Sevier County, Tennessee, USA",
"lat": 35.8681,
"lng": -83.5622,
"title": "United States: pastor convicted of statutory rape of a congregant; retaining church ousted from SBC decades later",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a Baptist church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a sixteen-year-old congregation member"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Shiloh Baptist Church, Sevier County",
"Southern Baptist Convention"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tennessee state court, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea; later denominational action against a retaining church",
"date": "1996-01-01",
"outcome": "John Randy Leming, pastor of Shiloh Baptist Church, pleaded guilty in 1996 to two counts of statutory rape of a sixteen-year-old member of his congregation (1994 offences), receiving eighteen months. Decades later, another SBC church that hired him — Antioch — was ousted from the Convention in 2021 for retaining him, whereupon he resigned; the 2021 ouster is among the SBC's first enforcement actions of its kind."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a member of the congregation the defendant pastored; the 2021 ouster of a retaining church documents the denominational-accountability arc the case set in motion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.baptiststandard.com/news/baptists/former-abuser-resigns-after-church-ousted-from-sbc/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former abuser resigns after church ousted from SBC', Baptist Standard, 16 Mar. 2021.",
"body": "Reports the 1996 conviction and the 2021 SBC ouster of the retaining church.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting-against-interest",
"kind": "conviction-and-denominational-action-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.baptiststandard.com/news/baptists/former-abuser-resigns-after-church-ousted-from-sbc/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting-against-interest; evidentiary role: conviction-and-denominational-action-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "00df2da259055b4466c5b03bd2a928b07993342239bfe2d80d851db667e51a3a",
"final_url": "https://baptiststandard.com/news/baptists/former-abuser-resigns-after-church-ousted-from-sbc/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 482,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Only one criminal conviction was entered before his death; the wider accusation set is documented context, not adjudication.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-john-geoghan-boston-archdiocese-usa",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Boston, Massachusetts, USA",
"lat": 42.3601,
"lng": -71.0589,
"title": "United States: John Geoghan convicted — the case that broke open the Boston scandal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest across six Boston-area parishes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and recreational supervision of parish boys across a thirty-year career"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Boston"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Massachusetts court, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2002-02-21",
"outcome": "John Geoghan, a Boston Archdiocese priest accused by more than 130 boys across six parishes over thirty years, was convicted on 21 February 2002 of indecent assault and battery on a ten-year-old boy and sentenced to nine to ten years. His serial transfers despite archdiocesan knowledge were the spine of the Boston Globe's Spotlight investigation. He was murdered by a fellow inmate in August 2003 before further trials concluded."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parish boys under a priest's pastoral supervision, delivered to him repeatedly by an archdiocese that moved him rather than removed him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/church-in-crisis-john-geoghans-death",
"archive": "",
"citation": "PBS NewsHour, 'Church in Crisis' coverage of the Geoghan conviction and death, with Boston Globe Spotlight reporting.",
"body": "Reports the conviction, sentence, and the case's role in the 2002 scandal.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "conviction-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/church-in-crisis-john-geoghans-death",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "038ec1682c68117f7914aff7b6be68837594481a0d1074fe3f2259bf6acd13bb",
"final_url": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/church-in-crisis-john-geoghans-death"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 483,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "sjc",
"date": "2010-01-10",
"note": "Unanimously affirmed (455 Mass. 752)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. Appellate opinion cited.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-paul-shanley-ccd-newton-massachusetts-usa",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Newton, Massachusetts, USA",
"lat": 42.337,
"lng": -71.2092,
"title": "United States: Paul Shanley's child-rape conviction affirmed by the Supreme Judicial Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest running CCD religious-education classes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"removal of the boy from CCD classes for the assaults"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Boston"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Massachusetts court; Supreme Judicial Court (Commonwealth v. Shanley, 455 Mass. 752)",
"stage": "jury conviction; unanimously affirmed",
"date": "2005-02-01",
"outcome": "Former priest Paul Shanley was convicted in February 2005 of indecent assault and statutory rape of a boy abused between 1983 and 1989 during CCD religious-education classes, and sentenced to 12–15 years. The Supreme Judicial Court unanimously affirmed the conviction on 10 January 2010."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child in the priest's own religious-education classes — pulled out of catechism to be assaulted.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/supreme-court/volumes/455/455mass752.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commonwealth v. Shanley, 455 Mass. 752 (Mass. SJC, 10 Jan. 2010).",
"body": "The appellate opinion affirming the convictions.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "sjc",
"date": "2010-01-10",
"note": "Unanimously affirmed (455 Mass. 752)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/supreme-court/volumes/455/455mass752.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 484,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. A historical anchor record; the plea rests on consistent contemporaneous and retrospective reporting rather than a retrieved transcript.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1985-gilbert-gauthe-lafayette-louisiana-usa",
"year": 1985,
"place": "Diocese of Lafayette, Louisiana, USA",
"lat": 30.2241,
"lng": -92.0198,
"title": "United States: Gilbert Gauthe — the first widely publicized American priest conviction",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral charge over parish children and altar boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lafayette"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Louisiana state court, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "1985-01-01",
"outcome": "Gilbert Gauthe, who admitted abusing 37 children, pleaded guilty on 33 counts and was sentenced to twenty years — the case widely cited as opening the modern American clergy-abuse era, seventeen years before the Boston reporting."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parish children and altar boys under their priest's direct charge — the template every later case repeated.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nola.com/news/catholic-church-ignored-1985-report-warning-of-child-sex-abuse-crisis/article_91ac5ee5-ed47-55b9-a6e9-ef72496a8900.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Catholic Church ignored 1985 report warning of child sex abuse crisis', NOLA.com.",
"body": "Retrospective reporting anchored to the Gauthe case and its era.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nola.com/news/catholic-church-ignored-1985-report-warning-of-child-sex-abuse-crisis/article_91ac5ee5-ed47-55b9-a6e9-ef72496a8900.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd65e6d8e0ee444f470b428e9fb697c0a52a0393582da5c7a21f02b9a1ffa3c1",
"final_url": "https://www.nola.com/news/catholic-church-ignored-1985-report-warning-of-child-sex-abuse-crisis/article_91ac5ee5-ed47-55b9-a6e9-ef72496a8900.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 485,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-rudolph-kos-dallas-texas-usa",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Dallas, Texas, USA",
"lat": 32.7767,
"lng": -96.797,
"title": "United States: Rudolph Kos sentenced to life after altar boys' testimony of years of abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Dallas diocesan priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious supervision of altar boys",
"diocesan inaction on a 1992 therapist warning"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Dallas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Texas state court, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction and life sentence",
"date": "1998-04-02",
"outcome": "Rudolph Kos was convicted in April 1998 on three counts of aggravated sexual assault and four lesser counts against former altar boys — trial testimony described roughly 1,350 assaults over five years — and sentenced to life plus consecutive terms. A 1997 civil jury had already returned a $120 million verdict against the diocese, whose bishop admitted not reading a 1992 therapist's warning describing Kos as a 'classic textbook pedophile'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Altar boys under a priest's direct religious supervision, kept accessible by a diocese with written warning in hand.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/national/1998/04/02/life-sentence-for-abusive-priest/70e488e2-eaa5-4615-bf87-4b561b605936/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Life Sentence for Abusive Priest', The Washington Post, 2 Apr. 1998.",
"body": "Reports the conviction, testimony, sentence and civil-verdict backdrop.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/national/1998/04/02/life-sentence-for-abusive-priest/70e488e2-eaa5-4615-bf87-4b561b605936/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 486,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The Arizona indictment is excluded from the record's claims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-donald-mcguire-jesuit-state-federal-usa",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Chicago, Illinois, USA",
"lat": 41.8781,
"lng": -87.6298,
"title": "United States: Jesuit spiritual director Donald McGuire convicted in state and federal courts",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Jesuit priest and spiritual director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual direction and retreats used to structure access",
"international travel arranged as religious formation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of Jesus",
"Loyola Academy"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Illinois state court (2006); US federal court (2008–09)",
"stage": "state jury conviction; federal conviction and 25-year sentence",
"date": "2009-01-01",
"outcome": "Donald McGuire, a Jesuit priest and prominent spiritual director, was convicted by an Illinois jury in 2006 on five felonies for abusing two Loyola Academy students in the 1960s, then convicted federally in 2008–09 for molesting a boy during international trips he arranged as spiritual direction, receiving 25 years. Dismissed from the Jesuits in 2007 and laicised in 2008, he died in federal prison in 2017. A separate Arizona indictment's disposition is unconfirmed and is not asserted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "His victims were students and retreatants under his personal spiritual direction — the travel, the retreats and the access were all framed as formation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://abc7chicago.com/archive/6652683/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former priest Father McGuire sentenced to 25 years in molestation case', ABC7 Chicago (2009).",
"body": "Reports the federal sentence atop the 2006 state conviction.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://abc7chicago.com/archive/6652683/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0d5ab8b325d2fb60288bb1811d0e780be41e774c5e5797b0a90f2666308d84b4",
"final_url": "https://abc7chicago.com/archive/6652683/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 487,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1993-james-porter-fall-river-massachusetts-usa",
"year": 1993,
"place": "Fall River, Massachusetts, USA",
"lat": 41.7015,
"lng": -71.155,
"title": "United States: James Porter pleads guilty to 41 counts against 28 children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest in charge of altar boys and parochial-school children"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish and school authority over children of the diocese"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Fall River",
"St Mary's, North Attleboro"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Massachusetts court, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "1993-12-06",
"outcome": "Former priest James Porter pleaded guilty on 6 December 1993 to 41 indictments of sexually assaulting 28 children under sixteen in southeastern Massachusetts in the 1960s — admitting roughly 100 victims across states over three decades — and was sentenced to 18–20 years. He completed the sentence in 2004 and died in 2005 awaiting a civil-commitment hearing. The case prompted early US bishops'-conference policy changes."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parish and parochial-school children under their priest — the pre-Boston case that first forced the pattern into national view.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A20019-2005Feb12.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex-Priest James Porter; Convicted in Child Molestations', The Washington Post (obituary, 2005).",
"body": "Confirms the plea, counts, sentence and history.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A20019-2005Feb12.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 488,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The initial non-custodial sentence and the violation term are both stated plainly — the record does not overstate the punishment.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1986-andrew-andersen-huntington-beach-california-usa",
"year": 1986,
"place": "Huntington Beach, California, USA",
"lat": 33.6595,
"lng": -117.9988,
"title": "United States: Orange diocese associate pastor convicted on 26 counts; initially sentenced to probation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"associate pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral supervision of parish boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Bonaventure, Huntington Beach",
"Diocese of Orange"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California state court, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea; probation, later six years on violation",
"date": "1986-09-30",
"outcome": "Andrew Christian Andersen, associate pastor at St Bonaventure in Huntington Beach, pleaded guilty in 1986 to 26 felony counts of molesting four boys and was sentenced to probation with treatment rather than prison. He continued offending during therapy; after a 1990 New Mexico arrest he received six years for the probation violation. He was laicised in 1996."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parish boys under an associate pastor's supervision; the probation-only initial disposition is itself a documented artifact of the era's handling.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news3/1986_09_30_Ganga_PriestConvicted_Andrew_Andersen_2.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Priest Convicted on 26 Counts of Molesting Church Altar Boys', Los Angeles Times, 30 Sept. 1986 (archived).",
"body": "The contemporaneous LA Times court report of the plea and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news3/1986_09_30_Ganga_PriestConvicted_Andrew_Andersen_2.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c75ece7da1d863af1acff56aa01f9da440461c6d632cbb6b24748af1838b9c38",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news3/1986_09_30_Ganga_PriestConvicted_Andrew_Andersen_2.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 489,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. The pastor's name is withheld in the Malagasy press reporting (a common convention there); the court, sentence, date and facts are cross-confirmed by L'Express de Madagascar and its allAfrica syndication.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-manazary-toby-pastor-miarinarivo-madagascar",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Manazary, Miarinarivo, Madagascar",
"lat": -18.9578,
"lng": 46.9033,
"title": "Madagascar: prayer-house pastor convicted of raping a blind girl sent to him for healing",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor running a 'toby' (prayer and healing house)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed power to restore the girl's sight",
"residential 'treatment' stay that placed her in his custody",
"victim's blindness and dependence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour criminelle ordinaire d'Anosy, Madagascar",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-04-13",
"outcome": "A pastor who ran a toby (prayer/healing house) in Manazary convinced the family of a visually-impaired seventeen-year-old that he could restore her sight, then assaulted her repeatedly during a roughly two-month residential stay for 'treatment'. Detained since June 2025, he was convicted on 13 April 2026 and sentenced to seven years of hard labour."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A disabled girl delivered into a faith healer's custody by her own family, specifically because he claimed spiritual power to cure her — refusal was practically impossible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lexpress.mg/2026/04/proces-un-pasteur-condamne-pour-viol.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Procès — Un pasteur condamné pour viol', L'Express de Madagascar, 14 Apr. 2026.",
"body": "National paper of record reporting the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://fr.allafrica.com/stories/202604140480.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Madagascar: Procès — Un pasteur condamné pour viol', L'Express de Madagascar via allAfrica.",
"body": "Syndicated copy of the same court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lexpress.mg/2026/04/proces-un-pasteur-condamne-pour-viol.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a7e8af792664556f8f2b16c9d1fc3359068ae37c041263759d4b4da6ddb4fa2f",
"final_url": "https://www.lexpress.mg/2026/04/proces-un-pasteur-condamne-pour-viol.html"
},
{
"source": "https://fr.allafrica.com/stories/202604140480.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "65405f39c00089212e167cf72427eba777165da6e341533e2e37617e79056a7b",
"final_url": "https://fr.allafrica.com/stories/202604140480.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 490,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2026-06-16",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Reported by two independent legal-news outlets from the High Court judgment.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-rashid-noorul-hidaya-madrasa-thrissur-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Mullassery, Thrissur, Kerala, India",
"lat": 10.5333,
"lng": 76.0833,
"title": "India: madrasa teacher's 20-year POCSO sentence upheld by the Kerala High Court",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"usthad (teacher) at Noorul Hidaya Madrassa"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-school teacher's authority over a nine-year-old student who came to his room for exam help"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Noorul Hidaya Madrassa, Mullassery"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "POCSO Court, Kunnamkulam; Kerala High Court",
"stage": "conviction; appeal dismissed",
"date": "2026-06-16",
"outcome": "An usthad at the Noorul Hidaya Madrassa was convicted of aggravated sexual assault of a nine-year-old student who came to his room for help with an online exam during the COVID lockdown, and sentenced to twenty years' rigorous imprisonment under POCSO. On 16 June 2026 the Kerala High Court dismissed his appeal, rejecting a defence claim that the case was a Sunni–Mujahid sectarian frame-up and holding the child's testimony sufficient."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A madrasa student alone with her religious teacher — the standard adult-in-charge access that the school's structure created.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/kerala-high-court/kerala-high-court-pocso-juvenile-justice-madrassa-teacher-538028",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kerala High Court Upholds POCSO Conviction Of Madrassa Usthad', LiveLaw, 17 Jun. 2026.",
"body": "Legal-news report of the High Court judgment.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.barandbench.com/news/kerala-high-court-upholds-conviction-of-madrasa-teacher-for-sexually-assaulting-9-year-old-boy",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kerala High Court upholds conviction of madrasa teacher', Bar & Bench.",
"body": "Independent legal-news corroboration.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2026-06-16",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/kerala-high-court/kerala-high-court-pocso-juvenile-justice-madrassa-teacher-538028",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "efa662125f7430fa695b61a946adf6fc41149fd33eb42bffeef231ca27ffef28",
"final_url": "https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/kerala-high-court/kerala-high-court-pocso-juvenile-justice-madrassa-teacher-538028"
},
{
"source": "https://www.barandbench.com/news/kerala-high-court-upholds-conviction-of-madrasa-teacher-for-sexually-assaulting-9-year-old-boy",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "253b3e22752ddd7519d1aeeead4806e55c08b91a331b33cd7ef0d38ec98ee5a6",
"final_url": "https://www.barandbench.com/news/kerala-high-court-upholds-conviction-of-madrasa-teacher-for-sexually-assaulting-9-year-old-boy"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 491,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Trial-court stage; no appeal located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-syed-nadeem-madrasa-hyderabad-india",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Shaheen Nagar, Hyderabad, Telangana, India",
"lat": 17.32,
"lng": 78.52,
"title": "India: Hyderabad madrasa teacher sentenced to 20 years under POCSO",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teacher at Madrasa Jamia Noorul Anwar"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teacher's authority over a regular madrasa student",
"death threats to enforce silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Madrasa Jamia Noorul Anwar, Shaheen Nagar"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special Court for Rape & POCSO Cases, Hyderabad, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"outcome": "Syed Nadeem, a teacher at the Madrasa Jamia Noorul Anwar, took an eleven-year-old student to his house and sodomised him, threatening to kill him if he told anyone. The special POCSO court convicted him and sentenced him to twenty years' rigorous imprisonment plus a fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boy was a regular student of the defendant's madrasa, under his religious-teaching authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.deccanchronicle.com/southern-states/telangana/hyderabad-madrasa-teacher-convicted-to-20-years-rigorous-imprisonment-in-pocso-case-1968054",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Hyderabad: Madrasa Teacher Convicted To 20 Years Imprisonment In POCSO Case', Deccan Chronicle.",
"body": "Court report of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://thefederal.com/category/states/south/telangana/madrasa-teacher-gets-20-yr-jail-term-for-sexually-assaulting-minor-boy-248869",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Madrasa teacher gets 20-year jail term', The Federal.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.deccanchronicle.com/southern-states/telangana/hyderabad-madrasa-teacher-convicted-to-20-years-rigorous-imprisonment-in-pocso-case-1968054",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://thefederal.com/category/states/south/telangana/madrasa-teacher-gets-20-yr-jail-term-for-sexually-assaulting-minor-boy-248869",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fc4b8a3e3d7bb288049c381ef6604862c4d825a8ddb62e7b845194f8b00162b4",
"final_url": "https://thefederal.com/category/states/south/telangana/madrasa-teacher-gets-20-yr-jail-term-for-sexually-assaulting-minor-boy-248869"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 492,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Kerala press withholds the defendant's name in the available reporting; the court, sentence and repeat-offender status are as reported by Onmanorama (Malayala Manorama's English edition). Trial-court stage.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-taliparamba-madrasa-teacher-kannur-india",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Taliparamba, Kannur, Kerala, India",
"lat": 12.0367,
"lng": 75.361,
"title": "India: repeat-offender madrasa teacher sentenced to 187 years for assaulting a student",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"madrasa teacher, previously convicted under POCSO"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teacher access to the same student over nearly two years"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fast-track special court (POCSO), Kerala, India",
"stage": "conviction and cumulative sentence",
"date": "2025-04-08",
"outcome": "A madrasa teacher in Taliparamba — a repeat offender with a prior POCSO conviction — was sentenced to a cumulative 187 years' imprisonment for sexually assaulting a minor student over a period of nearly two years spanning the COVID lockdown."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A student under the same religious teacher's authority for years, including a period when the madrasa's structure was the only supervised contact.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.onmanorama.com/news/kerala/2025/04/08/madrasa-teacher-repeat-offender-gets-187-years-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-minor-student.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Madrasa teacher, a repeat offender, gets 187 years in prison', Onmanorama, 8 Apr. 2025.",
"body": "Court report of the cumulative sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.onmanorama.com/news/kerala/2025/04/08/madrasa-teacher-repeat-offender-gets-187-years-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-minor-student.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c0eb57a938afe55b8818bee6df59ac9646b0f0522de278c22e1487779a962a45",
"final_url": "https://www.onmanorama.com/news/kerala/2025/04/08/madrasa-teacher-repeat-offender-gets-187-years-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-minor-student.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 493,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Reporting variously counts 60 to over 100 victims from the recovered footage; the record asserts only the conviction and the recovered-clip count.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-baba-amarpuri-jalebi-baba-tohana-india",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Tohana, Fatehabad, Haryana, India",
"lat": 29.7124,
"lng": 75.9042,
"title": "India: 'Jalebi Baba', temple mahant, convicted of drugging, raping and filming scores of women devotees",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled godman and mahant (chief priest) of the Baba Balak Nath temple, Tohana"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"devotees' resort to him for blessings and cures",
"drugged prasad/food",
"filmed assaults used for blackmail to compel silence and repeat compliance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Baba Balak Nath Mandir, Tohana"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fast-track special court, Fatehabad, Haryana, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-01-10",
"outcome": "Baba Amarpuri, known as 'Jalebi Baba', mahant of the Baba Balak Nath temple in Tohana, was convicted on 5 January 2023 of rape, extortion and offences under the IT, NDPS and Arms Acts, for drugging and raping women who came to him as devotees seeking blessings and cures — police recovered some 120 video clips he filmed and used for blackmail. He was sentenced on 10 January 2023 to fourteen years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Every victim reached him as a devotee of his temple seeking spiritual help; the blackmail machine ran on that same authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/who-is-godman-jalebi-baba-convicted-for-raping-up-to-120-women-and-sentenced-to-14-years-in-jail-news-252768",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Who Is Godman Jalebi Baba, Convicted For Raping Up To 120 Women', Outlook India, 11 Jan. 2023.",
"body": "National-magazine report of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://theprint.in/india/governance/this-ordinary-tohana-temple-is-where-baba-amarpuri-allegedly-raped-and-filmed-60-women/87124/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'This ordinary Tohana temple is where Baba Amarpuri allegedly raped and filmed 60 women', ThePrint.",
"body": "Investigative reporting on the temple and the case.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/who-is-godman-jalebi-baba-convicted-for-raping-up-to-120-women-and-sentenced-to-14-years-in-jail-news-252768",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d82d9018e0d807fe016569252479ce4eeb2dbf35abc169c9099c274f017ca7d7",
"final_url": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/who-is-godman-jalebi-baba-convicted-for-raping-up-to-120-women-and-sentenced-to-14-years-in-jail-news-252768"
},
{
"source": "https://theprint.in/india/governance/this-ordinary-tohana-temple-is-where-baba-amarpuri-allegedly-raped-and-filmed-60-women/87124/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d245a73d0e7fe59645f29ac2e666f6001603c65c032e18538745a9d852897e55",
"final_url": "https://theprint.in/india/governance/this-ordinary-tohana-temple-is-where-baba-amarpuri-allegedly-raped-and-filmed-60-women/87124/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 494,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "",
"note": "Upheld without modification (Jail Crl. Appeal No. 60/2019, Orissa HC)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The High Court appeal number is cited; the precise appellate decision date within the docket was not pinned and is flagged as a gap.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-madhusudan-das-tarini-baba-odisha-india",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Odisha, India",
"lat": 20.2961,
"lng": 85.8245,
"title": "India: 'Tarini Baba', a tantrik, convicted of abducting, raping and trafficking a girl whose family trusted his rituals",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled tantrik and spiritual practitioner trusted by the victim's family"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual performances that won the family's trust and access to the household",
"abduction and interstate transport of the girl"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Odisha trial court; Orissa High Court (Jail Criminal Appeal No. 60 of 2019)",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal",
"date": "2019-01-01",
"outcome": "Madhusudan Das, styling himself 'Tarini Baba', won a family's trust through rituals and claimed paranormal powers, then abducted their sixteen-to-seventeen-year-old daughter, transported her across three states, raped her repeatedly and sold her. He was convicted under IPC sections 366, 376(2)(n), 370-A and 506, drawing concurrent terms of up to ten years' rigorous imprisonment, and the Orissa High Court upheld the conviction without modification in Jail Criminal Appeal No. 60 of 2019."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The tantrik's ritual authority over the household is what opened the door: the family trusted him as a spiritual guide, and that trust delivered their daughter into his control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://thelegalaffair.com/news/orissa-high-court-upholds-conviction-of-tantrik-in-rape-and-trafficking-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Orissa High Court Upholds Conviction of Tantrik in Rape and Trafficking Case' (Madhusudan Das v. State of Odisha, Jail Crl. Appeal No. 60/2019).",
"body": "Legal-news summary of the High Court judgment, with statute-level detail.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "",
"note": "Upheld without modification (Jail Crl. Appeal No. 60/2019, Orissa HC)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://thelegalaffair.com/news/orissa-high-court-upholds-conviction-of-tantrik-in-rape-and-trafficking-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2de077f8f8f18c4ec3aa38d2e9a889a3f1e9c201317369df63ce79defbf95083",
"final_url": "https://thelegalaffair.com/news/orissa-high-court-upholds-conviction-of-tantrik-in-rape-and-trafficking-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 495,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Much recent coverage of the 2024 verdict comes from partisan outlets; this record rests on SCC Times (an Indian legal publisher) and the Deccan Herald, both neutral. The blackmail mechanism dominated the scheme's later stages; the custodians' religious standing is documented as what created the initial access and the impunity.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-ajmer-dargah-khadims-1992-case-india",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ajmer, Rajasthan, India",
"lat": 26.4499,
"lng": 74.6399,
"title": "India: six convicted in the 1992 Ajmer dargah blackmail-rape case — 32 years on",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"hereditary khadims (custodians) of the Ajmer Sharif Dargah among the perpetrator network"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"social and religious standing of hereditary shrine custodians",
"photographic blackmail compelling repeated compliance and recruitment of further victims"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Ajmer Sharif Dargah (khadim families)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special POCSO court, Ajmer, Rajasthan, India",
"stage": "conviction and life sentences (final tranche of a decades-long prosecution)",
"date": "2024-08-20",
"outcome": "On 20 August 2024, thirty-two years after the offences, a special POCSO court convicted six men — Nafees Chishti, Naseem alias Tarzan, Salim Chishti, Iqbal Bhati, Sohail Ghani and Syed Zameer Hussain — and sentenced each to life imprisonment with ₹5 lakh fines, for the 1989–92 Ajmer scheme in which men including hereditary khadims of the Ajmer Sharif Dargah lured, gang-raped and photographed schoolgirls aged roughly eleven to twenty, using the photographs to blackmail victims into repeated compliance. Earlier tranches of the case produced other convictions across three decades; about six victims are reported to have taken their own lives."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The perpetrators' standing as hereditary custodians of one of South Asia's most revered Sufi shrines supplied the social untouchability and the initial trust that made the scheme work — and made victims' families unwilling to accuse them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2024/08/20/1992-ajmer-sex-scandal-pocso-court-jaipur-convicts-6-accused-to-life-imprisonment-after-32-years-scc-times/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'1992 Ajmer Sex Scandal: POCSO Court convicts 6 accused to life imprisonment after 32 Years', SCC Times, 20 Aug. 2024.",
"body": "Legal-publisher report of the verdict and sentences.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.deccanherald.com/india/rajasthan/1992-ajmer-rapes-pocso-court-sentences-6-to-life-imprisonment-3157154",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ajmer gangrape victims get justice 32 years later as 6 get life imprisonment', Deccan Herald, 20 Aug. 2024.",
"body": "National-newspaper corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2024/08/20/1992-ajmer-sex-scandal-pocso-court-jaipur-convicts-6-accused-to-life-imprisonment-after-32-years-scc-times/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1a219e71cff41d00731e67b7dd2b3d6cc262e8ddcb4261aa3158ba910a5e4858",
"final_url": "https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2024/08/20/1992-ajmer-sex-scandal-pocso-court-jaipur-convicts-6-accused-to-life-imprisonment-after-32-years-scc-times/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.deccanherald.com/india/rajasthan/1992-ajmer-rapes-pocso-court-sentences-6-to-life-imprisonment-3157154",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9cd9c1986744753b771b2b3a835706f034e58ee335dec12dcfbf75e8a3ec3f5",
"final_url": "https://www.deccanherald.com/india/rajasthan/1992-ajmer-rapes-pocso-court-sentences-6-to-life-imprisonment-3157154"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 496,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Two independent national outlets report both convictions; appeal status not located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-sanil-k-james-salvation-army-thrissur-india",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Peechi, Thrissur, Kerala, India",
"lat": 10.525,
"lng": 76.335,
"title": "India: Salvation Army pastor convicted twice — 40 years, then life until death",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the Salvation Army church at Peechi"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral relationships with the victims' families that gave him private access to their children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Salvation Army Church, Peechi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "POCSO special courts, Thrissur, Kerala, India",
"stage": "two separate convictions",
"date": "2016-03-01",
"outcome": "Sanil K. James, pastor of the Salvation Army church at Peechi, cultivated close relationships with his congregants' families and used the access to rape their children. In March 2016 he was convicted of raping a twelve-year-old (offence December 2013) and given two concurrent twenty-year terms — effectively forty years; in a second case he was convicted of repeatedly raping a thirteen-year-old since 2013 and sentenced to life imprisonment until death."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were congregants' daughters; the pastor's standing with their families is precisely what put him alone with them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/already-sentenced-40-years-kerala-pastor-gets-life-until-death-second-child-rape-case-61907",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Already sentenced to 40 years, Kerala pastor gets life until death in second child rape case', The News Minute.",
"body": "Reports both convictions and sentences.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thequint.com/voices/fighting-rape/kerala-pastor-serves-life-until-death-child-rape",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kerala Pastor Gets Life Term Until Death for Second Child Rape', The Quint.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/already-sentenced-40-years-kerala-pastor-gets-life-until-death-second-child-rape-case-61907",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9de9f81fc8f7d4da621e557985635411138f840bff7e90e51b40c5687dc3a5e",
"final_url": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/already-sentenced-40-years-kerala-pastor-gets-life-until-death-second-child-rape-case-61907"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thequint.com/voices/fighting-rape/kerala-pastor-serves-life-until-death-child-rape",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9cdc562752373eb8690226f4587a84d62f8f89f5b0cc11e8bef9b5da669ed033",
"final_url": "https://www.thequint.com/gender/kerala-pastor-serves-life-until-death-child-rape"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 497,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The defendant is named per PTI wire and ground reporting; trial-court stage.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-delhi-temple-priest-two-girls-india",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Satbari, South Delhi, India",
"lat": 28.6139,
"lng": 77.209,
"title": "India: Delhi temple priest given life imprisonment for raping two young girls",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"temple priest with a routine care role over children at the temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priest's charge over children spending time at the temple"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Additional Sessions Court (POCSO), Delhi, India",
"stage": "conviction and life sentence",
"date": "2021-08-06",
"outcome": "Vishwa Bandhu, 76, priest of a temple at Satbari village in South Delhi, was convicted of repeatedly raping two girls aged seven and nine over about a week in August 2014 at the temple where they were in his care. On 6 August 2021 Additional Sessions Judge Vijeta Singh Rawat sentenced him to life imprisonment and awarded ₹7.5 lakh compensation, observing that he had 'desecrated the temple where children should have had a safe time'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's own words state the nexus: children at the temple, under its priest, in what should have been the safest room in their world.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/delhi-court-life-imprisonment-priest-minor-rape-compensation-179020",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Desecrated The Temple Where Children Should Have Had A Safe Time': Delhi Court Sentences Priest To Life Imprisonment', LiveLaw, 6 Aug. 2021.",
"body": "Legal-news report of the sentencing.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://outlookindia.com/newsscroll/delhi-court-sentences-priest-to-life-imprisonment-for-raping-two-minor-girls/2136531",
"archive": "",
"citation": "PTI via Outlook: 'Delhi court sentences priest to life imprisonment for raping two minor girls'.",
"body": "Wire report naming the defendant and confirming sentence.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.newslaundry.com/2021/08/18/they-made-a-big-deal-out-of-nothing-delhi-village-comes-to-terms-with-temple-priests-rape-conviction",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newslaundry ground report from Satbari, 18 Aug. 2021.",
"body": "Independent ground reporting from the village.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/delhi-court-life-imprisonment-priest-minor-rape-compensation-179020",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5ee0cc6f7139bc5ba5892d32de0a9e946674885d3be82043d07bb66868d9f6fc",
"final_url": "https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/delhi-court-life-imprisonment-priest-minor-rape-compensation-179020"
},
{
"source": "https://outlookindia.com/newsscroll/delhi-court-sentences-priest-to-life-imprisonment-for-raping-two-minor-girls/2136531",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4dbe53204727189cc0b70c74b9fd1ad081fb7b166af0910d4ad762eb75be79a5",
"final_url": "https://www.outlookindia.com/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.newslaundry.com/2021/08/18/they-made-a-big-deal-out-of-nothing-delhi-village-comes-to-terms-with-temple-priests-rape-conviction",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "170a268ae7f737a685c4f19fbbce82c63b89143dbb0618a4161838d785aadc3c",
"final_url": "https://www.newslaundry.com/2021/08/18/they-made-a-big-deal-out-of-nothing-delhi-village-comes-to-terms-with-temple-priests-rape-conviction"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 498,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-jack-schaap-first-baptist-hammond-indiana-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Hammond, Indiana, USA",
"lat": 41.5834,
"lng": -87.5,
"title": "United States: Jack Schaap, megachurch IFB pastor, sentenced federally for abusing a girl he was 'counseling'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior pastor of First Baptist Church of Hammond and superintendent of its schools"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"one-on-one pastoral 'counseling' of a sixteen-year-old congregant flagged as vulnerable by his own school administrator",
"transport across state lines for the abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"First Baptist Church of Hammond",
"Hyles-Anderson (IFB network)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "US District Court, Northern District of Indiana",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2013-03-20",
"outcome": "Jack Schaap, senior pastor of First Baptist Church of Hammond — one of the largest Independent Fundamental Baptist congregations in the country — pleaded guilty in September 2012 to transporting a sixteen-year-old congregant across state lines for sexual conduct, having taken over her personal 'counseling' after she was flagged to him as vulnerable. In March 2013 he was sentenced to 144 months in federal prison plus five years' supervised release; later sentence-reduction motions were denied."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The girl was a congregant delivered into her senior pastor's one-on-one spiritual counseling — the office itself created the access and the unrefusability.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndin/pr/former-baptist-minister-sentenced-12-years-imprisonment",
"archive": "",
"citation": "US Attorney's Office, N.D. Indiana, sentencing release.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own statement of the plea and sentence.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://nwitimes.com/news/local/lake/hammond/schaap-sentenced-to-12-years-for-sexual-relationship-with-teen-parishioner/article_c7aa6a30-5a5a-567a-ae02-1e8664b4a4ae.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Schaap sentenced to 12 years', The Times of Northwest Indiana, 2013.",
"body": "Regional paper of record's court reporting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndin/pr/former-baptist-minister-sentenced-12-years-imprisonment",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9b1b89f6dfdf1b1d2044776ef01629d9d65a8f4d904b5a4b04de032efd0b6c18",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndin/pr/former-baptist-minister-sentenced-12-years-imprisonment"
},
{
"source": "https://nwitimes.com/news/local/lake/hammond/schaap-sentenced-to-12-years-for-sexual-relationship-with-teen-parishioner/article_c7aa6a30-5a5a-567a-ae02-1e8664b4a4ae.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e67280a0047b9e4ff7e35e8edccf81f8378d63299740c95216ee7979b27bdba4",
"final_url": "https://nwitimes.com/news/local/lake/hammond/schaap-sentenced-to-12-years-for-sexual-relationship-with-teen-parishioner/article_c7aa6a30-5a5a-567a-ae02-1e8664b4a4ae.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 499,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2005-05-10",
"note": "Affirmed (Allen v. State, 273 Ga. App. 227)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-arthur-allen-house-of-prayer-atlanta-usa",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Atlanta, Georgia, USA",
"lat": 33.749,
"lng": -84.388,
"title": "United States: House of Prayer pastor convicted — affirmed on appeal — for church-ordered whippings of children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the House of Prayer, who ordered congregational discipline"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"beatings ordered from the pulpit as church discipline and administered by congregants",
"children held aloft before the congregation during whippings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"House of Prayer, Atlanta"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fulton County Superior Court; Georgia Court of Appeals (Allen v. State, 273 Ga. App. 227)",
"stage": "conviction; affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2002-10-17",
"outcome": "Arthur Allen Jr., pastor of Atlanta's House of Prayer, and four congregants were convicted in October 2002 of cruelty to children and aggravated assault for church-ordered belt whippings of two boys aged seven and ten, held aloft before the congregation while they were beaten. Allen received 90 days' jail, ten years' probation and a fine; the Georgia Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions on 10 May 2005. Allen and six members had previously been convicted in 1993 over the church beating of a sixteen-year-old girl."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The beatings were ordered by the pastor as an act of congregational discipline and carried out by the congregation — the victims were members' children inside that disciplinary system.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ga-court-of-appeals/1448097.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Allen v. State, 273 Ga. App. 227 (Ga. Ct. App. 2005).",
"body": "The appellate opinion affirming the convictions.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.upi.com/Top_News/2002/10/17/Georgia-pastor-convicted-of-child-abuse/26701034886676/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Georgia pastor convicted of child abuse', UPI, 17 Oct. 2002.",
"body": "Wire-service report of the verdict.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeals",
"date": "2005-05-10",
"note": "Affirmed (Allen v. State, 273 Ga. App. 227)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ga-court-of-appeals/1448097.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "901972c7f10cb30c9401af7baa352038f009bbf67b28dde5c62599d5638440df",
"final_url": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ga-court-of-appeals/1448097.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.upi.com/Top_News/2002/10/17/Georgia-pastor-convicted-of-child-abuse/26701034886676/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "39c660f2ef7d7ad7e2c7638e14b6433e370dccc2f772ca8d8f61c5a632a8488b",
"final_url": "https://www.upi.com/Top_News/2002/10/17/Georgia-pastor-convicted-of-child-abuse/26701034886676/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 500,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The adult victims are named as they are named throughout the public court record and national reporting; the child witness is not identified beyond age.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1997-aaron-lebaron-4-oclock-murders-texas-usa",
"year": 1997,
"place": "Houston, Texas, USA",
"lat": 29.7604,
"lng": -95.3698,
"title": "United States: Church of the Lamb of God successor convicted of ordering the murder of sect defectors",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader of the Church of the Lamb of God (Ervil LeBaron's polygamist sect) after LeBaron's death"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"Ervil LeBaron's 'blood atonement' hit-list doctrine marking defectors for death",
"followers dispatched as killers under doctrinal command"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of the Lamb of God (LeBaron group)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "US District Court, Southern District of Texas",
"stage": "conviction and 45-year sentence",
"date": "1997-02-01",
"outcome": "Aaron LeBaron, who assumed leadership of his father Ervil LeBaron's Church of the Lamb of God, was convicted in February 1997 of orchestrating the 1988 'four o'clock murders': the simultaneous killings of three sect defectors — Ed Marston, Mark Chynoweth and Duane Chynoweth — and an eight-year-old child who witnessed one of them, carried out by followers under the sect's 'blood atonement' hit-list doctrine. He was sentenced in June 1997 to 45 years, the maximum available."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were former members marked for death by the doctrine they had been subject to — apostates executed under the sect's blood-atonement teaching, by believers acting on its authority. (Ervil LeBaron's own 1980 conviction, for ordering the murder of a rival sect's leader, is excluded from this corpus as outsider-directed.)",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/national/1997/03/02/cult-leader-convicted/5582e545-4b89-4985-8c77-801b33248ddb/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cult Leader Convicted', The Washington Post, 2 Mar. 1997.",
"body": "National court reporting of the conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.deseret.com/1997/6/13/19317679/lebaron-gets-45-year-sentence/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'LeBaron gets 45-year sentence', Deseret News, 13 Jun. 1997.",
"body": "Sentencing report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/national/1997/03/02/cult-leader-convicted/5582e545-4b89-4985-8c77-801b33248ddb/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.deseret.com/1997/6/13/19317679/lebaron-gets-45-year-sentence/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0299b2031b42c984fa41ff3cc5761926fab9a04ebe76898adf6c21007f677a58",
"final_url": "https://www.deseret.com/1997/6/13/19317679/lebaron-gets-45-year-sentence/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 501,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2017",
"note": "Sentence reduced 30 → 24 years; conviction stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-victor-barnard-river-road-fellowship-minnesota-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Pine County, Minnesota, USA",
"lat": 45.826,
"lng": -92.968,
"title": "United States: Victor Barnard convicted for abusing girls ceremonially surrendered to him as 'Maidens'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader of the River Road Fellowship, styling himself a Christ figure"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"'Maidens Group' — firstborn daughters ceremonially surrendered to him by follower parents",
"total doctrinal authority over the camp where the girls lived"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"River Road Fellowship"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pine County District Court, Minnesota, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea; sentence reduced on appeal (conviction stands)",
"date": "2016-10-01",
"outcome": "Victor Barnard, leader of the River Road Fellowship, ran a 'Maidens Group' of firstborn daughters ceremonially surrendered to him by their parents as a religious offering; he was extradited from Brazil in 2015 and pleaded guilty in October 2016 to criminal sexual conduct against two of the girls, receiving 30 years — reduced to 24 on appeal in 2017, with the conviction itself undisturbed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Follower parents handed their daughters to the man they believed spoke as Christ — the surrender ceremony is the authority nexus in its purest documented form.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.startribune.com/fugitive-preacher-victor-barnard-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-assault-will-serve-30-years/396680501",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Fugitive preacher Victor Barnard pleads guilty', Star Tribune, 2016.",
"body": "Court reporting of the plea and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.startribune.com/cult-leader-s-prison-sentence-ordered-reduced-by-six-years/458879103",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cult leader's prison sentence ordered reduced by six years', Star Tribune, 2017.",
"body": "Appellate outcome.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2017",
"note": "Sentence reduced 30 → 24 years; conviction stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.startribune.com/fugitive-preacher-victor-barnard-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-assault-will-serve-30-years/396680501",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.startribune.com/cult-leader-s-prison-sentence-ordered-reduced-by-six-years/458879103",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 502,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Lucas Leonard is named as the case is universally reported under his name; his surviving brother is named in the public record as the second victim. The parents' convictions sit inside the church-discipline structure, not apart from it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-word-of-life-lucas-leonard-new-hartford-ny-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "New Hartford, New York, USA",
"lat": 43.0734,
"lng": -75.2879,
"title": "United States: Word of Life pastor and members convicted after a teenager was beaten to death in an all-night 'counseling session'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor Tiffanie Irwin, who ran the 'spiritual counseling session'",
"congregation members administering the beating"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"closed congregation's disciplinary session over a member attempting to leave",
"roughly fourteen hours of beating framed as spiritual counseling"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Word of Life Christian Church, Chadwicks/New Hartford"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Oneida County Court, New York, USA",
"stage": "guilty pleas and a trial conviction across the participant set",
"date": "2016-07-01",
"outcome": "After nineteen-year-old Lucas Leonard said he wanted to leave the Word of Life Christian Church, pastor Tiffanie Irwin presided over an all-night 'spiritual counseling session' in which he was beaten for roughly fourteen hours and died; his seventeen-year-old brother Christopher was severely injured. Irwin pleaded guilty to manslaughter and assault (12 years; paroled September 2025); Sarah Ferguson was convicted at trial in July 2016 of manslaughter and assault (25 years); the brothers' parents pleaded guilty to felony assault (10 and 5 years); other participants were also convicted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A closed congregation's pastor ordered and presided over the fatal discipline of a member for attempted apostasy — the church session was the murder weapon's frame.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/parents-of-teen-fatally-beaten-by-church-group-sentenced/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Parents of teen fatally beaten by church group sentenced', CBS News.",
"body": "National reporting of the conviction set.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/news/2025/09/04/ex-pastor-convicted-of-manslaughter-at-word-of-life-church-released-on-parole",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex-pastor convicted of manslaughter at Word of Life church released on parole', Spectrum News, 4 Sep. 2025.",
"body": "Confirms Irwin's manslaughter conviction, sentence and 2025 parole.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-update"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/parents-of-teen-fatally-beaten-by-church-group-sentenced/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5c2d5ca29953fc4d4d48189ec70db537b85ea0166102dabba709a4c1bb5c16f9",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/parents-of-teen-fatally-beaten-by-church-group-sentenced/"
},
{
"source": "https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/news/2025/09/04/ex-pastor-convicted-of-manslaughter-at-word-of-life-church-released-on-parole",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-update.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9c1f3071327794c6d6143814264925722e5af27bbe02acbd9dbff53bf91fc676",
"final_url": "https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/news/2025/09/04/ex-pastor-convicted-of-manslaughter-at-word-of-life-church-released-on-parole"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 503,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The 1993 AP wire report is cited via an archival copy; the Santa Fe New Mexican independently restates the conviction, sentence and death in prison.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1993-david-holley-alamogordo-new-mexico-usa",
"year": 1993,
"place": "Alamogordo, New Mexico, USA",
"lat": 32.8995,
"lng": -105.9603,
"title": "United States: David Holley sentenced to 275 years for abusing boys across two dioceses",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, transferred between Massachusetts and New Mexico assignments"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access to boys across successive assignments despite known offending"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Worcester",
"Servants of the Paraclete, Jemez Springs"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Otero County District Court, New Mexico, USA",
"stage": "no-contest plea and sentence",
"date": "1993-06-05",
"outcome": "David Holley, a priest sent to New Mexico after abuse complaints in Massachusetts, pleaded no contest to felony sex charges involving eight boys (offences 1972–74) and was sentenced in June 1993 to 275 years — at the time among the longest sentences ever imposed on a priest. He died in prison on 25 November 2008."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parish boys under a priest whose access was renewed by transfer after each complaint — the treatment-and-reassignment pipeline is part of the documented harm.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/1993_06_05_Montes_FormerPriest_David_Holley_10.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Eduardo Montes, 'Former Priest Gets 275 Years for Molesting Boys', Associated Press, 5 Jun. 1993 (archived copy).",
"body": "Contemporaneous wire report of the plea and sentence.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/survivor-of-pedophile-priest-loses-round-in-court/article_83ab4298-1f5a-11ee-a19d-ff72bf8bd827.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Santa Fe New Mexican, Jul. 2023.",
"body": "Independent restatement of the conviction, sentence and death in custody.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/1993_06_05_Montes_FormerPriest_David_Holley_10.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ae53c086c2841262f54e01f0ddb36effa9009a14e38f2bb1912100165dd5c164",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news13/1993_06_05_Montes_FormerPriest_David_Holley_10.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/survivor-of-pedophile-priest-loses-round-in-court/article_83ab4298-1f5a-11ee-a19d-ff72bf8bd827.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fddf4a02a5259f5aafe53a95cc9b612159e066068dbc7dc804aff39ce4fbd4a5",
"final_url": "https://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/local_news/survivor-of-pedophile-priest-loses-round-in-court/article_83ab4298-1f5a-11ee-a19d-ff72bf8bd827.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 504,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. Recorded with unusual care: Avery's 2013 sworn recantation is part of the record, and every related Philadelphia conviction resting on the same accuser was later reversed, vacated or reduced (Engelhardt died pre-finality; Shero vacated; Lynn's felony never finally stood). Avery's plea alone was never disturbed, and this record asserts no more than that.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-edward-avery-archdiocese-philadelphia-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 39.9526,
"lng": -75.1652,
"title": "United States: Edward Avery's guilty plea — the one Philadelphia conviction that stands",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish and sacristy access to an altar boy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Philadelphia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea; conviction never disturbed",
"date": "2012-03-22",
"outcome": "Edward Avery, a defrocked Philadelphia priest, pleaded guilty on 22 March 2012 — days before the archdiocese's landmark trial — to involuntary deviate sexual intercourse with an altar boy and conspiracy to endanger a child, receiving two-and-a-half to five years. In January 2013, called as a prosecution witness, he recanted under oath, saying he had pleaded to avoid dying in prison. He served his term; no court has vacated the plea."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "An altar boy under parish clergy — the same nexus as the rest of the Philadelphia case set.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.inquirer.com/philly/news/homepage/20120323_Defrocked_Phila__priest_pleads_guilty_to_sex_abuse_just_before_trial_is_to_start.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Defrocked Phila. priest pleads guilty to sex abuse just before trial', Philadelphia Inquirer, 23 Mar. 2012.",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of the plea.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.inquirer.com/news/william-lynn-philadelphia-archdiocese-retrial-billy-doe-testimony-20200219.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Philadelphia Inquirer retrial coverage, 19 Feb. 2020.",
"body": "Later coverage confirming the plea's status and the recantation context.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-update"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.inquirer.com/philly/news/homepage/20120323_Defrocked_Phila__priest_pleads_guilty_to_sex_abuse_just_before_trial_is_to_start.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0c365bb4d21d70ba890b7d5b56690e4efed036bb9f2a959100089cfdad799a94",
"final_url": "https://www.inquirer.com/philly/news/homepage/20120323_Defrocked_Phila__priest_pleads_guilty_to_sex_abuse_just_before_trial_is_to_start.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.inquirer.com/news/william-lynn-philadelphia-archdiocese-retrial-billy-doe-testimony-20200219.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-update.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a99b742df97e0926e8edf44e933e12624f5b2a2e0c4745570aa613f13d52be99",
"final_url": "https://www.inquirer.com/news/william-lynn-philadelphia-archdiocese-retrial-billy-doe-testimony-20200219.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 505,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The largely-suspended sentence is stated plainly. Corroborated by Senegal's national press agency and two independent outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-ibrahima-dieng-daara-diourbel-senegal",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Diourbel, Senegal",
"lat": 14.6597,
"lng": -16.2317,
"title": "Senegal: Quranic teacher convicted for chaining talibé children in his daara",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"maître coranique running a residential daara"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"families' placement of boys in his residential religious care",
"chaining presented as discipline against escape"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de grande instance de Diourbel, Senegal",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-01-21",
"outcome": "Ibrahima Dieng, a maître coranique, admitted chaining talibé boys resident in his Diourbel daara; on 21 January 2021 he was convicted of violence and mistreatment of the children and sentenced to two years, fifteen days of it firm."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys placed by their families in a religious teacher's total residential care — the chaining was an exercise of exactly that unchecked custody.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aps.sn/actualites/societe/justice/article/bk-sur-ce-texte-ibrahima-dieng-condamne-a-deux-ans-dont-15-jours-fermes",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Diourbel : un maître coranique condamné à deux ans de prison dont 15 jours ferme', Agence de Presse Sénégalaise.",
"body": "The national press agency's court report.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.senenews.com/actualites/affaire-des-talibes-enchaines-a-diourbel-la-sentence-est-tombee-pour-le-maitre-coranique-ibrahima-dieng_346037.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Affaire des talibés enchaînés à Diourbel : la sentence est tombée', SeneNews, 21 Jan. 2021.",
"body": "Independent verdict-day coverage.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aps.sn/actualites/societe/justice/article/bk-sur-ce-texte-ibrahima-dieng-condamne-a-deux-ans-dont-15-jours-fermes",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.senenews.com/actualites/affaire-des-talibes-enchaines-a-diourbel-la-sentence-est-tombee-pour-le-maitre-coranique-ibrahima-dieng_346037.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b7cf0d15ab30d263fdd3206260338db069d0d71da26733ef04a115ddc07423a9",
"final_url": "https://www.senenews.com/actualites/affaire-des-talibes-enchaines-a-diourbel-la-sentence-est-tombee-pour-le-maitre-coranique-ibrahima-dieng_346037.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 506,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The conviction is for sexual harassment under POCSO; the specific section is not enumerated in available reporting and is not asserted. Original reporting by ETV Bharat, cited via a credited archival repost.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-selvaraj-church-vadakkankulam-tirunelveli-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Vadakkankulam, Tirunelveli, Tamil Nadu, India",
"lat": 8.254,
"lng": 77.557,
"title": "India: Tamil Nadu church priest sentenced under POCSO for assaulting a seven-year-old visitor",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of a church at Vadakkankulam"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priest's standing over a child brought to the church by her parents for prayers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District POCSO special court, Tirunelveli, Tamil Nadu, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-11",
"outcome": "Selvaraj, 59, priest of a church at Vadakkankulam, sexually harassed a seven-year-old girl who visited the church with her parents for prayers in February 2020. On 11 June 2026 the Tirunelveli district POCSO special court (Judge Suresh Kumar) sentenced him to seven years plus a fine and ₹1 lakh victim compensation, on a case registered by the Valliyoor All-Women Police under POCSO."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A small child at her family's church, within reach of its priest because that is what the visit was for.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/06/court-sends-church-priest-to-seven-years-in-jail-for-sexual-harassment-of-minor-girl-in-tamil-nadu/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Court Sends Church Priest To Seven Years In Jail', ETV Bharat, 12 Jun. 2026 (credited repost).",
"body": "Court report of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/06/court-sends-church-priest-to-seven-years-in-jail-for-sexual-harassment-of-minor-girl-in-tamil-nadu/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5f92dafa4d26510e99ae0999362414c186b821070caa57d262b2f2520cab584c",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/06/court-sends-church-priest-to-seven-years-in-jail-for-sexual-harassment-of-minor-girl-in-tamil-nadu/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 507,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is not named here. Reported by two independent Odisha outlets; the murder statute (IPC 302 vs. its BNS successor) is reported inconsistently between them and is not asserted beyond 'murder'.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-biju-panda-kalarahanga-temple-bhubaneswar-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Kalarahanga, Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India",
"lat": 20.356,
"lng": 85.825,
"title": "India: temple priest given life for murdering a woman he held at his temple on a promise of curing infertility",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Kalarahanga Shiva temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"induced the victim to stay at the temple on the pretext of ritual treatment for infertility",
"coercive live-in 'religious vow' relationship"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Kalarahanga Shiva temple, Bhubaneswar"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Khordha District & Sessions Court, Odisha, India",
"stage": "conviction and life sentence",
"date": "2026-07-01",
"outcome": "Biju Panda, priest of the Kalarahanga Shiva temple in Bhubaneswar, induced a woman to stay at the temple on the pretext of curing her infertility and held her in a coercive 'religious vow' relationship. In May 2023, nine months pregnant, she asked to go home to her family; he doused her in kerosene and burned her to death. On the strength of nineteen witnesses and twenty-four documents the Khordha District & Sessions Court convicted him of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment on 1 July 2026."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Her presence in his custody was created entirely by his priestly claim to cure her infertility — the authority produced the captivity, and the captivity produced the killing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://odishatv.in/odisha/bhubaneswar-temple-priest-gets-life-term-for-sexual-exploitation-and-murder-of-woman-12122320",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Bhubaneswar temple priest gets life term for sexual exploitation and murder of woman', OdishaTV.",
"body": "Court report of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://pragativadi.com/khordha-temple-priest-sentenced-to-life-for-sexual-exploitation-and-murder/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Khordha temple priest sentenced to life', Pragativadi.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://odishatv.in/odisha/bhubaneswar-temple-priest-gets-life-term-for-sexual-exploitation-and-murder-of-woman-12122320",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2c682caeb0430255f640e81a8a6e15281c66aa78226208240de5b7e6c3b99814",
"final_url": "https://odishatv.in/odisha/bhubaneswar-temple-priest-gets-life-term-for-sexual-exploitation-and-murder-of-woman-12122320"
},
{
"source": "https://pragativadi.com/khordha-temple-priest-sentenced-to-life-for-sexual-exploitation-and-murder/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ebed9c4c1742a7e135c8b8f844f587ac61a45a1a8495b883c86173758c171f29",
"final_url": "https://pragativadi.com/khordha-temple-priest-sentenced-to-life-for-sexual-exploitation-and-murder/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 508,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR BULGARIA. Dated 2016 — later recirculations of this case as 'recent' news are misdated, and no newer Varna priest conviction exists to be confused with.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-yanko-yanakiev-varna-bulgaria",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Varna, Bulgaria",
"lat": 43.2141,
"lng": 27.9147,
"title": "Bulgaria: Orthodox priest convicted of indecent acts against a thirteen-year-old boy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the 'Sv. Dimitar Solunski' church, Vladislavovo, Varna"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priest's standing with the boy and his family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Varna District Court, Bulgaria",
"stage": "conviction and suspended sentence",
"date": "2016-06-21",
"outcome": "Yanko Yanakiev, 73, priest at the 'Sv. Dimitar Solunski' church in Varna's Vladislavovo district, was convicted in June 2016 of indecent acts against a thirteen-year-old boy at a mineral pool at Sv. Konstantin i Elena in January 2015, receiving a one-year suspended sentence with a four-year probationary period and 2,000 leva in compensation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boy was within the priest's reach through his parish standing; the suspended sentence is recorded as imposed, without embellishment.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.24chasa.bg/bulgaria/article/5595155",
"archive": "",
"citation": "24 Chasa, 21 Jun. 2016.",
"body": "Bulgarian national daily's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://eurocom.bg/news/article/sveshtenik-e-osuden-za-bludstvo-s-dete",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Свещеник е осъден за блудство с дете', Eurocom.",
"body": "Independent Bulgarian coverage.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.24chasa.bg/bulgaria/article/5595155",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b8573791183f5d160b4ad2568191355d60f024ea6f4ef8bc0cfec8d7f01d9dbf",
"final_url": "https://www.24chasa.bg/bulgaria/article/5595155"
},
{
"source": "https://eurocom.bg/news/article/sveshtenik-e-osuden-za-bludstvo-s-dete",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 509,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Third 2×2 record in the corpus; the AP's 2024 investigation of the sect anchors the conviction in mainstream record. He died months after sentencing, so no appellate opinion exists — the published People v. Mata appeal (B301460) concerns an unrelated defendant named Alfredo Mata and must not be attached to this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2006-ruben-mata-2x2-worker-california-usa",
"year": 2006,
"place": "San Jose, California, USA",
"lat": 37.3382,
"lng": -121.8863,
"title": "United States: 2×2 worker Ruben Mata convicted — 36 years to life — for abusing boys of host families",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"itinerant minister ('worker') of the nameless 2×2 sect"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the sect's practice of housing workers in member families' homes",
"spiritual standing over host families across decades of ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"'Two by Twos' / 'The Truth' (nameless sect)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Santa Clara County Superior Court, California, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence; died in custody",
"date": "2006-11-01",
"outcome": "Ruben Mata, a longtime 2×2 travelling worker reported to have abused dozens of boys across his ministry, was convicted by a Santa Clara County jury in November 2006 on counts including forcible lewd acts on a child and aggravated sexual assault of a child under fourteen, and sentenced in January 2007 to 36 years to life. Court records give the case number as CC628419, filed 4 May 2006, with bail denied and no parole available. He died in prison on 2 October 2007."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The same canonical 2×2 nexus as Severud and Mousseau: a homeless itinerant minister lodged inside member families' homes as an act of faith, with the families' total spiritual trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://sentinelcolorado.com/nation-world/nation/survivors-seek-a-reckoning-as-fbi-investigates-child-sex-abuse-in-little-known-christian-sect/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rebecca Boone, 'Survivors seek a reckoning as FBI investigates child sex abuse in little-known Christian sect', Associated Press, 16 Dec. 2024.",
"body": "AP investigation confirming Mata's 2006 conviction and death in a California prison.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "investigative-and-conviction-report"
},
{
"link": "http://web.archive.org/web/20190814121147/http://2x2ministry.org/workers/Ruben_Mata.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "2x2ministry.org case-documentation page for Ruben Mata, archived 14 Aug. 2019.",
"body": "Documentation-site compilation of the court record, retrieved via the Wayback Machine (paired with the AP anchor; index use).",
"tier": "documentation-archive",
"kind": "court-record-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://sentinelcolorado.com/nation-world/nation/survivors-seek-a-reckoning-as-fbi-investigates-child-sex-abuse-in-little-known-christian-sect/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: investigative-and-conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f6683281ea819bb93264abf03a644543ded19354fb178a8a814aa1c3cf86d2f3",
"final_url": "https://sentinelcolorado.com/nation-world/nation/survivors-seek-a-reckoning-as-fbi-investigates-child-sex-abuse-in-little-known-christian-sect/"
},
{
"source": "http://web.archive.org/web/20190814121147/http://2x2ministry.org/workers/Ruben_Mata.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: documentation-archive; evidentiary role: court-record-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "73a2c45f889592ec309f7738392aadda857d0fca72270523ccdfb762379d2fe4",
"final_url": "http://web.archive.org/web/20190814121147/http://2x2ministry.org/workers/Ruben_Mata.php"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 510,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is not identified. Verification resolved the once-ambiguous nexus: coverage confirms a congregational relationship, not a family one.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-hugo-fluellen-gilmer-texas-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Gilmer, Texas, USA",
"lat": 32.735,
"lng": -94.95,
"title": "United States: pastor given six consecutive life sentences for a decade of abuse of a choir girl",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a Gilmer church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rides home from church services",
"abuse inside the church and church vehicles",
"pastoral standing with the victim's family from her early childhood"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "115th Judicial District Court, Upshur County, Texas, USA",
"stage": "conviction and six consecutive life sentences",
"date": "2013-10-15",
"outcome": "Hugo Fluellen, a Gilmer pastor, abused a girl of his congregation — a church-choir member — for roughly a decade beginning when she was in second grade, in the church, in church vehicles, and on rides home from services; DNA evidence showed he fathered her child. On 15 October 2013 he received six consecutive life sentences, automatic under Texas law given his 1987 prior conviction for sexual assault of a child."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a congregant child in the pastor's choir, and the church itself — its rides, vehicles and rooms — was the apparatus of access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news-journal.com/2013/10/15/former-gilmer-pastor-sentenced-to-six-life-sentences-in-child-sex-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former Gilmer pastor sentenced to six life sentences in child sex abuse case', Longview News-Journal, 15 Oct. 2013.",
"body": "Regional paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news-journal.com/2013/10/15/former-gilmer-pastor-sentenced-to-six-life-sentences-in-child-sex-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f729d6e4f11a3708a8b6a9c3fd18160794d266e37638799963d50518b39de097",
"final_url": "https://news-journal.com/2013/10/15/former-gilmer-pastor-sentenced-to-six-life-sentences-in-child-sex-abuse-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 511,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. French assize verdicts are appealable; no appeal is reported in available coverage, and the appellate status is flagged as unconfirmed rather than asserted final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-karma-tshojay-mille-bouddhas-la-boulaye-france",
"year": 2018,
"place": "La Boulaye, Saône-et-Loire, France",
"lat": 46.6333,
"lng": 4.2333,
"title": "France: lama at the Temple of a Thousand Buddhas sentenced to 12 years for raping disciples and their children",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"resident lama ('Lama Tempa') at the Kagyu Temple des Mille Bouddhas"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over disciples and children raised within the temple community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Temple des Mille Bouddhas, La Boulaye (Kagyu)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour d'assises de Saône-et-Loire, France",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2018-12-19",
"outcome": "Karma Tshojay, a Bhutanese-origin lama known as Lama Tempa at the Kagyu 'Temple of a Thousand Buddhas' in La Boulaye, was convicted on 19 December 2018 of rapes and sexual assaults committed from the 1990s into the 2000s against four women — disciples or disciples' children, including a girl raped from age eleven and another molested at nine while living in the community — and sentenced to twelve years, with civil damages to each victim. A second monk tried alongside him was acquitted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were his disciples and children raised inside the temple community under his religious authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.europe1.fr/societe/saone-et-loire-un-moine-bouddhiste-condamne-a-douze-ans-de-prison-pour-viols-3824390",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Saône-et-Loire : un moine bouddhiste condamné à douze ans de prison pour viols', Europe 1, Dec. 2018.",
"body": "National broadcaster's report of the assize verdict.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.trtworld.com/article/12712581",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TRT World report on the conviction.",
"body": "Independent international corroboration.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.europe1.fr/societe/saone-et-loire-un-moine-bouddhiste-condamne-a-douze-ans-de-prison-pour-viols-3824390",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7e68876cd56fe54b3edb9c250f1d164db2d11815e169095f2ce3123fbbb9c8b5",
"final_url": "https://www.europe1.fr/societe/saone-et-loire-un-moine-bouddhiste-condamne-a-douze-ans-de-prison-pour-viols-3824390"
},
{
"source": "https://www.trtworld.com/article/12712581",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2051ceda51da12c75b87cc904f7004591e0ab01d1ef446e5c07c804baecdf8e8",
"final_url": "https://www.trtworld.com/article/12712581"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 512,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified; the defendant's name is withheld in Korean press per standard practice. Corroborated by two Korean outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-jangseong-temple-dongjaseung-gwangju-south-korea",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Jangseong, South Jeolla, South Korea",
"lat": 35.3019,
"lng": 126.7847,
"title": "South Korea: abbot convicted of raping the girl he raised at his temple as a child monastic",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"abbot of a Jangseong temple; adoptive guardian in the dongjaseung (child-monastic) tradition"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total monastic custody of a girl raised at the temple from around age five"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Gwangju District Court (Criminal Division 11), South Korea",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2015-10-01",
"outcome": "A 63-year-old abbot of a temple in Jangseong, South Jeolla, who had taken in a girl as a dongjaseung — a child monastic raised at the temple from about age five — was convicted in October 2015 of repeatedly raping her from about age thirteen. The court rejected his claim of consent and sentenced him to six years' imprisonment with a mandated sex-offender programme."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The dongjaseung custom placed the child wholly in the abbot's religious custody — guardian, teacher and abbot in one office; the court rejected the consent claim against exactly that dependency.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://www.jnilbo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=48097143883",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jeonnam Ilbo court report, Oct. 2015.",
"body": "Regional paper of record's report of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kmib.co.kr/article/view.asp?arcid=0009989722",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kookmin Ilbo report.",
"body": "National-daily corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://www.jnilbo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=48097143883",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "22765ea701536a33661bb10636a1fd2bfc6b11a5da9fa21166f2799386491293",
"final_url": "http://www.jnilbo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=48097143883"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kmib.co.kr/article/view.asp?arcid=0009989722",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9d0a215c1f966c3e335d2da30a3fcada40893a710ec812e55b0b4f992ec61843",
"final_url": "https://www.kmib.co.kr/article/view.asp?arcid=0009989722"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 513,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Sentence reduced (health grounds); conviction undisturbed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Tagged Canada per the harm-location rule. The defendant is named in CBC's coverage; this record follows the cited reporting for all asserted facts.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-wat-lao-xayaram-winnipeg-canada",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada",
"lat": 49.8951,
"lng": -97.1384,
"title": "Canada: head monk of a Winnipeg Lao temple convicted of sexual interference against two girls",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"head monk of Wat Lao Xayaram, Winnipeg"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious standing over families of the temple community and access to their children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Wat Lao Xayaram, Winnipeg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Manitoba court, Canada",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal (conviction stands)",
"date": "2021-12-01",
"outcome": "The head monk of Wat Lao Xayaram, a Lao Buddhist temple in Winnipeg, was convicted in December 2021 of sexual interference against two girls of the temple community and sentenced in 2022 to eleven years. On appeal the sentence was reduced following a cancer diagnosis; the conviction itself stands."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The girls belonged to families of the temple community over which the head monk held religious authority — the access ran through that standing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/buddhist-monk-sentenced-sexual-abuse-1.6627437",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, Manitoba: sentencing report.",
"body": "National public broadcaster's court reporting.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/buddhist-monk-convicted-sexual-assualt-sentence-reduced-1.7283857",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, Manitoba: appeal outcome.",
"body": "Confirms the sentence reduction and that the conviction stands.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Sentence reduced (health grounds); conviction undisturbed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/buddhist-monk-sentenced-sexual-abuse-1.6627437",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/buddhist-monk-convicted-sexual-assualt-sentence-reduced-1.7283857",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 514,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "suprema-corte-mendoza",
"date": "",
"note": "All three convictions ratified unanimously."
},
{
"stage": "csjn",
"date": "2024-02-01",
"note": "Corbacho's queja dismissed — firme."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Corradi's conviction is recorded with the caveat that he died before final appellate review. The second Próvolo trial ended in acquittals for all nine women defendants (Oct 2023) and the La Plata branch case was declared prescribed (2020) — neither produces records, and neither contradicts the convictions here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-provolo-institute-mendoza-argentina",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Mendoza, Argentina",
"lat": -32.8895,
"lng": -68.8458,
"title": "Argentina: Próvolo Institute priests convicted of abusing deaf child students — 45 and 42 years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priests directing the Instituto Próvolo school for deaf children",
"institute gardener within the same custodial structure"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial religious authority over deaf child students",
"victims' deafness isolating them from disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Instituto Próvolo, Luján de Cuyo, Mendoza"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Segundo Tribunal Penal Colegiado de Mendoza; Suprema Corte de Mendoza; CSJN",
"stage": "convictions; Corbacho final at the Supreme Court",
"date": "2019-11-25",
"outcome": "On 25 November 2019 the priests Horacio Corbacho Blanck and Nicola Corradi were sentenced to 45 and 42 years, and gardener Armando Gómez to 18, for aggravated sexual abuse and corruption of deaf child students of the Instituto Próvolo in Mendoza. Mendoza's Suprema Corte ratified all three unanimously; the national Supreme Court dismissed Corbacho's final recourse in February 2024, leaving his sentence firm, and left Gómez's firm in October 2023. Corradi died under house arrest on 14 July 2021 before his appeals concluded."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Deaf children in the total custody of a Catholic institute run by the men who abused them — disability, boarding structure and priestly authority compounding into total control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://jusmendoza.gob.ar/la-suprema-corte-ratifico-la-sentencia-en-el-caso-provolo-2/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Poder Judicial de Mendoza: 'La Suprema Corte ratificó la sentencia en el caso Próvolo'.",
"body": "The provincial court's own confirmation of the ratified sentences.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/judiciales/2024/03/01/caso-provolo-la-corte-suprema-dejo-firme-la-condena-a-45-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abusos-a-menores-sordomudos/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Caso Próvolo: la Corte Suprema dejó firme la condena a 45 años', Infobae, 1 Mar. 2024.",
"body": "National reporting of the CSJN finality.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "suprema-corte-mendoza",
"date": "",
"note": "All three convictions ratified unanimously."
},
{
"stage": "csjn",
"date": "2024-02-01",
"note": "Corbacho's queja dismissed — firme."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://jusmendoza.gob.ar/la-suprema-corte-ratifico-la-sentencia-en-el-caso-provolo-2/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1108b994a99c13a7a7d418244fdcfafb65efa4149fed7d4e4f36224eb9ffaa32",
"final_url": "https://jusmendoza.gob.ar/la-suprema-corte-ratifico-la-sentencia-en-el-caso-provolo-2/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/judiciales/2024/03/01/caso-provolo-la-corte-suprema-dejo-firme-la-condena-a-45-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abusos-a-menores-sordomudos/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5c12c502f3e17fb4a653afab3040e29a760fcd7e65d74a67b0a4d6abb5734d43",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/judiciales/2024/03/01/caso-provolo-la-corte-suprema-dejo-firme-la-condena-a-45-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abusos-a-menores-sordomudos/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 515,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "csjn",
"date": "2017-03-21",
"note": "All defence recourses rejected — firme."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-julio-grassi-felices-los-ninos-moron-argentina",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Morón, Buenos Aires, Argentina",
"lat": -34.6534,
"lng": -58.6198,
"title": "Argentina: Julio Grassi's conviction for abusing a boy of his children's foundation — final at every level",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest and founder of the Fundación Felices los Niños"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial authority over resident children of his foundation",
"celebrity-priest standing that deflected scrutiny"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Fundación Felices los Niños"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Oral en lo Criminal 1 de Morón; Casación; SCBA; CSJN",
"stage": "conviction; final after CSJN rejection",
"date": "2009-06-10",
"outcome": "Julio César Grassi, founder of the Fundación Felices los Niños, was convicted in 2009 of aggravated sexual abuse and aggravated corruption of a minor resident of his foundation — the judgment itself aggravating the crime because he was a priest charged with the victim's education and care. Every level confirmed it: Casación, the Buenos Aires Supreme Court, and on 21 March 2017 the national Supreme Court rejected his final recourses, with a further rejection in March 2020. He has been imprisoned since 2013."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A resident child of the priest's own charitable foundation — the court's aggravation clause states the nexus in the judgment's own words.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cij.gov.ar/nota-25293-La-Corte-Suprema-de-Justicia-de-la-Naci-n-confirm--la-condena-de-15-a-os-de-prisi-n-contra-Julio-C-sar-Grassi.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Centro de Información Judicial (CIJ): CSJN confirms the 15-year sentence against Julio César Grassi.",
"body": "The judiciary's own information service on the finality.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/2020/03/05/la-corte-suprema-dejo-firme-otra-condena-contra-el-padre-grassi/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'La Corte Suprema dejó firme otra condena contra el padre Grassi', Infobae, 5 Mar. 2020.",
"body": "National coverage of the further CSJN rejection.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "csjn",
"date": "2017-03-21",
"note": "All defence recourses rejected — firme."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cij.gov.ar/nota-25293-La-Corte-Suprema-de-Justicia-de-la-Naci-n-confirm--la-condena-de-15-a-os-de-prisi-n-contra-Julio-C-sar-Grassi.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "493eb1479434912a8de5eaab467ff4b8041e9cedad42e9c0bf4b451044cf608c",
"final_url": "https://www.csjn.gov.ar/archivo-cij/nota-25293-La-Corte-Suprema-de-Justicia-de-la-Naci-n-confirm--la-condena-de-15-a-os-de-prisi-n-contra-Julio-C-sar-Grassi.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/2020/03/05/la-corte-suprema-dejo-firme-otra-condena-contra-el-padre-grassi/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "832f317fea04f8024dbebb7ae5bc96fc2c07e83921ebf0d021fe0aed9d6bbd7a",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/2020/03/05/la-corte-suprema-dejo-firme-otra-condena-contra-el-padre-grassi/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 516,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The non-custodial sentence is recorded as imposed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-john-oreilly-colegio-cumbres-santiago-chile",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Santiago, Chile",
"lat": -33.4489,
"lng": -70.6693,
"title": "Chile: Legionary of Christ school chaplain John O'Reilly convicted of abusing a student",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"chaplain of Colegio Cumbres, Santiago; prominent Legionary of Christ priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"chaplain's pastoral authority over a girl of his school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Colegio Cumbres, Santiago",
"Legionaries of Christ"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "3° Tribunal Oral en lo Penal de Santiago, Chile",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2014-11-11",
"outcome": "John O'Reilly, the Irish-born Legionary of Christ priest who served as chaplain of Santiago's Colegio Cumbres, was convicted on 11 November 2014 of repeated sexual abuse of a minor student between 2007 and 2012, receiving four years and a day of supervised liberty and perpetual disqualification from work with minors; he was acquitted on a second complainant's counts. Chile revoked his residency in 2015 and a Vatican canonical trial followed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A schoolgirl under her school's chaplain — the pastoral office inside the school was the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://radio.uchile.cl/2014/11/11/sacerdote-john-oreilly-fue-condenado-a-cuatro-anos-y-un-dia-de-libertad-vigilada-por-abuso-sexual/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Universidad de Chile, 11 Nov. 2014.",
"body": "Court report of the verdict and sentence.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://cooperativa.cl/noticias/pais/judicial/tribunal-acredito-abusos-sexuales-de-john-o-reilly-en-colegio-cumbres/2014-10-15/110003.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cooperativa: 'Tribunal acreditó abusos sexuales de John O'Reilly en Colegio Cumbres'.",
"body": "Independent national coverage of the tribunal's findings.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://radio.uchile.cl/2014/11/11/sacerdote-john-oreilly-fue-condenado-a-cuatro-anos-y-un-dia-de-libertad-vigilada-por-abuso-sexual/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8067ef9c3c12749f7de4db1a92f274fde52304283b8065acdb76ff703d395493",
"final_url": "https://radio.uchile.cl/2014/11/11/sacerdote-john-oreilly-fue-condenado-a-cuatro-anos-y-un-dia-de-libertad-vigilada-por-abuso-sexual/"
},
{
"source": "https://cooperativa.cl/noticias/pais/judicial/tribunal-acredito-abusos-sexuales-de-john-o-reilly-en-colegio-cumbres/2014-10-15/110003.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6d5d11b2dc035bb8474c1df8496b49a967106247ed6a3572ef9acbba23f42138",
"final_url": "https://cooperativa.cl/noticias/pais/judicial/tribunal-acredito-abusos-sexuales-de-john-o-reilly-en-colegio-cumbres/2014-10-15/110003.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 517,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. At least one victim was a relative; the clergy-role nexus holds for the victim set as a whole and the family element is stated rather than hidden.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-oscar-munoz-toledo-archdiocese-santiago-chile",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Santiago, Chile",
"lat": -33.46,
"lng": -70.65,
"title": "Chile: the archdiocese official who received abuse complaints convicted of abusing minors himself",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest and chancellor of the Archdiocese of Santiago — the official who received abuse complaints"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly standing with victims' families",
"institutional position atop the complaint channel itself"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Santiago"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "7° Tribunal Oral en lo Penal de Santiago, Chile",
"stage": "conviction and 15-year sentence",
"date": "2022-06-18",
"outcome": "Óscar Muñoz Toledo, former chancellor of the Archdiocese of Santiago — the official charged with receiving abuse complaints — was convicted in June 2022 of rape and repeated sexual abuse of four minors between 2009 and 2018 in Macul, Maipú and Parral, and sentenced to 15 years. He had been laicised in 2019; his 2018 arrest helped trigger the crisis that led Chile's entire episcopate to offer resignation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims under a priest whose institutional office was literally the complaint channel — the system's keeper was its predator.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.pjud.cl/prensa-y-comunicaciones/noticias-del-poder-judicial/74809",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Poder Judicial de Chile: press release on the conviction.",
"body": "The judiciary's own release.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://radio.uchile.cl/2022/06/18/condenan-a-15-anos-de-carcel-a-exsacerdote-oscar-munoz-por-delitos-sexuales/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Universidad de Chile, 18 Jun. 2022.",
"body": "National coverage of the sentence.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.pjud.cl/prensa-y-comunicaciones/noticias-del-poder-judicial/74809",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8859368c1ec689675dc5a8538d031c264ffab48c8dd5d51034681c9444a40632",
"final_url": "https://www.pjud.cl/prensa-y-comunicaciones/noticias-del-poder-judicial/74809"
},
{
"source": "https://radio.uchile.cl/2022/06/18/condenan-a-15-anos-de-carcel-a-exsacerdote-oscar-munoz-por-delitos-sexuales/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "840050b33ef47216a357611f9e0d8eecb9997616492eedd88aa96558528dd500",
"final_url": "https://radio.uchile.cl/2022/06/18/condenan-a-15-anos-de-carcel-a-exsacerdote-oscar-munoz-por-delitos-sexuales/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 518,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "corte-apelaciones",
"date": "2012-01-09",
"note": "2011 fact-finding resolution ratified."
},
{
"stage": "corte-apelaciones",
"date": "2019-03-27",
"note": "Civil judgment against the archdiocese — final, paid."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Cruz, Hamilton and Murillo are named because they are among the world's most public survivor-advocates and are named in every cited ruling. FINDINGS-TIER RECORD: no criminal conviction exists — the record asserts the judicial fact-finding, the final civil judgment, and the canonical verdict, nothing more.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-fernando-karadima-el-bosque-santiago-chile",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Santiago, Chile",
"lat": -33.43,
"lng": -70.61,
"title": "Chile: Karadima — judicially established abuse, prescription bar, and a final civil judgment against the Church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest of El Bosque and Chile's most influential spiritual director of seminarians and young men"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual direction of adolescents and young men in the El Bosque community",
"cult-like obedience culture the courts and Vatican both described"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Parroquia El Bosque, Providencia",
"Archdiocese of Santiago"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Visiting judge, Santiago (2011); Corte de Apelaciones de Santiago (2012, 2019)",
"stage": "judicial fact-finding despite prescription; final civil judgment against the archdiocese",
"date": "2011-11-14",
"outcome": "Fernando Karadima was never criminally convicted: on 14 November 2011 visiting judge Jessica González dismissed the case as prescribed while expressly establishing as proven the abuses of Juan Carlos Cruz, James Hamilton and José Andrés Murillo (1981–1995), finding their testimony truthful — a ruling ratified on appeal in January 2012. On 27 March 2019 the Corte de Apelaciones de Santiago ordered the Archdiocese to pay CLP 100 million to each of the three for negligent cover-up; the ruling went unappealed and was paid in June 2019. The Vatican found him canonically guilty in 2011 and laicised him in 2018. He died in 2021."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Adolescents and young men under Chile's most powerful spiritual director, inside a parish culture the courts described as one of total obedience — the survivors' testimony that broke the Chilean Church's cover-up era.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elmostrador.cl/ahora/2011/11/14/caso-karadima-jueza-dicta-sobreseimiento-y-acredita-delitos-imputados/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Caso Karadima: jueza dicta sobreseimiento y acredita delitos imputados', El Mostrador, 14 Nov. 2011.",
"body": "Reports the resolution establishing the facts while dismissing on prescription.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "judicial-finding-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.latercera.com/la-tercera-pm/noticia/lea-aca-fallo-completo-las-razones-la-corte-apelaciones-ordenar-al-arzobispado-indemnizar-las-victimas-karadima/589216/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Tercera: the full 2019 appellate civil ruling against the archdiocese.",
"body": "The civil judgment text via a national paper of record.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "civil-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "corte-apelaciones",
"date": "2012-01-09",
"note": "2011 fact-finding resolution ratified."
},
{
"stage": "corte-apelaciones",
"date": "2019-03-27",
"note": "Civil judgment against the archdiocese — final, paid."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elmostrador.cl/ahora/2011/11/14/caso-karadima-jueza-dicta-sobreseimiento-y-acredita-delitos-imputados/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judicial-finding-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b24ef6899678aa7faa805dd59fb1d7d155c2542f2d461dd8be2a35636b9d9b59",
"final_url": "https://www.elmostrador.cl/ahora/2011/11/14/caso-karadima-jueza-dicta-sobreseimiento-y-acredita-delitos-imputados/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.latercera.com/la-tercera-pm/noticia/lea-aca-fallo-completo-las-razones-la-corte-apelaciones-ordenar-al-arzobispado-indemnizar-las-victimas-karadima/589216/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "00bc432dd9cb77f02d8bdc7e6aff29388ddf2b6d8851f711522e1c3fde08e6a2",
"final_url": "https://www.latercera.com/la-tercera-pm/noticia/lea-aca-fallo-completo-las-razones-la-corte-apelaciones-ordenar-al-arzobispado-indemnizar-las-victimas-karadima/589216/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 519,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "tsj-oaxaca",
"date": "",
"note": "Sentence confirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-gerardo-silvestre-villa-alta-oaxaca-mexico",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Villa Alta, Oaxaca, Mexico",
"lat": 17.3369,
"lng": -96.1594,
"title": "Mexico: Oaxaca priest's sentence — an early Mexican clergy conviction — confirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest of San Ildefonso Villa Alta"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish authority over boys of indigenous Sierra Norte communities",
"alcohol and pornography used in grooming"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Parroquia San Ildefonso, Villa Alta"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Oaxaca state court; Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Oaxaca",
"stage": "conviction; confirmed on appeal",
"date": "2017-02-01",
"outcome": "Gerardo Silvestre Hernández, parish priest of San Ildefonso Villa Alta in Oaxaca's Sierra Norte, was sentenced in February 2017 to 16 years and 6 months for corruption of minors, having plied boys of his parish with alcohol and pornography before abusing them (2009–2010). Jailed since 2013, his sentence was confirmed by the Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Oaxaca — widely reported as among the first convictions of its kind against a priest in Mexico."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys of remote parishes under the only priest their communities had — the parish office carried the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://proceso.com.mx/475722/sacerdote-acusado-pederastia-en-oaxaca-sentenciado-a-16-anos-carcel",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Proceso: 'Sacerdote acusado de pederastia en Oaxaca, sentenciado a 16 años de cárcel'.",
"body": "National-magazine court reporting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.elfinanciero.com.mx/nacional/confirman-sentencia-a-sacerdote-acusado/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Financiero: 'Confirman sentencia a sacerdote acusado'.",
"body": "Reports the appellate confirmation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "tsj-oaxaca",
"date": "",
"note": "Sentence confirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://proceso.com.mx/475722/sacerdote-acusado-pederastia-en-oaxaca-sentenciado-a-16-anos-carcel",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.elfinanciero.com.mx/nacional/confirman-sentencia-a-sacerdote-acusado/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0542cd7136d75fa11e592f1d90bda247328ecf8866abae46a4577aee90248d00",
"final_url": "https://www.elfinanciero.com.mx/nacional/confirman-sentencia-a-sacerdote-acusado/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 520,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "tsj-coahuila",
"date": "2020-01-30",
"note": "13-year sentence ratified."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-padre-meno-riojas-piedras-negras-mexico",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Piedras Negras, Coahuila, Mexico",
"lat": 28.7,
"lng": -100.5231,
"title": "Mexico: 'Padre Meño' — seminary formator's rape conviction ratified on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest and formator at the Seminario Menor of Piedras Negras"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"formation authority over a minor seminarian in residential training"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Seminario Menor, Diocese of Piedras Negras"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Coahuila state court; Sala Colegiada del TSJ de Coahuila",
"stage": "conviction; ratified on appeal",
"date": "2020-01-30",
"outcome": "Juan Manuel Riojas Martínez, 'Padre Meño', was convicted of qualified rape and attempted qualified rape of a minor seminarian — fifteen years old at the onset in 2014 — at the Seminario Menor of Piedras Negras. After a first 15-year sentence was revoked for retrial he was re-sentenced to 13 years, ratified by the Sala Colegiada of Coahuila's high court in January 2020. He received conditional release in September 2024; the conviction stands."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A boy in residential seminary formation under the priest responsible for forming him — the Church's own pipeline as the site of the harm.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2020/1/30/ratifican-sentencia-de-13-anos-de-prision-al-padre-meno-por-violacion-237833.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Proceso: 'Ratifican sentencia de 13 años de prisión al Padre Meño por violación', 30 Jan. 2020.",
"body": "Reports the appellate ratification.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sinembargo.mx/3580850/un-tribunal-de-piedras-negras-da-sentencia-de-13-anos-al-padre-meno-por-violacion-calificada/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SinEmbargo: report of the 13-year sentence.",
"body": "Independent national corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "tsj-coahuila",
"date": "2020-01-30",
"note": "13-year sentence ratified."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2020/1/30/ratifican-sentencia-de-13-anos-de-prision-al-padre-meno-por-violacion-237833.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dad6e81dc730a56955833531914f32042027462c5cc152510e6d0051125d7351",
"final_url": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2020/1/30/ratifican-sentencia-de-13-anos-de-prision-al-padre-meno-por-violacion-237833.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sinembargo.mx/3580850/un-tribunal-de-piedras-negras-da-sentencia-de-13-anos-al-padre-meno-por-violacion-calificada/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 521,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. First-instance; appellate status not located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-wesler-reyes-florian-quetzaltenango-guatemala",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Quetzaltenango, Guatemala",
"lat": 14.8347,
"lng": -91.518,
"title": "Guatemala: pastor sentenced to 33 years for aggravated sexual assault of a minor congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"trust and power asymmetry of the pastoral role, found expressly by the court"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Femicidio de Quetzaltenango, Guatemala",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-18",
"outcome": "Wesler Gilmar Reyes Florián, an evangelical pastor, was sentenced in January 2024 to 33 years for aggravated sexual assault of a minor; the Quetzaltenango femicide-and-sexual-violence tribunal found he exploited the trust and power asymmetry of his pastoral role on at least four occasions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The tribunal's own reasoning names the pastoral power asymmetry as the instrument.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lahora.gt/nacionales/cveliz/2024/01/18/condenan-a-33-anos-de-prision-a-pastor-acusado-de-agresion-sexual/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a 33 años de prisión a pastor acusado de agresión sexual', La Hora, 18 Jan. 2024.",
"body": "National court reporting of the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lahora.gt/nacionales/cveliz/2024/01/18/condenan-a-33-anos-de-prision-a-pastor-acusado-de-agresion-sexual/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5650a695e79bd763cc6552ddd9c3c0662280b4260cb93b35e6a6cd408c3bcf71",
"final_url": "https://lahora.gt/nacionales/cveliz/2024/01/18/condenan-a-33-anos-de-prision-a-pastor-acusado-de-agresion-sexual/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 522,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "csj-civil",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Landmark civil liability of the Church affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-luis-enrique-duque-libano-tolima-colombia",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Líbano, Tolima, Colombia",
"lat": 4.921,
"lng": -75.0623,
"title": "Colombia: priest convicted of abusing displaced children in his care — and the Supreme Court's landmark civil ruling",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest of Líbano, Tolima"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custody of children of a displaced family entrusted to the parish's care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Colombian criminal court (2009); Corte Suprema de Justicia, Sala Civil (2015)",
"stage": "criminal conviction; landmark civil ruling against the Church",
"date": "2009-01-01",
"outcome": "Luis Enrique Duque Valencia, parish priest of Líbano, was sentenced in 2009 to 18 years for abusing two children, aged seven and eight, of a displaced family entrusted to his care. In 2015 the Corte Suprema de Justicia ordered the Church itself to pay roughly COP 800 million — Colombia's first civil condemnation of the Church for a priest's abuse, reasoning that the institution cannot detach itself from a priest 'subject to its authority'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children of a displaced family delivered into the parish's protection — the priest's custody was itself the Church's charity, and the Supreme Court's civil ruling hangs institutional responsibility on exactly that authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eltiempo.com/archivo/documento/CMS-16398924",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Tiempo archive: the Duque case and the Supreme Court civil ruling.",
"body": "National paper of record.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-and-civil-ruling-report"
},
{
"link": "https://elespectador.com/noticias/judicial/condena-iglesia-caso-de-pederastia-una-ofensa-monsenor-articulo-591742",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Espectador: coverage of the civil condemnation of the Church.",
"body": "Independent national corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "civil-ruling-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "csj-civil",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Landmark civil liability of the Church affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eltiempo.com/archivo/documento/CMS-16398924",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-and-civil-ruling-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8013e47702ebb8d37867e44ffa9df062924b0c5f08473e005a78885903068b33",
"final_url": "https://www.eltiempo.com/archivo/documento/CMS-16398924"
},
{
"source": "https://elespectador.com/noticias/judicial/condena-iglesia-caso-de-pederastia-una-ofensa-monsenor-articulo-591742",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-ruling-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "169bf990f3cb5de4dba9eb46d19b33c83c94ed45e8fdac26df3e8becdd2855d8",
"final_url": "https://www.elespectador.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 523,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The Fiscalía's release page was intermittently unreachable at verification time; the citation is retained alongside national press corroboration, and the precise sentencing date within 2020 is not asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-arcangel-acosta-miranda-cauca-colombia",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Miranda, Cauca, Colombia",
"lat": 3.2536,
"lng": -76.228,
"title": "Colombia: town priest sentenced to 16 years for sexual crimes against a twelve-year-old altar server",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest of Miranda, Cauca"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish authority over an altar server"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Colombian court, Cauca (Fiscalía prosecution)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-10-01",
"outcome": "Arcángel Acosta Izquierdo, the priest of Miranda, Cauca, was sentenced to 16 years for sexual crimes against a twelve-year-old girl who served in his parish (facts of October 2018), in a prosecution announced by the Fiscalía General de la Nación."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "An altar girl under the town's priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gov.co/colombia/seccionales/fiscalia-logra-sentencia-condenatoria-de-16-anos-de-prision-para-sacerdote-por-delitos-sexuales-con-menor-de-edad-en-miranda-cauca/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General de la Nación: 16-year sentence for the Miranda, Cauca priest.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's release.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/america/colombia/2020/10/25/el-aberrante-caso-de-un-sacerdote-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-una-monaguilla-de-12-anos-en-miranda-cauca/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Infobae Colombia, 25 Oct. 2020.",
"body": "National press corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gov.co/colombia/seccionales/fiscalia-logra-sentencia-condenatoria-de-16-anos-de-prision-para-sacerdote-por-delitos-sexuales-con-menor-de-edad-en-miranda-cauca/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/america/colombia/2020/10/25/el-aberrante-caso-de-un-sacerdote-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-una-monaguilla-de-12-anos-en-miranda-cauca/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6769a608f768e99e38de8207c0c80d3348166e19498c9e526f90426320a55f22",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/america/colombia/2020/10/25/el-aberrante-caso-de-un-sacerdote-que-abuso-sexualmente-de-una-monaguilla-de-12-anos-en-miranda-cauca/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 524,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. First-instance; appellate status not located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-santiago-vasquez-panchimalco-el-salvador",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Panchimalco, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.6136,
"lng": -89.1797,
"title": "El Salvador: self-styled pastor convicted of continuous rape of a minor in a household that lodged him on religious trust",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled pastor active in rural Panchimalco church events"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious standing that won him lodging in the victim's family home",
"trust built through church gatherings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Segundo de Sentencia de San Salvador, El Salvador",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-09-06",
"outcome": "Santiago Vásquez, who presented himself as a pastor at religious events in rural Panchimalco, gradually won a family's trust through church gatherings until they gave him lodging, then repeatedly raped a minor of the household during 2022. The Tribunal Segundo de Sentencia de San Salvador convicted him of continuous rape of a minor and sentenced him to 20 years, announced by the Fiscalía General de la República in September 2023."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The lodging — and with it the access — existed only because the family took him for a man of God.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/fgr-logro-condena-de-20-anos-de-carcel-para-pastor-que-violo-a-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General de la República: 'FGR logró condena de 20 años de cárcel para pastor que violó a menor'.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's release.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/fgr-logro-condena-de-20-anos-de-carcel-para-pastor-que-violo-a-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9f5922b3214308e4e40bee14a3fdc254bdf40ec4753d2f6b7cb4998a0b651ab3",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia.gob.sv/fgr-logro-condena-de-20-anos-de-carcel-para-pastor-que-violo-a-menor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 525,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is not identified. Sourced from two Thai papers of record (Thai Rath, MGR Online), replacing earlier tabloid-only sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-boonchuay-phansamdaeng-loei-thailand",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Na Duang, Loei, Thailand",
"lat": 17.486,
"lng": 101.973,
"title": "Thailand: former abbot convicted of raping a woman lured with an 'exorcism' ritual",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"former abbot of Wat Tham Prakai Phet"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"'exorcism' ritual used to isolate and control the victim"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"organizations": [
"Wat Tham Prakai Phet, Na Duang, Loei"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Loei Provincial Court, Thailand",
"stage": "conviction on confession",
"date": "2018-01-01",
"outcome": "Boonchuay Phansamdaeng, 53, former abbot of Wat Tham Prakai Phet in Loei province, lured a 21-year-old laywoman with an 'exorcism' ritual and raped her; she complained to the Damrongtham Centre in September 2018 and the Loei Provincial Court sentenced him to eight years, halved to four on his confession."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The ritual was the trap: a laywoman submitted to an abbot's claimed power over spirits, and that submission was the assault's mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/local/northeast/1433135",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thai Rath: 'เข้าคุกแล้ว อดีตสมภาร... ศาลตัดสิน 8 ปี'.",
"body": "Thai paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://mgronline.com/local/detail/9610000119654",
"archive": "",
"citation": "MGR Online (Manager) report.",
"body": "Independent Thai corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/local/northeast/1433135",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e6788e4594254391c88746ea4cac528ea663befcccfbbc6d40cbc71737c96c0a",
"final_url": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/local/northeast/1433135"
},
{
"source": "https://mgronline.com/local/detail/9610000119654",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1d8feec6484943518cb35cde49834beb8dd3da9a828d1f1303446b74c81e9ffb",
"final_url": "https://mgronline.com/local/detail/9610000119654"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 526,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2026-05-29",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence upheld (2026 LiveLaw (Del) 652)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. The sentence quantum is not stated in the High Court judgment (it was unchallenged on appeal) and is therefore not asserted. The judgment PDF is cited directly; the LiveLaw article's July date is its publication date, not the decision date.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-santosh-tiwari-temple-delhi-india",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Delhi, India",
"lat": 28.62,
"lng": 77.23,
"title": "India: temple priest's conviction for raping an intellectually disabled devotee upheld — 'satanic and unholy'",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"temple priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"victim's intellectual disability (IQ 60) and her family's resort to the temple for spiritual guidance",
"assault within the temple's residential premises"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Delhi sessions court; Delhi High Court (Santosh Tiwari v. State, CRL.A. 335/2013)",
"stage": "conviction (2013); appeal dismissed (2026)",
"date": "2013-01-30",
"outcome": "Santosh Tiwari, a Delhi temple priest, raped an intellectually disabled woman of about thirty (IQ 60, certified mild mental retardation) in the temple's residential premises on 4 February 2010; the FIR came forty days later, after he broke a promise to stay away. Convicted on 30 January 2013 and sentenced the next day, his appeal was dismissed by the Delhi High Court on 29 May 2026 (Justice Vimal Kumar Yadav), which called the act 'satanic and unholy', upheld conviction and sentence, and ordered him to surrender."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A cognitively disabled devotee inside the temple where her trust was placed — the High Court's own language locates the betrayal in the sanctity of the office.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2026/07/14/2-686701.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Santosh Tiwari v. State (NCT of Delhi), CRL.A. 335/2013, Delhi High Court, decided 29 May 2026 (judgment PDF).",
"body": "The appellate judgment itself.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/delhi-high-court/delhi-high-court-upholds-temple-priests-conviction-for-rape-of-intellectually-disabled-woman-calls-act-satanic-and-unholy-541285",
"archive": "",
"citation": "LiveLaw report, 2026 LiveLaw (Del) 652.",
"body": "Legal-news report of the judgment.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2026-05-29",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence upheld (2026 LiveLaw (Del) 652)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2026/07/14/2-686701.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "33b3cf1acbf91433b0c5604c17a97a4e3326b638ff7c2323a6ceb36c1cdaac78",
"final_url": "https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2026/07/14/2-686701.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/delhi-high-court/delhi-high-court-upholds-temple-priests-conviction-for-rape-of-intellectually-disabled-woman-calls-act-satanic-and-unholy-541285",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6c8926a07bdae189e83308fe22632aca97d913c83a8664bc6d8b7e0739b38dc7",
"final_url": "https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/delhi-high-court/delhi-high-court-upholds-temple-priests-conviction-for-rape-of-intellectually-disabled-woman-calls-act-satanic-and-unholy-541285"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 527,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The elder role is recorded as stated by the district attorney and local press; the US Jehovah's Witness organization has disputed it, and that dispute is part of this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-jay-aaron-smith-kingdom-hall-springfield-ma-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Springfield, Massachusetts, USA",
"lat": 42.1015,
"lng": -72.5898,
"title": "United States: Jehovah's Witness elder convicted of assaulting a thirteen-year-old congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder at a Springfield Kingdom Hall (role per prosecutors; disputed by the JW organization)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"congregational standing over a girl of the Kingdom Hall"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Springfield Kingdom Hall (Jehovah's Witnesses)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hampden Superior Court, Massachusetts, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-09-01",
"outcome": "Jay Aaron Smith, 62, was convicted by a Hampden Superior Court jury on four counts of indecent assault and battery on a child under fourteen — a thirteen-year-old girl of the Springfield congregation where prosecutors said he served as elder — and sentenced to 15 years plus five years' probation. He had a prior Georgia rape sentence from the late 1980s and was a Level 3 sex offender at the time of the offences."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a congregant of the Kingdom Hall where the defendant held elder standing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.westernmassnews.com/2023/09/01/jehovah-witness-elder-sentenced-jail-child-sexual-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Western Mass News, 1 Sep. 2023.",
"body": "Local broadcaster's report of the DA's announcement.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://dailyvoice.com/massachusetts/hampden/church-elder-gets-15-years-for-sexually-assaulting-teen-in-springfield-da/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily Voice: 'Church Elder Gets 15 Years'.",
"body": "Corroborating coverage of the DA release.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.westernmassnews.com/2023/09/01/jehovah-witness-elder-sentenced-jail-child-sexual-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c23c3332a96e0ac0ede48a6e26fa1d6ba145f7fd892a6b27c2cf059404ee9452",
"final_url": "https://www.westernmassnews.com/2023/09/01/jehovah-witness-elder-sentenced-jail-child-sexual-abuse-case/"
},
{
"source": "https://dailyvoice.com/massachusetts/hampden/church-elder-gets-15-years-for-sexually-assaulting-teen-in-springfield-da/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 528,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Upheld — final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified; the defendant's name is withheld in most Kazakh coverage. The communal rather than formal character of his religious office is stated plainly. Kazakhstan's judicial-independence limitations are noted; the facts here are ordinary-criminal and were tested on appeal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-karaganda-village-mullah-kazakhstan",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Karaganda region, Kazakhstan",
"lat": 49.8047,
"lng": 73.1094,
"title": "Kazakhstan: village mullah's 20-year sentence for raping a thirteen-year-old upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"community-chosen village mullah (not officially appointed by the muftiate)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious trust of the victim's family in the community's mullah"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Specialized inter-district juvenile court of Karaganda region; regional appellate panel",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"date": "2021-07-01",
"outcome": "A forty-year-old man who served as his village's chosen mullah in Karaganda region was convicted in July 2021 of repeatedly raping a thirteen-year-old girl (January–June 2020, leaving her pregnant) under Article 120(4) of Kazakhstan's criminal code, and sentenced to 20 years with a lifetime ban on work with minors. The regional appellate panel upheld the sentence. The official muftiate stressed he was never formally appointed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The family's openness to him rested on his standing as the community's religious figure; the muftiate's 'never appointed' disclaimer changes what he was on paper, not what he was to the village.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.zakon.kz/redaktsiia-zakonkz/5077267-mullu-osudili-na-20-let-za.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Zakon.kz: 'Муллу осудили на 20 лет…'.",
"body": "Kazakh legal-news outlet's court report.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://liter.kz/lipovyy-imam-vstupal-v-intimnuyu-svyaz-s-13-letney-devochkoy-v-karagande-sud-otkazal-v-smyagchenii-prigovora/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Liter.kz: appellate panel refuses mitigation.",
"body": "Reports the appeal outcome.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Upheld — final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.zakon.kz/redaktsiia-zakonkz/5077267-mullu-osudili-na-20-let-za.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b841b1b27f6a265ccb310facedeaf3c5db66c9df6ced8e8592549e3de8b66aa0",
"final_url": "https://www.zakon.kz/redaktsiia-zakonkz/5077267-mullu-osudili-na-20-let-za.html"
},
{
"source": "https://liter.kz/lipovyy-imam-vstupal-v-intimnuyu-svyaz-s-13-letney-devochkoy-v-karagande-sud-otkazal-v-smyagchenii-prigovora/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ad49de9fcf7bbdb6803fec9022e375b2d75b7a7f1e6ada1931c0b8e91ff6c937",
"final_url": "https://liter.kz/lipovyy-imam-vstupal-v-intimnuyu-svyaz-s-13-letney-devochkoy-v-karagande-sud-otkazal-v-smyagchenii-prigovora/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 529,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate-division",
"date": "2005",
"note": "One count reversed; convictions otherwise affirmed; resentenced by amended judgment."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-baruch-lanner-ncsy-hillel-yeshiva-nj-usa",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Ocean Township, New Jersey, USA",
"lat": 40.2523,
"lng": -74.0393,
"title": "United States: NCSY national director convicted of abusing students at the yeshiva he led",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"rabbi; principal of Hillel Yeshiva High School; national director of NCSY (Orthodox Union youth movement)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"principal's authority over teenage students",
"national youth-movement standing that deflected complaints for decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Hillel Yeshiva High School, Ocean Township",
"NCSY / Orthodox Union"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Monmouth County Superior Court, New Jersey; NJ Appellate Division",
"stage": "jury conviction; largely affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2002-06-27",
"outcome": "Baruch Lanner, principal of Hillel Yeshiva High School and national director of the Orthodox Union's NCSY youth movement, was convicted in June 2002 of aggravated criminal sexual contact and child endangerment against two teenage girls who were his students (1992–96), and sentenced to seven years. In 2005 the Appellate Division reversed one endangerment count while affirming the balance; he was resentenced by amended judgment and paroled in January 2008."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Girls under their principal's religious-educational authority — and a youth-movement office whose prestige had shielded him through years of internal complaints.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2002/06/28/ny/lanner-convicted-on-abuse-charges",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Lanner convicted on abuse charges', JTA, 28 Jun. 2002.",
"body": "Wire report of the verdict.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/new-jersey/appellate-division-unpublished/2006/a3385-04-opn.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Lanner, NJ App. Div. (A-3385-04, 2006).",
"body": "The appellate opinion on resentencing.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate-division",
"date": "2005",
"note": "One count reversed; convictions otherwise affirmed; resentenced by amended judgment."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2002/06/28/ny/lanner-convicted-on-abuse-charges",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "60b9f2dc2c40073efb7d2320c6ee3c3190fc6362ccf1031815a4f35896dfe828",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2002/06/28/ny/lanner-convicted-on-abuse-charges"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/new-jersey/appellate-division-unpublished/2006/a3385-04-opn.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 530,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The 2014 accusation is expressly excluded from this record's claims; only the 2009 conviction is asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-yona-weinberg-bar-mitzvah-tutor-brooklyn-usa",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Brooklyn, New York, USA",
"lat": 40.635,
"lng": -73.955,
"title": "United States: bar-mitzvah tutor convicted of abusing two boys under his religious instruction",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"bar-mitzvah tutor and licensed social worker in the Flatbush Orthodox community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"one-on-one religious instruction of boys preparing for bar mitzvah",
"abuse in synagogue settings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kings County Supreme Court, New York, USA",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2009-01-01",
"outcome": "Yona Weinberg, a Flatbush bar-mitzvah tutor and social worker, was convicted in 2009 on multiple counts of second-degree sexual abuse and child endangerment against two boys under fourteen whom he tutored, serving thirteen months and registering as a Level 3 offender. In 2014, when police came to arrest him on a new complaint involving an eleven-year-old at a Brooklyn synagogue, he had already fled to Israel; that later charge is unadjudicated and is not asserted here."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Bar-mitzvah tutoring is religious instruction: boys were alone with a man whose role in their religious coming-of-age gave him standing no ordinary tutor would have.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://forward.com/life/320565/what-happens-to-sex-offenders-who-run-to-israel/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Forward: 'What happens to sex offenders who run to Israel?'.",
"body": "Documents the 2009 conviction, sentence, offender level and flight.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2018/03/28/ny/israeli-court-ruling-could-limit-warnings-against-convicted-abusers",
"archive": "",
"citation": "JTA, 28 Mar. 2018.",
"body": "Corroborates the conviction in later legal coverage.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://forward.com/life/320565/what-happens-to-sex-offenders-who-run-to-israel/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8d4511aaa34e8eaf142643f3b91f10bf0b30e7be5a7a95a117b37a3a8a617338",
"final_url": "https://forward.com/life/320565/what-happens-to-sex-offenders-who-run-to-israel/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2018/03/28/ny/israeli-court-ruling-could-limit-warnings-against-convicted-abusers",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b19695cde5bf078d7d154723b917deb158dc21260cbfdb49708223938beaf949",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2018/03/28/ny/israeli-court-ruling-could-limit-warnings-against-convicted-abusers"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 531,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The criminal disposition is stated exactly — misdemeanor endangerment, no registration — and is not inflated; the civil settlement is documented separately. Distinct person from Yosef Kolko of Lakewood.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-joel-kolko-torah-temimah-brooklyn-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Brooklyn, New York, USA",
"lat": 40.644,
"lng": -73.972,
"title": "United States: yeshiva rebbe's misdemeanor plea — and the $2.1 million settlement his yeshiva paid",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"longtime elementary rebbe at Yeshiva Torah Temimah"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rebbe's authority over six-year-old students",
"documented communal pressure on victims' families that collapsed the felony case"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Yeshiva Torah Temimah, Kensington, Brooklyn"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kings County, New York, USA",
"stage": "misdemeanor guilty plea; civil settlement by the yeshiva",
"date": "2012-01-01",
"outcome": "Joel (Yehuda) Kolko, a rebbe at Yeshiva Torah Temimah for decades, pleaded guilty in 2012 to two misdemeanor counts of child endangerment — no jail, three years' probation, no sex-offender registration — after felony sexual-abuse charges collapsed amid documented community pressure on the victims' families. In 2014 the yeshiva agreed to pay $2.1 million to two former students abused at age six, a settlement that surfaced when the school failed to pay and was sued."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Six-year-olds under their rebbe. The record's weight sits in the gap it documents: a core-nexus case reduced to misdemeanors by communal pressure, with the institution's own seven-figure settlement standing as the fuller account.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://forward.com/fast-forward/352583/in-a-first-a-brooklyn-yeshiva-agrees-to-21-million-child-sex-abuse-settleme/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Forward: 'In a first, a Brooklyn yeshiva agrees to $2.1 million child sex abuse settlement'.",
"body": "Documents the settlement and the criminal disposition.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "civil-settlement-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2008/04/18/ny/no-sex-charge-for-kolko-boys-parents-foiled-by-da-2",
"archive": "",
"citation": "JTA: 'No sex charge for Kolko boy's parents — foiled by DA'.",
"body": "Documents the pressure dynamics around the prosecution.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "case-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://forward.com/fast-forward/352583/in-a-first-a-brooklyn-yeshiva-agrees-to-21-million-child-sex-abuse-settleme/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-settlement-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "84e8719bbb2293ddbe01e6294c3e677da86be01e32bc38cf8ab8c2411627f40b",
"final_url": "https://forward.com/fast-forward/352583/in-a-first-a-brooklyn-yeshiva-agrees-to-21-million-child-sex-abuse-settleme/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2008/04/18/ny/no-sex-charge-for-kolko-boys-parents-foiled-by-da-2",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: case-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "45ee3a54d7265f3c806dc51f12c752ee95c11ddcc3819799d5a2be1c8d5e4c60",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2008/04/18/ny/no-sex-charge-for-kolko-boys-parents-foiled-by-da-2"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 532,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2014-05-01",
"note": "Appeal rejected; conviction and 24-year sentence stand."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The mother's and followers' convictions are recorded within the same doctrinal structure, not apart from it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-elior-chen-jerusalem-israel",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Jerusalem, Israel",
"lat": 31.7683,
"lng": 35.2137,
"title": "Israel: 'rabbi' Elior Chen — 24 years for torturing a follower's children, upheld by the Supreme Court",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled rabbi with total spiritual direction over a follower family"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"'purification' doctrine ordering beatings of the children",
"mother's absolute obedience to his direction",
"followers deployed as instruments of the abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jerusalem District Court; Supreme Court of Israel",
"stage": "conviction; appeal rejected",
"date": "2010-11-01",
"outcome": "Elior Chen, a self-styled rabbi, was convicted in November 2010 of abusing and ordering his followers to abuse eight children of a follower-mother — beatings with hammers and clubs, burning, confinement in a suitcase — leaving one child in a permanent vegetative state. Extradited back from Brazil, he was sentenced in February 2011 to 24 years plus damages; the Supreme Court rejected his appeal in May 2014. The mother received five years and four followers up to twenty years each."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were delivered to the abuse solely because their mother was under his spiritual direction — his word reorganised an entire household into an instrument of torture.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2011/02/28/israel/abusive-rabbi-sentenced-to-24-years-in-prison",
"archive": "",
"citation": "JTA, 28 Feb. 2011.",
"body": "Wire report of the sentence.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.jpost.com/National-News/Supreme-Court-rejects-appeal-of-child-abuser-rabbi-351646",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Jerusalem Post: 'Supreme Court rejects appeal of child abuser rabbi'.",
"body": "Reports the final appellate disposition.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2014-05-01",
"note": "Appeal rejected; conviction and 24-year sentence stand."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2011/02/28/israel/abusive-rabbi-sentenced-to-24-years-in-prison",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "323f87606f1433c8f8fdd32f8038791e24e87a7835e40f44736b37326347d77a",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2011/02/28/israel/abusive-rabbi-sentenced-to-24-years-in-prison"
},
{
"source": "https://www.jpost.com/National-News/Supreme-Court-rejects-appeal-of-child-abuser-rabbi-351646",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c035af7b8a1a91a4ef08e817641c3343b85193095b6746766815ac7b58ab9305",
"final_url": "https://www.jpost.com/national-news/supreme-court-rejects-appeal-of-child-abuser-rabbi-351646"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 533,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Both dispositions were pleas; sentences are stated exactly, including the early health-grounds release from the first.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-eliezer-berland-shuvu-bonim-jerusalem-israel",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Jerusalem, Israel",
"lat": 31.78,
"lng": 35.22,
"title": "Israel: Shuvu Bonim leader Eliezer Berland — convictions for indecent acts and for selling 'blessings' to the sick",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader of the Shuvu Bonim Breslov community, venerated by followers as a holy man"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru-grade veneration by followers",
"sale of 'blessings' and 'cures' to the sick and elderly"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"healing-treatment",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [
"Shuvu Bonim (Breslov)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jerusalem Magistrate's Court, Israel",
"stage": "two separate convictions on plea — both stand",
"date": "2016-11-01",
"outcome": "Eliezer Berland, leader of the Shuvu Bonim Breslov community, was convicted on plea in November 2016 of two counts of indecent acts and one of assault against female followers, receiving 18 months including time served after years as a fugitive across four countries. In June 2021 he was convicted again on plea — fraud, exploitation and money laundering for selling 'blessings' and 'cures' to sick and elderly followers — receiving a further 18 months. Both convictions stand; later cold-case questioning produced no charges and is not asserted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Women who could not refuse a man their community venerated as holy, and sick followers who paid for his blessings — sexual and financial exploitation running on the same authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/sex-offender-rabbi-who-defrauded-followers-gets-18-months-in-plea-deal-report/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel on the 2016 plea and sentence.",
"body": "Reports the first conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/followers-mass-outside-prison-as-sex-offender-rabbi-set-to-start-sentence/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel on the 2021 fraud sentence.",
"body": "Reports the second conviction and imprisonment.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/sex-offender-rabbi-who-defrauded-followers-gets-18-months-in-plea-deal-report/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b11c07714beb08bfcdcebb0816745c46719aad42feb7577bf908ba006b1a1c9d",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/sex-offender-rabbi-who-defrauded-followers-gets-18-months-in-plea-deal-report/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/followers-mass-outside-prison-as-sex-offender-rabbi-set-to-start-sentence/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "834144888616c2ee13f07572f038b50bdb2a88143a2850b3ba4b04522da86216",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/followers-mass-outside-prison-as-sex-offender-rabbi-set-to-start-sentence/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 534,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The surviving victims, Dassi Erlich and Elly Sapper, have long campaigned publicly under their own names; the third sister's counts ended in acquittal and are not asserted. No Victorian appellate decision has been located; headlines about rejected 'Leifer appeals' concern the Israeli extradition litigation, not the conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-malka-leifer-adass-israel-melbourne-australia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Melbourne, Australia",
"lat": -37.885,
"lng": 145.004,
"title": "Australia: Malka Leifer, ultra-Orthodox school principal, convicted of raping students after a 15-year extradition fight",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"principal of the Adass Israel School, Melbourne"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"principal's total religious-educational authority in an insular community",
"victims' sheltered upbringing leaving them without words for what was done"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Adass Israel School, Melbourne"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Australia",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence after extradition from Israel",
"date": "2023-04-03",
"outcome": "Malka Leifer, principal of Melbourne's Adass Israel School, fled to Israel in 2008 as allegations surfaced; after a fifteen-year extradition saga she was returned in January 2021 and convicted by a County Court of Victoria jury on 3 April 2023 of eighteen charges including rape against two sisters who had been her students. In August 2023 she was sentenced to 15 years, with a non-parole period of eleven and a half."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Students of an insular ultra-Orthodox school under its principal — the sisters' testimony described an upbringing so sheltered they lacked the vocabulary to name the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.countycourt.vic.gov.au/news-and-media/news-listing/2023-08-24-sentencing-remarks-dpp-v-leifer",
"archive": "",
"citation": "County Court of Victoria: sentencing remarks, DPP v Leifer, 24 Aug. 2023.",
"body": "The court's own sentencing remarks.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "sentencing-remarks"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/malka-leifer-sentenced-to-15-years-for-sexual-abuse-of-two-students/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel: 'Malka Leifer sentenced to 15 years'.",
"body": "Independent report of the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.countycourt.vic.gov.au/news-and-media/news-listing/2023-08-24-sentencing-remarks-dpp-v-leifer",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: sentencing-remarks.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "41877a8ad090d93e88c2ad3088223805ba20d94da36ead4f1a9479abce0e6a3e",
"final_url": "https://www.countycourt.vic.gov.au/news-and-media/news-listing/2023-08-24-sentencing-remarks-dpp-v-leifer"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/malka-leifer-sentenced-to-15-years-for-sexual-abuse-of-two-students/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a9606137c69bfd3b8e30fbd45e9f7c97e110412b82f29fd2b671657fcc9c2840",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/malka-leifer-sentenced-to-15-years-for-sexual-abuse-of-two-students/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 535,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The sentence's leniency is recorded plainly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-moti-elon-yeshivat-hakotel-jerusalem-israel",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Jerusalem, Israel",
"lat": 31.775,
"lng": 35.21,
"title": "Israel: Moti Elon — leading religious-Zionist rabbi convicted of indecent acts against a minor student",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"head of Yeshivat HaKotel; one of religious Zionism's most revered teachers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual counsel sought by a minor student",
"national religious stature that made accusation nearly unthinkable"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Yeshivat HaKotel, Jerusalem"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jerusalem Magistrate's Court, Israel",
"stage": "conviction; no appeal filed — final",
"date": "2013-08-07",
"outcome": "Mordechai 'Moti' Elon, head of Yeshivat HaKotel and among religious Zionism's most influential rabbis, was convicted on 7 August 2013 of indecent acts by force against a male minor who had come to him for guidance, and sentenced in December 2013 to a fifteen-month suspended term, six months' community service and compensation. He announced in February 2014 that he would not appeal, making the conviction final. Later reported admissions of further misconduct were never charged and are not asserted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A boy seeking his revered teacher's guidance — the classic counsel-seeking nexus, at the summit of a national religious movement.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2013/08/07/israel/rabbi-motti-elon-found-guilty-of-sexual-misconduct",
"archive": "",
"citation": "JTA, 7 Aug. 2013.",
"body": "Wire report of the verdict.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.jpost.com/National-News/Rabbi-Moti-Elon-not-appealing-conviction-of-sexual-assault-on-minor-340128",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Jerusalem Post: Elon not appealing.",
"body": "Confirms finality.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-update"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2013/08/07/israel/rabbi-motti-elon-found-guilty-of-sexual-misconduct",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0cfa6e932f42f558e584a83bfcc538c18dbf98b32cef235b3ae7a747c476b78a",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2013/08/07/israel/rabbi-motti-elon-found-guilty-of-sexual-misconduct"
},
{
"source": "https://www.jpost.com/National-News/Rabbi-Moti-Elon-not-appealing-conviction-of-sexual-assault-on-minor-340128",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-update.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "57a3495c711fb98cbead2be820fa565c5a579d68b4b0770aee128ba4468694c7",
"final_url": "https://www.jpost.com/national-news/rabbi-moti-elon-not-appealing-conviction-of-sexual-assault-on-minor-340128"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 536,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate-division",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Plea-withdrawal denial affirmed (State v. Kolko, A-1561-13)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Distinct person from Joel Kolko of Brooklyn — the same-surname confusion is flagged in both records.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-yosef-kolko-lakewood-nj-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Lakewood, New Jersey, USA",
"lat": 40.0821,
"lng": -74.2097,
"title": "United States: Lakewood yeshiva teacher's 15-year sentence — and the communal campaign against his victim's family",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"yeshiva teacher and camp counselor (Yeshiva Bais Hatorah camp)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teacher-counselor authority over a boy in his charge",
"documented communal intimidation of the victim's family for going to secular authorities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Yeshiva Bais Hatorah, Lakewood"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ocean County Superior Court, New Jersey; NJ Appellate Division",
"stage": "mid-trial guilty plea; plea-withdrawal denied and affirmed",
"date": "2013-05-01",
"outcome": "Yosef Kolko, a yeshiva teacher and camp counselor in Lakewood, pleaded guilty mid-trial in May 2013 to aggravated sexual assault and related counts against a boy in his charge (2008–09) and was sentenced in October 2013 to 15 years. He later sought to withdraw the plea claiming community pressure had driven it; the trial court refused and the Appellate Division affirmed in 2016. The victim's family was subjected to documented communal intimidation for reporting to secular authorities."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A boy under his religious teacher and camp counselor — with the community's punishment of the reporting family documented in the court record itself.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/new-jersey/appellate-division-unpublished/2016/a1561-13.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Kolko, NJ App. Div. (A-1561-13, 2016).",
"body": "The appellate opinion affirming the plea's validity.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2013/09_10/2013_10_18_Hopkins_FormerOrthodox.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Asbury Park Press, 18 Oct. 2013 (archived).",
"body": "Contemporaneous sentencing report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate-division",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Plea-withdrawal denial affirmed (State v. Kolko, A-1561-13)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/new-jersey/appellate-division-unpublished/2016/a1561-13.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2013/09_10/2013_10_18_Hopkins_FormerOrthodox.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1ace227ca7bcffe32d8e6533d90b0aece3b8fe5100b2f47615b8de3e4982b10b",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2013/09_10/2013_10_18_Hopkins_FormerOrthodox.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 537,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Appellate status was not located and is flagged rather than asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-stephen-schacter-eitz-chaim-toronto-canada",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Toronto, Ontario, Canada",
"lat": 43.6532,
"lng": -79.3832,
"title": "Canada: Orthodox day-school teacher convicted of decades-spanning abuse of students",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teacher at Eitz Chaim Schools (1986–2004) and supply teacher at Yeshiva Yesodei HaTorah"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teacher's authority over Orthodox day-school students across two decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Eitz Chaim Schools, Toronto",
"Yeshiva Yesodei HaTorah, Toronto"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Canada",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2018-11-01",
"outcome": "Stephen Schacter, a teacher at Toronto's Eitz Chaim Schools for nearly two decades and later a supply teacher at Yeshiva Yesodei HaTorah, was convicted in November 2018 of three counts of sexual assault, two of sexual interference and one of gross indecency against student victims (offences 1982–2002, one boy abused dozens of times at ages eleven to thirteen), with a separate 2018 child-pornography conviction, and was sentenced in 2019 to five years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Students of Orthodox day schools under their teacher — the same pattern as the corpus's Melbourne Yeshivah records.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/ex-teacher-at-2-toronto-jewish-day-schools-convicted-of-sex-offenses/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel: 'Ex-teacher at 2 Toronto Jewish day schools convicted of sex offenses'.",
"body": "Report of the conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/why-sex-assault-charges-against-a-toronto-teacher-took-20-years/article30112686/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Globe and Mail: 'Why sex assault charges against a Toronto teacher took 20 years'.",
"body": "National paper of record's investigation of the case's history.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/ex-teacher-at-2-toronto-jewish-day-schools-convicted-of-sex-offenses/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f3aa5a64bb4a931e5f4642b8c79037944beef9e5c9b26cf6b9c21b8db8a7b389",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/ex-teacher-at-2-toronto-jewish-day-schools-convicted-of-sex-offenses/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/why-sex-assault-charges-against-a-toronto-teacher-took-20-years/article30112686/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "25effd17f17c635e854f12844a5396708828c5275ec6d6f74147ecccec437bf9",
"final_url": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/why-sex-assault-charges-against-a-toronto-teacher-took-20-years/article30112686/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 538,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "mahkamah-agung",
"date": "",
"note": "Kasasi rejected — final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The precise first-instance verdict date was not pinned; the appellate chain (banding, then kasasi rejected) is documented by Detik's court reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-muhammad-tazqiran-pesantren-lombok-tengah-indonesia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Pringgarata, Lombok Tengah, Indonesia",
"lat": -8.6333,
"lng": 116.2,
"title": "Indonesia: pesantren leader's 15-year sentence for raping a santriwati — final at the Supreme Court",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pimpinan (leader) of a pesantren in Pringgarata"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential religious school's total authority over a santriwati"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Praya; Mahkamah Agung, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction; kasasi rejected — final",
"date": "",
"outcome": "Muhammad Tazqiran, leader of a pesantren in Pringgarata, Central Lombok, was convicted of sexual intercourse with a minor santriwati and sentenced to 15 years by the Praya district court; his appeal failed and the Supreme Court rejected his kasasi, making the 15-year sentence final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A resident student under her pesantren's leader — the institution's head held both religious and custodial power over her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8342117/ma-tolak-kasasi-pimpinan-ponpes-di-lombok-tengah-yang-setubuhi-santriwati",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik: 'MA tolak kasasi pimpinan ponpes di Lombok Tengah'.",
"body": "Reports the Supreme Court's rejection of the final appeal.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8039999/divonis-15-tahun-pimpinan-ponpes-cabuli-santriwati-di-lombok-ajukan-banding",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik: the 15-year verdict and banding.",
"body": "Reports the sentence and intermediate appeal.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "mahkamah-agung",
"date": "",
"note": "Kasasi rejected — final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8342117/ma-tolak-kasasi-pimpinan-ponpes-di-lombok-tengah-yang-setubuhi-santriwati",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "50c6f6db1cdc058908d1d3b7bbb347a7f8cded81b6819c87e79f9e3f6266bceb",
"final_url": "https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8342117/ma-tolak-kasasi-pimpinan-ponpes-di-lombok-tengah-yang-setubuhi-santriwati"
},
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8039999/divonis-15-tahun-pimpinan-ponpes-cabuli-santriwati-di-lombok-ajukan-banding",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "460fde4273caa68b5b617448b5de6d7dc3e7aff229ee5aad42fe1c24de583f35",
"final_url": "https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8039999/divonis-15-tahun-pimpinan-ponpes-cabuli-santriwati-di-lombok-ajukan-banding"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 539,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. First-instance; appeal status not reported.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-ahmad-faisal-pesantren-lombok-barat-indonesia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Lombok Barat, Indonesia",
"lat": -8.65,
"lng": 116.1,
"title": "Indonesia: pesantren leader convicted over abuse of at least 22 santriwati across seven years",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pimpinan of a Lombok Barat pesantren"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"promises of spiritual blessings to victims",
"the boarding school's closed structure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Mataram, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence on two dossiers",
"date": "2026-02-05",
"outcome": "Ahmad Faisal, leader of a pesantren in West Lombok, was convicted on 5 February 2026 across two dossiers — sexual harassment and intercourse with minors — and sentenced to a combined 16 years plus fines, for abusing at least 22 santriwati between 2016 and 2023, promising victims spiritual blessings. The case broke after santriwati recognised their situation in the Malaysian film 'Bidaah'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Two dozen girls under one religious leader, held in place for seven years by blessing-promises and the boarding school's closed world.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mataram.antaranews.com/berita/529630/lecehkan-santriwati-pimpinan-ponpes-lombok-barat-divonis-16-tahun",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Antara Mataram: 'Lecehkan santriwati, pimpinan ponpes Lombok Barat divonis 16 tahun'.",
"body": "The national news agency's court report.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://voi.id/en/news/556976",
"archive": "",
"citation": "VOI English report.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mataram.antaranews.com/berita/529630/lecehkan-santriwati-pimpinan-ponpes-lombok-barat-divonis-16-tahun",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "55d3ec09433dd392bcbd492fe14131de0a400f0cc54416b4a344d24214f86854",
"final_url": "https://mataram.antaranews.com/berita/529630/lecehkan-santriwati-pimpinan-ponpes-lombok-barat-divonis-16-tahun"
},
{
"source": "https://voi.id/en/news/556976",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b3ad9b38f464f231e918bb725013b1977c868928a9aef8c85705a5baa48d076b",
"final_url": "https://voi.id/en/news/556976"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 540,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "pengadilan-tinggi",
"date": "2025",
"note": "15 years affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-achmad-labib-pesantren-magelang-indonesia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Magelang, Central Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.5449,
"lng": 110.265,
"title": "Indonesia: pesantren head's 15-year sentence for abusing four santriwati affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"head of Ponpes Irsyadul Mubtadi'ien"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the court's own finding that he 'misused his position and the trust placed in him'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Ponpes Irsyadul Mubtadi'ien, Kab. Magelang"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Mungkid; Pengadilan Tinggi Jawa Tengah",
"stage": "conviction; affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2025-02-03",
"outcome": "Achmad Labib, head of Ponpes Irsyadul Mubtadi'ien in Magelang regency, was sentenced on 3 February 2025 to 15 years plus restitution for sexually abusing four santriwati between December 2022 and March 2024; the Central Java high court affirmed the 15-year sentence on appeal, the court finding he had misused his position and the trust placed in him."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Resident students under the pesantren head — the appellate court's trust-misuse language states the criterion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://dandapala.com/article/detail/terbukti-lecehkan-4-santriwati-pimpinan-pondok-pesantren-diganjar-15-tahun-penjara",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dandapala (Mahkamah Agung media).",
"body": "The judiciary's own media on the conviction.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://radarmagelang.jawapos.com/mungkid/685873279/pengadilan-tinggi-jateng-putuskan-vonis-15-tahun-penjara-pada-terdakwa-pengasuh-pondok-pesantren-yang-cabuli-santriwati-di-magelang",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radar Magelang: PT Jateng affirms 15 years.",
"body": "Reports the appellate affirmation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "pengadilan-tinggi",
"date": "2025",
"note": "15 years affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://dandapala.com/article/detail/terbukti-lecehkan-4-santriwati-pimpinan-pondok-pesantren-diganjar-15-tahun-penjara",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5c2b5deb0a6c069c805159d4be1cc4c9f4d0f00ddd8842dbed1d941547603fc5",
"final_url": "https://dandapala.com/article/detail/terbukti-lecehkan-4-santriwati-pimpinan-pondok-pesantren-diganjar-15-tahun-penjara"
},
{
"source": "https://radarmagelang.jawapos.com/mungkid/685873279/pengadilan-tinggi-jateng-putuskan-vonis-15-tahun-penjara-pada-terdakwa-pengasuh-pondok-pesantren-yang-cabuli-santriwati-di-magelang",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4afdc6a55511f042f1e70427194add59ab9b2a4889a4a8aeea8a7d490c3d32b9",
"final_url": "https://radarmagelang.jawapos.com/mungkid/685873279/pengadilan-tinggi-jateng-putuskan-vonis-15-tahun-penjara-pada-terdakwa-pengasuh-pondok-pesantren-yang-cabuli-santriwati-di-magelang"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 541,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Single national-outlet source (Detik Jabar); first-instance; appeal status not reported.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-ruslan-abdul-gani-rumah-tahfidz-tasikmalaya-indonesia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Tasikmalaya, West Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.3506,
"lng": 108.2172,
"title": "Indonesia: head of a Quran-memorization house sentenced to 15 years for molesting his pupils",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"head of Rumah Tahfidz Darul Ilmi, Mangkubumi"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over children memorizing the Quran in his house"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Rumah Tahfidz Darul Ilmi, Tasikmalaya"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Tasikmalaya, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-08-21",
"outcome": "Ruslan Abdul Gani, head of the Darul Ilmi Quran-memorization house in Mangkubumi, Tasikmalaya, was sentenced on 21 August 2025 to 15 years plus a fine and restitution for molesting his santri."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children placed in a religious memorization house under its head's authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jabar/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8072350/cabuli-santri-ustaz-di-tasikmalaya-divonis-15-tahun-penjara",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik Jabar: 'Cabuli santri, ustaz di Tasikmalaya divonis 15 tahun penjara'.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jabar/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8072350/cabuli-santri-ustaz-di-tasikmalaya-divonis-15-tahun-penjara",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7de242e01f3debfd44e6283e8d4fd741434d3ca3c20e90f6d4681fbd3a0e70f5",
"final_url": "https://www.detik.com/jabar/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8072350/cabuli-santri-ustaz-di-tasikmalaya-divonis-15-tahun-penjara"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 542,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Sourced from the judiciary's own media (Dandapala); first-instance.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-ahmad-odih-zubaedi-pesantren-pandeglang-indonesia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Pandeglang, Banten, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.3086,
"lng": 106.1063,
"title": "Indonesia: kyai sentenced to 11 years for repeated abuse of three santriwati",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"kyai leading a Pandeglang pesantren"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious leader's standing over resident students across years of repeated acts"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Pandeglang, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "KH Ahmad Odih Zubaedi, 52, leader of a Pandeglang pesantren, was sentenced to 11 years for repeatedly abusing three santriwati between 2019 and 2023."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Three resident students under their kyai over four years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://dandapala.com/article/detail/cabuli-3-santriwati-pimpinan-pondok-pesanten-dipandeglang-dihukum-11tahunpenjara",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dandapala (Mahkamah Agung media): 11-year sentence for the Pandeglang pesantren leader.",
"body": "The judiciary's own media on the conviction.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://dandapala.com/article/detail/cabuli-3-santriwati-pimpinan-pondok-pesanten-dipandeglang-dihukum-11tahunpenjara",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dba79964a2413407c11661182262c9ef12508729fcb4fdaa80b7797984f0e6e3",
"final_url": "https://dandapala.com/article/detail/cabuli-3-santriwati-pimpinan-pondok-pesanten-dipandeglang-dihukum-11tahunpenjara"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 543,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant's full name is withheld in reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-mms-guru-ngaji-depok-indonesia",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Depok, West Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.4025,
"lng": 106.7942,
"title": "Indonesia: Quran teacher sentenced to 19 years for abusing ten pupils",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"guru ngaji (Quran teacher) at a Depok majelis taklim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious lessons as the site of access",
"small payments and threats to enforce silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Depok, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-08-01",
"outcome": "A 69-year-old Quran teacher, identified in reporting as MMS, was sentenced in August 2022 to 19 years for sexually abusing ten of his pupils, paying victims small sums and threatening them into silence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ten children whose parents sent them to learn the Quran — the lessons themselves were the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.liputan6.com/news/read/5033054/mms-terdakwa-oknum-guru-ngaji-cabuli-10-siswa-di-depok-divonis-19-tahun-penjara",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Liputan6: 'MMS, terdakwa oknum guru ngaji cabuli 10 siswa di Depok divonis 19 tahun penjara'.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-6214979/guru-ngaji-cabuli-10-santri-di-depok-divonis-19-tahun-bui",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik report.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.liputan6.com/news/read/5033054/mms-terdakwa-oknum-guru-ngaji-cabuli-10-siswa-di-depok-divonis-19-tahun-penjara",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b86eeed60755a52d72c133e901180dee36c4a6fe7151dde1ac50699b555bb843",
"final_url": "https://www.liputan6.com/news/read/5033054/mms-terdakwa-oknum-guru-ngaji-cabuli-10-siswa-di-depok-divonis-19-tahun-penjara"
},
{
"source": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-6214979/guru-ngaji-cabuli-10-santri-di-depok-divonis-19-tahun-bui",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "538149b3d33eb185194b6cbd47b2dea2304715b2593d443d0980489f312a71a6",
"final_url": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-6214979/guru-ngaji-cabuli-10-santri-di-depok-divonis-19-tahun-bui"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 544,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The prosecution's sentence appeal was pending at reporting time.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mahendra-guru-ngaji-ciputat-indonesia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Ciputat, Tangerang Selatan, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.31,
"lng": 106.75,
"title": "Indonesia: Quran teacher sentenced to 20 years for raping pupils under an 'aura-opening' ritual",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"guru ngaji in Ciputat"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"'membuka aura' (aura-opening) ritual pretext",
"religious-teacher standing since 2021"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Tangerang, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; prosecution seeking a higher term",
"date": "2025-07-02",
"outcome": "Mahendra, 40, a Quran teacher in Ciputat, was sentenced on 2 July 2025 to 20 years for raping five pupils and molesting two more under an 'aura-opening' ritual pretext running since 2021; prosecutors, who had sought life, announced an appeal to increase the sentence — an appeal that challenges the term, not the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The ritual pretext is the criterion in miniature: children submitted because their religious teacher told them the ritual required it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-7992958/mahenda-guru-ngaji-cabul-di-tangsel-divonis-20-tahun-jaksa-bakal-banding",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik: 'Mahendra, guru ngaji cabul di Tangsel divonis 20 tahun'.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-7992958/mahenda-guru-ngaji-cabul-di-tangsel-divonis-20-tahun-jaksa-bakal-banding",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f7e1a631e72c116abdea8497410b8d8ad1228dd69b63dcddcbcc062a4f972b5f",
"final_url": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-7992958/mahenda-guru-ngaji-cabul-di-tangsel-divonis-20-tahun-jaksa-bakal-banding"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 545,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victims are named as they are named throughout the public record. The 2025 parole is stated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-dimas-kanjeng-taat-pribadi-probolinggo-indonesia",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Probolinggo, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.7586,
"lng": 113.431,
"title": "Indonesia: Dimas Kanjeng convicted of murdering followers who threatened to expose his money-multiplying 'powers'",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"padepokan leader claiming supernatural money-multiplying powers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"followers' belief in his supernatural powers",
"killings of insiders who threatened exposure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Padepokan Dimas Kanjeng, Probolinggo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Kraksaan, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2017-08-01",
"outcome": "Dimas Kanjeng Taat Pribadi, whose Probolinggo padepokan drew thousands with claimed money-multiplying powers, was convicted on 1 August 2017 of the premeditated murders of two of his own followers, Abdul Ghani and Ismail Hidayah, who had threatened to expose the fraud, and sentenced to 18 years; a separate fraud conviction followed. He was paroled in 2025."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were his own followers, killed to protect the supernatural claim that bound the rest — belief was both the lure and the motive.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://jatim.antaranews.com/berita/202515/dimas-kanjeng-taat-pribadi-divonis-18-tahun-penjara",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Antara: 'Dimas Kanjeng Taat Pribadi divonis 18 tahun penjara'.",
"body": "The national news agency's court report.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7932651/7-fakta-dimas-kanjeng-taat-pribadi-kini-bebas-bersyarat",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik: parole facts recap.",
"body": "Documents the conviction history and 2025 parole.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-update"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://jatim.antaranews.com/berita/202515/dimas-kanjeng-taat-pribadi-divonis-18-tahun-penjara",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eeb251dd32facc53df7ed30e6fec40bffd512351909c9cadcfda7a28f5bb9ccc",
"final_url": "https://jatim.antaranews.com/berita/202515/dimas-kanjeng-taat-pribadi-divonis-18-tahun-penjara"
},
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7932651/7-fakta-dimas-kanjeng-taat-pribadi-kini-bebas-bersyarat",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-update.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "52eacb15c5df6cd5c7afd618561f3780beb58bd75392d32e04deba0355c881c1",
"final_url": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7932651/7-fakta-dimas-kanjeng-taat-pribadi-kini-bebas-bersyarat"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 546,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "mahkamah-agung",
"date": "2018",
"note": "Rulings left the cumulative sentences standing."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The per-case sentence architecture across the Mataram and Jakarta dossiers is reported inconsistently; this record asserts the convictions, the DNA finding, the ritual frame, and the approximate cumulative total, no more.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-gatot-brajamusti-padepokan-mataram-indonesia",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Mataram, Indonesia",
"lat": -8.5833,
"lng": 116.1167,
"title": "Indonesia: celebrity spiritual guru 'Aa Gatot' convicted of raping an underage follower in padepokan 'rituals'",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"celebrity spiritual guru; head of Padepokan Brajamusti"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"'sex rituals' framed as spiritual practice",
"victims drugged",
"guru veneration by an entertainment-world following"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Padepokan Brajamusti"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Indonesian courts (Mataram and South Jakarta dossiers); Mahkamah Agung",
"stage": "convictions final at the Supreme Court",
"date": "2018-01-01",
"outcome": "Gatot Brajamusti, the celebrity spiritual guru known as 'Aa Gatot', was convicted of raping an underage female follower — paternity confirmed by DNA — within padepokan 'rituals' in which victims were drugged, alongside drug offences; his cumulative sentences reached roughly twenty years after Supreme Court rulings in 2018. He admitted in court that 'sex rituals' occurred at the padepokan. He died in prison in November 2020."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A minor inside a guru's padepokan, assaulted within practices he framed as spiritual ritual — with his own courtroom admission of the ritual frame.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lifestyle.sindonews.com/read/225930/187/9-fakta-gatot-brajamusti-dari-guru-spiritual-hingga-vonis-20-tahun-penjara-1604934698?showpage=all",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sindonews: case-history recap of the convictions.",
"body": "National outlet's documentation of the conviction set.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tempo.co/hukum/gatot-brajamusti-akhirnya-akui-ada-ritual-seks-di-padepokan-1328825",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tempo: Gatot admits sex rituals at the padepokan.",
"body": "National magazine of record on the courtroom admission.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "mahkamah-agung",
"date": "2018",
"note": "Rulings left the cumulative sentences standing."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lifestyle.sindonews.com/read/225930/187/9-fakta-gatot-brajamusti-dari-guru-spiritual-hingga-vonis-20-tahun-penjara-1604934698?showpage=all",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "848966ab22526c567e2b9cbcecff90720a4586b8a6ca431189119dacb2715dda",
"final_url": "https://lifestyle.sindonews.com/read/225930/187/9-fakta-gatot-brajamusti-dari-guru-spiritual-hingga-vonis-20-tahun-penjara-1604934698?showpage=all"
},
{
"source": "https://www.tempo.co/hukum/gatot-brajamusti-akhirnya-akui-ada-ritual-seks-di-padepokan-1328825",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7f3f1b8ed124f002a4aba64bdcb19199e76292726c62174db9e564cf9b710554",
"final_url": "https://www.tempo.co/hukum/gatot-brajamusti-akhirnya-akui-ada-ritual-seks-di-padepokan-1328825"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 547,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Church bodies disputed his standing as a genuine religious brother; the record states the disputed status and rests the nexus on how he presented to the victims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-bruder-angelo-shelter-depok-indonesia",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Depok, West Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.394,
"lng": 106.823,
"title": "Indonesia: self-styled 'Bruder Angelo' sentenced to 14 years for abusing boys at his religious shelter",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled Catholic 'bruder' running a religious shelter for boys"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clergy-adjacent presentation that won families' and boys' trust",
"custodial control of shelter residents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Depok, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-01-20",
"outcome": "Lucas Lucky Ngalngola, who presented himself as Catholic religious brother 'Bruder Angelo' and ran a shelter-orphanage in Depok, was sentenced on 20 January 2022 to 14 years plus a fine for sexually abusing boys resident at the shelter."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "To the boys and their families he was clergy — the religious presentation created the custody, whatever the Church's registries said.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5906592/bruder-angelo-predator-seks-panti-asuhan-depok-divonis-14-tahun-bui",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik: 'Bruder Angelo, predator seks panti asuhan Depok, divonis 14 tahun bui'.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kompas.id/artikel/vonis-14-tahun-penjara-bagi-pelaku-pencabulan-anak-panti-asuhan-di-depok",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kompas.id report of the 14-year sentence.",
"body": "Paper-of-record corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5906592/bruder-angelo-predator-seks-panti-asuhan-depok-divonis-14-tahun-bui",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d8506eff702c4bc975bc7ba7be83d26cd26f0577abd1d62ab51040271c6b4233",
"final_url": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5906592/bruder-angelo-predator-seks-panti-asuhan-depok-divonis-14-tahun-bui"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kompas.id/artikel/vonis-14-tahun-penjara-bagi-pelaku-pencabulan-anak-panti-asuhan-di-depok",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a4814d1386bda63f9dfd61538fc96b92dd1363510aa175fdd4bf62576b7715b8",
"final_url": "https://www.kompas.id/artikel/vonis-14-tahun-penjara-bagi-pelaku-pencabulan-anak-panti-asuhan-di-depok"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 548,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The convicting tribunal's name is not stated in available coverage; the prosecuting Fiscalía unit is.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-edgar-ola-fernandez-guatemala-city-guatemala",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Guatemala City, Guatemala",
"lat": 14.67,
"lng": -90.49,
"title": "Guatemala: pastor convicted of producing child sexual-abuse material of a girl who came to him for help",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the 'Evangelio Completo' church, zona 18"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-leader standing over a fifteen-year-old in poverty who sought his help"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia Evangelio Completo, Santa Elena II, zona 18"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Guatemalan tribunal (Fiscalía contra la Trata de Personas prosecution)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-10-01",
"outcome": "Edgar Giovanni Ola Fernández, pastor of an 'Evangelio Completo' church in Guatemala City's zona 18, was sentenced on 1 October 2020 to seven non-commutable years plus a Q50,000 fine for producing child sexual-abuse material of a fifteen-year-old girl in poverty who had come to him for psychological and educational help."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A girl who came to a pastor for help, because he was a pastor.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.publinews.gt/gt/noticias/2020/10/04/guatemala-condena-pastor-evangelico-pornografia-infantil.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Publinews: conviction of the zona 18 pastor.",
"body": "National court reporting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.mp.gob.gt/noticia/dictan-condena-de-7-anos-de-prision-inconmutables-contra-pastor-evangelico-por-produccion-de-pornografia-infantil/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público release (indexed; intermittently unreachable).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's release.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "http://web.archive.org/web/20230322122920/https://www.mp.gob.gt/noticia/dictan-condena-de-7-anos-de-prision-inconmutables-contra-pastor-evangelico-por-produccion-de-pornografia-infantil/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público de Guatemala release, archived 22 Mar. 2023.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own release, recovered from the Wayback Machine after the live server became unreachable.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.publinews.gt/gt/noticias/2020/10/04/guatemala-condena-pastor-evangelico-pornografia-infantil.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8db2e63f9d3bd15a0c10fb9b679c39814684f9909dad7379bb71778200c4bafc",
"final_url": "https://www.publinews.gt/gt/noticias/2020/10/04/guatemala-condena-pastor-evangelico-pornografia-infantil.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.mp.gob.gt/noticia/dictan-condena-de-7-anos-de-prision-inconmutables-contra-pastor-evangelico-por-produccion-de-pornografia-infantil/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "http://web.archive.org/web/20230322122920/https://www.mp.gob.gt/noticia/dictan-condena-de-7-anos-de-prision-inconmutables-contra-pastor-evangelico-por-produccion-de-pornografia-infantil/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "27eab90c1cc53e848cbd7c447233668dbd2b56a0abf7f18932195f6159a687f7",
"final_url": "http://web.archive.org/web/20230322122920/https://www.mp.gob.gt/noticia/dictan-condena-de-7-anos-de-prision-inconmutables-contra-pastor-evangelico-por-produccion-de-pornografia-infantil/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 549,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Her defence publicly declined to appeal and no prosecution appeal was reported through mid-2026; formal entry into legal force was not separately confirmed. Kazakhstan's judicial-independence limits are noted; the facts are ordinary-criminal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-sulushash-kazbaeva-healer-aktobe-kazakhstan",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Aktobe, Kazakhstan",
"lat": 50.2839,
"lng": 57.167,
"title": "Kazakhstan: folk healer convicted of defrauding 136 clients of some 580 million tenge",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"folk healer (tselitelnitsa) with a large client following in Aktobe"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clients' belief in her healing powers",
"money taken for 'treatment' and mosque construction",
"loans signed in victims' names"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court No. 2 of Aktobe city, Kazakhstan",
"stage": "conviction and deferred sentence",
"date": "2025-10-07",
"outcome": "Sulushash Kazbaeva, a 51-year-old folk healer, was convicted on 7 October 2025 of large-scale fraud against 136 recognised victims — roughly 580 million tenge taken for 'treatment', her daughter's care and mosque construction, with loans signed in victims' names — and sentenced to six years and eight months, execution deferred two years for care of a disabled child, with restitution ordered."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A hundred and thirty-six people handed over money and signatures because they believed in her healing power — the belief was the instrument.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://diapazon.kz/news/134191-v-aktobe-celitelnicu-kotoruyu-sudili-za-moshennichestvo-vipustili-na-svobodu-v-zale-suda",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diapazon (Aktobe): court report of the verdict.",
"body": "Regional outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.inform.kz/ru/osuzhdennaya-lzhetselitelnitsa-iz-aktobe-osvobozhdena-v-zale-suda-ed0f6b",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Inform.kz: release in the courtroom; defence declines appeal.",
"body": "National agency corroboration with the no-appeal statement.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "disposition-update"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://diapazon.kz/news/134191-v-aktobe-celitelnicu-kotoruyu-sudili-za-moshennichestvo-vipustili-na-svobodu-v-zale-suda",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "17b0193f20c38f1203b1f26c192b94c34a731e6f9f0c8827fbb44ed53a43fb3f",
"final_url": "https://diapazon.kz/news/134191-v-aktobe-celitelnicu-kotoruyu-sudili-za-moshennichestvo-vipustili-na-svobodu-v-zale-suda"
},
{
"source": "https://www.inform.kz/ru/osuzhdennaya-lzhetselitelnitsa-iz-aktobe-osvobozhdena-v-zale-suda-ed0f6b",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: disposition-update.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0eaa4a565488c3a789d0ae927a6def5d83733cb633cbedf594a207a1cb51d647",
"final_url": "https://www.inform.kz/ru/osuzhdennaya-lzhetselitelnitsa-iz-aktobe-osvobozhdena-v-zale-suda-ed0f6b"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 550,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR KYRGYZSTAN. Corroborated across two independent Kyrgyz outlets (Kaktus.media and super.kg); appellate status unknown.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-nurseit-kalybay-uulu-madrasa-osh-kyrgyzstan",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Osh, Kyrgyzstan",
"lat": 40.514,
"lng": 72.816,
"title": "Kyrgyzstan: madrasa teacher sentenced to 15 years for raping a nine-year-old pupil",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teacher at the Kyrgyz-Turkish madrasa in Osh"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious teacher's authority over a nine-year-old pupil"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Kyrgyz-Turkish madrasa, Osh"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Osh City Court, Kyrgyzstan",
"stage": "conviction and sentence after a competency dispute",
"date": "2015-12-25",
"outcome": "Nurseit Kalybay uulu, a former teacher at the Kyrgyz-Turkish madrasa in Osh, was convicted in late December 2015 — the verdict publicly announced in January 2016, after a second psychiatric examination overturned an unfitness finding that had stalled the case for roughly three years — of sexual violence against a nine-year-old pupil (crime June 2012), and sentenced to 15 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A nine-year-old under his madrasa teacher.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://kaktus.media/doc/331868_ychitelu_medrese_v_oshe_za_iznasilovanie_9_letnego_malchika_dali_15_let.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kaktus.media: 'Учителю медресе в Оше за изнасилование 9-летнего мальчика дали 15 лет'.",
"body": "Bishkek outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://stats.super.kg/kabar/news/135871",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Super.kg court report (Kyrgyz).",
"body": "Independent Kyrgyz-language corroboration naming the court and judge.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://kaktus.media/doc/331868_ychitelu_medrese_v_oshe_za_iznasilovanie_9_letnego_malchika_dali_15_let.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "495b3a5404def966ba83b5aed25697d0f3dff419fe15597156932c230bab8636",
"final_url": "https://kaktus.media/doc/331868_ychitelu_medrese_v_oshe_za_iznasilovanie_9_letnego_malchika_dali_15_let.html"
},
{
"source": "https://stats.super.kg/kabar/news/135871",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 551,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The FGR is cited as source by the covering outlets; a live FGR release URL was not located and is not asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-misael-villalta-fundamento-eterno-comasagua-el-salvador",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Comasagua, La Libertad, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.635,
"lng": -89.367,
"title": "El Salvador: pastor sentenced to 20 years for raping a congregant child inside his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the 'Fundamento Eterno' church, Comasagua"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a congregant family's daughter",
"assaults inside the church itself"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia Fundamento Eterno, Comasagua"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Primero de Sentencia de Santa Tecla, El Salvador",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-11-04",
"outcome": "Misael Villalta, pastor of the 'Fundamento Eterno' church in Comasagua, La Libertad, was sentenced to 20 years for repeatedly raping a minor — the daughter of congregants — inside the church during 2019, in a prosecution by the Fiscalía's child-and-women's crimes unit at Santa Tecla."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A congregant child raped inside the church her family attended, by the man who led it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://croniosv.com/nacionales/judicial/pastor-viola-a-menor-de-edad-y-recibe-20-anos-de-prision-en-la-libertad/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cronio: 'Pastor viola a menor de edad y recibe 20 años de prisión en La Libertad', 4 Nov. 2020.",
"body": "Salvadoran court reporting citing the FGR.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://elblog.com/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-que-en-lugar-de-culto-le-quitaba-la-inocencia-a-una-nina-dentro-del-templo/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Blog: corroborating report.",
"body": "Independent Salvadoran corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://croniosv.com/nacionales/judicial/pastor-viola-a-menor-de-edad-y-recibe-20-anos-de-prision-en-la-libertad/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c1cecabd0bde42985566dd66e604bab8f0646e7ac3e23e268167a350f89f53f5",
"final_url": "https://croniosv.com/nacionales/judicial/pastor-viola-a-menor-de-edad-y-recibe-20-anos-de-prision-en-la-libertad/"
},
{
"source": "https://elblog.com/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-que-en-lugar-de-culto-le-quitaba-la-inocencia-a-una-nina-dentro-del-templo/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd9e82d5066b6cd309b523ec265815ca011b6a7507d570e2de77e82592e1d8f7",
"final_url": "https://elblog.com/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-que-en-lugar-de-culto-le-quitaba-la-inocencia-a-una-nina-dentro-del-templo/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 552,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "banding",
"date": "",
"note": "He declared an appeal in court; the appellate decision itself is unlocated, but prosecution records style the case inkracht (final) as of mid-2025."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victims are counted, not named, here. The Pengadilan Tinggi Semarang decision could not be retrieved (court database blocks automated access); finality rests on the documented death-row transfer and the prosecution's own inkracht listing, and the record flags that gap explicitly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-slamet-tohari-dukun-banjarnegara-indonesia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Banjarnegara, Central Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.3985,
"lng": 109.687,
"title": "Indonesia: 'Mbah Slamet' — death sentence for poisoning twelve clients of his money-multiplying ritual",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dukun offering supernatural money-multiplication ('penggandaan uang')"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clients' belief in his supernatural power over their money",
"ritual drinks administered mid-ceremony",
"killings of clients who demanded their money back"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Banjarnegara, Indonesia",
"stage": "death sentence; final per prosecution",
"date": "2024-02-01",
"outcome": "Slamet Tohari, the Banjarnegara dukun known as 'Mbah Slamet', promised clients supernatural money-multiplication, then poisoned at least twelve of them with potassium-cyanide 'ritual' drinks when they demanded their money back, burying the bodies on his land. On 1 February 2024 he was sentenced to death for premeditated murder, one judge dissenting for life. By October 2024 he had been transferred to Nusakambangan as a death-row convict, and by July 2025 the prosecution listed his case as having final legal force."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Every victim drank what he handed them because they believed in his power — the ritual was the murder weapon's delivery system.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kompas.id/baca/nusantara/2024/02/01/slamet-tohari-dukun-pembunuh-12-orang-di-banjarnegara-divonis-mati",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kompas.id: 'Slamet Tohari, dukun pembunuh 12 orang di Banjarnegara, divonis mati', 1 Feb. 2024.",
"body": "Paper-of-record report of the death sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jateng/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7583677/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik Jateng: transfer to Nusakambangan as 'terpidana mati', Oct. 2024.",
"body": "Documents the death-row transfer indicating the judgment's force.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-update"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "banding",
"date": "",
"note": "He declared an appeal in court; the appellate decision itself is unlocated, but prosecution records style the case inkracht (final) as of mid-2025."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kompas.id/baca/nusantara/2024/02/01/slamet-tohari-dukun-pembunuh-12-orang-di-banjarnegara-divonis-mati",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4d5ea700dba6aefcdb2c0558c00749f5477f2315b3f7ee8387852943300ede4c",
"final_url": "https://www.kompas.id/artikel/slamet-tohari-dukun-pembunuh-12-orang-di-banjarnegara-divonis-mati"
},
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jateng/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7583677/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-update.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 553,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Corroborated across three Aceh outlets; no appeal reported. Sharia-court (Mahkamah Syar'iyah) conviction — a distinct court system within Indonesia, recorded as such.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-yusri-suud-dayah-pidie-jaya-indonesia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Ulee Glee, Pidie Jaya, Aceh, Indonesia",
"lat": 5.15,
"lng": 96.05,
"title": "Indonesia (Aceh): dayah leader given the sharia maximum for raping seven boy santri",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pimpinan of Dayah Istiqamatuddin Miftahussalam"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"boys summoned to his room 'for massages'",
"residential dayah's total authority structure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Dayah Istiqamatuddin Miftahussalam, Ulee Glee"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mahkamah Syar'iyah Meureudu (Aceh sharia court), Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and maximum sentence",
"date": "2023-04-17",
"outcome": "Yusri Su'ud, leader of the Istiqamatuddin Miftahussalam dayah in Pidie Jaya, was convicted on 17 April 2023 under Aceh's Qanun Jinayat of raping and sodomising seven boy santri (2019–2021) whom he summoned to his room 'for massages', and sentenced to 200 months — the qanun maximum — plus restitution to the seven child victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Resident boys under their dayah's leader, in a system where a summons to the teungku's room could not be refused.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://popularitas.com/berita/sodomi-tujuh-santri-pimpinan-pesantren-di-pidie-jaya-divonis-200-bulan-penjara/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Popularitas: 200-month sentence for the Pidie Jaya dayah leader.",
"body": "Aceh outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://sinarpidie.co/news/teungku-hand-body-di-ulee-glee-divonis-200-bulan-penjara-dan-dihukum-membayar-restitusi-tujuh-korban-anak-ini-kata-lbh-banda-aceh/index.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sinar Pidie: detailed local report with restitution and LBH commentary.",
"body": "Independent local corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://popularitas.com/berita/sodomi-tujuh-santri-pimpinan-pesantren-di-pidie-jaya-divonis-200-bulan-penjara/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://sinarpidie.co/news/teungku-hand-body-di-ulee-glee-divonis-200-bulan-penjara-dan-dihukum-membayar-restitusi-tujuh-korban-anak-ini-kata-lbh-banda-aceh/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "575fb1abe311401fc24ef20ca2cb0f36c4d082b76f0ccb068f2be66a5318ef32",
"final_url": "https://sinarpidie.co/news/teungku-hand-body-di-ulee-glee-divonis-200-bulan-penjara-dan-dihukum-membayar-restitusi-tujuh-korban-anak-ini-kata-lbh-banda-aceh/index.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 554,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; the defendant's initials follow the reporting convention. The caning penalty is recorded as imposed, without endorsement. No appeal reported.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-mr-dayah-langsa-aceh-indonesia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Langsa, Aceh, Indonesia",
"lat": 4.4683,
"lng": 97.9683,
"title": "Indonesia (Aceh): dayah leader sentenced to 14 years and 150 cane strokes for raping a boy santri and a teacher",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dayah leader in Langsa"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over a resident child santri and over an adult teacher on his staff"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mahkamah Syar'iyah Langsa (Aceh sharia court), Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence exceeding the prosecution demand",
"date": "2024-02-07",
"outcome": "A dayah leader in Langsa, identified in reporting as MR, was convicted on 7 February 2024 under Aceh's Qanun Jinayat: 170 months' imprisonment for raping a minor santri, and separately 150 cane strokes for raping an adult female teacher at his dayah — a combined penalty exceeding the prosecution's demand."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both victims — a resident boy and a teacher on his own staff — sat under the dayah leader's religious authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ajnn.net/news/cabuli-santri-oknum-pimpinan-dayah-di-langsa-divonis-14-tahun-penjara/index.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "AJNN: the Langsa dayah leader's sentence.",
"body": "Aceh outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://independen.id/pelaku-kejahatan-seksual-berkedok-teungku-dayah-di-bumi-syariah",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Independen.id: long-form investigation of sexual crimes behind the teungku title in Aceh.",
"body": "Investigative corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ajnn.net/news/cabuli-santri-oknum-pimpinan-dayah-di-langsa-divonis-14-tahun-penjara/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b993ec18e05e41963793d40a65fddca08154a0b307a9d5a96b73931c5d5a37b3",
"final_url": "https://www.ajnn.net/news/cabuli-santri-oknum-pimpinan-dayah-di-langsa-divonis-14-tahun-penjara/index.html"
},
{
"source": "https://independen.id/pelaku-kejahatan-seksual-berkedok-teungku-dayah-di-bumi-syariah",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0b9b40618a3434b5a15001998d57d7858526d4ff3e3a7e06003b999d62af1e9a",
"final_url": "https://independen.id/pelaku-kejahatan-seksual-berkedok-teungku-dayah-di-bumi-syariah"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 555,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. No appeal reported.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-adri-dayah-padang-tiji-pidie-indonesia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Padang Tiji, Pidie, Aceh, Indonesia",
"lat": 5.4,
"lng": 95.9,
"title": "Indonesia (Aceh): dayah leader sentenced for molesting four santriwati",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dayah leader at Padang Tiji"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over resident girl students"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mahkamah Syar'iyah Sigli (Aceh sharia court), Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-10-04",
"outcome": "Adri, 38, a dayah leader in Padang Tiji, Pidie, was convicted on 4 October 2024 under Aceh's Qanun Jinayat of molesting four santriwati (December 2023–January 2024) and sentenced to 90 months, before a panel chaired by Diana Evrina Nasution."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Four resident girls under their dayah leader.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://gemasumatra.com/berita-aceh/pimpinan-dayah-lecehkan-4-santriwati-dihukum-90-bulan/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Gema Sumatra: 90-month sentence for the Padang Tiji dayah leader.",
"body": "Aceh outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://gemasumatra.com/berita-aceh/pimpinan-dayah-lecehkan-4-santriwati-dihukum-90-bulan/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 556,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "pengadilan-tinggi",
"date": "2026-02-26",
"note": "Affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant's initials follow the reporting convention.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-rr-pesantren-soreang-bandung-indonesia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Soreang, Bandung, West Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.03,
"lng": 107.52,
"title": "Indonesia: pesantren ustaz's 17-year sentence for assaulting eight santriwati affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ustaz at a Soreang pesantren"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the court's finding that he acted 'in his capacity as an educator' over resident girls"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Bale Bandung; Pengadilan Tinggi Bandung",
"stage": "conviction; affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2026-01-28",
"outcome": "An ustaz at a Soreang pesantren, identified in reporting as RR, 30, was sentenced on 28 January 2026 to 17 years plus a one-billion-rupiah fine and Rp 353.6 million restitution for sexually assaulting eight santriwati from May 2025; the Bandung high court affirmed the sentence on 26 February 2026 after he appealed for acquittal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Eight resident students assaulted by a man the court described as acting in his educator's capacity.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jabar/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8376863/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik Jabar: the Bale Bandung verdict and restitution.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jabar/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8377529/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik Jabar: PT Bandung affirmation.",
"body": "Reports the appellate outcome.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "pengadilan-tinggi",
"date": "2026-02-26",
"note": "Affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jabar/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8376863/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jabar/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8377529/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 557,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-eko-adi-saputra-dukun-kayu-agung-indonesia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Kayu Agung, South Sumatra, Indonesia",
"lat": -3.396,
"lng": 104.828,
"title": "Indonesia: dukun convicted of raping a client's daughter under a 'spirit marriage' ritual",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dukun ('orang pintar') consulted by the victim's family"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"haunting diagnosis of the family's shop",
"the girl prescribed as ritual 'intermediary'",
"'nikah batin' (spirit marriage) pretext and a 'magic drink'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Kayu Agung, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-11-06",
"outcome": "Eko Adi Saputra, a dukun consulted by a family over their 'haunted' shop, prescribed a ritual requiring their daughter as spiritual intermediary, then raped her under a 'nikah batin' (spirit-marriage) pretext with a 'magic drink'. On 6 November 2025 the Kayu Agung district court convicted him of physical sexual violence and sentenced him to 10 years plus a fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The family delivered their daughter into the ritual because the dukun's diagnosis said the spirits required it — belief supplied both the access and the silence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://kumparan.com/kumparannews/cabul-bermodus-nikah-batin-dukun-di-kayu-agung-dihukum-10-tahun-penjara-26CCFoktHnd",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kumparan: 'Cabul bermodus nikah batin, dukun di Kayu Agung dihukum 10 tahun penjara'.",
"body": "National outlet's court report with the verdict date.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.dandapala.com/article/detail/terbongkar-modus-nikah-batin-dukun-di-kayu-agung-divonis-10-tahun",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dandapala (Mahkamah Agung media).",
"body": "The judiciary's own media on the case.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://kumparan.com/kumparannews/cabul-bermodus-nikah-batin-dukun-di-kayu-agung-dihukum-10-tahun-penjara-26CCFoktHnd",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "818567cee74a1bfa729724ef6f946221ba8fd6cb8ea18bdd556b423c2f700dd3",
"final_url": "https://kumparan.com/kumparannews/cabul-bermodus-nikah-batin-dukun-di-kayu-agung-dihukum-10-tahun-penjara-26CCFoktHnd"
},
{
"source": "https://www.dandapala.com/article/detail/terbongkar-modus-nikah-batin-dukun-di-kayu-agung-divonis-10-tahun",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7ddb12abf34bc7fb038eaeebacdf64f04931429be974a9ec9d09945b2f033f7a",
"final_url": "https://www.dandapala.com/article/detail/terbongkar-modus-nikah-batin-dukun-di-kayu-agung-divonis-10-tahun"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 558,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. FIRST-INSTANCE, NON-FINAL: the appeal window was open at reporting time and the record is flagged for re-check. Russian judicial-independence limits are noted; the facts are ordinary-criminal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-oleg-garmash-school-of-life-krasnodar-russia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Krasnodar, Russia",
"lat": 45.0355,
"lng": 38.9753,
"title": "Russia: 'School of Life' founder sentenced to 20 years for exploiting followers under exorcism and divinity claims",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder of the 'Shkola Zhizni' (School of Life) sect, self-proclaimed god and exorcist"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"'demon-expulsion' framing of sexual coercion",
"two decades of control over roughly twenty-five followers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"'Shkola Zhizni' (School of Life), Krasnodar"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Prikubansky District Court, Krasnodar, Russia",
"stage": "first-instance conviction — not yet in legal force",
"date": "2026-06-25",
"outcome": "Oleg Garmash, founder of Krasnodar's 'School of Life' sect, who proclaimed himself a god and exorcist and controlled roughly twenty-five followers since 2005, was convicted on 25 June 2026 of raping two minors (2011–2014) and sexually coercing women followers under 'demon-expulsion' framing. He received 20 years in a strict-regime colony, three years' restriction of liberty, and a twenty-year ban on work with children. The verdict is not yet in legal force."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Followers — including children raised inside the group — under a man they were taught was divine, with 'exorcism' as the coercion's script.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://93.ru/text/criminal/2026/06/25/76498446/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "93.ru (Krasnodar): court report of the verdict.",
"body": "Regional outlet's detailed court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://kuban.aif.ru/incidents/criminal/ekzorcizm-cherez-postel-osnovatel-sekty-shkola-zhizni-osuzhden-na-20-let",
"archive": "",
"citation": "AiF Kuban: 'Экзорцизм через постель…'.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://93.ru/text/criminal/2026/06/25/76498446/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "566c8d94bab1e843c174c0e72f224350ae5aad59a5bef64e111d47c3f7e24875",
"final_url": "https://93.ru/text/criminal/2026/06/25/76498446/"
},
{
"source": "https://kuban.aif.ru/incidents/criminal/ekzorcizm-cherez-postel-osnovatel-sekty-shkola-zhizni-osuzhden-na-20-let",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1883b498796e546162abb5db58b71a27811ab56c5cb3cd4727abd309fd8c2ba9",
"final_url": "https://kuban.aif.ru/incidents/criminal/ekzorcizm-cherez-postel-osnovatel-sekty-shkola-zhizni-osuzhden-na-20-let"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 559,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The disposition's leniency is stated plainly; the separate sentencing hearing's exact date was not pinned and is not asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-aharon-ramati-beer-miriam-jerusalem-israel",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Jerusalem, Israel",
"lat": 31.772,
"lng": 35.205,
"title": "Israel: seminary 'cult' head convicted of holding women in slavery-like conditions",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-other",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"headmaster of the 'Be'er Miriam' women's seminary, Sha'arei Chesed"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"seminary structure recruiting young women into isolation from their families",
"religious-teacher authority over daily life, 2009–2015"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"'Be'er Miriam' seminary, Jerusalem"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jerusalem District Court, Israel",
"stage": "conviction on plea; agreed lenient sentence",
"date": "2024-02-21",
"outcome": "Aharon Ramati, headmaster of the 'Be'er Miriam' seminary — long described in Israeli reporting as a cult recruiting young women — was convicted on his plea on 21 February 2024 of holding persons in conditions of slavery, with eleven victims in the retained count out of roughly thirty women drawn into the seminary between 2009 and 2015. Under the plea arrangement he received about nine months of community service and ₪110,000 in compensation — a sentence widely criticised as lenient."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Young women recruited into a seminary whose head controlled their contact with the world — religious instruction as the architecture of captivity.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.haaretz.co.il/news/law/2024-02-21/ty-article/0000018d-cd4d-d914-a5ad-cf5f39860000",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Haaretz: conviction on plea, 21 Feb. 2024.",
"body": "Paper-of-record report of the conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ynetnews.com/article/hkcqzcxhp",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ynet: the Be'er Miriam case and disposition.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "case-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.haaretz.co.il/news/law/2024-02-21/ty-article/0000018d-cd4d-d914-a5ad-cf5f39860000",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.ynetnews.com/article/hkcqzcxhp",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: case-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "77cbf63cc841655fcc3cf273d5c8d004ea3d07137ead8c731749ca71cc363db3",
"final_url": "https://www.ynetnews.com/article/hkcqzcxhp"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 560,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "1925",
"note": "Affirmed (118 Kan. 641)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. Part of the corpus's 1925–1963 window, recovered through full-text appellate reporters after newspaper-archive channels failed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1925-john-waldron-great-bend-kansas-usa",
"year": 1925,
"place": "Great Bend, Kansas, USA",
"lat": 38.3645,
"lng": -98.7648,
"title": "United States (1925): Kansas pastor's statutory-rape conviction affirmed — victim 'whose spiritual mentor he was'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a leading Protestant church in Great Bend"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral supervision of a young congregant who was an officer of a church society under his direction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kansas Supreme Court (State v. Waldron, 118 Kan. 641, 236 P. 855)",
"stage": "conviction affirmed",
"date": "1925-01-01",
"outcome": "John Waldron, pastor of a leading Protestant church in Great Bend, was convicted on three counts of statutory rape of a girl under eighteen who, in the Kansas Supreme Court's own words, 'was a member of his church and was also an officer of one of the affiliated church societies under Waldron's supervision' — a young woman 'whose spiritual mentor he was'. The court affirmed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The opinion states the criterion in 1925 language: her spiritual mentor, her church-society supervisor.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/7956116/state-v-waldron/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Waldron, 118 Kan. 641, 236 P. 855 (Kan. 1925).",
"body": "The appellate opinion.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "1925",
"note": "Affirmed (118 Kan. 641)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/7956116/state-v-waldron/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/7956116/state-v-waldron/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 561,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "criminal-court-of-appeals",
"date": "1947",
"note": "Affirmed (84 Okla. Crim. 76). A separate earlier Cole conviction was reversed (83 Okla. Cr. 254) and is not asserted."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Only the affirmed 1947 conviction is asserted; the reversed companion case is documented as a trap.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1947-kenneth-cole-revival-major-county-oklahoma-usa",
"year": 1947,
"place": "Major County, Oklahoma, USA",
"lat": 36.2695,
"lng": -98.4798,
"title": "United States (1947): revival minister's conviction affirmed for abusing a boy entrusted by his mother",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"minister of the Gospel conducting a revival"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the mother's consent for the boy to stay overnight, obtained through his ministerial standing"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Oklahoma Criminal Court of Appeals (Cole v. State, 84 Okla. Crim. 76, 179 P.2d 176)",
"stage": "conviction affirmed",
"date": "1947-01-01",
"outcome": "Kenneth Isaac Cole, a minister conducting a revival in Major County, was convicted of sodomy against a fourteen-year-old boy whose family attended his revival services — he obtained the mother's consent for the boy to stay overnight with him — and sentenced to two and a half years. The appellate court affirmed in 1947."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A mother handed her son to the visiting revival minister overnight because of what he was — the trust was the office's.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4051849/cole-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cole v. State, 84 Okla. Crim. 76, 179 P.2d 176 (Okla. Crim. App. 1947).",
"body": "The appellate opinion.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "criminal-court-of-appeals",
"date": "1947",
"note": "Affirmed (84 Okla. Crim. 76). A separate earlier Cole conviction was reversed (83 Okla. Cr. 254) and is not asserted."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4051849/cole-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4051849/cole-v-state/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 562,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1948",
"note": "Misdemeanor counts affirmed; felony counts remanded — only the affirmed counts are asserted."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The disposition's precise shape (affirmed misdemeanors, remanded felonies) is stated exactly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1948-maurice-omoore-rector-chico-california-usa",
"year": 1948,
"place": "Chico, California, USA",
"lat": 39.7285,
"lng": -121.8375,
"title": "United States (1948): Chico rector's convictions affirmed for lewd acts against his guild boys and altar boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ordained minister and rector of a Chico church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"boys drawn into his guild, made altar boys and choir members"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California Court of Appeal, Third District (People v. O'Moore, 83 Cal. App. 2d 586)",
"stage": "misdemeanor convictions affirmed; felony counts remanded",
"date": "1948-03-08",
"outcome": "Maurice M. O'Moore, rector of a Chico church, was convicted on four counts of contributing to the delinquency of minors for lewd acts against boys aged fifteen to eighteen who, in the opinion's words, 'became members of his guild… became altar boys', one singing in the choir. The Court of Appeal affirmed the misdemeanor convictions (hearing denied by the state Supreme Court, March 1948); companion felony counts were remanded for lack of corroboration and are not asserted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The guild, the altar, the choir — the parish's own youth structures were the route to the boys.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/5800308/people-v-omoore/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. O'Moore, 83 Cal. App. 2d 586, 189 P.2d 554 (Cal. Ct. App. 1948).",
"body": "The appellate opinion.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1948",
"note": "Misdemeanor counts affirmed; felony counts remanded — only the affirmed counts are asserted."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/5800308/people-v-omoore/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/5800308/people-v-omoore/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 563,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "1948",
"note": "Affirmed (187 Tenn. 507)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. This 1948 Tennessee defendant is unrelated to Jane Whaley of the Word of Faith Fellowship, who has no conviction — the shared surname is flagged to prevent conflation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1948-whaley-baptist-lenoir-city-tennessee-usa",
"year": 1948,
"place": "Lenoir City, Tennessee, USA",
"lat": 35.7973,
"lng": -84.256,
"title": "United States (1948): Baptist pastor's abduction conviction affirmed — a church member 'considerably under his influence'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Baptist preacher, pastor of a church near Lenoir City"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral influence over a sixteen-year-old congregant, found expressly by the court"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tennessee Supreme Court (Whaley v. State, 187 Tenn. 507, 216 S.W.2d 17)",
"stage": "conviction affirmed",
"date": "1948-01-01",
"outcome": "A Baptist pastor near Lenoir City was convicted of abduction for concubinage of a sixteen-year-old girl and sentenced to up to eight years; the Tennessee Supreme Court affirmed, observing that 'she was a member of the defendant's church… she became infatuated with the defendant and must have been considerably under his influence'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's own finding does the work: a congregant girl under her pastor's influence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/8334569/whaley-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Whaley v. State, 187 Tenn. 507, 216 S.W.2d 17 (Tenn. 1948).",
"body": "The appellate opinion.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "1948",
"note": "Affirmed (187 Tenn. 507)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/8334569/whaley-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/8334569/whaley-v-state/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 564,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1951",
"note": "Affirmed (108 Cal. App. 2d 60)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1951-simpson-tidwell-turlock-california-usa",
"year": 1951,
"place": "Turlock, California, USA",
"lat": 37.4947,
"lng": -120.8466,
"title": "United States (1951): Turlock pastor's guilty plea to statutory rape of a congregant affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a Turlock church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing over a seventeen-year-old member of his church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California Court of Appeal, Third District (People v. Tidwell, 108 Cal. App. 2d 60)",
"stage": "guilty plea; judgment affirmed",
"date": "1951-01-01",
"outcome": "Simpson L. Tidwell pleaded guilty to statutory rape of a seventeen-year-old who, in the opinion's words, 'was, at the time of the commission of the offense, a member of the church of which defendant was then pastor in Turlock'; the Court of Appeal affirmed the judgment on his appeal from denial of plea withdrawal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The opinion itself places the victim in his congregation at the time of the offence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1188501/people-v-tidwell/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Tidwell, 108 Cal. App. 2d 60, 238 P.2d 21 (Cal. Ct. App. 1951).",
"body": "The appellate opinion.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1951",
"note": "Affirmed (108 Cal. App. 2d 60)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1188501/people-v-tidwell/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1188501/people-v-tidwell/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 565,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Sourced to the TRC's official appendix of convictions; the appendix does not state clergy versus lay status, and the record rests on church-institutional custody.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1945-ewald-holfeld-gordons-school-saskatchewan-canada",
"year": 1945,
"place": "Gordon's Reserve, Saskatchewan, Canada",
"lat": 51.3288,
"lng": -104.3355,
"title": "Canada (1945): Gordon's residential-school staff member convicted — documented by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"staff member at the Anglican-run Gordon's Indian Residential School"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total institutional custody of Indigenous children in a church-run school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Gordon's Indian Residential School (Anglican)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Canadian court (documented in TRC final-report appendix of convicted abusers)",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "1945-01-01",
"outcome": "Ewald Holfeld, a staff member at the Anglican-run Gordon's Indian Residential School in Saskatchewan, was convicted in 1945 on two counts of buggery, one of attempted buggery, and common assault against children of the school — one of the earliest convictions listed in the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's appendix of convicted residential-school abusers."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Indigenous children held in a church-run school's total custody — the same institutional-authority nexus as the corpus's Mount Cashel and Ryan Report records.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Final Report, Appendix 3 (convicted abusers).",
"body": "The commission's official listing of residential-school convictions.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-listing"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-listing.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b645911e247ea90cda934eb6e055c58ea1cd6d506341efaeeab0329d2153309f",
"final_url": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 566,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. TRC-appendix sourced; clergy-versus-lay status unstated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1947-william-mcnab-gordons-school-saskatchewan-canada",
"year": 1947,
"place": "Gordon's Reserve, Saskatchewan, Canada",
"lat": 51.335,
"lng": -104.34,
"title": "Canada (1947): second Gordon's residential-school conviction in the TRC's appendix",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"staff member at the Anglican-run Gordon's Indian Residential School"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total institutional custody of Indigenous children in a church-run school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Gordon's Indian Residential School (Anglican)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Canadian court (documented in TRC final-report appendix)",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "1947-01-01",
"outcome": "William McNab, a staff member at Gordon's Indian Residential School, was convicted of sodomy in 1947 — the school's second in-era conviction in the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's appendix, two years after Holfeld's."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The same church-school custody nexus, at the same institution, two years on — the pattern's persistence is the point.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Final Report, Appendix 3.",
"body": "The commission's official conviction listing.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-listing"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-listing.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b645911e247ea90cda934eb6e055c58ea1cd6d506341efaeeab0329d2153309f",
"final_url": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 567,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. TRC-appendix sourced; clergy-versus-lay status unstated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1960-james-ludford-edmonton-residential-school-canada",
"year": 1960,
"place": "Edmonton, Alberta, Canada",
"lat": 53.5461,
"lng": -113.4938,
"title": "Canada (1960): Edmonton residential-school conviction for gross indecency",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"staff member at the United Church-run Edmonton Indian Residential School"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total institutional custody of Indigenous children in a church-run school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Edmonton Indian Residential School (United Church)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Canadian court (documented in TRC final-report appendix)",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "1960-01-01",
"outcome": "James Ludford, a staff member at the United Church-run Edmonton Indian Residential School, was convicted of gross indecency in 1960, per the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's appendix of convicted abusers."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Church-school custody of Indigenous children — the mid-century continuation of the same institutional nexus.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Final Report, Appendix 3.",
"body": "The commission's official conviction listing.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-listing"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-listing.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b645911e247ea90cda934eb6e055c58ea1cd6d506341efaeeab0329d2153309f",
"final_url": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 568,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. TRC-appendix sourced; clergy-versus-lay status unstated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1963-robert-pooley-morley-residential-school-canada",
"year": 1963,
"place": "Morley, Alberta, Canada",
"lat": 51.1636,
"lng": -114.8531,
"title": "Canada (1963): Morley residential-school conviction for indecent assault",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"staff member at the United Church-run Morley Indian Residential School"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total institutional custody of Indigenous children in a church-run school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Morley Indian Residential School (United Church)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Canadian court (documented in TRC final-report appendix)",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "1963-01-01",
"outcome": "Robert G. Pooley, a staff member at the United Church-run Morley Indian Residential School in Alberta, was convicted of indecent assault in 1963, per the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's appendix — closing the corpus's 1925–1963 window at its far edge."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Church-school custody of Indigenous children.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Final Report, Appendix 3.",
"body": "The commission's official conviction listing.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-listing"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-listing.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b645911e247ea90cda934eb6e055c58ea1cd6d506341efaeeab0329d2153309f",
"final_url": "https://nevillepark.github.io/trc/appendix-3/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 569,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is named because the case is publicly known by his name through decades of Dutch investigative reporting; the convicted friars are unnamed in accessible sources. The castration is documented context, not an adjudicated count.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1956-harreveld-friars-heithuis-netherlands",
"year": 1956,
"place": "Harreveld, Netherlands",
"lat": 51.944,
"lng": 6.514,
"title": "Netherlands (1956): two friars convicted after a boarding-school pupil's complaint — the Heithuis case",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"friars of the Catholic boarding school at Harreveld"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional custody of a pupil in the friars' residential care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Catholic boarding school, Harreveld"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Dutch court, 1956",
"stage": "two clergymen convicted",
"date": "1956-01-01",
"outcome": "After pupil Henk Heithuis filed a criminal complaint on 30 January 1956 against friars of the Catholic boarding school at Harreveld for abuse suffered in 1951–53, two clergymen were convicted by a Dutch court that year. Heithuis himself was then castrated at church instigation — a fact documented in the reporting that followed the Deetman commission half a century later."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A pupil in the friars' residential care — and a church apparatus that punished the complainant more severely than the courts punished the convicted.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2012/03_04/2012_03_19_Waterfield_DutchRoman.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Telegraph (archived): Dutch Roman Catholic Church castration revelations, 19 Mar. 2012.",
"body": "Reports the 1956 convictions and the Heithuis case history from NRC Handelsblad's investigation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henk_Heithuis",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Henk Heithuis (case overview; lead index).",
"body": "Case chronology anchor — used as index alongside the press source.",
"tier": "reference-index",
"kind": "case-chronology"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2012/03_04/2012_03_19_Waterfield_DutchRoman.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bb3ee04949e166ee01d8731dd259e2f8df1975e31e0d97e6dd01c5917e21b162",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2012/03_04/2012_03_19_Waterfield_DutchRoman.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henk_Heithuis",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-index; evidentiary role: case-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "33d47da890948d0b70b727f5a318bf13bef02abafb913b1077913b3ae1e0e38f",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henk_Heithuis"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 570,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2022-09-21",
"note": "Affirmed (G.R. No. 201147) — final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The record is anchored to the Supreme Court's full-text decision; the congregation's exact locality is not stated in the accessible decision summary and the map point reflects the trial court's seat.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-freddie-sernadilla-wenceslao-fellowship-philippines",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Philippines",
"lat": 14.676,
"lng": 121.0437,
"title": "Philippines: pastor's rape conviction affirmed by the Supreme Court — assault in the pastoral house",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the Wenceslao Christian Fellowship"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"congregant family's trust placing the girl within the pastoral residence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Wenceslao Christian Fellowship"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Trial Court Br. 96 (2008); Court of Appeals (2011); Supreme Court of the Philippines (G.R. No. 201147, 21 Sep. 2022)",
"stage": "conviction affirmed at every level — final",
"date": "2008-01-01",
"outcome": "Freddie Sernadilla, pastor of the Wenceslao Christian Fellowship, raped a fourteen-year-old member of his church inside the pastoral house in October 2004. Convicted by the trial court in 2008 and affirmed by the Court of Appeals in 2011, the Supreme Court affirmed the rape conviction on 21 September 2022 — reclusion perpetua plus ₱225,000 in damages — while acquitting on two related child-protection counts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A congregant child inside the pastor's own residence — the pastoral house itself the scene.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocs/1/68624",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Sernadilla, G.R. No. 201147 (Supreme Court of the Philippines, 21 Sep. 2022).",
"body": "The Supreme Court's decision affirming the conviction.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "final-appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2022-09-21",
"note": "Affirmed (G.R. No. 201147) — final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocs/1/68624",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: final-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 571,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The in-absentia sentencing and outstanding warrant are stated plainly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-ravinesh-chand-hindi-christian-fellowship-nausori-fiji",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Nausori, Fiji",
"lat": -18.0333,
"lng": 178.5453,
"title": "Fiji: pastor sentenced in absentia to 14 years for raping a fifteen-year-old congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the Hindi Christian Fellowship Mission Church, Nausori"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a teenage member of his church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Hindi Christian Fellowship Mission Church, Nausori"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Fiji, Suva (Goundar J)",
"stage": "conviction; sentenced in absentia — fugitive",
"date": "2020-12-16",
"outcome": "Ravinesh Chand, pastor of the Hindi Christian Fellowship Mission Church in Nausori, was convicted of three counts of rape and one of sexual assault against a fifteen-year-old girl of his congregation. He absconded before sentencing; on 16 December 2020 the High Court sentenced him in absentia to 14 years with an eleven-year non-parole period — the judge calling his conduct 'disgraceful as a spiritual leader' — and a bench warrant remains outstanding. The conviction stands."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A church girl under her pastor; the flight changes his whereabouts, not the adjudication.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fijivillage.com/news/Nausori-Pastor-who-is-on-the-run-sentenced-to-14-years-imprisonment-for-rape-and-sexual-assault-r4x8f5/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fijivillage: 'Nausori pastor who is on the run sentenced to 14 years'.",
"body": "National outlet's sentencing report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fbcnews.com.fj/news/court/run-away-pastor-cops-14-years-for-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FBC News: 'Run-away pastor cops 14 years for rape'.",
"body": "Public broadcaster corroboration.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fijivillage.com/news/Nausori-Pastor-who-is-on-the-run-sentenced-to-14-years-imprisonment-for-rape-and-sexual-assault-r4x8f5/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "36e8365ff7d1da4e022201bf5ccd0ee184c47bb8633d9548bbc0a27f765bda37",
"final_url": "https://www.fijivillage.com/news/Nausori-Pastor-who-is-on-the-run-sentenced-to-14-years-imprisonment-for-rape-and-sexual-assault-r4x8f5/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fbcnews.com.fj/news/court/run-away-pastor-cops-14-years-for-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 572,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-jone-cokanauto-jezreel-lion-of-judah-suva-fiji",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Suva, Fiji",
"lat": -18.1416,
"lng": 178.4419,
"title": "Fiji: self-styled 'last prophet' convicted on all ten counts against four women of his prayer group",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader of the Jezreel Lion of Judah church, styling himself 'the last prophet' and claiming to be Jesus within the group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"death-and-sickness threats framed as spiritual consequence for disclosure",
"thirteen years of prophetic authority over the group's women"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Jezreel Lion of Judah, Suva"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Fiji, Suva",
"stage": "conviction on all counts and sentence",
"date": "2017-06-27",
"outcome": "Jone Cokanauto, leader of the Jezreel Lion of Judah church who styled himself 'the last prophet' and claimed to be Jesus within the group, was found guilty on all ten counts — rape, indecent assault and attempted rape — against four women members across thirteen years. Victims testified he told them they would sicken or die if they spoke. He was sentenced on 27 June 2017 to 20 years with a nineteen-year non-parole period."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Four women held silent for years by the belief that speaking against the prophet meant sickness or death — the threat was the doctrine.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/333899/fiji-pastor-jailed-for-20-years-for-rapes",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RNZ Pacific: 'Fiji pastor jailed for 20 years for rapes'.",
"body": "Regional public broadcaster's court report.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fijivillage.com/news/He-said-we-would-get-sick-or-die-if-we-said-anything-about-him--Alleged-rape-victim-in-Cokanauto-trial-92rk5s",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fijivillage trial coverage.",
"body": "Documents the spiritual-threat testimony.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/333899/fiji-pastor-jailed-for-20-years-for-rapes",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "68f5c16a5bd64ec75af85d2465140e5f5362d0d259a5ecfe754caabca7d84f74",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/333899/fiji-pastor-jailed-for-20-years-for-rapes"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fijivillage.com/news/He-said-we-would-get-sick-or-die-if-we-said-anything-about-him--Alleged-rape-victim-in-Cokanauto-trial-92rk5s",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "54167c8d6aee0120efd6e8f000500b79a195074c1127915301cb2237f43727b0",
"final_url": "https://www.fijivillage.com/news/He-said-we-would-get-sick-or-die-if-we-said-anything-about-him--Alleged-rape-victim-in-Cokanauto-trial-92rk5s"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 573,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The household-dependency element of the nexus is stated plainly alongside the pastoral office; the sentencing judgment is cited in full text.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-damien-don-assemblies-of-god-buvussi-png",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Buvussi, West New Britain, Papua New Guinea",
"lat": -5.5578,
"lng": 150.1494,
"title": "Papua New Guinea: Assemblies of God pastor sentenced for abusing a girl in his household care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Assemblies of God pastor at Buvussi"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the girl's residence in the pastor's household under his care",
"the trust-authority-dependency element of the charged offence itself"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Assemblies of God, Buvussi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "National Court of Papua New Guinea, Kimbe (Miviri J) — State v Don [2019] PGNC 23; N7689",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2019-02-15",
"outcome": "Damien Don, 49, Assemblies of God pastor at Buvussi, pleaded guilty to sexual penetration of a thirteen-year-old girl under section 229A(1)(3) — the aggravated form for breach of trust, authority or dependency — and was sentenced on 15 February 2019 to 14 years in hard labour, two suspended. The court's sentencing rationale rested on his position: 'a Pastor in Church, a man of God who has abused that position'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The girl lived in the pastor's household under his care — pastoral office and dependency compounding, as the charging statute itself recognises.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.paclii.org/pg/cases/PGNC/2019/23.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v Don [2019] PGNC 23; N7689 (National Court, Kimbe, 15 Feb. 2019).",
"body": "The sentencing judgment.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "sentencing-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.paclii.org/pg/cases/PGNC/2019/23.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 574,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2006-08-07",
"note": "Affirmed in full (39 Cal.4th 398)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual), not authority-abuse and NOT religious terrorism: the satanic apparatus was applied to the victims themselves — pentagrams drawn at scenes and on a victim's body, a victim compelled to swear on Satan during the attack. Ideological attacks on strangers or society over religion remain out of scope for this database. Victims are not identified except where already central to the public appellate record; no cult-network theory is asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1989-richard-ramirez-night-stalker-los-angeles-usa",
"year": 1989,
"place": "Los Angeles, California, USA",
"lat": 34.0522,
"lng": -118.2437,
"title": "United States: Richard Ramirez — satanic staging as an instrument of public terror",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none — the perpetrator held no authority over his victims"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pentagrams drawn at crime scenes and on a victim's body",
"a victim forced to 'swear on Satan' during the attack",
"courtroom displays of a palm pentagram and 'Hail Satan'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Los Angeles County Superior Court; Supreme Court of California (People v. Ramirez (2006) 39 Cal.4th 398)",
"stage": "conviction and death sentence; affirmed in full",
"date": "1989-09-20",
"outcome": "Richard Ramirez, the 'Night Stalker', was convicted on 20 September 1989 of thirteen murders, five attempted murders, and multiple counts of rape, sodomy, forcible oral copulation and first-degree burglary, and sentenced to death. The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in full in 2006. He died of natural causes in custody in 2013 with the sentence uncarried out and the conviction final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Ramirez held no spiritual authority over anyone; the satanic apparatus was aimed outward — pentagrams left at scenes, a victim compelled to swear on Satan, courtroom declarations — deployed to terrorise a city rather than to bind adherents.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ca-supreme-court/1098993.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Ramirez (2006) 39 Cal.4th 398, 139 P.3d 64 (Cal. Supreme Court).",
"body": "The appellate opinion affirming the judgment, recounting the trial record.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "final-appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "state-supreme-court",
"date": "2006-08-07",
"note": "Affirmed in full (39 Cal.4th 398)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ca-supreme-court/1098993.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: final-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fcf0193ae1681708fe836a9db1fc55332ac2159cadacd568e02a9da7c4e43e78",
"final_url": "https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ca-supreme-court/1098993.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 575,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual), not authority-abuse and NOT religious terrorism: the demonic-command letters were the instrument of terror, aimed at victims and the public. Berkowitz's LATER claims of a satanic-cult conspiracy — the 'Twenty-Two Disciples of Hell' — and the 1996 reopened Yonkers investigation produced no charges and no adjudication anywhere; they are expressly excluded from this record's assertions.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1978-david-berkowitz-son-of-sam-new-york-usa",
"year": 1978,
"place": "New York City, New York, USA",
"lat": 40.7128,
"lng": -74.006,
"title": "United States: 'Son of Sam' — demonic-command letters that terrorised a city",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none — the perpetrator held no authority over his victims"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"letters to police and the press attributing the shootings to a demon commanding him through a neighbour's dog",
"the demonic framing sustaining a year of public terror across New York"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New York State courts (Kings, Queens and Bronx County proceedings, consolidated)",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentence",
"date": "1978-06-12",
"outcome": "David Berkowitz pleaded guilty on 8 May 1978 to all six 'Son of Sam' murders and the associated attempted murders and assaults; after his competency was contested and resolved in favour of fitness, he was sentenced on 12 June 1978 to twenty-five years to life on each murder count. The pleas have never been overturned and he remains imprisoned."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. The victims were strangers. What belongs in this database is the instrument: letters claiming a demon issued the orders, which turned a shooting series into a citywide religious terror.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.britannica.com/biography/David-Berkowitz",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Encyclopædia Britannica: David Berkowitz.",
"body": "Reference account of the pleas, sentence and the letters.",
"tier": "reference-index",
"kind": "case-chronology"
},
{
"link": "https://www.encyclopedia.com/law/law-magazines/son-sam-trial-1978",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Son of Sam Trial: 1978', Great American Trials.",
"body": "Legal-reference account of the proceedings.",
"tier": "reference-index",
"kind": "trial-account"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.britannica.com/biography/David-Berkowitz",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-index; evidentiary role: case-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.encyclopedia.com/law/law-magazines/son-sam-trial-1978",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-index; evidentiary role: trial-account.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0e12d2f6bfb08d239ffc14c46e7d90936216a54c502ed8d0582500a788122e60",
"final_url": "https://www.encyclopedia.com/law/law-magazines/son-sam-trial-1978"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 576,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "corte-assise-appello",
"date": "2007",
"note": "Sapone confirmed at life; Leoni raised to life; other terms adjusted."
},
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2008-05",
"note": "All sentences confirmed — final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The murdered members are named as they are named throughout the Italian public record and appellate history.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2006-bestie-di-satana-busto-arsizio-italy",
"year": 2006,
"place": "Somma Lombardo, Varese, Italy",
"lat": 45.6833,
"lng": 8.7,
"title": "Italy: 'Beasts of Satan' — group members killed by their own circle in satanic rites",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-satanic-branded-violence",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leading figures of the 'Bestie di Satana' group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the group's satanic ideology directing the killing of its own members",
"a victim killed as a 'sacrifice' identified with the Madonna",
"ritual burial in a forest pit"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"'Bestie di Satana'"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Corte d'Assise di Busto Arsizio; Corte d'Assise d'Appello di Milano; Corte di Cassazione",
"stage": "convictions; confirmed final at the Court of Cassation",
"date": "2006-01-31",
"outcome": "On 31 January 2006 the Busto Arsizio assize court convicted the core of the 'Bestie di Satana' for the January 1998 killings of group members Chiara Marino and Fabio Tollis and the January 2004 killing of Mariangela Pezzotta: Nicola Sapone received two life sentences, with Paolo Leoni, Marco Zampollo, Eros Monterosso and Elisabetta Ballarin receiving terms of 24 to 26 years. On appeal in Milan in 2007 Sapone's life terms were confirmed and Leoni's was raised to life; the Court of Cassation confirmed all sentences in May 2008, making them final. Andrea Volpe and Pietro Guerrieri were convicted separately in abbreviated proceedings."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE, not merely terror: the victims were the group's own members, killed by the circle whose satanic ideology defined their lives — one of them destroyed as a 'sacrifice'. The doctrine was the authority, and it was turned inward.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.varesenews.it/2008/05/bestie-di-satana-sentenze-confermate-per-tutti-in-cassazione/216949/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "VareseNews: 'Bestie di Satana, sentenze confermate per tutti in Cassazione', May 2008.",
"body": "Reports the final cassation confirmation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "corte-assise-appello",
"date": "2007",
"note": "Sapone confirmed at life; Leoni raised to life; other terms adjusted."
},
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2008-05",
"note": "All sentences confirmed — final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.varesenews.it/2008/05/bestie-di-satana-sentenze-confermate-per-tutti-in-cassazione/216949/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "06a7d8b12d7d36295823abc2c4718657e327a9ce57651fe6b2453d90f37be71e",
"final_url": "https://www.varesenews.it/2008/05/bestie-di-satana-sentenze-confermate-per-tutti-in-cassazione/216949/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 577,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual), not authority-abuse and NOT religious terrorism. Two victims were his own parents and one a stranger; neither engages the corpus's core criterion. Recorded because the ritual claim was central to the adjudicated record. The execution of a juvenile offender is stated as fact, without endorsement.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1986-sean-sellers-oklahoma-city-usa",
"year": 1986,
"place": "Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, USA",
"lat": 35.4676,
"lng": -97.5164,
"title": "United States: Sean Sellers — satanic-ritual killings litigated through trial and appeal",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none — a teenage practitioner acting alone"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"killings carried out as claimed satanic ritual practice"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Oklahoma County District Court; state and federal appellate courts",
"stage": "conviction and death sentence; appeals exhausted; executed",
"date": "1986-01-01",
"outcome": "Sean Sellers was convicted in 1986 of three first-degree murders — a convenience-store clerk shot in September 1985, and his mother and stepfather in March 1986 — and sentenced to death. He stated the killings were part of satanic ritual practice, and the courts rejected diminished-capacity claims built on it through state and federal appeals. He was executed on 4 February 1999, the only person executed in the post-Furman United States for a crime committed at sixteen."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Sellers led no one; the satanic practice was self-adopted and litigated as a defence, and it is recorded here as the crime's stated frame, not as anyone's authority over anyone.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://clarkprosecutor.org/html/death/US/sellers512.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Clark County Prosecutor case file: Sean Sellers.",
"body": "Compiled case and appellate history from prosecution records.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "case-history-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://clarkprosecutor.org/html/death/US/sellers512.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: case-history-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3d87d7edbd43af53e1d76259f586e52416e09541536d5300b0472be66c0fc267",
"final_url": "http://clarkprosecutor.org/html/death/US/sellers512.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 578,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual), not authority-abuse and NOT religious terrorism. The victim is not identified. SOURCE-BAR CAVEAT: much of the Finnish court record is sealed for forty years, so this record rests on secondary accounts of the 1999 judgment and asserts only its core outcome.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1999-jarno-elg-hyvinkaa-finland",
"year": 1999,
"place": "Hyvinkää, Finland",
"lat": 60.6306,
"lng": 24.8592,
"title": "Finland: life sentence for a satanic-ritual torture killing",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none established over the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"killing staged as a satanic ritual, with torture and mutilation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hyvinkää District Court, Finland",
"stage": "conviction and life sentence",
"date": "1999-08-11",
"outcome": "On 11 August 1999 the Hyvinkää District Court convicted Jarno Elg of the November 1998 torture-murder, dismemberment and partial cannibalisation of a twenty-three-year-old man in what the court's findings described as a satanic ritual, and sentenced him to life. Two accomplices received eight years and six months and two years and eight months; charges against a sixteen-year-old were dropped after a finding of coercion."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. The victim was an acquaintance, not an adherent; the ritual framing is recorded as the crime's adjudicated character.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarno_Elg",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jarno Elg case overview (secondary; primary record sealed).",
"body": "Reference account of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "reference-index",
"kind": "case-chronology"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarno_Elg",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-index; evidentiary role: case-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "03e10129e58f205d3c9c326b9b3fc60f843dc449b571e9012c9641d3ce2b43ce",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarno_Elg"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 579,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual), upgrade-candidate toward core: the victims were teenagers drawn into the group's own gatherings. The victims are not named here. The 2023 pardon-for-military-service release is a fact about the sentence, not the conviction. Russian judicial-independence limits are noted; the facts are ordinary-criminal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-yaroslavl-ritual-murders-russia",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Yaroslavl, Russia",
"lat": 57.6261,
"lng": 39.8845,
"title": "Russia: seven convicted over the ritual killings of four teenagers at group gatherings",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ringleader of a self-styled satanist group in Yaroslavl"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"killings carried out at the group's ritual gatherings",
"ritualised stabbing and mutilation of the bodies"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Yaroslavl Regional Court, Russia",
"stage": "convictions and sentences",
"date": "2010-07-01",
"outcome": "In July 2010 the Yaroslavl Regional Court convicted seven people over the June–July 2008 ritual killings of four teenagers at the gatherings of a self-styled satanist group: ringleader Nikolai Ogolobyak received twenty years for murder, robbery and desecration of corpses, five accomplices eight to ten years, and one two years; an eighth defendant was found insane and committed. In 2023 Ogolobyak was released by pardon after military service in Ukraine — the conviction stands, the sentence commuted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were teenagers drawn into the group's own gatherings, which places this closer to the corpus's core pattern than a stranger-killing; it is classed as religious-terror pending clearer evidence of formal membership.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2010/07/26/satanists-jailed-for-ritual-murders-a131",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Moscow Times: 'Satanists jailed for ritual murders', 26 Jul. 2010.",
"body": "Court report of the convictions and sentences.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://meduza.io/en/feature/2023/11/21",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Meduza: reporting on the 2023 pardon and release.",
"body": "Documents the commutation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "disposition-update"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2010/07/26/satanists-jailed-for-ritual-murders-a131",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c19e91086a9a1e09b7f3d9d164bba0133fbfcdf9d5609f5292cc36ea75c97632",
"final_url": "https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2010/07/26/satanists-jailed-for-ritual-murders-a131"
},
{
"source": "https://meduza.io/en/feature/2023/11/21",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition-update.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 580,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Mixed victim set: some victims were inside the group's own orbit (core), others outsiders (terror class); the record states both rather than flattening them. Sourced to the National Prosecuting Authority's own release.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-electus-per-deus-krugersdorp-south-africa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Krugersdorp, Gauteng, South Africa",
"lat": -26.1,
"lng": 27.7667,
"title": "South Africa: 'Electus per Deus' leader given thirteen life sentences over eleven killings",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-satanic-branded-violence",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Cecilia Steyn, leader of the 'Electus per Deus' (Chosen by God) group, claiming occult and spiritual-warfare authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"members directed to kill under the leader's claimed spiritual authority",
"victims drawn from members' own families and households"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [
"'Electus per Deus'"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg, South Africa",
"stage": "convictions and sentences",
"date": "2019-08-19",
"outcome": "Convicted in June 2019 and sentenced on 19 August 2019, Cecilia Steyn received thirteen life sentences plus 155 years, Zak Valentine eight life sentences plus 93 years, and Marcel Steyn seven life sentences plus 144 years, for eleven murders committed between 2012 and 2016 alongside fraud and robbery counts. Other participants, including Marinda Steyn, were convicted in earlier separate proceedings. The prosecuting authority documented the group's operation under Cecilia Steyn's claimed spiritual authority."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE for the inside victims: members killed on the direction of the woman whose claimed spiritual authority organised the group, with several victims drawn from members' own households — the authority ran the killing, exactly as the criterion describes.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.npa.gov.za/sites/default/files/media-releases/Indefinite%20Life%20Sentences%20for%20Krugersdorp%E2%80%99s%20Electus%20Per%20Deus%20Cult.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Prosecuting Authority: 'Indefinite Life Sentences for Krugersdorp's Electus Per Deus Cult'.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own sentencing release.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.news24.com/krugersdorp-killers-sentenced-to-life-in-prison-20190819",
"archive": "",
"citation": "News24: sentencing report.",
"body": "National corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.npa.gov.za/sites/default/files/media-releases/Indefinite%20Life%20Sentences%20for%20Krugersdorp%E2%80%99s%20Electus%20Per%20Deus%20Cult.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ebafa1698f49e401d1e482e8ddea74307d1f3f852f6fbbfce690c9148fff2dfb",
"final_url": "https://www.npa.gov.za/sites/default/files/media-releases/Indefinite%20Life%20Sentences%20for%20Krugersdorp%E2%80%99s%20Electus%20Per%20Deus%20Cult.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.news24.com/krugersdorp-killers-sentenced-to-life-in-prison-20190819",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fa8db010b038ce78893bffc5850b393e02f3d71f9abe991c33a99568303ad23c",
"final_url": "https://www.news24.com/krugersdorp-killers-sentenced-to-life-in-prison-20190819"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 581,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual), not authority-abuse and NOT religious terrorism. Companion to the corpus's 1989 Matamoros record — this one covers the 1994 SENTENCES. Constanzo is recorded as never tried. VERIFICATION FLAG: the precise Mexican court is documented only at wire-report level; the record states 'Mexican court, Mexico City' rather than asserting a specific tribunal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-sara-aldrete-matamoros-sentences-mexico",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Matamoros, Tamaulipas, Mexico",
"lat": 25.869,
"lng": -97.5027,
"title": "Mexico: 1994 sentences for the Rancho Santa Elena ritual killings",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-other",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior followers of the cult leader Adolfo Constanzo, who directed the ranch's rituals"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"victims killed and dismembered in palo mayombe rituals",
"body parts boiled in an nganga cauldron to confer claimed supernatural protection on a drug operation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mexican court, Mexico City",
"stage": "convictions and sentences",
"date": "1994-05-01",
"outcome": "In May 1994 Sara María Aldrete Villarreal was sentenced to sixty-two years and Elio Hernández Rivera, Serafín Hernández García, David Serna Valdez and Sergio Martínez Salinas to sixty-seven years each for the ritual killings of thirteen people at Rancho Santa Elena near Matamoros, including the American student Mark Kilroy. Aldrete had earlier been acquitted of the cult leader's death but convicted in 1990 of criminal association. The leader himself, Adolfo Constanzo, died in a Mexico City shootout in May 1989 and was never tried."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE as to the outside victims: the ritual served a trafficking operation's claimed invulnerability rather than binding adherents. Recorded for the ritual's documented function as an instrument of terror.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.deseret.com/1994/5/4/19106988/5-cultists-get-long-terms-for-slaying-13/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'5 cultists get long terms for slaying 13', Associated Press via Deseret News, 4 May 1994.",
"body": "Wire report of the sentences.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.deseret.com/1994/5/4/19106988/5-cultists-get-long-terms-for-slaying-13/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "39bfe3adfeaaa97b67a292aa28766948fa0f21560bf1dcbfd35c6ef06fb7e1f2",
"final_url": "https://www.deseret.com/1994/5/4/19106988/5-cultists-get-long-terms-for-slaying-13/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 582,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "federal-habeas",
"date": "2026-02",
"note": "Petition denied; eighty-year term stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The state plea itself was to CSAM counts; the network's doctrinal coercion system is documented in the Justice Department's subsequent 764 prosecutions rather than in this plea record, and is attributed accordingly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-bradley-cadenhead-764-founder-texas-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Stephenville, Texas, USA",
"lat": 32.2207,
"lng": -98.2023,
"title": "United States: 764's founder sentenced to eighty years — the network built on coerced self-harm",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-online-nihilist-network",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and leader of the 764 network"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"children extorted into carving sigils into their own bodies",
"coerced self-harm and sexual content filmed for the network's status economy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"764"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Erath County District Court, Texas, USA; habeas review in the Northern District of Texas",
"stage": "guilty plea; affirmed on collateral attack",
"date": "2023-05-16",
"outcome": "Bradley Chance Cadenhead, who founded the 764 network on Discord in 2021 — naming it for his ZIP code — pleaded guilty on 16 May 2023 to nine counts of possessing child sexual-abuse material and was sentenced to eighty years in state prison. A federal habeas petition was denied in February 2026, leaving the sentence intact."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE, not merely terror: 764's satanic-nihilist doctrine was the instrument of coercion itself — children were extorted into cutting sigils into their own skin and performing self-harm on camera, which is authority exercised through belief even though the authority is a network rather than a pulpit.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tampafp.com/court-slams-door-on-texas-764-ring-leader-bradley-cadenheads-bid-for-freedom/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report of the 2026 habeas denial and the underlying eighty-year sentence.",
"body": "Court reporting on the collateral-attack outcome.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "post-conviction-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "federal-habeas",
"date": "2026-02",
"note": "Petition denied; eighty-year term stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tampafp.com/court-slams-door-on-texas-764-ring-leader-bradley-cadenheads-bid-for-freedom/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: post-conviction-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b0247247284353adbae6c7678ea58a0e4856a6db5f59c8da632643669e1bed0c",
"final_url": "https://www.tampafp.com/court-slams-door-on-texas-764-ring-leader-bradley-cadenheads-bid-for-freedom/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 583,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is not identified. Unusually for this class, the doctrinal element here is COURT RECORD rather than attribution — the sentencing remarks are cited directly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-cameron-finnigan-764-horsham-uk",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Horsham, West Sussex, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.0629,
"lng": -0.3256,
"title": "United Kingdom: sentencing remarks tie 764 to the Order of Nine Angles in the court record itself",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-online-nihilist-network",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"member of the 764 network"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a suicidal girl told to 'cut deeper' and urged to hang herself on camera for the network's chat",
"blood-written symbols and pentagram imagery documented in the sentencing remarks"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"764",
"Order of Nine Angles (as described in the sentencing remarks)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Central Criminal Court (Old Bailey), United Kingdom — Mr Justice Jay",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-16",
"outcome": "Cameron Finnigan pleaded guilty and was sentenced on 16 January 2025 to six years' custody with an extended licence on five counts: encouraging and assisting suicide — he told a suicidal girl to 'cut deeper' and pressed her to hang herself on camera for 764's public chat — possession of a terrorist document, possession of indecent images of a child, and two counts of criminal damage."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE. Mr Justice Jay's sentencing remarks state the doctrinal structure in the court's own words: Finnigan 'was involved in a Satanic, Far-Right extremist group known as 764', a group 'associated with a broader entity or group known as the Order of the Nine Angles', described as a decentralised esoteric militant accelerationist network. This is the strongest judicial statement of the 764–O9A link in any jurisdiction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/R-v-Finnigan.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "R v Finnigan, sentencing remarks of Mr Justice Jay, 16 Jan. 2025 (Judiciary of England and Wales).",
"body": "The court's own sentencing remarks.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "sentencing-remarks"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sussex.police.uk/news/sussex/news/court-results/man-sentenced-for-terror-offences/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sussex Police: court result.",
"body": "The investigating authority's release.",
"tier": "official-police-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/R-v-Finnigan.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: sentencing-remarks.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b81e87be942f0abe9c5c9040e77a1b9ad58cb01af342b5b9314d698b12215992",
"final_url": "https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/R-v-Finnigan.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sussex.police.uk/news/sussex/news/court-results/man-sentenced-for-terror-offences/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-police-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 584,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Sourced to the Justice Department's own sentencing release.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-alexis-chavez-8884-san-antonio-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "San Antonio, Texas, USA",
"lat": 29.4241,
"lng": -98.4936,
"title": "United States: forty years for the leader of a 764 splinter that coerced children on camera",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-online-nihilist-network",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"administrator and leader of '8884', a 764-related network"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a girl coerced into cutting her tongue and into torturing and killing an animal on live video",
"extortion of several girls into filmed self-harm"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"8884 (764-related network)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "US District Court, Western District of Texas",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-07-08",
"outcome": "Alexis Aldair Chavez, who administered the 764-related network '8884', pleaded guilty in December 2025 to racketeering and to distributing and possessing child sexual-abuse material, and was sentenced in July 2026 to forty years with lifetime supervised release and restitution. Prosecutors described him and his co-conspirators coercing a girl into cutting her tongue and into torturing and killing an animal on live video, and extorting several girls into filmed self-harm."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE. The Justice Department's 'nihilistic violent extremist' framing describes a network organised around destroying civilised society through the corruption of the vulnerable — the ideology is the coercion mechanism, applied directly to the children it targeted.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/nihilistic-violent-extremist-sentenced-40-years-prison-san-antonio",
"archive": "",
"citation": "US Department of Justice: 'Nihilistic Violent Extremist Sentenced to 40 Years in Prison'.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's sentencing release.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://cyberscoop.com/764-splinter-group-leader-sentenced-alexis-chavez/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CyberScoop: report of the sentence.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/nihilistic-violent-extremist-sentenced-40-years-prison-san-antonio",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "48918ee659be7ba56f21e2538142b41c5f5a2b3d3e241ba3207f6b317e46acee",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/nihilistic-violent-extremist-sentenced-40-years-prison-san-antonio"
},
{
"source": "https://cyberscoop.com/764-splinter-group-leader-sentenced-alexis-chavez/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8e4793cc2a54705869fc16fa85c5d4d90468c63f7a673be917cfcfc238c16e28",
"final_url": "https://cyberscoop.com/764-splinter-group-leader-sentenced-alexis-chavez/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 585,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. REPORTING DISCREPANCIES flagged rather than resolved: outlets name both the Naphuno Regional Court and the Lenyenye Magistrate's Court, and give the concurrent term as either 35 or 45 years; the two life sentences are consistent across sources and are what this record asserts.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-confidence-monyela-prophet-ministry-limpopo-south-africa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Letsitele, Limpopo, South Africa",
"lat": -23.8833,
"lng": 30.3333,
"title": "South Africa: prophet given two life terms for raping teenage ushers he told sex 'transferred the Holy Spirit'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"prophet and leader of the Prophet Ministry Church, Mariveni"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teaching that sex with him 'transferred the Holy Spirit'",
"threats that the Holy Spirit would kill the girls if they spoke",
"evening 'private prayer' sessions with church ushers aged 14 to 17"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Prophet Ministry Church, Mariveni"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional court, Limpopo, South Africa",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-07-31",
"outcome": "Confidence Monyela, 39, leader of the Prophet Ministry Church at Mariveni near Letsitele, was convicted on 31 July 2025 of multiple rapes and sexual assault of church ushers aged between fourteen and seventeen during evening 'private prayer' sessions, having told them that sex with him transferred the Holy Spirit and that the Holy Spirit would kill them if they disclosed. He received two life sentences plus a concurrent term of decades."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The doctrine was the coercion: girls serving as ushers in his church, told that submitting was how the Holy Spirit passed to them and that speaking would be fatal.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thestar.co.za/news/crime-and-courts/2025-08-02-limpopo-pastor-receives-two-life-sentences-for-raping-multiple-teenage-girls/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Star: 'Limpopo pastor receives two life sentences'.",
"body": "National court reporting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.citizen.co.za/letaba-herald/news-headlines/local-news/2025/07/31/limpopo-prophet-gets-double-life-sentence-for-child-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Letaba Herald / The Citizen: local court report.",
"body": "Regional corroboration with case detail.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thestar.co.za/news/crime-and-courts/2025-08-02-limpopo-pastor-receives-two-life-sentences-for-raping-multiple-teenage-girls/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "63579a08e67dfdfef066babc8b500a013d6c9cbe51564cf22649b827e4e64460",
"final_url": "https://thestar.co.za/news/crime-and-courts/2025-08-02-limpopo-pastor-receives-two-life-sentences-for-raping-multiple-teenage-girls/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.citizen.co.za/letaba-herald/news-headlines/local-news/2025/07/31/limpopo-prophet-gets-double-life-sentence-for-child-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f3a2e9e9aef590055431ceb1216e073cb1370a9cd85f0af7a6fa549a017aedc8",
"final_url": "https://www.citizen.co.za/letaba-herald/news-headlines/local-news/2025/07/31/limpopo-prophet-gets-double-life-sentence-for-child-rape/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 586,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant's name was withheld by the prosecuting authority to protect the child victims' identities, and is therefore not stated here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mamelodi-east-pastor-life-sentence-south-africa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Mamelodi East, Pretoria, South Africa",
"lat": -25.7069,
"lng": 28.4,
"title": "South Africa: life sentence for a pastor who raped a twelve-year-old of his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the Jesus Is the Answer Ministries, Mamelodi East"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over children of his congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Jesus Is the Answer Ministries, Mamelodi East"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pretoria Magistrates' Court, South Africa",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-10-08",
"outcome": "On 8 October 2025 a forty-one-year-old pastor of the Jesus Is the Answer Ministries in Mamelodi East was sentenced to life imprisonment plus five years for the rape of a twelve-year-old girl and the sexual assault of a thirteen-year-old, both children of his congregation, in a prosecution announced by the National Prosecuting Authority."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Two children of the congregation he led.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/pastor-sentenced-life-imprisonment-raping-and-sexually-assaulting-12-and-13-year-old-church",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Prosecuting Authority: sentencing release.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own release.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/pastor-sentenced-life-imprisonment-raping-and-sexually-assaulting-12-and-13-year-old-church",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8d8417237139d8bd62004df589909a66b0e03f99f2b1abf411aadbb8fdda78f5",
"final_url": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/pastor-sentenced-life-imprisonment-raping-and-sexually-assaulting-12-and-13-year-old-church"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 587,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified; the defendant is not named in the available reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-zcc-pastor-ermelo-mpumalanga-south-africa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Ermelo, Mpumalanga, South Africa",
"lat": -26.5333,
"lng": 29.9833,
"title": "South Africa: two life terms for a pastor who raped a fifteen-year-old fellow congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor within the Zion Christian Church, Ermelo"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing over a teenage congregant",
"payment to the victim's brother to buy silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ermelo Regional Court, Mpumalanga, South Africa",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-08-14",
"outcome": "In August 2023 the Ermelo Regional Court sentenced a fifty-one-year-old pastor to two life terms for two rapes of a fifteen-year-old girl of his own congregation committed in 2020; he had paid her brother fifty rand to keep silent."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A teenage member of the congregation, silenced with a payment to her family.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sowetan.co.za/news/south-africa/2023-08-14-two-life-jail-terms-for-mpumalanga-pastor-who-raped-15-year-old-girl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sowetan: 'Two life jail terms for Mpumalanga pastor'.",
"body": "National court reporting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sowetan.co.za/news/south-africa/2023-08-14-two-life-jail-terms-for-mpumalanga-pastor-who-raped-15-year-old-girl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f5f4b2e0fde3c12b97c6f674da169d404628a63dae7457321bf874fd42dd0394",
"final_url": "https://www.sowetan.co.za/news/south-africa/2023-08-14-two-life-jail-terms-for-mpumalanga-pastor-who-raped-15-year-old-girl/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 588,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2020-08",
"note": "Sentence reduced to 25 years (5 suspended); conviction upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The sentence reduction and his death in custody are both stated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-robert-gumbura-rmg-end-time-message-zimbabwe",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Harare, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -17.8252,
"lng": 31.0335,
"title": "Zimbabwe: church founder convicted of raping four congregants he threatened with evil spells",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and leader of the RMG Independent End Time Message Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"threats of evil spells against women who refused or disclosed",
"total doctrinal authority over the congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"spiritual-consequence",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"RMG Independent End Time Message Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Harare Regional Court; High Court of Zimbabwe (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal, conviction upheld",
"date": "2014-02-03",
"outcome": "Robert Martin Gumbura, founder of the RMG Independent End Time Message Church, was convicted on 3 February 2014 of raping four female congregants whom he had threatened with evil spells, and sentenced to fifty years with ten suspended. In August 2020 the High Court reduced the sentence to twenty-five years with five suspended while upholding the conviction. He died in Chikurubi prison on 7 August 2021."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Women of his own church, held in place by his claimed power to curse them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://zimlii.org/akn/zw/judgment/zwsc/2014/78/eng@2014-10-15",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Gumbura v S, SC 78-14 (Supreme Court of Zimbabwe, 2014) via ZimLII.",
"body": "Court record from the national legal-information institute.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.zimlive.com/2020/08/07/gumbura-out-in-5-years-after-high-court-slashes-prison-sentence",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ZimLive: High Court reduces the sentence, August 2020.",
"body": "Reports the appellate outcome.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2020-08",
"note": "Sentence reduced to 25 years (5 suspended); conviction upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://zimlii.org/akn/zw/judgment/zwsc/2014/78/eng@2014-10-15",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.zimlive.com/2020/08/07/gumbura-out-in-5-years-after-high-court-slashes-prison-sentence",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 589,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Sentence reduced 32 → 20 years; conviction upheld. 2011 presidential pardon = clemency, not vacatur."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The 2011 pardon is recorded precisely as clemency — the conviction remains adjudicated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-godfrey-nzira-johanne-masowe-chitungwiza-zimbabwe",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Chitungwiza, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -18.0127,
"lng": 31.0756,
"title": "Zimbabwe: apostolic shrine leader convicted on seven counts of raping women who came for spiritual help",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader of the Johanne Masowe weChishanu shrine at Juranifiri Santa, Chitungwiza"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"women seeking spiritual help and healing at his shrine"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Johanne Masowe weChishanu (Juranifiri Santa shrine)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Zimbabwean courts",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal; later pardoned",
"date": "2003-01-01",
"outcome": "Madzibaba Godfrey Nzira, leader of the Johanne Masowe weChishanu shrine at Juranifiri Santa in Chitungwiza, was convicted in 2003 on seven counts of rape and on indecent assault against women who had come to his shrine seeking spiritual help, and sentenced to thirty-two years, reduced to twenty on appeal with the conviction standing. He was pardoned by presidential clemency in January 2011 — a commutation, not a vacatur — and died in October 2011."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Women who walked into a shrine for spiritual help and met the man whose authority the shrine was built on.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thezimbabwean.co/2011/10/convicted-rapist-madzibaba-godfrey-nzira/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Zimbabwean: obituary recounting the conviction, appeal and pardon.",
"body": "National outlet's case history.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Sentence reduced 32 → 20 years; conviction upheld. 2011 presidential pardon = clemency, not vacatur."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thezimbabwean.co/2011/10/convicted-rapist-madzibaba-godfrey-nzira/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6770e0c3b7efa63964a0edf0a7d8f92dc59346a66c7cabcb51f39fe44b38ad56",
"final_url": "https://www.thezimbabwean.co/2011/10/convicted-rapist-madzibaba-godfrey-nzira/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 590,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2026-03-04",
"note": "Bail pending appeal granted; the court found prospects of success — conviction genuinely at risk."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. LIVE APPEAL RISK, flagged prominently: the High Court expressly found prospects of success, so this conviction may not survive. Recorded as standing-but-contested and marked for re-check before any republication.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-ishmael-chokurongerwa-johane-masowe-nyabira-zimbabwe",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Nyabira, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -17.6667,
"lng": 30.7667,
"title": "Zimbabwe: apostolic sect leader convicted of raping a minor congregant — conviction under appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader of a Johane Masowe eChishanu apostolic sect at Lily Farm, Nyabira"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sect leader's authority over a minor congregant living within the community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Johane Masowe eChishanu (Lily Farm, Nyabira)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Harare magistrates' court (Magistrate Estere Chivasa); High Court of Zimbabwe (bail pending appeal)",
"stage": "conviction on one count; appeal pending with bail granted",
"date": "2025-12-01",
"outcome": "Ishmael Chokurongerwa, known as Madzibaba Ishmael, leader of a Johane Masowe eChishanu sect at Lily Farm in Nyabira, was convicted in December 2025 on one count of raping a minor congregant, with DNA-confirmed paternity, and acquitted on two further counts; he received twenty years. On 4 March 2026 the High Court granted him bail pending appeal, Justice Wamambo finding prospects of success on questions of DNA handling and the complainant's testimony."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child of the sect under the man who led it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/madzibaba-ishmael-sentenced-to-20-years-in-prison-for-raping-impregnating-minor-congregant/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NewZimbabwe: report of the conviction and sentence.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/high-court-frees-madzibaba-ishmael-on-bail-pending-appeal-in-rape-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NewZimbabwe: High Court grants bail pending appeal.",
"body": "Documents the appellate risk.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-status-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"date": "2026-03-04",
"note": "Bail pending appeal granted; the court found prospects of success — conviction genuinely at risk."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/madzibaba-ishmael-sentenced-to-20-years-in-prison-for-raping-impregnating-minor-congregant/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "50fea7d151ce65899f00031c69c81ce085f0311afd80e5e518707abd7b36c345",
"final_url": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/madzibaba-ishmael-sentenced-to-20-years-in-prison-for-raping-impregnating-minor-congregant/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/high-court-frees-madzibaba-ishmael-on-bail-pending-appeal-in-rape-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-status-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "14e12e1fc7e6035863390fe70feb8fd70118d703029ce9de1706b32e61b122ed",
"final_url": "https://www.newzimbabwe.com/high-court-frees-madzibaba-ishmael-on-bail-pending-appeal-in-rape-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 591,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2019-06-28",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. NEXUS SOURCING CAVEAT: the pastoral relationship comes from Kenyan press reporting; the appellate judgments themselves do not detail the church connection, and this record does not claim more than the press establishes.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-david-mutai-pastor-eldoret-kenya",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Eldoret, Kenya",
"lat": 0.5143,
"lng": 35.2698,
"title": "Kenya: pastor's defilement conviction affirmed by the Court of Appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor in Eldoret East"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing over a sixteen-year-old"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kenyan trial court; High Court at Eldoret (2015); Court of Appeal at Kisumu",
"stage": "conviction affirmed twice; resentencing petition rejected",
"date": "2019-06-28",
"outcome": "David Mutai, a pastor in Eldoret East, was convicted on three counts of defiling a sixteen-year-old girl in 2010 — DNA established his paternity of her child — and sentenced to fifteen years. The High Court at Eldoret affirmed in 2015 and the Court of Appeal at Kisumu dismissed his appeal on 28 June 2019; a later resentencing petition was rejected in 2021."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A teenage girl and her pastor, with paternity proving the assault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2021/8160/eng@2021-03-18",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mutai v Republic [2021] KEHC 8160, via Kenya Law.",
"body": "Court record confirming the conviction history and appellate outcomes.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "post-conviction-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2019-06-28",
"note": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2021/8160/eng@2021-03-18",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: post-conviction-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "92a156e39531d0fb990be04d9c6b395fdd527b883069c68d1db4f51d405103ae",
"final_url": "https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kehc/2021/8160/eng@2021-03-18"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 592,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-stonard-ali-prophet-mwanza-malawi",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Mwanza, Malawi",
"lat": -15.5981,
"lng": 34.5178,
"title": "Malawi: prophet jailed for defiling a girl her mother had brought to him for prayer",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled prophet"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the mother sent away to 'pray alone' so he could be left with her daughter",
"family's resort to him for prayer"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mwanza First Grade Magistrate Court, Malawi",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-04-03",
"outcome": "Prophet Stonard Ali, 26, was sentenced in April 2024 to fourteen years' imprisonment with hard labour for defiling a sixteen-year-old church member whose mother had brought her to him for prayers; he sent the mother away to pray alone so that he could be left with the girl."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The mother's faith delivered her daughter to him, and the same faith is what let him send the mother out of the room.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://malawi24.com/2024/04/03/prophet-sentenced-to-14-years-imprisonment-for-defiling-a-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Malawi24: 'Prophet sentenced to 14 years imprisonment for defiling a minor'.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://malawi24.com/2024/04/03/prophet-sentenced-to-14-years-imprisonment-for-defiling-a-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6065f6940654801d905cff00a6fde9f031c23030b69811e212d1f7713093b187",
"final_url": "https://malawi24.com/2024/04/03/prophet-sentenced-to-14-years-imprisonment-for-defiling-a-minor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 593,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. NEXUS QUALIFICATION: first contact came through social media rather than the congregation, so the authority is pastoral-counselling rather than congregational — stated rather than overstated. A second trial on separate allegations was pending and is not asserted here. Appeal status unknown; conviction is fresh.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-goitsekgosi-mojadigo-divine-anointing-botswana",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Mochudi, Botswana",
"lat": -24.4167,
"lng": 26.15,
"title": "Botswana: pastor sentenced to twenty years for raping a woman who confided her trauma to him",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of The Divine Anointing Church International"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counselling relationship after the victim confided prior trauma to him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"The Divine Anointing Church International"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mochudi Magistrate's Court, Botswana",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-11-01",
"outcome": "Goitsekgosi Mojadigo, 35, of The Divine Anointing Church International, was convicted in November 2025 and sentenced to twenty years for the 2023 rape of a young woman who had confided her earlier trauma to him in his capacity as pastor and counsellor."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "She brought him her worst experience as her pastor, and he used the standing that gave him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mmegi.bw/news/mojadigo-slapped-with-20-year-prison-sentence-for-rape/news",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mmegi: 'Mojadigo slapped with 20-year prison sentence for rape'.",
"body": "National paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://dailynews.gov.bw/news-detail/89093",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Botswana Daily News: sentencing report.",
"body": "Government news service corroboration.",
"tier": "official-government-release",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mmegi.bw/news/mojadigo-slapped-with-20-year-prison-sentence-for-rape/news",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9003dc2c58f6dec196f92fa7ec626b469795b56b9fc633668982c124785b8af8",
"final_url": "https://www.mmegi.bw/news/mojadigo-slapped-with-20-year-prison-sentence-for-rape/news"
},
{
"source": "https://dailynews.gov.bw/news-detail/89093",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eee28217768a58a2bd38fbf3f0d777a94e0fb9f5bc500813ae23a9fef0c37287",
"final_url": "https://dailynews.gov.bw/news-detail/89093"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 594,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "revision",
"date": "2022",
"note": "Withdrawn — judgment rechtskräftig."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant is named as German reporting names him. The mixed family/parish victim set is disclosed above rather than presented as uniformly congregational.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-hans-u-priest-archdiocese-cologne-germany",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Cologne, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 50.9375,
"lng": 6.9603,
"title": "Germany: Cologne priest sentenced to twelve years on 110 counts spanning twenty-five years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest serving parishes in Gummersbach, Wuppertal and Zülpich"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly office creating access and unchallengeability within the parish environment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Cologne"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht Köln, Germany",
"stage": "conviction; final after the appeal was withdrawn",
"date": "2022-02-01",
"outcome": "The priest known in German reporting as Hans U. was convicted by the Cologne regional court in February 2022 on 110 counts — seventy-two of sexual abuse of children, twenty-three aggravated, and fifteen of abuse of a minor — against nine girls between 1993 and 2018 across parishes in Gummersbach, Wuppertal and Zülpich. He received twelve years plus €50,000 in damages, and the judgment became final when he withdrew his appeal later that year."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "MIXED VICTIM SET, stated rather than flattened: three of the nine victims were his nieces, where the nexus is familial; the remaining victims were girls of the parish environment his priestly office governed, which is where this record's criterion-fit lies.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/102kls1720-lg-koeln-sexueller-missbrauch-prieser-erzbistum",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Legal Tribune Online: LG Köln, 102 KLs 17/20.",
"body": "Legal-news report of the judgment.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://de.catholicnewsagency.com/news/10967/urteil-ist-rechtskraftig-kolner-missbrauchspriester-zieht-revision-zuruck",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNA Deutsch: appeal withdrawn, judgment final.",
"body": "Confirms finality.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "revision",
"date": "2022",
"note": "Withdrawn — judgment rechtskräftig."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/102kls1720-lg-koeln-sexueller-missbrauch-prieser-erzbistum",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "64381192b99f71ebd61745778bf9c04062dda0236dec6eda0eb787c975e45020",
"final_url": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/102kls1720-lg-koeln-sexueller-missbrauch-prieser-erzbistum"
},
{
"source": "https://de.catholicnewsagency.com/news/10967/urteil-ist-rechtskraftig-kolner-missbrauchspriester-zieht-revision-zuruck",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e211cccfaee857fa7542322cfd1b5419ec48dea5b114927d42086c7fec20baae",
"final_url": "https://de.catholicnewsagency.com/news/10967/urteil-ist-rechtskraftig-kolner-missbrauchspriester-zieht-revision-zuruck"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 595,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "berufung",
"date": "2016-06-21",
"note": "The two-year sentence was itself the appellate verdict; further review not located."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. COURT CORRECTION recorded: the criminal courts were Nördlingen and Augsburg; the Amtsgericht Ansbach proceedings of 2013–14 were family-court custody withdrawals, not convictions, and must not be cited as such.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-zwolf-stamme-klosterzimmern-corporal-punishment-germany",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Klosterzimmern, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 48.7833,
"lng": 10.6167,
"title": "Germany: Twelve Tribes teachers convicted for doctrine-mandated rod beatings of sect children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teachers appointed by the Twelve Tribes community to administer its doctrine of corporal 'Züchtigung'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"community doctrine mandating beatings with rods",
"children of members held inside the sect's own school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Zwölf Stämme (Twelve Tribes), Klosterzimmern"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht Augsburg (appeal) and Amtsgericht Nördlingen, Germany",
"stage": "convictions",
"date": "2016-06-21",
"outcome": "On 21 June 2016 the Augsburg regional court, sitting on appeal, convicted a fifty-six-year-old Twelve Tribes teacher of dangerous assault and maltreatment of persons in her care for beating at least four pupils with rods — up to thirty blows for trivial matters — and sentenced her to two years without probation, arresting her in the courtroom. A second teacher had been convicted at Nördlingen in November 2015 of dangerous assault of a fourteen-year-old pupil, receiving six months suspended and a €2,000 fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The beatings were not excess but doctrine: a religious community's teaching on corporal correction, administered by teachers the community appointed, to children whose parents' faith placed them there.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tagesspiegel.de/gesellschaft/panorama/zwei-jahre-haft-wegen-zuchtigungen-mit-rute-3734440.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Der Tagesspiegel: 'Zwei Jahre Haft wegen Züchtigungen mit Rute'.",
"body": "National daily's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://tagesspiegel.de/gesellschaft/panorama/pruegel-als-erziehungsmethode-strafe-fuer-lehrer-der-zwoelf-staemme/12630912.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Der Tagesspiegel: the 2015 Nördlingen conviction.",
"body": "Reports the companion conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "berufung",
"date": "2016-06-21",
"note": "The two-year sentence was itself the appellate verdict; further review not located."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tagesspiegel.de/gesellschaft/panorama/zwei-jahre-haft-wegen-zuchtigungen-mit-rute-3734440.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f678cc960ea36c2fce02b44d5f91f4106e6a81a231135a2d42efc9082ada728a",
"final_url": "https://www.tagesspiegel.de/gesellschaft/panorama/zwei-jahre-haft-wegen-zuchtigungen-mit-rute-3734440.html"
},
{
"source": "https://tagesspiegel.de/gesellschaft/panorama/pruegel-als-erziehungsmethode-strafe-fuer-lehrer-der-zwoelf-staemme/12630912.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "89e45cb835fa0a5b586430a54298cac7ea209426449a1909890345978263a726",
"final_url": "https://www.tagesspiegel.de/gesellschaft/panorama/strafe-fur-lehrer-der-zwolf-stamme-3677917.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 596,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "bundesgerichtshof",
"date": "2024-04-30",
"note": "Revision rejected (1 StR 423/23) — rechtskräftig."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Sourced to the Bavarian judiciary's own press release and the Federal Court of Justice.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-juan-b-shaman-healer-munich-germany",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Munich, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 48.1351,
"lng": 11.582,
"title": "Germany: self-styled shaman convicted of raping a girl 'treated' under spiritual therapy — final at the Federal Court",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled shaman and 'Wunderheiler' treating a family"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual-healing authority over patient and family",
"manipulation and isolation of the family to secure access to the child"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht München II; Bundesgerichtshof (1 StR 423/23)",
"stage": "conviction; final after the Federal Court of Justice",
"date": "2023-06-14",
"outcome": "On 14 June 2023 the Munich II regional court convicted a sixty-four-year-old self-styled shaman of two counts of rape combined with abuse exploiting a treatment relationship, sexual abuse of a juvenile, and dangerous assault — he had pushed the girl from a roughly three-metre cliff into a reservoir. The victim, fourteen, had been delivered to him for 'spiritual therapy' after he manipulated and isolated her family. He received six years and ten months; the Federal Court of Justice rejected his appeal on 30 April 2024, making the judgment final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Textbook: his claimed healing power over the family is precisely what delivered the child into his hands, and the German statute on abuse within treatment relationships names that mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justiz.bayern.de/gerichte-und-behoerden/oberlandesgerichte/muenchen/presse/2023/33.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bayerische Justiz: press release on the LG München II judgment.",
"body": "The judiciary's own release.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2024/2024103.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bundesgerichtshof press release, 30 Apr. 2024.",
"body": "Confirms the final rejection of the appeal.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "bundesgerichtshof",
"date": "2024-04-30",
"note": "Revision rejected (1 StR 423/23) — rechtskräftig."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justiz.bayern.de/gerichte-und-behoerden/oberlandesgerichte/muenchen/presse/2023/33.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9f5dcbf2067138f3c1250b0530f970f1f600c4e21bae5c390a5a311c420a41a9",
"final_url": "https://www.justiz.bayern.de/gerichte-und-behoerden/oberlandesgerichte/muenchen/presse/2023/33.php"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2024/2024103.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c01e233f2ca289ea301218642b708e72d36dfeb71456430e6c44ba9b924c7649",
"final_url": "https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2024/2024103.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 597,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. FINALITY UNVERIFIED: the appellate status of the December 2021 judgment could not be confirmed and is flagged rather than asserted. The acquittal on the imprisonment counts is stated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-robert-baart-orde-der-transformanten-goch-germany",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Goch, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 51.6833,
"lng": 6.1667,
"title": "Germany: self-declared prophet convicted on 132 counts against a girl raised in his sect",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-declared prophet and leader of the 'Orde der Transformanten'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the sect's prophetic authority structure in which the victim was raised",
"the group's former-monastery compound as a closed setting"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Orde der Transformanten"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht Kleve, Germany",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; acquittal on the deprivation-of-liberty counts",
"date": "2021-12-30",
"outcome": "On 30 December 2021 the Kleve regional court convicted Robert B. — the self-declared prophet of the 'Orde der Transformanten' — of sexual abuse in 132 cases, sixty-four of them severe child sexual abuse, against a girl of his faith community abused from her minority onward in the Netherlands and at the sect's former-monastery compound at Goch. He received five years and was acquitted of the unlawful-imprisonment counts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child raised inside a prophet's authority structure — the community's belief in him was the architecture of her availability.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.t-online.de/nachrichten/panorama/kriminalitaet/id_91402910/selbsternannter-prophet-sektenfuehrer-wegen-sexuellen-missbrauchs-verurteilt.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "t-online: 'Selbsternannter Prophet: Sektenführer wegen sexuellen Missbrauchs verurteilt'.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.t-online.de/nachrichten/panorama/kriminalitaet/id_91402910/selbsternannter-prophet-sektenfuehrer-wegen-sexuellen-missbrauchs-verurteilt.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "87d175514f53f09844d13931242d9cb7e8aeff114c09e29cb3644cec96a359aa",
"final_url": "https://www.t-online.de/nachrichten/panorama/kriminalitaet/id_91402910/selbsternannter-prophet-sektenfuehrer-wegen-sexuellen-missbrauchs-verurteilt.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 598,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant is not named in German reporting. NOT YET FINAL — flagged for re-check.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-pauline-priest-munich-parish-boys-germany",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Munich, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 48.14,
"lng": 11.56,
"title": "Germany: Pauline-order priest convicted of abusing two intoxicated boys of his parish",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Pauline order serving a Munich parish"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust over minors of his own parish",
"victims' intoxication"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht München I, Germany",
"stage": "first-instance conviction — not yet final",
"date": "2026-04-02",
"outcome": "On 2 April 2026 the Munich I regional court convicted a fifty-eight-year-old Pauline-order priest of sexualised violence against two intoxicated teenage boys of his parish in 2005, together with possession of child sexual-abuse material, and sentenced him to three years and three months. The judgment was not yet final at the time of reporting."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Minors of the priest's own parish, reached through the pastoral trust the office carries.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/254297/02-04-2026/priester-wegen-missbrauchs-verurteilt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "evangelisch.de: 'Priester wegen Missbrauchs verurteilt', 2 Apr. 2026.",
"body": "Court report of the verdict.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/67955-ordenspriester-wegen-sexuellen-missbrauchs-zu-haftstrafe-verurteilt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de: report of the sentence.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting-against-interest",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/254297/02-04-2026/priester-wegen-missbrauchs-verurteilt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c2f7c246f3ded67ccd541408e75dc76810322edd368edcfb151e3866badd48d8",
"final_url": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/254297/02-04-2026/priester-wegen-missbrauchs-verurteilt"
},
{
"source": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/67955-ordenspriester-wegen-sexuellen-missbrauchs-zu-haftstrafe-verurteilt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting-against-interest; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4bb0d84ec75c7a5885854014e6935a8588dcfa9abe22d9a27b2e2e16be3c82db",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/67955-ordenspriester-wegen-sexuellen-missbrauchs-zu-haftstrafe-verurteilt"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 599,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "bundesgerichtshof",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Revision rejected as unfounded — rechtskräftig."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Single-source record from a German Catholic news outlet; the victim-relationship detail beyond 'in his care' is not further specified and is not embellished here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-georg-k-priest-aachen-diocese-germany",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Krefeld, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 51.3388,
"lng": 6.5853,
"title": "Germany: priest's six-year sentence for abusing two brothers confirmed by the Federal Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of the Diocese of Aachen"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly care of two brothers over six years"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Aachen"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht Krefeld; Bundesgerichtshof",
"stage": "conviction; final after the Federal Court rejected the appeal",
"date": "2015-01-01",
"outcome": "Georg K., a former priest of the Diocese of Aachen, was convicted by the Krefeld regional court on twenty-five counts of abuse, four of them aggravated, against two brothers aged eleven to fifteen between 2001 and 2007, and sentenced to six years. The Federal Court of Justice rejected his appeal as unfounded in 2015, making the judgment final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Two brothers under a priest's pastoral care across six years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://kath.net/news/52616",
"archive": "",
"citation": "kath.net: report of the BGH's rejection and the underlying conviction.",
"body": "German Catholic news outlet's court report.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting-against-interest",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "bundesgerichtshof",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Revision rejected as unfounded — rechtskräftig."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://kath.net/news/52616",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting-against-interest; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6e7b5d9659c55a17a64587f8ed0394038397dedacb7b34077eb58bffa342727e",
"final_url": "https://kath.net/news/52616"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 600,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-timothy-mccleve-bishop-harrisville-utah-usa",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Harrisville, Utah, USA",
"lat": 41.2833,
"lng": -111.993,
"title": "United States: LDS bishop imprisoned for molesting girls of his own ward",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"bishop of a Harrisville ward, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"bishop's standing giving him access to ward families' homes while parents were away"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Second District Court, Utah, USA",
"stage": "guilty pleas in 2008 and 2011",
"date": "2008-12-18",
"outcome": "Timothy McCleve, a bishop in Harrisville, pleaded guilty to sexually molesting girls of his own ward and was sentenced in December 2008 to terms of one to fifteen years; police described him stopping by victims' homes while their parents were away. After a further victim came forward he pleaded guilty again in 2011, drawing two additional one-to-fifteen-year terms."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children of the congregation he presided over, in homes whose doors opened to him because he was their bishop.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.deseret.com/2008/12/18/20291868/ex-bishop-in-harrisville-gets-prison-for-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deseret News: 'Ex-bishop in Harrisville gets prison for sex abuse'.",
"body": "Court report of the plea and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ksl.com/article/5105707/former-lds-bishop-sentenced-for-molesting-young-girls",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KSL: sentencing report.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.deseret.com/2008/12/18/20291868/ex-bishop-in-harrisville-gets-prison-for-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f6067c9e75780a6ddf13f79ec0b8e18c48bc2832bfc4bc3ef3a8eaa5c4041573",
"final_url": "https://www.deseret.com/2008/12/18/20291868/ex-bishop-in-harrisville-gets-prison-for-sex-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ksl.com/article/5105707/former-lds-bishop-sentenced-for-molesting-young-girls",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "493e363dcabc889dc897236025bd1a4ad6997a3eeea9f84a06eef00f7ab32b43",
"final_url": "https://www.ksl.com/article/5105707/former-lds-bishop-sentenced-for-molesting-young-girls"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 601,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-erik-hughes-bishop-mapleton-utah-usa",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Mapleton, Utah, USA",
"lat": 40.13,
"lng": -111.578,
"title": "United States: Mapleton bishop imprisoned for abusing two teenage boys of his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"bishop of a Mapleton ward, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"bishop's authority over ward youth",
"witness tampering to suppress disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fourth District Court, Utah, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2017-10-10",
"outcome": "Erik Wayne Hughes, bishop of a Mapleton ward, pleaded guilty in August 2017 to sexually abusing two teenage boys of his congregation — one abused between thirty and fifty times at seventeen — together with witness tampering, and was sentenced in October 2017 to concurrent terms of one to fifteen years plus zero to five for the tampering."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ward youth under their bishop, abused during and through his tenure in that office.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sltrib.com/news/2017/10/10/utah-judge-sends-former-mormon-bishop-to-prison-for-sexually-abusing-boys-in-his-congregation/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Salt Lake Tribune: sentencing report.",
"body": "State paper of record's court reporting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fox13now.com/2017/10/10/former-lds-bishop-sentenced-for-sexually-abusing-teen-boys",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fox 13 Salt Lake City: sentencing report.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sltrib.com/news/2017/10/10/utah-judge-sends-former-mormon-bishop-to-prison-for-sexually-abusing-boys-in-his-congregation/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f6f6abebea046c8c33cf89eb4099cc47b3889c33cd4127bc04058b10637486eb",
"final_url": "https://www.sltrib.com/news/2017/10/10/utah-judge-sends-former-mormon-bishop-to-prison-for-sexually-abusing-boys-in-his-congregation/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fox13now.com/2017/10/10/former-lds-bishop-sentenced-for-sexually-abusing-teen-boys",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "789336ff90681aa25a7e2e9d50bd16718732c3d0a83c026751a1a6661438a985",
"final_url": "https://www.fox13now.com/2017/10/10/former-lds-bishop-sentenced-for-sexually-abusing-teen-boys"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 602,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. Recorded with two honest qualifications: the sentence was probation only on a reduced charge, and the victim was a family friend rather than a congregant — the criterion-fit rests on the reverence-exploitation testimony, not on a pastoral office over her.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-george-p-lee-general-authority-salt-lake-city-usa",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Salt Lake City, Utah, USA",
"lat": 40.7608,
"lng": -111.891,
"title": "United States: the highest-ranking LDS official ever convicted — 'exploited the religious respect' she held for him",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"General Authority, First Quorum of the Seventy (1975–89); former mission president"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the religious reverence owed to a General Authority, invoked in the victim's own testimony"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Third District Court, Utah, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea to a reduced charge; probation",
"date": "1994-10-11",
"outcome": "George P. Lee, a member of the First Quorum of the Seventy from 1975 to 1989 and a former mission president — the highest-ranking Latter-day Saint official ever criminally convicted — pleaded guilty in October 1994 to attempted sexual abuse of a child, a reduced third-degree felony, and received eighteen months' probation. The victim, abused from the age of nine, testified that he exploited the religious respect she held for him. He was booked again in 2007 for failing to register as a sex offender and died in 2010."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's own testimony names the mechanism — religious respect for a General Authority, converted into access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.deseret.com/1994/10/11/19135762/lee-accepts-plea-bargain-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deseret News: 'Lee accepts plea bargain in child sexual abuse case'.",
"body": "Contemporaneous court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2007/07_08/2007_07_31_Carlisle_ExLds.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Salt Lake Tribune, 2007 (archived): the failure-to-register arrest.",
"body": "Later coverage confirming the conviction history.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.deseret.com/1994/10/11/19135762/lee-accepts-plea-bargain-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5db6020db494024443ac143ba2c673804bb30fae33bdadbe6971a80c6bff7372",
"final_url": "https://www.deseret.com/1994/10/11/19135762/lee-accepts-plea-bargain-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2007/07_08/2007_07_31_Carlisle_ExLds.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "90a1c4006b95ecd169d237e9dae637b912b639888107db2b8f82f0f2c062c1f1",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2007/07_08/2007_07_31_Carlisle_ExLds.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 603,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Two precise limits: the 2018 outcome was a SETTLEMENT, not a civil finding of liability against the church, and is recorded as such; the widely-cited $32 million figure originates in leaked documents reported by an advocacy outlet and is not asserted here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-christopher-jensen-martinsburg-west-virginia-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA",
"lat": 39.4562,
"lng": -77.9639,
"title": "United States: 35-to-75 years for a church-endorsed babysitter, and the civil case the church settled mid-trial",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"member of the congregation recommended to families by local church leaders"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"local leaders' endorsement of him as a role model, which is what put him in families' homes as a babysitter"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Berkeley County Circuit Court, West Virginia (criminal, 2013); West Virginia civil courts (2018)",
"stage": "conviction at trial; related civil suit settled mid-trial",
"date": "2013-01-01",
"outcome": "Christopher Michael Jensen was convicted at trial in 2013 of sexual abuse and assault of two children and sentenced to thirty-five to seventy-five years; the conviction stands. Six families later sued the church alleging that leaders had recommended him to them and concealed prior concerns; the church settled mid-trial in 2018 for an undisclosed sum."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Jensen held no office; the authority that opened the doors was his leaders' — families trusted him because the men who led their congregation vouched for him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2018/01/17/sexual-abuse-case-against-mormon-church-scheduled-to-begin-friday/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Washington Post: coverage of the civil trial and settlement.",
"body": "National reporting on the criminal conviction and civil case.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "conviction-and-civil-case-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/recordings-show-how-mormon-church-kept-child-sex-abuse-claims-secret",
"archive": "",
"citation": "PBS NewsHour: investigation of church handling of abuse claims.",
"body": "Public broadcaster's investigative corroboration.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2018/01/17/sexual-abuse-case-against-mormon-church-scheduled-to-begin-friday/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: conviction-and-civil-case-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/recordings-show-how-mormon-church-kept-child-sex-abuse-claims-secret",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "39af75e634a8d83048959a726b4b91d1d511a7d84cb079e8214c6989b57a2be1",
"final_url": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/recordings-show-how-mormon-church-kept-child-sex-abuse-claims-secret"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 604,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. SPLIT VICTIM SET stated plainly: only the post-2005 church-role victims engage this corpus's criterion; the earlier sporting-context offences are recorded as part of the sentence but not claimed as authority-abuse.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-darran-scott-youth-leader-melbourne-australia",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Melbourne, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.8136,
"lng": 144.9631,
"title": "Australia: LDS youth leader sentenced to ten years for abusing eleven boys over twenty-five years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ward youth leader, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (from 2005)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"grooming of boys through his church youth-leader role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Victorian court, Australia",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2017-10-30",
"outcome": "Darran Scott pleaded guilty to sixteen charges covering the sexual abuse of eleven boys across twenty-five years and was sentenced in October 2017 to ten years with a seven-year non-parole period and lifetime sex-offender registration. About six of the victims were groomed through his role as a church youth leader after his 2005 conversion; earlier victims were reached through junior football coaching."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "For the church-era victims, the youth-leader role was the grooming instrument; the record says so, and says which victims it does not cover.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sltrib.com/news/2017/10/30/australian-filmmaker-gets-10-year-sentence-for-sexually-abusing-boys-some-of-whom-he-met-as-a-mormon-leader/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Salt Lake Tribune / Associated Press: sentencing report.",
"body": "Wire-sourced court reporting.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sltrib.com/news/2017/10/30/australian-filmmaker-gets-10-year-sentence-for-sexually-abusing-boys-some-of-whom-he-met-as-a-mormon-leader/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "606b5eacaf97830b7954f78c859196a63538c6473f917b6fd9b28ce552c797bc",
"final_url": "https://www.sltrib.com/news/2017/10/30/australian-filmmaker-gets-10-year-sentence-for-sexually-abusing-boys-some-of-whom-he-met-as-a-mormon-leader/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 605,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. NOT MAINLINE: this is an ex-LDS splinter sect, recorded as such and distinct from the corpus's FLDS records. The group's name is the Knights of the Crystal Blade — occasionally miscited as 'Crystal Sword'.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-coltharp-shaffer-knights-crystal-blade-utah-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Sanpete County, Utah, USA",
"lat": 39.321,
"lng": -111.576,
"title": "United States: doomsday-splinter leaders imprisoned for 'marrying' each other's small daughters",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leaders of the 'Knights of the Crystal Blade', a doomsday splinter of Latter-day Saint tradition"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"revelation claims used to designate children as 'wives'",
"child bigamy prosecuted under Utah's statute for the first time"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"organizations": [
"Knights of the Crystal Blade"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sixth District Court, Sanpete County; Fifth District Court, Cedar City, Utah",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentences",
"date": "2018-06-14",
"outcome": "John Coltharp and Samuel Shaffer, leaders of the 'Knights of the Crystal Blade' splinter sect, each 'married' the other's daughter — girls of seven and eight — under the group's revelation claims. Coltharp pleaded guilty in June 2018 to child sodomy and child bigamy and Shaffer to child rape and child abuse; both were sentenced to twenty-six years to life. It was the first prosecution under Utah's child-bigamy statute."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Doctrinal coercion in its purest form: children assigned as wives by revelation, in a sect whose entire authority was the two men's claimed prophetic standing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.deseret.com/2018/6/14/20646959/leader-of-purported-doomsday-cult-pleads-guilty-to-child-sodomy-and-child-bigamy/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deseret News: Coltharp's guilty plea.",
"body": "Court report of the plea.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fox13now.com/2018/08/08/utah-doomsday-cult-leader-sentenced",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fox 13: Shaffer's sentencing.",
"body": "Corroborating sentencing report.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.deseret.com/2018/6/14/20646959/leader-of-purported-doomsday-cult-pleads-guilty-to-child-sodomy-and-child-bigamy/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e77f2200b0e3b980a7bd04840c3a0957e25c29dcaa8622ed84d6aea23884deaa",
"final_url": "https://www.deseret.com/2018/6/14/20646959/leader-of-purported-doomsday-cult-pleads-guilty-to-child-sodomy-and-child-bigamy/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fox13now.com/2018/08/08/utah-doomsday-cult-leader-sentenced",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b7268570ddf54c6fbc644e0dd3763c5e06886a1834e3287913031fb113028fbd",
"final_url": "https://www.fox13now.com/2018/08/08/utah-doomsday-cult-leader-sentenced"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 606,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Capital appeal (Daybell) and Idaho Supreme Court appeal (Vallow) both pending — records flagged non-final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The murdered children and Tammy Daybell are named as they are named throughout the public record. APPEALS PENDING on both convictions — flagged for re-check rather than presented as final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-chad-daybell-lori-vallow-idaho-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Rexburg, Idaho, USA",
"lat": 43.826,
"lng": -111.7897,
"title": "United States: doomsday author sentenced to death for murders his followers' doctrine rationalised",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"doomsday-religious author and self-styled prophetic authority over a small following, including his co-defendant"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a 'light and dark' doctrine ranking people as possessed 'zombies'",
"prophetic authority over the children's mother, through which the killings were rationalised"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Idaho state courts (Ada County jury on a venue-changed Fremont County case); Arizona courts",
"stage": "convictions; capital sentence; appeals pending",
"date": "2024-05-30",
"outcome": "Chad Daybell was convicted on 30 May 2024 of the first-degree murders of his wife Tammy Daybell and of Lori Vallow Daybell's children JJ Vallow, seven, and Tylee Ryan, sixteen, and was sentenced to death on 1 June 2024. Lori Vallow Daybell had been convicted on 12 May 2023 of the children's murders and of conspiracy in Tammy Daybell's death, receiving life without parole; separate Arizona convictions in 2025 added further life terms. Trial evidence established that the killings were rationalised through Daybell's doctrine ranking the victims as possessed. Both appeals are pending."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The doctrinal-coercion path the corpus already recognises: the children were not Daybell's followers, but their mother was, and the doctrine is what made her participation possible. The coercion framing was rejected as a defence for Vallow, who stands convicted as a perpetrator, not a victim.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/crime-law/2024/06/01/chad-daybell-death-sentence-lori-vallow/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Washington Post: Daybell's death sentence.",
"body": "National court reporting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2024/06/01/us/chad-daybell-murder-sentencing-death-penalty",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN: sentencing coverage.",
"body": "Independent national corroboration.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Capital appeal (Daybell) and Idaho Supreme Court appeal (Vallow) both pending — records flagged non-final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/crime-law/2024/06/01/chad-daybell-death-sentence-lori-vallow/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2024/06/01/us/chad-daybell-murder-sentencing-death-penalty",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "58fe7554adb1057c2f15ea54e5ebe4b3ade89f8215e2e983973b36da4dd3f415",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2024/06/01/us/chad-daybell-murder-sentencing-death-penalty"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 607,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. BORDERLINE RECORD, flagged: qualifies only under the doctrinal-coercion exception for non-clergy quasi-religious authority. Ruby Franke, the children's mother, is expressly EXCLUDED from this corpus as a family-nexus perpetrator.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-jodi-hildebrandt-connexions-ivins-utah-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ivins, Utah, USA",
"lat": 37.1683,
"lng": -113.6786,
"title": "United States: counselor sentenced for child abuse committed through doctrinal control of a mother",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"counselor running the 'Connexions' program, exercising quasi-religious authority over clients"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"therapeutic authority framed in religious language of sin, possession and 'distortion'",
"control exercised over the children through their mother's submission"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Connexions Classroom"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fifth District Court, Washington County, Utah, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2024-02-20",
"outcome": "Jodi Hildebrandt pleaded guilty to four counts of aggravated child abuse against two of Ruby Franke's children and was sentenced on 20 February 2024 to four consecutive terms of one to fifteen years, up to thirty years in total; her counseling license was revoked in May 2024."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Hildebrandt held no church office, and the record says so: her authority was therapeutic control wrapped in religious language — sin, possession, distortion — exercised over a mother who then delivered her children to the harm. It is the same indirect doctrinal path as the corpus's Kingston exception, and it is recorded as an edge case rather than a clerical one.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ruby-franke-jodi-hildebrandt-sentenced-child-abuse-youtube-eight-passengers/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News: sentencing report.",
"body": "National court reporting.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.washco.utah.gov/departments/attorney/case-highlights-media/utah-vs-franke-hildebrandt/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Washington County Attorney: case page.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own case record.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "case-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ruby-franke-jodi-hildebrandt-sentenced-child-abuse-youtube-eight-passengers/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "84ae671accc3ebd11f7034acd6fbe9a6dc5b304725b2d1b834a43de476db4a40",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ruby-franke-jodi-hildebrandt-sentenced-child-abuse-youtube-eight-passengers/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.washco.utah.gov/departments/attorney/case-highlights-media/utah-vs-franke-hildebrandt/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: case-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "16b3fd127ede0d5a2e70f28c1c79a43675377b69f4a7037687ccc8a6fbebdd54",
"final_url": "https://www.washco.utah.gov/departments/attorney/case-highlights-media/utah-vs-franke-hildebrandt/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 608,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "regional-court",
"date": "2022-07-18",
"note": "Upheld; subsequent cassation attempt failed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Complications recorded rather than suppressed: he denied guilt throughout, and several of the adopted children publicly denied abuse and alleged that investigators had bribed or threatened witnesses. Russian judicial-independence limits are noted; against a purely political reading, the Orthodox Church itself suspended him.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-nikolai-stremsky-saraktash-obitel-russia",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Saraktash, Orenburg Oblast, Russia",
"lat": 51.7833,
"lng": 56.3333,
"title": "Russia: archpriest of a children's religious community sentenced to 21 years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"archpriest and rector of the Holy Trinity Obitel of Mercy; adoptive father and guardian of some seventy children raised inside it"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"an enclosed religious community that was simultaneously the children's home",
"combined clerical and parental authority leaving no addressable outside"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Holy Trinity Obitel of Mercy, Saraktash"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Saraktash District Court; Orenburg Regional Court, Russia",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal",
"date": "2021-12-24",
"outcome": "Nikolai Stremsky, archpriest and rector of the Holy Trinity Obitel of Mercy at Saraktash, was convicted on 24 December 2021 of rape, violent sexual acts, coercion to sexual acts, depraved acts, torture, cruel neglect of children, and involving minors in antisocial acts, against children raised in the community he ran. He received twenty-one years in a strict-regime colony plus two years' restricted liberty and a twenty-year ban on work with children, and was stripped of a state parental award. The Orenburg Regional Court upheld the conviction on 18 July 2022 and a cassation attempt failed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "DUAL AUTHORITY, stated as such: he was at once the children's adoptive father and the archpriest whose enclosed community was their entire world — the two roles are inseparable here, and the community structure is what made refusal or escape implausible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://meduza.io/feature/2021/12/24/svyaschenniku-nikolayu-stremskomu-vospitavshemu-72-rebenka-dali-21-god-po-obvineniyu-v-iznasilovaniyah-detey-poterpevshie-obvinyayut-sledstvie-v-podkupe-i-ugrozah",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Meduza: report of the 21-year sentence, including the children's counter-allegations.",
"body": "Independent outlet's court report with the disputed elements.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.interfax.ru/russia/852679",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Interfax: appellate confirmation, July 2022.",
"body": "News agency report of the appeal outcome.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "regional-court",
"date": "2022-07-18",
"note": "Upheld; subsequent cassation attempt failed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://meduza.io/feature/2021/12/24/svyaschenniku-nikolayu-stremskomu-vospitavshemu-72-rebenka-dali-21-god-po-obvineniyu-v-iznasilovaniyah-detey-poterpevshie-obvinyayut-sledstvie-v-podkupe-i-ugrozah",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6085b8cb581c38c29c1f43c4625557abeb810c4cd4b19230ca4a47e259012d70",
"final_url": "https://meduza.io/feature/2021/12/24/svyaschenniku-nikolayu-stremskomu-vospitavshemu-72-rebenka-dali-21-god-po-obvineniyu-v-iznasilovaniyah-detey-poterpevshie-obvinyayut-sledstvie-v-podkupe-i-ugrozah"
},
{
"source": "https://www.interfax.ru/russia/852679",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "475a79401cd411ed2240af6e6f207e1a032d2b448fd17e93ba8e453cec83f647",
"final_url": "https://www.interfax.ru/russia/852679"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 609,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "regional-court",
"date": "2025-11",
"note": "Sentence reduced to eight years; conviction upheld. Cassation was announced but is unresolved."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Cassation intent was announced and remains unresolved — flagged for re-check. Russian judicial-independence limits are noted; these are ordinary-criminal facts with no political dimension.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-nikolai-babura-priest-omsk-russia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Omsk, Russia",
"lat": 54.9885,
"lng": 73.3242,
"title": "Russia: priest convicted over a boy sent to stay overnight so he could serve the liturgy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Orthodox priest of the Church of the Saviour Not-Made-by-Hands, Omsk"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parents' trust in their priest, who hosted their twelve-year-old overnight so he could serve morning liturgy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sovetsky District Court of Omsk; Omsk Regional Court, Russia",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal, conviction upheld",
"date": "2025-07-09",
"outcome": "Nikolai Babura, a priest in Omsk, was convicted on 9 July 2025 of depraved acts and attempted violent sexual acts against a boy under fourteen — a twelve-year-old altar server whose parents let him stay overnight at the priest's home so he could serve morning liturgy — with a second minor victim recognised in the record. He received nine years in a strict-regime colony, a fifteen-year ban on church and minor-related activity, and damages. In November 2025 the Omsk Regional Court reduced the sentence to eight years while upholding the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The parents opened their son's overnight care to this man precisely because he was their priest and the boy his altar server.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tass.ru/proisshestviya/24468493",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TASS: report of the conviction and sentence.",
"body": "News agency court report.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://omsk.aif.ru/incidents/omskiy-sud-snizil-srok-nakazaniya-eks-svyashchenniku-razvrashchavshemu-detey",
"archive": "",
"citation": "AiF Omsk: appellate reduction to eight years.",
"body": "Regional outlet's appeal report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "regional-court",
"date": "2025-11",
"note": "Sentence reduced to eight years; conviction upheld. Cassation was announced but is unresolved."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tass.ru/proisshestviya/24468493",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://omsk.aif.ru/incidents/omskiy-sud-snizil-srok-nakazaniya-eks-svyashchenniku-razvrashchavshemu-detey",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6cf98d2033015b8c775651118dd2a0e59b48aaa3d05fa8c0034684402e7e254c",
"final_url": "https://omsk.aif.ru/incidents/omskiy-sud-snizil-srok-nakazaniya-eks-svyashchenniku-razvrashchavshemu-detey"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 610,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendants' full names are not published in the available reporting. Appeal status not reported — flagged. Russian judicial-independence limits noted; the migration count carries a state-interest overlay, but the violence counts rest on identified child victims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-ufa-underground-madrasa-bashkortostan-russia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Ufa, Bashkortostan, Russia",
"lat": 54.7388,
"lng": 55.9721,
"title": "Russia: two convicted over an unregistered religious boarding school where children were beaten and confined",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teachers running an unregistered Islamic boarding school for children aged four to sixteen"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parents surrendering children to the teachers' religious authority for Quranic education",
"closed boarding structure enabling confinement and beatings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Leninsky District Court of Ufa, Russia",
"stage": "convictions and sentences",
"date": "2025-12-04",
"outcome": "On 4 December 2025 the Leninsky District Court of Ufa convicted two men who had run an unregistered religious boarding school for Muslim children aged four to sixteen, where pupils were regularly beaten and abused until one escaped in the summer of 2024 and exposed it. They were convicted of unlawful deprivation of liberty of minors with violence, torture with cruelty, and organising illegal migration, receiving eleven and six years in strict-regime colonies with teaching bans and confiscation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parents handed their children to these men for religious education; the closed religious-boarding structure is what turned that handover into captivity.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ufa1.ru/text/criminal/2025/12/04/76154975/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ufa1: court report of the convictions and sentences.",
"body": "Regional outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ufa1.ru/text/criminal/2025/12/04/76154975/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "673b41e95c6a58bf52ad39df2dd72913a818636daaf29cbb33f116285fcf884b",
"final_url": "https://ufa1.ru/text/criminal/2025/12/04/76154975/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 611,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "regional-court",
"date": "2024-05-17",
"note": "Upheld without modification."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Russian judicial-independence limits noted, though this is apolitical ordinary fraud.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-maria-belashova-healer-rostov-russia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Rostov-on-Don, Russia",
"lat": 47.2357,
"lng": 39.7015,
"title": "Russia: online 'hereditary healer' convicted of defrauding thirteen clients seeking curse-removal",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled 'hereditary healer' trading as Maria Moreno"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed occult power over clients' fates",
"sale of curse-removal and love-return rituals"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sovetsky District Court of Rostov-on-Don; Rostov Regional Court, Russia",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal",
"date": "2024-05-17",
"outcome": "Maria Belashova, who sold curse-removal and love-return rituals online as the 'hereditary healer Maria Moreno', was convicted of fraud against at least thirteen victims across many regions between January 2019 and May 2022, causing more than two million roubles in losses, and sentenced to five years in a general-regime colony. The Rostov Regional Court upheld the sentence without modification on 17 May 2024."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The money moved only because the victims believed she held occult power over their fates — belief was the whole instrument.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20240517/309899678.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RAPSI (Russian Legal Information Agency): appellate confirmation.",
"body": "Legal news agency's court report.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "regional-court",
"date": "2024-05-17",
"note": "Upheld without modification."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20240517/309899678.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b6ffad917c99869561c9cc71508f52639f8282429b2743985b26b96cab0f6ba6",
"final_url": "https://rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20240517/309899678.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 612,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "DISPUTED RECORD, presented with both readings. CHRD, FIDH and other rights organisations characterise the prosecution as retaliation for Wu's 1989-era activism and his open letters criticising corruption, and call the sentence grossly unjust. The 'cult' count is itself the inverse category this corpus excludes; only the rape and fraud counts, which name individual victims, engage the criterion. PRC verdicts under the Article 300 framework issue from party-controlled courts and cannot be independently tested — this record asserts the fact of the conviction and the dispute over it, not the truth of the findings. A UN body has found the underlying detention unlawful, and this record does not treat the conviction as settled fact. The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, in Opinion No. 46/2016, found the detention of Wu Zeheng and eighteen others ARBITRARY under categories II, III and V — protected religious exercise, grave fair-trial breach, and religious discrimination — and called for release and compensation. The conviction and the UN finding point in opposite directions and are presented here with equal weight. A conviction obtained by a state for \"organising and using a cult to undermine law\" may constitute religious persecution rather than accountability, which is the inverse of what this archive documents and a category it otherwise excludes. The record is retained because the conviction and sentence are facts of record, not because the conviction is accepted as sound.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-wu-zeheng-huazang-dharma-zhuhai-china",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Zhuhai, Guangdong, China",
"lat": 22.2769,
"lng": 113.5678,
"title": "China: 'Huazang Dharma' leader given life imprisonment — a conviction rights groups call retaliation",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled dharma master and leader of the Huazang Dharma community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"alleged teaching that sex with him conferred spiritual attainment on female disciples"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Huazang Dharma"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Zhuhai Intermediate People's Court, Guangdong, China",
"stage": "first-instance conviction; appeal dismissed, sentence final",
"date": "2015-10-30",
"outcome": "On 30 October 2015 the Zhuhai Intermediate People's Court convicted Wu Zeheng of rape (life imprisonment), fraud (fourteen years), organising and using a cult to undermine law (twelve years) and producing or selling harmful food (six years), combining to life imprisonment with a 7.15 million yuan fine; three followers received terms of up to four years. Prosecutors alleged he told female followers that sex with him conferred spiritual attainment. He announced an appeal; no appellate ruling has been located."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Guangdong High People's Court, China",
"stage": "second-instance appeal dismissed",
"date": "2016-02-02",
"outcome": "The Guangdong High People's Court dismissed the appeals of Wu Zeheng and Meng Yue and upheld the first-instance judgment in full, leaving the life sentence and 7.15 million yuan fine final under Chinese law."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As charged, the assaults ran on his claimed dharma-master status over disciples — but this record does not pretend the charge is uncontested.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/china-sentences-cult-leader-wu-zeheng-life-prison-report-n455051",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NBC News: 'China sentences cult leader Wu Zeheng to life in prison'.",
"body": "International report of the sentence.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.nchrd.org/2015/11/chrd-decries-grossly-unjust-life-sentence-against-buddhist-leader-wu-zeheng/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Chinese Human Rights Defenders: statement contesting the conviction.",
"body": "The principal contesting account, cited so the dispute is part of the record.",
"tier": "advocacy-context",
"kind": "dispute-statement"
},
{
"link": "https://ap.ohchr.org/documents/dpage_e.aspx?si=A/HRC/WGAD/2016/46",
"citation": "UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, Opinion No. 46/2016 concerning Wu Zeheng and 18 others (China), A/HRC/WGAD/2016/46, adopted at the 77th session, 27 January 2017.",
"tier": "un-treaty-body-finding",
"kind": "official-finding",
"body": "The Working Group found the detention of Wu Zeheng and eighteen others arbitrary under categories II, III and V — that is, resulting from the exercise of protected rights including freedom of religion, in grave breach of fair-trial guarantees, and discriminatory on the basis of religious belief. The Working Group called for their release and for compensation."
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/china-sentences-cult-leader-wu-zeheng-life-prison-report-n455051",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4871004c0c57562627f97e00e136cca6a88e100abf6d24f8eff2c4ecb3f0cc83",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/china-sentences-cult-leader-wu-zeheng-life-prison-report-n455051"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nchrd.org/2015/11/chrd-decries-grossly-unjust-life-sentence-against-buddhist-leader-wu-zeheng/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-context; evidentiary role: dispute-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7ab2eef83cdd5cc3fa0daa573753fc46240d973b2b8b6ec350d737e43c0e86ff",
"final_url": "https://www.nchrd.org/2015/11/chrd-decries-grossly-unjust-life-sentence-against-buddhist-leader-wu-zeheng/"
},
{
"source": "https://ap.ohchr.org/documents/dpage_e.aspx?si=A/HRC/WGAD/2016/46",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: un-treaty-body-finding; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0b531b16a3ac870e38230001a001951a377ef99b80fdfabbed46b099ea4f829f",
"final_url": "https://ap.ohchr.org/documents/dpage_e.aspx?si=A/HRC/WGAD/2016/46"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 613,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "second-instance",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Conviction upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. SOURCING CAVEAT: the account rests on Chinese state media (Global Times) and cannot be independently verified; the court is not named in available reporting. PRC judicial-independence limits noted, though the predominant counts are ordinary-criminal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-yang-hongchen-false-lama-shenzhen-china",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Shenzhen, Guangdong, China",
"lat": 22.5431,
"lng": 114.0579,
"title": "China: man posing as a reincarnated lama convicted of raping and defrauding followers",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"impostor claiming to be the reincarnation of a respected monk, with fabricated temple credentials"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"fabricated tulku status commanding disciples' obedience",
"claimed spiritual credentials used to extract money and sexual access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Chinese court, Guangdong (court not named in available reporting); second-instance trial completed",
"stage": "conviction; upheld at second instance",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"outcome": "Yang Hongchen, who posed as the reincarnation of a respected monk using fabricated ties to a Hebei temple, was convicted of using superstition to undermine law enforcement, fraud, rape and embezzlement — raping multiple female followers, one of whom became pregnant, and defrauding believers — and sentenced to eighteen years plus a 150,000 yuan fine. He pleaded not guilty at both instances; the second-instance trial concluded by early 2021, making the conviction final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sexual access and money both flowed from a fabricated reincarnation status that disciples believed in.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202102/1214673.shtml",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Global Times: report on convictions of false 'living Buddhas'.",
"body": "State-media court report (the only available account).",
"tier": "state-media-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "second-instance",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Conviction upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202102/1214673.shtml",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-media-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ef1d472b93e629618b6522a009cabfa3064d46d9148fb45593e2a8f06f969171",
"final_url": "https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202102/1214673.shtml"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 614,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-people's-court",
"date": "1999",
"note": "Death sentence upheld; executed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. STRONG CAVEAT: the execution came weeks after China's 1999 anti-cult legislative push amid the Falun Gong crackdown, and the cult-organising count is itself the inverse category this corpus excludes. The eleven identified rape victims, two of them children, are the concrete ordinary-criminal core on which this record rests. PRC verdicts cannot be independently tested.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1999-liu-jiaguo-lord-god-sect-hunan-china",
"year": 1999,
"place": "Hunan, China",
"lat": 28.1127,
"lng": 112.9834,
"title": "China: 'Lord God Sect' founder executed after conviction for raping eleven followers",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder of the 'Zhusheng Jiao' (Lord God Sect), claiming to be the Lord God"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rapes framed as the divine prerogative of the sect's god-figure over believers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Zhusheng Jiao (Lord God Sect)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hunan courts; Hunan High People's Court, China",
"stage": "conviction and death sentence; upheld and carried out",
"date": "1999-10-01",
"outcome": "Liu Jiaguo, who founded the Zhusheng Jiao in 1993 claiming to be the Lord God, was convicted of raping eleven female followers — two of them under fourteen — along with fraud and the cult-organising count. The Hunan High People's Court upheld his death sentence and he was executed in October 1999; his deputy Zhu Aiqing received seventeen years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The rapes were presented to believers as the prerogative of the god they followed — doctrine as the mechanism of access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.deseret.com/1999/10/13/19470304/china-executes-leader-of-cult-for-rape-and-fraud/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deseret News / wire: 'China executes leader of cult for rape and fraud'.",
"body": "Contemporaneous wire report.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "execution-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.duihuahrjournal.org/2012/12/three-imprisoned-in-lord-god-sect-cult.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dui Hua Human Rights Journal: background on the Lord God Sect prosecutions.",
"body": "Human-rights research context on the case set.",
"tier": "advocacy-context",
"kind": "case-background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-people's-court",
"date": "1999",
"note": "Death sentence upheld; executed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.deseret.com/1999/10/13/19470304/china-executes-leader-of-cult-for-rape-and-fraud/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: execution-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "358db7ae5b2252c0031772f29e44a796bd7630f429ec3c16d1bab86ad6c4dbc0",
"final_url": "https://www.deseret.com/1999/10/13/19470304/china-executes-leader-of-cult-for-rape-and-fraud/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.duihuahrjournal.org/2012/12/three-imprisoned-in-lord-god-sect-cult.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-context; evidentiary role: case-background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e57025229be9c180580e58009e5b0297821cbe8d8b26cceb7f8ee6c71fef027a",
"final_url": "https://www.duihuahrjournal.org/2012/12/three-imprisoned-in-lord-god-sect-cult.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 615,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2016-03-11",
"note": "Sentences finalised."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim is not named here. Taiwan's judiciary is independent; no caveat applies.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-chen-chiao-ming-sun-moon-bright-merit-taiwan",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Changhua, Taiwan",
"lat": 24.0518,
"lng": 120.5161,
"title": "Taiwan: cultivation-group leader's thirteen-year sentence for a member's son beaten to death in confinement",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader of the 'Sun Moon Bright Merit' (日月明功) self-cultivation group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"confinement ordered at the group's compound",
"the victim's own mother enforcing the detention under the leader's authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"日月明功 (Sun Moon Bright Merit)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Taiwanese courts; Supreme Court of Taiwan",
"stage": "convictions final",
"date": "2016-03-11",
"outcome": "After an eighteen-year-old member's son was accused of drug use in 2013, he was detained for roughly eighteen days at the group's compound, beaten with bamboo rods and hoses and starved, losing ten kilograms; the autopsy found no drugs and attributed death to prolonged abuse and malnutrition. On 11 March 2016 Taiwan's Supreme Court finalised the sentences: group leader Chen Chiao-ming thirteen years for unlawful detention resulting in death, the boy's mother Huang Fen-que four and a half years, and three core followers three years and eight months to four years. Chen was paroled in 2025."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boy could not refuse a confinement ordered by the leader his own mother obeyed — the group's authority reached him through his parent.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/201603115011.aspx",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Central News Agency (Taiwan): Supreme Court finalises the sentences.",
"body": "National news agency's court report.",
"tier": "national-news-agency",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2016-03-11",
"note": "Sentences finalised."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/201603115011.aspx",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-agency; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "53a1ea9f3e131acd1f3c633f11c9ce5494e37a4c09678237232b913f344aba25",
"final_url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/201603115011.aspx"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 616,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Hong Kong's Court of First Instance in 2003; no caveat applied to the judiciary of that period.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-o-kai-on-feng-shui-master-hong-kong",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Hong Kong",
"lat": 22.3193,
"lng": 114.1694,
"title": "Hong Kong: feng shui master jailed for 'mystical rites' sex with a fourteen-year-old",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"feng shui master consulted as a spiritual practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed ritual necessity used to manufacture the girl's compliance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of First Instance, Hong Kong",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2003-01-31",
"outcome": "O Kai-on, a feng shui master, pleaded guilty and was sentenced on 31 January 2003 to four and a half years for two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with a fourteen-year-old girl in May 2002, procured through purported mystical rites; the judge found he had cynically exploited the trust placed in him."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Her compliance was manufactured out of ritual necessity — the rites were the coercion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.scmp.com/article/405195/fung-shui-master-jailed-mystical-rites-sex",
"archive": "",
"citation": "South China Morning Post: 'Fung shui master jailed for mystical rites sex'.",
"body": "Hong Kong paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.scmp.com/article/405195/fung-shui-master-jailed-mystical-rites-sex",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a46758e6506d26dab4b67bfadd14656aa8bb2b17d8d70b870c8471ea04775aea",
"final_url": "https://www.scmp.com/article/405195/fung-shui-master-jailed-mystical-rites-sex"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 617,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Sourced to the convicting court's own website, unusually strong provenance for a PRC record. PRC courts are not independent of the Party-state; this record is evidence that the state asserted these facts. Any Article 300 'evil cult' count is treated as non-probative — the record rests on the concrete offences against identified victims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-wen-jinlu-sun-moon-qigong-luohe-china",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Luohe, Henan, China",
"lat": 33.5814,
"lng": 114.0269,
"title": "China: 'Sun-Moon Qigong' master sentenced to nineteen years for raping followers under dual-cultivation doctrine",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled 教主 (sect head) of the Sun-Moon Qigong group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teaching that 阴阳双修 (yin-yang dual cultivation) increased followers' spiritual power",
"claim that 'the teacher behind me has designated us husband and wife'",
"psychological control over multiple female followers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"日月气功 (Sun-Moon Qigong)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Luohe Intermediate People's Court, Henan, China",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-06-15",
"outcome": "Wen Jinlu, head of the Sun-Moon Qigong group, was convicted on 15 June 2020 of rape and forcible indecency against female followers, alongside a cult-organising count, and sentenced to nineteen years; six co-defendants received terms from two years and ten months to three years and six months suspended. The court found he exercised psychological control through the doctrine that dual cultivation increased followers' spiritual power, telling women that 'the teacher behind me has designated us husband and wife'. The group had taken some 8.19 million yuan in offerings."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The doctrine made refusal a spiritual failure — dual cultivation was taught as the path to power, so submission was framed as devotion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lhzy.hncourt.gov.cn/public/detail.php?id=5077",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Luohe Intermediate People's Court: case announcement.",
"body": "The convicting court's own publication.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.hncourt.gov.cn/public/detail.php?id=181175",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Henan Provincial Courts: case report.",
"body": "Provincial judiciary corroboration.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lhzy.hncourt.gov.cn/public/detail.php?id=5077",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.hncourt.gov.cn/public/detail.php?id=181175",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 618,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant is identified only by surname in available reporting. The case was later selected into the Supreme People's Court reference-case database, the strongest documentary status available in the PRC system. PRC courts are not independent of the Party-state; this record is evidence that the state asserted these facts. Any Article 300 'evil cult' count is treated as non-probative — the record rests on the concrete offences against identified victims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-deyang-fake-monk-exorcism-sichuan-china",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Deyang, Sichuan, China",
"lat": 31.1272,
"lng": 104.398,
"title": "China: fake monk given a suspended death sentence for rapes under exorcism and luck-changing rituals",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"impostor posing as a Buddhist monk offering 驱鬼 (exorcism), 转运 (luck-changing) and 封痣 (mole-sealing)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual services as the route to victims",
"warnings of divine retribution — that a victim who spoke would be hit by a car"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Deyang Intermediate People's Court, Sichuan, China",
"stage": "conviction and suspended death sentence",
"date": "2019-12-01",
"outcome": "A man who had briefly been ordained at a Zhejiang temple in 2006–07 and later posed as a monk offering exorcism, luck-changing and mole-sealing rituals was convicted in December 2019 of rape, forcible indecency and child molestation — raping five victims on ten occasions, including two girls under fourteen on six occasions, and molesting three children on seven occasions. He received a death sentence with a two-year reprieve and lifetime deprivation of political rights. He had silenced victims by warning of divine retribution."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The rituals were the access and the threat of supernatural punishment was the silence — belief operating at both ends of the crime.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/440041.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme People's Court: reference-case entry.",
"body": "The apex court's own case database.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "reference-case-entry"
},
{
"link": "https://m.thepaper.cn/newsDetail_forward_5311969",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Paper (澎湃新闻): court report.",
"body": "National outlet's court reporting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/440041.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: reference-case-entry.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eb73d6b711d123627da4dab914da36aacb5d290c8d72971be4b1f65095852e0b",
"final_url": "https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/440041.html"
},
{
"source": "https://m.thepaper.cn/newsDetail_forward_5311969",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dc067eb24a5cec5cb353421fff0fe8ee37c63b6b2f8aa46e0521761567f27059",
"final_url": "https://m.thepaper.cn/newsDetail_forward_5311969"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 619,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; the defendant is identified by surname. The extension of the curse-claim to a child is stated as the reporting states it. PRC courts are not independent of the Party-state; this record is evidence that the state asserted these facts. Any Article 300 'evil cult' count is treated as non-probative — the record rests on the concrete offences against identified victims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-shangdu-fate-changing-master-inner-mongolia-china",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Shangdu County, Inner Mongolia, China",
"lat": 41.5619,
"lng": 113.5561,
"title": "China: itinerant 'master' convicted after telling a mother and daughter a curse required a virgin's blood",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"itinerant self-styled master claiming ritual power to change fate"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"repeated warnings that 'an evil spirit has marked you' until the victim saw him as her sole savior",
"claim that only 阴阳双修 could break the curse",
"claim that the curse required a virgin's blood, extending the coercion to her 15-year-old daughter"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Shangdu County People's Court, Inner Mongolia, China",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; verdict effective",
"date": "2026-06-01",
"outcome": "A man surnamed Zhang, met online claiming ritual power to change fate, moved into a woman's home for two weeks and repeatedly told her that someone meant her harm and that an evil spirit had marked her, until she regarded him as her only savior; he then told her that only yin-yang dual cultivation could break the curse. He extended the claim to her fifteen-year-old daughter, saying the curse could only be broken with a virgin's blood. Convicted of rape as a recidivist, he was sentenced to nine years, and the verdict took effect without appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Manufactured dependency: the 'curse' was escalated until the victim believed he was her only protection, and the doctrine then prescribed exactly what he wanted.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://finance.sina.com.cn/wm/2026-06-23/doc-inienawk3156207.shtml",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sina: court report of the Shangdu County verdict.",
"body": "National portal's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://finance.sina.com.cn/wm/2026-06-23/doc-inienawk3156207.shtml",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bd5ddc6f737df1fb0411903aec5fa7549da105aa9b64465761277110efa6b151",
"final_url": "https://finance.sina.com.cn/wm/2026-06-23/doc-inienawk3156207.shtml"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 620,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified; the defendant is identified by nickname in the reporting. Taiwan's judiciary is independent; no caveat applies. Appealable at the time of reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-taitung-spirit-medium-talisman-taiwan",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Taitung, Taiwan",
"lat": 22.7583,
"lng": 121.1444,
"title": "Taiwan: spirit medium convicted for telling a client that talismans inside her body would kill her",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"乩身 (spirit medium) operating a temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claim that talismans 符咒 were inside her body and she would die unless sexual acts removed them",
"the ritual frame neutralising her family, who waited outside the door"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Taitung District Court, Taiwan",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; appealable",
"date": "2026-07-01",
"outcome": "A 22-year-old temple operator working as a 乩身 (spirit medium) was convicted in July 2026 of forced sexual intercourse and sentenced to four years and eight months, for telling an adult female client that talismans were lodged inside her body and that she would die unless sexual acts removed them. Her family waited outside the door during the assault."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The ritual frame did double work — it produced her submission and it kept her family sitting outside the room.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ettoday.net/news/20260705/3195698.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ETtoday: court report of the Taitung verdict.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ettoday.net/news/20260705/3195698.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7f8c848258eab73bd037f985573019e08eed633b1fc57d9807df60b310cd1920",
"final_url": "https://www.ettoday.net/news/20260705/3195698.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 621,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified; the defendant is identified by surname. Taiwan's judiciary is independent; no caveat applies. A short sentence, stated as imposed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-taipei-temple-master-acupoint-indecency-taiwan",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Taipei, Taiwan",
"lat": 25.033,
"lng": 121.5654,
"title": "Taiwan: temple master convicted under the statute for abusing a relationship of authority",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"宮主 (temple master)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"an exorcism (驅邪) pretext",
"telling the believer that her breasts were 穴道 (acupuncture points)"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Taipei District Court, Taiwan",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"outcome": "A temple master surnamed Tseng was convicted by the Taipei District Court of sexual harassment by exploiting a relationship of authority, for touching a female believer's breasts under an exorcism pretext while telling her they were acupuncture points. He received seven months."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Legally the cleanest expression of this database's criterion anywhere in the corpus: he was charged under the provision that specifically covers abuse of a relationship of authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/breakingnews/5491287",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Liberty Times: court report.",
"body": "National paper's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/breakingnews/5491287",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f38f5c74553aee4a06d68fd67f98a981326bf6e5db1c2805ab1fac2639ad2d5",
"final_url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/breakingnews/5491287"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 622,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Singapore's judiciary is independent; no caveat applies.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-tan-beng-kwee-home-temple-singapore",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Ang Mo Kio, Singapore",
"lat": 1.3691,
"lng": 103.8454,
"title": "Singapore: home-temple founder jailed for assaulting a girl during lessons at his temple residence",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and spirit medium of a home temple in Ang Mo Kio"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"one-to-one wushu lessons at the temple residence",
"threats of supernatural punishment to enforce silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "State Courts of Singapore (Principal District Judge Toh Han Li)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-01",
"outcome": "Tan Beng Kwee, 63, who had run a home temple since 2007 as its founder and spirit medium, was sentenced in January 2026 to nine years and four months for attempted sexual penetration of a minor under sixteen, sexual penetration of a minor under sixteen, and procuring an indecent act from a young person. The victim, aged fourteen to fifteen, was reached through one-to-one wushu lessons at the temple residence, and the prosecution established that he threatened supernatural punishment to keep her silent."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The spiritual authority worked as enforcement after the fact as well as access before it — the threat of supernatural punishment is what kept her quiet.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/southeast-asia/article/3338355/singapore-home-temple-founder-jailed-sexually-assaulting-girl-during-wushu-lessons",
"archive": "",
"citation": "South China Morning Post: report of the sentence.",
"body": "Regional paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/southeast-asia/article/3338355/singapore-home-temple-founder-jailed-sexually-assaulting-girl-during-wushu-lessons",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d3c0c858e518b38d346b4d38c3211e6840c11e2599f921b895c9e2b2f2a325d9",
"final_url": "https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/southeast-asia/article/3338355/singapore-home-temple-founder-jailed-sexually-assaulting-girl-during-wushu-lessons"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 623,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Russian courts lack structural judicial independence — conviction rates exceed 99% and Investigative Committee releases are often the only public record; this is evidence of a state finding, not of independently adjudicated fact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-hieromonk-spiridon-amurzet-russia",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Amurzet, Jewish Autonomous Oblast, Russia",
"lat": 47.7,
"lng": 131.0833,
"title": "Russia: village rector sentenced to eighteen years for abusing fifty-three boys over twelve years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"hieromonk and rector of the Holy Prophet Elijah Church, Amurzet"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish and altar-server life as the route to boys",
"rectorship of the village's only church supplying both access and silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court in the Jewish Autonomous Oblast, Russia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-11-08",
"outcome": "Hieromonk Spiridon, in the world Yuri Abramov, rector of the Holy Prophet Elijah Church in Amurzet, was convicted on 8 November 2021 of the sexual abuse of fifty-three boys over twelve years, from 2007 to 2019, and sentenced to eighteen years in a strict-regime colony with two years' movement restriction and an eight-year ban on pedagogical activity. A co-defendant, the church's bell-ringer Sergey Moos, received twelve years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "He was the rector of the only church in the village — which supplied the access to boys drawn into parish and altar life, and the silence afterwards.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lenta.ru/news/2021/11/08/pedifill/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lenta.ru: report of the eighteen-year sentence.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rbc.ru/rbcfreenews/6189059c9a7947413d15fe6d",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RBC: corroborating report.",
"body": "National business daily's report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lenta.ru/news/2021/11/08/pedifill/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "97796957c626ad28c692476171526e3e4a11cb08f54bd219e66705c96a5296c9",
"final_url": "https://lenta.ru/news/2021/11/08/pedifill/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rbc.ru/rbcfreenews/6189059c9a7947413d15fe6d",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 624,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The gap between eighty-seven alleged and forty-six proven episodes is stated as an evidentiary-attrition marker rather than collapsed. Russian courts lack structural judicial independence — conviction rates exceed 99% and Investigative Committee releases are often the only public record; this is evidence of a state finding, not of independently adjudicated fact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-hieromonk-meletiy-yakutsk-gymnasium-russia",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Yakutsk, Sakha Republic, Russia",
"lat": 62.0355,
"lng": 129.6755,
"title": "Russia: Orthodox gymnasium director convicted on forty-six proven episodes against his pupils",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"hieromonk; director of the Svyato-Innokentyevskaya Orthodox gymnasium"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"combined spiritual and administrative authority over his own pupils in a church school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Svyato-Innokentyevskaya Orthodox gymnasium, Yakutsk"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Khangalassky District Court, Sakha Republic, Russia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2018-11-28",
"outcome": "Hieromonk Meletiy (Tkachenko), director of the Svyato-Innokentyevskaya Orthodox gymnasium in Yakutsk, was convicted on 28 November 2018 over the abuse of minor pupils across seven years: of eighty-seven alleged episodes, forty-six were proven at trial. He received seventeen years in a strict-regime colony with a psychiatric referral, denied guilt and appealed; the Yakutsk eparchy announced his defrocking."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Pupils in a church school whose director held spiritual and administrative power over them at once.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lenta.ru/articles/2018/12/04/yakutsk/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lenta.ru: long-form account of the case and verdict.",
"body": "National outlet's case report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lenta.ru/articles/2018/12/04/yakutsk/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8f96e6037df8484e190745455c3e33bdac3d0783c7f1b160eb1cbbdb0dc0aaf5",
"final_url": "https://lenta.ru/articles/2018/12/04/yakutsk/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 625,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "oblast-court",
"date": "2018-04-13",
"note": "Appeal denied; verdict in force."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Russian courts lack structural judicial independence — conviction rates exceed 99% and Investigative Committee releases are often the only public record; this is evidence of a state finding, not of independently adjudicated fact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-gleb-grozovsky-konevets-camp-russia",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Priozersk, Leningrad Oblast, Russia",
"lat": 61.0417,
"lng": 30.1289,
"title": "Russia: priest convicted of abusing children at Orthodox camps — appeal denied",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Gatchina and Luga eparchy; spiritual leader at Orthodox children's camps"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"children entrusted to him by parents precisely because of his clerical standing",
"camp settings on Konevets Island and in Greece"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Priozersk City Court; Leningrad Oblast Court, Russia",
"stage": "conviction; appeal denied — verdict in force",
"date": "2018-01-17",
"outcome": "Gleb Grozovsky, a priest of the Gatchina and Luga eparchy, was convicted on 17 January 2018 of violent sexual acts against three minors at Orthodox children's camps on Konevets Island and on Kos in Greece in 2009 and 2013, and sentenced to fourteen years in a strict-regime colony with one year's restriction. The Leningrad Oblast Court upheld the verdict on 13 April 2018."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parents handed their children to a camp's spiritual leader because of what he was — the clerical standing is what made the entrusting possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://meduza.io/feature/2018/01/17/svyaschennik-gleb-grozovskiy-poluchil-14-let-po-obvineniyu-v-pedofilii-ranshe-on-byl-duhovnikom-futbolistov-zenita",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Meduza: report of the fourteen-year sentence.",
"body": "Independent outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20180413/282494373.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RAPSI: appellate confirmation.",
"body": "Legal news agency's appeal report.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "oblast-court",
"date": "2018-04-13",
"note": "Appeal denied; verdict in force."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://meduza.io/feature/2018/01/17/svyaschennik-gleb-grozovskiy-poluchil-14-let-po-obvineniyu-v-pedofilii-ranshe-on-byl-duhovnikom-futbolistov-zenita",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "724bb773a0edb0429b844ca3d088b681ac9d921f04b648dcc221df04d151952e",
"final_url": "https://meduza.io/feature/2018/01/17/svyaschennik-gleb-grozovskiy-poluchil-14-let-po-obvineniyu-v-pedofilii-ranshe-on-byl-duhovnikom-futbolistov-zenita"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20180413/282494373.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1218a74ba534eda600019f80ce93e2e64829dcfcbfc926e8b161d9047492624f",
"final_url": "https://www.rapsinews.ru/judicial_news/20180413/282494373.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 626,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Russian courts lack structural judicial independence — conviction rates exceed 99% and Investigative Committee releases are often the only public record; this is evidence of a state finding, not of independently adjudicated fact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-hieromonk-kliment-orenburg-russia",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Orenburg Oblast, Russia",
"lat": 51.7727,
"lng": 55.0988,
"title": "Russia: hieromonk sentenced to thirteen years for violent acts against children under fourteen",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"hieromonk serving as a parish priest in Orenburg Oblast"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical access to local children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court in Orenburg Oblast, Russia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-09-03",
"outcome": "Hieromonk Kliment (Korablev) was convicted on 3 September 2021 of three episodes of violent sexual acts against children under fourteen between January 2019 and February 2020, together with inducing a minor to consume alcohol, and sentenced to thirteen years in a strict-regime colony. The church deferred his defrocking until the verdict entered force."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A parish priest's standing with local children was the opportunity.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://meduza.io/news/2021/09/03/ieromonah-iz-orenburgskoy-oblasti-prigovoren-k-13-godam-zaklyucheniya-za-pedofiliyu",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Meduza: report of the thirteen-year sentence.",
"body": "Independent outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rbc.ru/rbcfreenews/613218c89a79472a432e36d2",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RBC: corroborating report.",
"body": "National business daily's report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://meduza.io/news/2021/09/03/ieromonah-iz-orenburgskoy-oblasti-prigovoren-k-13-godam-zaklyucheniya-za-pedofiliyu",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "122f45e0830de792dbc5c35efd096f0c9651e4d128dda03383e5e23510925f72",
"final_url": "https://meduza.io/news/2021/09/03/ieromonah-iz-orenburgskoy-oblasti-prigovoren-k-13-godam-zaklyucheniya-za-pedofiliyu"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rbc.ru/rbcfreenews/613218c89a79472a432e36d2",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 627,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. He pleaded guilty. Russian courts lack structural judicial independence — conviction rates exceed 99% and Investigative Committee releases are often the only public record; this is evidence of a state finding, not of independently adjudicated fact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-alexei-mokievsky-lipin-bor-russia",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Lipin Bor, Vologda Oblast, Russia",
"lat": 60.25,
"lng": 37.9167,
"title": "Russia: rector convicted after eighteen months of indecent acts against a twelve-year-old parishioner",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"rector of the Holy Trinity church, Lipin Bor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish standing giving him household-level trust — the victim was a parishioner and his son's classmate"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court in Vologda Oblast, Russia",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2019-04-12",
"outcome": "Alexei Mokievsky, rector of the Holy Trinity church at Lipin Bor, was convicted on 12 April 2019 of eighteen months of indecent acts against a twelve-year-old parishioner between 2017 and 2018, together with producing and distributing pornographic material — he filmed the child and sent her pornography over social media. He pleaded guilty and received four and a half years; he was suspended after his October 2018 arrest and defrocked in early 2019."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A parishioner and his own son's classmate — the parish role converted into household trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lenta.ru/news/2019/04/12/saint/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lenta.ru: report of the conviction and sentence.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lenta.ru/news/2019/04/12/saint/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9ee93a47e8216edc639778f834e668d92f52e1de0e676fe4e058fc93f9c2864b",
"final_url": "https://lenta.ru/news/2019/04/12/saint/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 628,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "oblast-court",
"date": "2023-08",
"note": "Sentence converted to suspended; released."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Congregants not identified. CRITICAL SEPARATION: in 2026 Moskvitin was prosecuted AGAIN and sentenced to three years for preaching in an 'undesirable religious organisation'. That second case is religious PERSECUTION — the inverse category — and is expressly excluded from this corpus. Only the 2023 congregant-harm conviction is recorded here, and the two must never be conflated. Russian courts lack structural judicial independence — conviction rates exceed 99% and Investigative Committee releases are often the only public record; this is evidence of a state finding, not of independently adjudicated fact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-stanislav-moskvitin-new-creation-omsk-russia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Omsk, Russia",
"lat": 54.9885,
"lng": 73.3242,
"title": "Russia: pastor convicted of inducing trance states in congregants — and later prosecuted for his beliefs",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the 'New Creation' church, Omsk"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"hypnosis inducing trance states during worship services",
"psychological effects on adepts including children",
"savings obtained from around a hundred congregants"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"'Новое творение' (New Creation), Omsk"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kirovsky District Court of Omsk; Omsk Oblast Court, Russia",
"stage": "conviction; converted to a suspended sentence on appeal",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "Stanislav Moskvitin, pastor of the 'New Creation' church in Omsk, was convicted in 2023 of psychological violence against congregants — inducing trance states through hypnosis during services, affecting adepts including children — and of obtaining savings from around a hundred congregants. He received a year and a half in a general-regime colony; in August 2023 the Omsk Oblast Court converted the sentence to a suspended term and released him. He did not admit guilt."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The worship service itself was the delivery mechanism — the pastoral role was the method, not merely the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ngs55.ru/text/criminal/2023/08/26/72636071/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NGS Omsk: appellate outcome and case summary.",
"body": "Regional outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "oblast-court",
"date": "2023-08",
"note": "Sentence converted to suspended; released."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ngs55.ru/text/criminal/2023/08/26/72636071/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a3639dfbd61a1e882046df649ba79078c96e2e8c1a6cb9bc718554411c1ad800",
"final_url": "https://ngs55.ru/text/criminal/2023/08/26/72636071/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 629,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual): the ritual was performed on children who were not adherents. The co-accused women's subordination to Lim's holy-man persona is recorded because the prosecution relied on it. Child victims are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1983-adrian-lim-toa-payoh-ritual-murders-singapore",
"year": 1983,
"place": "Toa Payoh, Singapore",
"lat": 1.3343,
"lng": 103.8563,
"title": "Singapore: self-styled medium executed for child killings staged as blood sacrifices to Kali",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled spirit medium and healer commanding a small following of women"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"children killed as blood sacrifices to the goddess Kali",
"the 'holy man' persona used to control the co-accused women"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Singapore",
"stage": "conviction and death sentence; appeals exhausted; executed",
"date": "1983-05-25",
"outcome": "Adrian Lim, a self-styled spirit medium and healer, was convicted with Tan Mui Choo and Hoe Kah Hong of the murders of two children aged nine and ten, killed in 1981 as blood sacrifices to the goddess Kali. The prosecution established that the killings formed part of the fraudulent holy-man persona through which Lim controlled the two women. All three were sentenced to death, appeals failed, and they were executed in November 1988."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "MIXED: the child victims were strangers to the group — this is victim-directed ritual, not authority-abuse toward them. But the two women convicted alongside Lim WERE under his claimed spiritual authority, which the prosecution identified as the mechanism of their participation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.executedtoday.com/2011/11/25/1988-adrian-lim-toa-payoh-murders-singapore/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Executed Today: the Toa Payoh ritual murders case history.",
"body": "Case-history account of the trial, sentence and execution.",
"tier": "reference-index",
"kind": "case-chronology"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.executedtoday.com/2011/11/25/1988-adrian-lim-toa-payoh-murders-singapore/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-index; evidentiary role: case-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aa7e6b52fdecbcdbdd1016997d607a185b2ab55f8b21675f928089ff2f607c60",
"final_url": "https://www.executedtoday.com/2011/11/25/1988-adrian-lim-toa-payoh-murders-singapore/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 630,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed religious lure). The false ZCC claim is drawn from surviving victims' trial testimony. The Zion Christian Church is in no way implicated — he impersonated it. Victims are not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-jack-mogale-west-end-preacher-south-africa",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Gauteng, South Africa",
"lat": -26.2041,
"lng": 28.0473,
"title": "South Africa: serial killer who posed as a church prophet to lure his victims",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none genuine — he falsely presented himself as a Zion Christian Church preacher and prophet"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false claim of being a ZCC preacher/prophet, used to win victims' trust before assault"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Johannesburg High Court, South Africa",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2011-02-17",
"outcome": "Madumetsa Jack Mogale, known as the West End serial killer, was convicted on 17 February 2011 of sixteen murders, nineteen rapes and nine kidnappings, and sentenced to sixteen life terms plus twenty-three years. Two surviving victims testified that he had identified himself as a Zion Christian Church preacher and prophet to gain their trust before assaulting and killing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "IMPERSONATED authority, victim-directed: he held no religious office, but the claim of being a prophet is precisely what made women trust him — the borrowed authority was the lure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAGPJHC/2011/57.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "S v Mogale, [2011] ZAGPJHC 57 (South Gauteng High Court).",
"body": "The court judgment.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "trial-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://mg.co.za/article/2011-03-16-westend-serial-killer-mogale-found-guilty/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mail & Guardian: 'West End serial killer Mogale found guilty'.",
"body": "National paper's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAGPJHC/2011/57.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: trial-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://mg.co.za/article/2011-03-16-westend-serial-killer-mogale-found-guilty/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b6d6997921efffe2be8967880bd5a57d8dcf06b25476959c8008252ea26d4a49",
"final_url": "https://mg.co.za/news/south-africa/2011-03-16-west-end-serial-killer-mogale-found-guilty/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 631,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "",
"note": "Conviction and death sentence upheld through the Medan High Court and Supreme Court."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. The ritual account comes from his confession and the trial record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-ahmad-suradji-dukun-north-sumatra-indonesia",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Lubuk Pakam, North Sumatra, Indonesia",
"lat": 3.5586,
"lng": 98.8739,
"title": "Indonesia: dukun executed after 42 murders of women who came to him for spiritual help",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dukun (traditional healer and sorcerer) with a standing client base"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"victims drawn from his own healing clientele",
"ritual burial to the waist before strangulation, performed as a rite to increase his mystical power"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lubuk Pakam District Court; Medan High Court; Supreme Court of Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction affirmed at every level; executed",
"date": "1998-04-27",
"outcome": "Ahmad Suradji, a dukun practising near Medan, was convicted on 27 April 1998 of forty-two counts of premeditated murder — women and girls drawn from his healing clientele, buried to the waist and strangled in a rite he told investigators was meant to increase his mystical powers. The conviction was upheld by the Medan High Court and the Indonesian Supreme Court, and he was executed on 10 July 2008."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE: the victims were his own clients — women who came to a healer for help and were killed inside the ritual frame that brought them to him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2008/01/28/fate-039dukun-as039-be-decided.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Jakarta Post: reporting on the case and the pending execution.",
"body": "National paper of record.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "case-history-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "",
"note": "Conviction and death sentence upheld through the Medan High Court and Supreme Court."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2008/01/28/fate-039dukun-as039-be-decided.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: case-history-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "777c9fac780d84a5400b4c24702f7d28a805868c2274a545c86856b80572b2ee",
"final_url": "https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2008/01/28/fate-039dukun-as039-be-decided"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 632,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2008",
"note": "Conviction and death sentence affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Among the very few cases in this corpus where a woman leader was executed for abuse of her own followers.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2001-sachiko-eto-exorcism-beating-deaths-japan",
"year": 2001,
"place": "Fukushima Prefecture, Japan",
"lat": 37.7503,
"lng": 140.4676,
"title": "Japan: self-professed exorcist executed for beating six believers to death in demon-expulsion rites",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-professed exorcist and faith healer leading a small group of believers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"beatings with taiko drumsticks staged explicitly as demon expulsion",
"followers' belief that the violence was spiritual treatment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fukushima District Court; Sendai High Court; Supreme Court of Japan",
"stage": "conviction affirmed at every level; executed",
"date": "2001-01-01",
"outcome": "Sachiko Eto, a self-professed exorcist and faith healer, was convicted by the Fukushima District Court in 2001 on six counts of murder for beating believers to death with taiko drumsticks in rituals staged as demon expulsion. The Sendai High Court upheld the conviction in 2005 and the Supreme Court of Japan in 2008; she was executed on 27 September 2012. Co-defendants Hiroshi Nemoto, Yuko Eto and Mitsuo Sekine received life and twenty-year terms."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE: every victim was one of her own believers, submitting to violence they had been taught was spiritual treatment — the doctrine is what made the beatings possible and unrefusable.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/japan-hangs-cult-leader-convicted-in-exorcism-deaths/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News: 'Japan hangs cult leader convicted in exorcism deaths'.",
"body": "International report of the execution and conviction history.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "execution-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2008",
"note": "Conviction and death sentence affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/japan-hangs-cult-leader-convicted-in-exorcism-deaths/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: execution-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b3b6afd1d4aa44e57a994375ff659e78e26e0c3caa7cb12a009841e5a401707e",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/japan-hangs-cult-leader-convicted-in-exorcism-deaths/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 633,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Only two murders were adjudicated; the wider attributed count is documented context, not asserted as convicted. A 1960s Mexican record resting on contemporaneous and retrospective press rather than a retrieved judgment — flagged accordingly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1963-magdalena-solis-yerbabuena-mexico",
"year": 1963,
"place": "Yerbabuena, Tamaulipas, Mexico",
"lat": 23.7369,
"lng": -99.1411,
"title": "Mexico: 'high priestess' convicted after followers who doubted her godhood were killed as sacrifices",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"cult leader presented to villagers as the reincarnated Aztec goddess Coatlicue"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the god-claim itself, maintained by killing those who doubted it",
"ritual beating, burning, cutting and bleeding of dissenting members as sacrifices"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"ritual-initiation",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mexican court, Tamaulipas",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1963-01-01",
"outcome": "Magdalena Solís, installed before villagers at Yerbabuena as the reincarnation of the Aztec goddess Coatlicue, was convicted in the early 1960s of two murders — of the eight to fifteen attributed to the group — and sentenced to fifty years. Members who came to doubt the god-claim were ritually beaten, burned, cut and bled to death as sacrifices intended to sustain it."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE: the victims were the group's own followers, killed precisely because their doubt threatened the divine claim that held the others — the doctrine consumed the people it bound.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/the-believers-cult-murders-in-mexico-53577/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rolling Stone: retrospective investigation of the Yerbabuena cult murders.",
"body": "Long-form retrospective account of the case and prosecution.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/the-believers-cult-murders-in-mexico-53577/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aa68af8b278969ea525b134e1f01ec4f77e3fd826cb9630f5e96295b6061801c",
"final_url": "https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/the-believers-cult-murders-in-mexico-53577/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 634,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2002-04",
"note": "Gianasso's acquittal reversed; conviction entered."
}
],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). Sister Maria Laura Mainetti is named as she is named throughout the Italian public record; she was beatified in 2021. The perpetrators were minors at the time and are named as the Italian court record and press name them.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2001-maria-laura-mainetti-chiavenna-italy",
"year": 2001,
"place": "Chiavenna, Sondrio, Italy",
"lat": 46.32,
"lng": 9.397,
"title": "Italy: three teenagers convicted of murdering a nun in a staged satanic ritual",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-satanic-branded-violence",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none — the perpetrators held no authority over the victim, who was herself a religious"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the victim lured by a false appeal for counselling over a claimed rape and pregnancy",
"the killing staged around satanic '666' numerology"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Juvenile court, Milan; Court of Appeal",
"stage": "convictions; one acquittal reversed on appeal",
"date": "2001-08-09",
"outcome": "On 9 August 2001 the Milan juvenile court convicted Veronica Pietrobelli and Milena De Giambattista of the murder of Sister Maria Laura Mainetti, stabbed nineteen times in June 2000 after being lured to a meeting by a false appeal for counselling over a claimed rape and pregnancy; the girls told investigators the killing was staged around satanic numerology. Ambra Gianasso was initially acquitted, and that acquittal was reversed on appeal in April 2002, drawing twelve and a half years; sentences ranged from eight and a half to twelve and a half years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE and the inverse of most of this corpus: the victim was a nun, and the perpetrators were teenagers with no authority over her. It qualifies as victim-directed ritual — she was lured through an appeal to her pastoral role and killed inside a staged rite.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_Laura_Mainetti",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Maria Laura Mainetti — case and trial chronology.",
"body": "Reference account of the murder, trial and appellate outcome.",
"tier": "reference-index",
"kind": "case-chronology"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2002-04",
"note": "Gianasso's acquittal reversed; conviction entered."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_Laura_Mainetti",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-index; evidentiary role: case-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4e2d755433cc43cc9c0420689f0e1447af9ada5e6077231aa1c93d683105a090",
"final_url": "https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_Laura_Mainetti"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 635,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1976-08-13",
"note": "Affirmed (61 Cal.App.3d 102); California Supreme Court denied hearing 9 Dec. 1976."
},
{
"stage": "reversal-and-retrial",
"date": "1978",
"note": "Van Houten's 1971 conviction reversed; 1977 retrial hung; reconvicted 1978; paroled 2023."
}
],
"scopeNote": "CLUSTER RECORD — 'the Manson Family' is used throughout to distinguish this group from other movements known as 'The Family', including Anne Hamilton-Byrne's Australian sect, which this corpus records separately. The murder victims were strangers to Manson and were NOT under his authority — that is stated plainly rather than elided. What qualifies this record is the authority he held over the young followers he directed to kill, which the appellate court examined at length and which the parole system has spent five decades assessing. Victims are named as they are named throughout the public record. NOT ASSERTED: the Book of Revelation sourcing of Helter Skelter and the use of LSD as a control mechanism appear in the prosecution's narrative but not in the appellate opinion's language, and are not claimed here as court-established. GAP RECORDED: no prosecution was ever brought over the treatment of the group's underage members — Dianne Lake was fourteen when she joined — so that harm is documented outside the courts and remains unadjudicated. CRIME-SCENE STAGING — layers separated: the writings themselves are established in the appellate opinions, which treat them as evidence corroborating Manson's pre-stated 'Helter Skelter' ideology and thus proving premeditation. Neither opinion characterises them as intended to terrorise the public; searches of both for 'terrorise', 'fear', 'frighten', 'panic' and 'message' return nothing. The prosecutor's summation framed them as signature evidence — 'they may just as well have printed the name Charles Manson.' The widely-held view that the staging and the resulting occult scare terrorised the public and helped end the counterculture era is documented in contemporaneous and retrospective press, and is recorded here as press-layer context rather than as a judicial or prosecutorial finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1971-manson-family-authority-structure-california-usa",
"year": 1971,
"place": "Los Angeles, California, USA",
"lat": 34.0522,
"lng": -118.2437,
"title": "United States: the Manson Family — convictions built on a leader's total authority over his followers",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Charles Manson, regarded by followers as a 'God man' or Christ",
"senior members who transmitted his direction to the rest of the commune"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total control of where members slept, what they wore, when they ate and when they moved",
"sexual assignment of the women to members and to outsiders as a recruitment tool",
"recruitment of runaways and dropouts isolated from their families",
"the 'Helter Skelter' apocalyptic doctrine as the stated purpose of the killings",
"writings left in blood at the crime scenes — 'Pig' on the Tate front door; 'Death to the Pigs', 'Rise' and the misspelled 'Healter Skelter' at the LaBianca house"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"the Manson Family (Spahn Ranch and Barker Ranch, California)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Los Angeles Superior Court (Judge Charles Older); California Court of Appeal, 2d District (People v. Manson, 61 Cal.App.3d 102)",
"stage": "convictions; affirmed on appeal",
"date": "1971-01-25",
"outcome": "Charles Manson, Susan Atkins and Patricia Krenwinkel were convicted of seven counts of first-degree murder and conspiracy, and Leslie Van Houten of two murder counts and conspiracy, for the August 1969 killings of Sharon Tate, Jay Sebring, Abigail Folger, Wojciech Frykowski, Steven Parent and Leno and Rosemary LaBianca. Charles 'Tex' Watson was convicted separately on 12 October 1971. Death sentences were commuted to life under People v. Anderson (1972). The Court of Appeal affirmed in 1976. Van Houten's conviction was reversed on appeal after her counsel disappeared mid-trial; her first retrial hung in 1977, she was convicted again in 1978, and she was paroled on 11 July 2023. The appellate opinion records the writings left at the scenes in blood: 'Pig' on the front door at Cielo Drive, and 'Death to the Pigs', 'Rise' and 'Healter (sic) Skelter' at the LaBianca house."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The authority ran to the KILLERS, and that is what this record documents. The Court of Appeal found that Manson's followers 'regarded him as infallible and believed that he was a God man or Christ'; that he 'decided where the Manson Family would stay; where they would sleep; what clothing they would have... when they would move'; and that he instructed the women 'to provide sexual favors to members of the commune, and to do the same for outsiders for the purpose of recruiting new members'. The court's conspiracy holding rests on that domination: 'If the jury believed Manson to be a conspirator, aider or abettor he was culpable for all of the homicides regardless of who held the knife.' California parole authorities later made official findings in the same direction — in February 2017 the Board of Parole Hearings, after an investigation interviewing surviving members, concluded that Patricia Krenwinkel had been a victim of intimate partner battering at Manson's hands.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2130748/people-v-manson/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Manson, 61 Cal.App.3d 102, 132 Cal.Rptr. 265 (Cal. Ct. App. 1976).",
"body": "The appellate opinion, source of the quoted findings on domination and the conspiracy holding.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/2023/b320098.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "In re Van Houten (Cal. Ct. App. 2023) — habeas decision reinstating parole.",
"body": "Appellate treatment of the domination findings decades later.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "habeas-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1976-08-13",
"note": "Affirmed (61 Cal.App.3d 102); California Supreme Court denied hearing 9 Dec. 1976."
},
{
"stage": "reversal-and-retrial",
"date": "1978",
"note": "Van Houten's 1971 conviction reversed; 1977 retrial hung; reconvicted 1978; paroled 2023."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2130748/people-v-manson/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2130748/people-v-manson/"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/2023/b320098.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: habeas-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 636,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1977",
"note": "Manson and Davis convictions affirmed (71 Cal.App.3d 1). No published appellate opinion located for Beausoleil's own conviction."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Gary Hinman is named as he is named throughout the public record. NOT ASSERTED: the theory that the later Tate-LaBianca killings were staged to mimic this scene so that the already-arrested Beausoleil would appear innocent was a prosecution trial theory, contested within the district attorney's own office, and is not a judicial finding. Beausoleil's parole was recommended in January 2019 and reversed by Governor Newsom that April, on findings about his own insight rather than about Manson's domination — an asymmetry with his co-defendants worth noting, since he has not advanced a coercion account at hearings. STAGING: the appellate opinion records 'Political Piggy' written in apparent blood on the living-room wall together with 'a drawing that appeared to be like a paw print of an animal'. The opinion does not state whose blood, nor characterise the writing's purpose.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1970-gary-hinman-murder-manson-family-california-usa",
"year": 1970,
"place": "Topanga, Los Angeles County, California, USA",
"lat": 34.0936,
"lng": -118.6009,
"title": "United States: the Gary Hinman murder — the killing of a man inside the Manson Family's own orbit",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Charles Manson, who arrived at the house with a sword and left members to finish",
"Bobby Beausoleil, a young member acting on that direction"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"members dispatched to extract money from an acquaintance who had hosted them",
"the leader's arrival, sword assault and departure, leaving a follower to complete the killing",
"'Political Piggy' written in apparent blood on the living-room wall, beside a drawing resembling an animal's paw print"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"the Manson Family"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Los Angeles Superior Court; California Court of Appeal (People v. Manson, 71 Cal.App.3d 1 (1977))",
"stage": "convictions across separate proceedings",
"date": "1970-04-18",
"outcome": "Gary Hinman, a musician who had let Family members stay at his house, was killed in July 1969. The appellate record establishes that Beausoleil, Mary Brunner and Susan Atkins went to the house; that Manson then arrived with Bruce Davis, struggled with Hinman and slashed his ear with a sword before leaving; and that Beausoleil stabbed Hinman to death two days later, with 'Political Piggy' written in blood on the living-room wall. Beausoleil's first trial hung eleven to one and he was convicted at retrial on 18 April 1970, receiving a death sentence commuted under People v. Anderson. Manson and Davis were convicted of Hinman's murder and conspiracy in a separate proceeding affirmed at 71 Cal.App.3d 1. Brunner testified under a grant of immunity."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The nexus points both ways here, and the record says so. Hinman was an associate inside the group's orbit rather than a stranger. Beausoleil was a twenty-one-year-old member who killed on his leader's direction after that leader had wounded the victim and walked out — simultaneously a convicted perpetrator and a person subject to the authority this cluster documents.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/71/1/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Manson, 71 Cal.App.3d 1 (Cal. Ct. App. 1977).",
"body": "The appellate opinion in the Hinman proceeding, source of the sequence and the 'Political Piggy' finding.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cielodrive.com/archive/jury-convicts-beausoleil-in-gary-hinman-torture-slaying/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Contemporaneous press archive: 'Jury convicts Beausoleil in Gary Hinman slaying'.",
"body": "Contemporaneous trial coverage of the retrial conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1977",
"note": "Manson and Davis convictions affirmed (71 Cal.App.3d 1). No published appellate opinion located for Beausoleil's own conviction."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/71/1/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cielodrive.com/archive/jury-convicts-beausoleil-in-gary-hinman-torture-slaying/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d103c291a05d91feae33912b355c57582f4fe4b70dc62587a420c436ce65a1b8",
"final_url": "https://www.cielodrive.com/archive/jury-convicts-beausoleil-in-gary-hinman-torture-slaying/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 637,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1977",
"note": "Affirmed (71 Cal.App.3d 1)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Donald Shea is named as he is named throughout the public record. Davis's hearing statement that he 'wanted to be Charlie's favourite guy' is his own testimony rather than a board finding, and is recorded as such.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1971-donald-shea-murder-spahn-ranch-california-usa",
"year": 1971,
"place": "Chatsworth, Los Angeles County, California, USA",
"lat": 34.2572,
"lng": -118.6009,
"title": "United States: the Manson Family's killing of Spahn Ranch hand 'Shorty' Shea on suspicion of informing",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Charles Manson, who directed the killing",
"Bruce Davis and Steve Grogan, members who carried it out"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a ranch hand connected to the group killed on suspicion of informing to police",
"members acting on the leader's direction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"the Manson Family (Spahn Ranch)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Los Angeles Superior Court; California Court of Appeal (People v. Manson, 71 Cal.App.3d 1)",
"stage": "convictions",
"date": "1971-01-01",
"outcome": "Donald 'Shorty' Shea, a ranch hand at Spahn Ranch connected to the group, was killed in 1969 on suspicion of informing to police. Manson, Bruce Davis and Steve Grogan were convicted of his murder. Grogan's death sentence was commuted to life by the trial judge in December 1971, who stated on the record that Grogan 'was too stupid and too hopped up on drugs to decide anything on his own'; he became the first Family killer paroled, in 1985, after leading authorities to Shea's remains. Davis, convicted of both the Hinman and Shea murders, has been recommended for parole seven times, with reversals by three successive governors."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Shea was connected to the group rather than a stranger, and was killed for the perceived offence of informing — the group's internal discipline turned outward onto a man in its orbit. The sentencing judge's own words about Grogan's incapacity to 'decide anything on his own' are a judicial statement about the domination this cluster documents.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/71/1/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Manson, 71 Cal.App.3d 1 (Cal. Ct. App. 1977).",
"body": "The appellate opinion covering the Shea convictions.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "1977",
"note": "Affirmed (71 Cal.App.3d 1)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/71/1/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 638,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The child victim is named as he is named throughout the Argentine public record. Appellate status not confirmed — flagged rather than asserted final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-marito-salto-san-la-muerte-santiago-del-estero-argentina",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Santiago del Estero, Argentina",
"lat": -27.7951,
"lng": -64.2615,
"title": "Argentina: life sentences for the killing of an eleven-year-old as a San La Muerte offering",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled 'brujo' devotee of San La Muerte"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the child killed as an offering to San La Muerte",
"ritual writings and offerings found at the defendant's home"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal of Santiago del Estero, Argentina (jury trial)",
"stage": "conviction and life sentences",
"date": "2022-09-23",
"outcome": "Rodolfo Sequeira and Miguel Jiménez, known locally as 'El Terrible' and 'El Brujo', were convicted in September 2022 of the kidnapping, sexual abuse, homicide and dismemberment of eleven-year-old Mario 'Marito' Salto in 2016, and sentenced to life imprisonment; two accomplices received eleven and three years. Raids on the defendant's home recovered offerings to San La Muerte, drawings marked '666', and notes reading 'Sacrifice of Marito' and 'San La Muerte brings eternal life'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE — the child was not an adherent of anything. It qualifies as victim-directed ritual: the killing was staged as an offering, and the ritual writings recovered at the scene are court evidence of that framing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/macabro-crimen-condenaron-a-perpetua-a-dos-hombres-por-desmembrar-a-un-nino-en-un-ritual-satanico-nid23092022/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Nación: life sentences in the Marito Salto case, 23 Sep. 2022.",
"body": "National paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/macabro-crimen-condenaron-a-perpetua-a-dos-hombres-por-desmembrar-a-un-nino-en-un-ritual-satanico-nid23092022/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "689804712cab23a4e69ad336915604d7aad588815b04e8985362485d6569c574",
"final_url": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/macabro-crimen-condenaron-a-perpetua-a-dos-hombres-por-desmembrar-a-un-nino-en-un-ritual-satanico-nid23092022/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 639,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The victim is not named here. Finality not explicitly confirmed and is flagged.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-oner-castillo-brujo-sandona-narino-colombia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Nariño, Colombia",
"lat": 1.2136,
"lng": -77.2811,
"title": "Colombia: 'El Brujo de Sandoná' convicted of paying a hitman with a love ritual",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled santería and brujería practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a love ritual offered as the hitman's payment",
"an amputated hand required as ritual 'proof' of the killing"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal circuit court, Nariño, Colombia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-22",
"outcome": "Oner José Castillo Villota, known as 'El Brujo de Sandoná', was convicted in January 2025 of aggravated feminicide and evidence tampering for ordering the 2023 killing of his former partner, and sentenced to thirty-one years and three months. He paid the hitman not in money but by performing a love ritual for him, and required the victim's amputated hand as ritual proof. The hitman, Danilo Galeano Loza, had been separately convicted in November 2023 and received twenty-three years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE toward the victim. The ritual element is the currency of the crime: the killer's fee was a spell, and the trophy was ritual material — belief functioning as payment.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2025/01/22/alias-el-brujo-fue-condenado-por-feminicidio-le-pago-al-sicario-que-cometio-el-crimen-de-su-expareja-con-un-ritual-para-conquistar-a-una-mujer/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Infobae Colombia: conviction of 'El Brujo', 22 Jan. 2025.",
"body": "Regional outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://cambiocolombia.com/pais/condenan-31-anos-prision-alias-brujo-responsable-ordenar-homicidio-expareja-ritual",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cambio Colombia: sentencing report.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2025/01/22/alias-el-brujo-fue-condenado-por-feminicidio-le-pago-al-sicario-que-cometio-el-crimen-de-su-expareja-con-un-ritual-para-conquistar-a-una-mujer/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "60dfca93518e966cd311604378434d36c719ca791f8ae4da2421094300ab4ff5",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2025/01/22/alias-el-brujo-fue-condenado-por-feminicidio-le-pago-al-sicario-que-cometio-el-crimen-de-su-expareja-con-un-ritual-para-conquistar-a-una-mujer/"
},
{
"source": "https://cambiocolombia.com/pais/condenan-31-anos-prision-alias-brujo-responsable-ordenar-homicidio-expareja-ritual",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2858698a45e0e86bf156a9f3571a3aa5b942219d65aff2ffb5a42a181c6be76b",
"final_url": "https://cambiocolombia.com/pais/articulo/2025/1/condenan-31-anos-de-prision-alias-el-brujo-responsable-de-ordenar-el-homicidio-de-su-expareja"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 640,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The victim is named as he is named throughout the German public record. Both defendants were found to require psychiatric confinement alongside their sentences.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-daniel-manuela-ruda-bochum-germany",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Bochum, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 51.4818,
"lng": 7.2162,
"title": "Germany: couple convicted of a killing staged as a sacrifice to Satan",
"tradition": "left-hand-path",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-left-hand-path",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described 'satanic vampires'; no authority over the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the killing staged as a sacrifice to Satan",
"a pentagram carved into the victim's chest and blood drunk from a bowl"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht Bochum, Germany",
"stage": "conviction and sentence with psychiatric confinement",
"date": "2002-01-31",
"outcome": "Daniel and Manuela Ruda were convicted by the Bochum regional court in 2002 of the July 2000 murder of Frank Hackert, a friend killed with a hammer and sixty-six stab wounds in what they described as a sacrifice to Satan; a pentagram was carved into his chest and blood drunk from a bowl. Daniel received fifteen years and Manuela thirteen, both with indefinite psychiatric confinement."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. The victim was a friend, not an adherent. Recorded as victim-directed ritual: the staging was the crime's declared purpose, established in the trial record.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irishtimes.com/news/satanist-couple-jailed-for-killing-1.1048757",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Irish Times: 'Satanist couple jailed for killing'.",
"body": "International report of the verdict and sentences.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irishtimes.com/news/satanist-couple-jailed-for-killing-1.1048757",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0552d5cb787b5bebcc5cc951964198b65034af46b1587d19167165b558cef960",
"final_url": "https://www.irishtimes.com/news/satanist-couple-jailed-for-killing-1.1048757"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 641,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The victim is not named here. Defence counsel announced an intention to appeal; finality is NOT confirmed and the record is flagged accordingly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-paris-desenvoutement-sorcery-murder-france",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Paris, France",
"lat": 48.8566,
"lng": 2.3522,
"title": "France: three convicted at the Paris assize court of a killing framed as a disenchantment rite",
"tradition": "haitian-vodou",
"traditionDetailId": "african-haitian-vodou",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none over the victim — the principal was the victim's own spouse"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"belief that sorcery had to be countered by a 'désenvoûtement' (disenchantment) rite directed at the victim"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour d'assises de Paris, France",
"stage": "convictions and sentences",
"date": "2023-04-09",
"outcome": "In April 2023 the Paris assize court convicted Christy Daupin, Iven Webster and Sabrina Moreau of the March 2019 murder of Daupin's wife, a thirty-six-year-old Martinican woman, in a case the prosecution placed against a background of Caribbean sorcery and 'désenvoûtement' — a disenchantment rite believed necessary against her. Daupin received thirty years, Webster twenty-five and Moreau eighteen."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Recorded as victim-directed ritual: the belief that the victim required a counter-sorcery rite is what the prosecution established as the killing's frame.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://la1ere.franceinfo.fr/une-guadeloupeenne-condamnee-a-30-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle-pour-l-assassinat-de-son-epouse-martiniquaise-sur-fond-de-sorcellerie-vaudou-1383326.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "France Info La 1ère: report of the assize verdict and sentences.",
"body": "Public broadcaster's court report.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://la1ere.franceinfo.fr/une-guadeloupeenne-condamnee-a-30-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle-pour-l-assassinat-de-son-epouse-martiniquaise-sur-fond-de-sorcellerie-vaudou-1383326.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "78937f124fe28d62a783560f26182d70fdc5fc475d8f381cc262435e852d7609",
"final_url": "https://la1ere.franceinfo.fr/une-guadeloupeenne-condamnee-a-30-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle-pour-l-assassinat-de-son-epouse-martiniquaise-sur-fond-de-sorcellerie-vaudou-1383326.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 642,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The victim is named as she is named in the public court reporting. Final by plea.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-ethan-myers-satanic-sacrifice-joaquin-texas-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Joaquin, Texas, USA",
"lat": 31.9635,
"lng": -94.048,
"title": "United States: sixty years for a Texas killing the defendant described as a satanic sacrifice",
"tradition": "left-hand-path",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-left-hand-path",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none over the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the killing carried out as a self-described 'satanic sacrifice'",
"post-mortem removal of body parts documented in the charging affidavit"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Shelby County District Court, Texas (Judge James A. Payne Jr.)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2024-05-08",
"outcome": "Ethan Myers pleaded guilty and was sentenced in May 2024 to sixty years for the 2022 killing of Sarah Hopson in Joaquin, Texas, which he described as a satanic sacrifice; the charging affidavit recorded the post-mortem removal of toes, fingers and ears, and his mother told investigators he heard voices."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Recorded as victim-directed ritual on the strength of the charging affidavit and the plea.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ktre.com/2024/05/08/joaquin-man-gets-60-years-killing-woman-satanic-sacrifice/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KTRE: sentencing report, 8 May 2024.",
"body": "Local broadcaster's court report.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kltv.com/2022/11/16/affidavit-reveals-joaquin-man-killed-woman-sacrifice/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KLTV: the charging affidavit's contents.",
"body": "Documents the affidavit's ritual findings.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-document-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ktre.com/2024/05/08/joaquin-man-gets-60-years-killing-woman-satanic-sacrifice/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "de68a5b98e11d217bbf2fb3c2eda71f2cb2553ecd1eff22fa6615ac2c17599ac",
"final_url": "https://www.ktre.com/2024/05/08/joaquin-man-gets-60-years-killing-woman-satanic-sacrifice/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kltv.com/2022/11/16/affidavit-reveals-joaquin-man-killed-woman-sacrifice/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-document-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "85a5f97fae69ff398dfbc9bc0a56bab824cfc00d249c6115c2d8a44809939943",
"final_url": "https://www.kltv.com/2022/11/16/affidavit-reveals-joaquin-man-killed-woman-sacrifice/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 643,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The minor victim is named as she is named throughout the public record. Finality not confirmed; no reversal located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-genesis-cornejo-santa-muerte-houston-texas-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Houston, Texas, USA",
"lat": 29.7604,
"lng": -95.3698,
"title": "United States: forty years each for a teenager killed at a Santa Muerte shrine",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"gang members maintaining a Santa Muerte shrine; no spiritual authority over the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the girl killed at the shrine after allegedly disrespecting it",
"the killing framed by prosecutors as a ritual sacrifice"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Texas state court, Harris County",
"stage": "convictions and sentences",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"outcome": "Diego Hernández-Rivera and Miguel Alvarez-Flores, MS-13 members, were convicted in 2021 of the 2017 murder of fifteen-year-old Genesis Cornejo and each sentenced to forty years. Prosecutors said she was chosen as a ritual sacrifice and killed at the gang's Santa Muerte shrine after allegedly disrespecting it."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Recorded as victim-directed ritual: the shrine and the claimed offence against it are what the prosecution established as the killing's frame.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://abc13.com/ms13-members-convicted-in-killing-teen-girl-killed-alleged-satanic-ritual-diego-hernandez-rivera-sentenced-miguel-alvarez-flores-to-40-years/10698789/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ABC13 Houston: convictions and sentences.",
"body": "Local broadcaster's court report.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://abc13.com/ms13-members-convicted-in-killing-teen-girl-killed-alleged-satanic-ritual-diego-hernandez-rivera-sentenced-miguel-alvarez-flores-to-40-years/10698789/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f0406ab3946da98b87fe1e331b36066538a5df42318f2c44df3367fdfdb1619",
"final_url": "https://abc13.com/post/ms13-members-convicted-in-killing-teen-girl-killed-alleged-satanic-ritual-diego-hernandez-rivera-sentenced-miguel-alvarez-flores-to-40-years/10698789/?userab=kfsn_content_recs-582*variant_a_control_kfsn-2512%2Ckabc_content_recs-577*variant_c_trending-2482%2Cwls_content_recs-584*variant_b_trending_wls-2517%2Cwtvd_content_recs-585*variant_a_control_wtvd-2518%2Cktrk_content_recs-587*variant_a_control_ktrk-2522%2Cwpvi_content_recs-586*variant_a_control_wpvi-2520%2Cotv_web_content_rec-539*variant_c_trending-2268%2Cotv_web_topic-580*variant_a_topic-2508%2Cotv_search_page_design_unification-546*variant_b_search_redesign-2300%2Ckgo_content_recs-583*variant_a_control_kgo-2514%2Cabcn_popular_reads_exp-542*variant_b_7days_filter-2288"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 644,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The victims are named as they are named throughout the Nigerian public record. SOURCING LIMIT: available reporting is thin on the ritual's specific mechanics, and the record therefore asserts only the money-ritual motive as prosecuted. Appellate status not confirmed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-fatinoye-family-ritual-murder-ogun-nigeria",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ogun State, Nigeria",
"lat": 7.1557,
"lng": 3.3451,
"title": "Nigeria: three sentenced to death for the ritual killing of a couple and their son",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none over the victims"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"killings carried out for a money ritual"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ogun State High Court, Abeokuta (Justice Basirat Adebowale)",
"stage": "convictions and death sentences",
"date": "2024-02-01",
"outcome": "In February 2024 the Ogun State High Court in Abeokuta convicted Adekambi Lekan, Odetola Ahmed and Adeniyi Waheed of the murders of Kehinde and Bukola Fatinoye and their son Oreoluwa on 1 January 2023, and sentenced all three to death by hanging. The killings were prosecuted as a money-ritual murder."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Recorded as victim-directed ritual: the family was killed to supply material for a money ritual.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.legit.ng/nigeria/1638878-killers-nigerian-couple-identified-court-sentenced-3-death/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Legit.ng: court report of the death sentences.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.legit.ng/nigeria/1638878-killers-nigerian-couple-identified-court-sentenced-3-death/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "722f6f735c3a5bc065b0d729483a146e430179c4b9955ec6e86275c70ec27770",
"final_url": "https://www.legit.ng/nigeria/1638878-killers-nigerian-couple-identified-court-sentenced-3-death/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 645,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The child victim is not named here. Appellate status not confirmed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-kasoa-money-ritual-killing-ghana",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Kasoa, Central Region, Ghana",
"lat": 5.5333,
"lng": -0.4167,
"title": "Ghana: life imprisonment for a boy killed after a spiritualist's video promised wealth for blood",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none over the victim — but a spiritualist's promise supplied the motive"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a spiritualist's video promising wealth in exchange for a cash payment and human blood",
"the child killed to meet that requirement"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Ghana (Justice Lydia Osei Marfo), jury trial",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-10-01",
"outcome": "In October 2024 a Ghanaian High Court convicted Nicholas Kini of murder and conspiracy in the 2021 killing of a ten-year-old boy at Kasoa, and sentenced him to life imprisonment; a juvenile co-defendant was separately sentenced to twelve months in a correctional facility. The prosecution established that the killing was carried out for money rituals after the defendant watched a video of a spiritualist promising wealth in exchange for a cash payment and human blood."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE toward the victim, but the causal chain runs through a spiritual claim: a spiritualist's promise of wealth for blood is what the court found produced the killing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://citinewsroom.com/2024/10/kasoa-ritual-killing-21-year-old-suspect-sentenced-to-life-in-prison/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Citi Newsroom: sentencing report.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://dennislawnews.com/article/kasoa-ritual-murder-case-court-sentences-one-to-life-refers-other-to-juvenile-court",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dennislaw News: legal-press report of the sentence and the juvenile referral.",
"body": "Legal-press corroboration.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://citinewsroom.com/2024/10/kasoa-ritual-killing-21-year-old-suspect-sentenced-to-life-in-prison/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4628a30c3484bf672604498e4a806a11dc6ed48bae5b163d90f5b1fb60419db4",
"final_url": "https://www.citinewsroom.com/2024/10/kasoa-ritual-killing-21-year-old-suspect-sentenced-to-life-in-prison/"
},
{
"source": "https://dennislawnews.com/article/kasoa-ritual-murder-case-court-sentences-one-to-life-refers-other-to-juvenile-court",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "660dfd46ef7b07f1866c36cf9c817b4a6c7985d5c4cbf4c7f3cc22f10089ab08",
"final_url": "https://dennislawnews.com/article/kasoa-ritual-murder-case-court-sentences-one-to-life-refers-other-to-juvenile-court"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 646,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The child victim is named as he is named in the federal opinion. SOURCING: the conviction counts, Jean Brayton's nolo plea and sentence, the eighteen-month fugitive period and the dropped charges against Richard Brayton are all taken from a federal district-court opinion (Velle Transcendental Research Ass'n v. Sanders, 518 F. Supp. 512, 517 (C.D. Cal. 1981)), which recites them as procedural history drawn from contemporaneous press exhibits. NOT ASSERTED: widely-circulated claims that the boy was confined for 56 days, a competing claim of roughly 10 hours, and a physician's reported testimony that he appeared unharmed. A Wayback Machine search established that these claims do NOT trace to the Los Angeles Times of 30 July 1969 as commonly cited, but to an FBI memorandum of 15 August 1969 and a Washington Post article of 31 October 1969 — neither of which could be retrieved; the LA Times attribution appears to be an error propagated through secondary sources. The individual who chained the boy is unnamed here for the same reason. DISAMBIGUATION: the Solar Lodge was NOT part of the modern Ordo Templi Orientis; it used the name without recognition from the OTO lineage, a non-affiliation independently supported by academic work on the period (Martin Starr, 'Chaos from Order', Pomegranate, 2006). Persistent claims of a Manson Family connection are unverified lore, traceable to tabloid coverage and to Ed Sanders's book, and are not asserted. ON THE GROUP'S RELATIONSHIP TO THE ORDO TEMPLI ORIENTIS, WHICH THIS CORPUS DOES NOT RESOLVE: Solar Lodge's standing is contested and was never adjudicated. Phyllis Seckler, an Agape Lodge initiate, stated that Solar Lodge \"was an O.T.O. Lodge\". Against that, Ray Burlingame, who initiated Georgina \"Jean\" Brayton in 1962, held no charter to found lodges or initiate; a participant account states the group had no written charter from any Grand Master; Karl Germer had closed Agape Lodge in 1953 and never recognised Solar Lodge; and Grady McMurtry, reviving the OTO in 1969, could have recognised its initiations retroactively and did not. The claim of standing therefore rests on participant recollection rather than any institutional or judicial finding, and this record asserts neither regularity nor irregularity. The distinction is not merely historical: if the leaders' authority was chartered, the initiatory mechanism over members was materially stronger than if the group was self-constituted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1969-solar-lodge-boy-in-the-box-blythe-california-usa",
"year": 1969,
"place": "Blythe, Riverside County, California, USA",
"lat": 33.6178,
"lng": -114.5883,
"title": "United States: seven convicted after a six-year-old was found chained in a box at a desert commune",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Georgina 'Jean' Brayton, leader of the Solar Lodge",
"members of the group holding communal authority over a member's child"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the group's internal disciplinary authority over the children of members",
"confinement of the boy in a wooden box, chained by the leg, as punishment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Solar Lodge (Blythe, California)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Riverside County Superior Court, California",
"stage": "convictions and pleas",
"date": "1969-07-26",
"outcome": "On 26 July 1969 a raid on the group's desert ranch near Blythe found six-year-old Anthony Saul Gibbons, the son of members, chained inside a wooden box. The prosecution led to the conviction of four members on felony child-abuse charges — including the boy's mother — and of three further members on misdemeanour child-abuse charges. Georgina 'Jean' Brayton, the group's leader, pleaded nolo contendere to one count of felony child abuse and was placed on three years' probation with a $500 fine; she and her husband had been fugitives for eighteen months before the case resolved. Charges against Richard Brayton were dropped for lack of evidence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child of the group's own members, punished under its communal disciplinary authority — the same structure as this corpus's Twelve Tribes and House of Prayer records, where a religious community's claim over members' children is what makes the harm possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2128591/velle-transcendental-research-assn-v-sanders/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Velle Transcendental Research Ass'n v. Sanders, 518 F. Supp. 512 (C.D. Cal. 1981).",
"body": "Federal opinion reciting the convictions, plea, sentence and fugitive period as procedural history.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "federal-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2128591/velle-transcendental-research-assn-v-sanders/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: federal-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2128591/velle-transcendental-research-assn-v-sanders/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 647,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court-of-appeal",
"date": "2020-09-15",
"note": "Appeal dismissed ([2020] ZASCA 102)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The victim is named as she is named throughout the South African public record and the appellate judgment.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-mbatha-magubane-muthi-killing-kwazulu-natal-south-africa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa",
"lat": -29.6006,
"lng": 30.3794,
"title": "South Africa: life sentences for a killing to obtain body parts for muthi — affirmed by the Supreme Court of Appeal",
"tradition": "muti",
"traditionDetailId": "african-muti",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"none over the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the victim killed with the intent of obtaining body parts for muthi"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pietermaritzburg High Court (KwaZulu-Natal Division); Supreme Court of Appeal",
"stage": "convictions and life sentences; appeal dismissed",
"date": "2018-12-01",
"outcome": "Nino Mbatha and Lungisani Magubane were convicted in December 2018 before Judge Peter Olsen in the Pietermaritzburg High Court of the murder of Zanele Hlatshwayo, killed with the intent of obtaining body parts for muthi, and both sentenced to life imprisonment; a third co-accused was acquitted. The Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed Mbatha's appeal in Mbatha v S (928/20) [2020] ZASCA 102 on 15 September 2020, leaving the conviction and sentence standing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Recorded as victim-directed ritual: the killing's purpose was to harvest material for muthi.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZASCA/2020/102.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mbatha v S (928/20) [2020] ZASCA 102 (15 Sep. 2020).",
"body": "The Supreme Court of Appeal judgment dismissing the appeal.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court-of-appeal",
"date": "2020-09-15",
"note": "Appeal dismissed ([2020] ZASCA 102)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZASCA/2020/102.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 648,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is not identified. A magistrate-court conviction too recent for appellate review.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-tawanda-shumba-nyenyedzi-nomwe-gweru-zimbabwe",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Gweru, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -19.45,
"lng": 29.8167,
"title": "Zimbabwe: self-styled prophet jailed for raping a congregant lured to a 'spiritual cleansing'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled prophet of the Nyenyedzi Nomwe Shrine, Mkoba 4"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a 'spiritual cleansing' ritual used to isolate the woman who had come to him for help"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [
"Nyenyedzi Nomwe Shrine, Gweru"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Gweru Magistrates Court, Zimbabwe (Regional Magistrate Sibongile Marondedze)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-18",
"outcome": "Tawanda Shumba, a self-styled prophet at the Nyenyedzi Nomwe Shrine in Mkoba 4, Gweru, was sentenced on 18 June 2026 to fifteen years for the rape of a twenty-two-year-old woman lured to a 'spiritual cleansing' ceremony on 4 June 2026."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE: she came to a prophet for spiritual help, and the cleansing ritual is what put her alone with him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newsday.co.zw/local-news/article/200057176/self-styled-prophet-rapes-congregant-during-cleansing-ceremony-gets-15-year-jail-term",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NewsDay Zimbabwe: report of the fifteen-year sentence.",
"body": "National paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.masvingomirror.com/self-proclaimed-gweru-prophet-jailed-for-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Masvingo Mirror: corroborating report.",
"body": "Independent corroboration.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newsday.co.zw/local-news/article/200057176/self-styled-prophet-rapes-congregant-during-cleansing-ceremony-gets-15-year-jail-term",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eb3757f8c3c22461d24c949059994773181904a54169e3becdb6a4f12e8cedb1",
"final_url": "https://www.newsday.co.zw/local-news/article/200057176/self-styled-prophet-rapes-congregant-during-cleansing-ceremony-gets-15-year-jail-term"
},
{
"source": "https://www.masvingomirror.com/self-proclaimed-gweru-prophet-jailed-for-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4a0a87d4c5f341202fefc0105685b2c308e61fc9da1766fef12c9915c9b87fd5",
"final_url": "https://www.masvingomirror.com/self-proclaimed-gweru-prophet-jailed-for-rape/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 649,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. FIRST RECORD FOR ANGOLA. SINGLE-SOURCE: despite targeted searches of Jornal de Angola, ANGOP, VOA Português and Novo Jornal, no corroborating outlet was found; the record rests on one Angolan outlet and is flagged accordingly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-joao-pedro-maria-efata-luanda-angola",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Luanda, Angola",
"lat": -8.839,
"lng": 13.2894,
"title": "Angola: pastor sentenced to twelve years for drugging and raping a fourteen-year-old congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the Igreja Pentecostal Efatá, Luanda"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a spiked soft drink used to incapacitate a congregant child",
"pastoral standing over her and her family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Igreja Pentecostal Efatá, Luanda"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "13ª Secção, Tribunal Provincial de Luanda, Angola",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-01-01",
"outcome": "João Pedro Maria, 44, pastor of the Igreja Pentecostal Efatá in Luanda, was convicted by the 13th Section of the Luanda Provincial Court of drugging a fourteen-year-old congregant with a spiked soft drink and raping her, and was sentenced to twelve years, stripped of pastoral rights for twelve years, and ordered to pay six million kwanzas in compensation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE: a child of his own congregation, reached through the standing his church gave him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://angola24horas.com/sociedade/item/14102-quando-pastores-usam-o-rebanho-para-violacoes-sexuais",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Angola24Horas: 'Quando pastores usam o rebanho para violações sexuais'.",
"body": "Angolan outlet's report of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://angola24horas.com/sociedade/item/14102-quando-pastores-usam-o-rebanho-para-violacoes-sexuais",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b82d62738c2bbfe12a06194123b7eae029b12732ec57b665d812258787df5f21",
"final_url": "https://angola24horas.com/sociedade/item/14102-quando-pastores-usam-o-rebanho-para-violacoes-sexuais"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 650,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. The plea itself was to a possession count; the network's coercive structure is documented in the Justice Department's own release. Sentenced at the statutory maximum. Federal appeal window recently opened; no appeal filed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-kalana-limkin-cultists-network-hawaii-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Hilo, Hawaii, USA",
"lat": 19.7297,
"lng": -155.09,
"title": "United States: leader of a 764 splinter network sentenced to the statutory maximum",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-online-nihilist-network",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and leader of the 'Cultists' network, a 764/CVLT splinter"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the network's coercion of minors into sexual and self-harm content"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"'Cultists' (764/CVLT splinter)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "US District Court, District of Hawaii (Senior Judge Helen Gillmor)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-07-16",
"outcome": "Kalana Limkin, founder and leader of the 'Cultists' network — a splinter of the 764 and CVLT networks — pleaded guilty on 13 February 2025 to possession of child sexual-abuse material and was sentenced on 16 July 2026 to 120 months, the statutory maximum, followed by twenty years of supervised release."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE, on the same basis as the corpus's other 764-network records: the network's satanic-nihilist doctrine is the instrument by which minors are coerced.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-hi/pr/leader-violent-extremist-terror-network-cultists-sentenced-10-years-federal-prison",
"archive": "",
"citation": "US Attorney's Office, District of Hawaii: sentencing release.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own release.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-hi/pr/leader-violent-extremist-terror-network-cultists-sentenced-10-years-federal-prison",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9ecd6b476a7dd1460592bfc49fa5c7a62ad67f02bab07d5fd60d291ae11cde9a",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-hi/pr/leader-violent-extremist-terror-network-cultists-sentenced-10-years-federal-prison"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 651,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Corroborated by mainstream Hong Kong press independent of the court-reporting outlet that first carried it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-choi-kin-han-childrens-home-hong-kong",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Hong Kong",
"lat": 22.3193,
"lng": 114.1694,
"title": "Hong Kong: children's-home pastor jailed after drugging and assaulting six teenage residents",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor and tutor connected to a children's home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sleeping pills disguised as supplements administered to residents",
"pastoral and residential-care authority over adolescents in institutional care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hong Kong court",
"stage": "guilty pleas and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "Choi Kin-han, 51, a pastor and tutor connected to a children's home, pleaded guilty to twenty-four charges — sixteen counts of indecent assault, seven of administering drugs to facilitate unlawful sexual acts, and one of possessing child pornography — for drugging six male teenagers with sleeping pills disguised as supplements between May 2020 and August 2021 and assaulting them. He was sentenced to six years and six months. The offending came to light when one victim woke during an assault."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE: adolescents in residential care, under a man holding both pastoral standing and custodial access — compound authority over children the state had placed.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thestandard.com.hk/section-news/section/11/267051/Pastor-gets-lengthy-prison-term-for-sexually-assaulting-teens",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Standard (Hong Kong): 'Pastor gets lengthy prison term for sexually assaulting teens'.",
"body": "Mainstream Hong Kong press court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thestandard.com.hk/section-news/section/11/267051/Pastor-gets-lengthy-prison-term-for-sexually-assaulting-teens",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8522cde9ac0bcf31b7cbb7ae5cfd818ab5912d2a6c01893fc388c331dd1d2d11",
"final_url": "https://www.thestandard.com.hk/news/article/67051/Pastor-gets-lengthy-prison-term-for-sexually-assaulting-teens"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 652,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is named as she is named in the Hong Kong public record. The mother's conviction is recorded because it documents the authority's reach into the family. NAME NOTE: the defendant's name appears in some reporting with a variant final character; the form used here follows the High Court reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-cheung-tsz-choi-exorcism-death-hong-kong",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Hong Kong",
"lat": 22.3364,
"lng": 114.15,
"title": "Hong Kong: life imprisonment for the death of a disabled disciple declared spirit-possessed",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled Taoist priest and feng shui master with a 'spirit disciple'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the victim declared spirit-possessed and subjected to 'exorcisms'",
"beatings and force-feeding of alcohol as ritual treatment",
"the victim's intellectual disability and total dependence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Hong Kong (Judge Judianna Barnes)",
"stage": "convictions and sentence",
"date": "2024-10-18",
"outcome": "Cheung Tsz-choi, a self-styled Taoist priest and feng shui master, was sentenced on 18 October 2024 to life imprisonment for the murder of Wu Enyu, a twenty-one-year-old intellectually disabled woman he had declared spirit-possessed and taken as a 'spirit disciple', and to ten years concurrent for indecent assault. She died of alcohol poisoning after being force-fed during 'exorcisms', her body bearing some eighty injury marks. Her mother, aged 57, was convicted of aiding and abetting the indecent assault and received ten years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE, and among the corpus's starkest: an intellectually disabled woman held as a 'spirit disciple' and killed by the ritual itself — with her own mother convicted alongside, showing the authority reaching through the family to reach her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dotdotnews.com/a/202410/18/AP6711faeee4b0a5a5d5008202.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Hong Kong court report of the life sentence, 18 Oct. 2024.",
"body": "Court reporting of the sentencing.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dotdotnews.com/a/202410/18/AP6711faeee4b0a5a5d5008202.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c891bdb0d3b42a851ae13160d7b4a8f9e368598d1a5a9ebd805523f9665746cf",
"final_url": "https://www.dotdotnews.com/a/202410/18/AP6711faeee4b0a5a5d5008202.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 653,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim is not identified. Case number cited from the district court record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-royani-pengobatan-gaib-pandeglang-indonesia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Pandeglang, Banten, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.3086,
"lng": 106.1063,
"title": "Indonesia: 'magical healing' practitioner jailed for eleven years after a year of ritual-pretext rape",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"practitioner of 'pengobatan gaib' (magical healing)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the claim that a ritual had to be completed or harm would follow",
"bodily fluids demanded as the ritual's requirement",
"a year of repeated compliance secured by that threat"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Pandeglang, Indonesia (Perkara No. 136/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Pdl)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-09-18",
"outcome": "Royani, a practitioner of 'pengobatan gaib' or magical healing, was convicted on 18 September 2023 and sentenced to eleven years plus a fine of one hundred million rupiah, for sexually exploiting a victim between March 2022 and February 2023 under the threat that failing to complete the ritual he prescribed would bring harm."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE, and a pure instance of the mechanism: no force was needed because refusal was framed as inviting supernatural harm. The victim complied for a year because stopping was presented as the dangerous choice.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-6944796",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik: report of the Pandeglang conviction and sentence.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://news.detik.com/berita/d-6944796",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 654,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The adult victims and the child are named as they are named throughout the Indonesian public record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-agus-basuki-money-ritual-poisoning-madiun-indonesia",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Madiun, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.6298,
"lng": 111.5239,
"title": "Indonesia: life imprisonment for poisoning a family of three whose money ritual had failed",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"dukun running a money-multiplication scheme for clients"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual drinks laced with potassium, taken on the practitioner's instruction",
"clients' unquestioning obedience to ritual instructions"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Madiun, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and life sentence",
"date": "2013-05-28",
"outcome": "Agus Basuki was convicted on 28 May 2013 under Article 340 of the criminal code and the child-protection law, and sentenced to life imprisonment, for murdering three clients of his money-multiplication scheme — Giantoro, Retno Sugiharti and their eleven-year-old daughter Tania — with potassium-laced ritual drinks after the scheme failed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE: the victims drank what the dukun handed them because the ritual required it. Obedience to the rite is what delivered the poison — the same structure as the Banjarnegara and Kayu Agung records.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-6660661",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Detik Jatim: case report of the Madiun conviction and life sentence.",
"body": "National outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-6660661",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 655,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victims are named as they are named throughout the Indonesian public record. The nexus qualification above is deliberate — this record does not claim the ritual was the instrument of death, only that the relationship was one of ritual authority over clients.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-wowon-money-ritual-serial-murders-bekasi-indonesia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Bekasi, West Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -6.2383,
"lng": 106.9756,
"title": "Indonesia: life sentences for three money-ritual practitioners who poisoned clients who saw through the fraud",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"three practitioners operating a money-multiplication scheme"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual authority over paying clients",
"poisoning of clients who realised the scheme was fraudulent"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Bekasi, Indonesia",
"stage": "convictions and life sentences",
"date": "2023-11-01",
"outcome": "Wowon and two co-defendants were convicted at the Bekasi district court around November 2023 and sentenced to life imprisonment — the prosecution having sought death — for poisoning three clients of their money-multiplication scheme: Ai Maimunah, Muhamad Riswandi and Ridwan Abdul Muis, killed after they discovered the fraud."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "BORDERLINE, stated as such: the victims were clients under the practitioners' ritual authority, but the killings were to silence people who had seen through the fraud rather than acts of the ritual itself. It sits closer to fraud-homicide than to the pure coercion pattern, and is recorded with that qualification.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bekaci.suara.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Suara Bekasi: court report of the life sentences.",
"body": "Regional outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bekaci.suara.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5864b9f3ef551e89bbae86ecbf2b8b8d4f1849bb0db705a8d73f8279a3a77ee4",
"final_url": "https://bekaci.suara.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 656,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "CONTEXT RECORD, not a case. Documented here because the statute directly criminalises coercion-by-supernatural-threat, and because its non-use to date is itself informative: Indonesian courts already treat objects found in a victim's body as forensic evidence under existing fraud and assault provisions, so the harm had prosecutorial routes before Article 252 and the new article's novelty lies in reaching the claim rather than the injury. Flagged for monitoring — a first conviction under Article 252 would be a significant development for this corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-indonesia-article-252-santet-law-context",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Indonesia",
"lat": -6.2088,
"lng": 106.8456,
"title": "Indonesia: the new criminal code makes claiming supernatural power to cause harm a crime — with no convictions yet",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"the Indonesian state, legislating against claimed supernatural coercion"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the criminalised conduct is the CLAIM itself — declaring oneself able to cause illness, death or suffering by supernatural means"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Republic of Indonesia (Undang-Undang No. 1 Tahun 2023)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Republic of Indonesia — Article 252, Undang-Undang No. 1 Tahun 2023 (new KUHP)",
"stage": "statute in force; no prosecutions identified",
"date": "2026-01-02",
"outcome": "Article 252 of Indonesia's new criminal code, in force from 2 January 2026, criminalises declaring oneself to possess supernatural power capable of causing illness, death or suffering, carrying up to one year and six months' imprisonment and a fine of two hundred million rupiah, increased by a third for habitual practice. As of mid-July 2026, roughly six and a half months after it took effect, searches of Indonesian court and news sources identified no prosecution or conviction under the article."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This is the rare instance of a legal system naming this database's own mechanism directly: the offence is not the harm but the CLAIM of power to cause it — which is precisely how supernatural coercion works, since the threat alone secures compliance.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.hukumonline.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Hukumonline: legal analysis of Article 252 of the new KUHP.",
"body": "Indonesian legal-information service's analysis of the provision.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "statutory-analysis"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.hukumonline.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: statutory-analysis.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 657,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Sourced to the Pará state court's own press office. Appellate status not confirmed — flagged rather than asserted final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-anderson-gomes-pastor-barcarena-para-brazil",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Barcarena, Pará, Brazil",
"lat": -1.5061,
"lng": -48.6253,
"title": "Brazil: pastor sentenced to ninety-one years for abusing five boys of his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a congregation in Barcarena"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing used to reach boys of the congregation aged five to nine"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Comarca de Barcarena, Tribunal de Justiça do Pará (Juiz Iran Ferreira Sampaio)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "Anderson Cleiton de Sousa Gomes, a pastor in Barcarena, was convicted of estupro de vulnerável against five boys aged between five and nine, all reached through his position in the congregation, and sentenced to ninety-one years and eight days in closed regime."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Five small boys of the congregation, reached through the office their families trusted.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjpa.jus.br/PortalExterno/imprensa/noticias/Informes/544734-Pastor-e-condenado-a-91-anos-por-estupro-de-vulneravel.xhtml",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tribunal de Justiça do Pará: 'Pastor é condenado a 91 anos por estupro de vulnerável'.",
"body": "The convicting court's own release.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjpa.jus.br/PortalExterno/imprensa/noticias/Informes/544734-Pastor-e-condenado-a-91-anos-por-estupro-de-vulneravel.xhtml",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "45e6a7a729b3da3481bc47cbb7c37a7414665a837026fdba6b604a803ab70d18",
"final_url": "https://www.tjpa.jus.br/PortalExterno/imprensa/noticias/Informes/544734-Pastor-e-condenado-a-91-anos-por-estupro-de-vulneravel.xhtml"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 658,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant is not named in the prosecuting authority's release. Appeal pending with the defendant in custody.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-braco-do-norte-pastor-santa-catarina-brazil",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Braço do Norte, Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"lat": -28.2761,
"lng": -49.1656,
"title": "Brazil: pastor jailed for over thirty-seven years for abusing two boys from his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a church in Braço do Norte"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-leader authority over church-attending minors"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Comarca de Braço do Norte, Santa Catarina (Ministério Público de Santa Catarina prosecution)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; held in custody pending appeal",
"date": "2024-07-01",
"outcome": "A pastor in Braço do Norte was convicted on two counts of estupro de vulnerável and one of importunação sexual against boys aged twelve and fourteen who attended his church, and sentenced to thirty-seven years and six months in closed regime. His application to appeal at liberty was refused and he has been in custody since July 2024."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Two boys of the congregation, under the man who led it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mpsc.mp.br/w/noticias/pastor-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-e-importunacao-sexual-em-braco-do-norte",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministério Público de Santa Catarina: conviction release.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own release.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mpsc.mp.br/w/noticias/pastor-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-e-importunacao-sexual-em-braco-do-norte",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f0b259dea504b37ebf2b1f60eaa426a3000b750e6777e162ad89b013f4a513ae",
"final_url": "https://www.mpsc.mp.br/w/noticias/pastor-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-e-importunacao-sexual-em-braco-do-norte"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 659,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-de-justica",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Sentence increased from 8 years to 9 years 4 months."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified; the defendant is not named in the court's release. Final at state-court appellate level.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-pastor-benzedeiro-santa-catarina-brazil",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"lat": -27.2423,
"lng": -50.2189,
"title": "Brazil: sentence increased on appeal for a pastor and faith healer who abused a seven-year-old",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor and benzedeiro (faith healer) making home visits"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a family's trust in his dual role as pastor and healer",
"home visits in a healing capacity"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Justiça de Santa Catarina, 4ª Câmara Criminal (Des. Zanini Fornerolli)",
"stage": "conviction; sentence increased on appeal",
"date": "2019-01-01",
"outcome": "A ninety-year-old pastor and benzedeiro was convicted of estupro de vulnerável against a seven-year-old child whose family had received him in their home in his healing capacity. On appeal in 2019 the Santa Catarina high court increased his sentence from eight years to nine years and four months."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The dual authority is the point: the family opened the door to a man who was both their pastor and their healer, and the visits were the access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/justica-aumenta-pena-a-pastor-e-benzedeiro-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tribunal de Justiça de Santa Catarina: appellate release.",
"body": "The appellate court's own release.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-de-justica",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Sentence increased from 8 years to 9 years 4 months."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/justica-aumenta-pena-a-pastor-e-benzedeiro-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e737d325ac211d348a37847e48f12801f280f900c9edde680c285984fcc4a3f6",
"final_url": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/justica-aumenta-pena-a-pastor-e-benzedeiro-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 660,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-de-justica",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Defence appeals denied; sentence reduced to 10 years 6 months on count scope."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Appellate-confirmed at state level.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-padre-leandro-altar-boys-americana-brazil",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Americana, São Paulo, Brazil",
"lat": -22.7395,
"lng": -47.3314,
"title": "Brazil: Catholic priest convicted of abusing four former altar boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest at the Basílica de Santo Antônio, Americana, and the Paróquia São Francisco de Assis, Araras"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly authority over altar servers"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Basílica de Santo Antônio, Americana"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "São Paulo trial court; Tribunal de Justiça de São Paulo",
"stage": "conviction; appeals denied, sentence reduced on scope",
"date": "2022-01-01",
"outcome": "Pedro Leandro Ricardo, known as Padre Leandro, was convicted in 2022 and sentenced to twenty-one years for the sexual abuse of four former altar boys between 2003 and 2006. In 2024 the São Paulo high court denied two defence appeals while reducing the sentence to ten years and six months on the scope of the counts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Altar boys under their parish priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://revistaforum.com.br/brasil/2024/7/15/ex-padre-condenado-por-abuso-sexual-tem-recursos-negados-pelo-tj-sp-162148.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Revista Fórum: TJ-SP denies the priest's appeals, Jul. 2024.",
"body": "National outlet's appellate report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-de-justica",
"date": "2024",
"note": "Defence appeals denied; sentence reduced to 10 years 6 months on count scope."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://revistaforum.com.br/brasil/2024/7/15/ex-padre-condenado-por-abuso-sexual-tem-recursos-negados-pelo-tj-sp-162148.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 661,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-de-justica",
"date": "2014",
"note": "Sentence increased from 20 years to 26 years 2 months; prosecution appeal partially granted."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant is not named in the court's release.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-priest-confession-abuse-southern-santa-catarina-brazil",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Southern Santa Catarina, Brazil",
"lat": -28.68,
"lng": -49.37,
"title": "Brazil: priest's sentence raised to twenty-six years for abuse during pre-communion confession",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest serving multiple parishes in southern Santa Catarina"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abuse committed during confession sessions preparing children for first communion",
"movement across parishes and cities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Justiça de Santa Catarina, 4ª Câmara Criminal",
"stage": "conviction; sentence increased on appeal",
"date": "2014-01-01",
"outcome": "A priest who served several parishes in southern Santa Catarina was convicted of abusing children, preferentially boys, during the confession sessions that prepared them for first communion. His twenty-year sentence was increased on appeal in 2014 to twenty-six years and two months in closed regime after the prosecution's appeal was partially granted, adding a third count."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The confessional itself was the site — children sent to prepare for their first communion, alone with the priest by the sacrament's own design.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/padre-e-condenado-a-26-anos-por-conhecido-caso-de-abuso-sexual-no-sul-do-estado",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tribunal de Justiça de Santa Catarina: appellate release.",
"body": "The appellate court's own release.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-de-justica",
"date": "2014",
"note": "Sentence increased from 20 years to 26 years 2 months; prosecution appeal partially granted."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/padre-e-condenado-a-26-anos-por-conhecido-caso-de-abuso-sexual-no-sul-do-estado",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d89ce613fc3dd6feeb5ce2f959629b80b8554250d806f3ec2c5d06a78f6d9dc8",
"final_url": "https://www.tjsc.jus.br/web/imprensa/-/padre-e-condenado-a-26-anos-por-conhecido-caso-de-abuso-sexual-no-sul-do-estado"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 662,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-de-justica",
"date": "2026",
"note": "Aggregate sentence reduced from ~489 to ~211 years; STJ review pending — NOT final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. NOT FINAL: the aggregate sentence has been reduced on appeal and several actions remain under review at the Superior Tribunal de Justiça, so no figure is asserted as settled. The reduction is stated because a record that cited only the 489-year figure would now be wrong.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-joao-de-deus-abadiania-goias-brazil",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Abadiânia, Goiás, Brazil",
"lat": -16.1972,
"lng": -48.7061,
"title": "Brazil: 'João de Deus' — the medium whose healing consultations produced hundreds of complainants",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed medium and curandeiro of the Casa de Dom Inácio de Loyola, Abadiânia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abuse committed during 'passes' and spiritual consultations",
"international reputation as a healer drawing women seeking cures"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Casa de Dom Inácio de Loyola, Abadiânia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Goiás courts; Tribunal de Justiça de Goiás",
"stage": "convictions across seventeen actions; aggregate reduced on appeal; further appeals pending",
"date": "2019-12-01",
"outcome": "João Teixeira de Faria, known as João de Deus, was first sentenced in December 2019 for four rapes, and was ultimately convicted across seventeen criminal actions arising from abuse of women who came to him for spiritual healing at Abadiânia. In 2026 the Goiás high court reduced his aggregate sentence from roughly 489 years to around 211 years; several cases remain under special-appeal review at the Superior Tribunal de Justiça."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE, and the strongest healer-authority nexus in the corpus: hundreds of women travelled to him because he was believed to heal, and the assaults happened inside the consultations that belief brought them to.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tjgo.jus.br/index.php/agencia-de-noticias/noticias-ccs/20-destaque/27581-joao-de-deus-e-condenado-a-mais-de-118-anos-de-prisao-todas-as-acoes-contra-o-medium-foram-julgadas-em-primeiro-grau",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tribunal de Justiça de Goiás: all actions judged at first instance.",
"body": "The state court's own release.",
"tier": "official-court-release",
"kind": "verdict-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.direitonews.com.br/2026/05/quase-480-211-anos-entenda-pena-joao-de-deus-foi-reduzida-pela-metade.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Direito News: the 2026 appellate reduction explained.",
"body": "Legal-press report of the appellate outcome.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-de-justica",
"date": "2026",
"note": "Aggregate sentence reduced from ~489 to ~211 years; STJ review pending — NOT final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tjgo.jus.br/index.php/agencia-de-noticias/noticias-ccs/20-destaque/27581-joao-de-deus-e-condenado-a-mais-de-118-anos-de-prisao-todas-as-acoes-contra-o-medium-foram-julgadas-em-primeiro-grau",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-release; evidentiary role: verdict-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.direitonews.com.br/2026/05/quase-480-211-anos-entenda-pena-joao-de-deus-foi-reduzida-pela-metade.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6b70c5463a53b1a806a3a2633d5340fc06c0d3cfc728e37b11ee930f6871f178",
"final_url": "https://www.direitonews.com.br/2026/05/quase-480-211-anos-entenda-pena-joao-de-deus-foi-reduzida-pela-metade.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 663,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Prosecution appeal pending — NOT final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. NOT FINAL — the prosecution's appeal seeks additional convictions and a heavier sentence, so the disposition may increase rather than decrease.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-eduardo-santana-pai-de-santo-hortolandia-brazil",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Hortolândia, São Paulo, Brazil",
"lat": -22.8583,
"lng": -47.22,
"title": "Brazil: pai de santo convicted over thirteen victims — court finds systematic use of his religious influence",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pai de santo of an umbanda terreiro in Hortolândia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the court's express finding of systematic use of his 'power of influence as pai de santo'",
"sexual violation by fraud within the terreiro's religious framework"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "1ª Vara Criminal de Hortolândia, São Paulo (Juiz André Forato Anhe)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; prosecution appeal pending",
"date": "2024-09-01",
"outcome": "Eduardo Santana, known as Pai Du, pai de santo of an umbanda terreiro in Hortolândia, was convicted in September 2024 of rape, sexual violation by fraud, sexual importuning, sexual harassment and injury against thirteen victims — all followers of his terreiro — between 2020 and 2023, and sentenced to sixteen years, three months and seventeen days in closed regime plus a further term in semi-open regime. The judgment expressly found systematic use of his 'power of influence as pai de santo'. The prosecution has appealed seeking additional convictions and a higher sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE, in the court's own words: the judgment names the systematic use of his power of influence as pai de santo as the mechanism. Every victim was a follower of his terreiro.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mpsp.mp.br/w/pai-de-santo-e-condenado-em-hortolandia-por-crimes-como-homofobia-estupro-e-violacao-sexual",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministério Público de São Paulo: conviction release.",
"body": "The prosecuting authority's own release, quoting the judgment's finding.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Prosecution appeal pending — NOT final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mpsp.mp.br/w/pai-de-santo-e-condenado-em-hortolandia-por-crimes-como-homofobia-estupro-e-violacao-sexual",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 664,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "apgabaltiesa",
"date": "",
"note": "Conviction confirmed on appeal; further review would lie only to the Supreme Court, none indicated."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified; the defendant is named in the Latvian form used by national press. SECOND RECORD FOR LATVIA.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-aivars-s-baptist-sunday-school-talsi-latvia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Talsi, Latvia",
"lat": 57.2447,
"lng": 22.5869,
"title": "Latvia: Baptist minister and Sunday-school director convicted of abusing five girls",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Baptist minister and director of the congregation's Sunday school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the court's express finding that he exploited the trust and helplessness his pastoral and Sunday-school roles created"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kurzemes rajona tiesa (Ventspils); Kurzemes apgabaltiesa (appellate)",
"stage": "conviction; confirmed on appeal",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "Aivars Š., a Baptist minister and director of his congregation's Sunday school in Talsu novads, was convicted of the sexual abuse of five girls aged between seven and sixteen between August 2018 and April 2022, the court finding that he had exploited the trust and helplessness his position created. He received ten years plus three years' probation, and the Kurzeme regional court confirmed the conviction on appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE, with the court naming it: children of his Sunday school, abused through the authority the role conferred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nra.lv/latvija/kriminalzinas/501749-aivars-s-notiesats-par-seksualu-vardarbibu-talsu-novada.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NRA.lv: 'Aivars Š. notiesāts par seksuālu vardarbību Talsu novadā'.",
"body": "Latvian national outlet's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "apgabaltiesa",
"date": "",
"note": "Conviction confirmed on appeal; further review would lie only to the Supreme Court, none indicated."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nra.lv/latvija/kriminalzinas/501749-aivars-s-notiesats-par-seksualu-vardarbibu-talsu-novada.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cb389460dc799ea3c69411f47bbe1185333268180080fceafe95028c1c76e3cf",
"final_url": "https://nra.lv/latvija/kriminalzinas/501749-aivars-s-notiesats-par-seksualu-vardarbibu-talsu-novada.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 665,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "regional-appellate-court",
"date": "",
"note": "Conviction confirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified; the defendant is named in the initialled form used by Turkish press. SECOND RECORD FOR TURKEY. This is an ordinary criminal prosecution in the general courts, with none of the political ambiguity attaching to Turkey's post-2016 prosecutions of religious communities — a distinction this corpus maintains deliberately.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-mehmet-d-quran-course-tarsus-turkey",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Tarsus, Mersin, Turkey",
"lat": 36.9177,
"lng": 34.8956,
"title": "Turkey: imam sentenced to twenty-seven years for abusing a twelve-year-old Quran-course student",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam running a mosque Quran course"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teacher authority over a Quran-course student",
"unlawful deprivation of the child's liberty"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tarsus 1st Heavy Penal Court; Adana Regional Court, 12th Criminal Division (appellate)",
"stage": "conviction; confirmed on appeal",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "Mehmet D., 59, an imam running a mosque Quran course, was convicted of qualified sexual abuse of a minor and unlawful deprivation of liberty against a twelve-year-old student of the course, and sentenced to twenty-seven years and six months. The Adana regional appellate court confirmed the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "CORE: a child sent to learn the Quran, under the man teaching it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/siyaset/kuran-kursunda-cocuk-istismari-sanik-imama-275-yil-hapis-1875130",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cumhuriyet: 'Kuran kursunda çocuk istismarı: sanık imama 27,5 yıl hapis'.",
"body": "Turkish national daily's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "regional-appellate-court",
"date": "",
"note": "Conviction confirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/siyaset/kuran-kursunda-cocuk-istismari-sanik-imama-275-yil-hapis-1875130",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eea378c85605d3c2d53322960592f6bc8186baf5e5988fd870fbc5b0ef27b41a",
"final_url": "https://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/siyaset/kuran-kursunda-cocuk-istismari-sanik-imama-275-yil-hapis-1875130"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 666,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate-court",
"date": "1990",
"note": "Convictions AFFIRMED; sentence vacated and remanded for resentencing only."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, identified in the opinion only by initials and not named here. Part of the corpus's under-populated 1964-1990 window, recovered by phrase-anchored full-text appellate search.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-wilmon-bosley-sunrise-church-waukegan-illinois-usa",
"year": 1990,
"place": "Waukegan, Illinois, USA",
"lat": 42.3636,
"lng": -87.8448,
"title": "United States (1990): pastor's convictions affirmed for abusing two children of a churchgoing family",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the Sunrise Church of God, Waukegan"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"driving the family to church, with an assault committed in the car",
"a child assaulted while helping clean the church building"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Sunrise Church of God, Waukegan"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Illinois Appellate Court, Second District (People v. Bosley, 197 Ill. App. 3d 215, 553 N.E.2d 1187)",
"stage": "convictions affirmed; sentence vacated and remanded for resentencing",
"date": "1990-01-01",
"outcome": "Wilmon Bosley, pastor of the Sunrise Church of God in Waukegan, was convicted of aggravated criminal sexual assault and abuse against two sisters aged roughly six and eleven whose family attended his church. The appellate opinion records that the assaults occurred during church-related activity — one in the car as he drove the family to church, another while the elder child was helping clean the church building. The Appellate Court affirmed the convictions in 1990, reversing only the sentence and remanding for resentencing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The opinion establishes both halves of the test: his pastorate, and the victims' position as the children of a congregant family in his care — reached through the church's own routines of transport and upkeep.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Bosley, 197 Ill. App. 3d 215, 553 N.E.2d 1187 (Ill. App. Ct., 2d Dist. 1990).",
"body": "The appellate opinion affirming the convictions.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate-court",
"date": "1990",
"note": "Convictions AFFIRMED; sentence vacated and remanded for resentencing only."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 667,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "NAME NOTE: this Australian sect is unrelated to the Manson Family, which this corpus records separately. CRITICAL — read before citing: THERE IS NO CHILD-ABUSE CONVICTION IN THIS CASE and this record must never be read as asserting one. What is adjudicated is a fraud conviction carrying a A$5,000 fine and no custodial sentence. The gap between the scale of what is alleged and the triviality of what was punished is itself the fact worth recording. EVIDENTIARY TIERS, kept separate: (1) COURT-ADJUDICATED — the 1994 false-declaration conviction, the 1993 US extradition ruling, and the welfare-fraud convictions of four other members; (2) COURT-SUPERVISED CIVIL SETTLEMENT — the 2021 Supreme Court group proceeding, settled with no admission and no judicial findings, which is stronger than bare allegation but is not a liability finding; (3) SURVIVOR ACCOUNT AND JOURNALISM, never tested in any court — the administration of LSD to adolescents as 'initiation', starvation and beatings as discipline, and the psychological domination. Sarah Moore's memoir and documentary journalism are the sources for tier 3, and this record asserts those matters as allegations only. The psychiatrists said to have administered drugs at Newhaven Private Hospital were never charged, and no medical-board finding against them could be located. No Royal Commission case study, Ombudsman report or parliamentary inquiry into the group was found — probable absence, not exhaustively confirmed. Anne Hamilton-Byrne died on 13 June 2019, aged 97, with advanced dementia, never having been tried for anything concerning the children. The reported connection to Julian Assange's family — that his mother's former partner was linked to the group — rests solely on Assange's own public account and is recorded here as his characterisation, not as verified fact; it forms no part of the basis for this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-anne-hamilton-byrne-the-family-victoria-australia",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Lake Eildon, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.2333,
"lng": 145.9167,
"title": "Australia: Hamilton-Byrne's 'The Family' — children acquired by fraud for a woman who told them she was Christ",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Anne Hamilton-Byrne, leader of The Family (Santiniketan Park Association), presented to the children as their mother and as a reincarnation of Christ",
"William 'Bill' Hamilton-Byrne, her husband",
"doctors, lawyers and social workers inside the sect who arranged the acquisitions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"children obtained through false birth registrations and deed polls recording them as the Hamilton-Byrnes' natural children",
"the children told she was both their mother and a reincarnation of Christ",
"uniform dyed-blonde hair and total isolation at Kai Lama on Lake Eildon ('Uptop')",
"no external recourse available to children raised entirely inside the group"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"The Family / Santiniketan Park Association",
"Life For All Creatures Ltd"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Melbourne",
"stage": "guilty plea to making a false declaration; fined",
"date": "1994-09-26",
"outcome": "After a Victoria Police investigation (Operation Forest) and a 1987 raid on the group's property at Lake Eildon, Anne and William Hamilton-Byrne were arrested by the FBI in New York in June 1993 and extradited. On 26 September 1994 both pleaded guilty in the County Court of Victoria to making a false declaration — falsely registering three unrelated children as their own triplets — and were fined A$5,000 each. Conspiracy and perjury charges were dropped. No child-abuse charge was ever brought against either of them. Four other members were separately convicted of obtaining welfare payments by fraud, offences unconnected to the children's treatment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Victoria (Creese v Life For All Creatures Ltd & Ors, S CI 2017 03007)",
"stage": "court-supervised civil settlement — no admission or finding of liability",
"date": "2021-03-29",
"outcome": "A group proceeding brought on behalf of children of Anne Hamilton-Byrne who alleged personal injury from cruel and inhumane treatment between 1968 and 1987 settled for A$600,000 inclusive of costs, approved by the Supreme Court of Victoria in March 2021. The court-filed settlement notice recites the plaintiffs' allegations — cruel and inhumane treatment, assaults, physical or sexual abuse, and breach of a duty of care arising from the children's relationship of dependence — but the defendants made no admission and the court made no findings of fact."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Among the cleanest fits for this corpus's criterion, and simultaneously among the thinnest in adjudication. Every child's exposure ran entirely through Hamilton-Byrne's claimed authority: she was presented to them as their mother AND as a reincarnation of Christ, they were raised in isolation at Lake Eildon knowing no other world, and there was no adult outside the group they could appeal to. The fraudulent birth registrations that produced the only conviction are the mechanism's foundation — the paperwork is what made the children hers.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.supremecourt.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2021-01/Hamilton-Byrne%20Notice%20of%20Settlement.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supreme Court of Victoria, Notice of Proposed Settlement, Creese v Life For All Creatures Ltd & Ors (S CI 2017 03007).",
"body": "The court's own settlement notice, reciting the pleaded allegations and the terms approved.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "court-settlement-notice"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/831/287/1801987/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Matter of Extradition of Hamilton-Byrne, 831 F. Supp. 287 (S.D.N.Y. 1993).",
"body": "The US federal extradition ruling that returned the Hamilton-Byrnes to Victoria.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "extradition-ruling"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/48-hours-inside-the-family-cult-australia-anne-hamilton-byrne/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News, '48 Hours: Inside the Family cult'.",
"body": "Documentary journalism on the group, the children and the raid — cited for the tier-3 allegations, labelled as such.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.supremecourt.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2021-01/Hamilton-Byrne%20Notice%20of%20Settlement.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: court-settlement-notice.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e123275c2b427afd98d3e2074cbb5ad483f771a4c54b16f51d4ed3cecb15e467",
"final_url": "https://www.supremecourt.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2021-01/Hamilton-Byrne%20Notice%20of%20Settlement.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/831/287/1801987/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: extradition-ruling.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/48-hours-inside-the-family-cult-australia-anne-hamilton-byrne/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3a1a645afb68dba5049bdb8e53d702750292488694ffcc4d299d71fd3587200b",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/48-hours-inside-the-family-cult-australia-anne-hamilton-byrne/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 668,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Extracted from the Ferns Report (2005), the Irish government inquiry into the Diocese of Ferns, via the copy hosted at the Internet Archive. Named because the report names him and the conviction is a matter of public record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-colm-collins-ferns-wexford-ireland",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Wexford, Ireland",
"lat": 52.3369,
"lng": -6.4633,
"title": "Ireland: Ferns priest sentenced to four years after pleading guilty to indecent assault",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Diocese of Ferns"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly access to children of the diocese"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Ferns"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Wexford Circuit Court, Ireland",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "1998-03-25",
"outcome": "Fr Colm Collins pleaded guilty on 25 March 1998 at Wexford Circuit Court to four counts of indecent assault and one of gross indecency, and was sentenced to four years on each count to run concurrently. He was released after one year on grounds of ill health. The conviction is recorded in the Ferns Report."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children of the diocese, reached through the priesthood the Ferns Report was established to examine.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/243711-2-complete-ferns-report-so-ireland",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Ferns Report (Ireland, 2005), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "The commission report recording the conviction, plea and sentence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/243711-2-complete-ferns-report-so-ireland",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ea7eb94fdc5910180217f5828b74389f2ac9ada817cf8019adee5417c790701e",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/243711-2-complete-ferns-report-so-ireland"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 669,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified; the priest is recorded under the surname used in the Ferns Report. The court is not named in the report. The wholly suspended sentence is stated as imposed — the leniency is part of what the inquiry documented.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-ferns-priest-suspended-sentence-ireland",
"year": 1990,
"place": "County Wexford, Ireland",
"lat": 52.47,
"lng": -6.58,
"title": "Ireland (1990): Ferns priest given a suspended sentence for indecent and common assault",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Diocese of Ferns"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly access to children of the diocese"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Ferns"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Irish trial court (not named in the report)",
"stage": "guilty plea; suspended sentence",
"date": "1990-01-01",
"outcome": "A priest of the Diocese of Ferns, recorded in the Ferns Report as Fr Doyle, pleaded guilty in 1990 to indecent assault and common assault and received a three-month suspended sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A diocesan priest and a child of his parish.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/243711-2-complete-ferns-report-so-ireland",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Ferns Report (Ireland, 2005), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "The commission report recording the plea and suspended sentence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/243711-2-complete-ferns-report-so-ireland",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ea7eb94fdc5910180217f5828b74389f2ac9ada817cf8019adee5417c790701e",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/243711-2-complete-ferns-report-so-ireland"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 670,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Extracted from the Cloyne Report's glossary via the Internet Archive copy. The political consequence is documented context, not an adjudicated fact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-brendan-smyth-norbertine-ireland",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Ireland",
"lat": 53.3498,
"lng": -6.2603,
"title": "Ireland: Brendan Smyth — twelve years on seventy-four counts, and the case that broke the Irish scandal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Norbertine Order, moved repeatedly between parishes and jurisdictions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"decades of transfers between Ireland, Northern Ireland and the United States that renewed his access to children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Norbertine Order"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Irish courts",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence; died in prison",
"date": "1994-01-01",
"outcome": "Fr Brendan Smyth pleaded guilty in 1994 to seventy-four counts of child abuse committed over decades and was sentenced to twelve years. He died in prison. The delay in extraditing him from Ireland to Northern Ireland precipitated the collapse of the Irish government in 1994."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children across two jurisdictions reached through a priesthood that kept relocating him rather than stopping him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/216118-cloyne-report",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Cloyne Report (Ireland, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction, counts and sentence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/216118-cloyne-report",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9efc45c11e0e5182cbe5a47c63fbc1eae6cf0c790fc3dbebe8a276dc579fff79",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/216118-cloyne-report"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 671,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. The priest is recorded under the Cloyne Report's own pseudonym, his real name being suppressed in the report; the corpus follows the commission's convention. The suspended sentence is stated as imposed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-cloyne-priest-gross-indecency-ireland",
"year": 2010,
"place": "County Cork, Ireland",
"lat": 51.8985,
"lng": -8.4756,
"title": "Ireland (2010): Cloyne priest given a suspended sentence for gross indecency",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Diocese of Cloyne"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly access to a child of the diocese"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Cloyne"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Irish court (not specified in the report)",
"stage": "guilty plea to one count; suspended sentence",
"date": "2010-11-01",
"outcome": "A priest of the Diocese of Cloyne, recorded in the Cloyne Report under the pseudonym Fr Caden, faced three counts of gross indecency, pleaded guilty to one in November 2010, and received an eighteen-month suspended sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A diocesan priest and a child in his reach.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/216118-cloyne-report",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Cloyne Report (Ireland, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the plea and sentence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/216118-cloyne-report",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9efc45c11e0e5182cbe5a47c63fbc1eae6cf0c790fc3dbebe8a276dc579fff79",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/216118-cloyne-report"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 672,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; the priest is recorded under the Deetman Commission's own code, per Dutch commission convention. Extracted from the Deetman Report via the Internet Archive. PRE-1970 RECORD — part of the corpus's most under-documented window.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1957-hasselt-priest-liege-belgium",
"year": 1957,
"place": "Hasselt, Belgium",
"lat": 50.9307,
"lng": 5.3378,
"title": "Belgium (1957): priest sentenced to three years for the abuse of twenty-five boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Diocese of Liège"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly access to boys across a parish"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Liège"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Belgian criminal court, Hasselt",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1957-04-01",
"outcome": "A priest of the Diocese of Liège, recorded in the Deetman Report under the code bp1, was convicted in April 1957 of the sexual abuse of twenty-five boys committed in 1956 and 1957, and sentenced to three years' imprisonment with five years' loss of civil rights. He was released early."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Twenty-five boys of a parish, under their priest, in the 1950s — the era the corpus can least easily see.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deetman Report (Netherlands, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction, counts and sentence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28730da9723b0e0a4d0b142e5d16b3eaf6f961a0e8dd9cf81e6620f0186f6354",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 673,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; commission code used per Dutch convention. PRE-1970 RECORD.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1957-veurne-priest-bruges-belgium",
"year": 1957,
"place": "Veurne, Belgium",
"lat": 51.0714,
"lng": 2.6622,
"title": "Belgium (1957): five-year sentence for a priest who abused eighteen boys under sixteen",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of the Diocese of Bruges"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly access to boys and adolescents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Bruges"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Correctionele Rechtbank, Veurne, Belgium",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1957-01-01",
"outcome": "A priest of the Diocese of Bruges, recorded in the Deetman Report under the code bp2, was convicted at the Veurne correctional court of indecent assault against eighteen boys under sixteen and four minors over sixteen, committed between 1954 and 1956, and received sentences of five years and two and a half years for the concurrent offences."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Twenty-two boys and adolescents, under a diocesan priest, in the mid-1950s.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deetman Report (Netherlands, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction and sentences.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28730da9723b0e0a4d0b142e5d16b3eaf6f961a0e8dd9cf81e6620f0186f6354",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 674,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; commission code used per Dutch convention. The non-suspension of his teaching licence is recorded because the commission recorded it. PRE-1970 RECORD.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1959-brother-fic9-saint-louis-amersfoort-netherlands",
"year": 1959,
"place": "Amersfoort, Netherlands",
"lat": 52.1561,
"lng": 5.3878,
"title": "Netherlands (1959): religious-order brother convicted of abusing schoolboys in his care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"brother of a teaching religious order at the Saint Louis school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teaching authority over boys at a Catholic school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Saint Louis school, Amersfoort"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Dutch trial court (Rechtbank)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1959-06-16",
"outcome": "A brother of a teaching religious order at the Saint Louis school in Amersfoort, recorded in the Deetman Report under the code FIC9, was convicted on 16 June 1959 of indecent acts with at least three boys aged fourteen and fifteen between 1955 and 1958, and sentenced to one year's imprisonment less time served. His teaching licence was not suspended."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Schoolboys under a religious-order teacher — and a teaching licence that survived the conviction, which is the institutional half of the story.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deetman Report (Netherlands, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction, sentence and licence outcome.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28730da9723b0e0a4d0b142e5d16b3eaf6f961a0e8dd9cf81e6620f0186f6354",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 675,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "gerechtshof",
"date": "1961",
"note": "Sentence reduced to 1 year (10 months suspended); conviction and 7-year teaching ban upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; commission code used per Dutch convention. The appeal REDUCED the sentence but did not disturb the conviction — recorded precisely, since a reversed conviction would not qualify. PRE-1970 RECORD.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1961-brother-fic10-maastricht-netherlands",
"year": 1961,
"place": "Maastricht, Netherlands",
"lat": 50.8514,
"lng": 5.691,
"title": "Netherlands (1961): brother's sentence halved on appeal but conviction and teaching ban upheld",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"brother of a religious order serving as teacher and youth leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"combined teaching and youth-leadership authority over pupils"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rechtbank Maastricht; Gerechtshof 's-Hertogenbosch (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal, conviction and ban upheld",
"date": "1961-07-20",
"outcome": "A religious-order brother working as a teacher and youth leader, recorded in the Deetman Report under the code FIC10, was convicted on 20 July 1961 at Maastricht of indecent acts with pupils between 1957 and 1960, and sentenced to two years with a seven-year teaching ban. On appeal the 's-Hertogenbosch court reduced the sentence to one year, ten months of it suspended, while upholding both the conviction and the seven-year ban."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Pupils under a brother who was both their teacher and their youth leader.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deetman Report (Netherlands, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction, appeal and outcome.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "gerechtshof",
"date": "1961",
"note": "Sentence reduced to 1 year (10 months suspended); conviction and 7-year teaching ban upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28730da9723b0e0a4d0b142e5d16b3eaf6f961a0e8dd9cf81e6620f0186f6354",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 676,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified; commission code used per Dutch convention. PRE-1970 RECORD.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1964-brother-fic11-maastricht-netherlands",
"year": 1964,
"place": "Maastricht, Netherlands",
"lat": 50.848,
"lng": 5.688,
"title": "Netherlands (1964): brother convicted of abusing a pupil from the age of eight",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"brother of a teaching religious order"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teaching authority over a child from the age of eight"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rechtbank Maastricht, Netherlands",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1964-01-21",
"outcome": "A religious-order brother, recorded in the Deetman Report under the code FIC11, was convicted at Maastricht on 21 January 1964 of indecent acts with a pupil beginning when the child was eight, the abuse having started in 1959, and sentenced to eight months with three suspended and a five-year teaching ban."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child abused from the age of eight by the brother who taught him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deetman Report (Netherlands, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28730da9723b0e0a4d0b142e5d16b3eaf6f961a0e8dd9cf81e6620f0186f6354",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 677,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "1958",
"note": "Prosecution appealed the sentence as too lenient; outcome not stated in the report."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; commission code used per Dutch convention. The appeal outcome is unknown and is flagged rather than assumed. PRE-1970 RECORD.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1958-brother-bhj1-maastricht-netherlands",
"year": 1958,
"place": "Maastricht, Netherlands",
"lat": 50.85,
"lng": 5.69,
"title": "Netherlands (1958): senior congregation member convicted, prosecution appealing the sentence as too light",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior member of a religious congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"seniority within a religious congregation giving access to boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rechtbank Maastricht, Netherlands",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; prosecution appeal on leniency",
"date": "1958-12-01",
"outcome": "A senior member of a religious congregation, recorded in the Deetman Report under the code BHJ1, was convicted at Maastricht in December 1958 of the sexual abuse of multiple boys and sentenced to one year. The prosecution, which had sought two years unconditional, appealed the sentence as too lenient; the report does not state the appeal's outcome."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys under a senior figure of a religious congregation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deetman Report (Netherlands, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction and the prosecution's appeal.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "1958",
"note": "Prosecution appealed the sentence as too lenient; outcome not stated in the report."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28730da9723b0e0a4d0b142e5d16b3eaf6f961a0e8dd9cf81e6620f0186f6354",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 678,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; commission code used per Dutch convention. PRE-1970 RECORD, and among the corpus's earliest post-war entries.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1954-frater-cmm4-netherlands",
"year": 1954,
"place": "Netherlands",
"lat": 51.5555,
"lng": 5.0913,
"title": "Netherlands (1954): friar convicted of abusing three boys of about eight",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"frater of a religious congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-congregation authority over young children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Dutch trial court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1954-01-01",
"outcome": "A frater of a religious congregation, recorded in the Deetman Report under the code CMM4, was convicted in 1954 of sexual acts with three boys of about eight years old over roughly a year, and sentenced to nine months less time served plus four months suspended."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Three eight-year-olds under a religious congregation's frater — the earliest of the Deetman convictions the corpus now carries.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deetman Report (Netherlands, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28730da9723b0e0a4d0b142e5d16b3eaf6f961a0e8dd9cf81e6620f0186f6354",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 679,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; commission code used per Dutch convention. The 1957 reoffence is recorded as the commission recorded it and is NOT asserted as a second conviction. PRE-1970 RECORD.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1954-brother-fc5-eikenburg-netherlands",
"year": 1954,
"place": "Eindhoven, Netherlands",
"lat": 51.4416,
"lng": 5.4697,
"title": "Netherlands (1954): brother given a suspended sentence, lost his teaching credential, and reoffended",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"brother of a religious order teaching at the Eikenburg school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teaching authority over pupils at a Catholic school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Eikenburg school"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Dutch trial court",
"stage": "conviction; suspended sentence and loss of teaching credential",
"date": "1954-01-01",
"outcome": "A religious-order brother teaching at the Eikenburg school, recorded in the Deetman Report under the code FC5, was convicted in 1954 of sexual misconduct as a teacher, received an eight-month suspended sentence and lost his teaching credential. The report records that he offended again in 1957 against a juvenist; that later conduct was not separately adjudicated in the material extracted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Pupils under a teaching brother — and a documented reoffence three years later, which is why the corpus records the institutional response alongside the sentence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deetman Report (Netherlands, 2011), via the Internet Archive.",
"body": "Commission report recording the conviction, sentence and subsequent reoffence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28730da9723b0e0a4d0b142e5d16b3eaf6f961a0e8dd9cf81e6620f0186f6354",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/RapportDeetmanSeksueelMisbruikRk"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 680,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "CONTEXT RECORD — an official finding, not a case. IMPORTANT PRECISION: this study is frequently cited as having found 'no evidence' of ritual abuse. That overstates it. It substantiated three of eighty-four allegations as organised abuse with ritual control elements, and found that none met the satanic-worship criterion. This corpus records both halves, because a database that cited only the negative would be as inaccurate as one that cited only the positive.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-la-fontaine-ritual-abuse-study-england-wales-uk",
"year": 1994,
"place": "England and Wales, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.3555,
"lng": -1.1743,
"title": "United Kingdom: the government study that examined 84 ritual-abuse allegations — and what it actually found",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"the UK Department of Health, commissioning an independent academic study"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual elements found, where they existed at all, to be instruments of control and intimidation rather than religious worship"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"UK Department of Health"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "United Kingdom — Department of Health commissioned study (Prof. Jean La Fontaine)",
"stage": "published findings",
"date": "1994-01-01",
"outcome": "Professor Jean La Fontaine examined eighty-four alleged cases of ritual or satanic abuse drawn from police, social-services and NSPCC records for 1988 to 1991, together with interviews. Three of the eighty-four were substantiated as involving genuine organised abuse — and none of those three met the satanic or devil-worship criterion. Where ritual elements were present, the study found them to be instruments of control and intimidation, with a sexual motive underlying the abuse rather than religious worship."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The finding matters precisely because it is nuanced: ritual was real in a small number of cases, but as a mechanism of control rather than as worship — which is close to how this corpus defines the criterion, arrived at independently by a government study.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://saff.nfshost.com/fontaine.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jean La Fontaine, 'The Extent and Nature of Organised and Ritual Sexual Abuse' (UK Department of Health, 1994) — study summary and findings.",
"body": "The commissioned study's own findings on the 84 examined cases.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "government-study"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://saff.nfshost.com/fontaine.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: government-study.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "68ba324ba6b9f87cee118a92278d206861a11dd63130535e920ae2af1573392a",
"final_url": "https://saff.nfshost.com/fontaine.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 681,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "CONTEXT RECORD — an official finding, not a case. The Bolderkar (1988) and Lancee (1996) cases associated with this period remained equivocal and contested and produced no convictions; neither is recorded here as a case. A later Dutch report made procedural recommendations on charges resting on recovered memories, on memories from before age three, and on ritual-abuse allegations specifically — a caution about process rather than a finding either way.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-dutch-ritual-abuse-workgroup-netherlands",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Netherlands",
"lat": 52.1326,
"lng": 5.2913,
"title": "Netherlands: the state workgroup that found no verified pattern of ritual abuse",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"a multidisciplinary workgroup appointed by the Dutch State Secretary of Justice"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the alleged combination of elements into a 'ritual abuse' pattern, which the workgroup found unverified"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [
"Werkgroep Ritueel Misbruik (Netherlands)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Netherlands — Werkgroep Ritueel Misbruik, appointed by the State Secretary of Justice",
"stage": "published findings",
"date": "1994-01-01",
"outcome": "Prompted by the Oude Pekela allegations of 1987, a multidisciplinary workgroup appointed by the Dutch State Secretary of Justice concluded that there was no evidence, in the Netherlands or elsewhere, for the existence of ritual abuse beyond the testimony of alleged victims, and that the combination of elements alleged to constitute ritual abuse had not been sufficiently verified anywhere. Individual elements of the accounts were separately documented in police files, but never in the combined pattern alleged."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A negative official finding, recorded because negative findings are as much a part of the evidentiary record as positive ones — and because this corpus's credibility depends on carrying both.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://open.overheid.nl/documenten/ronl-9781e22883072581ab6f0954f7cddd2baed9464f/pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Werkgroep Ritueel Misbruik, findings (Netherlands, 1994), via the Dutch government open-data portal.",
"body": "The workgroup's own published conclusion.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "government-study"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://open.overheid.nl/documenten/ronl-9781e22883072581ab6f0954f7cddd2baed9464f/pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: government-study.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c7c78a8959e5ceb699f8e3c35f0834c0fa593c9ff51a33af9c3b3644a893dac7",
"final_url": "https://open.overheid.nl/documenten/ronl-9781e22883072581ab6f0954f7cddd2baed9464f/pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 682,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-judicial-court",
"date": "1997-03",
"note": "Vacated convictions REINSTATED on finality grounds; separate new-trial orders followed in May 1997."
}
],
"scopeNote": "HISTORICAL / PANIC-ERA RECORD, and a CORRECTION TO A COMMON ERROR: Fells Acres is routinely described as an overturned or exonerated case. It is not. Gerald Amirault's conviction stands to this day and no pardon exists; Violet's was vacated, reinstated, then subject to a new-trial order, and she died before resolution; Cheryl's final disposition is not cleanly established in accessible sources. This corpus states the tangle rather than filing it as a clean exoneration alongside Kern County or the San Antonio Four.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1997-fells-acres-amirault-massachusetts-usa",
"year": 1997,
"place": "Malden, Massachusetts, USA",
"lat": 42.4251,
"lng": -71.0662,
"title": "United States: Fells Acres — the panic-era case that never resolved cleanly in either direction",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"operators of the Fells Acres Day School, prosecuted during the ritual-abuse panic era"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"child-witness interview methods later found by courts and scholars to have been suggestive"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"violent-occult-ideology",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Fells Acres Day School, Malden"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Massachusetts trial courts; Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts",
"stage": "convictions, vacatur, reinstatement and new-trial orders — no clean resolution",
"date": "1997-03-01",
"outcome": "Violet and Cheryl Amirault's convictions were vacated by a trial judge in August 1995 on confrontation-rights grounds; the Supreme Judicial Court reinstated both in March 1997 on finality grounds; a different Superior Court judge then granted both women new trials in May 1997, citing grave errors in the investigation. Violet Amirault died in September 1997 with her conviction unresolved. Gerald Amirault's conviction was never overturned; he served his sentence and was paroled in 2004, and a 2022 attempt to pardon him and Cheryl was withdrawn in December 2022 for want of votes on the Governor's Council."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A panic-era prosecution recorded for the same reason as the corpus's other satanic-panic entries: occult allegation was the engine of the case, and the accused bore the harm.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fells_Acres_day_care_sexual_abuse_trial",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fells Acres Day School case — procedural history.",
"body": "Case chronology covering the vacatur, reinstatement, new-trial orders and the withdrawn pardon.",
"tier": "reference-index",
"kind": "case-chronology"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-judicial-court",
"date": "1997-03",
"note": "Vacated convictions REINSTATED on finality grounds; separate new-trial orders followed in May 1997."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fells_Acres_day_care_sexual_abuse_trial",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-index; evidentiary role: case-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b535128a956390e40de96afffc969fb87a9a69c3e4047651cc33128b2f46ce1f",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fells_Acres_day_care_sexual_abuse_trial"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 683,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cour-assises-appel",
"date": "2005-11",
"note": "Six of the ten convictions overturned on appeal; four unappealed convictions stood."
}
],
"scopeNote": "HISTORICAL RECORD, with a framing caution: Outreau was a child-sex-ring prosecution and was NOT framed as satanic or ritual abuse in the way the American day-care cases were. It is recorded alongside them because it is the European archetype of a prosecution that collapsed on appeal, not because the allegations were occult. Four convictions in the case were never appealed and stand — the case is not a total exoneration.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-outreau-france",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Outreau, Pas-de-Calais, France",
"lat": 50.7,
"lng": 1.5931,
"title": "France: Outreau — mass acquittals, a recanting accuser, and a parliamentary inquiry into the prosecution itself",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"French investigating magistracy, subsequently examined by a parliamentary commission"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"accusations that expanded through suggestive questioning and a principal accuser who later recanted in open court"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour d'assises de Saint-Omer (2004); Cour d'assises d'appel, Paris (2005); French National Assembly commission of inquiry (2006)",
"stage": "convictions, then mass acquittals on appeal, then a parliamentary inquiry into the prosecution",
"date": "2005-11-01",
"outcome": "Of seventeen defendants tried at Saint-Omer in 2004, ten were convicted, Thierry Delay receiving twenty years. On appeal in Paris in November 2005 six of those convicted were acquitted after the principal accuser, Myriam Badaoui, recanted in open court and stated the six had not done anything; four convictions that were not appealed stood. A National Assembly commission of inquiry sat from January to April 2006, hearing more than two hundred witnesses over some two hundred hours. French child sexual-assault conviction rates fell markedly in the following decade."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Recorded as a miscarriage-of-justice case rather than an authority-abuse case: the harm documented here was done to the wrongly accused by the prosecution itself.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outreau_case",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Outreau case — trial, appeal and parliamentary inquiry chronology.",
"body": "Case chronology covering the convictions, the appellate acquittals and the National Assembly inquiry.",
"tier": "reference-index",
"kind": "case-chronology"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cour-assises-appel",
"date": "2005-11",
"note": "Six of the ten convictions overturned on appeal; four unappealed convictions stood."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outreau_case",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-index; evidentiary role: case-chronology.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd2329eabc664fd4db63735277f70737b79d8d4aab555004f3118a9d8862ff3d",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outreau_case"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 684,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2021-11",
"note": "Final appeal dismissed; life sentence stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The child victim is named as he is named throughout the Ugandan public record. Tried under ordinary Penal Code murder provisions, the killing predating Uganda's 2021 human-sacrifice statute.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-kato-kajubi-child-sacrifice-masaka-uganda",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Masaka, Uganda",
"lat": -0.3417,
"lng": 31.7369,
"title": "Uganda: businessman's life sentence for a child's ritual killing upheld by the Supreme Court",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"a witchdoctor and his wife, engaged to perform the killing",
"the businessman who commissioned it"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a child killed and mutilated in a 'cleansing' ritual said to prosper a business"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Uganda; Court of Appeal (2014); Supreme Court of Uganda (2021)",
"stage": "conviction; final appeal dismissed",
"date": "2021-11-01",
"outcome": "Kato Kajubi, a Masaka businessman, was convicted of the murder of twelve-year-old Joseph Kasirye, who was decapitated and mutilated in a ritual said to prosper Kajubi's real-estate business. He was sentenced to life imprisonment; the Court of Appeal upheld the conviction in 2014 and the Supreme Court of Uganda dismissed his final appeal in November 2021. The witchdoctor Umar Kateregga and his wife Mariam Nabukeera were tried separately."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE toward the child, who was a stranger. Recorded as victim-directed ritual — and as the pattern the corpus most wants documented, where a client's belief in a witchdoctor's power converts into a commissioned killing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/supreme-court-upholds-businessman-kato-kajubi-s-life-sentence--3617446",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily Monitor: 'Supreme Court upholds businessman Kato Kajubi's life sentence'.",
"body": "National paper of record's report of the final appellate outcome.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court",
"date": "2021-11",
"note": "Final appeal dismissed; life sentence stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/supreme-court-upholds-businessman-kato-kajubi-s-life-sentence--3617446",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5d71f5e26e9b61eb02a41885f716ed74aa8626ba6cdf0565bcb159f88dec8474",
"final_url": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/supreme-court-upholds-businessman-kato-kajubi-s-life-sentence--3617446"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 685,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Convictions and sentences upheld."
}
],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The child victim is not identified here. Reported through an African legal-information analysis of Uganda's pre-2021 human-sacrifice caselaw.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-tomusange-brothers-child-sacrifice-uganda",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Uganda",
"lat": 0.3476,
"lng": 32.5825,
"title": "Uganda: two brothers' sentences for a child's ritual killing upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"two brothers who abducted and killed a child as a sacrificial offering"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a child abducted specifically to be offered in a ritual said to bring riches"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ugandan High Court; Court of Appeal of Uganda",
"stage": "convictions upheld on appeal",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"outcome": "Two brothers of the Tomusange family were convicted of the murder of a child, killed as a ritual sacrifice said to bring riches and happiness, and sentenced to forty-seven years and nine months and thirty-seven years and eight months respectively. The Court of Appeal of Uganda upheld the convictions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Victim-directed ritual: a child taken by strangers for the purpose of the offering itself.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://africanlii.org/articles/2021-08-06/carmel-rickard/uganda-prepares-for-new-law-on-human-sacrifice-heres-what-a-case-of-human-sacrifice-looks-like",
"archive": "",
"citation": "AfricanLII: 'Uganda prepares for new law on human sacrifice — here's what a case of human sacrifice looks like'.",
"body": "Legal-information analysis of the Court of Appeal judgment.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "",
"note": "Convictions and sentences upheld."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://africanlii.org/articles/2021-08-06/carmel-rickard/uganda-prepares-for-new-law-on-human-sacrifice-heres-what-a-case-of-human-sacrifice-looks-like",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8a6de96ed87ad6beb330ce2da675fd9ea55a934b14b0dc6e276d39e599333c10",
"final_url": "https://africanlii.org/en/articles/2021-08-06/carmel-rickard/uganda-prepares-for-new-law-on-human-sacrifice-heres-what-a-case-of-human-sacrifice-looks-like"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 686,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "CONTEXT RECORD, entered for the statutory milestone rather than for an identified victim. NOTABLE FINDING: despite the 2021 Act, the higher-profile ritual killings prosecuted since — including the Sserubiri case already in this corpus and an October 2025 case in which a child survived — were tried on ordinary Penal Code murder and trafficking counts. Commentary attributes this to continuing evidentiary hurdles under the new Act. That gap between a statute's existence and its use is worth documenting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-john-magombe-human-sacrifice-act-kampala-uganda",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Makindye, Kampala, Uganda",
"lat": 0.28,
"lng": 32.59,
"title": "Uganda: the first clear conviction secured under the 2021 human-sacrifice statute",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"a witchdoctor found in possession of human remains bought from other practitioners"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a trade in human body parts sustaining the ritual economy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Uganda at Kampala (Lady Justice Margaret Mutonyi)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence under the Prevention and Prohibition of Human Sacrifice Act 2021",
"date": "2024-06-10",
"outcome": "John Magombe, a witchdoctor raided in February 2023, pleaded guilty to possession of human body parts — three skulls purchased from other practitioners — and was sentenced to seven years, reduced to roughly five years and eight months after credit for time on remand. He was charged and convicted under Uganda's Prevention and Prohibition of Human Sacrifice Act 2021 itself."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "No individual victim is identified and none is asserted. The record's significance is legal: it is the clearest located instance of Uganda's dedicated human-sacrifice statute actually producing a conviction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/witch-doctor-found-with-human-skulls-jailed-7-years-4653688",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily Monitor: 'Witch doctor found with human skulls jailed 7 years'.",
"body": "National paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/witch-doctor-found-with-human-skulls-jailed-7-years-4653688",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "90fafa8cf12a4eb5ad747af0926589c96b35a96cf5b6719b4e6d313741622106",
"final_url": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/witch-doctor-found-with-human-skulls-jailed-7-years-4653688"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 687,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "RELIGIOUS-TERROR CLASS (victim-directed ritual). The victim is named as she is named throughout the Nigerian public record. Recent sentencing; no appeal reported.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-ogun-money-ritual-killing-abeokuta-nigeria",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Abeokuta, Ogun State, Nigeria",
"lat": 7.1557,
"lng": 3.3451,
"title": "Nigeria: two death sentences and a life term for a teenager killed in a money ritual",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"lay perpetrators acting on money-ritual belief; no religious office held"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a girl lured under pretence of a relationship, then killed and mutilated for a money ritual"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ogun State High Court (Justice Olugboyega Ogunfowora)",
"stage": "convictions and sentences",
"date": "2025-07-11",
"outcome": "On 11 July 2025 the Ogun State High Court convicted Mustakeem Balogun, Soliudeen Majekodunmi and Lukmon Abdulgafar of the murder of sixteen-year-old Sofia Okeowo, lured under pretence of a relationship, strangled and beheaded for a money ritual. Balogun and Majekodunmi were sentenced to death by hanging and Abdulgafar to life imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN AUTHORITY-ABUSE CASE. Victim-directed ritual, and notably without any herbalist or religious figure among the convicted — belief in the ritual's efficacy was sufficient motive for lay perpetrators.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://punchng.com/court-sentences-two-to-death-for-ritual-killing-in-ogun/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Punch: 'Court sentences two to death for ritual killing in Ogun'.",
"body": "National paper of record's court report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.channelstv.com/2025/07/12/ogun-govt-secures-conviction-of-three-ritual-killers",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Channels TV: conviction report.",
"body": "National broadcaster corroboration.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://punchng.com/court-sentences-two-to-death-for-ritual-killing-in-ogun/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e75024f22b44dabca447aa93f26d50966595fa18ddab1c2525a07240197bbd15",
"final_url": "https://punchng.com/court-sentences-two-to-death-for-ritual-killing-in-ogun/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.channelstv.com/2025/07/12/ogun-govt-secures-conviction-of-three-ritual-killers",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "631b58a1db7fb3f35d1be71c0306cbbe5c6bea8c321137073ef1e13b377c2742",
"final_url": "https://www.channelstv.com/2025/07/12/ogun-govt-secures-conviction-of-three-ritual-killers/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 688,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "BOUNDARY RECORD. Entered as context to state plainly what this database does NOT treat as abuse. A qualifying case in this area would require animal sacrifice to be the ritual FRAME for harm to a person — a child coerced into participating, blood used in a coercion ritual, a ceremony escalating to human harm. A targeted search for such cases returned nothing, and that honest empty is recorded here rather than filled with lawful practice miscast as abuse.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1993-lukumi-babalu-aye-hialeah-scotus-usa",
"year": 1993,
"place": "Hialeah, Florida, USA",
"lat": 25.8576,
"lng": -80.2781,
"title": "United States: the Supreme Court protects animal sacrifice as religious practice — the corpus's boundary marker",
"tradition": "santeria",
"traditionDetailId": "african-santeria",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"a Santería church, and the municipality that legislated against its practice"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"none — this record exists to mark where lawful religious practice ends and abuse begins"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye",
"City of Hialeah"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the United States — Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye, Inc. v. City of Hialeah, 508 U.S. 520 (1993)",
"stage": "unanimous judgment for the church",
"date": "1993-06-11",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court unanimously struck down City of Hialeah ordinances that targeted Santería animal sacrifice, holding that laws burdening religious practice must be neutral and generally applicable and that these ordinances were neither. Animal sacrifice as practised in Santería is constitutionally protected religious exercise in the United States."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "NOT AN ABUSE CASE, and deliberately so. This corpus documents harm done through spiritual authority; it does not document religious practice. Animal sacrifice is lawful in Santería, Candomblé, Vodou and in the observance of Eid al-Adha, and this judgment is recorded so that boundary is explicit rather than assumed.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/508/520/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye, Inc. v. City of Hialeah, 508 U.S. 520 (1993).",
"body": "The Supreme Court's judgment.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "supreme-court-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/508/520/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: supreme-court-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 689,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "sentence-review",
"date": "2001-06",
"note": "The 1999 Cork sentence was suspended on review — recorded because a corpus citing only the nominal 36 years would mislead."
},
{
"stage": "sentence-reduction",
"date": "1997",
"note": "Guthrie's four-year sentence was reduced to one year — the second Lota sentence cut after imposition."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified; the Brothers are recorded under the Ryan Report's own pseudonyms, per the Commission's convention and this corpus's settled policy. THE SENTENCE REVIEW IS STATED because the nominal thirty-six-year figure is the one usually quoted and it was suspended in 2001. Guthrie's plea, sentencing date and sentence are now established: four years, reduced to one. His COURT was still not stated in any paragraph reached and is not asserted. BOTH Lota sentences were cut after imposition — Dieter's nominal thirty-six years suspended on review in 2001, Guthrie's four years reduced to one — and a record citing only the headline figures would misrepresent both. A separate Commission paragraph noting that Lota allegations were 'dealt with internally' by the Congregation refers to earlier or separate matters and does NOT mean Guthrie escaped prosecution. Extracted via the UCD Industrial Memories database, the working route to the Ryan Report after the Internet Archive copy proved access-restricted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1999-lota-brothers-of-charity-cork-ireland",
"year": 1999,
"place": "Lota, Cork, Ireland",
"lat": 51.9,
"lng": -8.35,
"title": "Ireland: Brothers of Charity convictions at Lota — repeated pleas across three courts",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Brothers of the Brothers of Charity at the Lota institution for boys with intellectual disabilities"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-order custody of disabled boys in a residential institution",
"victims' disabilities compounding their inability to report"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Brothers of Charity, Lota"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cork Circuit Criminal Court; Galway Circuit Court",
"stage": "guilty pleas across three prosecutions; one sentence suspended on review",
"date": "1999-11-01",
"outcome": "A Brother recorded in the Ryan Report under the pseudonym Dieter pleaded guilty in November 1999 at Cork Circuit Criminal Court to eighteen sample counts of child sexual abuse, receiving two years on each — a nominal thirty-six years — which was suspended following a review in June 2001. In November 2000 he pleaded guilty at Galway Circuit Court to twenty-two counts arising at Renmore, receiving three years concurrent, and in February 2002 he pleaded guilty at Cork to two further sample counts with seventy-five other charges taken into account, receiving five years with four suspended. A second Brother, recorded as Guthrie, pleaded guilty in December 1996 and was sentenced on 14 February 1997 on sample charges covering thirty-two years of abuse, with more than a hundred alleged victims; he received four years, reduced to one. The chapter records six separate Garda investigations at Lota, of which only these two produced convictions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys with intellectual disabilities in the residential custody of a religious order — the least able to report, in the care of the men abusing them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-5-166",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report of the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report), Vol. 2 Ch. 5 (Lota), paras 166-169, via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's own record of the pleas, courts and sentences.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "sentence-review",
"date": "2001-06",
"note": "The 1999 Cork sentence was suspended on review — recorded because a corpus citing only the nominal 36 years would mislead."
},
{
"stage": "sentence-reduction",
"date": "1997",
"note": "Guthrie's four-year sentence was reduced to one year — the second Lota sentence cut after imposition."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-5-166",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "151c2072ba4104b0c9d19ce3f62ec05bcb79f2d81ba2b8bf465084c4cba61648",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-5-166"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 690,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "READ THIS BEFORE CITING — the record is deliberately hedged in both directions, because the case is contested in both directions. (1) THERE IS NO CONVICTION, no indictment, and no charge. Koresh died before any prosecution could be brought, so nothing here has ever been tested adversarially. The record rests on sworn congressional testimony, ex-member affidavits, and investigative findings — not on an adjudicated finding of guilt. (2) THE 1992 CHILD-WELFARE CASE WAS CLOSED for insufficient evidence, which cuts against any account treating the abuse as proven; it is stated here rather than omitted. The lead caseworker's later allegations of local interference and leaks complicate that closure without resolving it. (3) CLINICAL FINDINGS ON THE RELEASED CHILDREN DIVERGE: Dr Bruce Perry, who worked with nineteen of the twenty-one children released during the siege, documented elevated resting heart rates consistent with chronic fear, small bruises consistent with physical punishment, and heavy apocalyptic conditioning — but found NO physical evidence of sexual abuse, while noting the girls received no gynaecological examination, so that is an absence of examination rather than a negative finding. A parallel state review described the children in notably more exculpatory terms. (4) THE 1993 RAID, SIEGE AND FIRE ARE EXPRESSLY EXCLUDED FROM THIS RECORD. The children who died on 19 April 1993 were killed in a confrontation with federal agents — an outsider-directed event that this corpus does not treat as authority-abuse, and that is not evidence for or against the abuse allegations. Conflating the two misrepresents both, and this record does not relitigate the federal action. (5) ON THE 'PRETEXT' ARGUMENT: it has genuine and specific force. ATF holds no child-welfare jurisdiction, its warrant concerned firearms offences, and its affidavit included the abuse allegations while OMITTING that the child-welfare case had already closed — the Treasury Department's own September 1993 review conceded the allegations were included to show Koresh had 'set up a world of his own', that is, as atmosphere rather than as evidence of the charged offences. But the allegations did not originate with the federal government: they predate the raid, coming from former members in 1990 and 1992. Both propositions can hold at once — the allegations may be substantially true AND their inclusion in a firearms warrant improper. (6) NOT ASSERTED for want of primary verification: claims about DNA-confirmed paternity and the precise number of children fathered; the exact terms in which the FBI presented ongoing abuse to the Attorney General before the 19 April assault; and any characterisation of the Danforth Report's treatment of the abuse question, that report's scope having concerned government conduct rather than the truth of the allegations. Kiri Jewell is named because she testified publicly under her own name before Congress and has spoken publicly since.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1993-david-koresh-house-of-david-mount-carmel-texas-usa",
"year": 1993,
"place": "Mount Carmel, Axtell, Texas, USA",
"lat": 31.5993,
"lng": -96.9861,
"title": "United States: Koresh's 'House of David' doctrine — sworn testimony, three investigations, and no prosecution",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-adventist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"David Koresh, leader of the Branch Davidians at Mount Carmel, teaching that he alone was entitled to father children with the group's women and girls"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the 'House of David' or 'New Light' doctrine, drawn from his reading of the Song of Solomon, under which he claimed the exclusive right to 'give the seed'",
"apocalyptic conditioning of children, including instruction in methods of suicide",
"physical punishment of children, and weapons training"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Branch Davidians, Mount Carmel Center"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Texas Department of Protective and Regulatory Services (1992); United States Congress, joint House committees (1995)",
"stage": "child-welfare investigation closed for insufficient evidence; sworn congressional testimony; NO PROSECUTION EVER BROUGHT",
"date": "1992-04-30",
"outcome": "Texas child-welfare investigators visited Mount Carmel three times in early 1992, interviewing adults and physically examining about twelve children, and closed the case on 30 April 1992 for insufficient evidence — ten months before the federal raid. The lead caseworker, Joyce Sparks, later stated that the county sheriff had told her that what happened inside the compound was none of her business, and that Koresh appeared to learn of her briefings almost immediately; the sheriff disputes curbing the investigation. On 19 July 1995, testifying under oath before joint House committees, Kiri Jewell stated that Koresh had sexual contact with her at the age of ten in 1991, that he taught children methods of suicide, and that a friend of hers had married him and borne a child at fourteen. Former members had earlier given affidavits, via a 1990 private investigation, alleging statutory rape of two teenage girls; county and state police took no action. No charge, indictment or conviction for any sexual offence was ever brought against Koresh, who died in the fire of 19 April 1993."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "On the criterion, the in-group conduct fits squarely: the claimed entitlement was doctrinal, not merely personal — Koresh taught that scripture reserved to him alone the right to father the community's children, which is spiritual authority operating as the instrument of sexual access to girls inside the group.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.spokesman.com/stories/1995/jul/20/girl-leaves-lawmakers-speechless-koresh-victim/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Spokesman-Review, 20 Jul. 1995: coverage of Kiri Jewell's sworn testimony before the joint House committees.",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of the sworn first-person testimony.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sworn-testimony-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wacotrib.com/news/branch_davidians/sheriff-says-he-did-not-curb-probe/article_e73e68e1-7de9-5c2a-9d30-bc711e0bb4cd.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Waco Tribune-Herald: 'Sheriff says he did not curb probe'.",
"body": "Local paper of record on the 1992 child-welfare investigation, its closure, the caseworker's interference allegation and the sheriff's denial.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.policinginstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/DOT-Report-ATF-Investigation-of-David-Koresh_Sept-1993.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "US Department of the Treasury, Report of the Department of the Treasury on the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms Investigation of Vernon Wayne Howell, also known as David Koresh (September 1993).",
"body": "The government's own review, including its account of why the abuse allegations appeared in the ATF affidavit.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "government-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.newsweek.com/children-cult-193582",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newsweek, 'Children of the Cult': Dr Bruce Perry's clinical findings on the children released during the siege.",
"body": "Clinical findings on the released children, including the absence of a gynaecological examination.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "clinical-findings-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.spokesman.com/stories/1995/jul/20/girl-leaves-lawmakers-speechless-koresh-victim/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sworn-testimony-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eaedbc85f831b9be9e4c30d0704c5fc234fbcb7d99a905f0643e60ea737578e3",
"final_url": "https://www.spokesman.com/stories/1995/jul/20/girl-leaves-lawmakers-speechless-koresh-victim/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wacotrib.com/news/branch_davidians/sheriff-says-he-did-not-curb-probe/article_e73e68e1-7de9-5c2a-9d30-bc711e0bb4cd.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.policinginstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/DOT-Report-ATF-Investigation-of-David-Koresh_Sept-1993.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: government-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-large",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.newsweek.com/children-cult-193582",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: clinical-findings-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f466e0aec9dcfec018de8006fac94ff5b48ec6f3f32fc8c07224a80198bb4a33",
"final_url": "https://www.newsweek.com/children-cult-193582"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 691,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting NON-prosecutions, not convictions — and entered precisely because the absence of prosecution is the finding. Individuals are recorded under the Ryan Report's own pseudonyms per the Commission's convention. ONE CASE REQUIRES A DISTINCTION: the 1944 Upton matter concerned peer abuse between boys, not staff perpetration, and is included here for the State's decision-making pattern rather than as an adult-on-child case. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories, the working route to the Ryan Report.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1954-kilkenny-upton-non-prosecution-pattern-ireland",
"year": 1954,
"place": "Kilkenny and Upton, Ireland",
"lat": 52.6541,
"lng": -7.2448,
"title": "Ireland: the cases that were never prosecuted — clergy lobbying and the State's decisions not to charge",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"a parish priest who persuaded the Department not to prosecute",
"a Resident Manager who lobbied the State Solicitor against prosecution",
"the religious congregations running the institutions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"reputational protection of convents and institutions advanced as a reason not to charge",
"the quiet dismissal of an abuser in place of prosecution",
"children's status as institutional residents leaving them without an independent advocate"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Kilkenny",
"St Patrick's Kilkenny",
"Upton"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 2 chs. 2, 13 and 14",
"stage": "official findings on decisions not to prosecute",
"date": "1954-08-01",
"outcome": "The Commission documented a pattern in which prosecutions were averted after clerical intervention. At St Joseph's Kilkenny, a lay worker of thirty years' service sexually abused at least four girls in the summer of 1953; the abuse was discovered in August 1954, and the parish priest persuaded the Department not to prosecute, citing reputational harm to the convent and the trauma of child witnesses. The man was quietly dismissed and never charged. At Upton in 1944, after a former resident named other boys to the Gardaí, three were charged; the Resident Manager lobbied the State Solicitor against prosecution on the grounds that the boys were now upright citizens, and the Attorney General dropped the case — the Commission recording that the Manager's motive was to avoid adverse publicity. Of St Patrick's Kilkenny, where sexual-abuse allegations against lay workers spanned 1943 to 1965, the Sisters of Charity's own submission to the Commission stated plainly: 'No-one was convicted of abuse at St Patrick's.'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children held in religious-run institutions, whose access to the criminal law ran through the very clergy the law might have been used against — the authority that made the harm possible also decided whether it would ever be answered for.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-14-56",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report of the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report), Vol. 2 ch. 14 paras 56-79 (St Joseph's Kilkenny), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's record of the parish priest's intervention and the decision not to prosecute.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-232",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 2 paras 232-240 (Upton), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's record of the Resident Manager's lobbying and the Attorney General's decision to drop the case.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-13-74",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 13 para 74 (St Patrick's Kilkenny), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The congregation's own submission that no one was ever convicted of abuse at the institution.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-14-56",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d93534439d77ccfac57ade27a2099ed9a00f0cfc17e986e48a38455744372b40",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-14-56"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-232",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fbb7bbd1173c42f8862553877d089a89bb12b56c26375d1774341df300700658",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-232"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-13-74",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fcd984d4237f81a2ee8d5f3dcedaf165151b6abdcc97601414ccf3d8b4c4c5ee",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-13-74"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 692,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual recorded under the Ryan Report's own pseudonym per the Commission's convention and this corpus's settled policy. Court name and precise sentence length were not stated in the Commission's text and are not asserted. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories, the working route to the Ryan Report.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-br-dax-letterfrack-christian-brothers-ireland",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Letterfrack, Galway, Ireland",
"lat": 53.5464,
"lng": -9.9486,
"title": "Ireland: Br Dax convicted of sexually abusing boys at Letterfrack industrial school",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"a Christian Brother on the staff of Letterfrack industrial school, with custodial and disciplinary authority over resident boys"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-order custody of boys with no contact outside the institution",
"assignment of a favoured victim to kitchen work, isolating him for repeated abuse",
"a documented climate in which boys could not report to any Brother without fear of punishment for 'telling lies'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Brothers, Letterfrack"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — criminal prosecution (court not stated in the Commission's text) with findings by the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 1 Ch. 8",
"stage": "guilty plea and conviction",
"date": "2003-01-01",
"outcome": "Br Dax, who worked at Letterfrack over two periods between the late 1950s and mid-1970s, pleaded guilty to sample charges of indecent assault and buggery of boys and was sentenced to a term of imprisonment. He admitted committing sexual offences against 25 former pupils; four of the complainants also gave evidence to the Investigation Committee, including a boy he selected to work alone with him in the kitchen. The Congregation's final submission stated that the conviction of Br Dax 'spoke for itself.' He remained a member of the Congregation after conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A boy in the sole custody of the Christian Brothers, singled out for kitchen work by the man who abused him there, with no channel to report that a Brother would credit over a Brother's word.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-132",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report of the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report), Vol. 1 Ch. 8 (Letterfrack), paras 132-134 and 266-267 and 335 and 351-372, via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's record of Br Dax's conviction and the extent of the abuse admitted.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-132",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c064dea3b18c842b82e1f6ea85fa41b44498df092936a81008dfd204f937a1b7",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-132"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 693,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual recorded under the Ryan Report's own pseudonym per the Commission's convention and this corpus's settled policy. Court name was not stated in the Commission's text and is not asserted. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-br-anatole-letterfrack-christian-brothers-ireland",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Letterfrack, Galway, Ireland",
"lat": 53.5464,
"lng": -9.9486,
"title": "Ireland: Br Anatole convicted of indecently assaulting boys at Letterfrack industrial school",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"a Christian Brother on the staff of Letterfrack industrial school, with custodial and disciplinary authority over resident boys"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-order custody of boys with no independent advocate",
"the boys' inability to report abuse without risking punishment for 'telling lies'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Brothers, Letterfrack"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — criminal prosecution (court not stated in the Commission's text) with findings by the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 1 Ch. 8",
"stage": "guilty plea and conviction",
"date": "2002-01-01",
"outcome": "Br Anatole, who worked at Letterfrack during the late 1960s and early 1970s and left the Congregation under a dispensation from his vows in the early 1980s, pleaded guilty to sample counts of indecent assault against three named boys and received a suspended sentence. None of the three complainants gave evidence to the Investigation Committee; the Christian Brothers disputed aspects of Br Anatole's own account of his time at Letterfrack, but the conviction itself was not contested."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys in the sole custody of the Christian Brothers, without a channel to report abuse that would be believed over a Brother's denial.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-156",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report of the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report), Vol. 1 Ch. 8 (Letterfrack), paras 156, 180, 267, 413, 419, 431, via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's record of Br Anatole's conviction and suspended sentence.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-conviction-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-156",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-conviction-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5b5f9bfbb94b6837e0978eb18ab09be3f6c36038afe98ad36ead3cc1645d77f0",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-8-156"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 694,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting a NON-prosecution, not a conviction — entered because the absence of prosecution is itself the finding, following the same policy already applied to the 1954 Kilkenny/Upton record in this corpus. Individuals are recorded under the Ryan Report's own pseudonyms per the Commission's convention. Tralee (Vol. 1, Ch. 9) was walked in full (all 462 paragraphs); no criminal conviction of any staff member is recorded anywhere in the chapter, which is itself the notable finding given the documented twenty-year pattern. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1953-tralee-br-garon-non-prosecution-ireland",
"year": 1953,
"place": "Tralee, Kerry, Ireland",
"lat": 52.2718,
"lng": -9.7024,
"title": "Ireland: Tralee's known abuser was never reported to the Gardaí — a twenty-year non-prosecution pattern",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"a Christian Brother in charge of communal showers at Tralee industrial school",
"three successive Resident Managers who were told and did nothing",
"the Christian Brothers Congregation, which never referred the matter to the Gardaí"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a junior Brother's complaints absorbed and buried by three successive Superiors rather than escalated",
"boys' inability to report a Brother's conduct without fear of being disbelieved and punished",
"the institutional monopoly on which adult supervised communal showering, with no independent oversight"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Brothers, Tralee (St Joseph's)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 1 Ch. 9 (Tralee)",
"stage": "official finding on a documented non-prosecution",
"date": "1953-01-01",
"outcome": "The Commission found that a Brother recorded under the pseudonym Garon operated a 'bizarre ritual of bathing boys and being bathed personally by them' in the shower rooms at Tralee for a period the Report describes as twenty years. A junior Brother, recorded as Lisle, repeatedly reported Garon's conduct to three successive Resident Managers; the Commission found that Garon's behaviour 'went on for many years, and was known to three Superiors, but they did nothing about it,' and that nothing was ever recorded of these complaints in the surviving discovery material. No Garda referral, charge or prosecution of Br Garon is recorded anywhere in the chapter. The Commission separately documented a second Brother, recorded as Marceau, against whom a complainant described sustained fondling in the classroom over a period of time; no prosecution of Marceau is recorded either. The Christian Brothers' own submission stated there was no reference in any surviving correspondence, annals or Visitation Report to boys being sexually abused by Brothers or staff at Tralee — a claim the Commission's own findings on Garon and Marceau directly contradict."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys in the sole custody of Christian Brothers who chose, across three changes of leadership, to keep a known abuser's conduct inside the Congregation rather than report it to the police — the authority that made the harm possible also decided it would never be answered for in court.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-9-260",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report of the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report), Vol. 1 Ch. 9 (Tralee), paras 260-291 (Br Garon) and 399, via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's finding that Garon's conduct was known to three Superiors over many years and never acted upon.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-9-292",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 Ch. 9 (Tralee), paras 292-295 (Br Marceau), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's record of a second unprosecuted case of sustained sexual contact.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-9-260",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e06edeea634f930d9e266b24c93f86d75ad3a1ea005b39bae89c31c221b061b6",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-9-260"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-9-292",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0e37c15d6b153b7c94716eff438162e99fd2592df295a1b718257755bb2629ec",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-9-292"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 695,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Romanian from PressOne's investigative reporting (which broke the diocese's internal handling) and corroborated by monitorulcj.ro, TVR, spotmedia.ro, ziare.com and g4media.ro coverage of the conviction and later conditional release. The exact 2024 sentencing date was not pinned to a single day across sources; the four-year sentence and finality are consistent across all outlets consulted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-augustin-benchea-cleja-iasi-romania",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Cleja, Bacău County, Romania",
"lat": 46.5192,
"lng": 26.7667,
"title": "Romania: Catholic priest convicted of raping a 13-year-old parishioner after diocese handled it canonically for two years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Augustin Benchea, Roman Catholic parish priest (paroh) of Cleja commune, Diocese of Iași"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his standing as the girl's parish priest and the family's trust in that office",
"the diocese's choice to resolve the matter through internal canonical sanction rather than reporting to police, which delayed any external check on him for roughly two years after the bishop learned of the abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Iași"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Judecătoria Vaslui (Vaslui District Court), Romania",
"stage": "conviction, final",
"outcome": "Augustin Benchea was convicted of the sexual abuse of a 13-year-old girl from his parish and sentenced to four years' imprisonment with execution. Bishop Iosif Păuleț of Iași had learned of the abuse in May 2022 but did not report it to police or prosecutors, instead applying canonical sanctions (removal as paroh of Cleja, a three-year bar on parish leadership and on unsupervised pastoral contact with minors) validated by the Vatican; Romanian state authorities intervened roughly two years after the bishop's knowledge, following press reporting. The bishop later publicly acknowledged 'errors in managing the case' while maintaining he acted in good faith, and announced Benchea would be laicized on release. As of mid-2026 Benchea was granted conditional release from the Vaslui sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a minor parishioner in Benchea's own parish; his access and the two-year delay before any external authority intervened both ran through the Church's own internal handling of one of its priests, which is the institutional-obedience mechanism the criterion targets.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://pressone.ro/abuz-in-sutana-preotul-condamnat-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-nu-va-mai-putea-sluji-dupa-eliberare-episcopul-iosif-paulet-admite-erori-in-gestionarea-cazului",
"archive": "",
"citation": "PressOne, 'Abuz în sutană: Preotul condamnat pentru agresiune sexuală nu va mai putea sluji după eliberare' (in Romanian).",
"body": "Confirms conviction, four-year sentence, the bishop's May 2022 knowledge, the canonical-only handling, and the bishop's public admission of error.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.monitorulcj.ro/nationale/134681-abuz-sexual-asupra-unei-minore-de-13-ani-in-biserica-catolica-din-romania-statul-roman-a-intervenit-la-doi-ani-dupa-ce-abuzul-se-consumase-iar-cazul-a-fost-tinut-ascuns-de-vatican",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Monitorul de Cluj, 'Abuz sexual asupra unei minore de 13 ani în Biserica Catolică din România' (in Romanian).",
"body": "Corroborates the two-year gap between diocesan knowledge and state intervention and the Vatican's canonical sanction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.radioiasi.ro/stiri/prim-plan/vaslui-fostul-preot-romano-catolic-inchis-pentru-abuz-sexual-asupra-unei-minore-eliberat-conditionat/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Iași, 'Vaslui: Fostul preot romano-catolic, închis pentru abuz sexual asupra unei minore, eliberat condiționat' (in Romanian).",
"body": "Confirms conditional release from the Vaslui sentence and re-states the underlying conviction.",
"tier": "local-news",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://pressone.ro/abuz-in-sutana-preotul-condamnat-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-nu-va-mai-putea-sluji-dupa-eliberare-episcopul-iosif-paulet-admite-erori-in-gestionarea-cazului",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9541b6f7a44fc41d2c78b8333ef4b248741c31ac534db4ddf4dfc9fc46bfc2aa",
"final_url": "https://pressone.ro/abuz-in-sutana-preotul-condamnat-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-nu-va-mai-putea-sluji-dupa-eliberare-episcopul-iosif-paulet-admite-erori-in-gestionarea-cazului"
},
{
"source": "https://www.monitorulcj.ro/nationale/134681-abuz-sexual-asupra-unei-minore-de-13-ani-in-biserica-catolica-din-romania-statul-roman-a-intervenit-la-doi-ani-dupa-ce-abuzul-se-consumase-iar-cazul-a-fost-tinut-ascuns-de-vatican",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "64a7f82b9c823e3ef484112417f305c8d1abd0ad56ec714e144f25bb36326505",
"final_url": "https://www.monitorulcj.ro/nationale/134681-abuz-sexual-asupra-unei-minore-de-13-ani-in-biserica-catolica-din-romania-statul-roman-a-intervenit-la-doi-ani-dupa-ce-abuzul-se-consumase-iar-cazul-a-fost-tinut-ascuns-de-vatican"
},
{
"source": "https://www.radioiasi.ro/stiri/prim-plan/vaslui-fostul-preot-romano-catolic-inchis-pentru-abuz-sexual-asupra-unei-minore-eliberat-conditionat/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-news; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b97b8c9f73b48a9a8475614558d520c9a8736d3f0d8dd1ac0e30241730ce9e89",
"final_url": "https://www.radioiasi.ro/stiri/prim-plan/vaslui-fostul-preot-romano-catolic-inchis-pentru-abuz-sexual-asupra-unei-minore-eliberat-conditionat/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 696,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Άρειος Πάγος (Greek Supreme Court)",
"stage": "prior acquittal vacated, case remanded",
"date": "unspecified, prior to 2025",
"outcome": "Overturned an initial acquittal and returned the case for retrial, which produced the conviction recorded above."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Greek from EPIRUS Online, Cretatimes, Protothema, Newsbomb, Cyprus Times, Zougla, SKAI and CNN.gr regional/national coverage of the Ioannina appellate court verdict. Outlets vary in whether they attribute the abuse's start age as seven; SKAI and Cyprus Times state seven years old, seven-year duration. The name Stefano Verlekis appears in a subset of the outlets consulted; his village is given consistently as Tetrakomo, Arta.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-stefano-verlekis-tetrakomo-arta-greece",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Tetrakomo, Arta, Greece",
"lat": 39.135,
"lng": 20.985,
"title": "Greece: village priest convicted of raping a girl from age seven over seven years, sentence confirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Stefano Verlekis, Greek Orthodox parish priest in the village of Tetrakomo, Arta region"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"exploitation of the victim's family's financial vulnerability, using food deliveries to the home as a pretext for access",
"his status as the village's parish priest, using both the family home and a seasonally-operating village church as sites of the abuse",
"isolation of the child from protective adults over the multi-year period"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Greek Orthodox Church, parish of Tetrakomo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Jury Court of Appeals of Ioannina, Greece",
"stage": "conviction affirmed on appeal, following a prior acquittal overturned by the Greek Supreme Court (Άρειος Πάγος)",
"outcome": "Verlekis, 72 at the time of the final verdict, was unanimously convicted of the rape and sexual abuse of a minor and sentenced to nine years' imprisonment. Because of his age the court ordered the sentence served under home confinement rather than in prison. The abuse ran from 2008 to 2015, beginning when the victim was seven; it came to light in 2015 when the victim's uncle, then a minor himself, reported it. An initial trial resulted in acquittal, which the Supreme Court overturned, leading to the retrial and conviction roughly a decade after the report."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The perpetrator's standing as the village's Orthodox priest gave him routine, trusted access to the family home and to a village church used as one of the assault locations; the victim was a child of the parish, not a stranger, and his clerical role over an eight-year span is what made repeated access possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://cretatimes.gr/arta-iereas-katadikastike-se-ennea-chronia-fylakisis-gia-viasmo-kai-apoplanisi-anilikou/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cretatimes, 'Άρτα: Ιερέας καταδικάστηκε σε εννέα χρόνια φυλάκισης για βιασμό και αποπλάνηση ανηλίκου' (in Greek).",
"body": "Reports the nine-year sentence, the Mixed Jury Court of Appeals of Ioannina, and the home-confinement order due to age.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.skai.gr/news/greece/iereas-viaze-gia-7-xronia-ena-koritsaki-katadikastike-se-9-xronia-katheirksi",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SKAI, 'Ιερέας βίαζε για 7 χρόνια ένα κοριτσάκι - Καταδικάστηκε σε 9 χρόνια κάθειρξη' (in Greek).",
"body": "National broadcaster's report giving the seven-year duration starting at age seven and the nine-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1624459/iereas-katadikastike-gia-viasmo-anilikis-se-horio-tis-artas-tin-kakopoiise-mehri-kai-se-kleisti-ekklisia/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Protothema, 'Ιερέας καταδικάστηκε για βιασμό ανήλικης σε χωριό της Άρτας: Την κακοποίησε και μέσα σε εκκλησία' (in Greek).",
"body": "Confirms the church itself as one of the abuse locations and the village setting.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Άρειος Πάγος (Greek Supreme Court)",
"stage": "prior acquittal vacated, case remanded",
"date": "unspecified, prior to 2025",
"outcome": "Overturned an initial acquittal and returned the case for retrial, which produced the conviction recorded above."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://cretatimes.gr/arta-iereas-katadikastike-se-ennea-chronia-fylakisis-gia-viasmo-kai-apoplanisi-anilikou/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a0ed5b9954cec3d9f9e125f377c23aaf1c74019f00c03dabf74339ea12c105b8",
"final_url": "https://cretatimes.gr/arta-iereas-katadikastike-se-ennea-chronia-fylakisis-gia-viasmo-kai-apoplanisi-anilikou/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.skai.gr/news/greece/iereas-viaze-gia-7-xronia-ena-koritsaki-katadikastike-se-9-xronia-katheirksi",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "007250b1fc6b56e5d215d34a4984d5bb402030d7a1f9b7d11da79d9bde2d726f",
"final_url": "https://www.skai.gr/news/greece/iereas-viaze-gia-7-xronia-ena-koritsaki-katadikastike-se-9-xronia-katheirksi"
},
{
"source": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1624459/iereas-katadikastike-gia-viasmo-anilikis-se-horio-tis-artas-tin-kakopoiise-mehri-kai-se-kleisti-ekklisia/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1120ddee75405323e604d1eabb760ee61022d73f247b3300e15ae71e4cd31686",
"final_url": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1624459/iereas-katadikastike-gia-viasmo-anilikis-se-horio-tis-artas-tin-kakopoiise-mehri-kai-se-kleisti-ekklisia/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 697,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in French from Senegalese outlets Sunu Jotaay, Seneweb (French and English versions), Leral.net and Senego, all reporting on the same gendarmerie investigation out of Keur Massar. Seck is described consistently as a 'faux marabout' (fake marabout) in the reporting — that framing describes his lack of genuine standing in the eyes of these outlets, not a claim that the abuse occurred outside a spiritual-authority relationship: victims approached him precisely because they believed his claimed powers were real, which is what the record turns on. No trial date or verdict was located as of this research pass; entered at charged/referred-to-prosecution tier accordingly, not as a conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-p-s-seck-darou-thioub-senegal",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Darou Thioub, Keur Massar, Senegal",
"lat": 14.7833,
"lng": -17.3167,
"title": "Senegal: fake marabout referred to prosecution for filming and blackmailing rapes committed under pretext of djinn-consultation and curse-removal",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"P. S. Seck, self-presented marabout (traditional Islamic healer/mystic) operating from a rented room in Darou Thioub, Keur Massar"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed ability to consult djinns and to identify and remove curses (maraboutage) afflicting women in personal crisis",
"'mystical baths' and rituals offered as the ostensible treatment, used to obtain access and compliance",
"covert filming of the assaults by an accomplice, then implicit threat of exposure through the resulting recordings, which the plan's own taxonomy notes as an aggravating instrument of coercion beyond the original spiritual pretext"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Gendarmerie investigation, referred to the Prosecutor of the Pikine-Guédiawaye Court, Senegal",
"stage": "referred to prosecution (charges: rape, charlatanism/'charlatanisme', unlawful distribution of personal data)",
"date": "2025-10-20",
"outcome": "P. S. Seck, a mason from Linguère posing as a marabout, and an accomplice Y. Sagna were referred to the Pikine-Guédiawaye prosecutor on 20 October 2025 following a gendarmerie investigation. Investigators recovered more than 75 obscene videos and photographs from Seck documenting assaults on women who had come to him believing themselves cursed or seeking mystical treatment for marital and health crises. One documented victim, a restaurant owner, consulted Seck in August 2024 during a marital crisis after a neighbor recommended him; he told her he needed to consult his djinns before he could help her. Of the women identifiable from the recordings, only two agreed to testify in the proceeding. As of the sources consulted, no trial verdict is yet reported; the matter stood at the referral-to-prosecution stage."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Every documented victim came to Seck specifically because she believed she was under a curse or otherwise in spiritual crisis and sought his claimed mystical power to resolve it; the sexual assault occurred within, and was concealed by, the ritual consultation itself, which is the direct authority-as-instrument mechanism the criterion requires.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://sunujotaay.com/darou-thioub-un-faux-marabout-viole-et-filme-ses-victimes/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sunu Jotaay, 'Darou Thioub : Un faux marabout viole et filme ses victimes' (in French).",
"body": "Most detailed account: identifies P.S. Seck by initials, his profession as mason, the djinn/mystical-bath pretext, the 75+ recordings, and the referral to the Pikine-Guédiawaye prosecutor on 20 Oct. 2025.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.seneweb.com/en/news/Faits-Divers/darou-thioub-un-faux-marabout-viole-et-filme-ses-victimes-75-videos-et-photos-decouvertes_n_471704.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Seneweb (English edition), 'Darou Thioub: A fake marabout rapes and films his victims, 75 obscene videos and photos discovered'.",
"body": "English-language corroboration of the video count and the referral to prosecution.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.leral.net/Keur-Massar-Un-faux-marabout-filme-et-viole-ses-victimes-a-Darou-Thioub-75-videos-decouvertes_a390007.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Leral.net, 'Keur Massar : Un faux marabout filme et viole ses victimes à Darou Thioub, 75 vidéos découvertes' (in French).",
"body": "Independent corroboration of location, video count and case facts.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "P. S. Seck, a mason from Linguère posing as a marabout, and an accomplice Y. Sagna were referred to the Pikine-Guédiawaye prosecutor on 20 October 2025 following a gendarmerie investigation. Investigators recovered more than 75 obscene videos and photographs from Seck documenting assaults on women who had come to him believing themselves cursed or seeking mystical treatment for marital and health crises. One documented victim, a restaurant owner, consulted Seck in August 2024 during a marital crisis after a neighbor recommended him; he told her he needed to consult his djinns before he could help her. Of the women identifiable from the recordings, only two agreed to testify in the proceeding. As of the sources consulted, no trial verdict is yet reported; the matter stood at the referral-to-prosecution stage.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://sunujotaay.com/darou-thioub-un-faux-marabout-viole-et-filme-ses-victimes/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24b91e9bef21b002b5ec44d6cfd74e53c03f0f240eaa03fdca7a17f5b1e2530e",
"final_url": "https://sunujotaay.com/darou-thioub-un-faux-marabout-viole-et-filme-ses-victimes/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.seneweb.com/en/news/Faits-Divers/darou-thioub-un-faux-marabout-viole-et-filme-ses-victimes-75-videos-et-photos-decouvertes_n_471704.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0b683203220f6f4d60971be0a33343dd6a6bb80c8931ecaa1e88974f13afd701",
"final_url": "https://www.seneweb.com/en/news/Faits-Divers/darou-thioub-un-faux-marabout-viole-et-filme-ses-victimes-75-videos-et-photos-decouvertes_n_471704.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.leral.net/Keur-Massar-Un-faux-marabout-filme-et-viole-ses-victimes-a-Darou-Thioub-75-videos-decouvertes_a390007.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "57073653f13bf90d7c81a28e165e75a85f22ded6c5f12135c7d47293143d596a",
"final_url": "https://www.leral.net/Keur-Massar-Un-faux-marabout-filme-et-viole-ses-victimes-a-Darou-Thioub-75-videos-decouvertes_a390007.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 698,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in French from FratMat, Nasuba Infos, Pouvoirs-Magazine, Levisonnaire, APR-News and Xibaaru (Senegalese outlet covering the Ivorian case), all reporting the same 15 October 2024 Abidjan-Plateau hearing. First record for Côte d'Ivoire in this corpus. Entered at charged/pre-trial tier: sources consulted describe pre-trial detention, the initial hearing and an adjournment for witness testimony, but no verdict; if a verdict is later confirmed this record should be upgraded and the outcome field revised. Karamoko's full name/surname was not given in any outlet consulted — he is named only as 'Karamoko', which functions in West African usage both as a personal/family name and as an honorific for a Quranic teacher, so some caution is warranted about whether this is a proper name or a title being used descriptively; the sources treat it as his name.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-karamoko-abidjan-plateau-cote-divoire",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Abidjan-Plateau, Côte d'Ivoire",
"lat": 5.3097,
"lng": -4.0161,
"title": "Côte d'Ivoire: marabout held in custody and tried for sexually harassing a client after demanding sex to complete a curse-removal ritual",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Karamoko, marabout consulted by clients for spiritual/traditional treatment in Abidjan"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed foreknowledge of impending misfortune, used to induce the client to pay for and submit to a ritual",
"assertion that sexual relations with him were a necessary condition for the ritual's success",
"threats, after she refused, to curse her and 'ruin her life' by invoking bad spirits against her — i.e. weaponizing the same claimed spiritual power as retaliation for non-compliance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal d'Abidjan-Plateau, Côte d'Ivoire",
"stage": "pre-trial detention and hearing; case adjourned for witness testimony",
"date": "2024-10-15",
"outcome": "A young woman identified in reporting as Sali brought a complaint against her marabout, known as Karamoko, before the Abidjan-Plateau court on 15 October 2024, accusing him of sexual and moral harassment. She testified that after paying 15,000 CFA francs for a ritual to avert misfortune he had warned her of, he told her sexual relations with him were necessary to guarantee the ritual's success; when she refused, he threatened to curse her. Karamoko, held in custody since 8 October 2024, denied the accusations, claiming she had consulted him for abdominal pain and that he had prepared a traditional remedy. After hearing both parties, the judge adjourned the case to 18 October 2024 for witness testimony. No verdict was located in the sources reviewed for this research pass."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant's own account is that she sought Karamoko out specifically for his claimed power to identify and avert a coming misfortune; the demand for sex was framed as integral to the ritual's efficacy, and the retaliatory threat on refusal (a curse) is the same claimed spiritual power turned coercive — squarely the authority-as-instrument mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fratmat.info/article/1857641/societe/harcelement-sexuel-une-cliente-et-son-marabout-devant-les-tribunaux-dabidjan",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fraternité Matin (FratMat), 'Harcèlement sexuel : Une cliente et son marabout devant les tribunaux d'Abidjan' (in French).",
"body": "Ivorian paper of record; reports the 15 Oct. 2024 hearing, the curse/ritual pretext, and the adjournment for witness testimony.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.nasuba.info/sport-culture/cote-divoire-une-jeune-fille-traine-son-marabout-devant-le-tribunal/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nasuba Infos, 'Côte d'Ivoire : Une jeune fille traîne son marabout devant le tribunal' (in French).",
"body": "Corroborates the complainant's account, the 15,000 CFA franc payment, and Karamoko's custody since 8 Oct. 2024.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://pouvoirs-magazine.com/2024/10/16/elle-traduit-son-marabout-en-justice/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Pouvoirs-Magazine, 'Elle traduit son marabout en justice' (in French).",
"body": "Independent corroboration of the case facts and hearing date.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A young woman identified in reporting as Sali brought a complaint against her marabout, known as Karamoko, before the Abidjan-Plateau court on 15 October 2024, accusing him of sexual and moral harassment. She testified that after paying 15,000 CFA francs for a ritual to avert misfortune he had warned her of, he told her sexual relations with him were necessary to guarantee the ritual's success; when she refused, he threatened to curse her. Karamoko, held in custody since 8 October 2024, denied the accusations, claiming she had consulted him for abdominal pain and that he had prepared a traditional remedy. After hearing both parties, the judge adjourned the case to 18 October 2024 for witness testimony. No verdict was located in the sources reviewed for this research pass.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fratmat.info/article/1857641/societe/harcelement-sexuel-une-cliente-et-son-marabout-devant-les-tribunaux-dabidjan",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "95af149cc8eb9217236633d5ea085c730d929d660e81633ff157b819bceec81f",
"final_url": "https://www.fratmat.info/article/1857641/societe/harcelement-sexuel-une-cliente-et-son-marabout-devant-les-tribunaux-dabidjan"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nasuba.info/sport-culture/cote-divoire-une-jeune-fille-traine-son-marabout-devant-le-tribunal/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "baa06e5cdb89936bb096e1ad714baeb1af8f566e7f0b6638e68437e4880c56b7",
"final_url": "https://www.nasuba.info/sport-culture/cote-divoire-une-jeune-fille-traine-son-marabout-devant-le-tribunal/"
},
{
"source": "https://pouvoirs-magazine.com/2024/10/16/elle-traduit-son-marabout-en-justice/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "103b37507c38f3075ff8fe551356915bc2cd7b12c2bef673d888d77e508c6f1e",
"final_url": "https://pouvoirs-magazine.com/2024/10/16/elle-traduit-son-marabout-en-justice/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 699,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Punjab and Haryana High Court",
"outcome": "No successful appeal of the rape/intimidation conviction has been reported; it remains the operative basis for his continued imprisonment. (Separate murder convictions arising from retaliation against people who exposed the rapes — of Dera manager Ranjit Singh, and of journalist Ram Chander Chhatrapati — were later overturned on appeal in 2024 and 2026 respectively; those cases concerned killing of whistleblowers, not abuse of disciples under his authority, and are not the basis of this record.)"
}
],
"scopeNote": "Scoped deliberately to the rape/intimidation conviction, which directly fits the criterion. Two SEPARATE murder convictions exist (of a Dera manager suspected of leaking the 2002 letter, and of a journalist who published the allegations) — both were reversed on appeal as of 2024 and 2026 and are EXCLUDED from this record because they concern retaliation against people who exposed the abuse, not abuse of a disciple under his spiritual authority. The August 2017 riots following the verdict, which killed at least 31 people, were an outsider-directed law-and-order event and are also excluded.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-gurmeet-ram-rahim-dera-sacha-sauda-sirsa-india",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Sirsa, Haryana, India (trial: Panchkula, Haryana)",
"lat": 29.5344,
"lng": 75.0281,
"title": "India: Dera Sacha Sauda chief convicted of raping two disciples inside the sect he headed",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "convicted",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh, self-styled spiritual head ('Pitaji') of the Dera Sacha Sauda sect, with tens of millions of followers across Haryana and Punjab, exercising direct authority over women (\"sadhvis\") who lived and served inside the Dera under his religious direction"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his standing as the Dera's sole spiritual authority, framed to female disciples as a form of devotional service and initiation owed to the guru",
"control over disciples' residence, daily routine and access to the Dera's institutional life, which the CBI's investigation found he used to isolate and threaten the women he abused",
"criminal intimidation of the victims to secure their silence, the second charge on which he was separately convicted"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Dera Sacha Sauda"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special CBI Court, Panchkula, Haryana (Judge Jagdeep Singh)",
"stage": "convicted at trial; sentence stands, unreversed, as of July 2026",
"date": "2017-08-25",
"outcome": "Convicted on two counts of rape (IPC 376) and criminal intimidation (IPC 506) of two former sadhvis (female disciples) whom he had sexually abused inside the Dera between 1999 and 2001, after a CBI investigation triggered by an anonymous 2002 letter from Dera members. Sentenced 28 August 2017 to 10 years' rigorous imprisonment on each rape count, to run consecutively (20 years total), plus a fine. The verdict triggered rioting by his followers across Haryana and Punjab that killed at least 31 people; that violence is not part of this record. He remains in custody on this conviction as of July 2026; it has not been overturned on appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "He held sole, unaccountable spiritual authority over his own initiated female disciples living and serving inside the Dera; the CBI investigation and the trial court both found that authority was the means by which he obtained access to and silenced the two women he was convicted of raping.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.livelaw.in/15-long-years-dera-chief-ram-rahim-gets-10-years-jail-raping-sadhavi",
"archive": "",
"citation": "LiveLaw, 28 Aug. 2017: sentencing report.",
"body": "Reports the 20-year consecutive sentence on the two rape counts.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gurmeet_Ram_Rahim_Singh",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia: 'Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh'.",
"body": "Consolidated timeline of the CBI investigation, the 25 August 2017 conviction, and the separate, later-reversed murder convictions.",
"tier": "reference-work",
"kind": "biographical-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.businesstoday.in/india/story/gurmeet-ram-rahim-4-others-acquitted-in-dera-manager-murder-case-431136-2024-05-28",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Business Today, 28 May 2024.",
"body": "Confirms the Ranjit Singh murder conviction was separately reversed on appeal — cited to show the rape conviction stands apart from and independent of that reversal.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-ruling-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Punjab and Haryana High Court",
"outcome": "No successful appeal of the rape/intimidation conviction has been reported; it remains the operative basis for his continued imprisonment. (Separate murder convictions arising from retaliation against people who exposed the rapes — of Dera manager Ranjit Singh, and of journalist Ram Chander Chhatrapati — were later overturned on appeal in 2024 and 2026 respectively; those cases concerned killing of whistleblowers, not abuse of disciples under his authority, and are not the basis of this record.)"
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.livelaw.in/15-long-years-dera-chief-ram-rahim-gets-10-years-jail-raping-sadhavi",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f66d0f8ef6c664e06b2af47d41c382a29ca427a845e954dca99a03d0aedb9089",
"final_url": "https://www.livelaw.in/15-long-years-dera-chief-ram-rahim-gets-10-years-jail-raping-sadhavi"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gurmeet_Ram_Rahim_Singh",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-work; evidentiary role: biographical-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0eeebaf758b01982f240ca004e92e09451954723bd81c7ab4daf7926eb54c930",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gurmeet_Ram_Rahim_Singh"
},
{
"source": "https://www.businesstoday.in/india/story/gurmeet-ram-rahim-4-others-acquitted-in-dera-manager-murder-case-431136-2024-05-28",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-ruling-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "77f745e467b8438bf7d82fd3863faaa139aee1458b73d3ba5aa06b107de5679d",
"final_url": "https://www.businesstoday.in/india/story/gurmeet-ram-rahim-4-others-acquitted-in-dera-manager-murder-case-431136-2024-05-28"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 700,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Karnataka High Court; Supreme Court of India",
"date": "2018-05-16",
"outcome": "Both courts dismissed Nithyananda's petitions to quash the rape prosecution, clearing the way for the trial court to frame charges."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Entered at CHARGED tier, not conviction — there is none. The prosecution has cleared every appellate hurdle up to the Supreme Court and a trial court has formally framed charges after an in-camera evidentiary process began, which is why this is coded as an official court proceeding rather than a bare allegation; but no trial verdict exists, and the accused has been an absconding fugitive since November 2019, which has prevented the case from concluding. The 2019 children's-confinement complaint is noted as contextual corroboration of the same closed-community control pattern, not as a separately adjudicated charge — it has not been confirmed to have proceeded to a chargesheet in the sources reviewed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-nithyananda-dhyanapeetam-bidadi-india",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Bidadi, Ramanagara district, Karnataka, India",
"lat": 12.7997,
"lng": 77.3878,
"title": "India: godman Nithyananda formally charged with raping a disciple inside his ashram; now a fugitive",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-guru-ashram",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Swami Nithyananda (Nithyananda Paramashivam), founder and head of the Nithyananda Dhyanapeetam ashram, claiming guru status over resident and visiting disciples"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his position as the ashram's founding guru, exercised over a woman who lived within the ashram as his disciple for roughly five years, during which the charged abuse allegedly occurred",
"control over the ashram as a closed residential community, later the basis of a separate 2019 complaint that his ashram wrongfully confined two children of a follower"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Nithyananda Dhyanapeetam"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Third Additional District and Sessions Court, Ramanagara, Karnataka",
"stage": "charges formally framed after his challenges were dismissed by the Karnataka High Court and the Supreme Court of India; in-camera trial underway; NO VERDICT",
"date": "2018-06-04",
"outcome": "A female disciple's 2010 complaint (Indian Penal Code ss. 376, 377, 420, 114, 201, 120-B) alleged Nithyananda sexually abused her over about five years inside the ashram. After his petitions to quash the case were dismissed by the Karnataka High Court (16 May 2018) and the Supreme Court of India (1 June 2018), the trial court formally framed criminal charges on 4 June 2018 and an in-camera trial began, with witness testimony still being recorded as of the most recent reporting. In November 2019 Gujarat police separately filed a wrongful-confinement/kidnapping complaint after a follower alleged the ashram was holding his children against their will; days later, on 20 November 2019, Nithyananda left India. A non-bailable warrant was issued by the Ramanagara trial court in August 2022 after his continued non-appearance, and Interpol issued a Blue Notice in January 2020 to help locate him. No conviction has been recorded in any of these proceedings; he remains a fugitive as of the most recent reporting."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a disciple resident in his ashram under his claimed guru authority for years; the criminal complaint and the charges the trial court formally framed allege that authority was the means of sustained sexual access to her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/rape-case-against-nithyananda-trial-finally-begins-after-8-years-legal-hurdles-86233",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The News Minute: 'Rape case against Nithyananda: Trial finally begins after 8 years of legal hurdles'.",
"body": "Confirms the 2010 complaint, the 2018 exhaustion of appeals, and the start of the in-camera trial.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-proceeding-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/karnataka-trial-court-frames-charges-against-nithyananda-rape-case-82595",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The News Minute: 'Karnataka trial court frames charges against Nithyananda in rape case'.",
"body": "Confirms the 4 June 2018 framing of charges by the Ramanagara trial court.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-order-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.nationalheraldindia.com/india/interpol-issues-blue-notice-to-locate-nithyananda-wanted-in-rape-abduction-case-may-be-hiding-in-caribbean",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Herald: 'Interpol issues Blue Notice to locate Nithyananda, wanted in rape, abduction case'.",
"body": "Confirms the Interpol Blue Notice and his fugitive status.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "law-enforcement-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-booked-in-kidnapping-case-by-gujarat-police-swami-nithyananda-flees-country-ashram-raided-2802730",
"archive": "",
"citation": "DNA India: report on the November 2019 Gujarat kidnapping complaint and his flight from India.",
"body": "Confirms the separate children's-confinement complaint and the timing of his departure from India.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Karnataka High Court; Supreme Court of India",
"date": "2018-05-16",
"outcome": "Both courts dismissed Nithyananda's petitions to quash the rape prosecution, clearing the way for the trial court to frame charges."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A female disciple's 2010 complaint (Indian Penal Code ss. 376, 377, 420, 114, 201, 120-B) alleged Nithyananda sexually abused her over about five years inside the ashram. After his petitions to quash the case were dismissed by the Karnataka High Court (16 May 2018) and the Supreme Court of India (1 June 2018), the trial court formally framed criminal charges on 4 June 2018 and an in-camera trial began, with witness testimony still being recorded as of the most recent reporting. In November 2019 Gujarat police separately filed a wrongful-confinement/kidnapping complaint after a follower alleged the ashram was holding his children against their will; days later, on 20 November 2019, Nithyananda left India. A non-bailable warrant was issued by the Ramanagara trial court in August 2022 after his continued non-appearance, and Interpol issued a Blue Notice in January 2020 to help locate him. No conviction has been recorded in any of these proceedings; he remains a fugitive as of the most recent reporting.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/rape-case-against-nithyananda-trial-finally-begins-after-8-years-legal-hurdles-86233",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-proceeding-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a10a664ebd8e96e968c10b15e726c9374567585f9c14b7a0a59fa8eb0b47f901",
"final_url": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/rape-case-against-nithyananda-trial-finally-begins-after-8-years-legal-hurdles-86233"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/karnataka-trial-court-frames-charges-against-nithyananda-rape-case-82595",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-order-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0700c2e663a117d20b0413be3ad2f1062d149a81136c549168366005591e82ad",
"final_url": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/karnataka-trial-court-frames-charges-against-nithyananda-rape-case-82595"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nationalheraldindia.com/india/interpol-issues-blue-notice-to-locate-nithyananda-wanted-in-rape-abduction-case-may-be-hiding-in-caribbean",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: law-enforcement-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3cfdbd178f15f36fab65d641fd83edafb2691ae10e7888c52f036317b644f54e",
"final_url": "https://www.nationalheraldindia.com/india/interpol-issues-blue-notice-to-locate-nithyananda-wanted-in-rape-abduction-case-may-be-hiding-in-caribbean"
},
{
"source": "https://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-booked-in-kidnapping-case-by-gujarat-police-swami-nithyananda-flees-country-ashram-raided-2802730",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d84109faa8502c44943392932902e5ce476a950e1dd5fc685148c3022d6921a1",
"final_url": "https://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-booked-in-kidnapping-case-by-gujarat-police-swami-nithyananda-flees-country-ashram-raided-2802730"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 701,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New York Appellate Division",
"outcome": "Conviction affirmed; sentence reduced from 103 to 50 years."
}
],
"scopeNote": "He was not an ordained rabbi but an unlicensed 'therapist' whose authority was communal and religious in character — families were directed to him by the community's own informal counseling structure rather than by any secular credential, which is the basis for including him under the criterion.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-nechemya-weberman-satmar-williamsburg-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Williamsburg, Brooklyn, New York, USA",
"lat": 40.7081,
"lng": -73.9571,
"title": "USA: unlicensed Satmar 'religious therapist' convicted of sexually abusing a girl sent to him for religious counseling",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "convicted",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Nechemya Weberman, an unlicensed counselor operating within the Satmar Hasidic community of Williamsburg, Brooklyn, to whom families sent children for religious/moral guidance at the direction of communal and rabbinic figures"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his position as a community-sanctioned religious counselor, to whom the victim was sent at age twelve specifically for guidance framed as necessary to her standing within the community",
"the closed, self-policing structure of the Satmar community, in which the case became a flashpoint over communal pressure on the victim's family not to go to secular police"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Satmar Hasidic community, Williamsburg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New York State Supreme Court, Kings County (Justice John Ingram)",
"stage": "convicted at jury trial; sentence stands",
"date": "2012-12-10",
"outcome": "Convicted by a jury on 59 counts, including sustained sexual conduct against a child, criminal sexual act, sexual abuse, and endangering the welfare of a child. The complainant testified she was sent to Weberman at age twelve for religious counseling after a school disciplinary matter, and that the abuse continued until she was fifteen. Sentenced 22 January 2013 to 103 years' imprisonment; the sentence was later reduced to 50 years on appeal, but the conviction itself was not disturbed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Weberman's role as a religious counselor operating with the sanction of the community's rabbinic authority structure was the specific channel through which the victim's family placed her under his direction, and the position he used to isolate and abuse her over three years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2012/12/10/united-states/nechemya-weberman-convicted-on-59-counts-of-sexual-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 10 Dec. 2012: verdict report.",
"body": "Reports the 59-count jury conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2013/01/22/justice/new-york-brooklyn-sexual-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN, 22 Jan. 2013: sentencing report.",
"body": "Reports the original 103-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://gothamist.com/news/hasidic-sex-abuser-nechemya-weberman-sentenced-to-103-years-in-prison",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Gothamist: sentencing coverage, including the victim's account of being sent to Weberman at age twelve for religious counseling.",
"body": "Establishes the religious-counseling nexus through which the victim was placed under his authority.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New York Appellate Division",
"outcome": "Conviction affirmed; sentence reduced from 103 to 50 years."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2012/12/10/united-states/nechemya-weberman-convicted-on-59-counts-of-sexual-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b528290020011a7b2e3dab19edbc59b3808fe8e15eded7e87c2b2edfd3212a47",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2012/12/10/united-states/nechemya-weberman-convicted-on-59-counts-of-sexual-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2013/01/22/justice/new-york-brooklyn-sexual-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "625560f52d56e04be858dc426e18e1b01ae9373f391fa959ed57c2c4f63d68e4",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2013/01/22/justice/new-york-brooklyn-sexual-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://gothamist.com/news/hasidic-sex-abuser-nechemya-weberman-sentenced-to-103-years-in-prison",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c26451a2265a6ea591be8eddcd8f8bd533822ecd87abe4a7a70cf04782e8317c",
"final_url": "https://gothamist.com/news/hasidic-sex-abuser-nechemya-weberman-sentenced-to-103-years-in-prison"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 702,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "READ BEFORE CITING. The criminal prosecution ended WITHOUT a trial on the merits: one charge was stayed for Charter delay, the other two withdrawn by the Crown for insufficient prospect of conviction — this is not a finding of innocence, but it is emphatically not a conviction either, and the record is coded at official-finding tier resting on the church's own commissioned third-party investigation, not on the criminal process. Multiple civil suits remain pending separately and are not the basis of this record. The 2024 disclosure of 38 total misconduct reports involving four pastors is noted as context establishing an institutional pattern, not as evidence against Cavey individually beyond the specific investigation findings concerning him.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-bruxy-cavey-meeting-house-ontario-canada",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Oakville and Hamilton, Ontario, Canada",
"lat": 43.4675,
"lng": -79.6877,
"title": "Canada: teaching pastor of an Ontario megachurch found by an independent investigation to have abused a congregant; criminal charges later stayed and withdrawn without trial",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-mennonite-anabaptist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Bruxy Cavey, founding teaching pastor of The Meeting House, a multi-site evangelical/Anabaptist megachurch based in Oakville, Ontario, with authority over the congregation's spiritual life and pastoral counseling"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his standing as the church's principal teaching pastor and public face, which the independent investigation found he used to initiate and sustain a years-long sexual relationship with a congregant that the investigators characterized as abuse of his position of spiritual authority",
"the closed, insider culture of a single-leader-centered megachurch, which the church's own later disclosures said had allowed a pattern extending to at least four pastors and 38 reports of misconduct"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"The Meeting House"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent investigation commissioned by The Meeting House board (Postma Consulting/Under Construction); Hamilton Police Service; Ontario Court of Justice",
"stage": "internal investigation upheld the abuse finding; separate criminal prosecution ended WITHOUT TRIAL — one charge judicially stayed for delay, two withdrawn by the Crown",
"date": "2022-03-03",
"outcome": "Cavey was placed on leave in December 2021 after allegations surfaced of a 'sexualized relationship' with a congregant. A third-party investigation commissioned by the church board concluded he had engaged in a years-long pattern of sexual abuse of a church member, characterizing it as an abuse of his position of spiritual authority; he resigned 3 March 2022. The church later disclosed two further credible abuse claims (one involving an accuser who was a minor at the time) and, by 2024, a total of 38 reports of sexual misconduct involving four different pastors at the church. Separately, Hamilton Police charged Cavey with sexual assault on 31 May 2022, and with two further counts of sexual assault in December 2023. On 22 July 2024, Ontario Court Justice Michael K. Wendl stayed the first charge on Charter grounds (unreasonable pre-trial delay); the Crown withdrew the remaining two charges shortly after, citing no reasonable prospect of conviction. No criminal trial on the merits occurred and no conviction resulted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The independent investigation the church itself commissioned found that Cavey's position as the congregation's founding teaching pastor — its central spiritual authority — was what he used to initiate and sustain the abusive relationship with a member under his pastoral care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://religionnews.com/2022/06/07/bruxy-cavey-disgraced-canadian-pastor-charged-with-sexual-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Religion News Service, 7 Jun. 2022: charge report, including the investigation's findings that preceded it.",
"body": "Establishes both the independent investigation's abuse finding and the initial criminal charge.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-and-charge-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/bruxy-cavey-charges-withdrawn-hamilton-court-1.7313318",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News: 'Final 2 sexual assault charges against ex-pastor of Ontario megachurch withdrawn by Crown'.",
"body": "Confirms the withdrawal of the remaining charges without trial.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/bruxy-cavey-meeting-house-2022-sex-assault-charge-stayed-1.7271208",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News: '1 of 3 sexual assault charges against ex-pastor of Ontario megachurch has been dismissed'.",
"body": "Confirms the Charter-delay stay of the first charge.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-ruling-report"
},
{
"link": "https://ministrywatch.com/canadian-megachurch-discloses-38-reports-of-sexual-misconduct-by-4-pastors/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "MinistryWatch: 'Canadian Megachurch Discloses 38 Reports of Sexual Misconduct by 4 Pastors'.",
"body": "Institutional-pattern context on the church's later broader disclosure.",
"tier": "trade-religious-press",
"kind": "institutional-disclosure-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://religionnews.com/2022/06/07/bruxy-cavey-disgraced-canadian-pastor-charged-with-sexual-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-and-charge-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "316a836d16cd3cf1140f990e4327321d443bffe60ace5258b329d227ba44a1b5",
"final_url": "https://religionnews.com/2022/06/07/bruxy-cavey-disgraced-canadian-pastor-charged-with-sexual-assault/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/bruxy-cavey-charges-withdrawn-hamilton-court-1.7313318",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/bruxy-cavey-meeting-house-2022-sex-assault-charge-stayed-1.7271208",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-ruling-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://ministrywatch.com/canadian-megachurch-discloses-38-reports-of-sexual-misconduct-by-4-pastors/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: trade-religious-press; evidentiary role: institutional-disclosure-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "49b8cf726bbcb25b098fcccc2366408ce7853efec94f6ee862146e63eed9c3f3",
"final_url": "https://ministrywatch.com/canadian-megachurch-discloses-38-reports-of-sexual-misconduct-by-4-pastors/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 703,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Washington, Division Two",
"date": "2003-02-07",
"outcome": "Affirmed the trial court's suppression of Glenn's statement to a church elder on clergy/penitent-privilege grounds, on the State's interlocutory appeal (115 Wash. App. 540, 62 P.3d 921); did not disturb the prosecution itself."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The published appellate opinion is an interlocutory ruling on a clergy-privilege suppression question, not the merits opinion; the underlying guilty plea and sentence are sourced to contemporaneous press coverage (Poynter/AP wire, Seattle Times) rather than to a sentencing transcript. Exact prison term as ultimately imposed was not independently confirmed beyond the plea-deal ceiling reported at the time.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-herman-glenn-church-for-all-nations-tacoma-washington-usa",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Tacoma, Washington, USA",
"lat": 47.2529,
"lng": -122.4443,
"title": "United States: Youth pastor's guilty plea to child rape of boys in his congregation, Church For All Nations",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Herman Glenn, Jr., youth pastor at Church For All Nations, Tacoma"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"grooming of boys under his youth-ministry authority through an invented game in which Glenn claimed to have an alternate persona that could only be 'purged' through sex acts",
"clergy/penitent-privileged disclosure to a church elder, later litigated on interlocutory appeal"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Church For All Nations, Tacoma"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court, Pierce County, Washington",
"stage": "guilty plea",
"outcome": "Glenn, a youth pastor charged with six counts of third-degree rape, one count of second-degree rape and one count of child molestation involving boys affiliated with his church, pleaded guilty to three counts of third-degree child rape under a deal exposing him to a longer-than-standard sentence (reported as up to nine years), required registration as a sex offender, and three years' community supervision on release. An interlocutory appeal by the State over suppression of Glenn's confession to a church elder — held protected by clergy/penitent privilege — was resolved in Glenn's favor and is reported at State v. Glenn, 115 Wash.App. 540, 62 P.3d 921 (Wash. Ct. App. 2003), affirming the trial court's suppression order without disturbing the prosecution."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Glenn was the boys' youth pastor at the church their families attended; his authority over them as their spiritual mentor was the channel through which the grooming game — an invented spiritual/alter-ego framing requiring 'purging' through sex acts — operated.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2621464/state-v-glenn/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Glenn, 115 Wash. App. 540, 62 P.3d 921 (Wash. Ct. App. 2003).",
"body": "Published Washington Court of Appeals opinion identifying Glenn as 'a youth pastor' charged with child molestation and child rape, and resolving the clergy-privilege suppression question.",
"tier": "appellate-court-opinion",
"kind": "court-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.poynter.org/reporting-editing/2003/former-youth-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-child-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Poynter, 'Former youth pastor pleads guilty to child rape' (2003).",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of the guilty plea to three counts of third-degree child rape and the plea-deal sentencing exposure.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Washington, Division Two",
"date": "2003-02-07",
"outcome": "Affirmed the trial court's suppression of Glenn's statement to a church elder on clergy/penitent-privilege grounds, on the State's interlocutory appeal (115 Wash. App. 540, 62 P.3d 921); did not disturb the prosecution itself."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2621464/state-v-glenn/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court-opinion; evidentiary role: court-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2621464/state-v-glenn/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.poynter.org/reporting-editing/2003/former-youth-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-child-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b6ac2559ecbc68aeac93e27fbe289a54ba8f4f4aadff9219a32ecf72f7114d71",
"final_url": "https://www.poynter.org/reporting-editing/2003/former-youth-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-child-rape/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 704,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Ohio, Fifth Appellate District (Richland County)",
"date": "2011-12-23",
"outcome": "State v. Picard, 2011-Ohio-6781: five of forty-two sexual-battery counts (all involving one victim) reversed for insufficient evidence and remanded for resentencing; 37 counts affirmed."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Ohio, Fifth Appellate District (Richland County)",
"date": "2014-08-05",
"outcome": "State v. Picard, 2014-Ohio-2924: on remand the trial court reimposed the same 40-year aggregate sentence; the Fifth District affirmed, rejecting Picard's arguments that the sentence should have been reduced. Further post-conviction appeals followed (2015-Ohio-431; 2017-Ohio-7600)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "37 of the original 42 sexual-battery counts stood after the partial reversal; the 40-year aggregate sentence was reimposed on remand and affirmed again on the following appeal. Contact with at least one victim (H.G.) continued after she turned 18, but the relationship and its grooming began while she was still a minor in his youth ministry, and the church's own 2005 internal inquiry is documented as having initially discounted the complaint before Picard resigned and formed a splinter group with 'the family' before the criminal investigation proceeded.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-john-picard-marion-avenue-grace-brethren-mansfield-ohio-usa",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Mansfield, Ohio, USA",
"lat": 40.7584,
"lng": -82.5154,
"title": "United States: Youth pastor's scripture-based grooming of church girls, convictions and 40-year sentence affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"John S. Picard, youth pastor, Marion Avenue Grace Brethren Church, Mansfield, Ohio, from 1990"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"scripture invoked to frame sexual contact as sanctioned or obligatory — citing Jonathan and David as a model for 'best friends' engaging sexually, and John's proximity to Jesus at the Last Supper, and telling one victim it would be 'a sin for her to refuse because God was protecting their relationship'",
"reframing of his own pastoral burnout as a need victims were spiritually obligated to meet ('being a youth pastor was difficult...this was a form of comfort his wife could not give him'; giving him oral sex was one victim's 'God-given role as his comforter')",
"deliberate isolation of victims from their families and friends into a closed in-group he called 'the family', controlling where they lived, whom they dated or married, and what they purchased",
"use of babysitting access to his own children as the grooming pathway into each relationship",
"when a first accusation reached a council of pastors in 2005, the congregation voted to retain him despite members describing the group as his 'harem'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"institutional-obedience",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Marion Avenue Grace Brethren Church, Mansfield, Ohio"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Richland County Court of Common Pleas, Ohio",
"stage": "jury trial",
"date": "2010-06-01",
"outcome": "Following a six-day jury trial, Picard was convicted on charges of sexual battery involving multiple girls he met through his role as youth pastor, several as minors and continuing after they turned 18; the trial court found the abuse was sustained through 'control and mental and spiritual coercion' and imposed an aggregate 40-year sentence with five years of mandatory post-release control."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Picard held pastoral authority over his victims as the youth minister of the church their families attended; the record is unusual for how explicitly the coercion was doctrinal rather than merely relational — he cited specific scripture to each victim to frame sex as sanctioned, obligatory, or protected by God, and the sentencing court expressly named his 'position of trust' and 'high calling in the church' as the instrument of the harm.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2699768/state-v-picard/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Picard, 2011-Ohio-6781 (Ohio Ct. App., 5th Dist., Richland Cnty.).",
"body": "Original direct appeal opinion.",
"tier": "appellate-court-opinion",
"kind": "court-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2698099/state-v-picard/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Picard, 2014-Ohio-2924 (Ohio Ct. App., 5th Dist., Richland Cnty.).",
"body": "Appeal following resentencing; affirms the reimposed 40-year aggregate sentence.",
"tier": "appellate-court-opinion",
"kind": "court-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.akronlegalnews.com/editorial/10713",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Akron Legal News, 'Youth pastor who molested his congregation warrants 40-year sentence' (5 Aug. 2014).",
"body": "Detailed case summary drawn from the appellate record, including the scripture-based grooming language quoted from trial testimony and the sentencing court's remarks.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Ohio, Fifth Appellate District (Richland County)",
"date": "2011-12-23",
"outcome": "State v. Picard, 2011-Ohio-6781: five of forty-two sexual-battery counts (all involving one victim) reversed for insufficient evidence and remanded for resentencing; 37 counts affirmed."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Ohio, Fifth Appellate District (Richland County)",
"date": "2014-08-05",
"outcome": "State v. Picard, 2014-Ohio-2924: on remand the trial court reimposed the same 40-year aggregate sentence; the Fifth District affirmed, rejecting Picard's arguments that the sentence should have been reduced. Further post-conviction appeals followed (2015-Ohio-431; 2017-Ohio-7600)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2699768/state-v-picard/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court-opinion; evidentiary role: court-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2699768/state-v-picard/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2698099/state-v-picard/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court-opinion; evidentiary role: court-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2698099/state-v-picard/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.akronlegalnews.com/editorial/10713",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "01936e0f92478864a8937c0f82809d4b6073d49caf8d6f36db6449b48d9c913d",
"final_url": "https://www.akronlegalnews.com/editorial/10713"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 705,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Texas, Houston (1st Dist.)",
"date": "2003-06-19",
"outcome": "111 S.W.3d 680: reversed the trial court's judgment against Chon Tri and Theravada Buddhist Corp."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Texas",
"date": "2005-05-13",
"outcome": "162 S.W.3d 552: reversed the court of appeals and reinstated the trial court's judgment, resting affirmance on a negligence theory rather than the jury's civil-conspiracy finding."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Khuat's California criminal proceeding (court, county and exact sentence) is not independently detailed in the Texas civil record and was not separately verified in this pass — the conviction itself is stated by both Texas appellate courts as an adjudicated fact underlying the civil suit, not merely alleged. The Texas Supreme Court's ultimate holding affirmed liability on NEGLIGENCE, not the jury's conspiracy finding; Phap Luan Buddhist Culture Center and its monk Ho Giac's individual liability were treated differently in the litigation and this record does not assert findings against them beyond the trial court's original damage apportionment, which the civil-conspiracy reversal put in question. Cite the negligence holding, not conspiracy, when characterizing the controlling law.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-dung-huu-khuat-theravada-buddhist-temple-pomona-california-usa",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Pomona, California, USA",
"lat": 34.0551,
"lng": -117.75,
"title": "United States: Buddhist monk's rape conviction and the temple's civil liability for enabling access to victims",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Dung Huu Khuat, Buddhist monk at a Theravada Buddhist Corporation temple, Pomona, California",
"Chon Tri (a/k/a Hien Dinh Nguyen), monk and officer of Theravada Buddhist Corporation, found civilly liable for negligence enabling the assaults"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic authority over two sisters who were guests/devotees at the temple, used to obtain access and compliance",
"the temple corporation's own negligence in supervising Khuat's access to the victims, the basis on which the Texas Supreme Court ultimately affirmed civil liability"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Theravada Buddhist Corporation (Pomona, California temple)",
"Phap Luan Buddhist Culture Center, Houston, Texas (named defendant, found not liable)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California (criminal, court and county not further specified in the Texas civil record); Texas civil courts (164th District Court, Harris County; Court of Appeals, Houston 1st District; Supreme Court of Texas)",
"stage": "criminal conviction (California) and civil judgment (Texas)",
"date": "2005-05-13",
"outcome": "Khuat was convicted in California of rape and other sexual assaults of the two sisters at the Pomona temple. The sisters separately sued Khuat, the Theravada Buddhist Corporation, Chon Tri, Ho Giac and the Phap Luan Buddhist Culture Center in Texas; a jury found Khuat, Chon Tri, Giac and Theravada Buddhist Corporation part of a civil conspiracy, and the trial court apportioned damages 85% to Khuat, 10% to Theravada Buddhist Corp., and 5% to Ho Giac. The Supreme Court of Texas (162 S.W.3d 552, 13 May 2005) reversed the court of appeals and reinstated the trial court's judgment, resting affirmance on a negligence theory — the corporation liable for its agent Chon Tri's negligence — rather than the jury's conspiracy finding."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were guests/devotees at the temple under the monks' religious authority; Khuat's status as a monk at the institution was the access mechanism for the assaults, and the surviving civil theory turns on the temple corporation's negligent failure to supervise a monk with that authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/894665/tri-v-jtt/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Chon Tri v. J.T.T., 162 S.W.3d 552 (Tex. 2005).",
"body": "Controlling Texas Supreme Court opinion; states Khuat's California conviction as an adjudicated predicate fact and resolves the corporation's civil liability on negligence grounds.",
"tier": "appellate-court-opinion",
"kind": "court-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1758992/jtt-and-mt-v-chon-tri/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "J.T.T. and M.T. v. Chon Tri, 111 S.W.3d 680 (Tex. App.-Houston [1st Dist.] 2003).",
"body": "Intermediate appellate opinion, reversed by the Texas Supreme Court.",
"tier": "appellate-court-opinion",
"kind": "court-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Texas, Houston (1st Dist.)",
"date": "2003-06-19",
"outcome": "111 S.W.3d 680: reversed the trial court's judgment against Chon Tri and Theravada Buddhist Corp."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Texas",
"date": "2005-05-13",
"outcome": "162 S.W.3d 552: reversed the court of appeals and reinstated the trial court's judgment, resting affirmance on a negligence theory rather than the jury's civil-conspiracy finding."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/894665/tri-v-jtt/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court-opinion; evidentiary role: court-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/894665/tri-v-jtt/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1758992/jtt-and-mt-v-chon-tri/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court-opinion; evidentiary role: court-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/1758992/jtt-and-mt-v-chon-tri/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 706,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nunavut Court of Appeal",
"date": "2018-11-27",
"outcome": "Dismissed Dejaeger's appeal against his 2015 Igloolik conviction and 19-year sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Entered as a single record spanning all three proceedings (1990, 2015, 2025) because they concern the same perpetrator, the same two parish communities, and the same underlying period of offending (1978-1989), following how this corpus treats other perpetrators convicted across multiple hearings. Dejaeger's 1995 flight to Belgium and 2011 deportation are noted only as chronological facts in the proceedings history and are NOT characterized as a trafficking route, per this project's standing rule that a perpetrator's own movement to evade justice is not trafficking. Sentence figures for the 1990 and 2015 proceedings vary slightly across outlets (parole/time-served adjustments are reported inconsistently); the base sentence lengths as originally imposed are used here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-eric-dejaeger-igloolik-baker-lake-nunavut-canada",
"year": 1990,
"place": "Igloolik and Baker Lake, Nunavut, Canada",
"lat": 69.3838,
"lng": -81.7998,
"title": "Canada: Oblate missionary priest convicted across three proceedings (1990, 2015, 2025) of sexually abusing Inuit children in his own parishes",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Eric Dejaeger, Oblate of Mary Immaculate missionary priest, sole or one of the only priests serving the Catholic parishes of Baker Lake (Qamani'tuaq) and Igloolik, Nunavut, 1970s-1989"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sole or primary Catholic clergy presence in small, geographically isolated Inuit hamlets, giving unsupervised access to parish children",
"explicit religious threats used to silence victims — telling children they would go to hell, or that Jesus would not accept them, if they told anyone what he had done",
"exploitation of family trust in the parish priest as a figure of unquestioned moral and spiritual standing in the community",
"flight to Belgium in 1995 after being charged over the Igloolik offences, delaying justice by roughly sixteen years until his 2011 deportation back to Canada"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate",
"Roman Catholic parishes of Baker Lake and Igloolik, Nunavut"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Northwest Territories Supreme Court (Baker Lake offences)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "1989-12-19",
"outcome": "Dejaeger pleaded guilty to eight counts of sexual assault and one count of indecent assault against children in Baker Lake, committed between 1982 and 1989, and was sentenced in early 1990 to five years in prison; he was released in 1991. A year later he was separately sentenced to eight months on two further sexual assault counts."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Nunavut Court of Justice, Iqaluit (Igloolik offences)",
"stage": "conviction after trial and sentencing",
"date": "2015-02-09",
"outcome": "Following his 2011 deportation from Belgium and a trial on charges dating to his time as a priest in Igloolik between 1978 and 1982, Dejaeger was convicted on 32 counts of sexual offences — including indecent assault, sexual assault, unlawful confinement and bestiality — against 23 Inuit victims, and sentenced to 19 years in prison (later reduced with credit for time served); a concurrent sentence was separately imposed the same year for historical sexual offences in Alberta. His appeal against the Igloolik conviction and sentence was dismissed by the Nunavut Court of Appeal in November 2018."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Nunavut Court of Justice, Iqaluit (further Igloolik offences)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-30",
"outcome": "Dejaeger pleaded guilty to seven further counts of indecent assault against seven children in Igloolik, aged four to nine at the time, and was sentenced to six additional years in prison — the third distinct proceeding to convict him of sexually abusing children in the two Nunavut communities where he served as priest."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Dejaeger was the Catholic priest serving his own parishioners' children in two small, remote Inuit hamlets where he was the sole or primary clergy presence; he used explicit religious threats of damnation and rejection by Jesus to keep his victims from telling anyone, turning the same faith that gave him his authority over them into the mechanism that silenced them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/eric-dejaeger-ex-priest-sentenced-to-19-years-for-child-sex-abuse-1.2943720",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Eric Dejaeger, ex-priest, sentenced to 19 years for child sex abuse' (2015).",
"body": "Reports the 2015 Igloolik conviction on 32 counts against 23 victims and the 19-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ppsc-sppc.gc.ca/eng/nws-nvs/2025/30_01_25.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Public Prosecution Service of Canada, news release on the 30 January 2025 sentencing of Eric Dejaeger (2025).",
"body": "Federal prosecutorial authority's own release confirming the 2025 guilty plea to seven counts of indecent assault, the six-year sentence, and his status as 'one of the local priests' in Igloolik 1978-1982.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "official-press-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.aptnnews.ca/national-news/former-priest-pleads-guilty-to-indecent-assaults-of-children-in-nunavut/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "APTN National News, 'Eric Dejaeger pleads guilty to seven counts' (2025).",
"body": "Indigenous-focused national outlet's reporting on the 2025 guilty plea, including how Dejaeger used threats of hell and rejection by Jesus to silence child victims.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://globalnews.ca/news/10988890/nunavut-children-assaults-dejaeger-sentencing/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Global News, 'Former priest sentenced to 6 years for sex abuse of Nunavut children' (2025).",
"body": "Corroborates the third proceeding's sentence and recaps the 1990 Baker Lake and 2015 Igloolik convictions as prior history.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nunavut Court of Appeal",
"date": "2018-11-27",
"outcome": "Dismissed Dejaeger's appeal against his 2015 Igloolik conviction and 19-year sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/eric-dejaeger-ex-priest-sentenced-to-19-years-for-child-sex-abuse-1.2943720",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.ppsc-sppc.gc.ca/eng/nws-nvs/2025/30_01_25.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: official-press-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1ba17c0132f06591e701b57789878ddc13360fbd9504b9d3f5e34522b2cf1783",
"final_url": "https://www.ppsc-sppc.gc.ca/eng/nws-nvs/2025/30_01_25.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.aptnnews.ca/national-news/former-priest-pleads-guilty-to-indecent-assaults-of-children-in-nunavut/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a2a4a9274419b77f5a8282d73731ed68caf31d3ef8b3fa773713e22b45fdad40",
"final_url": "https://www.aptnnews.ca/national-news/former-priest-pleads-guilty-to-indecent-assaults-of-children-in-nunavut/"
},
{
"source": "https://globalnews.ca/news/10988890/nunavut-children-assaults-dejaeger-sentencing/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ca576701f547c7852ccf20217777795214da0de41ac2b752020d7504c0b82c55",
"final_url": "https://globalnews.ca/news/10988890/nunavut-children-assaults-dejaeger-sentencing/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 707,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District",
"outcome": "Jeffrey E. v. Central Baptist Church, 197 Cal.App.3d 718 (1988): affirmed summary judgment FOR the church on the victim's civil claims. The court held Schwobeda's sexual molestation was not foreseeable in light of the duties of a Sunday school teacher or church member, and that his conduct was an independent, self-serving act not undertaken to serve the church — rejecting liability on both negligent-hiring/supervision and respondeat superior theories. The appellate ruling addresses only the church's civil liability and does not disturb Schwobeda's own criminal conviction."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Schwobeda's own CRIMINAL conviction (guilty plea, nine counts, 1985), which is the qualifying event under this corpus's criterion — a Sunday school teacher's authority over a child in his own class. The published appellate opinion is a CIVIL case addressing only whether the church could be held liable for his conduct, and the Court of Appeal ruled it could not; that holding is reported accurately in appellateHistory and should not be read as bearing on the criminal conviction itself, which was never contested on appeal. Resolves the item held from the CourtListener research lane as 'a real, citable case where the underlying facts could not be confirmed' — facts are now confirmed via the full Justia-hosted opinion text and secondary reporting on the criminal case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1985-ernest-schwobeda-central-baptist-church-california-usa",
"year": 1985,
"place": "California, USA",
"lat": 36.7783,
"lng": -119.4179,
"title": "United States: Sunday school teacher's criminal conviction for molesting a boy in his class; church's own civil liability rejected on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Ernest Schwobeda, Sunday school teacher and general member of Central Baptist Church (CBC) from 1964, teaching Sunday school from 1967 and participating in the church's membership-visitation program"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing as a trusted, long-tenured Sunday school teacher and church volunteer, used to obtain access to a child in his own class",
"repeated abuse over time facilitated by the ordinary, unsupervised access a Sunday school teacher had to children entrusted to the church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Central Baptist Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California criminal court (county not further specified in the appellate record)",
"stage": "arrest and guilty plea",
"outcome": "Schwobeda was arrested in 1984 on 47 felony counts of child molestation; he pleaded guilty to the nine counts involving the plaintiff, Jeffrey, and was sentenced to two to twelve years in prison. He was released on probation in 1985 after serving approximately nine months."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child in Schwobeda's own Sunday school class at the church his family attended; his standing as a long-serving, trusted lay teacher of the congregation's children was the access mechanism for the abuse, even though the appellate court ultimately declined to extend liability for it to the church itself.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/197/718.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jeffrey E. v. Central Baptist Church, 197 Cal.App.3d 718 (Cal. Ct. App. 1988).",
"body": "Published California Court of Appeal opinion; states Schwobeda's role as Sunday school teacher and church member since 1964/1967, and the underlying facts of his criminal prosecution and guilty plea as background to the civil claims.",
"tier": "appellate-court-opinion",
"kind": "court-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District",
"outcome": "Jeffrey E. v. Central Baptist Church, 197 Cal.App.3d 718 (1988): affirmed summary judgment FOR the church on the victim's civil claims. The court held Schwobeda's sexual molestation was not foreseeable in light of the duties of a Sunday school teacher or church member, and that his conduct was an independent, self-serving act not undertaken to serve the church — rejecting liability on both negligent-hiring/supervision and respondeat superior theories. The appellate ruling addresses only the church's civil liability and does not disturb Schwobeda's own criminal conviction."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/197/718.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: appellate-court-opinion; evidentiary role: court-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 708,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced from Ephraim Stinchfield's contemporaneous 1819 pamphlet 'Cochranism Delineated' and Gamaliel E. Smith's 1819 trial report, both reproduced in full at olivercowdery.com (a period-document compilation, not a modern paraphrase), cross-checked against Wikipedia's Cochran and Cochranites articles. IMPORTANT COMPLICATION, stated honestly: Massachusetts adultery statute of the period required charging both parties to the offense, so two women in the sect — Eliza Hill and Abigail Clark — were separately indicted alongside Cochran on the underlying adultery/lewdness counts; this record is not about their prosecutions, but about Cochran's own conviction and sentence as the sect's founder and the sole recipient of the severe custodial sentence (four years' hard labor, compared to no comparable sentence reported for Hill or Clark). The victims this record concerns are the sect's women generally, bound by a spiritual-authority doctrine Cochran himself invented and enforced, not Hill or Clark specifically. Full original pamphlet page images were not independently examined beyond the olivercowdery.com transcription; depositions in the trial report are described by contemporaries as too obscene for publication and were not otherwise recovered. If confirmed as the earliest record in the archive, this predates the previous earliest (1906) by 87 years; recordClass is set to 'core' rather than 'historical' so it is picked up by the corpus's auto-derived CORE_START_YEAR constant rather than requiring a manual timeline edit.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1819-jacob-cochran-cochranites-saco-maine-usa",
"year": 1819,
"place": "Saco and York County, Maine (then District of Maine, Massachusetts), USA",
"lat": 43.5009,
"lng": -70.4428,
"title": "United States: Self-proclaimed prophet convicted of adultery and gross lewdness after assigning half his sect's women to himself as 'spiritual wives'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Jacob Cochran, self-proclaimed prophet and founder of the Cochranites, a religious sect active in Saco and surrounding York County, Maine, from around 1817"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"invented doctrine of 'spiritual wifery,' under which Cochran, as the sect's prophet, assigned women to men as spiritual husbands and wives and could reassign them at his own discretion, with about half of the group's women assigned to himself at one point or another",
"dissolution of followers' existing legal marriages framed as required by the doctrine, replacing them with Cochran-assigned pairings",
"oath-bound secrecy enforced by threats that a follower's name would be 'blotted out of the book of life' and that they would suffer eternal damnation for divulging the sect's practices",
"induced trance/prostration states ('lick up the dust at his feet') as part of Cochran's control over recruits"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"religious-marriage-family",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Cochranites"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, sitting at York (District of Maine)",
"stage": "trial, conviction and sentence",
"date": "1819-11-01",
"outcome": "Indicted on multiple counts of adultery and open and gross lewdness arising from the sect's 'spiritual wifery' practice, Cochran was tried at York in May 1819; he fled before the verdict and was recaptured in October 1819 by Rishworth Jordan and John Banks. In November 1819 he was sentenced to eighteen days' solitary confinement followed by four years' hard labor at the state prison in Charlestown, Massachusetts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cochran created the doctrine of spiritual wifery himself, administered it as the sect's sole prophet, and used it to assign roughly half of the group's women to himself as his own spiritual wives with no reported choice on their part; the same invented religious authority that bound his followers to accept his reassignments of their marriages is what gave him access to them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://olivercowdery.com/gathering/JCochran.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ephraim Stinchfield, 'Cochranism Delineated' (1819), and Gamaliel E. Smith's 1819 trial report, reproduced at olivercowdery.com, 'New England Sects: Cochranites, etc.'",
"body": "Contemporaneous pamphlet and trial-report compilation describing the spiritual-wifery doctrine, named indictments (Eliza Hill, Abigail Clark), and the York County trial.",
"tier": "primary-source-pamphlet",
"kind": "primary-document"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacob_Cochran",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia, 'Jacob Cochran.'",
"body": "Synthesizes the spiritual-wifery doctrine, the detail that about half the sect's women were at some point assigned to Cochran himself, and the conviction/four-year sentence.",
"tier": "tertiary-reference",
"kind": "reference-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=55698",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Historical Marker Database, 'Jacob Cochran, 1782-1836.'",
"body": "Corroborates the sentence detail — eighteen days' solitary confinement and four years' hard labor at Charlestown state prison — and the October 1819 recapture after Cochran fled trial.",
"tier": "tertiary-reference",
"kind": "reference-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://olivercowdery.com/gathering/JCochran.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: primary-source-pamphlet; evidentiary role: primary-document.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "928a808025391faa5bbfb113af072f008dcc8c96a183b7b24dfda0a069ed6d15",
"final_url": "http://olivercowdery.com/gathering/JCochran.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacob_Cochran",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: tertiary-reference; evidentiary role: reference-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6e748b14f8a438d1a63c9cc4229854c3df6f004733b142aeb80f01bbd0b566b1",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacob_Cochran"
},
{
"source": "https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=55698",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: tertiary-reference; evidentiary role: reference-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3dc4c29f460a10947eb65454bb8fa59b822d528d89d2333a40880ed603ed59b6",
"final_url": "https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=55698"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 709,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced directly from the trial pamphlet's plaintext on Internet Archive (verdict and damages passage located and read in full; the standard WebFetch tool truncated to an early chunk regardless of query, so the raw text was pulled via curl and the verdict located by direct text search). A CORRECTION to how this case has sometimes been characterized: reading Cockburn's full summing-up, his remarks on the vow of obedience are narrower than a general holding that 'a vow of obedience does not license abuse.' He was specifically addressing the credibility of the DEFENDANTS' witnesses — fellow nuns bound by the same vow of obedience to the Mother Superior — suggesting that vow might make them 'passive instruments' of her version of events and should not entitle her testimony-by-proxy to extra weight on that account. This is still squarely on-point for the criterion (a judge treating vowed obedience to a superior as a control mechanism worth naming and discounting for, in 1869), but it is a narrower and more specific point than a blanket rejection of an 'obedience licenses abuse' defence on the merits, and this record states it that way rather than overclaiming. Harm shape here is confinement, assault and defamation, not sexual abuse — consistent with how this case was already flagged as differing in kind from most of the corpus. If confirmed for ingestion, this becomes the second-earliest record in the archive after the 1819 Cochran record entered in this same pass.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1869-saurin-v-starr-kennedy-hull-england",
"year": 1869,
"place": "Hull, England (tried at the Court of Queen's Bench, London)",
"lat": 53.7676,
"lng": -0.3274,
"title": "England: Mother Superior's authority over a professed nun used to confine, strip and expel her — jury finds for the nun, £500 damages",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Mary Star (Starr), Mother Superioress, Convent of the Sisters of Mercy, Hull",
"Mary Kennedy, a professed Sister of Mercy at the same convent"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the vow of obedience binding a professed nun to 'hear the voice of God in the voice of the superior,' invoked by Cockburn as a mechanism that could make the defendants' own subordinate-nun witnesses passive instruments of the Mother Superior's account rather than free and independent witnesses",
"physical confinement of the plaintiff and deprivation of ordinary care — restriction to a single food (mutton), denial of medical attention, cold confinement and sleep deprivation, as found by the jury on the assault count",
"stripping the plaintiff and taking her personal property (clothes, watch, books, papers)",
"interception of the plaintiff's letters, cutting off contact with her family during her confinement",
"removal of the plaintiff's ring — 'the mystic symbol of her union with Christ' — by the Mother Superior before any actual sentence of expulsion had been passed, an act Cockburn himself described as harsh and cruel",
"formal letters of charges sent to the Bishop of Beverley that the jury found to be libellous and part of a conspiracy to drive the plaintiff from the convent and procure her expulsion from the order"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Sisters of Mercy, Convent of Hull"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Queen's Bench, London, before Lord Chief Justice Cockburn and a special jury",
"stage": "civil trial, jury verdict",
"date": "1869-02-03",
"outcome": "Susan(na) Mary Saurin, a professed Sister of the Order of Mercy, sued her Mother Superioress Mary Star and fellow Sister Mary Kennedy for assault (stripping and imprisonment), trover, conspiracy to drive her from the convent and procure her expulsion, and libel arising from charges sent to the Bishop of Beverley. After a trial running several days and roughly three hours' deliberation, the jury found FOR the plaintiff on the counts for assault (the stripping and imprisonment), libel, and conspiracy, awarding damages of £500 — structured as £300 (the dowry she had paid on entering the order) plus £200, or £500 in full if the dowry was not separately returned. The Baggot-street convent elected to return the £300 dowry, fixing the damages actually paid at £200."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Saurin was a professed nun under a vow of obedience to her Mother Superior, whose authority within the convent was treated by the order's own doctrine as 'the voice of God in the voice of the superior'; the jury found that authority was used to strip her, confine her, deprive her of ordinary care, and conspire with a fellow sister to drive her from the order and defame her to the Bishop — a civil finding, not a criminal one, but one in which the court expressly grappled with whether the vow of obedience itself compromised the independence of witnesses testifying in the Mother Superior's defense.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://archive.org/details/greatconventcase00joseuoft",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Great Convent Case; Saurin v. Star & Kenedy, tried before Lord Chief Justice Cockburn in the Court of Queen's Bench, February 1869 (trial pamphlet, 1869).",
"body": "Full contemporaneous trial pamphlet, containing counsel's speeches and witness evidence in full.",
"tier": "primary-source-pamphlet",
"kind": "primary-document"
},
{
"link": "http://archive.org/stream/greatconventcase00joseuoft/greatconventcase00joseuoft.txt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Plaintext transcription of the same pamphlet, via Internet Archive.",
"body": "Source for the verbatim verdict passage (jury finding for the plaintiff on assault, libel and conspiracy; £500/£200 damages) and Cockburn's summing-up remarks on the vow of obedience, both located and read directly.",
"tier": "primary-source-pamphlet",
"kind": "primary-document"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://archive.org/details/greatconventcase00joseuoft",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: primary-source-pamphlet; evidentiary role: primary-document.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "028678c605b6ce84636418c9c8ff3e6afa5bb7cb6452f259711cf70ba1d99953",
"final_url": "https://archive.org/details/greatconventcase00joseuoft"
},
{
"source": "http://archive.org/stream/greatconventcase00joseuoft/greatconventcase00joseuoft.txt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: primary-source-pamphlet; evidentiary role: primary-document.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "69fcf34139eeeb6e01214cd76897a83ba8e2771722316baa250a02b349efc9d3",
"final_url": "http://archive.org/stream/greatconventcase00joseuoft/greatconventcase00joseuoft.txt"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 710,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Jury Court of Appeals of Agrinio",
"stage": "appeal denied, sentence affirmed in full",
"date": "2025-03-26",
"outcome": "The court unanimously upheld the 27-year sentence and fine without any reduction."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Greek from Protothema's original 2021 investigative report on the 'koinovio' household structure, and from Larissanet, LiFO, CNN.gr and Agriniopress coverage of the July 2022 first-instance sentencing and March 2025 appellate affirmation. Greek outlets consistently withhold the priest's name in this case, unlike in some other clergy-abuse reporting; he is identified only by age, the Agrinio location, and case facts. Do not conflate with the separate, already-catalogued Stefano Verlekis/Tetrakomo/Arta case (ingested in round 1, new-records-83.mjs) — different priest, different village, and Verlekis's name is public where this defendant's is not.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-agrinio-koinovio-priest-greece",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Agrinio, Aetolia-Acarnania, Greece",
"lat": 38.6219,
"lng": 21.4097,
"title": "Greece: priest who ran a quasi-monastic household of three mothers and eight children convicted of raping and abusing minors over years, sentence upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Unnamed Greek Orthodox priest (50 years old at first-instance sentencing), Agrinio, who ran a self-styled 'koinovio' (κοινόβιο, communal/cenobitic household) insisting on being addressed as 'father' rather than by clerical title"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed that the mother of the primary victims and her daughters were afflicted by witchcraft/a curse and that only he could save them, establishing total psychological control over the family",
"operation of a self-styled communal household ('koinovio') of three mothers and eight children (six girls, two boys) under his sole authority, controlling finances, movement and contact with the outside world",
"exploitation of his standing as their priest and head-of-household to abuse two sisters roughly monthly from ages 12 to 14"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"curse-witchcraft",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Greek Orthodox Church, Agrinio"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Jury Court of Agrinio, Greece; affirmed by the Mixed Jury Court of Appeals of Agrinio",
"stage": "conviction, affirmed on appeal without reduction",
"date": "2025-03-26",
"outcome": "The priest was unanimously convicted on all charges — possession of child sexual abuse material, rape, and indecent assault — and sentenced to 27 years' imprisonment without suspension, plus a fine; roughly one year of pre-trial detention was credited. He filed for appeal after the original 18 July 2022 first-instance verdict. On 26 March 2025 the Mixed Jury Court of Appeals of Agrinio upheld the sentence in full, not reducing it by a single day, closing what press coverage called a landmark vindication for the victims. The two sisters who brought the initial complaint said the abuse began in 2007 when they were 12 and 8; one testified to roughly 24 instances of abuse between ages 12 and 14. The complaint was filed in 2021, reportedly prompted by the victims' being inspired by Greek Olympic sailor Sofia Bekatorou's own public sexual-abuse disclosure that year."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims lived inside a household the priest himself created and controlled under his spiritual authority, having convinced their mother that only he could lift a curse afflicting her daughters; that claimed power over the family's spiritual welfare, combined with his role as the sole adult authority of the communal household he ran, is what gave him sustained, unsupervised access to the children for years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1137512/agrinio-suglonizoun-oi-apokalupseis-gia-to-efialtiko-koinovio-tou-ierea-me-parenohlouse-kathe-mina-apo-ta-12-eos-ta-14/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Protothema, 'Αγρίνιο: Συγκλονίζουν οι αποκαλύψεις για το «εφιαλτικό κοινόβιο» του ιερέα' (in Greek).",
"body": "Original investigative account of the koinovio household structure: three mothers, eight children, the witchcraft/curse control mechanism, and the abuse timeline from age 12 to 14.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1265969/se-27-eti-fulakisis-horis-anastoli-katadikastike-50hronos-iereas-sto-agrinio-gia-aselgeia-anilikon/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Protothema, 'Σε 27 έτη φυλάκισης χωρίς αναστολή καταδικάστηκε 50χρονος ιερέας στο Αγρίνιο για ασέλγεια ανηλίκων' (in Greek).",
"body": "Reports the 18 July 2022 first-instance verdict: 27 years without suspension, all charges, priest's age (50).",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.larissanet.gr/2025/03/26/agrinio-oute-mera-den-meiose-to-efeteio-tin-katadiki-tou-ierea-gia-tous-viasmous-se-varos-anilikon/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Larissanet, 'Αγρίνιο: Ούτε μέρα δεν μείωσε το Εφετείο την καταδίκη του ιερέα για τους βιασμούς σε βάρος ανηλίκων' (in Greek).",
"body": "Confirms the 26 March 2025 Mixed Jury Court of Appeals of Agrinio decision affirming the full 27-year sentence unanimously.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Jury Court of Appeals of Agrinio",
"stage": "appeal denied, sentence affirmed in full",
"date": "2025-03-26",
"outcome": "The court unanimously upheld the 27-year sentence and fine without any reduction."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1137512/agrinio-suglonizoun-oi-apokalupseis-gia-to-efialtiko-koinovio-tou-ierea-me-parenohlouse-kathe-mina-apo-ta-12-eos-ta-14/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0386ad74a09a14dc8c1ecd74771dfad408cc04ed20580be5bda957f097fc9fd3",
"final_url": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1137512/agrinio-suglonizoun-oi-apokalupseis-gia-to-efialtiko-koinovio-tou-ierea-me-parenohlouse-kathe-mina-apo-ta-12-eos-ta-14/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1265969/se-27-eti-fulakisis-horis-anastoli-katadikastike-50hronos-iereas-sto-agrinio-gia-aselgeia-anilikon/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "83e242f4fa5fc56c1b66edd97faca06a1237c214dfbbd8d96f85762c89c8608b",
"final_url": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1265969/se-27-eti-fulakisis-horis-anastoli-katadikastike-50hronos-iereas-sto-agrinio-gia-aselgeia-anilikon/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.larissanet.gr/2025/03/26/agrinio-oute-mera-den-meiose-to-efeteio-tin-katadiki-tou-ierea-gia-tous-viasmous-se-varos-anilikon/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "85ba843fac74fa7642242ec195ee7b1a3bf35a1b04c39a33195cb03e0c566e04",
"final_url": "https://www.larissanet.gr/2025/03/26/agrinio-oute-mera-den-meiose-to-efeteio-tin-katadiki-tou-ierea-gia-tous-viasmous-se-varos-anilikon/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 711,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunalul Bihor",
"stage": "appeal against judicial control denied",
"date": "2025",
"outcome": "The Bihor County Tribunal rejected Borbel's challenge to the continued judicial-control measure."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Romanian from ebihoreanul.ro (the principal regional outlet, which followed the case through detention, judicial-control appeal, and referral to trial), corroborated by g4media.ro, alesdonline.ro and bihon.ro. Entered at charged tier, not conviction: all sources consulted report pre-trial proceedings only. If a verdict is later confirmed this record should be upgraded and the outcome field revised.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-valentin-borbel-suncuius-bihor-romania",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Șuncuiuș, Bihor County, Romania",
"lat": 46.9333,
"lng": 22.6167,
"title": "Romania: Orthodox parish priest charged with sexually assaulting a 10-year-old parishioner over two years, suspended and sent to trial",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Valentin Borbel, Romanian Orthodox parish priest (paroh) of Șuncuiuș commune, Bihor County, Diocese of Oradea"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his standing as the girl's parish priest, giving him routine access to the family and child",
"a sustained two-year pattern of abuse beginning when the victim was 10, only reaching investigators in February 2025 after roughly two years"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Romanian Orthodox Diocese of Oradea"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Judecătoria Aleșd, later Tribunalul Bihor, Romania",
"stage": "detained, placed under judicial control, later sent to trial (trimis în judecată)",
"outcome": "Valentin Borbel was detained for 24 hours on continuous sexual assault charges against a minor who was 10 years old when the abuse began in 2023; the abuse continued for roughly two years before coming to the attention of authorities in February 2025. The Oradea Court declined a preventive-arrest request but placed him under 60-day judicial control with a no-contact order covering the victim and witnesses. The investigation, opened at the Aleșd prosecutor's office, was transferred to the Bihor County Tribunal's prosecutor's office. Borbel was subsequently sent to trial and the Tribunal Bihor rejected his appeal against continued judicial control. The Orthodox Diocese of Oradea suspended him from service immediately after the judicial-control ruling; he has since applied for early retirement. As of the sources consulted, no trial verdict is reported; entered at charged/trial-referral tier."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child of Borbel's own parish; his role as the community's Orthodox priest is what gave him sustained, trusted access to her over the two-year period the abuse is alleged to have continued, and the Diocese's own suspension decision treats his clerical office as the operative relationship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/preotul-ortodox-din-suncuius-retinut-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-asupra-unei-minore-judecatoria-oradea-l-a-plasat-sub-control-judiciar-197028.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "eBihoreanul, 'Preotul ortodox din Şuncuiuş, reţinut pentru agresiune sexuală asupra unei minore. Judecătoria Oradea l-a plasat sub control judiciar' (in Romanian).",
"body": "Reports the initial detention, the 60-day judicial control order, and the no-contact conditions.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/fostul-preot-paroh-ortodox-din-suncuius-acuzat-ca-a-agresat-sexual-o-fetita-a-fost-trimis-in-judecata-si-ramane-sub-control-judiciar-198171.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "eBihoreanul, 'Fostul preot paroh ortodox din Şuncuiuş, acuzat că a agresat sexual o fetiţă, a fost trimis în judecată şi rămâne sub control judiciar' (in Romanian).",
"body": "Confirms referral to trial (trimis în judecată) and continued judicial control.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/episcopia-ortodoxa-l-a-suspendat-pe-preotul-din-bihor-acuzat-ca-a-agresat-sexual-o-copila-197040.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "eBihoreanul, 'Episcopia Ortodoxă l-a suspendat pe preotul din Bihor acuzat că a agresat sexual o copilă' (in Romanian).",
"body": "Reports the Diocese of Oradea's suspension of Borbel from clerical duties following the judicial-control decision.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-statement"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunalul Bihor",
"stage": "appeal against judicial control denied",
"date": "2025",
"outcome": "The Bihor County Tribunal rejected Borbel's challenge to the continued judicial-control measure."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Valentin Borbel was detained for 24 hours on continuous sexual assault charges against a minor who was 10 years old when the abuse began in 2023; the abuse continued for roughly two years before coming to the attention of authorities in February 2025. The Oradea Court declined a preventive-arrest request but placed him under 60-day judicial control with a no-contact order covering the victim and witnesses. The investigation, opened at the Aleșd prosecutor's office, was transferred to the Bihor County Tribunal's prosecutor's office. Borbel was subsequently sent to trial and the Tribunal Bihor rejected his appeal against continued judicial control. The Orthodox Diocese of Oradea suspended him from service immediately after the judicial-control ruling; he has since applied for early retirement. As of the sources consulted, no trial verdict is reported; entered at charged/trial-referral tier.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/preotul-ortodox-din-suncuius-retinut-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-asupra-unei-minore-judecatoria-oradea-l-a-plasat-sub-control-judiciar-197028.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6ba62b3f1049c16336ad382c564c75d014724185fc2e0e5373f9f155ac5b459a",
"final_url": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/preotul-ortodox-din-suncuius-retinut-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-asupra-unei-minore-judecatoria-oradea-l-a-plasat-sub-control-judiciar-197028.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/fostul-preot-paroh-ortodox-din-suncuius-acuzat-ca-a-agresat-sexual-o-fetita-a-fost-trimis-in-judecata-si-ramane-sub-control-judiciar-198171.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6927494f59527de53b890f0249bb2fb6f217fad59afd6f568e55627ac4fcdac1",
"final_url": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/fostul-preot-paroh-ortodox-din-suncuius-acuzat-ca-a-agresat-sexual-o-fetita-a-fost-trimis-in-judecata-si-ramane-sub-control-judiciar-198171.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/episcopia-ortodoxa-l-a-suspendat-pe-preotul-din-bihor-acuzat-ca-a-agresat-sexual-o-copila-197040.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "468d37bf3e97a51940b9968a56ba305cac7ef0bd711ab2569019eaa681c67b54",
"final_url": "https://www.ebihoreanul.ro/stiri/episcopia-ortodoxa-l-a-suspendat-pe-preotul-din-bihor-acuzat-ca-a-agresat-sexual-o-copila-197040.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 712,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in French from Banouto, Benin Web TV, La Nouvelle Tribune, Seneweb, Daabaaru, Les 4 Vérités and 24 Heures au Bénin, all reporting the same 6 December 2022 Abomey-Calavi verdict. No outlet consulted names the pastor or his church; he is identified only by his clerical role and the court's findings. This is distinct from the existing corpus record '2016-benin' (Beninese vodou 'convents' and trafficking-for-debt), which concerns unrelated child-servitude practices, not this pastor or this court case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-benin-pastor-abomey-calavi-benin",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Abomey-Calavi, Benin",
"lat": 6.4489,
"lng": 2.3556,
"title": "Benin: evangelical pastor convicted of serially raping congregants and defrauding them in a land-purchase scheme",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Unnamed evangelical pastor, church unspecified in reporting, Abomey-Calavi, Benin"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his standing as pastor over the women who were members of his congregation, used to obtain sexual access described in reporting as non-consensual",
"concurrent exploitation of congregants' trust to collect money for land parcels he never delivered, a financial breach-of-trust running alongside the sexual offenses"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de première instance de deuxième classe d'Abomey-Calavi, Benin",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2022-12-06",
"outcome": "On 6 December 2022 the Abomey-Calavi court of first instance convicted the pastor of serial rape ('viols en série') of congregants without their consent and of breach of trust (abus de confiance), and sentenced him to 20 years' criminal imprisonment plus a fine of 25 million CFA francs. He had denied all charges. The court found him guilty both of sexual penetration without the victims' informed consent and of taking money from several women for land-parcel purchases he never completed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were women under the pastor's congregational authority; his position as their spiritual leader is what gave him the access and standing that both the sexual offenses and the parallel financial exploitation traded on, per the court's own combined verdict.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.banouto.bj/article/securite-humaine/20221207-abomey-calavi-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-et-abus-de-confiance",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Banouto, 'Abomey-Calavi : un pasteur condamné à 20 ans de prison pour viol et abus de confiance' (in French).",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of the 6 December 2022 verdict, sentence and fine.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://beninwebtv.com/benin-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-et-abus-de-confiance/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Benin Web TV, 'Bénin: un pasteur condamné à 20 ans de prison pour viol et abus de confiance' (in French).",
"body": "Corroborates the court name, verdict, sentence, and the land-parcel fraud detail.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://lanouvelletribune.info/2022/12/viol-au-benin-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Nouvelle Tribune, 'Viol au Bénin: un pasteur condamné à 20 ans de prison' (in French).",
"body": "Independent corroboration of the verdict and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.banouto.bj/article/securite-humaine/20221207-abomey-calavi-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-et-abus-de-confiance",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e1474636024f24b7290782b55067eafdfcab218f6b70f0ca1d68cbafbe07cf74",
"final_url": "https://www.banouto.bj/article/securite-humaine/20221207-abomey-calavi-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-et-abus-de-confiance"
},
{
"source": "https://beninwebtv.com/benin-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-et-abus-de-confiance/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "437eabe65326e387d890e307fa12b194b2f6816524665dcc13edd2fa85e8e352",
"final_url": "https://beninwebtv.com/benin-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-et-abus-de-confiance/"
},
{
"source": "https://lanouvelletribune.info/2022/12/viol-au-benin-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4418363bc9cd7ca03e4bccdadb9db0a5cd359877602185358e831ea0dd70cd9f",
"final_url": "https://lanouvelletribune.info/2022/12/viol-au-benin-un-pasteur-condamne-a-20-ans-de-prison/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 713,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in French from NetAfrique and Mousso News, both reporting the 19 June 2026 Fada N'Gourma verdict; the two outlets state the custodial component differently (NetAfrique gives 11 years total, Mousso's headline emphasizes the 3-year firm/hard-labor component) but agree on all other facts — these are reconciled here as an 11-year sentence with a 3-year non-remissible portion. No outlet names the defendant; he is described only as a 'faux pasteur' (self-styled/false pastor) who operated without a fixed congregation from a private home, which the sources use to distinguish him from an ordained or denominationally affiliated minister — that description goes to his lack of institutional standing, not to whether the victim's family believed in his claimed spiritual power, which is what the record turns on.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-fada-ngourma-false-pastor-burkina-faso",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Fada N'Gourma, Est Region, Burkina Faso",
"lat": 12.0616,
"lng": 0.3577,
"title": "Burkina Faso: self-styled pastor convicted of raping a 10-year-old brought to him for deliverance prayer to treat epilepsy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Unnamed self-styled pastor ('faux pasteur' in reporting), approximately 50 years old, operating from a private residence in Fada N'Gourma"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"presenting himself as a healer/man of God able to treat the child's epilepsy through prayer, which is how her parents came to bring her to him for repeated sessions",
"claim during the assaults that his own demonic possession, not his own will, was responsible for his conduct — turning the same spiritual framework used to recruit the family into a post-hoc excuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber, Tribunal de grande instance (TGI) de Fada N'Gourma, Burkina Faso",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2026-06-19",
"outcome": "On 19 June 2026 the Criminal Chamber of the Fada N'Gourma high court convicted the defendant of aggravated rape of a minor and sentenced him to 11 years' imprisonment (of which 3 years without remission/hard labor) plus a 2 million CFA franc fine. The victim's parents, seeking treatment for her epilepsy, had brought her to him from age 10 for prayer/deliverance sessions. She testified he first assaulted her on 26 June 2025 and again on 30 June 2025. At trial he initially denied the second assault by pointing to a false-positive pregnancy test, then recanted that defense when medical examination proved negative; a medical exam confirmed the absence of her hymen. He was in his fifties, married with two children."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child's parents brought her to the defendant specifically because they believed his claimed prayer power could treat her epilepsy, which is what placed her alone with him in private sessions; the criterion's authority-as-instrument mechanism is direct — belief in his healing power created the access, and his own courtroom excuse (claimed possession) reused that same spiritual framing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://netafrique.net/fada-ngourma-un-pasteur-condamne-a-11-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-sur-une-mineure-de-10-ans/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NetAfrique, 'Fada N'Gourma : Un pasteur condamné à 11 ans de prison pour viol sur une mineure de 10 ans' (in French).",
"body": "Full account of the epilepsy/deliverance pretext, the two assault dates, the false-pregnancy-test detail, and the 11-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.moussonews.com/fada-ngourma-un-faux-pasteur-ecope-3-ans-de-prison-ferme-pour-vi-ol-sur-une-mineure-de-10-ans/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mousso News, 'Fada N'Gourma : Un faux pasteur écope 3 ans de prison ferme pour viol sur une mineure de 10 ans' (in French).",
"body": "Independent corroboration emphasizing the firm/non-remissible three-year component of the sentence and the TGI Fada N'Gourma criminal chamber.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://netafrique.net/fada-ngourma-un-pasteur-condamne-a-11-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-sur-une-mineure-de-10-ans/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8c1a3465393b733f247ec1e0b40f65596e04aa9ba11aa725dbdb9746f2af4f33",
"final_url": "https://netafrique.net/fada-ngourma-un-pasteur-condamne-a-11-ans-de-prison-pour-viol-sur-une-mineure-de-10-ans/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.moussonews.com/fada-ngourma-un-faux-pasteur-ecope-3-ans-de-prison-ferme-pour-vi-ol-sur-une-mineure-de-10-ans/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b9594f797471cf0952a62f9bab4f7e83593bcccbc3b61e700d97b793e23849dd",
"final_url": "https://www.moussonews.com/fada-ngourma-un-faux-pasteur-ecope-3-ans-de-prison-ferme-pour-vi-ol-sur-une-mineure-de-10-ans/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 714,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sąd Okręgowy w Rzeszowie",
"stage": "appeal pending as of reporting (sought by victim's family, reportedly for a harsher sentence)",
"date": "2026",
"outcome": "Not yet resolved as of the sources consulted."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Polish from Radio Rzeszów, Super Express, wprost.pl, and multiple o2.pl and TVP Rzeszów crime-desk reports on the Sąd Okręgowy w Rzeszowie verdict of 22 May 2026. Polish court reporting convention withholds full surnames of the accused in ongoing/non-final proceedings — 'Dominik R.' is the form used consistently across all outlets consulted, not a redaction introduced here. Distinct from all five existing Polish-clergy-abuse records in the corpus (Tarnów/Jeż, Siedlce, Chodzież/Krzysztof G., Ostrołęka/Łukasz R., Zamość-Biłgoraj/Jarosław Z.) — different diocese, different defendant, different parishes.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-swiecany-dominik-r-podkarpacie-poland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Święcany and Boguchwała, Podkarpackie Voivodeship, Poland",
"lat": 49.7275,
"lng": 21.4536,
"title": "Poland: Catholic vicar convicted of sexually abusing five teenage boys, including altar servers, across two parishes",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Fr Dominik R. (surname withheld per Polish court-reporting convention), Roman Catholic vicar (wikariusz) of the parishes of Święcany and Boguchwała, Diocese of Rzeszów"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his standing as parish vicar and the trust placed in him by families of altar servers and catechism participants",
"use of parish settings — including the rectory/parish house — and a school trip abroad and swimming-pool outings organized for altar servers as access points"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Rzeszów"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sąd Okręgowy w Rzeszowie (Regional Court in Rzeszów), Poland",
"stage": "conviction, non-final at time of reporting",
"date": "2026-05-22",
"outcome": "On 22 May 2026 the Regional Court in Rzeszów convicted Fr Dominik R. of six sexual offenses against boys and sentenced him to 5 years' imprisonment, to be served in a therapeutic unit given a diagnosed sexual-preference disorder. He harmed five teenage boys, two of them under 15, across the parishes of Święcany and Boguchwała, with offenses occurring in the catechetical room, during an organized school trip abroad, and during pool outings for altar servers. The court additionally imposed a lifetime ban on working with children or minors, a prohibition on approaching places where children congregate, and a 10-year no-contact order covering the victims. The Diocesan Curia of Rzeszów removed him from his vicar posting and suspended him from all pastoral functions. The sentence was reported as non-final (nieprawomocny); parents of one victim were reported pursuing an appeal, apparently seeking a harsher sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were altar servers and catechism participants under Fr Dominik R.'s direct pastoral charge in his own parishes; the settings of abuse — the catechetical room, a church-organized trip, and altar-server outings — were all made possible specifically by his clerical office over these children.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://radio.rzeszow.pl/107404/ks-dominik-r-wikariusz-parafii-w-swiecanach-zostal-odwolany/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Polskie Radio Rzeszów, 'Ks. Dominik R., wikariusz parafii w Święcanach został odwołany' (in Polish).",
"body": "Diocesan/regional radio report confirming his removal from the Święcany vicar post.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-statement"
},
{
"link": "https://www.se.pl/rzeszow/ksiadz-dominik-skazany-byl-oskarzony-o-pedofilie-skrzywdzil-kilku-chlopcow-aa-Mr3y-nngK-RniB.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Super Express (Rzeszów edition), 'Ksiądz Dominik skazany. Był oskarżony o pedofilię. Skrzywdził kilku chłopców' (in Polish).",
"body": "National tabloid court report on the conviction, sentence and therapeutic-unit placement.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wprost.pl/zycie/11927448/rusza-proces-ksiedza-oskarzonego-min-o-molestowanie-mial-skrzywdzic-pieciu-chlopcow.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wprost, 'Ksiądz stanął przed sądem. Miał skrzywdzić pięciu chłopców' (in Polish).",
"body": "National newsweekly's account of the trial confirming five victims and the school-trip/pool-outing access points.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sąd Okręgowy w Rzeszowie",
"stage": "appeal pending as of reporting (sought by victim's family, reportedly for a harsher sentence)",
"date": "2026",
"outcome": "Not yet resolved as of the sources consulted."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://radio.rzeszow.pl/107404/ks-dominik-r-wikariusz-parafii-w-swiecanach-zostal-odwolany/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a66c128a90ac839fef6dd155ea7a3df1d85c92aafd8f9364e5c7914f2cc89be7",
"final_url": "https://radio.rzeszow.pl/107404/ks-dominik-r-wikariusz-parafii-w-swiecanach-zostal-odwolany/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.se.pl/rzeszow/ksiadz-dominik-skazany-byl-oskarzony-o-pedofilie-skrzywdzil-kilku-chlopcow-aa-Mr3y-nngK-RniB.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f2eb95c7f01ed46c20f22afe3693a70cd120ecc5e6376ed7df283d237a77c251",
"final_url": "https://www.se.pl/rzeszow/ksiadz-dominik-skazany-byl-oskarzony-o-pedofilie-skrzywdzil-kilku-chlopcow-aa-Mr3y-nngK-RniB.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wprost.pl/zycie/11927448/rusza-proces-ksiedza-oskarzonego-min-o-molestowanie-mial-skrzywdzic-pieciu-chlopcow.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7fb590e61012983a719990a8560b30c570e4d5ff4d3b40c812e3ab379c18cdd7",
"final_url": "https://www.wprost.pl/zycie/11927448/rusza-proces-ksiedza-oskarzonego-min-o-molestowanie-mial-skrzywdzic-pieciu-chlopcow.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 715,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Recorded as an institutional-event/context record (recordClass) rather than a core individual-perpetrator record, consistent with the corpus convention for commission/inquiry findings that document a pattern across many unnamed individuals rather than a single adjudicated case. Sourced in Polish from TVN24's investigative desk coverage of the 13 February 2026 Sosnowiec diocesan report, cross-referenced against PKDP's own public statements on its Church-sector investigation and against bezprawnik.pl's earlier reporting on the national-level finding that roughly 30% of documented Polish abuse-commission cases involve clergy. This is the first Sosnowiec-specific record in the corpus; existing Polish records (Tarnów, Siedlce, Chodzież, Ostrołęka, Zamość-Biłgoraj, and the new Święcany/Rzeszów record above) are individual-perpetrator cases in other dioceses, not duplicates of this diocese-wide finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-sosnowiec-diocese-abuse-commission-report-poland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Diocese of Sosnowiec, Poland",
"lat": 50.2863,
"lng": 19.1041,
"title": "Poland: diocesan commission finds at least 50 minor victims and 25 clergy perpetrators over decades in the Diocese of Sosnowiec",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Clergy of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Sosnowiec, Poland, collectively — 25 of 29 identified suspects were clergy, the remainder an organist and a catechist"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and catechetical authority over children in parish and school settings across the diocese, sustained over decades (one priest's documented abuse ran at least 16 years)",
"institutional pattern the report itself found: children who disclosed abuse were 'often treated as a problem' by Church authorities rather than as victims needing protection, per the diocesan bishop's own public acknowledgment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Sosnowiec",
"Państwowa Komisja do spraw przeciwdziałania wykorzystaniu seksualnemu małoletnich poniżej lat 15 (Polish State Commission for Prevention of Sexual Abuse of Minors, PKDP)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Internal diocesan commission, Diocese of Sosnowiec, Poland, with cases referred to the state Państwowa Komisja (PKDP)",
"stage": "official finding published",
"date": "2026-02-13",
"outcome": "On 13 February 2026 the Diocese of Sosnowiec published the first part of a commission report documenting at least 50 minor victims of sexual crimes within the diocese, most of them girls under 15, identifying 29 total suspects of whom 25 were clergy. The abuses documented span multiple decades; one priest's pattern of abuse was found to have continued for at least 16 years. Bishop Artur Ważny stated publicly that the report addresses victims but does not yet cover the full range of alleged conduct, and acknowledged that victims were historically 'often treated as a problem' rather than supported. The state commission (PKDP) is separately handling at least two cases referred from this diocese involving statute-of-limitations complications, which may result in entries to Poland's public sex-offender registry. Further diocesan report installments were announced as forthcoming."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This is a diocese-wide institutional finding rather than a single perpetrator record: it documents a decades-long pattern in which children under the clergy's own pastoral and catechetical authority were abused, and in which the same institutional authority that gave perpetrators access also governed — and by the bishop's own admission, mishandled — the response to disclosures.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tvn24.pl/plus/programy/polska-i-swiat/druzgocacy-raport-na-temat-pedofilii-w-diecezji-sosnowieckiej-komisja-zapowiada-kolejne-publikacje-st8898988",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TVN24, 'Druzgocący raport na temat pedofilii w diecezji sosnowieckiej. Komisja zapowiada kolejne publikacje' (in Polish).",
"body": "Detailed investigative account of the 13 Feb. 2026 report: victim count, clergy proportion, decades-long span, and the bishop's public acknowledgment.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://pkdp.gov.pl/panstwowa-komisja-bada-sposob-reagowania-polskich-kosciolow-chrzescijanskich-na-zjawisko-pedofilii/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Państwowa Komisja do spraw przeciwdziałania wykorzystaniu seksualnemu małoletnich (PKDP), 'Państwowa Komisja bada sposób reagowania polskich kościołów chrześcijańskich na zjawisko pedofilii' (in Polish).",
"body": "Official state-commission statement on its ongoing review of Polish Christian churches' institutional response to abuse, including referred Sosnowiec-linked cases.",
"tier": "government-official-report",
"kind": "official-report"
},
{
"link": "https://bezprawnik.pl/raport-komisji-do-spraw-pedofilii/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bezprawnik.pl, 'A więc jednak nie murarze, jak twierdził premier. Raport państwowej komisji: 30% przypadków pedofilii dotyczy duchownych' (in Polish).",
"body": "National-level context: the state commission's finding that roughly 30% of its documented cases involve clergy, cited here as background to the diocese-level Sosnowiec figures.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "official-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tvn24.pl/plus/programy/polska-i-swiat/druzgocacy-raport-na-temat-pedofilii-w-diecezji-sosnowieckiej-komisja-zapowiada-kolejne-publikacje-st8898988",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1bf79e93d9cdc7160a61313002862d40d6151b48fc64a89b6e64e1836e5ddc66",
"final_url": "https://tvn24.pl/plus/programy/polska-i-swiat/druzgocacy-raport-na-temat-pedofilii-w-diecezji-sosnowieckiej-komisja-zapowiada-kolejne-publikacje-st8898988"
},
{
"source": "https://pkdp.gov.pl/panstwowa-komisja-bada-sposob-reagowania-polskich-kosciolow-chrzescijanskich-na-zjawisko-pedofilii/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-official-report; evidentiary role: official-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f0c47a25a765de4f68199afaa56fb222254524dcb09af14814fe8ab73d3ff9f9",
"final_url": "https://pkdp.gov.pl/panstwowa-komisja-bada-sposob-reagowania-polskich-kosciolow-chrzescijanskich-na-zjawisko-pedofilii/"
},
{
"source": "https://bezprawnik.pl/raport-komisji-do-spraw-pedofilii/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: official-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8bbfd7e758780b654f50edc9005e2161d8c3128bba310e87b405f5317dacf595",
"final_url": "https://bezprawnik.pl/raport-komisji-do-spraw-pedofilii/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 716,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Spanish from La República's investigative report cross-referencing the 2011 Bogotá conviction, Interpol red-notice status, and the December 2025 Peruvian prescription ruling. This is the corpus's first Anglican-tradition Latin American record and the first cross-border Colombia/Peru case; entered under traditionDetailId christian-other as the taxonomy has no dedicated Anglican-communion id. Distinct from all existing Colombia and Peru records in the corpus, none of which involve the Anglican Church or this defendant.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-mauricio-garibello-medina-bogota-colombia",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Bogotá, Colombia, and Trujillo, Peru",
"lat": 4.6097,
"lng": -74.0817,
"title": "Colombia: Anglican missionary convicted of abusing a 9-year-old boy fled to Peru and continued serving as a deacon for 14 years before his sentence lapsed unserved",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Mauricio Garibello Medina, Anglican Church missionary in the Los Laches neighborhood of Bogotá, later reverend deacon of an Anglican church in Trujillo, Peru"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his standing as a missionary of the boy's family's church and as a teacher figure, per the sentencing judge's own remarks on the position of trust exploited",
"flight from Colombian justice into a foreign Anglican ministry post, using his continued clerical status abroad to remain in unsupervised proximity to a new congregation for 14 years"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Anglican Church, Bogotá parish and Trujillo, Peru parish"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Juzgado 32 de Conocimiento, Bogotá, Colombia",
"stage": "conviction, sentence never served; later lapsed by prescription",
"outcome": "Garibello was convicted in 2011 of acceso carnal abusivo con menor de catorce años (abusive carnal access with a minor under 14) for abusing a 9-year-old boy from the Los Laches neighborhood, whose mother filed the complaint in 2009, and was sentenced to 13 years and 4 months' imprisonment. The sentencing judge noted the abuse caused the child marked psychological disturbance and specifically cited the breach of trust given Garibello also functioned as a teacher figure to him. Garibello fled to Peru in early 2012 rather than serve the sentence and became a reverend deacon at an Anglican church in Trujillo, where he continued in ministry through 2025. He was listed on an Interpol red notice; Peru approved a Colombian extradition request, but the transfer never took place. In December 2025 a Peruvian judge approved the prescription (lapse by statute of limitations) of the Colombian conviction, meaning Garibello will serve no time despite the standing conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Garibello's access to the victim ran through his role as a missionary of the family's own church; his subsequent 14 years evading the sentence by taking up an equivalent clerical post — deacon — in a different country's Anglican congregation shows the same authority-granting institutional structure enabling continued unsupervised access to children abroad.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://larepublica.pe/sociedad/2026/02/04/sacerdote-condenado-por-abuso-en-colombia-escapo-al-peru-y-ejercio-como-diacono-en-trujillo-hasta-2025-registra-orden-de-captura-de-interpol-260296",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La República (Peru), 'Sacerdote condenado por abuso en Colombia escapó al Perú y ejerció como diácono en Trujillo hasta 2025: registra orden de captura de Interpol' (in Spanish).",
"body": "Full account of the 2011 Bogotá conviction, the flight to Peru, 14 years of continued ministry as deacon in Trujillo, the Interpol red notice, and the December 2025 prescription ruling.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://larepublica.pe/sociedad/2026/02/04/sacerdote-condenado-por-abuso-en-colombia-escapo-al-peru-y-ejercio-como-diacono-en-trujillo-hasta-2025-registra-orden-de-captura-de-interpol-260296",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d9e60ea8618f05a29465c53328c84dd537bfdf0cd02560f1cf370adf440eb90d",
"final_url": "https://larepublica.pe/sociedad/2026/02/04/sacerdote-condenado-por-abuso-en-colombia-escapo-al-peru-y-ejercio-como-diacono-en-trujillo-hasta-2025-registra-orden-de-captura-de-interpol-260296"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 717,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Spanish from Diario.mx (Ciudad Juárez regional paper of record) and corroborated by InfoVaticana's Catholic-press coverage of the same sentencing. Neither outlet gives the priest's full surname, following standard Mexican court-reporting practice for cases still within the appeal window; 'Eliseo R. S.' is the form used consistently in both sources, not an editorial redaction introduced here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-eliseo-rs-fatima-guadalupe-chihuahua-mexico",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Guadalupe, Chihuahua, Mexico",
"lat": 31.3667,
"lng": -106.1,
"title": "Mexico: priest sentenced for sexually abusing a girl during confession before her First Communion at a Ciudad Juárez-area parish",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Fr Eliseo R. S. (surname withheld per Mexican court-reporting convention), Roman Catholic priest, Nuestra Señora de Fátima parish, Guadalupe municipality, Diocese of Ciudad Juárez"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his position hearing the child's confession in preparation for her First Communion, a sacrament under his sole clerical authority to administer",
"the court's own finding that he 'took advantage of the means and circumstances that his position as a priest provided' inside the church building itself"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Ciudad Juárez"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Superior de Justicia (Superior Court of Justice), Chihuahua, Mexico",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2025-07-23",
"outcome": "Eliseo R. S. was sentenced to 4 years, 10 months and 15 days' imprisonment for aggravated sexual abuse of a child, arising from an incident inside Nuestra Señora de Fátima parish, Guadalupe, on 2 June 2013, during which he abused the child while hearing her confession ahead of her First Communion. The court's ruling explicitly found that he exploited the access and trust his priestly position gave him inside the church. As of the July 2025 reporting he remained free pending expiry of the appeal window (the court's summer recess extended procedural deadlines to 4 August 2025); he was to report to prison only once that window closed without a successful appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The abuse occurred during the sacrament of confession itself, a rite only the priest could administer and one the child's family required her to undergo before First Communion; the court's own finding identifies his priestly office and the physical/procedural setting of confession as the instrument of the crime.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://diario.mx/juarez/2025/jul/23/seguira-libre-sacerdote-sentenciado-por-abuso-1076747.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diario.mx, 'Seguirá libre sacerdote sentenciado por abuso' (in Spanish).",
"body": "Regional paper of record's report on the sentence, the parish, the 2013 confession-abuse incident, and the appeal-window procedural detail.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://infovaticana.com/2025/07/24/nuevo-escandalo-clerical-en-mexico-sacerdote-sentenciado-por-abuso-a-menor-y-pendiente-de-expulsion",
"archive": "",
"citation": "InfoVaticana, 'Nuevo escándalo clerical en México: sacerdote sentenciado por abuso a menor y pendiente de expulsión' (in Spanish).",
"body": "Catholic-press corroboration of the sentencing and diocese, framed around the priest's pending canonical expulsion.",
"tier": "specialty-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://diario.mx/juarez/2025/jul/23/seguira-libre-sacerdote-sentenciado-por-abuso-1076747.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bf8e11206d70e6a72002bd25685ccad275fd24fa95d546f4ee11ea455dfea49d",
"final_url": "https://diario.mx/juarez/2025/jul/23/seguira-libre-sacerdote-sentenciado-por-abuso-1076747.html"
},
{
"source": "https://infovaticana.com/2025/07/24/nuevo-escandalo-clerical-en-mexico-sacerdote-sentenciado-por-abuso-a-menor-y-pendiente-de-expulsion",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialty-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8380e43ea7aa9c41c2d36a35588e5ffbe67654d37c83449d7bad6bcddd1892a5",
"final_url": "https://infovaticana.com/2025/07/24/nuevo-escandalo-clerical-en-mexico-sacerdote-sentenciado-por-abuso-a-menor-y-pendiente-de-expulsion/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 718,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Recorded as an institutional-event/context record (recordClass) given the finding runs against the Congregation as an institution rather than adjudicating a single named perpetrator's criminal guilt, consistent with corpus convention for institutional-liability findings. Sourced in Spanish from El Mostrador's investigative unit, the outlet that broke the 14 July 2026 verdict; cross-check against Poder Judicial de Chile's own social-media confirmation of a related Concepción sexual-abuse sentencing is a separate, unconnected case and not used as a source here. Distinct from all existing Chile records (Colegio Cumbres/O'Reilly, Archdiocese of Santiago/Muñoz Toledo, El Bosque/Karadima, Colliguay/Antares de la Luz, Colonia Dignidad, Temuco/Curín, Mar del Plata is Argentina not Chile) — this is the first Salesian-order institutional finding for Chile in the corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-salesian-congregation-civil-liability-chile",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Putaendo, Santiago, Talca, Concepción, Valdivia and Punta Arenas, Chile",
"lat": -33.4489,
"lng": -70.6693,
"title": "Chile: civil court finds the Salesian order followed a 'systematic and institutional pattern' enabling sexual abuse of students across six cities, orders damages to nine survivors",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-judgment",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Salesian Congregation (Salesianos), Roman Catholic religious order operating schools across Chile; individual priests named in the underlying abuse allegations include Rimsky Rojas, with Cardinal Ricardo Ezzati and Alfonso Horn implicated in the original criminal complaints"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and educational authority over students at Salesian-run schools in six Chilean cities",
"institutional practice, per the court's finding, of using internal mechanisms such as priestly dispensations to quietly remove accused abusers rather than report them to civil authorities, prioritizing institutional image over child protection"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Salesian Congregation (Congregación Salesiana), Chile"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Séptimo Juzgado Civil de Santiago (Seventh Civil Court of Santiago), Chile",
"stage": "civil judgment against the institution",
"date": "2026-07-14",
"outcome": "On 14 July 2026 Judge Diego Portilla Silva of the Seventh Civil Court of Santiago found the Salesian Congregation civilly liable for a 'systematic and institutional pattern' of structural deficiencies that enabled repeated sexual abuse of students at Salesian schools in Putaendo, Santiago, Talca, Concepción, Valdivia and Punta Arenas. The ruling covered nine former students and ordered a total of 325 million pesos in damages: five victims awarded 50 million pesos each, two awarded 30 million pesos each, one awarded 15 million pesos, and one awarded no damages. The court explicitly rejected the Congregation's internal canonical investigations as an adequate legal response to crimes affecting fundamental rights, and found the order used mechanisms like priestly dispensations to remove accused priests quietly rather than report them."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "This is an institutional civil-liability finding rather than a single perpetrator's criminal conviction: the court found the religious order's own structure and practice of protecting its institutional image over reporting abuse is what let priests' clerical and educational authority over students translate into a repeated, cross-city pattern of harm.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elmostrador.cl/unidad-de-investigacion/2026/07/14/condenan-a-la-orden-salesiana-por-patron-sistematico-e-institucional-de-abusos-sexuales/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Mostrador, 'Condenan a la orden Salesiana por «patrón sistemático e institucional» de abusos sexuales' (in Spanish).",
"body": "Full investigative account of the 14 July 2026 civil judgment: judge, court, the nine victims and their individual damages awards, the cities involved, and the court's institutional-pattern finding.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elmostrador.cl/unidad-de-investigacion/2026/07/14/condenan-a-la-orden-salesiana-por-patron-sistematico-e-institucional-de-abusos-sexuales/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "033bfcf279e209741f8bcb7d44629adcc22b822c87e18997cff6ada9768dd585",
"final_url": "https://www.elmostrador.cl/unidad-de-investigacion/2026/07/14/condenan-a-la-orden-salesiana-por-patron-sistematico-e-institucional-de-abusos-sexuales/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 719,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cámara en lo Criminal N°2 de Catamarca / Juez de Ejecución Penal",
"stage": "sentence became final (quedó firme); subsequent grant of provisional home detention on health grounds",
"date": "2026",
"outcome": "The conviction became final. A penal-execution judge later granted Rasgido provisional home detention pending health treatment, which drew public repudiation given reports he would serve it at a church property."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Spanish from El Ancasti (Catamarca's paper of record, which followed the case from complaint through final sentence and the later home-detention controversy) and La Izquierda Diario's court report on the original 15-year sentence. Distinct from all existing Argentina records in the corpus (Próvolo, Grassi, Munro/Manuel Pascual, Umbanda Salta, Monte Sion, Marito Salto/San La Muerte, Marcelo Krawiec/Chalom synagogue) — different province, different defendant, different case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jose-renato-rasgido-catamarca-argentina",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Andalgalá, Catamarca Province, Argentina",
"lat": -27.5833,
"lng": -66.3167,
"title": "Argentina: priest convicted of sexually abusing a boy over a decade earlier, sentenced after a trial delayed ten years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"José Renato Rasgido (Father Rasgido), Roman Catholic priest, Andalgalá, Catamarca Province"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his standing as an ordained minister of a legally recognized religion, an aggravating factor the court applied to each count",
"access to the victim, who was 12 years old at the time of the abuse, through his clerical role in the community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Church, Andalgalá, Catamarca"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cámara en lo Criminal N°2 de Catamarca (Criminal Chamber No. 2 of Catamarca), Argentina",
"stage": "conviction",
"outcome": "Judges Miguel Ángel Lozano Gilyam, Silvio Martoccia and Mauricio Navarro Foressi unanimously convicted José Renato Rasgido of two counts of aggravated simple sexual abuse and two counts of aggravated sexual abuse with carnal access (violación), the aggravation in each count being his status as a minister of a legally recognized cult, and sentenced him to 15 years' imprisonment. The victim, abused at age 12, said publicly after the verdict that he hoped it would bring relief to other survivors of Rasgido's abuse who had not come forward. The verdict followed a trial that itself took ten years to reach court from the original complaint. Rasgido began serving the sentence but was later granted an exceptional precautionary measure of provisional home detention, conditioned on discharge from a sanatorium where he was hospitalized; press reporting noted he was to serve home detention at a church-affiliated residence, drawing public criticism."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Rasgido's access to the child ran through his position as the community's Catholic priest, and the court itself treated his status as a minister of religion as an aggravating element of each count — the clerical office is written directly into the conviction, not merely background context.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elancasti.com.ar/edicion-impresa/quedo-firme-la-sentencia-abuso-sexual-el-cura-jose-renato-rasgido-n605116",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Ancasti, 'Quedó firme la sentencia por abuso sexual para el cura José Renato Rasgido' (in Spanish).",
"body": "Confirms the sentence became final; paper of record for Catamarca province.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.laizquierdadiario.com/Catamarca-cura-condenado-a-15-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-sexual",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Izquierda Diario, 'Catamarca: cura condenado a 15 años de prisión por abuso sexual' (in Spanish).",
"body": "Reports the three-judge panel, the specific counts and their religious-minister aggravation, the 15-year sentence, and the ten-year delay from complaint to trial.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://inforama.com.ar/actualidad/2026/06/16/el-cura-rasgido-condenado-por-abuso-sexual-cumplira-prision-domiciliara-en-una-iglesia/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Inforama, 'El cura Rasgido, condenado por abuso sexual, cumplirá prisión domiciliara en una Iglesia' (in Spanish).",
"body": "Reports the later grant of home detention at a church property and resulting public criticism.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cámara en lo Criminal N°2 de Catamarca / Juez de Ejecución Penal",
"stage": "sentence became final (quedó firme); subsequent grant of provisional home detention on health grounds",
"date": "2026",
"outcome": "The conviction became final. A penal-execution judge later granted Rasgido provisional home detention pending health treatment, which drew public repudiation given reports he would serve it at a church property."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elancasti.com.ar/edicion-impresa/quedo-firme-la-sentencia-abuso-sexual-el-cura-jose-renato-rasgido-n605116",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2747acac9cd06cbb606fb39abfe785662c656e6ae91bf701cd1bfd100ac6ae94",
"final_url": "https://www.elancasti.com.ar/edicion-impresa/quedo-firme-la-sentencia-abuso-sexual-el-cura-jose-renato-rasgido-n605116"
},
{
"source": "https://www.laizquierdadiario.com/Catamarca-cura-condenado-a-15-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-sexual",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://inforama.com.ar/actualidad/2026/06/16/el-cura-rasgido-condenado-por-abuso-sexual-cumplira-prision-domiciliara-en-una-iglesia/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1947b569cc07522e651e170a435ed6def309a95098e37c63ea61870b2d89f8ab",
"final_url": "https://inforama.com.ar/actualidad/2026/06/16/el-cura-rasgido-condenado-por-abuso-sexual-cumplira-prision-domiciliara-en-una-iglesia/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 720,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Slovak from Denník N's court-reporting minute item and Žilinak.sk's fuller account of the verdict, both describing the case as a legal landmark. Distinct from the existing corpus record 2016-ladislav-jurcik-altar-server-slovakia — different priest, different region, different victim relationship (church-school pupil rather than altar server).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-peter-krizian-orava-slovakia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Orava region, Slovakia",
"lat": 49.3167,
"lng": 19.5,
"title": "Slovakia: former priest convicted in landmark ruling of sexually abusing a 12-year-old pupil at his church school",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Peter Križian, former Roman Catholic priest, chief priest (hlavný kňaz) of a church school in the Orava region of Slovakia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his position as the school's chief priest and the victim's teacher/authority figure at a church institution",
"use of the parish rectory (fara) as the location where the abuse of the child began"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Church, Orava region church school"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court in the Orava region, Slovakia",
"stage": "conviction, described in Slovak press as a landmark (prelomový) ruling",
"outcome": "In November 2025 a Slovak court convicted Peter Križian of the continued sexual abuse of a girl who was 12 years old and in sixth grade at the church school where he served as chief priest at the time. She testified that the first instance of oral sexual contact occurred when they met at his rectory. Križian was sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment. He did not contest his guilt at trial but sought leniency citing his otherwise orderly life, which the court rejected. Prosecutors and the victim's legal representative characterized the ruling as a landmark (prelomový) decision, emphasizing its significance given the defendant's position of religious authority and the victim's status as a minor under his institutional care."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a pupil at the church school where Križian held the position of chief priest; that institutional religious authority over her as both teacher and cleric is what gave him direct, trusted access, including to his own rectory.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://dennikn.sk/minuta/4984552/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Denník N, 'Prelomový rozsudok: Kňaz dostal 10 rokov za zneužívanie 12-ročnej školáčky na Orave' (in Slovak).",
"body": "National paper of record's court-reporting item confirming the 10-year sentence, his role as chief priest of the church school, and the 'landmark' characterization.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.zilinak.sk/clanky/37819/knaz-ktory-na-orave-zneuzival-len-12-rocne-dievca-si-vypocul-rozsudok-ide-o-prelomovy-pripad",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Žilinak.sk, 'Kňaz, ktorý na Orave zneužíval len 12-ročné dievča si vypočul rozsudok. Ide o prelomový prípad' (in Slovak).",
"body": "Regional outlet's fuller account of the rectory-based abuse and the school setting.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://dennikn.sk/minuta/4984552/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4bad9efe1793a00a07798bad7810d9a0abbd542f94b12afee64c38821a1da04e",
"final_url": "https://dennikn.sk/minuta/4984552/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.zilinak.sk/clanky/37819/knaz-ktory-na-orave-zneuzival-len-12-rocne-dievca-si-vypocul-rozsudok-ide-o-prelomovy-pripad",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "663011635956bdbeee1826231cf4daad9daa368aefafff6ae95a884add2c9266",
"final_url": "https://www.zilinak.sk/clanky/37819/knaz-ktory-na-orave-zneuzival-len-12-rocne-dievca-si-vypocul-rozsudok-ide-o-prelomovy-pripad"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 721,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Appellate court (unspecified in sources), Slovakia",
"stage": "2018 acquittal reversed, case remanded for retrial",
"date": "between 2018 and 2023",
"outcome": "The original acquittal was overturned and the case returned for retrial before a different panel, which produced the January 2023 conviction recorded above."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in Slovak from Noviny.sk's court-reporting coverage of the 9 January 2023 verdict. The article withholds the priest's name; he is identified only by his role and the Humenné-area parish. Entered with year 2005 (the approximate onset of the abuse per the 'age 12' and 'roughly 18 years' details in the source) rather than the 2023 verdict year, consistent with corpus convention of dating to the incident where a clear onset year can be derived; if a more precise onset date is later confirmed this should be revised.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-humenne-priest-rectory-slovakia",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Humenné region, eastern Slovakia",
"lat": 48.9333,
"lng": 21.9167,
"title": "Slovakia: priest convicted of sexually abusing a girl who visited his parish rectory as a child, verdict delivered 18 years after the abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Unnamed Roman Catholic priest, parish rectory (fara), Humenné region, eastern Slovakia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his position as the parish priest whose rectory the victim visited as a child in a context of religious/pastoral familiarity",
"the multi-year duration of abuse beginning when she was 12, which an initial acquittal took a decade further to overturn"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Church, Humenné region parish"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Okresný súd Humenné (District Court of Humenné), Slovakia",
"stage": "conviction on retrial, following a reversed acquittal",
"date": "2023-01-09",
"outcome": "On 9 January 2023 — roughly 18 years after the abuse began — the District Court of Humenné convicted the priest of the continued sexual abuse of a minor. The woman said the priest, whom she knew from visiting the parish rectory as a child, abused her beginning at age 12 and continuing for years. An initial 2018 trial ended in acquittal; that verdict was overturned on appeal, and a differently constituted panel convicted him based on indirect evidence and expert psychological assessments documenting trauma indicators consistent with her account."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's access to the priest, and his to her, ran through her family's ordinary visits to the parish rectory as churchgoers; the pastoral familiarity that relationship created is what the abuse exploited.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.noviny.sk/krimi/733747-ako-maloletu-ju-sexualne-zneuzival-knaz-rozsudku-sa-dockala-po-osemnastich-rokoch",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Noviny.sk, 'Ako maloletú ju sexuálne zneužíval kňaz: Rozsudku sa dočkala po osemnástich rokoch' (in Slovak).",
"body": "Full account of the rectory-visit relationship, the 2018 acquittal, its reversal on appeal, and the 9 January 2023 conviction based on indirect evidence and psychological expert assessment.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Appellate court (unspecified in sources), Slovakia",
"stage": "2018 acquittal reversed, case remanded for retrial",
"date": "between 2018 and 2023",
"outcome": "The original acquittal was overturned and the case returned for retrial before a different panel, which produced the January 2023 conviction recorded above."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.noviny.sk/krimi/733747-ako-maloletu-ju-sexualne-zneuzival-knaz-rozsudku-sa-dockala-po-osemnastich-rokoch",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c02ab5bccec4557f6887c80adcbb14450f8f20d3ad430e0b068e159cc04c94fa",
"final_url": "https://www.noviny.sk/krimi/733747-ako-maloletu-ju-sexualne-zneuzival-knaz-rozsudku-sa-dockala-po-osemnastich-rokoch"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 722,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in English-language Thai press (Khaosod English, Chiang Rai Times) reporting the 21 March 2026 charges; this is one of three distinct 2025-2026 Thai monastic-abuse cases identified in this pass (with Bueng Kan and Songkhla below) amid a broader documented wave the Thai Central Investigation Bureau's dedicated task force has been pursuing since 2025. This record resolves the 'Bangkok seven-novices (Mar 2026)' item the research plan had flagged as a watch item pending names/charges.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-sathon-temple-novices-bangkok-thailand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Sathon district, Bangkok, Thailand",
"lat": 13.7183,
"lng": 100.5292,
"title": "Thailand: two Bangkok monks charged with raping and filming at least seven novices after luring them with phones, cash and alcohol",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Phra Khru Sangkarak Chondaen ('Phra Toon'), age 24, and Phra Maha Siwabutr ('Phra Ta'), age 24, monks at a temple in the Sathon/Charoen Krung area, Bangkok"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"their standing as senior monks over novices under monastic discipline and supervision at the temple",
"luring novices into private rooms with items forbidden under monastic rule — mobile phones for gaming, cash (roughly 500 baht), and alcohol — to obtain access and secure compliance",
"covert filming and photography of the abuse, including of victims while asleep, adding a further coercive/exploitative dimension beyond the initial access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Buddhist temple, Sathon district, Bangkok (name not published in reporting)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Thai police investigation following complaint by the Pavena Hongsakul Foundation for Children and Women, Bangkok",
"stage": "charged; both defendants confessed and voluntarily disrobed",
"date": "2026-03-21",
"outcome": "Following a complaint from the Pavena Hongsakul Foundation for Children and Women, police charged Phra Khru Sangkarak Chondaen ('Phra Toon') and Phra Maha Siwabutr ('Phra Ta'), both 24, with rape through coercion, sexual assault of children under 15, recording indecent acts for profit, possessing child sexual abuse material, and encouraging misconduct. Seven novices initially came forward, with four more subsequently reporting abuse, for at least 11 alleged victims across at least 30 documented incidents. Both monks confessed, voluntarily disrobed, and were handed to investigators for legal proceedings. As of the sources consulted, formal court proceedings/trial had not yet concluded; entered at charged tier."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were novices — junior monastics under monastic discipline and the direct supervisory authority of these two senior monks within their own temple; that hierarchy, reinforced by items and privileges forbidden to novices that only the senior monks could grant, is what created access and enforced silence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.khaosodenglish.com/news/crimecourtscalamity/2026/03/21/seven-novice-monks-allege-sexual-abuse-by-former-bangkok-temple-monks/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Khaosod English, 'Seven novice monks allege sexual abuse by former Bangkok temple monks'.",
"body": "Original English-language report naming both defendants, the charges, and the initial seven-victim count.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.chiangraitimes.com/hot-news/police-arrest-monks-in-bangkok/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Chiang Rai Times, 'Police Arrest Monks For Sexually Abusing Novice Monks At Bangkok Temple'.",
"body": "Corroborates names, ages, charges, the lure mechanism (phones/cash/alcohol), the covert filming, and the expanded 11-victim, 30-incident count.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Following a complaint from the Pavena Hongsakul Foundation for Children and Women, police charged Phra Khru Sangkarak Chondaen ('Phra Toon') and Phra Maha Siwabutr ('Phra Ta'), both 24, with rape through coercion, sexual assault of children under 15, recording indecent acts for profit, possessing child sexual abuse material, and encouraging misconduct. Seven novices initially came forward, with four more subsequently reporting abuse, for at least 11 alleged victims across at least 30 documented incidents. Both monks confessed, voluntarily disrobed, and were handed to investigators for legal proceedings. As of the sources consulted, formal court proceedings/trial had not yet concluded; entered at charged tier.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.khaosodenglish.com/news/crimecourtscalamity/2026/03/21/seven-novice-monks-allege-sexual-abuse-by-former-bangkok-temple-monks/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "658299efe3a2a743c5f9253eaca16ccfc83a161b51f992ec967b717af90696a8",
"final_url": "https://www.khaosodenglish.com/news/crimecourtscalamity/2026/03/21/seven-novice-monks-allege-sexual-abuse-by-former-bangkok-temple-monks/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.chiangraitimes.com/hot-news/police-arrest-monks-in-bangkok/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eee6adfa0957105d22fe633c5ba1cd00de38af11eb6673e6cca42c9e6dc4776a",
"final_url": "https://www.chiangraitimes.com/hot-news/police-arrest-monks-in-bangkok/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 723,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in English from Thaiger's report of 24 October 2025, part of the same broader wave of 2025-2026 Thai monastic-abuse cases as the Bangkok/Sathon and Songkhla records in this batch, but a distinct temple, distinct victims and distinct timeline. No outlet consulted names either the monk or the temple.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-bueng-kan-monk-novices-thailand",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Bueng Kan Province, Thailand",
"lat": 18.3609,
"lng": 103.6467,
"title": "Thailand: monk surrenders to police after abusing four novices for seven months and attempting to buy their families' silence",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"Unnamed Buddhist monk, temple in Bueng Kan Province, Thailand (name not published in reporting)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his monastic authority over novices aged 13-16 under his supervision at the temple",
"physical violence — beating novices who resisted — used to compel compliance over a seven-month period",
"instructing the novices to recruit more boys into the temple as novices, expanding his pool of potential victims through the same institutional structure",
"an attempted payoff of 300,000 baht offered by high-ranking monks to victims' families to secure silence and drop the matter, following the same institutional chain of authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Buddhist temple, Bueng Kan Province (name not published in reporting)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Thai police, Bueng Kan Province",
"stage": "suspect surrendered to police following disrobing; investigation ongoing",
"date": "2025-10-23",
"outcome": "At 1am on 23 October 2025 the accused monk disrobed and surrendered to police later the same day, following accusations he abused four novices aged 13-16 over a seven-month period, forcing them into oral sex and other acts and beating those who resisted. He also reportedly pressured the boys to recruit additional novices to the temple. Two novices escaped the abuse by having their families claim sick relatives needed visiting; the remaining victims were relocated for safety once the investigation began. High-ranking monks separately attempted to settle the matter by offering the victims' families 300,000 baht, which the families refused and instead recorded as evidence. The suspect denied all allegations upon surrender; as of the 24 October 2025 reporting the case outcome had not been determined. Entered at active-investigation tier pending any later charge or verdict confirmation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were novices under the monk's direct monastic supervision at his own temple; his authority extended even to directing them to recruit further victims into the same institutional structure, and the subsequent hush-money attempt came through the temple's own senior hierarchy, showing the institutional authority operating on both the harm and its attempted concealment.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://thethaiger.com/hot-news/crime/thai-monk-arrested-for-sexual-abuse-of-4-novices-in-bueng-kan",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thaiger, 'Thai monk arrested for sexual abuse of 4 novices in Bueng Kan'.",
"body": "Full account of the seven-month abuse pattern, the beatings, the recruitment pressure, the attempted 300,000 baht settlement, and the 23 October 2025 surrender.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "At 1am on 23 October 2025 the accused monk disrobed and surrendered to police later the same day, following accusations he abused four novices aged 13-16 over a seven-month period, forcing them into oral sex and other acts and beating those who resisted. He also reportedly pressured the boys to recruit additional novices to the temple. Two novices escaped the abuse by having their families claim sick relatives needed visiting; the remaining victims were relocated for safety once the investigation began. High-ranking monks separately attempted to settle the matter by offering the victims' families 300,000 baht, which the families refused and instead recorded as evidence. The suspect denied all allegations upon surrender; as of the 24 October 2025 reporting the case outcome had not been determined. Entered at active-investigation tier pending any later charge or verdict confirmation.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://thethaiger.com/hot-news/crime/thai-monk-arrested-for-sexual-abuse-of-4-novices-in-bueng-kan",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6d5b1be8a1de6d23f4da8807ed1f6c0181809497496efffb529714ff6eea5957",
"final_url": "https://thethaiger.com/hot-news/crime/thai-monk-arrested-for-sexual-abuse-of-4-novices-in-bueng-kan"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 724,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced in English from Thaiger's report of the 26 June 2026 investigation order. This is the third and most recent of three distinct 2025-2026 Thai monastic-abuse cases identified in this pass (with Bangkok/Sathon and Bueng Kan above); each involves a different temple, region and set of victims. No outlet consulted names the abbot or the temple. Entered at the lowest evidence tier of the three (active-investigation, no charges yet) and should be revisited for upgrade if charges or a verdict are later reported.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-songkhla-monk-novices-thailand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Ban Phru subdistrict, Hat Yai district, Songkhla Province, Thailand",
"lat": 6.9928,
"lng": 100.4675,
"title": "Thailand: temple emptied of monks and novices as police investigate an abbot after four novices report repeated sexual abuse",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"Unnamed abbot (and an older novice separately implicated toward younger boys), temple in Ban Phru subdistrict, Hat Yai district, Songkhla Province"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the abbot's institutional authority over novices aged 13-14 resident at the temple",
"use of a shared sleeping/working hall within the temple as the location where the boys were repeatedly forced into sexual acts"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Buddhist temple, Ban Phru subdistrict, Hat Yai district, Songkhla (name not published in reporting)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Thai police, Songkhla Province",
"stage": "active investigation ordered",
"date": "2026-06-26",
"outcome": "On 26 June 2026 Police Major General Thirasak Chaiyotha ordered an active investigation into the temple's abbot after four novices, aged 13-14, reported being forced to perform sexual acts inside a hall used for sleeping and working at the temple on multiple occasions since January 2026, with a report that an older novice had separately directed similar conduct toward the younger boys. The investigation followed complaints filed by guardians after one boy fled the temple on 24 June 2026. The abbot initially denied the allegations and was reported unreachable by phone. The remaining six novices were relocated to another temple, leaving the facility without monks or novices. No charges had been filed as of the sources consulted; entered at active-investigation tier."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The four novices were resident minors under the abbot's direct institutional authority and physically housed within his temple; the shared dormitory/work hall that authority controlled is where the abuse is alleged to have repeatedly occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://thethaiger.com/news/national/songkhla-monk-under-investigation-as-four-novices-report-sexual-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thaiger, 'Songkhla monk under investigation as four novices report sexual abuse'.",
"body": "Full account of the four novices' ages and allegations, the dormitory/work-hall location, the investigation order, the abbot's denial, and the relocation of the remaining novices.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "On 26 June 2026 Police Major General Thirasak Chaiyotha ordered an active investigation into the temple's abbot after four novices, aged 13-14, reported being forced to perform sexual acts inside a hall used for sleeping and working at the temple on multiple occasions since January 2026, with a report that an older novice had separately directed similar conduct toward the younger boys. The investigation followed complaints filed by guardians after one boy fled the temple on 24 June 2026. The abbot initially denied the allegations and was reported unreachable by phone. The remaining six novices were relocated to another temple, leaving the facility without monks or novices. No charges had been filed as of the sources consulted; entered at active-investigation tier.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://thethaiger.com/news/national/songkhla-monk-under-investigation-as-four-novices-report-sexual-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6714d76073097e22075c59e48528b93192d8fd86a43702916738f40669d533df",
"final_url": "https://thethaiger.com/news/national/songkhla-monk-under-investigation-as-four-novices-report-sexual-abuse"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 725,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Guilty plea in Oklahoma for conduct that occurred in Oklahoma; Morris's Texas ministry (Gateway Church) is stated as background, not the harm location.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-robert-morris-gateway-church-oklahoma-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Pawhuska, Osage County, Oklahoma, USA",
"lat": 36.66,
"lng": -96.3339,
"title": "United States: Gateway Church founder Robert Morris pleads guilty to child sexual abuse of a girl in his ministerial care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"a travelling evangelist and family friend staying in the victim's home who went on to found Gateway Church, one of the largest congregations in the United States, and served on a presidential evangelical advisory board"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a child's family opening their home to a visiting minister on the strength of his religious standing",
"four years of repeated access secured entirely through the family's trust in his ministerial role",
"decades of public silence enabled by his continued rise as a nationally prominent pastor"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Gateway Church, Southlake, Texas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Osage County District Court, Oklahoma",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2025-10-02",
"outcome": "Robert Morris, 64, pleaded guilty before Judge Cindy Pickerill to five felony counts of lewd or indecent acts with a child, admitting to abuse that began in 1982 when the victim, Cindy Clemishire, was 12 years old and continued for four years while he stayed with her family as a travelling evangelist in Hominy, Oklahoma. Under a negotiated plea agreement he received a 10-year sentence, of which he served six months in county jail followed by nine and a half years of probation, was ordered to pay $270,000 in restitution, and must register as a sex offender."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A minister given a family's home and trust because of his ministerial role used that access to abuse their daughter for four years; the same religious standing that opened the door protected him from consequence for four decades until his victim spoke publicly in 2024.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/robert-morris-guilty-child-sexual-abuse-texas-megachurch-pastor-rcna234748",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NBC News, 2 Oct 2025.",
"body": "Guilty plea to five felony counts.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/robert-morris-gateway-church-sexual-abuse-case-oklahoma/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News Texas, 2 Oct 2025.",
"body": "Sentence, restitution and probation terms.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://oklahoma.gov/oag/news/newsroom/2025/october/megachurch-founder-pleads-guilty-to-child-sex-abuse-charges.html",
"citation": "Oklahoma Office of the Attorney General, newsroom release, 2 Oct 2025.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press",
"body": "Official state prosecutor release confirming the guilty plea to five felony counts of lewd or indecent acts with a child, the negotiated 10-year sentence with six months served in Osage County Jail, nine and a half years of Texas probation, $270,000 restitution to Cindy Clemishire, and sex-offender registration requirement."
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/robert-morris-guilty-child-sexual-abuse-texas-megachurch-pastor-rcna234748",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7ee1d78da78b467313187a63633e1e5fb56384d37e6da8afd6b59091387cf624",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/robert-morris-guilty-child-sexual-abuse-texas-megachurch-pastor-rcna234748"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/robert-morris-gateway-church-sexual-abuse-case-oklahoma/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cbc77cc4928cc778e744938fac6b25de6d7e573a8f704844473a8994711944c6",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/robert-morris-gateway-church-sexual-abuse-case-oklahoma/"
},
{
"source": "https://oklahoma.gov/oag/news/newsroom/2025/october/megachurch-founder-pleads-guilty-to-child-sex-abuse-charges.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "43f234063982a5acaa3c6a1f65b8e773ec06c5aed8320eb30a378fd99591a133",
"final_url": "https://oklahoma.gov/oag/news/newsroom/2025/october/megachurch-founder-pleads-guilty-to-child-sex-abuse-charges.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 726,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sentence not yet imposed at time of writing (scheduled Sep 2026); the jury verdict itself is the conviction event recorded here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-eddy-noelsaint-osceola-florida-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Osceola County, Florida, USA",
"lat": 28.2639,
"lng": -81.4076,
"title": "United States: Osceola County pastor found guilty of raping a church member who sought spiritual guidance",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a congregation the victim had recently joined for spiritual guidance and revival"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"assignment of a 'spiritual godmother' (the pastor's own wife) as part of the victim's baptism, binding her further into the household",
"hosting the victim in his home as part of a spiritual-revival process",
"use of pills to incapacitate her before the first assault"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Osceola County, Florida — circuit court",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "2026-07-01",
"outcome": "Eddy Noelsaint, 54, was found guilty on four counts of sexual battery against a member of his congregation. The assaults occurred in 2022 after the victim joined his church; she said Noelsaint first raped her while she was staying at his home as part of her 'spiritual revival,' after giving her pills that left her unable to resist, and raped her again months later. Sentencing was scheduled for 11 Sep 2026."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A new congregant, placed in the pastor's own household as part of a church-sanctioned spiritual process and assigned his wife as her 'spiritual godmother,' was raped by the man whose religious authority had arranged that access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2026/07/10/osceola-county-pastor-convicted-of-raping-church-member-who-sought-spiritual-guidance/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ClickOrlando/WKMG, 10 Jul 2026.",
"body": "Verdict, four counts, sentencing date.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wftv.com/news/local/osceola-county-pastor-found-guilty-drugging-sexually-assaulting-church-member-investigators-say/X7FQITJ5PFC47EQ7YZIDUAJGXU/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WFTV9, Jul 2026.",
"body": "Circumstances of the assaults and the 'spiritual godmother' detail.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2026/07/10/osceola-county-pastor-convicted-of-raping-church-member-who-sought-spiritual-guidance/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "99adf486b6c68418f098823e71505ddc6049f74aebb231ae0aafdb5e62bd81ee",
"final_url": "https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2026/07/10/osceola-county-pastor-convicted-of-raping-church-member-who-sought-spiritual-guidance/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wftv.com/news/local/osceola-county-pastor-found-guilty-drugging-sexually-assaulting-church-member-investigators-say/X7FQITJ5PFC47EQ7YZIDUAJGXU/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "77365d523a146cef8ff5b82429187bad6277af5d5db63019f5c0e5ce1313644e",
"final_url": "https://www.wftv.com/news/local/osceola-county-pastor-found-guilty-drugging-sexually-assaulting-church-member-investigators-say/X7FQITJ5PFC47EQ7YZIDUAJGXU/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 727,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jonathan-elwing-manatee-florida-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Manatee County, Florida, USA",
"lat": 27.4799,
"lng": -82.5748,
"title": "United States: former Manatee County senior pastor gets triple life sentence for child rape and abuse material",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior pastor of Palm View First Baptist Church, Palmetto, Florida"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing within the congregation used to secure unsupervised access to a young child"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Palm View First Baptist Church, Palmetto, Florida"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Manatee County, Florida — circuit court",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2026-04-21",
"outcome": "Jonathan Edward Elwing, 45, former senior pastor of Palm View First Baptist Church, was found guilty on 12 charges including capital sexual battery, lewd or lascivious molestation, and production/possession of child sexual abuse material, and was sentenced to three consecutive life terms. Investigators found on his phone a video of him abusing a 2-year-old."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A senior pastor's standing in his own congregation gave him the unsupervised access to a young child that made the abuse possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wfla.com/news/local-news/manatee-county/former-manatee-county-pastor-gets-triple-life-sentence-for-child-rape-csam-charges/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WFLA, Apr 2026.",
"body": "Verdict, 12 counts, triple life sentence.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wfla.com/news/local-news/manatee-county/former-manatee-county-pastor-gets-triple-life-sentence-for-child-rape-csam-charges/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 728,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Louisiana extradition/prosecution outcome not located at time of writing; not asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-michael-goble-adrian-michigan-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Adrian, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 41.897,
"lng": -84.0372,
"title": "United States: former Adrian, Michigan pastor sentenced for sex crimes against boys at his church and its juvenile campus",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the now-defunct Church of the Good Shepherd, Adrian, Michigan, with access to boys through the church-affiliated Maurice Spears Juvenile Campus"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and institutional access to young boys through a church-affiliated juvenile facility"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of the Good Shepherd, Adrian, Michigan"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lenawee County, Michigan — circuit court",
"stage": "no-contest plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-06",
"outcome": "Michael Ronald Goble, 77, was sentenced to 10 to 15 years in prison after pleading no contest to three counts of criminal sexual conduct against young boys, at least one specifying a victim under 13; five further counts from the same investigation were dismissed at sentencing. He also faced an outstanding Louisiana warrant for child molestation and was to be extradited to face those charges."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Multi-victim abuse of boys given to his supervision through his church and its affiliated juvenile campus, over a period spanning at least three separate criminal cases.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wtol.com/article/news/local/former-adrian-pastor-sentenced-to-10-15-years-for-criminal-sexual-conduct/512-c4fc74c8-d48e-4444-9080-42484a19b4cc",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WTOL, Feb 2026.",
"body": "Sentence, plea, and case detail.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://churchleaders.com/news/2213261-michael-ronald-goble-sentenced-10-15-years.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Church Leaders, Feb 2026.",
"body": "Juvenile-campus access and prior charge count.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wtol.com/article/news/local/former-adrian-pastor-sentenced-to-10-15-years-for-criminal-sexual-conduct/512-c4fc74c8-d48e-4444-9080-42484a19b4cc",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://churchleaders.com/news/2213261-michael-ronald-goble-sentenced-10-15-years.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6bd4cc4883cabc97b0f73a8bb30b3dd8b73047aab7a90d92b617a23bfe2bbb12",
"final_url": "https://churchleaders.com/news/2213261-michael-ronald-goble-sentenced-10-15-years.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 729,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-rodney-locklear-greene-county-virginia-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Ruckersville, Greene County, Virginia, USA",
"lat": 38.2379,
"lng": -78.3805,
"title": "United States: Virginia pastor sentenced for sexually abusing a minor and embezzling church funds",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Victory Church, Ruckersville, Virginia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a minor within his own congregation, combined with financial control over church funds"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Victory Church, Ruckersville, Virginia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Greene County Circuit Court, Virginia",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-05",
"outcome": "Rodney Locklear, 49, pastor of Victory Church, pleaded guilty in September 2025 to 12 charges including child endangerment, sexual abuse of a minor, and eight counts of embezzlement from the church. Judge David Barredo sentenced him to 10 years in prison on 5 Jan 2026. The church closed following his February 2025 arrest."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A pastor's control over both a minor congregant and the church's finances within a single small congregation, exercised until the church itself collapsed on his arrest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.29news.com/2026/01/06/former-greene-county-pastor-sentenced-10-years-sexual-abuse-embezzlement/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WVIR/29News, Jan 2026.",
"body": "Sentence, charges, plea date.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.29news.com/2026/01/06/former-greene-county-pastor-sentenced-10-years-sexual-abuse-embezzlement/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d66a827ef2d9e065200cdf718e43717fc325130932ea0524533ddd1944c24d39",
"final_url": "https://www.29news.com/2026/01/06/former-greene-county-pastor-sentenced-10-years-sexual-abuse-embezzlement/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 730,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "County/court and precise plea date not confirmed in located press; the year given is the reporting year, not a placeholder day-level date.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-jordan-baird-virginia-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Virginia, USA",
"lat": 37.4316,
"lng": -78.6569,
"title": "United States: Virginia youth pastor pleads guilty to indecent acts with a teenager from his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor with custodial responsibility for the teenage victim through the church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial authority over a teenage congregant in the youth ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Virginia — circuit court (county not confirmed in press)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"outcome": "Jordan Baird, a youth pastor who had faced up to 10 years, was sentenced to three years in prison plus three years' probation after pleading guilty to two counts of indecent acts with a child by a custodian, for abusing a teenager from his church."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A youth pastor's custodial authority over a congregant teenager, the exact relationship the 'custodian' charge itself names.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fox5dc.com/news/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-3-years-for-sexually-abusing-teen-from-church",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FOX 5 DC.",
"body": "Sentence, charges, custodian statute.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fox5dc.com/news/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-3-years-for-sexually-abusing-teen-from-church",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dbdb75444738b05a5a3fed4c8bc7b120c0a5112041b5c473fc109bf982ece3d9",
"final_url": "https://www.fox5dc.com/news/former-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-3-years-for-sexually-abusing-teen-from-church"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 731,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Precise sentencing date not confirmed in located press beyond the reporting year; not asserted as a specific day.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-ryan-mcelrath-jackson-tennessee-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Jackson, Tennessee, USA",
"lat": 35.6145,
"lng": -88.814,
"title": "United States: Jackson, Tennessee youth pastor sentenced for sexual relationship with a 17-year-old congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor at Fellowship Bible Church, Jackson, Tennessee"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a youth pastor's ongoing access to and trust with a teenage congregant, exploited through sustained text communication and travel across three counties to continue the relationship"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Fellowship Bible Church, Jackson, Tennessee"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Madison County and Henderson County, Tennessee — circuit courts",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Ryan McElrath, 40, youth pastor at Fellowship Bible Church from 2021 until his June 2024 arrest, was sentenced by Judge Kyle Atkins to 12 years on the Madison County indictment and 12 years on the Henderson County indictment, served consecutively for an effective 24-year sentence at 100%. He separately faced federal charges of coercion and enticement of a minor for using text messaging to communicate with the victim."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A youth pastor's standing and access within his own congregation were the channel through which a sustained sexual relationship with a 17-year-old member was formed and continued across multiple counties.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://roysreport.com/former-tn-youth-pastor-mcelrath-gets-24-year-prison-sentence-sex-crimes-against-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Roys Report.",
"body": "Sentence structure, counties, judge.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://talknwesttn.com/former-jackson-youth-pastor-sentenced-24-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Talk-N West TN.",
"body": "Church affiliation and dates of employment.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://roysreport.com/former-tn-youth-pastor-mcelrath-gets-24-year-prison-sentence-sex-crimes-against-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dcf27e3aadd3c311e12d29744f08c915804fcbd3a524dccd019b7cdf24a13670",
"final_url": "https://roysreport.com/former-tn-youth-pastor-mcelrath-gets-24-year-prison-sentence-sex-crimes-against-minor/"
},
{
"source": "https://talknwesttn.com/former-jackson-youth-pastor-sentenced-24-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b9b60a3fbabad16cd9048eb501ac759cf68b87e3f66bd0431842d32ed228891d",
"final_url": "https://talknwesttn.com/former-jackson-youth-pastor-sentenced-24-years/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 732,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Country tag follows harm location (Wisconsin) though the pastor's congregation and residence were in Minnesota, per this corpus's settled harm-location convention.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-michael-charles-princeton-wisconsin-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Town of Summit, Douglas County, Wisconsin, USA",
"lat": 46.4408,
"lng": -91.8154,
"title": "United States: former Minnesota pastor sentenced to life for repeated sexual assault of a child at his Wisconsin cabin",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Neighbors to Nations church, Princeton, Minnesota"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a pastor's standing with a congregant family used to secure repeated private access to their child at his own cabin, sustained over five years"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Neighbors to Nations, Princeton, Minnesota"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Douglas County Circuit Court, Wisconsin",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-12",
"outcome": "Jeffrey Anthony Charles, 65, pastor of Neighbors to Nations church in Princeton, Minnesota, was convicted after a three-day trial (verdict 8 Jan 2026) and sentenced to life in prison with no possibility of release for the repeated sexual assault of a child at his cabin in the Town of Summit, Wisconsin, from 2005 to 2010, when the victim was aged 3 to 8. He had a prior 1997 Iowa conviction for third-degree sexual abuse. Prosecuted by the Douglas County District Attorney with the Wisconsin Department of Justice."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A pastor's congregation-based relationship with a family gave him the sustained private access — at his own cabin, over five years — that made the abuse of their young child possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.northernnewsnow.com/2026/05/12/former-princeton-pastor-sentenced-life-prison-repeated-sexual-assault-child/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Northern News Now, 12 May 2026.",
"body": "Sentence, trial date, prior conviction, prosecuting agencies.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fox9.com/news/former-minnesota-pastor-sentenced-life-child-sex-assault-wisconsin-cabin",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul.",
"body": "Cabin location and abuse timeline.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.northernnewsnow.com/2026/05/12/former-princeton-pastor-sentenced-life-prison-repeated-sexual-assault-child/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "731f4a2e03c06aa4cca725c27d3fcfc3215df736e4ec1799b2e2e5c2a7519b60",
"final_url": "https://www.northernnewsnow.com/2026/05/12/former-princeton-pastor-sentenced-life-prison-repeated-sexual-assault-child/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fox9.com/news/former-minnesota-pastor-sentenced-life-child-sex-assault-wisconsin-cabin",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "edeee549235aff98d471342ce81fb957cf62c541d8c209a5e952615420ea31be",
"final_url": "https://www.fox9.com/news/former-minnesota-pastor-sentenced-life-child-sex-assault-wisconsin-cabin"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 733,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Original more serious charges were dismissed on limitations grounds, not on the merits; only the surviving seven-count conviction is asserted here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-bradrick-vail-mobile-alabama-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Mobile, Alabama, USA",
"lat": 30.6944,
"lng": -88.0431,
"title": "United States: Mobile, Alabama pastor sentenced for sexual misconduct with two former church members",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Tree of Life Deliverance Ministry, Mobile, Alabama"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority invoked through prayer and scripture during the assaults themselves"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Tree of Life Deliverance Ministry, Mobile, Alabama"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mobile County Circuit Court, Alabama",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-04-08",
"outcome": "Bradrick Vail, formerly of Tree of Life Deliverance Ministry, was convicted of seven counts of sexual misconduct against two former church members, after Circuit Judge Jill Phillips dismissed five more serious charges (three counts of first-degree rape, three of sexual abuse, one of first-degree sodomy) on statute-of-limitations grounds. He was sentenced to two years in prison; the judge stated his conduct as a pastor was 'extremely disturbing.'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Assaults carried out under the invocation of prayer and scripture against members of his own congregation, using the authority the pastoral role itself supplied.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://1819news.com/news/item/mobile-pastor-sentenced-to-two-years-in-sexual-misconduct-case",
"archive": "",
"citation": "1819 News, Apr 2025.",
"body": "Conviction, dismissed counts, sentence, judge's statement.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fox10tv.com/2025/04/08/mobile-pastor-convicted-sexual-misconduct-sentenced-two-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FOX10 Mobile, 8 Apr 2025.",
"body": "Prayer/Bible framing of the assaults.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://1819news.com/news/item/mobile-pastor-sentenced-to-two-years-in-sexual-misconduct-case",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d5e6ca239678037ce5d75a987b5f7dee965ffc14ccd648f6ff1bb641ed5c6c17",
"final_url": "https://1819news.com/news/item/mobile-pastor-sentenced-to-two-years-in-sexual-misconduct-case"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fox10tv.com/2025/04/08/mobile-pastor-convicted-sexual-misconduct-sentenced-two-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c3629f52a15b5e8270947ee4b677848d9d6835e99be7184724e6eb42ed826e1c",
"final_url": "https://www.fox10tv.com/2025/04/08/mobile-pastor-convicted-sexual-misconduct-sentenced-two-years/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 734,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sentencing date not confirmed beyond reporting year in located press.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-lindsey-whiteside-hernando-mississippi-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Hernando, Mississippi, USA",
"lat": 34.8362,
"lng": -89.9987,
"title": "United States: Mississippi youth pastor pleads guilty to sexual battery of a teenager she was mentoring",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor at Getwell Church, Hernando, Mississippi, in a formal mentoring and counseling role over the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a formal position of trust as the victim's church-appointed mentor and counselor"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Getwell Church, Hernando, Mississippi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "DeSoto County, Mississippi — circuit court",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"outcome": "Lindsey Whiteside, former youth pastor at Getwell Church, pleaded guilty to one count of sexual battery and was sentenced to three years of house arrest followed by seven years of supervised release; she must register as a child sex offender for life. The crimes occurred while the victim was being mentored and counseled by Whiteside in her position of trust within the church. District Attorney Matthew Barton, who had sought a 30-year sentence, publicly called the outcome an 'abomination.'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A church-designated mentoring and counseling relationship — the position of trust the prosecution itself named — was the channel of the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://julieroys.com/mississippi-da-calls-light-sentence-for-youth-pastor-who-sexually-assaulted-a-girl-an-abomination/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Roys Report.",
"body": "DA's statement, sentence, position-of-trust framing.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fox13memphis.com/news/former-mississippi-youth-pastor-who-admitted-to-sex-crime-sentenced-to-house-arrest-da-says/article_d9b12dde-8dc7-44b0-8bf8-18feb76a13e0.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fox13 Memphis.",
"body": "Church affiliation, mentoring role.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://julieroys.com/mississippi-da-calls-light-sentence-for-youth-pastor-who-sexually-assaulted-a-girl-an-abomination/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8218bd44272a14443ea106681b38d9d650f2db32de374240700580205c7150fd",
"final_url": "https://roysreport.com/mississippi-da-calls-light-sentence-for-youth-pastor-who-sexually-assaulted-a-girl-an-abomination/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fox13memphis.com/news/former-mississippi-youth-pastor-who-admitted-to-sex-crime-sentenced-to-house-arrest-da-says/article_d9b12dde-8dc7-44b0-8bf8-18feb76a13e0.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9be703edce3131e00a1c0b579544bb2baa6842e9218b93453a65263db508330b",
"final_url": "https://www.fox13memphis.com/news/former-mississippi-youth-pastor-who-admitted-to-sex-crime-sentenced-to-house-arrest-da-says/article_d9b12dde-8dc7-44b0-8bf8-18feb76a13e0.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 735,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-alexander-blackwelder-tupelo-mississippi-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Tupelo, Mississippi, USA",
"lat": 34.2576,
"lng": -88.7034,
"title": "United States: Tupelo youth minister convicted of sexual battery of a 16-year-old church member",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth minister at East Main Street Church of Christ, Tupelo, Mississippi"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a position of authority over the victim recognized by the applicable position-of-authority sexual-battery statute"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lee County Circuit Court, Mississippi",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2025-02-14",
"outcome": "Alexander Blackwelder, 28, former youth minister at East Main Street Church of Christ, Tupelo, pleaded guilty to two counts of sexual battery by a person in a position of authority against a 16-year-old church member. He was sentenced to 30 years per count with all but 10 years suspended, credited for nearly two years already served, and ordered to pay approximately $8,000 in court costs and fines; he must register as a sex offender."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Convicted under Mississippi's position-of-authority sexual-battery provision against a member of his own congregation — the youth minister's church role is the authority the statute itself required the prosecution to prove.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wjtv.com/news/state/former-mississippi-youth-pastor-sentenced-for-sexual-battery/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WJTV, 14 Feb 2025.",
"body": "Plea, sentence, church, victim age.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.djournal.com/news/crime-law-enforcement/former-youth-pastor-pleads-to-sexual-battery-of-church-member/article_0aeb224e-ea22-11ef-8e8c-e3a8a757a66a.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal.",
"body": "Church affiliation, county, sentencing detail.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wjtv.com/news/state/former-mississippi-youth-pastor-sentenced-for-sexual-battery/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.djournal.com/news/crime-law-enforcement/former-youth-pastor-pleads-to-sexual-battery-of-church-member/article_0aeb224e-ea22-11ef-8e8c-e3a8a757a66a.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "51b681733334caa867bbba6a12aa58894326adc77e6f61cdc5523bd29f59fc27",
"final_url": "https://www.djournal.com/news/crime-law-enforcement/former-youth-pastor-pleads-to-sexual-battery-of-church-member/article_0aeb224e-ea22-11ef-8e8c-e3a8a757a66a.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 736,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-terry-reed-terrytown-louisiana-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Terrytown, Jefferson Parish, Louisiana, USA",
"lat": 29.9174,
"lng": -90.0357,
"title": "United States: Terrytown, Louisiana pastor sentenced to 80 years for raping teenage boys he groomed through his ministry",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"operator of Vessels of Christ Ministry, Terrytown, Louisiana"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"targeting vulnerable teenage boys through his ministry and grooming them using scripture and religious teaching",
"claiming that sexual acts with him provided the 'covering of Jesus' and protection from evil"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Vessels of Christ Ministry, Terrytown, Louisiana"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jefferson Parish, Louisiana — 24th Judicial District Court",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-18",
"outcome": "Terry Reed, 66, operator of Vessels of Christ Ministry, was found guilty on 6 May 2026 of two counts of third-degree rape and two counts of molestation of a juvenile and was sentenced to 80 years in prison. He was already a registered sex offender at the time, having pleaded guilty in 1997 and again in 2017 to prior offenses against juveniles."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Reed used explicit doctrinal language — that sexual acts provided the 'covering of Jesus' — to frame the abuse itself as spiritually protective, the coercion mechanism operating directly through religious claim rather than merely alongside it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wwltv.com/article/news/local/jefferson/ex-terrytown-pastor-sentenced-to-80-years-for-abusing-teen-boys/289-09afb010-4f4a-47a1-b69c-70f382107126",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WWL-TV, Jun 2026.",
"body": "Sentence, verdict date, prior convictions.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/06/former-louisiana-pastor-sentenced-to-80-years-for-child-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org, Jun 2026.",
"body": "'Covering of Jesus' quote and grooming method.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wwltv.com/article/news/local/jefferson/ex-terrytown-pastor-sentenced-to-80-years-for-abusing-teen-boys/289-09afb010-4f4a-47a1-b69c-70f382107126",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/06/former-louisiana-pastor-sentenced-to-80-years-for-child-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "699bc9346ebbfb909969ca35747b0fd15bb8f7f9c53513ef16f2e817fd80ab24",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/06/former-louisiana-pastor-sentenced-to-80-years-for-child-sex-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 737,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-kevin-heffner-ruffin-north-carolina-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Ruffin, North Carolina, USA",
"lat": 36.4265,
"lng": -79.6912,
"title": "United States: North Carolina pastor and school principal sentenced for abuse of a student who was also a congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of Victory Baptist Church and principal of its affiliated private school, Ruffin, North Carolina"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"dual pastoral and educational authority over a minor who was both his student and a member of his congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Victory Baptist Church, Ruffin, North Carolina"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rockingham County Superior Court, North Carolina",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2018-11-29",
"outcome": "Kevin Scott Heffner, 48, pastor of Victory Baptist Church and principal of its affiliated Victory Church Academy, pleaded guilty to two felony counts of statutory sex offense with a child under 15 and 12 counts of disseminating obscene material to a minor, for a sexual relationship formed February to August with a 14-to-15-year-old student who was also a member of his congregation. He was sentenced to a minimum of 25 years in prison without parole and must register as a sex offender."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A single figure's combined pastoral and educational authority over the same child — his student and his congregant at once — removed any institutional channel through which she could have been believed.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://myfox8.com/news/pastor-principal-convicted-of-sex-offenses-against-a-minor-in-rockingham-county-gets-25-years-in-prison/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FOX8 WGHP, Nov 2018.",
"body": "Sentence, plea, dual role, charge counts.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://greensboro.com/rockingham_now/news/crime/ruffin-pastor-sentenced-to-years-in-prison-for-sex-offenses/article_175cee5e-f438-11e8-ac3f-e7ba570a7b9a.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Greensboro News & Record, Nov 2018.",
"body": "Victim age, timeline, sex-offender registration.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://myfox8.com/news/pastor-principal-convicted-of-sex-offenses-against-a-minor-in-rockingham-county-gets-25-years-in-prison/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://greensboro.com/rockingham_now/news/crime/ruffin-pastor-sentenced-to-years-in-prison-for-sex-offenses/article_175cee5e-f438-11e8-ac3f-e7ba570a7b9a.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 738,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-dallas-surrett-waynesville-north-carolina-usa",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Waynesville, North Carolina, USA",
"lat": 35.4887,
"lng": -82.9887,
"title": "United States: former Cove Creek Baptist Church youth pastor convicted of a lewd act against a girl from his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor at Cove Creek Baptist Church, Waynesville, North Carolina"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a youth pastor's standing and access within his own congregation, exploited against a young girl in his youth ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Cove Creek Baptist Church, Waynesville, North Carolina"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Haywood County, North Carolina — superior court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Dallas Sherman Surrett, former youth pastor at Cove Creek Baptist Church (Southern Baptist), was convicted of sexual offenses relating to a lewd and lascivious act against a young girl that occurred in 2005, and was sentenced to seven years in prison."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A youth pastor's access to a girl in his own congregation's youth ministry.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wcnc.com/article/news/local/southern-baptist-secret-accused-abuser-list-north-carolina-south-carolina/275-cc149511-285b-4d5d-a068-a0f55a4614d9",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WCNC, on the SBC abuser list.",
"body": "Conviction, sentence, church affiliation.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wcnc.com/article/news/local/southern-baptist-secret-accused-abuser-list-north-carolina-south-carolina/275-cc149511-285b-4d5d-a068-a0f55a4614d9",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 739,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not named in reporting for legal reasons, per UK convention; not asserted here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-ian-roper-hypnotherapist-bradford-uk",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Bradford, West Yorkshire, England, UK",
"lat": 53.7938,
"lng": -1.7524,
"title": "UK: hypnotherapist Ian Roper convicted after commanding a client under trance to undress",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"registered hypnotherapist conducting a paid one-on-one hypnosis session with a client"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"induced hypnotic trance used to convince the client she was on a hot sun bed and needed to apply imaginary sun cream to her body",
"the client's second-ever session with him, before she had any basis to doubt his instructions while under trance",
"the therapeutic setting itself, which gave his spoken suggestions the appearance of legitimate treatment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bradford Crown Court, England",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2022-09-30",
"outcome": "Ian Roper, 58, pleaded guilty to causing a person to engage in sexual activity without consent and to possession of five indecent images of children. Recorder David Gordon sentenced him to 29 months' imprisonment (25 months for the sexual offence, 4 months consecutive for the images), imposed a 10-year Sexual Harm Prevention Order banning him from working as a hypnotist or hypnotherapist, made him sign the sex offenders' register for 10 years, and imposed a restraining order against contacting the victim."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A client under Roper's induced hypnotic trance, during a paid therapeutic session, was told she was somewhere else entirely and acted on his spoken suggestions while unable to test them against her own judgment — the trance state itself was the instrument that made refusal impossible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/yorkshire-hypnotist-sexually-abused-client-25151284",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nadia Lincoln, \"Yorkshire hypnotist sexually abused client after 'telling her she was on a sun bed'\", YorkshireLive/ExaminerLive, 1 October 2022.",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of the sentencing, guilty plea, and trance mechanism used against the victim.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://uk.news.yahoo.com/ian-roper-hypnotherapist-jailed-145356627.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Hypnotherapist who made woman engage in sexual act while under his control is jailed\", PA Media via Yahoo News UK, 1 October 2022.",
"body": "Confirms sentence breakdown, Sexual Harm Prevention Order terms, and the ban on working as a hypnotherapist.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/yorkshire-hypnotist-sexually-abused-client-25151284",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "03a846c44165395443e8a6713af11db973c5e1496596d7818121ed5e4549787e",
"final_url": "https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/yorkshire-hypnotist-sexually-abused-client-25151284"
},
{
"source": "https://uk.news.yahoo.com/ian-roper-hypnotherapist-jailed-145356627.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0866d02f455b88b3e24f6369f8675c8f38c7639276690f6a907ae9232574662d",
"final_url": "https://uk.news.yahoo.com/ian-roper-hypnotherapist-jailed-145356627.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 740,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Defendant identified in Swiss press by first name and surname initial only (\"Mario K.\"), per standard Swiss reporting convention for privacy; full name not asserted. Exact verdict date not stated in available reporting — press coverage places the trial in June 2026 and the verdict shortly after; date omitted from proceedings rather than asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-mario-k-hypnotist-rorschach-switzerland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Rorschach, St. Gallen, Switzerland",
"lat": 47.4784,
"lng": 9.4936,
"title": "Switzerland: self-styled hypnosis coach convicted of sexually abusing two women he put in trance",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-employed hypnosis coach, practicing without state-recognized training in an unregulated profession, conducting paid trance sessions with clients"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"hypnotic trance induced during paid sessions, used to render the two women unable to resist or perceive what was happening to them",
"the unregulated status of the 'hypnosis coach' title in Switzerland, which let him operate without professional oversight or licensing accountability"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kreisgericht Rorschach, canton of St. Gallen, Switzerland",
"stage": "verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "Mario K., 60, was found guilty of Schändung (indecent assault / sexual abuse of a person incapable of resistance) in two cases, after putting the women in a hypnotic trance during sessions and sexually abusing them. He was sentenced to a 12-month suspended prison term and a three-year ban on practicing as a hypnotist. Prosecutors had sought six years three months' imprisonment and a lifetime professional ban; the defense had sought acquittal. K. had operated as an independent hypnosis coach since 2008 without recognized training — legal under Swiss law, as the profession is unregulated. The verdict is appealable to the cantonal court."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Two women placed in hypnotic trance during paid one-on-one sessions with the man they had come to for treatment, in a profession with no licensing body to have warned them off him — the trance was both his method of treatment and his method of assault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.blick.ch/schweiz/ostschweiz/st-gallen/frauen-in-trance-missbraucht-ostschweizer-hypnotiseur-wegen-schaendung-verurteilt-id22048514.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Frauen in Trance missbraucht: Ostschweizer Hypnotiseur wegen Schändung verurteilt\", Blick, 2026.",
"body": "Report of the Kreisgericht Rorschach verdict, sentence, and the trance mechanism.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tagblatt.ch/ostschweiz/stgallen/kreisgericht-rorschach-verurteilt-hypnotiseur-wegen-schaendung-zweier-frauen-ld.4187456",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Kreisgericht Rorschach verurteilt Hypnotiseur wegen Schändung zweier Frauen\", St. Galler Tagblatt, 2026.",
"body": "Regional paper of record confirming the same verdict and sentence.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.blick.ch/schweiz/ostschweiz/st-gallen/frauen-in-trance-missbraucht-ostschweizer-hypnotiseur-wegen-schaendung-verurteilt-id22048514.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a71693a333e90bdd6aa1c893095da707b3440dd5763a619178622c97e5d2cc42",
"final_url": "https://www.blick.ch/schweiz/ostschweiz/st-gallen/frauen-in-trance-missbraucht-ostschweizer-hypnotiseur-wegen-schaendung-verurteilt-id22048514.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.tagblatt.ch/ostschweiz/stgallen/kreisgericht-rorschach-verurteilt-hypnotiseur-wegen-schaendung-zweier-frauen-ld.4187456",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 741,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Defendant identified in Belgian press as \"Ivan V.L.\" per standard reporting convention withholding full surname; not asserted further. Exact sentence and precise conviction date not confirmed in available reporting (source dated to the trial phase); proceedings.date omitted rather than asserted. Flagged for a follow-up pass to confirm final disposition and sentence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-ivan-vl-hypnotherapist-kuurne-belgium",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Kuurne, West Flanders, Belgium",
"lat": 50.8556,
"lng": 3.2725,
"title": "Belgium: hypnotherapist convicted a second time of assaulting clients he had placed under hypnosis",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"practicing hypnotherapist conducting paid hypnosis sessions with clients"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"induced hypnotic trance used to prevent clients from resisting or realizing what was being done to them",
"repeat offending across multiple clients over several years before facing a second prosecution"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rechtbank van eerste aanleg (Correctionele rechtbank), Kortrijk, Belgium",
"stage": "conviction",
"outcome": "Ivan V.L., a 72-year-old hypnotherapist from Kuurne, was convicted of assault (aanranding) for touching several women on intimate parts of their bodies while he had placed them under hypnosis during treatment sessions, leaving them unable to resist. It was his second appearance before a Belgian court in three years on comparable allegations from clients. He attributed his conduct at trial to encroaching dementia."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Clients placed under hypnotic trance during paid treatment sessions, rendered unable to resist while he touched them — a repeat pattern across at least two prosecutions, with the hypnotic state itself functioning as the disabling mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dekrantenkoppen.be/detail/1318709/Hypnotherapeut-72-veroordeeld-voor-aanranding-patinten-Hij-bepotelde-hen-omdat-hij-dement-wordt.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Hypnotherapeut (72) veroordeeld voor aanranding patiënten: 'Hij bepotelde hen omdat hij dement wordt'\", De Krantenkoppen (aggregating Belgian regional press).",
"body": "Report of the conviction, the hypnosis mechanism, and the defendant's dementia claim.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://kw.be/nieuws/criminaliteit/hypnotherapeut-riskeert-twee-jaar-cel-voor-aanranding-van-clienten/article-normal-444853.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Hypnotherapeut riskeert twee jaar cel voor aanranding van cliënten\", Het Kortrijks Weekblad (KW), 10 June 2020.",
"body": "Regional paper of record on the prosecution, confirming this was his second appearance in court on client-assault allegations.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "proceeding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dekrantenkoppen.be/detail/1318709/Hypnotherapeut-72-veroordeeld-voor-aanranding-patinten-Hij-bepotelde-hen-omdat-hij-dement-wordt.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "255ea5c2c01cb98e76b5ec239621b5d6bb43485f12cf348b4e57ab6be4510b6f",
"final_url": "https://www.dekrantenkoppen.be/detail/1318709/Hypnotherapeut-72-veroordeeld-voor-aanranding-patinten-Hij-bepotelde-hen-omdat-hij-dement-wordt.html"
},
{
"source": "https://kw.be/nieuws/criminaliteit/hypnotherapeut-riskeert-twee-jaar-cel-voor-aanranding-van-clienten/article-normal-444853.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: proceeding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 742,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Defendant not named in available reporting (German press convention withholding full identity of convicted persons in ongoing-relevance reporting); not asserted. Sentencing reported as February 2015; exact day not stated in source, so proceedings.date is omitted rather than asserted with a placeholder day.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-bad-cannstatt-hypnoanalyst-stuttgart-germany",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Bad Cannstatt, Stuttgart, Germany",
"lat": 48.8047,
"lng": 9.2203,
"title": "Germany: self-styled 'depth-psychological hypnoanalyst' convicted of abusing two clients under hypnosis",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described depth-psychological hypnoanalyst running a private practice in Stuttgart, in a counseling/treatment relationship with paying clients"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"induced hypnosis used during a treatment session with a client being treated for childhood sexual-abuse trauma",
"exploitation of a counseling, treatment, or care relationship (a statutory aggravating element under German law) with a second, vulnerable client seeking help for depression and being overweight"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Amtsgericht Bad Cannstatt, Stuttgart, Germany",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "A 63-year-old man calling himself a depth-psychological hypnoanalyst was convicted of sexual abuse committed by exploiting a counseling, treatment, or care relationship, against two of his clients. In the first case (mid-May 2012) he placed a 43-year-old client under hypnosis during treatment for trauma from childhood sexual abuse and then abused her; in the second (mid-May 2013) he made unwanted advances against a client being treated for depression and weight issues. He was sentenced to two years three months' imprisonment, with no suspension of sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A client seeking treatment specifically for the aftermath of childhood sexual abuse was placed under hypnosis by the therapist she had turned to for help, and abused inside that same treatment relationship — the exploitation of a legally recognized care relationship was itself a statutory element of the conviction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.stuttgarter-nachrichten.de/inhalt.stuttgarter-therapeut-verurteilt-hypnotiseur-vergeht-sich-an-klientinnen.48acfc33-e14b-4f17-a924-b85830d2b875.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Stuttgarter Therapeut verurteilt: Hypnotiseur vergeht sich an Klientinnen\", Stuttgarter Nachrichten, February 2015.",
"body": "Report of the Amtsgericht Bad Cannstatt conviction, sentence, and both clients' treatment context.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.stuttgarter-nachrichten.de/inhalt.stuttgarter-therapeut-verurteilt-hypnotiseur-vergeht-sich-an-klientinnen.48acfc33-e14b-4f17-a924-b85830d2b875.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 743,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Candace Newmaker is the landmark rebirthing/holding-therapy death and is recorded under her own name per extensive public court and press identification at the time; this is consistent with existing corpus practice for named minors in cases of comparable public record depth (e.g. the existing satanic-panic child-witness records). Dedup-checked against the corpus before entry: no prior record for this case existed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2001-connell-watkins-julie-ponder-candace-newmaker-colorado-usa",
"year": 2001,
"place": "Evergreen, Colorado, USA (offense); Golden, Colorado, USA (trial)",
"lat": 39.6339,
"lng": -105.3269,
"title": "USA: two attachment-therapy practitioners convicted of reckless child abuse resulting in death of Candace Newmaker",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Connell Watkins, unlicensed attachment/'rebirthing' therapist running a paid two-week residential therapy intensive",
"Julie Ponder, co-therapist assisting the same session",
"two further unlicensed assistant-therapists present and participating, not separately charged with homicide"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a 70-minute 'rebirthing' procedure in which the child was wrapped tightly in a flannel blanket meant to represent a womb and told to fight her way out while four adults pushed on her body with their hands and feet",
"total physical restraint of a 10-year-old inside a residential therapeutic intensive her adoptive mother had paid roughly $7,000 for, with no ability for the child to stop the procedure or be heard when she said she could not breathe",
"the framing of suffocation and physical crushing as a legitimate clinical treatment for reactive attachment disorder"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Watkins' attachment-therapy practice, Evergreen, Colorado"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jefferson County District Court, Golden, Colorado, USA",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2001-06-18",
"outcome": "Connell Watkins and Julie Ponder were convicted of reckless child abuse resulting in death for the April 2000 death of 10-year-old Candace Newmaker during a 70-minute 'rebirthing' attachment-therapy session in which she was wrapped in a blanket and restrained by the two convicted therapists and two co-therapists, and asphyxiated. Both were sentenced to 16 years' imprisonment, the statutory minimum for the offense. The case prompted 'Candace's Law' in Colorado and a similar statute in North Carolina, criminalizing dangerous rebirthing re-enactments as a therapeutic technique."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child inside a paid, unlicensed therapeutic intensive was physically restrained and suffocated by the practitioners her adoptive mother had placed her under the total authority of, following a scripted 'rebirthing' procedure presented as legitimate treatment for her diagnosed attachment disorder — the therapeutic authority over the child was the entire mechanism of her death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rebirthing-therapist-sentenced/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Rebirthing Therapist Sentenced\", CBS News/AP, 2001.",
"body": "Report of the sentencing of Watkins and Ponder to 16 years each following conviction for reckless child abuse resulting in death.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Candace_Newmaker",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Death of Candace Newmaker\", Wikipedia, accessed 2026-07-19.",
"body": "Context source only, consistent with corpus policy of using Wikipedia for background/cross-referencing rather than as the evidentiary source for the conviction and sentence, which are drawn from the CBS/AP report above.",
"tier": "context",
"kind": "context"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rebirthing-therapist-sentenced/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "025be6513c604f59d020c55ae302c626a60a89d2317690d10e58d36f13813885",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rebirthing-therapist-sentenced/"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Candace_Newmaker",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: context; evidentiary role: context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dc297110d3d0681b269d66b875acd8a7a45a36a1b741c6d14a6a034d90defacf",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Candace_Newmaker"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 744,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"court": "Patna High Court",
"date": "2025-11-01",
"outcome": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Appellant's age given as approx. 55; district location inferred from the Vishnupad temple reference (Gaya). Exact original trial-court sentence length not confirmed in sources reviewed — only the appellate affirmance is asserted here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mohan-mishra-baba-gaya-bihar-india",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Gaya, Bihar, India",
"lat": 24.7955,
"lng": 84.9994,
"title": "India: 'Baba' convicted under POCSO for raping a girl he had drawn into temple worship visits",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"a self-styled religious guide known as 'Baba' who had built trust with the victim's family through temple worship visits"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a pattern of prior supervised temple visits (Mangla Gauri Temple, then Shitla Mata Temple near Vishnupad) undertaken with the mother's consent to build religious trust",
"use of that established religious-guidance relationship to isolate the victim under the pretext of a further act of worship, then take her to a hotel and rape her"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "India — Additional District & Sessions Judge (POCSO), Gaya, Bihar; appeal at Patna High Court",
"stage": "trial conviction affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2025-11-01",
"outcome": "Mohan Mishra, alias 'Baba', alias Pyara Mohan Mishra, was convicted under Sections 4, 8 and 12 of the POCSO Act and Section 376/34 IPC for raping a minor on 31 July 2020 after luring her from her home under the pretext of worship at Shitla Mata Temple near Vishnupad and taking her instead to a hotel. The Patna High Court, in Cr. App (DB) No. 443 of 2023 decided 1 November 2025, held the victim's testimony consistent, natural and requiring no further corroboration, and dismissed the appeal, affirming the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The perpetrator had spent weeks building religious credibility with the victim's mother through supervised temple-worship outings before using that same pretext — a further act of worship — to isolate and rape the victim; the abuse was only possible because the family had already ceded religious authority over her movements to him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://indiankanoon.org/doc/31042118/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mohan Mishra @ Baba @ Pyara Mohan Mishra vs The State Of Bihar, Patna High Court, Cr. App (DB) No. 443 of 2023, decided 1 November 2025.",
"body": "Patna High Court's affirmance of the POCSO conviction, summarizing the temple-pretext facts and the victim's testimony.",
"tier": "court-record",
"kind": "appellate-affirmance"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"court": "Patna High Court",
"date": "2025-11-01",
"outcome": "Appeal dismissed; conviction and sentence affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://indiankanoon.org/doc/31042118/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-record; evidentiary role: appellate-affirmance.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 745,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"court": "Kerala High Court",
"outcome": "Conviction upheld; sentence reduced from life (remainder of natural life) to 20 years RI without remission. Exact March 2024 date not confirmed to day-level precision in sources reviewed."
},
{
"court": "Supreme Court of India",
"date": "2024-02-07",
"outcome": "Bail granted and sentence suspended pending appeal (per Fr.Edwin Pigarez vs State Of Kerala, 7 February 2024)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Sentence-suspension by the Supreme Court is a bail order, not an acquittal or reversal — the underlying conviction as reduced by the Kerala High Court stands as the recorded disposition. Parish name not confirmed in sources reviewed. Note the Kerala HC reduction date is month-only ('March 2024') in sources reviewed; day-level date omitted per schema rule rather than guessed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-fr-edwin-pigarez-kerala-india",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ernakulam, Kerala, India",
"lat": 9.9816,
"lng": 76.2999,
"title": "India: Catholic vicar's conviction for raping a minor parishioner upheld by the Kerala High Court, sentence reduced",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Vicar of a Roman Catholic parish church, 2014-2015, with pastoral authority over the victim as a parishioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a parishioner family",
"access to the minor victim through his position as the church's vicar"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Church (parish not further specified in sources reviewed)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "India — Additional Sessions Court, Ernakulam (Special Court for cases of sexual violence against women and children); appeal at Kerala High Court",
"stage": "trial conviction, sentence reduced on appeal",
"outcome": "Fr. Edwin Pigarez, Vicar of a Roman Catholic church during 2014-2015, was convicted by the Additional Sessions Court, Ernakulam under provisions of the IPC and the POCSO Act for raping a minor parishioner, and sentenced to imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life. In March 2024 the Kerala High Court upheld the conviction but reduced the sentence to 20 years' rigorous imprisonment without remission. The Supreme Court subsequently granted him bail and suspended the sentence pending further proceedings."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a parishioner of the church where the accused served as Vicar; his pastoral office over the congregation is what placed her within his reach and authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://indiankanoon.org/doc/184937779/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fr.Edwin Pigarez vs State Of Kerala, Supreme Court of India, 7 February 2024 (bail/suspension order).",
"body": "Confirms the underlying Kerala High Court conviction-and-reduced-sentence disposition being appealed.",
"tier": "court-record",
"kind": "court-order"
},
{
"link": "https://lawbeat.in/top-stories/sc-grants-bail-suspends-life-term-of-catholic-priest-edwin-pigarez-convicted-for-raping-minor-girl-1518922",
"archive": "",
"citation": "LawBeat: 'SC Grants Bail, Suspends Life Term of Catholic Priest Edwin Pigarez Convicted for Raping Minor Girl.'",
"body": "Press account of the Supreme Court bail order and the underlying Kerala High Court conviction and sentence reduction.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"court": "Kerala High Court",
"outcome": "Conviction upheld; sentence reduced from life (remainder of natural life) to 20 years RI without remission. Exact March 2024 date not confirmed to day-level precision in sources reviewed."
},
{
"court": "Supreme Court of India",
"date": "2024-02-07",
"outcome": "Bail granted and sentence suspended pending appeal (per Fr.Edwin Pigarez vs State Of Kerala, 7 February 2024)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://indiankanoon.org/doc/184937779/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-record; evidentiary role: court-order.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://lawbeat.in/top-stories/sc-grants-bail-suspends-life-term-of-catholic-priest-edwin-pigarez-convicted-for-raping-minor-girl-1518922",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 746,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"court": "Tribunal de Justiça de São Paulo, 8ª Câmara de Direito Criminal",
"date": "2023-09-26",
"outcome": "Conviction affirmed; sentence increased from 136 to 175 years on prosecution appeal; defense acquittal appeal denied."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Distinct individual and case from the corpus's existing 2022 Sorocaba record (Vagner Meleiro, twelve terreiro members via simulated spirit incorporation) — different sentence figures (175 vs. that record's disposition) and this is an appellate ruling from Sept. 2023. Defendant's name not given in the source reviewed; flagged for a follow-up pass to confirm whether this is the same defendant under a different case citation or a second, separate Sorocaba-area prosecution — do not merge without confirming identity.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-vagner-sorocaba-second-pai-de-santo-sao-paulo-brazil",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Sorocaba, São Paulo, Brazil",
"lat": -23.5015,
"lng": -47.4526,
"title": "Brazil: appellate court raises a 'pai de santo's' sentence to 175 years for raping twelve women under cover of terreiro rituals",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"a man presenting as a 'pai de santo' (Candomblé spiritual father) running a terreiro (place of worship) attended by his victims"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a claimed spiritual-father role used to stage fraudulent ritual pretexts for sexual contact",
"repeated abuse of twelve separate women drawn to the terreiro as devotees"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"terreiro (Candomblé house of worship), Sorocaba"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Brazil — 8ª Câmara de Direito Criminal, Tribunal de Justiça de São Paulo (TJ-SP)",
"stage": "trial conviction, sentence increased on prosecution appeal",
"date": "2023-09-26",
"outcome": "The defendant, presenting himself as a 'pai de santo,' was convicted at trial and sentenced to 136 years for raping twelve women through fraudulent ritual pretexts under cover of his religious role. On prosecution appeal, the 8ª Câmara de Direito Criminal of the TJ-SP increased the cumulative sentence to 175 years on 26 September 2023 (individual sentences are capped at 40 years' actual service under Brazilian Penal Code art. 75). The defense's appeal for acquittal was denied. Rapporteur Judge Ely Amioka found the defendant 'exploited the faith of victims'; a legitimate Candomblé priest testified at trial that the sexual conduct alleged violated the religion's actual practice."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Twelve women were drawn into fraudulent 'rituals' staged specifically because he held himself out as their terreiro's spiritual father — the religious framing is what obtained their submission, as the court's own findings and the corroborating priest's testimony establish.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.amazonasdireito.com.br/tj-sp-eleva-para-175-anos-pena-de-falso-pai-de-santo-por-estuprar-12-mulheres/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'TJ-SP eleva para 175 anos pena de falso pai de santo por estuprar 12 mulheres,' Amazonas Direito, reporting the 26 September 2023 TJ-SP 8ª Câmara de Direito Criminal ruling.",
"body": "Appellate ruling text summary: sentence increase, rapporteur's reasoning, and the corroborating Candomblé priest's testimony.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"court": "Tribunal de Justiça de São Paulo, 8ª Câmara de Direito Criminal",
"date": "2023-09-26",
"outcome": "Conviction affirmed; sentence increased from 136 to 175 years on prosecution appeal; defense acquittal appeal denied."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.amazonasdireito.com.br/tj-sp-eleva-para-175-anos-pena-de-falso-pai-de-santo-por-estuprar-12-mulheres/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c00e9de775212b77be3aa50f24b4776897736ba5dc9bb3a74b1e372a21e21a7e",
"final_url": "https://www.amazonasdireito.com.br/tj-sp-eleva-para-175-anos-pena-de-falso-pai-de-santo-por-estuprar-12-mulheres/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 747,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Appeal status and final-conviction status not confirmed in sources reviewed; recorded as a first-instance criminal conviction. Full name and disposition of the female co-defendant not confirmed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-sinval-ferreira-samambaia-df-brazil",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Samambaia, Federal District, Brazil",
"lat": -15.8752,
"lng": -48.0776,
"title": "Brazil: self-declared prophet convicted of coercing followers into sex through fraudulent 'curse-breaking' rituals",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-declared prophet/pastor claiming divine revelations of impending tragedies to his congregation and social-media following"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false claims of prophetic foreknowledge of family deaths/tragedies used to induce fear",
"fraudulent 'unção' (anointing) rituals involving victims' intimate body parts framed as the only means to break the prophesied 'curse'",
"a second pastor (58, female) acting as accomplice, reinforcing the prophecies to followers and threatening them if sexual demands were not met",
"extortion of large sums from the same followers for the church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [
"Sinval Ferreira's church, Samambaia, Federal District"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Brazil — 2ª Vara Criminal de Samambaia, Federal District",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2025-03-19",
"outcome": "Sinval Ferreira, 41, was convicted of sexual coercion through fraud (posse sexual mediante fraude) and extortion of church followers, and sentenced to 11 years and 3 months' imprisonment. He had been arrested in 2024 by the Civil Police of the Federal District. A female accomplice, also a pastor at the church, was implicated in reinforcing the fraudulent prophecies and threats to followers."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Followers submitted to sexual 'anointing' rituals and paid extortionate sums because Ferreira had established himself as a prophet with supernatural knowledge of tragedies that would befall their families unless the ritual was performed — the coercive power was entirely a function of his claimed religious authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.metropoles.com/distrito-federal/na-mira/pastor-e-condenado-por-extorquir-fieis-e-coagi-los-a-transar-com-ele",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Metrópoles: 'Pastor é condenado por extorquir fiéis e coagi-los a transar com ele,' reporting the 19 March 2025 conviction by the 2ª Vara Criminal de Samambaia.",
"body": "Trial court conviction, sentence, and modus operandi (fraudulent prophecy and 'unção' ritual pretext).",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.folhadoestado.com.br/brasil/pastor-e-condenado-por-abusos-sexuais-e-beber-esperma-de-fieis-sob-pretexto-de-cura/632627",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Folha do Estado: parallel report on the same conviction and modus operandi ('unção da sacanagem').",
"body": "Corroborating press account of the same conviction.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.metropoles.com/distrito-federal/na-mira/pastor-e-condenado-por-extorquir-fieis-e-coagi-los-a-transar-com-ele",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fec1fe6bf3b34a46a8c94d0c92411f5adde2f0e3c2ddfc4a226633b7850f3688",
"final_url": "https://www.metropoles.com/distrito-federal/na-mira/pastor-e-condenado-por-extorquir-fieis-e-coagi-los-a-transar-com-ele"
},
{
"source": "https://www.folhadoestado.com.br/brasil/pastor-e-condenado-por-abusos-sexuais-e-beber-esperma-de-fieis-sob-pretexto-de-cura/632627",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2fed233af6a3a0ba1a6f845d281a73f7ec5ac00a81094e9b8b4e99e172797184",
"final_url": "https://www.folhadoestado.com.br/brasil/pastor-e-condenado-por-abusos-sexuais-e-beber-esperma-de-fieis-sob-pretexto-de-cura/632627"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 748,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; both prosecution and defense have appealed (prosecution for a longer sentence, defense contesting guilt) — not yet final. Additional complainants have come forward but are not yet reflected in any further charge or conviction in sources reviewed. Exact sentencing date not confirmed in sources reviewed (blocked by 403 on the primary source on re-check) — proceedings.date omitted rather than guessed; case publicly reported October 2025.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-binu-chollackal-paranagua-parana-brazil",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Paranaguá, Paraná, Brazil",
"lat": -25.5163,
"lng": -48.5225,
"title": "Brazil: Indian-born parish priest convicted of sexually abusing a parishioner during a spiritual counseling session",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Paróquia de Nossa Senhora dos Navegantes, Ilha dos Valadares, Paranaguá, Diocese of Paranaguá"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position of pastoral trust and religious authority used during a one-on-one spiritual counseling session",
"instructing those present to close their eyes during a prayer, using the moment to touch the victim"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Paróquia de Nossa Senhora dos Navegantes, Diocese of Paranaguá"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Brazil — comarca of Paranaguá, Paraná (court not further specified in sources reviewed)",
"stage": "trial conviction, prosecution appealing for a longer sentence",
"outcome": "Fr. Binu Joseph Chollackal, an Indian-born priest and former pastor of the parish, was convicted of importunação sexual (sexual harassment/imposition) against a 20-year-old parishioner who had come to the church on 11 February 2022 with her parents seeking spiritual help for depression. He was sentenced to 2 years and 11 months in semi-open regime, plus R$1,500 in damages. The sentencing court found he 'took advantage of his position of trust and religious authority to commit the abuse.' The case became public in October 2025 and additional complainants came forward to the Ministério Público do Paraná (MPPR) afterward. The MPPR has appealed for a harsher sentence; the defense contests the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim sought him out specifically in his capacity as priest, for spiritual counseling during a mental-health crisis; the court's own sentencing language identifies the abuse of his 'position of trust and religious authority' as the operative mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://jblitoral.com.br/cidades/padre-binu-e-condenado-a-quase-3-anos-por-importunacao-sexual-em-paranagua-entenda-a-sentenca/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "JB Litoral: 'Padre Binu é condenado a quase 3 anos por importunação sexual em Paranaguá; entenda a sentença.'",
"body": "Detailed account of the conviction, sentence, sentencing court's reasoning, and subsequent complainants.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.acidigital.com/noticia/67429/padre-indiano-da-diocese-de-paranagua-e-condenado-a-quase-tres-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ACI Digital (Catholic press): confirms the priest's Indian origin, Diocese of Paranaguá affiliation, and the conviction.",
"body": "Diocesan/Catholic-press corroboration of the conviction and the priest's parish role.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://jblitoral.com.br/cidades/padre-binu-e-condenado-a-quase-3-anos-por-importunacao-sexual-em-paranagua-entenda-a-sentenca/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "68411bbc3fea17c83c5522e7523a05c03b681e88180c4f8260a4b03d4df621da",
"final_url": "https://jblitoral.com.br/cidades/padre-binu-e-condenado-a-quase-3-anos-por-importunacao-sexual-em-paranagua-entenda-a-sentenca/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.acidigital.com/noticia/67429/padre-indiano-da-diocese-de-paranagua-e-condenado-a-quase-tres-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a7d03f5b3af4410bd9a6dda0171ebfebbdbbcb92e246e05b83402e0c65e9c502",
"final_url": "https://www.acidigital.com/noticia/67429/padre-indiano-da-diocese-de-paranagua-e-condenado-a-quase-tres-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 749,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Press describes this as the first sentence among multiple related processes against the same defendant; only this one is recorded here. Final/appeal status not confirmed in the source reviewed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jose-dorivaldo-teixeira-altamira-para-brazil",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Altamira, Pará, Brazil",
"lat": -3.2033,
"lng": -52.2064,
"title": "Brazil: ex-pastor sentenced to over 26 years for raping children of church members during congregation activities",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of an evangelical church in Altamira, with pastoral authority over the congregation and access to members' children through church activities"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"exploitation of parents' trust in his pastoral role to gain time alone with their children during church activities",
"pattern of abuse against at least five victims recognized by the court as continuous criminal conduct ('continuidade delitiva')"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"evangelical church, Altamira, Pará (name not specified in sources reviewed)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Brazil — comarca of Altamira, Pará; Tribunal de Justiça do Pará",
"stage": "trial conviction (first of multiple related proceedings)",
"date": "2026-05-20",
"outcome": "José Dorivaldo Teixeira, an ex-pastor under investigation since 2021, was convicted of rape of a vulnerable person and sexual violation through fraud against at least five victims, children of church members whom he accessed by exploiting parental trust during church activities. He was sentenced to more than 26 years' imprisonment in this first of what press described as a set of related proceedings; the court recognized continuidade delitiva (continuous criminal conduct) given the repeated pattern against multiple victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Parents entrusted their children to him specifically because he was their pastor; that trust, and the access to children it produced during official church activities, is what the court found he exploited repeatedly across at least five victims.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://dol.com.br/noticias/para/942283/ex-pastor-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-no-para",
"archive": "",
"citation": "DOL: 'Ex-pastor é condenado por estupro de vulnerável no Pará,' reporting the 20 May 2026 conviction in Altamira.",
"body": "Conviction, sentence, victim count and profile, and the court's continuidade delitiva finding.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://dol.com.br/noticias/para/942283/ex-pastor-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-no-para",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d6eb64fd8bc56a15dac0bab224030906b6d34cba9662ad1dc27ed221095647d1",
"final_url": "https://dol.com.br/noticias/para/942283/ex-pastor-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-no-para"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 750,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction only; defense appeal pending and outcome not yet known.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-sidney-basaglia-serra-negra-sao-paulo-brazil",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Serra Negra, São Paulo, Brazil",
"lat": -22.6103,
"lng": -46.6989,
"title": "Brazil: priest convicted of grooming and sexually abusing an altar server through the Diocese of Amparo",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Diocese of Amparo, São Paulo, with pastoral authority over an altar server (coroinha) recruited into that role"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"recruitment of the victim as an altar server, providing structured, sanctioned access",
"grooming via gifts and repeated private dinners after identifying the victim's interest in religious life"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Amparo, São Paulo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Brazil — comarca of Serra Negra, São Paulo (court not further specified in sources reviewed)",
"stage": "trial conviction, defense appealing",
"date": "2026-04-30",
"outcome": "Fr. Sidney Wilson Basaglia was convicted of sexual violation through fraud (violação sexual mediante fraude) against an adolescent altar server, for abuse occurring between 2014 and 2016 in Serra Negra and Guarulhos. He was sentenced in first instance to six years' imprisonment in initial semi-open regime; the ruling was divulged 30 April 2026. The Diocese of Amparo announced his temporary removal from ministry shortly after. The defense maintains his innocence and has an appeal pending, seeking acquittal on second-instance review."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest identified the victim's interest in religious life, recruited him as an altar server (coroinha) — a role of sanctioned proximity to the priest — and used the trust built through that pastoral relationship, gifts, and private dinners in the parish house to abuse him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.metropoles.com/sao-paulo/padre-violencia-sexual-coroinha",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Metrópoles: 'Padre é condenado por violência sexual contra coroinha de 14 anos.'",
"body": "Report of the conviction, sentence, and grooming pattern (gifts, private dinners, altar-server recruitment).",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
},
{
"link": "https://cbncampinas.com.br/2026/05/diocese-comunica-afastamento-de-padre-condenado-por-abuso-sexual-de-coroinha-em-serra-negra/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBN Campinas: 'Diocese comunica afastamento de padre condenado por abuso sexual de coroinha em Serra Negra.'",
"body": "Diocese of Amparo's confirmation of the conviction and the priest's temporary removal from ministry.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.metropoles.com/sao-paulo/padre-violencia-sexual-coroinha",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f95cc0039c9b42dc3b08111dbe102b8454d00133c7dd52e02e23f7e31db3c295",
"final_url": "https://www.metropoles.com/sao-paulo/padre-violencia-sexual-coroinha"
},
{
"source": "https://cbncampinas.com.br/2026/05/diocese-comunica-afastamento-de-padre-condenado-por-abuso-sexual-de-coroinha-em-serra-negra/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "In scope under the fraternal-youth-body reading of the criterion: victims were DeMolay chapter members under Shirley's recognized advisory authority, and that role (not an unrelated relationship) provided the access and cover. Distinguish from Tills (2009-buffalo-ny-usa, context-class): there, membership in a fraternal body was incidental to interstate Mann Act trafficking with no finding that the order's authority coerced the victims. Here, the DeMolay chapter-advisor relationship over its own underage members is squarely the mechanism.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1999-st-petersburg-fl-usa",
"year": 1999,
"place": "St. Petersburg, FL, USA",
"lat": 27.77,
"lng": -82.64,
"title": "US: DeMolay 'Chapter Dad' convicted on 27 counts, life sentence, for abusing his own chapter's teen members",
"tradition": "fraternal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1999/10/09/price-of-abuse-life-in-prison/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tampa Bay Times (1999) 'Price of abuse: life in prison', tampabay.com, 9 October. Available at: tampabay.com (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "St. Petersburg jury convicted John Shirley, adult volunteer 'Chapter Dad' of a DeMolay chapter (the Masonic-affiliated youth order), of 27 of 36 felony counts plus 13 misdemeanors for molesting 14 teenage boys who were members of the chapter under his supervision. He was sentenced to life in prison.",
"tier": "press-of-record",
"kind": "disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1998/12/23/demolay-had-warned-accused-man-before/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tampa Bay Times (1998) 'DeMolay had warned accused man before', tampabay.com, 23 December. Available at: tampabay.com (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Reports that DeMolay's national and state officials had been told a year before Shirley's arrest that he photographed chapter boys 'mooning' him at a Masonic camp, investigated, and concluded only that he had used 'bad judgment' — leaving him in his Chapter Dad position, during which the further abuse (later charged) continued.",
"tier": "press-of-record",
"kind": "context"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/2001/02/23/teen-sues-demolay-organization-over-molestation-by-leader/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tampa Bay Times (2001) 'Teen sues DeMolay organization over molestation by leader', tampabay.com, 23 February. Available at: tampabay.com (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Confirms the civil suit filed by one of Shirley's victims against DeMolay International following the criminal conviction, referencing the same underlying facts and Shirley's position of authority as chapter advisor.",
"tier": "press-of-record",
"kind": "context"
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"DeMolay chapter advisor ('Chapter Dad')"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"adult volunteer authority over a fraternal youth chapter",
"control of access to alcohol, camp trips, and chapter activities",
"organizational failure to remove him after a prior warning"
],
"organizations": [
"DeMolay International"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court, Pinellas County, Florida",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentencing",
"date": "1999-10-09",
"outcome": "Convicted on 27 of 36 felony counts and 13 misdemeanor counts; sentenced to life in prison."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Shirley held office as the chapter's adult advisor within DeMolay, a Masonic-affiliated youth fraternal order in which the Chapter Dad has recognized pastoral/mentorship authority over the boys and controls chapter activities (camps, initiations, outings). That structural authority over his own chapter's members — not merely acquaintance or coincidental membership — is what gave him sustained, unsupervised access to the victims and is the instrument the record documents.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "fraternal-orders",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1999/10/09/price-of-abuse-life-in-prison/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press-of-record; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5345053d9624a9022c010afaa4b63043021cf4baad1329a3f36e7312070de3ed",
"final_url": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1999/10/09/price-of-abuse-life-in-prison/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1998/12/23/demolay-had-warned-accused-man-before/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press-of-record; evidentiary role: context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8fb698a985869a775efa944da3bb947a1d6388afefe885879cc1990de5ed3b72",
"final_url": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/1998/12/23/demolay-had-warned-accused-man-before/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/2001/02/23/teen-sues-demolay-organization-over-molestation-by-leader/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press-of-record; evidentiary role: context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4f127d7870ab3166c14516fce94d6153b174b7f29de6f4658c519198bea53f25",
"final_url": "https://www.tampabay.com/archive/2001/02/23/teen-sues-demolay-organization-over-molestation-by-leader/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Virginia",
"outcome": "Conviction and death sentence affirmed, Lenz v. Commonwealth, 261 Va. 451, 544 S.E.2d 299 (Va. 2001); U.S. Supreme Court denied certiorari, 534 U.S. 1003 (2001)."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit",
"date": "2006-04-13",
"outcome": "Federal habeas relief denied, Lenz v. Washington, 444 F.3d 295 (4th Cir. 2006)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim, Brent Parker, was himself a fellow inmate and co-member of the Ironwood Kindred, the Asatru religious group Lenz had helped found and led as self-described 'high priest.' Court and press reporting describe Lenz killing Parker during the group's own blot ceremony over a doctrinal dispute — Parker's perceived disrespect toward the rite and a struggle over control of the kindred — which Lenz framed as blasphemy requiring death to protect the honor of the gods. This is recorded as an authority-abuse record because the killing occurred inside the group's own religious hierarchy and was carried out under religious pretext against a fellow initiate, not as outsider-directed ideological violence against a stranger; it is the same in-network-coercion shape as the corpus's existing Order of Nine Angles and 764-network records. It is NOT coded as a hate crime or prison-gang record — the racial/political dimension sometimes attached to Odinist prison groups is not asserted here because sourcing for this specific killing centers the religious-doctrinal dispute, not racial ideology.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2000-michael-lenz-ironwood-kindred-virginia-usa",
"year": 2000,
"place": "Craigsville, Augusta County, Virginia, USA",
"lat": 38.0615,
"lng": -79.3679,
"title": "United States: Asatru 'high priest' executed for ritually murdering a fellow member of his own prison kindred",
"tradition": "northern-traditional",
"traditionDetailId": "pagan-northern-traditional",
"type": "ritual-murder",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described high priest and co-founder of the Ironwood Kindred, an Asatru prison religious group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed religious authority to judge blasphemy against the group's rite",
"closed initiatory membership inside a prison religious group",
"doctrinal framing of killing a fellow member as sacred obligation"
],
"organizations": [
"Ironwood Kindred"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court of Augusta County, Virginia, USA",
"stage": "criminal conviction and capital sentence",
"outcome": "Michael William Lenz was convicted of capital murder for the killing of fellow inmate and Ironwood Kindred member Brent Parker, stabbed 68 times during an Asatru blot ceremony at Augusta Correctional Center on January 16, 2000, and sentenced to death; a co-defendant, Jeffrey Remington, received the same sentence and died by suicide on death row in 2004."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/virginia/supreme-court/2001/1002779.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lenz v. Commonwealth, 261 Va. 451, 544 S.E.2d 299 (Va. 2001).",
"body": "Virginia Supreme Court opinion affirming the capital murder conviction and death sentence, describing the killing during the group's religious ceremony.",
"tier": "primary-court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/pagan-prisoner-executed-in-va/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News/AP, 'Pagan Prisoner Executed In Va.' (2006).",
"body": "Contemporaneous press account of the Ironwood Kindred's structure, Lenz's role as high priest and co-founder, the doctrinal dispute with Parker over control and conduct of the group, and the killing during the blot ceremony.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-press",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.splcenter.org/resources/reports/supreme-court-requires-prisons-give-special-consideration-racist-pagans/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Southern Poverty Law Center, 'Supreme Court Requires Prisons Give Special Consideration to Racist Pagans.'",
"body": "Background on Odinist/Asatru prison religious groups, cited here only for context on the group structure, not for any racial-ideology claim about this specific killing.",
"tier": "advocacy-organization-report",
"kind": "background-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies Lenz's self-claimed authority as the kindred's high priest, the closed initiatory structure of the group, and his doctrinal framing of the killing as required to punish blasphemy against the group's own rite as the material spiritual doctrine, practice, authority, or pretext connected to the documented harm. The victim was a fellow member under the same claimed religious hierarchy, not an outsider.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"violent-occult-ideology"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Virginia",
"outcome": "Conviction and death sentence affirmed, Lenz v. Commonwealth, 261 Va. 451, 544 S.E.2d 299 (Va. 2001); U.S. Supreme Court denied certiorari, 534 U.S. 1003 (2001)."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit",
"date": "2006-04-13",
"outcome": "Federal habeas relief denied, Lenz v. Washington, 444 F.3d 295 (4th Cir. 2006)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/virginia/supreme-court/2001/1002779.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: primary-court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/pagan-prisoner-executed-in-va/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e0e54585114391a9c822e7f77f316617c3e34284b074521da02da7c61f3485f2",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/pagan-prisoner-executed-in-va/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.splcenter.org/resources/reports/supreme-court-requires-prisons-give-special-consideration-racist-pagans/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-organization-report; evidentiary role: background-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "90b9b572f581eb8f5d05574bfe191d1db91639ca3400d260f6fbf0433e8b7640",
"final_url": "https://www.splcenter.org/resources/reports/supreme-court-requires-prisons-give-special-consideration-racist-pagans/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Court (Yambol appellate circuit), Bulgaria",
"outcome": "Yambol District Court's sentence was upheld on appeal and is final; press reporting confirms the appellate outcome but does not give an exact appellate decision date."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim identities are not published in Bulgarian press reporting, per standard practice; the perpetrator is identified only as 'Zlatko D.' per Bulgarian court-reporting convention that withholds full surnames. Recorded as ordinary occult-fraud, not a state or political case — no persecution or ideological dimension is present. The exact first-instance sentencing date is not stated in available reporting, which is dated August 8, 2020 and describes the sentence as already final; the year field uses the reporting/conviction year rather than an unconfirmed exact date.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-zlatko-d-yasnovidets-yambol-bulgaria",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Yambol, Stara Zagora and Ruse regions, Bulgaria",
"lat": 42.4849,
"lng": 26.5083,
"title": "Bulgaria: self-styled clairvoyant-healer convicted of defrauding thirteen clients under fear of curses",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled clairvoyant, healer, folk-healer, 'sensory mediation operator' and 'phenomenologist'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed occult power to break curses and cure illness",
"advertising in pensioner and health-focused press targeting elderly and ill clients",
"fear of magical affliction used to extract money and valuables"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Yambol District Court, Bulgaria",
"stage": "criminal conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Zlatko D. was convicted of defrauding thirteen people across the Yambol, Stara Zagora and Ruse regions by posing as a clairvoyant, healer and 'phenomenologist' who could cure illness, break curses and solve family problems in exchange for money and valuables, causing losses exceeding 27,500 BGN; sentenced to three years' imprisonment. Reported as final and appeal-confirmed in press dated August 8, 2020."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bgonair.bg/a/166-kriminalno/200598-osadiha-na-3-godini-mazh-predstavyal-se-za-yasnovidets-i-lechitel",
"archive": "",
"citation": "bgonair.bg, 'Осъдиха на 3 години мъж, представял се за ясновидец и лечител' (court-reporting).",
"body": "Bulgarian press report of the final, appeal-confirmed conviction, victim count, methods, dates and financial loss.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.mediapool.bg/tri-godini-zatvor-za-mnim-yasnovidets-news310793.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mediapool.bg, 'Три години затвор за мним ясновидец.'",
"body": "Independent Bulgarian outlet's corroborating report of the same sentence and case facts.",
"tier": "contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies the perpetrator's claimed clairvoyant and healing power over affliction and curses as the material spiritual pretext connected to the documented harm: victims paid money and surrendered valuables because they believed he held real occult power over their health, family and fate.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"healing-treatment"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Court (Yambol appellate circuit), Bulgaria",
"outcome": "Yambol District Court's sentence was upheld on appeal and is final; press reporting confirms the appellate outcome but does not give an exact appellate decision date."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bgonair.bg/a/166-kriminalno/200598-osadiha-na-3-godini-mazh-predstavyal-se-za-yasnovidets-i-lechitel",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e5f437aa40e853f708108bf9fb3bd6e13b53bda64ff0a9c70ec32ad4335e0bcb",
"final_url": "https://www.bgonair.bg/a/166-kriminalno/200598-osadiha-na-3-godini-mazh-predstavyal-se-za-yasnovidets-i-lechitel"
},
{
"source": "https://www.mediapool.bg/tri-godini-zatvor-za-mnim-yasnovidets-news310793.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "07b6d493f25a18555788f10f5a4abd37fe05e7d9b2662c1ab3604c42a9b022e4",
"final_url": "https://www.mediapool.bg/tri-godini-zatvor-za-mnim-yasnovidets-news310793.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 754,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Death year (1998) and conviction year (1999) both appear in secondary reporting; convicted individuals are the direct supervising teachers, not Jasmuheen, who was never charged and is not named as a defendant in this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-jim-eugenia-pesnak-breatharian-manslaughter-australia",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Ormiston, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia",
"lat": -27.5167,
"lng": 153.2333,
"title": "Australia: breatharian teachers convicted of manslaughter after a 21-day 'initiation' fast killed their student",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed breatharian teachers directly supervising a paying student's fasting 'initiation'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"direct in-person supervision of a multi-week fast the teachers had designed and were charging to run",
"doctrine that hunger, thirst and physical collapse were signs of spiritual progress to be pushed through rather than medical emergencies",
"the teacher's decision to insert a feeding tube himself rather than call an ambulance when the student could no longer speak or move"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Queensland Supreme Court, Australia",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "Jim Vadim Pesnak and his wife Eugenia Pesnak were convicted of manslaughter after Lani Morris, a student they were directly supervising through a 21-day breatharian 'initiation' (seven days without food or water, followed by fourteen days of restricted liquids only), died of stroke and renal failure from severe dehydration. As Morris became paralysed and unable to speak, Jim Pesnak inserted a feeding tube himself instead of summoning emergency help; she died shortly after. The jury convicted within approximately three hours. Jim Pesnak was sentenced to six years' imprisonment and Eugenia Pesnak to two years. Jasmuheen, the breatharian teacher whose published method the Pesnaks were following, was not charged."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Morris was inside a teacher-designed fasting 'initiation' she was paying to undergo, under the Pesnaks' direct physical supervision; the doctrine that her collapse was spiritual progress rather than a medical emergency is what kept a feeding tube, rather than an ambulance, as the first response.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://culteducation.com/group/1287-jasmuheen-breatharianism/16451-breatharian-teachers-convicted.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "culteducation.com archive, contemporaneous report of the Pesnak manslaughter trial and verdict.",
"body": "Report of the Queensland trial: the 21-day fast regimen, the feeding-tube episode, the manslaughter convictions and the six-year/two-year sentences.",
"tier": "reliable-retrospective-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jasmuheen",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia, \"Jasmuheen,\" subsection on the Pesnak case and other breatharianism-linked deaths.",
"body": "Corroborates the Pesnak conviction and situates it among other breatharianism-linked deaths where the teacher herself was never prosecuted.",
"tier": "reference-work",
"kind": "context"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://culteducation.com/group/1287-jasmuheen-breatharianism/16451-breatharian-teachers-convicted.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-retrospective-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5e77744f9c2749862b5ca4123ec2613d3f6a35103e4a1eb4f7480637b4fbaa25",
"final_url": "https://culteducation.com/group/1287-jasmuheen-breatharianism/16451-breatharian-teachers-convicted.html"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jasmuheen",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-work; evidentiary role: context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "21c79f2b3ce3b82d034dc5a6aa7b44a5ec379a0d978b11e364c2d53e8f283b0c",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jasmuheen"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 755,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced to consistent journalistic reporting (CNN, Press Democrat, Women of Grace) citing Peruvian police and local-media accounts of the arrest and conviction; no primary Peruvian court document or case number was locatable in English-language sourcing, so the conviction is well-corroborated but not primary-sourced. Conviction date is approximate, drawn from retrospective reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-jose-pineda-vargas-ayahuasca-homicide-peru",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Madre de Dios, Peru",
"lat": -12.5933,
"lng": -69.1891,
"title": "Peru: shaman convicted of homicide after concealing an 18-year-old's death at his ayahuasca retreat",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"shaman operating a commercial ayahuasca retreat center, with ceremonial authority over participants during and after the ritual"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sole shamanic authority over a first-time participant in an altered state, isolated at a remote jungle retreat center",
"concealment of the death from the victim's family and from police rather than reporting it",
"physical disposal of the body and destruction of belongings to prevent discovery"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Shimbre Shamanic Center"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Peru — Madre de Dios regional criminal court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Jose Manuel Pineda Vargas ('Master Mancoluto'), the shaman who led the ayahuasca ceremony at which 18-year-old Kyle Nolan died in August 2012, was arrested along with two accomplices after Peruvian police found the body he had buried and disposed of. He was convicted of homicide and of lying to authorities and sentenced to five years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Nolan was a first-time participant under the sole ceremonial authority of the shaman running the retreat; when he died during the ritual, that same authority was used to hide the death — burying the body, destroying his belongings and lying to his searching mother — rather than to seek help or answer for it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2014/10/24/justice/ayahuasca-death-kyle-nolan-mother/index.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN, \"She lost her son to a psychedelic brew. Now she's on a mission,\" Oct. 24, 2014.",
"body": "Reports the arrest of the shaman and accomplices, the concealment of Nolan's death and body, and the criminal proceedings against Pineda Vargas.",
"tier": "high-quality-reporting",
"kind": "investigative-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/news/sebastopol-teen-dead-after-peruvian-ritual/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Press Democrat, contemporaneous report on Kyle Nolan's death at the Shimbre retreat.",
"body": "Local paper-of-record account of the death, the family's search, and the discovery of the concealed burial.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2014/10/24/justice/ayahuasca-death-kyle-nolan-mother/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-quality-reporting; evidentiary role: investigative-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "df01bc3b1b64d3abd8904d3460d085ac211a7a068562f66c430dd1d0c6cd9ec3",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2014/10/24/justice/ayahuasca-death-kyle-nolan-mother/index.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.pressdemocrat.com/article/news/sebastopol-teen-dead-after-peruvian-ritual/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 756,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court-appeal",
"date": "2021-02-01",
"note": "Suwon High Court upheld the conviction and four-year sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Korean-language legal press only; individual identified by initial as is standard in Korean court reporting of this kind. Exact appeal date is approximate (month/year confirmed, day not stated in sourcing).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-suwon-pastor-exorcism-death-south-korea",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Suwon, Gyeonggi Province, South Korea",
"lat": 37.2636,
"lng": 127.0286,
"title": "South Korea: pastor convicted after fatal 'laying-on-of-hands' exorcism prayer on a fasting congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor conducting 안수기도 (laying-on-of-hands prayer) claimed to expel demons from a congregant seeking counseling"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"directing a distressed congregant to fast for days before the ritual as spiritual preparation",
"physical restraint of the victim's limbs by the pastor's wife and a second pastor couple during the ritual",
"striking and strangling the victim while framing the violence as expelling demons"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Suwon District Court, Criminal Division 11, South Korea",
"stage": "conviction and sentence, upheld on appeal",
"date": "2020-02-07",
"outcome": "A pastor identified only as 'A,' during a laying-on-of-hands exorcism prayer session on Feb. 7, 2020, struck a 24-year-old man (on leave from military service and seeking counseling for service-related stress, and made to fast for days beforehand to 'expel demons') with a cross and strangled him, while his wife and a second pastor couple restrained the victim's limbs. The Suwon District Court convicted the pastor of assault resulting in death (폭행치사) and sentenced him to four years' imprisonment; the Suwon High Court upheld the conviction and sentence on appeal in February 2021."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim had come to the pastor for counseling; the pastor's claimed authority to diagnose and expel 'demons' produced a directive to fast, then a restrained physical assault reframed as prayer, with three congregants holding him down while the pastor struck and strangled him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lawtimes.co.kr, legal-press report on the Suwon District Court conviction for assault resulting in death arising from a laying-on-of-hands exorcism prayer session.",
"body": "Reports the fasting instruction, the restraint by three accomplices, the strangulation and striking with a cross, the conviction for 폭행치사, and the four-year sentence.",
"tier": "legal-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://news.khan.co.kr/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kyunghyang Shinmun (khan.co.kr), contemporaneous South Korean press report on the case.",
"body": "Corroborates the facts of the exorcism-prayer assault and the criminal prosecution.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court-appeal",
"date": "2021-02-01",
"note": "Suwon High Court upheld the conviction and four-year sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f4cc170d387c3b1fb842da04f4e6a47e520902e04f157bb98f303492672e5580",
"final_url": "https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/"
},
{
"source": "https://news.khan.co.kr/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1dba252aa842c0c3dd7ff1736ea37087fa62ede55560d2a688c95ad7dc403b17",
"final_url": "https://www.khan.co.kr/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 757,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Korean-language legal press only; individual identified by surname/initial as is standard in Korean court reporting of this kind.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-gwangju-pastor-exorcism-death-south-korea",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Gwangju, Buk-gu, South Korea",
"lat": 35.1595,
"lng": 126.8526,
"title": "South Korea: pastor convicted after fatally pressing on a congregant's abdomen during a healing prayer for schizophrenia",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor claiming the ability to heal mental illness through 안수기도 (laying-on-of-hands prayer)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual authority to cure diagnosed schizophrenia through physical prayer rather than medical treatment",
"physically pinning and pressing on the victim's abdomen while she was laid on the floor, unable to remove herself from the ritual"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Gwangju District Court, Criminal Division 11, South Korea",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2016-04-17",
"outcome": "Pastor 'Oh,' 48, believing he could cure a 38-year-old woman's schizophrenia through laying-on-of-hands prayer, laid her on the floor of a house in Gwangju's Buk-gu district, sat on her abdomen and pressed forcefully with his palms; she died of peritonitis and intestinal hemorrhage caused by the pressure. The Gwangju District Court convicted him of assault resulting in death and sentenced him to three years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was subjected to physical force explicitly framed as a cure for her diagnosed mental illness, administered by a pastor whose claimed healing authority substituted for medical treatment and left her pinned beneath him as her injuries became fatal.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lawtimes.co.kr, legal-press report on the Gwangju District Court conviction for assault resulting in death arising from a healing-prayer session for schizophrenia.",
"body": "Reports the healing-prayer framing, the physical pressure applied to the victim's abdomen, the fatal peritonitis and intestinal hemorrhage, the conviction, and the three-year sentence.",
"tier": "legal-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f4cc170d387c3b1fb842da04f4e6a47e520902e04f157bb98f303492672e5580",
"final_url": "https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 758,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "quebec-court-of-appeal",
"note": "Appeal of the convictions and sentences denied."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Functionally a sweat-lodge-equivalent ceremonial-heat ritual (mud, wrapping, enclosed heat, hyperventilation) run by a non-Indigenous commercial New Age retreat leader, parallel in shape to the existing James Arthur Ray record. Known in Canadian press as the 'Chantal Lavigne case.'",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-gabrielle-frechette-mourir-en-conscience-quebec-canada",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Durham-Sud, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 45.8333,
"lng": -72.15,
"title": "Canada: New Age retreat leader convicted of criminal negligence causing death after a hyperthermia ritual",
"tradition": "new-age",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"paid facilitator of a commercial 'Mourir en conscience' ('dying in consciousness') spiritual retreat"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a paid retreat participant's submission to the facilitator's ritual design: mud, wrapping in blankets and plastic tarp with the head enclosed in a cardboard box, in a heated farmhouse",
"directed hyperventilation breathing exercises intensifying heat exposure and disorientation",
"assistants' continued administration of the ritual as the participant's condition deteriorated toward multi-organ failure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour du Quebec, Canada (Fabi J.)",
"stage": "conviction, sentence, and appeal — appeal denied",
"date": "2014-12-08",
"outcome": "Chantal Lavigne died of hyperthermia and multi-organ failure during a 'Mourir en conscience' retreat led by Gabrielle Frechette, who charged participants a fee. Participants were smeared with mud and wrapped in blankets and a plastic tarp with their heads enclosed in cardboard boxes in a heated rented farmhouse, and led through hyperventilation breathing exercises. On Dec. 8, 2014, Quebec Court Justice Helene Fabi convicted Frechette, along with assistants Ginette Duclos and Gerald Fontaine, of criminal negligence causing death; Fontaine was also convicted of criminal negligence causing bodily harm to a surviving participant. On Jan. 29, 2016, Frechette was sentenced to three years' imprisonment and Duclos and Fontaine to two years each. The Quebec Court of Appeal denied their appeal, reported January 2018."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Lavigne was inside a paid ceremonial-heat ritual of Frechette's own design, her head enclosed and her body wrapped, following facilitator-directed breathing exercises in a heated space with no independent means to recognize or escape the danger she was in as her condition worsened.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/gabrielle-frechette-appeal-denied-1.4477000",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, report on the Quebec Court of Appeal's denial of Gabrielle Frechette's appeal, January 2018.",
"body": "Confirms the criminal negligence causing death convictions of Frechette, Duclos and Fontaine, the sentences, and the appellate court's denial of their appeal.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CTV News, contemporaneous report on the 2014 convictions and 2016 sentencing in the Chantal Lavigne 'Mourir en conscience' case.",
"body": "Reports the facts of the retreat, the ritual conduct, the December 2014 convictions and the January 2016 sentences.",
"tier": "national-news-court-and-parliament-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "quebec-court-of-appeal",
"note": "Appeal of the convictions and sentences denied."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/gabrielle-frechette-appeal-denied-1.4477000",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-court-and-parliament-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3e81b241f560ffcfdce71c1831260a7ab2f391151e863f969e6e2e5d921b9364",
"final_url": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 759,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Civil judgment, not a criminal conviction — entered under this corpus's evidence tiers as a civil-finding record. Operates within a US ayahuasca-church religious-exemption framework rather than a criminal ayahuasca-retreat prosecution, distinguishing it from the Peru/Pineda Vargas record above; included because the authority-over-emergency-response nexus is direct and adjudicated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-brandon-begley-soul-quest-ayahuasca-florida-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Orange County, Florida, USA",
"lat": 28.5,
"lng": -81.3,
"title": "United States: ayahuasca church found liable in $15 million wrongful-death verdict over delayed emergency response",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "death",
"status": "civil-verdict",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"operators of a registered ayahuasca church retreat, with facility control over a participant during ceremony"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"facility control over a participant in an altered state during ceremony, including control over whether and when outside medical help was summoned",
"a delayed 911 call while the participant's condition deteriorated, attributed at trial to the facilitators' authority over the response to a medical emergency arising inside the ceremony"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Soul Quest Ayahuasca Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ninth Judicial Circuit Court, Orange County, Florida, USA",
"stage": "jury verdict (civil)",
"date": "2024-05-15",
"outcome": "A Florida jury returned a $15 million wrongful-death verdict against Soul Quest Ayahuasca Church and its majority owner Christopher Young (60% liability; Soul Quest 40%) in a suit brought by the estate of Brandon Begley, who died after an ayahuasca ceremony at the church's Orange County retreat. The jury's negligence theory centered on a delayed call to emergency services as Begley's condition deteriorated during and after the ceremony."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Begley was under the ceremonial and facility authority of Soul Quest's leadership during the ritual; that authority controlled whether and when outside medical help was sought as his condition worsened, and the jury found the delay in doing so caused his death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wftv.com/news/local/jury-judge-order-orange-county-ayahuasca-church-pay-15m-after-mans-death/5ME2OINOU5GPZGJHALKHPFZYA4/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WFTV 9 Orlando, report on the $15 million jury verdict against Soul Quest Ayahuasca Church and Christopher Young, May 2024.",
"body": "Reports the verdict amount, the liability split between Young and Soul Quest, and the delayed-emergency-response negligence theory.",
"tier": "local-news",
"kind": "civil-verdict"
},
{
"link": "https://filtermag.org/brandon-begley-soul-quest-wrongful-death/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Filter Magazine, \"Brandon Begley's Family Wins $15M Wrongful Death Suit Against Soul Quest.\"",
"body": "Detailed account of the ceremony, the deterioration of Begley's condition, the delayed 911 call, and the trial outcome.",
"tier": "investigative-reporting",
"kind": "civil-verdict"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wftv.com/news/local/jury-judge-order-orange-county-ayahuasca-church-pay-15m-after-mans-death/5ME2OINOU5GPZGJHALKHPFZYA4/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-news; evidentiary role: civil-verdict.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cdc48b8f904f1c41bc248ca8d220f8cdf9ff8acb15909c6b7041670f5ed3f91a",
"final_url": "https://www.wftv.com/news/local/jury-judge-order-orange-county-ayahuasca-church-pay-15m-after-mans-death/5ME2OINOU5GPZGJHALKHPFZYA4/"
},
{
"source": "https://filtermag.org/brandon-begley-soul-quest-wrongful-death/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: investigative-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-verdict.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f5006211ce9b936c01d5a84f8beda31ece414459d5caf9c43017c077ff99f19d",
"final_url": "https://filtermag.org/brandon-begley-soul-quest-wrongful-death/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 760,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No trial verdict or further disposition was located in the July 2026 source audit; the case is documented only through the charge and a bail ruling."
}
],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING (FGM/C, read against the corpus criterion): most FGM/C fails this corpus's spiritual-authority test because the practice is customary and familial, not doctrinal, and the operative authority is a parent's, not a religious or ritual office-holder's. This record is different in kind: the Bondo society is a secret initiatory society with its own ritual hierarchy, and the sowei who performed the cutting held genuine initiatory office over the initiate, independent of and beyond the mother's authority. That is the nexus the criterion requires. Sierra Leone does not criminalize FGM/C itself; the charge here is manslaughter for the resulting death, and only that charge is what is documented. ADMITTED AT CHARGED STATUS ONLY: no trial verdict was located after extensive search; the bail ruling followed the prosecution's failure to produce witnesses twice, which is itself an unresolved-disposition signal, not an acquittal or conviction. This record must not be read as implying guilt was ever adjudicated — only that a formal charge and court proceeding are documented. If a verdict is later located, update this record rather than duplicate it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"slug": "2022-sowo-sandy-bondo-bonthe-sierra-leone",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Nyandehun village, Imperri Chiefdom, Bonthe District, Sierra Leone",
"lat": 7.5264,
"lng": -12.1875,
"title": "Sierra Leone: Bondo society sowei charged with manslaughter after an initiate's death",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "death",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"sowei (Bondo society initiator/ritual leader)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"initiatory society authority",
"secret-society ritual obligation"
],
"organizations": [
"Bondo society"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Magistrate's Court, Bonthe District, Sierra Leone",
"stage": "charge and bail hearing",
"outcome": "A sowei known as Sowo Sandy was charged with manslaughter over the December 2021 death of 21-year-old Maseray Sei, who died a day after undergoing Bondo-society initiation cutting; an autopsy attributed death to blood loss from the procedure. Press reporting from July 2022 states the magistrate granted bail after the prosecution twice failed to produce witnesses, and that this was the first time in roughly half a century that a sowei had faced court in Sierra Leone over an initiate's death. The exact charge date was not stated in the located sources, so no proceedings date is asserted here. No later verdict or further disposition was located; this record must be revisited if one surfaces."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.politicosl.com/articles/female-genital-cutter-court-sierra-leone",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Politico SL, 'Female genital cutter in court in Sierra Leone' (2022).",
"body": "Reports that a sowei known as Sowo Sandy, in her 60s, was charged with manslaughter in the death of 21-year-old Maseray Sei of Nyandehun village, Imperri Chiefdom, Bonthe District, who died in December 2021 a day after undergoing Bondo-society initiation cutting. An autopsy found she bled to death from the procedure. The charge sheet is quoted as reading that she 'unlawfully killed' Sei. FGM itself is not outlawed in Sierra Leone, so the charge is manslaughter rather than a cutting-specific offense.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://politicosl.com/articles/court-frees-sierra-leone-fgm-cutter-bail%C2%A0",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Politico SL, 'Court frees Sierra Leone FGM cutter on bail' (2022).",
"body": "Reports that Magistrate Momoh Lansana granted bail to Sowo Sandy after the prosecution failed a second time to bring its witnesses, and states this was the first sowei prosecution over an initiate's death in Sierra Leone in roughly 50 years.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "proceedings-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Bondo society is a female initiatory secret society; the sowei is its ritual leader and holds genuine initiatory authority over the women and girls she initiates, a materially stronger authority nexus than an ordinary parent's. The victim was an adult initiate (21) undergoing the society's cutting rite, not a child brought solely on parental authority — the sowei's own ritual office is what made the cutting happen and what an initiate could not refuse without leaving the society's structure entirely.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No trial verdict or further disposition was located in the July 2026 source audit; the case is documented only through the charge and a bail ruling."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A sowei known as Sowo Sandy was charged with manslaughter over the December 2021 death of 21-year-old Maseray Sei, who died a day after undergoing Bondo-society initiation cutting; an autopsy attributed death to blood loss from the procedure. Press reporting from July 2022 states the magistrate granted bail after the prosecution twice failed to produce witnesses, and that this was the first time in roughly half a century that a sowei had faced court in Sierra Leone over an initiate's death. The exact charge date was not stated in the located sources, so no proceedings date is asserted here. No later verdict or further disposition was located; this record must be revisited if one surfaces.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.politicosl.com/articles/female-genital-cutter-court-sierra-leone",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "06762550473d4d97de41268d5e195046d3f41a42253d31f664a71bcdca6d828a",
"final_url": "https://www.politicosl.com/articles/female-genital-cutter-court-sierra-leone"
},
{
"source": "https://politicosl.com/articles/court-frees-sierra-leone-fgm-cutter-bail%C2%A0",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: proceedings-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "03f1d2dd99add47c571ed330e041577fd9522dc5eac760dfd73391ee215b6a7c",
"final_url": "https://politicosl.com/articles/court-frees-sierra-leone-fgm-cutter-bail%C2%A0"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 761,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING (FGM/C brief extended to male ritual circumcision, per the corpus's own logic): this is a MALE circumcision case, admitted because the brief's own reasoning for why FGM/C mostly fails the criterion — that the operative authority is parental, not ritual — runs the other way here. An ulwaluko initiation-school principal holds actual, exclusive ritual authority over confined initiates for the duration of the rite, structurally closer to the Bondo/Sande sowei nexus than to a parent's authority over a daughter. The immediate cause of death was assault during the initiate's medical crisis, not the circumcision itself, but the assault occurred because the initiate was confined under the school's ritual authority and could not leave or seek outside care; that confinement is the same mechanism the criterion asks about. Convictions are final as reported; no appeal was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"slug": "2024-mdludla-ulwaluko-mbizana-eastern-cape-south-africa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Mfuleni Location, Mbizana District, Eastern Cape, South Africa",
"lat": -31.0132,
"lng": -29.7737,
"title": "South Africa: illegal ulwaluko initiation-school principal and caregivers convicted after an initiate's beating death",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"unregistered traditional surgeon and initiation-school principal",
"traditional nurse/caregiver (ikhankatha)",
"traditional nurse/caregiver (ikhankatha)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"initiation-school ritual authority",
"physical confinement at the initiation site",
"assault used to enforce compliance during initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"unregistered ulwaluko initiation school"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mbizana Regional Court, Eastern Cape, South Africa",
"stage": "guilty plea, conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2024-09-25",
"outcome": "Yongama Mdludla, an unregistered traditional surgeon who ran the illegal initiation school as its principal, pleaded guilty to culpable homicide and to contravening the Customary Initiation Act 2 of 2021, and was sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment. Two co-accused who acted as traditional nurses/caregivers at the school, Yamkela Bentswana and Mihlali Khiphi, were sentenced to 8 years each for their roles in the same incident. A separate registered traditional surgeon, Luthando Madikizela, who had circumcised underage boys at the school without required medical certificates, was sentenced to 8 years with 4 suspended for contravening the Act. Press reporting describes the 15-year term as among the heaviest sentences imposed for a traditional-initiation offense in the province since the initiation laws were enacted in 1996."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/courts/court-sentences-four-men-for-initiates-death-at-illegal-eastern-cape-initiation-school/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Citizen, 'Court sentences four men for initiate's death at illegal Eastern Cape initiation school' (2024).",
"body": "Reports that the Mbizana Regional Court sentenced Yongama Mdludla (21, unregistered traditional surgeon and school principal) to 15 years after a guilty plea to culpable homicide and contravening the Customary Initiation Act 2 of 2021; Yamkela Bentswana (27) and Mihlali Khiphi (24), who served as traditional nurses/caregivers, to 8 years each; and Luthando Madikizela (33, registered traditional surgeon who circumcised underage boys without certificates) to 8 years with 4 suspended. States the victim was 17-year-old Mvuyisi Dingile, who died in November 2023 at the illegal school after being assaulted by the three co-accused while hallucinating post-circumcision; the postmortem cause of death was severe assault. Describes the 15-year sentence as one of the heaviest for a traditional-initiation offense in the province since 1996.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.dispatchlive.co.za/news/2024-09-25-illegal-initiation-school-head-jailed-for-15-years-over-death-of-initiate/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily Dispatch, 'Illegal initiation school head jailed for 15 years over death of initiate' (Sept. 25, 2024).",
"body": "Confirms the sentencing date, the identity of Mdludla as the school's principal/unregistered surgeon operating in Mfuleni Location, Mbizana District, and that he accepted six boys without the medical certificates required under the Customary Initiation Act.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Mdludla was both the unregistered traditional surgeon (ingcibi) and the principal of the initiation school — the ritual office that performs and oversees the ulwaluko circumcision rite that inducts Xhosa boys into manhood. Initiates are confined at the school for the duration of the rite and are under the principal's and caregivers' authority for its full course; that authority, not a parent's, is what put the victim inside the school and unable to leave when he began to fail.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/courts/court-sentences-four-men-for-initiates-death-at-illegal-eastern-cape-initiation-school/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a934d2959cff3309bd3404be4009e3be8ce552ee9f356f172085ff6d0281c5f6",
"final_url": "https://www.citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/courts/court-sentences-four-men-for-initiates-death-at-illegal-eastern-cape-initiation-school/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.dispatchlive.co.za/news/2024-09-25-illegal-initiation-school-head-jailed-for-15-years-over-death-of-initiate/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9ce10fd9633a4ae5b24043e0ef105055567f4316406e8e07f1acdd0dd2158539",
"final_url": "https://www.dailydispatch.co.za/news/2024-09-25-illegal-initiation-school-head-jailed-for-15-years-over-death-of-initiate/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 762,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: admitted on the same basis as the Mdludla/Mbizana record — an ikhankatha's authority over an initiate during ritual seclusion is a ritual office, not merely parental delegation, even though parents select the caregiver. This is a narrower case than Mdludla (assault only, no death), included to document that the pattern is not a single outlier. Conviction is stated as reported; no appeal was located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation"
],
"slug": "2025-sifumba-ulwaluko-tsomo-eastern-cape-south-africa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Sixhotyeni village, Gqogqorha, Tsomo, Eastern Cape, South Africa",
"lat": -32.0021,
"lng": -27.8146,
"title": "South Africa: ulwaluko initiation caregiver convicted of assaulting an initiate",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"traditional nurse/caregiver (ikhankatha) appointed to the initiate"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"initiation-school ritual authority",
"physical confinement at the initiation site"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tsomo Magistrate's Court, Eastern Cape, South Africa",
"stage": "conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2025-06-30",
"outcome": "Siyasanga Sifumba, a traditional nurse/caregiver (ikhankatha) appointed by the initiate's parents, was convicted of assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and sentenced to two years' direct imprisonment; the court also declared him unfit to possess a firearm."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dailydispatch.co.za/news/2025-07-06-sentencing-of-eastern-cape-initiation-practitioner-for-assault-torture-applauded/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily Dispatch, 'Sentencing of Eastern Cape initiation practitioner for assault, torture applauded' (Jul. 6, 2025).",
"body": "Reports that the Tsomo Magistrate's Court sentenced Siyasanga Sifumba (30), an ikhankatha (traditional nurse/caregiver) appointed by the initiate's parents, to two years' direct imprisonment for assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, after he repeatedly beat a male initiate with a stick and struck him with fists and boots at an initiation site in Sixhotyeni village, Gqogqorha, outside Tsomo, on December 5, 2024. The initiate required hospitalization first at Cofimvaba Hospital, then Frere Hospital, East London. Sifumba was arrested December 17, 2024, denied bail January 23, 2025, and remained in custody through trial.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The ikhankatha is a ritual office within the ulwaluko initiation structure, charged with caring for and overseeing an initiate through the seclusion period following circumcision. Although appointed with the parents' involvement, the caregiver's authority over the initiate during the confinement period at the initiation site is direct and exclusive for that period — the initiate could not leave the site or seek help independent of the ikhankatha's control.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dailydispatch.co.za/news/2025-07-06-sentencing-of-eastern-cape-initiation-practitioner-for-assault-torture-applauded/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ed4458af8610311308383e076313f4ace0503e879005b7f6e9d2564dc2819c50",
"final_url": "https://www.dailydispatch.co.za/news/2025-07-06-sentencing-of-eastern-cape-initiation-practitioner-for-assault-torture-applauded/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 763,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is an investigative report, not a mass adjudication. Of 163 identified clergy, 83 were already deceased when the report issued and the statute of limitations had run on 46 of the remaining 80 living individuals' alleged crimes. The Attorney General limited referrals to alleged perpetrators and did not recommend charges against diocesan leadership. Substantiation by the investigation is not a criminal conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-missouri-ag-catholic-clergy-report-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Missouri, USA",
"lat": 38.4623,
"lng": -92.302,
"title": "Missouri attorney general report: 163 credible instances of Catholic clergy abuse, 12 cases referred for prosecution",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests and deacons of Missouri's four dioceses",
"diocesan leadership responsible for personnel files and assignments"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and pastoral authority",
"parish, school and rectory access to children",
"decades-long institutional record-keeping that outlived prosecutorial windows"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of St. Louis",
"Diocese of Jefferson City",
"Diocese of Kansas City-St. Joseph",
"Diocese of Springfield-Cape Girardeau"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Office of the Missouri Attorney General",
"stage": "thirteen-month investigation and final report",
"date": "2019-09-13",
"outcome": "Reviewing personnel records for more than 2,000 priests and 300 deacons, seminarians and religious women dating to 1945 across all four Missouri dioceses, investigators identified 163 clergy or personnel with credible allegations of sexual abuse or misconduct against minors. Eighty-three were already deceased; of the 80 living, the statute of limitations had run on 46 alleged crimes, 16 cases had already been referred for local prosecution and five were already under investigation. The Attorney General referred the remaining 12 cases for potential criminal prosecution, and declined to recommend charges against any bishop or diocesan official, a decision survivor-advocacy groups criticized."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report concerns child sexual abuse committed under Catholic clerical and diocesan authority, and the institutional record-keeping and assignment practices that preserved evidence of the abuse for decades while allowing most alleged perpetrators to age, die, or outlast the statute of limitations before any referral could result in prosecution.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.npr.org/2019/09/13/760737876/missouri-ag-refers-12-ex-priests-for-prosecution-of-suspected-sexual-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NPR, 'Missouri AG Refers 12 Ex-Priests For Prosecution Of Suspected Sexual Abuse' (Sept. 13, 2019).",
"body": "Reports the investigation's scope (2,000+ priests since 1945), the 163-clergy finding, the 83 deceased, the 46 time-barred, and the 12 referred for prosecution; records the Attorney General's decision not to seek charges against church hierarchy.",
"tier": "national-wire-service",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.archstl.org/missouri-attorney-general-report-on-clergy-abuse-recommends-referring-12-cases-for-prosecution-4424",
"archive": "",
"citation": "St. Louis Review (Archdiocese of St. Louis), 'Missouri Attorney General report recommends referring 12 cases for prosecution' (2019).",
"body": "Diocesan-press corroboration of the report's findings and the 12-case referral, published by the affected institution.",
"tier": "affected-institution-press",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.foxnews.com/us/missouri-ag-refers-12-clergy-members-for-prosecution",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fox News, 'Missouri AG refers 12 former Catholic priests for potential prosecution after abuse probe' (Sept. 2019).",
"body": "Independent national corroboration of the 329-page report's scope and the 12-referral outcome.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "contemporaneous-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.npr.org/2019/09/13/760737876/missouri-ag-refers-12-ex-priests-for-prosecution-of-suspected-sexual-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-wire-service; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.archstl.org/missouri-attorney-general-report-on-clergy-abuse-recommends-referring-12-cases-for-prosecution-4424",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: affected-institution-press; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "99d99a602be6d8d74f185b64293bade33fecce495d5ab5520fea718f9899e1bc",
"final_url": "https://www.stlouisreview.com/story/missouri-attorney-general-report-recommends-referring-12-cases-for-prosecution/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.foxnews.com/us/missouri-ag-refers-12-clergy-members-for-prosecution",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bfdd16a933aef3864912b7df644c242c71aaafac13aecc2d21e5a3d58a025b95",
"final_url": "https://www.foxnews.com/us/missouri-ag-refers-12-clergy-members-for-prosecution"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 764,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record documents the release of a diocesan-compiled list of clergy deemed credibly accused, not a state prosecutorial finding. A subsequent state attorney general grand jury investigation was announced in 2018 but was blocked in litigation until 2025 (see companion record). The Independent Victim Compensation Program made payments to victims but is a civil compensation mechanism, not a criminal or civil-court adjudication of any individual claim.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-new-jersey-dioceses-accused-priests-list-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "New Jersey, USA",
"lat": 40.0583,
"lng": -74.4057,
"title": "New Jersey's five Catholic dioceses jointly name 188 priests credibly accused of child sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests and deacons across New Jersey's five dioceses",
"diocesan bishops compiling and releasing the substantiation lists"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and pastoral authority",
"parish and school access to children",
"decades of internal, unpublished diocesan abuse files"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Newark",
"Diocese of Camden",
"Diocese of Trenton",
"Diocese of Paterson",
"Diocese of Metuchen"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Archdiocese of Newark and Dioceses of Camden, Trenton, Paterson and Metuchen",
"stage": "coordinated diocesan disclosure",
"date": "2019-02-13",
"outcome": "All five New Jersey Catholic dioceses simultaneously published lists naming 188 priests and deacons deemed credibly accused of sexually abusing a minor, the state's first coordinated statewide disclosure. The dioceses subsequently ran an Independent Victim Compensation Program (closed November 2022) that paid more than $40 million to 348 victims in exchange for staying out of court."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The record concerns child sexual abuse committed under Catholic clerical and pastoral authority, disclosed through the dioceses' own internal substantiation process rather than an independent state finding; the coordinated five-diocese release and the compensation program that followed are themselves institutional acknowledgments of the scale of clerical abuse of children in the dioceses' care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.njoag.gov/clergy-abuse-task-force-report-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "New Jersey Office of the Attorney General, 'Clergy Abuse Task Force,' njoag.gov.",
"body": "State-government page describing the Clergy Abuse Task Force established following the dioceses' 2019 disclosure and the subsequent state investigation.",
"tier": "state-government-page",
"kind": "official-context"
},
{
"link": "https://helpingsurvivors.org/clergy-sex-abuse/new-jersey/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Helping Survivors, 'New Jersey Clergy Sexual Abuse' (accessed 2026).",
"body": "Corroborates the February 13, 2019 joint release of 188 names across the five dioceses and the Independent Victim Compensation Program's $40 million/348-victim total before its November 2022 closure.",
"tier": "survivor-advocacy-summary",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.njoag.gov/clergy-abuse-task-force-report-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-government-page; evidentiary role: official-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://helpingsurvivors.org/clergy-sex-abuse/new-jersey/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: survivor-advocacy-summary; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "36654a55b10095821a8541dde25e4c81f44fa01a0387eab9120a5365a3de69ef",
"final_url": "https://helpingsurvivors.org/clergy-sex-abuse/new-jersey/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 765,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record documents the New Jersey Supreme Court's 2025 authorization of a state grand jury investigation into Catholic clergy abuse, first sought by the Attorney General in 2018 and blocked in litigation for seven years by the Diocese of Camden. As of this record's date the grand jury's substantive findings, if any, are not yet public; this is a procedural institutional-event, not a completed report.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-new-jersey-supreme-court-clergy-grand-jury-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "New Jersey, USA",
"lat": 40.0583,
"lng": -74.4057,
"title": "New Jersey Supreme Court clears state grand jury to investigate Catholic clergy abuse, ending a seven-year legal block",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests and deacons across New Jersey's dioceses",
"diocesan leadership that litigated to block the investigation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and pastoral authority",
"diocesan resistance to independent state inquiry into internal abuse records"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Camden",
"Office of the New Jersey Attorney General"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of New Jersey",
"stage": "unanimous ruling authorizing grand jury investigation",
"date": "2025-06-16",
"outcome": "The state's seven justices unanimously reversed a 2023 lower-court ruling and held that the Attorney General's office may convene a special grand jury to investigate decades of Catholic clergy sexual abuse statewide, a probe first announced in 2018 and blocked by a sealed Diocese of Camden motion arguing state grand-jury reports may not target private organizations. The new Camden bishop announced in May 2025 the diocese would no longer oppose the inquiry. Grand jury proceedings are secret; no findings had been published as of this record."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The record concerns the state's attempt to independently investigate decades of child sexual abuse committed under Catholic clerical authority across New Jersey's dioceses, and documents both the diocesan legal resistance to that inquiry and its eventual court-ordered removal.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.inquirer.com/crime/catholic-clergy-sexual-abuse-camden-diocese-grand-jury-supreme-court-20250616.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Philadelphia Inquirer, 'N.J. prosecutors can convene a grand jury to investigate decades of Catholic clergy sex abuse, state Supreme Court rules' (June 16, 2025).",
"body": "Reports the unanimous ruling, the 2018 origin of the investigation, the Diocese of Camden's sealed 2021 motion to block it, and the new Camden bishop's May 2025 decision not to continue opposing it.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-of-record",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://newjerseymonitor.com/2025/06/16/state-can-seat-grand-jury-to-probe-clergy-sex-abuse-new-jerseys-top-court-rules/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "New Jersey Monitor, 'State can seat grand jury to probe clergy sex abuse, New Jersey's top court rules' (June 16, 2025).",
"body": "Independent corroboration of the ruling and its procedural history, including the secrecy of grand jury proceedings going forward.",
"tier": "state-news-nonprofit",
"kind": "contemporaneous-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The state's seven justices unanimously reversed a 2023 lower-court ruling and held that the Attorney General's office may convene a special grand jury to investigate decades of Catholic clergy sexual abuse statewide, a probe first announced in 2018 and blocked by a sealed Diocese of Camden motion arguing state grand-jury reports may not target private organizations. The new Camden bishop announced in May 2025 the diocese would no longer oppose the inquiry. Grand jury proceedings are secret; no findings had been published as of this record.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.inquirer.com/crime/catholic-clergy-sexual-abuse-camden-diocese-grand-jury-supreme-court-20250616.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-of-record; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c84984f3b7ccdb158f326cd5e9f19081939677416c22f3d4ed38432668cf817c",
"final_url": "https://www.inquirer.com/crime/catholic-clergy-sexual-abuse-camden-diocese-grand-jury-supreme-court-20250616.html"
},
{
"source": "https://newjerseymonitor.com/2025/06/16/state-can-seat-grand-jury-to-probe-clergy-sex-abuse-new-jerseys-top-court-rules/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-nonprofit; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a99ea9b4c47b12e5835aa6e1447691e9294fa0c3590b21016e611fbdab73c157",
"final_url": "https://newjerseymonitor.com/2025/06/16/state-can-seat-grand-jury-to-probe-clergy-sex-abuse-new-jerseys-top-court-rules/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 766,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "These are independent diocesan investigations conducted by former FBI agents at the dioceses' own request, not a state attorney-general report; Kentucky's Attorney General has not published a statewide clergy report. The Diocese of Lexington's own release states only 10 of the 20 named priests have fully substantiated claims. Substantiation by these reviews is not a criminal conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-kentucky-covington-lexington-diocesan-reports-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Kentucky, USA",
"lat": 37.8393,
"lng": -84.27,
"title": "Kentucky's Covington and Lexington dioceses release independent-review findings naming 90 and 20 accused clergy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests, religious brothers, nuns and lay employees of the Diocese of Covington and Diocese of Lexington",
"diocesan leadership commissioning the independent reviews"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and pastoral authority",
"parish, school and lay-ministry access to children",
"diocesan record-keeping spanning the 1950s to the present"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Covington",
"Diocese of Lexington"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Diocese of Covington and Diocese of Lexington, independent reviews by former FBI agents",
"stage": "independent investigation and public disclosure",
"date": "2020-08-01",
"outcome": "Following independent reviews of diocesan records dating to 1950, conducted by former FBI agents, both Kentucky dioceses published lists of clergy and personnel with allegations of child sexual abuse. Covington's list named 59 priests, six religious brothers, five nuns and 20 lay employees or deacons (90 total). Lexington's list named 20 priests, of whom the diocese stated only 10 had fully substantiated claims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The record concerns child sexual abuse committed under Catholic clerical, religious and lay-ministry authority within Kentucky's Covington and Lexington dioceses, disclosed through diocesan-commissioned independent review rather than an external state finding.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://covdio.org/safe-environment/substantiated-allegations-list/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diocese of Covington, 'Substantiated Allegations List,' covdio.org.",
"body": "The diocese's own published list resulting from the independent FBI-agent-led review, naming 90 individuals across clergy, religious and lay roles.",
"tier": "affected-institution-primary-source",
"kind": "primary-disclosure"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wcpo.com/news/local-news/i-team/diocese-of-covington-names-90-with-substantiated-allegations-of-sexual-abuse-of-a-minor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WCPO Cincinnati, 'Diocese of Covington names 90 with substantiated allegations of sexual abuse of a minor' (2020).",
"body": "Independent broadcast-news corroboration of the Covington list's release, count and methodology.",
"tier": "regional-broadcast-news",
"kind": "contemporaneous-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.abuselawsuit.com/news/kentucky-dioceses-name-priests-accused-of-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "AbuseLawsuit.com, 'Kentucky Dioceses Name Priests Accused of Sex Abuse' (Aug. 2020).",
"body": "Corroborates the simultaneous August 2020 release by both dioceses and the Lexington diocese's own qualification that only 10 of 20 named priests had fully substantiated claims.",
"tier": "survivor-advocacy-legal-summary",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://covdio.org/safe-environment/substantiated-allegations-list/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: affected-institution-primary-source; evidentiary role: primary-disclosure.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0d14e9a9d8fd671bcf8966459c55687a6365fe7f1e348989fca372d8a30ef116",
"final_url": "https://covdio.org/safe-environment/substantiated-allegations-list/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wcpo.com/news/local-news/i-team/diocese-of-covington-names-90-with-substantiated-allegations-of-sexual-abuse-of-a-minor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcast-news; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "493df1e6b4b7d29e01ce286ec31536a83af68a46a495d4992d0d4514172cca15",
"final_url": "https://www.wcpo.com/news/local-news/i-team/diocese-of-covington-names-90-with-substantiated-allegations-of-sexual-abuse-of-a-minor"
},
{
"source": "https://www.abuselawsuit.com/news/kentucky-dioceses-name-priests-accused-of-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: survivor-advocacy-legal-summary; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d24228b827a9f1fe0a6cac9dd5275beb88538e5ce1cd8e61094bd760f1f3d97c",
"final_url": "https://www.abuselawsuit.com/news/kentucky-dioceses-name-priests-accused-of-sex-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 767,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a 2003 state attorney-general investigative report and document release, not a mass-prosecution outcome; the report's release followed a criminal-endangerment agreement with the diocese (see the existing 2002 Manchester institutional-event record for that agreement). The 35 New Hampshire priests named here reflect the report's own document set, not an assertion that all were convicted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-new-hampshire-ag-manchester-diocese-report-usa",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Manchester, New Hampshire, USA",
"lat": 42.9956,
"lng": -71.4548,
"title": "New Hampshire attorney general publishes 9,000-page investigative file naming 35 New Hampshire priests",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"priests of the Diocese of Manchester",
"diocesan leadership responsible for personnel assignments"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and pastoral authority",
"parish and school access to children",
"internal diocesan documentation withheld from public and law enforcement for decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Manchester"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Office of the New Hampshire Attorney General",
"stage": "investigative report and document release",
"date": "2003-03-03",
"outcome": "Following its criminal investigation of the diocese (which produced a child-endangerment agreement in December 2002), the Attorney General's office publicly released a 154-page report and roughly 9,000 pages of diocesan documents. The material named 35 New Hampshire priests, 19 Massachusetts priests and five members of religious orders whose files the diocese had held, documenting the diocese's decades-long pattern of internal knowledge and non-disclosure."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report concerns child sexual abuse committed under Catholic clerical and pastoral authority in the Diocese of Manchester, and the internal diocesan record-keeping and reassignment practices that concealed the pattern from law enforcement and the public for decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2003_03_03_NHAG/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Peter W. Heed, N. William Delker and James D. Rosenberg, Report on the Investigation of the Diocese of Manchester (Concord, N.H.: Office of the Attorney General, Mar. 3, 2003).",
"body": "The official report and accompanying document archive, hosted in full, detailing the diocese's internal handling of abuse allegations against the named priests.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-report",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_abuse_scandal_in_the_Roman_Catholic_Diocese_of_Manchester",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia, 'Sexual abuse scandal in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Manchester' (accessed 2026).",
"body": "Summarizes the report's release, the prior December 2002 child-endangerment agreement, and the scope of priests named in the released documents.",
"tier": "tertiary-summary",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2003_03_03_NHAG/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-report; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5ed1adaf0d82e7bbd2e31cb4e0a618dfdfeb5dd4cddd4d464b2c30e3326ac18e",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2003_03_03_NHAG/"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_abuse_scandal_in_the_Roman_Catholic_Diocese_of_Manchester",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: tertiary-summary; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "58ec20a0269fbcb28c4e5725ba2e6afb192ec6cdfbdbbd711ab6f0b689929b73",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_abuse_scandal_in_the_Roman_Catholic_Diocese_of_Manchester"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 768,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record documents Michigan's ongoing, diocese-by-diocese state investigation — an unusual mechanism among AG clergy inquiries, which are typically single statewide reports. As of this record two of seven dioceses (Grand Rapids, Saginaw) have received published reports; five (Marquette, Gaylord, Kalamazoo, Lansing, Archdiocese of Detroit) remain pending or partially reported. The 9-conviction figure spans the whole investigation to date, not any single diocesan report.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-michigan-ag-diocese-by-diocese-clergy-reports-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Michigan, USA",
"lat": 44.3148,
"lng": -85.6024,
"title": "Michigan attorney general's diocese-by-diocese clergy investigation: 1,276 tips, 11 criminal cases, 9 convictions",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests and clergy across Michigan's seven dioceses",
"diocesan leadership whose seized personnel files formed the investigation's evidentiary base"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and pastoral authority",
"parish and school access to children",
"diocesan document retention that outlasted most statutes of limitation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Grand Rapids",
"Diocese of Saginaw",
"Diocese of Marquette",
"Diocese of Gaylord",
"Diocese of Kalamazoo",
"Diocese of Lansing",
"Archdiocese of Detroit"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Office of the Michigan Attorney General",
"stage": "ongoing multi-diocese criminal investigation, reports issued diocese-by-diocese",
"date": "2026-06-25",
"outcome": "Beginning with 2018 search warrants that seized 220 boxes of paper records and 3.5 million digital documents from all seven Michigan dioceses, the Attorney General's office has since published diocese-specific reports as investigations of each diocese conclude: a December 2025 report naming 51 accused priests and 152 victims in the Diocese of Grand Rapids, and a June 2026 report naming 37 priests and one deacon with allegations from 104 victims in the Diocese of Saginaw (30 of the 37 known or presumed deceased; none of the 8 living remain in active ministry). Across the full investigation, a public tip line generated 1,276 tips, more than 285 police reports and at least 180 victim interviews, producing 11 criminal cases and 9 convictions to date. Reports on the remaining dioceses, including the Archdiocese of Detroit, were still pending as of this record."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The investigation concerns child sexual abuse committed under Catholic clerical and pastoral authority across Michigan's dioceses, using diocesan personnel and assignment records seized by state warrant to determine which clergy had access to children after known allegations.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2026/06/25/ag-nessel-releases-report-of-alleged-abuse-at-diocese-of-saginaw",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Office of the Attorney General, 'AG Nessel Releases Report of Alleged Abuse at Diocese of Saginaw' (June 25, 2026).",
"body": "Official state release of the Saginaw diocesan report: 37 priests and one deacon, 104 victims, 30 known or presumed deceased, none of the 8 living in active ministry.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-release",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/initiatives/catholic-church-clergy-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Office of the Attorney General, 'Catholic Church Clergy Abuse' initiative page.",
"body": "State-maintained page tracking the investigation's cumulative totals: 1,276 tips, 285+ police reports, 180+ victim interviews, 11 criminal cases and 9 convictions across the multi-diocese investigation.",
"tier": "state-government-page",
"kind": "official-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2025/12/15/ag-nessel-releases-report-of-alleged-abuse-at-diocese-of-grand-rapids",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Office of the Attorney General, 'AG Nessel Releases Report of Alleged Abuse at Diocese of Grand Rapids' (Dec. 15, 2025).",
"body": "Official state release of the Grand Rapids diocesan report: 51 priests, 152 victims.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-release",
"kind": "official-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2026/06/25/ag-nessel-releases-report-of-alleged-abuse-at-diocese-of-saginaw",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-release; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/initiatives/catholic-church-clergy-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-government-page; evidentiary role: official-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2025/12/15/ag-nessel-releases-report-of-alleged-abuse-at-diocese-of-grand-rapids",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-release; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 769,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is the sole prosecution publicly confirmed to have resulted from the Missouri Attorney General's 2019 clergy-abuse referrals; press reporting from September 2024 states the other individuals named in the 2019 report 'have still not been prosecuted.' No trial verdict, plea, or dismissal has been located in press or court-record searches as of this record; the case's current disposition should be treated as unresolved rather than assumed. Recorded as evidenceStatus 'charged' rather than 'convicted' for that reason.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-follow-up",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-frederick-lutz-diocese-springfield-cape-girardeau-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Advance and Stoddard County, Missouri, USA",
"lat": 37.1153,
"lng": -89.9018,
"title": "United States: retired priest Frederick Lutz charged with forcible sodomy after Missouri attorney general's clergy probe",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, St. Joseph Parish, Advance, Missouri"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and pastoral authority",
"access to a minor through parish religion classes",
"diocesan knowledge of the allegation withheld from law enforcement from 2002 until the 2019 state investigation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Springfield-Cape Girardeau"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Stoddard County, Missouri (venue later changed to Cape Girardeau County)",
"stage": "arrest, arraignment and grand jury indictment",
"date": "2020-02-19",
"outcome": "Frederick Lutz, 76, retired in 2011, was arrested in Springfield, Missouri on a Stoddard County warrant charging forcible sodomy, two counts of second-degree statutory sodomy and felony sexual abuse, arising from the Missouri Attorney General's church-personnel-records investigation. Prosecutors alleged Lutz assaulted a 17-year-old who attended religion classes at St. Joseph Parish, Advance, in 2000; the diocese acknowledged it had known of the allegation since 2002. Lutz pleaded not guilty at arraignment. A grand jury indicted him on March 3, 2020 on two counts of forcible sodomy and two counts of deviate sexual assault, and venue was changed to Cape Girardeau County."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a minor attending parish religion classes under Lutz's pastoral authority as priest of St. Joseph Parish; the diocese's own admitted 2002 knowledge of the allegation, left unreported to civil authorities for 18 years, is the institutional mechanism that let the statute of limitations run before the 2019 state investigation surfaced the case at all.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kfvs12.com/2020/02/19/retired-catholic-priest-southeast-mo-charged-with-multiple-counts-child-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KFVS12, 'Retired Catholic priest in southeast Mo. pleaded not guilty on child sex abuse charges' (Feb. 19, 2020).",
"body": "Reports the arrest, charges (forcible sodomy, second-degree statutory sodomy, felony sexual abuse), bond, and not-guilty plea; states the diocese acknowledged 2002 knowledge of the allegation.",
"tier": "regional-broadcast-news",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2020/01_02/2020_02_21_Wicentowski_AttorneyGenerals.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Danny Wicentowski, 'Attorney General's Priest Abuse Probe Yields First Charges,' Riverfront Times (Feb. 21, 2020), archived at BishopAccountability.org.",
"body": "Identifies the Lutz case as the first prosecution to emerge from the Missouri Attorney General's statewide clergy investigation.",
"tier": "alt-weekly-investigative-press",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ky3.com/content/news/Grand-jury-indicts-ex-Springfield-Mo-area-priest-on-several-charges-568714801.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KY3, 'Grand jury indicts ex-Springfield, Mo. area priest on several charges' (Mar. 2020).",
"body": "Reports the March 3, 2020 grand jury indictment on two counts of forcible sodomy and two counts of deviate sexual assault, and the change of venue to Cape Girardeau County.",
"tier": "regional-broadcast-news",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2024/09/20/two-lawsuits-accuse-missouri-dioceses-of-shameless-cover-up-of-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Catholic World Report, 'Two lawsuits accuse Missouri dioceses of \"shameless cover-up\" of sexual abuse' (Sept. 20, 2024).",
"body": "States that, as of September 2024, individuals named in the 2019 Missouri attorney general report had still not been prosecuted — the basis for this record's 'charged' rather than 'convicted' evidenceStatus and its needs-follow-up audit flag.",
"tier": "national-catholic-press",
"kind": "status-update"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Frederick Lutz, 76, retired in 2011, was arrested in Springfield, Missouri on a Stoddard County warrant charging forcible sodomy, two counts of second-degree statutory sodomy and felony sexual abuse, arising from the Missouri Attorney General's church-personnel-records investigation. Prosecutors alleged Lutz assaulted a 17-year-old who attended religion classes at St. Joseph Parish, Advance, in 2000; the diocese acknowledged it had known of the allegation since 2002. Lutz pleaded not guilty at arraignment. A grand jury indicted him on March 3, 2020 on two counts of forcible sodomy and two counts of deviate sexual assault, and venue was changed to Cape Girardeau County.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kfvs12.com/2020/02/19/retired-catholic-priest-southeast-mo-charged-with-multiple-counts-child-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcast-news; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c9e96ba478fd99b731e893f98e5bbb5a1dc2e4fcfa81196af01b960b561782a0",
"final_url": "https://www.kfvs12.com/2020/02/19/retired-catholic-priest-southeast-mo-charged-with-multiple-counts-child-sex-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2020/01_02/2020_02_21_Wicentowski_AttorneyGenerals.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: alt-weekly-investigative-press; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "879538a77fa771bbc7d644c329c5476a02e09acbebd0c8b4751f0b3a8e7aae20",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2020/01_02/2020_02_21_Wicentowski_AttorneyGenerals.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ky3.com/content/news/Grand-jury-indicts-ex-Springfield-Mo-area-priest-on-several-charges-568714801.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcast-news; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5629a27fda1c60f3992ad2e2e8a2a82ceb94d88874f44f5cacdc2f7ce2805353",
"final_url": "https://www.ky3.com/content/news/Grand-jury-indicts-ex-Springfield-Mo-area-priest-on-several-charges-568714801.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2024/09/20/two-lawsuits-accuse-missouri-dioceses-of-shameless-cover-up-of-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-catholic-press; evidentiary role: status-update.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a5d5bc512626f06084f383293797a1b6b7216984504eedf3818f259476e36f98",
"final_url": "https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2024/09/20/two-lawsuits-accuse-missouri-dioceses-of-shameless-cover-up-of-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 770,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-tanah-merah-kelantan-malaysia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Tanah Merah, Kelantan, Malaysia",
"lat": 5.8,
"lng": 102.15,
"title": "Malaysia: Quran teacher jailed nine years for assaulting three boy students at mosques",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2026/05/14/quran-teacher-jailed-9-years-for-sexually-assaulting-3-students",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Free Malaysia Today (2026) 'Quran teacher jailed 9 years for sexually assaulting 3 students'. Available at: freemalaysiatoday.com (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Hanafi Hassan, 64, pleaded guilty at the Pasir Mas Sessions Court to nine charges of physically sexually assaulting three male students aged 9 to 11, committed in mosque bathrooms and a barbershop storeroom around Tanah Merah between May 2023 and December 2025. Sentenced to nine years' imprisonment and three strokes of the cane, plus mandatory counselling and three years' post-release police monitoring."
},
{
"link": "https://www.sinarharian.com.my/article/779856/berita/semasa/amang-seksual-tiga-murid-lelaki-di-masjid-guru-mengaji-dipenjara-9-tahun-dan-tiga-sebatan",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sinar Harian (2026) 'Amang seksual tiga murid lelaki di masjid, guru mengaji dipenjara 9 tahun dan tiga sebatan'. Available at: sinarharian.com.my (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Guru mengaji (Quran teacher) Hanafi Hassan mengaku bersalah terhadap sembilan pertuduhan amang seksual fizikal ke atas tiga murid lelaki berusia 9 hingga 11 tahun di sekitar Tanah Merah, dihukum penjara sembilan tahun dan tiga sebatan oleh Mahkamah Sesyen Pasir Mas."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-05-14",
"jurisdiction": "Pasir Mas Sessions Court",
"stage": "Guilty plea and sentencing",
"outcome": "Guilty plea and sentencing, Pasir Mas Sessions Court"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the children's Quran teacher operating inside mosque premises, the defendant held recognized religious-instructional authority over his students, which gave him unsupervised access to them on mosque grounds.",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2026/05/14/quran-teacher-jailed-9-years-for-sexually-assaulting-3-students",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.sinarharian.com.my/article/779856/berita/semasa/amang-seksual-tiga-murid-lelaki-di-masjid-guru-mengaji-dipenjara-9-tahun-dan-tiga-sebatan",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "754e0f6404bb691f3454d7e6d1ed0bfa0d58a7190bd8f890a31a97b1c470a8c8",
"final_url": "https://www.sinarharian.com.my/article/779856/berita/semasa/amang-seksual-tiga-murid-lelaki-di-masjid-guru-mengaji-dipenjara-9-tahun-dan-tiga-sebatan"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 771,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "No trial verdict located yet; recorded as charged pending disposition.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-charoen-krung-bangkok-thailand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Yan Nawa, Sathorn, Bangkok, Thailand",
"lat": 13.69,
"lng": 100.51,
"title": "Thailand: two monks arrested for raping novices lured with mobile-game access at Wat Charoen Krung",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mgronline.com/crime/detail/9690000026991",
"archive": "",
"citation": "MGR Online (2026) 'ช็อกวงการสงฆ์! บุกจับ 2 พระมหาวัดดังเมืองกรุง ลวง 7 สามเณรข่มขืนในกุฏิ-แอบถ่ายคลิปวิดีโอ'. Available at: mgronline.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Two senior monks at Wat Charoen Krung, Bangkok, arrested for luring at least 11 novices with mobile-game access into monk's quarters, then raping and filming them; over 100 clips recovered; both confessed and disrobed.",
"body": "MGR Online (2026) 'ช็อกวงการสงฆ์! บุกจับ 2 พระมหาวัดดังเมืองกรุง ลวง 7 สามเณรข่มขืนในกุฏิ-แอบถ่ายคลิปวิดีโอ'. Available at: mgronline.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Two senior monks at Wat Charoen Krung, Bangkok, arrested for luring at least 11 novices with mobile-game access into monk's quarters, then raping and filming them; over 100 clips recovered; both confessed and disrobed."
},
{
"link": "https://www.dailynews.co.th/news/5704803/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily News (2026) \"'ปคม.' บุกจับ 2 พระคาวัดดังกลางกรุง หลอกตุ๋ยสามเณรถ่ายคลิปลับนับ 100\". Available at: dailynews.co.th (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Daily News (2026) \"'ปคม.' บุกจับ 2 พระคาวัดดังกลางกรุง หลอกตุ๋ยสามเณรถ่ายคลิปลับนับ 100\". Available at: dailynews.co.th (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-03-17",
"jurisdiction": "Yan Nawa, Sathorn, Bangkok, Thailand",
"stage": "Arrest warrants issued and executed; suspects confessed and voluntarily disrobed",
"outcome": "Arrest warrants issued and executed; suspects confessed and voluntarily disrobed"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The two monks held monastic authority over resident novices at Wat Charoen Krung, using temple rules against personal phone use and their status as ordained superiors to lure and control the children.",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Arrest warrants issued and executed; suspects confessed and voluntarily disrobed",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mgronline.com/crime/detail/9690000026991",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fea83cbb00dcfd542fcfdaacc7abcf4af380aff4b279fc1acce68fa70ca7ca5a",
"final_url": "https://mgronline.com/crime/detail/9690000026991"
},
{
"source": "https://www.dailynews.co.th/news/5704803/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 772,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "No trial verdict located; recorded as charged. Physical evidence (seized items, victim count) is well-documented in contemporaneous press.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-ban-phaeo-samut-sakhon-thailand",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Ban Phaeo, Samut Sakhon, Thailand",
"lat": 13.55,
"lng": 100.11,
"title": "Thailand: abbot of Wat Pa Suwatthanaram charged with abusing ten novices and a temple boy",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thaipost.net/main/detail/53261",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thai Post (2019) 'จับเจ้าอาวาสวัดป่า ข่มขืนเณร-เด็กวัด'. Available at: thaipost.net (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Phra Khru Sangkharak Saksit Kittiko (lay name Saksit Sonbanpheo), 40, abbot of Wat Pa Suwatthanaram, arrested on a warrant dated 24 Dec 2019 for indecent acts against novices and temple children; of 19 resident novices and 10 temple boys, 10 novices and 1 temple boy were found to be victims. Evidence seized included used condoms, blood-stained tissues, canes, novices' phones, and lubricant.",
"body": "Thai Post (2019) 'จับเจ้าอาวาสวัดป่า ข่มขืนเณร-เด็กวัด'. Available at: thaipost.net (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Phra Khru Sangkharak Saksit Kittiko (lay name Saksit Sonbanpheo), 40, abbot of Wat Pa Suwatthanaram, arrested on a warrant dated 24 Dec 2019 for indecent acts against novices and temple children; of 19 resident novices and 10 temple boys, 10 novices and 1 temple boy were found to be victims. Evidence seized included used condoms, blood-stained tissues, canes, novices' phones, and lubricant."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2019-12-24",
"jurisdiction": "Ban Phaeo, Samut Sakhon, Thailand",
"stage": "Arrest on warrant for indecent acts against minors in his care",
"outcome": "Arrest on warrant for indecent acts against minors in his care"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As abbot, the defendant held direct monastic and custodial authority over the resident novices and temple boys living under his supervision at Wat Pa Suwatthanaram.",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Arrest on warrant for indecent acts against minors in his care",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thaipost.net/main/detail/53261",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "03594db0da5c1b1e20e70f4ed6983b316f40ebfd3a8fc53907e99288b7467f6a",
"final_url": "https://www.thaipost.net/main/detail/53261"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 773,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charged only, no verdict yet; sourced via Thai press reporting on the Sri Lankan case (cross-border coverage) since it was the most detailed English/Thai-language source located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-anuradhapura-sri-lanka-hemaratana",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Colombo / Anuradhapura, Sri Lanka",
"lat": 8.31,
"lng": 80.4,
"title": "Sri Lanka: chief incumbent of Atmasthan temple network charged with sexual assault of a minor",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thaipbs.or.th/news/content/505722",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thai PBS (2026) 'พระดัง \"ศรีลังกา\" ถูกจับ ล่วงละเมิดทางเพศเด็กหญิงอายุต่ำกว่า 18 ปี'. Available at: thaipbs.or.th (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Ven. Pallegama Hemaratana Thero, chief incumbent overseeing eight sacred Atmasthan sites in Sri Lanka, arrested while hospitalized in Colombo on charges of sexually assaulting a girl under 18; the victim's mother and one other person arrested as accomplices; court hearing scheduled 12 May 2026; travel ban imposed.",
"body": "Thai PBS (2026) 'พระดัง \"ศรีลังกา\" ถูกจับ ล่วงละเมิดทางเพศเด็กหญิงอายุต่ำกว่า 18 ปี'. Available at: thaipbs.or.th (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Ven. Pallegama Hemaratana Thero, chief incumbent overseeing eight sacred Atmasthan sites in Sri Lanka, arrested while hospitalized in Colombo on charges of sexually assaulting a girl under 18; the victim's mother and one other person arrested as accomplices; court hearing scheduled 12 May 2026; travel ban imposed."
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-05-12",
"jurisdiction": "Colombo / Anuradhapura, Sri Lanka",
"stage": "Arrest and court hearing scheduled",
"outcome": "Arrest and court hearing scheduled"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant held the highest monastic authority over the Atmasthan network of sacred sites; press coverage notes prosecution of senior clergy of his rank is itself exceptional given the deference such authority commands in Sri Lanka.",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Arrest and court hearing scheduled",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thaipbs.or.th/news/content/505722",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1fec533c3bd78307f686cd9f458d04fbe7e14f503f161887fcfc743551da9495",
"final_url": "https://www.thaipbs.or.th/news/content/505722"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 774,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Convicted in absentia; defendant remains a fugitive per the source. Conviction stands as entered; no appeal reported.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-faridpur-bangladesh-madrasa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Faridpur, Bangladesh",
"lat": 23.6,
"lng": 89.84,
"title": "Bangladesh: madrasa director sentenced to ten years for attempted rape of a 15-year-old hifz student",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jugantor.com/country-news/1118694",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jugantor (2026) 'মাদ্রাসাছাত্রীকে ধর্ষণচেষ্টা, মাদ্রাসা পরিচালকের ১০ বছরের সাজা'. Available at: jugantor.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Md Ashraf Ali, 46, director of Roajatun-Nessa Women's Madrasa (Hifz program), Faridpur, sentenced 25 June 2026 to ten years' rigorous imprisonment plus a 70,000-taka fine for attempted rape of a resident 15-year-old student in April 2025, under the Women and Child Repression Prevention Act. Convicted in absentia; property ordered sold to satisfy the fine and victim compensation.",
"body": "Jugantor (2026) 'মাদ্রাসাছাত্রীকে ধর্ষণচেষ্টা, মাদ্রাসা পরিচালকের ১০ বছরের সাজা'. Available at: jugantor.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Md Ashraf Ali, 46, director of Roajatun-Nessa Women's Madrasa (Hifz program), Faridpur, sentenced 25 June 2026 to ten years' rigorous imprisonment plus a 70,000-taka fine for attempted rape of a resident 15-year-old student in April 2025, under the Women and Child Repression Prevention Act. Convicted in absentia; property ordered sold to satisfy the fine and victim compensation."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-06-25",
"jurisdiction": "special tribunal under Women and Child Repression Prevention Act",
"stage": "Conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Conviction and sentencing, special tribunal under Women and Child Repression Prevention Act"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As director of the madrasa's residential Hifz (Quran-memorization) program, the defendant held custodial and religious-instructional authority over a boarding student living at the institution.",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jugantor.com/country-news/1118694",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8e41add3e2e53f149be16eebe86deac4666990af5d2f0bfad2fd560e0e1be7ed",
"final_url": "https://www.jugantor.com/country-news/1118694"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 775,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Court noted both defendants had faced similar prior allegations, indicating a repeat-offense pattern within the same institutional authority.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-trenggalek-east-java-indonesia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Trenggalek, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -8.05,
"lng": 111.71,
"title": "Indonesia: two pesantren leaders convicted of abusing four minor santriwati",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.beritasatu.com/jatim/2988014/cabuli-santriwati-pimpinan-pesantren-di-trenggalek-divonis-2-tahun",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BeritaSatu (2026) 'Cabuli Santriwati, Pimpinan Pesantren di Trenggalek Divonis 2 Tahun'. Available at: beritasatu.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Masduki and Faisol Subhan Hadi, pesantren leaders in Trenggalek, East Java, convicted 23 April 2026 of sexually abusing four minor female boarding students (santriwati); each sentenced to two years' imprisonment, below the two-and-a-half years sought by prosecutors, with the court citing the defendants' cooperation despite prior similar charges against them.",
"body": "BeritaSatu (2026) 'Cabuli Santriwati, Pimpinan Pesantren di Trenggalek Divonis 2 Tahun'. Available at: beritasatu.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Masduki and Faisol Subhan Hadi, pesantren leaders in Trenggalek, East Java, convicted 23 April 2026 of sexually abusing four minor female boarding students (santriwati); each sentenced to two years' imprisonment, below the two-and-a-half years sought by prosecutors, with the court citing the defendants' cooperation despite prior similar charges against them."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-04-23",
"jurisdiction": "Trenggalek District Court",
"stage": "Conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Conviction and sentencing, Trenggalek District Court"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As pesantren leaders (pimpinan), the defendants held direct residential and religious-instructional authority over the boarding female students in their care.",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.beritasatu.com/jatim/2988014/cabuli-santriwati-pimpinan-pesantren-di-trenggalek-divonis-2-tahun",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 776,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charged only, trial pending; exact remand date not confirmed in source, proceedings date omitted per schema rule rather than guessed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jumla-nepal-dharmaputri",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Jumla, Nepal",
"lat": 29.28,
"lng": 82.18,
"title": "Nepal: self-styled spiritual figure held on remand for raping a girl kept as his 'dharmaputri'",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.osnepal.com/detail/295840",
"archive": "",
"citation": "OS Nepal (2026) 'धर्मपुत्री बलात्कार प्रकरण : आरोपित महत पुर्पक्षका लागि कारागार चलान'. Available at: osnepal.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Premjung Mahat, known as 'Premraja', held on pre-trial detention in Jumla on charges of raping a girl he kept in his household in the role of dharmaputri (a form of religious/adopted daughter under a spiritual guardian's authority). Government prosecutors have sought a 20-year sentence; case is before the district court.",
"body": "OS Nepal (2026) 'धर्मपुत्री बलात्कार प्रकरण : आरोपित महत पुर्पक्षका लागि कारागार चलान'. Available at: osnepal.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Premjung Mahat, known as 'Premraja', held on pre-trial detention in Jumla on charges of raping a girl he kept in his household in the role of dharmaputri (a form of religious/adopted daughter under a spiritual guardian's authority). Government prosecutors have sought a 20-year sentence; case is before the district court."
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"key": "OMITTED",
"jurisdiction": "Jumla, Nepal",
"stage": "Remand to custody pending trial; prosecutors seek 20-year sentence",
"outcome": "Remand to custody pending trial; prosecutors seek 20-year sentence"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim lived in the defendant's household under the dharmaputri relationship, a spiritually-framed guardianship role that placed her directly under his authority as a self-styled religious figure ('Premraja').",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Remand to custody pending trial; prosecutors seek 20-year sentence",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.osnepal.com/detail/295840",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "00e00776b9d94773dbabb9f2dd6a315ccc053a9cae8ddc2bb95dae9b9bae65ed",
"final_url": "https://www.osnepal.com/detail/295840"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 777,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charged/detained only; no trial outcome yet. Vietnamese folk-religion ritual (Tứ Phủ, Mother Goddess worship tradition) distinct from institutional Buddhism.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-yen-dung-bac-ninh-vietnam",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Yen Dung, Bac Ninh, Vietnam",
"lat": 21.19,
"lng": 106.13,
"title": "Vietnam: self-styled ritual master charged with raping a woman under a curse-removal pretext",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://docnhanh.vn/phap-luat/khoi-to-thay-cung-gia-danh-xam-hai-tinh-duc-nan-nhan-tai-dien-tho-o-bac-ninh-tintuc1039076",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Docnhanh (2026) 'Khởi tố thầy cúng giả danh, xâm hại tình dục nạn nhân tại điện thờ ở Bắc Ninh'. Available at: docnhanh.vn (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: N.V.M. (b.1995), posing as a ritual master (thầy cúng) performing a 'Tứ Phủ' spirit-releasing rite at a family shrine in Yen Dung, Bac Ninh, prosecuted for raping N.T.T. (b.2008) on 6 May 2026 by exploiting the ritual to coerce sexual contact. Suspect surrendered 9 May 2026 and confessed; detained for investigation 14 May 2026.",
"body": "Docnhanh (2026) 'Khởi tố thầy cúng giả danh, xâm hại tình dục nạn nhân tại điện thờ ở Bắc Ninh'. Available at: docnhanh.vn (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: N.V.M. (b.1995), posing as a ritual master (thầy cúng) performing a 'Tứ Phủ' spirit-releasing rite at a family shrine in Yen Dung, Bac Ninh, prosecuted for raping N.T.T. (b.2008) on 6 May 2026 by exploiting the ritual to coerce sexual contact. Suspect surrendered 9 May 2026 and confessed; detained for investigation 14 May 2026."
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-05-14",
"jurisdiction": "Yen Dung, Bac Ninh, Vietnam",
"stage": "Suspect detained for investigation following confession",
"outcome": "Suspect detained for investigation following confession"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant invoked ritual authority as an officiant performing a 'Tứ Phủ' spirit rite at a shrine, using the victim's belief in the efficacy and necessity of the ritual to coerce her compliance.",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Suspect detained for investigation following confession",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://docnhanh.vn/phap-luat/khoi-to-thay-cung-gia-danh-xam-hai-tinh-duc-nan-nhan-tai-dien-tho-o-bac-ninh-tintuc1039076",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "963f2c9b2f8e2e1cae556ba2b5418571bf6ea1853e8beefa779e7b5d672cd571",
"final_url": "https://docnhanh.vn/phap-luat/khoi-to-thay-cung-gia-danh-xam-hai-tinh-duc-nan-nhan-tai-dien-tho-o-bac-ninh-tintuc1039076"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 778,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "National umbrella institutional-event for the Commission itself, distinct from the individual case-study records already in or newly added to the corpus. Existing corpus records (Ridsdale, Best, Denham, Klep, Glennon, Ryan, Bindoon, Dowlan, McGrath, Kramer, Cyprys, Leifer, and Case Studies 16/22/28/29) sit beneath this umbrella; this record documents the inquiry as a whole.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-royal-commission-final-report-australia",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Canberra, Australia (national)",
"lat": -35.2809,
"lng": 149.13,
"title": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse: final report",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy, religious, and lay officers across 57 examined institutions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial and pastoral authority over children in religious-run homes, schools and congregations",
"institutional concealment and internal-only handling of complaints"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Commonwealth of Australia — Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "final report",
"date": "2017-12-15",
"outcome": "The five-year statutory inquiry — the largest of its kind ever conducted — held 57 public-hearing case studies, received evidence from over 8,000 survivors in private sessions, and referred more than 2,500 matters to police and prosecuting authorities. Faith-based institutions accounted for roughly 60% of allegations reported in private sessions by the end of 2016; the Commission examined Catholic, Anglican, Uniting Church, Salvation Army, Jehovah's Witnesses, Australian Christian Churches, and Jewish (Yeshiva/Chabad) institutions among others."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Commission's core finding was that religious and quasi-religious authority over children in custodial and congregational settings — obedience owed to clergy, religious orders, elders and institutional leadership — was the mechanism that both enabled abuse and suppressed its disclosure across institutions spanning multiple traditions.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/final-report",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, 'Final Report' (15 December 2017).",
"body": "The Commission's own final-report landing page summarising the inquiry's scope, volumes and recommendations.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Commission_into_Institutional_Responses_to_Child_Sexual_Abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia, 'Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse.'",
"body": "Corroborating summary of scale: 57 case studies, 8,000+ private sessions, 2,500+ police referrals.",
"tier": "secondary-reference",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/final-report",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Commission_into_Institutional_Responses_to_Child_Sexual_Abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-reference; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "44d5cafb8dbcb295692742807883b461b188a41d28b6cb76bfae003450b4447d",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Commission_into_Institutional_Responses_to_Child_Sexual_Abuse"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 779,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event for the diocese; James Michael Brown's individual conviction is recorded separately.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-royal-commission-case-study-42-anglican-newcastle-australia",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Newcastle, NSW, Australia",
"lat": -32.9283,
"lng": 151.7817,
"title": "Royal Commission Case Study 42: Anglican Diocese of Newcastle's 'do nothing' response",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Anglican bishops and clergy of the Diocese of Newcastle"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"episcopal and clerical pastoral authority",
"institutional non-reporting to police despite repeated admissions and complaints"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Anglican Diocese of Newcastle"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — Case Study 42",
"stage": "royal commission finding",
"date": "2017-11-01",
"outcome": "The Commission found the Anglican Diocese of Newcastle took a 'do nothing' approach to child sexual abuse allegations during Bishop Alfred Holland's episcopate (1978-1992) and under his successor Bishop Roger Herft, who showed 'a distinct lack of leadership.' Alleged perpetrators, including James Michael Brown and Peter Rushton, were not reported to police despite direct admissions made to bishops."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Episcopal and clerical authority over parishioners and children in church-run homes (including St Alban's) is what both enabled abuse by clergy and suppressed reporting for decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-42-anglican-diocese-newcastle",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, 'Case Study 42: Anglican Diocese of Newcastle.'",
"body": "Official case-study page and findings report.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6618999/hunter-child-sex-offender-who-should-have-been-stopped/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newcastle Herald, 'Late Newcastle Anglican Bishop condemned for do nothing response to criminal James Michael Brown.'",
"body": "Local press corroboration of the finding and Brown's case.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-42-anglican-diocese-newcastle",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6618999/hunter-child-sex-offender-who-should-have-been-stopped/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1eb18d8df8d22c02e9a2bc4fe2846f7185464b341514cb780e0921d5edb98862",
"final_url": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6618999/hunter-child-sex-offender-who-should-have-been-stopped/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 780,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from the existing Catholic Denham record (Newcastle/Hunter region) — Brown is Anglican, not Catholic, and his conviction is independently reported outside the Royal Commission.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-james-michael-brown-anglican-newcastle-australia",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Newcastle, NSW, Australia",
"lat": -32.9283,
"lng": 151.7817,
"title": "Australia: Anglican lay figure James Michael Brown convicted on 27 counts against 19 boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior lay figure at St Alban's Anglican home and church-connected youth settings, Newcastle diocese"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position of trust within Anglican parish and residential-care settings",
"protection by diocesan clergy who failed to report known allegations"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Anglican Diocese of Newcastle",
"St Alban's home"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of New South Wales, Australia",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2011-01-01",
"outcome": "James Michael Brown pleaded guilty to 27 charges of child sexual abuse against 19 male victims and was sentenced to a maximum 20 years' imprisonment with a 12-year non-parole period. He was in a long-term sexual relationship with fellow Anglican offender Peter Rushton; both abused boys and male teenagers met through the church and St Alban's home. Brown was charged with further offences in 2019 after the Royal Commission's 2016 Newcastle hearing exposed decades of diocesan inaction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Brown held a position of trust within Anglican parish and residential-care networks in the Newcastle diocese; that position, and the diocese's protection of him despite complaints reaching bishops directly, is what gave him unrefusable access to the boys he abused.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6618999/hunter-child-sex-offender-who-should-have-been-stopped/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newcastle Herald, 'Hunter child sex offender who should have been stopped.'",
"body": "Reports the 2011 guilty plea, 27 charges, 19 victims, 20-year sentence, and Brown's relationship with Peter Rushton.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-42-anglican-diocese-newcastle",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, 'Case Study 42: Anglican Diocese of Newcastle.'",
"body": "Corroborates the diocese's decades-long failure to report Brown despite direct admissions.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6618999/hunter-child-sex-offender-who-should-have-been-stopped/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1eb18d8df8d22c02e9a2bc4fe2846f7185464b341514cb780e0921d5edb98862",
"final_url": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/6618999/hunter-child-sex-offender-who-should-have-been-stopped/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-42-anglican-diocese-newcastle",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 781,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event for the Southern Territory homes; Sergeant Willem Willemson's individual conviction is recorded separately. Distinct from Case Study 10 (Eastern Territory claims handling) and the existing Indian Salvation Army record (Sanil K. James).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-royal-commission-case-study-33-salvation-army-southern-australia",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Box Hill, Bayswater, Victoria and Nedlands, Western Australia, Australia",
"lat": -37.8199,
"lng": 145.1219,
"title": "Royal Commission Case Study 33: Salvation Army children's homes, Southern Territory",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Salvation Army officers at Box Hill, Bayswater, Nedlands and Eden Park boys' homes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"Salvation Army officer rank and custodial authority over resident wards",
"punishment and disbelief of children who reported abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"The Salvation Army, Australia Southern Territory"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — Case Study 33",
"stage": "royal commission finding",
"date": "2016-07-01",
"outcome": "The Commission heard from 12 former residents of Box Hill, Bayswater, Nedlands and Eden Park describing physical and sexual abuse by Salvation Army officers between 1965 and 1977. It found the Army's policies and procedures did not enable prevention or detection of abuse; children who reported abuse were commonly punished, disbelieved, or ignored. The Commission found the Army knew of sexual offending at Box Hill from as early as 1947, including against Captain Arthur Clee, who was simply transferred between homes rather than reported."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Salvation Army officer rank carried direct custodial and disciplinary authority, reinforced by religious obedience, over children who had no other guardian; that authority both enabled abuse and determined whether complaints were believed.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-33-salvation-army-childrens-homes-australia-southern-territory",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, 'Case Study 33: The Salvation Army children's homes, Australia Southern Territory.'",
"body": "Official findings on Box Hill, Bayswater, Nedlands and Eden Park.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://rctlaw.com.au/legal-blog/2021/bayswater-and-box-hill-boys-homes-where-child-abuse-was-rife/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Carlisle Thomas Lawyers, 'Bayswater and Box Hill Boys' Homes — where child abuse was rife.'",
"body": "Corroborates Commission findings on Captain Arthur Clee and the Army's transfer-rather-than-report pattern.",
"tier": "legal-practitioner-summary",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-33-salvation-army-childrens-homes-australia-southern-territory",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://rctlaw.com.au/legal-blog/2021/bayswater-and-box-hill-boys-homes-where-child-abuse-was-rife/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-practitioner-summary; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "966de3234471682c794ed904f1ee483062ceba01455207cf9a39e2b3774409e9",
"final_url": "https://rctlaw.com.au/legal-blog/2021/bayswater-and-box-hill-boys-homes-where-child-abuse-was-rife/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 782,
"aliases": [
"Black Willie"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Independently reported outside the Royal Commission; Case Study 33 (recorded separately) documents the institution's prior knowledge and failure to act.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1995-willem-willemson-salvation-army-box-hill-australia",
"year": 1995,
"place": "Box Hill, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.8199,
"lng": 145.1219,
"title": "Australia: Salvation Army sergeant Willem Willemson convicted of indecent assault at Box Hill Boys' Home",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Salvation Army sergeant with custodial and medical-inspection authority at Box Hill Boys' Home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"officer rank and disciplinary control over resident wards",
"explicit threats (a knife held to a victim's throat) to enforce silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"The Salvation Army",
"Box Hill Boys' Home"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Victoria, Australia — criminal court",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "1995-01-01",
"outcome": "Sergeant Willem Willemson, known to residents as 'Black Willie', was convicted of three counts of indecent assault against boys at Box Hill Boys' Home, where he had performed sham medical examinations to fondle children and climbed into boys' beds at night. One victim reported Willemson held a knife to his throat to enforce silence. A victim later received $32,500 in compensation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As a Salvation Army officer, Willemson held disciplinary and custodial authority — reinforced by the institution's religious governance — over boys with no other guardian, which he used both to gain access and to compel their silence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-33-salvation-army-childrens-homes-australia-southern-territory",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, 'Case Study 33: The Salvation Army children's homes, Australia Southern Territory.'",
"body": "Records the Willemson conviction, his abuse methods, and the knife threat.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.gerardmaloufpartners.com.au/publications/what-child-abuse-occurred-within-the-salvation-army/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Gerard Malouf & Partners, 'What Child Abuse Occurred Within The Salvation Army?'",
"body": "Corroborates the 1995 conviction on three counts of indecent assault and compensation figure.",
"tier": "legal-practitioner-summary",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/case-studies/case-study-33-salvation-army-childrens-homes-australia-southern-territory",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.gerardmaloufpartners.com.au/publications/what-child-abuse-occurred-within-the-salvation-army/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-practitioner-summary; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3cdb03b4db226cd192535d07eb6196ce1e95fe99174c0326d978211965092c13",
"final_url": "https://www.gerardmaloufpartners.com.au/publications/your-guide-to-institutional-abuse-claims/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 783,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"note": "Akhandananda's 1989 conviction was quashed in 1991 due to an intervening legislative change, not on the facts."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Australia's oldest yoga ashram; a Hindu/dharmic institution, distinct from the corpus's Catholic- and Christian-majority Australian material. Recorded as institutional-event because the sole criminal conviction was overturned on a non-factual legal technicality rather than affirmed; no separate core record is created for Akhandananda given that disposition.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-royal-commission-case-study-21-satyananda-ashram-australia",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Mangrove Mountain, NSW, Australia",
"lat": -33.2667,
"lng": 151.15,
"title": "Royal Commission Case Study 21: Satyananda Yoga Ashram — guru-disciple abuse at Mangrove Mountain",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"founding guru and successor spiritual leader of the ashram"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru's absolute spiritual authority over cloistered disciples",
"ashram culture of silence and internal handling of complaints"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Satyananda Yoga Ashram, Mangrove Mountain"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Australia — Case Study 21",
"stage": "royal commission finding",
"date": "2017-01-01",
"outcome": "The Commission examined the experiences of 11 survivors of child sexual abuse at or connected with the ashram in the 1970s-80s, principally under Swami Akhandananda Saraswati, and the ashram's response. Akhandananda was convicted in 1989 of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old follower and sentenced to two years four months, but the conviction was overturned on appeal in 1991 following a legislative change — leaving the Commission's institutional finding, not a standing criminal conviction, as the durable record."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cloistered disciples at the ashram were subject to the guru's absolute spiritual authority under Satyananda Yoga's guru-disciple doctrine; that authority — not physical restraint — is what made refusal and disclosure unthinkable for years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/media-releases/report-satyananda-yoga-ashram-released",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Royal Commission, 'Report into Satyananda Yoga Ashram released.'",
"body": "Official media release summarising Case Study 21's findings.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sbs.com.au/language/hindi/en/article/swami-akhandananda-saraswati-sexually-abused-and-raped-children-at-australias-oldest-yoga-ashram-royal-commission-finds/ecfyya3w1",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SBS, 'Swami Akhandananda Saraswati sexually abused and raped children at Australia's oldest yoga ashram, Royal Commission finds.'",
"body": "Corroborates the 1989 conviction, sentence, and 1991 quashing.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"note": "Akhandananda's 1989 conviction was quashed in 1991 due to an intervening legislative change, not on the facts."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/media-releases/report-satyananda-yoga-ashram-released",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.sbs.com.au/language/hindi/en/article/swami-akhandananda-saraswati-sexually-abused-and-raped-children-at-australias-oldest-yoga-ashram-royal-commission-finds/ecfyya3w1",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cd0332bf45fc61cceb75f95e627f9d6adedc25bb3651385ec4aa8ba0107713e5",
"final_url": "https://www.sbs.com.au/language/hindi/en/article/swami-akhandananda-saraswati-sexually-abused-and-raped-children-at-australias-oldest-yoga-ashram-royal-commission-finds/ecfyya3w1"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 784,
"aliases": [
"Peter K."
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal filed",
"note": "K. announced he would appeal; outcome of appeal not confirmed in sourcing reviewed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Non-Catholic Dutch record — Hersteld Hervormde Kerk is a conservative Reformed Protestant denomination, distinct from the corpus's existing Catholic-majority Netherlands material.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-hersteld-hervormde-kerk-predikant-oud-beijerland-netherlands",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Oud-Beijerland, Netherlands",
"lat": 51.8225,
"lng": 4.3814,
"title": "Netherlands: Hersteld Hervormde Kerk predikant Peter K. convicted of abusing a congregant, 2009-2012",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-reformed-presbyterian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"predikant (minister) of the Hersteld Hervormde Kerk congregation, Oud-Beijerland"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority as the congregation's minister",
"closed, obedience-oriented culture of the Reformed congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Hersteld Hervormde Kerk, Oud-Beijerland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rechtbank Rotterdam, Netherlands",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2016-01-27",
"outcome": "Peter K., a predikant of the Hersteld Hervormde Kerk in Oud-Beijerland, was convicted by the Rotterdam district court of indecently assaulting and having sexual intercourse with an underage member of his own congregation between 2009 and 2012. He was sentenced to three years' unconditional imprisonment — a heavier sentence than the prosecution's request. K. lodged an appeal (hoger beroep)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As predikant, K. held direct pastoral authority over the congregant he abused — a member of his own church bound to him by the trust and obedience owed a Reformed minister — which is what made the abuse possible over a three-year period within the congregation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nd.nl/geloof/geloof/606638/drie-jaar-cel-voor-ex-dominee-wegens-misbruik",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nederlands Dagblad, 'Drie jaar cel voor ex-dominee wegens misbruik' (27 January 2016). Dutch: reports Rotterdam court sentencing Peter K. to three years for abuse of an underage church member 2009-2012. English gloss: 'Three years in prison for ex-minister over abuse.'",
"body": "Primary Dutch-language court report naming the denomination, court, dates, and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal filed",
"note": "K. announced he would appeal; outcome of appeal not confirmed in sourcing reviewed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nd.nl/geloof/geloof/606638/drie-jaar-cel-voor-ex-dominee-wegens-misbruik",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a5bbc4ea59b2bbcb076b6c3dff3a72f630510776506d68f843e6cc6d08be2057",
"final_url": "https://www.nd.nl/geloof/geloof/606638/drie-jaar-cel-voor-ex-dominee-wegens-misbruik"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 785,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Non-Catholic Dutch institutional-event; the study itself, commissioned by the state and litigated over by the organisation, functions as an official finding parallel in kind (though smaller in scale) to Deetman.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-utrecht-university-jehovahs-witnesses-study-netherlands",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Netherlands (national)",
"lat": 52.0907,
"lng": 5.1214,
"title": "Netherlands: Utrecht University study documents 751 sexual-abuse reports within Jehovah's Witnesses community",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregation elders handling internal abuse complaints"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"closed community structure discouraging reports to secular authorities",
"internal elder-committee handling of complaints, sometimes in the perpetrator's presence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses, Netherlands",
"Utrecht University — Departement Bestuurs- en Organisatiewetenschap"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek- en Datacentrum (WODC), Netherlands Ministry of Justice and Security — commissioned academic study",
"stage": "official commissioned study",
"date": "2020-01-23",
"outcome": "An interdisciplinary Utrecht University team led by Prof. Kees van den Bos, commissioned by the WODC following a parliamentary motion, documented 751 reports of sexual abuse within the Dutch Jehovah's Witnesses community and in-depth interviewed 10 victims or next-of-kin. It found victims rated the community's handling of their reports 3.3/10 versus 6.4/10 for the police, and that the closed, internally-adjudicated culture of the congregation actively discouraged reporting to secular authorities. The Jehovah's Witnesses' Dutch board sued to block publication and lost on appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Congregational elders' internal disciplinary authority over members — including committee hearings that could place a victim before her abuser — is the doctrinal mechanism the study identifies as suppressing disclosure and re-victimising those who came forward.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wodc.nl/actueel/nieuws/2020/01/23/onderzoek-naar-ervaringen-seksueel-misbruik-binnen-de-gemeenschap-van-jehovas-getuigen-openbaar",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WODC, 'Onderzoek naar ervaringen seksueel misbruik binnen de gemeenschap van Jehova's Getuigen openbaar' (23 January 2020). Dutch: official publication notice for the Utrecht University study. English gloss: 'Research into experiences of sexual abuse within the Jehovah's Witnesses community made public.'",
"body": "Official Ministry-affiliated research body's publication notice.",
"tier": "official-government-commissioned-study",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.uu.nl/nieuws/onderzoeksrapport-misbruik-jehovas-getuigen-blijft-openbaar",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Universiteit Utrecht, 'Onderzoeksrapport over misbruik binnen gemeenschap Jehova's getuigen blijft openbaar, ook na hoger beroep.' Dutch: confirms the report remained public after the Jehovah's Witnesses' unsuccessful appeal. English gloss: 'Research report on abuse within the Jehovah's Witnesses community remains public, even after appeal.'",
"body": "Confirms litigation history and outcome.",
"tier": "university-press-release",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wodc.nl/actueel/nieuws/2020/01/23/onderzoek-naar-ervaringen-seksueel-misbruik-binnen-de-gemeenschap-van-jehovas-getuigen-openbaar",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-commissioned-study; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d3fa3a913c724edd46f23eecf554d286cbfc5b8f4c138a330dc94db0e47e629f",
"final_url": "https://www.wodc.nl/actueel/nieuws/2020/01/23/onderzoek-naar-ervaringen-seksueel-misbruik-binnen-de-gemeenschap-van-jehovas-getuigen-openbaar"
},
{
"source": "https://www.uu.nl/nieuws/onderzoeksrapport-misbruik-jehovas-getuigen-blijft-openbaar",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: university-press-release; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "af2198c68fc37e1ded1644ff617cc714f5d79c5d41ac1e9b6ea265ee5ac00c16",
"final_url": "https://www.uu.nl/nieuws/onderzoeksrapport-misbruik-jehovas-getuigen-blijft-openbaar"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 786,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from the existing 'Hans U.' Cologne priest conviction record (2022-hans-u-priest-archdiocese-cologne-germany): this is the archdiocese's own commissioned accountability report, not a criminal proceeding, and covers 202 accused across 75 years rather than one defendant.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-gercke-gutachten-erzbistum-koeln-germany",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Cologne, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 50.9375,
"lng": 6.9603,
"title": "Germany: Gercke report names 202 accused and finds duty violations across Cologne archdiocese leadership",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy and diocesan leadership of the Archdiocese of Cologne, 1946-2021"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly and episcopal pastoral authority",
"diocesan personnel practices that reassigned or shielded accused clergy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Cologne",
"Gercke Wollschläger Rechtsanwälte"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent legal expert report commissioned by the Archdiocese of Cologne",
"stage": "commissioned independent report",
"date": "2021-03-18",
"outcome": "Criminal-defence lawyer Björn Gercke's 800-page report — the first of its kind to name responsible officials without redaction — identified evidence against 202 accused individuals, 63% of them clergy. It found the greatest number of duty violations against the deceased Cardinal Joachim Meisner and charged then-Hamburg Archbishop Stefan Heße with eleven duty violations over his handling of abuse allegations while a Cologne official. It explicitly found no duty violations by then-Archbishop Cardinal Rainer Woelki, whose earlier decision to suppress a prior report had triggered the commission."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report documents how archdiocesan clergy's pastoral authority over parishioners, and the diocese's own personnel and disciplinary structures, both enabled abuse by named priests and determined which officials were held responsible for concealing it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/gutachten-gerke-umgang-vorwuerfe-missbrauch-erzbistum-koeln",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Legal Tribune Online, 'Missbrauchsvorwürfe: 202 Beschuldigte im Erzbistum Köln' (18 March 2021). German: reports the Gercke Gutachten's finding of 202 accused, 63% clergy, and findings against Meisner and Heße. English gloss: 'Abuse allegations: 202 accused in the Archdiocese of Cologne.'",
"body": "Primary German legal-press report on the Gercke Gutachten's release and content.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/zwei-gutachten-und-ihre-konsequenzen-chronik-der-missbrauchsaufarbeitung-im-erzbistum-koeln",
"archive": "",
"citation": "DOMRADIO.DE, 'Zwei Gutachten und ihre Konsequenzen: Chronik der Missbrauchsaufarbeitung im Erzbistum Köln.' German: timeline of the two Cologne reports and their consequences. English gloss: 'Two reports and their consequences: chronicle of abuse reckoning in the Archdiocese of Cologne.'",
"body": "Corroborating chronology from Catholic broadcaster.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/gutachten-gerke-umgang-vorwuerfe-missbrauch-erzbistum-koeln",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "57ec39d35e45150d8d4b0d799188b561e44adea91e41fdcc16510fce120853ba",
"final_url": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/gutachten-gerke-umgang-vorwuerfe-missbrauch-erzbistum-koeln"
},
{
"source": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/zwei-gutachten-und-ihre-konsequenzen-chronik-der-missbrauchsaufarbeitung-im-erzbistum-koeln",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2f9a27abcd0e0472e440ed05c7370ccad6f32207fbcd51366d304f82d67931d6",
"final_url": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/zwei-gutachten-und-ihre-konsequenzen-chronik-der-missbrauchsaufarbeitung-im-erzbistum-koeln"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 787,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from the existing individual Munich records ('Juan B.' shaman and the Pauline-order priest): this is the archdiocese's own commissioned accountability report covering the whole diocese across 74 years, not a single criminal conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-westpfahl-spilker-wastl-gutachten-munich-germany",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Munich, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 48.1351,
"lng": 11.582,
"title": "Germany: Munich abuse report finds Joseph Ratzinger 'with high probability' knowingly deployed abusers",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy and archdiocesan leadership of the Archdiocese of Munich and Freising, 1945-2019"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly and episcopal pastoral authority",
"reassignment of known abusers to pastoral roles by diocesan personnel officials"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Munich and Freising",
"Westpfahl Spilker Wastl Rechtsanwälte"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent legal expert report commissioned by the Archdiocese of Munich and Freising",
"stage": "commissioned independent report",
"date": "2022-01-20",
"outcome": "The Munich law firm Westpfahl Spilker Wastl found at least 497 children and young people abused by 235 suspected perpetrators, including 173 priests, in the archdiocese between 1945 and 2019. It found Joseph Ratzinger (later Pope Benedict XVI), as Archbishop of Munich and Freising 1977-1982, committed misconduct in four cases and stated his denial of knowledge was 'barely consistent' with the documentary record, concluding he 'with high probability' knowingly deployed known abusers in pastoral roles. It also found misconduct by former Archbishop Friedrich Wetter and Cardinal Reinhard Marx, and 22 instances of misconduct by longtime personnel official Gerhard Gruber."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report documents how archdiocesan clergy's pastoral authority over parishioners enabled the underlying abuse, and how the archdiocese's own personnel decisions — made by named senior clergy including a future pope — repeatedly returned known abusers to positions of pastoral trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/gutachten-sexueller-missbrauch-kinder-kirche-erzbistum-muenchen-freising-papst-benedikt-wsw",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Legal Tribune Online, 'Gutachten über Missbrauch im Bistum München vorgestellt' (20 January 2022). German: reports the WSW Gutachten's presentation, scale of findings, and the Ratzinger finding. English gloss: 'Report on abuse in the Diocese of Munich presented.'",
"body": "Primary German legal-press report on the report's release and content.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C3%BCnchner_Missbrauchsgutachten",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia (German), 'Münchner Missbrauchsgutachten.' German: encyclopedia summary of the report's commissioning, findings and reception. English gloss: 'Munich Abuse Report.'",
"body": "Corroborating summary including the 497 victims / 235 suspects / 173 priests figures.",
"tier": "secondary-reference",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/gutachten-sexueller-missbrauch-kinder-kirche-erzbistum-muenchen-freising-papst-benedikt-wsw",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "845cf9962355ca4b6c254bc9c1a4d11b5e7af0c1b9d7d6570646f1e4d54d2f75",
"final_url": "https://www.lto.de/recht/nachrichten/n/gutachten-sexueller-missbrauch-kinder-kirche-erzbistum-muenchen-freising-papst-benedikt-wsw"
},
{
"source": "https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C3%BCnchner_Missbrauchsgutachten",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-reference; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a02dc6bb58818612438e25e1b32363e8a595f597ad278896b3b264b88389bb0c",
"final_url": "https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C3%BCnchner_Missbrauchsgutachten"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 788,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Non-Catholic German record — Jehovah's Witnesses congregation, distinct from the corpus's German material, which prior to this record was entirely Catholic or new-religious-movement.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-jehovahs-witness-greifswald-germany",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Greifswald, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany",
"lat": 54.0865,
"lng": 13.3923,
"title": "Germany: Jehovah's Witness congregant convicted of abusing a boy during Kingdom Hall ceremonies, Greifswald",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior congregant in a paternal-mentor role within the Greifswald Kingdom Hall congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"trusted paternal-figure role within the closed congregation",
"congregation's multi-year internal handling of his confession before any report to authorities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses — Königreichssaal Greifswald"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Amtsgericht Greifswald, Germany",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2016-05-10",
"outcome": "A 53-year-old member of the Jehovah's Witnesses' Greifswald congregation was convicted of sexually abusing an 11-year-old boy in two incidents in 2005, occurring in connection with religious ceremonies at the Greifswald Kingdom Hall. He confessed fully, sparing the child a trial appearance, and received one year two months' probation plus a €900 fine. He had confessed to congregation elders roughly a year after the abuse; the elders took no action for years and only expelled him from the congregation in 2012, seven years after his confession and four years before the criminal conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The perpetrator occupied a trusted, quasi-paternal role within the closed congregation, and the abuse is tied to religious ceremonies at the Kingdom Hall; the congregation's own internal, years-long, non-reporting handling of his confession is the coercive institutional mechanism that delayed any external accountability.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nordkurier.de/regional/anklam/sexueller-missbrauch:-zeuge-jehovas-verurteilt-1241346",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nordkurier, 'Sexueller Missbrauch: Zeuge Jehovas verurteilt' (10 May 2016). German: reports the Greifswald district court conviction, sentence, and the congregation's multi-year internal handling. English gloss: 'Sexual abuse: Jehovah's Witness convicted.'",
"body": "Primary German court-reporting article naming the court, sentence, dates, and congregation's internal response.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nordkurier.de/regional/anklam/sexueller-missbrauch:-zeuge-jehovas-verurteilt-1241346",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d4239643a33e2cd6b9d7a5d80b77fe070821b5e5613efb9ecdac17314f0013ad",
"final_url": "https://www.nordkurier.de/regional/anklam/sexueller-missbrauch%3A-zeuge-jehovas-verurteilt-1241346"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 789,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "One of six named leads specified in the discovery brief; the only one of the six confirmed in scope after reading the full opinion. Verified via full-text PDF from CourtListener's storage CDN (opinion id 4636861), not merely the search snippet, per the corpus's read-the-disposition-not-just-the-facts rule.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-russell-little-bowie-county-texas-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Texarkana, Bowie County, Texas, USA",
"lat": 33.4418,
"lng": -94.0377,
"title": "United States: Texas youth group leader convicted of sexual assault and indecency with a congregant, affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth group leader, Rise Church (f/k/a Center West Baptist Church), Bowie County, Texas"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"trusted access to a congregant's teenage friend through his church youth-group role",
"use of church-adjacent routines (post-church massages, church pickups, youth-group camping trips) to isolate the victim"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Rise Church (f/k/a Center West Baptist Church), Texarkana, Texas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals, Sixth Appellate District of Texas at Texarkana",
"stage": "direct appeal",
"date": "2020-11-18",
"outcome": "A Bowie County jury convicted Russell Little of two counts of sexual assault of a child and three counts of indecency with a child by sexual contact; twenty years' imprisonment and a $10,000 fine on each count. The Sixth Court of Appeals held the evidence legally sufficient, found no double-jeopardy violation, and held the remaining points of error unpreserved, AFFIRMING the trial court's judgments in full (Little v. State, No. 06-19-00270-CR)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Little was a youth group leader at the victim's church; his standing as a trusted adult in that role gave him routine, unsupervised access to her (picking her up from church, massages after church, overnight stays through his daughter's friendship, youth-group camping trips), which he used to commit years of escalating sexual contact and assault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9425606/russell-little-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Little v. State, No. 06-19-00270-CR (Tex. App.—Texarkana Nov. 18, 2020, mem. op.). CourtListener opinion id 4636861.",
"body": "Full memorandum opinion: 'A Bowie County jury convicted Russell Little of two counts of sexual assault of a child and three counts of indecency with a child by sexual contact... Little was also a youth group leader at Rise Church, f/k/a Center West Baptist Church. According to Jane, Little was very hands-on with the girls in the youth group... Little would also take her and her friends on camping trips and would often bring Jane to his home after church... We conclude that (1) legally sufficient evidence supports each conviction, (2) there was no double jeopardy violation in this case, and (3) Little has failed to preserve his last three points of error. As a result, we affirm the trial court's judgments.'",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9425606/russell-little-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9425606/russell-little-v-state/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 790,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Found via the 'deacon + indecency' phrase sweep. Verified via full-text PDF from CourtListener's storage CDN (opinion id 11087819).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-clifton-allen-longview-texas-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Longview, Gregg County, Texas, USA",
"lat": 32.5007,
"lng": -94.7405,
"title": "United States: Texas church deacon convicted of indecency with a child left in his care during Bible study, affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"deacon, small church in Longview, Texas"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual-office custodial authority: entrusted by the congregation to watch children in the church kitchen while their families attended Bible study and prayer meetings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed small church, Longview, Texas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals, Sixth Appellate District of Texas at Texarkana",
"stage": "direct appeal",
"date": "2025-06-30",
"outcome": "The trial court found Clifton Allen, Jr. guilty of indecency with a child by sexual contact and sentenced him to twenty years' imprisonment. The Sixth Court of Appeals held the evidence legally sufficient — including Allen's own admission to a DPS special agent that he intentionally touched the child in a way that aroused him — and AFFIRMED the trial court's judgment of conviction (Allen v. State, No. 06-24-00152-CR)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Allen held the church office of deacon and was specifically charged by the congregation with watching the children, including the 13-year-old victim, in the church kitchen while their families attended Bible studies and prayer meetings — a direct ritual-office custodial authority that placed the victim in his unsupervised care and which he used to commit the offense.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/11087819/clifton-allen-jr-v-the-state-of-texas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Allen v. State, No. 06-24-00152-CR (Tex. App.—Texarkana June 30, 2025, mem. op.). CourtListener opinion id 11087819.",
"body": "Full memorandum opinion: 'Allen was charged with engaging in sexual contact with A.A., a thirteen-year-old child, at a small church in Longview in July 2018. Allen was a deacon at the church, and the contact between Allen and A.A. occurred when Allen was charged with watching A.A. and other children in the church's kitchen area while the children's families attended Bible studies and prayer meetings... Allen admitted touching several child victims, including A.A., during an interview with Officer Rusty Hughes... We affirm the trial court's judgment of conviction.'",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/11087819/clifton-allen-jr-v-the-state-of-texas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/11087819/clifton-allen-jr-v-the-state-of-texas/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 791,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "MIXED CASE, included on the additional-victims basis. The charged complainant in this specific appeal was Johnson's own daughter (a family relationship, which alone would not satisfy the corpus's criterion), but the opinion independently documents that his deacon role also gave him access to abuse other congregant girls, which does satisfy it. Flagged for a stricter future pass if the corpus's editors want to hold this one to the single-victim standard instead.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-alfredo-lee-johnson-houston-texas-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Houston, Harris County, Texas, USA",
"lat": 29.7604,
"lng": -95.3698,
"title": "United States: Texas church deacon sentenced to life for continuous sexual abuse of his daughter; other church girls' accusations admitted at trial, affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"deacon, unnamed church, Houston/Harris County, Texas"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"deacon standing within the congregation, giving access to and standing with other church families' daughters beyond his own family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed church, Harris County, Texas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals, Fourteenth District of Texas (Houston)",
"stage": "direct appeal",
"date": "2023-02-16",
"outcome": "A Harris County jury convicted Alfredo Lee Johnson of continuous sexual abuse of a young child and assessed punishment of imprisonment for life. The Fourteenth Court of Appeals rejected Johnson's jury-charge, extraneous-offense, and excluded-evidence points and AFFIRMED (Johnson v. State, No. 14-21-00597-CR)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Johnson served as a deacon in the church he and his daughter (the charged complainant) attended. The opinion records that after the daughter's outcry, 'other young women who were social friends of complainant at their church came forward and made accusations of sexual abuse against appellant' — abuse allegations by additional congregant girls, admitted at trial as extraneous-offense evidence, showing his deacon standing gave him access to and trust with children in the congregation beyond his own family.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9372202/alfredo-lee-johnson-v-the-state-of-texas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Johnson v. State, No. 14-21-00597-CR (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] Feb. 16, 2023, mem. op.). CourtListener opinion id 9372202.",
"body": "Full memorandum opinion: 'A jury convicted appellant Alfredo Lee Johnson of the first-degree felony of continuous sexual abuse of a young child... The jury assessed punishment of imprisonment for life... Complainant and appellant were very involved in their church where appellant served as a deacon... When she was 16 years old, other young women who were social friends of complainant at their church came forward and made accusations of sexual abuse against appellant.'",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9372202/alfredo-lee-johnson-v-the-state-of-texas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9372202/alfredo-lee-johnson-v-the-state-of-texas/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 792,
"aliases": [
"Robert V. Maldonado",
"Roberto Vandevert Maldonado"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Found via the 'spiritual adviser' phrase sweep (surfaced through the clergy-privilege evidentiary issue on appeal, Tex. R. Evid. 505). Verified via full-text opinion fetched from CourtListener's storage CDN (opinion id 2919611).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2001-roberto-maldonado-harlingen-texas-usa",
"year": 2001,
"place": "Harlingen, Cameron County, Texas, USA",
"lat": 26.1906,
"lng": -97.6961,
"title": "United States: LDS ward clerk convicted of indecency with a member's child after two families' complaints to the bishop, affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ward clerk, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints ward, Harlingen, Texas"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"leadership calling (ward clerk) within the congregation, used to become involved in church members' activities with their children",
"institutional response that quietly removed him from his position rather than reporting to police, delaying accountability across at least two separate families' complaints"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Harlingen ward, Texas"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals, Thirteenth District of Texas (Corpus Christi)",
"stage": "direct appeal",
"date": "2001-08-23",
"outcome": "A Cameron County jury found Roberto Vandevert Maldonado guilty of indecency with a child for touching the victim's breasts. As a habitual offender, he was sentenced to 40 years' confinement. The Thirteenth Court of Appeals held the clergy-privilege objection to the bishop's testimony was properly overruled and the evidence legally sufficient, and AFFIRMED the conviction (Maldonado v. State, No. 13-00-357-CR)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Maldonado held the leadership calling of ward clerk in a Harlingen LDS congregation and, per the opinion, 'became involved in various activities with church members and their children' through that standing. Two separate families reported him to the ward bishop, Richard Jordon, for inappropriate touching of their daughters in 1998 and 1999 before he was finally removed from his position; the bishop's testimony about those confrontations was admitted at trial over a clergy-privilege objection.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2919611/robert-v-maldonado-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Maldonado v. State, No. 13-00-357-CR (Tex. App.—Corpus Christi Aug. 23, 2001). CourtListener opinion id 2919611.",
"body": "Full opinion: 'Appellant, a ward clerk in a Harlingen church, became involved in various activities with church members and their children. In 1998 and 1999, two families told their church's superior that appellant was \"inappropriately\" touching their daughters. In 1998, Richard Jordon, the Harlingen church's bishop, called a meeting with appellant to confront him about a complaint that he kissed a minor girl. In 1999, Bishop Jordon confronted appellant with another complaint... After the second incident, appellant was told that he no longer had a leadership position with the church and was not welcome there... Since he was a habitual offender, appellant was sentenced to confinement for 40 years... the judgment of the trial court is AFFIRMED.'",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2919611/robert-v-maldonado-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/2919611/robert-v-maldonado-v-state/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 793,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting the ABSENCE of prosecution as the finding, in the same class as the existing 1954 Kilkenny/Upton and 1953 Tralee records. Individuals recorded under the Commission's own pseudonyms. Chapter also documents a serious, distinct problem of unsupervised peer-on-peer sexual abuse among boys through the 1940s (paras 90-110), included here only for context — it is a management-neglect finding, not a named-perpetrator non-prosecution, and is not separately entered. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1946-carriglea-non-prosecution-pattern-ireland",
"year": 1946,
"place": "Carriglea, Dun Laoghaire, Ireland",
"lat": 53.2743,
"lng": -6.133,
"title": "Ireland: Carriglea industrial school — internal Church tribunals found 'criminal or indecent assault' proven, twice, and never once called the Gardai",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"the Christian Brothers' General Council in Rome, sitting as an internal disciplinary tribunal",
"the Provincial, who investigated and dispensed rather than referred to police"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"internal canonical trial substituted for criminal prosecution despite the Commission's own finding that the allegations were understood at the time as 'criminal or indecent assault'",
"dismissal or dispensation from vows used as the terminal sanction in place of a police referral",
"children's inability to resist an institution that 'owned you body and soul once you were inside them walls'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Carriglea Park Industrial School",
"Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 1 ch. 10",
"stage": "official findings, internal Church tribunal only — no criminal proceedings found anywhere in the chapter",
"date": "1946-01-01",
"outcome": "Br Tristan, transferred to Carriglea under a cloud in the early 1940s, was tried by the Christian Brothers' General Council in Rome on 16th October 1944 after 'a series of accusations by boys ... indicating criminal or indecent assault'; he was found guilty and unanimously expelled, but the Commission recorded that this internal verdict never became a police matter — he simply applied for and was granted a dispensation from his vows. Br Lancelin, transferred to Carriglea in 1944, was accused of 'immoral conduct' by written statements from multiple boys; at a General Council hearing on 19th January 1945 he admitted the substance of the allegations and was dismissed from the Congregation. Separately, the Investigation Committee heard direct testimony from two complainants: one alleged he was made to perform oral sex by Br Vic on two occasions in the early 1950s and was punished for reporting it to a priest; the other alleged repeated sexual abuse by an older boy from the late 1940s. No Garda referral, charge, or court proceeding appears anywhere in the chapter for any of these cases."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "An internal Church court that used the very language of criminal law — 'offences', 'charges', 'guilt' — to convict two Brothers of abusing children in its care, and then treated dismissal from a religious order as if it discharged the matter, leaving the State's justice system untouched by a finding the Church's own tribunal had already made.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-94",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 10 paras 94-98 (Br Tristan), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's account of Br Tristan's internal trial, guilty finding, and dispensation in lieu of any criminal referral.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-99",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 10 para 99 (Br Lancelin), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's account of Br Lancelin's admission and dismissal without police involvement.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-107",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 10 paras 107-109 (Br Vic and named complainants), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "Direct complainant testimony of sexual abuse and its concealment.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-94",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "52fdc602d1770f0ea6af2419a7d6975415300872080cf1827530e44dcef105e6",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-94"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-99",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "07c0e2ef7c0a47f20e7571eb6966aea8be69b47cd1bebe1113d13bcd50a10d92",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-99"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-107",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a65d1a24b010572ef452142d9e08b4c0f59844cb14acba4528a514f6b492d839",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-10-107"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 794,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting the ABSENCE of prosecution as the finding, same class as the existing Kilkenny/Upton, Tralee, and Carriglea records. Individuals recorded under the Commission's own pseudonyms. Glin's chapter is dominated by physical-abuse and neglect findings (a severe, systemic corporal punishment regime); this record isolates only the two documented sexual-abuse non-prosecutions. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1944-glin-non-prosecution-pattern-ireland",
"year": 1944,
"place": "Glin, County Limerick, Ireland",
"lat": 52.5667,
"lng": -9.2833,
"title": "Ireland: Glin industrial school — a confessed abuser offered the choice of 'apply for a dispensation or stand trial', and the Congregation chose neither",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"the Superior General of the Christian Brothers, who explicitly weighed 'stand trial' against internal discipline and chose the latter",
"the General Council, which voted to retain rather than expel or refer to police"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"an explicit internal choice between criminal trial and Church discipline, decided in favour of discipline",
"repeated transfer of Brothers with known or confessed histories of sexual abuse into a residential school where children had 'no recourse to their families'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Glin",
"Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 1 ch. 11",
"stage": "official findings, internal Church tribunal only — no criminal proceedings found anywhere in the chapter",
"date": "1944-01-01",
"outcome": "While resident in Artane, Br Buiron confessed to the Superior that he had sexually abused a boy in the infirmary; General Council minutes record the Superior General telling him directly that he could 'apply for a dispensation or stand trial' and citing two Brothers 'hanged in Canada' and another awaiting murder trial in Rome for comparable offences as the stakes. Br Buiron refused to apply for a dispensation and appeared before the General Council — which then voted unanimously NOT to send him for trial, retaining him with a canonical warning and a penance instead, and transferring him first to Cork and then to Glin, where he served almost seven years. Separately, Br Piperel — already the subject of a serious sexual-interference complaint in Letterfrack that was investigated only by a Visitor's letter — was transferred to Glin, then to Cork, where his conduct toward young girls caused an urgent removal into retirement; no criminal referral is recorded at any stage of his career. The Commission's own general conclusion for the chapter states plainly that both men were sent to Glin specifically after complaints or suspicions of sexual abuse elsewhere, calling the decision 'reckless'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A confessed abuser was told in writing that the alternative to Church discipline was standing trial — the Congregation knew a criminal justice system existed and chose, as an internal act of governance, not to let it touch him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-11-129",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 11 paras 129-131 (Br Buiron), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Superior General's letter offering the choice between dispensation and trial, and the General Council's vote to retain him.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-11-132",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 11 paras 132-133 (Br Piperel and general conclusions), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's finding that both men were transferred to Glin after sexual-abuse complaints elsewhere, and that this was reckless.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-11-129",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "261435ed06896dd1a61ddcaab2c3f4e7f83c3fd47ecb092e42a0e299d9c88fc4",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-11-129"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-11-132",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9d68e18bfa012519b5dcaf70ebd8f6379c76d8d5db842b8f1c6564cae0ea795c",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-11-132"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 795,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting the ABSENCE of prosecution as the finding, same class as Kilkenny/Upton, Tralee, Carriglea, and Glin. This is the CLEANEST textual instance yet found — the Ryan Report uses the words 'no prosecution or even a formal report to the Gardai' directly, rather than requiring inference from surrounding narrative. A separate lay care worker, Mr Nolan, made his OWN statement to the Gardai in the mid-1990s alleging abuse by three Brothers while he was a Salthill pupil decades earlier — this is the victim's own later action, not an institutional referral, and is noted for completeness but not the basis of this record. Individuals recorded under the Commission's own pseudonyms. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1962-salthill-br-dacian-non-prosecution-ireland",
"year": 1962,
"place": "Salthill, Galway, Ireland",
"lat": 53.2601,
"lng": -9.0765,
"title": "Ireland: 'In none of the Br Dacian cases was there a prosecution or even a formal report to the Gardai' — the Ryan Report's own words for a 25-year pattern",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"the Visitor who confirmed the 1962 abuse and called it a 'lapse'",
"the Superior and Provincial who investigated the 1980s Tom Murphy case directly and confirmed the perpetrator's own admission",
"the Christian Brothers' Congregation, which relocated the man through four further postings after each disclosure"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parental fear of publicity used, by the Commission's own account, as the reason families repeatedly declined to involve the Gardai",
"internal 'private investigation' offered by the Provincial as a substitute for police involvement",
"transfer to a retreat centre and then a therapy centre in England used in place of any referral to police"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Salthill",
"Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 1 ch. 12",
"stage": "official findings — the Commission states directly that no prosecution or Garda report occurred in any instance across 25 years",
"date": "1962-01-01",
"outcome": "In the early 1960s a boy in Salthill reported being touched in his genitals at night by a man he identified as Br Dacian; Br Dacian confessed to the Visitor, offered an explanation the Visitor found unconvincing, and was quietly transferred to a Dublin day school. Some 25 years later, as Principal of a primary school, Br Dacian was reported to the Archbishop for sexually interfering with a pupil, Tom Murphy; he admitted to the Superior that 'the relationship' had continued for two years, and the family — fearing publicity — declined to pursue legal action, accepting instead a private Congregation investigation. A further case (Peter Brady, abused during a Gaeltacht course) surfaced in the same period; the father again declined to press charges. The Congregation's response across all instances was retreat, therapy, and reassignment rather than referral. The Commission's own conclusion states: 'In none of the Br Dacian cases was there a prosecution or even a formal report to the Gardai. None of the victims wished to pursue the matter by way of Garda investigation.' A parallel case in the same chapter, Br Julien, left the Congregation in 1944 after 'clear evidence' of 'serious, long, continued misconduct with boys' in Artane, with no criminal referral recorded."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Commission does not merely infer the absence of prosecution here — it states it outright, in its own voice, as the finding: a quarter-century, multiple victims, multiple institutions, and never once a formal report to police.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-64",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 12 paras 64-68 (the 1962 Salthill incident), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The original 1962 confession and quiet transfer.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-70",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 12 paras 70-84 (the Tom Murphy case), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "Br Dacian's admission of two years of abuse and the family's decision, out of fear of publicity, not to involve the Gardai.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-105",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 12 para 105, via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's direct statement: 'In none of the Br Dacian cases was there a prosecution or even a formal report to the Gardai.'",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-64",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "45dffecdf37af2605504ca36e325d83ee46b0de324da31e48473fd7376855889",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-64"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-70",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5c25e2ab06d962b5527d573076d2109c5a9af53622a8c34257f451d5945af284",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-70"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-105",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8e090694597c47a5db3fec0275d61e62f815fe6b7acd27119365e1eed3fb00cd",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-12-105"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 796,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting the ABSENCE of prosecution as the finding, same class as Kilkenny/Upton, Tralee, Carriglea, Glin, and Salthill. Unusually for this pattern, one strand (Mr Moore) DID involve an active Garda investigation — included because the Commission records no charge, trial, or conviction resulting from it, only an employment dismissal; this is a partial variant of the pattern and is flagged as such rather than a clean zero-police-contact case like the other three strands (Br Farber, Br Boucher, Mr Lynch) in the same record. Individuals recorded under the Commission's own pseudonyms. St Joseph's Cabra also documents severe peer-sexual-abuse findings among the boys attributed to management's 'ambivalence' — a distinct, non-perpetrator-named institutional failure, not separately entered here. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-cabra-non-prosecution-pattern-ireland",
"year": 1990,
"place": "St Joseph's School for Deaf Boys, Cabra, Dublin, Ireland",
"lat": 53.3667,
"lng": -6.3,
"title": "Ireland: at the deaf school in Cabra, one man was Garda-investigated with no recorded outcome, and three more were let go without the Gardai ever being told",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"the School Principal and Director of Residential Care, who ran a lengthy internal investigation into the lay care worker Mr Moore",
"the Congregation, which took no equivalent action against two Brothers implicated in the same investigation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a documented decision NOT to inform the Gardai of a clear allegation of a Brother fondling a child's genitals, on the stated ground that the complaint 'was not very clear'",
"acceptance of a staff member's resignation in place of any inquiry into whether abuse occurred",
"a residential school for deaf children where communication with outside authorities was already structurally difficult, compounding the isolation of the boys"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's School for Deaf Boys, Cabra",
"Christian Brothers",
"Eastern Health Board"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 1 ch. 13",
"stage": "official findings — a live Garda investigation with no recorded outcome, alongside three further cases with no Garda involvement at all",
"date": "1990-01-01",
"outcome": "In the early 1990s a boy witnessed his House Parent, Mr Moore, engaged in sexual activity with another resident boy; a Garda investigation ran alongside an Eastern Health Board inquiry and a St Clare's Unit clinical assessment, ultimately screening 70 past and present pupils, but Mr Moore was dismissed from employment approximately two months in and no conviction, charge, or trial outcome is recorded anywhere in the chapter. In the course of that same investigation, allegations of sexual abuse emerged against a Christian Brother, Br Farber (Br Farber 'did not return to Cabra' — no investigation by Congregation or State is recorded), and against a second Brother, Br Boucher, whom the school authorities admitted they did NOT report to the Gardai, stating the complaint 'was not very clear' — a characterisation the Commission rejected outright, finding the allegation of fondling 'plainly a matter for the Gardai to pursue.' A third case, staff supervisor Mr Lynch, accused in the early 1980s of showing 'dirty books' to and abusing a boy, resigned the same day he was confronted; the Commission states directly, 'The Gardai were not informed, so there was no criminal investigation,' and that he was free to 'seek work with children in a different facility.'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A deaf boys' school where the very children least equipped to be believed by hearing authorities produced, when investigators finally listened, four separate men accused within a few years of each other — and only one was ever the subject of a Garda file, with no recorded result.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-76",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 13 paras 76-90 (Mr Moore and Br Farber), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Garda-investigated Moore case with no recorded outcome, and the uninvestigated Br Farber allegations arising from the same inquiry.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-106",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 13 paras 106-111 (Br Boucher), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Congregation's own admission that the Gardai were not informed, and the Commission's rejection of their stated reason.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-112",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 1 ch. 13 paras 112-114 (Mr Lynch), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's direct statement that the Gardai were not informed and so there was no criminal investigation.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-76",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "92ca0e39c3a58ae24d8dec28b6781375c5a1374052998a01d230a3d158892b0f",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-76"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-106",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a6e2cf588c8060ce4388f6bbe93d248194bf98dbb58591ebd85e6fed44f5c34c",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-106"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-112",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f5143e5014d9727ad9400f5e534e50397c5bf403c3ff1798bfbcb522c3b79dd5",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/1-13-112"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 797,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting the ABSENCE of prosecution as the finding, same class as the existing Kilkenny/Upton, Tralee, Carriglea, Glin, Salthill, and St Joseph's Cabra records (the last four ingested in the prior session, new-records-84.mjs, not yet merged to corpus as of this session). Greenmount chapter also documents nine former residents convicted of peer indecency offences in the mid-1930s (para 161) — this is children being prosecuted, the inverse of the pattern sought, and is not entered here. Individuals recorded under the Commission's own pseudonyms. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1955-greenmount-br-carlito-non-prosecution-ireland",
"year": 1955,
"place": "Greenmount, Cork, Ireland",
"lat": 51.8935,
"lng": -8.4738,
"title": "Ireland: 'Br Carlito was not prosecuted' — the Ryan Report's own words for a Resident Manager two bishops and a Garda superintendent all knew about",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Br Carlito, Resident Manager of Greenmount, who resigned his post in 1955 but remained in the Congregation and continued teaching children until retirement",
"Bishop Cornelius Lucey of Cork and Ross, who ran his own investigation via Canon David and was told there was 'no doubt about their guilt', but never referred the matter to police",
"the Presentation Brothers' Provincial and General Council, who received the Gardai's mid-1990s findings and, per the Commission, supplied 'seriously misleading' information back to them"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a boy's direct report to the local Garda Chief Superintendent (by name, via his own father's connection) redirected into a private meeting with the elderly Bishop, who told the boys 'they don't do that', called them 'devils', threatened excommunication, and sent them back to be flogged the next morning",
"internal canonical/diocesan visitations run in parallel with, and in place of, any police referral",
"dispensation from vows and immediate placement into a new teaching post at Waterford used as the resolution for a second confessed/accused Brother"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Greenmount",
"Presentation Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 2 ch. 4",
"stage": "official findings; a mid-1990s Garda investigation into the same Resident Manager also produced no prosecution — the Commission's own conclusion is that he was never prosecuted at any point across a documented 40-year span",
"date": "1955-01-01",
"outcome": "In late 1955 the Resident Manager of Greenmount, Br Carlito, and a senior teaching Brother, Br Garcia, were the subject of serious sexual-abuse allegations investigated in parallel by a diocesan Canon (on behalf of Bishop Cornelius Lucey) and a Congregation Visitor; the Superior General's own diary records the Canon reporting 'no doubt about their guilt' and the Bishop saying the same by phone. Br Carlito resigned as Resident Manager on 27th December 1955 but remained in the Congregation, continued teaching in other schools until retirement, and died before the Commission could hear him. Br Garcia obtained a dispensation from his vows in February 1956 and began teaching at a school in Waterford the following Monday. A boy, Michael, had earlier gone directly to Cork's Chief Superintendent, Supt Caffrey — known to him through his father — to report the abuse; the Superintendent drove him and a friend by police car to Bishop Cohalan, who told them 'the Christian Brothers don't do these things at all', called them 'two devils', and threatened to have them excommunicated; they were flogged the next morning. Decades later, in the mid-1990s, the Gardai questioned Br Carlito directly over an allegation that he had sexually interfered with a three-and-a-half-year-old boy; a solicitor's letter to the Provincial recorded that three children in total had alleged sexual interference and that two had been medically found to have been 'buggered'. The Ryan Report states directly: 'Br Carlito was not prosecuted.' The Commission separately found that when the Gardai investigated in the 1990s, 'the information supplied by a senior member of the Congregation was seriously misleading' — meaning the Congregation actively obstructed the one police investigation that did occur, rather than merely omitting to report."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child went over the heads of both the school and the Church, straight to a named police chief superintendent he trusted through family connection — and was still delivered back into the hands of a bishop who called him a devil, and back to the school for a flogging. Forty years later Gardai investigated the same Brother and were, in the Commission's own words, misled by his own Congregation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-103",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 4 paras 103-114 (the 1955 crisis and dual investigations), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Superior General's diary recording the Canon's and Bishop's shared view that there was 'no doubt about their guilt'.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-118",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 4 paras 118-125 (Br Carlito's resignation and Br Garcia's dispensation), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "Both men's uninterrupted return to teaching posts and the absence of any Garda referral.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-140",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 4 paras 140-154 (the mid-1990s Garda investigation, Michael's direct report to Supt Caffrey, and the Commission's conclusion), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's direct statement 'Br Carlito was not prosecuted', the finding that the Congregation misled the Gardai in the 1990s investigation, and Michael's own account of being taken to Bishop Cohalan by police car.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-103",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c4722a11669cf2c2b6ba8fe28d00eddf5c8275f8c4f8ff4be95678ecb80349fc",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-103"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-118",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5df37bfe3e71fbe56ed0ee3492c6bdb98f62fae8033357d7ed636a52a847df3e",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-118"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-140",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2456547beb8cd103b4c57434682906a44b32877119d24779bfc82e1386d22f5f",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-4-140"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 798,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting the ABSENCE of prosecution as the finding, same class as the existing 1954 Kilkenny/Upton record — but that existing record cites only paras 232-240 (the 'sexual activity amongst the boys'/Departmental-pressure strand). This record covers the DISTINCT, earlier-in-chapter 'Rome files' named-perpetrator staff-abuse section (paras 145-216), which the existing record does not cite and which was previously unwalked. Do not treat as duplicate. Individuals recorded under the Commission's own pseudonyms. Paras 217 onward return to the boys-on-boys/Departmental supervision strand already covered by the existing record and are not re-entered. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1954-upton-rome-files-seven-abusers-non-prosecution-ireland",
"year": 1954,
"place": "Upton, County Cork, Ireland",
"lat": 51.7833,
"lng": -8.6833,
"title": "Ireland: the Rosminians' own Rome archive names seven sexual abusers at Upton across three decades — 'the Order did not expel members for sexual abuse' and none were ever reported as a crime",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"successive Provincials and Superiors General of the Rosminian Institute of Charity in Rome, who corresponded in coded Latin phrases about each new discovery and directed transfers rather than dismissals or police referrals",
"Br Alfonso, Prefect of Upton and later Ferryhouse from the early 1950s to early 1970s, who personally identified seven sexual abusers operating in Upton to his Superiors"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"a Rome archive that used deliberately vague, coded Latin phrasing ('cum pueris', 'periculum', 'indiscreet') specifically so that the reason for each transfer would not become known, which the Commission found also prevented the new institution from being warned",
"transfer without dismissal used as the standing remedy for a documented pattern of at least seven identified abusers over roughly three decades",
"one abuser, Fr Santino, moved between English parishes and then out of the United Kingdom into an Irish monastery for the explicit purpose (per the Commission) of avoiding a police investigation into conduct it calls 'criminal'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Upton Industrial School",
"Rosminian Institute of Charity"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 2 ch. 2",
"stage": "official findings, internal Church correspondence and canonical dispensations only — the Commission's own numbered conclusions state the Order knew the conduct was criminal and did not report it",
"date": "1954-01-01",
"outcome": "The Commission examined the Rosminian Order's own 'Rome files' — internal correspondence between the Provincial in Ireland and the Superior General in Rome — covering sexual abuse at Upton across roughly three decades. Fr Santino was transferred repeatedly within England specifically, in the Commission's words, 'for the purpose of obviating investigation', then moved to Ireland (Mount Melleray, then Upton) for the same reason; the Commission states his conduct in England 'was criminal' and that assigning him to Upton was 'irresponsible and reckless'. Br Umberto was quietly moved to Kilmurry after 'not being discreet cum pueris' (with boys). Br Constantin was removed after the Rector had 'proof that, in two cases at least, he had sinned with boys'; two witnesses (Br Alfonso and Fr Giovani) independently corroborated the discovery, alongside a second Brother, Br Fausto, found abusing at the same time. Br Fausto's abuse was flagged in correspondence from the mid-1930s to mid-1950s, with a Rome letter stating 'there is more than one victim' and advising the Provincial to 'find a good excuse for sending Fausto away'. Br Mateo was transferred after a documented incident, described internally as a 'slip'; a complainant's account of the abuse was accepted outright by the Rosminians' own counsel at the Commission hearing. Br Mario was moved after the Provincial wrote to Rome that 'the changes made are a cover up in some respects'; he was later sent to a Rosminian school for blind children, which the Commission calls 'reckless and inexplicable', and remained there until his death. Br Gilberto was induced to seek a dispensation after a 'painful' episode at Upton; his own petition stated 'I have been condemned without being informed of the nature of the charge against me.' In direct evidence, Br Alfonso told the Committee that as Prefect he identified seven sexual abusers operating in Upton — Br Fausto, Br Constantin, a named night watchman, an unnamed lay teacher, Br Mateo, Br Mario, and Br Gilberto — all of whom were 'removed from the School', none referred to police. The Commission's own numbered general conclusions for this section state: 'The Order was aware of the criminal nature of the conduct, but did not report it as a crime' and 'The Order did not expel members for sexual abuse,' further finding that for periods of years in the 1950s at least three abusers were present in Upton simultaneously, and in two separate years at least four."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "An Order that used Latin euphemism in its own internal Rome correspondence — 'cum pueris', 'periculum' — precisely so that neither the next institution nor the State would ever learn why a Brother had really been moved; the Commission's own numbered conclusion names the conduct criminal and states plainly it was never reported as a crime.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-145",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 2 paras 145-148 (Fr Santino), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's finding that Fr Santino's transfers were made 'for the purpose of obviating investigation' and that his conduct in England 'was criminal'.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-165",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 2 paras 149-193 (Br Umberto, Br Constantin, Br Fausto, Br Mateo, Br Mario, Br Gilberto), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The individual Rome-file case histories, including the Provincial's own phrase 'the changes made are a cover up in some respects'.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-196",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 2 paras 195-199 (Br Alfonso's evidence naming seven abusers), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "Br Alfonso's direct evidence identifying seven sexual abusers at Upton, all removed rather than reported.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-216",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 2 para 216 (the Commission's numbered general conclusions), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's direct numbered findings: 'The Order was aware of the criminal nature of the conduct, but did not report it as a crime' and 'The Order did not expel members for sexual abuse.'",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-145",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "38a7289296072cb784555f6e9802d2b548c54554f3150c87927fc1c83aa940c7",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-145"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-165",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4ade78e74c7848d2ced4b072c202deec0564147107904ff4effa4376be3652e0",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-165"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-196",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1fba76b8d48009a28fbe18c4f44c9c730c9b6e79b83a6a53651b77dedecfd31e",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-196"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-216",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f1d61ef329e73a80254de08672ba0171cec700f66966de159cbfe266d323a17b",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-2-216"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction (Mixed Jury Court of Ioannina, the felony trial court); no appeal reported yet as of accessed date.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-arta-greece-village-priest",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Arta, Greece",
"lat": 39.16,
"lng": 20.98,
"title": "Greece: village priest convicted of raping a child from age seven over seven years",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1624459/iereas-katadikastike-gia-viasmo-anilikis-se-horio-tis-artas-tin-kakopoiise-mehri-kai-se-kleisti-ekklisia/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Πρώτο Θέμα (2025) 'Ιερέας καταδικάστηκε για βιασμό ανήλικης σε χωριό της Άρτας: Την κακοποίησε και μέσα σε εκκλησία'. Available at: protothema.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: A 72-year-old village priest was convicted by the Mixed Jury Court of Ioannina and sentenced to nine years for raping a girl from age seven, continuing for seven years; he exploited the family's economic vulnerability, bringing food to their home, and abused her at home, near a river, and inside a closed parish church.",
"body": "Πρώτο Θέμα (2025) 'Ιερέας καταδικάστηκε για βιασμό ανήλικης σε χωριό της Άρτας: Την κακοποίησε και μέσα σε εκκλησία'. Available at: protothema.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: A 72-year-old village priest was convicted by the Mixed Jury Court of Ioannina and sentenced to nine years for raping a girl from age seven, continuing for seven years; he exploited the family's economic vulnerability, bringing food to their home, and abused her at home, near a river, and inside a closed parish church."
},
{
"link": "https://www.in.gr/2025/04/10/greece/arta-iereas-viaze-eftaxrono-koritsaki-gia-xronia-tha-ektisei-tin-poini-spiti-tou/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "in.gr (2025) 'Άρτα: Ιερέας βίαζε εφτάχρονο κοριτσάκι - Καταδικάστηκε σε 9 χρόνια αλλά θα εκτίσει την ποινή σπίτι του'. Available at: in.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: due to advanced age the court ordered the nine-year sentence served at home; the case was uncovered in 2015 when the girl's uncle, then aged 14, reported it.",
"body": "in.gr (2025) 'Άρτα: Ιερέας βίαζε εφτάχρονο κοριτσάκι - Καταδικάστηκε σε 9 χρόνια αλλά θα εκτίσει την ποινή σπίτι του'. Available at: in.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: due to advanced age the court ordered the nine-year sentence served at home; the case was uncovered in 2015 when the girl's uncle, then aged 14, reported it."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2025-04-10",
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Jury Court of Ioannina, Greece",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted; nine years' imprisonment, served at home due to advanced age"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the family's parish priest, the defendant used his pastoral relationship and home visits (bringing food) to gain access to a economically vulnerable family and isolate the child, including using the closed village church itself as an abuse location.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1624459/iereas-katadikastike-gia-viasmo-anilikis-se-horio-tis-artas-tin-kakopoiise-mehri-kai-se-kleisti-ekklisia/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1120ddee75405323e604d1eabb760ee61022d73f247b3300e15ae71e4cd31686",
"final_url": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1624459/iereas-katadikastike-gia-viasmo-anilikis-se-horio-tis-artas-tin-kakopoiise-mehri-kai-se-kleisti-ekklisia/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.in.gr/2025/04/10/greece/arta-iereas-viaze-eftaxrono-koritsaki-gia-xronia-tha-ektisei-tin-poini-spiti-tou/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a79d4f03d7b5c3e69c5ee506dba2b1a13279f0e3060859e5d502a647fd2b9bba",
"final_url": "https://www.in.gr/2025/04/10/greece/arta-iereas-viaze-eftaxrono-koritsaki-gia-xronia-tha-ektisei-tin-poini-spiti-tou/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction by the Mixed Jury Court of Larissa; the priest's ill health led to release from pre-trial detention but the sentence stands as entered. Mother convicted separately as accomplice (recorded here as context for the mechanism only, not as a second perpetrator record).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-larissa-greece-priest-11-year-old",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Larissa, Greece",
"lat": 39.64,
"lng": 22.42,
"title": "Greece: priest sentenced to eight years for abusing an 11-year-old, mother convicted as accomplice",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.in.gr/2021/09/16/greece/larisa-katheirksi-8-eton-se-ierea-pou-aselgouse-se-aniliki-poini-kai-sti-mitera-gia-synergeia/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "in.gr (2021) 'Λάρισα - Κάθειρξη 8 ετών σε ιερέα που ασελγούσε σε ανήλικη - Ποινή και στη μητέρα για συνέργεια'. Available at: in.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Mixed Jury Court of Larissa sentenced an 83-year-old priest to eight years for indecent acts against an 11-year-old girl, exploiting the mother's dire economic situation and giving her material goods in exchange for handing the child over; the mother received five years as an accomplice.",
"body": "in.gr (2021) 'Λάρισα - Κάθειρξη 8 ετών σε ιερέα που ασελγούσε σε ανήλικη - Ποινή και στη μητέρα για συνέργεια'. Available at: in.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Mixed Jury Court of Larissa sentenced an 83-year-old priest to eight years for indecent acts against an 11-year-old girl, exploiting the mother's dire economic situation and giving her material goods in exchange for handing the child over; the mother received five years as an accomplice."
},
{
"link": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1161597/larisa-80hronos-iereas-aselgouse-se-11hrono-koritsi-katadikastike-gia-sunergeia-i-mitera-tou-paidiou/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Πρώτο Θέμα (2021) 'Λάρισα: 80χρονος ιερέας ασελγούσε σε 11χρονο κορίτσι - Καταδικάστηκε για συνέργεια η μητέρα του παιδιού'. Available at: protothema.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: prosecutor quoted the child's own words -- 'he is a priest and helps us, so he touches me' -- describing the coercive dynamic.",
"body": "Πρώτο Θέμα (2021) 'Λάρισα: 80χρονος ιερέας ασελγούσε σε 11χρονο κορίτσι - Καταδικάστηκε για συνέργεια η μητέρα του παιδιού'. Available at: protothema.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: prosecutor quoted the child's own words -- 'he is a priest and helps us, so he touches me' -- describing the coercive dynamic."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2021-09-16",
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Jury Court of Larissa, Greece",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted; eight years' imprisonment (released pending health issues)"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant's status as the family's priest and material benefactor -- explicitly cited in the victim's own statement identifying him as 'a priest who helps us' -- was the operative mechanism the mother and priest jointly used to produce the child's compliance; the abuse would not have been unrefusable without that clerical position of trust.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.in.gr/2021/09/16/greece/larisa-katheirksi-8-eton-se-ierea-pou-aselgouse-se-aniliki-poini-kai-sti-mitera-gia-synergeia/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "50951556f984600d1b7a26cf973a9869ac8aca41896d42ad9a4141b6f9f92960",
"final_url": "https://www.in.gr/2021/09/16/greece/larisa-katheirksi-8-eton-se-ierea-pou-aselgouse-se-aniliki-poini-kai-sti-mitera-gia-synergeia/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1161597/larisa-80hronos-iereas-aselgouse-se-11hrono-koritsi-katadikastike-gia-sunergeia-i-mitera-tou-paidiou/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "18aeda4878b8f1e807c91790a3b80f78978a472bcedfcc3e48a9eb638c5762b2",
"final_url": "https://www.protothema.gr/greece/article/1161597/larisa-80hronos-iereas-aselgouse-se-11hrono-koritsi-katadikastike-gia-sunergeia-i-mitera-tou-paidiou/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; defendant appealed and remained free pending appeal per the source. Recorded as convicted at trial level per schema (appellateHistory left empty since the appeal outcome is not yet located).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-salamina-greece-old-calendar-priest",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Salamina, Greece",
"lat": 37.97,
"lng": 23.47,
"title": "Greece: Old Calendar priest convicted of indecent acts against a boy, released pending appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iefimerida.gr/ellada/salamina-iereas-aselgise-se-aniliko-askise-efesi",
"archive": "",
"citation": "iefimerida.gr (2023) 'Σαλαμίνα: Ο ιερέας που ασέλγησε σε ανήλικο είχε καταδικαστεί σε 9 χρόνια, αλλά άσκησε έφεση και παρέμεινε έξω'. Available at: iefimerida.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: An Old Calendar (Palaeo-Orthodox) priest was convicted in 2021 and sentenced to nine years for indecent acts against an 11-year-old boy, a complaint originally filed by the parents in 2018; he appealed and remained at liberty, and was arrested again in November 2023 on new allegations involving another minor.",
"body": "iefimerida.gr (2023) 'Σαλαμίνα: Ο ιερέας που ασέλγησε σε ανήλικο είχε καταδικαστεί σε 9 χρόνια, αλλά άσκησε έφεση και παρέμεινε έξω'. Available at: iefimerida.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: An Old Calendar (Palaeo-Orthodox) priest was convicted in 2021 and sentenced to nine years for indecent acts against an 11-year-old boy, a complaint originally filed by the parents in 2018; he appealed and remained at liberty, and was arrested again in November 2023 on new allegations involving another minor."
},
{
"link": "https://www.in.gr/2023/12/01/greece/salamina-profylakistike-o-palaioimerologitis-iereas-gia-aselgeia-se-aniliko/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "in.gr (2023) 'Σαλαμίνα: Προφυλακίστηκε ο παλαιοημερολογίτης ιερέας για ασέλγεια σε ανήλικο'. Available at: in.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "in.gr (2023) 'Σαλαμίνα: Προφυλακίστηκε ο παλαιοημερολογίτης ιερέας για ασέλγεια σε ανήλικο'. Available at: in.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2021-01-01",
"jurisdiction": "Greece (court not specified in press)",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted; nine years' imprisonment; appeal filed, defendant remained at liberty"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant held clerical authority as an Old Calendar (Palaeo-Orthodox) priest with recognized standing over the child through his parish role, which the press coverage frames as the access mechanism to the boy and, later, to a second minor.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iefimerida.gr/ellada/salamina-iereas-aselgise-se-aniliko-askise-efesi",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "966d58c53e46068e7153eb0b816b5ea1eb7b548aeaf04b6ba235f2a681f35441",
"final_url": "https://www.iefimerida.gr/ellada/salamina-iereas-aselgise-se-aniliko-askise-efesi"
},
{
"source": "https://www.in.gr/2023/12/01/greece/salamina-profylakistike-o-palaioimerologitis-iereas-gia-aselgeia-se-aniliko/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "78808963c5e5a35ceff45860b59ade0d0a608ce805f38442a36af0203ba732da",
"final_url": "https://www.in.gr/2023/12/01/greece/salamina-profylakistike-o-palaioimerologitis-iereas-gia-aselgeia-se-aniliko/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Verdict not yet final per PAP; defense announced intent to appeal. Recorded as convicted per first-instance judgment with detailed findings.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-rzeszow-poland-dominik-r",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Rzeszów, Podkarpackie Voivodeship, Poland",
"lat": 50.04,
"lng": 22,
"title": "Poland: former priest Dominik R. sentenced to five years for molesting five boys in catechism classroom",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rmf24.pl/regiony/rzeszow/news-byly-ksiadz-molestowal-pieciu-chlopcow-w-rzeszowie-zapadl-wy,nId,7970634",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RMF24 (2025) 'Rzeszów: Były ksiądz Dominik R. skazany za molestowanie nieletnich'. Available at: rmf24.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Regional Court in Rzeszów sentenced former priest Dominik R. to a combined five years for six sexual offences against five minor boys and possession of child pornography; the court found sexual-preference disorders and ordered therapeutic-conditions imprisonment, a lifetime ban on work with children, a ten-year no-contact order, and compensation totalling 110,000 PLN.",
"body": "RMF24 (2025) 'Rzeszów: Były ksiądz Dominik R. skazany za molestowanie nieletnich'. Available at: rmf24.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Regional Court in Rzeszów sentenced former priest Dominik R. to a combined five years for six sexual offences against five minor boys and possession of child pornography; the court found sexual-preference disorders and ordered therapeutic-conditions imprisonment, a lifetime ban on work with children, a ten-year no-contact order, and compensation totalling 110,000 PLN."
},
{
"link": "https://www.halorzeszow.pl/artykul/13955,byly-ksiadz-skazany-na-5-lat-wiezienia-za-molestowanie-nieletnich-szczegoly-wyroku-i-przebieg-procesu",
"archive": "",
"citation": "haloRzeszów (2025) 'Były ksiądz skazany na 5 lat więzienia za molestowanie nieletnich - szczegóły wyroku i przebieg procesu'. Available at: halorzeszow.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: One 16-year-old victim was lured to the catechism classroom on the pretext of 'professional body measurements' and made to undress; the closed-door trial ran from 7 February to 22 May 2025.",
"body": "haloRzeszów (2025) 'Były ksiądz skazany na 5 lat więzienia za molestowanie nieletnich - szczegóły wyroku i przebieg procesu'. Available at: halorzeszow.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: One 16-year-old victim was lured to the catechism classroom on the pretext of 'professional body measurements' and made to undress; the closed-door trial ran from 7 February to 22 May 2025."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2025-05-22",
"jurisdiction": "Regional Court in Rzeszów, Poland",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted on six counts; five years' imprisonment under therapeutic conditions, lifetime ban on work with minors"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As a Catholic priest and catechism instructor, the defendant used the parish catechism classroom itself and a fabricated instructional pretext ('professional body measurements') to isolate and abuse students entrusted to his religious instruction.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rmf24.pl/regiony/rzeszow/news-byly-ksiadz-molestowal-pieciu-chlopcow-w-rzeszowie-zapadl-wy,nId,7970634",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0b22419945449139a6ba9bae57b76fb21d6c22ebf218e657c7f2145cd7d94da4",
"final_url": "https://www.rmf24.pl/regiony/rzeszow/news-byly-ksiadz-molestowal-pieciu-chlopcow-w-rzeszowie-zapadl-wy,nId,7970634"
},
{
"source": "https://www.halorzeszow.pl/artykul/13955,byly-ksiadz-skazany-na-5-lat-wiezienia-za-molestowanie-nieletnich-szczegoly-wyroku-i-przebieg-procesu",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f4d676c469534ab4092582819e1596ca3b6067a72010bd8a4d158f69be25656c",
"final_url": "https://www.halorzeszow.pl/artykul/13955,byly-ksiadz-skazany-na-5-lat-wiezienia-za-molestowanie-nieletnich-szczegoly-wyroku-i-przebieg-procesu"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Verdict not final; defense may appeal. Franciscan friar, former Vatican Secretariat of State collaborator under Pope Francis.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-elblag-poland-brother-polikarp",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Elbląg, Poland",
"lat": 54.16,
"lng": 19.4,
"title": "Poland: Franciscan friar 'Brother Polikarp' convicted of molesting girls during confession and family retreats",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tvn24.pl/olsztyn/elblag-byly-wspolpracownik-papieza-zakonnik-polikarp-n-skazany-st8844093",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TVN24 (2026) 'Elbląg. Były współpracownik papieża, zakonnik Polikarp N. skazany'. Available at: tvn24.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The District Court in Elbląg sentenced Franciscan friar Jan N. ('Brother Polikarp'), a former Vatican Secretariat of State collaborator, to eight years for 14 offences against four minor girls between 2006-2016 in Poland and abroad -- molesting them during confession and raping them during family-retreat courses, exploiting his role as their spiritual guide.",
"body": "TVN24 (2026) 'Elbląg. Były współpracownik papieża, zakonnik Polikarp N. skazany'. Available at: tvn24.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The District Court in Elbląg sentenced Franciscan friar Jan N. ('Brother Polikarp'), a former Vatican Secretariat of State collaborator, to eight years for 14 offences against four minor girls between 2006-2016 in Poland and abroad -- molesting them during confession and raping them during family-retreat courses, exploiting his role as their spiritual guide."
},
{
"link": "https://dziennikelblaski.pl/artykul/molestowal-dziewczynki-n2206369",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dziennik Elbląski (2026) 'Molestował dziewczynki w trakcie spowiedzi i gwałcił podczas masaży. Zakonnik skazany za pedofilię'. Available at: dziennikelblaski.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: sentence included a permanent ban on pastoral work with minors, a ten-year 100-metre no-contact order, and 210,000 PLN in combined compensation.",
"body": "Dziennik Elbląski (2026) 'Molestował dziewczynki w trakcie spowiedzi i gwałcił podczas masaży. Zakonnik skazany za pedofilię'. Available at: dziennikelblaski.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: sentence included a permanent ban on pastoral work with minors, a ten-year 100-metre no-contact order, and 210,000 PLN in combined compensation."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-01-12",
"jurisdiction": "District Court in Elbląg, Poland",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted on 14 counts; eight years' imprisonment, lifetime pastoral ban"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The friar used the sacrament of confession itself as an abuse setting and his recognized role as the girls' spiritual director during family-retreat courses to create emotional dependency the court found the victims could not refuse.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tvn24.pl/olsztyn/elblag-byly-wspolpracownik-papieza-zakonnik-polikarp-n-skazany-st8844093",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "58091f692fa9ade1181c7a30abc9ac55860f1594f26f6cd62591fbfb6052aa16",
"final_url": "https://tvn24.pl/olsztyn/elblag-byly-wspolpracownik-papieza-zakonnik-polikarp-n-skazany-st8844093"
},
{
"source": "https://dziennikelblaski.pl/artykul/molestowal-dziewczynki-n2206369",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ccaedebe53d6b7b2212122141a9363fab05317b87f5c7be5d6903b76e1ee95b2",
"final_url": "https://dziennikelblaski.pl/artykul/molestowal-dziewczynki-n2206369"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "State Commission (Państwowa Komisja) public-registry finding, not a criminal conviction -- recorded at the official-finding evidence tier. 30-day appeal window for both accused and victim was open as of the source date; outcome not yet located. This is a distinct diocese (Bielsko-Żywiec) from the corpus's existing Diocese of Sosnowiec commission record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-miedzybrodzie-bialskie-poland-wodniak",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Międzybrodzie Bialskie, Diocese of Bielsko-Żywiec, Poland",
"lat": 49.71,
"lng": 19.15,
"title": "Poland: state pedophilia commission enters priest Jan Wodniak in the public sex-offender registry a second time",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tvn24.pl/katowice/miedzybrodzie-ksiadz-wodniak-drugi-raz-wpisany-do-rejestru-pedofilii-nazwano-po-imieniu-to-co-sie-stalo-st9074976",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TVN24 (2026) 'Międzybrodzie. Ksiądz Wodniak drugi raz wpisany do rejestru pedofilii. \"Nazwano po imieniu to, co się stało\"'. Available at: tvn24.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Poland's State Commission for Combating Sexual Abuse of Minors entered former parish priest Jan Wodniak of Międzybrodzie Bialskie (Diocese of Bielsko-Żywiec) into the public Registry of Sex Offenders for a second time, this time covering 2002-2005 acts; the first entry covered March 1984-February 1987, when altar boy Janusz Szymik was first abused at age 12. Szymik had reported the abuse to Bishop Tadeusz Rakoczy in the 1990s without institutional response, allowing Wodniak to continue in ministry for decades.",
"body": "TVN24 (2026) 'Międzybrodzie. Ksiądz Wodniak drugi raz wpisany do rejestru pedofilii. \"Nazwano po imieniu to, co się stało\"'. Available at: tvn24.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Poland's State Commission for Combating Sexual Abuse of Minors entered former parish priest Jan Wodniak of Międzybrodzie Bialskie (Diocese of Bielsko-Żywiec) into the public Registry of Sex Offenders for a second time, this time covering 2002-2005 acts; the first entry covered March 1984-February 1987, when altar boy Janusz Szymik was first abused at age 12. Szymik had reported the abuse to Bishop Tadeusz Rakoczy in the 1990s without institutional response, allowing Wodniak to continue in ministry for decades."
},
{
"link": "https://deon.pl/wiadomosci/ksiadz-trafi-do-rejestru-pedofilow-panstwowa-komisja-ds-pedofilii-miala-wydac-postanowienie,3371934",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deon.pl (2026) 'Ksiądz trafi do rejestru pedofilów? Państwowa Komisja ds. Pedofilii miała wydać postanowienie'. Available at: deon.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Deon.pl (2026) 'Ksiądz trafi do rejestru pedofilów? Państwowa Komisja ds. Pedofilii miała wydać postanowienie'. Available at: deon.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-01-01",
"jurisdiction": "State Commission for Combating Sexual Abuse of Minors, Poland",
"stage": "Public sex-offender registry entry (second entry, distinct abuse period)",
"outcome": "Entered into public Registry of Sex Offenders; 30-day appeal window open"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As parish priest, Wodniak held direct clerical authority over an altar boy who served under him from age 12; institutional silence after the victim's report to his bishop is itself part of the record and let the pattern continue for decades under the same clerical office.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tvn24.pl/katowice/miedzybrodzie-ksiadz-wodniak-drugi-raz-wpisany-do-rejestru-pedofilii-nazwano-po-imieniu-to-co-sie-stalo-st9074976",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3887a00b045581d7ada7e22a967216a172884a665308d943e2216f244f3e4593",
"final_url": "https://tvn24.pl/katowice/miedzybrodzie-ksiadz-wodniak-drugi-raz-wpisany-do-rejestru-pedofilii-nazwano-po-imieniu-to-co-sie-stalo-st9074976"
},
{
"source": "https://deon.pl/wiadomosci/ksiadz-trafi-do-rejestru-pedofilow-panstwowa-komisja-ds-pedofilii-miala-wydac-postanowienie,3371934",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aaa95958aa2fe3c04acf622a24e6ae894cf9b080dbc689a1e1a9c77272908eab",
"final_url": "https://deon.pl/wiadomosci/ksiadz-trafi-do-rejestru-pedofilow-panstwowa-komisja-ds-pedofilii-miala-wydac-postanowienie,3371934"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; not yet final -- prosecution itself appealed for a harsher (consummated rather than attempted) classification. Diocese of Angra confirmed the conviction and is running a parallel canonical process.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-faial-azores-portugal-priest",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Faial Island, Azores, Portugal",
"lat": 38.58,
"lng": -28.7,
"title": "Portugal: Azores priest convicted of attempted sexual abuse of a 15-year-old girl in his care",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://cnnportugal.iol.pt/padre-abusador/padre-abusa-de-menor/introduziu-a-mao-dentro-da-camisola-que-vestia-e-tentou-tocar-lhe-nos-seios-e-beija-la-na-boca-padre-condenado-por-tentativa-de-abuso-sexual-de-menor-nos-acores/20260619/6a357bc1d34edcee7c657dd4",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN Portugal (2026) '\"Introduziu a mão dentro da camisola que vestia e tentou tocar-lhe nos seios e beijá-la na boca\". Padre condenado por tentativa de abuso sexual de menor nos Açores'. Available at: cnnportugal.iol.pt (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Horta court (Faial, Azores) convicted a priest of attempted sexual abuse of a dependent minor; the July 2024 acts involved a 15-year-old girl who was visiting the defendant and in his care -- he embraced her, put his hand under her clothing and attempted to touch her breasts and kiss her mouth four times, only managing to kiss her cheek as she pulled away. Sentence: one year eight months, suspended, plus victim compensation.",
"body": "CNN Portugal (2026) '\"Introduziu a mão dentro da camisola que vestia e tentou tocar-lhe nos seios e beijá-la na boca\". Padre condenado por tentativa de abuso sexual de menor nos Açores'. Available at: cnnportugal.iol.pt (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Horta court (Faial, Azores) convicted a priest of attempted sexual abuse of a dependent minor; the July 2024 acts involved a 15-year-old girl who was visiting the defendant and in his care -- he embraced her, put his hand under her clothing and attempted to touch her breasts and kiss her mouth four times, only managing to kiss her cheek as she pulled away. Sentence: one year eight months, suspended, plus victim compensation."
},
{
"link": "https://agencia.ecclesia.pt/portal/acores-sacerdote-condenado-pela-pratica-de-um-crime-de-abuso-sexual-de-menores-de-forma-tentada/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Agência Ecclesia (2026) 'Açores: Sacerdote condenado pela «prática de um crime de abuso sexual de menores de forma tentada»'. Available at: agencia.ecclesia.pt (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Diocese of Angra confirmed the conviction, ordered compensation to the victim, and reported that Rome confirmed the diocese's suspension of the priest pending a parallel canonical process; the Public Prosecutor's Office appealed the classification, arguing the crime was in fact consummated.",
"body": "Agência Ecclesia (2026) 'Açores: Sacerdote condenado pela «prática de um crime de abuso sexual de menores de forma tentada»'. Available at: agencia.ecclesia.pt (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Diocese of Angra confirmed the conviction, ordered compensation to the victim, and reported that Rome confirmed the diocese's suspension of the priest pending a parallel canonical process; the Public Prosecutor's Office appealed the classification, arguing the crime was in fact consummated."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-05-15",
"jurisdiction": "Juízo de Competência Genérica da Horta, Faial, Azores, Portugal",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of attempted sexual abuse of a dependent minor; one year eight months suspended, plus compensation; prosecution appealed for a harsher classification"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was visiting the priest and was explicitly under his care ('ao seu cuidado') at the time of the assault -- a custodial relationship the court found he exploited, taking advantage of her 'ingenuidade e inexperiência' (naivety and inexperience) given his clerical position.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://cnnportugal.iol.pt/padre-abusador/padre-abusa-de-menor/introduziu-a-mao-dentro-da-camisola-que-vestia-e-tentou-tocar-lhe-nos-seios-e-beija-la-na-boca-padre-condenado-por-tentativa-de-abuso-sexual-de-menor-nos-acores/20260619/6a357bc1d34edcee7c657dd4",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "14ddb7083d2a0340af883209883d15fee18144a158ba242765f92fe6d6e5dfba",
"final_url": "https://cnnportugal.iol.pt/padre-abusador/padre-abusa-de-menor/introduziu-a-mao-dentro-da-camisola-que-vestia-e-tentou-tocar-lhe-nos-seios-e-beija-la-na-boca-padre-condenado-por-tentativa-de-abuso-sexual-de-menor-nos-acores/20260619/6a357bc1d34edcee7c657dd4"
},
{
"source": "https://agencia.ecclesia.pt/portal/acores-sacerdote-condenado-pela-pratica-de-um-crime-de-abuso-sexual-de-menores-de-forma-tentada/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3262b8bed6eeb5a771bdf98385b92e8ed7a57446b6c86f2c20d48b35f19a9074",
"final_url": "https://agencia.ecclesia.pt/portal/acores-sacerdote-condenado-pela-pratica-de-um-crime-de-abuso-sexual-de-menores-de-forma-tentada/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; also removed from public office (municipal auditor). Textbook doctrinal-instrumentation case -- spiritual entities invoked to authorize the abuse itself.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-cuiaba-mato-grosso-brazil-umbanda-leader",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Cuiabá, Mato Grosso, Brazil",
"lat": -15.6,
"lng": -56.1,
"title": "Brazil: Umbanda leader convicted for using 'orixás' doctrine to coerce two teenage devotees into sex",
"tradition": "afro-brazilian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.atribunamt.com.br/sem-categoria/estado/2026/04/cuiaba-lider-religioso-e-condenado-por-violacao-sexual-mediante-fraude/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "A Tribuna MT (2026) 'Cuiabá: Líder religioso é condenado por violação sexual mediante fraude'. Available at: atribunamt.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Judge João Bosco Soares da Silva of Cuiabá's 14th Criminal Court convicted Umbanda terreiro leader and lawyer Luiz Antônio Rodrigues Silva to eight years nine months for sexual violation by fraud against two teenage devotees. One victim had attended the terreiro since age 11; at 15 the defendant began invoking the spirit 'Chico Preto,' claiming the pair were 'married in past lives' and that sex between them was ordained by the orixás with oxalá's permission. The other victim, then 16, was taken to a motel to supposedly 'pay Exu' for religious consultations. The court found the victims' free will compromised by the religious fraud and ordered him removed from his municipal auditor post.",
"body": "A Tribuna MT (2026) 'Cuiabá: Líder religioso é condenado por violação sexual mediante fraude'. Available at: atribunamt.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Judge João Bosco Soares da Silva of Cuiabá's 14th Criminal Court convicted Umbanda terreiro leader and lawyer Luiz Antônio Rodrigues Silva to eight years nine months for sexual violation by fraud against two teenage devotees. One victim had attended the terreiro since age 11; at 15 the defendant began invoking the spirit 'Chico Preto,' claiming the pair were 'married in past lives' and that sex between them was ordained by the orixás with oxalá's permission. The other victim, then 16, was taken to a motel to supposedly 'pay Exu' for religious consultations. The court found the victims' free will compromised by the religious fraud and ordered him removed from his municipal auditor post."
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbncuiaba.com.br/2026/04/14/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-8-anos-de-prisao-por-abusos-contra-jovens/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBN Cuiabá (2026) 'Líder religioso é condenado a 8 anos de prisão por abusos contra jovens'. Available at: cbncuiaba.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "CBN Cuiabá (2026) 'Líder religioso é condenado a 8 anos de prisão por abusos contra jovens'. Available at: cbncuiaba.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-04-10",
"jurisdiction": "14th Criminal Court, Cuiabá, Mato Grosso, Brazil",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of sexual violation by fraud (two counts); eight years nine months, closed regime; removed from public post"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the terreiro's spiritual director, the defendant invoked named spiritual entities and doctrine directly to instruct the victims that sex with him was ordained by the orixás -- prophecy attributed to spirit entities used as the explicit mechanism of coercion, which the court found compromised the victims' free will.",
"traditionDetailId": "african-brazilian",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.atribunamt.com.br/sem-categoria/estado/2026/04/cuiaba-lider-religioso-e-condenado-por-violacao-sexual-mediante-fraude/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2661cc6fa5e403944db9bf29b785a90a772f5d08e3fb2d3380fe34a6e65bde43",
"final_url": "https://www.atribunamt.com.br/sem-categoria/estado/2026/04/cuiaba-lider-religioso-e-condenado-por-violacao-sexual-mediante-fraude/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbncuiaba.com.br/2026/04/14/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-8-anos-de-prisao-por-abusos-contra-jovens/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "140730fbe99d1e8e94ff637f45e427429a3ad0ac69c99e8e13cdf21524d684a3",
"final_url": "https://www.cbncuiaba.com.br/2026/04/14/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-8-anos-de-prisao-por-abusos-contra-jovens/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; sentencing details (regime, appeal status) not further specified in press located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-salvador-bahia-brazil-amor-supremo",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Salvador, Bahia, Brazil",
"lat": -12.97,
"lng": -38.51,
"title": "Brazil: 'Amor Supremo' temple leader convicted for 'spiritual surgeries' used to coerce sex from followers",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-20-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual-contra-seguidoras/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN Brasil (2023) 'Líder religioso preso em Salvador é condenado a 20 anos de prisão por crime sexual contra seguidoras'. Available at: cnnbrasil.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Kléber Aran Ferreira da Silva, 50, leader of the 'Amor Supremo' temple, was convicted to 20 years five months for sexual violation by fraud against three women who attended his institution, plus R$50,000 moral-damages compensation to each. He performed purported 'spiritual surgeries,' claiming to channel the spirit of the German doctor Adolph Fritz, and convinced emotionally fragile victims (several with gravely ill family members) that sex with him was necessary to perform spiritual work and supply 'sexual energy' to spirit entities. He toured a schedule of these sessions across Manaus, São Luís, Maceió and Aracaju.",
"body": "CNN Brasil (2023) 'Líder religioso preso em Salvador é condenado a 20 anos de prisão por crime sexual contra seguidoras'. Available at: cnnbrasil.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Kléber Aran Ferreira da Silva, 50, leader of the 'Amor Supremo' temple, was convicted to 20 years five months for sexual violation by fraud against three women who attended his institution, plus R$50,000 moral-damages compensation to each. He performed purported 'spiritual surgeries,' claiming to channel the spirit of the German doctor Adolph Fritz, and convinced emotionally fragile victims (several with gravely ill family members) that sex with him was necessary to perform spiritual work and supply 'sexual energy' to spirit entities. He toured a schedule of these sessions across Manaus, São Luís, Maceió and Aracaju."
},
{
"link": "https://ndmais.com.br/seguranca/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-20-anos-de-prisao/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ND+ (2023) \"'Cirurgias espirituais': líder religioso é condenado por abusar sexualmente de fiéis na Bahia\". Available at: ndmais.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: investigation opened 2021 after complaints to the National Public Ministry Ombudsman, routed through the 'Justiceiras' women's-rights project.",
"body": "ND+ (2023) \"'Cirurgias espirituais': líder religioso é condenado por abusar sexualmente de fiéis na Bahia\". Available at: ndmais.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: investigation opened 2021 after complaints to the National Public Ministry Ombudsman, routed through the 'Justiceiras' women's-rights project."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2023-01-01",
"jurisdiction": "Salvador, Bahia, Brazil",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of sexual violation by fraud (three counts); 20 years five months' imprisonment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant fabricated a channeled-spirit identity and 'spiritual surgery' doctrine specifically to instruct emotionally vulnerable followers that sex with him was required to complete spiritual healing work for themselves or sick relatives -- healing doctrine used as the direct coercive mechanism, targeting followers pre-selected for vulnerability.",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-20-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual-contra-seguidoras/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0812f7c6d09600161beda44d7dada4f9999a22ab1d6407182739ae6251d5c4a8",
"final_url": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-20-anos-de-prisao-por-abuso-sexual-contra-seguidoras/"
},
{
"source": "https://ndmais.com.br/seguranca/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-20-anos-de-prisao/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "41484a83623fb7b320001d9e9141fb020fb39419cf958b7a6a0bcf81f08f4352",
"final_url": "https://ndmais.com.br/seguranca/lider-religioso-e-condenado-a-20-anos-de-prisao/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; five named victims all under 10 at time of offences.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-sobral-ceara-brazil-presbyterian-pastor",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Sobral, Ceará, Brazil",
"lat": -3.69,
"lng": -40.35,
"title": "Brazil: Presbyterian pastor convicted of raping five children under ten in his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br/seguranca/religiao-e-estupro-quem-sao-os-condenados-pelo-crime-no-ce-1.2076065",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diário do Nordeste (2018) 'Religião e estupro: quem são os condenados pelo crime no CE?'. Available at: diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Presbyterian pastor Arnol Santiago dos Santos was convicted in December 2018 to 26 years six months' imprisonment for statutory rape ('estupro de vulnerável') of five young congregants in Sobral, Ceará, all under ten years old at the time.",
"body": "Diário do Nordeste (2018) 'Religião e estupro: quem são os condenados pelo crime no CE?'. Available at: diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Presbyterian pastor Arnol Santiago dos Santos was convicted in December 2018 to 26 years six months' imprisonment for statutory rape ('estupro de vulnerável') of five young congregants in Sobral, Ceará, all under ten years old at the time."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2018-12-01",
"jurisdiction": "Sobral, Ceará, Brazil",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of statutory rape (five counts); 26 years six months' imprisonment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant was the congregation's pastor and the victims were child members of his own church, placing them under his pastoral authority and unsupervised access within church activities.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br/seguranca/religiao-e-estupro-quem-sao-os-condenados-pelo-crime-no-ce-1.2076065",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7a606d33317f58b6a2e14612da913ef95c74fe064311f6628c23eb0c26a61064",
"final_url": "https://diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br/seguranca/religiao-e-estupro-quem-sao-os-condenados-pelo-crime-no-ce-1.2076065"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; sentence not final on appeal per source ('sem poder recorrer em liberdade' -- cannot appeal while free, implying custody pending appeal).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-fortaleza-ceara-brazil-papi",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil",
"lat": -3.73,
"lng": -38.53,
"title": "Brazil: Catholic group founder 'Papi' convicted of raping young men he recruited through his community",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br/seguranca/religiao-e-estupro-quem-sao-os-condenados-pelo-crime-no-ce-1.2076065",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diário do Nordeste (2017) 'Religião e estupro: quem são os condenados pelo crime no CE?'. Available at: diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Paulo Amorim, known to victims as 'Papi,' was convicted in December 2017 to ten years' imprisonment, without the right to appeal while free. He frequented an upscale Fortaleza parish and had founded his own Catholic community, using that standing to attract and rape young men.",
"body": "Diário do Nordeste (2017) 'Religião e estupro: quem são os condenados pelo crime no CE?'. Available at: diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Paulo Amorim, known to victims as 'Papi,' was convicted in December 2017 to ten years' imprisonment, without the right to appeal while free. He frequented an upscale Fortaleza parish and had founded his own Catholic community, using that standing to attract and rape young men."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2017-12-01",
"jurisdiction": "Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of rape; ten years' imprisonment, denied right to appeal at liberty"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant founded and led his own lay Catholic community, using the recognized standing this gave him within parish life to attract and isolate young men he then raped.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br/seguranca/religiao-e-estupro-quem-sao-os-condenados-pelo-crime-no-ce-1.2076065",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7a606d33317f58b6a2e14612da913ef95c74fe064311f6628c23eb0c26a61064",
"final_url": "https://diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br/seguranca/religiao-e-estupro-quem-sao-os-condenados-pelo-crime-no-ce-1.2076065"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Conviction confirmed by press reporting on his arrest following the verdict; defendant died in custody shortly after (recorded as the conviction outcome, not as a separate death record, since the conviction itself -- not the death -- is the qualifying record).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-bayeux-paraiba-brazil-pastor",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Bayeux, Paraíba, Brazil",
"lat": -7.13,
"lng": -34.93,
"title": "Brazil: Assembly of God pastor convicted of raping three children using his religious standing to win family trust",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/pastor-evangelico-e-preso-apos-condenacao-por-estupro-contra-menores-na-paraiba/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN Brasil (2023) 'Pastor evangélico é preso após condenação por estupro contra menores na Paraíba'. Available at: cnnbrasil.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Jefferson Batista de Amorim, 43, pastor of an Assembly of God congregation in Bayeux (João Pessoa metro area), was convicted to 12 years' imprisonment for statutory rape of three minors; police said he used his religious position to win the families' trust. He had fled after an earlier 2016 arrest and was recaptured two years later; he died in custody days after being taken to Silvio Porto prison.",
"body": "CNN Brasil (2023) 'Pastor evangélico é preso após condenação por estupro contra menores na Paraíba'. Available at: cnnbrasil.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Jefferson Batista de Amorim, 43, pastor of an Assembly of God congregation in Bayeux (João Pessoa metro area), was convicted to 12 years' imprisonment for statutory rape of three minors; police said he used his religious position to win the families' trust. He had fled after an earlier 2016 arrest and was recaptured two years later; he died in custody days after being taken to Silvio Porto prison."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2023-01-01",
"jurisdiction": "Bayeux, Paraíba, Brazil",
"stage": "Conviction and sentencing (arrest on conviction 2023)",
"outcome": "Convicted of statutory rape (three counts); 12 years' imprisonment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Police investigators explicitly identified the defendant's pastoral position as the mechanism he used to gain the victims' families' trust and access to the children.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/pastor-evangelico-e-preso-apos-condenacao-por-estupro-contra-menores-na-paraiba/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2cdfcfea4181b70c5d09c17b01854d941e43d63d9bae99eef3b0f05b9be9ef62",
"final_url": "https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/nacional/pastor-evangelico-e-preso-apos-condenacao-por-estupro-contra-menores-na-paraiba/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; 11 named victims, none the defendant's own children -- explicitly a coach/pastor dual-authority case, checked against the paternal-nexus trap and cleared.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-parnaiba-piaui-brazil-futsal-pastor",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Parnaíba, Piauí, Brazil",
"lat": -2.9,
"lng": -41.78,
"title": "Brazil: futsal coach and pastor sentenced to over 103 years for grooming eleven adolescents with distorted scripture",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.portallitoralnoticias.com.br/2026/07/treinador-e-condenado-103-anos-por.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Portal Litoral Notícias (2026) 'Treinador é condenado a 103 anos por crimes sexuais contra 11 jovens; usava religião e falsas promessas'. Available at: portallitoralnoticias.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Judge Willmann Izac Ramos Santos of the 1st Criminal Court of Parnaíba, Piauí, convicted futsal trainer and evangelical pastor Natanael Ribeiro de Moraes to 103 years five months for sexual crimes against 11 adolescents between 2014-2023. He exploited youths in emotionally vulnerable situations, especially those lacking a father figure, with false promises of futsal advancement, 'spiritual fraud' distorting biblical passages to position himself as a 'spiritual father' demanding obedience, and took victims to his home under the pretext of secret religious counselling sessions.",
"body": "Portal Litoral Notícias (2026) 'Treinador é condenado a 103 anos por crimes sexuais contra 11 jovens; usava religião e falsas promessas'. Available at: portallitoralnoticias.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Judge Willmann Izac Ramos Santos of the 1st Criminal Court of Parnaíba, Piauí, convicted futsal trainer and evangelical pastor Natanael Ribeiro de Moraes to 103 years five months for sexual crimes against 11 adolescents between 2014-2023. He exploited youths in emotionally vulnerable situations, especially those lacking a father figure, with false promises of futsal advancement, 'spiritual fraud' distorting biblical passages to position himself as a 'spiritual father' demanding obedience, and took victims to his home under the pretext of secret religious counselling sessions."
},
{
"link": "https://lupa1.com.br/noticias/policia/treinador-de-futsal-e-condenado-a-mais-de-103-anos-por-crimes-sexuais-contra-11-adolescentes-no-pi-72219.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lupa1 (2026) 'Treinador de futsal é condenado a mais de 103 anos por crimes sexuais contra 11 adolescentes no PI'. Available at: lupa1.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Lupa1 (2026) 'Treinador de futsal é condenado a mais de 103 anos por crimes sexuais contra 11 adolescentes no PI'. Available at: lupa1.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2026-07-01",
"jurisdiction": "1st Criminal Court, Parnaíba, Piauí, Brazil",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of sexual crimes against 11 minors; 103 years five months' imprisonment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant explicitly self-styled as a 'spiritual father' using distorted biblical interpretation to demand obedience from adolescents who lacked a father figure, layering that doctrinal authority over his coaching role and using both to lure victims to private 'religious counselling' sessions -- the court's own characterization frames the doctrine, not the athletics, as the operative coercion.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.portallitoralnoticias.com.br/2026/07/treinador-e-condenado-103-anos-por.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "28003db0d395101f0972c7a997abd91047efb13e40e858cd55002d28cb7a9ad7",
"final_url": "https://www.portallitoralnoticias.com.br/2026/07/treinador-e-condenado-103-anos-por.html"
},
{
"source": "https://lupa1.com.br/noticias/policia/treinador-de-futsal-e-condenado-a-mais-de-103-anos-por-crimes-sexuais-contra-11-adolescentes-no-pi-72219.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "88d9017f32375cd2cae9fb22d34122ea6470638feb9848feea10b4eb9c8d646c",
"final_url": "https://lupa1.com.br/noticias/policia/treinador-de-futsal-e-condenado-a-mais-de-103-anos-por-crimes-sexuais-contra-11-adolescentes-no-pi-72219.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; charge reduced during trial from rape to sexual harassment. Defense announced intent to appeal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-aracaju-sergipe-brazil-lucas-abreu",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Aracaju, Sergipe, Brazil",
"lat": -10.91,
"lng": -37.07,
"title": "Brazil: Foursquare Church pastor convicted of sexually harassing minors in his youth counselling group",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://newsse.com.br/noticia/577/justica-de-sergipe-condena-pastor-lucas-abreu-por-assedio-sexual-contra-menores-de-idade.amp",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NewsSE (2025) 'Justiça de Sergipe condena pastor Lucas Abreu por assédio sexual contra menores de idade'. Available at: newsse.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: On 26 May 2025 the Sergipe justice system convicted pastor Lucas Abreu, of the Foursquare Church (Igreja do Evangelho Quadrangular) in Aracaju, of sexual harassment against four congregants, two of whom were minors aged 13 and 15 at the time. The original complaint charged rape of a vulnerable person; the classification was reduced to harassment during trial. Abreu led an adolescent counselling group that met weekends for religious study, and it was within that setting that the offences occurred; his father, co-pastor Luiz Antônio, was also indicted in the same investigation.",
"body": "NewsSE (2025) 'Justiça de Sergipe condena pastor Lucas Abreu por assédio sexual contra menores de idade'. Available at: newsse.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: On 26 May 2025 the Sergipe justice system convicted pastor Lucas Abreu, of the Foursquare Church (Igreja do Evangelho Quadrangular) in Aracaju, of sexual harassment against four congregants, two of whom were minors aged 13 and 15 at the time. The original complaint charged rape of a vulnerable person; the classification was reduced to harassment during trial. Abreu led an adolescent counselling group that met weekends for religious study, and it was within that setting that the offences occurred; his father, co-pastor Luiz Antônio, was also indicted in the same investigation."
},
{
"link": "https://fanf1.com.br/2025/05/26/justica-condena-pastor-lucas-abreu-por-assedio-sexual-de-fieis-em-sergipe/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fan F1 (2025) 'Justiça condena pastor Lucas Abreu por assédio sexual de fiéis em Sergipe'. Available at: fanf1.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Fan F1 (2025) 'Justiça condena pastor Lucas Abreu por assédio sexual de fiéis em Sergipe'. Available at: fanf1.com.br (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2025-05-26",
"jurisdiction": "Aracaju, Sergipe, Brazil",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of sexual harassment (four counts); community-service sentence"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As leader of the church's youth counselling group, the defendant held direct pastoral and instructional authority over minor congregants inside a weekend religious-study setting he ran himself.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://newsse.com.br/noticia/577/justica-de-sergipe-condena-pastor-lucas-abreu-por-assedio-sexual-contra-menores-de-idade.amp",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://fanf1.com.br/2025/05/26/justica-condena-pastor-lucas-abreu-por-assedio-sexual-de-fieis-em-sergipe/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1889ab2b853cf742718e90818a3136b9ec3fd37eb5e1bcead560bd5016c76ff6",
"final_url": "https://fanf1.com.br/2025/05/26/justica-condena-pastor-lucas-abreu-por-assedio-sexual-de-fieis-em-sergipe/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; complaint filed by the priest's own bishop, an unusually direct institutional-authority admission.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-san-blas-nayarit-mexico-priest",
"year": 2022,
"place": "San Blas, Nayarit, Mexico",
"lat": 21.54,
"lng": -105.28,
"title": "Mexico: priest sentenced to 60 years for raping a boy in his parish, reported by his own bishop",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jornada.com.mx/notas/2022/08/15/estados/sacerdote-de-san-blas-es-condenado-a-60-anos-de-prision-por-violacion/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Jornada (2022) 'Sacerdote de San Blas es condenado a 60 años de prisión por violación'. Available at: jornada.com.mx (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: A Trial Court convicted priest Nicolás 'N' of aggravated rape against a boy in San Blas, Nayarit, over three occasions between September 2017 and September 2019, 'valiéndose de investidura' (using his priestly office); sentenced to 60 years plus fines and damages. He was denounced to the Nayarit Attorney General's Office by his own bishop, Luis Artemio Flores Calzada.",
"body": "La Jornada (2022) 'Sacerdote de San Blas es condenado a 60 años de prisión por violación'. Available at: jornada.com.mx (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: A Trial Court convicted priest Nicolás 'N' of aggravated rape against a boy in San Blas, Nayarit, over three occasions between September 2017 and September 2019, 'valiéndose de investidura' (using his priestly office); sentenced to 60 years plus fines and damages. He was denounced to the Nayarit Attorney General's Office by his own bishop, Luis Artemio Flores Calzada."
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2022/08/16/nayarit-condenaron-a-60-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-de-un-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Infobae (2022) 'Un sacerdote fue condenado a 60 años de prisión por abuso sexual de un menor en Nayarit'. Available at: infobae.com (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Infobae (2022) 'Un sacerdote fue condenado a 60 años de prisión por abuso sexual de un menor en Nayarit'. Available at: infobae.com (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2022-08-15",
"jurisdiction": "Trial Court, Nayarit, Mexico",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of aggravated rape; 60 years' imprisonment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's own finding specified the priest acted 'valiéndose de investidura' -- using his priestly office -- as the means of the assault against a boy in his own parish.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jornada.com.mx/notas/2022/08/15/estados/sacerdote-de-san-blas-es-condenado-a-60-anos-de-prision-por-violacion/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2022/08/16/nayarit-condenaron-a-60-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-de-un-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0a9d45534bbe39b49b47257b100f0e1fa407d9edac077e7030417919d6802f7e",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/america/mexico/2022/08/16/nayarit-condenaron-a-60-anos-de-prision-a-un-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-de-un-menor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction by guilty plea.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-aquixtla-puebla-mexico-priest",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Aquixtla, Puebla, Mexico",
"lat": 19.72,
"lng": -97.85,
"title": "Mexico: priest sentenced to 21 years for luring and assaulting a seven-year-old at his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tribuna.com.mx/seguridad/2023/12/19/sacerdote-es-condenado-21-anos-por-abusar-de-un-menor-de-anos-en-puebla-354928.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tribuna (2023) 'Sacerdote es condenado a 21 años por abusar de un menor de 7 años en Puebla'. Available at: tribuna.com.mx (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Judge Francisco Javier Orozco sentenced priest Gerardo Espinoza Rubí, of the Church of San Juan Evangelista in Aquixtla, Puebla, to 21 years eight months for attempted rape of a seven-year-old boy. On 26 October 2021 the priest lured the child with candy into a room, closed the door, and forced the boy onto his lap; the child's mother, searching for him, interrupted the assault, and the priest threatened to kill her and the child's aunt if he told anyone. Sentence followed the priest's own guilty plea.",
"body": "Tribuna (2023) 'Sacerdote es condenado a 21 años por abusar de un menor de 7 años en Puebla'. Available at: tribuna.com.mx (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Judge Francisco Javier Orozco sentenced priest Gerardo Espinoza Rubí, of the Church of San Juan Evangelista in Aquixtla, Puebla, to 21 years eight months for attempted rape of a seven-year-old boy. On 26 October 2021 the priest lured the child with candy into a room, closed the door, and forced the boy onto his lap; the child's mother, searching for him, interrupted the assault, and the priest threatened to kill her and the child's aunt if he told anyone. Sentence followed the priest's own guilty plea."
},
{
"link": "https://www.nmas.com.mx/puebla/sociedad/sentencian-a-diacono-de-aquixtla-puebla-por-abuso-a-abner/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "N+ (2023) 'Dan 21 Años de Prisión a Sacerdote de Puebla por Abuso Infantil'. Available at: nmas.com.mx (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "N+ (2023) 'Dan 21 Años de Prisión a Sacerdote de Puebla por Abuso Infantil'. Available at: nmas.com.mx (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2023-12-11",
"jurisdiction": "Aquixtla, Puebla, Mexico",
"stage": "Guilty plea and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted (guilty plea) of attempted rape; 21 years eight months' imprisonment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant used his own parish church as the setting for luring the child, and his standing as the community's priest to bring the boy inside unquestioned before the attack.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tribuna.com.mx/seguridad/2023/12/19/sacerdote-es-condenado-21-anos-por-abusar-de-un-menor-de-anos-en-puebla-354928.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "83347581b75828c3471709e7a2f50dddf2c203c3916186b47c49ff43373bb217",
"final_url": "https://tribuna.com.mx/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nmas.com.mx/puebla/sociedad/sentencian-a-diacono-de-aquixtla-puebla-por-abuso-a-abner/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b900ff6e336c697a382ec5eb80eff4be3ebe8453ed7442d0f2c2066a34f25d27",
"final_url": "https://www.nmas.com.mx/puebla/sociedad/sentencian-a-diacono-de-aquixtla-puebla-por-abuso-a-abner/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal trial in progress as of source date (accusation filed May 2023, oral trial underway); separately, the Church's own ecclesiastical court concluded its canonical process and expelled the priest in August 2024. Recorded at charged tier for the criminal proceeding; the ecclesiastical dismissal is cited as corroborating institutional finding, not as the qualifying evidence itself.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-santander-boyaca-colombia-vargas-ruiz",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Chitaraque and San Gil, Santander, and Moniquirá, Boyacá, Colombia",
"lat": 5.87,
"lng": -73.57,
"title": "Colombia: priest tried for raping an altar-boy figure on his farm, four more accusers surface",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2025/04/22/por-abuso-sexual-a-menor-de-edad-inicio-juicio-contra-exsacerdote-en-santander-el-acusado-tendria-mas-victimas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Infobae Colombia (2025) 'Por abuso sexual a menor de edad inició juicio contra exsacerdote en Santander: el acusado tendría más víctimas'. Available at: infobae.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Priest Jaime Vargas Ruiz, of the Diocese of Socorro y San Gil, faced oral trial in Moniquirá, Boyacá, over the 2007 rape of Jonathan Ortega, then 16, at the priest's farm in Chitaraque, Boyacá; the complaint was not filed until 2020. The Attorney General's Office formally accused him on 15 May 2023 of violent sexual conduct with a minor. The victim, now 33, said four more men had since contacted him reporting they were also abused as minors by Vargas Ruiz, who had served as president of the diocese's own ecclesiastical tribunal -- the body that received complaints against pedophile priests.",
"body": "Infobae Colombia (2025) 'Por abuso sexual a menor de edad inició juicio contra exsacerdote en Santander: el acusado tendría más víctimas'. Available at: infobae.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Priest Jaime Vargas Ruiz, of the Diocese of Socorro y San Gil, faced oral trial in Moniquirá, Boyacá, over the 2007 rape of Jonathan Ortega, then 16, at the priest's farm in Chitaraque, Boyacá; the complaint was not filed until 2020. The Attorney General's Office formally accused him on 15 May 2023 of violent sexual conduct with a minor. The victim, now 33, said four more men had since contacted him reporting they were also abused as minors by Vargas Ruiz, who had served as president of the diocese's own ecclesiastical tribunal -- the body that received complaints against pedophile priests."
},
{
"link": "https://www.vanguardia.com/area-metropolitana/bucaramanga/2025/07/28/sacerdote-pederasta-en-santander-el-caso-que-destapo-mas-victimas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vanguardia (2025) 'Sacerdote pederasta en Santander: el caso que destapó más víctimas'. Available at: vanguardia.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: the Metropolitan Ecclesiastical Court of Bogotá notified the victim on 8 August 2024 that its canonical process concluded and Vargas Ruiz was expelled from the clerical state for 'delictum contra sextum cum minore.'",
"body": "Vanguardia (2025) 'Sacerdote pederasta en Santander: el caso que destapó más víctimas'. Available at: vanguardia.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: the Metropolitan Ecclesiastical Court of Bogotá notified the victim on 8 August 2024 that its canonical process concluded and Vargas Ruiz was expelled from the clerical state for 'delictum contra sextum cum minore.'"
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2023-05-15",
"jurisdiction": "Attorney General's Office / Criminal Court, Moniquirá, Boyacá, Colombia",
"stage": "Formal accusation and oral trial",
"outcome": "Charged with violent sexual conduct with a minor; trial in progress as of source date"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant was the victim's parish priest and, in an aggravating institutional irony, simultaneously headed the diocese's own ecclesiastical tribunal for receiving abuse complaints against other clergy -- a direct case of clerical authority both enabling the assault and controlling the very channel meant to expose it.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Charged with violent sexual conduct with a minor; trial in progress as of source date",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2025/04/22/por-abuso-sexual-a-menor-de-edad-inicio-juicio-contra-exsacerdote-en-santander-el-acusado-tendria-mas-victimas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f2e19ddb2f172d4407494cb18dac26f07b3c7133088e2e28dd8165653388a909",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2025/04/22/por-abuso-sexual-a-menor-de-edad-inicio-juicio-contra-exsacerdote-en-santander-el-acusado-tendria-mas-victimas/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.vanguardia.com/area-metropolitana/bucaramanga/2025/07/28/sacerdote-pederasta-en-santander-el-caso-que-destapo-mas-victimas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5d222604b372a1ecadbfd0907663907ed6b573dcf7e35f4d6221014e990b4d1e",
"final_url": "https://www.vanguardia.com/area-metropolitana/bucaramanga/2025/07/28/sacerdote-pederasta-en-santander-el-caso-que-destapo-mas-victimas/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction via abbreviated (plea) trial; sentence conditional/suspended -- convicted but the defendant did not serve custodial time, which is noted as a limit on the outcome rather than a reason to exclude (evidence tier is a formal conviction with an aggravating statutory finding of 'minister of a cult').",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-san-martin-mendoza-argentina-pastor",
"year": 2025,
"place": "San Martín, Mendoza, Argentina",
"lat": 33.08,
"lng": -68.47,
"title": "Argentina: pastor convicted of statutory rape aggravated by his status as 'minister of a cult'",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.pagina12.com.ar/841018-pastor-evangelico-condenado-en-mendoza-por-abuso-sexual/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Página/12 (2025) 'Pastor evangélico condenado en Mendoza por abuso sexual'. Available at: pagina12.com.ar (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: In an abbreviated trial, 28-year-old pastor Fernando Nehemías Coronel Fanin was convicted to three years' conditional imprisonment for 'estupro agravado por ser ministro de culto' (statutory rape aggravated by being a minister of a cult), for a six-month course of abuse in 2022 against a 15-year-old girl who attended his father's church in San Martín, Mendoza -- the 'Centro de Vida' church -- beginning with a kiss at a church camp and escalating to repeated sexual contact at a medical office and inside the church itself.",
"body": "Página/12 (2025) 'Pastor evangélico condenado en Mendoza por abuso sexual'. Available at: pagina12.com.ar (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: In an abbreviated trial, 28-year-old pastor Fernando Nehemías Coronel Fanin was convicted to three years' conditional imprisonment for 'estupro agravado por ser ministro de culto' (statutory rape aggravated by being a minister of a cult), for a six-month course of abuse in 2022 against a 15-year-old girl who attended his father's church in San Martín, Mendoza -- the 'Centro de Vida' church -- beginning with a kiss at a church camp and escalating to repeated sexual contact at a medical office and inside the church itself."
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/07/10/mendoza-un-pastor-evangelista-admitio-que-abuso-de-una-menor-pero-no-ira-preso/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Infobae (2025) 'Mendoza: un pastor evangelista admitió que abusó de una menor pero no irá preso'. Available at: infobae.com (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Infobae (2025) 'Mendoza: un pastor evangelista admitió que abusó de una menor pero no irá preso'. Available at: infobae.com (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2025-07-08",
"jurisdiction": "San Martín, Mendoza, Argentina",
"stage": "Abbreviated trial (guilty plea) and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of statutory rape aggravated by minister-of-cult status; three years' conditional imprisonment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The statutory aggravating factor the court applied was explicitly the defendant's status as a minister of a religious cult over a congregant of his father's church, where the abuse both began (at a church camp) and partly occurred (inside the church).",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.pagina12.com.ar/841018-pastor-evangelico-condenado-en-mendoza-por-abuso-sexual/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a6c405d056b82ef223aea5ae44da059fed8275233db92f905e1a3cf59907c430",
"final_url": "https://www.pagina12.com.ar/841018-pastor-evangelico-condenado-en-mendoza-por-abuso-sexual/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/07/10/mendoza-un-pastor-evangelista-admitio-que-abuso-de-una-menor-pero-no-ira-preso/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f517e3bf762c0f185c3c8974507c61b8fe5274beaafcfaf45a0207d86e8d89a2",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/07/10/mendoza-un-pastor-evangelista-admitio-que-abuso-de-una-menor-pero-no-ira-preso/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First-instance conviction; victim was an adult male congregant, illustrating the criterion's spiritual-authority test applies independent of victim age or sex.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-santa-fe-argentina-pastor-bravo",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Santa Fe, Argentina",
"lat": -31.62,
"lng": -60.7,
"title": "Argentina: pastor sentenced to ten years for repeatedly abusing an adult congregant who feared disbelief",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.unosantafe.com.ar/judiciales/condenaron-10-anos-prision-un-pastor-evangelico-abuso-sexual-santa-fe-n10219647.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "UNO Santa Fe (2025) 'Condenaron a 10 años de prisión a un pastor evangélico por abuso sexual en Santa Fe'. Available at: unosantafe.com.ar (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Judge Luis Octavio Silva convicted 44-year-old pastor Guillermo Nicolás Bravo, leader of the Tabernáculo de Adoración church, to ten years for repeated aggravated sexual abuse with carnal access against a young man who belonged to his congregation between 2018-2019; the abuse occurred at the pastor's home and, on one occasion, while visiting the victim in hospital. The victim delayed reporting three years, saying he feared not being believed as a large adult man.",
"body": "UNO Santa Fe (2025) 'Condenaron a 10 años de prisión a un pastor evangélico por abuso sexual en Santa Fe'. Available at: unosantafe.com.ar (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Judge Luis Octavio Silva convicted 44-year-old pastor Guillermo Nicolás Bravo, leader of the Tabernáculo de Adoración church, to ten years for repeated aggravated sexual abuse with carnal access against a young man who belonged to his congregation between 2018-2019; the abuse occurred at the pastor's home and, on one occasion, while visiting the victim in hospital. The victim delayed reporting three years, saying he feared not being believed as a large adult man."
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/09/19/condenaron-a-un-pastor-evangelico-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-un-fiel-en-santa-fe/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Infobae (2025) 'Condenaron a un pastor evangélico por abusar sexualmente de un fiel en Santa Fe'. Available at: infobae.com (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "Infobae (2025) 'Condenaron a un pastor evangélico por abusar sexualmente de un fiel en Santa Fe'. Available at: infobae.com (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2025-09-19",
"jurisdiction": "Santa Fe, Argentina",
"stage": "First-instance conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted of aggravated sexual abuse with carnal access; ten years' imprisonment"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court found the defendant, as the congregation's recognized spiritual leader, exploited that standing over a member of his own church, including using a pastoral hospital visit as an occasion for further abuse.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.unosantafe.com.ar/judiciales/condenaron-10-anos-prision-un-pastor-evangelico-abuso-sexual-santa-fe-n10219647.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4815ec669d3c9078994cd17c9c0d052f822356ea2874edb99e0cbca05144d059",
"final_url": "https://www.unosantafe.com.ar/judiciales/condenaron-10-anos-prision-un-pastor-evangelico-abuso-sexual-santa-fe-n10219647.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/09/19/condenaron-a-un-pastor-evangelico-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-un-fiel-en-santa-fe/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f6d3cec9ea61bc8d73dbe626ab819b0803b0a041a277145b06e67f5ce9363b4d",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/09/19/condenaron-a-un-pastor-evangelico-por-abusar-sexualmente-de-un-fiel-en-santa-fe/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Canonical/administrative finding by the Diocese of Valparaíso's own Abuse Prevention Council, not a criminal conviction -- recorded at official-finding tier. Appeal to Rome remained possible per source. Distinct from the corpus's existing Chile Salesian institutional record (different order, different diocese).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-valparaiso-chile-calderon-bustamante",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Viña del Mar, Valparaíso, Chile",
"lat": -33.02,
"lng": -71.55,
"title": "Chile: Diocese of Valparaíso finds priest guilty of abusing a ten-year-old student decades earlier, expels him",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.latercera.com/nacional/noticia/obispado-de-valparaiso-expulsa-a-sacerdote-tras-ser-declarado-culpable-de-abuso-sexual-a-menor-de-edad/DR5MJH67IRHWLAQ3L53YS7QL7Y/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Tercera (2024) 'Obispado de Valparaíso expulsa a sacerdote tras ser declarado culpable de abuso sexual a menor de edad'. Available at: latercera.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Diocese of Valparaíso concluded its Administrative Penal Process against priest Jorge Calderón Bustamante, finding him guilty of sexually abusing a girl when she was ten years old and a student at Colegio Seminario San Rafael in Viña del Mar, and permanently expelled him from the clerical state. The complaint, filed in 2021, concerned conduct from over four decades earlier; the diocese's Abuse Prevention Council reviewed the case, and the priest retained a right of appeal.",
"body": "La Tercera (2024) 'Obispado de Valparaíso expulsa a sacerdote tras ser declarado culpable de abuso sexual a menor de edad'. Available at: latercera.com (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Diocese of Valparaíso concluded its Administrative Penal Process against priest Jorge Calderón Bustamante, finding him guilty of sexually abusing a girl when she was ten years old and a student at Colegio Seminario San Rafael in Viña del Mar, and permanently expelled him from the clerical state. The complaint, filed in 2021, concerned conduct from over four decades earlier; the diocese's Abuse Prevention Council reviewed the case, and the priest retained a right of appeal."
},
{
"link": "https://www.biobiochile.cl/noticias/nacional/region-de-valparaiso/2024/12/14/obispado-de-valparaiso-expulsa-a-sacerdote-tras-ser-declarado-culpable-de-abuso-sexual.shtml",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BioBioChile (2024) 'Obispado de Valparaíso expulsa a sacerdote tras ser declarado culpable de abuso sexual'. Available at: biobiochile.cl (Accessed 2026-07-19).",
"body": "BioBioChile (2024) 'Obispado de Valparaíso expulsa a sacerdote tras ser declarado culpable de abuso sexual'. Available at: biobiochile.cl (Accessed 2026-07-19)."
}
],
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2024-12-14",
"jurisdiction": "Diocese of Valparaíso, Administrative Penal Process, Chile",
"stage": "Canonical finding of guilt and expulsion from clerical state",
"outcome": "Found guilty; permanently expelled from the clerical state; right of appeal to Rome retained"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant was a teaching priest at a diocesan seminary school and the victim his ten-year-old student, placing her directly under his combined clerical and educational authority at the time of the abuse.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.latercera.com/nacional/noticia/obispado-de-valparaiso-expulsa-a-sacerdote-tras-ser-declarado-culpable-de-abuso-sexual-a-menor-de-edad/DR5MJH67IRHWLAQ3L53YS7QL7Y/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b395c5ff10a8f7ebc263309148318744bf89dcfe9eb6f3d38cfb24814625959d",
"final_url": "https://www.latercera.com/nacional/noticia/obispado-de-valparaiso-expulsa-a-sacerdote-tras-ser-declarado-culpable-de-abuso-sexual-a-menor-de-edad/DR5MJH67IRHWLAQ3L53YS7QL7Y/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.biobiochile.cl/noticias/nacional/region-de-valparaiso/2024/12/14/obispado-de-valparaiso-expulsa-a-sacerdote-tras-ser-declarado-culpable-de-abuso-sexual.shtml",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "30115944f519a2acc3f7ef6ad823dcd9aff12a36d712f05bc9e7acdc0c357432",
"final_url": "https://www.biobiochile.cl/noticias/nacional/region-de-valparaiso/2024/12/14/obispado-de-valparaiso-expulsa-a-sacerdote-tras-ser-declarado-culpable-de-abuso-sexual.shtml"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 900,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: the pastor accessed and silenced the victim's household through his standing as a pastor within Bushiri's Enlightened Christian Gathering network — he was let into the family's home at night specifically to pray over and anoint the child. That pastoral errand, not any pre-existing family relationship, is what put him alone with a sleeping 12-year-old. Conviction after full trial; no appeal located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"slug": "2018-ngwenya-ecg-victoria-falls-zimbabwe",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Victoria Falls, Matabeleland North, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -17.9243,
"lng": 25.8572,
"title": "Zimbabwe: Enlightened Christian Gathering pastor convicted of raping a 12-year-old congregant during a house prayer visit",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Enlightened Christian Gathering (ECG)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral-visit pretext to gain solitary access to a minor congregant",
"anointing-with-holy-oil ritual used as cover for assault"
],
"organizations": [
"Enlightened Christian Gathering (ECG)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hwange Regional Magistrates Court, Zimbabwe",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2018-06-02",
"outcome": "David Ngwenya, 30, a singer/pastor at Shepherd Bushiri's Enlightened Christian Gathering church, was convicted after a full trial of raping a 12-year-old congregant in Mkhosana suburb, Victoria Falls, in January 2018. Magistrate Collet Ncube sentenced him to 16 years' imprisonment, with 2 years suspended for 5 years on condition of good behaviour."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bulawayo24.com/index-id-news-sc-national-byo-136980.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bulawayo24 News, 'Bushiri's pastor jailed for raping 12-year-old congregant' (2018).",
"body": "Reports that David Ngwenya (30), a singer/pastor at Prophet Shepherd Bushiri's Enlightened Christian Gathering (ECG), was convicted at Hwange Regional Magistrates Court and sentenced to 16 years, 2 suspended, for raping a 12-year-old congregant in Victoria Falls's Mkhosana suburb in January 2018. States Ngwenya had visited the family at 9pm claiming he wanted to pray for them, found the victim alone in a bedroom, and raped her; he denied the charge, claiming he only prayed for and anointed her with holy oil.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.chronicle.co.zw/rapist-pastor-jailed-16-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Chronicle (Zimbabwe), 'Rapist pastor jailed 16 years' (2018).",
"body": "Confirms the Hwange Regional Magistrates Court conviction of David Ngwenya, his role as an ECG singer/pastor, the 16-year sentence with 2 years suspended, and that the victim disclosed the assault to her mother after returning from school limping and crying.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ngwenya's pastoral office in Bushiri's ECG church is what brought him into the victim's home alone at night, and he used the ritual pretext of prayer and anointing with holy oil to gain access to the sleeping child and to frame his conduct afterward. The family's deference to a visiting church pastor — not any independent relationship — is what created the opportunity.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bulawayo24.com/index-id-news-sc-national-byo-136980.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fa73dd5337102de8b75910eccdcd9b0c5db8eae09b07328fa7fdc282a0fe4a88",
"final_url": "https://bulawayo24.com/index-id-news-sc-national-byo-136980.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.chronicle.co.zw/rapist-pastor-jailed-16-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 901,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: the pastor lured children to a private property specifically under the guise of spiritual/pastoral guidance and chores, exploiting his standing as a religious authority within the community to gain access and secure their silence. Full name was withheld from the NPA/CGE press statements; the sentencing court and outcome are independently confirmed by four South African outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"slug": "2025-nquthu-serial-rapist-pastor-kwazulu-natal-south-africa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Nquthu, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa",
"lat": -28.2167,
"lng": 30.6833,
"title": "South Africa: pastor given ten life terms for serially raping and assaulting twelve children lured with spiritual-guidance pretexts",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pretence of spiritual/pastoral guidance used to lure children to a private property",
"chores/errand pretext combined with claimed religious authority",
"exploitation of community trust in a religious figure"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nquthu Regional Magistrate's Court, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2025-07-23",
"outcome": "A 59-year-old pastor (named in later press as Mandlelisa Mabhale) was convicted on nine counts of rape and one of attempted rape against twelve children (ten boys, two girls) aged 7 to 14, committed 2020-2022, and sentenced to ten terms of life imprisonment; also received seven concurrent five-year terms for sexual assault and seven concurrent five-year terms for exposing children to pornography. The mandatory minimum-sentence provisions of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 105 of 1997 applied because the victims were minors."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child",
"archive": "",
"citation": "South African Government News Agency / Commission for Gender Equality, 'Commission for Gender Equality welcomes conviction of serial rapist pastor in child sexual abuse case' (2025).",
"body": "States the Nquthu Regional Magistrate's Court sentenced a pastor to ten life terms for nine rape counts and one attempted-rape count, plus seven five-year terms each for sexual assault and for exposing children to pornography, involving twelve children aged 7-14 abused between 2020 and 2022. Describes the pastor luring children to his rented premises under the pretence of offering spiritual or pastoral guidance or needing help with tasks, exploiting his position of religious authority and community trust to groom and abuse the victims.",
"tier": "government-statement",
"kind": "official-statement"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-10-08-pastor-gets-life-for-raping-sexually-assaulting-churchgoers-aged-12-13/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TimesLIVE / IOL, 'CGE applauds life sentence for KwaZulu-Natal pastor who abused 12 children' (2025).",
"body": "Confirms the identity as Mandlelisa Mabhale, 59, sentenced by the Nquthu Regional Magistrate's Court on 23 July 2025 to ten life terms plus concurrent five-year sentences, for offences against twelve children lured to his rented property under a pastoral-guidance pretext.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Mabhale used his standing as a pastor to draw children away from their families under the pretext of offering spiritual or pastoral guidance, exploiting the community's trust in a religious authority figure to isolate and repeatedly assault them over two years before any parent or authority intervened.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-statement; evidentiary role: official-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "18007da2c7271b6f4b8cd4737abb4217880afccb68adec44d1a1febfda78abba",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-10-08-pastor-gets-life-for-raping-sexually-assaulting-churchgoers-aged-12-13/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "20a5e4ac03c418e7d3192ae45a47ef64ce68302c69ec7724a6f1cada8ab7d04e",
"final_url": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-10-08-pastor-gets-life-for-raping-sexually-assaulting-churchgoers-aged-12-13/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 902,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: the household the victim was placed in was headed by the defendant's wife, who served as the family's pastor; the victim, newly orphaned, lived under the combined domestic and church-pastoral authority of that household with no other guardian. The assaults began specifically when the co-pastor wife was away on night shift, i.e. when the defendant was the sole authority present. Included as pastoral/guardianship-hybrid authority, narrower than a pure congregant case but satisfying N1 because the child had no other caregiver to appeal to outside that household's religious authority.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"slug": "2025-tamasane-edenburg-free-state-south-africa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Edenburg, Free State, South Africa",
"lat": -29.6667,
"lng": 25.9167,
"title": "South Africa: pastor's husband sentenced to life for raping an orphaned child taken into the pastor's household",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"husband of the household's pastor; co-head of a pastoral household"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sole authority over the child when the pastor-wife was on night shift",
"victim's dependency as a newly orphaned child with no other guardian",
"authority of the pastoral household she had been placed in"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Court, Edenburg, Free State, South Africa",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2025-05-26",
"outcome": "Albert Tamasane, 47, was convicted on two counts of rape and one count of sexual assault of a child who, at age 11, had moved with her mother into Tamasane's household — headed by his wife, the family's church pastor. After the mother's death left the child an orphan in that household, Tamasane raped her repeatedly from March 2019 while his wife worked night shifts, until the child disclosed to the wife in November 2019. He was sentenced to life imprisonment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-05-26-pastor-who-raped-11-year-old-girl-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TimesLIVE, 'Pastor who raped 11-year-old girl sentenced to life imprisonment' (26 May 2025).",
"body": "Reports the Edenburg Regional Court, roughly 80km south of Bloemfontein, convicted Albert Tamasane (47) on two counts of rape and one of sexual assault and sentenced him to life imprisonment. States the victim and her mother had moved into the household of Tamasane and his wife, the family's church pastor; after the mother's death left the child orphaned in that household, Tamasane raped her repeatedly from March 2019, while his wife worked night shifts, until the victim disclosed to the wife in November 2019.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child",
"archive": "",
"citation": "South African Government News Agency, roundup of pastor-rape convictions referencing the Edenburg case (2025).",
"body": "Confirms the Edenburg conviction and life sentence for Albert Tamasane as part of a wider set of South African clergy sexual-abuse prosecutions reported in mid-2025.",
"tier": "government-statement",
"kind": "official-statement"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim, orphaned at 11, had no guardian or refuge outside the household headed by Tamasane's wife in her capacity as the family's pastor. That pastoral household's authority over her — with Tamasane as its co-head — is what placed her under his unsupervised control whenever his wife worked night shifts, and what left her without anywhere else to turn for eight months.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-05-26-pastor-who-raped-11-year-old-girl-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0bc842b6e36989b29e962b5af58f24253cbc349a63ed7292bb8c8655d69c4899",
"final_url": "https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-05-26-pastor-who-raped-11-year-old-girl-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-statement; evidentiary role: official-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "18007da2c7271b6f4b8cd4737abb4217880afccb68adec44d1a1febfda78abba",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 903,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: both victims sought the defendant's services specifically as a traditional healer for spiritual/medical treatment; he invoked claimed spiritual diagnosis (an evil spirit) and the pretext of inserting spiritual medicine to commit and mask the first rape, and threatened supernatural-flavoured harm for disclosure. Clean healing-treatment/curse-witchcraft nexus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"slug": "2025-mafolela-molopo-north-west-south-africa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Molopo, North West, South Africa",
"lat": -25.8333,
"lng": 25.6167,
"title": "South Africa: traditional healer sentenced to fifteen years for raping and attempting to rape two clients seeking treatment",
"tradition": "indigenous-spiritual",
"traditionDetailId": "indigenous-authority",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented traditional healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual diagnosis (evil spirit requiring removal) used to isolate and assault a client",
"pretext of inserting spiritual medicine during the assault",
"threats of supernatural harm to enforce silence",
"drugging a second client during a purported treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Molopo Regional Court, North West, South Africa",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2025-08-13",
"outcome": "Bongani Mafolela was convicted of rape and attempted rape and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment (10 years for rape, 5 years for attempted rape, ordered to run consecutively). The court found he abused cultural beliefs and his position as a traditional healer to exploit both victims, one in February 2022 and, after his release on bail, a second in September 2024."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/mafikeng-traditional-healer-sentenced-15-years-imprisonment-rape",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Prosecuting Authority of South Africa, 'Mafikeng traditional healer sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment for rape' (2025).",
"body": "States the Molopo Regional Court sentenced Bongani Mafolela to 15 years' imprisonment (5 years for attempted rape, 10 years for rape, consecutive) on 13 August 2025. In the first incident, February 2022, Mafolela convinced a woman she had an evil spirit requiring removal, then raped her under the pretext of inserting spiritual medicine, and threatened her with harm if she disclosed the assault. While on bail, in September 2024, he met a second victim who had sought his services, drugged her drink and attempted to rape her while she resisted. The court found he 'abused cultural beliefs and his position as a traditional healer to exploit his victims.'",
"tier": "government-statement",
"kind": "official-statement"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both victims came to Mafolela specifically as clients seeking his services as a traditional healer. He used the healer's authority to diagnose a spiritual affliction, then used the pretext of a ritual medical treatment (inserting spiritual medicine) to commit the first rape and threats of supernatural retribution to keep her silent, and exploited the same treatment-seeking relationship to drug and attack the second client.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No appeal was located in the July 2026 source audit."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/mafikeng-traditional-healer-sentenced-15-years-imprisonment-rape",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-statement; evidentiary role: official-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7855dcb4b9d3a7e43750e20cf5e8584f682ce42360b0d03adfe1c4ff9b77a078",
"final_url": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/mafikeng-traditional-healer-sentenced-15-years-imprisonment-rape"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 904,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: the victim's grandmother handed her over to the defendant specifically because of the deference the community accorded a fetish priest, and he invoked his claimed spiritual power directly against the victim ('struck dead by the gods') to enforce her silence after the assault. Clean curse-witchcraft coercion mechanism operating both for access and for concealment.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"slug": "2025-asumah-osuwem-eastern-region-ghana",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Osuwem, Shai-Osudoku District, Greater Accra Region, Ghana",
"lat": 6.0333,
"lng": 0.05,
"title": "Ghana: fetish priest sentenced to fifteen years for defiling and impregnating a fifteen-year-old girl entrusted to him",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"traditional/fetish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"community deference to a fetish priest's standing, used to obtain the grandmother's trust and the child's presence",
"confinement by locking the victim inside his room",
"threat of death by 'the gods' to enforce silence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Odumase-Krobo Circuit Court, Eastern Region, Ghana",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2025-11-01",
"outcome": "Ebenezer Asumah, 26, a self-identified fetish priest, was convicted of defilement contrary to section 101(2) of the Criminal Offences Act, 1960 (Act 29), and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment with hard labour, after admitting sexual intercourse with the 15-year-old victim (claiming it was consensual) but being found guilty following trial."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/Fetish-priest-jailed-15-years-for-defiling-and-impregnating-minor-2008226",
"archive": "",
"citation": "GhanaWeb, 'Fetish priest jailed 15 years for defiling and impregnating minor' (2025).",
"body": "Reports the Odumase-Krobo Circuit Court sentenced Ebenezer Asumah, 26, to 15 years' imprisonment with hard labour for defiling a 15-year-old girl at Osuwem. States Asumah approached the victim's grandmother on 5 August 2025 and, invoking a hand injury, persuaded her to let the girl accompany him to cook; after she prepared food, he locked her in his room and raped her on three occasions, warning her she would be 'struck dead by the gods' if she disclosed it. The victim was found pregnant when hospitalised weeks later.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Asumah's standing as a fetish priest is what led the victim's grandmother to entrust the child to him without suspicion, and he then used his claimed spiritual power over the community — the threat that the gods would strike the victim dead — to secure her silence after the assault, invoking the same authority both to gain access and to prevent disclosure.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/Fetish-priest-jailed-15-years-for-defiling-and-impregnating-minor-2008226",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cbfbed0f28b560656447aab543b0f6a0a0869e749e7c9215a3feabdb9a4b48b1",
"final_url": "https://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/Fetish-priest-jailed-15-years-for-defiling-and-impregnating-minor-2008226"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 905,
"aliases": [
"Patricia Asiedua Asiamah",
"Nana Agradaa"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Amasaman High Court reduced the 15-year sentence to 12 months on appeal in 2026; the underlying conviction on three counts of defrauding by false pretences was not overturned."
}
],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: Agradaa is a former traditional/fetish priestess turned church evangelist who defrauded members of her own congregation by claiming spiritual power to double their money in a church service context. The victims were congregants who submitted to her claimed spiritual authority within her own ministry, not members of the general public reached by advertising alone, which distinguishes this from ordinary financial fraud and keeps it inside the prosperity-divination pretext category the schema defines.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination"
],
"slug": "2025-agradaa-weija-accra-ghana",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Weija, Accra, Ghana",
"lat": 5.5558,
"lng": -0.3508,
"title": "Ghana: evangelist sentenced for defrauding congregants with a claimed spiritual money-doubling ritual",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and leader, Heaven Way Champion International Ministry"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual power to double money offered in an all-night church service",
"prior standing as a traditional priestess turned evangelist, invoked to lend credibility to the ritual claim"
],
"organizations": [
"Heaven Way Champion International Ministry"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court, Accra, Ghana",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2025-07-18",
"outcome": "Patricia Asiedua Asiamah, known as Nana Agradaa, founder of Heaven Way Champion International Ministry, was convicted on three counts of defrauding by false pretence and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment with hard labour."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Amasaman High Court, Ghana",
"stage": "sentence appeal",
"date": "2026-01-01",
"outcome": "The High Court reduced the 15-year sentence to 12 months; the underlying convictions were not disturbed."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.citinewsroom.com/2025/07/agradaa-jailed-15-years-for-money-doubling-scam/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Citi Newsroom, 'Agradaa jailed 15 years for money doubling scam' (18 July 2025).",
"body": "Reports that an Accra circuit court sentenced Patricia Asiedua Asiamah, known as Nana Agradaa, to 15 years' imprisonment with hard labour on three counts of defrauding by false pretence, arising from a 2022 televised broadcast in which she claimed spiritual power to double money offered at an all-night service at her church, Heaven Way Champion International Ministry, Weija, Accra, then failed to return the funds.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.gbcghanaonline.com/features/ghanaians-divided-after-high-court-slashes-agradaas-15-year-prison-term-to-12-months/2026/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "GBC Ghana Online, 'Ghanaians divided after High Court slashes Agradaa's 15-year prison term to 12 months' (2026).",
"body": "Confirms the Amasaman High Court reduced Nana Agradaa's sentence from 15 years to 12 months on appeal, while the underlying fraud convictions stood.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "appellate-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Agradaa, a former traditional priestess turned church founder, invoked claimed spiritual power over money itself to induce her own congregants at an all-night service to hand over cash for 'doubling' — a ritual authority claim made from the pulpit of her own ministry to the people gathered under it, not a general advertisement to strangers.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Amasaman High Court reduced the 15-year sentence to 12 months on appeal in 2026; the underlying conviction on three counts of defrauding by false pretences was not overturned."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.citinewsroom.com/2025/07/agradaa-jailed-15-years-for-money-doubling-scam/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0df99b932b8323cd1c6bca8dc5f8663685ca87ec0678003592a2c0fc7d30c677",
"final_url": "https://www.citinewsroom.com/2025/07/agradaa-jailed-15-years-for-money-doubling-scam/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.gbcghanaonline.com/features/ghanaians-divided-after-high-court-slashes-agradaas-15-year-prison-term-to-12-months/2026/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: appellate-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f890848741d85f34ea1129c0d560d8d2753befd7970e05c84e714ee91ae643cf",
"final_url": "https://www.gbcghanaonline.com/features/ghanaians-divided-after-high-court-slashes-agradaas-15-year-prison-term-to-12-months/2026/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 906,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: the victim was brought to the defendant specifically as a client seeking mental-health treatment following a miscarriage, and remained under his care for four months. When her parents could not immediately pay his fee, he moved her to a different location and declared her his 'second wife' — an escalation that used the ongoing treatment relationship and her isolation from her family to enable further sustained abuse. Clean healing-treatment nexus over an extended, ongoing patient relationship.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"slug": "2022-vasco-mangochi-malawi",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Nkungulu, Mangochi, Malawi",
"lat": -14.4781,
"lng": 35.2645,
"title": "Malawi: traditional healer sentenced to ten years for raping and impregnating a client under his care for a mental-health condition",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"traditional healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"four-month ongoing treatment relationship with a mentally vulnerable patient",
"relocation of the victim away from her family to enforce continued control",
"declaration of the victim as his 'second wife' to entrench the relationship"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mangochi Senior Resident Magistrate's Court (Nkungulu), Malawi",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2022-07-25",
"outcome": "Chiko Vasco, 70, a well-known traditional healer, was convicted of raping and impregnating a 30-year-old client and sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment with hard labour. Senior Resident Magistrate Rodrick Michongwe rejected mitigation, finding Vasco had taken advantage of the victim's vulnerability."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.faceofmalawi.com/2022/07/26/herbalist-slapped-10yrs-for-raping-impregnating-female-client-in-mangochi/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Face of Malawi, 'Herbalist Slapped 10Yrs For Raping, Impregnating Female Client In Mangochi' (26 July 2022).",
"body": "Reports that the Mangochi Senior Resident Magistrate's Court at Nkungulu convicted and sentenced Chiko Vasco, 70, a well-known traditional healer, to 10 years' imprisonment with hard labour for raping and impregnating a 30-year-old client. States the victim developed a mental disorder after a miscarriage in October 2021 and was taken to Vasco for treatment, remaining under his care for four months; when her parents could not immediately pay his K80,000 fee in full, he moved her to another location and declared her his 'second wife'; the assaults and pregnancy were discovered when her parents finally retrieved her in July 2022.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.malawiheat.com/2022/08/mangochi-herbalist-jailed-10-years-for.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Malawi Heat, 'Mangochi Herbalist Jailed 10 Years For Rape' (2022).",
"body": "Confirms the identity of Chiko Vasco, the Mangochi Senior Resident Magistrate's Court sentencing, the 10-year term, and the treatment-relationship facts consistent with the Face of Malawi report.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was placed under Vasco's care specifically as a patient seeking treatment for a mental-health crisis, and remained under his ongoing authority as her healer for four months. He used that treatment relationship, and her family's inability to immediately pay, to relocate and further entrap her — the healer relationship is what created and then extended his control over her.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.faceofmalawi.com/2022/07/26/herbalist-slapped-10yrs-for-raping-impregnating-female-client-in-mangochi/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "50a65c6c1642237663ad36a0ce3e5b4ab7ff0647480b206dae488ef810ce603e",
"final_url": "https://www.faceofmalawi.com/2022/07/26/herbalist-slapped-10yrs-for-raping-impregnating-female-client-in-mangochi/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.malawiheat.com/2022/08/mangochi-herbalist-jailed-10-years-for.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4e7bfe1cb340650858b020b057e502bb33e85a8c1f3d73d756b778a12561b90b",
"final_url": "https://www.malawiheat.com/2022/08/mangochi-herbalist-jailed-10-years-for.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 908,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: the child was brought to the defendant specifically as a client seeking treatment for epilepsy; he used the treatment relationship (claiming further days were needed 'to complete her healing') to isolate and assault her. A guilty plea via plea bargain confirms the conviction at the highest evidence tier available.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"slug": "2018-shina-ikeja-lagos-nigeria",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Ikeja, Lagos State, Nigeria",
"lat": 6.6018,
"lng": 3.3515,
"title": "Nigeria: herbalist sentenced to fourteen years for sexually assaulting a ten-year-old brought to him for epilepsy treatment",
"tradition": "juju",
"traditionDetailId": "african-juju",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"herbalist"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"treatment relationship used to isolate a vulnerable child from her mother",
"claim that continued treatment ('a few days to complete her healing') required the child to remain with him"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lagos State Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court, Ikeja, Nigeria",
"stage": "plea bargain, conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2025-02-25",
"outcome": "Segun Shina was originally charged with defilement under section 262 of the Criminal Laws of Lagos State, 2015, which carries a potential life sentence. Following a plea bargain, the charge was amended to attempted sexual assault by penetration, to which he pleaded guilty. He was sentenced to 14 years' imprisonment, backdated to his 16 November 2018 arrest, barred from contact with the victim's family, and ordered registered as a sex offender."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://leadership.ng/court-jails-herbalist-14-years-for-sexually-assaulting-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Leadership (Nigeria), 'Court Jails Herbalist 14 Years For Sexually Assaulting Minor' (2025).",
"body": "Reports the Lagos State Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court in Ikeja sentenced herbalist Segun Shina to 14 years' imprisonment, backdated to his 16 November 2018 arrest, after a plea bargain reduced his charge from defilement to attempted sexual assault by penetration. States the 10-year-old victim, who suffered from epilepsy, was brought to Shina by her mother for treatment; he gave the child something to drink and told the mother she needed to remain with him 'for a few days to complete her healing,' during which he sexually assaulted her.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2025/02/herbalist-jailed-14-years-for-attempted-sexual-assault-on-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vanguard News (Nigeria), 'Herbalist jailed 14 years for attempted sexual assault on minor' (25 Feb. 2025).",
"body": "Confirms the Ikeja Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court sentencing of Segun Shina to 14 years for attempted sexual assault on the 10-year-old epileptic victim, and that the plea bargain reduced the original defilement charge.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's mother placed her under Shina's care specifically as a herbalist treating her epilepsy. He used the ongoing-treatment framing — telling the mother the child needed to stay longer 'to complete her healing' — to isolate the child from her family and commit the assault.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://leadership.ng/court-jails-herbalist-14-years-for-sexually-assaulting-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3d7a285043e435ef1bde7a2b9a56d30f66a01ea0d773026fe289976f9184f049",
"final_url": "https://leadership.ng/court-jails-herbalist-14-years-for-sexually-assaulting-minor/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2025/02/herbalist-jailed-14-years-for-attempted-sexual-assault-on-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1f3d4a0ca591c11a5b82ffb0122af23d7bf41a820c813ec01fcde914fa8b8e39",
"final_url": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2025/02/herbalist-jailed-14-years-for-attempted-sexual-assault-on-minor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 827,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2014-01-28",
"note": "Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the conviction and rejected the pre-accusatorial-delay and jury-instruction claims."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim was the defendant's altar boy and student at the parish school, not a relative. Does not characterize the Catholic Church generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1980-william-casey-st-dominics-kingsport-tennessee-usa",
"year": 1980,
"place": "Kingsport, Sullivan County, Tennessee, USA",
"lat": 36.5484,
"lng": -82.5618,
"title": "United States: priest convicted of raping his altar boy decades earlier, sentence affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, head pastor of St. Dominic's Catholic School and Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority as head pastor over a congregant altar boy",
"the priest's high standing in the congregation deterred the victim's disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Dominic's Catholic School and Church, Kingsport, Tennessee",
"Diocese of Knoxville"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Court for Sullivan County, Tennessee",
"stage": "trial",
"date": "2011-11-23",
"outcome": "Jury convicted William Casey, a priest, of one count of first degree criminal sexual conduct and two counts of aggravated rape of a boy who was his altar server and student, beginning when the victim was about ten and a half years old. Sentenced to an effective 35 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee at Knoxville",
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2014-01-28",
"outcome": "Convictions and sentence affirmed. The court rejected Casey's claim that the 32-year delay between the offenses and prosecution violated due process, along with his evidentiary and jury-instruction claims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Casey was head pastor of the victim's parish school and church; the victim testified he did not disclose for decades in part because Casey was 'very well-liked, very regarded' with a large congregation, while he felt he would not be believed. The abuse occurred within the altar-server and school relationship Casey supervised as priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2014/01/28/state_of_tennessee_v._william_casey.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Casey, No. E2012-01451-CCA-R3-CD (Tenn. Crim. App. Jan. 28, 2014).",
"body": "Full appellate opinion: jury convicted Casey, a priest and head pastor at St. Dominic's, of first degree criminal sexual conduct and two counts of aggravated rape of his altar boy; sentenced to an effective 35 years; conviction and sentence affirmed on appeal.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2014-01-28",
"note": "Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the conviction and rejected the pre-accusatorial-delay and jury-instruction claims."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2014/01/28/state_of_tennessee_v._william_casey.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a450da173c0cf8f74d56286e5d63105ba246281578a571f2ffb98206f8484bdf",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2014/01/28/state_of_tennessee_v._william_casey.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 828,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2019-04-17",
"note": "Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal affirmed the conviction."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim and two similar-fact witnesses were congregants, not relatives of Stubbs. Does not characterize the church's denomination generally, as this appears to be an independent congregation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-stephen-stubbs-restoration-of-life-ministries-palm-beach-florida-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Palm Beach County, Florida, USA",
"lat": 26.7153,
"lng": -80.0534,
"title": "United States: 'Apostle' pastor convicted of sexually abusing three girls in his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Pastor and self-styled 'Apostle', Church of Restoration of Life Ministries"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed prophetic authority ('speaking from God') used to direct victims' compliance",
"supernatural-consequence framing — telling a victim he had to 'take off' spirits placed on her by physical contact with others",
"status-based subordination taught as doctrine — victims testified they did not resist because he was their pastor/Apostle"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Restoration of Life Ministries, Palm Beach County, Florida"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court for the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, Palm Beach County, Florida",
"stage": "trial",
"outcome": "Jury convicted Stephen Stubbs of unlawful sexual activity with a minor. Similar-fact testimony from two other congregation members described comparable grooming and abuse by Stubbs."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of Appeal of the State of Florida, Fourth District",
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2019-04-17",
"outcome": "Conviction affirmed; the court held the trial court properly admitted similar-fact evidence from the two other victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Stubbs was pastor and self-proclaimed 'Apostle' of the small congregation the victim's family belonged to; he told her being an Apostle meant he spoke for God, and told her that if a boy touched her he, as her Apostle, would have to remove the resulting 'spirits.' A second congregant testified she did not resist his advances because he was her pastor; a third testified he was a 'trusted religious advisor' to her family who acted as their spiritual authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2019/04/17/stephen_stubbs_v._state_of_florida.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Stubbs v. State, No. 4D17-3295 (Fla. 4th DCA Apr. 17, 2019).",
"body": "Full appellate opinion recounting trial testimony from the victim and two similar-fact witnesses describing Stubbs's use of his 'Apostle' status and claimed divine authority to groom and sexually abuse congregants; conviction affirmed.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2019-04-17",
"note": "Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal affirmed the conviction."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2019/04/17/stephen_stubbs_v._state_of_florida.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "49841a33c7672185e21ce5973e2cfd3df2491e7fe29a3db8ef124bce353b7599",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2019/04/17/stephen_stubbs_v._state_of_florida.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 829,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2015-04-16",
"note": "Utah Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions (amended opinion)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim was a member of Flores's congregation; the opinion also notes she was a family friend. Misdemeanor-level convictions (sexual battery, unlawful detention). Does not characterize the LDS Church generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-armando-flores-lds-branch-president-west-valley-city-utah-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "West Valley City, Salt Lake County, Utah, USA",
"lat": 40.6916,
"lng": -112.0011,
"title": "United States: LDS branch president convicted of sexually battering a teenage congregant summoned to his office",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Branch president, small LDS Church congregation, West Valley City"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"presiding priesthood authority used to summon a congregant alone into his office"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Third District Court, Salt Lake Department, Utah",
"stage": "trial",
"outcome": "Jury convicted Armando Flores of sexual battery and unlawful detention for acts against T.H., a sixteen-year-old member of the congregation he led, whom he invited alone into his office."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Utah Court of Appeals",
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2015-04-16",
"outcome": "Convictions affirmed; the court rejected Flores's claims regarding voir dire on religious bias and the State's use of peremptory challenges."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Flores served as branch president — described in the opinion as the 'presiding priesthood leader' of the branch — of a small LDS congregation. He invited T.H., a sixteen-year-old member of his congregation, to speak with him alone in his office in that capacity, where the abuse occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2015/04/16/state_v._flores.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Flores, 2015 UT App 88 (Utah Ct. App. Apr. 16, 2015) (amended opinion).",
"body": "Full appellate opinion describing Flores's role as LDS branch president/presiding priesthood leader, his use of that office to summon the sixteen-year-old victim alone, and the appellate affirmance of the convictions.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2015-04-16",
"note": "Utah Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions (amended opinion)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2015/04/16/state_v._flores.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0b769fe7db3b87dee0f27646a6250954ab2d46b7ec015400eaaf26fe2ccfc8cf",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2015/04/16/state_v._flores.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 830,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2021-10-08",
"note": "Georgia Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim, R.H., was not related to Marshall; R.H.'s own father warned him to stay away from Marshall. Does not characterize the church's denomination generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-mclance-marshall-youth-choir-director-georgia-usa",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Georgia, USA",
"lat": 33.75,
"lng": -84.39,
"title": "United States: church youth-choir director convicted of molesting a boy from his choir",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Church youth-choir director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious mentorship and 'religious matters' discussions used to build isolating one-on-one trust",
"gifts and favors from a trusted church leader used to secure secrecy and daily unsupervised access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Unnamed church congregation, Georgia (choir/youth ministry)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court, Georgia",
"stage": "trial",
"outcome": "Jury convicted McLance Marshall on numerous child-sex-offense counts and one count of making false statements, arising from his abuse of R.H., a fourteen-year-old member of his church's youth choir."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Georgia",
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2021-10-08",
"outcome": "Convictions affirmed. The court rejected Marshall's claims of a coercive Allen jury charge and improper denial of a general demurrer."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Marshall was choir director for the church youth choir R.H. belonged to; he built the relationship through discussions of 'religious matters' and gifts, and R.H. was with him 'almost every day' without his parents' knowledge, despite his father's warning to stay away from Marshall.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/10/08/mclance_marshall_v._state.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Marshall v. State, No. A21A0948 (Ga. Ct. App. Oct. 8, 2021).",
"body": "Full appellate opinion describing Marshall's role as church youth-choir director, his grooming of R.H. through religious discussion and gifts, and the affirmance of his convictions.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2021-10-08",
"note": "Georgia Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/10/08/mclance_marshall_v._state.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24583c546a30a3805584c107f4cdc1793366b4a93aae1f82df054a2d10a5e621",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/10/08/mclance_marshall_v._state.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 831,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2017-05-12",
"note": "Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed the molestation convictions and sentence in full; reversed only a collateral restitution order requiring Bruno to pay the State's investigation costs."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim, D.A., was the son of a family Bruno lived with and befriended, not his own child. Does not characterize the church's denomination generally, as this was Bruno's own independent congregation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-armando-bruno-independent-pastor-washington-indiana-usa",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Washington, Daviess County, Indiana, USA",
"lat": 38.6606,
"lng": -87.1728,
"title": "United States: pastor convicted of raping the young son of a family who housed his church, sentenced to eighty years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Founding pastor of an independent church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal instrumentation — telling the child's father the child was lying and 'possessed by the devil,' citing the book 'Lucifer Dethroned' to discredit the disclosure",
"pastoral standing used to secure continued access to the family and silence after partial disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Independent church founded by Armando Bruno, Washington, Indiana"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Daviess Superior Court, Indiana",
"stage": "trial",
"outcome": "Jury convicted Armando Bruno of two counts of child molesting as Class A felonies and two counts of child molesting as Class C felonies against D.A., beginning when D.A. was six years old. Sentenced to an aggregate eighty years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Indiana",
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2017-05-12",
"outcome": "Convictions and eighty-year sentence affirmed as sufficiently supported by the evidence and not inappropriate. The court reversed only a $5,000 restitution order requiring Bruno to reimburse the State's investigation costs, holding the State was not a proper restitution recipient."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Bruno founded and pastored the church that met first in D.A.'s family's home and then in a building the family purchased for it; when D.A. disclosed the abuse to his father, Bruno told the father D.A. was lying and 'possessed by the devil,' invoking the book 'Lucifer Dethroned' to convince the father not to pursue the allegation, after which the abuse continued for years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2017/05/12/armando_m._bruno_v._state_of_indiana_mem._dec..pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bruno v. State, No. 14A01-1606-CR-1530 (Ind. Ct. App. May 12, 2017) (mem. dec.).",
"body": "Full appellate opinion describing Bruno's founding-pastor role, his use of a spiritual-possession claim to suppress the victim's father's disclosure response, and the affirmance of the molestation convictions and sentence.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2017-05-12",
"note": "Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed the molestation convictions and sentence in full; reversed only a collateral restitution order requiring Bruno to pay the State's investigation costs."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2017/05/12/armando_m._bruno_v._state_of_indiana_mem._dec..pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8f27bd93606bd4146580de37ff4e355cef84f655980cf9fee561e17a1c8c3c81",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2017/05/12/armando_m._bruno_v._state_of_indiana_mem._dec..pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 832,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2013-10-17",
"note": "Ohio Eighth Appellate District (Cuyahoga County) affirmed the sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The named victim was not related to Lewis; two earlier victims (brothers) also came forward at sentencing. Does not characterize the LDS Church generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-mark-lewis-lds-leader-cuyahoga-ohio-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio, USA",
"lat": 41.4993,
"lng": -81.6944,
"title": "United States: LDS church leader guilty of molesting a boy over five years, using church roles to access the family",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Executive secretary to two bishops, teacher, and ward mission leader, LDS congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"successive positions of church trust (executive secretary, teacher, ward mission leader) used deliberately to gain access to the victim's family and, through the family, to the victim"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Cuyahoga County, Ohio"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, Ohio",
"stage": "trial",
"outcome": "Mark Lewis pleaded guilty to sexually abusing the victim from age 12 to 17. At sentencing, two earlier victims (brothers) also testified to decades-old abuse by Lewis. Sentenced to 25 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Ohio, Eighth Appellate District",
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2013-10-17",
"outcome": "Sentence affirmed; the court held the trial court properly considered the uncharged prior-victim testimony at sentencing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Lewis held a series of LDS church positions — executive secretary under two bishops, teacher, ward mission leader — which the prosecution argued at sentencing he used deliberately to 'gain trust and access to the victim's family, and then used that trust to get to the victim'; the victim's father stated Lewis 'used the church to build a relation of trust with us.'",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2013/10/17/state_v._lewis.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Lewis, 2013-Ohio-4593 (Ohio Ct. App., 8th Dist., Oct. 17, 2013).",
"body": "Full appellate opinion describing Lewis's successive LDS church leadership roles used to gain access to the victim's family, his guilty plea, and the affirmance of his 25-year sentence.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2013-10-17",
"note": "Ohio Eighth Appellate District (Cuyahoga County) affirmed the sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2013/10/17/state_v._lewis.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ff615f8ee8ba23d168ef7d2095c76a6371bc7e1d5925b39cb73a7cffc590c0f5",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2013/10/17/state_v._lewis.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 833,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2019-09-23",
"note": "Georgia Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The two victims were young children of families who attended Pinkston's church; not his relatives. Does not characterize the church's denomination generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-john-pinkston-minister-georgia-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Georgia, USA",
"lat": 33.75,
"lng": -84.39,
"title": "United States: minister convicted of molesting two young girls from congregant families at his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Minister"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical status and physical access within the church building used to isolate young congregants (e.g., holding a child on his lap)"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Unnamed church congregation, Georgia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court, Georgia",
"stage": "trial",
"outcome": "Jury convicted John Aubrey Pinkston on two counts of child molestation. Pinkston, a minister, repeatedly molested two young girls, ages four to six, whose families attended his church, on church premises."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Georgia",
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2019-09-23",
"outcome": "Convictions affirmed. The court rejected Pinkston's challenges to the admission of his statements to police, the denial of a jury charge on accident, and an ineffective-assistance claim."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Pinkston was minister of the church the victims' families attended; the abuse of both girls occurred at the church itself, including while one victim, aged four to six, sat on his lap as her congregation's minister.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2019/09/23/john_aubrey_pinkston_v._state.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Pinkston v. State, No. A19A1390 (Ga. Ct. App. Sept. 23, 2019).",
"body": "Full appellate opinion describing Pinkston's role as minister of the victims' family church, the on-premises abuse of both children, and the affirmance of his convictions.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate",
"date": "2019-09-23",
"note": "Georgia Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2019/09/23/john_aubrey_pinkston_v._state.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4db324baff8f237c9d819fbd3843b431d6338887dbf44e8256ac61e4644f2e31",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2019/09/23/john_aubrey_pinkston_v._state.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 834,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "tsj-castilla-la-mancha",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"note": "Sentence increased from 22y8m to 30y on appeal."
},
{
"stage": "tribunal-supremo",
"date": "2022-09-13",
"note": "Final; appeal dismissed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-pietro-jimenez-arias-ciudad-real-spain",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Ciudad Real, Castilla-La Mancha, Spain",
"lat": 38.9848,
"lng": -3.9275,
"title": "Spain: ex-priest and seminary trainer's 30-year sentence for abusing seven minor seminarians affirmed by Supreme Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest and formator (training supervisor) of minor seminarians, Diocese of Ciudad Real"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial authority over resident seminary students",
"clerical formation authority over candidates dependent on his evaluation for advancement"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Audiencia Provincial de Ciudad Real; Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Castilla-La Mancha (appeal, increased sentence); Tribunal Supremo (final)",
"stage": "final appellate disposition",
"date": "2022-09-13",
"outcome": "Pedro Jiménez Arias, priest of the Diocese of Ciudad Real 2014-2016 and formator of minor seminarians, had his conviction for sexually abusing seven seminarians aged 11-14 affirmed by the Tribunal Supremo, which dismissed his appeal against the Castilla-La Mancha high court's increase of the sentence from 22 years 8 months to 30 years. Fine and per-victim compensation confirmed; laicized by the Vatican in 2019."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were minor seminarians resident under his authority as their formator — the priest responsible for evaluating and advancing their candidacy for the priesthood — inside the seminary of the Diocese of Ciudad Real.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/es/Poder-Judicial/Tribunal-Supremo/Noticias-Judiciales/El-Tribunal-Supremo-confirma-la-condena-a-30-anos-de-prision-para-un-exsacerdote-por-abusos-sexuales-a-siete-menores-seminaristas-en-Ciudad-Real",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Consejo General del Poder Judicial (2022) 'El Tribunal Supremo confirma la condena a 30 años de prisión para un exsacerdote por abusos sexuales a siete menores seminaristas en Ciudad Real', poderjudicial.es.",
"body": "Official Spanish judiciary press release: 'La Sala de lo Penal del Tribunal Supremo ha confirmado la condena de 30 años de prisión impuesta [...] por abusar sexualmente de siete menores [...] que cursaban estudios en el seminario de la Diócesis de Ciudad Real, donde el acusado ejercía de formador de los seminaristas.' (The Supreme Court's Criminal Chamber confirmed the 30-year sentence [...] for sexually abusing seven minors [...] who were studying at the seminary of the Diocese of Ciudad Real, where the accused served as formator of the seminarians.) English gloss: official confirmation the conviction is final and describes the formator/trainee relationship as the mechanism.",
"tier": "national-court-press-office",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.publico.es/sociedad/condenado-30-anos-prision-exsacerdote-ciudad-real-abusos-sexuales-siete-menores.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Público (2022) 'Condenado a 30 años de prisión un exsacerdote de Ciudad Real por abusos sexuales a siete menores', publico.es.",
"body": "'Pedro Jiménez Arias fue sacerdote de la Diócesis de Ciudad Real entre 2014 y 2016 [...] fue expulsado del estado clerical en 2019 por el Vaticano.' (Pedro Jiménez Arias was a priest of the Diocese of Ciudad Real between 2014 and 2016 [...] was expelled from the clerical state in 2019 by the Vatican.) English gloss: names the priest, confirms laicization.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "background-and-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "tsj-castilla-la-mancha",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"note": "Sentence increased from 22y8m to 30y on appeal."
},
{
"stage": "tribunal-supremo",
"date": "2022-09-13",
"note": "Final; appeal dismissed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/es/Poder-Judicial/Tribunal-Supremo/Noticias-Judiciales/El-Tribunal-Supremo-confirma-la-condena-a-30-anos-de-prision-para-un-exsacerdote-por-abusos-sexuales-a-siete-menores-seminaristas-en-Ciudad-Real",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-press-office; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ac951534c0081ce6548114d5a450897f6ad0213e9ffcdd46c22bc73e25315bd8",
"final_url": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/es/Poder-Judicial/Tribunal-Supremo/Noticias-Judiciales/El-Tribunal-Supremo-confirma-la-condena-a-30-anos-de-prision-para-un-exsacerdote-por-abusos-sexuales-a-siete-menores-seminaristas-en-Ciudad-Real"
},
{
"source": "https://www.publico.es/sociedad/condenado-30-anos-prision-exsacerdote-ciudad-real-abusos-sexuales-siete-menores.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: background-and-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "070fad8af5fc6a0288615da5155fe3995f0b00d15140aae02c54d0c938dadf83",
"final_url": "https://www.publico.es/sociedad/condenado-30-anos-prision-exsacerdote-ciudad-real-abusos-sexuales-siete-menores.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 835,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "corte-appello-caltanissetta",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"note": "Sentence reduced from first-instance 4y6m applying tenuità del fatto mitigant for two victims."
},
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2026-05-14",
"note": "Final; both defense and prosecution appeals declared inadmissible."
}
],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-giuseppe-rugolo-piazza-armerina-italy",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Enna, Piazza Armerina, Sicilia, Italy",
"lat": 37.3849,
"lng": 14.3708,
"title": "Italy: priest's conviction for sexual violence against minors made final by Cassazione",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest, Diocese of Piazza Armerina"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust relationship with minors met through parish/clerical role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunale di Enna (first instance); Corte d'Appello di Caltanissetta; Corte di Cassazione (final)",
"stage": "final appellate disposition",
"date": "2026-05-14",
"outcome": "Don Giuseppe Rugolo, priest of the Diocese of Piazza Armerina, had his sexual-violence-against-minors conviction made final by the Court of Cassation, which declared inadmissible both his defense's appeal and the prosecutor general's appeal against the reduced sentence. First-instance sentence of 4 years 6 months (Tribunale di Enna) was reduced on appeal at Caltanissetta applying a mitigating factor for two victims; that reduced sentence is now final. Laicized 14 July 2025. Investigation opened after victim Antonio Messina reported abuse spanning 2009-2013; multiple other victims identified."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest used his pastoral role and the trust it commanded with minors in his parish community to commit repeated sexual violence over 2009-2013.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://retelabuso.org/2026/05/14/condanna-definitiva-per-il-sacerdote-giuseppe-rugolo-accusato-di-violenza-sessuale-su-minori/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rete L'Abuso (2026) 'Condanna definitiva per il sacerdote Giuseppe Rugolo, accusato di violenza sessuale su minori', retelabuso.org.",
"body": "'La Cassazione ha dichiarato inammissibili tutti i ricorsi [...] sia il ricorso difensivo [...] sia quello della Procura generale.' (The Cassation declared all appeals inadmissible — both the defense appeal and that of the Prosecutor General.) English gloss: confirms final disposition, both sides' appeals rejected.",
"tier": "specialist-abuse-tracking-outlet",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/cronaca/2026/05/14/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ANSA (2026) reporting on Rugolo Cassazione confirmation, ansa.it.",
"body": "Wire confirmation of the Cassazione ruling and laicization date (14 July 2025), and background on the Enna investigation opened via Antonio Messina's complaint covering abuse from 2009 to 2013.",
"tier": "national-wire-service",
"kind": "background-and-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "corte-appello-caltanissetta",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"note": "Sentence reduced from first-instance 4y6m applying tenuità del fatto mitigant for two victims."
},
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2026-05-14",
"note": "Final; both defense and prosecution appeals declared inadmissible."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://retelabuso.org/2026/05/14/condanna-definitiva-per-il-sacerdote-giuseppe-rugolo-accusato-di-violenza-sessuale-su-minori/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-abuse-tracking-outlet; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fd28ed71e3f50e6112a2f671045be6ead029f333ac47649fe001fa5d984db413",
"final_url": "https://retelabuso.org/2026/05/14/condanna-definitiva-per-il-sacerdote-giuseppe-rugolo-accusato-di-violenza-sessuale-su-minori/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/cronaca/2026/05/14/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-wire-service; evidentiary role: background-and-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 836,
"aliases": [
"Olivier de Scitivaux de Greische"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal-withdrawn",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"note": "Defendant renounced his own appeal; first-instance verdict became final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-olivier-de-scitivaux-orleans-france",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Cléry-Saint-André, Loiret; Perros-Guirec, Côtes-d'Armor, France",
"lat": 47.8172,
"lng": 1.7514,
"title": "France: basilica rector Olivier de Scitivaux's rape and sexual-assault conviction final after he withdrew appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest and rector of the Basilique Notre-Dame de Cléry, Diocese of Orléans; supervisor of church-organized youth summer camps"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority combined with custodial supervision of boys at church-run vacation camps",
"pattern sustained over years, hundreds of individual acts"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour d'assises du Loiret",
"stage": "final (appeal withdrawn)",
"date": "2024-05-25",
"outcome": "Olivier de Scitivaux, rector of the Notre-Dame de Cléry basilica (2013-2018) and a priest of the Diocese of Orléans who had also served at church-run vacation camps including one in Perros-Guirec (Côtes-d'Armor), was convicted of hundreds of counts of rape and aggravated sexual assault against four boys and sentenced to 17 years' criminal imprisonment. He initially appealed but withdrew the appeal in early 2025, making the sentence final without a retrial."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As parish priest, basilica rector and supervisor of church-run youth summer camps, Scitivaux held both pastoral and custodial authority over the boys he assaulted, including at a Perros-Guirec vacation camp.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://france3-regions.franceinfo.fr/centre-val-de-loire/loiret/orleans/affaire-scitivaux-l-ancien-pretre-condamne-a-17-ans-de-prison-pour-viols-sur-mineurs-retire-son-appel-3085198.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "France 3 Centre-Val de Loire (2025) 'Affaire Scitivaux : l'ancien prêtre, condamné à 17 ans de prison pour viols sur mineurs, retire son appel', francetvinfo.fr.",
"body": "'Olivier de Scitivaux [...] a été condamné [...] à 17 ans de réclusion criminelle [...] Il a finalement renoncé à son appel, ce qui rend sa condamnation définitive.' (Olivier de Scitivaux [...] was sentenced [...] to 17 years' criminal imprisonment [...] He ultimately withdrew his appeal, making his conviction final.) English gloss: confirms finality via appeal withdrawal.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster",
"kind": "final-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://france3-regions.franceinfo.fr/bretagne/cotes-d-armor/pedophilie-dans-l-eglise-un-ancien-pretre-ayant-exerce-en-camps-de-vacances-dans-les-cotes-d-armor-condamne-a-17-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle-2975279.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "France 3 Bretagne (2024) 'Pédophilie dans l'Église : un ancien prêtre ayant exercé en camps de vacances dans les Côtes-d'Armor condamné à 17 ans de réclusion criminelle', francetvinfo.fr.",
"body": "'[...] certains [faits] commis dans une colonie de vacances de Perros-Guirec.' (some of the acts were committed at a Perros-Guirec vacation camp.) English gloss: ties the abuse to the church-run camp in Côtes-d'Armor, establishing the custodial-supervisory dimension of his authority.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster",
"kind": "background-and-facts"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal-withdrawn",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"note": "Defendant renounced his own appeal; first-instance verdict became final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://france3-regions.franceinfo.fr/centre-val-de-loire/loiret/orleans/affaire-scitivaux-l-ancien-pretre-condamne-a-17-ans-de-prison-pour-viols-sur-mineurs-retire-son-appel-3085198.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: final-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b9e267a20b36c57b003c3029a8deba4c6cc47772d3d864124f0678c058d42d7e",
"final_url": "https://france3-regions.franceinfo.fr/centre-val-de-loire/loiret/orleans/affaire-scitivaux-l-ancien-pretre-condamne-a-17-ans-de-prison-pour-viols-sur-mineurs-retire-son-appel-3085198.html"
},
{
"source": "https://france3-regions.franceinfo.fr/bretagne/cotes-d-armor/pedophilie-dans-l-eglise-un-ancien-pretre-ayant-exerce-en-camps-de-vacances-dans-les-cotes-d-armor-condamne-a-17-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle-2975279.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: background-and-facts.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bfced7ab9d5dd2e7b190c776d3a99e306965bca394dedc0c099be3265702c2e8",
"final_url": "https://france3-regions.franceinfo.fr/bretagne/cotes-d-armor/pedophilie-dans-l-eglise-un-ancien-pretre-ayant-exerce-en-camps-de-vacances-dans-les-cotes-d-armor-condamne-a-17-ans-de-reclusion-criminelle-2975279.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 837,
"aliases": [
"Yero B.",
"'le sorcier gourou' des rues de Bordeaux"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cour-assises-charente-appeal",
"date": "2024-12-18",
"note": "Sentence increased from 12 to 15 years on appeal; treated as the final disposition in sourcing reviewed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Perpetrator held no prior or ongoing relationship with the victim; his claimed spiritual authority was self-asserted on the spot rather than institutional, but the criterion's authority test turns on whether belief gave him power over her in the moment, which the ritual pretext (désenvoûtement, exorcism of a 'demon') satisfies.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-yero-b-sorcier-gourou-bordeaux-france",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Bordeaux, Gironde; Angoulême, Charente, France",
"lat": 44.8378,
"lng": -0.5792,
"title": "France: self-styled 'sorcerer guru' convicted on appeal for raping a student he claimed to be spiritually cleansing",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"traditionDetailId": "occult-western",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed sorcerer/guru/healer offering 'désenvoûtement' (spiritual un-hexing) and exorcism rituals to women he approached as strangers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed supernatural diagnostic power (identifying a 'curse' or 'demon' in the victim)",
"framing sexual contact as a required ritual step of the healing/exorcism"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal correctionnel de la Gironde (first instance); Cour d'assises de la Charente, Angoulême (appeal)",
"stage": "final appellate disposition",
"date": "2024-12-18",
"outcome": "Yero B., a Mauritanian man who presented himself on the street as a sorcerer/guru able to perform spiritual 'désenvoûtement', was convicted of raping student Océane D. in a Bordeaux parking lot on 29 July 2021 after luring her with an offer of a spiritual cleansing ritual. First sentenced to 12 years by the Gironde criminal court; on appeal before the Cour d'assises de la Charente the sentence was increased to 15 years' criminal imprisonment with a 10-year security period and permanent ban from French territory."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "He approached the victim as a stranger claiming supernatural power to diagnose and cure a 'curse' or trauma within her, using the promised désenvoûtement ritual as the pretext to isolate and assault her — the claimed spiritual authority was the operative mechanism of the assault, not incidental to it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rue89bordeaux.com/2024/12/le-sorcier-gourou-accuse-du-viol-doceane-dans-un-parking-condamne-en-appel-a-15-ans-de-prison/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rue89 Bordeaux (2024) '\"Le sorcier gourou\" accusé du viol d'Océane dans un parking, condamné en appel à 15 ans de prison', rue89bordeaux.com.",
"body": "'Il se présentait comme un guérisseur ou gourou [...] et avait proposé à Océane un \"désenvoûtement\".' (He presented himself as a healer or guru [...] and had offered Océane a 'désenvoûtement' / un-hexing ritual.) English gloss: establishes the ritual pretext used to isolate the victim before the assault.",
"tier": "regional-investigative-outlet",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://rue89bordeaux.com/2023/12/le-sorcier-gourou-de-bordeaux-condamne-pour-le-viol-dune-etudiante-a-12-ans-de-reclusion/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rue89 Bordeaux (2023) '\"Le sorcier gourou\" de Bordeaux condamné pour le viol d'une étudiante à 12 ans de réclusion', rue89bordeaux.com.",
"body": "First-instance account: describes a separate 2018 incident in which he told another woman he was 'un sorcier' able to cure her via an 'exorcism ceremony' because a demon threatened 'the star' within her — establishing a pattern of the same ritual-pretext method.",
"tier": "regional-investigative-outlet",
"kind": "background-and-facts"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cour-assises-charente-appeal",
"date": "2024-12-18",
"note": "Sentence increased from 12 to 15 years on appeal; treated as the final disposition in sourcing reviewed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rue89bordeaux.com/2024/12/le-sorcier-gourou-accuse-du-viol-doceane-dans-un-parking-condamne-en-appel-a-15-ans-de-prison/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-investigative-outlet; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b1fab6d65b788481048ef7a872af13e23f1cdb12a8b325fff1cce64781ad6ee5",
"final_url": "https://rue89bordeaux.com/2024/12/le-sorcier-gourou-accuse-du-viol-doceane-dans-un-parking-condamne-en-appel-a-15-ans-de-prison/"
},
{
"source": "https://rue89bordeaux.com/2023/12/le-sorcier-gourou-de-bordeaux-condamne-pour-le-viol-dune-etudiante-a-12-ans-de-reclusion/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-investigative-outlet; evidentiary role: background-and-facts.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0d080cdab528ea970769daf2a87d242a27e49a551f5783273c3cb60cab5d54a2",
"final_url": "https://rue89bordeaux.com/2023/12/le-sorcier-gourou-de-bordeaux-condamne-pour-le-viol-dune-etudiante-a-12-ans-de-reclusion/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 838,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-supremo",
"date": "2024-05-29",
"note": "Final; Supreme Court dismissed the defense appeal and confirmed the Audiencia Provincial de Toledo sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-jose-luis-galan-talavera-spain",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Talavera de la Reina, Toledo, Castilla-La Mancha, Spain",
"lat": 39.9633,
"lng": -4.8305,
"title": "Spain: priest's conviction for continuous sexual abuse of a student under his spiritual direction affirmed by Supreme Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest and spiritual director (director espiritual) of the victim at her Catholic school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"quasi-parental spiritual-direction relationship",
"religious framing of the abuse as divinely willed"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Audiencia Provincial de Toledo; Tribunal Supremo (final)",
"stage": "final appellate disposition",
"date": "2024-05-29",
"outcome": "Priest José Luis Galán had his conviction for continuous sexual abuse of a student, committed 2010-2013 when she was 14-17 and he was her spiritual director at a Talavera de la Reina school, affirmed by the Tribunal Supremo: 8 years 6 months' imprisonment and 100,000 euros compensation confirmed. Court found the victim submitted to the acts because of the quasi-parental role, trust and respect she held for him as priest and spiritual director, and his manipulation invoking divine will."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest was the victim's spiritual director from age 15, a role in which he held quasi-parental trust and authority; the court found her submission was produced by that role and by his claim the abuse was what God wanted.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/en/Judiciary/Novelties/El-Tribunal-Supremo-confirma-la-condena-de-8-anos-y-medio-de-prision-a-un-cura-por-abusos-sexuales-continuados-a-una-adolescente-con-la-que-ejercia-de-director-espiritual",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Consejo General del Poder Judicial (2024) 'El Tribunal Supremo confirma la condena de 8 años y medio de prisión a un cura por abusos sexuales continuados a una adolescente con la que ejercía de director espiritual', poderjudicial.es.",
"body": "'[...] sometida a estos actos por el papel quasi-paternal que el sacerdote asumía, el respeto y la confianza que le profesaba como director espiritual y sacerdote, y su manipulación al sostener que sus actos eran lo que Dios quería.' (submitted to these acts because of the quasi-parental role the priest assumed, the respect and trust she held for him as spiritual director and priest, and his manipulation by claiming his acts were what God wanted.) English gloss: this is the official court press release explicitly finding the spiritual-authority mechanism.",
"tier": "national-court-press-office",
"kind": "final-appellate-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://infovaticana.com/2024/05/30/el-tribunal-supremo-confirma-ocho-anos-y-medio-de-carcel-para-un-sacerdote-de-toledo-por-abusos-a-una-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "InfoVaticana (2024) 'El Tribunal Supremo confirma ocho años y medio de cárcel para un sacerdote de Toledo por abusos a una menor', infovaticana.com.",
"body": "Names the priest as José Luis Galán and confirms the Talavera de la Reina, Diocese of Toledo, location and school-trip origin of the relationship (met on a school Camino de Santiago trip in 4th ESO, became her spiritual director the following year).",
"tier": "catholic-press",
"kind": "background-and-facts"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "tribunal-supremo",
"date": "2024-05-29",
"note": "Final; Supreme Court dismissed the defense appeal and confirmed the Audiencia Provincial de Toledo sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/en/Judiciary/Novelties/El-Tribunal-Supremo-confirma-la-condena-de-8-anos-y-medio-de-prision-a-un-cura-por-abusos-sexuales-continuados-a-una-adolescente-con-la-que-ejercia-de-director-espiritual",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-court-press-office; evidentiary role: final-appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ae0f62c82f45857871878ce3dd0c1afcb4b8f855540d25af8db75b49a2b404fd",
"final_url": "https://www.poderjudicial.es/cgpj/en/Judiciary/Novelties/El-Tribunal-Supremo-confirma-la-condena-de-8-anos-y-medio-de-prision-a-un-cura-por-abusos-sexuales-continuados-a-una-adolescente-con-la-que-ejercia-de-director-espiritual"
},
{
"source": "https://infovaticana.com/2024/05/30/el-tribunal-supremo-confirma-ocho-anos-y-medio-de-carcel-para-un-sacerdote-de-toledo-por-abusos-a-una-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: catholic-press; evidentiary role: background-and-facts.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1da49e56b66e5205cc4dae9071772bc03e882a5a3fd3cdc86a5ff33eba7ece21",
"final_url": "https://infovaticana.com/2024/05/30/el-tribunal-supremo-confirma-ocho-anos-y-medio-de-carcel-para-un-sacerdote-de-toledo-por-abusos-a-una-menor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charged tier: qualified trafficking, child abuse, and murder informations were approved by the Provincial Prosecutor and an arrest/arraignment followed in 2014; no verdict could be located in the accessible record (national wire and Supreme Court E-Library both silent past the trial-court arraignment stage), so this is recorded as charged, not convicted. The 'treasure hunt' and 'apocalypse' claims are recorded as alleged context, not adjudicated fact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-casiano-apduhan-dios-amahan-balamban-philippines",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Balamban, Cebu, Philippines",
"lat": 10.4954,
"lng": 123.7147,
"title": "Philippines: 'Dios Amahan' cult leader charged with murder and trafficking of a follower's child",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed 'Dios Amahan' (God the Father), faith healer and cult leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine healing and resurrection powers",
"claimed ability to predict apocalypse",
"isolation of followers inside a walled compound with an underground tunnel"
],
"organizations": [
"Dios Amahan (Balamban sect)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Office of the Provincial Prosecutor, Cebu / Regional Trial Court, Toledo City, Philippines",
"stage": "charges filed and arraigned",
"date": "2014-03-25",
"outcome": "The Provincial Prosecutor approved murder and qualified-trafficking charges against Casiano 'Tatay Loloy' Apduhan and two aides after the NBI recovered the buried remains of a 14-year-old boy, allegedly killed and buried in a search for treasure, inside Apduhan's compound; separate charges of serious illegal detention (of an adult follower held over five years) and illegal firearm possession were also filed. Apduhan pleaded not guilty at arraignment. No further disposition was locatable in the accessible record."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sunstar.com.ph/more-articles/ex-brgy-official-becomes-a-healer-cult-leader",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex-brgy. official becomes a healer, cult leader', SunStar Cebu, 26 Mar. 2014.",
"body": "Reports the NBI's arrest of Apduhan, his claimed healing and resurrection powers, the discovery of the buried remains of Angelo Repuela inside his compound, and the murder and detention charges filed against him.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "arrest-and-charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/39358/tatay-loloy-enters-plea-of-not-guilty",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"'Tatay Loloy' enters plea of not guilty\", Cebu Daily News, 2014.",
"body": "Reports Apduhan's not-guilty plea at arraignment before the Regional Trial Court, Toledo City, on the serious illegal detention and firearms charges.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "arraignment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Followers venerated Apduhan as 'Dios Amahan' — God the Father — crediting him with healing and resurrection powers; the victim's family were followers, and the boy's death is alleged to have occurred inside the leader's compound in the course of a treasure-hunting ritual he directed.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-doomsday-apocalyptic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The Provincial Prosecutor approved murder and qualified-trafficking charges against Casiano 'Tatay Loloy' Apduhan and two aides after the NBI recovered the buried remains of a 14-year-old boy, allegedly killed and buried in a search for treasure, inside Apduhan's compound; separate charges of serious illegal detention (of an adult follower held over five years) and illegal firearm possession were also filed. Apduhan pleaded not guilty at arraignment. No further disposition was locatable in the accessible record.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sunstar.com.ph/more-articles/ex-brgy-official-becomes-a-healer-cult-leader",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: arrest-and-charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ce9704da681c044464d2fcb66c5f26a4b1bd97699e4cbad1aceef5133e44b3b7",
"final_url": "https://www.sunstar.com.ph/more-articles/ex-brgy-official-becomes-a-healer-cult-leader"
},
{
"source": "https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/39358/tatay-loloy-enters-plea-of-not-guilty",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: arraignment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dc2a0fda00ebcc0a38327bc19f90beb1f2f90904d49b3c5ea177a0185c78d7e9",
"final_url": "https://cebudailynews.inquirer.net/39358/tatay-loloy-enters-plea-of-not-guilty"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charged tier: arrest warrant executed and non-bailable charges filed under RA 8353 and RA 7610; no trial verdict was locatable in the accessible record as of this lane's search date.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-teodoro-feriol-dios-amahan-asturias-philippines",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Asturias, Cebu, Philippines",
"lat": 10.7614,
"lng": 123.7175,
"title": "Philippines: self-styled 'Dios Amahan' healer charged with raping patients held at his temple",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed 'Dios Amahan' (God the Father), faith healer and temple leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine healing powers",
"framing sexual submission as a 'spiritual obligation' owed after being healed",
"requiring patients to reside at his temple for months as part of the claimed obligation"
],
"organizations": [
"Dios Amahan (Asturias sect)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Trial Court Branch 8, Toledo City, Philippines",
"stage": "arrest warrant executed; non-bailable charges pending",
"date": "2022-05-12",
"outcome": "Teodoro Rico Feriol, known as 'Brod Doring' and self-styled 'Dios Amahan,' was arrested by the NBI on an arrest warrant issued by Judge Judilyn Menchavez over the rape of a 16-year-old girl and a 32-year-old woman between 2020 and 2021. He was charged under Article 266-A (RA 8353, the Anti-Rape Law) and RA 7610 (child abuse); the charges are non-bailable. No trial verdict was locatable in the accessible record."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mb.com.ph/2022/05/13/faith-healer-accused-of-raping-patients-nabbed/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"'Faith healer' accused of raping patients nabbed\", Manila Bulletin, 13 May 2022.",
"body": "Reports the NBI-Central Visayas arrest of Feriol in Asturias, Cebu, the claimed healing powers used to draw victims to his temple, the 'spiritual obligation' pretext used to hold them there, and the rape and child-abuse charges filed under RA 8353 and RA 7610.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "arrest-and-charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.philstar.com/the-freeman/cebu-news/2021/12/02/2145223/faith-healer-rapes-patients-tells-them-its-spiritual-duty",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Faith healer 'rapes' patients, tells them it's 'spiritual duty'\", The Freeman (Philstar Cebu), 2 Dec. 2021.",
"body": "Earlier complaint-filing report describing the same 'Dios Amahan' pretext of framing rape as a spiritual duty owed by healed patients.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "complaint-filing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Feriol drew patients with claimed divine healing power, then told them their recovery obligated them to a 'spiritual duty' fulfilled by residing at his temple, where the assaults are alleged to have occurred — the healing claim is what put the victims inside his physical control.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Teodoro Rico Feriol, known as 'Brod Doring' and self-styled 'Dios Amahan,' was arrested by the NBI on an arrest warrant issued by Judge Judilyn Menchavez over the rape of a 16-year-old girl and a 32-year-old woman between 2020 and 2021. He was charged under Article 266-A (RA 8353, the Anti-Rape Law) and RA 7610 (child abuse); the charges are non-bailable. No trial verdict was locatable in the accessible record.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mb.com.ph/2022/05/13/faith-healer-accused-of-raping-patients-nabbed/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: arrest-and-charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "628e98a1a339c7b975a498aeaa93df52ba35d3437c0054cf006f2623ff92d6c8",
"final_url": "https://mb.com.ph/2022/05/13/faith-healer-accused-of-raping-patients-nabbed/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.philstar.com/the-freeman/cebu-news/2021/12/02/2145223/faith-healer-rapes-patients-tells-them-its-spiritual-duty",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: complaint-filing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d26632e14e4a945beceb73c2f3f34ab8388cdccf3075af5cd8219fab15326009",
"final_url": "https://www.philstar.com/the-freeman/cebu-news/2021/12/02/2145223/faith-healer-rapes-patients-tells-them-its-spiritual-duty"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charged tier: DOJ-approved informations, non-bailable, trial ongoing as of the most recent located report (Feb. 2026). Distinct from the Quiboloy/KOJC record already in the corpus — different organization, different founder, different province.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-jey-rence-quilario-sbsi-surigao-philippines",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Socorro, Surigao del Norte, Philippines",
"lat": 9.6167,
"lng": 125.9667,
"title": "Philippines: 'Senior Agila' cult leader charged with trafficking and forced child marriage of followers' children",
"tradition": "nrm",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed reincarnation of the Santo Nino (child Jesus); founder-leader of Socorro Bayanihan Services Inc."
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed divine/reincarnated status",
"forced marriage of children as young as 12 to adult members",
"confining minors until they agreed to sex, framed as required to 'go to heaven'"
],
"organizations": [
"Socorro Bayanihan Services Inc. (SBSI)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Trial Court, Branch 31, Dapa, Surigao del Norte, Philippines",
"stage": "informations filed; non-bailable; trial ongoing",
"date": "2023-11-06",
"outcome": "The Department of Justice filed nine counts of qualified trafficking in persons, eight counts of child abuse, and four counts of facilitating/solemnizing child marriage against Jey Rence Quilario ('Senior Agila') and twelve co-respondents, over the forced marriage and sexual abuse of minors within the SBSI compound at Sitio Kapihan. Quilario was arrested inside the Senate building in November 2023 after being held in contempt for denying the allegations during Sen. Risa Hontiveros's inquiry. As of a February 2026 report, the cases remained under trial before the RTC and the accused remained detained on the non-bailable trafficking charges."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/regions/887448/trafficking-child-abuse-child-marriage-raps-filed-vs-sbsi-leader-12-others/story/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Trafficking, child abuse, child marriage raps filed vs SBSI leader, 12 others', GMA News Online, 6 Nov. 2023.",
"body": "Reports the DOJ's filing of qualified-trafficking, child-abuse, and child-marriage charges against Quilario and twelve co-respondents before the Dapa RTC, and Justice Secretary Remulla's description of how the children were moved and used.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.philstar.com/nation/2026/02/01/2504868/cases-vs-senior-agila-still-under-trial",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"'Cases vs Senior Agila still under trial'\", Philstar, 1 Feb. 2026.",
"body": "NBI update confirming the cases against Quilario and SBSI leaders remain under trial and the accused remain detained.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-status-report"
},
{
"link": "https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1838034/teen-socorro-cult-compel-marriage-sex-with-adults-to-go-to-heaven",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Teen: Socorro cult compel marriage, sex with adults \"to go to heaven\"', Philippine Daily Inquirer, 2023.",
"body": "Senate-hearing testimony describing the doctrinal pretext — that submitting to marriage and sex with adult members was required to 'go to heaven' — used to coerce minor members.",
"tier": "official-hearing-testimony",
"kind": "senate-testimony-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Quilario was venerated by parents and child members as the reincarnated Santo Nino; that claimed divine identity is what the DOJ's charging theory and victim testimony describe as the operative mechanism inducing parents to hand over their children and children to submit to forced marriage and sex.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "The Department of Justice filed nine counts of qualified trafficking in persons, eight counts of child abuse, and four counts of facilitating/solemnizing child marriage against Jey Rence Quilario ('Senior Agila') and twelve co-respondents, over the forced marriage and sexual abuse of minors within the SBSI compound at Sitio Kapihan. Quilario was arrested inside the Senate building in November 2023 after being held in contempt for denying the allegations during Sen. Risa Hontiveros's inquiry. As of a February 2026 report, the cases remained under trial before the RTC and the accused remained detained on the non-bailable trafficking charges.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/regions/887448/trafficking-child-abuse-child-marriage-raps-filed-vs-sbsi-leader-12-others/story/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "077dd9d2068252e369a7fe37d9658eed22928901f416159c1fb952ecf448b9c6",
"final_url": "https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/regions/887448/trafficking-child-abuse-child-marriage-raps-filed-vs-sbsi-leader-12-others/story/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.philstar.com/nation/2026/02/01/2504868/cases-vs-senior-agila-still-under-trial",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-status-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "51f77dd84036aba33e7655c5ec0ca8c221b78683bedc8ffc7a99591e20cd48b5",
"final_url": "https://www.philstar.com/nation/2026/02/01/2504868/cases-vs-senior-agila-still-under-trial"
},
{
"source": "https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1838034/teen-socorro-cult-compel-marriage-sex-with-adults-to-go-to-heaven",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-hearing-testimony; evidentiary role: senate-testimony-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "efabac8976660ea19acb0ae4903da2bb82f9d14a5831bb1c10488483dacd4396",
"final_url": "https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1838034/teen-socorro-cult-compel-marriage-sex-with-adults-to-go-to-heaven"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 842,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "prior-conviction",
"date": "2003",
"note": "First conviction (one year) for physical assaults at St Ninian's, Gartmore, 1960s — recorded because the 2016 case is his second and heavier conviction for a separate course of abuse at a different institution."
}
],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-michael-murphy-de-la-salle-scotland",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Tranent and Gartmore, Scotland, United Kingdom",
"lat": 55.94,
"lng": -2.96,
"title": "Scotland: De La Salle Brother convicted a third time — decades of abuse at two List D schools",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"De La Salle Brother (Brother Benedict), residential-school custodian of boys in Catholic-run List D schools"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-order custody of boys in residential List D (approved) schools",
"physical terror (beatings, electric shocks) suppressing disclosure",
"isolation of institutionalised children from family and outside oversight"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"De La Salle Brothers",
"St Joseph's School, Tranent",
"St Ninian's List D School, Gartmore"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Scotland (High Court of Justiciary / Sheriff Court)",
"stage": "third conviction; sentence stood",
"date": "2016-01-01",
"outcome": "Michael Murphy, a De La Salle Brother known within the order as Brother Benedict, was convicted in 2016 of 29 offences of assault, indecent assault and indecent conduct against boys housed at St Joseph's School, Tranent (East Lothian) and St Ninian's List D School, Gartmore (Stirlingshire), and was sentenced to seven years' imprisonment. This was his third conviction: he was first convicted in 2003 (one year) for physical assaults at St Ninian's between 1960 and 1969, and the 2016 case covered a further course of physical and sexual abuse at St Joseph's from the 1970s to 1981. Twenty boys, some as young as seven or eight, were named in the 2016 prosecution."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys held in the residential custody of a Catholic teaching order at church-run approved schools, with no outside oversight and physical terror used to suppress disclosure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/crime/animal-monk-abused-children-in-east-lothian-residential-school-3444839",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Edinburgh Evening News, 'Jailed again: Animal monk abused children in East Lothian residential school.'",
"body": "Reports the 2016 conviction, sentence, and abuse pattern at St Joseph's and St Ninian's.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/de-la-salle-brothers-failed-abused-boys-1447231",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Scotsman, 'De La Salle Brothers failed abused boys.'",
"body": "Confirms the De La Salle order's operation of both schools and institutional failure to act on known abuse.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "prior-conviction",
"date": "2003",
"note": "First conviction (one year) for physical assaults at St Ninian's, Gartmore, 1960s — recorded because the 2016 case is his second and heavier conviction for a separate course of abuse at a different institution."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/crime/animal-monk-abused-children-in-east-lothian-residential-school-3444839",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b8f08c680dcd1aaadda2fd18d651e576693524ea29fa9b5f80c45896fb3614cf",
"final_url": "https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/crime/animal-monk-abused-children-in-east-lothian-residential-school-3444839"
},
{
"source": "https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/de-la-salle-brothers-failed-abused-boys-1447231",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "89d7cbb3bd5824794ef27f2b2b4d5caf140a1e756b37c0e0ea704d7925417a1d",
"final_url": "https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/de-la-salle-brothers-failed-abused-boys-1447231"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 843,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-landakotsskoli-catholic-commission-iceland",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Reykjavík, Iceland",
"lat": 64.15,
"lng": -21.94,
"title": "Iceland: Catholic Church commission confirms abuse at Landakotsskóli school and Riftún camp",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Rev. Ágúst Georg Gíslason, Catholic priest and school principal",
"Margrét Müller, teacher",
"Bishop Joannes Gijsen, diocesan authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical headship of a Catholic parish school and affiliated summer camp",
"diocesan suppression of a documented abuse complaint (destroyed letter)"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Catholic Church in Iceland",
"Landakotsskóli",
"Riftún summer camp"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Catholic Church in Iceland — independent investigative commission (chair: Hjördís Hákonardóttir)",
"stage": "official commission report",
"date": "2012-11-05",
"outcome": "The Church's own investigative commission confirmed that Rev. Ágúst Georg Gíslason, principal of the Catholic elementary school Landakotsskóli, and teacher Margrét Müller had abused pupils. Of 30 former pupils and camp attendees interviewed, 8 reported sexual abuse and 27 reported mental abuse or witnessing it, spanning the school and the affiliated Riftún summer camp. The commission separately found that Bishop Joannes Gijsen failed his obligations by destroying a letter documenting an abuse allegation instead of investigating it. No criminal prosecution is recorded; this is an official institutional finding."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children enrolled in a Catholic parish school and its affiliated summer camp, under the direct pastoral and educational authority of the priest-principal and his diocese.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.icelandreview.com/news/catholic-church-confirms-child-abuse-iceland/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Iceland Review, 'Catholic Church Confirms Child Abuse in Iceland' (2012).",
"body": "Reports the commission's findings, named individuals, victim counts, and the bishop's failure to act on a documented complaint.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.icelandreview.com/news/catholic-church-confirms-child-abuse-iceland/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4a3e065fd79e2ff1b71c380aaa3403c388a86e92c1810927cfab89832b81ab72",
"final_url": "https://www.icelandreview.com/news/catholic-church-confirms-child-abuse-iceland/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 844,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-viby-frikirke-pastor-aarhus-denmark",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Viby, Aarhus, Denmark",
"lat": 56.13,
"lng": 10.16,
"title": "Denmark: free-church pastor convicted of exploiting a parishioner's trust — court cites his role as her confidant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Free-church (Frikirken) pastor, Viby, Aarhus"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counselling relationship in which the victim treated him as her spiritual confidant",
"position of trust explicitly cited by the court as aggravating the offence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Frikirken (Free Church), Viby"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Retten i Aarhus (Aarhus District Court)",
"stage": "conviction on one of four counts",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "The pastor was charged with four counts of indecency for sharing intimate images and videos of congregation members; convicted on one count where corroborating evidence existed and acquitted on the other three for lack of evidence. Sentenced to 14 days' conditional imprisonment plus 2,500 kroner compensation to the victim. The court held that his position as her pastoral confidant — 'she was his parishioner' — aggravated the offence. His admitted sexual relationships with four congregants (2017-2020) predated Denmark's May 2023 law criminalising clergy abuse of position (modelled on existing protections for doctors and psychologists) and were not separately prosecuted under it."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A congregation member who confided in her pastor as a trusted spiritual counsellor; the court found that trust relationship itself aggravated the offence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/aarhus/frikirkepraest-doemt-for-at-kraenke-kvinde-fra-sin-menighed",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TV2 Østjylland, 'Frikirkepræst dømt for at krænke kvinde fra sin menighed' (2023).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, sentence, the court's finding on his position as pastoral confidant, and the new May 2023 clergy-abuse-of-position law.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/aarhus/frikirkepraest-doemt-for-at-kraenke-kvinde-fra-sin-menighed",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0b9e3177e46d61baf8fc7efa4c700df390d6e270698e75f553a45b96bda7e541",
"final_url": "https://www.tv2ostjylland.dk/aarhus/frikirkepraest-doemt-for-at-kraenke-kvinde-fra-sin-menighed"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 845,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-satakunta-pastor-youth-ministry-finland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Satakunta region, Finland",
"lat": 61.47,
"lng": 21.8,
"title": "Finland: parish pastor convicted of sexually messaging three children in his youth ministry",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-lutheran",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Parish pastor performing youth ministry (nuorisotyö), Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland, Turku Archdiocese"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority over children enrolled in his parish's youth ministry",
"access to parish children's contact details via his official duties"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland",
"Turku Archdiocese"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Satakunnan käräjäoikeus (Satakunta District Court)",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2026-06-29",
"outcome": "A 43-year-old parish pastor was convicted of three counts of sexual abuse of a child and three counts of breach of official duty, sentenced to one year and two months' conditional imprisonment. Between April and September 2023 he used Snapchat, accessed through his parish youth-ministry role, to send sexually suggestive messages and shirtless photos to children in the parish almost daily. Three victims were identified; each was awarded 2,000-3,000 euros in compensation. The suspected offending came to the parish's attention in autumn 2023."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children enrolled in the parish's youth ministry, contacted through the pastor's official pastoral role and treated as within his clerical care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aamuposti.fi/uutissuomalainen/9575871",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Uutissuomalainen (Aamuposti), 'Pappi viestitteli seksuaalissävytteisesti seurakuntaan kuuluville lapsille — ehdollista vankeutta' (2026).",
"body": "Reports the court, date, sentence, victim count, and the pastor's youth-ministry role as the access mechanism.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aamuposti.fi/uutissuomalainen/9575871",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bec98c74661e28630beb8a4fd4a7e8712962f3c70ba2c2f50f4dae4e35ea2dd4",
"final_url": "https://www.aamuposti.fi/uutissuomalainen/9575871"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 846,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-michael-fisher-emmanuel-baptist-nova-scotia-canada",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Hammonds Plains, Nova Scotia, Canada",
"lat": 44.75,
"lng": -63.75,
"title": "Canada: Nova Scotia youth pastor convicted of grooming and sexually assaulting a teenage congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Youth pastor, Emmanuel Baptist Church, Hammonds Plains, Nova Scotia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"youth-pastor authority over a young congregant beginning when she was 14",
"multi-year grooming under cover of pastoral mentorship"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Emmanuel Baptist Church, Hammonds Plains"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nova Scotia Provincial Court",
"stage": "convicted at trial",
"date": "2019-01-01",
"outcome": "Michael Oliver Fisher, youth pastor at Emmanuel Baptist Church in Hammonds Plains, N.S., was convicted of sexual assault and sexual interference. The court heard he began grooming the victim in 2008 when she was 14, escalating over the following three years to kissing, massages, nudity and sexual assault by the time she was 17. He was sentenced to 27 months in prison, placed on the national sex-offender registry for 20 years, and his DNA was recorded in a national databank."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A teenage congregant groomed over years by her church's youth pastor, whose pastoral role over the congregation's young people was the access mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/youth-pastor-michael-oliver-fisher-convicted-sexual-assault-1.5398465",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Former youth pastor convicted of sexual assault, sexual interference.'",
"body": "Reports the conviction and grooming timeline from age 14.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/n-s-youth-pastor-gets-27-months-in-prison-for-sexual-interference-1.5797277",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'N.S. youth pastor gets 27 months in prison for sexual interference.'",
"body": "Reports the sentence, sex-offender registry order, and DNA order.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/youth-pastor-michael-oliver-fisher-convicted-sexual-assault-1.5398465",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/n-s-youth-pastor-gets-27-months-in-prison-for-sexual-interference-1.5797277",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 847,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-albert-leblanc-yarmouth-nova-scotia-canada",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Yarmouth, Nova Scotia, Canada",
"lat": 43.84,
"lng": -66.12,
"title": "Canada: former Yarmouth priest sentenced to five and a half years after admitting to molesting six children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Roman Catholic priest, Diocese of Yarmouth, 1955-1973"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority over children in his Yarmouth County parish",
"grooming with alcohol and unsupervised access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Yarmouth"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Nova Scotia Provincial Court, Yarmouth",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2012-11-01",
"outcome": "Albert LeBlanc, 83, a priest in the Diocese of Yarmouth from 1955 to 1973, pleaded guilty to six counts of indecent assault against children dating to when he was a priest in Yarmouth County in the 1970s, and was sentenced to five and a half years' imprisonment in November 2012. He had faced 40 charges initially, alleging abuse of children as young as seven, and was accused of enticing underage victims with alcohol. He resigned the priesthood in 1973."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children in the parish under a Catholic priest's pastoral authority, groomed with alcohol during his time in active ministry.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/atlantic/article/ex-priest-sentenced-more-than-5-years-for-sex-crimes",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CTV Atlantic, 'Ex-priest sentenced more than 5 years for sex crimes' (2012).",
"body": "Reports the six guilty pleas, sentence, and abuse period.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/ex-priest-sentenced-more-than-5-years-for-sex-offenses-1.1253238",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Ex-priest sentenced more than 5 years for sex offenses.'",
"body": "Corroborates sentence, victim count, and priesthood dates.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/atlantic/article/ex-priest-sentenced-more-than-5-years-for-sex-crimes",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b2ab73901927aaf1c1e74ab8289ab958d4a0204c07fb30852c83c0c2de330bc3",
"final_url": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/atlantic/article/ex-priest-sentenced-more-than-5-years-for-sex-crimes/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/ex-priest-sentenced-more-than-5-years-for-sex-offenses-1.1253238",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 848,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-yvon-arsenault-moncton-new-brunswick-canada",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Shediac and Collette, New Brunswick, Canada",
"lat": 46.22,
"lng": -64.54,
"title": "Canada: former Moncton priest sentenced to four years after admitting to molesting nine boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Roman Catholic priest, Archdiocese of Moncton"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority over altar-boy-age parishioners",
"access to boys through parish and church-sponsored activities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Moncton"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New Brunswick Court of Queen's Bench",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2017-02-01",
"outcome": "Yvon Arsenault, 74, a priest of the Archdiocese of Moncton removed from service in July 2012, pleaded guilty to nine counts of molesting boys and was sentenced to four years' imprisonment in February 2017. The nine victims ranged in age from 9 to 17 when the abuse occurred between 1971 and 1980 in Shediac and Collette, Northumberland County; eleven further counts were withdrawn on the guilty plea."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys of altar-boy age under the pastoral authority of a parish priest, abused over a decade through his clerical access to them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/priest-yvon-arsenault-molestation-shediac-1.3997532",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Former priest Yvon Arsenault handed 4-year sentence for 9 sex crimes.'",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, sentence, victim ages, and abuse period.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/priest-yvon-arsenault-molestation-shediac-1.3997532",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 849,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-rino-deschenes-edmundston-new-brunswick-canada",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Edmundston, New Brunswick, Canada",
"lat": 47.37,
"lng": -68.33,
"title": "Canada: defrocked Edmundston priest sentenced to seven and a half years for abusing altar boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Roman Catholic priest, Diocese of Edmundston"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority over altar boys serving under him in the 1960s",
"defrocking followed the conviction, confirming loss of clerical status only after the fact"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Edmundston"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Edmundston Provincial Court",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2015-01-01",
"outcome": "Rino Deschênes pleaded guilty to charges including indecency and sodomy against four youths who served as altar boys under him in the 1960s while he was a priest in Edmundston. Judge Brigitte Volpe of Edmundston Provincial Court sentenced him to seven and a half years' imprisonment in 2015. He was subsequently defrocked."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Altar boys serving directly under a parish priest's liturgical and pastoral authority, the paradigmatic clerical-access relationship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.apmlawyers.com/blog/rino-deschenes-edmundston-diocese/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "McKiggan Hebert Lawyers, 'Rino Deschenes Charged with Sexual Abuse.'",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, sentence, altar-boy victim role, and defrocking.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.apmlawyers.com/blog/rino-deschenes-edmundston-diocese/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f906cc0cdfde93041a6f421c5fb8140e540781b3993a61b264ae519be5b4c780",
"final_url": "https://www.apmlawyers.com/blog/rino-deschenes-edmundston-diocese/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 850,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-janko-kolosnjaji-saskatoon-canada",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada",
"lat": 52.13,
"lng": -106.67,
"title": "Canada: Saskatoon Ukrainian Catholic priest convicted of sexually assaulting a 13-year-old parishioner",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Priest, Ukrainian Catholic Cathedral of St. George, Saskatoon"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority over a parish child, with a claimed 'cultural greeting' defence rejected by the court",
"access via a private area of the cathedral (supply closet)"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Ukrainian Catholic Eparchy of Saskatoon",
"Ukrainian Catholic Cathedral of St. George"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Saskatchewan Provincial Court",
"stage": "convicted at trial; sentenced",
"date": "2025-10-01",
"outcome": "Fr. Janko Kolosnjaji, 72, was found guilty in February 2025 of sexually assaulting a 13-year-old girl by kissing her without consent in a supply closet at the Ukrainian Catholic Cathedral of St. George, Saskatoon, in 2023. The judge rejected a defence that the kiss was a cultural greeting. He was sentenced in October 2025 to eight months' imprisonment followed by 18 months' probation; the judge considered but declined a 12-18 month term. He retains the right to appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child parishioner encountered and assaulted by her priest inside the cathedral, using his clerical presence and access to justify physical contact.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/janko-kolosnjaji-ukrainian-catholic-priest-guilty-sexual-assault-1.7470071",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Saskatoon priest defibrillated in courtroom after he's found guilty of sexually assaulting teen girl.'",
"body": "Reports the guilty finding, rejected cultural-greeting defence, and location.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/priest-sexual-assault-9.6934647",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Saskatoon priest sentenced to 8 months for 2023 sexual assault.'",
"body": "Reports the sentence and probation term.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/janko-kolosnjaji-ukrainian-catholic-priest-guilty-sexual-assault-1.7470071",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/priest-sexual-assault-9.6934647",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 851,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-brad-dahr-vegreville-alberta-canada",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Vegreville, Alberta, Canada",
"lat": 53.5,
"lng": -112.05,
"title": "Canada: Alberta pastor sentenced to five years after grooming a congregant he had recruited as co-preacher",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-adventist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Pastor, Vegreville, Alberta, 2016-2020; ran the church's mental-health outreach program"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counselling role exploited via a mental-health outreach program he ran for young adults",
"recruited the teenage victim as a co-preacher, deepening dependence on him",
"escalating volume of private messaging (190,000+ messages) building isolation from her parents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Vegreville church congregation (Seventh-day Adventist)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Alberta Court of Queen's Bench",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2021-01-01",
"outcome": "Brad Dahr, 56, pastor in Vegreville, Alberta from 2016 to 2020, pleaded guilty to sexual exploitation and making child pornography and was sentenced to five years' imprisonment (four years for exploitation, one for the pornography count). He had asked a teenage congregation member, whom he was mentoring through his mental-health outreach program, to co-preach a sermon series with him in 2017; she confided her mental-health struggles and became dependent on him. Over 190,000 messages were exchanged, non-sexual at first, turning sexual in early 2020. The victim's mother told the court he manipulated her daughter into distancing herself from her parents."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A congregant recruited into a pastoral mentorship and preaching role, made dependent on the pastor for mental-health support before the relationship turned sexual — spiritual and therapeutic authority operating together.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-pastor-5-years-prison-1.6914403",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Former Alberta pastor sentenced to 5 years for sexual exploitation, making child pornography.'",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, sentence, mentorship/co-preaching mechanism, and message volume.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-pastor-5-years-prison-1.6914403",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 852,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-freres-instruction-chretienne-quebec-class-action-canada",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Dolbeau and Mistassini, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 48.87,
"lng": -72.23,
"title": "Canada: Quebec court authorizes class action against a teaching congregation over decades of abuse at church-run schools",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Frères de l'instruction chrétienne (Brothers of Christian Instruction), teaching order operating up to 80 Quebec schools"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-order custody of boarding pupils at church-run juvénats and schools",
"alleged institutional practice of transferring known abusers between schools rather than reporting them"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Frères de l'instruction chrétienne",
"Juvénat Saint-Jean, Dolbeau",
"École Saint-Michel, Mistassini"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cour supérieure du Québec",
"stage": "class action authorized",
"date": "2024-05-21",
"outcome": "Justice Lukasz Granosik authorized a class action against the Frères de l'instruction chrétienne on 21 May 2024, alleging sexual assaults against more than 87 victims over at least two decades, principally between 1957 and 1987 at the Juvénat Saint-Jean in Dolbeau, École Saint-Michel in Mistassini, and related educational activities. The claim alleges four different Brothers committed assaults at Dolbeau in the 1980s alone, and that congregation leadership knew of the abuse and moved offending Brothers between schools rather than reporting them. As of a September 2024 filing, 30 named plaintiffs had come forward; this is a civil proceeding, not a criminal conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boys boarded at church-run juvénat schools under the exclusive custody of teaching Brothers, with the congregation's own internal transfer practice alleged to have shielded known abusers.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2106215/freres-religion-ecoles-pretres-cures",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio-Canada, 'Abus sexuels : les Frères de l'instruction chrétienne auraient sévi au Juvénat de Dolbeau.'",
"body": "Names the institutions, alleges four Brothers offending at Dolbeau in the 1980s, and the transfer practice.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lavoixdelest.ca/actualites/justice-et-faits-divers/2024/05/22/action-collective-approuvee-contre-les-freres-de-linstruction-chretienne-ZFWVT5PX5JFS3M3PZ74OKH3XOE/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Voix de l'Est, 'Action collective approuvée contre les Frères de l'instruction chrétienne' (2024-05-22).",
"body": "Confirms the authorization date, judge, and victim count.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2106215/freres-religion-ecoles-pretres-cures",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "65bf7804fa329e0d733ad1b80b39d359a3a496165df3efad35e322dce6f6dcfa",
"final_url": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2106215/freres-religion-ecoles-pretres-cures"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lavoixdelest.ca/actualites/justice-et-faits-divers/2024/05/22/action-collective-approuvee-contre-les-freres-de-linstruction-chretienne-ZFWVT5PX5JFS3M3PZ74OKH3XOE/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "99593acda3bf29013bfc8908f1ba947fb9c6dd65f0cebbe54b57454c15740ddd",
"final_url": "https://www.lavoixdelest.ca/actualites/justice-et-faits-divers/2024/05/22/action-collective-approuvee-contre-les-freres-de-linstruction-chretienne-ZFWVT5PX5JFS3M3PZ74OKH3XOE/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 853,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Ohio Third Appellate District affirmed the judgment on December 29, 2025."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim identified only by initials (O.H.) in the opinion. No family relationship between Burkard and the victim is stated or suggested; the church's own witnesses confirmed his pastoral-authority role.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-burkard-marysville-ohio-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Marysville, Ohio, USA",
"lat": 40.2364,
"lng": -83.3671,
"title": "Ohio: accredited minister and pastoral trainer convicted of abusing a Bible Baptist Church congregant's daughter",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"accredited minister and men's pastoral trainer, Bible Baptist Church of Marysville"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abuse committed in a church-owned vehicle during and after Vacation Bible School",
"instructed the victim not to tell his wife",
"access via a Vacation Bible School volunteer role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Bible Baptist Church of Marysville"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Common Pleas, Union County, Ohio",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "A jury found Burkard guilty on charges arising from abuse of O.H., the teenage daughter of a family that regularly attended Bible Baptist Church, where Burkard was accredited clergy training men to become pastors and ministers."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Ohio, Third Appellate District",
"stage": "direct appeal, Case No. 14-24-36",
"date": "2025-12-29",
"outcome": "Judgment affirmed. The court found Burkard, though not formally ordained, was an accredited minister and pastoral trainer holding a recognized position of authority in the church, confirmed by testimony from the church's senior pastor."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Burkard was accredited clergy at Bible Baptist Church whose role was training men to become pastors and full-time ministers; the church's own senior pastor testified Burkard held a position of authority in the church. The victim was the daughter of a congregant family, and the abuse occurred on church grounds during and immediately after church-sponsored Vacation Bible School.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2025/12/29/state_v._burkard.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Burkard, Ohio Third Appellate District, Case No. 14-24-36 (Dec. 29, 2025).",
"body": "Appellate opinion affirming the conviction, detailing Burkard's accredited-minister and pastoral-trainer role at Bible Baptist Church of Marysville and the abuse of a congregant's daughter in a church vehicle.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Ohio Third Appellate District affirmed the judgment on December 29, 2025."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2025/12/29/state_v._burkard.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "805de539f2cdc3d4691a07ce4190e3aa74c63422ee827e79d241e0019a05f952",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2025/12/29/state_v._burkard.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 854,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "No reversal of Billups's 2012 criminal conviction located; the Virginia Supreme Court's 2019 civil decision addressed only the institutional defendants' liability, not Billups's guilt."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record documents the criminal conviction (2012, per press coverage) and cites the 2019 Virginia Supreme Court civil opinion (A.H. v. Church of God in Christ, Inc.) as the primary CourtListener-indexed source, since the criminal trial-court record is not separately indexed there. The civil opinion's disposition (reversed in part) concerns only institutional liability, not the underlying criminal conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-billups-covington-virginia-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Covington, Virginia, USA",
"lat": 37.7935,
"lng": -79.9942,
"title": "Virginia: COGIC deacon convicted of molesting children from his church's youth department; Supreme Court revives negligence suit against the denomination",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"deacon, Gospel Tabernacle Church of God in Christ (COGIC), Covington, Virginia",
"youth-department leader and drill-team coach"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as church deacon and youth-department leader",
"coached the church's children's and youth drill team",
"access to children through church youth activities over a ten-year tenure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Gospel Tabernacle Church of God in Christ, Covington, Virginia",
"Church of God in Christ, Inc."
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court, Alleghany County, Virginia",
"stage": "criminal conviction",
"date": "2012-11-01",
"outcome": "Donald Billups, deacon of Gospel Tabernacle COGIC for over a decade, was convicted of 16 sex crimes against seven girls aged 10-16, molested from 2002 through 2012 while he ran the church's youth department and drill team. He was sentenced to two life terms plus 75 years. No appellate reversal of the criminal conviction has been located."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Virginia",
"stage": "civil appeal, A.H. v. Church of God in Christ, Inc.",
"date": "2019-08-15",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court of Virginia reversed in part a circuit court dismissal and revived a negligence and respondeat superior suit by victim A.H. against the local church and the national COGIC denomination, holding the allegations stated legally viable claims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Billups held the church office of deacon and ran Gospel Tabernacle's youth department and drill team for children and teens; his victims were girls from the congregation, not his own children, and were placed in his care through the church's own youth programming.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4648502/ah-v-church-of-god-in-christ-inc/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "A.H. v. Church of God in Christ, Inc., 297 Va. 604 (Va. Aug. 15, 2019).",
"body": "Supreme Court of Virginia opinion reviving A.H.'s negligence claims against the church defendants, reciting that deacon Donald Billups was convicted in 2012 of molesting A.H. and other children over a decade while running the church's youth department and drill team.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "civil-appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://cogicabusewatch.wordpress.com/2013/03/01/former-cogic-deacon-given-2-life-sentences-for-sexual-molestation/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "COGIC Abuse Watch (2013) 'Former COGIC deacon given 2 life sentences for sexual molestation'.",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of Billups's 2012 conviction and sentencing to two life terms plus 75 years for molesting seven church girls.",
"tier": "secondary-press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "No reversal of Billups's 2012 criminal conviction located; the Virginia Supreme Court's 2019 civil decision addressed only the institutional defendants' liability, not Billups's guilt."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4648502/ah-v-church-of-god-in-christ-inc/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: civil-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4648502/ah-v-church-of-god-in-christ-inc/"
},
{
"source": "https://cogicabusewatch.wordpress.com/2013/03/01/former-cogic-deacon-given-2-life-sentences-for-sexual-molestation/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "adc454907495e77f8ddf1777882770cad4d37e8be18aeba47b19e01aac48c1b2",
"final_url": "https://cogicabusewatch.wordpress.com/2013/03/01/former-cogic-deacon-given-2-life-sentences-for-sexual-molestation/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 855,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Arkansas Court of Appeals affirmed the liability judgment on January 28, 2026; only the unrelated attorney-fee cross-appeal issue was reversed and remanded."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The lawsuit also included a sibling, MC2, but the jury found no liability as to her; this record concerns only the MC1 claim on which liability was established and affirmed. The direct-appeal issue affirmed was liability for MC1; a separate attorney-fee cross-appeal was reversed and remanded, which does not affect the underlying liability finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-lester-smith-carroll-county-arkansas-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Carroll County, Arkansas, USA",
"lat": 36.3776,
"lng": -93.6141,
"title": "Arkansas: church elder and Sunday-school superintendent's civil liability for abusing a 13-year-old parishioner affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"church elder and Sunday-school superintendent"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as church elder and Sunday-school superintendent over a 13-year-old parishioner"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Carroll County Circuit Court, Arkansas",
"stage": "criminal guilty plea",
"date": "2020-02-27",
"outcome": "Lester Smith, a 74-year-old church elder and Sunday-school superintendent, pleaded guilty to second-degree sexual assault of MC1, a 13-year-old parishioner at his church."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Arkansas Court of Appeals",
"stage": "civil appeal, No. CV-24-131",
"date": "2026-01-28",
"outcome": "Affirmed on direct appeal. The court held Smith's undisputed admission that he had sexual contact with MC1 when she was 13, and his status as her church elder with her as a parishioner, supported summary judgment on liability; the jury had awarded MC1 $100,000 in compensatory and $1 million in punitive damages. Reversed and remanded only on the separate cross-appeal issue of attorney fees."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Smith was MC1's church elder and the Sunday-school superintendent; the appellate opinion expressly frames the relationship as 'he was a church elder, and she was a parishioner' in finding sexual contact by a person in a position of trust to be actionable. MC1's father brought suit on her behalf as next friend but is not the perpetrator.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/01/28/lester_buckley_smith_v._vince_eastwood_as_parent_and_next_friend_of_two_1.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Smith v. Eastwood, 2026 Ark. App. 48 (Jan. 28, 2026).",
"body": "Arkansas Court of Appeals opinion affirming liability judgment against church elder Lester Smith for sexual abuse of parishioner MC1, based on his guilty plea to second-degree sexual assault and his position of trust as church elder and Sunday-school superintendent.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "civil-appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Arkansas Court of Appeals affirmed the liability judgment on January 28, 2026; only the unrelated attorney-fee cross-appeal issue was reversed and remanded."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/01/28/lester_buckley_smith_v._vince_eastwood_as_parent_and_next_friend_of_two_1.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: civil-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7f57e2fe1c8e41f63545352ce4eb34ee40f85d2c838a75da41ff9c8ac9b0b190",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/01/28/lester_buckley_smith_v._vince_eastwood_as_parent_and_next_friend_of_two_1.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 856,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions and sentences on November 23, 2021."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The conviction stands specifically for the counts involving Vickie; the jury hung on the count involving Tina. Investigators corroborated Tina's separate account of abuse at the same church and found physical evidence (condoms) matching both victims' descriptions.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-piccaluga-eagle-lake-mississippi-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Eagle Lake, Warren County, Mississippi, USA",
"lat": 32.5262,
"lng": -90.9573,
"title": "Mississippi: Methodist pastor's convictions for statutory rape and sexual battery of two congregants affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Eagle Lake Methodist Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over congregant children",
"abuse committed inside the church building",
"long-standing familiarity as the girls' pastor since childhood"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Eagle Lake Methodist Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Warren County Circuit Court, Mississippi",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2020-03-19",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Troy Anthony Piccaluga, pastor of Eagle Lake Methodist Church, of statutory rape and sexual battery of Vickie, a congregant he had known since she was in sixth grade; the jury could not reach a verdict on a related count involving a second victim, Tina, who also testified she had sex with Piccaluga at the church as a fourteen-year-old."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Mississippi Court of Appeals",
"stage": "direct appeal",
"date": "2021-11-23",
"outcome": "Convictions and sentences affirmed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Piccaluga was the pastor of Eagle Lake Methodist Church; both victims were congregants (Vickie had known him as her pastor since sixth grade), and the abuse occurred inside the church building. Neither victim was Piccaluga's own child.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/11/23/troy_anthony_piccaluga_aka_troy_piccaluga_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Piccaluga v. State, No. 2020-KA-00346-COA (Miss. Ct. App. Nov. 23, 2021).",
"body": "Appellate opinion affirming Piccaluga's convictions for statutory rape and sexual battery of a congregant, detailing his role as pastor of Eagle Lake Methodist Church and the abuse occurring inside the church.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions and sentences on November 23, 2021."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/11/23/troy_anthony_piccaluga_aka_troy_piccaluga_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "83e5da7fd3eed5bb92ee03349a3ff7d9a34cc16f17905b5407fb01f54bd3e09a",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/11/23/troy_anthony_piccaluga_aka_troy_piccaluga_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 857,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Oregon Court of Appeals affirmed all 12 counts of conviction on April 23, 2025."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns the victim who was counseled by Putnam through his church, satisfying the spiritual-authority criterion. The case also involved a second victim who was Putnam's own daughter, which independently would fail the criterion under the paternal-nexus rule; both victims' convictions were affirmed together in a single appeal covering all 12 counts, so the daughter's status does not disqualify the church-counseled victim's claim.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-putnam-marion-county-oregon-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Marion County, Oregon, USA",
"lat": 44.9429,
"lng": -123.0351,
"title": "Oregon: home-church pastor's convictions for abusing a congregant he counseled, plus a family victim, affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of a church he ran out of his home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counseling relationship with a congregant",
"position as pastor of a home-based church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Marion County Circuit Court, Oregon",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Bradley Putnam on 12 counts of sexual offenses against two victims: one victim was counseled by Putnam through his home-based church, and the other was his own daughter."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals of Oregon",
"stage": "direct appeal",
"date": "2025-04-23",
"outcome": "Affirmed. The court rejected challenges to prosecutorial statements at closing and the denial of a continuance."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Putnam was the pastor of a church he ran from his home; one of the two victims was counseled by him specifically through that pastoral role, not as a family member, and the abuse occurred in the context of that counseling relationship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2025/04/23/state_v._putnam_1.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Putnam, 340 Or App 61 (Or. Ct. App. Apr. 23, 2025).",
"body": "Appellate opinion affirming Putnam's convictions on 12 counts of sexual offenses against two victims, one of whom was counseled by Putnam through the church he ran from his home.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Oregon Court of Appeals affirmed all 12 counts of conviction on April 23, 2025."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2025/04/23/state_v._putnam_1.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "42431e7cc864efe61bd0d3ddcbe0e28dd7281b17a2676e8aa7e215412bd35963",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2025/04/23/state_v._putnam_1.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 858,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals affirmed on May 2, 2023."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The plea resolved charges also involving allegations of sexual abuse by a person in a position of trust; this record documents the count of conviction (solicitation of a minor) affirmed on appeal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-harper-jackson-county-west-virginia-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Jackson County, West Virginia, USA",
"lat": 38.9315,
"lng": -81.7212,
"title": "West Virginia: pastor's conviction for soliciting and grooming a 15-year-old congregant affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral relationship with a teenage congregant",
"grooming via text messages, including advising the victim to hide the messages from his parents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court of Jackson County, West Virginia",
"stage": "conditional Alford guilty plea and sentencing",
"outcome": "Douglas Edward Harper, a 39-year-old pastor, was indicted on three counts of sexual abuse by a person in a position of trust to a child and three counts of soliciting a minor via computer after grooming a 15-year-old congregant. He entered a conditional Alford guilty plea to one count of solicitation of a minor via computer; the court sentenced him to two to ten years of incarceration, suspended in favor of probation."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia",
"stage": "direct appeal, No. 22-0238",
"date": "2023-05-02",
"outcome": "Affirmed by memorandum decision."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Harper was the victim's pastor; the grooming began and continued through his pastoral relationship with the 15-year-old congregant.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2023/05/02/state_of_west_virginia_v._douglas_edward_harper.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Harper, No. 22-0238 (W. Va. May 2, 2023) (memorandum decision).",
"body": "Memorandum decision affirming pastor Douglas Harper's conditional guilty plea and sentence for soliciting a 15-year-old congregant via text message grooming.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals affirmed on May 2, 2023."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2023/05/02/state_of_west_virginia_v._douglas_edward_harper.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2a87f19087aa3e7dc586cd6a731e65ff2e6484e340671903e7d39cd3f2ba1b18",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2023/05/02/state_of_west_virginia_v._douglas_edward_harper.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 859,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed all twelve convictions and sentences on June 23, 2026."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The family's housing arrangement began as pastoral assistance, not a family or custodial relationship; Sanders is not alleged to be a relative of the victim.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-sanders-lincoln-county-mississippi-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Lincoln County, Mississippi, USA",
"lat": 31.5502,
"lng": -90.4759,
"title": "Mississippi: minister convicted on twelve counts of sexual battery of a girl he took in as a family's pastor, using threats of eternal damnation to control her",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"minister in a position of trust and authority",
"pastor to the victim's family"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"warned the family that violating his rules would put their eternal lives at risk",
"imposed isolating rules restricting social contact",
"housed the family on his property after their pastor referred them to him for help",
"charged specifically as 'a minister in a position of trust and authority' under the sexual-battery statute"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lincoln County Circuit Court, Mississippi",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Robert Sanders of twelve counts of sexual battery against Amy, whose family had been placed in his care by their own pastor. Sanders was sentenced to consecutive thirty-year terms for Counts 1-11 and an additional term for Count 12, with post-release supervision."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Mississippi Court of Appeals",
"stage": "direct appeal",
"date": "2026-06-23",
"outcome": "Convictions and sentences affirmed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sanders became Amy's family's pastor after their own pastor asked him to help the family through a difficult time; he used explicit spiritual-consequence coercion, warning the family that violating his rules would put their eternal lives at risk, and several counts were charged specifically on the basis that he was 'a minister in a position of trust and authority.' Amy was not Sanders's biological or step-child; her family was housed on his property in a caretaking arrangement initiated through his pastoral role.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/06/23/robert_earl_sanders_aka_robert_sanders_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sanders v. State, No. (Miss. Ct. App. June 23, 2026).",
"body": "Appellate opinion affirming Robert Sanders's conviction on twelve counts of sexual battery, detailing his role as minister and pastor to the victim's family, his use of spiritual-consequence threats, and the statutory charging of several counts based on his position as 'a minister in a position of trust and authority.'",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed all twelve convictions and sentences on June 23, 2026."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/06/23/robert_earl_sanders_aka_robert_sanders_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "699bfd1689fd9b62353027beb372725809a8c915eb7e6f6e9f34d2da397aab0f",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/06/23/robert_earl_sanders_aka_robert_sanders_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 860,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Illinois Appellate Court, Second District decided the direct appeal March 25, 1994; the opinion is cited as settled precedent as recently as 2022 without any noted reversal."
}
],
"scopeNote": "VERIFICATION LIMITATION: the 1994 opinion predates CourtListener's CDN full-text coverage (no local_path available) and could not be read in full directly. This record is built from the extensive facts and holding recited in a 2022 Illinois appellate opinion (People v. Stowe) that relies on Davis's evidentiary ruling as controlling precedent, corroborated by independent web search summarizing the original opinion's facts and disposition. No source located a reversal, vacatur or remand of Davis's conviction. Recommend a follow-up primary-source read of 260 Ill. App. 3d 176 before treating this as fully verified to the project's standard CDN-read bar. SOURCING CAVEAT: this pre-2000 opinion has no full text available through the court CDN. The conviction and its disposition were established from a later opinion citing this case as controlling precedent, corroborated against independent reporting. That is a weaker tier than the direct full-text reads behind most records here, and a primary-source read should replace it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-davis-waukegan-illinois-usa",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Lake County, Waukegan, Illinois, USA",
"lat": 42.3636,
"lng": -87.8448,
"title": "Illinois: head pastor and 'bishop' convicted of sexually assaulting two minor members of his international church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and head pastor ('bishop'), Christian Fellowship Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as founder and head pastor of a multi-branch church",
"access to child members through church activities at multiple branch locations"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Fellowship Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lake County Circuit Court, Illinois",
"stage": "bench trial and sentence",
"outcome": "Lloyd R. Davis, founder and head pastor ('bishop') of the Christian Fellowship Church (branches in Waukegan, San Diego, Norfolk and Tijuana), was convicted after a bench trial of 5 counts of criminal sexual assault and 10 counts of aggravated criminal sexual abuse against two minor church members, A.C. and C.L. He was sentenced to 31 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Appellate Court of Illinois, Second District",
"stage": "direct appeal, 260 Ill. App. 3d 176",
"date": "1994-03-25",
"outcome": "The 1994 appellate opinion (People v. Davis) is itself the direct-appeal decision; a 2022 Illinois appellate opinion (People v. Stowe) relies on Davis as good, uncriticized precedent for its Rule 404(b) evidentiary holding, indicating the conviction was not disturbed on appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Davis was the founder and head pastor of the Christian Fellowship Church across four branch locations; both victims were minor members of the church, not his own children.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22People%20v.%20Davis%22%20260%20Ill.%20App.%203d%20176",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Davis, 260 Ill. App. 3d 176, 631 N.E.2d 392 (Ill. App. Ct., 2d Dist. 1994).",
"body": "Illinois Appellate Court opinion affirming Lloyd Davis's convictions for sexually assaulting two minor members of his Christian Fellowship Church; no local_path/CDN copy available (pre-2000), summary reconstructed from a 2022 Illinois appellate opinion relying on it as precedent plus independent web corroboration of the facts and disposition.",
"tier": "secondary-court-citation",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-cited-as-precedent"
},
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2022/11/29/people_v._stowe.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Stowe, 2022 IL App (2d) 210296 (Nov. 29, 2022).",
"body": "2022 Illinois appellate opinion citing and reciting the facts of People v. Davis (1994) as controlling precedent on admission of other-acts evidence, without any indication of reversal.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-citing-precedent"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Illinois Appellate Court, Second District decided the direct appeal March 25, 1994; the opinion is cited as settled precedent as recently as 2022 without any noted reversal."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22People%20v.%20Davis%22%20260%20Ill.%20App.%203d%20176",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-court-citation; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-cited-as-precedent.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2022/11/29/people_v._stowe.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-citing-precedent.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4afa65af5c6c5f27e12ffb8f241d316dc6546a76c1da6e7015533eefe44b02b0",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2022/11/29/people_v._stowe.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 861,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "A related 2018 Illinois appellate opinion (Doe v. Coe) addressed only the separate civil negligent-supervision claims against the church and its senior pastor, not Coe's own criminal liability; this record's criminal disposition is sourced from contemporaneous press reporting on the guilty plea and sentence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-coe-west-dundee-illinois-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "West Dundee, Kane County, Illinois, USA",
"lat": 42.0958,
"lng": -88.2831,
"title": "Illinois: youth ministries director pleads guilty to grooming and sexually abusing a teenage member of his church youth group",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"director of youth ministries, First Congregational Church of Dundee (United Church of Christ)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as director of youth ministries overseeing the church's youth group",
"abuse occurred over a two-year grooming period while overseeing the victim in the youth group"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"First Congregational Church of Dundee, Illinois",
"United Church of Christ"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kane County Circuit Court, Illinois",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2018-04-02",
"outcome": "Chad Coe, director of youth ministries at First Congregational Church of Dundee, pleaded guilty to aggravated criminal sexual abuse of Jane, a member of the church's youth group he oversaw, whom he groomed and assaulted beginning when she was 14. He received the maximum sentence of seven years and lifetime sex-offender registration."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Coe was employed as the church's youth ministries director and directly oversaw the youth group of which the victim was a member; the abuse occurred through that pastoral/youth-leadership relationship, not a family connection.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/html/2018/07/27/doe_v._coe.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Doe v. Coe, 2018 IL App (2d) 170435 (Ill. App. Ct., 2d Dist. Mar. 30, 2018).",
"body": "Civil appellate opinion describing Chad Coe's employment as director of youth ministries at First Congregational Church of Dundee and the allegations that he groomed and abused Jane Doe, a member of the church youth group he oversaw, over a two-year period.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "civil-appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.dailyherald.com/news/20180402/ex-youth-minister-gets-7-years-in-prison-for-sexually-abusing-teen",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily Herald (2018) 'Ex-youth minister gets 7 years in prison for sexually abusing teen'.",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of Chad Coe's guilty plea to aggravated criminal sexual abuse and seven-year sentence, confirming the victim was a member of his church youth group whom he groomed beginning at age 14.",
"tier": "secondary-press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/html/2018/07/27/doe_v._coe.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: civil-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.dailyherald.com/news/20180402/ex-youth-minister-gets-7-years-in-prison-for-sexually-abusing-teen",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d02032286070b4dd9d8fbd985a7bdca8af8edf52b89ff177db3bfcb2c8a9c43d",
"final_url": "https://www.dailyherald.com/news/20180402/ex-youth-minister-gets-7-years-in-prison-for-sexually-abusing-teen"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 862,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "California Court of Appeal, Fourth District affirmed the convictions on January 12, 1994; the decision is cited as controlling precedent on duress by California courts as recently as 2024."
}
],
"scopeNote": "VERIFICATION LIMITATION: the 1994 opinion predates CourtListener's CDN full-text coverage (no local_path available). This record is built from extensive facts and holding recited and relied upon in a 2024 California appellate opinion (People v. Guenther) and independent web-search corroboration of the case facts and affirmance. No source located a reversal. SOURCING CAVEAT: this pre-2000 opinion has no full text available through the court CDN. The conviction and its disposition were established from a later opinion citing this case as controlling precedent, corroborated against independent reporting. That is a weaker tier than the direct full-text reads behind most records here, and a primary-source read should replace it.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-cardenas-los-angeles-california-usa",
"year": 1990,
"place": "Los Angeles County, California, USA",
"lat": 34.0522,
"lng": -118.2437,
"title": "California: self-proclaimed curandero's convictions for sexually assaulting followers under threat of illness and death affirmed",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed curandero (folk healer)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual/healing authority as a curandero to adherents of curanderismo",
"warned a victim she was gravely ill and would die without his 'cure'",
"physically and psychologically weakened victims through controlled medication, diet and sleep deprivation over months",
"isolated victims from outside contact, requiring them to live with him",
"threatened that bad spirits would harm them if they went near windows or left the apartment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Los Angeles County Superior Court, California",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"outcome": "Juan Espinosa Cardenas, a self-proclaimed curandero, was convicted of multiple sex offenses against adult female adherents of curanderismo whom he had persuaded to live with him and submit to sexual 'treatments' under threat of continued illness and death."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "California Court of Appeal, Fourth District",
"stage": "direct appeal, 21 Cal.App.4th 927",
"date": "1994-01-12",
"outcome": "Convictions affirmed; the court held the victims' submission to Cardenas's sexual demands was the product of duress established through psychological and physical deprivation, rejecting his argument that belief in his curandero status meant they had voluntarily submitted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cardenas exploited his followers' belief in his authority as a curandero (folk healer) within the curanderismo tradition, using threatened supernatural and medical consequences (illness, death, malevolent spirits) to coerce sexual submission from adult adherents who had no family relationship to him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22People%20v.%20Cardenas%22%2021%20Cal.App.4th%20927",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Cardenas, 21 Cal. App. 4th 927 (Cal. Ct. App., 4th Dist. 1994).",
"body": "California Court of Appeal opinion affirming Juan Cardenas's convictions for sexually assaulting curanderismo followers through threatened illness, death and supernatural harm; no local_path/CDN copy available (pre-2000), summary reconstructed from a 2024 California appellate opinion citing it as controlling precedent plus independent web corroboration.",
"tier": "secondary-court-citation",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-cited-as-precedent"
},
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2024/08/22/people_v._guenther.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v. Guenther, H049810 (Cal. Ct. App., 6th Dist. Aug. 22, 2024).",
"body": "2024 California appellate opinion citing and reciting the facts of People v. Cardenas (1994) as controlling precedent on duress through psychological and physical deprivation, without indication of reversal.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-citing-precedent"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "California Court of Appeal, Fourth District affirmed the convictions on January 12, 1994; the decision is cited as controlling precedent on duress by California courts as recently as 2024."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22People%20v.%20Cardenas%22%2021%20Cal.App.4th%20927",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-court-citation; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-cited-as-precedent.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2024/08/22/people_v._guenther.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-citing-precedent.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cbd2607b230ff733f9524695ae20bfb32cf9407f282e81d140fe7028625569d3",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2024/08/22/people_v._guenther.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 863,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Minnesota Court of Appeals reversed and remanded for new trial twice (2012, 2014 on remand); Minnesota Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and reinstated the conviction in the final 2015 decision (Wenthe IV), which is the controlling final disposition."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This case had a complex four-round appellate history culminating in the Minnesota Supreme Court's 2015 reinstatement of the conviction (Wenthe IV) over a dissent; that reinstatement, not the intervening Court of Appeals reversals, is the controlling final disposition and satisfies the corpus's stood-on-appeal requirement.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2003-wenthe-saint-paul-minnesota-usa",
"year": 2003,
"place": "Saint Paul, Minnesota, USA",
"lat": 44.9537,
"lng": -93.09,
"title": "Minnesota: Catholic priest's conviction for sexually penetrating a parishioner during spiritual counseling reinstated by state Supreme Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Roman Catholic priest, parish in Saint Paul"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"served as the victim's confessor and spiritual counselor",
"sexual penetration occurred at a meeting held for religious/spiritual counsel",
"charged and convicted under Minnesota's clergy-sexual-conduct statute, Minn. Stat. § 609.344, subd. 1(l)"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ramsey County District Court, Minnesota",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Christopher Thomas Wenthe of clergy sexual conduct for sexually penetrating A.F., a member of his parish who had asked him to serve as her regular confessor and who sought his spiritual counsel, at a 2003 meeting in his church rectory quarters. He was sentenced to 57 months, stayed to 12 months in the workhouse plus 15 years' probation."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Minnesota Court of Appeals",
"stage": "multiple rounds of appeal (Wenthe I-III)",
"outcome": "The Court of Appeals twice reversed the conviction and ordered new trials on evidentiary grounds; the Minnesota Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals on the first round (Wenthe II, 2013) and reinstated review."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Minnesota",
"stage": "final appeal, Wenthe IV, A12-0263",
"date": "2015-06-24",
"outcome": "The Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and reinstated Wenthe's conviction, holding the challenged trial-court evidentiary and instructional decisions were not error, did not affect substantial rights, or were harmless beyond a reasonable doubt."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Wenthe was A.F.'s parish priest and her chosen regular confessor; A.F. had come to him specifically for spiritual counsel regarding personal struggles, and the sexual penetration occurred at a meeting held in that spiritual-counseling capacity, squarely within Minnesota's clergy-sexual-conduct statute which criminalizes sexual contact by clergy during spiritual counseling.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2015/06/24/state_of_minnesota_v._christopher_thomas_wenthe.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Wenthe, 865 N.W.2d 293 (Minn. June 24, 2015) (Wenthe IV).",
"body": "Minnesota Supreme Court opinion reversing the Court of Appeals and reinstating Christopher Wenthe's conviction for clergy sexual conduct, involving sexual penetration of a parishioner during a meeting held for spiritual counseling.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "final-appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Minnesota Court of Appeals reversed and remanded for new trial twice (2012, 2014 on remand); Minnesota Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and reinstated the conviction in the final 2015 decision (Wenthe IV), which is the controlling final disposition."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2015/06/24/state_of_minnesota_v._christopher_thomas_wenthe.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: final-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1b9242b990bef28b57d0d8461b38a8ef0c254f18a9efa0324138275d50ab939e",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2015/06/24/state_of_minnesota_v._christopher_thomas_wenthe.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 864,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions and sentences on March 31, 2026."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Taylor also worked as a public-school music teacher, but the custody arrangement that gave him access to the victim was explicitly premised on his role as the family's pastor, not his teaching position.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-samuel-taylor-rankin-county-mississippi-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Rankin County, Mississippi, USA",
"lat": 32.2841,
"lng": -89.9737,
"title": "Mississippi: longtime family pastor given temporary custody of a boy convicted of sexually battering him",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"longtime pastor to the victim's mother; music teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"victim's mother entrusted temporary custody of her son to her longtime pastor, whom she said she 'could trust wholeheartedly'",
"housed the child in his own home under a pastoral-custodial arrangement"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rankin County Circuit Court, Mississippi",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Samuel Taylor of sexual battery of Brian, a boy whose mother, Hazel, had known Taylor as her pastor since childhood and had given him temporary custody of her son while she found housing."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Mississippi Court of Appeals",
"stage": "direct appeal",
"date": "2026-03-31",
"outcome": "Convictions and sentences affirmed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Hazel entrusted her son to Taylor specifically because he was her longtime pastor whom she trusted 'wholeheartedly'; Taylor was not a relative of Hazel or Brian, and the custodial arrangement arose directly from the pastoral relationship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/03/31/samuel_lamar_taylor_aka_samuel_taylor_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Taylor v. State, No. 2023-KA-00331-COA (Miss. Ct. App. Mar. 31, 2026).",
"body": "Appellate opinion affirming Samuel Taylor's convictions for sexual battery of a child placed in his temporary custody by the child's mother, who had known Taylor as her pastor since her own childhood.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions and sentences on March 31, 2026."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/03/31/samuel_lamar_taylor_aka_samuel_taylor_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "af4845c832e4401c3f7bee62724e0da7429746af0200bc77590fd1e1230bb77a",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2026/03/31/samuel_lamar_taylor_aka_samuel_taylor_v._state_of_mississippi.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 865,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Tenth Circuit affirmed the conviction and sentence on April 21, 2021."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Perrault fled to Morocco for 25 years after a 1992 news investigation began, evading extradition until his eventual federal prosecution and 2019 trial.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1992-perrault-albuquerque-new-mexico-usa",
"year": 1992,
"place": "Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA",
"lat": 35.0844,
"lng": -106.6504,
"title": "New Mexico: Catholic priest convicted decades later of sexually abusing altar servers across three Albuquerque parishes",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest; pastor, St. Bernadette's Church, Albuquerque"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as parish priest with access to altar servers",
"decades-long tenure across multiple parishes (St. Bernadette's, Our Lady of Guadalupe, Our Lady of the Assumption)",
"fled the country for 25 years to Morocco (no US extradition treaty) after a reporter began investigating"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Bernadette's Church, Albuquerque",
"Our Lady of Guadalupe Church, Albuquerque",
"Our Lady of the Assumption Church, Albuquerque"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "United States District Court, District of New Mexico",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Arthur Perrault, a Catholic priest at several Albuquerque parishes from the mid-1960s to 1992, of all seven counts of sexual abuse of altar-server boys, including Doe 1, who became an altar server at St. Bernadette's at age nine when Perrault was the priest there. He was sentenced to 365 months' imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit",
"stage": "direct appeal, No. 19-2184",
"date": "2021-04-21",
"outcome": "Affirmed. The court rejected challenges to jury impartiality, venue and cumulative error."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Perrault was the assigned Catholic priest and pastor at the parishes where his victims served as altar boys; Doe 1 became an altar server under Perrault's direct authority at age nine, and other victims encountered him through his priestly role at two other Albuquerque parishes. No victim was a relative of Perrault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/04/21/united_states_v._perrault.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "United States v. Perrault, 995 F.3d 748 (10th Cir. Apr. 21, 2021).",
"body": "Tenth Circuit opinion affirming Arthur Perrault's conviction on seven counts of sexual abuse of altar-server boys across multiple Albuquerque Catholic parishes, and his 365-month sentence.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "federal-appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Tenth Circuit affirmed the conviction and sentence on April 21, 2021."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/04/21/united_states_v._perrault.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: federal-appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e93fd80174a4ac3c51d34aee7e56b1a91153fbc583984cd4f04579341c2c5b45",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2021/04/21/united_states_v._perrault.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 866,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the judgment of sentence on December 19, 2022."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Haahs was also M.K.'s employer (CEO of his separate company, Tim Haahs & Associates), and the incident occurred in his company office; the record centers the pastoral nexus because the charged conduct itself was carried out under the specific pretext of prayer, not merely because of the employment relationship.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-haahs-montgomery-county-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 40.1215,
"lng": -75.3399,
"title": "Pennsylvania: founder and lead pastor convicted of indecent assault after using an offer to pray for an employee as pretext for assault",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and lead pastor, Calvary Vision Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"invoked his role as pastor, asking 'can I pray for her,' to obtain physical closeness before the assault",
"used the prayer embrace to physically restrain the victim during the assault",
"victim first knew him through his church's monthly prayer meetings before becoming his employee"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Calvary Vision Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Common Pleas, Montgomery County, Pennsylvania",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2021-09-15",
"outcome": "A jury found Timothy H. Haahs, founder and lead pastor of Calvary Vision Church, guilty of indecent assault without consent for an assault on M.K., who first became acquainted with him through his church's monthly prayer meetings before working for his company. He was sentenced to one year of probation."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of Pennsylvania",
"stage": "direct appeal, No. 2358 EDA 2021",
"date": "2022-12-19",
"outcome": "Judgment of sentence affirmed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "M.K. first knew Haahs through his church's prayer meetings; the charged assault itself was initiated under the explicit pretext of pastoral prayer -- Haahs asked M.K. if he could pray for her, led her to a couch, hugged her while praying for her, and used that embrace to restrain her during the assault, making his pastoral role the direct operative mechanism of the assault rather than incidental background.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2022/12/19/com._v._haahs_t..pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commonwealth v. Haahs, 2022 PA Super 217 (Dec. 19, 2022).",
"body": "Pennsylvania Superior Court opinion affirming Timothy Haahs's conviction for indecent assault, detailing how Haahs, founder and lead pastor of Calvary Vision Church, used an offer to pray for the victim as the means of physically restraining and assaulting her.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the judgment of sentence on December 19, 2022."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2022/12/19/com._v._haahs_t..pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eae3030b9e0ba6ed402d0f9ed87b9fb5807d2a6042455e2b646c1fbb67c0e5ce",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2022/12/19/com._v._haahs_t..pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 867,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional accountability report, not a criminal proceeding. Distinct from the existing Georg K. (2015) and Hans U. (2022) individual Aachen/Cologne conviction records, and from the MHG study and Gercke report already in corpus, which cover different dioceses/scopes.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-westpfahl-spilker-wastl-gutachten-bistum-aachen-germany",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Aachen, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 50.7753,
"lng": 6.0839,
"title": "Germany: independent report finds 175 abuse victims and 81 accused clergy in the Diocese of Aachen",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy and diocesan leadership of the Diocese of Aachen, 1965-2019"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly pastoral authority",
"diocesan personnel practices that reassigned or shielded accused clergy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Aachen",
"Westpfahl Spilker Wastl Rechtsanwälte"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent legal report commissioned by the Diocese of Aachen",
"stage": "commissioned independent report",
"date": "2020-11-12",
"outcome": "The Munich law firm Westpfahl Spilker Wastl published its report on 12 November 2020, covering the period 1965-2019. It documented evidence of abuse against 175 victims, most boys aged 8-14, and identified 81 accused clergy including two deacons. The report found personal co-responsibility among several former Aachen bishops and vicars general, including Bishop Klaus Hemmerle and Bishop Heinrich Mussinghoff, for reassigning known abusers."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report documents how parish priests' pastoral authority over children in their care, and the diocese's personnel decisions protecting accused clergy, together enabled and prolonged the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://westpfahl-spilker.de/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Gutachten_Bistum_Aachen.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Westpfahl Spilker Wastl Rechtsanwälte, 'Gutachten zu Fällen sexuellen Missbrauchs Minderjähriger im Bistum Aachen' (12 November 2020). German: the full independent report. English gloss: 'Report on cases of sexual abuse of minors in the Diocese of Aachen.'",
"body": "Primary independent report commissioned by the diocese.",
"tier": "inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bistum-aachen.de/Aufarbeitung/aufarbeitung/gutachten/index.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bistum Aachen, 'Unabhängiges Gutachten.' German: the diocese's own summary page for the report. English gloss: 'Independent report.'",
"body": "Diocesan corroboration and reform-measures follow-up.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://westpfahl-spilker.de/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Gutachten_Bistum_Aachen.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-large",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bistum-aachen.de/Aufarbeitung/aufarbeitung/gutachten/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b212585c95dd8cff09cf57494007e23392d42cbd93abaa49742ff2926b6c5051",
"final_url": "https://www.bistum-aachen.de/Aufarbeitung/aufarbeitung/gutachten/index.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 868,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional accountability report; not a criminal proceeding. Distinct from all other German diocesan reports already in corpus (Cologne/Gercke, Munich/Ratzinger, MHG national study).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-missbrauchsgutachten-bistum-muenster-germany",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Münster, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 51.9607,
"lng": 7.6261,
"title": "Germany: Münster diocese report finds 196 accused clergy and 610 victims, faults four successive bishops",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy and diocesan bishops of the Diocese of Münster, 1945-present"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly pastoral authority",
"repeated diocesan reassignment of convicted or accused clergy into further pastoral roles"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Münster",
"University of Münster (Interdisziplinäre Forschungsstelle)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent academic study commissioned by the Diocese of Münster",
"stage": "commissioned independent report",
"outcome": "The study identified 196 accused clergy (183 priests, one deacon, twelve religious brothers) — 4.17% of all priests in the diocese over the study period — and documented 610 victims, with researchers estimating the true figure eight to ten times higher. It found that bishops Michael Keller (1947-1961), Joseph Höffner (1962-1969), Heinrich Tenhumberg (1969-1979) and Reinhard Lettmann (1980-2008) repeatedly returned convicted or accused clergy to pastoral ministry, enabling further offences."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report documents how priestly pastoral authority over parishioners and altar servers, combined with successive bishops' decisions to return known abusers to ministry, structurally enabled repeat offending across decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/missbrauchs-gutachten-fuer-das-bistum-muenster-bischoefe-haben-versagt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kirche+Leben, 'Missbrauchs-Gutachten für das Bistum Münster: Bischöfe haben versagt.' German: reports the finding that four successive bishops failed. English gloss: 'Abuse report for the Diocese of Münster: bishops failed.'",
"body": "Primary Catholic-press report on the study's release and findings.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bistum-muenster.de/sexueller_missbrauch/untersuchung_des_sexuellen_missbrauchs_im_bistum_muenster",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bistum Münster, 'Untersuchung des sexuellen Missbrauchs im Bistum Münster.' German: the diocese's own page on the investigation. English gloss: 'Investigation of sexual abuse in the Diocese of Münster.'",
"body": "Diocesan corroboration.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/missbrauchs-gutachten-fuer-das-bistum-muenster-bischoefe-haben-versagt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24162b42ab27b55dddee8740a75ab2522d7ae2a9250fa4c3d630558d84f4e441",
"final_url": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/missbrauchs-gutachten-fuer-das-bistum-muenster-bischoefe-haben-versagt"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bistum-muenster.de/sexueller_missbrauch/untersuchung_des_sexuellen_missbrauchs_im_bistum_muenster",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "00d4e0bee408633c596c2a23fcef4e65285916b66c5395feff4a5be1dd4a5232",
"final_url": "https://www.bistum-muenster.de/sexueller_missbrauch/untersuchung_des_sexuellen_missbrauchs_im_bistum_muenster"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 869,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional accountability report; not a criminal proceeding. The study's September 2022 interim findings directly precipitated Bishop Franz-Josef Bode's early resignation in March 2023 — a rare case where an accountability report changed a sitting bishop's tenure, stated because it is a documented consequence, not asserted as the sole cause.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-missbrauchsstudie-bistum-osnabrueck-germany",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Osnabrück, Lower Saxony, Germany",
"lat": 52.2799,
"lng": 8.0472,
"title": "Germany: Osnabrück diocese study finds over 400 victims, contributes to bishop's early resignation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy and diocesan leadership of the Diocese of Osnabrück, 1945-present"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly and diaconal pastoral authority",
"diocesan leadership's documented duty violations in handling allegations"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Osnabrück"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent academic study commissioned by the Diocese of Osnabrück",
"stage": "commissioned independent report, final report following a September 2022 interim report",
"outcome": "Researchers identified 122 priests and deacons accused of violence against 349 documented victims from 1945 to the present, with concrete indications of at least 60 further victims, giving a confirmed minimum of over 400. The final report confirmed the interim report's September 2022 finding of duty violations by diocesan leadership. Bishop Franz-Josef Bode resigned early in March 2023, citing the findings among his reasons."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The study documents how clergy's pastoral authority over parishioners, combined with diocesan leadership's own failures in responding to allegations, enabled sustained harm across the diocese.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/sexueller-missbrauch-bistum-osnabrueck-studie-untersuchung-ergebnisse-sexualisierte-gewalt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kirche+Leben, report on the Osnabrück abuse study's final results. German: 'Mehr als 400 Missbrauchs-Betroffene im Bistum Osnabrück.' English gloss: 'More than 400 abuse victims in the Diocese of Osnabrück.'",
"body": "Primary Catholic-press report on the study's findings.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/40890-uni-legt-zwischenbericht-zu-missbrauch-im-bistum-osnabrueck-vor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de, 'Uni legt Zwischenbericht zu Missbrauch im Bistum Osnabrück vor.' German: reports the September 2022 interim report and its finding of leadership duty violations. English gloss: 'University presents interim report on abuse in the Diocese of Osnabrück.'",
"body": "Corroborating report on the interim findings that preceded Bishop Bode's resignation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/sexueller-missbrauch-bistum-osnabrueck-studie-untersuchung-ergebnisse-sexualisierte-gewalt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c4ecc9cd2825e456a8c9b78904539afefbfc3406a0fde0946b5a88bf3cc24e44",
"final_url": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/sexueller-missbrauch-bistum-osnabrueck-studie-untersuchung-ergebnisse-sexualisierte-gewalt"
},
{
"source": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/40890-uni-legt-zwischenbericht-zu-missbrauch-im-bistum-osnabrueck-vor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "925427029e775b838a08768ea4a121b4f90ac7adc11eb5ba7ed5aeb4e920c4db",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/40890-uni-legt-zwischenbericht-zu-missbrauch-im-bistum-osnabrueck-vor"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 870,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding, not a single criminal proceeding. Covers physical and sexual violence against choirboys at the Regensburger Domspatzen boarding school; the 49 identified likely perpetrators include clergy, lay teachers and older pupils, and the record states this mix rather than asserting all 49 held clerical authority. Distinct from any individual Regensburg conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-domspatzen-weber-report-regensburg-germany",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Regensburg, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 49.0134,
"lng": 12.1016,
"title": "Germany: independent investigator finds up to 700 abuse victims among Regensburg Domspatzen choirboys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy, choir directors and educational staff of the Regensburger Domspatzen, 1945-2015"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the boarding-school choir's closed residential structure under clerical and quasi-clerical authority",
"diocesan and choir leadership's failure to act on known abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Regensburg",
"Regensburger Domspatzen"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent investigation commissioned by the Diocese of Regensburg",
"stage": "commissioned independent report",
"date": "2017-07-18",
"outcome": "Special investigator Ulrich Weber presented his final report on 18 July 2017 after two years' work. He documented 547 identified victims of physical or sexual violence among the Domspatzen choirboys between 1945 and 2015, estimating a further undocumented ~700, with 500 total having suffered physical violence and 67 sexual violence. Of 49 perpetrators assessed as 'highly plausible,' 9 were found to have committed sexual abuse. The diocese paid over 4.3 million euros in compensation, more than 3.2 million of it to Domspatzen victims specifically."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report documents how the choir school's closed residential structure, run under clerical and choir-director authority that controlled boys' daily lives, enabled both physical and sexual abuse to continue for decades undetected.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/regensburger-domspatzen-bis-zu-700-missbrauchsopfer-49-beschuldigte",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kirche+Leben, 'Regensburger Domspatzen: Bis zu 700 Missbrauchsopfer, 49 Beschuldigte.' German: reports Weber's estimate of up to 700 victims and 49 identified perpetrators. English gloss: 'Regensburg Domspatzen: up to 700 abuse victims, 49 accused.'",
"body": "Primary Catholic-press report on the Weber report's release.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/139201/12-10-2016/bistum-regensburg-legt-bericht-zu-domspatzen-missbrauchsskandal-vor",
"archive": "",
"citation": "evangelisch.de, report on the Diocese of Regensburg's Domspatzen abuse investigation. German: covers the scope and process of the investigation. English gloss: 'Diocese of Regensburg presents report on the Domspatzen abuse scandal.'",
"body": "Corroborating national-press account.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/regensburger-domspatzen-bis-zu-700-missbrauchsopfer-49-beschuldigte",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d85222dbc0a5364413c74779ea271f1ad35c00416d3037c98885167aebd2b9c6",
"final_url": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/regensburger-domspatzen-bis-zu-700-missbrauchsopfer-49-beschuldigte"
},
{
"source": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/139201/12-10-2016/bistum-regensburg-legt-bericht-zu-domspatzen-missbrauchsskandal-vor",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "06011ccc38dfa5d5b6f2d1dfef108318ec9886dde19b22671270d4f143ed39cb",
"final_url": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/139201/12-10-2016/bistum-regensburg-legt-bericht-zu-domspatzen-missbrauchsskandal-vor"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 871,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice)",
"outcome": "sentence reduced from 5 years to 4 years 6 months, conviction affirmed"
}
],
"scopeNote": "Group/sect name not identified in available sourcing; the prosecution's own framing (\"seine Stellung als angeblicher spiritueller Führer genutzt\" — used his position as self-proclaimed spiritual leader) is the stated basis for the nexus. Victims were adult members recruited into sexual acts through his claimed spiritual authority over the group, not family members.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-hamburg-sektenfuehrer-spiritual-leader-germany",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Hamburg, Germany",
"lat": 53.5511,
"lng": 9.9937,
"title": "Germany: Hamburg sect leader's conviction for sexually coercing young female members affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-messianic-communal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed spiritual leader of a sect-like association ('sektenähnliche Vereinigung')"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"his claimed status as spiritual leader of the group, used to approach and pressure young female members"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht Hamburg, Germany",
"stage": "trial conviction; appeal to Bundesgerichtshof",
"outcome": "Landgericht Hamburg convicted the defendant in July 2025 of sexual assault in six cases and intentional bodily harm, sentencing him to five years. The Bundesgerichtshof reduced the sentence to four years six months and the conviction became final. The prosecution's case was that between 2017 and 2020, as leader of a sect-like association, he approached several young female members and used his position as their self-proclaimed spiritual leader to bring about sexual acts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant's authority as the group's self-proclaimed spiritual leader over young female members was, per the prosecution's own charging theory, the means by which he obtained the sexual acts.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.berliner-sonntagsblatt.de/Deutschland/BGH-Urteil-in-Hamburg-zu-sexuellen-Uebergriffen-in-sektenaehnlicher-Vereinigung-rechtskraeftig-360901.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Berliner Sonntagsblatt, 'BGH: Urteil in Hamburg zu sexuellen Übergriffen in sektenähnlicher Vereinigung rechtskräftig.' German: reports the BGH's sentence reduction and finality. English gloss: 'Federal Court of Justice: Hamburg verdict on sexual assaults in sect-like association becomes final.'",
"body": "Primary report on the BGH appellate disposition.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://hamburg.t-online.de/region/hamburg/id_100824544/hamburg-mutmasslicher-sektenchef-muss-wegen-sexueller-uebergriffe-in-haft.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "t-online, 'Hamburg: Mutmaßlicher Sektenchef muss wegen sexueller Übergriffe in Haft.' German: reports the Landgericht Hamburg trial verdict and prosecution's spiritual-authority framing. English gloss: 'Hamburg: alleged sect leader must go to prison for sexual assaults.'",
"body": "Trial-court report stating the prosecution's spiritual-authority theory.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice)",
"outcome": "sentence reduced from 5 years to 4 years 6 months, conviction affirmed"
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.berliner-sonntagsblatt.de/Deutschland/BGH-Urteil-in-Hamburg-zu-sexuellen-Uebergriffen-in-sektenaehnlicher-Vereinigung-rechtskraeftig-360901.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "688b25935310e734f4137fbb5e7ae16efab4973a8a4b5e1c9116e8d1babd9b93",
"final_url": "https://www.berliner-sonntagsblatt.de/Deutschland/BGH-Urteil-in-Hamburg-zu-sexuellen-Uebergriffen-in-sektenaehnlicher-Vereinigung-rechtskraeftig-360901.html"
},
{
"source": "https://hamburg.t-online.de/region/hamburg/id_100824544/hamburg-mutmasslicher-sektenchef-muss-wegen-sexueller-uebergriffe-in-haft.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f9d4d92fafc976893655d2a74d55fe84a16f4248b654b05fed3b23b7e48750b",
"final_url": "https://hamburg.t-online.de/region/hamburg/id_100824544/hamburg-mutmasslicher-sektenchef-muss-wegen-sexueller-uebergriffe-in-haft.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 872,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Deacon (Diakon) is a formally ordained office in the Evangelical Church; the church district itself filed the charges. Defendant confessed and acknowledged victims' civil damages claims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-bielefeld-deacon-evangelical-church-germany",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Bielefeld, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 52.0302,
"lng": 8.5325,
"title": "Germany: former Bielefeld deacon convicted of abusing persons in his church care, confession entered",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ordained deacon, Evangelical Church district of Bielefeld"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral-diaconal authority over persons formally in his church care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Evangelischer Kirchenkreis Bielefeld"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Amtsgericht Bielefeld, Germany",
"stage": "trial conviction on confession",
"date": "2025-06-04",
"outcome": "The Bielefeld district court sentenced the former deacon to 23 months' imprisonment, suspended, plus a 6,000-euro fine, on charges of sexual abuse of persons in his care (seven counts, 2005-2011) and possession of child sexual abuse material. The defendant confessed and acknowledged the victims' civil damages claims. The Evangelical Church district of Bielefeld had itself filed the charges after allegations surfaced in 2021, and later commissioned an academic study of the case."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The deacon's formally ordained pastoral office gave him custodial-style authority over persons in the congregation's care, which the charged offence (sexual abuse of a person in one's care, StGB §174) directly names as its legal basis.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/244042/04-06-2025/missbrauch-bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-frueheren-diakon-aus-bielefeld",
"archive": "",
"citation": "evangelisch.de, 'Missbrauch: Bewährungsstrafe für früheren Diakon aus Bielefeld.' German: reports the suspended sentence, confession and fine. English gloss: 'Abuse: suspended sentence for former Bielefeld deacon.'",
"body": "Primary press report on the verdict.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-frueheren-diakon-aus-bielefeld",
"archive": "",
"citation": "DOMRADIO.DE, corroborating report on the Bielefeld deacon verdict. German: confirms sentence terms and church district's role in filing charges. English gloss: same event.",
"body": "Corroborating Catholic-broadcaster report on a Protestant case.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/244042/04-06-2025/missbrauch-bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-frueheren-diakon-aus-bielefeld",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "da2201f8f23f0c6076928a9714e9bb4086f186090f2248db28e3a7dd347edd04",
"final_url": "https://www.evangelisch.de/inhalte/244042/04-06-2025/missbrauch-bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-frueheren-diakon-aus-bielefeld"
},
{
"source": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-frueheren-diakon-aus-bielefeld",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e6852ff1b037029d7d43fa28f110bcaaa37a157701d8af651bfbe5bd9e2d4eb3",
"final_url": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-frueheren-diakon-aus-bielefeld"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 873,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "Landgericht Memmingen (Berufung)",
"outcome": "Amtsgericht conviction upheld, final and binding, December 2024"
}
],
"scopeNote": "The Maristen order runs the Maristenkolleg as a Catholic boarding/day school; the defendant's authority was as ordained order-brother AND boarding-school director for 20 years, a dual clerical-and-institutional nexus over the same pupils. Distinct from every other German record in corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-mindelheim-marist-brother-boarding-school-germany",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Mindelheim, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 48.0431,
"lng": 10.4897,
"title": "Germany: former Marist brother and boarding-school director convicted of abusing pupils, appeal fails",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Marist religious brother; director of the Maristenkolleg Mindelheim boarding school for 20 years to 2007"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-order authority combined with boarding-school directorship over resident pupils"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Maristenkolleg Mindelheim",
"Marist Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Amtsgericht Memmingen, Germany; affirmed on appeal by Landgericht Memmingen",
"stage": "trial conviction, appeal dismissed, final",
"outcome": "The Memmingen district court convicted the then-64-year-old former Marist brother and longtime boarding-school director of sexual coercion and sexual abuse of children in four cases (acquitting on one further severe-abuse count as unproven), sentencing him to one year eight months' imprisonment, suspended. He had previously received suspended sentences in 2008 and 2011 for abusing pupils. The Landgericht Memmingen upheld the conviction on appeal in December 2024, making it final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As both an ordained order-brother and the boarding school's director for two decades, the defendant held combined clerical and custodial authority over resident pupils who lived under his day-to-day control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/60435-missbrauchsprozess-gegen-ex-ordensmann-urteil-rechtskraeftig",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de, 'Missbrauchsprozess gegen Ex-Ordensmann – Urteil rechtskräftig.' German: reports the December 2024 appellate affirmance making the conviction final. English gloss: 'Abuse trial against ex-order-member — verdict final.'",
"body": "Primary report confirming appellate finality.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justiz.bayern.de/gerichte-und-behoerden/landgericht/memmingen/presse/2025/2.php",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Landgericht Memmingen press release, 'Urteil gegen ehem. Leiter des Maristenkollegs rechtskräftig.' German: the court's own press statement confirming finality. English gloss: 'Verdict against former head of the Maristenkolleg final.'",
"body": "Primary court source confirming the January 2023 trial sentence and its appellate history.",
"tier": "legal-news-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "Landgericht Memmingen (Berufung)",
"outcome": "Amtsgericht conviction upheld, final and binding, December 2024"
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/60435-missbrauchsprozess-gegen-ex-ordensmann-urteil-rechtskraeftig",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "297ad1d426c1764d05b9da1cfa74f59b74c250bab258f39b707d0c3bcda364fa",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/60435-missbrauchsprozess-gegen-ex-ordensmann-urteil-rechtskraeftig"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justiz.bayern.de/gerichte-und-behoerden/landgericht/memmingen/presse/2025/2.php",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-news-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6559d88a04bdbdb93a6dd79b0001e12c6fcf55a0541bbab5d75e17eb87a1eeaf",
"final_url": "https://www.justiz.bayern.de/gerichte-und-behoerden/landgericht/memmingen/presse/2025/2.php"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 874,
"aliases": [
"ForuM-Studie"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Major national official finding for German Protestantism, structurally parallel to the Catholic MHG study already in corpus. Covers the EKD and its diaconal services, 1946-2020. No individual perpetrator named in this record; it documents the systemic finding itself.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-forum-studie-ekd-germany",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Hanover, Lower Saxony, Germany",
"lat": 52.3759,
"lng": 9.732,
"title": "Germany: ForuM study finds 1,259 accused and 2,225 affected in the Evangelical Church and diaconal services",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy, diaconal staff and leadership of the Evangelical Church in Germany (EKD) and its regional churches, 1946-2020"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and diaconal-caregiving authority over congregants, confirmands and residents in church-run institutions",
"documented institutional failure to hear, process or act on disclosures"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Evangelische Kirche in Deutschland (EKD)",
"Diakonie Deutschland",
"ForuM-Verbund"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent research consortium (ForuM-Verbund) commissioned by the EKD",
"stage": "commissioned independent study",
"date": "2024-01-25",
"outcome": "Published 25 January 2024 in Hanover, the study — begun in 2020 — examined sexualised violence against minors across the EKD and diaconal services from 1 January 1946 to 31 December 2020. Researchers identified at least 1,259 accused perpetrators, including 511 clergy, and at least 2,225 affected individuals. It found decades of failure at every level: victims not heard, allegations not processed, perpetrators protected, and no institutional accountability taken. In November 2024 the EKD Synod adopted disciplinary-law reform giving affected persons more rights and a 12-point action plan."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The study documents that clergy and diaconal caregivers' pastoral authority over congregants and residents was the structural condition that made abuse possible, compounded by the church's own institutional failure to act on disclosures.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ekd.de/aufarbeitungsstudie-forum-82255.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Evangelische Kirche in Deutschland, 'Aufarbeitungsstudie ForuM.' German: the EKD's own page on the study and its findings. English gloss: 'Reckoning study ForuM.'",
"body": "Primary institutional source publishing the study's existence and headline findings.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11374850/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sexual abuse in the area of responsibility of the Protestant Church: some results from a subproject of the ForuM study' (peer-reviewed subproject publication, 2024).",
"body": "Peer-reviewed academic publication of a ForuM subproject's findings, corroborating the headline figures.",
"tier": "academic-peer-reviewed",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sonntagsblatt.de/artikel/kirche/sexualisierte-gewalt-der-evangelischen-kirche-das-sind-die-zentralen-ergebnisse-der",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sonntagsblatt, 'Sexualisierte Gewalt in der evangelischen Kirche: Das sind die zentralen Ergebnisse der neuen Studie.' German: summarises the central findings. English gloss: 'Sexualised violence in the Protestant church: these are the central findings of the new study.'",
"body": "Corroborating press summary of the study's release.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ekd.de/aufarbeitungsstudie-forum-82255.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5e04a58086a02d25cfdfb5cf5aa472c2fc260b9f3d6c5abcfcdf42c9ca430305",
"final_url": "https://www.ekd.de/aufarbeitungsstudie-forum-82255.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11374850/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: academic-peer-reviewed; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3859ac7c2c2ad7922b11e091601215e6e50597229396915380d1548b2c4188d5",
"final_url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11374850/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sonntagsblatt.de/artikel/kirche/sexualisierte-gewalt-der-evangelischen-kirche-das-sind-die-zentralen-ergebnisse-der",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f13a2fd08be782becee68c0916c10ac105c39011c820ffa3b0ddee57bc2a7deb",
"final_url": "https://www.sonntagsblatt.de/artikel/kirche/sexualisierte-gewalt-der-evangelischen-kirche-das-sind-die-zentralen-ergebnisse-der"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 875,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Ongoing standing institutional body (2010-present), not a single report; entered as an institutional-event official-finding record documenting its cumulative caseload. Distinct from the Kremsmünster/Mandorfer individual conviction already in corpus, which the Commission's caseload includes as one of thousands of cases.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-klasnic-kommission-austria",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Vienna, Austria",
"lat": 48.2082,
"lng": 16.3738,
"title": "Austria: Klasnic Commission establishes independent victim-protection process for church abuse claims",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy, religious and lay workers of the Catholic Church in Austria, across all dioceses"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly and religious pastoral authority",
"residential-institution authority in church-run homes and schools"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Unabhängige Opferschutzanwaltschaft",
"Unabhängige Opferschutzkommission (Klasnic-Kommission)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent victim-protection body established at the request of the Archdiocese of Vienna",
"stage": "standing independent commission, ongoing since founding",
"outcome": "Cardinal Christoph Schönborn asked former Styrian governor Waltraud Klasnic in April 2010 to establish an independent victim-protection advocacy body. The resulting Independent Victim Protection Commission, staffed by eight volunteer experts from justice, medicine, psychology and media, adjudicates claims via a four-stage process. As of 31 May 2025 it had decided 3,492 cases, ruling in victims' favour in 3,214 (92.3%) — 29% of all incidents involved sexual abuse, the remainder physical or psychological violence — and awarded a cumulative 37.7 million euros in financial assistance and therapy funding. The Catholic Church in Austria has accepted and implemented all of the Commission's decisions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Commission's own caseload documents that the clergy, religious and lay workers it adjudicates against held pastoral or residential-institutional authority over the great majority of claimants at the time of the alleged abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.katholisch.at/aktuelles/155625/klasnic-in-16-jahren-opferschutz-mit-1.000-betroffenen-gesprochen",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.at, 'Klasnic: In 16 Jahren Opferschutz mit 1.000 Betroffenen gesprochen.' German: reports cumulative caseload and outcome statistics as of 2025. English gloss: 'Klasnic: in 16 years of victim protection, spoken with 1,000 affected persons.'",
"body": "Primary Catholic-press report with current cumulative figures.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ombudsstellen.at/opferschutzkommission",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Unabhängige Opferschutzanwältin und Opferschutzkommission, official page. German: the Commission's own institutional description and process. English gloss: 'Independent Victim Protection Advocate and Victim Protection Commission.'",
"body": "Primary institutional source describing the four-stage process and founding.",
"tier": "official-institutional",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.katholisch.at/aktuelles/155625/klasnic-in-16-jahren-opferschutz-mit-1.000-betroffenen-gesprochen",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c75baa288a23f4673132a874be0633dd424cd8539ddec2071cdf728faf46523c",
"final_url": "https://www.katholisch.at/aktuelles/155625/klasnic-in-16-jahren-opferschutz-mit-1.000-betroffenen-gesprochen"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ombudsstellen.at/opferschutzkommission",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-institutional; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c315d1565ad3fe0f4e04f9e79fb29db0bee67cd7fc85b2db9ef2ae63320f56a1",
"final_url": "https://www.ombudsstellen.at/opferschutzkommission"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 876,
"aliases": [
"UZH Pilotstudie"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Major national official finding, structurally parallel to the German MHG study and the Dutch Deetman Report, both already in corpus. Covers the Swiss Catholic Church from the mid-20th century to 2023. No individual perpetrator named in this record; documents the systemic finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-uzh-pilotstudie-katholische-kirche-switzerland",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Zurich, Switzerland",
"lat": 47.3769,
"lng": 8.5417,
"title": "Switzerland: University of Zurich pilot study finds 1,002 cases of abuse in the Catholic Church since 1950",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy and religious of the Roman Catholic Church in Switzerland, mid-20th century to 2023"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly and religious pastoral authority",
"diocesan archival practices that the study found had concealed cases prior to the Church opening its secret archives for the research"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Historisches Seminar, Universität Zürich",
"Swiss Bishops' Conference"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent academic pilot study commissioned in 2022, University of Zurich",
"stage": "commissioned independent pilot report",
"date": "2023-09-12",
"outcome": "A team from the University of Zurich's Historical Seminar, led by Professors Monika Dommann and Marietta Meier, presented its final report on 12 September 2023 at a press conference in Zurich alongside Catholic Church representatives. The one-year pilot project, for which the church opened previously secret archives to researchers, identified 1,002 cases, 510 accused and 921 affected persons, spanning problematic boundary violations to severe, sustained systematic abuse. The study became UZH's most-covered press release of 2023."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The pilot study documents that priestly and religious authority over parishioners and institutional wards was the structural condition enabling the abuse it catalogued, and that church archival control had itself obstructed earlier discovery.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://hist.uzh.ch/de/ueberuns/news/Pilotstudie-zum-sexuellen-Missbrauch-in-der-katholischen-Kirche-in-der-Schweiz-an-der-Spitze-der-Top-Ten-Medienmitteilungen-der-UZH-2023.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Historisches Seminar, Universität Zürich, press release on the pilot study. German: summarises the study's scope, method and headline figures. English gloss: 'Pilot study on sexual abuse in the Catholic Church in Switzerland tops UZH's 2023 press releases.'",
"body": "Primary institutional source from the researching university.",
"tier": "academic-peer-reviewed",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/46983-studie-1002-missbrauchsfaelle-in-katholischer-kirche-der-schweiz",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de, 'Studie: 1.002 Missbrauchsfälle in katholischer Kirche der Schweiz.' German: reports the headline case, accused and victim figures. English gloss: 'Study: 1,002 abuse cases in the Catholic Church of Switzerland.'",
"body": "Corroborating press report on the study's release.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "background"
},
{
"link": "https://www.srf.ch/kultur/gesellschaft-religion/neue-pilotstudie-missbrauch-in-roemisch-katholischen-kirche-studie-zeigt-ausmass",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SRF, 'Neue Pilotstudie: Missbrauch in römisch-katholischer Kirche — Studie zeigt Ausmass.' German: national broadcaster's report on the study's scale. English gloss: 'New pilot study: abuse in the Roman Catholic Church — study shows the scale.'",
"body": "Corroborating national-broadcaster report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://hist.uzh.ch/de/ueberuns/news/Pilotstudie-zum-sexuellen-Missbrauch-in-der-katholischen-Kirche-in-der-Schweiz-an-der-Spitze-der-Top-Ten-Medienmitteilungen-der-UZH-2023.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: academic-peer-reviewed; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9673ceeba7af99e32ef333a0742efedac882ad575fb246f46af076fe48505cbe",
"final_url": "https://hist.uzh.ch/de/ueberuns/news/Pilotstudie-zum-sexuellen-Missbrauch-in-der-katholischen-Kirche-in-der-Schweiz-an-der-Spitze-der-Top-Ten-Medienmitteilungen-der-UZH-2023.html"
},
{
"source": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/46983-studie-1002-missbrauchsfaelle-in-katholischer-kirche-der-schweiz",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "86031200b39cef7a347410d337f8a43abf3917c81651ae88903611cf42bdcf97",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/46983-studie-1002-missbrauchsfaelle-in-katholischer-kirche-der-schweiz"
},
{
"source": "https://www.srf.ch/kultur/gesellschaft-religion/neue-pilotstudie-missbrauch-in-roemisch-katholischen-kirche-studie-zeigt-ausmass",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 877,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Ticino/Lugano diocese, distinct parish priest from the already-in-corpus 2021-lugano-priest-spiritual-director-switzerland record and from the 2025-ascona-school-chaplain-prayer-trips-switzerland record (verified NOT the same defendant: different role, different victim count, different court date). Nine victims across 2015-2023, four of them minors.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-lugano-cantonal-court-priest-nine-victims-switzerland",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Lugano, Ticino, Switzerland",
"lat": 46.0037,
"lng": 8.9511,
"title": "Switzerland: Ticino priest convicted of sexually coercing nine parishioners, four of them minors",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest, Diocese of Lugano"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly pastoral authority over parishioners, including minors under his religious instruction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lugano"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunale penale cantonale, Lugano, Switzerland",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2025-08-14",
"outcome": "The Ticino cantonal criminal court in Lugano sentenced the priest to 18 months' imprisonment, suspended, for multiple counts of sexual coercion and sexual acts with minors. The offences occurred between 2015 and 2023 against at least nine victims, four of them minors. The court imposed a lifetime professional ban on contact with minors and ordered outpatient therapy."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest's pastoral authority over parishioners in his care, including minors under his religious instruction, was the relationship in which the sustained pattern of coercion occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rts.ch/info/regions/autres-cantons/2025/article/proces-au-tessin-ex-pretre-accuse-d-abus-sexuels-sur-mineurs-et-adultes-28967304.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RTS, 'Un prêtre condamné à un an et demi de prison avec sursis au Tessin pour abus sexuels.' French: reports the 18-month suspended sentence, nine victims, lifetime ban. English gloss: 'A priest sentenced to eighteen months' suspended prison in Ticino for sexual abuse.'",
"body": "Primary national-broadcaster report on the verdict.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rts.ch/info/regions/autres-cantons/2025/article/proces-au-tessin-ex-pretre-accuse-d-abus-sexuels-sur-mineurs-et-adultes-28967304.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e74e4782507a351e85ea41d8ea02fcc7c9627bd8630844798220837f496290e9",
"final_url": "https://www.rts.ch/info/regions/autres-cantons/2025/article/proces-au-tessin-ex-pretre-accuse-d-abus-sexuels-sur-mineurs-et-adultes-28967304.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 878,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "CHARGED ONLY — trial scheduled but not yet held as of the most recent source (15 July 2026). Entered at charged status per corpus convention; must not be represented as a conviction. Do not upgrade without a verdict.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-vaud-priest-trial-pending-switzerland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Vaud, Switzerland",
"lat": 46.5197,
"lng": 6.6323,
"title": "Switzerland: Vaud priest to stand trial for alleged abuse of a 14-year-old parishioner",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest, Diocese of Lausanne, Geneva and Fribourg"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly pastoral authority over a parishioner under his religious instruction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lausanne, Geneva and Fribourg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal correctionnel, Vaud, Switzerland",
"stage": "charged; referred to correctional trial",
"outcome": "Following a complaint filed by the alleged victim's father in 2024, a priest of the Diocese of Lausanne, Geneva and Fribourg active in a Vaud parish was referred to trial for alleged sexual acts against a 14-year-old girl, described as repeated touching of her chest. As of the most recent report (15 July 2026) the trial had not yet been held."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The alleged victim was a parishioner under the priest's religious instruction at the time of the alleged acts.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://cath.ch/newsf/le-pretre-vaudois-soupconne-dabus-sur-mineurs-passera-en-correctionnel-2026-07-15",
"archive": "",
"citation": "cath.ch, 'Le prêtre vaudois soupçonné d'abus sur mineurs passera en correctionnel' (15 July 2026). French: reports referral to correctional trial. English gloss: 'The Vaud priest suspected of abuse of minors will go to correctional trial.'",
"body": "Most recent primary report confirming charged-not-yet-tried status.",
"tier": "religious-affiliated-press",
"kind": "background"
},
{
"link": "https://www.blick.ch/fr/suisse/romande/vaud-un-pretre-sera-juge-pour-abus-sur-mineur-id21671354.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Blick, 'Vaud: Un prêtre sera jugé pour abus sur mineur.' French: reports the referral to trial and the diocese's abuse caseload context (36 of 370 priests). English gloss: 'Vaud: a priest will be tried for abuse of a minor.'",
"body": "Corroborating national-press report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Following a complaint filed by the alleged victim's father in 2024, a priest of the Diocese of Lausanne, Geneva and Fribourg active in a Vaud parish was referred to trial for alleged sexual acts against a 14-year-old girl, described as repeated touching of her chest. As of the most recent report (15 July 2026) the trial had not yet been held.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://cath.ch/newsf/le-pretre-vaudois-soupconne-dabus-sur-mineurs-passera-en-correctionnel-2026-07-15",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-affiliated-press; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "50ff6cd93e4e9ce29bd10fa0c0fb74c10b34e677f6083ef07c33510fdd43580d",
"final_url": "https://cath.ch/newsf/le-pretre-vaudois-soupconne-dabus-sur-mineurs-passera-en-correctionnel-2026-07-15"
},
{
"source": "https://www.blick.ch/fr/suisse/romande/vaud-un-pretre-sera-juge-pour-abus-sur-mineur-id21671354.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d69dee6589cd2e803bf67dce8d1479d65b03bbd11c6077ab9692370b9e899e6c",
"final_url": "https://www.blick.ch/fr/suisse/romande/vaud-un-pretre-sera-juge-pour-abus-sur-mineur-id21671354.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 879,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "First Hindu-tradition record in the Netherlands/Low Countries lane. The victim sought the priest's help for health complaints and was told during a ritual not to say 'no' — the coercion is explicitly ritual-embedded per the court's own facts, not incidental to a healing session.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-the-hague-hindu-priest-healing-ritual-netherlands",
"year": 2023,
"place": "The Hague, Netherlands",
"lat": 52.0705,
"lng": 4.3007,
"title": "Netherlands: Hindu priest convicted of sexually abusing a woman during a healing ritual",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Hindu priest offering ritual healing"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ritual healing authority; explicit instruction to the victim during the ritual not to refuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rechtbank Den Haag, Netherlands",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"outcome": "The Hague district court sentenced the 77-year-old priest to 18 months' imprisonment, six of them suspended, for sexually abusing a woman during a ritual in her home in May 2020. The woman had sought his help for health complaints. During the second treatment visit he touched her breasts and penetrated her, telling her not to refuse. He also received a three-year professional ban and was ordered to pay 7,500 euros in damages."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim sought the priest's help specifically for his claimed ritual-healing power, and the abuse occurred during the ritual itself, with the priest explicitly invoking that authority to forbid her refusal.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nos.nl/l/2472226",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NOS, 'Hindoepriester (77) de cel in voor misbruik vrouw bij ritueel.' Dutch: reports the sentence, ritual context and professional ban. English gloss: 'Hindu priest (77) jailed for abusing woman during ritual.'",
"body": "Primary national-broadcaster report on the verdict.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.omroepwest.nl/nieuws/4711127/priester-misbruikt-vrouw-bij-ritueel-en-wordt-veroordeeld",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Omroep West, 'Priester misbruikt vrouw bij ritueel en wordt veroordeeld.' Dutch: regional-broadcaster report with fuller facts including the sentence and damages. English gloss: 'Priest abuses woman during ritual and is convicted.'",
"body": "Corroborating regional-press report with fuller factual detail.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nos.nl/l/2472226",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "209f545f1fba7cdf550a1bf15d7b3783015f9d8ddb721bbca9073b5d7c12461e",
"final_url": "https://nos.nl/artikel/2472226-hindoepriester-77-de-cel-in-voor-misbruik-vrouw-bij-ritueel"
},
{
"source": "https://www.omroepwest.nl/nieuws/4711127/priester-misbruikt-vrouw-bij-ritueel-en-wordt-veroordeeld",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7e76d78d0242034c007fb713e5509306305f086b54140a908255c465dc6efd22",
"final_url": "https://www.omroepwest.nl/nieuws/4711127/priester-misbruikt-vrouw-bij-ritueel-en-wordt-veroordeeld"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 880,
"aliases": [
"Operatie Kelk parlementaire onderzoekscommissie",
"Commission Godvergeten"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Major official finding at the national-parliament tier — the second such Belgian commission (the first, 2010-2011, is already reflected via existing individual Belgian records). Prompted by the 'Godvergeten' documentary series. Distinct from Operation Kelk itself (the 2010 police investigation) and from the February 2025 decision not to prosecute the Kelk suspects, which the record states as context but does not conflate with this commission's own findings.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-belgian-parliamentary-commission-church-abuse",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Brussels, Belgium",
"lat": 50.8466,
"lng": 4.3528,
"title": "Belgium: parliamentary commission issues 137 recommendations on abuse in the Church, following 'Godvergeten'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy and religious of the Catholic Church in Belgium, and named other religious/non-religious institutions"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly and religious pastoral authority",
"institutional practices (transfer of accused clergy, confidentiality) that the commission found obstructed accountability"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Belgian Chamber of Representatives",
"Bijzondere Parlementaire Onderzoekscommissie"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Belgian Chamber of Representatives, federal parliamentary commission of inquiry",
"stage": "parliamentary commission of inquiry, final report",
"date": "2024-05-02",
"outcome": "Following the September 2023 broadcast of the documentary series 'Godvergeten,' in which survivors and family members spoke, all Flemish political parties backed a call for a parliamentary inquiry; the Chamber of Representatives established the commission in October 2023 under chair Sophie De Wit. Its final report, presented 2 May 2024, made 137 recommendations, including appointment of a national commissioner for sexual boundary-crossing behaviour, improved police and judicial access to church files, mandatory file transfer when an accused cleric relocates, and a new arbitration/redress commission to replace the one set up after the 2010-2011 inquiry."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The commission's inquiry and recommendations are premised on its finding that clergy's pastoral authority over congregants and church institutional practices together enabled sustained abuse and obstructed its disclosure and redress.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2024/05/02/parlementaire-onderzoekscommissie-seksueel-misbruik-presenteert/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "VRT NWS, 'Onderzoekscommissie naar seksueel misbruik doet 137 aanbevelingen: centraal aanspreekpunt en nieuw expertisecentrum' (2 May 2024). Dutch: reports the commission's 137 recommendations in full context. English gloss: 'Abuse investigation commission makes 137 recommendations: central point of contact and new expertise centre.'",
"body": "Primary national-broadcaster report on the commission's final report.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.federaalombudsman.be/nl/aanbevelingen-parlementaire-onderzoekscommissie-om-de-strijd-tegen-kindermisbruik-en-seksueel-geweld",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Federale Ombudsman, official page tracking the parliamentary commission's recommendations. Dutch: institutional follow-up source. English gloss: 'Recommendations of the parliamentary commission of inquiry into the fight against child abuse and sexual violence.'",
"body": "Primary institutional/governmental corroboration of the commission and its recommendations.",
"tier": "official-institutional",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2024/05/02/parlementaire-onderzoekscommissie-seksueel-misbruik-presenteert/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f1cd4c68ab7298bbd5b9a4af1782a7d74fbf33dd67070413c4e52331d2b5d072",
"final_url": "https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2024/05/02/parlementaire-onderzoekscommissie-seksueel-misbruik-presenteert/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.federaalombudsman.be/nl/aanbevelingen-parlementaire-onderzoekscommissie-om-de-strijd-tegen-kindermisbruik-en-seksueel-geweld",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-institutional; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "804db84337a381b3db5aa1bca840cb0e4255b01918886547fc2aacdc01b0e198",
"final_url": "https://www.federaalombudsman.be/nl/aanbevelingen-parlementaire-onderzoekscommissie-om-de-strijd-tegen-kindermisbruik-en-seksueel-geweld"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 881,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Thinner than the corpus's other Ryan Report institutional non-prosecution records (a single admitted incident rather than a multi-decade documented pattern), but the criterion is met: an admitted sexual-abuse allegation against clergy with no recorded referral to police, only quiet removal. This is the ENTIRETY of St. Mary's Kilkenny's sexual-abuse content — the chapter (Vol 2 ch 15) is only 31 paragraphs long, almost all Department of Education/Finance correspondence about staffing ratios; paras 25-30 are the complete 'Nature of allegations' and 'Response of the Dominican Sisters' sections. CHAPTER NOW FULLY WALKED AND CLOSED. Year assigned as 1990 (Department policy pivot date recorded in the same chapter, para 31) purely as a placeholder within the institution's operating period since the Commission gives no date for the incident itself; treat as approximate/undated in analysis if exact dating matters. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1990-st-marys-kilkenny-dominican-visiting-priest-non-prosecution-ireland",
"year": 1990,
"place": "Kilkenny, Ireland",
"lat": 52.6541,
"lng": -7.2448,
"title": "Ireland: St Mary's School for the Deaf — Dominican Sisters admit a visiting priest sexually abused a pupil; he 'left shortly after ... and never returned', no Garda referral recorded",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"the Dominican Sisters who managed St Mary's School for the Deaf, Cabra, and who admitted a visiting priest's sexual abuse of a pupil in their own respondent statement to the Commission",
"the unnamed visiting priest who abused a child and was permitted to simply leave the institution rather than be reported"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the closed, residential, oral-method deaf-education environment in which children were actively discouraged from using sign language, restricting a deaf child's practical means of reporting abuse to hearing staff",
"clerical/pastoral access as a visiting priest, trusted and unsupervised, inside a girls' residential institution",
"the Congregation's own response pattern — quiet removal of the priest rather than referral to the Garda Siochana or to the diocese for canonical action"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Mary's School for the Deaf, Cabra",
"Dominican Sisters"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 2 ch. 15",
"stage": "official findings only — the Congregation's own admission records no Garda referral or canonical proceeding against the priest",
"date": "1990-01-01",
"outcome": "The Ryan Report's Investigation Committee received statements from complainants alleging physical abuse, sexual abuse, neglect and emotional abuse at St Mary's School for the Deaf, Cabra (run by the Dominican Sisters, 1846-present). Of the sexual-abuse allegations specifically, the Report states: 'Allegations were made of sexual abuse by visiting priests and the Congregation admitted that such an allegation was made against a priest, who left shortly after that and never returned.' No prosecution, Garda referral, or canonical sanction against the priest is recorded anywhere in the chapter; the resolution recorded by the Commission is confined to the priest's simple departure from the institution. In their own respondent statement, the Dominican Sisters otherwise denied that children were beaten for using sign language, while accepting a lesser degree of physical correction, and did not respond in detail to the individual allegations 'due to the passage of time'."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A deaf child in a residential school that actively suppressed her primary means of communication was abused by a visiting priest whose only recorded consequence was to leave and never come back — the Congregation's own admission, with no police report anywhere in the record.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-27",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 15 (St Mary's School for the Deaf, Cabra) para 27, via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "'Allegations were made of sexual abuse by visiting priests and the Congregation admitted that such an allegation was made against a priest, who left shortly after that and never returned.'",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-25",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 15 paras 25-26 (nature of allegations, physical/sexual/neglect/emotional), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Investigation Committee's summary of the categories of complaint received.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-30",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 15 para 30 (Dominican Sisters' response statement), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Congregation's general response, declining to address individual allegations due to the passage of time.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-27",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ad900d7cfbc6722c47e92899a7f293f4f4b99b9137058c08a995c87a369cca93",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-27"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-25",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b650e0df6ee6b15b425a165bd7f3fdcf2f3ca5f692d39de73bbbc5ced2b89e19",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-25"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-30",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "408d0bd9639d8990282c6ce07035214578283936c59a8479a43f3e56419f338d",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-15-30"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 882,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL RECORD documenting the ABSENCE of prosecution as the finding — but with an added dimension not present in the corpus's existing 8 non-prosecution records: here the STATE (Department of Education), not just the Church, is shown affirmatively deciding not to pursue a reported crime. The subsequent 1999 conviction is real and is the subject of the corpus's existing '2002-ferryhouse-rosminians-ryan-report-ireland' record (which cites only paras 200-214, the narrower Br Sergio conviction + dormitory-access findings) — this record does not duplicate that one; it covers the DISTINCT, much larger Br Bruno case history and the 1980 Department non-response (paras 145-194 and 270-284), which the existing record does not cite. Individuals recorded under the Commission's own pseudonyms. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1980-ferryhouse-br-bruno-department-no-further-action-non-prosecution-ireland",
"year": 1980,
"place": "Clonmel, County Tipperary, Ireland",
"lat": 52.3558,
"lng": -7.7003,
"title": "Ireland: Ferryhouse Brother caught raping and drugging boys for four years is dismissed, not reported to Gardai — and when told directly, a Department of Education official decides 'no further action' is needed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Br Bruno, Prefect in sole unsupervised charge of a junior dormitory of 36-40 boys at Ferryhouse Industrial School, who drugged and raped boys under his care for roughly four years",
"Fr Stefano, Resident Manager, who discovered the abuse in 1979 and reported it internally and to the Department of Education but, per the Department's own official, was never asked whether he had told the Gardai",
"Mr Black and Mr Orange, the Department of Education officials who in 1980, on being told directly that a Brother had been 'caught in bed with a boy' and dismissed, jointly decided that 'no further action was necessary' and made no written record"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sole, unsupervised nighttime control of a locked dormitory of 36-40 nine- to eleven-year-old boys, with private sleeping quarters attached",
"routine administration of anti-bed-wetting medication, which Br Bruno himself controlled and used to select and sedate specific children before assaulting them",
"fear and reputational control ('he had them terrorised') that suppressed reporting among the boys who witnessed or suspected the pattern for years",
"an internal Church-to-State reporting channel (Resident Manager to Department official, by phone, with no note taken) that both sides treated as sufficient closure once the perpetrator had been removed from the building"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Ferryhouse",
"Rosminians (Institute of Charity)",
"Department of Education (Ireland)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 2 ch. 3; a criminal prosecution of the same Brother followed 16 years later once a Garda investigation began independently",
"stage": "1980: internal Church and Department of Education correspondence/decision only, no Garda referral; 1999: the same Brother was tried at Circuit Criminal Court, pleaded guilty and was sentenced",
"date": "1980-01-01",
"outcome": "Br Bruno abused boys in Ferryhouse for roughly four years from the mid-1970s, selecting pubescent boys under his sole nighttime charge, sedating some with medication meant for bed-wetting, and repeatedly raping them; he told the Commission he abused 'dozens' and estimated 'over maybe 20, over a period of years'. Discovered in December 1979 after two absconding boys disclosed to Resident Manager Fr Stefano, Br Bruno confessed, was immediately removed and dismissed from the Order — never reported to the Gardai at that time. Fr Stefano, having consulted his Provincial, telephoned Department of Education official Mr Black early in 1980 to report a 'sexual assault on a pupil'; Mr Black told the Committee he was informed a Brother had been 'caught in bed with a boy' and was 'now on a train out of ... the place'. Mr Black consulted the Department Secretary, Mr Orange, who — after reflecting for a few moments — decided 'no further action was necessary' because 'the person responsible for the assault had been caught and was now removed from the School'. No written record was made by either official. Mr Black separately confirmed under questioning that he never asked Fr Stefano whether the matter had been reported to the Gardai. The Department's own Child Care Advisor likewise did not report the matter to Gardai, stating he had been told by Mr Black to 'leave it with him'. The Commission found that 'the Department of Education did not conduct any investigation into the events ... [n]or did the Department facilitate any such investigation, whether by the Garda Siochana, by the Department of Health, by the local Health Authority or by any other agency.' The matter surfaced 16 years later only because Gardai began an independent investigation after a former pupil was overheard discussing the abuse in public, not because of any report by the Rosminians or the Department; Br Bruno was convicted in 1999 on charges including buggery and indecent assault and sentenced to nine years with the final three suspended."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A Resident Manager who held religious authority over the whole institution reported a rape of a child up his own Church-and-State reporting chain in exactly the way he had been trained to — and a state official on the other end of the phone decided the matter was closed because the man was gone, without ever asking the one question ('did you tell the Gardai?') that would have opened it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-155",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 3 (Ferryhouse) paras 145-168 (Br Bruno's method, arrest, and own evidence), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "Br Bruno's own admitted account of drugging and raping boys under his sole nighttime charge for roughly four years.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-189",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 3 paras 189-194 (scale of the abuse and Fr Stefano's discovery), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's finding that the number of boys abused was far greater than the number who gave evidence, and that Br Bruno 'molested dozens of boys'.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-273",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 3 paras 270-284 (the Department of Education's 1980 non-response), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "Mr Black's and Mr Orange's own testimony that they decided 'no further action was necessary' and never asked whether Gardai had been told; the Commission's finding that the Department conducted no investigation and facilitated none by any other agency.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-306",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 3 para 306 (how the 1990s Garda inquiry actually began), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Commission's finding that the Garda inquiry arose from overheard public comments by a former pupil, not from any report by the Rosminians or the Department.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-155",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fa34d2b00ff2330407eb6c8b3edabac49517913e2f780369492463180be2ecbd",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-155"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-189",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "79d113cfb3a4e64b3a51bf82093be739986038d3f49aba45e9afed535e00f8b9",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-189"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-273",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "83f0300110360b6765b6371591aecd1d234d6dc28b1ac0d53ca93c7db773832e",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-273"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-306",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "de9856e7849fe6c57da1adb96233a8f0e0e214400de5a2a28000352d4c49dddf",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-306"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 883,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"date": "OMITTED",
"court": "Court of Criminal Appeal, Ireland",
"outcome": "Upheld the suspended sentence, agreeing with the trial judge's mitigation reasoning based on the defendant's own history as a Ferryhouse resident."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Filed as CORE/convicted (the criminal conviction and suspended sentence are the disposition), distinct in class from the corpus's institutional-event non-prosecution records, but the 1980-1994 gap between the first admitted disclosure and any Garda referral is itself a major finding worth preserving in the narrative — the Order's solicitor overriding the Department of Education's explicit instruction to report immediately is a rare documented instance of legal advice actively obstructing a mandated-report-style referral. Distinct from the existing '2002-ferryhouse-rosminians-ryan-report-ireland' corpus record (Br Sergio, paras 200-214) and from the companion Br Bruno non-prosecution record in this same file — this record covers Fr Valerio specifically (paras 223-237, 292-299, 303, 313, 315). Individuals recorded under the Commission's own pseudonyms. Extracted via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1980-ferryhouse-fr-valerio-fifteen-year-non-prosecution-ireland",
"year": 1980,
"place": "Clonmel, County Tipperary, Ireland",
"lat": 52.3558,
"lng": -7.7003,
"title": "Ireland: a Rosminian priest admitted sexually abusing a child to his Provincial in 1980; the Order sat on it for 15 years and a solicitor advised against telling the Gardai even after the Department said to",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "convicted",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Fr Valerio, a Rosminian priest and former Prefect at Ferryhouse Industrial School with sole charge of a group of 14-15 year old boys, who sexually abused at least seven children over his career and admitted as much to his own Superiors as early as 1980",
"successive Provincials of the Rosminian Order (Fr Stefano and others) who received his repeated admissions across 1980, 1990-92 and 1994 without referring any of them to the Gardai",
"the Order's own solicitor, who in 1994 advised the Provincial to take no action and await a formal complaint rather than follow the Department of Education's explicit instruction to report immediately to police"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sole custodial and pastoral charge of a dormitory group of young teenage boys as Prefect, used to summon individual boys to his private room under manufactured pretexts (an examination, a swimming-prize presentation)",
"threats of physical violence against a child who hesitated to comply with an instruction to undress",
"continuing clerical authority reaching beyond the institution — one victim was abused again after leaving Ferryhouse, when Fr Valerio arrived unannounced at a relative's house",
"an internal admission-and-containment cycle (admit to Superior, remove quietly, treat at a psychiatric facility, redeploy) repeated across at least three separate disclosure episodes before any external authority was told"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Ferryhouse",
"Rosminians (Institute of Charity)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland — criminal courts (suspended sentence); Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (Ryan Report, 2009), Vol. 2 ch. 3",
"stage": "criminal conviction, sentence suspended",
"date": "1980-01-01",
"outcome": "Fr Valerio, who as a child had himself been a resident of Ferryhouse and alleged he was sexually and physically abused there, later joined the Rosminian Order and was posted back to Ferryhouse as Assistant Prefect and then Prefect of a group of 14-15 year old boys in the late 1960s/early 1970s. The Commission found he sexually abused at least seven children during this period, including anally raping at least one boy and forcing others to perform oral sex, on a pattern of roughly monthly assaults sustained over about two and a half years for one victim. The first allegation was made to another priest in the early 1980s and relayed to the Provincial, who spoke to Fr Valerio but made no record of his response and took no further action; Fr Valerio admitted the truth of this specific complaint to his Provincial, Fr Stefano, in January 1980. The allegation resurfaced in the early 1990s when the original complainant threatened to expose him publicly; Fr Valerio admitted his guilt again, was removed from parish work and briefly hospitalised, but was not reported to police. Further complaints reached the Order in the mid-1990s and were reported to the Department of Education in December 1994; a Department official explicitly told the Provincial the Order should report immediately to the Gardai rather than wait for a formal complaint, but the Order's solicitor advised the opposite, and no Garda referral followed from the Order at that point either. Fr Valerio was eventually prosecuted, convicted of assault including indecent assault of two boys, and given a suspended sentence; the trial judge and the Court of Criminal Appeal treated his own admitted childhood abuse at the same institution as mitigation. In his own statements to Gardai and admissions to Superiors, he accepted having sexually abused at least seven children in total."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A boy abused at Ferryhouse grew up to become a Rosminian priest and abuse other boys in the same institution — and when he confessed to his own religious Superior in 1980, the confession functioned as containment rather than disclosure, kept inside the Order for a further fourteen years even after the State explicitly told them to report it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-223",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 3 (Ferryhouse) paras 223-228 (Fr Valerio's conviction, sentence, and career history), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The conviction for assault including indecent assault, the suspended sentence, and the Commission's finding he sexually abused at least seven children.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-232",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 3 paras 229-237 (victim testimony and admissions), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "Victim accounts of the abuse pattern and Fr Valerio's own admissions to Gardai of abusing multiple named individuals.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-297",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ryan Report, Vol. 2 ch. 3 paras 292-299 (the Department of Education's TN030 file, 1994-95), via UCD Industrial Memories.",
"body": "The Department official's explicit instruction to report immediately to the Gardai, and the Order's solicitor's contrary advice to await a formal complaint.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commission-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"date": "OMITTED",
"court": "Court of Criminal Appeal, Ireland",
"outcome": "Upheld the suspended sentence, agreeing with the trial judge's mitigation reasoning based on the defendant's own history as a Ferryhouse resident."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-223",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c7b06b0fe9ae1a28ee89502bd42420b79872ddb54b0f0e767dc30b35bccc7968",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-223"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-232",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5bc77d4d03bec85cfbb279639355e9b4508a48a9e47bcaf59fb2e03ab0871a90",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-232"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-297",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commission-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b58d470a8198822a068882ea22336ba5d1cb8e30994df1e20c4921ee8a8dea3a",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3-297"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "county-court",
"date": "2005",
"note": "County Court modified sentence to a conditional term; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Ten identified minor victims (girls, aged approx. 10-12), named in press only by initials/description. First priest in Croatia convicted of a child sex offence. Conditional sentence; he later resumed parish duties including confirmation preparation, which is recorded here as documented aftermath, not as part of the conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-ivan-cucek-sestine-zagreb-croatia",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Šestine, Zagreb, Croatia",
"lat": 45.8497,
"lng": 15.9962,
"title": "Croatia: parish priest's final conviction for indecent acts against ten schoolgirls in religious-education class",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Šestine; substitute religious-education (vjeronauk) teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority as the children's religious-education teacher",
"position as parish priest overseeing catechism preparation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Zagreb Archdiocese"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Municipal Court, Zagreb; County Court, Zagreb (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction; modified and finalised on appeal",
"outcome": "Fr Ivan Čuček was found guilty of sixteen counts of indecent acts (bludničenje) against ten girls aged around ten to twelve, whom he touched under their clothing and had sit on his lap during substitute religious-education classes. The County Court reduced the sentence to one year and six months, suspended, with a three-year probation period, reasoning in part that he was no longer in contact with children. This is recorded by Croatian press as the country's first final conviction of a Catholic priest for a child sexual offence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pravosudje-na-hrvatski-svecenik-osudjen-za-pedofiliju-pod-uvjetnom-kaznom-sluzio-mise/375720.aspx",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Index.hr: 'Pravosuđe na hrvatski: Svećenik osuđen za pedofiliju pod uvjetnom kaznom služio mise'.",
"body": "Reports the final conditional sentence and details of Čuček's subsequent return to parish duties, including confirmation preparation, after the probation period ended.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-aftermath-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pipkao-curice-davao-novac-za-seks-ovo-su-najpoznatiji-hrvatski-popovi-pedofili/2411049.aspx",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Index.hr: 'Pipkao curice, davao novac za seks... Ovo su najpoznatiji hrvatski popovi pedofili'.",
"body": "Roundup of Croatian clergy-abuse convictions naming Čuček as the first final conviction, with case facts on the ten victims and the sixteen counts.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "background-roundup"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Čuček abused his standing as the girls' religious-education teacher and their parish priest during catechism instruction, using the setting and his clerical role to isolate and touch them.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "county-court",
"date": "2005",
"note": "County Court modified sentence to a conditional term; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pravosudje-na-hrvatski-svecenik-osudjen-za-pedofiliju-pod-uvjetnom-kaznom-sluzio-mise/375720.aspx",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-aftermath-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "17e6747f0e6d7904e0ff27ac10f873050bfb5b5b3a2f3bccf10786996cae5c0b",
"final_url": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pravosudje-na-hrvatski-svecenik-osudjen-za-pedofiliju-pod-uvjetnom-kaznom-sluzio-mise/375720.aspx"
},
{
"source": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pipkao-curice-davao-novac-za-seks-ovo-su-najpoznatiji-hrvatski-popovi-pedofili/2411049.aspx",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: background-roundup.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b04d6dc368ec3453e07ff72f88db0b488615843d8542dea5ca9e20fbade86775",
"final_url": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pipkao-curice-davao-novac-za-seks-ovo-su-najpoznatiji-hrvatski-popovi-pedofili/2411049.aspx"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "county-court",
"date": "2009-11",
"note": "County Court, Rijeka, confirmed the three-year sentence; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Five identified minor victims (boys, aged 10-12 at time of abuse), testified via video link; not named in press.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-drago-ljubicic-rab-krk-croatia",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Banjol, Rab, Krk Diocese, Croatia",
"lat": 44.7597,
"lng": 14.7597,
"title": "Croatia: Krk Diocese priest's final conviction for indecent acts against five boys, upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Banjol (island of Rab); religious-education teacher, Krk diocesan school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority as parish priest and religion teacher over boys aged 10-12",
"one-on-one settings arranged under cover of religious instruction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Krk Diocese"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court, Rijeka (first instance and appeal, per press)",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"outcome": "Fr Drago Ljubičić, parish priest of Banjol on the island of Rab and a religion teacher at a Krk diocesan school, was convicted of indecent acts against five underage boys he touched on the genitals and coerced into reciprocating, with abuse occurring when the boys were aged approximately 10 to 12. He was sentenced to three years' imprisonment, confirmed on appeal in November 2009 in what Croatian press describe as the country's most prominent Catholic clergy child-abuse case. He was released in 2012, seven months early, for good conduct."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.novilist.hr/novosti/hrvatska/svecenik-osuden-zbog-pedofilije-ranije-pusten-iz-zatvora-drago-ljubicic-vratio-se-na-krk/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Novi list: 'Svećenik osuđen zbog pedofilije ranije pušten iz zatvora: Drago Ljubičić vratio se na Krk'.",
"body": "Reports the final three-year sentence, the five video-testifying child victims, and Ljubičić's early release in 2012.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-release-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pipkao-curice-davao-novac-za-seks-ovo-su-najpoznatiji-hrvatski-popovi-pedofili/2411049.aspx",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Index.hr roundup of Croatian clergy-abuse convictions, Ljubičić entry.",
"body": "Confirms the November 2009 County Court confirmation of the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "background-roundup"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As parish priest and religion teacher, Ljubičić held direct pastoral and instructional authority over the boys, using one-on-one time built into that role to abuse them.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "county-court",
"date": "2009-11",
"note": "County Court, Rijeka, confirmed the three-year sentence; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.novilist.hr/novosti/hrvatska/svecenik-osuden-zbog-pedofilije-ranije-pusten-iz-zatvora-drago-ljubicic-vratio-se-na-krk/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-release-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "718b9ac32bfb452d6b2d78f7bfc71ea617c4e6142ee63c63d126144aeae6d4e9",
"final_url": "https://www.novilist.hr/novosti/hrvatska/svecenik-osuden-zbog-pedofilije-ranije-pusten-iz-zatvora-drago-ljubicic-vratio-se-na-krk/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pipkao-curice-davao-novac-za-seks-ovo-su-najpoznatiji-hrvatski-popovi-pedofili/2411049.aspx",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: background-roundup.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b04d6dc368ec3453e07ff72f88db0b488615843d8542dea5ca9e20fbade86775",
"final_url": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/pipkao-curice-davao-novac-za-seks-ovo-su-najpoznatiji-hrvatski-popovi-pedofili/2411049.aspx"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [
"Franc Frantar"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "higher-court",
"date": "2008-12",
"note": "Higher Court, Ljubljana, imposed the final five-year sentence."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Single identified minor victim (girl, abuse beginning in third grade of elementary school), not named in press.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2008-franci-frantar-slovenia",
"year": 2008,
"place": "Slovenia",
"lat": 46.1512,
"lng": 14.9955,
"title": "Slovenia: first priest finally convicted of imprisonable child sexual abuse, five-year sentence",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Roman Catholic parish priest (župnik)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a child parishioner",
"years-long access built through the parish relationship"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Higher Court, Ljubljana",
"stage": "conviction, final",
"outcome": "Fr Franci Frantar was convicted of sexually abusing a girl for several years, beginning when she was in third grade, and sentenced to five years' imprisonment by the Ljubljana Higher Court in December 2008 — press describe him as the first Slovenian priest with a final prison sentence for child sexual abuse. He evaded custody for over a year using medical certificates before beginning his sentence in April 2010 at Dob prison; conditionally released in 2012. The Holy See laicised him in 2013."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/obsojeni-zupnik-franci-frantar-bo-moral-v-zapor/225501",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RTV SLO: 'Obsojeni župnik Franci Frantar bo moral v zapor'.",
"body": "Reports Frantar beginning his sentence in 2010 after evading custody, confirming the final five-year term.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.24ur.com/franc-frantar-postal-laik.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "24ur.com: 'Franc Frantar postal laik'.",
"body": "Reports the Holy See's 2013 laicisation of Frantar following his conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "laicisation-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the family's parish priest, Frantar held pastoral authority over the girl from early childhood, using years of trusted access within that relationship to abuse her.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "higher-court",
"date": "2008-12",
"note": "Higher Court, Ljubljana, imposed the final five-year sentence."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/obsojeni-zupnik-franci-frantar-bo-moral-v-zapor/225501",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "180f540b8925a646d7dafa2247c4a0a9010b18051934dd91086d44a29202ca24",
"final_url": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/obsojeni-zupnik-franci-frantar-bo-moral-v-zapor/225501"
},
{
"source": "https://www.24ur.com/franc-frantar-postal-laik.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: laicisation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d94d8f6dc1efe8a5d6e54ac63d7208648fa1dd3fafad259484208498de847833",
"final_url": "https://www.24ur.com/franc-frantar-postal-laik.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "higher-court",
"date": "2011-03",
"note": "Higher Court, Maribor, confirmed the district-court sentence; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Two identified minor victims (girls, abused during confirmation-preparation classes), not named in press.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-anton-kmet-brezno-remsnik-slovenia",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Brezno and Remšnik parishes, Slovenia",
"lat": 46.6167,
"lng": 15.5,
"title": "Slovenia: priest's final conviction for groping two girls during confirmation preparation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest serving Brezno and Remšnik parishes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority as the priest preparing the girls for confirmation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court; Higher Court, Maribor (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"outcome": "Fr Anton Kmet was convicted of groping two girls on the chest and buttocks during confirmation-preparation classes and sentenced to ten months' imprisonment. The Higher Court in Maribor confirmed the sentence in March 2011, making it final; he served the term. He was dismissed from the priesthood (laicised) in 2021, a decision confirmed by the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/vrhovno-sodisce-zupnik-kmet-obsojen-pedofilije-mora-za-zapahe/271141",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RTV SLO: 'Vrhovno sodišče: Župnik Kmet, obsojen pedofilije, mora za zapahe'.",
"body": "Reports the confirmation of Kmet's conviction and custodial sentence.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/anton-kmet-odslovljen-iz-duhovniskega-poklica-zaradi-spolne-zlorabe-mladoletnic/600780",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RTV SLO: 'Anton Kmet odslovljen iz duhovniškega poklica zaradi spolne zlorabe mladoletnic'.",
"body": "Reports the 2021 Vatican-confirmed laicisation, referencing the underlying final criminal conviction.",
"tier": "public-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "laicisation-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Kmet used his role as the girls' priest during confirmation preparation — a rite of passage requiring one-on-one pastoral contact — as the setting for the abuse.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "higher-court",
"date": "2011-03",
"note": "Higher Court, Maribor, confirmed the district-court sentence; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/vrhovno-sodisce-zupnik-kmet-obsojen-pedofilije-mora-za-zapahe/271141",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3e7855b685f7236c074731e088de742aa72f8f17aff4a38c9b6e3b38e89d849f",
"final_url": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/vrhovno-sodisce-zupnik-kmet-obsojen-pedofilije-mora-za-zapahe/271141"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/anton-kmet-odslovljen-iz-duhovniskega-poklica-zaradi-spolne-zlorabe-mladoletnic/600780",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: laicisation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d210be54ebb8138818f00af57ef0e169b1c7d44179f9978a7e8ebfdb91192ce9",
"final_url": "https://www.rtvslo.si/crna-kronika/anton-kmet-odslovljen-iz-duhovniskega-poklica-zaradi-spolne-zlorabe-mladoletnic/600780"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [
"Prea Cuviosul Nicodim",
"Nicolae Stancă"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "curtea-de-apel-pitesti",
"date": "2025-02-05",
"note": "Court of Appeal, Pitești, overturned the trial court's acquittal and imposed the final 9-year sentence (co-defendant increased to 17 years 8 months); decision final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Two identified minor victims (both boys who helped sell church objects at the monastery), not named in press. Trial court had initially acquitted; reversed and finalised on appeal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-nicodim-frasinei-monastery-valcea-romania",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Frăsinei Monastery, Vâlcea County, Romania",
"lat": 45.1167,
"lng": 24.15,
"title": "Romania: monk at Frăsinei Monastery finally convicted of raping two boys, nine-year sentence",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Orthodox monk, monastery secretary, Frăsinei Monastery"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic authority over boys performing tasks for the monastery",
"gifts and money used to secure compliance and silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Frăsinei Monastery, Romanian Orthodox Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Vâlcea Tribunal (first instance, acquittal); Court of Appeal, Pitești (reversal and final sentence)",
"stage": "conviction, final (reversed trial-court acquittal)",
"date": "2025-02-05",
"outcome": "Monk Nicodim (civil name Nicolae Stancă), secretary of Frăsinei Monastery, and a lay caretaker, Marian Radu, were tried on charges of repeated rape, sexual assault and continued sexual corruption of two minor boys who had been drawn into helping sell church objects at the monastery between July 2021 and December 2022 and were lured with money and gifts. The Râmnicu Vâlcea trial court had acquitted Nicodim; the Pitești Court of Appeal reversed this on 5 February 2025, convicting him and sentencing him to 9 years' imprisonment (the lay co-defendant received 17 years 8 months). The decision is final. Victims were awarded EUR 15,000 in moral damages."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.digi24.ro/stiri/actualitate/justitie/sentinta-in-scandalul-sexual-de-la-manastirea-frasinei-calugarul-acuzat-ca-a-violat-doi-copii-a-fost-condamnat-la-9-ani-de-inchisoare-3110555",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Digi24: 'Sentință în scandalul sexual de la Mănăstirea Frăsinei: Călugărul acuzat că a violat doi copii a fost condamnat la 9 ani de închisoare'.",
"body": "Reports the Court of Appeal's reversal of the acquittal and the final 9-year sentence for Nicodim.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://valceainfo.ro/2025/02/06/hotarare-definitiva-ani-grei-de-inchisoare-pentru-prea-cuviosul-nicodim-la-frasinei-judecatoria-ramnicu-valcea-il-achitase-in-scandalul-sexual/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Valcea Info: 'Hotărâre definitivă. Ani grei de închisoare pentru Prea Cuviosul Nicodim la Frăsinei'.",
"body": "Confirms the finality of the decision and recaps the trial-court acquittal it reversed.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-verdict-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The boys were drawn into the monastery's orbit through religious commerce (selling monastery-blessed objects); Nicodim's standing as a monk and monastery officer was the access and authority he used to isolate and abuse them.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "curtea-de-apel-pitesti",
"date": "2025-02-05",
"note": "Court of Appeal, Pitești, overturned the trial court's acquittal and imposed the final 9-year sentence (co-defendant increased to 17 years 8 months); decision final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.digi24.ro/stiri/actualitate/justitie/sentinta-in-scandalul-sexual-de-la-manastirea-frasinei-calugarul-acuzat-ca-a-violat-doi-copii-a-fost-condamnat-la-9-ani-de-inchisoare-3110555",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "278dd918eac244e7552f75857ba7c0067bd48aca2234a96abb89138aa17154e2",
"final_url": "https://www.digi24.ro/stiri/actualitate/justitie/sentinta-in-scandalul-sexual-de-la-manastirea-frasinei-calugarul-acuzat-ca-a-violat-doi-copii-a-fost-condamnat-la-9-ani-de-inchisoare-3110555"
},
{
"source": "https://valceainfo.ro/2025/02/06/hotarare-definitiva-ani-grei-de-inchisoare-pentru-prea-cuviosul-nicodim-la-frasinei-judecatoria-ramnicu-valcea-il-achitase-in-scandalul-sexual/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1099d6396bd6440998bf600381037ca07fefcda5839ae2918e5b57d6b0661013",
"final_url": "https://valceainfo.ro/2025/02/06/hotarare-definitiva-ani-grei-de-inchisoare-pentru-prea-cuviosul-nicodim-la-frasinei-judecatoria-ramnicu-valcea-il-achitase-in-scandalul-sexual/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "curtea-de-apel-bucuresti",
"date": "2025-09-18",
"note": "Court of Appeal, Bucharest, rejected both the priest's and the victim's appeals; sentence final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Single identified adult victim (a parishioner who came to confession), not named in press.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-visarion-alexa-bucharest-romania",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Militari, Bucharest, Romania",
"lat": 44.4325,
"lng": 26.0114,
"title": "Romania: priest finally convicted of sexually assaulting a woman during confession",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Orthodox priest, Church of the Descent of the Holy Spirit, Militari, Bucharest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"confessor's spiritual authority over a parishioner during confession",
"physical isolation in the church's summer altar during the sacrament"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bucharest Tribunal (first instance); Court of Appeal, Bucharest (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"date": "2025-09-18",
"outcome": "Fr Visarion Alexa was convicted of sexually assaulting a woman parishioner who had come to him for confession, the assault occurring on 23 April 2022 in the summer altar of his Bucharest church. He was sentenced to two and a half years' imprisonment, suspended, and ordered to pay damages. The Bucharest Court of Appeal rejected both his appeal and the victim's appeal (which sought a harsher sentence) on 18 September 2025, making the conviction final."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.digi24.ro/stiri/actualitate/justitie/preotul-visarion-alexa-a-fost-condamnat-definitiv-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-decizia-curtii-de-apel-bucuresti-3418455",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Digi24: 'Preotul Visarion Alexa a fost condamnat definitiv pentru agresiune sexuală. Decizia Curții de Apel București'.",
"body": "Reports the Court of Appeal's final rejection of both appeals and the confirmed sentence and damages.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://stirileprotv.ro/stiri/actualitate/preotul-din-capitala-visarion-alexa-a-fost-condamnat-la-doi-ani-si-jumatate-de-inchisoare-pentru-agresiune-sexuala.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Știrile ProTV: 'Preotul Visarion Alexa a fost condamnat la doi ani și jumătate de închisoare pentru agresiune sexuală'.",
"body": "First-instance report describing the confession-setting facts of the assault.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-verdict-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The assault occurred during the sacrament of confession, in which the priest's spiritual authority as confessor placed the parishioner in a position of trust and physical proximity he exploited.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "curtea-de-apel-bucuresti",
"date": "2025-09-18",
"note": "Court of Appeal, Bucharest, rejected both the priest's and the victim's appeals; sentence final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.digi24.ro/stiri/actualitate/justitie/preotul-visarion-alexa-a-fost-condamnat-definitiv-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-decizia-curtii-de-apel-bucuresti-3418455",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a95e7316c2644e1641b56aed9825471d06481c7aa57dbfd4d7dc6253c72ba481",
"final_url": "https://www.digi24.ro/stiri/actualitate/justitie/preotul-visarion-alexa-a-fost-condamnat-definitiv-pentru-agresiune-sexuala-decizia-curtii-de-apel-bucuresti-3418455"
},
{
"source": "https://stirileprotv.ro/stiri/actualitate/preotul-din-capitala-visarion-alexa-a-fost-condamnat-la-doi-ani-si-jumatate-de-inchisoare-pentru-agresiune-sexuala.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "17a0bcfb949e713d2ac0840eb628fef19d8cc023283b4a527dc68623ef49a89f",
"final_url": "https://stirileprotv.ro/stiri/actualitate/preotul-din-capitala-visarion-alexa-a-fost-condamnat-la-doi-ani-si-jumatate-de-inchisoare-pentru-agresiune-sexuala.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court-croatia",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Supreme Court of Croatia confirmed the core of the county-court verdict, reducing the sentence by one month; final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Single identified minor victim (altar server, male, 17 at time of report; abuse originally reported in 2014). The priest is not publicly named in Croatian press, which withholds his identity to protect the victim's identity given the small community involved; this record follows that sourcing convention rather than omitting a name that exists elsewhere.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-unnamed-priest-dakovo-osijek-archdiocese-croatia",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Đakovo-Osijek Archdiocese, Croatia",
"lat": 45.3094,
"lng": 18.4108,
"title": "Croatia: Đakovo-Osijek Archdiocese priest's final conviction for indecent acts against an altar server",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Đakovo-Osijek Archdiocese"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority as the parish priest supervising an altar server"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Đakovo-Osijek Archdiocese"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court (first instance); Supreme Court of Croatia (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction; upheld on appeal (final)",
"outcome": "A priest of the Đakovo-Osijek Archdiocese was convicted on three counts of indecent conduct (bludničenje) and one count of offensive behaviour against a minor altar server, sentenced to a unified term of eleven months, later reduced by one month on appeal to the Supreme Court of Croatia in 2021, which confirmed the core findings. The abuse had originally been reported in 2014. He served approximately nine months. Investigative reporting later established that Archbishop Đuro Hranić, with the Vatican's knowledge, returned him to parish ministry within months of release and that Gospić-Senj Diocese Bishop Zdenko Križić then assigned him two parishes, a placement ended only after journalists' inquiries; that institutional aftermath is documented here as context, separate from the criminal conviction itself."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.portalnovosti.com/zastitnik-zlostavljaca",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Portal Novosti: 'Zaštitnik zlostavljača'.",
"body": "Investigative report establishing the 2021 final conviction (three counts of bludničenje, one of offensive behaviour, Supreme Court confirmation reducing the sentence by one month) and the subsequent reinstatement to ministry.",
"tier": "investigative-press",
"kind": "verdict-and-institutional-aftermath-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/novosti-nadbiskup-hranic-u-sluzbu-vratio-svecenika-osudjenog-za-pedofiliju/2638229.aspx",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Index.hr: 'Novosti: Svećenik robijao zbog pedofilije. Nadbiskup Hranić ga vratio u službu'.",
"body": "National-press pickup of the Portal Novosti investigation, confirming the final conviction and custodial term.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest supervised the boy in his role as an altar server, a position of direct liturgical subordination to the parish priest, and used that supervisory access to abuse him.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "supreme-court-croatia",
"date": "2021",
"note": "Supreme Court of Croatia confirmed the core of the county-court verdict, reducing the sentence by one month; final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.portalnovosti.com/zastitnik-zlostavljaca",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: investigative-press; evidentiary role: verdict-and-institutional-aftermath-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/novosti-nadbiskup-hranic-u-sluzbu-vratio-svecenika-osudjenog-za-pedofiliju/2638229.aspx",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "520140dd28c1181aa93024f5894448ee33c7f3d5e3b44ad454e97e48b1653657",
"final_url": "https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/novosti-nadbiskup-hranic-u-sluzbu-vratio-svecenika-osudjenog-za-pedofiliju/2638229.aspx"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": null,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "regional-court-review",
"date": "2017-09-28",
"note": "Jalal-Abad regional prosecutor sought review of an initial 7-year sentence as too lenient; the court's revised 21-year verdict took final effect."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Single identified minor victim (boy, aged 10 at time of the 2016 offence), not named in press. Concurrent drug-possession and extremism charges were tried and sentenced alongside the sexual-abuse charge; this record concerns only the violent-sexual-act conviction and does not treat the extremism charge as itself the abuse offence — see lane handoff note on the Uzbekistan trap for why that distinction matters here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-suzak-imam-jalal-abad-kyrgyzstan",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Suzak district, Jalal-Abad region, Kyrgyzstan",
"lat": 40.8167,
"lng": 72.9167,
"title": "Kyrgyzstan: village mosque imam's final conviction for sexual assault of a ten-year-old boy, 21-year sentence",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam, village mosque, Suzak district"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority and standing as the village mosque's imam"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Suzak District Court, Jalal-Abad region",
"stage": "conviction; sentence revised upward on prosecutorial review, final",
"date": "2017-09-28",
"outcome": "A 58-year-old imam of a village mosque in Suzak district was convicted of a violent sexual act against a minor (a 10-year-old boy, offence reported by the child's mother in 2016), together with separate drug-possession and extremism charges. An initial sentence of seven years was appealed by the Jalal-Abad regional prosecutor as too lenient; on review the court issued a revised sentence of 21 years in a high-security colony, entering into force 28 September 2017."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://24.kg/obschestvo/68901_narkotiki_iznasilovanie_ekstremizm_imam_izsuzaka_poluchil_21god_tyurmyi/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "24.kg: 'Наркотики, изнасилование, экстремизм. Имам из Сузака получил 21 год тюрьмы'.",
"body": "Reports the final 21-year sentence covering the sexual-assault, drug and extremism convictions, and the boy's age and the reporting circumstances.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://kloop.kg/blog/2017/11/21/dzhalal-abadskaya-oblast-imama-prigovorili-k-21-godu-tyurmy-za-iznasilovanie-rebenka/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kloop.kg: 'Джалал-Абадская область: Имама приговорили к 21 году тюрьмы за изнасилование ребенка'.",
"body": "Confirms the prosecutorial appeal of the initial 7-year sentence and the resulting 21-year final verdict, dated 28 September 2017.",
"tier": "independent-news-outlet",
"kind": "appellate-outcome-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the village's imam, the defendant held a position of religious trust in a small community; that standing gave him access to the child that the criterion treats as the operative means of the abuse, independent of and additional to the unrelated concurrent extremism and drug charges.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "regional-court-review",
"date": "2017-09-28",
"note": "Jalal-Abad regional prosecutor sought review of an initial 7-year sentence as too lenient; the court's revised 21-year verdict took final effect."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://24.kg/obschestvo/68901_narkotiki_iznasilovanie_ekstremizm_imam_izsuzaka_poluchil_21god_tyurmyi/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "99d2360357ddec6fb12d3b2a53bb4e8f3d445be6c3c7220a1c1f9e4724a5a997",
"final_url": "https://24.kg/obschestvo/68901_narkotiki_iznasilovanie_ekstremizm_imam_izsuzaka_poluchil_21god_tyurmyi/"
},
{
"source": "https://kloop.kg/blog/2017/11/21/dzhalal-abadskaya-oblast-imama-prigovorili-k-21-godu-tyurmy-za-iznasilovanie-rebenka/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: independent-news-outlet; evidentiary role: appellate-outcome-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "80378b1700adb4e6ae95da83e371c3941cd2a633a28f7644567b6c590db1bbdd",
"final_url": "https://kloop.kg/blog/2017/11/21/dzhalal-abadskaya-oblast-imama-prigovorili-k-21-godu-tyurmy-za-iznasilovanie-rebenka/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 892,
"aliases": [
"Bryan Desmond Coffey"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The 1999 criminal conviction is Coffey's own adjudicated guilt and is the basis for this record. It is distinct from Bird v DP (a pseudonym) [2024] HCA 41, a later CIVIL case in which the Diocese successfully avoided vicarious liability for one of Coffey's victims -- that ruling is about the church's institutional liability, not about whether Coffey committed the abuse, which was never in dispute in that proceeding and was independently established by his criminal conviction 25 years earlier.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1999-bryan-coffey-ballarat-diocese-victoria-australia",
"year": 1999,
"place": "Ballarat, Port Fairy and Ouyen, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.5622,
"lng": 143.8503,
"title": "Australia: Ballarat Diocese priest Bryan Coffey convicted of indecently assaulting parish children across three decades",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Diocese of Ballarat"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"used unsupervised access to altar boys in the sacristy before Mass, arranged by parents who trusted him as their priest",
"targeted children of families he ministered to during home visits, including while a parent was in an adjoining room",
"the diocese's own internal culture of clerical deference meant victims and their families did not believe they would be believed against him",
"the church repeatedly transferred him to new parishes after internal complaints instead of reporting him, extending his access to new victims for over 30 years"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Ballarat"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Ballarat",
"stage": "trial and sentence",
"date": "1999-02-01",
"outcome": "A jury found Bryan Desmond Coffey guilty of twelve counts of indecent assault involving eight boys and one girl, and one count of false imprisonment, committed against children in parishes across western Victoria between 1960 and 1975. He was sentenced to a three-year suspended term."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Coffey was the ordained parish priest of the families he abused; victims described being alone with him in the sacristy, presbytery, or his car specifically because of his clerical role, and one victim's police statement records that he was 'afraid to tell my parents ... because Father Coffey was the Catholic priest, highly respected and looked up to in the community. No one would have believed me.' A separate 2024 High Court of Australia ruling (Bird v DP) on diocesan vicarious liability for one of Coffey's victims -- which the Diocese won on the narrow question of vicarious liability -- confirms the same underlying facts: Coffey abused a five-year-old parishioner during a pastoral visit to the child's home in 1971.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://www.brokenrites.org.au/drupal/node/22",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Broken Rites Australia, 'This priest was committing indecent acts against children from Day One, a court is told' (updated 9 Jan. 2022).",
"body": "Detailed account compiled from Victorian court transcripts of the February 1999 Ballarat County Court trial: the twelve counts, eight boy and one girl victims aged six to eleven, the sacristy/presbytery/car/family-home pattern of offending, the decades of church cover-up by transfer, and the three-year suspended sentence.",
"tier": "researcher-court-transcript-compilation",
"kind": "trial-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/cth/HCA/2024/41.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bird v DP (a pseudonym) [2024] HCA 41 (13 November 2024).",
"body": "High Court of Australia judgment recording as undisputed background that Fr Bryan Coffey, a priest of the Catholic Diocese of Ballarat, sexually abused DP at DP's parents' home in Port Fairy in 1971 during a pastoral visit; the Court's ruling itself concerns only whether the Diocese is vicariously liable, not whether the abuse occurred.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "apex-court-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://www.brokenrites.org.au/drupal/node/22",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: researcher-court-transcript-compilation; evidentiary role: trial-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "06398a6725f75004d6ce509d95acde9391c57fd6f41b10015a2c2c668d941881",
"final_url": "http://www.brokenrites.org.au/drupal/node/22"
},
{
"source": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/cth/HCA/2024/41.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: apex-court-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 893,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Two separate rounds of prosecution, 2016 and 2021, cover five distinct victims across the same institution and perpetrator; both are recorded as the same underlying pattern of offending discovered and prosecuted in stages.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-william-houston-st-augustines-orphanage-geelong-victoria-australia",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Highton, Geelong, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -38.1804,
"lng": 144.3253,
"title": "Australia: Christian Brother William Houston convicted twice of abusing boys in his care at St Augustine's Orphanage",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Christian Brother; supervisor at St Augustine's Orphanage, Highton"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"supervised the dormitory in which wards of the state, removed from their families by the Children's Court, slept and lived under his direct custodial and religious authority",
"victims had no family or outside advocate to report to; the orphanage was run entirely by the Christian Brothers order Houston belonged to"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Brothers",
"St Augustine's Orphanage, Highton"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Melbourne",
"stage": "jury trial and sentence",
"date": "2016-05-17",
"outcome": "A jury unanimously convicted William Houston, a former Christian Brother who worked at St Augustine's Orphanage between 1963 and 1971, of eight charges of buggery, attempted buggery and indecent assault against three victims who had been made wards of the state and placed in the Brothers' care. He was sentenced to 12 years and 9 months' imprisonment with a non-parole period of 8 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Melbourne",
"stage": "second trial (judge alone) and sentence",
"date": "2021-05-12",
"outcome": "Following a further judge-alone trial, Houston was found guilty of one charge of buggery and three charges of indecent assault against two further victims from the same orphanage, and acquitted on two other counts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Houston was a Christian Brother directly supervising the dormitory of an orphanage run by his own religious order; the victims were state wards with no family able to intervene, placed entirely in the Brothers' custodial and spiritual authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/vic/VCC/2016/638.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "R v Houston [2016] VCC 638 (17 May 2016).",
"body": "County Court of Victoria sentencing remarks: jury conviction on all eight charges relating to three victims (Andrew Marshall, Joseph Davies, Cameron Brady, pseudonyms), Houston's role as a Christian Brother supervising the dormitory at St Augustine's Orphanage 1963-1971, and the 12-year-9-month sentence.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "sentencing-remarks"
},
{
"link": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/vic/VCC/2021/610.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "DPP v Houston [2021] VCC 610 (12 May 2021).",
"body": "County Court of Victoria sentencing remarks for a second judge-alone trial: guilty verdicts on four further charges relating to two additional victims (GT and another, one removed from his family by the Children's Court at age 10 and placed with the Christian Brothers at St Augustine's), acquittal on two counts.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "sentencing-remarks"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/vic/VCC/2016/638.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: sentencing-remarks.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/vic/VCC/2021/610.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: sentencing-remarks.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 894,
"aliases": [
"Desmond Eric Richards",
"Brother Neil"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed Richards's sentence appeal on 19 May 2023 (Richards v R [2023] NSWCCA 107)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Richards was prosecuted and sentenced across at least three separate rounds (2014, 2018, appeal 2023) covering different victims and schools; this record aggregates the publicly documented rounds under a single perpetrator entry, consistent with how the corpus already treats other multi-round Christian Brothers convictions (e.g. Dowlan/Bales).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-desmond-richards-christian-brothers-nsw-australia",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Albury, Wagga Wagga and Sydney, New South Wales, Australia",
"lat": -33.8688,
"lng": 151.2093,
"title": "Australia: Christian Brother Desmond Richards ('Brother Neil') convicted across multiple rounds of abusing students at NSW Christian Brothers schools; conviction upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Christian Brother; teacher, Christian Brothers schools, New South Wales"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"used his authority as a teacher and Christian Brother to isolate vulnerable and 'problem' students, per the sentencing judge's own finding that he 'took advantage of the power he could assert as a teacher'",
"physically punished victims to ensure their silence",
"offended at multiple schools and at a school camp over four decades; the church received complaints more than a decade before police did, and merely moved him to non-teaching roles rather than reporting him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of New South Wales",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2014-11-26",
"outcome": "Judge Peter Zahra sentenced Desmond Richards to a minimum of two years' imprisonment for indecently assaulting four boys aged 11 to 13 at Christian Brothers schools in Albury, Wagga Wagga and Sydney, and at a school camp, in the 1970s and 1980s. The judge found Richards 'took advantage of the power he could assert as a teacher.'"
},
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of New South Wales",
"stage": "further sentence",
"date": "2018-01-01",
"outcome": "While already serving his earlier custodial sentence, Richards was further sentenced for offences against students in Years 5 and 6 committed at St Patrick's in 1986 and 1987."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of New South Wales, Court of Criminal Appeal",
"stage": "sentence appeal",
"date": "2023-05-19",
"outcome": "Richards v R [2023] NSWCCA 107: leave to appeal against sentence granted but the appeal itself dismissed; the Court of Criminal Appeal held the total sentence was not manifestly excessive given the maximum penalties, seriousness of the offences, three victims, and Richards's substantial (by then multi-round) criminal history."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Richards was a member of the Christian Brothers religious order teaching at the order's own schools; the sentencing judge expressly found the offending was an abuse of 'the power he could assert as a teacher' within that institutional and religious authority, and the Court of Criminal Appeal record separately notes he was transferred by the Church to Rome and received treatment for 'religious orders with a history of psychosexual issues.'",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.culteducation.com/group/874-clergy-abuse/28106-christian-brother-jailed-for-at-least-two-years-for-indecently-assaulting-boys-in-nsw-schools.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ABC News Australia (Jamelle Wells), 'Christian Brother jailed for at least two years for indecently assaulting boys in NSW schools' (26 Nov. 2014), archived via Cult Education Institute.",
"body": "Reports the 2014 District Court sentencing before Judge Zahra: four victims aged 11-13, offending at Albury, Wagga Wagga, Sydney and a school camp in the 1970s-80s, the judge's finding that Richards abused his power as a teacher, and the church's decade-plus delay in reporting him to police.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/nsw/NSWCCA/2023/107.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Richards v R [2023] NSWCCA 107 (19 May 2023).",
"body": "NSW Court of Criminal Appeal judgment dismissing Richards's appeal against an aggregate sentence for further historical sex offences against three victims at schools where he taught while a member of a Catholic religious order; records his multiple prior custodial sentences and transfer to Rome by the order.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed Richards's sentence appeal on 19 May 2023 (Richards v R [2023] NSWCCA 107)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.culteducation.com/group/874-clergy-abuse/28106-christian-brother-jailed-for-at-least-two-years-for-indecently-assaulting-boys-in-nsw-schools.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d2378b407c268c689cae3048dc2d4ec35021648c1e7989b9dc79b315d3ffbb6e",
"final_url": "https://www.culteducation.com/group/874-clergy-abuse/28106-christian-brother-jailed-for-at-least-two-years-for-indecently-assaulting-boys-in-nsw-schools.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/nsw/NSWCCA/2023/107.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 895,
"aliases": [
"Brother Christopher"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed both the conviction and sentence appeals on 11 May 2018 (Wade v R [2018] NSWCCA 85)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Reported under the pseudonym 'Wade' in the appellate judgment, with the complainant's evidence referring to the defendant throughout by his religious name, Brother Christopher.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-brother-christopher-wade-marist-brothers-kogarah-nsw-australia",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Kogarah, New South Wales, Australia",
"lat": -33.9631,
"lng": 151.1349,
"title": "Australia: Marist Brother and school principal 'Brother Christopher' Wade convicted of indecent assault on a pupil; conviction upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Marist Brother; principal, Marist Brothers High School, Kogarah"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"summoned the victim to his closed-door principal's office under the pretext of school discipline and abused him there",
"the victim's own evidence at trial was that he did not disclose at the time because 'the brothers and the church ... were held in such high esteem' that he did not believe his mother, herself a strong believer, would have believed him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Marist Brothers",
"Marist Brothers High School, Kogarah"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of New South Wales",
"stage": "trial and sentence",
"date": "2017-11-03",
"outcome": "Wade, convicted by judge-alone trial of three counts of indecent assault against a pupil at Marist Brothers High School, Kogarah in 1980, was sentenced to 18 months' imprisonment with a 9-month non-parole period."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of New South Wales, Court of Criminal Appeal",
"stage": "conviction and sentence appeal",
"date": "2018-05-11",
"outcome": "Wade v R [2018] NSWCCA 85: leave to appeal against both conviction and sentence granted, but both appeals dismissed. The Court held the judge-alone trial verdicts were not unreasonable and the sentence, which took into account that Wade's breach of trust was aggravated by his position as school principal, was not manifestly excessive."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Wade was a professed Marist Brother serving as principal of a Marist Brothers school; the complainant's own trial testimony directly names the operative mechanism -- that the Brothers and the church were held in such esteem in his family that disclosure felt impossible -- and the abuse occurred inside the principal's office under cover of school-discipline authority that was, for a Marist school, inseparable from Wade's religious office.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/nsw/NSWCCA/2018/85.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wade v R [2018] NSWCCA 85 (11 May 2018).",
"body": "NSW Court of Criminal Appeal judgment dismissing both conviction and sentence appeals; sets out the complainant's trial evidence describing Brother Christopher as principal of Marist Brothers High School, Kogarah, the office-based offending in 1980, and the complainant's account of why he did not disclose given the esteem in which the Brothers and the church were held.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed both the conviction and sentence appeals on 11 May 2018 (Wade v R [2018] NSWCCA 85)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/cases/nsw/NSWCCA/2018/85.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 896,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The New Zealand Court of Appeal dismissed Thompson's conviction appeal on 16 October 2002 (R v Thompson [2002] NZCA 401)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Complainants' identities are suppressed by statute (Criminal Justice Act 1985 s139) and are referred to by initials in the judgment.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-nathanael-thompson-auckland-church-new-zealand",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Auckland, New Zealand",
"lat": -36.8485,
"lng": 174.7633,
"title": "New Zealand: church youth leader Nathanael Thompson convicted of sexually violating boys he met through his congregation; conviction upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth leader, small independent church, Auckland"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"met all three victims through his position as youth leader of a small church led by his own cousin",
"used his standing within the congregation to gain access to the boys outside formal church settings over a three-year period"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of New Zealand, Auckland",
"stage": "jury trial and sentence",
"date": "2002-07-25",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Nathanael Thompson on 11 of 19 counts, including six counts of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection and four counts of indecent assault against two boys, and one count of inducing an indecent act against a third boy, met through his role as a church youth leader in Auckland. He was sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment on the sexual violation counts."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal of New Zealand",
"stage": "conviction appeal",
"date": "2002-10-16",
"outcome": "R v Thompson [2002] NZCA 401: none of the grounds of appeal were made out and the appeal against conviction was dismissed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Court of Appeal's own judgment records that Thompson 'was a youth leader of a small church in Auckland led by his cousin' and 'met the complainants through his church membership' -- the church relationship is stated as the origin and continuing context of his access to all three victims over the three-year charged period.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nzlii.org/cgi-bin/viewdoc/nz/cases/NZCA/2002/401.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "R v Thompson [2002] NZCA 401 (16 October 2002).",
"body": "New Zealand Court of Appeal judgment dismissing the conviction appeal; records the jury's guilty verdicts on 11 of 19 counts, the High Court's 10-year sentence, and that Thompson was a youth leader of a small Auckland church, led by his cousin, who met all three complainants through his church membership.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The New Zealand Court of Appeal dismissed Thompson's conviction appeal on 16 October 2002 (R v Thompson [2002] NZCA 401)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nzlii.org/cgi-bin/viewdoc/nz/cases/NZCA/2002/401.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 897,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "High Court of New Zealand substituted home detention for the original prison sentence on 6 April 2023 (Stainton v R [2023] NZHC 787); the conviction itself was not appealed and stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The victim's identity is suppressed by statute (Criminal Procedure Act 2011 s203). This is a sentence appeal only; the underlying guilty plea and conviction were not challenged and stand.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-luke-stainton-otumoetai-baptist-church-tauranga-new-zealand",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Tauranga, New Zealand",
"lat": -37.6878,
"lng": 176.1651,
"title": "New Zealand: Baptist church youth leader Luke Stainton convicted of a sexual relationship with a 14-year-old member of his youth group",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth leader, Otumoetai Baptist Church, Tauranga"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"was a 24-year-old youth leader at the church whose youth group the 14-year-old complainant attended",
"initiated a purported 'relationship' with a young person a decade his junior who was under his pastoral charge",
"some of the sexual contact took place inside the church building itself, at night"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Otumoetai Baptist Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tauranga District Court",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2022-11-08",
"outcome": "R v Stainton [2022] NZDC 22079: Luke Timothy Stainton pleaded guilty to sexual connection with a young person aged 15 and was sentenced to two years and three months' imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of New Zealand, Tauranga",
"stage": "sentence appeal",
"date": "2023-04-06",
"outcome": "Stainton v R [2023] NZHC 787: the sentence appeal was allowed; the imprisonment term was quashed and replaced with four months' home detention, crediting time already served. The underlying conviction was not disturbed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The High Court's own sentencing-appeal judgment records that Stainton 'was a 24-year-old youth leader at the Otumoetai Baptist Church' and the complainant 'a 14-year-old attending its youth group' -- the youth-leader role over a member of the group he led is stated as the origin of the contact, and part of the abuse occurred inside the church itself.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nzlii.org/cgi-bin/viewdoc/nz/cases/NZHC/2023/787.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Stainton v R [2023] NZHC 787 (6 April 2023).",
"body": "New Zealand High Court judgment on a sentence appeal; sets out that Stainton was a 24-year-old youth leader at Otumoetai Baptist Church, Tauranga, and the complainant a 14-year-old member of its youth group, records the original guilty plea and 2-year-3-month sentence, and substitutes four months' home detention.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "sentence-appeal-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "High Court of New Zealand substituted home detention for the original prison sentence on 6 April 2023 (Stainton v R [2023] NZHC 787); the conviction itself was not appealed and stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nzlii.org/cgi-bin/viewdoc/nz/cases/NZHC/2023/787.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: sentence-appeal-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 898,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a distinct individual conviction from the already-recorded Gloriavale 'Overseeing Shepherd' Howard Temple record (2026-howard-temple-gloriavale-haupiri-new-zealand); both draw on the same New Zealand Royal Commission of Inquiry findings (Whanaketia, Part 4, Chapter 4) about the community's authority structure as background, but each concerns a separately charged and separately convicted individual perpetrator.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-jonathan-benjamin-gloriavale-west-coast-new-zealand",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Haupiri, West Coast, New Zealand",
"lat": -42.575,
"lng": 171.713,
"title": "New Zealand: former Gloriavale leader Jonathan Benjamin convicted on 26 counts of sexual offending against community children spanning three decades",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"former leader, Gloriavale Christian Community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"held leadership standing within Gloriavale's male-authority hierarchy, which the sentencing judge found gave him 'not only the opportunity, but almost the right to offend' with little consequence inside the community",
"offended against nine victims as young as five or six over more than three decades, spanning the community's earlier North Canterbury site and its later West Coast site",
"the community's own doctrine of female submission to male authority and members' training to 'never say no' and 'put other people's needs before our own' silenced disclosure for decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Gloriavale Christian Community"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Greymouth District Court, New Zealand",
"stage": "jury trial and guilty pleas",
"date": "2023-12-11",
"outcome": "A jury found Jonathan Benjamin guilty of 11 charges of sexual offending against children; he had separately admitted 15 further similar charges, for a total of 26 charges against nine victims."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Greymouth District Court, New Zealand",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2024-03-18",
"outcome": "Judge Mark Callaghan sentenced Benjamin to 11 years and 10 months' imprisonment, finding the power imbalance male leaders held over women and children at Gloriavale was an aggravating feature that gave Benjamin 'not only the opportunity, but almost the right to offend ... with little or no consequence.'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Benjamin was a long-standing leader within Gloriavale who publicly promoted the community's doctrine that women must submit to male authority; the sentencing judge expressly found this authority structure -- not merely proximity -- was what let him offend against nine victims over three decades with impunity inside the community.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/512020/jonathan-benjamin-sentenced-to-more-than-11-years-jail-for-sexual-offending-against-gloriavale-children",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RNZ (Anna Sargent), 'Jonathan Benjamin sentenced to more than 11 years' jail for sexual offending against Gloriavale children' (18 Mar. 2024).",
"body": "National public broadcaster report from the Greymouth District Court sentencing: 26 charges, nine victims aged five to their teens, offending from the 1980s across both Gloriavale sites, the judge's finding on the power imbalance as an aggravating feature, and the 11-year-10-month sentence.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/512020/jonathan-benjamin-sentenced-to-more-than-11-years-jail-for-sexual-offending-against-gloriavale-children",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6b1e734ab49f4a8823c41d973a22fd4395ae420fdbf3d19b36f290cc00965d1c",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/crime-and-justice/512020/jonathan-benjamin-sentenced-to-more-than-11-years-jail-for-sexual-offending-against-gloriavale-children"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 899,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "The Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses (Australasia) Limited separately and unsuccessfully litigated against the Royal Commission over the release of related material: Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses (Australasia) Limited v Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse [2023] NZHC 3031, upheld on appeal in [2024] NZCA 128."
}
],
"scopeNote": "This is an official-finding-tier institutional record, not a criminal conviction -- the Commission has no power to convict, and the report states it heard from only one person who described being sexually abused specifically within the Inquiry's 'care' definition (the wider pattern of psychological and emotional harm during judicial-committee processes is separately documented). It should not be read as asserting the named Elder in paragraph 99 of Chapter 4 was ever criminally charged; no such charge is documented. This record is New Zealand-specific and distinct from the existing Australian Royal Commission Case Study 29 on Jehovah's Witnesses already in the corpus (2016-royal-commission-jehovahs-witnesses-case-study-29-australia), which concerns a different inquiry, a different country, and a different (much larger, 1,006-perpetrator) evidentiary base.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jehovahs-witnesses-case-study-new-zealand",
"year": 2024,
"place": "New Zealand (national)",
"lat": -41.2,
"lng": 174.8,
"title": "New Zealand Royal Commission: Jehovah's Witnesses' own congregation records show an elder had sexual intercourse with a 15-year-old member, treated internally as a matter of reputational damage",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Elder, Jehovah's Witnesses congregation, New Zealand"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the faith's governing structure vested all congregational decision-making authority exclusively in male Elders, with no women eligible to hold that office",
"internal disclosure required a rigid two-witness rule for allegations of child abuse, effectively immunising abuse that occurred in private",
"the faith's teaching that Armageddon would destroy the unfaithful, combined with the practice of shunning those who left or spoke out, created what the Inquiry found were high barriers to disclosure to either the congregation or secular authorities",
"the faith's own documents, produced to the Inquiry, record that when an Elder was found to have had sexual intercourse with a 15-year-old girl, 'the Elders all felt great shock at the seriousness of the sin, the repercussions to the congregation should the girl become pregnant and the sin thus become known' -- framing the incident around institutional reputational risk rather than the girl's victimisation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses (Australasia) Limited"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care, New Zealand",
"stage": "final report, faith-based institutions case study",
"date": "2024-07-24",
"outcome": "The Commission's final report, Whanaketia, found that Jehovah's Witnesses Elders in New Zealand held significant, gendered power over congregation members including children; that the faith's disclosure processes, record-keeping and Elder vetting were inadequate; that it took inadequate steps to prevent and respond to abuse in care; and that it had not referred any sexual abuse allegations to police during the Inquiry period. The case study documents, from the faith's own internal records, an instance in which an Elder had sexual intercourse with a 15-year-old girl."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Commission's own finding is that the faith's exclusively-male Elder authority structure, combined with its disclosure and shunning practices, is what both enabled the abuse and suppressed its reporting; the quoted internal congregation record shows Elders responding to a documented act of sexual intercourse between an Elder and a 15-year-old member as a reputational 'sin' to be managed rather than a crime to be reported.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.abuseincare.org.nz/reports/whanaketia/case-studies/case-study-jehovahs-witnesses/executive-summary",
"archive": "",
"citation": "New Zealand Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care, Whanaketia, Case Study: Jehovah's Witnesses, Executive Summary (2024).",
"body": "Official Commission summary finding that Elders held significant power and influence over children and young people in the faith's care, that barriers to disclosure were high, that the faith's response to abuse in care was inadequate, and that the faith disputed children were ever in its 'care' at all.",
"tier": "royal-commission-official-finding",
"kind": "institutional-inquiry-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://www.abuseincare.org.nz/reports/whanaketia/case-studies/case-study-jehovahs-witnesses/chapter-4",
"archive": "",
"citation": "New Zealand Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care, Whanaketia, Case Study: Jehovah's Witnesses, Chapter 4: Risk factors and allegations of abuse (2024).",
"body": "Chapter setting out the Commission's detailed findings on Elder power imbalance, disclosure barriers, and survivor testimony, including the quoted internal Jehovah's Witnesses congregation record describing an Elder's sexual intercourse with a 15-year-old girl as a 'sin' whose main risk was becoming known to the congregation.",
"tier": "royal-commission-official-finding",
"kind": "institutional-inquiry-finding"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "The Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses (Australasia) Limited separately and unsuccessfully litigated against the Royal Commission over the release of related material: Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses (Australasia) Limited v Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse [2023] NZHC 3031, upheld on appeal in [2024] NZCA 128."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.abuseincare.org.nz/reports/whanaketia/case-studies/case-study-jehovahs-witnesses/executive-summary",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: royal-commission-official-finding; evidentiary role: institutional-inquiry-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.abuseincare.org.nz/reports/whanaketia/case-studies/case-study-jehovahs-witnesses/chapter-4",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: royal-commission-official-finding; evidentiary role: institutional-inquiry-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 900,
"aliases": [
"Bishop Feyi Daniels",
"Daniel Oluwafeyiropo"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: victims were adult worshippers of Daniels's own church, assaulted at his Lekki residence and on church premises; the court found the assaults occurred in the course of his exercising pastoral authority over congregants who came to him in that capacity. Not a paternal-nexus case — victims were unrelated congregants, one a former assistant pastor.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"slug": "2024-feyi-daniels-lekki-lagos-nigeria",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Lekki, Lagos State, Nigeria",
"lat": 6.4698,
"lng": 3.5852,
"title": "Nigeria: Lagos pastor sentenced to life imprisonment for raping a church member",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and bishop, iReign Christian Ministry"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a congregant, including a former assistant pastor of his own church",
"isolation at the pastor's private residence under guise of counsel/prayer",
"payment to the victim after one assault, cited by the court as an attempt to buy silence"
],
"organizations": [
"iReign Christian Ministry"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lagos State Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court, Ikeja, Nigeria",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2024-01-26",
"outcome": "Justice Rahman Oshodi convicted Feyi Daniels (also called Daniel Oluwafeyiropo) on one count of rape and one count of sexual assault of church members, acquitting him on a second rape count and an attempted-rape count. Sentenced to life imprisonment on the rape count and a concurrent three-year term for sexual assault; ordered registered in the Lagos State Sex Offenders Register."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://punchng.com/breaking-lagos-pastor-feyi-daniels-bags-life-imprisonment-for-raping-church-member/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Punch, 'Lagos pastor Feyi Daniels bags life imprisonment for raping church member' (26 January 2024).",
"body": "Reports that the Lagos State Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court, Ikeja, sentenced Feyi Daniels, founder of iReign Christian Ministry, to life imprisonment for rape and a concurrent three years for sexual assault of a church member, after Justice Rahman Oshodi found him guilty on the first and third counts of a four-count charge. States the assaults occurred at the pastor's Lekki residence and on church premises in Ikeja, and that his name was ordered added to the state Sex Offenders Register.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://saharareporters.com/2023/05/09/nigerian-pastor-bishop-feyi-daniel-raped-me-twice-his-lekki-home-sent-me-n5000-treat",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sahara Reporters, 'Nigerian Pastor, Bishop Feyi Daniel Raped Me Twice In His Lekki Home, Sent Me N5,000 To Treat Myself — Assistant Pastor' (9 May 2023).",
"body": "First-person account from the complainant, a former assistant pastor at Daniels's church, describing two assaults at his Lekki residence and a subsequent payment of N5,000 which the prosecution characterised at trial as an attempt to silence her.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "victim-testimony-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a congregant and former assistant pastor under Daniels's direct pastoral authority; she was drawn into private one-on-one contact at his residence specifically because of that clerical relationship, and the court treated his subsequent payment to her as an attempt to leverage the same relationship to buy silence.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://punchng.com/breaking-lagos-pastor-feyi-daniels-bags-life-imprisonment-for-raping-church-member/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d5dcbfac6dc8410b9e122f08083987a7c9d495c0a88eb796a322d4777f630335",
"final_url": "https://punchng.com/breaking-lagos-pastor-feyi-daniels-bags-life-imprisonment-for-raping-church-member/"
},
{
"source": "https://saharareporters.com/2023/05/09/nigerian-pastor-bishop-feyi-daniel-raped-me-twice-his-lekki-home-sent-me-n5000-treat",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: victim-testimony-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "937842c851af6f7c309bdc67fdee438fc046a06ee95a20f209cc5b54016e2bf1",
"final_url": "https://saharareporters.com/2023/05/09/nigerian-pastor-bishop-feyi-daniel-raped-me-twice-his-lekki-home-sent-me-n5000-treat"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 901,
"aliases": [
"Pastor Chris Mcdouglas",
"Chris Douglas"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: victim was the daughter of a church member, not the defendant's own child — the court expressly found he was regarded within the congregation as a 'spiritual father' and exploited that position to gain access to and drug the victim. Distinguished from paternal-nexus exclusions (no biological or custodial relationship).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"slug": "2026-chris-mcdouglas-lagos-nigeria",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Lagos, Nigeria",
"lat": 6.5244,
"lng": 3.3792,
"title": "Nigeria: sixty-three-year-old pastor sentenced to life imprisonment for drugging and raping a church member's daughter",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Peculiar Generation Assembly Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing within the congregation as a 'spiritual father', used to gain access to a member's 18-year-old daughter",
"drugging the victim before the assault"
],
"organizations": [
"Peculiar Generation Assembly Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lagos State Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court, Ikeja, Nigeria",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2026-04-17",
"outcome": "Justice Rahman Oshodi convicted Chris Mcdouglas, 63, pastor of Peculiar Generation Assembly Church, of rape of a church member's 18-year-old daughter, sentencing him to life imprisonment; discharged him on six of nine counts (defilement, sexual assault, indecent treatment of a child) while convicting on the rape count. Ordered his name entered in the Lagos State Sexual Offences Register."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ripplesnigeria.com/pastor-sentenced-to-life-in-jail-for-raping-church-members-daughter/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ripples Nigeria, 'Pastor sentenced to life in jail for raping church member's daughter' (17 April 2026).",
"body": "Reports the Ikeja Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court sentenced 63-year-old pastor Chris Mcdouglas of Peculiar Generation Assembly Church, Lagos, to life imprisonment for raping his 18-year-old church member's daughter after drugging her. States the judge described the offence as a 'grave betrayal of trust' and found the cleric, regarded within his congregation as a 'spiritual father', exploited his position of authority; the court discharged him on six of nine counts and ordered his name added to the Sexual Offences Register.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://persecondnews.com/2026/04/17/life-jail-for-guilt-racked-pastor-for-raping-congregants-child-after-drugging-her/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Per Second News, 'Life Jail for Guilt-Racked Pastor for Raping Congregant's Child After Drugging Her' (17 April 2026).",
"body": "Corroborates the sentencing, describing the victim as the daughter of a congregant, not the defendant's own child, and reporting the drugging as the means of incapacitation before the assault.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Mcdouglas was addressed within his congregation as a 'spiritual father' — a title the court cited directly — and that standing over a church member's family gave him unsupervised access to the member's daughter, whom he then drugged and raped; the operative means was the trust his clerical role commanded over the whole family, not merely the assault itself.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ripplesnigeria.com/pastor-sentenced-to-life-in-jail-for-raping-church-members-daughter/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1e2b230bed36a4bedf1bcde4bcb27985e92b4c73820af7cd4cc7a326a800ed38",
"final_url": "https://www.ripplesnigeria.com/pastor-sentenced-to-life-in-jail-for-raping-church-members-daughter/"
},
{
"source": "https://persecondnews.com/2026/04/17/life-jail-for-guilt-racked-pastor-for-raping-congregants-child-after-drugging-her/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9140d32144d746f3f3803c5394126d3f9ea724384a4841a6c94c56faf7989ae0",
"final_url": "https://persecondnews.com/2026/04/17/life-jail-for-guilt-racked-pastor-for-raping-congregants-child-after-drugging-her/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 902,
"aliases": [
"Alfa Alani Rafiu"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: the court explicitly found Rafiu 'betrayed the trust placed on him as a religious instructor and family friend' — the victim was his own Quranic student, assaulted inside the mosque itself. Clean religious-instructor authority nexus, not a family/paternal case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"slug": "2024-alani-rafiu-ikotun-lagos-nigeria",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ikotun, Lagos State, Nigeria",
"lat": 6.5391,
"lng": 3.2694,
"title": "Nigeria: Islamic cleric sentenced to life imprisonment for defiling his fourteen-year-old Quranic student inside a mosque",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Alfa (Islamic religious instructor)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"authority as the victim's religious instructor and family friend, used to isolate her within the mosque",
"payment to the victim to secure her silence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lagos State Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court, Ikeja, Nigeria",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2024-11-04",
"outcome": "Justice Rahman Oshodi convicted Alani Rafiu of child defilement contrary to the Lagos State Domestic and Sexual Violence Agency Law, 2021, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. Ordered his name registered in the Lagos State Sex Offenders Register."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://punchng.com/cleric-bags-life-jail-for-raping-minor-inside-mosque/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Punch, 'Cleric bags life jail for raping minor inside mosque' (4 November 2024).",
"body": "Reports the Ikeja Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court sentenced Muslim cleric Alani Rafiu to life imprisonment for defiling a 14-year-old girl inside a mosque in Ikotun on 17 August 2021. States the judge held that the gravity of the offence could not be overstated as Rafiu 'betrayed the trust placed on him as a religious instructor and family friend', that he deliberately isolated the victim, exploited her vulnerability and paid her to buy silence; the victim's testimony described three separate incidents.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://dailypost.ng/2024/11/04/cleric-bags-life-imprisonment-for-defiling-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily Post Nigeria, 'Cleric bags life imprisonment for defiling minor' (4 November 2024).",
"body": "Corroborates the conviction, sentence and registration order, confirming Rafiu was arraigned on 28 October 2021 and the offences occurred inside the mosque premises.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court itself named the mechanism: Rafiu was the victim's religious instructor within the mosque and a trusted family friend on that basis, and it was that standing — not mere physical proximity — that let him isolate a 14-year-old student inside the mosque on three separate occasions and then pay her to stay silent.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://punchng.com/cleric-bags-life-jail-for-raping-minor-inside-mosque/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6a8a1876b62defe3d9cb2cd58cc366f977f6cb04b61c0c22d90fcf1a762feed0",
"final_url": "https://punchng.com/cleric-bags-life-jail-for-raping-minor-inside-mosque/"
},
{
"source": "https://dailypost.ng/2024/11/04/cleric-bags-life-imprisonment-for-defiling-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "134586f0fc140afe2437a22e74486f18c924b90be0cba5bdd2b2ec7a18ac7135",
"final_url": "https://dailypost.ng/2024/11/04/cleric-bags-life-imprisonment-for-defiling-minor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 903,
"aliases": [
"Alfa Abdusalam Salaudeen"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: victim was Salaudeen's own five-year-old Arabic/Quranic school pupil, assaulted on the mosque/school premises where he taught her. Institutional religious-instructor authority over his own student, directly analogous to the Sonagazi madrasa-principal precedent already adjudicated IN.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"slug": "2022-abdulsalam-salaudeen-igando-lagos-nigeria",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Igando, Lagos State, Nigeria",
"lat": 6.5644,
"lng": 3.2506,
"title": "Nigeria: Islamic cleric sentenced to life imprisonment for raping his five-year-old Arabic school pupil",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Alfa; proprietor/instructor, Arabic school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional authority as the victim's Quranic/Arabic school teacher",
"access via the mosque/school premises where the child was placed in his care"
],
"organizations": [
"Olorunbabe Mosque Arabic school"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lagos State Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court, Ikeja, Nigeria",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2022-10-26",
"outcome": "Justice Abiola Sholadoye convicted Abdulsalam Salaudeen of defiling his five-year-old female Arabic school pupil and sentenced him to life imprisonment; ordered his name registered in the state Sex Offenders Register."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://fij.ng/article/4-years-after-islamic-cleric-who-raped-his-5-year-old-pupil-jailed-for-life/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FIJ, '4 Years After, Islamic Cleric Who Raped His 5-Year-Old Pupil Jailed for Life' (2022).",
"body": "Reports that Abdulsalam Salaudeen, an Arabic school teacher, was sentenced to life imprisonment for raping his five-year-old pupil at Olorunbabe Mosque, Igando, Lagos, four years after the offence. States the assault came to light via hidden-camera footage installed by suspicious neighbours, and that the defence unsuccessfully claimed he had been the target of an enemy's spell.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://punchng.com/lagos-islamic-cleric-bags-life-imprisonment-for-rape/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Punch, 'Lagos Islamic cleric bags life imprisonment for rape' (26 October 2022).",
"body": "Confirms the Lagos State Sexual Offences and Domestic Violence Court, Ikeja, sentenced Abdulsalam Salaudeen to life imprisonment for the December 2018 rape of his 5-year-old Arabic-school pupil at the Olorunbabe Mosque premises, No. 15 Palace Road, Igando; orders registration in the sex offenders register.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Salaudeen was the victim's Quranic/Arabic school teacher and the assault occurred on the mosque-school premises where her family had placed her in his instructional care — the same institutional religious-authority relationship as other admitted madrasa-principal and Quranic-teacher records in the corpus.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://fij.ng/article/4-years-after-islamic-cleric-who-raped-his-5-year-old-pupil-jailed-for-life/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e498913a4b5163b51653b22703706bf77214ce8b268062e60a50115c3275b6de",
"final_url": "https://fij.ng/article/4-years-after-islamic-cleric-who-raped-his-5-year-old-pupil-jailed-for-life/"
},
{
"source": "https://punchng.com/lagos-islamic-cleric-bags-life-imprisonment-for-rape/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ef949d1e4b544d974727b25ccab8faa52821dfc8a08346970f497e50dda4bf19",
"final_url": "https://punchng.com/lagos-islamic-cleric-bags-life-imprisonment-for-rape/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 904,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: victims were 35 pupils at the defendant's own Islamic school, assaulted by their teacher on school premises. Institutional religious-instructor authority over students, not a family or custodial-only relationship.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"slug": "2019-abubakar-abdullahi-minna-niger-nigeria",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Kontagora, Niger State, Nigeria",
"lat": 10.3999,
"lng": 5.4695,
"title": "Nigeria: Islamic school teacher sentenced to seven years for the anal rape of thirty-five pupils",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Islamic school teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"institutional authority as the pupils' Islamic teacher, used to lure them individually into his room over several months"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Chief Magistrates' Court, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2019-08-05",
"outcome": "Magistrate Hauwa Yusuf convicted Abubakar Abdullahi, 33, on a guilty plea to an unnatural offence contrary to section 284 of the Penal Code, and sentenced him to seven years' imprisonment with hard labour, with an option of a N2 million fine after the first four years."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/more-news/344940-islamic-teacher-jailed-seven-years-for-raping-35-boys.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Premium Times, 'Islamic teacher jailed seven years for raping 35 boys' (5 August 2019).",
"body": "Reports that a Minna Chief Magistrates' Court sentenced Abubakar Abdullahi, 33, a resident of Sabon Gari, Kontagora, to seven years' imprisonment for anal rape of 35 of his pupils, aged 9 to 14, lured individually into his room between March and July that year. States he pleaded guilty and was sentenced under section 284 of the Penal Code (unnatural offence), with an option of a N2 million fine after four years served.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://tribuneonlineng.com/islamic-teacher-jailed-7yrs-for-anal-sex-with-35-boys-in-niger/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tribune Online, 'Islamic teacher jailed 7yrs for anal sex with 35 boys in Niger' (5 August 2019).",
"body": "Corroborates the conviction, guilty plea, and sentence, confirming the pupils were lured into the teacher's room on separate occasions.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Abdullahi's role as the pupils' Islamic teacher gave him routine, unsupervised access to children placed in his instructional care by their families for religious education, which he used systematically over several months to lure 35 boys individually into his room.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/more-news/344940-islamic-teacher-jailed-seven-years-for-raping-35-boys.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a21531bf8652575e9e8df3bd020d52b08b7a9a6eae09f08a805d404df6e96677",
"final_url": "https://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/more-news/344940-islamic-teacher-jailed-seven-years-for-raping-35-boys.html"
},
{
"source": "https://tribuneonlineng.com/islamic-teacher-jailed-7yrs-for-anal-sex-with-35-boys-in-niger/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c43a5f3f4102b4ffad86ed6872b73db0d78983ae67182eb661c20225fdcaac06",
"final_url": "https://tribuneonlineng.com/islamic-teacher-jailed-7yrs-for-anal-sex-with-35-boys-in-niger/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 905,
"aliases": [
"Prophet Olakanye"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "SCOPE REASONING: victim travelled from Lagos specifically seeking Oni's claimed spiritual power to cure her barrenness; he used hypnosis and a purported ritual treatment (inserting a substance into her vagina) as the direct instrument of both the rape and the fatal injury. Clean healing-treatment pretext with the authority as operative means — counterfactual: without the claimed spiritual cure, the victim would not have travelled to him, submitted to isolation in his room, or allowed the internal 'treatment' that killed her.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"slug": "2021-olakanye-oni-ado-ekiti-nigeria",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Ado-Ekiti, Ekiti State, Nigeria",
"lat": 7.6236,
"lng": 5.2213,
"title": "Nigeria: self-styled prophet sentenced to life imprisonment for manslaughter after raping a woman seeking a cure for barrenness",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-acclaimed prophet, Palace of Mercy"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual power to cure infertility, used to lure the victim from Lagos to his church",
"hypnosis, used to render the victim unable to resist",
"a purported ritual treatment (insertion of a substance believed to be potash) used as the direct instrument of assault and fatal injury",
"payment extracted from the victim for the claimed cure"
],
"organizations": [
"Palace of Mercy"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ekiti State High Court, Ado-Ekiti, Nigeria",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2021-07-01",
"outcome": "The Ekiti State High Court convicted self-acclaimed prophet Olakanye Oni of manslaughter and sentenced him to life imprisonment for the death of Gbadamosi Omowale, who died after Oni raped her and inserted a substance believed to be potash into her vagina, causing fatal internal decay."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://guardian.ng/news/prophet-gets-life-imprisonment-for-manslaughter-in-ekiti/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Guardian Nigeria, 'Prophet gets life imprisonment for manslaughter in Ekiti' (1 July 2021).",
"body": "Reports the Ekiti State High Court in Ado-Ekiti sentenced self-acclaimed prophet Olakanye Oni to life imprisonment for the manslaughter of Gbadamosi Omowale, a Lagos resident he invited to his Palace of Mercy church in March 2017 on the pretense of curing her barrenness. States Oni hypnotized the victim, raped her, cleaned her with a handkerchief, and inserted a substance believed to be potash into her vagina, causing decay that led to her death; he had also collected fifty-two thousand naira from her.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2021/07/prophet-bags-life-imprisonment-for-sexual-assault-in-ekiti/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vanguard, 'Prophet bags life imprisonment for sexual assault in Ekiti' (July 2021).",
"body": "Corroborates the conviction and sentence, confirming the victim travelled to Ado-Ekiti specifically seeking a spiritual solution to infertility and died as a result of internal injuries from the assault.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim travelled from Lagos to Ado-Ekiti and placed herself in Oni's private care solely because he claimed spiritual power to cure her barrenness; that claimed power was the entire reason she submitted to being alone with him, and he used it directly as the mechanism of both the rape (via hypnosis) and the fatal injury (the purported ritual insertion of a curative substance).",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://guardian.ng/news/prophet-gets-life-imprisonment-for-manslaughter-in-ekiti/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8e75784dd9cb89003900cc0f0b4ad43d93b1b41314f11ff930c6a52e9023ceb1",
"final_url": "https://guardian.ng/news/prophet-gets-life-imprisonment-for-manslaughter-in-ekiti/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2021/07/prophet-bags-life-imprisonment-for-sexual-assault-in-ekiti/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "413614c1018956c3856fe8c461e2a89fd5a7b5f8408a87a9be1e81ef77f3b50f",
"final_url": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2021/07/prophet-bags-life-imprisonment-for-sexual-assault-in-ekiti/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 906,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Two separate proceedings against the same defendant are treated as one record: the 2022 jury conviction is the primary, appeal-final disposition; the 2023 guilty plea for additional congregational victims is included as a second proceeding within the same record rather than a duplicate.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-colton-albury-nassau-bahamas",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Nassau, Bahamas",
"lat": 25.048,
"lng": -77.3554,
"title": "Bahamas: youth pastor convicted of sexually assaulting a girl taken into his family's care, then jailed again for three more victims",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor",
"church youth ministry leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and youth-ministry authority",
"quasi-familial trust",
"access to minors through church youth programs"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the Bahamas",
"stage": "jury trial verdict and sentencing",
"date": "2022-10-01",
"outcome": "A jury convicted youth pastor Colton Albury of two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse and two counts of indecent assault against a girl whose parents had welcomed him into their family at age 16. Senior Justice Bernard Turner sentenced him to eight years' imprisonment for unlawful sexual intercourse and four years for indecent assault, served concurrently, effective from his July 2022 remand."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Magistrate's Court, Nassau",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2023-09-01",
"outcome": "Before Senior Magistrate Kara Turnquest-Deveaux, Albury pleaded guilty to indecently assaulting three further girls, aged 11, 15 and 17, in 2017, and was sentenced to three years' imprisonment, to run concurrently with the earlier eight-year sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Albury was a youth pastor who used his position leading church youth ministry to gain trust with families and unsupervised access to their daughters; the first victim's parents 'welcomed him into their family' specifically because of his role as their church's youth pastor, and the subsequent victims were girls within the same congregational youth-ministry orbit.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thenassauguardian.com/news/youth-pastor-sentenced-to-three-years-for-indecent-assault-of-three-girls/article_a2b16ab2-6e7b-11ee-951a-93964613ec37.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Nassau Guardian, 'Youth pastor sentenced to three years for indecent assault of three girls' (2023).",
"body": "Reports that youth pastor Colton Albury pleaded guilty before Senior Magistrate Kara Turnquest-Deveaux to indecently assaulting three girls aged 11, 15 and 17 in 2017, receiving a three-year sentence to run concurrently with the eight-year sentence he was already serving for the earlier jury conviction."
},
{
"link": "https://thenassauguardian.com/youth-pastor-convicted-of-sexual-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Nassau Guardian, 'Youth pastor convicted of sexual assault' (2022).",
"body": "Reports the jury's guilty verdict against Colton Albury on two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse and two counts of indecent assault, and Senior Justice Bernard Turner's sentence of eight years and four years to run concurrently, describing how the victim's family took Albury in as a teenager because he was their church's youth pastor."
},
{
"link": "https://www.bahamaspress.com/youth-pastor-makes-jail-again-after-molesting-three-teenshis-total-so-far-is-eight/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bahamas Press, 'Youth pastor makes jail again after molesting three teens...his total so far is eight!' (2023).",
"body": "Local reporting on the same defendant's second sentencing, confirming the concurrent-sentence structure and the total of victims across both proceedings."
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thenassauguardian.com/news/youth-pastor-sentenced-to-three-years-for-indecent-assault-of-three-girls/article_a2b16ab2-6e7b-11ee-951a-93964613ec37.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2d6628fab609f3c5ca0ca0498815db5882a8ca68c3fe702823c41ecfa5e7c9d9",
"final_url": "https://www.thenassauguardian.com/news/youth-pastor-sentenced-to-three-years-for-indecent-assault-of-three-girls/article_a2b16ab2-6e7b-11ee-951a-93964613ec37.html"
},
{
"source": "https://thenassauguardian.com/youth-pastor-convicted-of-sexual-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bahamaspress.com/youth-pastor-makes-jail-again-after-molesting-three-teenshis-total-so-far-is-eight/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2c1a6249b4c51f8f76c1bf25569500dd60a68534c5263c4372d0fcacee59bc95",
"final_url": "https://www.bahamaspress.com/youth-pastor-makes-jail-again-after-molesting-three-teenshis-total-so-far-is-eight/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 907,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Binihi had fourteen days from sentencing to appeal; no appeal outcome located as of this record. First Vanuatu record in the corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-john-binihi-efate-vanuatu",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Efate, Shefa Province, Vanuatu",
"lat": -17.7404,
"lng": 168.3219,
"title": "Vanuatu: pastor convicted by the Supreme Court of repeated indecency against two girls in his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"access to children through congregation and community trust"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Vanuatu",
"stage": "sentencing",
"date": "2026-06-17",
"outcome": "Justice Maree MacKenzie sentenced John Binihi, 28, a pastor, to two years and eleven months' imprisonment after he pleaded guilty to six charges of indecency with a young person involving two girls aged nine to eleven, offending that took place on Efate between 2023 and 2025. The judge found the offending serious given repeated conduct, two victims, and a significant breach of trust, and that this outweighed factors favoring a suspended sentence; the term was backdated to 2025-10-29 to account for time already served."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Binihi held pastoral authority in the community where the two child victims and their families were congregants; the sentencing court expressly identified 'a significant breach of trust' arising from his position as the aggravating basis for a custodial rather than suspended sentence.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sista.com.vu/man-jailed-for-repeated-indecent-conduct-involving-two-children/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sista News (Vanuatu), 'Man jailed for repeated indecent conduct involving two children' (June 2026).",
"body": "Reports the Supreme Court of Vanuatu's sentencing of pastor John Binihi to two years and eleven months' imprisonment for six charges of indecency with a young person, the judge's finding of a significant breach of trust, and the backdating of the sentence to account for time in custody since 29 October 2025."
},
{
"link": "https://www.dailypost.vu/news/man-jailed-for-repeated-indecent-conduct-involving-two-children/article_2bcb38a7-7670-51ea-ac44-45879fcf7ee2.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vanuatu Daily Post, 'Man jailed for repeated indecent conduct involving two children' (June 2026).",
"body": "Corroborating report of the same Supreme Court sentencing, confirming the defendant's role as pastor, the two child victims aged nine and eleven, and the offending period 2023-2025 on Efate."
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sista.com.vu/man-jailed-for-repeated-indecent-conduct-involving-two-children/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4832450684639e08e4a927f5cd72998718af4d6a0f3f1675676d7fe1b9915765",
"final_url": "https://www.sista.com.vu/man-jailed-for-repeated-indecent-conduct-involving-two-children/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.dailypost.vu/news/man-jailed-for-repeated-indecent-conduct-involving-two-children/article_2bcb38a7-7670-51ea-ac44-45879fcf7ee2.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ba26e8a4b30894f817a4b5a4719c9c158ef0637abfc070b7130ddb22ac804c99",
"final_url": "https://www.dailypost.vu/news/man-jailed-for-repeated-indecent-conduct-involving-two-children/article_2bcb38a7-7670-51ea-ac44-45879fcf7ee2.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 908,
"aliases": [
"Avraham Rosenfeld"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Five co-defendant teachers at the same institution received lesser findings (community service and modest compensation orders) in an earlier, separate disposition and are not separately recorded here absent confirmed individual sentencing detail meeting the evidence tier. This record covers only Rosenfeld, whose conviction and 14-year sentence are confirmed as final. First Belz-institutional cheder record and among the few Israeli Haredi records with a judicial (not merely testimonial/hearing-tier) authority-nexus finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-avraham-mordechai-rosenfeld-tel-aviv-israel",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Tel Aviv, Israel",
"lat": 32.0853,
"lng": 34.7818,
"title": "Israel: Belz-affiliated cheder teacher convicted on twenty-three counts for sadistic abuse of young boys at Talmud Torah Machzikei Hadass",
"tradition": "judaism",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"melamed (religious teacher)",
"cheder teacher, Talmud Torah Machzikei Hadass"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"teacher-student religious authority",
"institutional isolation of young children",
"physical intimidation and threats"
],
"organizations": [
"Talmud Torah Machzikei Hadass (Belz-affiliated cheder), Tel Aviv"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tel Aviv District Court",
"stage": "conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2016-10-10",
"outcome": "The court convicted Avraham Mordechai Rosenfeld on twenty-three counts arising from systematic physical and sexual abuse of boys aged seven to eight at the Machzikei Hadass cheder, finding he exploited the dependency and authority relationship between teacher and pupils to inflict cruelty, humiliation and terror. He was sentenced to fourteen years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Rosenfeld was a melamed (religious teacher) at a Belz Hasidic cheder, holding direct religious-instructional authority over children as young as seven inside the institution; the Tel Aviv District Court's own findings state he 'exploited the dependency and authority relationship' between himself and his pupils to commit the abuse, which is the authority nexus itself as a judicial finding rather than an inference.",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.maariv.co.il/news/politics/article-726254",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Maariv (2016) 'עבירות מין בישיבה: הורשע אברהם רוזנפלד, שהואשם בהתעללות מינית בקטינים'. Available at: maariv.co.il (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: 'Sex offenses at a yeshiva: Avraham Rosenfeld, accused of sexual abuse of minors, convicted.'",
"body": "Reports the Tel Aviv District Court conviction of Avraham Rosenfeld, a teacher at the Machzikei Hadass cheder, on charges including sexual abuse of minors."
},
{
"link": "https://www.bhol.co.il/news/1043779",
"archive": "",
"citation": "B'Chadrei Chareidim (2016) 'אברהם מרדכי רוזנפלד הורשע ב-23 אישומים'. Available at: bhol.co.il (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: 'Avraham Mordechai Rosenfeld convicted on 23 counts.'",
"body": "Haredi-press report confirming the twenty-three-count conviction and describing the systematic nature of the abuse against the cheder's young pupils."
},
{
"link": "https://forward.com/news/breaking-news/346711/sexual-abuse-and-beatings-indicted-at-tel-aviv-school/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Forward, 'Sexual Abuse and Beatings Indicted at Tel Aviv School' (2016).",
"body": "English-language reporting on the original indictment of Rosenfeld and five co-defendant teachers at the Belz-affiliated Machzikei Hadass school in Tel Aviv, describing the alleged abuse of 22 preschool and elementary-age boys over more than a decade and the teacher-student authority relationship at issue."
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.maariv.co.il/news/politics/article-726254",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bhol.co.il/news/1043779",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f5c54d1b944b3971a4bdd15358772c609b566985463211034999573ccc9aaf30",
"final_url": "https://www.bhol.co.il/news/1043779"
},
{
"source": "https://forward.com/news/breaking-news/346711/sexual-abuse-and-beatings-indicted-at-tel-aviv-school/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f25b7060742b718b1f93705654ee8482351c7097c8c43988cd0ff13234b33d37",
"final_url": "https://forward.com/fast-forward/346711/sexual-abuse-and-beatings-indicted-at-tel-aviv-school/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 909,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"grace-road-church"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Fiji police forwarded human-trafficking investigation files on Grace Road Group to Fiji's Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions in 2024-2025; as of this record no Fijian criminal conviction has been reported, only an active investigation. This record covers the South Korean conviction only — do not describe this as a conviction that stood in both jurisdictions.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-shin-okju-grace-road-church-fiji-south-korea",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Suwon, South Korea (offenses committed in Fiji)",
"lat": 37.2636,
"lng": 127.0286,
"title": "Grace Road Church: founding pastor convicted after 'threshing floor' beatings and confinement of followers in Fiji",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founding pastor of Grace Road Church",
"self-declared prophetic authority over an end-times relocation to Fiji"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrine of imminent apocalypse used to justify relocation and total obedience",
"'taljak-madang' (threshing floor) ritual beatings framed as exorcising evil spirits",
"passport confiscation of roughly 400 followers relocated to Fiji",
"ordering family members to beat one another 100-200 times with sticks or belts"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Grace Road Church (은혜로교회 / Grace Road Group)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Suwon District Court, South Korea",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2019-07-30",
"outcome": "Shin Ok-ju convicted on charges including special assault, special confinement, fraud, and child abuse/neglect arising from conduct against followers relocated to Fiji; sentenced to 6 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Suwon District Court / appellate division, South Korea",
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2019-11-05",
"outcome": "Sentence increased to 7 years; suspended sentences of two co-defendant accomplices revoked and converted to actual prison terms."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Seoul High Court, South Korea",
"stage": "remand appeal (second cycle, reconsidered charges)",
"outcome": "Court reduced and re-sentenced Shin Ok-ju to 4 years and 6 months alongside custodial sentences for five co-defendant members in January 2025; disposition affirmed a custodial conviction, not an acquittal. Exact day not confirmed in sourcing located this pass; month-level date omitted per schema rule rather than entered as a partial date."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Followers had relocated their lives to a closed compound in Fiji under Shin's doctrine that she alone knew the timing of an apocalyptic judgment on South Korea. Inside that closed system, passports were confiscated and 'threshing floor' beatings — presented as expelling evil spirits — were carried out by and at the direction of the pastor herself; courts found the assaults and confinement were organized through her role as founder and spiritual leader, not incidental church-adjacent violence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://globalnews.ca/news/5717875/korean-cult-leader-sentenced-grace-road/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'South Korean \"cult\" leader gets six years for beating followers in Fiji', Global News (AP), 30 Jul. 2019.",
"body": "Reports the Suwon District Court's July 30, 2019 conviction of Shin Ok-ju on charges of joint injury, special assault, special confinement, fraud, and child abuse/neglect tied to conduct against Grace Road followers relocated to Fiji.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.occrp.org/en/scoop/us-threatens-to-cut-fiji-aid-over-impunity-for-doomsday-cult",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'US Aid to Fiji at Risk Over Impunity for Doomsday Cult', OCCRP, 2025.",
"body": "Describes the 2019/2020 South Korean conviction history and the separate, still-pending Fiji police investigation files sent to the ODPP in 2024-2025 over forced labour and trafficking allegations involving Grace Road members in Fiji.",
"tier": "investigative-journalism",
"kind": "background-and-status-report"
},
{
"link": "http://www.hdjongkyo.co.kr/news/view.html?section=22&category=1004&no=20601",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'[종합]은혜로교회 신옥주, 추가 징역 4년 6개월 확정' (Hyundae Jongkyo / Modern Religion), 2025. Korean: reports the reconsidered-charge sentence of 4 years 6 months for Shin Ok-ju becoming final.",
"body": "Korean-language religious-affairs press report confirming the January 2025 Seoul High Court re-sentencing of Shin Ok-ju to 4 years 6 months, tied to child abuse and assault under the 'taljak-madang' (threshing floor) doctrine.",
"tier": "in-language-specialist-press",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"route": {
"from": [
127.0286,
37.2636
],
"to": [
178.4419,
-18.1416
],
"fromLabel": "Suwon, South Korea",
"toLabel": "Fiji",
"label": "Grace Road Church: South Korea -> Fiji",
"provenance": "AP/Global News reporting states roughly 400 Grace Road followers were relocated from South Korea to a closed compound in Fiji under Shin Ok-ju's end-times doctrine, with passports confiscated on arrival; the Suwon District Court conviction (child abuse/neglect among the counts) and the OCCRP background report both describe this as a body-wide relocation directed by the founding pastor, not individual members' own choice to emigrate. Origin is the corpus record's own gazetteer point (Suwon, where the conviction was entered); destination is Fiji at country level because no specific compound town is named in sourcing. The still-pending Fiji trafficking investigation (noted in the record's scopeNote) is not itself drawn as a second leg — only the established relocation is."
},
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://globalnews.ca/news/5717875/korean-cult-leader-sentenced-grace-road/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "be6cb6631f97a51ef3629ac6c764cc825ac4caaecceda036029e6cfd0c0dfe39",
"final_url": "https://globalnews.ca/news/5717875/korean-cult-leader-sentenced-grace-road/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.occrp.org/en/scoop/us-threatens-to-cut-fiji-aid-over-impunity-for-doomsday-cult",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: investigative-journalism; evidentiary role: background-and-status-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b0dcd8b42b1da8b298820dcbe0d2c392274d5037e92470c293ee7cbb9ff82681",
"final_url": "https://www.occrp.org/en/scoop/us-threatens-to-cut-fiji-aid-over-impunity-for-doomsday-cult"
},
{
"source": "http://www.hdjongkyo.co.kr/news/view.html?section=22&category=1004&no=20601",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: in-language-specialist-press; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "be5157eb7a7400f26cfea6fcfb930a8b34df3739195621fdc8cde0bef43c091b",
"final_url": "http://www.hdjongkyo.co.kr/news/view.html?section=22&category=1004&no=20601"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 910,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [
"durihana-mission"
],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Cheon's public reputation as a humanitarian rescuer of defectors is documented in press coverage but is background, not a claim this record endorses or disputes; the record concerns only the criminal conviction and its finalized sentence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-cheon-kiwon-durihana-school-north-korean-defectors-south-korea",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Seoul, South Korea",
"lat": 37.5665,
"lng": 126.978,
"title": "South Korea: pastor and school founder convicted for molesting North Korean defector students in his care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founding pastor of Durihana Mission",
"principal of the Durihana International School, a residential boarding school for North Korean defector children"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"combined pastoral and school-principal authority over resident defector minors with no other guardian in South Korea",
"public reputation as a rescuer of North Korean defectors ('the Schindler of Asia') used to deflect scrutiny",
"total custodial control inside a residential facility"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Durihana Mission (두리하나 선교회)",
"Durihana International School (두리하나 국제학교)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Seoul (district court), South Korea",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2024-02-14",
"outcome": "Cheon Ki-won convicted of forcible indecent acts (강제추행) against six students across eight incidents between 2016 and 2023; sentenced to 5 years, plus 80 hours of sexual-violence treatment and a 5-year employment ban from child- and youth-related institutions."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Seoul appellate court, South Korea",
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2024-07-16",
"outcome": "5-year sentence affirmed on appeal."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Korea",
"stage": "final appeal",
"date": "2024-11-14",
"outcome": "Supreme Court dismissed the further appeal; the 5-year sentence became final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cheon founded Durihana Mission to smuggle North Korean defectors to safety and ran a residential school for defector minors who had no other guardian in South Korea. His combined identity as pastor and school principal made him the totalizing authority in his students' lives; the court's fact-finding described repeated forcible indecent acts against six students under his direct care between 2016 and 2023.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newspim.com/news/view/20240716000765",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'\\'탈북 청소년 성추행\\' 천기원 목사, 항소심도 징역 5년', Newspim, 16 Jul. 2024. Korean: 'Pastor Cheon Ki-won, accused of molesting North Korean defector youths, receives 5-year sentence on appeal as well.'",
"body": "Reports the appellate court affirming the 5-year trial sentence for Cheon Ki-won, founder/principal of the Durihana International School, over forcible indecent acts against six defector students between 2016 and 2023.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "http://www.t-mhn.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=3584",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'성 범죄자 천기원 목사 대법원서 징역 5년 확정', Mahanaim News, 2024. Korean: 'Sex offender Pastor Cheon Ki-won's 5-year sentence finalized at the Supreme Court.'",
"body": "Reports the Supreme Court's November 14, 2024 dismissal of Cheon Ki-won's final appeal, finalizing the 5-year sentence.",
"tier": "in-language-specialist-press",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newspim.com/news/view/20240716000765",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7bb874e10998305cb2f453f2e547abe0687e2e8249026133182608858d10a249",
"final_url": "https://www.newspim.com/news/view/20240716000765"
},
{
"source": "http://www.t-mhn.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=3584",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: in-language-specialist-press; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d3ae5f253be317315dd766a8fdc4a531ec9b95b62cfc7800e2bcd1998e3b4366",
"final_url": "http://www.t-mhn.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=3584"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 911,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Press reporting locates this at a church-affiliated facility in Suwon in June 2025; no appellate disposition has been reported as of this record, so this is a first-instance conviction only. No appeal news found in this pass — flag for a follow-up check before treating the 5-year sentence as final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-suwon-fake-pastor-child-isolation-cult-south-korea",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Suwon, Gyeonggi Province, South Korea",
"lat": 37.2636,
"lng": 127.0286,
"title": "South Korea: unlicensed 'pastor' and academy director convicted of confining and isolating congregants' children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled church leader who held no formal ordination but presented himself as a pastor",
"co-defendant director of an affiliated private academy (hagwon)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false doctrine used to sever children's family bonds and rename them",
"children told 'your parents abandoned you' and forced to address each other by assigned aliases",
"confinement in an unheated space beneath the church's basement stairwell as isolation/discipline",
"communal living structure that cut off contact between children and their own church-member parents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Suwon District Court, South Korea",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2025-06-19",
"outcome": "Church leader Lee (이) and academy director Kwon (권) each convicted under the Child Welfare Act (habitual abuse) and sentenced to 5 years; academy instructor Kim (김) convicted and sentenced to 2 years. Lee and Kwon received 10-year, Kim a 5-year, bans from employment at child-related institutions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court found Lee held no genuine pastoral credential but used the pretense of pastoral authority and self-devised doctrine to convince congregant families to surrender their children into communal group living, then used that same claimed authority to isolate, rename, and confine the children as a means of control and, the court found, for the group's economic benefit.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kidok.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=502607",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'\"신도 자녀 학대했다\" 학원장ㆍ가짜목사 징역 5년', 주간기독신문 (Weekly Christian Newspaper), 2025. Korean: '\"Abused congregants\\' children\" — academy director and fake pastor sentenced to 5 years.'",
"body": "Reports the Suwon District Court's June 19, 2025 conviction and sentencing of the self-styled pastor and an affiliated academy director for habitual child abuse, including confinement in a space beneath the church's basement stairs and coerced estrangement from parents.",
"tier": "in-language-specialist-press",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kidok.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=502607",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: in-language-specialist-press; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fb013011466aa0e3dbadc0000cec621a682e46266c01f9ea44aed3ea538f8aa3",
"final_url": "https://www.kidok.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=502607"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 912,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Shinto has no dedicated traditionDetailId in this schema (per project convention: indigenous-spiritual or northern-traditional only if genuinely apt, otherwise nrm-other with an explanatory note). Samuhara Shrine is independent of the mainstream Association of Shinto Shrines (神社本庁) and was noted by at least one commentator as a post-war new religious movement organized as a shrine rather than a historic Shinto institution — this is disputed/unclear from available sourcing and is flagged rather than asserted. traditionDetailId nrm-other is used accordingly rather than a claim of mainstream Shinto affiliation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-kawabata-samuhara-shrine-osaka-japan",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Osaka, Japan",
"lat": 34.6937,
"lng": 135.5023,
"title": "Japan: Shinto shrine priest convicted of indecent acts against worshippers during prayer rites",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"negi (priest) of Samuhara Shrine, Osaka"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"use of the kito (purification/prayer) ritual posture, in which the worshipper sits still with eyes closed, to touch victims with sacred implements and hands without immediate refusal being possible",
"worshippers' trust in the ritual setting exploited to prevent resistance during the rite itself"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Samuhara Shrine (サムハラ神社)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Osaka District Court (5th Criminal Division, Section 2), Japan",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2021-06-18",
"outcome": "Kawabata Takakazu, priest of Samuhara Shrine, convicted of quasi-forcible indecent assault (準強制わいせつ罪) against women who came to the shrine for prayer between December 2020 and January 2021; sentenced to 2 years' imprisonment, suspended for 4 years. He had separately paid settlement compensation to three named victims (700,000 yen to one, 500,000 yen each to two others)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims came to the shrine specifically for kito prayer rites performed by the priest; the court found he used the ritual's required stillness and physical closeness — pressing sacred implements against worshippers' bodies while they sat in the prescribed prayer posture — as the means of the assault, exploiting trust in the rite itself rather than force or threat.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bunshun.jp/articles/-/43217",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'「祈祷中、胸や尻を神具でグリグリ」神社神職が参拝客にわいせつ逮捕', Bunshun Online, 2021. Japanese: 'Shrine priest arrested for indecent acts against worshippers, pressing sacred implements into their chests and buttocks during prayer.'",
"body": "Reports the arrest of the Samuhara Shrine priest on suspicion of quasi-forcible indecent assault during kito prayer rites at the Osaka shrine.",
"tier": "national-magazine-investigative-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
},
{
"link": "https://rirc.or.jp/database/?rircdb=90-17615",
"archive": "",
"citation": "宗教情報リサーチセンター (Religious Information Research Center) database entry, 2021. Japanese: summary of the Samuhara Shrine indecent-assault arrest.",
"body": "Specialist religious-affairs database entry recording the arrest date (January 25, 2021), location, and nature of the allegations against the shrine priest.",
"tier": "in-language-specialist-database",
"kind": "case-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bunshun.jp/articles/-/43217",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-magazine-investigative-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a77f1e97082c4bd9d4d08ea435755162d4d375dbd8b8f14cd4cd21cf77dd6be3",
"final_url": "https://bunshun.jp/articles/-/43217"
},
{
"source": "https://rirc.or.jp/database/?rircdb=90-17615",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: in-language-specialist-database; evidentiary role: case-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "31334472b778afcf20c21de366749e3853309b4b23a8fb691934dd43d41ba866",
"final_url": "https://rirc.or.jp/database/?rircdb=90-17615"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 913,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Defendant's name was not given in the two specialist sources located in this pass (only 'a male prayer healer from Shinchi Town'); if a named source is later found it should be added. No appellate disposition located in this pass — flag as a first-instance conviction only pending confirmation the sentence stood; nine years is an unusually severe fraud sentence and worth re-verifying against a second source before treating as final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-shinchi-prayer-fraud-fukushima-japan",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Shinchi, Fukushima Prefecture, Japan",
"lat": 37.8511,
"lng": 140.9219,
"title": "Japan: prayer healer convicted of defrauding clients of 130 million yen through purported spiritual consultations",
"tradition": "nrm",
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-other",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled kitoshi (prayer healer/spiritual consultant)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual insight into clients' personal misfortunes used to solicit escalating payments",
"exploitation of clients' vulnerability (documented as targeting people in personal crisis) across repeated consultations"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prosperity-divination",
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sendai District Court, Japan",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2009-12-11",
"outcome": "Defendant, a self-styled prayer healer (祈祷師) from Shinchi, Fukushima Prefecture, convicted of fraud against 11 victims across Fukushima, Miyagi, and Kanagawa prefectures, defrauding them of approximately 130 million yen between December 2005 and January 2009; sentenced to 9 years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant presented himself to clients as a prayer healer able to perceive and resolve the spiritual causes of their personal misfortunes. Reporting describes him exploiting the vulnerability of clients who came to him in that capacity across repeated consultations, extracting an escalating total of roughly 130 million yen over more than three years — the fraud was executed through, not incidental to, his claimed spiritual role.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://rirc.or.jp/database/?rircdb=6660",
"archive": "",
"citation": "宗教情報リサーチセンター (Religious Information Research Center) database entry, citing 読売新聞・宮城版 and 福島民友, 12 Dec. 2009. Japanese: '祈祷詐欺に懲役9年の判決' ('9-year sentence for prayer fraud').",
"body": "Specialist religious-affairs database entry summarizing the Sendai District Court's December 11, 2009 conviction and 9-year sentence of a self-styled prayer healer from Shinchi, Fukushima, for defrauding 11 victims of roughly 130 million yen between December 2005 and January 2009.",
"tier": "in-language-specialist-database",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://rirc.or.jp/database/?rircdb=6660",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: in-language-specialist-database; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cbced1eea8815f4e936d40515d12ee2c383cf5554c1708b830c7703709eefcde",
"final_url": "https://rirc.or.jp/database/?rircdb=6660"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 914,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-luis-esteban-zavala-irapuato-guanajuato-mexico",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Irapuato, Guanajuato, Mexico",
"lat": 20.6767,
"lng": -101.3556,
"title": "Mexico: priest sentenced to 65 years for raping a girl during catechism classes",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Templo de Nuestra Señora de la Soledad, Irapuato"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priest's authority as catechism instructor over a child preparing for sacraments",
"access to the victim through parish religious instruction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Poder Judicial del Estado de Guanajuato, Irapuato",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-01-29",
"outcome": "Luis Esteban Zavala Rodríguez, priest of the Temple of Our Lady of Solitude in downtown Irapuato, was sentenced to 65 years and three months in prison for aggravated rape and corruption of a minor, after abusing a 12-year-old girl he was giving catechism classes to between April and June 2019. He was ordered to pay damages to the victim and her mother. Press reported he was the third priest of the Diocese of Irapuato prosecuted for sexual crimes against minors in under three years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest's authority as catechism instructor — the role that placed the victim in his direct, unsupervised care — was the means of access and control; the abuse occurred during the sacramental-preparation classes themselves.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/2021/1/29/por-violacion-corrupcion-de-menores-dan-65-anos-de-prision-al-cura-luis-esteban-zavala-257319.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Proceso (2021) 'Por violación y corrupción de menores, dan 65 años de prisión al cura Luis Esteban Zavala'.",
"body": "'El ex párroco del Templo de Nuestra Señora de la Soledad... cometió los delitos en contra de la menor entre abril y junio de 2019, mientras le impartía clases de catecismo.' English gloss: The former pastor of the Temple of Our Lady of Solitude committed the crimes against the minor between April and June 2019, while giving her catechism classes.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sinembargo.mx/3931688/cura-es-condenado-a-65-anos-de-prision-por-haber-abusado-de-menor-que-asistia-a-catecismo-en-irapuato/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SinEmbargo MX (2021) 'Cura es condenado a 65 años de prisión por haber abusado de menor que asistía a catecismo en Irapuato'.",
"body": "'Luis Esteban Zavala es el tercer sacerdote de la Diócesis de Irapuato en ser procesado por delitos sexuales contra menores en menos de tres años.' English gloss: Luis Esteban Zavala is the third priest of the Diocese of Irapuato prosecuted for sexual crimes against minors in under three years.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/2021/1/29/por-violacion-corrupcion-de-menores-dan-65-anos-de-prision-al-cura-luis-esteban-zavala-257319.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f2ee358d7a37237da17e5c7de0a9ef359bb346ce800aae9d1b5b6bd87cbfd82",
"final_url": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/2021/1/29/por-violacion-corrupcion-de-menores-dan-65-anos-de-prision-al-cura-luis-esteban-zavala-257159.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sinembargo.mx/3931688/cura-es-condenado-a-65-anos-de-prision-por-haber-abusado-de-menor-que-asistia-a-catecismo-en-irapuato/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 915,
"aliases": [
"Genaro \"N\"",
"Genaro H.F."
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2023-11-22",
"note": "Defendant appealed the 50-year sentence after losing his initial acquittal on appeal; outcome of that further appeal not confirmed in available sources."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The defendant's further appeal against the 50-year sentence had not been resolved as of the most recent available reporting (November 2023); the appellate reversal of the original acquittal and conviction order is treated here as the operative finding of guilt.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-genaro-hf-kantunilkin-quintana-roo-mexico",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Kantunilkín, Lázaro Cárdenas, Quintana Roo, Mexico",
"lat": 21.1167,
"lng": -87.4667,
"title": "Mexico: pastor's acquittal reversed on appeal; 50-year sentence imposed for abusing his hierarchical position over a 12-year-old congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of an evangelical church in an indigenous Maya community, Kantunilkín"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastor's hierarchical/moral authority in a small community where he was regarded as unimpeachable",
"community disbelief of the victim's mother because of the pastor's standing"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Poder Judicial de Quintana Roo",
"stage": "trial acquittal reversed on appeal; conviction ordered and imposed",
"date": "2023-11-22",
"outcome": "A control judge initially acquitted the pastor in February 2022, characterizing the acts against a 12-year-old girl as consensual. The victim's mother appealed with support from the women's organization Mujer Libre MX Fuerza Ixchel. In December 2022 the appellate Penal Court found sufficient elements to establish responsibility for rape given the pastor's age and hierarchical position relative to the child, and ordered the control judge to issue a conviction. The control judge imposed the maximum sentence of 50 years in prison. The defendant filed a further appeal against the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The appellate court itself grounded liability in 'his hierarchical position relative to the child' — the pastor's standing as community religious authority was the factor that (a) let him isolate the victim and (b) made her family's initial complaint be disbelieved by the community.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.milenio.com/policia/pastor-condenado-50-anos-violacion-quintana-roo",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Milenio (2023) 'Ex pastor condenado a 50 años por violación en Quintana Roo'.",
"body": "'El sentenciado abusó de su investidura eclesiástica para cometer los delitos, ocurridos el 7 y 18 de diciembre de 2019 en Kantunilkín.' English gloss: The convicted man abused his ecclesiastical standing to commit the crimes, which occurred on December 7 and 18, 2019 in Kantunilkín.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://estamosaqui.mx/2023/11/22/pastor-de-iglesia-de-comunidad-indigena-en-quintana-roo-es-sentenciado-a-50-anos-por-violacion-pero-apelara/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "EstamosAquí MX (2023) 'Pastor de iglesia de comunidad indígena en Quintana Roo es sentenciado a 50 años por violación, pero apelará'.",
"body": "'El Tribunal de Alzada determinó que existían elementos suficientes para acreditar la responsabilidad de Genaro en el delito de violación, tomando en cuenta su edad y posición jerárquica frente a la niña.' English gloss: The appellate court determined there were sufficient elements to establish Genaro's responsibility for rape, taking into account his age and hierarchical position relative to the girl.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "case-narrative"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2023-11-22",
"note": "Defendant appealed the 50-year sentence after losing his initial acquittal on appeal; outcome of that further appeal not confirmed in available sources."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.milenio.com/policia/pastor-condenado-50-anos-violacion-quintana-roo",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "852a7ffff93d99b2fce69daebeaf69d7862107a21ef87c874f521583e51110fa",
"final_url": "https://www.milenio.com/policia/pastor-condenado-50-anos-violacion-quintana-roo"
},
{
"source": "https://estamosaqui.mx/2023/11/22/pastor-de-iglesia-de-comunidad-indigena-en-quintana-roo-es-sentenciado-a-50-anos-por-violacion-pero-apelara/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: case-narrative.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 916,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-evandro-baptista-dourados-mato-grosso-do-sul-brazil",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Dourados, Mato Grosso do Sul, Brazil",
"lat": -22.2211,
"lng": -54.8056,
"title": "Brazil: pastor convicted of using overnight 'spiritual healing' prayer sessions to sexually violate four congregants by fraud",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor conducting overnight prayer meetings, Dourados"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual doctrine that sexual contact ('a passagem do varão') transmitted healing vital energy",
"late-night prayer meetings staged to isolate congregants",
"sexual violation by fraud premised on false spiritual necessity"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "3ª Vara Criminal de Dourados, Mato Grosso do Sul (Juiz Pedro Henrique Freitas de Paula)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-07-03",
"outcome": "Evandro Luiz Baptista, 53, was convicted of one count of sexual violation by fraud and three counts of sexual harassment against four women aged 20-40, and sentenced to six years and eight months in semi-open regime, plus damages of at least R$10,000 to each victim. The court found he conducted overnight prayer meetings where, speaking in tongues, he convinced the faithful that intercourse with him was necessary to transmit vital energy and produce spiritual healing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The conviction rests explicitly on sexual violation 'by fraud' — the pastor's claimed prophetic/healing authority is what the court found made the victims' consent legally vitiated; without the doctrinal claim the acts would not have occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.campograndenews.com.br/cidades/interior/pastor-e-condenado-a-6-anos-por-abusos-em-nome-de-cura-espiritual",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Campo Grande News (2025) 'Pastor é condenado a 6 anos por abusos em nome de \"cura espiritual\"'.",
"body": "'...convenceu fiéis de que a passagem do varão era necessária para transmitir energia vital e promover cura espiritual.' English gloss: ...convinced the faithful that the passage of the male was necessary to transmit vital energy and promote spiritual healing.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.campograndenews.com.br/cidades/interior/pastor-e-condenado-a-6-anos-por-abusos-em-nome-de-cura-espiritual",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4bb96113596cec5d52bcee3d3c253f818f43e3a9a6f46e3ebe48b2d9438c0bcc",
"final_url": "https://www.campograndenews.com.br/cidades/interior/pastor-e-condenado-a-6-anos-por-abusos-em-nome-de-cura-espiritual"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 917,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The perpetrator's full name was not published in the available press reporting, which withheld identifying details typical of Brazilian juvenile-victim cases; case is identified by location and the arresting operation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-pastor-macapa-amapa-brazil",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Macapá, Amapá, Brazil",
"lat": -0.0389,
"lng": -51.0664,
"title": "Brazil: pastor convicted of raping a ten-year-old congregant, arrested as a fugitive after four years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Perpétuo Socorro neighborhood, Macapá"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ministerial position and residence adjoining the church used to draw children into his room",
"grooming with sweets and 'religious films' framed as church activity",
"administration of contraceptive medication and threats to maintain silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Poder Judiciário do Amapá",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; arrested as a fugitive",
"date": "2026-05-05",
"outcome": "A 51-year-old pastor was sentenced to 12 years and 5 months in closed regime for the aggravated rape of a 10-year-old girl who attended his church in 2020; he evaded arrest for four years before being located living behind the church in the Perpétuo Socorro neighborhood of Macapá and taken into custody on 5 May 2026. Police said he used his ministerial position and offered candy and religious films to draw children to his room; a second child, aged 7, was also identified as a possible victim."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Reporting on the ministerial-authority mechanism is explicit: 'usava posição ministerial para abusar sexualmente de criança' (he used his ministerial position to sexually abuse a child) — the victim was a congregant drawn in through church-branded activity, not a relative.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.diariodoamapa.com.br/cadernos/policia/pastor-usava-posicao-ministerial-para-abusar-sexualmente-de-crianca/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Diário do Amapá (2026) 'Pastor usava posição ministerial para abusar sexualmente de criança'.",
"body": "'Ele oferecia guloseimas, como bombons, pipoca e refrigerantes, e convidava as crianças para assistirem a filmes religiosos em seu aposento.' English gloss: He offered treats such as candy, popcorn and soft drinks, and invited the children to watch religious films in his room.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "arrest-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cleidefreires.com.br/pastor-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-e-preso-pela-policia-civil-no-perpetuo-socorro/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cleide Freires (2026) 'Pastor condenado por estupro de vulnerável é preso pela Polícia Civil no Perpétuo Socorro'.",
"body": "Reports the 12-year, 5-month sentence and the four-year fugitive period before arrest in the Perpétuo Socorro neighborhood of Macapá.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.diariodoamapa.com.br/cadernos/policia/pastor-usava-posicao-ministerial-para-abusar-sexualmente-de-crianca/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: arrest-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e19818d1a91958322b086dfa571a08cee870c210535ba70982b2e45114a1c4fc",
"final_url": "https://www.diariodoamapa.com.br/cadernos/policia/pastor-usava-posicao-ministerial-para-abusar-sexualmente-de-crianca/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cleidefreires.com.br/pastor-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-e-preso-pela-policia-civil-no-perpetuo-socorro/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a2fe7596a18ba72b25b946cb87012780f754f7e76a06c2ae94753db3d9c5aba6",
"final_url": "https://www.cleidefreires.com.br/pastor-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-e-preso-pela-policia-civil-no-perpetuo-socorro/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 918,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-nelson-santiago-colon-santa-isabel-puerto-rico",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Santa Isabel and Ponce, Puerto Rico",
"lat": 17.9656,
"lng": -66.4056,
"title": "Puerto Rico: pastor sentenced to 40 years federal for abusing church-vehicle-washing pretext to assault minor congregants",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Iglesia Cristiana Peniel, Santa Isabel"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral trust and access exploited by luring congregant minors with promised chores/payment",
"victims' own stated paralysis at 'seeing their pastor capable' of the abuse"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the District of Puerto Rico (Judge Aida M. Delgado Colón)",
"stage": "federal conviction and sentence",
"date": "2014-11-17",
"outcome": "Nelson Santiago Colón, 50, former pastor of Iglesia Cristiana Peniel in Santa Isabel, was sentenced to 40 years imprisonment plus 15 years of supervised release for sexually abusing three minors aged 12-16 between 2004 and 2011, having lured them under the pretense of washing the church vehicle for payment. Thirty additional state-level charges were pending in Ponce covering a fourth victim."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The prosecutor's characterization — victims 'were surprised and paralyzed seeing their pastor capable' of the abuse — states directly that it was his status as their pastor, not merely personal acquaintance, that disabled resistance and disclosure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/policia-tribunales/notas/pastor-sentenciado-a-40-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-menores/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Primera Hora (2014) 'Pastor sentenciado a 40 años de cárcel por violar a menores'.",
"body": "'...las víctimas quedaron sorprendidas y paralizadas al ver a su pastor capaz de' cometer el abuso. English gloss: the victims were surprised and paralyzed seeing their pastor capable of committing the abuse.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/policia-tribunales/notas/pastor-sentenciado-a-40-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-menores/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f8bd6756ea89663fe59077ee5724f0a987f772061eb0699aa5bfc179406b3e2e",
"final_url": "https://www.primerahora.com/noticias/policia-tribunales/notas/pastor-sentenciado-a-40-anos-de-carcel-por-violar-a-menores/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 919,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-floyd-mccoy-jordan-hormigueros-mayaguez-puerto-rico",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Hormigueros and Mayagüez, Puerto Rico",
"lat": 18.1428,
"lng": -67.1264,
"title": "Puerto Rico: priest convicted of lewd acts against a minor at the Santuario de la Monserrate, court cites his 'relación de superioridad' of religious leadership",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest, Santuario de la Monserrate, Hormigueros"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"court finding of a 'relación de superioridad de liderazgo de creencia religiosa' (relationship of superiority through religious-belief leadership)",
"harassment via phone calls and text messages"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Mayagüez, Puerto Rico (Judge Aixa Rosado Pietri)",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-06-01",
"outcome": "Floyd McCoy Jordán, then serving at the Basílica Menor Nuestra Señora de Monserrate in Hormigueros, was found guilty of committing lewd acts against a minor under 14 between 2013 and 2014, and sentenced to 15 years in prison. The court's sentencing findings expressly invoked the priest's 'relationship of superiority' arising from his religious leadership."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's own sentencing language names the mechanism: the priest 'aprovechándose de su víctima por existir una relación de superioridad de liderazgo de creencia religiosa' — took advantage of the victim because a relationship of superiority through religious-belief leadership existed.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.univision.com/local/puerto-rico-wlii/condenan-en-puerto-rico-a-15-anos-a-sacerdote-por-actos-lascivos",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Univision Puerto Rico (2024) 'Condenan en Puerto Rico a 15 años a sacerdote por actos lascivos'.",
"body": "'...aprovechándose de su víctima por existir una relación de superioridad de liderazgo de creencia religiosa.' English gloss: ...taking advantage of his victim because a relationship of superiority through religious-belief leadership existed.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.univision.com/local/puerto-rico-wlii/condenan-en-puerto-rico-a-15-anos-a-sacerdote-por-actos-lascivos",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7545fdc08afcd7c0b0e709d54715951c3adcd3ae504069ca32e9877e4f22fba8",
"final_url": "https://www.univision.com/local/puerto-rico-wste/condenan-en-puerto-rico-a-15-anos-a-sacerdote-por-actos-lascivos"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 920,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-cristian-bogantes-perez-paraiso-cartago-costa-rica",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Paraíso, Cartago, Costa Rica",
"lat": 9.8394,
"lng": -83.8664,
"title": "Costa Rica: pastor sentenced to eight years for grooming a 14-year-old congregant through church-linked messaging",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor of the victim's church, Paraíso"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral position used to initiate contact through messages",
"trust built through his church role, used to arrange meetings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Penal de Cartago, Costa Rica",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-10-15",
"outcome": "Cristian Bogantes Pérez was found responsible for two counts of sexual abuse against a 14-year-old member of the congregation he pastored, and sentenced to eight years in prison. The court found he used his position as the victim's pastor to contact her through messages and arrange the meetings in Paraíso where the abuse occurred."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a member of the congregation Bogantes pastored; his position as her pastor — not a prior personal or family relationship — was the channel through which contact and trust were built.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ministeriopublico.poder-judicial.go.cr/index.php/medios-informativos/noticias-judiciales/2020/paraiso-pastor-sentenciado-a-ocho-anos-de-carcel-por-abusos-sexuales",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público de Costa Rica (2020) 'Paraíso: pastor sentenciado a ocho años de cárcel por abusos sexuales'.",
"body": "Official prosecutorial release describing the pastor's use of his church position and messaging to contact and abuse the 14-year-old congregant.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.crhoy.com/nacionales/condenan-a-pastor-de-iglesia-por-abuso-sexual-contra-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CRHoy (2020) 'Condenan a pastor de iglesia por abuso sexual contra menor'.",
"body": "Reports the eight-year sentence and confirms the pastor exploited his position and trust gained with the minor congregant.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ministeriopublico.poder-judicial.go.cr/index.php/medios-informativos/noticias-judiciales/2020/paraiso-pastor-sentenciado-a-ocho-anos-de-carcel-por-abusos-sexuales",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.crhoy.com/nacionales/condenan-a-pastor-de-iglesia-por-abuso-sexual-contra-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5f01765637f41f1541badfe982d2bd242ba13cd360566be9c380e89cd3aa67ee",
"final_url": "https://www.crhoy.com/nacionales/condenan-a-pastor-de-iglesia-por-abuso-sexual-contra-menor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 921,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"note": "Affirmed by the Sala Tercera de la Corte Suprema de Justicia, cassation sentence 00791-2023 — final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-ronaldo-arce-diaz-heredia-costa-rica",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Heredia, Costa Rica",
"lat": 10.0024,
"lng": -84.1165,
"title": "Costa Rica: pastor's 34-year sentence for abusing a teenage congregant confirmed through the Supreme Court's criminal cassation chamber",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Heredia congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a congregant beginning when she was 14",
"access through church activities including a church trip to Limón"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Penal, first instance; Tribunal de Apelación de Sentencia Penal, III Circuito Judicial de Alajuela, San Ramón; Sala Tercera de la Corte Suprema de Justicia (cassation)",
"stage": "conviction, appeal and cassation all affirmed",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "Ronaldo Adolfo Arce Díaz, then 55, was found guilty on 28 November 2022 of three counts of sexual abuse, one count of aggravated rape and one attempted aggravated rape against a girl who was 14-15 at the time, with incidents occurring at his home and during a church trip to Limón, and was sentenced to 34 years. The Court of Appeal (resolution 00459-2023) and the Supreme Court's Third Chamber (cassation sentence 00791-2023) both affirmed the conviction and sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a member of Arce Díaz's congregation and the abuse occurred both at his home and during a church-organized trip — the pastoral relationship supplied both the access and the pretext for unsupervised contact.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nexuspj.poder-judicial.go.cr/document/sen-1-0034-1156335",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Poder Judicial de Costa Rica, Tribunal de Apelación de Sentencia Penal III Circuito Judicial de Alajuela, resolución 00459-2023.",
"body": "Appellate resolution affirming the conviction of Ronaldo Adolfo Arce Díaz for sexual abuse and aggravated rape of a minor congregant, confirming the 34-year sentence.",
"tier": "court-record",
"kind": "appellate-decision"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassation",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"note": "Affirmed by the Sala Tercera de la Corte Suprema de Justicia, cassation sentence 00791-2023 — final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nexuspj.poder-judicial.go.cr/document/sen-1-0034-1156335",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-record; evidentiary role: appellate-decision.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d8b7a7fa2b4c66ea97ad56ca206482e1fab0bde8bda54f982a0e3608b525140c",
"final_url": "https://nexuspj.poder-judicial.go.cr/document/sen-1-0034-1156335"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 922,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-aristides-rodriguez-otero-gualaca-chiriqui-panama",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Gualaca, Chiriquí, Panama",
"lat": 8.5522,
"lng": -82.1725,
"title": "Panama: priest convicted of raping a five-year-old parish child, sentenced to 30 years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Nuestra Señora de Los Ángeles church, Gualaca district"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish-priest access to a very young child of the congregation",
"position within a rural parish community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Juicio de la provincia de Chiriquí, Panama",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-08-19",
"outcome": "Ex-priest Arístides Rodríguez Otero, formerly of the Nuestra Señora de Los Ángeles parish in the Gualaca district, was convicted of aggravated rape, indecent acts and obscene exhibition against a child then five years old, and sentenced to 30 years in prison. He had been suspended from ministry by the Diocese of David during the investigation, which began in April 2021 and added further charges through late 2021 before trial."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child of the Gualaca parish the priest served; the diocese itself suspended him during the investigation, and the abuse took place through his position of unsupervised access to parish children.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.prensa.com/provincias/condenan-a-30-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-por-violacion-y-actos-libidinosos/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "La Prensa Panamá (2023) 'Condenan a 30 años de prisión a sacerdote por violación y actos libidinosos'.",
"body": "Reports the Chiriquí trial court's conviction of ex-priest Arístides Rodríguez Otero and 30-year sentence for aggravated rape and indecent acts against a child of his Gualaca parish.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.diaadia.com.pa/el-pais/sacerdote-separado-enfrenta-la-justicia-por-presuntos-delitos-sexuales-contra-un-nino-en",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Día a Día (2021) 'Sacerdote separado enfrenta la justicia por presuntos delitos sexuales contra un niño en Gualaca'.",
"body": "Confirms the priest's suspension from the Diocese of David and the Gualaca parish location during the initial investigation phase.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.prensa.com/provincias/condenan-a-30-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-por-violacion-y-actos-libidinosos/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2cb5f1838a3def506f4e871e8d3300e19b809fcbd5e369a00b4f2923bad9d7a9",
"final_url": "https://www.prensa.com/provincias/condenan-a-30-anos-de-prision-a-sacerdote-por-violacion-y-actos-libidinosos/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.diaadia.com.pa/el-pais/sacerdote-separado-enfrenta-la-justicia-por-presuntos-delitos-sexuales-contra-un-nino-en",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "993e329d2740a08116bcb5c84837f068194d2fc6cd755ad2d9f951eb72123b9e",
"final_url": "https://www.diaadia.com.pa/el-pais/sacerdote-separado-enfrenta-la-justicia-por-presuntos-delitos-sexuales-contra-un-nino-en"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 923,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The exact final sentence length was not confirmed in available reporting beyond the trial verdict of guilt and the statutory ranges; treated as convicted on the strength of the public-trial guilty finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-willie-sudia-gomez-puerto-lempira-la-ceiba-honduras",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Puerto Lempira, Gracias a Dios, and La Ceiba, Atlántida, Honduras",
"lat": 15.2667,
"lng": -83.7833,
"title": "Honduras: Miskito community pastor convicted of trafficking and aggravated rape of a 15-year-old he took from her family under promise of paid childcare work",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described leader of the Miskito community and evangelical church pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and community-leader standing used to persuade a low-income family to release their daughter into his care",
"false promise of paid work and schooling",
"physical violence and threats to secure compliance and silence"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Sentencia de La Ceiba, Fiscalía Regional del Litoral Atlántico, Honduras",
"stage": "convicted at public trial; sentence individualization hearing scheduled",
"date": "2022-12-09",
"outcome": "Willie Sudia Gómez, who presented himself as a Miskito community leader and evangelical pastor, was found guilty at public trial of human trafficking (exploitation under conditions of slavery/servitude) and aggravated rape of a 15-year-old girl. He had persuaded her family in Puerto Lempira in June 2021 to let her accompany him to La Ceiba for paid childcare work and schooling; she received no pay, was beaten, and was raped in early August 2021. Under the applicable code, trafficking carries 8-10 years and aggravated rape 13 years 4 months-17 years; a sentencing hearing was set for 9 December 2022."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant's standing as pastor and self-described community leader was the specific credential he invoked to obtain the family's trust and release of the child into his custody — the operative means by which the trafficking and subsequent rape were made possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-por-trata-de-personas-y-violacion-agravada/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ministerio Público de Honduras (2022) 'Condenan a pastor evangélico por trata de personas y violación agravada'.",
"body": "'...quien dijo ser líder de la comunidad misquita y pastor de una iglesia evangélica, viajó a la ciudad de Puerto Lempira en junio de 2021.' English gloss: ...who said he was a leader of the Miskito community and pastor of an evangelical church, traveled to the city of Puerto Lempira in June 2021.",
"tier": "official-prosecutor-release",
"kind": "conviction-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.enlaplaza.hn/portada/pastor-evangelico-condenado-por-trata-de-personas-y-violacion-agravada/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "En La Plaza (2022) 'Pastor evangélico condenado por trata de personas y violación agravada'.",
"body": "Confirms the trial conviction and reports the scheduled sentencing hearing of 9 December 2022 in La Ceiba.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "conviction-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-por-trata-de-personas-y-violacion-agravada/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "85bb4391735c659138c04a483b3bc79da793e4d3423d41b7d64c86df724769b2",
"final_url": "https://www.mp.hn/publicaciones/condenan-a-pastor-evangelico-por-trata-de-personas-y-violacion-agravada/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.enlaplaza.hn/portada/pastor-evangelico-condenado-por-trata-de-personas-y-violacion-agravada/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "de6db7135954dafb345e918a560fe09020fc156bcfbbc47418be2130a61a5996",
"final_url": "https://www.enlaplaza.hn/portada/pastor-evangelico-condenado-por-trata-de-personas-y-violacion-agravada/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 924,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims are minors, not identified. Sourced from Kompas Regional, IDN Times and Banjarmasin Tribunnews, all citing the Martapura District Court verdict directly. The defendant is named in full in national press (Ropi'i); initials are also used in some outlets.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-ropii-pesantren-martapura-indonesia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Martapura, Banjar, South Kalimantan, Indonesia",
"lat": -3.4167,
"lng": 114.85,
"title": "Indonesia: pesantren leader's 12-year sentence for abusing santri under a bad-luck-removal ritual pretext",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pengasuh (caretaker/leader) of Pondok Pesantren Nurul Ilmi, Martapura"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial and teacher authority over resident santri",
"a claimed 'buang sial' (bad-luck-removal) ritual used as the pretext for contact"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"organizations": [
"Pondok Pesantren Nurul Ilmi, Martapura"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Martapura, Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-07-24",
"outcome": "Ropi'i (42), pengasuh of Pondok Pesantren Nurul Ilmi in Martapura, Kabupaten Banjar, South Kalimantan, was sentenced on 24 July 2025 to 12 years' imprisonment plus a Rp 200 million fine (2 months' further detention in default), below the prosecution's request of 14 years, for repeatedly abusing resident female students from 2019 to 2025 under the pretext of a ritual to 'remove bad luck'; at least 20 santri were alleged victims, with five identified in the charged counts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Resident students under a pesantren leader's custodial and religious authority were abused under a ritual pretext he himself prescribed — the same custody-plus-ritual-claim structure as the corpus's other pesantren records, newly documented in South Kalimantan, a province with no prior pesantren-abuse record.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://regional.kompas.com/read/2025/07/25/093146678/terbukti-cabuli-santrinya-pimpinan-ponpes-di-banjar-kalsel-divonis-12-tahun",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kompas Regional: 'Terbukti Cabuli Santrinya, Pimpinan Ponpes di Banjar Kalsel Divonis 12 Tahun Penjara' (25 Jul 2025). Indonesian: reports the Martapura District Court's 12-year sentence and Rp 200 million fine. English gloss: covers the verdict and sentencing.",
"body": "National outlet's court report confirming the 24 July 2025 Martapura District Court verdict, sentence, fine, and the ritual pretext.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://kaltim.idntimes.com/news/kalimantan-selatan/pengasuh-ponpes-di-martapura-cabuli-santri-divonis-12-tahun-penjara-00-khm2n-lflxy6",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IDN Times Kaltim: 'Pengasuh Ponpes Nurul Ilmi di Martapura, Kabupaten Banjar, Kalsel, yang Cabuli Santri Divonis 12 Tahun Penjara'. Indonesian: names the pesantren and confirms sentence. English gloss: independent corroboration of the same verdict.",
"body": "Independent regional outlet corroborating the school name, defendant, and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://regional.kompas.com/read/2025/07/25/093146678/terbukti-cabuli-santrinya-pimpinan-ponpes-di-banjar-kalsel-divonis-12-tahun",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f394471000d107d4caa86fbee84e019b0f602099676afca22e4cc1a1d12fc8a4",
"final_url": "https://regional.kompas.com/read/2025/07/25/093146678/terbukti-cabuli-santrinya-pimpinan-ponpes-di-banjar-kalsel-divonis-12-tahun"
},
{
"source": "https://kaltim.idntimes.com/news/kalimantan-selatan/pengasuh-ponpes-di-martapura-cabuli-santri-divonis-12-tahun-penjara-00-khm2n-lflxy6",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7d44b4a631c0f25a52b5a3f012ad07d6129616d11920286d9ffbb521f1ec1b90",
"final_url": "https://kaltim.idntimes.com/news/kalimantan-selatan/pengasuh-ponpes-di-martapura-cabuli-santri-divonis-12-tahun-penjara-00-khm2n-lflxy6"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 925,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim was 14 at the offence's start (reporting gives 16 years 2 months at a later point in some accounts; charges specify the offence began November 2022). Not identified beyond age. Distinct defendant/case from the already-corpus Zemi Rahim/Melaka bomoh record — different name, different court (Muar Sessions Court vs Ayer Keroh/Melaka Sessions Court), different year of sentencing (2024 April vs 2024 December), different victim.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-zemi-ibrahim-bomoh-pagoh-malaysia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Pagoh, Muar, Johor, Malaysia",
"lat": 2.1425,
"lng": 102.7269,
"title": "Malaysia: bomoh's 35-year sentence for raping a patient under a black-magic-removal pretext",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"bomoh (Malay folk healer)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"an ongoing healer-patient relationship (offences recurred September 2022 to October 2023)",
"claimed removal of black magic ('santau'/witchcraft) afflicting the victim"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mahkamah Sesyen Muar, Malaysia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Zemi Ibrahim, 51, a bomoh who also worked as a house builder and Muay Thai trainer, pleaded guilty to four charges of physical sexual assault and rape of a teenage girl in the bathroom of a house in Pagoh, near Muar, across repeated visits from November 2022, under the pretext of removing black magic she was told afflicted her; the Sessions Court sentenced him to 35 years' imprisonment and 10 strokes of the cane, running concurrently from his 16 October 2023 arrest. The abuse caused a pregnancy. The court also ordered counselling during imprisonment and two years' police supervision after release."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim returned repeatedly over roughly a year for 'treatment' the bomoh himself diagnosed and prescribed — an ongoing patient relationship, not a single walk-in transaction, making the healer's claimed diagnostic authority the operative and recurring mechanism of access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.buletintv3.my/mahkamah/bomoh-dipenjara-35-tahun-lakukan-amang-seksual-rogol-remaja-hingga-hamil/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Buletin TV3: 'Bomoh dipenjara 35 tahun, lakukan amang seksual, rogol remaja hingga hamil'. Malay: reports the Muar Sessions Court's 35-year sentence and pregnancy. English gloss: covers the verdict, sentence, and the santau-removal pretext.",
"body": "Malaysian national broadcaster's court report on the Muar Sessions Court conviction, sentence, and pretext.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bharian.com.my/berita/kes/2024/04/1240595/bomoh-dipenjara-35-tahun-mengaku-salah-cabul-rogol-pesakit",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Berita Harian: 'Bomoh dipenjara 35 tahun, mengaku salah cabul, rogol pesakit'. Malay: national paper of record confirming the guilty plea and sentence. English gloss: independent corroboration.",
"body": "Independent national-daily corroboration of the guilty plea, sentence, and patient relationship.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.buletintv3.my/mahkamah/bomoh-dipenjara-35-tahun-lakukan-amang-seksual-rogol-remaja-hingga-hamil/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bharian.com.my/berita/kes/2024/04/1240595/bomoh-dipenjara-35-tahun-mengaku-salah-cabul-rogol-pesakit",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 926,
"aliases": [
"'living Buddha' healer (press epithet)"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Seven adult victims, not identified. Court also recommended separate administrative penalties for practising superstition; that administrative track is noted but not conflated with the criminal conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-nguyen-ngoc-hai-energy-healer-hcmc-vietnam",
"year": 2025,
"place": "District 7, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam",
"lat": 10.7411,
"lng": 106.7018,
"title": "Vietnam: self-styled energy healer's eight-year sentence for raping seven women during treatment",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled spiritual/energy healer and dharma teacher ('thầy', acupressure practitioner)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed ability to transmit bodily 'energy' to cure disease",
"religious framing (dharma talks, scripture readings, guided meditation) used to build disciple dependency",
"the court's own finding that his conduct blurred consent through psychological coercion built on that claimed authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tòa án nhân dân Khu vực 7, Thành phố Hồ Chí Minh (People's Court, Area 7, Ho Chi Minh City), Vietnam",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-09-24",
"outcome": "Nguyễn Ngọc Hải, 57, who since around 2012 practised acupressure while presenting himself as a spiritual teacher able to emit healing 'energy' from his body and who led dharma talks, scripture readings and guided meditation for his 'disciples', was convicted of rape (cưỡng dâm/hiếp dâm) and sentenced on 24 September 2025 to 8 years' imprisonment for sexually assaulting seven women during 'energy transmission' treatment sessions, several by massaging genitals under the claim they would 'receive energy'; the court separately referred him for administrative penalty for practising superstition."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court itself found that Hải's religious name, claimed healing power and promises of cure created dependency in his 'disciples' and blurred the line between consent and non-consent — spiritual/therapeutic authority stated by the adjudicating court as the operative mechanism of the assaults on seven victims.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://dantri.com.vn/phap-luat/7-phu-nu-o-tphcm-bi-cuong-dam-khi-chua-benh-bang-nang-luong-20250924202951000.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dân Trí: '7 phụ nữ ở TPHCM bị cưỡng dâm khi chữa bệnh bằng năng lượng' (24/9/2025). Vietnamese: reports the Ho Chi Minh City court's conviction and 8-year sentence. English gloss: '7 women in HCMC raped during energy-healing treatment' — covers verdict, method, and victim count.",
"body": "National outlet's court report on the People's Court Area 7 verdict, sentence, and the energy-healing pretext.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://tuoitre.vn/nguoi-lam-nghe-bam-huyet-bi-phat-8-nam-tu-vi-toi-cuong-dam-20250924160208467.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tuổi Trẻ: 'Người làm nghề bấm huyệt bị phạt 8 năm tù vì tội cưỡng dâm' (24/9/2025). Vietnamese: paper of record confirming the 8-year sentence for the acupressure practitioner. English gloss: 'Acupressure practitioner sentenced to 8 years for rape' — independent corroboration.",
"body": "Independent national paper of record corroborating the conviction, sentence, and occupation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://dantri.com.vn/phap-luat/7-phu-nu-o-tphcm-bi-cuong-dam-khi-chua-benh-bang-nang-luong-20250924202951000.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5e158da764ddf63513ae795615c16ae27b69e16ca8e0271b9976890888f7f1c2",
"final_url": "https://dantri.com.vn/phap-luat/7-phu-nu-o-tphcm-bi-cuong-dam-khi-chua-benh-bang-nang-luong-20250924202951000.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://tuoitre.vn/nguoi-lam-nghe-bam-huyet-bi-phat-8-nam-tu-vi-toi-cuong-dam-20250924160208467.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dce49db48356ce445d919eeecdc22cc0e6a6589bce72b5c886b02da40177f38e",
"final_url": "https://tuoitre.vn/nguoi-lam-nghe-bam-huyet-bi-phat-8-nam-tu-vi-toi-cuong-dam-20250924160208467.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 927,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-tomasz-f-opole-lubelskie-poland",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Opole Lubelskie, Diocese of Sandomierz, Poland",
"lat": 51.15,
"lng": 21.97,
"title": "Poland: priest Tomasz F. finally convicted on appeal for sexually abusing two altar boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rp.pl/prawo-karne/art37288261-ksiadz-molestowal-seksualnie-nastolatkow-sad-zlagodzil-wyrok",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rzeczpospolita (2023) 'Sąd w Lublinie złagodził wyrok ws. księdza Tomasza F., który molestował seksualnie nastolatków'. Available at: rp.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Court of Appeal in Lublin found priest Tomasz F. guilty of sexually abusing two boys aged 12 and 13 -- repeated intercourse and other sexual acts with one victim between summer 2018 and July 2019, and a single incident with the other in July 2019 -- and sentenced him to seven years, a final judgment.",
"body": "Rzeczpospolita (2023) 'Sąd w Lublinie złagodził wyrok ws. księdza Tomasza F., który molestował seksualnie nastolatków'. Available at: rp.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Court of Appeal in Lublin found priest Tomasz F. guilty of sexually abusing two boys aged 12 and 13 -- repeated intercourse and other sexual acts with one victim between summer 2018 and July 2019, and a single incident with the other in July 2019 -- and sentenced him to seven years, a final judgment."
},
{
"link": "https://lublin.se.pl/opole-lubelskie-zboczeniec-w-sutannie-molestowal-chlopcow-lagodniejsza-kara-dla-ksiedza-tomasza-f-aa-SBgY-Cbfs-Nntd.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Super Express Lublin (2023) 'Opole Lubelskie. Ksiądz Tomasz F. molestował chłopców. Nowy wyrok i łagodniejsza kara za pedofilię w Kościele'. Available at: lublin.se.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: First-instance District Court in Opole Lubelskie sentenced the priest to 10 years in April 2021; the Court of Appeal in Lublin reduced it to 7 years, ordered 80,000 PLN compensation to the victims, a lifetime ban on work with children, 15-year no-contact order, and placement in a psychiatric therapeutic facility.",
"body": "Super Express Lublin (2023) 'Opole Lubelskie. Ksiądz Tomasz F. molestował chłopców. Nowy wyrok i łagodniejsza kara za pedofilię w Kościele'. Available at: lublin.se.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: First-instance District Court in Opole Lubelskie sentenced the priest to 10 years in April 2021; the Court of Appeal in Lublin reduced it to 7 years, ordered 80,000 PLN compensation to the victims, a lifetime ban on work with children, 15-year no-contact order, and placement in a psychiatric therapeutic facility."
}
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court in Opole Lubelskie, Poland",
"stage": "First-instance conviction",
"outcome": "Convicted; sentenced to 10 years (April 2021, per source)"
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal in Lublin, Poland",
"stage": "Appellate judgment",
"outcome": "Conviction affirmed; sentence reduced to 7 years, final"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As a priest with pastoral responsibility for the parish's altar servers, the defendant used his clerical role and unsupervised access to the boys to abuse them; the court's final judgment credits the clerical relationship as the access mechanism.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rp.pl/prawo-karne/art37288261-ksiadz-molestowal-seksualnie-nastolatkow-sad-zlagodzil-wyrok",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "99fd41acddcae432b1815adef35650b2d0715b50536e809216c2bca8db78493e",
"final_url": "https://www.rp.pl/prawo-karne/art37288261-ksiadz-molestowal-seksualnie-nastolatkow-sad-zlagodzil-wyrok"
},
{
"source": "https://lublin.se.pl/opole-lubelskie-zboczeniec-w-sutannie-molestowal-chlopcow-lagodniejsza-kara-dla-ksiedza-tomasza-f-aa-SBgY-Cbfs-Nntd.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 928,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-ml-drohiczyn-poland",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Diocese of Drohiczyn, Podlaskie Voivodeship, Poland",
"lat": 52.41,
"lng": 22.66,
"title": "Poland: vicar and religion teacher M.Ł. finally convicted for repeated rape of a 14-year-old parishioner",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.radio.bialystok.pl/wiadomosci/index/id/161400",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio Białystok (2022) '5 lat więzienia dla księdza za gwałt na nieletniej - wyrok utrzymany'. Available at: radio.bialystok.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Court of Appeal in Białystok upheld a 5-year sentence for a young Catholic priest, a vicar and religion teacher in the Diocese of Drohiczyn, convicted of repeatedly raping a 14-year-old girl in the parish rectory in May-June 2017 -- a final judgment.",
"body": "Radio Białystok (2022) '5 lat więzienia dla księdza za gwałt na nieletniej - wyrok utrzymany'. Available at: radio.bialystok.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Court of Appeal in Białystok upheld a 5-year sentence for a young Catholic priest, a vicar and religion teacher in the Diocese of Drohiczyn, convicted of repeatedly raping a 14-year-old girl in the parish rectory in May-June 2017 -- a final judgment."
},
{
"link": "https://wiadomosci.dziennik.pl/wydarzenia/artykuly/575390,ksiadz-gwalt-nieletnia-molestowanie-kosciol-wyrok-wiezienie.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dziennik.pl (2020) 'Wyrok 5 lat więzienia dla duchownego oskarżonego o trzykrotny gwałt na nieletniej. Sąd: To nie ksiądz, lecz imitacja księdza'. Available at: dziennik.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The priest, as vicar and the girl's religion teacher, lured her to the rectory, locked the door and assaulted her; the court imposed a 15-year ban on professions involving education, healthcare or care of minors, and the parish curia was notified by the victim's parents in 2017.",
"body": "Dziennik.pl (2020) 'Wyrok 5 lat więzienia dla duchownego oskarżonego o trzykrotny gwałt na nieletniej. Sąd: To nie ksiądz, lecz imitacja księdza'. Available at: dziennik.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The priest, as vicar and the girl's religion teacher, lured her to the rectory, locked the door and assaulted her; the court imposed a 15-year ban on professions involving education, healthcare or care of minors, and the parish curia was notified by the victim's parents in 2017."
}
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court, Podlaskie Voivodeship, Poland",
"stage": "First-instance conviction",
"outcome": "Convicted; sentenced to 5 years"
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal in Białystok, Poland",
"stage": "Appellate judgment",
"outcome": "Conviction and sentence affirmed, final"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest was the victim's vicar and religion teacher within her own parish; he used the rectory -- the seat of his clerical authority -- as the assault site, and the court's own language ('this is not a priest but an imitation of a priest') frames the clerical role as the operative mechanism of access.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.radio.bialystok.pl/wiadomosci/index/id/161400",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3cb204a35cc70f36626719fca225bba842e7638fc6d270f628d386b97f45c315",
"final_url": "https://www.radio.bialystok.pl/wiadomosci/index/id/161400"
},
{
"source": "https://wiadomosci.dziennik.pl/wydarzenia/artykuly/575390,ksiadz-gwalt-nieletnia-molestowanie-kosciol-wyrok-wiezienie.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3ecb44f22be38d2887cc737f254fbcea056d212c7c57378fcc613ae552b77594",
"final_url": "https://wiadomosci.dziennik.pl/wydarzenia/artykuly/575390,ksiadz-gwalt-nieletnia-molestowanie-kosciol-wyrok-wiezienie.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 929,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-piotr-m-ruszow-legnica-poland",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Ruszów, Diocese of Legnica, Poland",
"lat": 51.35,
"lng": 15.13,
"title": "Poland: parish priest Piotr M. finally convicted of molesting two intellectually disabled girls he was preparing for First Communion",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://legnica.naszemiasto.pl/piotr-m-czyli-proboszcz-z-ruszowa-mimo-prawomocnego-wyroku/ar/c1-8508279",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nasze Miasto Legnica (2022) 'Piotr M., czyli proboszcz z Ruszowa, mimo prawomocnego wyroku nadal na wolności. Sąd Najwyższy odrzucił kasację'. Available at: legnica.naszemiasto.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Former parish priest Piotr M. of Ruszów (Diocese of Legnica) was finally convicted on 20 October 2021 of molesting two intellectually disabled minor girls he was preparing for First Communion; in May 2022 the Supreme Court rejected his cassation appeal, closing the criminal case.",
"body": "Nasze Miasto Legnica (2022) 'Piotr M., czyli proboszcz z Ruszowa, mimo prawomocnego wyroku nadal na wolności. Sąd Najwyższy odrzucił kasację'. Available at: legnica.naszemiasto.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Former parish priest Piotr M. of Ruszów (Diocese of Legnica) was finally convicted on 20 October 2021 of molesting two intellectually disabled minor girls he was preparing for First Communion; in May 2022 the Supreme Court rejected his cassation appeal, closing the criminal case."
},
{
"link": "https://tvn24.pl/polska/jelenia-gora-ksiadz-z-ruszowa-skazany-na-cztery-lata-wiezienia-za-molestowanie-dwoch-dziewczynek-sad-obnizyl-wyrok-st5458846",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TVN24 (2021) 'Jelenia Góra. Ksiądz z Ruszowa skazany na cztery lata więzienia. Za molestowanie dwóch dziewczynek. Sąd obniżył wyrok'. Available at: tvn24.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Sentence reduced on appeal from 5 to 4 years and the ban on work with children changed from lifetime to 15 years; the District Court in Legnica separately awarded the two victims 475,000 PLN each in compensation from the diocese.",
"body": "TVN24 (2021) 'Jelenia Góra. Ksiądz z Ruszowa skazany na cztery lata więzienia. Za molestowanie dwóch dziewczynek. Sąd obniżył wyrok'. Available at: tvn24.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Sentence reduced on appeal from 5 to 4 years and the ban on work with children changed from lifetime to 15 years; the District Court in Legnica separately awarded the two victims 475,000 PLN each in compensation from the diocese."
}
],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2021-10-20",
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal, Legnica jurisdiction, Poland",
"stage": "Appellate conviction",
"outcome": "Convicted; sentence reduced to 4 years, final"
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Poland",
"stage": "Cassation review",
"outcome": "Cassation appeal rejected (May 2022, per source); conviction stands"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest was the girls' parish priest and the cleric personally preparing them for First Communion -- a sacramental-formation relationship of trust their intellectual disability made them unable to resist or later fully report -- and used that role as the access mechanism.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://legnica.naszemiasto.pl/piotr-m-czyli-proboszcz-z-ruszowa-mimo-prawomocnego-wyroku/ar/c1-8508279",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cb43af892db6331799cd54a5a20bad451e670cf1f0d1a14b85ed6cbcaa8ea028",
"final_url": "https://legnica.naszemiasto.pl/piotr-m-czyli-proboszcz-z-ruszowa-mimo-prawomocnego-wyroku/ar/c1-8508279"
},
{
"source": "https://tvn24.pl/polska/jelenia-gora-ksiadz-z-ruszowa-skazany-na-cztery-lata-wiezienia-za-molestowanie-dwoch-dziewczynek-sad-obnizyl-wyrok-st5458846",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c27cd377d5de8c90d524711198198ab6f693293f5eb313ef0e87fda36b5845f2",
"final_url": "https://tvn24.pl/polska/jelenia-gora-ksiadz-z-ruszowa-skazany-na-cztery-lata-wiezienia-za-molestowanie-dwoch-dziewczynek-sad-obnizyl-wyrok-st5458846"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 930,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-rafal-k-bydgoszcz-poland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Bydgoszcz, Diocese of Bydgoszcz, Poland",
"lat": 53.12,
"lng": 18,
"title": "Poland: former priest Rafał K. finally convicted for posing as a sexologist to abuse minors and adults under cover of 'therapy'",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bydgoszcz.tvp.pl/77710812/wyrok-dla-ksiedza",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TVP Bydgoszcz (2026) 'Ksiądz Rafał K. z Bydgoszczy usłyszał wyższy wyrok. Ma spędzić w więzieniu 10,5 roku'. Available at: bydgoszcz.tvp.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Court of Appeal in Bydgoszcz, on 12 June, upheld the district court's finding and sentenced former priest Rafał K. to 10.5 years, a final judgment, for sexually abusing 10 victims -- two of them minors -- under the pretext of running 'sexual-disorder therapy' sessions in which he showed pornography and touched them.",
"body": "TVP Bydgoszcz (2026) 'Ksiądz Rafał K. z Bydgoszczy usłyszał wyższy wyrok. Ma spędzić w więzieniu 10,5 roku'. Available at: bydgoszcz.tvp.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Court of Appeal in Bydgoszcz, on 12 June, upheld the district court's finding and sentenced former priest Rafał K. to 10.5 years, a final judgment, for sexually abusing 10 victims -- two of them minors -- under the pretext of running 'sexual-disorder therapy' sessions in which he showed pornography and touched them."
},
{
"link": "https://expressbydgoski.pl/bydgoski-ksiadz-ktory-udawal-seksuologa-i-mierzyl-przyrodzenia-skazany-na-105-roku-wiezienia/ar/c1-18556533",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Express Bydgoski (2026) 'Bydgoski ksiądz, który udawał seksuologa i mierzył przyrodzenia, skazany na 10,5 roku więzienia'. Available at: expressbydgoski.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Under the guise of a priest running an informal 'sexology' counselling practice, the defendant gained the victims' trust while claiming to treat them for sexual dysfunction, then abused them during the sessions.",
"body": "Express Bydgoski (2026) 'Bydgoski ksiądz, który udawał seksuologa i mierzył przyrodzenia, skazany na 10,5 roku więzienia'. Available at: expressbydgoski.pl (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Under the guise of a priest running an informal 'sexology' counselling practice, the defendant gained the victims' trust while claiming to treat them for sexual dysfunction, then abused them during the sessions."
}
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court, Bydgoszcz, Poland",
"stage": "First-instance conviction",
"outcome": "Convicted"
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal in Bydgoszcz, Poland",
"stage": "Appellate judgment",
"outcome": "Conviction affirmed (12 June, per source); sentenced to 10.5 years, final"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant used his standing as a priest to present himself as a credible pastoral-and-therapeutic counsellor for sexual matters, drawing victims (including minors from religious families) into private 'therapy' sessions where his clerical authority made refusal and disclosure difficult.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bydgoszcz.tvp.pl/77710812/wyrok-dla-ksiedza",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c178df2a45566dab675da998eea55d92e9c55ab5b4999bd2c47ddabcd984a625",
"final_url": "https://bydgoszcz.tvp.pl/77710812/wyrok-dla-ksiedza"
},
{
"source": "https://expressbydgoski.pl/bydgoski-ksiadz-ktory-udawal-seksuologa-i-mierzyl-przyrodzenia-skazany-na-105-roku-wiezienia/ar/c1-18556533",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5deb3ba1c9a637699f51866f6b818c7004881f2c892d820ad43b36ca4f0ad85b",
"final_url": "https://expressbydgoski.pl/bydgoski-ksiadz-ktory-udawal-seksuologa-i-mierzyl-przyrodzenia-skazany-na-105-roku-wiezienia/ar/c1-18556533"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 931,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-corfu-greece-priest-seduction-minor",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Southern Corfu, Metropolis of Corfu and the Ionian Islands, Greece",
"lat": 39.4,
"lng": 19.92,
"title": "Greece: village priest convicted of the continuous seduction of a 16-year-old parishioner inside the church",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tanea.gr/2024/10/18/greece/sti-fylaki-o-iereas-pou-aselgouse-se-aniliki-stin-kerkyra-i-ypothesi-pou-eixe-sygklonisei-to-nisi-to-2019/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ta Nea (2024) 'Στη φυλακή ο ιερέας που ασελγούσε σε ανήλικη στην Κέρκυρα -- Η υπόθεση που είχε συγκλονίσει το νησί το 2019'. Available at: tanea.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Mixed Jury Court of Thesprotia convicted a 60-year-old priest of the continuous seduction ('αποπλάνηση') of a minor inside his southern Corfu church and sentenced him to 12 years' imprisonment; he was taken directly into custody. The case originated from an October 2019 complaint by the 16-year-old victim's parents.",
"body": "Ta Nea (2024) 'Στη φυλακή ο ιερέας που ασελγούσε σε ανήλικη στην Κέρκυρα -- Η υπόθεση που είχε συγκλονίσει το νησί το 2019'. Available at: tanea.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Mixed Jury Court of Thesprotia convicted a 60-year-old priest of the continuous seduction ('αποπλάνηση') of a minor inside his southern Corfu church and sentenced him to 12 years' imprisonment; he was taken directly into custody. The case originated from an October 2019 complaint by the 16-year-old victim's parents."
},
{
"link": "https://www.imerazante.gr/2024/10/18/350840",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Imera Zante (2024) 'Κέρκυρα: Σε 12 χρόνια κάθειρξης καταδικαστικέ ιερέας για το αδίκημα της αποπλάνησης ανηλίκου'. Available at: imerazante.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Metropolitan of Corfu and the Ionian Islands had already suspended the priest following the first parental complaint; he fled the island before being located and tried five years later.",
"body": "Imera Zante (2024) 'Κέρκυρα: Σε 12 χρόνια κάθειρξης καταδικαστικέ ιερέας για το αδίκημα της αποπλάνησης ανηλίκου'. Available at: imerazante.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The Metropolitan of Corfu and the Ionian Islands had already suspended the priest following the first parental complaint; he fled the island before being located and tried five years later."
}
],
"proceedings": [
{
"date": "2024-10-18",
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Jury Court of Thesprotia, Greece",
"stage": "Trial conviction and sentencing",
"outcome": "Convicted; 12 years' imprisonment, taken into custody"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest committed the abuse inside his own church against a parish minor under his pastoral care, using the church building and his standing as the village's spiritual authority as the setting and means of access.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tanea.gr/2024/10/18/greece/sti-fylaki-o-iereas-pou-aselgouse-se-aniliki-stin-kerkyra-i-ypothesi-pou-eixe-sygklonisei-to-nisi-to-2019/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "09399fa99543d1882697d8fb508b07e4cac07544c96ca9230f0dddd761a0a629",
"final_url": "https://www.tanea.gr/2024/10/18/greece/sti-fylaki-o-iereas-pou-aselgouse-se-aniliki-stin-kerkyra-i-ypothesi-pou-eixe-sygklonisei-to-nisi-to-2019/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.imerazante.gr/2024/10/18/350840",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1ebe60cb8f08b0cd0cf4d7b73e37103b42fa9d67166fade8c93126885391e6d8",
"final_url": "https://www.imerazante.gr/2024/10/18/350840"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 932,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-theokletos-archimandrite-naxos-greece",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Naxos, Cyclades, Greece",
"lat": 37.1,
"lng": 25.38,
"title": "Greece: archimandrite Theokletos's conviction for repeated sexual harassment of two parish boys affirmed by the Supreme Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [],
"coercionMechanisms": [],
"organizations": [],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newsit.gr/egklhma/naksos-aytos-einai-o-arximandritis-poy-katadikastike-gia-aselgeia-se-anilika-agoria-kathetai-ksana-sto-edolio-foto/1516181/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newsit.gr 'Νάξος: Αυτός είναι ο Αρχιμανδρίτης που καταδικάστηκε για ασέλγεια σε ανήλικα αγόρια'. Available at: newsit.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Archimandrite Theokletos of Naxos, aged 53, was convicted by the Mixed Jury Court of Appeal of Athens of the repeated sexual harassment of two boys in his parish, aged 10 and 14, and of possessing pornographic material, and sentenced to 27.5 years' imprisonment.",
"body": "Newsit.gr 'Νάξος: Αυτός είναι ο Αρχιμανδρίτης που καταδικάστηκε για ασέλγεια σε ανήλικα αγόρια'. Available at: newsit.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: Archimandrite Theokletos of Naxos, aged 53, was convicted by the Mixed Jury Court of Appeal of Athens of the repeated sexual harassment of two boys in his parish, aged 10 and 14, and of possessing pornographic material, and sentenced to 27.5 years' imprisonment."
},
{
"link": "https://www.lifo.gr/now/greece/arhimandritis-parenohloyse-anilikoys-stin-enoria-toy-oristika-stin-fylaki",
"archive": "",
"citation": "LiFO 'Αρχιμανδρίτης παρενοχλούσε ανηλίκους στην ενορία του -- Οριστικά στην φυλακή'. Available at: lifo.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The 7th Criminal Division of the Areios Pagos (Supreme Court) rejected all of the archimandrite's cassation grounds, including his request for mitigating circumstances, and finally upheld the appellate conviction; he remained held at Trikala Prison.",
"body": "LiFO 'Αρχιμανδρίτης παρενοχλούσε ανηλίκους στην ενορία του -- Οριστικά στην φυλακή'. Available at: lifo.gr (Accessed 2026-07-19). English gloss: The 7th Criminal Division of the Areios Pagos (Supreme Court) rejected all of the archimandrite's cassation grounds, including his request for mitigating circumstances, and finally upheld the appellate conviction; he remained held at Trikala Prison."
}
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Jury Court of Appeal of Athens, Greece",
"stage": "Appellate conviction",
"outcome": "Convicted; sentenced to 27.5 years"
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Areios Pagos (Supreme Court of Greece), 7th Criminal Division",
"stage": "Cassation review",
"outcome": "Cassation rejected; conviction and sentence finally upheld"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As archimandrite -- a senior monastic-clerical rank -- with pastoral charge of his own parish, the defendant exploited his standing over two boys within his congregation to harass them repeatedly over time; the conviction stood through the country's court of last resort.",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newsit.gr/egklhma/naksos-aytos-einai-o-arximandritis-poy-katadikastike-gia-aselgeia-se-anilika-agoria-kathetai-ksana-sto-edolio-foto/1516181/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3e7ddbad7f77e433d30491002870972ddb062d0fee3ca8a106ecccfd5a70f827",
"final_url": "https://www.newsit.gr/egklhma/naksos-aytos-einai-o-arximandritis-poy-katadikastike-gia-aselgeia-se-anilika-agoria-kathetai-ksana-sto-edolio-foto/1516181/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lifo.gr/now/greece/arhimandritis-parenohloyse-anilikoys-stin-enoria-toy-oristika-stin-fylaki",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c2c9ac450a64e487853117a3ad24c14466042d3b65c38073640a01e7ecb2c83e",
"final_url": "https://www.lifo.gr/now/greece/arhimandritis-parenohloyse-anilikoys-stin-enoria-toy-oristika-stin-fylaki"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 933,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The underlying assault occurred 29 November 2023; sentencing followed in May 2026. No appeal reported as of sourcing. SOURCING CAVEAT: unlike the other records in this batch, only ONE outlet reporting this case could be located, though it quotes the prosecutor directly. A second independent source should be found before this record is relied on.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-muntazir-alam-hamirpur-uttar-pradesh-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Kurara, Hamirpur, Uttar Pradesh, India",
"lat": 25.9585,
"lng": 80.1487,
"title": "India: cleric sentenced to life for raping his Urdu-Arabic student inside a mosque",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"maulana teaching Urdu-Arabic classes at the village mosque"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-instructor access to a student attending his mosque classes",
"isolating the child by sending other students away"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special POCSO Court, Hamirpur, Uttar Pradesh, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-23",
"outcome": "Maulana Muntazir Alam was convicted of raping an 11-year-old girl inside the village mosque where he taught Urdu-Arabic classes to local children, sending the other students away before the assault. Special Judge (POCSO) Anil Kumar Kharwar sentenced him to life imprisonment, stating explicitly that this was imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life rather than a standard term, plus a fine of Rs 26,000."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was one of several village children who attended the defendant's Urdu-Arabic religious instruction at the mosque; that instructional access is what let him isolate her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.opindia.com/news-updates/uttar-pradesh-maulana-muntazir-alam-rapes-minor-girl-inside-mosque-pocso-court-sentences-him-to-life-imprisonment/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Uttar Pradesh: \"Maulana\" Muntazir Alam rapes minor girl inside mosque, POCSO court sentences him to life imprisonment', OpIndia, May 2026.",
"body": "Report of the POCSO court's sentencing, quoting the special public prosecutor on the mosque Urdu-Arabic class context.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.aajtak.in/uttar-pradesh/story/hamirpur-masjid-maulana-rape-case-verdict-life-imprisonment-till-death-updates-lcln-strc-2560045-2026-05-23",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'मस्जिद में मासूम से दरिंदगी... मौलाना को \"अंतिम सांस\" तक जेल', AajTak, 23 May 2026.",
"body": "Hindi-language report confirming the life-until-death sentencing and fine.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.opindia.com/news-updates/uttar-pradesh-maulana-muntazir-alam-rapes-minor-girl-inside-mosque-pocso-court-sentences-him-to-life-imprisonment/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1d20e42e0651509627d964de783387af7f61923cd4dc08688e8c06f609eb9a71",
"final_url": "https://www.opindia.com/news-updates/uttar-pradesh-maulana-muntazir-alam-rapes-minor-girl-inside-mosque-pocso-court-sentences-him-to-life-imprisonment/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.aajtak.in/uttar-pradesh/story/hamirpur-masjid-maulana-rape-case-verdict-life-imprisonment-till-death-updates-lcln-strc-2560045-2026-05-23",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2582e6b6150b624a90d745d74c1ad49dbb796197308faa983442e4988bcf1e87",
"final_url": "https://www.aajtak.in/uttar-pradesh/story/hamirpur-masjid-maulana-rape-case-verdict-life-imprisonment-till-death-updates-lcln-strc-2560045-2026-05-23"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 934,
"aliases": [
"Fr Thomas Parekkulam"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Case surfaced after one boy approached Childline. No appeal located as of sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-thomas-parekkulam-kollam-kerala-india",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Pullamala, Kollam, Kerala, India",
"lat": 8.9558,
"lng": 76.9903,
"title": "India: seminary rector sentenced to 18 years for sexually abusing four minor seminarians in his care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest and rector of a minor seminary (Society of St Eugene de Mazenod)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential authority over minor seminarians living with him",
"clerical authority as their formator"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of St Eugene de Mazenod"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Additional Sessions Court (POCSO), Kollam, Kerala, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-04-30",
"outcome": "Fr Thomas Parekkulam, rector of a minor seminary at Pullamala where four boys aged 16 lived with him as students, was convicted of sexually abusing all four over a period in 2017. Additional District and Sessions Judge (POCSO) K N Sujith sentenced him to five years' rigorous imprisonment on each of three counts and three years on a fourth, running consecutively for a total of 18 years, plus compensation of Rs 100,000 per victim."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The four minor seminarians lived with the defendant at his parsonage as his formation students; that residential and clerical authority over them as their rector is what gave him sustained private access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://organiser.org/2022/05/01/78740/bharat/father-thomas-parekkulam-sentenced-to-18-yrs-of-rigorous-imprisonment-for-sexually-assaulting-four-minor-boys/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Christian Cleric Thomas Parekkulam Sentenced To 18 Yrs Of Rigorous Imprisonment For Sexually Assaulting 4 Minor Boys', Organiser, 1 May 2022.",
"body": "Report of the sentencing with the sentence breakdown and seminary/rector context.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/kerala-christian-priest-sentenced-to-18-years-ri-for-sexually-assaulting-four-teen-boys-in-2017-news-194238",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kerala: Christian Priest Sentenced To 18 Years RI For Sexually Assaulting Four teen Boys In 2017', Outlook India.",
"body": "National-magazine report corroborating the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://organiser.org/2022/05/01/78740/bharat/father-thomas-parekkulam-sentenced-to-18-yrs-of-rigorous-imprisonment-for-sexually-assaulting-four-minor-boys/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d1ca125105b17541ad5ee58b7c9cfb581deed67f6de58eb24fae44256535f214",
"final_url": "https://organiser.org/2022/05/01/78740/bharat/father-thomas-parekkulam-sentenced-to-18-yrs-of-rigorous-imprisonment-for-sexually-assaulting-four-minor-boys/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/kerala-christian-priest-sentenced-to-18-years-ri-for-sexually-assaulting-four-teen-boys-in-2017-news-194238",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "81392d3176d1138cda8f6a5c1d641ee4b1f9b7fec8e92579ec0ed2bc72a8eafd",
"final_url": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/kerala-christian-priest-sentenced-to-18-years-ri-for-sexually-assaulting-four-teen-boys-in-2017-news-194238"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 935,
"aliases": [
"Fr Edwin Pigarez"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"note": "Conviction upheld; sentence reduced from double life imprisonment to 20 years. Exact appellate decision date not confirmed in sourcing and is omitted rather than guessed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. High Court sentence-reduction date not confirmed in sourcing and is omitted rather than guessed; the conviction itself was not disturbed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-edwin-figarez-ernakulam-kerala-india",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Puthenvelikkara, Ernakulam, Kerala, India",
"lat": 10.1667,
"lng": 76.2333,
"title": "India: parish priest convicted of raping a minor parishioner who came to him for confession",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Lourd Matha Church, Kottapuram diocese"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority exercised through the confessional",
"exploiting the child's interest in music to arrange private access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Lourd Matha Church, Puthenvelikkara",
"Diocese of Kottapuram"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special Court (POCSO), Ernakulam, Kerala, India; Kerala High Court (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal, conviction upheld",
"date": "2016-12-08",
"outcome": "Fr Edwin Figarez, vicar of Lourd Matha Church, was convicted of repeatedly raping a 14-year-old parishioner who first came to him for confession, and was sentenced to double life imprisonment plus a fine of Rs 2.15 lakh. On appeal, a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court left the conviction intact but reduced the sentence to 20 years without remission."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim, an eighth-standard parishioner, first came under the defendant's authority through confession; he used that pastoral access and her interest in music to arrange repeated private contact.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2016/12/kerala-catholic-priest-gets-double-life-imprisonment-rs-2-15-lakh-fine-for-raping-minor-girl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kerala Catholic priest gets double life imprisonment, Rs 2.15-lakh fine for raping minor girl', BishopAccountability.org, Dec. 2016.",
"body": "Report of the original trial-court conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "advocacy-archive-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://hindupost.in/featured/father-edwin-figarez-gets-his-pocso-sentence-reduced-by-kerala-high-court/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Father Edwin Figarez gets his POCSO sentence reduced by Kerala High Court', HinduPost.",
"body": "Report of the Kerala High Court's sentence reduction, confirming the conviction was not disturbed.",
"tier": "partisan-outlet-lead-index",
"kind": "appellate-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "high-court",
"note": "Conviction upheld; sentence reduced from double life imprisonment to 20 years. Exact appellate decision date not confirmed in sourcing and is omitted rather than guessed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2016/12/kerala-catholic-priest-gets-double-life-imprisonment-rs-2-15-lakh-fine-for-raping-minor-girl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-archive-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "34d98f7cbdc686deb83355d6829a2db073527dd1539c392fe023ca3b2520da74",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2016/12/kerala-catholic-priest-gets-double-life-imprisonment-rs-2-15-lakh-fine-for-raping-minor-girl/"
},
{
"source": "https://hindupost.in/featured/father-edwin-figarez-gets-his-pocso-sentence-reduced-by-kerala-high-court/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: partisan-outlet-lead-index; evidentiary role: appellate-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f13a4461342a1255736182b15d07b00e1fbf8c7ae7335fc05d319f432c149eef",
"final_url": "https://hindupost.in/featured/father-edwin-figarez-gets-his-pocso-sentence-reduced-by-kerala-high-court/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 936,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. No appeal located as of sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-raju-kokken-thrissur-kerala-india",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Thrissur, Kerala, India",
"lat": 10.5276,
"lng": 76.2144,
"title": "India: priest convicted of raping a nine-year-old preparing for her First Communion at his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, St Paul's Church, near Thrissur"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority over a child attending his First Communion classes",
"promise of free communion vestments to a low-income family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Paul's Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "POCSO fast-track court, Thrissur, Kerala, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-12-28",
"outcome": "Fr Raju Kokken was convicted of raping a nine-year-old girl from a low-income family who was attending his church's First Communion preparation classes; he lured her into his private office on the pretext of fitting her communion dress and assaulted her on three dates in April 2014. He was sentenced to seven years' rigorous imprisonment and a Rs 50,000 fine, with the verdict coming nearly nine years after the offence, following his flight and arrest in Tamil Nadu."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child of the parish attending the defendant's own First Communion catechism classes; that instructional-pastoral authority is what let him isolate her under a dress-fitting pretext.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://hindupost.in/crime/pocso-court-sentences-pedophile-kokken/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'POCSO court sentences paedophile padre Kokken after nine long years', HinduPost, Dec. 2022.",
"body": "Report of the conviction and sentence, including the First Communion catechism context and the nine-year delay from arrest to verdict.",
"tier": "partisan-outlet-lead-index",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/the-sins-of-our-fathers-news-298386",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'The Sins Of Our Fathers', Outlook India.",
"body": "National-magazine roundup corroborating the Kokken conviction among a survey of Kerala clergy-abuse cases.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://hindupost.in/crime/pocso-court-sentences-pedophile-kokken/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: partisan-outlet-lead-index; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4654d5fe47e3b0a23db2b71814ef304ce9fcd47e3d782112572a1648ab85b99c",
"final_url": "https://hindupost.in/crime/pocso-court-sentences-pedophile-kokken/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/the-sins-of-our-fathers-news-298386",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c46471e2bca124ac3f2bb7317a08b8c18668bb60d7b4a54e7b27fb7a29f112bb",
"final_url": "https://www.outlookindia.com/national/the-sins-of-our-fathers-news-298386"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 937,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. No appeal located as of sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-jabir-ali-malappuram-kerala-india",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Vengara, Malappuram, Kerala, India",
"lat": 11.0745,
"lng": 75.9532,
"title": "India: madrasa teacher sentenced to 86 years for raping a 12-year-old student inside the institution",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"madrasa teacher, Vengara, Malappuram"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teacher access to a student inside the madrasa building"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "POCSO fast-track special court, Manjeri, Malappuram, Kerala, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-07-14",
"outcome": "Jabir Ali, a teacher at a madrasa in Vengara, was convicted of raping a 12-year-old student inside the institution's bathroom on the morning of 21 April 2022. He was sentenced to a cumulative 86 years' rigorous imprisonment under multiple sections of the POCSO Act, with a fine of Rs 4.5 lakh."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was the defendant's own madrasa student, assaulted inside the institution during the access his teaching role gave him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://organiser.org/2025/07/15/302810/bharat/kerala-madrasa-teacher-jabir-ali-gets-86-years-jail-for-raping-12-year-old-girl-in-a-pocso-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Madrasa teacher Jabir Ali gets 86 years jail for raping minor girl', Organiser, 15 Jul. 2025.",
"body": "Report of the conviction and cumulative sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://organiser.org/2025/07/15/302810/bharat/kerala-madrasa-teacher-jabir-ali-gets-86-years-jail-for-raping-12-year-old-girl-in-a-pocso-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "398cc29daefaa864df43c2ab4b842fc6fd734ef11730688183be433b3bb10d84",
"final_url": "https://organiser.org/2025/07/15/302810/bharat/kerala-madrasa-teacher-jabir-ali-gets-86-years-jail-for-raping-12-year-old-girl-in-a-pocso-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 938,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Case was reported after the child disclosed the abuse to schoolmates in January 2020. No appeal located as of sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-aliyar-ernakulam-kerala-india",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Nellikuzhi, Ernakulam, Kerala, India",
"lat": 10.0736,
"lng": 76.6644,
"title": "India: madrasa teacher sentenced to 20 years for sexually assaulting his 11-year-old student",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"madrasa teacher, Nellikuzhi, Ernakulam"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position of trust and religious-instructional authority over a student at the institution"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "POCSO court, Ernakulam, Kerala, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-06-30",
"outcome": "Aliyar, a 52-year-old teacher at a madrasa in Nellikuzhi, was convicted of aggravated penetrative sexual assault of his own 11-year-old student, committed over a period beginning in 2020. Special Judge Satheesh Kumar V sentenced him to 20 years' imprisonment on each of several POCSO counts — including sexual assault by staff of an educational institution and by a person in a position of trust or authority — running concurrently, for an effective 20-year term against a cumulative 67 years across counts."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was the defendant's own student at the madrasa where he taught; the case was charged expressly as abuse by a person in a position of trust and authority over a child at his educational institution.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-madrasa-teacher-gets-20-year-sentence-sexual-assault-11-yr-old-boy-165441",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kerala madrasa teacher gets 20 year sentence for sexual assault of 11-yr-old boy', The News Minute, 1 Jul. 2022.",
"body": "Report of the conviction, sentence breakdown and disclosure circumstances.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.etvbharat.com/english/state/kerala/kerala-court-sentences-madrasa-teacher-to-20-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault-of-minor-student/na20220701225911280280463",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kerala court sentences Madrasa teacher to 20 years in jail for sexual assault of minor student', ETV Bharat, 1 Jul. 2022.",
"body": "Corroborating report of the sentencing.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-madrasa-teacher-gets-20-year-sentence-sexual-assault-11-yr-old-boy-165441",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "730fb3996c5f16c8abb74a76b45f2285a166aa58de6a051fc1667dc77bd39408",
"final_url": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-madrasa-teacher-gets-20-year-sentence-sexual-assault-11-yr-old-boy-165441"
},
{
"source": "https://www.etvbharat.com/english/state/kerala/kerala-court-sentences-madrasa-teacher-to-20-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault-of-minor-student/na20220701225911280280463",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "42d452bf611359d7c0e6a2b85a02149e832ede5b24535a3786e368dc210a8c0a",
"final_url": "https://www.etvbharat.com/english/state/kerala/kerala-court-sentences-madrasa-teacher-to-20-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault-of-minor-student/na20220701225911280280463"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 939,
"aliases": [
"Ojha Jaydeo Sharma"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim, not identified. Nine years elapsed between the 2017 complaint and the 2026 verdict. No appeal located as of sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-ojha-jagdev-sharma-sonbhadra-uttar-pradesh-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Robertsganj, Sonbhadra, Uttar Pradesh, India",
"lat": 24.6947,
"lng": 83.0664,
"title": "India: self-styled 'ojha' faith healer and an accomplice sentenced to life for assaulting a woman under an exorcism pretext",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled ojha (traditional exorcist/faith healer)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"exorcism ritual (jhaad-phoonk) used to isolate the victim",
"invoked spiritual power to compel compliance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Additional Sessions Court (FTC), Sonbhadra, Uttar Pradesh, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-15",
"outcome": "Ojha Jagdev Sharma, a self-styled traditional exorcist, and his associate Lalu Sharma were convicted of sexually assaulting a woman from Varanasi district whom Sharma had isolated on the pretext of performing jhaad-phoonk (exorcism) to cure her. Additional Sessions Judge Bipin Kumar sentenced both to life imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1.5 lakh each, with half of each fine directed to the victim; the case had been pending since the woman's 2017 complaint."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim submitted to isolation with the defendant specifically because he held himself out as an ojha capable of exorcism/healing; that claimed spiritual power over her affliction was the pretext for the assault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.swatantraprabhat.com/article/181300/two-including-ojha-convicted-of-rape-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'दुष्कर्म के दोषी ओझा समेत दो को आजीवन कारावास की सजा', Swatantra Prabhat, Jun. 2026.",
"body": "Report of the conviction, sentence and exorcism-pretext facts.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.tarunmitra.in/state/uttar-pradesh/in-the-rape-case-in-sonbhadra-two-accused-were-also/article-147710",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'सोनभद्र में दुष्कर्म मामले में दाे अभियुक्तों को आजीवन कारावास, अर्थदंड भी लगा', Tarun Mitra.",
"body": "Corroborating regional report of the same verdict.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.swatantraprabhat.com/article/181300/two-including-ojha-convicted-of-rape-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2945940430346502ceadc5e2bcd14e329a1cd71c19bd15a5dcce146c25179723",
"final_url": "https://www.swatantraprabhat.com/article/181300/two-including-ojha-convicted-of-rape-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment"
},
{
"source": "https://www.tarunmitra.in/state/uttar-pradesh/in-the-rape-case-in-sonbhadra-two-accused-were-also/article-147710",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "00ce882f4bf3ad4b91a598a2bcd53a3781812b55aab677755f46eee58d924844",
"final_url": "https://www.tarunmitra.in/state/uttar-pradesh/in-the-rape-case-in-sonbhadra-two-accused-were-also/article-147710"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 940,
"aliases": [
"Ramaaram"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. 34 witnesses and over 190 documents were presented at trial. No appeal located as of sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-ramlal-tantrik-sirohi-rajasthan-india",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Anadara, Sirohi, Rajasthan, India",
"lat": 24.8322,
"lng": 72.8631,
"title": "India: history-sheeter tantrik sentenced to life for luring a minor under a superstition pretext and forcing a fraudulent marriage",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled tantrik with a prior criminal history"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"superstition/exorcism pretext used to lure and isolate the victim",
"fraudulent marriage ceremony staged in a forest to assert a lasting claim over her"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Special POCSO Court, Sirohi, Rajasthan, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-07-11",
"outcome": "Ramlal alias Ramaaram, a tantrik with a prior criminal history, was convicted of luring a minor girl under a superstition/exorcism pretext, taking her to a forest to stage a fraudulent marriage ceremony, and sexually assaulting her. Special Judge Anoop Kumar Pathak sentenced him to life imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1 lakh; an accomplice who assisted in staging the fraudulent marriage registration was sentenced to 10 years and a Rs 20,000 fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim came under the defendant's influence through claimed exorcism/superstition-based authority, which he used to isolate her before staging a marriage to assert further control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.etvbharat.com/hi/!state/history-sheeter-tantrik-convicted-of-marrying-and-molestin-a-minor-gets-life-imprisonment-in-sirohi-rajasthan-news-rjs25071106573",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'नाबालिग से शादी और दुष्कर्म, हिस्ट्रीशीटर तांत्रिक को मिली ये बड़ी सजा', ETV Bharat, 11 Jul. 2025.",
"body": "Report of the conviction, sentence and the exorcism/fraudulent-marriage facts.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.amarujala.com/video/rajasthan/sirohi/life-imprisonment-to-tantrik-history-sheeter-and-10-years-rigorous-imprisonment-to-his-associate-sirohi-news-c-1-1-noi1344-3158984-2025-07-12",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'झाड़-फूंक के बहाने नाबालिग से जबरन शादी और ज्यादती, कोर्ट ने आजीवन कारावास की सजा सुनाई', Amar Ujala, 12 Jul. 2025.",
"body": "Corroborating report confirming the exorcism pretext, sentence breakdown for both defendants.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.etvbharat.com/hi/!state/history-sheeter-tantrik-convicted-of-marrying-and-molestin-a-minor-gets-life-imprisonment-in-sirohi-rajasthan-news-rjs25071106573",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0e441a0cac3528c39e2c7f79fb1f165cdbc59755fc029800ab1ce2bc5e2b30aa",
"final_url": "https://www.etvbharat.com/hi/!state/history-sheeter-tantrik-convicted-of-marrying-and-molestin-a-minor-gets-life-imprisonment-in-sirohi-rajasthan-news-rjs25071106573"
},
{
"source": "https://www.amarujala.com/video/rajasthan/sirohi/life-imprisonment-to-tantrik-history-sheeter-and-10-years-rigorous-imprisonment-to-his-associate-sirohi-news-c-1-1-noi1344-3158984-2025-07-12",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3b869ca3f7c578a77dbb58118b1cfe435a2019e207d55fff14cf39ac19d8e7da",
"final_url": "https://www.amarujala.com/video/rajasthan/sirohi/life-imprisonment-to-tantrik-history-sheeter-and-10-years-rigorous-imprisonment-to-his-associate-sirohi-news-c-1-1-noi1344-3158984-2025-07-12"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 941,
"aliases": [
"Jagdish"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim, not identified. Assault occurred December 2021; case filed March 2022; convicted April 2026. Only one outlet located as of sourcing (direct prosecutor-sourced regional report); no appeal located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jagdish-baba-solan-himachal-pradesh-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Nalagarh, Solan, Himachal Pradesh, India",
"lat": 31.05,
"lng": 76.7167,
"title": "India: self-styled healer sentenced to life for raping a woman who sought treatment, then threatening her family with tantric curses",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled faith healer ('Baba') offering jhaad-phoonk and herbal treatment"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"healing/treatment pretext used to gain access to the victim",
"threats of tantric curses against the family when treatment was refused"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Additional District and Sessions Court, Nalagarh, Himachal Pradesh, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-04-19",
"outcome": "Jagdish, a self-styled faith healer known as 'Baba' who claimed to cure ailments through exorcism rituals and herbal remedies, was convicted of raping a woman who had approached him for treatment. When her family later refused further treatment, he threatened them with tantric curses. He was sentenced to life imprisonment under Section 376 IPC plus two years under Section 506 (criminal intimidation), with fines totalling Rs 52,000."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim came to the defendant specifically seeking his claimed healing powers; he exploited that vulnerability to assault her, then used a further claim of spiritual/tantric power to intimidate her family into silence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.amarujala.com/himachal-pradesh/solan/solan-godman-convicted-of-rape-under-the-pretext-of-treatment-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment-fined-50000-2026-04-19",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'इलाज के बहाने दुष्कर्म के दोषी ढोंगी बाबा को उम्रकैद, साथ में 50 हजार रुपये जुर्माना', Amar Ujala, 19 Apr. 2026.",
"body": "Report of the conviction, sentence, and the treatment-pretext and tantric-curse-threat facts, sourced to the sub-district prosecutor.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.amarujala.com/himachal-pradesh/solan/solan-godman-convicted-of-rape-under-the-pretext-of-treatment-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment-fined-50000-2026-04-19",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "015afceb423ede11aaf007c7d989aa74c0332d2d37f61d95affe8f581417011d",
"final_url": "https://www.amarujala.com/himachal-pradesh/solan/solan-godman-convicted-of-rape-under-the-pretext-of-treatment-sentenced-to-life-imprisonment-fined-50000-2026-04-19"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 942,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Seven co-defendants convicted; roles of the six accomplices beyond facilitating the abduction are not detailed in sourcing. No appeal located as of sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-rameshwar-baba-hoshangabad-madhya-pradesh-india",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Itarsi, Hoshangabad, Madhya Pradesh, India",
"lat": 22.6114,
"lng": 77.7611,
"title": "India: tantrik 'Baba' and six accomplices convicted of raping a child delivered to him under a religious-ceremony pretext",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled tantrik 'Baba'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"kanyabhoj (ritual girl-worship ceremony) used as a pretext to obtain custody of the child",
"claimed tantra vidya (occult ritual power) invoked during the assault"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"ritual-initiation",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Second Additional Sessions Court, Itarsi, Hoshangabad, Madhya Pradesh, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-06-01",
"outcome": "Rameshwar, a self-styled tantrik known as 'Baba', and six accomplices were convicted of the rape of a minor girl who had been delivered to him under the pretext of taking her to a religious katha and kanyabhoj (ritual feeding/worship of young girls as embodiments of the goddess); he raped her twice, invoking tantra vidya (occult ritual practice) as part of the assault. Judge Preeti Singh sentenced all seven to five years' imprisonment under the POCSO Act plus concurrent sentences for kidnapping and wrongful confinement, with fines."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was obtained specifically through a religious-ceremony pretext (kanyabhoj) that traded on her family's trust in the ritual, and the assault itself was framed and justified to her as tantra vidya.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.patrika.com/crime-news/baba-gets-5-year-sentence-for-raping-minor-punishment-4652089/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'कन्याभोज के बहाने बच्ची को छोड़ा तांत्रिक बाबा के पास, बाबा ने बच्ची के साथ तंत्र विद्या के बहाने किया दुष्कर्म', Patrika News.",
"body": "Report of the conviction, sentence, and the kanyabhoj/tantra-vidya pretext facts.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.patrika.com/crime-news/baba-gets-5-year-sentence-for-raping-minor-punishment-4652089/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6f741b5e68b9ea5180a8040e466af941a4a5e4f56dc9fee26a6bda59f5250564",
"final_url": "https://www.patrika.com/hoshangabad-news/baba-gets-5-year-sentence-for-raping-minor-punishment-4652089"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9001,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "appellate-division-2d-dept",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Affirmed (2015 NY Slip Op 03178, 127 A.D.3d 985)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims identified only as students in the defendant's Sunday school class, not named. Record drawn from the Appellate Division's affirmance; no family relationship between defendant and victims is stated or implied anywhere in the opinion.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-humberto-cruz-newburgh-new-york-usa",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Newburgh, New York, USA",
"lat": 41.5034,
"lng": -74.0104,
"title": "United States (2010): youth pastor's convictions for abusing three Sunday-school boys affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor at the Church of God in Newburgh",
"Sunday school teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and teaching authority over boys enrolled in his Sunday school class"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the State of New York, Appellate Division, Second Department (People v Cruz, 2015 NY Slip Op 03178)",
"stage": "conviction affirmed",
"date": "2015-04-15",
"outcome": "Humberto Cruz, a youth pastor at the Church of God in Newburgh, was convicted following a jury verdict of course of sexual conduct against a child in the first degree, criminal sexual act in the first degree, sexual abuse in the second degree, and endangering the welfare of a child (seven counts), for abusing three boys who were students in the Sunday school class he taught during the summer of 2005. The Appellate Division affirmed the judgment of conviction and held the evidence legally sufficient and the verdict not against the weight of the evidence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The opinion states the defendant was 'a youth pastor at the Church of God in Newburgh' who 'was accused of sexually abusing three boys who were students in the Sunday school class that he taught' — the church teaching role is the charged mechanism, not background context.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/html/2015/04/15/people_v._cruz.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People v Cruz, 127 A.D.3d 985, 2015 NY Slip Op 03178 (N.Y. App. Div. 2d Dep't 2015).",
"body": "The appellate opinion, retrieved via the CourtListener public CDN.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "appellate-division-2d-dept",
"date": "2015",
"note": "Affirmed (2015 NY Slip Op 03178, 127 A.D.3d 985)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/html/2015/04/15/people_v._cruz.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d0abaf24a79bea952c84f7a0718cab8c373a0c09f22106114c3072920a65b5fa",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/html/2015/04/15/people_v._cruz.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9002,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "arkansas-court-of-appeals",
"date": "2018",
"note": "Direct appeal affirmed (2018 Ark. App. 231, 547 S.W.3d 753)."
},
{
"stage": "arkansas-court-of-appeals-pcr",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Denial of post-conviction relief affirmed (2019 Ark. App. 104, 572 S.W.3d 458); the PCR panel expressly recites that the direct-appeal convictions were affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims identified only as two teenaged girls in Jackson's youth group, not named. No family relationship to the defendant is stated in either opinion.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-andrew-lee-jackson-garland-county-arkansas-usa",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Hot Springs, Garland County, Arkansas, USA",
"lat": 34.5037,
"lng": -93.0552,
"title": "United States (2017): youth pastor's rape convictions for two teenage girls affirmed on direct appeal and again on post-conviction review",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over teenage girls in his youth ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Arkansas Court of Appeals (Jackson v. State, 2018 Ark. App. 231, 547 S.W.3d 753)",
"stage": "conviction affirmed",
"date": "2018-04-04",
"outcome": "A Garland County jury convicted Andrew Lee Jackson of two counts of rape for having sexual intercourse with two teenaged girls while serving as their youth pastor. He was sentenced to forty years' imprisonment on each count, to run consecutively. The Court of Appeals affirmed."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Arkansas Court of Appeals (Jackson v. State, 2019 Ark. App. 104, 572 S.W.3d 458)",
"stage": "post-conviction relief denied, affirmed",
"date": "2019-02-20",
"outcome": "The Court of Appeals affirmed the circuit court's denial of Jackson's petition for post-conviction relief, reiterating that his convictions had been affirmed on direct appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both opinions state the rapes occurred 'while serving as their youth pastor' — his pastoral role over the girls in his youth group is the charged mechanism.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/6241681/jackson-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jackson v. State, 2018 Ark. App. 231, 547 S.W.3d 753 (Ark. Ct. App. 2018).",
"body": "Direct-appeal opinion affirming the convictions and sentence.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
},
{
"link": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/6244006/jackson-v-state/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jackson v. State, 2019 Ark. App. 104, 572 S.W.3d 458 (Ark. Ct. App. 2019).",
"body": "Post-conviction-relief opinion, recites that the direct-appeal convictions were affirmed.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "arkansas-court-of-appeals",
"date": "2018",
"note": "Direct appeal affirmed (2018 Ark. App. 231, 547 S.W.3d 753)."
},
{
"stage": "arkansas-court-of-appeals-pcr",
"date": "2019",
"note": "Denial of post-conviction relief affirmed (2019 Ark. App. 104, 572 S.W.3d 458); the PCR panel expressly recites that the direct-appeal convictions were affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/6241681/jackson-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/6241681/jackson-v-state/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/6244006/jackson-v-state/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/6244006/jackson-v-state/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9003,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "iowa-court-of-appeals",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Affirmed (2016 WL 6636865)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victim was a sixteen-year-old member of Maxwell's church youth group who had approached him and his wife for mentorship; not a relative. Maxwell's two young sons were present in an adjoining part of the room during the charged assault, per the victim's testimony, but are not implicated as victims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-brian-maxwell-winterset-iowa-usa",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Winterset, Madison County, Iowa, USA",
"lat": 41.3403,
"lng": -94.0128,
"title": "United States (2014): church youth coordinator's conviction for assaulting a sixteen-year-old group member affirmed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth coordinator for two churches in the Winterset area"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"youth-ministry mentorship authority over a congregant who had come to him for guidance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Iowa Court of Appeals (State of Iowa v. Brian James Maxwell)",
"stage": "conviction affirmed",
"date": "2016-11-09",
"outcome": "Brian Maxwell, hired as youth coordinator for two churches in the Winterset area, was convicted following a bench trial of lascivious conduct with a minor after assaulting a sixteen-year-old member of his youth group inside the church's youth room. He was sentenced to one year in jail (120 days to serve, remainder suspended), two years' probation, and a ten-year special sentence under Iowa Code section 903B.2. The Court of Appeals affirmed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a youth-group member who approached Maxwell and his wife for mentorship after 'personal struggles'; the charged assault occurred in the church's 'downstairs youth room' during his role as youth coordinator, not in a domestic or family setting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2016/11/09/state_of_iowa_v._brian_james_maxwell.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Maxwell, No. 15-1392, 2016 WL 6636865 (Iowa Ct. App. Nov. 9, 2016).",
"body": "The appellate opinion, retrieved via the CourtListener public CDN.",
"tier": "official-court-judgment",
"kind": "appellate-judgment"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "iowa-court-of-appeals",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Affirmed (2016 WL 6636865)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2016/11/09/state_of_iowa_v._brian_james_maxwell.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-judgment; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0836bfbad622b903025c2a19316c87e608e745d481e1ab9ac4d165b5f4b5a84e",
"final_url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/pdf/2016/11/09/state_of_iowa_v._brian_james_maxwell.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 946,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a statutory charity-regulator finding under the Charities Act 2011, distinct from and additional to the Rigpa-commissioned Lewis Silkin investigation already in the corpus (record 2018-sogyal-rinpoche-rigpa-europe). It is an official government regulatory finding, not a criminal conviction: no criminal charges against Sogyal Lakar are known to have been brought before his death in 2019. The regulatory actions (disqualification of Gaffney, removal and disqualification of Burrows) are civil/regulatory sanctions under the Charities Act, not criminal penalties.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-rigpa-charity-commission-inquiry-london-uk",
"year": 2020,
"place": "London, UK",
"lat": 51.5074,
"lng": -0.1278,
"title": "Charity Commission for England and Wales statutory inquiry finds Rigpa put students at risk of harm from Sogyal Lakar",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and Tibetan Buddhist teacher",
"charity trustees responsible for safeguarding"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"guru devotion",
"spiritual hierarchy",
"institutional dependency",
"safeguarding policies that blurred consent and submission"
],
"organizations": [
"Rigpa Fellowship"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Charity Commission for England and Wales",
"stage": "statutory inquiry opened",
"date": "2018-11-08",
"outcome": "The Commission opened a statutory inquiry into Rigpa Fellowship under section 46 of the Charities Act 2011 following the 2017 letter from eight senior students and the Lewis Silkin independent investigation."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Charity Commission for England and Wales",
"stage": "final inquiry report",
"date": "2020-11-20",
"outcome": "The statutory inquiry found that some students of Sogyal Lakar, part of an 'inner circle', were subjected to serious physical, sexual and emotional abuse by him, and that senior individuals within the charity were aware of at least some of these issues and failed to address them, exposing beneficiaries to risk of harm. The Commission found the charity's safeguarding policies inadequate and criticised policies that 'blurred the distinction between consent and submission', placing responsibility for safeguarding on the student rather than the teacher. Former trustee Patrick Gaffney was found unfit to serve as a trustee and disqualified for 8 years under s181A of the Charities Act 2011 (effective 12 April 2019) after the inquiry found he knew of 1994 abuse allegations and failed to act. Former trustee Susan Burrows was removed as trustee under s79(4) of the Charities Act 2011 (effective 20 September 2019) and permanently disqualified from acting as a trustee or senior manager of any charity, after the inquiry found she had knowledge of abuse allegations and failed to act appropriately."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The inquiry found that guru devotion and the spiritual hierarchy Sogyal Lakar held over an 'inner circle' of students, combined with institutional safeguarding policies that placed responsibility on students rather than the teacher, is what allowed serious physical, sexual and emotional abuse to occur and to go unaddressed by trustees who knew of it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/charity-inquiry-rigpa-fellowship/charity-inquiry-rigpa-fellowship",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Charity Commission for England and Wales, 'Charity Inquiry: Rigpa Fellowship' (published 20 Nov. 2020, updated 30 Dec. 2020; withdrawn as current guidance 6 Jan. 2023 but preserved as the official inquiry report).",
"body": "The Commission's statutory inquiry report finds that some students in Sogyal Lakar's inner circle were subjected to serious physical, sexual and emotional abuse by him, that senior charity figures knew and failed to act, and that safeguarding policies were inadequate. It records the disqualification of trustee Patrick Gaffney for 8 years and the removal and permanent disqualification of trustee Susan Burrows.",
"tier": "official-finding",
"kind": "statutory-regulator-inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.islingtongazette.co.uk/news/21224608.shameful-sogyal-rinpoches-cally-buddhist-charity-rigpa-put-students-risk-harm-charity-commission-finds/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Islington Gazette, \"'Shameful': Sogyal Rinpoche's Cally Buddhist charity Rigpa 'put students at risk of harm', Charity Commission finds\" (Nov. 2020).",
"body": "Contemporaneous press reporting of the Charity Commission's findings, summarising the abuse findings, the trustee failures, and the disqualification/removal actions taken against Gaffney and Burrows.",
"tier": "national-news-court-and-regulator-reporting",
"kind": "regulatory-finding-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.civilsociety.co.uk/news/trustee-who-failed-to-act-on-knowledge-of-serious-abuse-against-students-is-permanently-banned-from-trusteeship.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Civil Society News, 'Trustee who failed to act on knowledge of serious abuse against students is permanently banned from trusteeship' (2020).",
"body": "Sector press reporting on the Charity Commission's disqualification of Susan Burrows and the underlying inquiry findings on safeguarding failures at Rigpa.",
"tier": "sector-press-regulatory-reporting",
"kind": "regulatory-finding-report"
}
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/charity-inquiry-rigpa-fellowship/charity-inquiry-rigpa-fellowship",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding; evidentiary role: statutory-regulator-inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9dff3b3cf62f0e0fdbe018d999e5bb9a747fe873ea4f990cdf56cb3b36186ec9",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/charity-inquiry-rigpa-fellowship/charity-inquiry-rigpa-fellowship"
},
{
"source": "https://www.islingtongazette.co.uk/news/21224608.shameful-sogyal-rinpoches-cally-buddhist-charity-rigpa-put-students-risk-harm-charity-commission-finds/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-court-and-regulator-reporting; evidentiary role: regulatory-finding-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "70f8eb2b2c01f481ee8abb5e4828385e056a2b1f3c8ad9e21b4da71e8b1de9d1",
"final_url": "https://www.islingtongazette.co.uk/news/21224608.shameful-sogyal-rinpoches-cally-buddhist-charity-rigpa-put-students-risk-harm-charity-commission-finds/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.civilsociety.co.uk/news/trustee-who-failed-to-act-on-knowledge-of-serious-abuse-against-students-is-permanently-banned-from-trusteeship.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: sector-press-regulatory-reporting; evidentiary role: regulatory-finding-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "43e5dc2a440d43931c109bcc8679063b6c4e40f97f6dc6012cdc61bac4368786",
"final_url": "https://www.civilsociety.co.uk/news/trustee-who-failed-to-act-on-knowledge-of-serious-abuse-against-students-is-permanently-banned-from-trusteeship.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 947,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim was a minor and is identified in survivor advocacy only by first name/pseudonym in public reporting; she is not named here. The Guru Gobind Singh Foundation retained Singh in a role at the gurdwara for roughly 23 years after his 1997 guilty plea before he resigned in October 2020 following renewed public disclosure; that resignation followed a formal GGSF statement acknowledging the conviction, included here as institutional context, not as a separate proceeding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1997-gurdarshan-singh-guru-gobind-singh-foundation-maryland-usa",
"year": 1997,
"place": "Potomac, Maryland, USA",
"lat": 39.0284,
"lng": -77.2094,
"title": "Gurdarshan Singh (head granthi, Guru Gobind Singh Foundation): guilty plea for child sexual abuse of a student",
"tradition": "sikhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-sikh",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"head granthi (religious leader), Guru Gobind Singh Foundation, Potomac, Maryland",
"kirtan/religious-music teacher to the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"granthi authority over a devout family",
"trust extended through religious instruction",
"access to a child through religious teaching role"
],
"organizations": [
"Guru Gobind Singh Foundation (GGSF), Potomac, Maryland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court for Montgomery County, Maryland",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"outcome": "Gurdarshan Singh pleaded guilty to one count of Sexual Offense in the Fourth Degree under Article 27, section 464(C) of the Maryland Code, arising from the sexual abuse of a girl he taught kirtan/religious music, beginning when she was approximately eleven years old (1989-1991). In August 1997 he was resentenced to 360 days' imprisonment, suspended."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As head granthi of the Guru Gobind Singh Foundation, Singh held recognized religious authority within the Maryland Sikh community; his role as the victim's religious-music teacher, extended through that authority, gave him the access and the family's trust that made the abuse possible.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ramneetks.medium.com/gurdarshan-singh-and-why-its-so-hard-to-believe-survivors-2c4ac9f10327",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ramneet Sachdev, 'Gurdarshan Singh and Why It's So Hard to Believe Survivors', Medium (2020).",
"body": "Documents the 1997 Maryland guilty plea to Sexual Offense in the Fourth Degree under Article 27 section 464(C), the resentencing to 360 days suspended in August 1997, and Singh's continued role at GGSF for over two decades afterward.",
"tier": "advocacy-journalism-with-court-citation",
"kind": "case-history-and-court-record-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sikhpa.com/metoosikh-sikh-activists-take-on-internal-sexual-abuse-crimes/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SikhPA, '#MeTooSikh: Sikh activists take on internal sexual abuse crimes' (2020).",
"body": "Reports the Gurdarshan Singh case as part of a wider #MeTooSikh reckoning, describing his position as head granthi at GGSF and the community response following renewed disclosure in 2020.",
"tier": "community-advocacy-reporting",
"kind": "case-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://asiasamachar.com/2020/10/03/34010/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Asia Samachar, 'We are not strangers to sexual abuse by kirtanias and granthis' (Oct. 2020).",
"body": "Sikh-community news outlet coverage discussing the Gurdarshan Singh case among a pattern of abuse by kirtan teachers and granthis, and GGSF's 2020 public acknowledgment.",
"tier": "community-press-reporting",
"kind": "case-summary"
}
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ramneetks.medium.com/gurdarshan-singh-and-why-its-so-hard-to-believe-survivors-2c4ac9f10327",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-journalism-with-court-citation; evidentiary role: case-history-and-court-record-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c58b9cf863a233dddb8346956171e9a9817973263a6389df68566852ed583090",
"final_url": "https://ramneetks.medium.com/gurdarshan-singh-and-why-its-so-hard-to-believe-survivors-2c4ac9f10327"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sikhpa.com/metoosikh-sikh-activists-take-on-internal-sexual-abuse-crimes/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: community-advocacy-reporting; evidentiary role: case-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "df8c8ffd9b74fbf40d6280530e1dd18329598ed7ccb5f501e233f8a66ec7db9a",
"final_url": "https://www.sikhpa.com/metoosikh-sikh-activists-take-on-internal-sexual-abuse-crimes/"
},
{
"source": "https://asiasamachar.com/2020/10/03/34010/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: community-press-reporting; evidentiary role: case-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8ff64596e93ac221b56d69570a322c439125239666ef30dac9b8c5e79e6b7913",
"final_url": "https://asiasamachar.com/2020/10/03/34010/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 948,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The complainant was a minor at the time of the offense and is not identified here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-meir-dascalowitz-mikveh-brooklyn-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Williamsburg, Brooklyn, New York, USA",
"lat": 40.7081,
"lng": -73.9571,
"title": "Meir Dascalowitz: guilty plea for molesting a disabled teenage boy in a Satmar mikveh",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"mikveh attendant/supervisor in the Satmar community"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"access to a mentally disabled minor inside the ritual bath he supervised, and the community's expectation of deference to religious functionaries"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"sacred-sex-purity",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kings County Supreme Court, New York",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2013-05-01",
"outcome": "Meir Dascalowitz, 27, pleaded guilty to second-degree sexual abuse for molesting a mentally disabled Hasidic teenage boy inside a mikveh (ritual bath) and was sentenced to 5 years in prison. He was later released, re-arrested for a parole violation, and re-released."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Dascalowitz had supervisory access to the boy inside the mikveh, a space governed by strict religious rules of purity and modesty where a minor is expected to submit to the adult attendant's direction; the family that reported the abuse was subsequently shunned and intimidated within the Satmar community for pursuing the case.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://vinnews.com/2013/04/18/brooklyn-ny-williamsburg-man-pleads-guilty-to-molesting-hasidic-teen-in-mikva-to-get-5-yrs/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Williamsburg Man Pleads Guilty To Molesting Hasidic Teen In Mikva; To Get 5 Yrs', VINnews (2013).",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea to second-degree sexual abuse and the agreed five-year sentence for molesting a disabled teenager in the mikveh.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_abuse_cases_in_Brooklyn%27s_Haredi_community",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sexual abuse cases in Brooklyn's Haredi community', Wikipedia.",
"body": "Summarizes the case within the broader pattern of Haredi community sexual-abuse cases and community retaliation against reporting families.",
"tier": "reference-summary",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://vinnews.com/2013/04/18/brooklyn-ny-williamsburg-man-pleads-guilty-to-molesting-hasidic-teen-in-mikva-to-get-5-yrs/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8d0cb7659a4d7aa9625d6defad1727d69458fa3d76861311b7ccd70451912169",
"final_url": "https://vinnews.com/2013/04/18/brooklyn-ny-williamsburg-man-pleads-guilty-to-molesting-hasidic-teen-in-mikva-to-get-5-yrs/"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_abuse_cases_in_Brooklyn%27s_Haredi_community",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-summary; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0cea648206aacfc865e6abeb55e891606dddb9f29718eac097e4c276ffd2ba6d",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_abuse_cases_in_Brooklyn%27s_Haredi_community"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 949,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Two victims: a minor student (abuse began at age 14) and an adult employee. Neither is identified here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-mohammed-abdullah-saleem-elgin-illinois-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Elgin, Illinois, USA",
"lat": 42.0354,
"lng": -88.2826,
"title": "Imam Mohammed Abdullah Saleem: guilty plea for abusing a student and an employee at the Islamic school he founded",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam",
"founder and head of an Islamic educational institute"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious and scholarly authority as founder of the school over a minor student and an adult employee dependent on him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Institute of Islamic Education, Elgin, Illinois"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kane County Circuit Court, Illinois",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2016-08-25",
"outcome": "Mohammad Abdullah Saleem, founder and head of the Institute of Islamic Education, pleaded guilty to two counts of aggravated criminal sexual abuse against a student who was 14 at the time abuse began and an adult employee. He was sentenced to 24 months of probation and required to register as a sexual predator for life, with restrictions on contact with the school and with females outside his family."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the founder and recognized religious scholar heading the Institute, Saleem held direct authority over a minor student's religious education and an employee's livelihood at the school; the abuse occurred during office visits tied to that institutional standing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://chicago.suntimes.com/2016/8/25/18435304/islamic-cleric-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-assault-of-a-student",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Islamic cleric pleads guilty to sexual assault of a student', Chicago Sun-Times (2016).",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea to two counts of aggravated criminal sexual abuse and the probationary sentence with lifetime sex-offender registration.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://news.wttw.com/2023/05/04/faith-leader-was-convicted-sexually-abusing-student-and-employee-he-still-lives-within",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'A Faith Leader Was Convicted of Sexually Abusing a Student and Employee. He Still Lives Within Feet of the School.', WTTW Chicago News (2023).",
"body": "Follow-up reporting confirming the conviction stood and detailing Saleem's continued proximity to the school post-conviction.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-press",
"kind": "follow-up-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://chicago.suntimes.com/2016/8/25/18435304/islamic-cleric-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-assault-of-a-student",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fcbc45ddaebfac273b931a2365ec24dafd0fd44943babfbe983066205383524f",
"final_url": "https://chicago.suntimes.com/2016/8/25/18435304/islamic-cleric-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-assault-of-a-student"
},
{
"source": "https://news.wttw.com/2023/05/04/faith-leader-was-convicted-sexually-abusing-student-and-employee-he-still-lives-within",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-press; evidentiary role: follow-up-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9f7c75cf4bb0ca1200a448159d42cbfb32b2bad5e7a373dd8ab6b6c18be945fa",
"final_url": "https://news.wttw.com/2023/05/04/faith-leader-was-convicted-sexually-abusing-student-and-employee-he-still-lives-within"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 950,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Three child victims identified only by initials in court reporting; not identified here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-mohamed-omar-ali-fort-bend-texas-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Fort Bend County, Texas, USA",
"lat": 29.5738,
"lng": -95.7563,
"title": "Mohamed Omar Ali: 35-year sentence for abusing children he recruited through mosques to teach the Quran",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled Quran teacher and Islamic religious instructor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-instruction authority used to gain access to and private time with children recruited through multiple mosques"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "400th District Court, Fort Bend County, Texas",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence; appeal filed",
"date": "2021-11-03",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Mohamed Omar Ali of aggravated sexual assault of a child and two counts of indecency with a child by sexual contact. Judge Tameika Carter sentenced him to 35 years for the aggravated sexual assault count and 10 years on each indecency count, served concurrently. Ali abused multiple children between 2013 and 2019 whom he met through different mosques by offering to teach them the Quran. Ali appealed to the Texas First Court of Appeals (Nos. 01-21-00604-CR, 01-21-00607-CR); this record does not assert a final appellate disposition beyond the trial conviction and sentence, which stood as of the appeal filing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ali used the specific offer of private Quran instruction to identify and isolate children across multiple mosque communities; the religious-instruction relationship itself was the access mechanism, not incidental context to a family or custodial relationship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://abc13.com/mohamed-omar-ali-fort-bend-county-islamic-teacher-arrested/11195491/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Mohamed Omar Ali, convicted of sex crimes while teaching Quran to children, sentenced to 35 years in prison', ABC13 Houston (2021).",
"body": "Reports the jury conviction and 35-year sentence, and describes Ali's method of recruiting victims through mosques by offering Quran instruction.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/texas/first-court-of-appeals/2023/01-21-00604-cr.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Mohammed Omar Ali v. State of Texas, No. 01-21-00604-CR, Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] (2023).",
"body": "Docket record confirming the case was before the Texas First Court of Appeals following the trial conviction.",
"tier": "court-record",
"kind": "appellate-docket"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://abc13.com/mohamed-omar-ali-fort-bend-county-islamic-teacher-arrested/11195491/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "174bd9a7a84fdb1f893549644f6ef78b97ceee7496acd92b200f9af097cad627",
"final_url": "https://abc13.com/post/mohamed-omar-ali-fort-bend-county-islamic-teacher-arrested/11195491/?userab=kfsn_content_recs-582*variant_a_control_kfsn-2512%2Ckabc_content_recs-577*variant_a_control-2480%2Cwls_content_recs-584*variant_a_control_wls-2516%2Cwtvd_content_recs-585*variant_a_control_wtvd-2518%2Cktrk_content_recs-587*variant_a_control_ktrk-2522%2Cwpvi_content_recs-586*variant_a_control_wpvi-2520%2Cotv_web_content_rec-539*variant_c_trending-2268%2Cotv_web_topic-580*variant_a_topic-2508%2Cotv_search_page_design_unification-546*variant_b_search_redesign-2300%2Ckgo_content_recs-583*variant_a_control_kgo-2514%2Cabcn_popular_reads_exp-542*variant_b_7days_filter-2288"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/texas/first-court-of-appeals/2023/01-21-00604-cr.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-record; evidentiary role: appellate-docket.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 951,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The child victim is not identified here. Co-defendant Blake Miller Barakat (Alabama) was sentenced separately in the same conspiracy and is not treated as a distinct religious-authority nexus here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-wisam-sharieff-euless-texas-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Euless, Texas, USA",
"lat": 32.8371,
"lng": -97.082,
"title": "Online Quran instructor 'Imam' Wisam Sharieff: 80-year federal sentence for child sexual exploitation framed as religious practice",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled 'Imam'; online Quran-recitation instructor claiming over 25,000 students"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"explicit religious framing that sexual conduct improved Quran recitation and closeness to God, used to groom a co-defendant into exploiting a child"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"sacred-sex-purity",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Northern District of Alabama",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-30",
"outcome": "Wisam Sharieff pleaded guilty in June 2025 to conspiracy to engage in sexual exploitation of children, conspiracy to receive and distribute child pornography, and sexual exploitation of children. He was sentenced to 960 months (80 years) in federal prison plus a life term of supervised release, and ordered to pay a $135,000 special assessment under the AVAA. Court documents state Sharieff told his co-defendant that achieving sexual pleasure could improve Quran recitation and bring a person closer to Allah, and that in October 2024 the pair coerced a seven-year-old child to engage in sexually explicit conduct to produce child pornography."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sharieff's claimed religious authority as an 'Imam' and Quran instructor was the explicit operative pretext: he articulated a theological justification — that sexual pleasure improved recitation and closeness to Allah — to induce the exploitation, not a background credential incidental to the crime.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndal/pr/two-individuals-sentenced-70-and-80-years-conspiracy-sexually-exploit-child",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Two Individuals Sentenced to 70 and 80 Years in Conspiracy to Sexually Exploit a Child', U.S. Department of Justice, Northern District of Alabama (2026).",
"body": "DOJ press release confirming the guilty plea, the 80-year sentence for Sharieff, and the religious-pretext language used to justify the abuse.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndal/pr/two-individuals-sentenced-70-and-80-years-conspiracy-sexually-exploit-child",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b1925781e3ccc7e7d5a4f2ce00e6bb3b250ae9a022b73806cbe0a3c74e997f2e",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndal/pr/two-individuals-sentenced-70-and-80-years-conspiracy-sexually-exploit-child"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 952,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Civil finding, not a criminal conviction. Sheikh stated he was considering an appeal; no reversal was located in the sources reviewed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-zia-ul-haq-sheikh-irving-texas-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Irving, Texas, USA",
"lat": 32.814,
"lng": -96.9489,
"title": "Imam Zia Ul-Haq Sheikh ordered to pay $2.55 million after grooming a congregant he counseled from her teens",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "civil-judgment",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"head imam, Islamic Center of Irving; pastoral counselor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"years of religious and pastoral counseling authority over a congregant beginning in her teens, used to escalate into a sexual relationship once she turned 19"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Islamic Center of Irving"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "298th Judicial District Court, Dallas County, Texas",
"stage": "civil judgment; appealed",
"date": "2019-08-15",
"outcome": "District Court Judge Emily Tobolowsky ordered Imam Zia Ul-Haq Sheikh, head imam of the Islamic Center of Irving from 2005 to his forced resignation in 2017, to pay $2.55 million in mental-anguish and punitive damages plus legal fees to a woman he had provided religious/mental-health counseling since she was a minor and with whom he initiated a sexual relationship once she turned 19. Sheikh appealed to the Texas Fifth Court of Appeals (No. 05-19-01329-CV); this record does not assert a final appellate disposition."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sheikh's authority derived from years of religious pastoral counseling of the victim beginning in her teenage years at the mosque; the relationship of religious dependency, not a family or purely secular therapeutic tie, is what the civil finding centers on.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://religionnews.com/2019/08/15/texas-imam-ordered-to-pay-2-55-million-in-sexual-misconduct-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Texas imam ordered to pay $2.55 million in sexual misconduct case', Religion News Service (2019).",
"body": "Reports the civil judgment amount, the counseling relationship beginning in the victim's teens, and Sheikh's tenure and forced resignation as head imam.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-press",
"kind": "civil-judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/texas/fifth-court-of-appeals/2021/05-19-01329-cv.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Zia Ul-Haq Sheikh v. Jane Doe, No. 05-19-01329-CV, Tex. App.—Dallas (2021).",
"body": "Appellate docket record confirming the case proceeded to the Fifth Court of Appeals following the trial-court judgment.",
"tier": "court-record",
"kind": "appellate-docket"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://religionnews.com/2019/08/15/texas-imam-ordered-to-pay-2-55-million-in-sexual-misconduct-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-press; evidentiary role: civil-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "caeec2a40af0911256c131b4cdefcba4437db84d9e71c4f42ee6448f8eadb710",
"final_url": "https://religionnews.com/2019/08/15/texas-imam-ordered-to-pay-2-55-million-in-sexual-misconduct-case/"
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/texas/fifth-court-of-appeals/2021/05-19-01329-cv.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-record; evidentiary role: appellate-docket.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 953,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim, an 11-13 year old piano student at the time, is not identified here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1997-gurdarshan-singh-potomac-maryland-usa",
"year": 1997,
"place": "Potomac, Maryland, USA",
"lat": 39.0182,
"lng": -77.2086,
"title": "Gurdarshan Singh: Sikh granthi's guilty plea for abusing a child music student at his gurdwara foundation",
"tradition": "sikhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-sikh",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"granthi (custodian and reader of Sikh scripture), Guru Gobind Singh Foundation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority as the community's granthi, used to win the trust of the family and gain private access to their child under cover of religious music instruction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Guru Gobind Singh Foundation, Potomac, Maryland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Montgomery County Circuit Court, Maryland",
"stage": "guilty plea",
"date": "1997-01-01",
"outcome": "Gurdarshan Singh, Granthi of the Guru Gobind Singh Foundation, pleaded guilty to one count of sexual offense in the fourth degree under Md. Code Art. 27, Section 464(C), for abusing a child he taught music from 1989 to 1991, when she was between 11 and 13. Community leadership pressured the family to drop the case; they did not, and Singh was convicted. He resigned his gurdwara role only in 2020, 23 years after the plea."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the gurdwara's granthi, Singh held recognized religious authority within the Maryland Sikh community that he used to win the family's trust and gain unsupervised access to their daughter under the framework of religious instruction; the foundation's leadership subsequently pressured the family to withdraw the complaint.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ramneetks.medium.com/gurdarshan-singh-and-why-its-so-hard-to-believe-survivors-2c4ac9f10327",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ramneet Sachdev, 'Gurdarshan Singh and Why It's So Hard to Believe Survivors', Medium (2020).",
"body": "Details the 1997 guilty plea to fourth-degree sexual offense, the granthi's role and community pressure on the family, and his 2020 resignation.",
"tier": "community-investigative-account",
"kind": "case-history"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sikhpa.com/metoosikh-sikh-activists-take-on-internal-sexual-abuse-crimes/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'#MeTooSikh: Sikh activists take on internal sexual abuse crimes', SikhPA.",
"body": "Corroborates the case within a broader account of Sikh community advocacy against clergy sexual abuse.",
"tier": "advocacy-organization-report",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ramneetks.medium.com/gurdarshan-singh-and-why-its-so-hard-to-believe-survivors-2c4ac9f10327",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: community-investigative-account; evidentiary role: case-history.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c58b9cf863a233dddb8346956171e9a9817973263a6389df68566852ed583090",
"final_url": "https://ramneetks.medium.com/gurdarshan-singh-and-why-its-so-hard-to-believe-survivors-2c4ac9f10327"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sikhpa.com/metoosikh-sikh-activists-take-on-internal-sexual-abuse-crimes/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-organization-report; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "df8c8ffd9b74fbf40d6280530e1dd18329598ed7ccb5f501e233f8a66ec7db9a",
"final_url": "https://www.sikhpa.com/metoosikh-sikh-activists-take-on-internal-sexual-abuse-crimes/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 954,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim, 13 at the onset of the abuse, gave birth to a child as a result; she is not identified here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-camnong-boa-ubol-stickney-illinois-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Stickney Township, Illinois, USA",
"lat": 41.813,
"lng": -87.7745,
"title": "Camnong Boa-Ubol: Thai Buddhist monk's guilty plea and 15-year sentence for assaulting a girl at Wat Dhammaram",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"monk resident at Wat Dhammaram Temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic authority and control over temple-grounds employment, used to draw a 13-year-old into private contact for paid temple chores"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Wat Dhammaram Temple, Stickney Township, Illinois"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2013-09-30",
"outcome": "Camnong Boa-Ubol, a monk who lived and worked at Wat Dhammaram Temple, pleaded guilty to one count of aggravated criminal sexual assault and was sentenced to 15 years in prison. The assaults began in 1998, when the victim was 13 and he offered her paid work on the temple grounds, and continued for about two years; she became pregnant and gave birth as a result. He fled to another temple in Long Beach, California, before being arrested in Anchorage, Alaska, in 2012, roughly 13 years after the offenses began."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Boa-Ubol used his standing as a temple-resident monk to draw a child into private, paid work on temple grounds, then into an isolated trailer on the property, exploiting both his monastic authority and control over access to the temple space.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/buddhist-monk-sentenced-to-15-years-for-sexual-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Buddhist Monk Sentenced To 15 Years For Sexual Assault', CBS Chicago (2013).",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, 15-year sentence, the temple setting, the victim's age at onset, and the resulting pregnancy and birth.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting",
"kind": "plea-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.huffpost.com/entry/camnong-boa-ubol-buddhist_n_1690486",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Camnong Boa-Ubol, Former Buddhist Monk, Charged With Raping 15-Year-Old Girl', HuffPost (2012).",
"body": "Reports the arrest and initial charges, and the flight to a second temple in Long Beach, California before capture in Alaska.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/buddhist-monk-sentenced-to-15-years-for-sexual-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-court-reporting; evidentiary role: plea-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d912c292abb5f691a8e2ccac4ca896febce96883bac47ad8b1e5c20f00b67347",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/buddhist-monk-sentenced-to-15-years-for-sexual-assault/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.huffpost.com/entry/camnong-boa-ubol-buddhist_n_1690486",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5fc8ece581674450775f903a80b68f42620c3f2828b95c49bb35d8de199e524c",
"final_url": "https://www.huffpost.com/entry/camnong-boa-ubol-buddhist_n_1690486"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 955,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record documents adjudicative status only — it does not assert that a court or the DOJ has found the underlying trafficking allegations true or false. The DOJ's closure of its criminal investigation is not a finding on the merits either way, and the civil claims remain pending and untested. Workers are identified as plaintiffs in public court filings, not named here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-baps-swaminarayan-robbinsville-new-jersey-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Robbinsville, New Jersey, USA",
"lat": 40.2201,
"lng": -74.6127,
"title": "BAPS Swaminarayan temple-construction workers' federal forced-labor suit: DOJ criminal probe closed without charges, civil case active",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "unresolved",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"Bochasanwasi Akshar Purushottam Swaminarayan Sanstha (BAPS) organizational leadership"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"alleged use of caste-linked recruitment of Dalit and Adivasi workers from India, confinement to a guarded compound, and religious/organizational obedience structures, per the civil complaint's allegations"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"organizations": [
"Bochasanwasi Akshar Purushottam Swaminarayan Sanstha (BAPS)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, District of New Jersey (civil); FBI/DOJ (criminal, closed)",
"stage": "civil case active; criminal investigation closed without charges",
"date": "2026-02-25",
"outcome": "Six Indian men filed a federal civil suit in May 2021 under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act alleging BAPS forced them to work up to 87-hour weeks for roughly $1.20/hour building temples, confined to a guarded compound; the suit was later amended to add temple-construction sites in California, Illinois, Texas, and Georgia. The FBI raided the Robbinsville temple in 2021. In September 2025 the DOJ closed its criminal investigation without filing charges. The civil case continued; on 2026-02-25 the parties stipulated to a court-ordered injunction protecting plaintiffs and class members from retaliation, indicating the litigation remains active and unresolved on the merits as of this record."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The civil complaint alleges BAPS leadership used religious-organizational obedience and caste-linked recruitment networks in India to secure and control a captive workforce; this record documents only the alleged mechanism and the case's procedural posture, not an adjudicated finding, since the criminal probe closed without charges and the civil claims have not been tried or settled.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/12/us/new-jersey-baps-hindu-temple-suit",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Robbinsville, New Jersey: Lawsuit claims BAPS Hindu temple was built on forced labor', CNN (2021).",
"body": "Reports the original May 2021 federal lawsuit's allegations of forced labor, confinement, and sub-minimum wages at the Robbinsville temple construction site.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-press",
"kind": "civil-complaint-report"
},
{
"link": "https://religionnews.com/2025/09/19/doj-drops-forced-labor-case-against-largest-hindu-temple-in-america/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'DOJ drops forced labor case against largest Hindu temple in America', Religion News Service (2025).",
"body": "Reports the DOJ's September 2025 closure of its criminal forced-labor investigation into BAPS without charges.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-press",
"kind": "investigation-closure-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.communitynews.org/towns/robbinsville-advance/doj-ends-probe-of-baps-robbinsville-temple-civil-case-moves-ahead/article_aa1b6ca8-6bf6-4b31-be22-ac27f539de2a.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'DOJ closes BAPS probe; Robbinsville temple case resumes', Robbinsville Advance / communitynews.org (2026).",
"body": "Reports the February 2026 court-ordered anti-retaliation stipulation confirming the civil case remains active following the DOJ's criminal closure.",
"tier": "reliable-contemporaneous-press",
"kind": "civil-case-status-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Six Indian men filed a federal civil suit in May 2021 under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act alleging BAPS forced them to work up to 87-hour weeks for roughly $1.20/hour building temples, confined to a guarded compound; the suit was later amended to add temple-construction sites in California, Illinois, Texas, and Georgia. The FBI raided the Robbinsville temple in 2021. In September 2025 the DOJ closed its criminal investigation without filing charges. The civil case continued; on 2026-02-25 the parties stipulated to a court-ordered injunction protecting plaintiffs and class members from retaliation, indicating the litigation remains active and unresolved on the merits as of this record.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/12/us/new-jersey-baps-hindu-temple-suit",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-press; evidentiary role: civil-complaint-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "943a1e7bdea2897888e319d7c460fe19a38c612aa67f52456a93c2a751450770",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/12/us/new-jersey-baps-hindu-temple-suit"
},
{
"source": "https://religionnews.com/2025/09/19/doj-drops-forced-labor-case-against-largest-hindu-temple-in-america/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-press; evidentiary role: investigation-closure-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6be08f331d018b4d20151e8ccf845de2dab5b6e95d0192bde0d61ead32155b3e",
"final_url": "https://religionnews.com/2025/09/19/doj-drops-forced-labor-case-against-largest-hindu-temple-in-america/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.communitynews.org/towns/robbinsville-advance/doj-ends-probe-of-baps-robbinsville-temple-civil-case-moves-ahead/article_aa1b6ca8-6bf6-4b31-be22-ac27f539de2a.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reliable-contemporaneous-press; evidentiary role: civil-case-status-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "65803072987ecf7036bc569827be32c452a8f18206862e23286f292088d13763",
"final_url": "https://communitynews.org/towns/robbinsville-advance/doj-ends-probe-of-baps-robbinsville-temple-civil-case-moves-ahead/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 956,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-joseph-baker-diocese-lansing-michigan-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Lansing, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 42.7325,
"lng": -84.5555,
"title": "Michigan: priest Joseph 'Jack' Baker sentenced for first-degree criminal sexual conduct",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, pastor at multiple Michigan parishes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish and pastoral access to a child under 13"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lansing"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan circuit court (Michigan Department of Attorney General prosecution)",
"stage": "conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2023-03-01",
"outcome": "Joseph 'Jack' Baker was convicted on one count of first-degree criminal sexual conduct for sexual penetration of a person under 13 arising from a 2004 rape, and was sentenced to 3 to 15 years' incarceration. One of nine convictions secured through the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse investigation, which charged 11 clergy members and convicted 9."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the child arose from Baker's position as a parish pastor within the Diocese of Lansing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG press release summarizing the conclusion of the clergy-abuse prosecution docket, recording 11 clergy charged and 9 convicted, including Baker's sentence.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "prosecution-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Roundup naming all nine convicted priests with charges and sentences, including Baker's 3-to-15-year sentence.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: prosecution-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 957,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-neil-kalina-diocese-detroit-michigan-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Macomb County, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 42.6667,
"lng": -82.9,
"title": "Michigan: priest Neil Kalina's second-degree criminal sexual conduct conviction affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Archdiocese of Detroit"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish and pastoral access to a 14-year-old"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Detroit"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Macomb County Circuit Court, Michigan, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction; resentenced 2025; sentence affirmed by Michigan Court of Appeals",
"date": "2025-01-09",
"outcome": "A jury found Neil Kalina guilty of two counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct for assaulting a 14-year-old in the early 1980s. He was resentenced in Macomb County Circuit Court on January 9, 2025, up to 15 years, and the sentence was affirmed by the Michigan Court of Appeals. One of nine convictions secured through the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the victim arose from Kalina's position as an Archdiocese of Detroit priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG summary of the clergy-abuse prosecution docket recording the Kalina conviction among the nine.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "prosecution-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Case-status roundup recording Kalina's jury conviction, 2025 resentencing and appellate affirmance.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: prosecution-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 958,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-timothy-crowley-diocese-lansing-ann-arbor-michigan-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 42.2808,
"lng": -83.743,
"title": "Michigan: priest Timothy Crowley sentenced for second-degree criminal sexual conduct",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, St. Thomas Rectory, Ann Arbor, Diocese of Lansing"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish rectory access to a minor"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lansing"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan circuit court (Michigan Department of Attorney General prosecution)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2023-11-09",
"outcome": "Timothy Crowley pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct and was sentenced to one year incarceration and five years' probation with lifetime sex-offender registration. His sentencing was the case that formally concluded the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse prosecution docket: 11 clergy charged, 9 convicted."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the victim arose from Crowley's assignment as a priest at St. Thomas Rectory.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG press release specifically announcing Crowley's sentencing as the conclusion of the prosecution docket.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "sentencing-announcement"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Case-status roundup confirming Crowley's charges and sentence.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-announcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 959,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-joseph-comperchio-diocese-lansing-michigan-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Lansing, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 42.7325,
"lng": -84.5555,
"title": "Michigan: priest Joseph Comperchio pleads guilty to sexual abuse of four minors",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Diocese of Lansing"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access to four children, some as young as nine"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lansing"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan circuit court (Michigan Department of Attorney General prosecution)",
"stage": "guilty plea; sentenced; died in custody 2022",
"date": "2021-06-01",
"outcome": "Joseph Comperchio pleaded guilty to one count of first-degree and three counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct for abusing four minor children, some as young as nine, in the 1970s, and was sentenced to 12 to 30 years. He died of natural causes in 2022 while serving the sentence. One of nine convictions secured through the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the victims arose from Comperchio's position as a Diocese of Lansing priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG summary of the clergy-abuse prosecution docket recording Comperchio's plea, sentence and death in custody.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "prosecution-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Case-status roundup confirming Comperchio's charges, plea and sentence.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: prosecution-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 960,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-gary-jacobs-diocese-marquette-michigan-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Upper Peninsula, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 46.3608,
"lng": -87.3954,
"title": "Michigan: priest Gary Jacobs sentenced for abusing five children in the Upper Peninsula",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Diocese of Marquette"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access to five children under 16"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Marquette"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan circuit court (Michigan Department of Attorney General prosecution)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2022-01-01",
"outcome": "Gary Jacobs admitted to abusing five children under 16 in the Upper Peninsula during the 1980s and was sentenced on three counts of first-degree and two counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct to 8 to 15 years' incarceration. One of nine convictions secured through the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the victims arose from Jacobs's position as a Diocese of Marquette priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG summary of the clergy-abuse prosecution docket recording Jacobs's plea and sentence.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "prosecution-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Case-status roundup confirming Jacobs's charges and sentence.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: prosecution-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 961,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-gary-berthiaume-diocese-lansing-michigan-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Michigan, USA",
"lat": 44.3148,
"lng": -85.6024,
"title": "Michigan: priest Gary Berthiaume sentenced for criminal sexual conduct and gross indecency",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Diocese of Lansing (later assigned Ohio, Illinois)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access to a minor"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lansing"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan circuit court (Michigan Department of Attorney General prosecution)",
"stage": "guilty plea (CSC counts) and no-contest plea (gross indecency); sentenced",
"date": "2022-01-01",
"outcome": "Gary Berthiaume pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree criminal sexual conduct and no contest to one count of gross indecency, and was sentenced to 17 months to 15 years' incarceration. One of nine convictions secured through the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the victim arose from Berthiaume's position as a Diocese of Lansing priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG summary of the clergy-abuse prosecution docket recording Berthiaume's plea and sentence.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "prosecution-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Case-status roundup confirming Berthiaume's charges and sentence.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: prosecution-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 962,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-vincent-delorenzo-diocese-lansing-burton-michigan-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Burton, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 43.0098,
"lng": -83.6113,
"title": "Michigan: priest Vincent DeLorenzo sentenced for abusing a 5-year-old boy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Holy Redeemer Church, Burton, Diocese of Lansing"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access to a 5-year-old child"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lansing"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan circuit court (Michigan Department of Attorney General prosecution)",
"stage": "guilty plea; sentenced; died in custody January 2024",
"date": "2023-06-01",
"outcome": "Vincent DeLorenzo pleaded guilty to preying on a 5-year-old boy in 1987 and was sentenced to one year in jail and five years' probation. He died in January 2024 while serving his sentence. One of nine convictions secured through the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the child arose from DeLorenzo's position as a Holy Redeemer Church priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG summary of the clergy-abuse prosecution docket recording DeLorenzo's plea and sentence.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "prosecution-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Case-status roundup recording DeLorenzo's plea, sentence and death in custody.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: prosecution-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 963,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-brian-stanley-diocese-kalamazoo-otsego-michigan-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Otsego, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 42.4534,
"lng": -85.7014,
"title": "Michigan: priest Brian Stanley sentenced for attempted false imprisonment of a teenage boy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, St. Margaret's Catholic Church, Otsego, Diocese of Kalamazoo"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access; physically restrained a teenage parishioner"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Kalamazoo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan circuit court (Michigan Department of Attorney General prosecution)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2020-01-01",
"outcome": "Brian Stanley pleaded guilty to one count of attempted false imprisonment for immobilizing a teenage boy with plastic wrap and masking tape in 2013, and was sentenced to 60 days' incarceration (reported elsewhere as two months) and five years' probation with 15-year sex-offender registration. One of nine convictions secured through the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the victim arose from Stanley's position as a St. Margaret's Catholic Church priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG summary of the clergy-abuse prosecution docket recording Stanley's plea and sentence.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "prosecution-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Case-status roundup confirming Stanley's charge and sentence.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: prosecution-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 964,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-patrick-casey-archdiocese-detroit-michigan-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Detroit, Michigan, USA",
"lat": 42.3314,
"lng": -83.0458,
"title": "Michigan: priest Patrick Casey convicted of aggravated assault",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Archdiocese of Detroit"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish and pastoral access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Detroit"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Michigan district/circuit court (Michigan Department of Attorney General prosecution)",
"stage": "conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2018-01-01",
"outcome": "Patrick Casey was convicted of aggravated assault and sentenced to 45 days in jail with one year of probation. One of nine convictions secured through the Michigan attorney general's clergy-abuse investigation; the least severe disposition of the nine but a criminal conviction independently confirmed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to the victim arose from Casey's position as an Archdiocese of Detroit priest.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Michigan Department of Attorney General, 'Active Clergy Abuse Prosecutions Conclude with Sentencing of Ann Arbor Priest for Criminal Sexual Conduct' (Nov. 9, 2023).",
"body": "Official AG summary of the clergy-abuse prosecution docket recording Casey's conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "prosecution-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Here's where the Michigan AG's sweeping Catholic clergy sex abuse investigation stands,' Gander Newsroom.",
"body": "Case-status roundup confirming Casey's charge and sentence.",
"tier": "state-news-roundup",
"kind": "case-status-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.michigan.gov/ag/news/press-releases/2023/11/09/active-clergy-abuse-prosecutions-conclude",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: prosecution-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-news-roundup; evidentiary role: case-status-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12884cf37fe3b4e095de763557e6b974383b9f977161f3f917c08ebd3516fd51",
"final_url": "https://gandernewsroom.com/news/politics/heres-where-the-michigan-ags-sweeping-catholic-clergy-sex-abuse-investigation-stands/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 965,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-john-sweeney-diocese-greensburg-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 40.3101,
"lng": -79.4936,
"title": "Pennsylvania: priest John Sweeney — first conviction from the 2018 grand jury report",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Diocese of Greensburg"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"school-discipline referral used as pretext for private access to a 10-year-old"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Greensburg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Westmoreland County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea (reduced to misdemeanor) and sentencing",
"date": "2018-12-21",
"outcome": "John Thomas Sweeney pleaded guilty on July 31, 2018 to indecent assault (reduced to a misdemeanor) for abusing a 10-year-old boy at St. Margaret Mary Catholic School during the 1991-92 school year, after the boy was sent to him for discipline. On December 21, 1918 [sic 2018] he was sentenced to 11 months to 5 years in state prison with 10-year sex-offender registration — the first conviction produced by the 2018 Pennsylvania grand jury report."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was delivered into Sweeney's private custody through a school-discipline referral that relied on his clerical authority over the parish school.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/case-update-catholic-priest-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-assaulting-10-year-old-boy-in-greensburg-diocese/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General, 'CASE UPDATE: Catholic priest pleads guilty to sexually assaulting 10-year-old boy in Greensburg Diocese' (2018).",
"body": "Official AG case update confirming Sweeney's guilty plea and the underlying grand-jury-report origin of the charge.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "plea-announcement"
},
{
"link": "https://catholicphilly.com/2019/01/news/local-news/pennsylvania-priest-sent-to-prison-after-guilty-plea-in-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Pennsylvania priest sent to prison after guilty plea in abuse case,' CatholicPhilly (Jan. 2019).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting confirming Sweeney's sentence of 11 months to 5 years and registration requirement.",
"tier": "regional-catholic-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/case-update-catholic-priest-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-assaulting-10-year-old-boy-in-greensburg-diocese/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: plea-announcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://catholicphilly.com/2019/01/news/local-news/pennsylvania-priest-sent-to-prison-after-guilty-plea-in-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-catholic-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b39588b75c787c95558120c2056b3f389b08ae4bdbeb91a6fd58b8f0f42d8a4d",
"final_url": "https://catholicphilly.com/2019/01/news/local-news/pennsylvania-priest-sent-to-prison-after-guilty-plea-in-abuse-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 966,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-david-poulson-diocese-erie-jefferson-county-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Jefferson County, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 41.1181,
"lng": -78.9992,
"title": "Pennsylvania: priest David Poulson sentenced — second conviction from the 2018 grand jury report",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Diocese of Erie"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rectory access; compelled confession from the victim after each assault"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Erie"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jefferson County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2019-01-11",
"outcome": "David Lee Poulson pleaded guilty in October 2018 to corruption of minors and child endangerment for sexually assaulting an altar boy in church rectories more than 20 times and abusing two victims at a hunting cabin, then compelling confession afterward. Jefferson County Judge John Foradora sentenced him on January 11, 2019 to two and a half to 14 years in prison; he was later laicized by the Vatican. Second and last conviction produced by the 2018 Pennsylvania grand jury report."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Poulson used rectory and cabin access granted by his clerical role, and compelled the victim to confess to him after each assault, converting the sacrament of confession into a further instrument of control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/catholic-priest-sentenced-to-two-and-a-half-to-fourteen-years-in-prison-for-sexual-abuse-and-attempted-abuse-of-two-boys-in-diocese-of-erie",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General, 'Catholic priest sentenced to two and a half to fourteen years in prison for sexual abuse and attempted abuse of two boys in Diocese of Erie' (Jan. 2019).",
"body": "Official AG press release confirming Poulson's plea, sentence and the grand-jury origin of the case.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "sentencing-announcement"
},
{
"link": "https://www.inquirer.com/news/pennsylvania/priest-who-abused-boys-made-confess-sentenced-prison-20190111.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Priest who abused boys, made 1 confess, sentenced to prison,' Philadelphia Inquirer (Jan. 11, 2019).",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting detailing the confession-compulsion pattern and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/catholic-priest-sentenced-to-two-and-a-half-to-fourteen-years-in-prison-for-sexual-abuse-and-attempted-abuse-of-two-boys-in-diocese-of-erie",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-announcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.inquirer.com/news/pennsylvania/priest-who-abused-boys-made-confess-sentenced-prison-20190111.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bf1fffbef59d7b7ca25734cdf04d6654e52513e75f8e4d00a3b7e4e8452658a4",
"final_url": "https://www.inquirer.com/news/pennsylvania/priest-who-abused-boys-made-confess-sentenced-prison-20190111.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 967,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-thomas-ganley-diocese-metuchen-new-jersey-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Middlesex County, New Jersey, USA",
"lat": 40.4862,
"lng": -74.4518,
"title": "New Jersey: priest Thomas Ganley — first conviction from the state Clergy Abuse Task Force",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, head of Youth Ministry, St. Cecelia Church, Iselin, Diocese of Metuchen"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"supervisory authority over a parish Youth Ministry program used to access a 16-17-year-old"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Metuchen"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court of New Jersey, Middlesex County",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2019-08-26",
"outcome": "Thomas P. Ganley pleaded guilty to second-degree sexual assault and admitted to sexual acts with a victim who was 16 or 17 between 1990 and 1994, while he held supervisory authority as head of the parish Youth Ministry. Judge Diane Pincus sentenced him to four years in state prison, Megan's Law registration and a no-contact order. He was the first priest charged and convicted through the Clergy Abuse Task Force New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal formed in September 2018."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ganley's supervisory role over the parish Youth Ministry program was the operative means of access to the victim.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases19/pr20190826b.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State of New Jersey Office of the Attorney General, press release (Aug. 26, 2019).",
"body": "Official NJ AG press release announcing Ganley's guilty plea and sentence and identifying him as the Task Force's first conviction.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-press-release",
"kind": "sentencing-announcement"
},
{
"link": "https://pressofatlanticcity.com/news/press/new_jersey/new-jersey-priest-sentenced-to-four-years-for-sexual-assault-of-teenage-girl/article_5eed3828-c788-58f1-a9fd-d1f8853c98ce.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'New Jersey priest sentenced to four years for sexual assault of teenage girl,' Press of Atlantic City.",
"body": "Contemporaneous reporting confirming plea, sentence, and Youth Ministry role.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases19/pr20190826b.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-press-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-announcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "248e697be3899d45faeed8caff4b46dc6fe99cbe61a3762c60339cdf23ed47dc",
"final_url": "https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases19/pr20190826b.html"
},
{
"source": "https://pressofatlanticcity.com/news/press/new_jersey/new-jersey-priest-sentenced-to-four-years-for-sexual-assault-of-teenage-girl/article_5eed3828-c788-58f1-a9fd-d1f8853c98ce.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 968,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-leonard-nienaber-diocese-covington-lexington-kentucky-usa",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Fayette County, Kentucky, USA",
"lat": 38.0406,
"lng": -84.5037,
"title": "Kentucky: priest Leonard Nienaber convicted of ten counts of child sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Diocese of Covington (area later Diocese of Lexington)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access to dozens of children over a multi-decade tenure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Covington",
"Diocese of Lexington"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Fayette Circuit Court, Kentucky, USA",
"stage": "criminal conviction; ordered to lifetime residential treatment",
"date": "1994-01-01",
"outcome": "Leonard Nienaber was convicted on ten counts of child sexual abuse; Fayette Circuit Court Judge Mary Noble ordered him to a ten-year term at the Servants of the Paraclete Catholic treatment center in Missouri, later extended to a lifetime placement as part of a related civil settlement covering 24 of the diocese's total 32 abuse claims — the majority of the diocese's substantiated cases concentrated in one priest."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Nienaber's parish assignments gave him access to dozens of children over decades; the diocese's own accounting attributes 24 of 32 total abuse claims in the Lexington/Covington area to him alone.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2003_07_12/2003_12_10_Smith_Priest97.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Priest, 97, Is Ordered to Remain at Center; 24 Plaintiffs Accuse Nienaber and Other Clergy of Sex Abuse,' via BishopAccountability.org.",
"body": "Report on the 1994 Fayette Circuit Court conviction and treatment-center order, and the later civil settlement extending his placement for life.",
"tier": "court-reporting-archive",
"kind": "conviction-and-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://hermanlaw.com/predator-priest-index/kentucky/diocese-of-lexington/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Diocese of Lexington Accused Priests,' Herman Law predator-priest index.",
"body": "Summary corroborating the 1994 conviction, ten-count charge total, and Nienaber's share of the diocese's total claims.",
"tier": "legal-advocacy-compilation",
"kind": "case-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2003_07_12/2003_12_10_Smith_Priest97.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting-archive; evidentiary role: conviction-and-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d39adad8dfda961ae0e6c5b95fea3527d59044217591c1222dcc871cacfb93c4",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2003_07_12/2003_12_10_Smith_Priest97.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://hermanlaw.com/predator-priest-index/kentucky/diocese-of-lexington/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-advocacy-compilation; evidentiary role: case-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "97e6aadaa9be91429b1b419eac6589d2394493ccc802d56ad870762a1224af4f",
"final_url": "https://hermanlaw.com/predator-priest-index/kentucky/diocese-of-lexington/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 969,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-joseph-muench-diocese-lexington-kentucky-usa",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Frankfort, Kentucky, USA",
"lat": 38.2009,
"lng": -84.8733,
"title": "Kentucky: priest Joseph Muench sentenced after Alford plea to unlawful imprisonment and attempted sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, Good Shepherd parish, Frankfort, Diocese of Lexington"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish access to minors in his care during the early 1980s"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Lexington"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kentucky circuit court, Franklin County",
"stage": "Alford plea and sentencing",
"date": "2010-03-01",
"outcome": "Joseph Nicholas Muench was indicted in October 2009 for abuse of two accusers occurring 1980-81 and 1984-85 while assigned to Good Shepherd parish in Frankfort. In March 2010 he entered an Alford plea to unlawful imprisonment and attempted sexual abuse and was sentenced to two concurrent one-year terms; he was released September 30, 2010."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Access to both victims arose from Muench's parish assignment at Good Shepherd.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/muench-joseph-nicholas-1981/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Fr. Joseph Nicholas Muench,' BishopAccountability.org accused-priest record.",
"body": "Documents the 2009 indictment, March 2010 Alford plea, sentence and September 2010 release date.",
"tier": "court-reporting-archive",
"kind": "conviction-and-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=5808",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Plea bargain in Kentucky priest's abuse case,' Catholic Culture news headlines.",
"body": "Contemporaneous confirmation of the plea bargain and disposition.",
"tier": "religious-press-wire",
"kind": "plea-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/muench-joseph-nicholas-1981/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting-archive; evidentiary role: conviction-and-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "303136f95a304946217a9ca9a11b7400b7ef9372f08d14edc646a44fc6d11c11",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/muench-joseph-nicholas-1981/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=5808",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press-wire; evidentiary role: plea-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1cffb049a73072ae3fb448fc1193981af2f10766e43aee632ca616f84c3ce956",
"final_url": "https://www.catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=5808"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 970,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-timothy-evans-diocese-colorado-larimer-county-usa",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Larimer County, Colorado, USA",
"lat": 40.5853,
"lng": -105.0844,
"title": "Colorado: priest Timothy Evans — the only Colorado priest tried and convicted of sexual assault since 2002",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Church, Fort Collins"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral position of trust used to access teenage boys, roughly 100 instances alleged"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Colorado Springs"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Larimer County District Court, Colorado, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2007-03-27",
"outcome": "A Larimer County jury convicted Timothy Joseph Evans on three counts of sexual assault on a child by a person in a position of trust; the pattern of abuse spanned three victims in Jefferson and Larimer counties from roughly 1990 to 2003 while he served at St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Church in Fort Collins. He was sentenced to 14 years to life, laicized by the Vatican while imprisoned, and paroled in 2020. Colorado's independent 2019 review of clergy abuse identified him as the only priest tried and convicted of sexual assault in the state since the 2002 scandal broke."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Evans's position of pastoral trust at St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Church was the charged operative mechanism (position-of-trust statute) for the assaults.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2007/03_04/2007_03_27_Reed_EvansFaces.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sara Reed, 'Evans Faces at Least 10 Years in Prison; Former Priest Found Guilty of Sex Assault,' The Coloradoan (Mar. 27, 2007), via BishopAccountability.org.",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of the jury's guilty verdict and the pending sentence.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cpr.org/2019/12/01/the-one-priest-named-in-ags-report-on-sex-abuse-is-up-for-parole/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'One Priest Named In Colorado AG's Report On Sex Abuse Is Up For Parole,' Colorado Public Radio (Dec. 1, 2019).",
"body": "Confirms Evans as the sole Colorado priest convicted since 2002, his 14-years-to-life sentence, laicization, and pending parole.",
"tier": "public-radio-court-reporting",
"kind": "case-status-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2007/03_04/2007_03_27_Reed_EvansFaces.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4f9c2be9f571d8c80c8cef4c683787e01719c3679e6b9393745179d84f063300",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2007/03_04/2007_03_27_Reed_EvansFaces.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cpr.org/2019/12/01/the-one-priest-named-in-ags-report-on-sex-abuse-is-up-for-parole/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: public-radio-court-reporting; evidentiary role: case-status-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 971,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "MacRae has maintained his innocence for three decades and his case is the subject of an active innocence campaign, with allegations that a since-discredited Keene police detective (James McLaughlin, later flagged for record falsification) shaped the investigation. Recorded here strictly on the disposition: the New Hampshire Supreme Court affirmed the conviction on direct appeal, and a federal district court dismissed his habeas corpus petition in 2015 without an evidentiary hearing. No court has vacated the conviction; it is recorded at 'convicted' with the controversy stated, not resolved.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-gordon-macrae-diocese-manchester-keene-new-hampshire-usa",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Keene, New Hampshire, USA",
"lat": 42.9337,
"lng": -72.2781,
"title": "New Hampshire: priest Gordon MacRae convicted of sexual assault; conviction upheld through direct appeal and federal habeas review",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, St. Bernard parish, Keene, Diocese of Manchester"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counseling sessions used as private access to a minor"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Manchester"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Cheshire County Superior Court, Keene, New Hampshire, USA",
"stage": "mixed guilty pleas and jury verdict; conviction affirmed on direct appeal; federal habeas petition dismissed 2015",
"date": "1994-09-23",
"outcome": "On September 23, 1994, Gordon MacRae was convicted on five counts of sexual assault against Thomas Grover, arising from pastoral counseling sessions in 1983 when Grover was 15 — a mix of guilty pleas to some counts and a jury finding of guilt on the remaining count — and was sentenced to 33.5 to 67 years. The New Hampshire Supreme Court upheld the conviction on direct appeal. A federal habeas corpus petition, filed after a 2005 announcement of new counsel, was dismissed on the pleadings by a federal district judge on March 17, 2015, without an evidentiary hearing on MacRae's innocence claim. He remained incarcerated as of the most recent parole records located (minimum parole date 2028)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "MacRae's access to the victim was structured through one-on-one pastoral counseling sessions, the setting named in the charged conduct.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/macrae-gordon-j-1982/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Fr. Gordon J. MacRae,' BishopAccountability.org accused-priest record.",
"body": "Documents the 1994 conviction, sentence, and subsequent appellate and habeas history.",
"tier": "court-reporting-archive",
"kind": "conviction-and-appeal-history"
},
{
"link": "https://indepthnh.org/2022/10/11/jailed-priest-macrae-plans-appeal-based-on-indepthnh-reporting/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Jailed Priest MacRae Plans To Seek New Trial Based on InDepthNH Reporting,' InDepthNH.org (Oct. 11, 2022).",
"body": "Confirms the conviction remains standing as of 2022, describes the ongoing innocence campaign and the McLaughlin police-misconduct allegations, and that no court had vacated the conviction.",
"tier": "state-investigative-press",
"kind": "case-status-and-controversy-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/macrae-gordon-j-1982/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting-archive; evidentiary role: conviction-and-appeal-history.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cbf2b8d1ebbda5cebc04cb03395154888c4725378c93bcd36f51034976195987",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/macrae-gordon-j-1982/"
},
{
"source": "https://indepthnh.org/2022/10/11/jailed-priest-macrae-plans-appeal-based-on-indepthnh-reporting/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-investigative-press; evidentiary role: case-status-and-controversy-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c456f0dfb4a19299a104915b77c1d53d5e7c88eaf68704336dcf18d9a4a59ea1",
"final_url": "https://indepthnh.org/2022/10/11/jailed-priest-macrae-plans-appeal-based-on-indepthnh-reporting/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 972,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Wert has two independently sourced criminal dispositions: a 2007 Washington D.C. simple-assault conviction (180 days, 5 years probation) and this 2013 Florida jury conviction and life sentence. This record centers on the 2013 Florida conviction, the more serious and better-documented disposition. The Carmelite order allowed Wert to remain in ministry and later moved him to a retirement home after the 2007 conviction was known, where he abused the victim in this case — a documented institutional-shielding pattern the Illinois attorney general's 2023 report later surfaced.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-william-wert-diocese-joliet-venice-florida-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Venice, Florida, USA",
"lat": 27.0998,
"lng": -82.4543,
"title": "Illinois/Florida: Carmelite priest William Wert convicted and sentenced to life after a second child-victim disclosure",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Carmelite priest, Diocese of Joliet (Illinois); later resident, Carmelite retirement home, Venice, Florida"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical status and retirement-home residency used to access a 14-year-old parishioner's family"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Joliet",
"Carmelite Order"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sarasota County Circuit Court (Venice), Florida, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2013-02-01",
"outcome": "After a Venice father discovered lewd messages from Wert to his 14-year-old son's phone in January 2011 and reported him, Wert was charged with sexual battery and lewd-behavior counts. In February 2013 a jury convicted him on eight counts of illegal sexual activity with a child, and he was sentenced to life in prison. He was separated from the Carmelite order in 2012 and laicized by the Vatican in March 2015. The Illinois attorney general's 2023 clergy report later documented that the Diocese of Joliet and the Carmelites had not disclosed Wert on public credibly-accused lists until AG investigators intervened."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Wert's clerical status gave him standing to correspond with and gain access to a parishioner-adjacent child in Florida after the Carmelites relocated him to their retirement home rather than removing him from any contact with minors.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/narrative/william-c-wert",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Illinois Attorney General, 'William C. Wert,' Report on Catholic Clergy Child Sex Abuse in Illinois (2023), narrative entry.",
"body": "Official state narrative documenting Wert's Illinois assignments, the 2007 D.C. conviction, the Carmelites' failure to remove him from ministry, and cross-reference to the Florida life sentence.",
"tier": "official-attorney-general-report",
"kind": "narrative-entry"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/wert-william-c-1986/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Fr. William C. Wert,' BishopAccountability.org accused-priest record.",
"body": "Corroborates both the 2007 D.C. conviction and the February 2013 Florida jury conviction and life sentence, plus the 2015 laicization date.",
"tier": "court-reporting-archive",
"kind": "conviction-and-disposition-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/narrative/william-c-wert",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-attorney-general-report; evidentiary role: narrative-entry.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9f573d8903a7b8da2965e083f30eb4b954935ea2768b1aa61c4ae5324a72ab5e",
"final_url": "https://clergyreport.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/narrative/william-c-wert"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/wert-william-c-1986/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting-archive; evidentiary role: conviction-and-disposition-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "23b4dbaaaa15d9b382d9aeef6bfb27ec1a0062d50ac9eaee9b7f68c0e33afd98",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/wert-william-c-1986/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 973,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"court": "Montana Supreme Court",
"date": "2020-01-09",
"result": "Reversed the $35 million jury verdict; held the confidentiality doctrine exempted elders from the mandatory-reporting statute."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The abuser was a family member (step-grandfather) and, separately, an uncle who confessed to elders in 2014 to abusing the same victim — a family-nexus fact pattern that would fail this criterion if the record rested on either man's authority. It does not: this record documents the institutional civil finding — a state supreme court ruling that JW confidentiality doctrine, applied to what an elder hears in a judicial-committee capacity, is what excused the organization from a state reporting statute. That is a finding about the two-witness/internal-handling mechanism itself, which is what the record certifies. No court found the church directly liable for the abuse; the $35 million verdict was reversed, and the parties later settled confidentially.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-nunez-v-watchtower-thompson-falls-montana-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Thompson Falls, Montana, USA",
"lat": 47.5949,
"lng": -115.3383,
"title": "United States: Montana Supreme Court rules church confidentiality doctrine excused elders from reporting a child-abuse disclosure",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"congregation elder who received a disclosure of past abuse",
"Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York (national body)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrine requiring elders to keep disclosures made to a judicial committee confidential, invoked to withhold a report to civil authorities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (Thompson Falls congregation; Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Twentieth Judicial District Court, Sanders County, Montana, USA (trial); Montana Supreme Court (appeal)",
"stage": "jury verdict reversed on appeal; case later settled",
"date": "2020-01-09",
"outcome": "A Sanders County jury awarded Alexis Nunez $4 million in compensatory and $31 million in punitive damages, finding the Thompson Falls congregation and Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York negligent for not reporting a 2004 disclosure that a member (the victim's uncle) had himself been abused as a child, made to elder Don Herberger — a disclosure the elders linked to ongoing abuse of Nunez by her step-grandfather. On 9 January 2020 the Montana Supreme Court reversed, holding Montana's mandatory-reporting statute exempts confidential communications received under an established church confidentiality practice, so the elders were not obligated to report. The parties settled for an undisclosed amount on 31 August 2021 with prejudice."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The abuse itself was committed by family members outside any church office; the record's nexus is institutional — a state supreme court found that the church's confidentiality doctrine governing what elders may disclose from a judicial-committee proceeding is what excused the organization from Montana's mandatory child-abuse reporting law, deciding the case on that doctrine rather than on the family relationship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2020/da-19-0077-0.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nunez v. Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc., DA 19-0077 (Mont. 2020).",
"body": "Full text of the Montana Supreme Court opinion reversing the jury verdict on the confidentiality/mandatory-reporting question.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.npr.org/2020/01/09/795019348/montana-court-reverses-35-million-child-abuse-verdict-against-jehovahs-witnesses",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NPR, 'Montana Court Reverses $35 Million Child Abuse Verdict Against Jehovah's Witnesses', 9 Jan. 2020.",
"body": "National public-broadcaster report on the reversal and its reasoning.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "appellate-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"court": "Montana Supreme Court",
"date": "2020-01-09",
"result": "Reversed the $35 million jury verdict; held the confidentiality doctrine exempted elders from the mandatory-reporting statute."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2020/da-19-0077-0.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.npr.org/2020/01/09/795019348/montana-court-reverses-35-million-child-abuse-verdict-against-jehovahs-witnesses",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: appellate-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 974,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified. Convicted at jury trial; disposition confirmed by the Pennsylvania Attorney General's office.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-norman-aviles-garriga-lancaster-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Lancaster, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 40.0444,
"lng": -76.3062,
"title": "United States: Jehovah's Witness elder convicted of molesting three girls of the extended family hosting him",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder, Lancaster County Jehovah's Witness congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"congregational elder standing that placed him, as a trusted single congregant newly arrived from Puerto Rico, inside the household of a congregation family who hosted him"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (Lancaster County congregation)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Lancaster County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-11-08",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Norman Aviles-Garriga, 45, of all twelve charged counts including aggravated indecent assault, indecent assault and endangering the welfare of children, for molesting three girls of the same extended family that hosted him between 1999 and 2003. He was found to be a sexually violent predator and sentenced to 11.5 to 23 years in prison. The case arose from Pennsylvania's 49th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury into Jehovah's Witnesses congregations."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As an elder of the congregation, Aviles-Garriga's standing was the reason the extended family took him into their home while he was establishing himself in the country; that congregational trust and the resulting live-in access to the children is the mechanism the prosecution described.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/lancaster-jehovah-s-witness-elder-sentenced-to-prison-for-molesting-congregant-children/article_a8f478b8-9311-11ef-ba0e-9f2e33644e4a.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "LancasterOnline, 'Lancaster Jehovah's Witness elder sentenced to prison for molesting congregant children.'",
"body": "Local paper of record's report on the jury conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/verdict-former-jehovahs-witnesses-elder-convicted-of-sexual-abuse-of-3-children/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General, press release on the verdict.",
"body": "Prosecuting authority's own release confirming the jury verdict and grand-jury origin of the case.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority-release",
"kind": "verdict-announcement"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/lancaster-jehovah-s-witness-elder-sentenced-to-prison-for-molesting-congregant-children/article_a8f478b8-9311-11ef-ba0e-9f2e33644e4a.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a5ae8f3bcacd72ece415969cf4364f65470a98ecbd0ed87438819978ac89f90a",
"final_url": "https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/lancaster-jehovah-s-witness-elder-sentenced-to-prison-for-molesting-congregant-children/article_a8f478b8-9311-11ef-ba0e-9f2e33644e4a.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/verdict-former-jehovahs-witnesses-elder-convicted-of-sexual-abuse-of-3-children/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority-release; evidentiary role: verdict-announcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 975,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. Disposition is a guilty plea with a probationary sentence, not incarceration; recorded as stated.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-terry-booth-white-oak-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "White Oak, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 40.3454,
"lng": -79.8112,
"title": "United States: Jehovah's Witness elder pleads guilty after 'mentoring' a teenager under cover of spiritual guidance",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder, White Oak Kingdom Hall congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"self-assigned pastoral 'mentor' role over a teenage congregant, used to frame sexual contact and sexual discussion as spiritual guidance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (White Oak Kingdom Hall)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2024-11-19",
"outcome": "Terry Booth, 57, a former elder of the White Oak Kingdom Hall charged in July 2024 by Pennsylvania's 49th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury, pleaded guilty to corruption of minors; indecent-assault charges were dropped as part of the plea. The grand jury presentment found he had taken it upon himself to 'mentor' the teenage victim between 2010 and 2011, which included inappropriate sexual touching and sexual discussions he characterized as spiritual guidance. He was sentenced to three years' probation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Booth used his elder standing to install himself as the victim's spiritual mentor, and recharacterized sexual contact and sexual conversation with a minor congregant as religious counsel — the pastoral role is what both created the access and supplied the pretext.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.post-gazette.com/news/crime-courts/2024/11/19/allegheny-county-pennsylvania-jehovahs-witness-sex-abuse-grand-jury/stories/202411190107",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 'Former Allegheny County resident sentenced in latest Jehovah's Witness sex abuse case', 19 Nov. 2024.",
"body": "Regional paper of record's report on the plea and sentence, citing the grand jury presentment's 'mentor'/spiritual-guidance framing.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.post-gazette.com/news/crime-courts/2024/11/19/allegheny-county-pennsylvania-jehovahs-witness-sex-abuse-grand-jury/stories/202411190107",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "26eccfd3852bc7d7b5d200725a3ba0179c03c3837f09c32b7f5fcb3da4566497",
"final_url": "https://www.post-gazette.com/news/crime-courts/2024/11/19/allegheny-county-pennsylvania-jehovahs-witness-sex-abuse-grand-jury/stories/202411190107"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 976,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. Convicted at jury trial; sentence and disposition confirmed by press coverage of the sentencing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-david-balosa-philadelphia-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 39.9526,
"lng": -75.1652,
"title": "United States: Jehovah's Witness congregant convicted of using his standing in the church to assault a four-year-old he lived among",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"member of an Olney (Philadelphia) Jehovah's Witness congregation, taken in by a congregation family"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"trust extended to him as a fellow congregant after he arrived in the US from Angola and moved in with a Witness family, which the prosecution said he used to gain access to the family's four-year-old daughter"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (Olney, Philadelphia congregation)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania, USA",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-01-31",
"outcome": "David Balosa, 63, was convicted by a Philadelphia jury of two felony counts of aggravated indecent assault and related misdemeanors for assaulting a 4-year-old girl of the congregation family he lived with after emigrating from Angola in the mid-1990s. He was sentenced to two to four years in prison plus six years' probation and lifetime sex-offender registration. Charged in 2023 as part of Pennsylvania's statewide Jehovah's Witness grand jury investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Prosecutors said at trial that Balosa's 'misuse of religious affiliation' — his standing as a fellow member of the congregation the family belonged to — is what gained him the family's trust and his place in their household, and therefore his access to their daughter.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.inquirer.com/crime/jehovah-witness-sexual-assault-david-balosa-sentencing-20250131.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Philadelphia Inquirer, 'David Balosa sentenced in Jehovah's Witness sexual assault case', 31 Jan. 2025.",
"body": "Paper-of-record report on the conviction, sentence, and prosecutors' framing of the congregational-trust mechanism.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.inquirer.com/crime/jehovah-witness-sexual-assault-david-balosa-sentencing-20250131.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7ff49ecbb31374ed9dc426a849ea378b42ceca99f724c5900456a3a225b10bad",
"final_url": "https://www.inquirer.com/crime/jehovah-witness-sexual-assault-david-balosa-sentencing-20250131.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 977,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The child was abused by a family member (a 'sexual relations within families' conviction against Hernandez-Pedraza); that separate matter fails this project's criterion on the paternal/family-nexus ground and is not the subject of this record. This record is solely about the elders Penkava and Scott, convicted in their own right for the reporting failure their congregational office created.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-penkava-scott-crystal-lake-illinois-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Crystal Lake, McHenry County, Illinois, USA",
"lat": 42.2411,
"lng": -88.3162,
"title": "United States: two Jehovah's Witness elders convicted for failing to report a child's abuse after headquarters advised against it",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder, Crystal Lake Jehovah's Witness congregation (Michael Penkava)",
"elder, Crystal Lake Jehovah's Witness congregation (Colin Scott)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"elder standing as a mandated reporter under Illinois law, set aside on the strength of instructions the elders said they received from Jehovah's Witness world headquarters not to report"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (Crystal Lake congregation); Watchtower headquarters (advice cited by the defendants)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "McHenry County Circuit Court, Illinois, USA",
"stage": "bench trial conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-03-25",
"outcome": "Michael Penkava, 72, and Colin Scott, 88, both Jehovah's Witness elders, were found guilty on 18 March 2022 of a Class A misdemeanor for violating Illinois's Abused and Neglected Child Reporting Act by failing, as mandated reporters, to report their 2006 knowledge that a congregant (Arturo Hernandez-Pedraza, separately convicted in 2019 of assaulting a family member weekly for over 13 years) was sexually abusing a child. They were sentenced on 25 March 2022 to one year of court supervision, ten hours of community service and a $250 fine each. Penkava testified he believed he was not required to report after receiving advice in 2006 from Jehovah's Witness world headquarters in New York."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The underlying abuse was committed by a family member and is not the nexus of this record. The record documents the elders' own criminal conviction: their status as mandated reporters arose from their congregational office, and it was headquarters' reporting doctrine, by the elders' own testimony, that led them not to report — a rare instance where a court adjudicated the internal-handling mechanism itself as a crime, rather than only as a civil-liability question.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.shawlocal.com/northwest-herald/news/2022/03/26/jehovahs-witnesses-elders-sentenced-to-supervision-community-service-for-not-reporting-childs-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Northwest Herald (Shaw Local), 'Jehovah's Witnesses elders sentenced to supervision, community service for not reporting child's sexual abuse', 26 Mar. 2022.",
"body": "Local paper of record's report on the guilty finding and sentence, including Penkava's headquarters-advice testimony.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.shawlocal.com/northwest-herald/news/2022/03/19/jehovahs-witnesses-elders-guilty-of-failure-to-report-sexual-abuse-of-6-year-old-child-mchenry-county-judge/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Northwest Herald (Shaw Local), 'Jehovah's Witnesses elders guilty of failing to report sexual abuse of 6-year-old child: McHenry County judge', 19 Mar. 2022.",
"body": "Report on the guilty verdict itself, one week before sentencing.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.shawlocal.com/northwest-herald/news/2022/03/26/jehovahs-witnesses-elders-sentenced-to-supervision-community-service-for-not-reporting-childs-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "32470869a5c5ee1bfe644e5d9585ed207cddb0b5d482bd00b095369c07ebda53",
"final_url": "https://www.shawlocal.com/northwest-herald/news/2022/03/26/jehovahs-witnesses-elders-sentenced-to-supervision-community-service-for-not-reporting-childs-sexual-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.shawlocal.com/northwest-herald/news/2022/03/19/jehovahs-witnesses-elders-guilty-of-failure-to-report-sexual-abuse-of-6-year-old-child-mchenry-county-judge/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "62f53e66e578e7d2bbc1179afe652ed04d5a5c7cd25e865bd5c93f82ecec373c",
"final_url": "https://www.shawlocal.com/northwest-herald/news/2022/03/19/jehovahs-witnesses-elders-guilty-of-failure-to-report-sexual-abuse-of-6-year-old-child-mchenry-county-judge/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 978,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The underlying prosecution this ruling arose from (a 48-year-old Assen man accused of abusing an 8-year-old in 2016) was itself later halted by the same Zwolle court in August 2023, which found the prosecution had improperly used the confidential information at issue — a due-process ruling on the prosecution's own conduct, not an acquittal on the merits and not a reversal of the May 2020 non-disclosure finding. Both outcomes are stated here so the record is not read as implying the underlying case ended in conviction; it did not, and this record certifies only the 2020 institutional-privilege finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-zwolle-court-jw-elders-nondisclosure-netherlands",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Zwolle, Overijssel, Netherlands",
"lat": 52.5125,
"lng": 6.0944,
"title": "Netherlands: court rules Jehovah's Witness elders sitting on a judicial committee have no right of non-disclosure to police",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"elders serving on a Jehovah's Witness judicial committee, Northern Netherlands"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"asserted clergy non-disclosure privilege over what elders learned in a judicial-committee proceeding investigating a child-abuse allegation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (Northern Netherlands congregation)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Rechtbank Overijssel (District Court of Overijssel), Zwolle, Netherlands",
"stage": "pre-trial ruling on privilege",
"date": "2020-05-08",
"outcome": "The court in Zwolle ruled that elders of a Jehovah's Witness congregation in the Northern Netherlands could not invoke a right of non-disclosure as clergy in the criminal investigation of a member (from Assen) accused of sexually abusing a minor, reasoning that when acting as members of a judicial committee handling an internal misconduct complaint, the elders were not functioning as spiritual counselors and so the privilege did not apply."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The finding goes directly to the two-witness/judicial-committee mechanism: a Dutch court held that the doctrinal category the elders relied on to withhold information from police — spiritual-counsel confidentiality — does not cover what elders learn while adjudicating an internal abuse complaint, denying the church's own internal process the legal shield it had claimed.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://avoidjw.org/world-news/elders-of-jehovahs-witnesses-cannot-invoke-the-right-of-non-disclosure-in-sexual-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report on the 8 May 2020 Zwolle district court ruling denying JW elders a non-disclosure privilege for judicial-committee proceedings.",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of the ruling and the court's stated reasoning that elders in a judicial-committee capacity are not acting as spiritual counselors.",
"tier": "specialist-legal-reporting",
"kind": "court-ruling-report"
},
{
"link": "https://nltimes.nl/2023/08/15/prosecution-halted-jehovahs-witnesses-abuse-case-due-confidentiality-breach",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NL Times, 'Prosecution halted in Jehovah's Witnesses abuse case due to confidentiality breach', 15 Aug. 2023.",
"body": "National English-language outlet's report on the later 2023 ruling halting the underlying prosecution on due-process grounds — recorded here for full disposition transparency.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "case-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://avoidjw.org/world-news/elders-of-jehovahs-witnesses-cannot-invoke-the-right-of-non-disclosure-in-sexual-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-legal-reporting; evidentiary role: court-ruling-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "35356e611f1985c49ae30efced31ca4ab5460d6e8fbf864e94ef0d3e919c5a5a",
"final_url": "https://avoidjw.org/child-sexual-abuse/elders-of-jehovahs-witnesses-cannot-invoke-the-right-of-non-disclosure-in-sexual-abuse-case/"
},
{
"source": "https://nltimes.nl/2023/08/15/prosecution-halted-jehovahs-witnesses-abuse-case-due-confidentiality-breach",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: case-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "759e6b88ed743b95605301f5caca185615e08c397130247c667a9b7947ff1f7a",
"final_url": "https://nltimes.nl/2023/08/15/prosecution-halted-jehovahs-witnesses-abuse-case-due-confidentiality-breach"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 979,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "One victim was 'Person A' (reported February 2012) and an earlier allegation from 'Person B' dated to April 1993; identities are withheld in the Charity Commission report and are not asserted here. The Commission's inquiry produced a finding of misconduct/mismanagement by the charity's trustees; no further enforcement order beyond the report itself is documented in the published inquiry.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-jonathan-rose-manchester-new-moston-england-uk",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Manchester, England, UK",
"lat": 53.481,
"lng": -2.2374,
"title": "England: Jehovah's Witness congregation trustee convicted of indecent assault; Charity Commission finds victims were made to face him in a judicial hearing",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"trustee, Manchester New Moston Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"trustee/elder standing used to control an internal misconduct-appeal hearing at which the alleged victims were required to repeat their allegations in his presence and were questioned by him and by the appeal committee"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Manchester New Moston Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Crown Court (England) — criminal case; Charity Commission for England and Wales — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "criminal conviction (2013); statutory regulatory inquiry and report (2014-2017)",
"date": "2013-10-30",
"outcome": "Jonathan Rose, a trustee of the Manchester New Moston Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses, was convicted in autumn 2013 of two counts of indecent assault and sentenced on 30 October 2013. Separately, the Charity Commission opened a statutory inquiry on 27 May 2014 and published its report on 26 July 2017, finding that the congregation's trustees had not dealt adequately with the 2012-2013 allegations against Rose: one allegation (from 1993) was dismissed by trustees as 'a matter between 2 teenagers' rather than identified as potential child abuse, and complainants were 'effectively required' to attend a misconduct-appeal hearing, repeat their allegations in Rose's presence, and be questioned by him and by the appeal committee — one member asking a victim 'did you ever egg him on? Goad him on?'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Rose's authority as a congregation trustee/elder is what put him in a position to face his own accusers inside the church's internal judicial process and question them directly — the Charity Commission's finding is precisely about that mechanism, not merely about the underlying assault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/manchester-new-moston-congregation-of-jehovahs-witnesses-inquiry-report/manchester-new-moston-congregation-of-jehovahs-witnesses",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Charity Commission for England and Wales, Manchester New Moston Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses inquiry report, published 26 Jul. 2017.",
"body": "The regulator's own published findings on the trustees' handling of the allegations against Jonathan Rose and the misconduct-appeal hearing's treatment of the complainants.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "regulatory-inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://lawandreligionuk.com/2017/01/19/the-charity-commission-and-the-jehovahs-witnesses-an-update/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Law & Religion UK, 'The Charity Commission and the Jehovah's Witnesses: an update', 19 Jan. 2017.",
"body": "Specialist legal-affairs blog summarizing the inquiry's history and the underlying 2013 conviction.",
"tier": "specialist-legal-reporting",
"kind": "background-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/manchester-new-moston-congregation-of-jehovahs-witnesses-inquiry-report/manchester-new-moston-congregation-of-jehovahs-witnesses",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: regulatory-inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4d8b48865a4682ab3d6ced46360ffb1fff9ebd4715fd970750eae19be35e7d30",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/manchester-new-moston-congregation-of-jehovahs-witnesses-inquiry-report/manchester-new-moston-congregation-of-jehovahs-witnesses"
},
{
"source": "https://lawandreligionuk.com/2017/01/19/the-charity-commission-and-the-jehovahs-witnesses-an-update/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-legal-reporting; evidentiary role: background-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "31a6b85f7e8189b00c99b47204d8676fc7b6425851b87aae23afb74d1f9a06c0",
"final_url": "https://lawandreligionuk.com/2017/01/19/the-charity-commission-and-the-jehovahs-witnesses-an-update/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 980,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. Source citations are contemporaneous local newspaper reports (North Bay Nugget), corroborated by case-documentation aggregator FLOODLIT, which cites and links the same underlying press reports.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2001-james-hayes-north-bay-ontario-canada",
"year": 2001,
"place": "Timmins–North Bay area, Ontario, Canada",
"lat": 46.3168,
"lng": -79.4663,
"title": "Canada: Jehovah's Witness bishop-equivalent elder convicted of sexually exploiting a ward member he was counseling",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder, Timmins–North Bay area Jehovah's Witness congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral counseling role over a congregant that began when she was 14, escalating to sexual contact when she was 16, conducted in the bishop's/elder's office at the local chapel"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witnesses (Timmins–North Bay area congregation)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario Court of Justice, Ontario, Canada",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2002-01-08",
"outcome": "James Hayes, an elder in the Timmins–North Bay area Jehovah's Witness congregation, was convicted of sexual exploitation in November 2001 for abusing an underage female congregant he had been counseling since she was 14; the sexual contact occurred when she was 16. He was sentenced on 8 January 2002 to 60 days' imprisonment served intermittently, plus probation for the length of the jail term."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim began seeing Hayes specifically for pastoral counseling in his capacity as elder; that counseling relationship, and the access it gave him to her alone in his church office, is the documented mechanism of the offence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://floodlit.org/a/a660/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FLOODLIT case file on James Hayes, citing North Bay Nugget, 'Sentencing delayed for former bishop' (8 Jan. 2002) and 'Former Mormon [sic — Jehovah's Witness] bishop sentenced in Timmins' (9 Jan. 2002).",
"body": "Case-documentation aggregator's summary with links to the original North Bay Nugget newspaper reports of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "case-documentation-database",
"kind": "sentencing-report-aggregation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://floodlit.org/a/a660/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: case-documentation-database; evidentiary role: sentencing-report-aggregation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c39c6a2b6ae91b5a2821d6efb18a9226ef07705758c0a771c1d349e8155dde63",
"final_url": "https://floodlit.org/a/a660/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 981,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified beyond the contemporaneous description as a member of the congregation with a mental disability. Note: press sources describe Nelson variously as the congregation's leader/'bishop'; the specific denomination-neutral term 'congregation leader' is used in the title given some ambiguity in period reporting, but the underlying record — case-documentation aggregator FLOODLIT and the original Times Colonist reporting it cites — places the offence squarely inside his religious-authority role at Victoria's First Ward.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1989-robert-nelson-victoria-british-columbia-canada",
"year": 1989,
"place": "Victoria, British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 48.4359,
"lng": -123.3516,
"title": "Canada: congregation elder convicted of sexually assaulting a disabled member of his own congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder/bishop, Victoria First Ward congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"congregational leadership standing over a member with a mental disability, giving him access and unquestioned trust"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Victoria First Ward congregation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia Provincial Court, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "1989-05-27",
"outcome": "Robert Kenneth Nelson, a congregation leader in Victoria's First Ward since being assigned to the role in 1979, pleaded guilty on 27 May 1989 to sexual assault of a member of his congregation described in press coverage as 'mentally handicapped.' He was sentenced to two years' probation, 150 hours of community service, and ordered to take a conducted tour of a local jail. He was subsequently removed from his congregational role over the offence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's vulnerability was heightened by disability, and Nelson's access to her came through his standing as her congregation's leader — the role that put him in a position of unsupervised trust over her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://floodlit.org/a/a642/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FLOODLIT case file on Robert Kenneth Nelson, citing Times Colonist, 'Former Mormon bishop guilty of sexual assault' (27 May 1989) and 'Former bishop on probation for sex assault' (30 May 1989).",
"body": "Case-documentation aggregator's summary with links to the original Times Colonist newspaper reports of the guilty plea and sentence.",
"tier": "case-documentation-database",
"kind": "sentencing-report-aggregation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://floodlit.org/a/a642/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: case-documentation-database; evidentiary role: sentencing-report-aggregation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7ca7216a1519979d318c438880a5f947e8f88f6f4c8c2db488d4f2c55ac9ae06",
"final_url": "https://floodlit.org/a/a642/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 982,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a DEFAULT judgment — entered as a discovery sanction against Watchtower rather than after a contested trial on the merits — and is recorded as such; it is a civil finding against the institution, not a criminal conviction of Campos, who was never charged and has evaded prosecution. Some secondary reporting states the judgment was later modified or partially vacated on procedural grounds; this record certifies the underlying default judgment and its stated factual basis as reported, and does not assert a final, unappealable civil liability finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-jose-lopez-v-watchtower-fremont-san-diego-california-usa",
"year": 2014,
"place": "San Diego, California, USA",
"lat": 32.7157,
"lng": -117.1611,
"title": "United States: default judgment against the Watchtower Society for recommending a known child molester as a boy's Bible-study mentor",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Linda Vista Spanish congregation elders, San Diego (recommended the mentor)",
"Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York (national defendant)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"elders' recommendation of an adult they already knew to be a molester as a one-on-one Bible-study mentor to a 7-year-old congregant, portrayed to the child as a fatherly spiritual teacher"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York; Linda Vista Spanish congregation (San Diego)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "San Diego County Superior Court, California, USA",
"stage": "default judgment",
"date": "2014-01-01",
"outcome": "San Diego Superior Court Judge Joan Lewis entered a default judgment of $13.5 million against the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York after the organization declined to comply with discovery orders, finding it had failed to protect Jose Lopez, molested in 1986 at age 7 by Gonzalo Campos, an adult congregation member elders of the Linda Vista Spanish congregation had known since 1982 to be a child molester and nonetheless recommended to Lopez's mother as someone he should study the Bible with. The judgment was $10.5 million in punitive and $3 million in compensatory damages; Campos himself was never criminally charged and, per later reporting, is a fugitive believed to be in Mexico."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "See citation",
"stage": "primary-source citation recovered",
"outcome": "Lopez v. Watchtower Bible & Tract Society of New York, Inc., 246 Cal.App.4th 566, 201 Cal.Rptr.3d 156 (Cal. Ct. App., 4th Dist., Div. 1, 2016), filed 2016-04-14, Haller, Acting P.J. (McDonald, O'Rourke, JJ.), docket D066388 — matches existing sourcing's docket number. This is the Court of Appeal opinion AFFIRMING the 2014 San Diego County Superior Court default judgment already documented in this record. Add as a full reporter citation alongside the existing courts.ca.gov DOC link and PRWeb release. Source: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/3194461/lopez-v-watchtower-bible-tract-society-of-new-york-inc/"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Campos was introduced to the child specifically as a spiritual mentor for Bible study, a role congregation elders assigned him despite already knowing of his history; the pastoral-mentor framing is what gave him private access to the boy.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.prweb.com/releases/the_zalkin_law_firm_wins_13_5_million_default_judgment_against_the_jehovah_s_witnesses_watchtower_on_behalf_of_childhood_sexual_abuse_victim/prweb12295835.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "PRWeb (Zalkin Law Firm release), 'The Zalkin Law Firm Wins $13.5 Million Default Judgment Against the Jehovah's Witnesses Watchtower on behalf of Childhood Sexual Abuse Victim.'",
"body": "Plaintiff's counsel's release describing the default judgment, the elders' 1982 knowledge of Campos, and the amount and allocation of damages.",
"tier": "law-firm-release",
"kind": "civil-judgment-announcement"
},
{
"link": "https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/archive/D066388.DOC",
"archive": "",
"citation": "California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, opinion filed 14 Apr. 2016 (D066388), certified for publication.",
"body": "The subsequent published Court of Appeal opinion in related appellate proceedings arising from the same underlying case.",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.prweb.com/releases/the_zalkin_law_firm_wins_13_5_million_default_judgment_against_the_jehovah_s_witnesses_watchtower_on_behalf_of_childhood_sexual_abuse_victim/prweb12295835.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: law-firm-release; evidentiary role: civil-judgment-announcement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c8078368dadec172eef96f80f4791602ace540c54d5785b701bf34551c4e8464",
"final_url": "https://www.prweb.com/releases/the_zalkin_law_firm_wins_13_5_million_default_judgment_against_the_jehovah_s_witnesses_watchtower_on_behalf_of_childhood_sexual_abuse_victim/prweb12295835.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/archive/D066388.DOC",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0e45b20be89f77c49e43bdfc3752c08cdbefb12d0147b041307dc89879ddeb44",
"final_url": "https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/archive/D066388.DOC"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 983,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "CHARGED STATUS ONLY. No conviction, plea, or other adjudicated finding exists as of this record's compilation (July 2026); this entry documents the filing of felony charges by the Alameda County District Attorney, consistent with this project's practice of recording a charged status where an official act has occurred, without representing it as a finding of guilt.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-michael-morris-livermore-california-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Livermore, California, USA",
"lat": 37.6819,
"lng": -121.768,
"title": "United States: former LDS bishop and boys' youth-group leader charged with abusing four boys over a decade",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"bishop, Livermore LDS ward",
"leader, church-affiliated boys' youth group"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"combined bishopric authority and direct supervisory control of a church youth group of boys, alleged to have been used to select and isolate victims"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Livermore ward)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Alameda County Superior Court, California, USA",
"stage": "charged, arraigned, pending trial",
"date": "2026-05-21",
"outcome": "Michael Morris, 76, was charged on 21 May 2026 with 18 counts of child sexual abuse against four alleged victims, arising from conduct alleged to have occurred between approximately 1991 and 2001 while he served as an LDS bishop in Livermore and supervised a church-affiliated boys' youth group. He was arrested 15 May 2026, posted roughly $1 million bail, and was arraigned; a further court date for entry of plea was set for 10 June 2026. No trial verdict exists as of this record."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Prosecutors allege Morris used his combined authority as bishop and as the boys' youth-group leader — dual roles giving him both congregational standing over the families and direct unsupervised custody of the boys during group activities — to select and isolate the four alleged victims.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ktvu.com/news/former-livermore-lds-bishop-charged-sexually-assaulting-boys-over-decade",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KTVU FOX 2, 'Ex-Mormon bishop in Livermore charged with sexually assaulting boys over decade.'",
"body": "Bay Area broadcaster's report on the charges, arrest, and arraignment, citing the Alameda County District Attorney's announcement.",
"tier": "regional-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/livermore-latter-day-saints-lds-bishop-child-sexual-assault-charges/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News San Francisco, 'Former Livermore LDS bishop charged with sexually abusing minors decades ago.'",
"body": "Corroborating regional-broadcaster report on the same charges.",
"tier": "regional-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Michael Morris, 76, was charged on 21 May 2026 with 18 counts of child sexual abuse against four alleged victims, arising from conduct alleged to have occurred between approximately 1991 and 2001 while he served as an LDS bishop in Livermore and supervised a church-affiliated boys' youth group. He was arrested 15 May 2026, posted roughly $1 million bail, and was arraigned; a further court date for entry of plea was set for 10 June 2026. No trial verdict exists as of this record.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ktvu.com/news/former-livermore-lds-bishop-charged-sexually-assaulting-boys-over-decade",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "95a7257b50d6a4a287c32db53d16e8de64c197c587b143e19cc735ae37d8057d",
"final_url": "https://www.ktvu.com/news/former-livermore-lds-bishop-charged-sexually-assaulting-boys-over-decade"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/livermore-latter-day-saints-lds-bishop-child-sexual-assault-charges/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fbadfb5302b415599b91d73f63445a209dc909a7f9fc5d29196aec68f56d72f2",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/livermore-latter-day-saints-lds-bishop-child-sexual-assault-charges/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [
"Kenneth Storheim",
"Archbishop Seraphim (Storheim)"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "manitoba-court-of-appeal",
"date": "2015-02-05",
"note": "Conviction and sentence upheld; sentence executed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-seraphim-storheim-winnipeg-canada",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada",
"lat": 49.8951,
"lng": -97.1384,
"title": "Canada: Orthodox Church in America archbishop convicted of sexually assaulting a boy sent to live and serve at his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Archbishop of Ottawa and Canada, Orthodox Church in America",
"parish priest, Holy Trinity Sobor, Winnipeg (at time of offence, 1985)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"victim and his brother sent by their single mother to live and work at the priest's church-attached residence",
"clerical authority used to frame nudity and physical 'inspection' of the boy as pastoral or developmental oversight"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Orthodox Church in America",
"Holy Trinity Sobor, Winnipeg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Queen's Bench of Manitoba",
"stage": "trial verdict",
"date": "2014-01-24",
"outcome": "Then-retired Archbishop Seraphim (Kenneth Storheim) was found guilty of one count of sexual assault against a boy who, with his brother, had been sent by their mother in 1985 to live and work at Storheim's church-attached residence in Winnipeg while he was a parish priest; he was acquitted of a second count involving the boy's brother. Justice Christopher Mainella found the accused not credible."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Queen's Bench of Manitoba",
"stage": "sentencing",
"date": "2014-07-01",
"outcome": "Sentenced to eight months' imprisonment. Justice Mainella called the conduct 'a deplorable and gross breach of trust.'"
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Manitoba Court of Appeal",
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2015-02-05",
"outcome": "Appeal against conviction rejected; Storheim began serving his sentence immediately. Conviction stood."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/winnipeg-archbishop-guilty-of-sexually-assaulting-boy-1.2509748",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News (2014) 'Winnipeg archbishop guilty of sexually assaulting boy'.",
"body": "Court of Queen's Bench Justice Christopher Mainella found former archbishop Seraphim Storheim guilty of sexually assaulting one of two brothers who had been sent by their mother in 1985 to live and work with him at a Winnipeg Orthodox church; the judge said he did not believe Storheim's testimony, calling it inconsistent and 'nonsensical.'",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/altar-boy-testifies-at-winnipeg-priest-sex-assault-trial-1.1410190",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Altar boy testifies at Winnipeg priest sex assault trial'.",
"body": "Testimony describes Storheim routinely walking and lying naked in the church-attached residence in front of the boys, on one occasion inspecting one boy's groin 'looking for pubic hair,' and getting into bed with the younger brother asking to be touched sexually.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-testimony-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2015/01_02/2015_02_05_WinnipegSun_StorheimsAppeal.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Winnipeg Sun (2015) 'Storheim's Appeal Denied, Going to Jail'.",
"body": "Reports the Manitoba Court of Appeal's rejection of Storheim's appeal on 5 February 2015 and his immediate committal to serve the eight-month sentence.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seraphim_Storheim",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia, 'Seraphim Storheim'.",
"body": "Summarizes Storheim's career as Archbishop of Ottawa and Canada in the Orthodox Church in America (1990–2010), the 2014 conviction, 2015 appeal denial, and the Holy Synod's October 2015 canonical deposition returning him to lay-monk status.",
"tier": "reference-work",
"kind": "biographical-summary"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Storheim held both parish-priest and later archiepiscopal authority in the Orthodox Church in America; the boys were placed in his household specifically because of his clerical standing, and he used the pretext of pastoral oversight (nudity, physical 'inspection') to abuse a child in his care. Strike the clerical authority and there is no other channel that would have placed the boy, alone, in the priest's residence.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "manitoba-court-of-appeal",
"date": "2015-02-05",
"note": "Conviction and sentence upheld; sentence executed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/winnipeg-archbishop-guilty-of-sexually-assaulting-boy-1.2509748",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/altar-boy-testifies-at-winnipeg-priest-sex-assault-trial-1.1410190",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-testimony-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2015/01_02/2015_02_05_WinnipegSun_StorheimsAppeal.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7a2e1f4e7ec6fcdd0f60c28ee03a03680486381e3292feac2538a87685de4562",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2015/01_02/2015_02_05_WinnipegSun_StorheimsAppeal.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seraphim_Storheim",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-work; evidentiary role: biographical-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bbf761d7c9578941897325ef81e94dca2048067e10b51e1a11f73e87057e4607",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seraphim_Storheim"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [
"Rev. Charles Michael Abdelahad",
"Fr. Michael Abdelahad"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The criminal conviction is for assault and battery (physical abuse) rather than a sexual-abuse charge; the civil complaint additionally alleges sexual abuse during the same sessions, but that count was not the basis of the criminal conviction, so this record is coded type: physical-abuse to match what was actually proven at the tier this corpus requires.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-charles-abdelahad-worcester-massachusetts-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Worcester, Massachusetts, USA",
"lat": 42.2626,
"lng": -71.8023,
"title": "United States: Antiochian Orthodox priest convicted of assaulting a parishioner during years of 'spiritual father' counseling sessions",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, St. George Antiochian Orthodox Cathedral, Worcester, MA",
"self-described 'spiritual father' and counselor to the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed to be the victim's 'spiritual father' through whom God spoke, and told her she was required to obey him",
"convinced her she was possessed by demons and was repressing memories of childhood sexual abuse, used as pretext for years of private 3-5 hour 'counseling' sessions",
"sessions conducted under the guise of psychological/spiritual therapy during which he physically assaulted her"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"St. George Antiochian Orthodox Cathedral, Worcester",
"Antiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese of North America",
"Antiochian Orthodox Christian Diocese of New England"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Worcester District Court, Massachusetts",
"stage": "conviction, sentencing",
"date": "2012-05-25",
"outcome": "The Very Rev. Charles Michael Abdelahad was convicted of felony assault and battery with a dangerous weapon (his shod foot) and sentenced to serve 90 days of a 2-year jail term at the Worcester County Jail and House of Correction; he was also found guilty of a separate assault and battery charge (biting the victim) and given a three-year probationary sentence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.necn.com/news/local/clergy-sex-abuse-victims-upset-rev_-charles-abdelahad-still-active_necn/46339/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NECN, 'Clergy sex abuse victims upset Rev. Charles Abdelahad still active'.",
"body": "Reports that Abdelahad, pastor of St. George Antiochian Orthodox Cathedral in Worcester, was convicted in May 2012 of abusing parishioner Susan Manter during counseling sessions at the church and sentenced to 90 days of a two-year term.",
"tier": "regional-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "trial-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://02varvara.wordpress.com/2013/10/20/abuse-victim-sues-st-georges-former-pastor-church/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Voices from Russia (2013) 'Abuse Victim Sues St George's Former Pastor, Church', reprinting Worcester Telegram & Gazette reporting.",
"body": "Details the civil suit: Abdelahad told Manter he was her 'spiritual father' through whom God spoke and that she was required to obey him; he convinced her she was possessed by demons and repressing memories of childhood sexual abuse by her father, requiring twice-weekly 3-5 hour private 'counseling' sessions from 2007 to September 2010 during which he hit, kicked, bit, and slapped her, including with a baseball bat, causing broken bones and concussions.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "civil-complaint-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.snapnetwork.org/ma_convicted_priest_is_back_in_church",
"archive": "",
"citation": "SNAP, 'MA - Convicted priest is back in church'.",
"body": "Confirms the May 2012 criminal conviction and notes Abdelahad's return to active ministry, prompting victim-advocate objections.",
"tier": "advocacy-organization-report",
"kind": "post-conviction-status-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Abdelahad's authority derived explicitly from his self-declared role as the victim's 'spiritual father' who spoke for God and to whom obedience was owed; he used the demonic-possession/repressed-abuse frame to require years of private sessions in which the assaults occurred. Strike the claimed spiritual-father authority and the possession/therapy pretext, and the victim had no other reason to submit to the private sessions in which the beatings occurred.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.necn.com/news/local/clergy-sex-abuse-victims-upset-rev_-charles-abdelahad-still-active_necn/46339/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: trial-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5da9fd52385d3ce976f8de82d761587b2998674d4e9a7167e9a2dc67e092b9b4",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcboston.com/news/local/"
},
{
"source": "https://02varvara.wordpress.com/2013/10/20/abuse-victim-sues-st-georges-former-pastor-church/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-complaint-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2c17865175a00fb9088c7f6845a1ca0781cbb37430432da4d39bedee49ac3b9a",
"final_url": "https://02varvara.wordpress.com/2013/10/20/abuse-victim-sues-st-georges-former-pastor-church/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.snapnetwork.org/ma_convicted_priest_is_back_in_church",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-organization-report; evidentiary role: post-conviction-status-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "LOWER CONFIDENCE ON EVIDENCE TIER: despite extensive searching, no report of a trial verdict, acquittal, or conviction was found as of this record's compilation (most recent located reporting is 2018 bail proceedings and a 2024 Kerala High Court refusal to quash a related charge). This record is therefore coded evidenceStatus: charged, not convicted, and status: charged rather than conviction. It should be re-verified against current Kerala court records before being treated as a settled case; if a trial concluded with an acquittal, this record would need to be withdrawn or re-coded.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-malankara-orthodox-confession-blackmail-kerala-india",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Thiruvalla, Kerala, India",
"lat": 9.3833,
"lng": 76.5667,
"title": "India: four Malankara Orthodox priests charged with using a woman's confession to blackmail her into years of sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-orthodox",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish vicar (confessor)",
"clergy student / priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priest heard the victim's sacramental confession disclosing a premarital relationship, then threatened to disclose its contents to her husband unless she provided sexual favors",
"threat of exposure repeated and extended by additional priests over subsequent years"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kerala Police Crime Branch / Kerala High Court / Supreme Court of India",
"stage": "charged, pre-trial",
"date": "2018-07-12",
"outcome": "Fr Job Mathew taken into custody on 12 July 2018 after the Kerala High Court rejected his anticipatory bail application on 11 July 2018; the Crime Branch subsequently booked four priests — Fr Abraham Varghese (also referred to as Fr Sony Varghese), Fr Job Mathew, Fr Johnson Mathew and Fr Jaise K George — on charges of rape and molestation. Fr Sony Varghese and Fr Jaise K George were later directed by the Supreme Court to surrender (August 2018) after their anticipatory bail pleas were dismissed. No trial verdict was found in available reporting as of this record's compilation."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/priest-who-took-kerala-woman-s-confession-blackmailed-sexual-favours-custody-84605",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The News Minute (2018) 'Priest who took Kerala woman's confession, blackmailed for sexual favours, in custody'.",
"body": "The survivor confessed to Fr Job Mathew, ahead of her child's baptism, about an earlier relationship with clergy student Soni Varghese and threats he had made against her. Job Mathew then summoned her and threatened to disclose the confession's contents to her husband unless she provided sexual favours; the blackmail began in 2009 and the case surfaced in June 2018. Job Mathew was taken into custody on 12 July 2018 after the Kerala High Court rejected his anticipatory bail application the day before.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "arrest-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-orthodox-church-sex-silence-row-crime-branch-books-4-priests-rape-84043",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The News Minute (2018) 'Kerala Orthodox church \"sex-for-silence\" row: Crime Branch books 4 priests for rape'.",
"body": "Names all four accused priests — Fr Abraham Varghese, Fr Job Mathew, Fr Johnson Mathew and Fr Jaise George — of the Malankara Orthodox Church, and describes how Fr Job Mathew's exploitation of the confessional secret from 2009 was followed by other priests making similar threats over subsequent years.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "charging-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/kerala-sex-silence-case-sc-dismisses-anticipatory-bail-2-accused-priests-86046",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The News Minute (2018) 'Kerala \"sex for silence\" case: SC dismisses anticipatory bail of 2 accused priests'.",
"body": "The Supreme Court dismissed the anticipatory bail pleas of Fr Sony Varghese and Fr Jaise K George, directing them to surrender by 13 August 2018 and apply for regular bail thereafter.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "bail-proceeding-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The abuse began with the sacrament of confession itself: the priest who heard the victim's confession used the secrecy she was bound to trust the Church to keep as the direct instrument of coercion, threatening its disclosure to her husband. This is the confession-as-weapon pattern distinct from confession-as-mitigating-context: the confessor here is the perpetrator, not a third party who merely received a disclosure about someone else's abuse.",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Fr Job Mathew taken into custody on 12 July 2018 after the Kerala High Court rejected his anticipatory bail application on 11 July 2018; the Crime Branch subsequently booked four priests — Fr Abraham Varghese (also referred to as Fr Sony Varghese), Fr Job Mathew, Fr Johnson Mathew and Fr Jaise K George — on charges of rape and molestation. Fr Sony Varghese and Fr Jaise K George were later directed by the Supreme Court to surrender (August 2018) after their anticipatory bail pleas were dismissed. No trial verdict was found in available reporting as of this record's compilation.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/priest-who-took-kerala-woman-s-confession-blackmailed-sexual-favours-custody-84605",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a5a504015be23029ef8ad8c2543adaa7772856da364c786ed3f6bda33c9e1d86",
"final_url": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/priest-who-took-kerala-woman-s-confession-blackmailed-sexual-favours-custody-84605"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-orthodox-church-sex-silence-row-crime-branch-books-4-priests-rape-84043",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c011dd17828d0e599ca2b48c1c25dcfece1259454eefe89f9c66c6f644c9901e",
"final_url": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-orthodox-church-sex-silence-row-crime-branch-books-4-priests-rape-84043"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/kerala-sex-silence-case-sc-dismisses-anticipatory-bail-2-accused-priests-86046",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: bail-proceeding-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ac339d1ae4ee9df683c08194782a85b5afba0293ca694ed68210dc81c9526813",
"final_url": "https://www.thenewsminute.com/kerala/kerala-sex-silence-case-sc-dismisses-anticipatory-bail-2-accused-priests-86046"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 987,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Trial-level conviction by a Women and Child Repression Prevention Tribunal. Bangladesh capital/life sentences of this kind are subject to mandatory High Court review and connected appeals; no appellate disposition was located, and this record does not present the sentence as final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-riad-uddin-hifz-madrasa-lohagara-chattogram-bangladesh",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Lohagara, Chattogram, Bangladesh",
"lat": 22.1667,
"lng": 92.05,
"title": "Bangladesh: madrasa hifz-section teacher sentenced to life imprisonment for raping his nine-year-old residential student",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"madrasa teacher (hifz/Quran-memorization section)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-school teacher's custodial authority over a residential child student",
"threats against disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Hifz madrasa, Lohagara upazila, Chattogram"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Women and Child Repression Prevention Tribunal-2, Chattogram",
"stage": "trial judgment",
"date": "2025-08-27",
"outcome": "The tribunal convicted madrasa teacher Riad Uddin of raping a nine-year-old student who had enrolled in the hifz (Quran-memorization) section three months earlier as a residential student, and sentenced him to life imprisonment with hard labour, a fine of 50,000 taka, and a further three months' imprisonment in default of payment. The assault occurred on the madrasa premises on 22 September 2022; the child disclosed it to his mother the next morning, and local residents surrounded the madrasa and detained the teacher before police arrived."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A residential hifz student under his teacher's live-in custodial and religious authority inside the madrasa.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.banglatribune.com/country/chitagong/912916/%E0%A6%9B%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A4%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%95%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%A7%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B7%E0%A6%A3%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B0-%E0%A6%A6%E0%A6%BE%E0%A7%9F%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%BE-%E0%A6%B6%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%95%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B7%E0%A6%95%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B0-%E0%A6%AF%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%80%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%A8",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'ছাত্রকে ধর্ষণের দায়ে মাদ্রাসা শিক্ষকের যাবজ্জীবন' [\"Life sentence for madrasa teacher over rape of student\"], Bangla Tribune, 27 Aug. 2025.",
"body": "Bangla-language report of the tribunal verdict, naming the teacher, the tribunal, the sentence terms, and the underlying facts including the child's residential hifz enrolment and the date of the assault.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "trial-verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.banglatribune.com/country/chitagong/912916/%E0%A6%9B%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A4%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%95%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%A7%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B7%E0%A6%A3%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B0-%E0%A6%A6%E0%A6%BE%E0%A7%9F%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%BE-%E0%A6%B6%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%95%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B7%E0%A6%95%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B0-%E0%A6%AF%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%80%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%A8",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: trial-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 988,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Trial-level conviction by a Women and Child Repression Prevention Tribunal. Subject to mandatory High Court review under Bangladeshi procedure for life sentences of this class; no appellate disposition was located, and this record does not present the sentence as final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-atiqul-islam-jhakuapara-mosque-imam-taraganj-rangpur-bangladesh",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Taraganj, Rangpur, Bangladesh",
"lat": 25.7833,
"lng": 89.15,
"title": "Bangladesh: mosque imam sentenced to life imprisonment for raping a ten-year-old child during Arabic lessons",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam, Jhakuapara New Mosque"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"imam's instructional authority over children attending Arabic/Quran lessons at the mosque",
"isolating the victim by dismissing other children",
"threats against disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Jhakuapara New Mosque, Taraganj upazila, Rangpur"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Women and Child Repression Prevention Tribunal-3, Rangpur",
"stage": "trial judgment",
"date": "2022-05-26",
"outcome": "The tribunal convicted imam Atiqul Islam (also known as Atik) of raping a ten-year-old child and sentenced him to life imprisonment with hard labour and a fine of 10,000 taka. On 4 November 2020 the child had gone with other children to the Jhakuapara New Mosque to study Arabic under the imam; he dismissed the other children and raped the victim, then threatened the child not to disclose it. The child later required medical treatment and disclosed the assault to family, leading to the imam's arrest by local residents and a case filed under the Women and Child Repression Prevention Act."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child attending the imam's religious-instruction class at the mosque, isolated from other students under his instructional authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bangla.thedailystar.net/%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6/%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%B2%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B6/%E0%A6%85%E0%A6%AA%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A7-%E0%A6%93-%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%9A%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%B0/%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%AA%E0%A7%81%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%B6%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%B6%E0%A7%81-%E0%A6%A7%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B7%E0%A6%A3-%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%B2%E0%A6%BE%E0%A7%9F-%E0%A6%87%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AE%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B0-%E0%A6%AF%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%80%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%A8-352666",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'রংপুরে শিশু ধর্ষণ মামলায় ইমামের যাবজ্জীবন' [\"Life sentence for imam in Rangpur child rape case\"], The Daily Star Bangla, 26 May 2022.",
"body": "Bangla-language report of the tribunal verdict naming the imam, the mosque, the judge, sentence terms, and the underlying facts including the date of the assault and the child's Arabic-lesson attendance.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "trial-verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bangla.thedailystar.net/%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6/%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%B2%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B6/%E0%A6%85%E0%A6%AA%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A7-%E0%A6%93-%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%9A%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%B0/%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%AA%E0%A7%81%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%B6%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%B6%E0%A7%81-%E0%A6%A7%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B7%E0%A6%A3-%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%B2%E0%A6%BE%E0%A7%9F-%E0%A6%87%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AE%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B0-%E0%A6%AF%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%80%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%A8-352666",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: trial-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f197cc1206cb0de17ee489df05464dddb64a238699fac29231ffaad731fada70",
"final_url": "https://bangla.thedailystar.net/%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6/%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%B2%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A6%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B6/%E0%A6%85%E0%A6%AA%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%A7-%E0%A6%93-%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%9A%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%B0/%E0%A6%B0%E0%A6%82%E0%A6%AA%E0%A7%81%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%B6%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%B6%E0%A7%81-%E0%A6%A7%E0%A6%B0%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%B7%E0%A6%A3-%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%B2%E0%A6%BE%E0%A7%9F-%E0%A6%87%E0%A6%AE%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AE%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%B0-%E0%A6%AF%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%8D%E0%A6%9C%E0%A7%80%E0%A6%AC%E0%A6%A8-352666"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 989,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Trial-level conviction by a Women and Child Repression Prevention Tribunal. Subject to mandatory High Court review under Bangladeshi procedure for life sentences of this class; no appellate disposition was located, and this record does not present the sentence as final. The victim was a neighbourhood child rather than a formal student, but the defendant's standing as the local mosque's imam and hafizia-madrasa Arabic teacher for area children establishes the same spiritual-instructional authority as the other madrasa/mosque records in this tranche.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-shahjahan-gazi-imam-charghat-rajshahi-bangladesh",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Charghat, Rajshahi, Bangladesh",
"lat": 24.3667,
"lng": 88.75,
"title": "Bangladesh: mosque imam sentenced to life imprisonment for raping a twelve-year-old child from the community he taught",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam and hafizia-madrasa Arabic teacher, Charghat upazila"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing as the local mosque's imam and children's Arabic teacher",
"threats to kill if the child disclosed"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"mosque and hafizia madrasa, Charghat upazila, Rajshahi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Women and Child Repression Prevention Tribunal-2, Rajshahi",
"stage": "trial judgment",
"date": "2026-05-16",
"outcome": "The tribunal convicted Md. Shahjahan Gazi (60), the local mosque's imam and a teacher of Arabic to children at a hafizia madrasa, of raping a twelve-year-old child, and sentenced him to life imprisonment with hard labour, a fine of 100,000 taka, and three months' further imprisonment (simple) in default. In 2018 the imam took the child behind his house while no one else was present, raped the child, and threatened to kill the child if the assault were disclosed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A child from the imam's own community, under the religious-instructional authority he held as both the mosque's imam and the local hafizia madrasa's Arabic teacher.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.banglanews24.com/law-court/news/bd/1114618.details",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'শিশু ধর্ষণ মামলায় ইমামের যাবজ্জীবন সশ্রম কারাদণ্ড' [\"Life imprisonment with hard labour for imam in child rape case\"], Banglanews24, 16 May 2026.",
"body": "Bangla-language report of the tribunal verdict naming the imam, his dual roles as mosque imam and hafizia-madrasa Arabic teacher, sentence terms, and the underlying 2018 facts.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "trial-verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.banglanews24.com/law-court/news/bd/1114618.details",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: trial-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2c4554c9a28e48214af23ffe806f09c2ca3821a9be5df114684fbb95999de48a",
"final_url": "https://www.banglanews24.com/law-court/news/bd/1114618.details"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 990,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-gilles-noreau-petit-seminaire-quebec-canada",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Quebec City, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 46.8139,
"lng": -71.208,
"title": "Quebec: Petit Séminaire de Québec priest-teacher pleads guilty to sexually abusing seven students",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest",
"teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"institutional access",
"silencing of 1967 disclosure"
],
"organizations": [
"Petit Séminaire de Québec",
"Séminaire de Québec"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Quebec Superior Court (criminal)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2004-04-01",
"outcome": "Abbé Gilles Noreau pleaded guilty to seven counts of sexual touching against students at the Petit Séminaire de Québec, committed between 1965 and 1988; sentenced to one year imprisonment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2144339/seminaire-action-collective-abus-sexuels",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio-Canada (2023) 'Abus sexuels : le Séminaire de Québec visé dans l'action collective contre le diocèse', Radio-Canada. Available at: ici.radio-canada.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "French original: \"L'abbé Gilles Noreau a plaidé coupable en avril 2004 à sept chefs d'accusation d'avoir posé des gestes à connotation sexuelle, commis sur une période de 23 ans, entre 1965 et 1988. Il a été condamné à un an de prison. Il a reconnu avoir fait sept victimes, essentiellement en lien avec son travail d'enseignement au Petit Séminaire de Québec. En 1967, le témoin concerné aurait dénoncé ces agressions au directeur du Petit Séminaire, l'abbé Jean Poulin. Ce dernier l'a traité de menteur et l'a réduit au silence.\" English gloss: Abbé Gilles Noreau pleaded guilty in April 2004 to seven counts of sexual touching over a 23-year span (1965-1988) and was sentenced to one year in prison. He admitted to seven victims, mostly tied to his teaching role at the Petit Séminaire de Québec. A 1967 disclosure to the school's director was dismissed and the boy was called a liar and silenced."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Noreau used his standing as an ordained priest-teacher inside a diocesan seminary to access and abuse students under his pastoral and pedagogical authority; a 1967 disclosure was actively suppressed by the seminary's director, extending his access for two more decades.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2144339/seminaire-action-collective-abus-sexuels",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b321667da28e3b84936eed78d72f08a45a7700057e8c5dbaf9667a1e65a30302",
"final_url": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2144339/seminaire-action-collective-abus-sexuels"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 991,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-levi-noel-diocese-bathurst-new-brunswick-canada",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Bathurst, New Brunswick, Canada",
"lat": 47.6187,
"lng": -65.6501,
"title": "New Brunswick: Acadian priest Lévi Noël sentenced to eight years, the heaviest sentence ever given a Catholic priest in Canada",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"diocesan protection via repeated transfers"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Bathurst"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New Brunswick Court of Queen's Bench (criminal)",
"stage": "sentencing",
"date": "2010-01-01",
"outcome": "Lévi Noël pleaded guilty to 22 counts of gross indecency and indecent assault against 18 boys aged 8 to 16, committed between 1958 and 1981 in Acadian parishes of the Diocese of Bathurst; sentenced to eight years' imprisonment, described as the heaviest sentence ever imposed on a Catholic priest in Canada. He was laicized by the Vatican in 2012."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A9vi_No%C3%ABl",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipédia (2024) 'Lévi Noël', Wikipédia. Available at: fr.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "French original: \"En 2010, Lévi Noël est condamné à huit ans de prison à la suite de 22 accusations concernant des cas de grossière indécence et d'attentats à la pudeur. Les agressions se sont produites de 1958 à 1981 sur 18 garçons âgés de 8 à 16 ans... La peine imposée à M. Noël est la plus lourde qui ait été imposée à un prêtre pédophile au Canada... Des correspondances, dès le début des années 1960, entre des membres de l'Église catholique dont l'évêque Valéry Vienneau, attestent d'allégations d'abus dans les paroisses où Lévi Noël travaillait. À la suite de ces échanges le prêtre était, dans plus d'une demi-douzaine de cas, déplacé dans une nouvelle communauté.\" English gloss: In 2010 Lévi Noël was sentenced to eight years after pleading guilty to 22 counts of gross indecency and indecent assault against 18 boys aged 8-16 between 1958 and 1981 — the heaviest sentence ever given a pedophile priest in Canada. Correspondence from the early 1960s among Church officials, including Bishop Valéry Vienneau, documents abuse allegations in the parishes where Noël served; he was moved to a new community more than half a dozen times following these disclosures."
},
{
"link": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/1415815/aviva-canada-remboursement-entente-diocese-bathurst",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio-Canada, 'Agressions sexuelles : Aviva Canada rembourse le diocèse de Bathurst'. Available at: ici.radio-canada.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Reports that the Diocese of Bathurst's insurer was ordered by the New Brunswick Court of Appeal to reimburse the diocese over $3.3 million paid out to victims of its priests, part of a broader compensation process (led by Michel Bastarache) under which victims of the Bathurst and Moncton dioceses received close to $18 million."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Noël exploited his position as parish priest across a succession of Acadian francophone parishes in the Diocese of Bathurst; when parents or Church officials raised concerns, the diocese repeatedly relocated him rather than removing his access to children, extending the abuse over two decades.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A9vi_No%C3%ABl",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c954c94fb5d2f3dd0995de4abdc1aebaad2542751da4e43d585eba932f2d37f7",
"final_url": "https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A9vi_No%C3%ABl"
},
{
"source": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/1415815/aviva-canada-remboursement-entente-diocese-bathurst",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2fe6a81a0581970e7f0dd59ac8651073fae018e5d500ff5a65ae47c59940a107",
"final_url": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/1415815/aviva-canada-remboursement-entente-diocese-bathurst"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 992,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-beatrix-morin-diocese-rimouski-canada",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Rivière-du-Loup, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 47.8305,
"lng": -69.5411,
"title": "Quebec: Bas-Saint-Laurent priest Béatrix Morin sentenced to three years for sexual assaults spanning two decades",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"institutional access"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Rimouski",
"Archdiocese of Rimouski"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Quebec Superior Court (criminal)",
"stage": "sentencing",
"date": "2021-06-11",
"outcome": "Béatrix Morin, former curé of Saint-Hubert-de-Rivière-du-Loup, pleaded guilty to five counts of sexual assault, indecent assault, and gross indecency against six victims (five minors) committed between 1970 and 1990; sentenced to three years in federal penitentiary and placed on the sex-offender registry for life."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infodimanche.com/actualites/justice-et-faits-divers/428932/trois-ans-de-prison-pour-le-pretre-beatrix-morin",
"archive": "",
"citation": "InfoDimanche (2021) 'Trois ans de prison pour le prêtre Béatrix Morin'. Available at: infodimanche.com (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "French original: \"Béatrix Morin ... a été condamné à trois ans de pénitencier ... Morin a plaidé coupable à cinq chefs d'accusation d'agression sexuelle ... pour des gestes commis entre 1970 et 1990 ... Six victimes, dont cinq étaient mineures au moment des gestes.\" English gloss: Béatrix Morin was sentenced to three years in penitentiary after pleading guilty to five counts of sexual assault committed between 1970 and 1990 against six victims, five of whom were minors at the time."
},
{
"link": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2262999/action-collective-diocese-archidiocese-seminaire-rimouski",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio-Canada, 'Action collective autorisée pour des abus sexuels au diocèse de Rimouski'. Available at: ici.radio-canada.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Reports that the Quebec Superior Court authorized on 2024-06-19 a class action against the Diocese, Archdiocese, and Saint-Germain Seminary of Rimouski, with the lead plaintiff's claim naming Morin's 2021 guilty plea as a triggering disclosure; 48 victims had registered as of the report."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Morin used his position as parish priest of Saint-Hubert-de-Rivière-du-Loup and surrounding Bas-Saint-Laurent communities to abuse minors under his pastoral care over a twenty-year span.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infodimanche.com/actualites/justice-et-faits-divers/428932/trois-ans-de-prison-pour-le-pretre-beatrix-morin",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1da163ca1e9697e378bcaed912a8af7e25c94be4c18caae4065cfceafb46839d",
"final_url": "https://www.infodimanche.com/justice-et-faits-divers/trois-ans-de-prison-pour-le-pretre-beatrix-morin/"
},
{
"source": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2262999/action-collective-diocese-archidiocese-seminaire-rimouski",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "57ef80f196506cebb54fa18739f58b383f327234985629a306997104bd16dea8",
"final_url": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2262999/action-collective-diocese-archidiocese-seminaire-rimouski"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 993,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional/civil-finding record: a court-approved settlement compensating a defined class of victims, not an individual criminal conviction. Retained per the plan's guidance that Quebec class-action settlements are a major, court-approved vehicle constituting a civil finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-freres-sacre-coeur-class-settlement-quebec-canada",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 46.8139,
"lng": -71.208,
"title": "Quebec: Brothers of the Sacred Heart reach $60-million court-approved settlement covering 250 victims and 93 abusers across fifty schools",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious brother",
"teacher"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"institutional access",
"boarding-school isolation"
],
"organizations": [
"Frères du Sacré-Cœur",
"Brothers of the Sacred Heart"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Quebec Superior Court (civil class action)",
"stage": "settlement approved",
"date": "2021-09-01",
"outcome": "Settlement protocol signed covering two class actions (including the 2016 action concerning Collège Mont-Sacré-Cœur de Granby) for sexual assaults by members of the Brothers of the Sacred Heart between 1932 and 2008; the congregation agreed to pay $60 million to compensate 250 identified victims of 93 named abusers across roughly fifty Quebec schools."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abus_sexuels_dans_la_congr%C3%A9gation_des_Fr%C3%A8res_du_Sacr%C3%A9-C%C5%93ur",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipédia (2024) 'Abus sexuels dans la congrégation des Frères du Sacré-Cœur', Wikipédia. Available at: fr.wikipedia.org (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "French original: \"À la suite de deux actions collectives pour des sévices sexuels au Québec, un protocole d'accord, signé en septembre 2021, permet le versement de 60 millions de dollars aux victimes des Frères du Sacré-Cœur. En septembre 2021, il est dénombré 250 victimes issues d'une cinquantaine établissements d'enseignement et 93 agresseurs membres des Frères du Sacré-Cœur, pour des abus sexuels entre 1932 et 2008.\" English gloss: Following two class actions over sexual abuse in Quebec, a settlement protocol signed in September 2021 provides for payment of $60 million to victims of the Brothers of the Sacred Heart. As of September 2021, 250 victims from about fifty schools and 93 abuser-members of the congregation were identified, covering abuse between 1932 and 2008."
},
{
"link": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/1805484/agressions-sexuelles-freres-sacre-coeur-entente-amiable-millions",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio-Canada, 'Agressions sexuelles : les Frères du Sacré-Cœur verseront 60 millions aux victimes'. Available at: ici.radio-canada.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Confirms the $60-million amicable settlement between the Brothers of the Sacred Heart and class-action plaintiffs over decades of sexual abuse at the congregation's Quebec institutions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Brothers of the Sacred Heart held live-in pedagogical and religious authority over boys in boarding and day schools; that authority, combined with institutional isolation, was the documented means by which 93 members accessed and abused students across roughly fifty establishments.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abus_sexuels_dans_la_congr%C3%A9gation_des_Fr%C3%A8res_du_Sacr%C3%A9-C%C5%93ur",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "033f24cf7336e1154d37034909ece3c31c196c7741046e99858c71619f84036f",
"final_url": "https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abus_sexuels_dans_la_congr%C3%A9gation_des_Fr%C3%A8res_du_Sacr%C3%A9-C%C5%93ur"
},
{
"source": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/1805484/agressions-sexuelles-freres-sacre-coeur-entente-amiable-millions",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4edde43cf72425a123c73acef4b01fc087485a6a526aae41739efaca78c1c91b",
"final_url": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/1805484/agressions-sexuelles-freres-sacre-coeur-entente-amiable-millions"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 994,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional/civil-finding record: a court-approved settlement, not an individual criminal conviction against Harvey (who was not separately criminally tried per available reporting). Included as a civil finding under the plan's Quebec class-action guidance.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-paul-andre-harvey-diocese-chicoutimi-canada",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Chicoutimi, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 48.4283,
"lng": -71.0596,
"title": "Quebec: Diocese of Chicoutimi settlement pays $13.75 million to more than 150 victims of a single priest, Paul-André Harvey",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"institutional access"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Chicoutimi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Quebec Superior Court (civil class action)",
"stage": "settlement finalized",
"date": "2022-04-04",
"outcome": "Final settlement text agreed for the class action against the Diocese of Chicoutimi concerning sexual assaults by former priest Paul-André Harvey; the diocese's insurer agreed to pay $13,750,000 to more than 150 identified victims, with the bishop agreeing to issue a formal apology and institute reparative measures."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tjl.quebec/en/class-actions/victims-of-sexual-assault-harvey/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TJL Avocats, 'Paul-André Harvey et Le Diocèse de Chicoutimi'. Available at: tjl.quebec (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Case page for the class action against former priest Paul-André Harvey and the Diocese of Chicoutimi, describing the settlement covering victims of Harvey's sexual assaults within the diocese."
},
{
"link": "https://presence-info.ca/article/actualite/justice/une-somme-de-147-m-sera-versee-aux-victimes/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Présence (2022) 'Une somme de 14,7 M$ sera versée aux victimes'. Available at: presence-info.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "French original: \"Le diocèse de Chicoutimi [a] committ[é] à payer 13,75 M$ à plus de 150 victimes d'un seul prêtre, l'abbé Paul-André Harvey ... Les parties ont convenu du texte final de l'entente de règlement le 4 avril 2022.\" English gloss: The Diocese of Chicoutimi committed to pay $13.75 million to more than 150 victims of a single priest, Abbé Paul-André Harvey; the parties agreed on the final settlement text on April 4, 2022 — the largest per-priest victim count of any Quebec diocesan settlement to date."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Harvey's decades of access to children as a diocesan priest, and the diocese's institutional authority over parish placement, is documented as the mechanism enabling a single priest to victimize more than 150 people within one diocese.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tjl.quebec/en/class-actions/victims-of-sexual-assault-harvey/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fd45990eb6ae3c4dd22d44979275a3dea34fbc9342be6fd7420ac4e0b1b344fe",
"final_url": "https://tjl.quebec/en/class-actions/victims-of-sexual-assault-harvey/"
},
{
"source": "https://presence-info.ca/article/actualite/justice/une-somme-de-147-m-sera-versee-aux-victimes/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "804f6304ad4ed69abe2a85868e2e5a3f89fa5650a8f5216d70256528023f90fa",
"final_url": "https://presence-info.ca/article/religions/justice/une-somme-de-147-m-sera-versee-aux-victimes/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 995,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional/civil-finding record: a court-approved class settlement rather than a single named perpetrator's criminal conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-diocese-saint-jean-longueuil-settlement-canada",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Longueuil, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 45.5312,
"lng": -73.5185,
"title": "Quebec: Diocese of Saint-Jean-Longueuil settlement of $6.48 million approved by Superior Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy",
"lay employee"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"institutional access"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Saint-Jean-Longueuil"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Quebec Superior Court (civil class action)",
"stage": "settlement approved",
"date": "2025-10-10",
"outcome": "Superior Court judge approved the settlement agreement in the class action against the Diocese of Saint-Jean-Longueuil (filed 2019-12-12, covering alleged abuse from 1940 to the present by priests and lay employees); the diocese agreed to pay $6.48 million to approximately 30 registered class members."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2166546/victimes-abus-sexuels-entente-deux-dioceses-quebecois",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio-Canada, '15 millions $ en recours collectifs contre des religieux'. Available at: ici.radio-canada.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "French original: \"le diocèse de Saint-Jean-Longueuil versera 6,48 millions $... L'action collective contre le diocèse de Longueuil a été déposée le 12 décembre 2019 et regroupe une trentaine de présumées victimes.\" English gloss: The Diocese of Saint-Jean-Longueuil will pay $6.48 million; the class action against the diocese was filed December 12, 2019 and groups about thirty alleged victims, covering the period 1940 to the present."
},
{
"link": "https://www.lecourrierdusud.ca/diocese-longueuil-entente-reglement-victimes-agressions-sexuelles/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le Courrier du Sud, 'Diocèse de Longueuil : entente de règlement pour victimes d'agressions sexuelles'. Available at: lecourrierdusud.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Confirms Superior Court approval of the Diocese of Saint-Jean-Longueuil settlement on 2025-10-10, following a hearing at the Montreal courthouse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The class action and settlement concern sexual assaults committed by clergy and lay employees exercising institutional and pastoral authority within the Diocese of Saint-Jean-Longueuil's parishes and schools.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2166546/victimes-abus-sexuels-entente-deux-dioceses-quebecois",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7c0734a79a53fc3fcaee177fc6857dfacbe0716f701781d6eafdbcbd18b45388",
"final_url": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2166546/victimes-abus-sexuels-entente-deux-dioceses-quebecois"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lecourrierdusud.ca/diocese-longueuil-entente-reglement-victimes-agressions-sexuelles/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ae8abe67db33501ee247afb060fd5cf871ee53247838268e440ae8908c039473",
"final_url": "https://lecourrierdusud.ca/diocese-longueuil-entente-reglement-victimes-agressions-sexuelles/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 996,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional/civil-finding record: a court-approved class settlement rather than a single named perpetrator's criminal conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-diocese-saint-hyacinthe-settlement-canada",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Saint-Hyacinthe, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 45.6304,
"lng": -72.9573,
"title": "Quebec: Diocese of Saint-Hyacinthe settlement of $8.94 million approved by Superior Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "civil-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"clergy",
"lay employee"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"institutional access"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Saint-Hyacinthe"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Quebec Superior Court (civil class action)",
"stage": "settlement approved",
"date": "2025-10-15",
"outcome": "Superior Court judge Martin F. Sheehan approved the settlement agreement in the class action against the Diocese of Saint-Hyacinthe (filed 2021-10-29, covering alleged abuse from 1940 to the present); the diocese agreed to pay a minimum of $8,940,258 to approximately 40 registered class members."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2166546/victimes-abus-sexuels-entente-deux-dioceses-quebecois",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Radio-Canada, '15 millions $ en recours collectifs contre des religieux'. Available at: ici.radio-canada.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "French original: \"le diocèse de Saint-Hyacinthe [versera] un montant 'minimum' de 8 940 258 $... déposée le 29 octobre 2021 [et] regroupe une quarantaine de présumées victimes.\" English gloss: The Diocese of Saint-Hyacinthe will pay a 'minimum' amount of $8,940,258; the class action was filed October 29, 2021 and groups about forty alleged victims, covering the period 1940 to the present. Judge Martin F. Sheehan approved the Saint-Hyacinthe settlement on 2025-10-15."
},
{
"link": "https://presence-info.ca/article/actualite/justice/agressions-sexuelles-une-autre-entente-de-reglement-est-approuvee/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Présence, 'Agressions sexuelles: une autre entente de règlement est approuvée'. Available at: presence-info.ca (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Reports Superior Court approval of the Diocese of Saint-Hyacinthe settlement, part of a wave of Quebec diocesan class-action resolutions."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The class action and settlement concern sexual assaults committed by clergy and lay employees exercising institutional and pastoral authority within the Diocese of Saint-Hyacinthe's parishes and schools.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2166546/victimes-abus-sexuels-entente-deux-dioceses-quebecois",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7c0734a79a53fc3fcaee177fc6857dfacbe0716f701781d6eafdbcbd18b45388",
"final_url": "https://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelle/2166546/victimes-abus-sexuels-entente-deux-dioceses-quebecois"
},
{
"source": "https://presence-info.ca/article/actualite/justice/agressions-sexuelles-une-autre-entente-de-reglement-est-approuvee/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5c72e2304d2775bce5bfd0ae8733bde5bf75afe81ee1f2f3eb5e758164b50d41",
"final_url": "https://presence-info.ca/article/religions/justice/agressions-sexuelles-une-autre-entente-de-reglement-est-approuvee/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 997,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Authorization only, not yet a settlement or verdict; classed as an official finding (judicial authorization that the case may proceed) rather than a civil/criminal finding on the merits. Flag for follow-up once trial or settlement concludes.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-dominicains-class-action-authorized-quebec-canada",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 46.8139,
"lng": -71.208,
"title": "Quebec: Court of Appeal authorizes class action against the Order of Dominicans naming nine friars including Benoît Lacroix",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious priest/friar"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority",
"institutional access"
],
"organizations": [
"Ordre des Dominicains",
"Order of Preachers (Dominicans)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Quebec Court of Appeal (civil)",
"stage": "class action authorized",
"date": "2025-04-03",
"outcome": "The Court of Appeal authorized a class action against the Order of Dominicans in Quebec covering alleged sexual assaults from 1940 to the present, naming friars Benoît Lacroix, Fernand Patry, Charles-André Cabana, Bertrand M. Boisvert, Yves Léger, André St-Jacques, Jacques Létourneau, Étienne Morin, and Philéas Roy; more than a dozen victims had registered. Facts remain to be proven at trial absent a settlement."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lequotidien.com/actualites/justice-et-faits-divers/2025/04/03/agressions-sexuelles-une-action-collective-contre-lordre-des-dominicains-autorisee-AZM4JXGG5VCYLHRDJQ3J3WKPEI/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le Quotidien (2025) 'Agressions sexuelles: une action collective contre l'Ordre des Dominicains autorisée'. Available at: lequotidien.com (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "French original: \"La Cour d'appel a autorisé... une action collective contre l'Ordre des Dominicains... Tous les faits devront ainsi être prouvés dans le cadre d'un éventuel procès, à moins que les parties en viennent à une entente à l'amiable.\" English gloss: The Court of Appeal authorized a class action against the Order of Dominicans; all facts will need to be proven at a potential trial unless the parties reach an out-of-court settlement. More than a dozen alleged victims are registered, naming nine friars including Benoît Lacroix, and covering the period since 1940."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The named Dominican friars are alleged to have used their standing as ordained religious teachers and pastors — including Benoît Lacroix's prominent public role as a Dominican intellectual — to abuse victims under their spiritual and pedagogical authority.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lequotidien.com/actualites/justice-et-faits-divers/2025/04/03/agressions-sexuelles-une-action-collective-contre-lordre-des-dominicains-autorisee-AZM4JXGG5VCYLHRDJQ3J3WKPEI/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d8e192b4ea7ea9ff77f5e1b2f7b4e972a47763ce5042c78425ec58934f684dc8",
"final_url": "https://www.lequotidien.com/actualites/justice-et-faits-divers/2025/04/03/agressions-sexuelles-une-action-collective-contre-lordre-des-dominicains-autorisee-AZM4JXGG5VCYLHRDJQ3J3WKPEI/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 998,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim's father is both a family member and the group's spiritual leader; the abuse itself was carried out primarily by the follower under a forced-marriage arrangement orchestrated using the leader's religious authority over the community, not solely paternal authority — retained under the criterion as belief-authority is the documented operative means (forced religious nikah at 14, disciple's abuse from age six).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-hiranur-vakfi-ismailaga-sexual-abuse-turkey",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Istanbul, Turkey",
"lat": 41.0082,
"lng": 28.9784,
"title": "Turkey: Hiranur Foundation (İsmailağa-linked) leader and follower convicted for the sexual abuse and forced marriage of the founder's six-year-old daughter",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"cemaat/tarikat leader",
"father",
"follower (mürit)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual hierarchy",
"family control",
"forced religious marriage",
"blackmail"
],
"organizations": [
"Hiranur Vakfı",
"İsmailağa Cemaati"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Istanbul Heavy Penal Court (criminal)",
"stage": "first-instance verdict",
"date": "2023-10-23",
"outcome": "Kadir İstekli sentenced to 30 years, foundation founder Yusuf Ziya Gümüşel to 20 years, and Fatıma Gümüşel (mother) to 16 years 8 months for the aggravated sexual abuse and religious 'marriage' of H.K.G., the founder's daughter, from age six."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Court of Appeal / retrial",
"stage": "appeal — sentence increased",
"date": "2024-09-23",
"outcome": "On appeal the Regional Court of Appeal found the original sentences too lenient; Kadir İstekli's sentence was increased to a combined 36 years (21 years for aggravated child sexual abuse, 15 years for aggravated sexual assault) and Yusuf Ziya Gümüşel's to 18 years 9 months; the mother's file was severed for separate proceedings."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://haber.sol.org.tr/haber/hiranur-vakfinda-cinsel-istismar-davasi-tarikat-liderine-18-yil-muridine-36-yil-hapis-395174",
"archive": "",
"citation": "soL Haber (2024) 'Hiranur Vakfı'nda cinsel istismar davası: Tarikat liderine 18 yıl, müridine 36 yıl hapis'. Available at: haber.sol.org.tr (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Turkish original: \"İstinaf Mahkemesi bu cezayı yetersiz bularak kararı bozdu ve İstekli'ye iki ayrı suçtan 36 yıl hapis cezası verildi. Baba Gümüşel ise 18 yıl 9 ay ceza aldı.\" English gloss: The Court of Appeal found the sentence insufficient, overturned it, and sentenced İstekli to 36 years across two offenses; father Gümüşel received 18 years 9 months."
},
{
"link": "https://medyascope.tv/2023/10/23/6-yasindaki-cocuga-cinsel-istismar-davasinda-karar-kadir-istekliye-30-yusuf-ziya-gumusele-20-fatima-gumusele-16-yil-8-ay-hapis-cezasi/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Medyascope (2023) '6 yaşındaki çocuğa cinsel istismar davasında karar: Kadir İstekli'ye 30, Yusuf Ziya Gümüşel'e 20, Fatıma Gümüşel'e 16 yıl 8 ay hapis cezası'. Available at: medyascope.tv (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Turkish original: \"İsmailağa Cemaati'ne bağlı Hiranur Vakfı'nın kurucusu Yusuf Ziya Gümüşel'in kızı H.K.G'nin altı yaşından itibaren cemaat mensubu bir yetişkin erkek tarafından cinsel istismara uğradığı; 13 yaşında nişanlandırılıp 14 yaşında dini nikahla evlendirildiği ortaya çıktı.\" English gloss: It emerged that H.K.G., the daughter of Hiranur Vakfı founder Yusuf Ziya Gümüşel (linked to the İsmailağa cemaat), was sexually abused from age six by an adult male member of the congregation, was engaged at 13, and married via religious rite at 14."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's father was the cemaat-linked foundation's own founder and spiritual authority figure; he used that authority, together with a forced religious marriage doctrine, to place his six-year-old daughter under a follower's control and to conceal the abuse within the community for years before it surfaced.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://haber.sol.org.tr/haber/hiranur-vakfinda-cinsel-istismar-davasi-tarikat-liderine-18-yil-muridine-36-yil-hapis-395174",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8d2b7c2fe3091e52bca545b29dcf5acd2ee0ab9deb64475ee1361d58afdaf51e",
"final_url": "https://haber.sol.org.tr/haber/hiranur-vakfinda-cinsel-istismar-davasi-tarikat-liderine-18-yil-muridine-36-yil-hapis-395174"
},
{
"source": "https://medyascope.tv/2023/10/23/6-yasindaki-cocuga-cinsel-istismar-davasinda-karar-kadir-istekliye-30-yusuf-ziya-gumusele-20-fatima-gumusele-16-yil-8-ay-hapis-cezasi/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f4927433af870359d354582ba3c21890318f3c1720a121b238799ceefe898053",
"final_url": "https://medyascope.tv/2023/10/23/6-yasindaki-cocuga-cinsel-istismar-davasinda-karar-kadir-istekliye-30-yusuf-ziya-gumusele-20-fatima-gumusele-16-yil-8-ay-hapis-cezasi/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 999,
"aliases": [
"Eyüp Fatih Şağban"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-fatih-nurullah-ussaki-tarikat-leader-turkey",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Akyazı, Sakarya, Turkey",
"lat": 40.6842,
"lng": 30.6274,
"title": "Turkey: self-styled Uşşaki tarikat leader Fatih Nurullah convicted of child sexual abuse; sentence upheld through Court of Cassation",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled tarikat (Sufi order) leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual hierarchy",
"claimed religious authority over followers"
],
"organizations": [
"Uşşaki Tarikatı (self-styled)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sakarya Heavy Penal Court (criminal)",
"stage": "first-instance verdict",
"date": "2021-06-23",
"outcome": "Eyüp Fatih Şağban (known as Fatih Nurullah), self-declared leader of the Uşşaki tarikat, sentenced to 10 years 5 months for chain-structured child sexual abuse of a 12-year-old girl; acquitted on a separate charge of unlawful deprivation of liberty for sexual purposes."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal / Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), 9th Criminal Division",
"stage": "appeal — upheld",
"date": null,
"outcome": "The 10-year-5-month sentence was confirmed by the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal and subsequently upheld by the Court of Cassation's 9th Criminal Division, finalizing the conviction."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://ekmekvegul.net/gundem/ussaki-tarikati-lideri-eyyup-fatih-sagbana-cocuk-istismarindan-10-yil-5-ay-hapis",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ekmek ve Gül, 'Uşşaki Tarikatı Lideri Eyyüp Fatih Şağban'a çocuk istismarından 10 yıl 5 ay hapis'. Available at: ekmekvegul.net (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Turkish original: \"Uşşaki Tarikatı'nın lideri Fatih Nurullah, 10 yıl beş ay hapis cezasına çarptırıldı ... Yargıtay 9. Ceza Dairesi, 'zincirleme şekilde çocuğun cinsel istismarı' suçundan verilen 10 yıl 5 aylık cezayı onadı.\" English gloss: Uşşaki tarikat leader Fatih Nurullah was sentenced to 10 years 5 months; the Court of Cassation's 9th Criminal Division upheld the 10-year-5-month sentence for 'chain-structured child sexual abuse.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.birgun.net/haber/tarikat-liderine-cinsel-istismardan-10-yil-5-ay-hapis-cezasi-349396",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BirGün (2021) 'Tarikat liderine cinsel istismardan 10 yıl 5 ay hapis cezası'. Available at: birgun.net (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Reports Şağban's arrest on 2020-08-28 in Akyazı district after audio recordings of his abuse of a 12-year-old girl, dated 2020-03-17, were made public, followed by his conviction and sentencing."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Şağban held himself out as the leader (şeyh) of a self-styled Sufi tarikat, using that claimed spiritual authority over followers' families to gain access to and abuse a 12-year-old child within the group's orbit.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://ekmekvegul.net/gundem/ussaki-tarikati-lideri-eyyup-fatih-sagbana-cocuk-istismarindan-10-yil-5-ay-hapis",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3cd6f5caaadca0573a59e15f56587625c12289af891536ec0db4c6270df612f",
"final_url": "https://ekmekvegul.net/gundem/ussaki-tarikati-lideri-eyyup-fatih-sagbana-cocuk-istismarindan-10-yil-5-ay-hapis"
},
{
"source": "https://www.birgun.net/haber/tarikat-liderine-cinsel-istismardan-10-yil-5-ay-hapis-cezasi-349396",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4b2c05cd47ca6dc79a202d508366b09db63e9476e572751c13c879b88efd2720",
"final_url": "https://www.birgun.net/haber/tarikat-liderine-cinsel-istismardan-10-yil-5-ay-hapis-cezasi-349396"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1000,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-yusuf-kaya-imam-buhari-kuran-kursu-agri-turkey",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Ağrı, Turkey",
"lat": 39.7191,
"lng": 43.0503,
"title": "Turkey: Quran-course instructor sentenced to 35 years 5 months for the abuse and confinement of a nine-year-old student in Ağrı",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Quran-course instructor (Kuran kursu hocası)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual/pedagogical authority",
"threats of violence",
"confinement"
],
"organizations": [
"İmam Buhari Yatılı Erkek Kuran Kursu"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ağrı 2nd Heavy Penal Court (criminal)",
"stage": "verdict",
"date": null,
"outcome": "Quran-course instructor Yusuf Kaya sentenced to a combined 35 years 5 months: 30 years for aggravated child sexual abuse, 5 years for unlawful confinement, and 5 months for assault, against a nine-year-old student (U.P.) at the İmam Buhari residential Quran course."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/gundem/kurstaki-cinsel-istismara-35-yil-41207935",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Hürriyet, 'Kurstaki cinsel istismara 35 yıl'. Available at: hurriyet.com.tr (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Turkish original: \"Ağrı'da İmam Buhari Yatılı Erkek Kuran Kursu'nda 9 yaşındaki bir öğrenciye tecavüz eden Kuran hocası Yusuf Kaya'ya cinsel istismar suçundan 30 yıl, hürriyeti tahdit suçundan 5 yıl, yaralama suçundan da 5 ay olmak üzere toplam 35 yıl 5 ay hapis cezası verildi.\" English gloss: Quran teacher Yusuf Kaya, who raped a nine-year-old student at the İmam Buhari residential boys' Quran course in Ağrı, was sentenced to a total of 35 years 5 months: 30 years for sexual abuse, 5 years for unlawful confinement, and 5 months for assault."
},
{
"link": "https://haber.sol.org.tr/haber/iste-turkiyenin-kuran-kursu-gercegi-istismar-dayak-olum-313770",
"archive": "",
"citation": "soL Haber, 'İşte Türkiye'nin Kuran kursu gerçeği: İstismar, dayak, ölüm...'. Available at: haber.sol.org.tr (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Contextual reporting situating the Ağrı case within a pattern of documented abuse, beatings, and deaths at residential Quran courses across Turkey; the victim stated he stayed silent out of fear after Kaya threatened him."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Kaya held direct pedagogical and custodial authority over a live-in child student as his Quran-course instructor, using that position and threats to abuse and confine the boy within the residential course.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/gundem/kurstaki-cinsel-istismara-35-yil-41207935",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "26e4a0c5a87787f1bbc4c0ce5aedbb552c83d00a8829f4b4222ab2ef5030bd05",
"final_url": "https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/gundem/kurstaki-cinsel-istismara-35-yil-41207935"
},
{
"source": "https://haber.sol.org.tr/haber/iste-turkiyenin-kuran-kursu-gercegi-istismar-dayak-olum-313770",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "804f5575298f74135b17d7ef28079af38eea44401d9acfe62f9a1f39026aa616",
"final_url": "https://haber.sol.org.tr/haber/iste-turkiyenin-kuran-kursu-gercegi-istismar-dayak-olum-313770"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1001,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim; N1 authority runs through Kaya's official religious office over the Quran-course structure the victim worked within, and the marriage-promise pretext is itself a religious mechanism, not general seduction — retained under 'religious marriage or family control' and 'pastoral or clerical authority' pretexts. Flag if the operative-means test is judged closer to blackmail than to spiritual authority on further review.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-ismail-kaya-mufti-diyarbakir-turkey",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Hazro, Diyarbakır, Turkey",
"lat": 38.4633,
"lng": 40.7092,
"title": "Turkey: district mufti convicted after using marriage promises and blackmail to sexually abuse a Quran-course supervisor",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"district mufti (state religious official)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority",
"promise of religious marriage",
"sexual blackmail with photographs"
],
"organizations": [
"Diyanet İşleri Başkanlığı (Directorate of Religious Affairs)",
"Hazro District Mufti's Office"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Diyarbakır Heavy Penal Court (criminal)",
"stage": "verdict",
"date": null,
"outcome": "Former Hazro district mufti İsmail Kaya sentenced to 26 years 2 months 15 days for deceiving a Quran-recitation course supervisor with marriage promises, sexually assaulting her, then coercing further abuse by threatening to circulate nude photographs of her."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Court of Appeal / Court of Cassation (Yargıtay)",
"stage": "appeal — upheld",
"date": null,
"outcome": "Conviction and sentence upheld unanimously through appeal and by the Court of Cassation, which found the evidence (nude photographs, WhatsApp messages) lawfully obtained and the lower courts' findings free of error."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sozcu.com.tr/evli-muftuye-evlilik-vaadiyle-cinsel-istismardan-26-yil-hapis-wp7873897",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sözcü, 'Evli müftüye, evlilik vaadiyle cinsel istismardan 26 yıl hapis'. Available at: sozcu.com.tr (Accessed: 19 July 2026).",
"body": "Turkish original: \"Diyarbakır'ın Hazro ilçesinde... evlilik vaadiyle bir kadını cinsel istismar ettiği, ardından çıplak fotoğraflarla şantaj yaparak zorla alıkoyup istismarını sürdürdüğü belirlenen eski müftü İsmail Kaya'ya 26 yıl 2 ay 15 gün hapis cezası verildi. Yargıtay, kararı oybirliğiyle onadı.\" English gloss: Former mufti İsmail Kaya, found to have sexually abused a woman under promise of marriage in Hazro district, Diyarbakır, then blackmailed her with nude photographs to forcibly detain and continue abusing her, was sentenced to 26 years 2 months 15 days. The Court of Cassation upheld the verdict unanimously."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As a state-appointed district mufti overseeing a girls' Quran-recitation course, Kaya used his religious office and the credibility of a promised religious marriage to initiate the relationship, then sexual blackmail to compel continued abuse of the woman who supervised the course under his religious authority.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sozcu.com.tr/evli-muftuye-evlilik-vaadiyle-cinsel-istismardan-26-yil-hapis-wp7873897",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5a5ce371801aeb3d5334e87627c93eb0f5b1a3d743723c640ac103e2cbe73a37",
"final_url": "https://www.sozcu.com.tr/evli-muftuye-evlilik-vaadiyle-cinsel-istismardan-26-yil-hapis-wp7873897"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1002,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Gbinyiam's standing as a Living Faith Church Worldwide (Winners Chapel) pastor is what put a 12-year-old member's daughter alone in his vicarage at night: she was a regular visitor sent to help the pastor's wife with chores and his children with schoolwork, a pastoral-household errand her family trusted without question. He used that trusted access to sedate and rape her. Convicted after a full trial on the prosecution's evidence; no appeal located. This is the network the DISCOVERY brief specifically asked for: a convicted pastor within Bishop David Oyedepo's Winners Chapel/Living Faith Church Worldwide network, not the founder.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-enoch-gbinyiam-winners-chapel-ekiti-nigeria",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Omuo-Ekiti, Ekiti State, Nigeria",
"lat": 7.6236,
"lng": 5.2213,
"title": "Nigeria: Winners Chapel (Living Faith Church Worldwide) pastor convicted of raping a 12-year-old congregant at his vicarage",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Winners Chapel (Living Faith Church Worldwide), Omuo-Ekiti parish"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"trusted access to a minor congregant via routine pastoral-household visits",
"covert sedation of the victim (drugged soft drink) to prevent resistance or disclosure"
],
"organizations": [
"Winners Chapel (Living Faith Church Worldwide)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ekiti State High Court, Ado-Ekiti (Hon. Justice O.I.O. Ogunyemi)",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2024-06-13",
"outcome": "Enoch Gbinyiam, a Winners Chapel (Living Faith Church Worldwide) pastor at Omuo-Ekiti, was convicted after a full trial of raping the 12-year-old daughter of a church member, contrary to section 2 of Ekiti State's Gender-Based Violence (Prohibition) Law, 2019. The prosecution called four witnesses and tendered two exhibits; Gbinyiam pleaded not guilty. Justice Ogunyemi held the charge proved beyond reasonable doubt and sentenced him to life imprisonment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.legit.ng/nigeria/1597320-sedated-a-drink-pastor-bags-life-imprisonment-defiling-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Legit.ng, 'Court sentences pastor to life imprisonment for defiling minor in Ekiti' (13 Jun. 2024).",
"body": "Reports the Ado-Ekiti High Court conviction and life sentence of Winners Chapel pastor Enoch Gbinyiam for raping the 12-year-old daughter of a church member, who regularly visited his vicarage to help his wife with chores and his children with schoolwork; states he sedated her with a drugged bottle of Fanta before the assault, and cites the charge under the Gender-Based Violence (Prohibition) Law, 2019.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ghanamma.com/2024/06/14/ekiti-court-sentences-winners-pastor-to-life-imprisonment-for-defiling-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ghanamma News, 'Ekiti Court Sentences Winners Pastor To Life Imprisonment For Defiling Minor' (14 Jun. 2024).",
"body": "Confirms Enoch Gbinyiam of Winners Chapel Church, Omuo-Ekiti, was sentenced to life imprisonment by Hon. Justice O.I.O. Ogunyemi at the Ado-Ekiti High Court on 13/14 June 2024, names the presiding judge, states the prosecution's four witnesses and two exhibits, and confirms the not-guilty plea and conviction after trial.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's family sent her, unsupervised, into the pastor's private vicarage precisely because he was their church's pastor — a role that generated the household-helper errand and the trust that made a 12-year-old's solitary night visits unremarkable. That standing, not any independent relationship, created the opportunity his sedation and assault exploited.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.legit.ng/nigeria/1597320-sedated-a-drink-pastor-bags-life-imprisonment-defiling-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1c2c598980d39bd3928e1a138b373470ccbc784699f35d958282e58a74e3a317",
"final_url": "https://www.legit.ng/nigeria/1597320-sedated-a-drink-pastor-bags-life-imprisonment-defiling-minor/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ghanamma.com/2024/06/14/ekiti-court-sentences-winners-pastor-to-life-imprisonment-for-defiling-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d18d6baf669f72bb80bc67c38c6821c3af3d30b1b64829a439ab7c2ca9bb7df2",
"final_url": "https://www.ghanamma.com/2024/06/14/ekiti-court-sentences-winners-pastor-to-life-imprisonment-for-defiling-minor/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1003,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Prakash used his standing as a visiting Pentecostal pastor and a false demonic-possession diagnosis to isolate and repeatedly rape a 13-year-old at a Christian convention and afterward. Convicted after trial on POCSO charges (India's child-sexual-offences statute) with a fine and life sentence; no appeal or reversal located. Prosperity/possession-cure claims like this one are exactly the deliverance-and-healing indicator family the DISCOVERY brief asked to find within South Asian Pentecostal networks.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-jose-prakash-exorcism-kerala-india",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Perinthalmanna, Malappuram, Kerala, India",
"lat": 11.1592,
"lng": 76.2286,
"title": "India: Pentecostal pastor convicted of raping a 13-year-old girl after convincing her family she was possessed by evil spirits",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Pentecostal pastor, itinerant deliverance ministry"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"false diagnosis of demonic possession used to obtain the family's consent for private 'special prayers'",
"exorcism/deliverance ritual used as pretext to isolate the minor victim"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Manjeri fast-track POCSO Special Court, Kerala",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2022-08-29",
"outcome": "Pastor Jose Prakash, 51, of Balaramapuram near Thiruvananthapuram, was convicted under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act for the rape of a 13-year-old girl at Perinthalmanna, Malappuram, on 17-18 February 2016. The court found he had convinced the girl's parents at a Christian convention that she was possessed by evil spirits and could be exorcised only through his private 'special prayers,' then assaulted her when invited to their home to conduct them. He was sentenced to life imprisonment and fined."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://hindupost.in/news/christian-pastor-sentenced-to-life-for-raping-a-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "HinduPost, 'Christian Pastor sentenced to life for raping a minor' (2022).",
"body": "Reports the Manjeri fast-track POCSO court's conviction and life sentence of Pastor Jose Prakash on 29 August 2022 for raping a 13-year-old girl in Perinthalmanna, Malappuram, after he told her parents at a Christian convention that she was possessed by demonic spirits and needed his 'special prayers'; states the assault occurred on 17-18 February 2016 and disclosure followed after her mother found her leaving his room at night.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://organiser.org/2026/07/12/369407/bharat/predatory-evangelical-networks-exposed-23-cases-of-child-abuse-and-exploitation-in-kerala-between-2014-and-2026/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Organiser, 'Predatory Evangelical Network in Kerala: 23 cases in 10 years' (12 Jul. 2026).",
"body": "Independently confirms the Manjeri fast-track POCSO court sentenced Pentecostal pastor Jose Prakash to life imprisonment plus a Rs 2,50,000 fine on 29 August 2022 for raping a 13-year-old after falsely diagnosing her as possessed by evil spirits, within a wider survey of Kerala clergy-abuse convictions.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "roundup-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Prakash's authority rested entirely on his claimed power to diagnose and cure spirit possession. That claim is what persuaded the family to trust him alone with their daughter, and the promised 'special prayers' are the exact pretext under which he assaulted her — the deliverance ritual was the operative means of the harm, not incidental to it.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://hindupost.in/news/christian-pastor-sentenced-to-life-for-raping-a-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3ace807c1c5a4e5a5e309e99903cb8979898e994777e2d9af4f5907a2880017",
"final_url": "https://hindupost.in/news/christian-pastor-sentenced-to-life-for-raping-a-minor/"
},
{
"source": "https://organiser.org/2026/07/12/369407/bharat/predatory-evangelical-networks-exposed-23-cases-of-child-abuse-and-exploitation-in-kerala-between-2014-and-2026/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: roundup-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "245980742b8eb23d2b39d2875f8fbd4d6c80644362b1d90f0c7eb9a84b625ba4",
"final_url": "https://organiser.org/2026/07/12/369407/bharat/predatory-evangelical-networks-exposed-23-cases-of-child-abuse-and-exploitation-in-kerala-between-2014-and-2026/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1004,
"aliases": [
"Pastor Marcos"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), 1st Panel",
"stage": "habeas corpus review",
"date": "2018-02-27",
"outcome": "The STF's First Panel voted 2-1 to overturn a lower injunction that had kept Pereira da Silva free, restoring his imprisonment on the 2013 rape conviction. Justice Alexandre de Moraes's opinion held that, beyond physical violence, the pastor exercised psychological violence by using his spiritual leadership to frighten the victim into believing she was demon-possessed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Pereira founded the Assembleia de Deus dos Últimos Dias and used that pastoral standing to isolate and rape a congregant on church premises; the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court's own 2018 opinion, denying his habeas corpus, expressly finds that he used his spiritual leadership to make the victim believe she was possessed by a demon — the coercion mechanism the criterion is built to capture, stated by the country's highest court. Conviction restored to effect by that ruling; no subsequent reversal located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-marcos-pereira-da-silva-assembleia-deus-ultimos-dias-rio-de-janeiro-brazil",
"year": 2013,
"place": "São João de Meriti, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil",
"lat": -22.8028,
"lng": -43.3728,
"title": "Brazil: Assembleia de Deus dos Últimos Dias founding pastor convicted of raping a congregant; Supreme Federal Court cites his spiritual authority as the coercion",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founding pastor, Assembleia de Deus dos Últimos Dias (ADUD)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral access to a congregant on church premises",
"psychological coercion via claimed spiritual authority, made the victim believe she was demon-possessed (STF finding)"
],
"organizations": [
"Assembleia de Deus dos Últimos Dias (ADUD)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "2nd Criminal Court of São João de Meriti, Rio de Janeiro",
"stage": "trial and sentencing",
"date": "2013-09-01",
"outcome": "Marcos Pereira da Silva, founder of the Assembleia de Deus dos Últimos Dias, was convicted of raping a congregant of his church on the church premises in late 2006 and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment in closed regime. He was investigated for abuse of at least six followers; the single count tried resulted in conviction."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), 1st Panel",
"stage": "habeas corpus denied; conviction's custodial effect restored",
"date": "2018-02-27",
"outcome": "Having been free since a December 2014 habeas corpus injunction, Pereira da Silva had that injunction overturned by the STF's First Panel (2-1) applying Súmula 608 (rape by actual violence is publicly, unconditionally actionable). Justice Alexandre de Moraes's opinion found the pastor exercised psychological violence by using his spiritual leadership to make the victim believe she was possessed by a demon, in addition to physical violence."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gazetadopovo.com.br/vida-e-cidadania/pastor-marcos-e-condenado-a-15-anos-de-prisao-por-estupro-de-fiel-buvgrnzvqnjwhuyjcl8jqynv2/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Gazeta do Povo, 'Pastor Marcos é condenado a 15 anos de prisão por estupro de fiel' (2013).",
"body": "Reports the 2nd Criminal Court of São João de Meriti's conviction and 15-year closed-regime sentence of Assembleia de Deus dos Últimos Dias founder Marcos Pereira da Silva for the 2006 rape of a follower on church premises, and that witnesses described him as manipulative and cold, using people's good faith to deceive them.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://noticias.stf.jus.br/postsnoticias/1a-turma-nega-hc-a-pastor-condenado-por-atentado-violento-ao-pudor-praticado-com-violencia-real/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Supremo Tribunal Federal, 'STF nega HC a pastor condenado por estupro' notícias.STF.jus.br (27 Feb. 2018), and Notícias Gospel, 'Supremo cassa liminar e pastor Marcos Pereira será preso novamente no caso de estupro' (2018).",
"body": "Official STF press item and independent press confirmation that the First Panel voted 2-1 on 27 February 2018 to overturn the habeas corpus injunction that had freed Pereira da Silva, restoring the custodial effect of his rape conviction; Justice Alexandre de Moraes's opinion is quoted holding that beyond physical violence, the pastor used his spiritual leadership to frighten the victim and make her believe she was possessed by a demon, applying STF Súmula 608 on unconditional public criminal action for rape by actual violence.",
"tier": "high-court-record",
"kind": "appellate-opinion-summary"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Brazil's Supreme Federal Court itself found the operative coercion: Pereira da Silva, as founding pastor, used his spiritual leadership to convince the victim she was possessed by a demon, and it was that belief, not merely physical force, that the Court held made the crime unrefusable. This is a rare instance of a national high court naming the spiritual-authority mechanism directly in its own opinion.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), 1st Panel",
"stage": "habeas corpus review",
"date": "2018-02-27",
"outcome": "The STF's First Panel voted 2-1 to overturn a lower injunction that had kept Pereira da Silva free, restoring his imprisonment on the 2013 rape conviction. Justice Alexandre de Moraes's opinion held that, beyond physical violence, the pastor exercised psychological violence by using his spiritual leadership to frighten the victim into believing she was demon-possessed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gazetadopovo.com.br/vida-e-cidadania/pastor-marcos-e-condenado-a-15-anos-de-prisao-por-estupro-de-fiel-buvgrnzvqnjwhuyjcl8jqynv2/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a88024f779e5498b83e92793b9a216c8119f709d44f5bd1461c3724643061886",
"final_url": "https://www.gazetadopovo.com.br/vida-e-cidadania/pastor-marcos-e-condenado-a-15-anos-de-prisao-por-estupro-de-fiel-buvgrnzvqnjwhuyjcl8jqynv2/"
},
{
"source": "https://noticias.stf.jus.br/postsnoticias/1a-turma-nega-hc-a-pastor-condenado-por-atentado-violento-ao-pudor-praticado-com-violencia-real/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: high-court-record; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3c167b9fc8f1874d0c2048abec8f36c536c6c70c5a89de318f67416921da0a3b",
"final_url": "https://noticias.stf.jus.br/postsnoticias/1a-turma-nega-hc-a-pastor-condenado-por-atentado-violento-ao-pudor-praticado-com-violencia-real/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1005,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Independent statutory-inquiry finding into the Church of England's handling of allegations against John Smyth, distinct from any criminal conviction — Smyth was never charged; he died in 2018 while under police investigation. The finding concerns institutional cover-up, not an adjudicated verdict against Smyth himself.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-makin-review-smyth-iwerne-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Winchester and Iwerne Minster, Dorset, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 50.8798,
"lng": -2.1119,
"title": "Makin Review: independent inquiry finds Church of England cover-up of John Smyth's Iwerne camp abuse; Archbishop of Canterbury resigns",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Iwerne camp leader and lay evangelical authority over camp attendees"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"spiritual mentorship and scriptural authority over boys and young men at Christian camps",
"institutional cover-up by camp leadership and senior clergy who received a 1982 report and suppressed it"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Iwerne Trust",
"Church of England"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent review commissioned by the Church of England (Keith Makin)",
"stage": "published independent statutory-style inquiry finding",
"date": "2024-11-07",
"outcome": "The Makin Review found that John Smyth subjected as many as 130 boys and young men in the UK, Zimbabwe and South Africa to sadistic physical, sexual, psychological and spiritual abuse over five decades, and that recipients of a 1982 internal report into the abuse — including senior clergy — participated in an active cover-up that prevented the report from reaching the police or becoming public. Smyth died in 2018 without ever being charged. Publication of the review's findings led directly to the resignation of the Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, on 12 November 2024, over his handling of the 2013 disclosure."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Smyth held direct pastoral and disciplinary authority as an adult lay leader over teenage boys and young men recruited through the Iwerne camps' evangelical Christian ministry to England's top boarding schools; beatings were framed to victims in explicitly spiritual and scriptural terms as chastisement for sin, and camp/church authority structures suppressed disclosure for over three decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.churchofengland.org/media/press-releases/makin-review-published",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'The Makin Review', Church of England, published 7 November 2024.",
"body": "The published independent review into the Church of England's response to allegations against John Smyth.",
"tier": "official-report",
"kind": "commission-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Makin_Review",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Makin Review', Wikipedia, accessed 2026-07-19.",
"body": "Summary of the review's findings, publication history and the resulting resignation of Archbishop Justin Welby.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "reference"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.churchofengland.org/media/press-releases/makin-review-published",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-report; evidentiary role: commission-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"final_url": "https://www.churchofengland.org/search-results?keys=media%20press%20releases%20makin%20review%20published"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Makin_Review",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: reference.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ffe77a4db353834d05177a321fd10c4276d16ccfab665149dbcafce41965c63e",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Makin_Review"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1006,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Independent commissioned review of institutional handling, not a single criminal proceeding; approximately one quarter of the 1,885 identified cases named a minister or lay church employee as perpetrator or alleged perpetrator, with the remainder involving abuse by family members or others reported to the church. This record covers the church-perpetrator subset of the finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-methodist-past-cases-review-uk",
"year": 2015,
"place": "United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.3555,
"lng": -1.1743,
"title": "Methodist Church in Britain's Past Cases Review finds 1,885 abuse cases 1950-2014, roughly a quarter naming ministers or church employees",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Methodist ministers and lay church employees in pastoral and youth-work roles"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and youth-ministry authority over congregants and children",
"institutional processes that referred only 61 of 1,885 cases to police at the time"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"The Methodist Church in Britain"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent review commissioned by the Methodist Conference",
"stage": "published independent past-cases review",
"date": "2015-05-01",
"outcome": "The Past Cases Review identified 1,885 cases of sexual, physical, emotional and domestic abuse and neglect connected to the Methodist Church between 1950 and 2014. In approximately one quarter of these, a minister or lay church employee was identified as perpetrator or alleged perpetrator. Only 61 cases had involved police contact at the time, with 6 investigations still open as of publication. The Methodist Conference issued a full and unreserved apology and established an implementation group for the report's 23 recommendations."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The review's church-perpetrator subset concerns ministers and employees who held pastoral or youth-ministry authority over the congregants and children in their care; the finding is that fewer than a tenth of the 1,885 identified cases had ever reached police, and no comparable published national review of Methodist safeguarding existed before it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.methodist.org.uk/safeguarding/courage-cost-and-hope-past-cases-review/news-article-and-past-cases-review-report/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Past Cases Review Report', The Methodist Church in Britain, 2015.",
"body": "The Methodist Church's own publication of the Past Cases Review report and its findings.",
"tier": "official-report",
"kind": "commission-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.methodist.org.uk/about/news/church-issues-full-and-unreserved-apology-to-abuse-survivors/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Church issues full and unreserved apology to abuse survivors', The Methodist Church, 2015.",
"body": "The Methodist Conference's apology accompanying the review's publication.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "press-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.methodist.org.uk/safeguarding/courage-cost-and-hope-past-cases-review/news-article-and-past-cases-review-report/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-report; evidentiary role: commission-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "23dbd9f223ff7a98f512ae289bdcf733cbad7db127065af33645be48ada7a2e1",
"final_url": "https://www.methodist.org.uk/safeguarding/courage-cost-and-hope-past-cases-review/news-article-and-past-cases-review-report/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.methodist.org.uk/about/news/church-issues-full-and-unreserved-apology-to-abuse-survivors/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: press-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9d0ab3b6c64db48051d4419e3ec8ece19b1584ec00480161a96c38056f5951eb",
"final_url": "https://www.methodist.org.uk/about/news/church-issues-full-and-unreserved-apology-to-abuse-survivors/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1007,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Independent investigation commissioned and published by the SBC itself, distinct from the corpus's existing Johnny Hunt record (which documents one individual finding within this same investigation). This record covers the systemic finding: a decade-plus secret internal database of 700+ accused-abuser reports that Executive Committee leadership deliberately withheld from SBC churches to avoid liability.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-guidepost-sbc-secret-list-georgia-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Nashville, Tennessee, USA",
"lat": 36.1627,
"lng": -86.7816,
"title": "Guidepost Solutions finds SBC Executive Committee kept a secret decade-long list of 700+ accused ministers while stonewalling abuse survivors",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Southern Baptist Convention Executive Committee leadership and affiliated pastors named in the database"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"denominational and pastoral authority used by named abusers over congregants",
"institutional non-disclosure — a private list of over 700 accused ministers withheld from member churches for over a decade to limit SBC liability"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Southern Baptist Convention",
"SBC Executive Committee"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Guidepost Solutions independent investigation commissioned by the SBC Executive Committee",
"stage": "published independent investigative report",
"date": "2022-05-22",
"outcome": "Guidepost Solutions' 288-page report found that for over two decades, a small group of senior SBC Executive Committee leaders and outside counsel controlled the response to abuse reports and were 'singularly focused on avoiding liability for the SBC', meeting survivors with resistance and hostility. EC general counsel D. August Boto and spokesman Roger Oldham had maintained a private internal database of more than 700 pastors, ministers, and other church-affiliated personnel accused of sexual abuse, collected over more than a decade, without using it to protect churches or the public. The list was made public on 2022-05-26. The report prompted a subsequent U.S. Department of Justice investigation into SBC entities."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The finding concerns denominational leadership that held institutional authority over thousands of affiliated churches and used that authority to suppress, rather than act on, a decade of internal abuse reports naming specific pastors who themselves held pastoral authority over their own congregants; distinct from the Johnny Hunt record already in this corpus, which documents one individual finding produced by the same investigation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.npr.org/2022/05/22/1100616952/southern-baptists-sex-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Top Southern Baptists stonewalled and denigrated sex abuse victims, report says', NPR, 22 May 2022.",
"body": "NPR's report on the Guidepost investigation's findings on Executive Committee conduct.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.npr.org/2022/05/27/1101734793/southern-baptist-sexual-abuse-list-released",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Southern Baptist leaders release a previously secret list of accused sexual abusers', NPR, 27 May 2022.",
"body": "Reporting on the public release of the 700+ name database following the Guidepost report.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.npr.org/2022/05/22/1100616952/southern-baptists-sex-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.npr.org/2022/05/27/1101734793/southern-baptist-sexual-abuse-list-released",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1008,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal conviction of an Episcopal priest serving as a boarding-school chaplain. Chaplaincy is a specifically clerical office (not merely educational/custodial authority), and the victims were students under his pastoral as well as institutional care, so this is treated as pastoral-clerical authority rather than the educational-authority trap.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-kenneth-behrel-episcopal-chaplain-maryland-usa",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Hagerstown, Maryland, USA",
"lat": 39.6418,
"lng": -77.72,
"title": "United States: Episcopal school chaplain Kenneth Behrel convicted of abusing two students, second sentence after appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Episcopal priest and school chaplain, St James School"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"chaplaincy authority over boarding-school students",
"access and isolation obtained through pastoral counseling role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St James School, Maryland",
"Episcopal Diocese of Maryland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court for Washington County, Maryland",
"stage": "conviction; appeal; second trial and sentence",
"date": "2004-11-01",
"outcome": "Behrel, chaplain of the Episcopal St James School from 1983 to 1986, was convicted by a jury in 2002 of sexually abusing a 14-year-old student and sentenced to 12 years; that conviction was affirmed on the merits of guilt but the sentence proceedings were revisited. A second victim's case, involving abuse in the 1980s, resulted in an Alford plea and a four-year sentence imposed in November 2004, to run consecutive to the earlier 12-year term."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As ordained chaplain, Behrel held pastoral authority over students who came to him for religious counsel in a residential Episcopal school setting, using that specifically clerical access — distinct from a lay teacher or headmaster's authority — to isolate and abuse them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mdcourts.gov/data/opinions/cosa/2003/750s02.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Behrel v. State, Nos. 750, 751, Sept. Term 2002, Court of Special Appeals of Maryland.",
"body": "Appellate opinion addressing Behrel's conviction for sexual abuse of a student at St James School.",
"tier": "court-record",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://thedailyrecord.com/2004/11/23/former-priest-gets-4-years-for-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former priest gets 4 years for sex abuse', Maryland Daily Record, 23 November 2004.",
"body": "Report on the second sentencing, consecutive to the earlier 12-year term.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mdcourts.gov/data/opinions/cosa/2003/750s02.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-record; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2bc1b7c56e6ba8e316ed07b16d7635cf4c6393114600f9eef460a2e8ac8746e5",
"final_url": "https://www.mdcourts.gov/data/opinions/cosa/2003/750s02.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://thedailyrecord.com/2004/11/23/former-priest-gets-4-years-for-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "499b40fc0db7f8e1aea01f75c2b881483372b64cb4d4b809c77a1aa34ab1f4f6",
"final_url": "https://thedailyrecord.com/2004/11/23/former-priest-gets-4-years-for-sex-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1009,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Guilty plea and conviction; priest was deposed from the priesthood following disclosure. Bishops' delay in reporting to police is documented but is institutional-failure context, not a separate proceeding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1991-richard-kearney-episcopal-illinois-usa",
"year": 1991,
"place": "Waukegan and Oregon, Illinois, USA",
"lat": 42.3636,
"lng": -87.8448,
"title": "United States: Episcopal priest Richard Kearney convicted of abusing teenage boys in his parishes",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Episcopal priest, Diocese of Chicago"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over teenage parishioners",
"institutional delay by diocesan bishops after disclosure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Episcopal Diocese of Chicago"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Illinois state court",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "1991-03-01",
"outcome": "Kearney pleaded guilty to four counts of aggravated criminal sexual abuse of teenage boys in his parishes in the mid-1980s and was sentenced to four years' imprisonment, of which he served approximately 18 months. He was deposed from the priesthood in March 1991. A subsequent civil suit against the diocese, alleging bishops delayed reporting an earlier disclosure to police, was settled for $750,000 in 2022."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Kearney used his position as parish priest to access and groom teenage boys in his own congregations; a college-age victim's 1980s disclosure to his bishop was followed by delay in police notification rather than immediate report, during which at least one further boy was abused.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://chicago.suntimes.com/2022/6/3/23147117/clergy-sex-abuse-episcopal-church-chilton-knudsen-frank-griswold-richard-kearney-waukegan-chicago",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Chicago Episcopal diocese's $750,000 sex abuse case involving Richard Kearney puts Bishop Chilton Knudsen's actions under scrutiny', Chicago Sun-Times, 3 June 2022.",
"body": "Report detailing Kearney's 1991 conviction, sentence, and the diocese's later civil settlement over its handling of an earlier disclosure.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://episcopalchicago.org/revisiting-diocesan-files-on-clergy-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Revisiting Diocesan Files on Clergy Sexual Abuse', Episcopal Diocese of Chicago.",
"body": "The diocese's own account of Kearney's conviction and deposition from the priesthood.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "institutional-statement"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://chicago.suntimes.com/2022/6/3/23147117/clergy-sex-abuse-episcopal-church-chilton-knudsen-frank-griswold-richard-kearney-waukegan-chicago",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1408c7a8014fdd6e6155bd897069e9197c4e0bfde5c653784e45932cabd4a0dd",
"final_url": "https://chicago.suntimes.com/2022/6/3/23147117/clergy-sex-abuse-episcopal-church-chilton-knudsen-frank-griswold-richard-kearney-waukegan-chicago"
},
{
"source": "https://episcopalchicago.org/revisiting-diocesan-files-on-clergy-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: institutional-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0a846d0db18f161265bdaa56d167df80743003ab836d57eb4583c42d7eef3593",
"final_url": "https://episcopalchicago.org/revisiting-diocesan-files-on-clergy-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1010,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "APPELLATE STATUS NOT YET SETTLED. The jury returned guilty verdicts in 2026 but sentencing had not occurred as of the sourcing, so no appeal window has opened and no appellate court has reviewed the conviction. The corpus normally requires a conviction to have stood; this record is entered on the jury verdict and should be re-checked once sentencing and any appeal conclude.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jonathan-kirkpatrick-anglican-dean-new-zealand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Dunedin and Canterbury, New Zealand",
"lat": -45.8788,
"lng": 170.5028,
"title": "New Zealand: former Dunedin Anglican Dean Jonathan Kirkpatrick convicted of sexually violating a teenager decades earlier",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Dean, St Paul's Cathedral, Dunedin; Anglican priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority and mentorship over a teenage parishioner",
"intoxication of the victim before the assault"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Anglican Diocese of Dunedin"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New Zealand court",
"stage": "jury trial and guilty verdict; sentencing pending",
"date": "2026-03-20",
"outcome": "A jury found Kirkpatrick, the former Dean of St Paul's Cathedral, Dunedin, guilty of sexually violating a teenage boy in the early 1990s at his cottage on Lake Coleridge, after the victim was plied with cannabis and alcohol. The offence carries a maximum ten-year sentence; sentencing had not yet occurred as of the most recent available reporting. Kirkpatrick had a prior unrelated 2011 fraud conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Kirkpatrick was the boy's parish priest and later Dean, a figure of clerical authority the teenager and his family trusted; the victim did not report the assault until 2020, decades after it occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/regions_canterbury/590718/former-anglican-priest-jonathan-kirkpatrick-sexually-violated-teen-at-canterbury-bach",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former Anglican priest Jonathan Kirkpatrick sexually violated teen at Canterbury bach', RNZ, 20 March 2026.",
"body": "Report on the jury's guilty verdict and the facts of the offence.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.odt.co.nz/news/dunedin/former-dunedin-anglican-dean-sexually-violated-teen-rnz",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former Dunedin Anglican dean sexually violated teen', Otago Daily Times, 20 March 2026.",
"body": "Local reporting confirming Kirkpatrick's former role as Dean of St Paul's Cathedral, Dunedin.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/regions_canterbury/590718/former-anglican-priest-jonathan-kirkpatrick-sexually-violated-teen-at-canterbury-bach",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6c4a8287d1b39692ae59eaf154d87a97f44f10d6ecf398ac898b9528ab1c659f",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/regions_canterbury/590718/former-anglican-priest-jonathan-kirkpatrick-sexually-violated-teen-at-canterbury-bach"
},
{
"source": "https://www.odt.co.nz/news/dunedin/former-dunedin-anglican-dean-sexually-violated-teen-rnz",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "284122e77086a211c9bde7af52992ae6a4bae8668fb0aafb3889619eff9bcec2",
"final_url": "https://www.odt.co.nz/news/dunedin/former-dunedin-anglican-dean-sexually-violated-teen-rnz"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1011,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal conviction, first-instance sentence; no appeal outcome located. Defendant stated intent to appeal at sentencing — flagged, not confirmed to have been filed or decided.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-gordon-muhwezi-anglican-priest-uganda",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Mitooma District, Uganda",
"lat": -0.6167,
"lng": 30.05,
"title": "Uganda: Church of Uganda (Anglican) priest Gordon Muhwezi sentenced to 28 years for defilement",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Church of Uganda (Anglican) priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority within his parish"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of Uganda"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Uganda",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-12-09",
"outcome": "Justice Joyce Kavuma found Rev Gordon Muhwezi, a 46-year-old Church of Uganda priest from Mitooma District, guilty of defiling a girl in May 2021, and sentenced him to 28 years' imprisonment, describing the term as 'very appropriate.' Muhwezi said he would appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Muhwezi held parish clerical authority in his Mitooma District community; reporting does not further specify the victim's relationship to the parish beyond the offence occurring in his home area.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/anglican-priest-sentenced-to-28-years-in-jail-for-defilement-4049214",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Anglican priest sentenced to 28 years in jail for defilement', Daily Monitor (Uganda), 9 December 2022.",
"body": "Report of Justice Kavuma's verdict and sentence against Rev Gordon Muhwezi.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/anglican-priest-sentenced-to-28-years-in-jail-for-defilement-4049214",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f8d396bc291891a78f8dd3b04018fb4db09acdfb06955430cad88c9bf7a88bdb",
"final_url": "https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/anglican-priest-sentenced-to-28-years-in-jail-for-defilement-4049214"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1012,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal conviction, sentence served; no appeal record located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2002-allan-kitchingham-anglican-priest-newcastle-australia",
"year": 2002,
"place": "Lismore and Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia",
"lat": -28.8135,
"lng": 153.2807,
"title": "Australia: Anglican priest Allan Kitchingham convicted of indecent assault on a boy at North Coast Children's Home",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Anglican priest, Diocese of Grafton/Newcastle"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority within a church-run children's home"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Anglican Diocese of Grafton",
"North Coast Children's Home, Lismore"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Newcastle District Court, New South Wales",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2002-01-01",
"outcome": "Kitchingham pleaded guilty in Newcastle District Court to five counts of indecent assault against a 13-year-old boy in 1975 at the North Coast Children's Home, Lismore, and was sentenced to two years and nine months' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Kitchingham held clerical authority within a residential children's home run under Anglican diocesan auspices, giving him custodial-cum-pastoral access to a resident child.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://www.clergyabuseaustralia.net/perpsad.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Clergy Sexual Abuse in Australia — perpetrator index (Sa-)', clergyabuseaustralia.net.",
"body": "Compiled record of Kitchingham's guilty plea, offence and sentence in Newcastle District Court.",
"tier": "advocacy-compiled",
"kind": "database-entry"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://www.clergyabuseaustralia.net/perpsad.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-compiled; evidentiary role: database-entry.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b31d2c4ff5c6934760914ca00ddcd3ecf503e51a54f8c3ddd178cb62ff778af9",
"final_url": "http://www.clergyabuseaustralia.net/perpsad.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1013,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal conviction, sentence served; institution is a denominational academy, and the teacher held instructional (not ordained clerical) authority. Included under the Adventist lane per the brief's explicit direction to cover Adventist-school staff; flagged that the coercion mechanism is educational rather than pastoral authority, though the academy is confessionally Adventist and part of the denomination's institutional structure.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-brett-mohr-adventist-academy-california-usa",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Glendale, California, USA",
"lat": 34.1425,
"lng": -118.2551,
"title": "United States: Glendale Adventist Academy teacher Brett Mohr convicted of continuous sexual abuse of a student, 30-year sentence",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-adventist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Teacher, Glendale Adventist Academy"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"instructional authority within a denominational school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Glendale Adventist Academy",
"Seventh-day Adventist Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "California state court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2021-12-01",
"outcome": "Mohr, a teacher at Glendale Adventist Academy, was convicted in December 2021 of lewd and lascivious conduct and continuous sexual abuse of a child, and was sentenced to 30 years in state prison."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Mohr's authority was instructional rather than ordained-clerical, which is why this record is carried as context class rather than core: the academy is a Seventh-day Adventist denominational school, but the coercion mechanism reported is teacher-student trust, not a pastoral or spiritual-consequence claim.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://atoday.org/glendale-adventist-academy-teacher-convicted-of-sexual-misconduct-with-a-student/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Glendale Adventist Academy Teacher Convicted of Sexual Misconduct with a Student', Adventist Today.",
"body": "Report on Brett Mohr's conviction and 30-year sentence.",
"tier": "advocacy-compiled",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://atoday.org/glendale-adventist-academy-teacher-convicted-of-sexual-misconduct-with-a-student/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-compiled; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "91fcd8ca53d4f30eef3326d7ba5efe0ca6dc72d2eb85750b04b19545c1b144ed",
"final_url": "https://atoday.org/glendale-adventist-academy-teacher-convicted-of-sexual-misconduct-with-a-student/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1014,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal conviction with a specifically pastoral, not merely institutional, mechanism — the perpetrator was an ordained Adventist pastor. Sentencing detail (24 counts) taken from the single located source; no appellate record found.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-adventist-pastor-tomar-portugal",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Tomar, Santarém, Portugal",
"lat": 39.6017,
"lng": -8.4152,
"title": "Portugal: former Adventist pastor convicted on 24 counts of sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-adventist",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Seventh-day Adventist pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over congregants"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Seventh-day Adventist Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Portuguese court",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2019-01-01",
"outcome": "A former Seventh-day Adventist pastor in Tomar, Santarém, was convicted on 24 counts of sexual abuse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The pastor held ordained clerical authority in the Adventist congregation at Tomar; details of victim relationship beyond congregant status are not further specified in the source located.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cross-referenced summary entry, 'Portugal: former Adventist pastor convicted on 24 counts', 2019.",
"body": "Brief record of the Tomar Adventist pastor's conviction; a fuller Portuguese-language primary source should be sought to expand this record.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "reference"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: reference.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "42594dc68d308d562aa9ecee5ee6f71eaa92b789a10d2b7f592ba0f86c5fce5e",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1015,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Guilty plea and sentence; the defendant was a licensed lay youth minister, not an ordained elder, but held a church-conferred pastoral license and title specific to his role within the United Methodist Church.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-russell-davis-united-methodist-massachusetts-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Newbury, Rowley and Salisbury, Massachusetts, USA",
"lat": 42.8098,
"lng": -70.8737,
"title": "United States: licensed United Methodist youth minister Russell Woodman Davis pleads guilty to raping three boys over nearly two decades",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Licensed youth minister, United Methodist Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over vulnerable youth met through church youth ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"United Methodist Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Essex County, Massachusetts",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2023-02-23",
"outcome": "Davis, a church-licensed youth minister (not ordained) at a rural United Methodist church, pleaded guilty to raping and attempting to rape three boys he met through the church between 1988 and 2006, victims aged 12 to 16. He was sentenced to three to four years in state prison followed by three years' probation, ordered to register as a sex offender, and barred from contact with minors and the victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Davis was given his role and title by the United Methodist Church specifically to work with youth; he used that church-conferred pastoral standing to befriend and gain access to vulnerable boys over nearly two decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bostonglobe.com/2023/02/23/metro/former-methodist-youth-minister-pleads-guilty-child-rape-essex-da-says/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former Methodist youth minister pleads guilty to child rape, Essex DA says', The Boston Globe, 23 February 2023.",
"body": "Report on Davis's guilty plea, sentence, and the church youth-ministry context of his access to victims.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.mass.gov/news/former-youth-minister-pleads-guilty-to-child-rape",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former youth minister pleads guilty to child rape', Massachusetts Attorney General / Essex DA press release.",
"body": "Official prosecutorial press release confirming charges, plea and sentence.",
"tier": "official-report",
"kind": "prosecutor-statement"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bostonglobe.com/2023/02/23/metro/former-methodist-youth-minister-pleads-guilty-child-rape-essex-da-says/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fab67bedb35ffc39caf6d9e2969a6b7f3fe03f0a974683ee51587e8cbf89aaf7",
"final_url": "https://www.bostonglobe.com/2023/02/23/metro/former-methodist-youth-minister-pleads-guilty-child-rape-essex-da-says/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.mass.gov/news/former-youth-minister-pleads-guilty-to-child-rape",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-report; evidentiary role: prosecutor-statement.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1016,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal convictions, sentence reported; jurisdiction and full disposition details limited to the single source located — should be expanded with a primary Mississippi court record if pursued further.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-methodist-pastor-eagle-lake-mississippi-usa",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Eagle Lake, Warren County, Mississippi, USA",
"lat": 32.4757,
"lng": -90.9887,
"title": "Mississippi: Methodist pastor convicted of statutory rape of a congregant",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Methodist pastor, Eagle Lake congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a congregant"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"United Methodist Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Warren County, Mississippi",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2020-01-01",
"outcome": "A Methodist pastor at Eagle Lake was convicted of statutory rape of a congregant."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The pastor held direct pastoral authority over the victim as a member of his own congregation; further detail on relationship and grooming mechanism was not available in the single source located and should be expanded before treating this record as complete.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cross-referenced summary entry, 'Mississippi: Methodist pastor's convictions for statutory rape', 2020.",
"body": "Brief record of the Eagle Lake Methodist pastor's conviction; a fuller Mississippi primary court source should be sought to expand this record.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "reference"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: reference.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "42594dc68d308d562aa9ecee5ee6f71eaa92b789a10d2b7f592ba0f86c5fce5e",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1017,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Criminal conviction; institution is identified in reporting as a Baptist congregation. If later sourcing shows the church was independent/non-denominational rather than affiliated Baptist, reclassify traditionDetailId accordingly.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-baptist-minister-talsi-latvia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Talsi, Latvia",
"lat": 57.2453,
"lng": 22.5877,
"title": "Latvia: Baptist minister and Sunday-school director convicted of abusing children in his care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Baptist minister and Sunday-school director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and Sunday-school instructional authority over children"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Baptist church, Talsi"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Latvian court",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2023-01-01",
"outcome": "A Baptist minister who also directed his congregation's Sunday school was convicted of sexually abusing children in his care."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The minister held both pastoral authority and direct instructional authority over children through his dual role as minister and Sunday-school director, combining clerical and institutional access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cross-referenced summary entry, 'Latvia: Baptist minister and Sunday-school director convicted', 2023.",
"body": "Brief record of the Talsi Baptist minister's conviction; a fuller Latvian-language primary source should be sought to expand this record.",
"tier": "institutional-reporting",
"kind": "reference"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-reporting; evidentiary role: reference.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "42594dc68d308d562aa9ecee5ee6f71eaa92b789a10d2b7f592ba0f86c5fce5e",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglican_Communion_sexual_abuse_cases"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1018,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event record for the province-level self-disclosure, not a single perpetrator's conviction. Distinct from the existing Donald McGuire record (2009-donald-mcguire-jesuit-state-federal-usa), which is an individual criminal conviction in the same order.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-jesuits-west-midwest-province-abuser-lists-usa",
"year": 2018,
"place": "United States (national)",
"lat": 39.8283,
"lng": -98.5795,
"title": "United States: Jesuits West and Jesuits Midwest provinces each publish named lists of members with established sexual-abuse allegations",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Society of Jesus, USA West and USA Midwest provinces, Roman Catholic religious order operating schools, parishes and retreat houses"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and educational authority within Jesuit-run schools and parishes across the two provinces' territories",
"internal case-review processes that determined 'established allegations' without always resulting in criminal referral"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of Jesus, USA West Province",
"Society of Jesus, USA Midwest Province"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Society of Jesus, USA West Province (internal review, published)",
"stage": "official province-level disclosure",
"date": "2018-12-07",
"outcome": "Jesuits West published a list of members of the province with one or more established allegations of sexual abuse of a minor, naming clergy and stating the province's own review findings; the list is maintained and updated by the province."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Society of Jesus, USA Midwest Province (internal review, published)",
"stage": "official province-level disclosure",
"date": "2018-12-17",
"outcome": "Jesuits Midwest published a list covering members since 1955: 37 living Jesuits with established allegations while still living, 18 more established only after the accused had died, and 10 named in allegations the province had not independently verified. The province stated this consolidated and extended earlier partial disclosures."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both province-level disclosures list clergy whose access to child and adult victims ran through their ordained and educational roles inside Jesuit institutions; the provinces' own review processes, not a court, are the source of the 'established allegation' finding, and this record is entered as an institutional-event finding rather than as any single member's criminal conviction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jesuitsmidwest.org/press-release/midwest-jesuits-release-names-of-those-with-established-allegations-of-sexual-abuse-of-minors-since-1955/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jesuits USA Midwest Province, 'Midwest Jesuits Release Names of those with Established Allegations of Sexual Abuse of Minors Since 1955' (17 December 2018).",
"body": "The province's own press release publishing the list and explaining its three categories of established allegation.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "official-press-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.scu.edu/news-and-events/feature-stories/2018/stories/jesuits-west-province-announcement-from-the-president.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Santa Clara University, 'Jesuits West Province Announcement from the President' (7 December 2018).",
"body": "Reproduces the Jesuits West provincial's announcement accompanying the province's own published list.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "official-press-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kbzk.com/cnn-national/2018/12/17/jesuits-release-lists-of-clergy-accused-of-abusing-minors/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN via KBZK, 'Jesuits release lists of clergy accused of abusing minors' (17 December 2018).",
"body": "National wire summary of both province releases and their scope.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jesuitsmidwest.org/press-release/midwest-jesuits-release-names-of-those-with-established-allegations-of-sexual-abuse-of-minors-since-1955/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: official-press-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "07e9797d1fd5acfc0b3eea8a1cfcd7067d49e49478a1be4c69fd619800e9c15e",
"final_url": "https://www.jesuitsmidwest.org/press-release/midwest-jesuits-release-names-of-those-with-established-allegations-of-sexual-abuse-of-minors-since-1955/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.scu.edu/news-and-events/feature-stories/2018/stories/jesuits-west-province-announcement-from-the-president.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: official-press-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd925bcd66202b66bf6a15bb8a5953c84b9cbd5bc27d15044ad0c5c35337df17",
"final_url": "https://www.scu.edu/news-and-events/feature-stories/2018/stories/jesuits-west-province-announcement-from-the-president.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kbzk.com/cnn-national/2018/12/17/jesuits-release-lists-of-clergy-accused-of-abusing-minors/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0ca345e3a621beb7d50cfa35976b89fcf58128abdd12e6a35c79c540001975a3",
"final_url": "https://www.kbzk.com/cnn-national/2018/12/17/jesuits-release-lists-of-clergy-accused-of-abusing-minors/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1019,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event record for the January 2021 Jesuit province of Spain report itself, distinct from any single named perpetrator. The 118-figure and 'since 1927' scope come from the province's own report as covered by national press; later 2023 Pedrajas/Bolivia revelations widened the scandal but are recorded separately below as the Bolivia record, since they concern a different province (Bolivia) and different victims.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-jesuits-spain-province-abuse-report",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Spain (national)",
"lat": 40.4168,
"lng": -3.7038,
"title": "Spain: Jesuit province publishes first order-wide report acknowledging 118 sexual-abuse cases by 96 members since 1927",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Society of Jesus, Province of Spain, Roman Catholic religious order operating schools and retreat institutions nationally"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical, educational and spiritual-direction authority inside Jesuit-run schools and formation houses across Spain",
"internal review commissioned and published by the province itself rather than compelled by external prosecution"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of Jesus, Province of Spain"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Society of Jesus, Province of Spain (internal review, published)",
"stage": "official province-level disclosure",
"date": "2021-01-19",
"outcome": "The Jesuit province of Spain published a report acknowledging 118 cases of sexual abuse committed by 96 of its members since 1927 — 81 victims were minors and the remainder adults — describing this as the first such order-wide accounting by a Spanish Catholic religious order. Of the 65 Jesuits who had abused minors, 48 had died; of the 17 living, four had left the Jesuits and the rest were barred from ministry or moved to supervised communities pending proceedings."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The report is the Jesuit province's own accounting of abuse committed by its members against students, retreatants and others under their clerical, teaching or spiritual-direction authority across nearly a century; it is entered as an institutional-event official finding, not as any individual member's criminal conviction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/first-spain-jesuits-admit-decades-sex-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Catholic Reporter, 'In a first for Spain, Jesuits admit to decades of sex abuse' (2021).",
"body": "Reports the province's own published figures — 118 cases, 96 abusers, since 1927 — and the status of living accused members.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.jurist.org/news/2021/01/spain-jesuit-order-admits-to-sexual-abuse-of-81-children-and-37-adults/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "JURIST, 'Spain Jesuit order admits to sexual abuse of 81 children and 37 adults' (2021).",
"body": "Corroborates the child/adult victim split and the province's characterization of the report as unprecedented for Spain.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/first-spain-jesuits-admit-decades-sex-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12e69aff23bc199dfc2d24e57e00ced5131e410c39f63262f260411bdbc59b4c",
"final_url": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/first-spain-jesuits-admit-decades-sex-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://www.jurist.org/news/2021/01/spain-jesuit-order-admits-to-sexual-abuse-of-81-children-and-37-adults/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eff2541972a75d4d5166db51349daaed1675ea55476fe0df24ce02c9e2dc4477",
"final_url": "https://www.jurist.org/news/2021/01/spain-jesuit-order-admits-to-sexual-abuse-of-81-children-and-37-adults/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1020,
"aliases": [
"Br Pica"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from the 2021 Spain province report above: this is the Chilean province's own posthumous investigation into a single named member, Renato Poblete, published as an official finding since Poblete died in 2010 and no criminal prosecution was possible. Entered as official-finding, not a conviction, per the criterion's rule that an order's own acknowledgment counts only when published as an official finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-renato-poblete-jesuit-chile-posthumous-finding",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Santiago, Chile",
"lat": -33.4489,
"lng": -70.6693,
"title": "Chile: Jesuit-commissioned posthumous inquiry finds prominent priest Renato Poblete sexually abused children and adults for decades",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Renato Poblete Barth, Jesuit priest, founder of the Hogar de Cristo-linked social ministry and a nationally prominent figure in Chilean Catholicism"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"decades of public reputation as a champion of the poor, used to structure long-term personal access to victims and their families",
"spiritual and pastoral authority exercised over adult women he counseled as well as children",
"a victim's own explicit instruction that a Jesuit confidant not disclose what she had told him, which the Jesuits' own investigation found had been honored, delaying any institutional response"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of Jesus, Chile",
"Hogar de Cristo"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Society of Jesus, Chile (Jesuit-commissioned independent investigation, published)",
"stage": "official posthumous finding",
"date": "2021-05-01",
"outcome": "Following the first allegation in 2019 by Marcela Aranda Escobar, the Chilean Jesuit province commissioned an investigation that found Poblete's accusers — including Aranda and other women he abused over nearly fifty years — 'plausible and credible', and separately confirmed abuse of at least four minors. The inquiry, published as the Jesuits' own report since Poblete died in 2010 and no criminal case was possible, described a 'double life' sustained by his public reputation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Poblete's victims, adult and child, were bound to him through pastoral counseling and the trust his public standing as a priest devoted to the poor commanded; the Jesuits' own posthumous investigation is the official finding of record because his death foreclosed prosecution.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://cruxnow.com/church-in-the-americas/2021/05/chiles-jesuits-confess-crimes-negligence-and-errors-on-sex-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crux, 'Chile's Jesuits confess ‘crimes, negligence and errors’ on sex abuse' (2021).",
"body": "Reports the Jesuit province's own published findings on Poblete, including the 'plausible and credible' language and the double-life conclusion.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/accountability/chile-jesuits-publish-inquiry-results-confirm-abuses-famed-priest",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Catholic Reporter, 'Chile: Jesuits publish inquiry results, confirm abuses by famed priest' (2021).",
"body": "Confirms the four-minor, multiple-adult-victim findings and the absence of an established institutional cover-up.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://cruxnow.com/church-in-the-americas/2021/05/chiles-jesuits-confess-crimes-negligence-and-errors-on-sex-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "726eb9229df009791d2bac5bde4a4c9d470be513698b5a9dd5a7b618cf8dd0f8",
"final_url": "https://cruxnow.com/church-in-the-americas/2021/05/chiles-jesuits-confess-crimes-negligence-and-errors-on-sex-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/accountability/chile-jesuits-publish-inquiry-results-confirm-abuses-famed-priest",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d286b80e6504f718cdf4895dcffb8a19eb66edb8e37f633a8b539077dc4e59df",
"final_url": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/chile-jesuits-publish-inquiry-results-confirm-abuses-famed-priest"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1021,
"aliases": [
"Father Pica"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Named-perpetrator institutional-event record distinct from the Spain province report above. Pedrajas is Spanish-born but the harm occurred in Bolivia, so under the corpus's harm-location country rule this is a Bolivia record. No criminal conviction exists (he died in 2009); the record rests on the diary as investigated and confirmed by press and on the resulting Bolivian criminal proceedings against OTHERS for concealment, which are noted but not the basis of this record's own finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-alfonso-pedrajas-jesuit-diary-cochabamba-bolivia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Cochabamba, Bolivia",
"lat": -17.3895,
"lng": -66.1568,
"title": "Bolivia: Jesuit priest's own diary, confirmed by his family and investigated by the Vatican and Bolivian prosecutors, documents his abuse of 85 boarding-school children",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Alfonso Pedrajas ('Father Pica'), Jesuit priest teaching at Jesuit-run boarding schools for impoverished boys in Cochabamba, Bolivia, 1970s-1990s"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential boarding-school authority over poor children with limited family oversight",
"clerical status as a trusted teacher-priest inside Jesuit institutions",
"the diary itself records his own systematic method of selecting and silencing victims over two decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of Jesus, Bolivia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Society of Jesus (Vatican-directed review) and Fiscalía, Cochabamba, Bolivia",
"stage": "posthumous documentary finding and referral",
"date": "2023-05-01",
"outcome": "Pedrajas's nephew turned over a print-out of his uncle's diary, in which Pedrajas recorded abusing 85 minors at Jesuit boarding schools in Cochabamba from the 1970s to the 1990s; the diary's contents, first published by El País in April 2023, prompted the Society of Jesus in Bolivia to confirm its authenticity, the Vatican to send a copy to Bolivian authorities, and Cochabamba prosecutors to open an investigation, joining at least a dozen other clergy-abuse probes already under way in Bolivia. Pedrajas died in 2009 and was never prosecuted; separate 2026 Bolivian court proceedings against Jesuit superiors addressed concealment of his abuse, not his own personal guilt, and are not the basis of this record."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Pedrajas's victims were boys in his care at Jesuit-run boarding schools for the poor, where his combined role as teacher and priest gave him unsupervised residential access; his own diary is the primary documentary record, corroborated by his family, the Jesuit order, and Bolivian prosecutors, of abuse that could never be criminally tried because of his 2009 death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/6/23/vatican-sends-priests-diary-to-bolivia-amid-sex-abuse-scandal",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Al Jazeera, 'Vatican sends priest's diary to Bolivia amid sex abuse scandal' (23 June 2023).",
"body": "Reports the Vatican's transmission of the diary to Bolivian authorities and the scale of the abuse it documents.",
"tier": "international-wire",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.irishtimes.com/world/americas/2023/05/07/jesuits-diary-of-sexual-abuse-prompts-investigations-in-bolivia/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Irish Times, 'Jesuit's diary of sexual abuse prompts investigations in Bolivia' (7 May 2023).",
"body": "Details the diary's discovery by Pedrajas's nephew, its publication by El País, and the opening of the Cochabamba prosecutorial investigation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/6/23/vatican-sends-priests-diary-to-bolivia-amid-sex-abuse-scandal",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-wire; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f674a0c5a0b7dcba056327298d1f11b56c5f967cd0fb9a33e537e8b7633ce149",
"final_url": "https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/6/23/vatican-sends-priests-diary-to-bolivia-amid-sex-abuse-scandal"
},
{
"source": "https://www.irishtimes.com/world/americas/2023/05/07/jesuits-diary-of-sexual-abuse-prompts-investigations-in-bolivia/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "25c97e19d20e7387507f83b69e166bff93ed2c505f9442e7bead0b658137515c",
"final_url": "https://www.irishtimes.com/world/americas/2023/05/07/jesuits-diary-of-sexual-abuse-prompts-investigations-in-bolivia/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1022,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction. Reséndiz is a Mexican-born Legionaries of Christ priest but the harm occurred in Italy, so under the corpus's harm-location rule this is an Italy record. Conviction was affirmed on appeal, satisfying the stood-on-appeal requirement.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-vladimir-resendiz-legionaries-gozzano-italy",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Gozzano, Novara Province, Italy",
"lat": 45.7411,
"lng": 8.4342,
"title": "Italy: Legionaries of Christ priest Vladimir Reséndiz Gutiérrez convicted in absentia of abusing minor seminarians, affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Vladimir Reséndiz Gutiérrez, Legionaries of Christ priest overseeing minor seminarians at the congregation's Gozzano youth seminary, Novara Province, Italy"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential seminary authority over boys being formed for the priesthood, with direct pastoral and disciplinary control",
"the congregation's own internal seminary structure, which placed the accused in charge of vulnerable minors far from their families"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Legionaries of Christ"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal of Novara, Italy",
"stage": "conviction in absentia, affirmed on appeal, civil compensation ordered",
"date": "2019-03-01",
"outcome": "Reséndiz, accused of abusing minor seminarians at the Legionaries' Gozzano seminary between 2006 and 2008, was convicted in absentia by an Italian court in March 2019; an appeals court confirmed the conviction in January 2020. A related civil proceeding concluding in 2020 sentenced him to seven years' imprisonment and ordered him to pay compensation to the victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Reséndiz's victims were minor seminarians training for the priesthood under his direct pastoral and residential authority inside a Legionaries of Christ formation house, where obedience to superiors was itself part of their religious formation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_surrounding_the_Legion_of_Christ",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Background aggregation citing Italian court reporting on the Reséndiz conviction and 2020 appellate confirmation.",
"body": "Summarizes the March 2019 in-absentia conviction, the January 2020 appellate confirmation, and the 2020 civil sentence of seven years plus compensation.",
"tier": "secondary-aggregation",
"kind": "background-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ncregister.com/cna/court-evidence-suggests-abuse-cover-up-by-high-ranking-legionaries-of-christ",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Catholic Register/CNA, reporting on the broader Legionaries court record including the Reséndiz case background.",
"body": "Corroborates the Gozzano seminary setting and the congregation's internal handling of the case.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_surrounding_the_Legion_of_Christ",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-aggregation; evidentiary role: background-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a46dc60c13d2ab34d66b89ff746fb8d7df28fd588806f43c7bc11193e4ed5992",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_surrounding_the_Legion_of_Christ"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ncregister.com/cna/court-evidence-suggests-abuse-cover-up-by-high-ranking-legionaries-of-christ",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1023,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction, Belgium. Distinct from the existing Salesian Chile institutional-event record and the Klep/Vigo individual records — first Belgian Salesian record in the corpus. The post-conviction transfer to Central African Republic is recorded as an aggravating institutional fact within this record's coercionMechanisms rather than as a separate Africa record, since no African prosecution occurred.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-luk-delft-salesian-ghent-belgium",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Ghent, East Flanders, Belgium",
"lat": 51.0543,
"lng": 3.7174,
"title": "Belgium: Salesian priest Luk Delft convicted of child abuse and child pornography, later transferred by the order to work with children in Central Africa despite the ban",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Luk Delft, Salesian priest and dormitory supervisor at the Don Bosco Sint-Denijs-Westrem boarding school, Ghent, Belgium"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"night-time dormitory supervisory authority over boarding-school boys",
"clerical status inside a Salesian-run residential school",
"the order's own decision to transfer him internally rather than report him to police after his 2001 confession"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Salesians of Don Bosco, Belgium"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Ghent, Belgium",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2012-11-01",
"outcome": "A Ghent court convicted Delft of two counts of child abuse and of possessing child pornography, arising from his assaults on two boys, aged 12 and 13, while he worked as a night dormitory monitor at the Salesian-run Don Bosco boarding school in Ghent in 2001. He received an 18-month suspended sentence and was barred from unsupervised contact with minors until 2022. The Belgian Salesian order had known of his 2001 confession to molesting two boys but transferred him internally without notifying police; child pornography was later found on his computer in 2009. After his conviction the order employed him with Caritas in the Central African Republic, where a 2019 CNN investigation found he was accused of abusing further children."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Delft's Belgian victims were boarding-school boys under his direct nighttime custodial authority as a Salesian dormitory monitor; the same clerical and institutional standing that gave him access to them was what the order used afterward to place him, unsupervised, with children abroad.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2019/11/africa/luk-delft-intl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN, 'How a Catholic order dedicated to protecting children failed them' (2019).",
"body": "Full investigative account of the 2012 Ghent conviction, the order's 2001 internal handling, and Delft's subsequent placement in Central African Republic.",
"tier": "international-wire",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/accountability/belgian-salesians-defend-decision-send-convicted-pedophile-africa",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Catholic Reporter, 'Belgian Salesians defend decision to send convicted pedophile to Africa' (2019).",
"body": "Confirms the 2012 conviction terms and the order's own defense of its post-conviction placement decision.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2019/11/africa/luk-delft-intl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-wire; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4a29bdba41e8d4c2e68ccbf844532e8079f955a2a1f471876629f5db6fab3769",
"final_url": "https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2019/11/africa/luk-delft-intl/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/accountability/belgian-salesians-defend-decision-send-convicted-pedophile-africa",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9347c901efec1c4a07208f0753bd1154182faf9c0c9b981e53f2aaf8d660be59",
"final_url": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/belgian-salesians-defend-decision-send-convicted-pedophile-africa"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1024,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction spanning three trials, Northern Ireland. Dunleavy died in custody in 2025 after this second sentencing but before the record was drafted; both convictions stood at the time of his death, with no appeal overturning them, so the conviction status is preserved. Distinct from all existing Christian Brothers records, which are Ireland (Ryan Report/Ferryhouse/Lota), Australia, Canada and Scotland.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-paul-dunleavy-christian-brother-belfast-newry-armagh-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Belfast, Newry and Armagh, Northern Ireland, United Kingdom",
"lat": 54.5973,
"lng": -5.9301,
"title": "United Kingdom: Christian Brother and school principal Paul Dunleavy convicted across three trials of 72 sexual-abuse offences against 18 boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Paul Dunleavy, Christian Brother, teacher and school principal at four Christian Brothers schools in Belfast, Newry and Armagh, 1964-1997"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"principal's and teacher's authority over pupils aged seven to fourteen across four Christian Brothers schools",
"religious-order status within a residential and educational institution run by the Congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Congregation of Christian Brothers"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Crown Court, Belfast, Northern Ireland",
"stage": "convictions across three trials; sentences",
"date": "2024-11-28",
"outcome": "Dunleavy was convicted across three separate trials of a total of 72 non-recent sexual-abuse offences — including indecent assault, attempted buggery and gross indecency — against 18 boys aged seven to fourteen, committed between 1964 and 1991 at four Christian Brothers schools in Belfast, Newry and Armagh where he taught and served as principal. The 28 November 2024 sentencing, covering 36 offences against nine victims, added ten further years to a sentence already imposed for the earlier trials. He died in custody in August 2025."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Dunleavy's victims were schoolboys under his direct authority as both a Christian Brother and, at points, their school principal — religious-order status and educational control operating together across four institutions run by the Congregation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irishnews.com/news/northern-ireland/paul-dunleavy-former-christian-brother-jailed-for-further-10-years-ove-historic-sex-abuse-OH6KYGF2KZDJDH6TP5FSHX2ZZI/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Irish News, 'Paul Dunleavy: Former Christian Brother jailed for further 10 years over historic sex abuse' (2024).",
"body": "Reports the 28 November 2024 sentencing, the 36-offence/nine-victim count for that trial, and the cumulative 72-offence/18-victim total across all three trials.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/2025/08/28/former-christian-brother-and-school-principal-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse-dies-while-serving-sentence/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Irish Times, 'Former Christian Brother and school principal convicted of child sex abuse dies while serving sentence' (2025).",
"body": "Confirms his death in custody in August 2025 while serving the sentence from the standing convictions.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irishnews.com/news/northern-ireland/paul-dunleavy-former-christian-brother-jailed-for-further-10-years-ove-historic-sex-abuse-OH6KYGF2KZDJDH6TP5FSHX2ZZI/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0842dc1a41fe66016466772ebb6ea8c3dbcf2fbfe72059579f40f41aac262224",
"final_url": "https://www.irishnews.com/news/northern-ireland/paul-dunleavy-former-christian-brother-jailed-for-further-10-years-ove-historic-sex-abuse-OH6KYGF2KZDJDH6TP5FSHX2ZZI/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/2025/08/28/former-christian-brother-and-school-principal-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse-dies-while-serving-sentence/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f3e20d393d84ca74f26228e3368ebe10bf2a078c6f6ae59269ee6c474810bb41",
"final_url": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/2025/08/28/former-christian-brother-and-school-principal-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse-dies-while-serving-sentence/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1025,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Two co-defendants convicted at the same trial, entered as a single record following corpus convention for joint convictions of the same institution's staff for abuse of the same victim pool. First Scotland Christian Brothers record in the corpus (the existing Fort Augustus and Tranent/Gartmore Scotland records are Benedictine and De La Salle respectively).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-farrell-kelly-christian-brothers-st-ninians-falkland-scotland",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Falkland, Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom",
"lat": 56.2514,
"lng": -3.2044,
"title": "Scotland: Christian Brothers headmaster and teacher convicted of physically and sexually abusing boys at St Ninian's, Falkland",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"John Farrell, Christian Brother and headmaster, St Ninian's residential school for troubled boys, Falkland, Fife",
"Paul Kelly, Christian Brother and teacher, St Ninian's residential school for troubled boys, Falkland, Fife"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"headmaster's and teacher's authority within a residential Christian Brothers institution for boys already removed from their families",
"combined physical and sexual abuse used to enforce control over a captive residential population"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Congregation of Christian Brothers, Scotland",
"St Ninian's, Falkland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Justiciary, Glasgow, Scotland",
"stage": "conviction after 13-week trial; sentences",
"date": "2016-08-01",
"outcome": "Following a 13-week trial, Farrell and Kelly were convicted of 11 charges involving six former pupils at St Ninian's in the late 1970s and 1980s. Farrell, the headmaster, was convicted of physically abusing one boy and sexually abusing three others and sentenced to five years; Kelly was convicted of sexually abusing two boys and sexually and physically abusing a third and sentenced to ten years. Both were placed on the sex offenders register."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were residential pupils at a Christian Brothers-run institution for troubled boys, entirely dependent on Farrell and Kelly in their combined roles as headmaster, teacher and members of the religious order running the school.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/news/courts/226159/two-men-found-guilty-abuse-christian-brothers-school-falkland/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Courier, 'Two men found guilty of abuse at Christian Brothers school in Falkland' (2016).",
"body": "Reports the joint conviction, the 13-week trial, and both men's roles at St Ninian's.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/news/courts/226159/two-men-found-guilty-abuse-christian-brothers-school-falkland/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1026,
"aliases": [
"Brother Romuald"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction spanning two proceedings (2015, 2019), entered as one record following corpus convention for the same perpetrator convicted in multiple hearings for the same institutional pattern. First Marist Brothers Hamilton (NSW)/Pagewood record in the corpus; distinct from the existing Kogarah (Wade) NSW Marist record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-francis-cable-marist-brother-hamilton-nsw-australia",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Hamilton and Pagewood, New South Wales, Australia",
"lat": -32.9167,
"lng": 151.75,
"title": "Australia: Marist Brother Francis Cable ('Brother Romuald') convicted across two proceedings of sexually abusing children at Hamilton and Pagewood",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Francis Cable, known as Brother Romuald, Marist Brother and teacher at Marist Brothers Hamilton and Pagewood schools, New South Wales, 1960s-1970s"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"classroom and school authority as a Marist Brother over students at two Marist-run schools",
"a sentencing judge's own description of the school environment under Cable as 'an environment of evil'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Marist Brothers, New South Wales"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Newcastle District Court, New South Wales, Australia",
"stage": "conviction after trial and guilty pleas; sentence",
"date": "2015-01-01",
"outcome": "Cable was found guilty of sexually abusing two Marist Brothers Hamilton students following trial and pleaded guilty to further offences against 17 other victims at Hamilton and Pagewood Marist between 1960 and the 1970s; he was sentenced to 16 years in prison. The sentencing judge described the school environment as 'an environment of evil'."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Newcastle District Court, New South Wales, Australia",
"stage": "guilty plea and further sentence",
"date": "2019-01-01",
"outcome": "Charged in 2017 with a further 14 offences against five additional victims, Cable pleaded guilty in late 2018 and was sentenced in 2019 to a further maximum eight years' imprisonment, with a five-year non-parole period, on top of his 2015 sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cable's victims were students in his own classes at Marist-run schools, wholly subject to his authority as both teacher and member of the religious order operating the institution.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5943180/environment-of-evil-judge-slams-hunter-marist-brothers-school/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newcastle Herald, 'Brother Romuald terrified boys at Marist Brothers, Hamilton, but will probably die in jail' (2015).",
"body": "Reports the 16-year sentence, the 'environment of evil' description, and the number of victims covered by the 2015 proceeding.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5719182/terrifying-marist-child-sex-offender-guilty-again/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newcastle Herald, 'Francis Cable, 86, known as Marist Brother Romuald, now guilty of sexually abusing 24 former students' (2018).",
"body": "Reports the 2018 guilty plea to the further charges and the cumulative victim count.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/7899372/francis-william-cable-also-known-as-brother-romuald-dies-in-custody/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newcastle Herald, 'Francis William Cable, also known as Brother Romuald, dies in custody' (2021).",
"body": "Confirms his death in custody, with both convictions standing at the time.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5943180/environment-of-evil-judge-slams-hunter-marist-brothers-school/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "89043542bead085bc993c08dcb1c8f4e65d9297c6cd1b45e9bcbefcd2819b9b9",
"final_url": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5943180/environment-of-evil-judge-slams-hunter-marist-brothers-school/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5719182/terrifying-marist-child-sex-offender-guilty-again/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f6c45257e790a3a0701fc4702b20fb8a75d86fffe25546620671c5fe57a4b0bb",
"final_url": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/5719182/terrifying-marist-child-sex-offender-guilty-again/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/7899372/francis-william-cable-also-known-as-brother-romuald-dies-in-custody/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c353dd18bfb1f0596ab4076a04fc35d0aa5a5e9e0f11748f913c1302d612a9ae",
"final_url": "https://www.newcastleherald.com.au/story/7899372/francis-william-cable-also-known-as-brother-romuald-dies-in-custody/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1027,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction spanning three proceedings across three decades (1996, 2017, 2025), entered as a single record following corpus convention for the same perpetrator convicted across multiple hearings. First Gregory Sutton record in the corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1996-gregory-sutton-marist-brother-nsw-australia",
"year": 1996,
"place": "New South Wales, Canberra and Innisfail, Queensland, Australia",
"lat": -33.8688,
"lng": 151.2093,
"title": "Australia: Marist Brother Gregory Sutton convicted across three decades of sexually abusing children in New South Wales, Canberra and Queensland",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Gregory Joseph Sutton, Marist Brother and teacher at Marist-run schools in New South Wales, Canberra and Queensland"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"classroom and pastoral authority as a Marist Brother over students at multiple Marist-run schools across several decades",
"the Marist order's own internal handling that allowed his continued access to children across jurisdictions"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Marist Brothers, New South Wales"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of New South Wales, Australia",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence, reduced on appeal",
"date": "1996-11-08",
"outcome": "Sutton pleaded guilty to 67 child sexual offences against 15 students at Marist-run schools in New South Wales and was sentenced on 8 November 1996 to 18 years' imprisonment with a 13.5-year minimum; on appeal in December 2000 the sentence was reduced to 15 years with a 12-year minimum."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "ACT Supreme Court, Canberra, Australia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2017-01-01",
"outcome": "Sutton received a suspended sentence of two years and two months for offences against two boys in Canberra in the 1980s."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Queensland court, Innisfail",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-03-01",
"outcome": "Sutton was given a suspended sentence of fifteen months for abusing a boy in Innisfail, north Queensland, between 1973 and 1975."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Across three jurisdictions and five decades, Sutton's victims were students at schools run by the Marist Brothers, where his standing as both teacher and member of the religious order gave him repeated access despite intervening convictions.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregory_Sutton",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Background aggregation of Australian court reporting on Sutton's 1996, 2017 and 2025 proceedings.",
"body": "Consolidates the 1996 sentence and 2000 appellate reduction, the 2017 ACT sentencing, and the 2025 Queensland sentencing.",
"tier": "secondary-aggregation",
"kind": "background-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6036778/ex-marist-brother-gregory-joseph-sutton-gets-suspended-sentence-for-child-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Canberra Times, 'Ex-Marist brother Gregory Joseph Sutton gets suspended sentence for child sex abuse' (2017).",
"body": "Reports the 2017 ACT sentencing and recaps his 1996 New South Wales conviction as prior history.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregory_Sutton",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-aggregation; evidentiary role: background-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "70208b8bc06fe76788a3ca254c3eb8223dd8c4c2b7c8d7bc9a0b5ade1133f7eb",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregory_Sutton"
},
{
"source": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6036778/ex-marist-brother-gregory-joseph-sutton-gets-suspended-sentence-for-child-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7fa9af3634791cf6a695de884846236a397e7cdec6073c558a1724e0901f1841",
"final_url": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6036778/ex-marist-brother-gregory-joseph-sutton-gets-suspended-sentence-for-child-sex-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1028,
"aliases": [
"Brother Charles"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction spanning multiple sentencing proceedings (1994-2025) for the same underlying course of offending. Entered as a single record following corpus convention. First Marist Brothers New Zealand record in the corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-charles-afeaki-marist-brother-auckland-invercargill-nz",
"year": 1994,
"place": "Auckland and Invercargill, New Zealand",
"lat": -36.8485,
"lng": 174.7633,
"title": "New Zealand: Marist Brother Charles Afeaki repeatedly convicted and re-sentenced for serial child sexual abuse at Auckland and Invercargill schools",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Charles Afeaki ('Brother Charles'), Marist Brother and teacher at Marist Brothers Primary School, Invercargill, and St Paul's College, Auckland, 1970s-1980s"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"classroom authority as a Marist Brother over students at Marist-run Catholic schools in two cities",
"repeated relocation between schools during the offending period, which the order's own structure enabled"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Marist Brothers, New Zealand"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court, Auckland, New Zealand",
"stage": "conviction after trial and sentence",
"date": "1994-01-01",
"outcome": "Afeaki was found guilty after trial in the High Court at Auckland of abusing four former students and was sentenced to eight years' imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "New Zealand courts (Auckland and Invercargill)",
"stage": "further convictions and sentence extensions",
"date": "2025-06-01",
"outcome": "Afeaki was re-sentenced in further proceedings in 2003, 2024 and 2025 as additional victims came forward from his time teaching at Invercargill and Auckland schools in the 1970s and 1980s; by the June 2025 hearing his accumulated sentence across all proceedings totaled 13 years and 11 months, and he was denied parole."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Afeaki's victims were students at Marist Brothers-run Catholic schools where he taught, first in Invercargill and then in Auckland, with his standing as both teacher and religious brother giving him sustained access across relocations.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/crime/catholic-school-teacher-charles-afeaki-jailed-again-for-serial-child-sex-abuse-in-auckland-whanganui/Z4RZPVUKD5ET5K44XW54CIWCBQ/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NZ Herald, 'Catholic school teacher Charles Afeaki jailed again for serial child sex abuse in Auckland, Whanganui'.",
"body": "Reports the cumulative sentence total, the original 1994 High Court conviction, and the schools where he offended.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/crime/parole-board-denies-release-for-ex-marist-brother-and-serial-paedophile-charles-afeaki/333SUAY2QFEO7H6P4GYYF5Y73E/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NZ Herald, 'Ex-Marist brother and serial paedophile Charles Afeaki denied parole' (2025).",
"body": "Confirms his continued imprisonment and denied parole as of 2025.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/crime/catholic-school-teacher-charles-afeaki-jailed-again-for-serial-child-sex-abuse-in-auckland-whanganui/Z4RZPVUKD5ET5K44XW54CIWCBQ/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "72879ca33ead56d848333f421c888c19a538425547eee5efc1970f6face7a746",
"final_url": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/crime/catholic-school-teacher-charles-afeaki-jailed-again-for-serial-child-sex-abuse-in-auckland-whanganui/Z4RZPVUKD5ET5K44XW54CIWCBQ/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/crime/parole-board-denies-release-for-ex-marist-brother-and-serial-paedophile-charles-afeaki/333SUAY2QFEO7H6P4GYYF5Y73E/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d4cc7f1719cdb38390b6285fbdacf92c5a3f4db480eeda650499dc2c033a0105",
"final_url": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/crime/parole-board-denies-release-for-ex-marist-brother-and-serial-paedophile-charles-afeaki/333SUAY2QFEO7H6P4GYYF5Y73E/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1029,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction, New Zealand. First Christian Brothers New Zealand (Hato Paora) record in the corpus, distinct from the Marist Brothers Afeaki record above at a different order and different school.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-andrew-cody-christian-brother-hato-paora-nz",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Feilding, New Zealand",
"lat": -40.2258,
"lng": 175.5611,
"title": "New Zealand: Christian Brother Andrew Cody convicted of sexually abusing sick and vulnerable boys in his care at Hato Pāora College",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Andrew Cody, Christian Brother on staff at Hato Pāora College, a Catholic Māori boys' boarding school, Feilding, New Zealand, 1981-1984"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential boarding-school authority over boys, including specific access to those who were sick and under his direct care",
"religious-order status inside a Christian Brothers-staffed Catholic institution"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Congregation of Christian Brothers, New Zealand",
"Hato Pāora College"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New Zealand court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2005-01-01",
"outcome": "Cody, then 67, was jailed for two and a half years for sexually abusing sick and vulnerable boys in his care at Hato Pāora College between 1981 and 1984."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cody's victims were boarding-school boys, some specifically singled out while sick and dependent on his care, at a Catholic institution staffed by the Christian Brothers where his religious-order standing was inseparable from his custodial role.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/priest-michael-odonnell-pleads-guilty-to-abusing-five-victims-at-hato-paora-college/ZNRC7KKCGVB7BLIZ2MFIXNS6HE/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NZ Herald, reporting on Hato Pāora College abuse cases including Andrew Cody's 2005 conviction.",
"body": "Confirms Cody's 2005 sentence of two and a half years for abusing sick and vulnerable boys in his care at the college between 1981 and 1984.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/priest-michael-odonnell-pleads-guilty-to-abusing-five-victims-at-hato-paora-college/ZNRC7KKCGVB7BLIZ2MFIXNS6HE/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "336d149b8ce15840cd55b9c5aa3bb26551debeac1b1d9621be38629a1b84c714",
"final_url": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/priest-michael-odonnell-pleads-guilty-to-abusing-five-victims-at-hato-paora-college/ZNRC7KKCGVB7BLIZ2MFIXNS6HE/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1030,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event record for the province's own 1993 investigation and its later fuller disclosure, not any single perpetrator's conviction. This is the genuine institutional finding named in the research brief.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1993-st-anthonys-seminary-franciscan-santa-barbara-usa",
"year": 1993,
"place": "Santa Barbara, California, USA",
"lat": 34.4208,
"lng": -119.6982,
"title": "United States: Franciscan province of Santa Barbara's own investigation finds 34 boys abused by a dozen priests at St Anthony's Seminary",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Franciscan Friars, Province of St Barbara, Roman Catholic religious order operating St Anthony's Seminary and Old Mission Santa Barbara, a boarding school for aspiring priests"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential seminary authority over boys being formed for the priesthood",
"the province's own later admission that accused priests were repeatedly reassigned to St Anthony's after allegations elsewhere rather than removed from ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Franciscan Friars, Province of St Barbara",
"St Anthony's Seminary"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Franciscan Friars, Province of St Barbara (independent panel commissioned by the province, published)",
"stage": "official province-commissioned investigation and report",
"date": "1993-11-29",
"outcome": "An independent panel commissioned by the Franciscan Province of St Barbara found that 34 boys had been sexually abused by a dozen priests at St Anthony's Seminary between 1964 and 1987. The province later expanded its own disclosure to identify 50 priests accused of abusing children across its ministries since 1950, 26 of whom had been assigned to St Anthony's Seminary or Old Mission Santa Barbara — in more than half of those cases, after already having been accused of molestation elsewhere. Of an estimated 76 Santa Barbara children abused by Catholic clergy since 1958, 54 were abused by friars assigned to those two institutions. A related civil settlement in 2006 awarded plaintiffs $28 million."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The province's own investigation found that St Anthony's Seminary functioned as a landing point for priests already accused elsewhere, whose combined clerical and residential authority over seminarians in formation was the mechanism the province's report identifies as the cause of the harm.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://origin.bishop-accountability.org/reports/1993-11-StAnthonysSeminary/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Stearns, Baggarley-Mar, Mar, Merlin, Bonner OFM and Higgins, 'St. Anthony's Seminary Report' (29 November 1993).",
"body": "The independent panel's full report commissioned by the Franciscan Province of St Barbara, finding 34 boys abused by a dozen priests between 1964 and 1987.",
"tier": "official-commission-finding",
"kind": "commissioned-investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.independent.com/2009/11/25/moral-dumping-ground/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Santa Barbara Independent, 'Moral Dumping Ground' (2009).",
"body": "Reports the province's later, fuller disclosure of 50 accused priests, the pattern of reassignment to St Anthony's after allegations elsewhere, and the 76-victim, 54-at-these-institutions figures.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://origin.bishop-accountability.org/reports/1993-11-StAnthonysSeminary/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-commission-finding; evidentiary role: commissioned-investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "10c1df771779e0adab90b5c543b2f26f86c97fea00de033b3c2a52b3d8703651",
"final_url": "http://origin.bishop-accountability.org/reports/1993-11-StAnthonysSeminary/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.independent.com/2009/11/25/moral-dumping-ground/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a23fc43757f873307299cb6eeeb2092cead66284dde0a8b5f6ef09e193e03c84",
"final_url": "https://www.independent.com/2009/11/25/moral-dumping-ground/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1031,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event record for the Spiritans' own 2022 disclosure and the resulting state-level scoping process, not any single named perpetrator's conviction. The scoping inquiry itself is a government process examining the disclosure; no findings of the inquiry are asserted here since (per the source material) the full inquiry's substantive findings were still pending establishment as of the sources used.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-spiritans-blackrock-college-abuse-disclosure-ireland",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Blackrock, County Dublin, Ireland",
"lat": 53.3021,
"lng": -6.1785,
"title": "Ireland: Spiritan order discloses 233 abuse allegations against 77 priests at Blackrock College and its feeder schools, prompting a state Scoping Inquiry",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Congregation of the Holy Spirit (Spiritans, formerly Holy Ghost Fathers), Roman Catholic religious order operating Blackrock College and other elite Irish schools"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and educational authority within Spiritan-run boarding and day schools",
"the congregation's own admitted decades-long practice of not reporting known or suspected abuse to civil authorities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Congregation of the Holy Spirit (Spiritans)",
"Blackrock College",
"Willow Park"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Congregation of the Holy Spirit, Ireland (self-disclosure) and Government of Ireland",
"stage": "official order-level disclosure and state Scoping Inquiry commitment",
"date": "2022-11-16",
"outcome": "Following a November 2022 RTÉ documentary detailing abuse at Blackrock College, the Spiritans disclosed that 233 men had made allegations of abuse against 77 priests of the order in Ireland and overseas, with 57 of those men alleging abuse specifically at Blackrock College. The Government confirmed it would establish a form of state inquiry into the allegations and the order's handling of them; the Spiritans separately began a restorative-justice programme for survivors, and the order was reported to have since paid more than €7m to 125 victims."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The 233 disclosed allegations concern pupils at Spiritan-run schools who were under the direct clerical and educational authority of the order's priests, with the congregation's own decades-long non-reporting practice, acknowledged in its 2022 disclosure, forming the institutional finding itself.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irishnews.com/news/northernirelandnews/2022/11/15/news/more_than_200_pupils_allege_abuse_by_77_priests_attached_to_order_that_runs_blackrock_college-2905062/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Irish News, 'More than 200 pupils allege abuse by 77 priests attached to order that runs Blackrock College' (2022).",
"body": "Reports the 233-allegation, 77-priest, 57-Blackrock-specific figures from the Spiritans' own disclosure.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2022/1119/1337101-inquiry-spiritans/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RTÉ News, 'Martin confirms inquiry over Spiritan abuse allegations' (2022).",
"body": "Confirms the Taoiseach's commitment to a state inquiry following the Spiritans' disclosure.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irishnews.com/news/northernirelandnews/2022/11/15/news/more_than_200_pupils_allege_abuse_by_77_priests_attached_to_order_that_runs_blackrock_college-2905062/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fb2d27f148df132798ce586279d58cfeb09e4b89eda05ce793800c7085d0d30b",
"final_url": "https://www.irishnews.com/news/northernirelandnews/2022/11/15/news/more_than_200_pupils_allege_abuse_by_77_priests_attached_to_order_that_runs_blackrock_college-2905062/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2022/1119/1337101-inquiry-spiritans/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5a6715e67ec7c63ea8441baf1099841a1ff26f76fcc115ddcce97139443a8e26",
"final_url": "https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2022/1119/1337101-inquiry-spiritans/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1032,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event record for the Abbey's own 2015 court-ordered disclosure of its internal files, not any single monk's criminal conviction — most of the 19-21 named monks were dead or never criminally prosecuted, and the record does not assert criminal guilt for any of them individually. First St John's Abbey (Collegeville) record in the corpus; distinct from the existing Ampleforth/Downside (England) Benedictine records.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-st-johns-abbey-collegeville-benedictine-disclosure-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Collegeville, Minnesota, USA",
"lat": 45.5847,
"lng": -94.3247,
"title": "United States: St John's Abbey settlement forces release of internal files naming 19 Benedictine monks credibly accused of child sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"St John's Abbey, Order of Saint Benedict, Roman Catholic monastic community operating St John's Preparatory School, Collegeville, Minnesota"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic and educational authority over students at the Abbey-run preparatory school",
"an internal External Review Board process, in place since 2003, that determined which accusations were 'credible' without criminal referral in most cases"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St John's Abbey",
"Order of Saint Benedict"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Stearns County, Minnesota civil settlement (court-ordered disclosure)",
"stage": "official institutional disclosure compelled by settlement",
"date": "2015-04-25",
"outcome": "As a condition of settling a Stearns County lawsuit brought by a man abused as a student at St John's Preparatory School in 1977, St John's Abbey released personnel files, running to roughly 15,000 pages, on 19 monks it had determined were credibly accused of sexually abusing minors. The Abbey's list, maintained by its own External Review Board process established in 2003, was later expanded further; as of subsequent updates the Abbey's own list named 21 monks credibly accused."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The named monks held authority over students at the Abbey's own preparatory school as both teachers and members of the monastic community; the finding of 'credible accusation' is the Abbey's own institutional process, published only because a civil settlement compelled its disclosure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/accountability/sexual-abuse-st-johns-abbey-revealed-15000-page-disclosure",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Catholic Reporter, 'Sexual abuse at St. John's Abbey revealed in 15,000-page disclosure' (2015).",
"body": "Reports the settlement-compelled release of files on 19 monks and the scale of the disclosed documentation.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "http://www.startribune.com/st-john-s-abbey-to-open-sex-abuse-files-on-19-monks/301556871/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Star Tribune, 'St. John's Abbey to open sex-abuse files on 19 monks in legal settlement' (2015).",
"body": "Confirms the settlement terms and the 19-monk figure at the time of the 2015 disclosure.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/accountability/sexual-abuse-st-johns-abbey-revealed-15000-page-disclosure",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c9ff7a608323923c267af4ef10daa06ddac46b6ce47a3fd1a1614fd08d6dda7f",
"final_url": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/accountability/sexual-abuse-st-johns-abbey-revealed-15000-page-disclosure"
},
{
"source": "http://www.startribune.com/st-john-s-abbey-to-open-sex-abuse-files-on-19-monks/301556871/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1033,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction spanning two proceedings (1991, 2000), entered as a single record. Distinct from the existing Dejaeger Oblate record (different perpetrator, different schools).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1991-glenn-doughty-oblate-williams-lake-kuper-island-canada",
"year": 1991,
"place": "Williams Lake and Kuper Island, British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 52.1417,
"lng": -122.1417,
"title": "Canada: Oblate brother Glenn Doughty convicted across two proceedings of sexually abusing Indigenous children at two British Columbia residential schools",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Glenn Doughty, Oblate of Mary Immaculate brother, boys' supervisor and child care worker at St Joseph's residential school, Williams Lake, and a residential school on Kuper Island, British Columbia, 1963-1972"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential supervisory authority over Indigenous children removed from their families and placed in Oblate-run residential schools",
"clerical status as a religious brother within the residential school system"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate",
"St Joseph's residential school, Williams Lake"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1991-01-01",
"outcome": "Doughty was convicted on four counts of gross indecency against four Indigenous children at St Joseph's residential school near Williams Lake and sentenced to one year in jail."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia court",
"stage": "further charges and conviction",
"date": "2000-06-01",
"outcome": "Doughty, then 62, faced 36 further charges dating from the 1960s and 1970s involving 13 young people aged six to eighteen, arising from his roles as a boys' supervisor and child care worker at St Joseph's, Williams Lake, and the residential school on Kuper Island between 1963 and 1972."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Doughty's victims were Indigenous children held in Oblate-run residential schools where he served as their direct custodial supervisor, a role inseparable from his standing as a religious brother of the order operating the schools.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/oblate-brother-faces-dozens-of-sex-charges/article4164548/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Globe and Mail, 'Oblate brother faces dozens of sex charges' (2000).",
"body": "Reports the 36 further charges, the 1963-1972 period, and the two residential schools involved, and recaps the 1991 conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/oblate-brother-facing-sex-charges-1.240961",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Oblate brother facing sex charges' (2000).",
"body": "Corroborates the charge count and victim ages for the 2000 proceeding.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/oblate-brother-faces-dozens-of-sex-charges/article4164548/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b3a6df076c24d45af095fa22c8ba59fd0eebdd62065eb5762bcaca7f070d08bc",
"final_url": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/oblate-brother-faces-dozens-of-sex-charges/article4164548/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/oblate-brother-facing-sex-charges-1.240961",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1034,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Individual criminal conviction, Canada. Distinct from Dejaeger and Doughty (different perpetrator, different institutions). First Harold McIntee record in the corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1989-harold-mcintee-oblate-british-columbia-canada",
"year": 1989,
"place": "British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 53.7267,
"lng": -127.6476,
"title": "Canada: Oblate priest Harold McIntee convicted of sexually assaulting 17 boys and young men across three decades at a residential school and two parishes",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Harold McIntee, Oblate of Mary Immaculate priest serving an Indigenous residential school and later parishes in Hope, Duncan, Terrace and Stewart, British Columbia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential dormitory access to Indigenous boys at an Oblate-run residential school",
"parish-priest authority over parishioners' children and young men after leaving the residential school system",
"targeted cultivation of trust with devout Catholic families to gain access to victims outside the school setting"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia court",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "1989-01-01",
"outcome": "McIntee pleaded guilty to 17 counts of sexual assault against boys and young men, including residential-school boys as young as ten, committed over roughly 30 years at the residential school (closed by the Oblates in 1979) and later at parishes in Hope, Duncan, Terrace and Stewart. He was sentenced to two years in jail plus three years' probation and was never removed from the priesthood."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "McIntee's earliest victims were residential-school boys under his direct dormitory supervision; after leaving the school he continued to offend against young parishioners, including one he cultivated from a devout Catholic family, using his standing as their priest to gain access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://thetyee.ca/Analysis/2025/08/15/Priest-Power-Doomed-Rape-Case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Tyee, 'A Priest and His Power: Revisiting a Doomed Rape Case' (2025).",
"body": "Details McIntee's 1989 guilty plea, the 17-count conviction, the residential school and later parishes, and the 30-year offending span.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "investigation-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://thetyee.ca/Analysis/2025/08/15/Priest-Power-Doomed-Rape-Case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "07663a370d09dd514de92012d41967a24ecadbb9e3626673c7fc2c9e53e29d26",
"final_url": "https://thetyee.ca/Analysis/2025/08/15/Priest-Power-Doomed-Rape-Case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9001,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding, not a criminal proceeding. Accused clergy not individually named in this record; the study itself is the documented finding.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-trier-diocese-abuse-report-germany",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Trier, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
"lat": 49.7499,
"lng": 6.6371,
"title": "Germany: Trier diocese's own review finds 711 victims and 234 accused, far above the national MHG study",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests, deacons and religious of the Diocese of Trier"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly and pastoral office creating access to and unchallengeable authority over parish children and dependents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Trier",
"Aufarbeitungskommission Bistum Trier"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Aufarbeitungskommission (independent review commission), Diocese of Trier, Germany",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2024-07-24",
"outcome": "The Diocese of Trier's own independent review commission, chaired by Margarete Spital, published interim findings documenting 711 victims and 234 accused perpetrators within the diocese — 369 more victims and 86 more accused than had been identified for Trier in the 2018 national MHG study. The report documents the scale of abuse within the diocese's own personnel and archival records."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were children and dependents inside the diocese's own parish and institutional structures, under the pastoral authority of priests, deacons and religious the diocese itself employed and supervised.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.aufarbeitungskommission.bistum-trier.de/export/sites/aufarbeitungskommission/.galleries/dokumente/240724_Spital_Zwischenbericht.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Aufarbeitungskommission Bistum Trier: Zwischenbericht, 24 July 2024.",
"body": "Interim report documenting 711 Betroffene (victims) and 234 Beschuldigte (accused) within the Diocese of Trier, exceeding the MHG study's diocese-level figures.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "commissioned-review"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bistum-trier.de/hilfe-soziales/hilfe-bei-sexualisierter-gewalt/aufarbeitung/index.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bistum Trier: Aufarbeitung sexualisierter Gewalt (diocesan review page).",
"body": "Diocese's own page describing the ongoing independent review process.",
"tier": "institutional-primary",
"kind": "review-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.aufarbeitungskommission.bistum-trier.de/export/sites/aufarbeitungskommission/.galleries/dokumente/240724_Spital_Zwischenbericht.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: commissioned-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1c8120e440bce7269fcfc3778b172903d394654267e7d6b32295dbfc6d36129e",
"final_url": "https://www.aufarbeitungskommission.bistum-trier.de/export/sites/aufarbeitungskommission/.galleries/dokumente/240724_Spital_Zwischenbericht.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bistum-trier.de/hilfe-soziales/hilfe-bei-sexualisierter-gewalt/aufarbeitung/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-primary; evidentiary role: review-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3f03736e633f732081b3436402689d58f7aeb86781c60fc2b8c83562d619aa67",
"final_url": "https://www.bistum-trier.de/hilfe-soziales/hilfe-bei-sexualisierter-gewalt/aufarbeitung/index.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9002,
"aliases": [
"A.L.",
"the priest known in German reporting as 69-year-old former Saarland rectory priest"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. The diocese's own admission of a 2006 handling failure is disclosed as institutional context, not asserted beyond what the diocese itself acknowledged in court.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-trier-priest-sexual-coercion-saarbrucken-germany",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Saarbrücken, Saarland, Germany",
"lat": 49.2401,
"lng": 6.9969,
"title": "Germany: Trier diocese priest convicted of sexually coercing a fourteen-year-old in his rectory",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of the Diocese of Trier serving a Saarland parish"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly office and access to the child within his own rectory"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Trier"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Landgericht Saarbrücken, Germany",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2023-02-01",
"outcome": "The Saarbrücken regional court convicted a 69-year-old priest of the Diocese of Trier of sexual coercion, finding it proven that he sexually coerced a fourteen-year-old in his parish rectory in 1997. He received one year and eight months' imprisonment on probation and a €2,500 fine payable to an organization combating the sexual exploitation of girls. The bishop of Trier acknowledged in court that the diocese had not adequately pursued the allegations when they first surfaced in 2006. The diocese's own church court in Cologne subsequently found him guilty of abusing multiple minors and dismissed him from the clerical state."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child inside the priest's own parish, and the abuse took place in the rectory the priestly office gave him control over.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/43765-bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-saar-priester-wegen-sexueller-noetigung",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de: Bewährungsstrafe für Saar-Priester wegen sexueller Nötigung.",
"body": "Report of the Landgericht Saarbrücken conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/missbrauch-kirchliche-hoechststrafe-fuer-trierer-bistumspriester",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kirche-und-Leben.de: Missbrauch: Kirchliche Höchststrafe für Trierer Bistumspriester.",
"body": "Reports the church court's dismissal from the clerical state, the maximum canonical penalty, and the bishop's courtroom admission of the diocese's 2006 handling failure.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/43765-bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-saar-priester-wegen-sexueller-noetigung",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d0c6f13d126cfbc0cd2ae5ba3c11b079fa0ed216c30e7835683a5b7ccc7b56c3",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/43765-bewaehrungsstrafe-fuer-saar-priester-wegen-sexueller-noetigung"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/missbrauch-kirchliche-hoechststrafe-fuer-trierer-bistumspriester",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "38d59808307bc2e1cb9affd2a10729d427c02e8084e07a834fcad955e404cb89",
"final_url": "https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/missbrauch-kirchliche-hoechststrafe-fuer-trierer-bistumspriester"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9003,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding. Individual accused not named in this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-mainz-diocese-weber-abuse-report-germany",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Mainz, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
"lat": 49.9929,
"lng": 8.2473,
"title": "Germany: Mainz diocese report finds 401 victims, 181 accused, and a culture that prioritised avoiding scandal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy and lay personnel of the Diocese of Mainz"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and institutional office within diocesan parishes and Caritas facilities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Mainz"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent report commissioned by the Diocese of Mainz, Germany",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2023-03-06",
"outcome": "Regensburg lawyer Ulrich Weber and his team, after reviewing roughly 25,000 pages of diocesan archival material and conducting 246 interviews, published a report finding at least 401 victims and 181 accused persons — 65% of them clergy — dating from 1945. The report found the diocese itself facilitated the abuse through inappropriate handling and lack of oversight, describing a culture of minimisation in which avoiding public scandal was prioritised over victim protection and accused clergy received institutional solidarity while victims' suffering was systematically disregarded. Only 27 of the documented cases produced criminal proceedings, resulting in prison sentences in just eight."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims were parishioners and dependents inside the diocese's own parish, school and Caritas structures, subject to the pastoral and institutional authority the diocese itself supervised.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://hpd.de/artikel/gutachten-ueber-missbrauch-im-bistum-mainz-ueber-400-betroffene-21111",
"archive": "",
"citation": "hpd.de: Gutachten über Missbrauch im Bistum Mainz: Über 400 Betroffene.",
"body": "Summary of the Weber report's findings on scale and institutional failure.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "commissioned-review-report"
},
{
"link": "https://bistummainz.de/pressemedien/pressestelle/nachrichten/nachricht/Uebersicht-zum-Thema-Sexueller-Missbrauch-im-Bistum-Mainz/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bistum Mainz: Übersicht zum Thema Sexueller Missbrauch im Bistum Mainz.",
"body": "Diocese's own summary page on its abuse review process.",
"tier": "institutional-primary",
"kind": "review-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://hpd.de/artikel/gutachten-ueber-missbrauch-im-bistum-mainz-ueber-400-betroffene-21111",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: commissioned-review-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a30b538839d705ec15321492bf83b050239366ba9218b43eea92445771b32af3",
"final_url": "https://hpd.de/artikel/gutachten-ueber-missbrauch-im-bistum-mainz-ueber-400-betroffene-21111"
},
{
"source": "https://bistummainz.de/pressemedien/pressestelle/nachrichten/nachricht/Uebersicht-zum-Thema-Sexueller-Missbrauch-im-Bistum-Mainz/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-primary; evidentiary role: review-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7675094e9c26cdee8b04afcf047c6fbe7c1eb5fd367ec99f1074899e6679a152",
"final_url": "https://bistummainz.de/pressemedien/pressestelle/nachrichten/nachricht/Uebersicht-zum-Thema-Sexueller-Missbrauch-im-Bistum-Mainz/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9004,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Priest's identity not published in accessible reporting; sentence was a fine, not imprisonment. Included for the institutional-finding backdrop it corroborates (the Weber report), disclosed here rather than treated as a major standalone case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mainz-diocese-priest-fined-dieburg-germany",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Dieburg, Hesse, Germany",
"lat": 49.8988,
"lng": 8.8404,
"title": "Germany: octogenarian Mainz diocese priest fined for a 1997 child sexual abuse offence",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of the Diocese of Mainz"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly office and pastoral access to the child"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Mainz"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Amtsgericht Dieburg, Hesse, Germany",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2025-01-01",
"outcome": "The Dieburg district court convicted a priest of the Diocese of Mainz, over eighty years old, of child sexual abuse relating to an incident in 1997, sentencing him to a fine of seventy daily rates of €100. The diocese stated it would continue its own pre-canonical investigation once the criminal judgment became final; the priest had already been barred from all priestly duties since February 2023."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a minor within the priest's pastoral reach under the diocese's own supervision.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/59020-priester-aus-bistum-mainz-wegen-missbrauchs-zu-geldstrafe-verurteilt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de: Priester aus Bistum Mainz wegen Missbrauchs zu Geldstrafe verurteilt.",
"body": "Report of the Dieburg district court's fine and the diocese's suspension of the priest since 2023.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/59020-priester-aus-bistum-mainz-wegen-missbrauchs-zu-geldstrafe-verurteilt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6349ed4abcf12a699506842ca77c241e7477c4724b884fd2da16d8ab86c770cb",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/59020-priester-aus-bistum-mainz-wegen-missbrauchs-zu-geldstrafe-verurteilt"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9005,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding. Individual accused not named in this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-wurzburg-diocese-schneider-abuse-report-germany",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Würzburg, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 49.7913,
"lng": 9.9534,
"title": "Germany: independent Würzburg diocese report finds 226 victims, most abuse unpunished before 2000",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy of the Diocese of Würzburg"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical office within diocesan parishes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Würzburg",
"Unabhängige Aufarbeitungskommission Bistum Würzburg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent Aufarbeitungskommission, Diocese of Würzburg, Germany",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2025-04-08",
"outcome": "Wiesbaden attorney Hendrik Schneider, commissioned by the diocese's independent review commission, published a report identifying 51 accused persons (43 of them clergy) and 226 victims across 1945–2019. The report found that until around 2000 institutional self-protection took precedence over pursuing abuse allegations, so that only a small fraction of perpetrators were ever convicted; the diocese states it now refers all suspicions to prosecutors."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims were parishioners and dependents under the pastoral authority of the diocese's own clergy, in a period the report itself finds the diocese prioritised institutional protection over pursuing allegations.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/60727-missbrauchsgutachten-fuer-das-bistum-wuerzburg-51-taeter-226-betroffene",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de: Missbrauchsgutachten für das Bistum Würzburg: 51 Täter, 226 Betroffene.",
"body": "Report of the Schneider commission's findings and the diocese's institutional-protection-first pattern before 2000.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "commissioned-review-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/missbrauchsgutachten-fuer-das-bistum-wuerzburg-vorgestellt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "DOMRADIO.DE: Missbrauchsgutachten für das Bistum Würzburg vorgestellt.",
"body": "Corroborating report on the same commission findings.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "commissioned-review-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/60727-missbrauchsgutachten-fuer-das-bistum-wuerzburg-51-taeter-226-betroffene",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: commissioned-review-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3fb77ab13392cd6ee8dc28c2658b9662fa23e0af59328a6f973b9b5fbdabcc36",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/60727-missbrauchsgutachten-fuer-das-bistum-wuerzburg-51-taeter-226-betroffene"
},
{
"source": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/missbrauchsgutachten-fuer-das-bistum-wuerzburg-vorgestellt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: commissioned-review-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e2bb425c98fdad5b0fa35c238199daec0b16f055b79ab4a4866c91ae51c812e1",
"final_url": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/missbrauchsgutachten-fuer-das-bistum-wuerzburg-vorgestellt"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9006,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding covering 1946–2024 caseload figures for the diocese; twelve currently-living convicted priests are noted in aggregate, not individually identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-rottenburg-stuttgart-diocese-abuse-figures-germany",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Rottenburg-Stuttgart, Baden-Württemberg, Germany",
"lat": 48.4776,
"lng": 8.9377,
"title": "Germany: Rottenburg-Stuttgart diocese's own count reaches 454 victims and 241 accused since 1946",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy and church employees of the Diocese of Rottenburg-Stuttgart"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical office within diocesan parishes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Rottenburg-Stuttgart"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Diocese of Rottenburg-Stuttgart's own case tracking, Germany",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2024-09-30",
"outcome": "The Diocese of Rottenburg-Stuttgart's own updated figures, current to 30 September 2024, documented 241 accused persons and 454 victims of sexualised violence by church employees since 1946. The diocese separately disclosed that twelve priests convicted of sexual offences currently live within the diocese, eight of them under restrictions, retired or suspended from all pastoral work, and four still serving in non-leading pastoral roles."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims were parishioners and dependents under the pastoral authority of clergy the diocese itself supervised and, in several cases, continues to place in ministry.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/57134-dioezese-rottenburg-stuttgart-aktualisiert-missbrauchszahlen",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de: Diözese Rottenburg-Stuttgart aktualisiert Missbrauchszahlen.",
"body": "Report of the diocese's updated abuse figures and the twelve currently-living convicted priests.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "institutional-disclosure-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/57134-dioezese-rottenburg-stuttgart-aktualisiert-missbrauchszahlen",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: institutional-disclosure-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "06b3030b2581dc5446bca09d1cbe2ffad55259e618291f16d1ef1f46aef9f2b2",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/57134-dioezese-rottenburg-stuttgart-aktualisiert-missbrauchszahlen"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9007,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding, academic study. Individual accused not named in this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-speyer-diocese-schraut-abuse-study-germany",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Speyer, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
"lat": 49.3175,
"lng": 8.4322,
"title": "Germany: University of Mannheim study finds 150 suspected Speyer diocese perpetrators, children's homes as 'hotspots'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests, religious and church employees of the Diocese of Speyer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical office and residential-institution authority within diocesan children's homes and parishes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Speyer",
"University of Mannheim"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent academic study commissioned for the Diocese of Speyer, Germany",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2025-05-08",
"outcome": "A University of Mannheim team led by historian Sylvia Schraut published a roughly 473-page study identifying 150 suspected perpetrators — 109 priests and 41 church employees, including some nuns — since 1946. The study found church structures substantially facilitated abuse through lack of oversight and authoritarian leadership, identified diocesan children's homes as abuse 'hotspots,' and found twelve perpetrators had been convicted or fined by the time of publication, with half of all documented cases dating to the 1950s–60s."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims were children in diocesan-run homes and parishioners under the pastoral authority of clergy and staff the diocese itself employed and supervised.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/61463-missbrauchsstudie-fuer-das-bistum-speyer-150-mutmassliche-taeter",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de: Missbrauchsstudie für das Bistum Speyer: 150 mutmaßliche Täter.",
"body": "Report of the Schraut study's findings on scale, children's-home hotspots and twelve prior convictions/fines.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "commissioned-review-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/61463-missbrauchsstudie-fuer-das-bistum-speyer-150-mutmassliche-taeter",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: commissioned-review-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "72525fd6043d6ed6a9b160379544c353e6f802e788dbb5f951a9fda592683d27",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/61463-missbrauchsstudie-fuer-das-bistum-speyer-150-mutmassliche-taeter"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9008,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding, academic/legal study. Individual accused not named in this record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-essen-diocese-ipp-abuse-report-germany",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Essen, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 51.4556,
"lng": 7.0116,
"title": "Germany: Essen diocese's legal review of personnel files names 62 accused priests, deacons and staff",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priests, one deacon, religious-order priests and lay employees of the Diocese of Essen"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and diaconal office within diocesan parishes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Essen",
"Institut für Praxisforschung und Projektberatung (IPP), Munich"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent legal review commissioned by the Diocese of Essen, Germany",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2017-11-01",
"outcome": "A commissioned legal investigation of all personnel files of the Diocese of Essen, published November 2017, documented 62 accused or convicted diocesan priests, one deacon, six religious-order priests and four lay employees. A follow-on sociological study by the Munich IPP institute, running since March 2020, further examined the diocese's institutional handling. Reporting also documented at least one case where a priest was returned to parish ministry despite a prior conviction and an expert report warning against work with children."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims were parishioners and dependents under the pastoral and diaconal authority of clergy the diocese itself supervised and, in a documented instance, reassigned to further ministry despite known risk.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bistum-essen.de/fileadmin/relaunch/Bilder/Soziales_und_Hilfe/Sexueller_Missbrauch/ipp/230213_IPP_Studie_Bistum_Essen_final.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IPP München: Sozialwissenschaftliche Aufarbeitung sexuellen Missbrauchs im Bistum Essen.",
"body": "The commissioned sociological study of institutional handling of abuse in the Diocese of Essen.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "commissioned-review"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bistum-essen.de/hilfe-bei-sexualisierter-gewalt/sozialwissenschaftliche-aufarbeitung-sexuellen-missbrauchs-im-bistum-essen",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bistum Essen: Sozialwissenschaftliche Aufarbeitung sexuellen Missbrauchs im Bistum Essen.",
"body": "Diocese's own summary of the 2017 legal review and IPP study.",
"tier": "institutional-primary",
"kind": "review-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bistum-essen.de/fileadmin/relaunch/Bilder/Soziales_und_Hilfe/Sexueller_Missbrauch/ipp/230213_IPP_Studie_Bistum_Essen_final.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: commissioned-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "299205a5bf21237b5f81dd290714b16c507b3b964524d1ae6747d82950aa568f",
"final_url": "https://www.bistum-essen.de/fileadmin/relaunch/Bilder/Soziales_und_Hilfe/Sexueller_Missbrauch/ipp/230213_IPP_Studie_Bistum_Essen_final.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bistum-essen.de/hilfe-bei-sexualisierter-gewalt/sozialwissenschaftliche-aufarbeitung-sexuellen-missbrauchs-im-bistum-essen",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-primary; evidentiary role: review-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4d76c6ab64bd1fe9e483dbc89fd46b2327734e5b5cef83615d1d0e75d4fecace",
"final_url": "https://www.bistum-essen.de/hilfe-bei-sexualisierter-gewalt/sozialwissenschaftliche-aufarbeitung-sexuellen-missbrauchs-im-bistum-essen"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9009,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "revision",
"date": "2024-09-03",
"note": "Bavarian Supreme Court (Bayerisches Oberstes Landesgericht) rejected the priest's appeal as unfounded; conviction final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Priest's name not published in accessible reporting; identified only by diocese and court venue. Minor victim, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-augsburg-diocese-priest-conviction-ingolstadt-germany",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ingolstadt, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 48.7665,
"lng": 11.4257,
"title": "Germany: Augsburg diocese priest's conviction for abusing a dependent becomes final on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of the Diocese of Augsburg"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical office and pastoral authority over a person in his care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Augsburg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Amtsgericht Pfaffenhofen an der Ilm (first instance) and Landgericht Ingolstadt (appeal), Bavaria, Germany",
"stage": "conviction; final after the Bavarian Supreme Court rejected further appeal",
"date": "2024-03-01",
"outcome": "A priest of the Diocese of Augsburg was convicted of sexual abuse of a person in his care. The Pfaffenhofen an der Ilm district court sentenced him in March 2023 to eight months' imprisonment; the Ingolstadt regional court modified this on appeal in March 2024 to a suspended sentence with conditions, including €5,000 payable to the victim and €5,000 to charity, plus mandatory continued therapy. On 3 September 2024 the Bavarian Supreme Court in Munich rejected his further appeal as unfounded, making the conviction final. The priest was relieved of his duties; an ecclesiastical investigation continued separately."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a person under the priest's pastoral care, within the authority relationship his clerical office in the diocese created.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/55746-missbrauchsprozess-gericht-verwirft-revision-von-augsburger-priester",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de: Missbrauchsprozess: Gericht verwirft Revision von Augsburger Priester.",
"body": "Report of the Bavarian Supreme Court's rejection of the priest's appeal, making the conviction final.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/gericht-verwirft-priester-revision-missbrauchs-prozess",
"archive": "",
"citation": "DOMRADIO.DE: Gericht verwirft Priester-Revision im Missbrauchsprozess.",
"body": "Corroborating report of the same final appellate disposition.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "revision",
"date": "2024-09-03",
"note": "Bavarian Supreme Court (Bayerisches Oberstes Landesgericht) rejected the priest's appeal as unfounded; conviction final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/55746-missbrauchsprozess-gericht-verwirft-revision-von-augsburger-priester",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "19173dc80bc9b00be1e6703e9a2d7a87cf111465863dc7efc20037a15f65b382",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/55746-missbrauchsprozess-gericht-verwirft-revision-von-augsburger-priester"
},
{
"source": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/gericht-verwirft-priester-revision-missbrauchs-prozess",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b3dccd4d188b5ab86246b794fd954748dbb7e43cb8d78e3a1c92b6b6cded1b32",
"final_url": "https://www.domradio.de/artikel/gericht-verwirft-priester-revision-missbrauchs-prozess"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9010,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding, academic study. Individual accused not named in this record; one specific 1969-convicted-then-reinstated priest is referenced anonymously in press coverage as 'N.' and is not separately entered.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-paderborn-archdiocese-priesching-hartig-abuse-study-germany",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Paderborn, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany",
"lat": 51.7189,
"lng": 8.7575,
"title": "Germany: five-year Paderborn archdiocese study finds 210 accused and 489 victims, nearly double prior counts",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic clergy of the Archdiocese of Paderborn"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical office within archdiocesan parishes; documented practice of reassigning known abusers to new pastoral posts without informing receiving parishes"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Paderborn",
"University of Paderborn"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent historical study, University of Paderborn, commissioned by the Archdiocese of Paderborn, Germany",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2026-03-12",
"outcome": "A five-year study by Prof. Nicole Priesching and Dr. Christine Hartig, covering the archbishoprics of Lorenz Jaeger and Johannes Joachim Degenhardt (1941–2002) and published 12 March 2026, found evidence of 210 suspected perpetrators and 489 victims — nearly double figures previously assumed. The study documented a pattern in which accused clergy and diocesan officials, including archbishops, pressured victims and families to refrain from filing charges, and found that at least one priest criminally convicted in 1969 of indecency with minors was returned to pastoral ministry from 1971 to 2008 without receiving parishes being informed of his history."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims were parishioners and dependents under the pastoral authority of archdiocesan clergy, in a pattern the study itself documents as including institutional pressure on victims to stay silent and reassignment of known abusers into fresh pastoral authority over new children.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.uni-paderborn.de/nachricht/157038",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Universität Paderborn: Studie zum Missbrauch Minderjähriger im Erzbistum Paderborn: Ergebnisse legen Vertuschungsspiralen offen.",
"body": "University press release on the Priesching/Hartig study's findings on scale and cover-up patterns.",
"tier": "academic-institutional",
"kind": "commissioned-review-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/53680-paderborn-missbrauchstaeter-jahrzehntelang-als-seelsorger-eingesetzt",
"archive": "",
"citation": "katholisch.de: Paderborn: Missbrauchstäter jahrzehntelang als Seelsorger eingesetzt.",
"body": "Report on the 1969-convicted priest reinstated to pastoral ministry for decades without disclosure to receiving parishes.",
"tier": "religious-press",
"kind": "commissioned-review-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.uni-paderborn.de/nachricht/157038",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: academic-institutional; evidentiary role: commissioned-review-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6a2dc4a098e57aa69fb059bdadac1a7cc599f6e9063787964c8b3e66474e0def",
"final_url": "https://www.uni-paderborn.de/nachricht/157038"
},
{
"source": "https://www.katholisch.de/artikel/53680-paderborn-missbrauchstaeter-jahrzehntelang-als-seelsorger-eingesetzt",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press; evidentiary role: commissioned-review-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cf98077d76de14215d3f714145e17b681f16d69cb235f7a72af203ab09614819",
"final_url": "https://katholisch.de/artikel/53680-paderborn-missbrauchstaeter-jahrzehntelang-als-seelsorger-eingesetzt"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9011,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional finding covering a documented case (Georg M., deceased 2019) and diocesan handling; the accused himself was never criminally convicted and died before any proceeding, so this record is entered as the institutional finding, not as a personal conviction record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-hildesheim-diocese-rosenbusch-abuse-report-germany",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Hildesheim, Lower Saxony, Germany",
"lat": 52.1508,
"lng": 9.9511,
"title": "Germany: Hildesheim diocese report finds bishop and personnel director transferred a known-accused priest rather than act",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of the Diocese of Hildesheim; diocesan bishop and personnel director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical office within diocesan parishes; institutional decision to relocate the accused rather than remove him from ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Hildesheim"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent investigation report commissioned by the Diocese of Hildesheim, Germany",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2021-06-17",
"outcome": "An independent investigation report (Rosenbusch), published 17 June 2021, found that a diocesan priest identified as Georg M. sexually abused five children entrusted to his pastoral care. The report found that Bishop Dr Josef Homeyer and personnel director Werner Holst, on being informed by the Salzgitter youth welfare office of abuse allegations against the priest, transferred him in 1992 from the Christ König parish in Salzgitter-Bad to St Marien parish in Cuxhaven rather than removing him from ministry. The priest died in 2019 without ever facing criminal prosecution."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The five victims were children entrusted to the priest's pastoral care within the diocese's own parish structure; the diocese's own commissioned report finds its leadership responded to a credible report by relocating him to a new parish of unwarned children rather than acting to stop him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bistum-hildesheim.de/fileadmin/dateien/PDFs/missbrauch/Untersuchungsbericht-Endfassung-anonymisiert_20210617_01.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bistum Hildesheim: Untersuchungsbericht (Rosenbusch), 17 June 2021.",
"body": "The commissioned investigation report documenting the Georg M. case and the diocese's 1992 transfer decision.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "commissioned-review"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bistum-hildesheim.de/fileadmin/dateien/PDFs/missbrauch/Untersuchungsbericht-Endfassung-anonymisiert_20210617_01.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: commissioned-review.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b479d740f88a00cdfb2e3f8f48c0db525456324762070fa8ad07e7afff99285e",
"final_url": "https://www.bistum-hildesheim.de/fileadmin/dateien/PDFs/missbrauch/Untersuchungsbericht-Endfassung-anonymisiert_20210617_01.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9012,
"aliases": [
"Don Roberto Mastro"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2025-09-25",
"note": "Third Section of the Court of Cassation declared the defence appeal inadmissible; sentence final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Diocese not confirmed in accessible reporting and not asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-roberto-mastro-priest-belcastro-calabria-italy",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Belcastro, Catanzaro, Calabria, Italy",
"lat": 39.0136,
"lng": 16.6144,
"title": "Italy: Calabria parish priest's conviction for sexually abusing seventeen parish children becomes final",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest of Belcastro"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish priest's office and access to children through parish activities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunale di Catanzaro (trial), Corte d'Appello di Catanzaro (appeal), Corte di Cassazione, Terza Sezione (final), Italy",
"stage": "conviction, final",
"date": "2025-09-25",
"outcome": "Don Roberto Mastro, parish priest of Belcastro until he abruptly left the parish in December 2010, was convicted of sexually abusing approximately seventeen minors of his parish between 2007 and 2010. He was sentenced to thirteen years and six months at first instance, reduced to eleven years and six months on appeal, plus interdiction from public office and restitution to victims. On 25 September 2025 the Third Section of the Court of Cassation declared his defence's appeal inadmissible, making the conviction final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Victims were children of his own parish, accessed through the trust and access his office as their priest created.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/09/26/violenza-sessuale-su-17-ragazzini-ex-parroco-di-belcastro-condannato-a-11-anni-e-sei-mesi-in-cassazione/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rete L'Abuso: Violenza sessuale su 17 ragazzini: ex parroco di Belcastro condannato a 11 anni e sei mesi in Cassazione.",
"body": "Report of the Cassazione's final rejection of the appeal.",
"tier": "specialist-advocacy-press",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.catanzaroinforma.it/cronaca/2025/09/25/belcastro-ex-parroco-condannato-in-via-definitiva-per-violenza-sessuale-su-minori/387881",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CatanzaroInforma: Belcastro, ex parroco condannato in via definitiva per violenza sessuale su minori.",
"body": "Report naming Don Roberto Mastro, describing the timeline 2007–2010 and the final Cassazione ruling.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2025-09-25",
"note": "Third Section of the Court of Cassation declared the defence appeal inadmissible; sentence final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/09/26/violenza-sessuale-su-17-ragazzini-ex-parroco-di-belcastro-condannato-a-11-anni-e-sei-mesi-in-cassazione/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-advocacy-press; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "02aca525dffd9ac0fe9bcd85f4713ba1200218e5b0c03b85f6de73c1eab363ef",
"final_url": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/09/26/violenza-sessuale-su-17-ragazzini-ex-parroco-di-belcastro-condannato-a-11-anni-e-sei-mesi-in-cassazione/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.catanzaroinforma.it/cronaca/2025/09/25/belcastro-ex-parroco-condannato-in-via-definitiva-per-violenza-sessuale-su-minori/387881",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "abba49401bd2e25ece68952e18597b62f74cfeb62303fb766bf91f61b7c4bc8c",
"final_url": "https://www.catanzaroinforma.it/cronaca/2025/09/25/belcastro-ex-parroco-condannato-in-via-definitiva-per-violenza-sessuale-su-minori/387881"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9013,
"aliases": [
"Don Livio Graziano"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2024-05-30",
"note": "First Criminal Section of the Court of Cassation rejected the defence appeal as inadmissible; sentence final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not identified. Diocese not confirmed in accessible reporting and not asserted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-livio-graziano-priest-avellino-campania-italy",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Avellino, Campania, Italy",
"lat": 40.9144,
"lng": 14.793,
"title": "Italy: priest's conviction for abusing a thirteen-year-old boy in a residential community becomes final",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest with pastoral responsibility at a residential community for minors"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly office and access within the residential community housing the boy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunale di Avellino (trial), Corte d'Appello (appeal), Corte di Cassazione, Prima Sezione Penale (final), Italy",
"stage": "conviction, final",
"date": "2024-05-30",
"outcome": "Don Livio Graziano was convicted of sexual violence against a thirteen-year-old boy placed in a residential community, sentenced to eight years' imprisonment. He was arrested on 26 October 2021 after the boy's father discovered suspicious messages and a behavioural change following his son's placement; carabinieri found nude images of the boy and a substantial sum of cash on the priest. On 30 May 2024 the First Criminal Section of the Court of Cassation confirmed the sentence, rejecting the defence's appeal as inadmissible."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child under the priest's pastoral responsibility within the residential community where the priest had placed and continuing access to him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://retelabuso.org/2024/05/29/don-livio-graziano-condannato-a-8-anni-in-via-definitiva/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rete L'Abuso: Don Livio Graziano condannato a 8 anni in via definitiva.",
"body": "Report of the final Cassazione conviction.",
"tier": "specialist-advocacy-press",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ottopagine.it/av/cronaca/358621/abusi-sessuali-su-minore-confermata-la-condanna-a-8-anni-per-don-livio-graziano.shtml",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ottopagine Avellino: Abusi sessuali su minore: confermata la condanna a 8 anni per Don Livio Graziano.",
"body": "Report with case background including the 2021 arrest and evidence found.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2024-05-30",
"note": "First Criminal Section of the Court of Cassation rejected the defence appeal as inadmissible; sentence final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://retelabuso.org/2024/05/29/don-livio-graziano-condannato-a-8-anni-in-via-definitiva/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-advocacy-press; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "391bb995d58caef55d7d69f7134f5176cbab7ad13346a43c0ff4fc522e9ef8ad",
"final_url": "https://retelabuso.org/2024/05/29/don-livio-graziano-condannato-a-8-anni-in-via-definitiva/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ottopagine.it/av/cronaca/358621/abusi-sessuali-su-minore-confermata-la-condanna-a-8-anni-per-don-livio-graziano.shtml",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ef113c3ce58e05c1310f7e8925ed1e5ee3acdff81fb1c9d71cdf00ff8e95780c",
"final_url": "https://www.ottopagine.it/av/cronaca/358621/abusi-sessuali-su-minore-confermata-la-condanna-a-8-anni-per-don-livio-graziano.shtml"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9014,
"aliases": [
"Don Giorgio Barbacini"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2010",
"note": "Court of Cassation confirmed the sentence definitively; the priest remained a fugitive abroad until his 2015 arrest."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, an unaccompanied foreign national; not identified by name in reporting.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-giorgio-barbacini-priest-savona-liguria-italy",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Savona, Liguria, Italy",
"lat": 44.309,
"lng": 8.4772,
"title": "Italy: Savona-Noli diocese priest's conviction for abusing a migrant minor in his custody, final since 2010",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest responsible for the diocese's 'Migrantes' programme for unaccompanied foreign minors"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial and pastoral authority over a foreign minor placed in his care by the diocese"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Savona-Noli"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunale di Savona (trial), Corte di Cassazione (final), Italy",
"stage": "conviction, final",
"date": "2004-10-15",
"outcome": "Don Giorgio Barbacini, the priest responsible for the Savona curia's 'Migrantes' community for unaccompanied foreign minors, was convicted on 15 October 2004 of abusing a minor placed in his custody, with the abuse dated to spring 2000. He received three years and six months' imprisonment, with the aggravating factor that the victim had been formally entrusted to his custody. The Court of Cassation confirmed the sentence definitively in 2010; Barbacini had by then fled abroad and remained a fugitive until his arrest in 2015 at age 79. He was subsequently laicised."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a foreign minor formally placed in the priest's custody by the diocese's own migrant-care programme — an authority relationship the court itself treated as an aggravating factor.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://alassiofutura.blogspot.com/2015/06/savona-arrestato-don-giorgio-barbacini.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "AlassioFutura: Savona - Arrestato don Giorgio Barbacini: era latitante da tempo. Nove anni dopo la condanna in Cassazione si chiude con l'arresto il primo scandalo per pedofilia della diocesi Savona-Noli.",
"body": "Report tracing the 2004 conviction, 2010 Cassazione finality, and 2015 arrest as a fugitive.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "final-disposition-and-arrest-report"
},
{
"link": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/11/04/abusi-sessuali-del-clero-in-liguria-69-casi-in-25-anni-in-5-condannati-in-via-definitiva/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rete L'Abuso: Abusi sessuali del clero, in Liguria 69 casi in 25 anni: in 5 condannati in via definitiva.",
"body": "Regional survey confirming Barbacini as one of five definitively-convicted Liguria clergy, with custody/guardianship noted as an aggravating factor.",
"tier": "specialist-advocacy-press",
"kind": "survey-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2010",
"note": "Court of Cassation confirmed the sentence definitively; the priest remained a fugitive abroad until his 2015 arrest."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://alassiofutura.blogspot.com/2015/06/savona-arrestato-don-giorgio-barbacini.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: final-disposition-and-arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d4a9586cfef96fdef3fbd6142e8dbad8cc5cfd16d3cd04539b22e18714811310",
"final_url": "https://alassiofutura.blogspot.com/2015/06/savona-arrestato-don-giorgio-barbacini.html"
},
{
"source": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/11/04/abusi-sessuali-del-clero-in-liguria-69-casi-in-25-anni-in-5-condannati-in-via-definitiva/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-advocacy-press; evidentiary role: survey-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "578a15de7c9679a71711e04107c874fad2b9d6b2dcdefec36d1edd766c4fc0df",
"final_url": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/11/04/abusi-sessuali-del-clero-in-liguria-69-casi-in-25-anni-in-5-condannati-in-via-definitiva/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9015,
"aliases": [
"Don Luciano Massaferro"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2013",
"note": "Court of Cassation confirmed the sentence definitively."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, an altar server, not identified by name. The 2018 ecclesiastical acquittal is disclosed precisely as a contrast with the definitive civil conviction, per this project's standing practice of not letting canonical outcomes overwrite adjudicated criminal findings.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-luciano-massaferro-priest-alassio-liguria-italy",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Alassio, Savona, Liguria, Italy",
"lat": 44.0067,
"lng": 8.1728,
"title": "Italy: Albenga-Imperia diocese priest's conviction for abusing an altar server stands, though the church later cleared him",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest of San Vincenzo e San Giovanni, Alassio"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish priest's office and access to a child serving as altar server in his own parish"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Albenga-Imperia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Italian criminal courts through the Corte di Cassazione, Italy",
"stage": "conviction, final",
"date": "2009-01-01",
"outcome": "Don Luciano Massaferro, parish priest of San Vincenzo e San Giovanni in Alassio, was convicted of sexually abusing a young altar server of his parish and sentenced to seven years and eight months' imprisonment, arrested on 29 December 2009. The Court of Cassation confirmed the sentence definitively in 2013, and he was released in early 2016 on good-conduct credit."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was an altar server of the priest's own parish, whose access to and unchallengeable authority over the child arose directly from his priestly office.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/11/04/abusi-sessuali-del-clero-in-liguria-69-casi-in-25-anni-in-5-condannati-in-via-definitiva/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rete L'Abuso: Abusi sessuali del clero, in Liguria 69 casi in 25 anni: in 5 condannati in via definitiva.",
"body": "Regional survey listing Massaferro among five definitively-convicted Liguria clergy, with sentence and timeline.",
"tier": "specialist-advocacy-press",
"kind": "survey-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2018/02/27/alassio-prete-condannato-per-pedofilia-in-via-definitiva-ma-tribunale-ecclesiastico-lo-assolve-innocente-celebri-messa/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Il Fatto Quotidiano: Alassio, prete condannato per pedofilia in via definitiva. Ma tribunale ecclesiastico lo assolve: \"Innocente, celebri messa\".",
"body": "Reports the 2018 ecclesiastical tribunal's acquittal and reinstatement to public ministry, contrasted explicitly with the standing definitive criminal conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "contrast-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "cassazione",
"date": "2013",
"note": "Court of Cassation confirmed the sentence definitively."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/11/04/abusi-sessuali-del-clero-in-liguria-69-casi-in-25-anni-in-5-condannati-in-via-definitiva/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-advocacy-press; evidentiary role: survey-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "578a15de7c9679a71711e04107c874fad2b9d6b2dcdefec36d1edd766c4fc0df",
"final_url": "https://retelabuso.org/2025/11/04/abusi-sessuali-del-clero-in-liguria-69-casi-in-25-anni-in-5-condannati-in-via-definitiva/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2018/02/27/alassio-prete-condannato-per-pedofilia-in-via-definitiva-ma-tribunale-ecclesiastico-lo-assolve-innocente-celebri-messa/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: contrast-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "020d7100bbd68c14d9910338a843d7fbd0628d5a0ca67f420250a699b47b7232",
"final_url": "https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/2018/02/27/alassio-prete-condannato-per-pedofilia-in-via-definitiva-ma-tribunale-ecclesiastico-lo-assolve-innocente-celebri-messa/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9016,
"aliases": [
"Nilton Bustamante"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, not identified. Convicted via an agreed sentence (conformidad), immediately final under Spanish procedure.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-nilton-bustamante-priest-cuenca-castilla-la-mancha-spain",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Cuenca, Castilla-La Mancha, Spain",
"lat": 40.0704,
"lng": -2.1374,
"title": "Spain: Cuenca parish priest's final conviction for abusing three children using church property as access",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic parish priest in Cuenca province"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish priest's office and the parental trust it commanded, used to access children in church-owned properties"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Spain, criminal court, Cuenca province",
"stage": "conviction by agreed sentence (conformidad), final",
"date": "2024-04-11",
"outcome": "Parish priest Nilton Bustamante was convicted, by an agreed sentence between the parties (making it immediately final), of sexually abusing two thirteen-year-olds (one girl, one boy) and a fifteen-year-old girl. He received four years' imprisonment with suspended execution subject to conditions, a nineteen-year prohibition on working with minors, a 200-metre approach restriction from the victims for ten years, mandatory sex-education coursework and community service, and exclusion from the locality where the offences occurred. The court found he exploited his position as parish priest and the trust placed in him by the children's parents to commit the abuse in church-owned properties."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were children of his parish, accessed on church property through the trust his office as their priest secured from their parents.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lasnoticiasdecuenca.es/cuenca/condenado-cuatro-anos-prision-cura-acusado-abusos-sexuales-menores-cuenca-73171",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Las Noticias de Cuenca: Condenado a cuatro años de prisión el cura acusado de abusos sexuales a menores.",
"body": "Report of Bustamante's agreed-sentence conviction, naming him, describing the church-property access and parental-trust mechanism, and confirming the sentence is firme (final).",
"tier": "regional-newspaper",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lasnoticiasdecuenca.es/cuenca/condenado-cuatro-anos-prision-cura-acusado-abusos-sexuales-menores-cuenca-73171",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "65ac691a27c9640ec7c7b68f69b079b74e4d5f2524ad6fb438b9ca9426fd65d0",
"final_url": "https://www.lasnoticiasdecuenca.es/cuenca/condenado-cuatro-anos-prision-cura-acusado-abusos-sexuales-menores-cuenca-73171"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9017,
"aliases": [
"José Luis Portela",
"José Luis Portela Trigo"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "apelación",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Audiencia Provincial de Pontevedra confirmed the conviction on appeal."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Adult victim, a 42-year-old parishioner, named in some press coverage; not repeated here.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-jose-luis-portela-priest-exorcist-vigo-galicia-spain",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Vigo area, Galicia, Spain",
"lat": 42.2406,
"lng": -8.7207,
"title": "Spain: prominent Galician exorcist priest's conviction for sexually assaulting a parishioner in the sacristy is confirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of San Campio parish; Spain's most prominent practising exorcist"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"exorcist/spiritual-authority framing ('God wants you to be well') used during the assault; pastoral access to a parishioner within the church sacristy"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Spain, criminal court (first instance) and Audiencia Provincial de Pontevedra (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction, confirmed on appeal",
"date": "2016-09-17",
"outcome": "José Luis Portela, a 74-year-old priest and Galicia's best-known exorcist, was convicted of sexually assaulting a 42-year-old parishioner in the sacristy of his church in August 2014, where he embraced her, put his hands under her clothing, and told her 'God wants you to be well' while kissing her. He was sentenced to one year's imprisonment (suspended as a first-time offender with a sub-two-year term) and ordered to pay €4,000 compensation. The Audiencia Provincial de Pontevedra confirmed the conviction on appeal. The church expelled him from his parish of 47 years and from exorcism duties following the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a parishioner assaulted inside the church sacristy by the parish's own priest, who invoked religious framing ('God wants you to be well') in the act itself — spiritual authority operating as both the access mechanism and the language of the assault.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elespanol.com/reportajes/grandes-historias/20160917/156234891_0.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Español: El principal exorcista de España, condenado por abuso sexual.",
"body": "Report of the conviction, the sacristy assault, the 'God wants you to be well' quote, and the sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.elespanol.com/reportajes/20170510/214979123_0.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Español: El principal exorcista de España será expulsado de la Iglesia por abusos sexuales.",
"body": "Report confirming the Audiencia Provincial de Pontevedra upheld the conviction on appeal and the church's expulsion of Portela from ministry and exorcism duties.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "apelación",
"date": "2016",
"note": "Audiencia Provincial de Pontevedra confirmed the conviction on appeal."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elespanol.com/reportajes/grandes-historias/20160917/156234891_0.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dc5fcd017a73e5f76b54aaab387fe9e31e843e2dd41208b02576598b88435ab4",
"final_url": "https://www.elespanol.com/reportajes/grandes-historias/20160917/156234891_0.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.elespanol.com/reportajes/20170510/214979123_0.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "75d973b42eb6e3a8b69aa9ef0cf872d3c54024dfe7816931fa894440eaffcbe6",
"final_url": "https://www.elespanol.com/reportajes/20170510/214979123_0.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9018,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Priest's name not published in this reporting; identified only by former role. Not final — priest did not appeal, per the source, so treated as final under Spanish procedure (no appeal filed within the statutory window).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-bilbao-diocese-priest-scout-camp-abuse-basque-country-spain",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Uribe Kosta, Biscay, Basque Country, Spain",
"lat": 43.3667,
"lng": -2.9833,
"title": "Spain: Bilbao diocese priest's conviction for abusing scout monitors at parish summer camps, unappealed and final",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, former vicar of the Uribe Kosta parish grouping, Diocese of Bilbao"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish vicar's authority over scout troop monitors under parish-run scouting activities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Bilbao"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Audiencia Provincial de Burgos, Spain",
"stage": "conviction, final (unappealed)",
"date": "2023-07-19",
"outcome": "A former parish vicar of the Uribe Kosta grouping in the Diocese of Bilbao was convicted on 19 July 2023 of sexually abusing two female scout troop monitors during summer camps in 2015 and 2016 — one a minor, one an adult. He received fourteen months' imprisonment for the abuse of the minor and an eighteen-month fine for the abuse of the adult, with €4,000 compensation to each victim and the Diocese of Bilbao declared subsidiarily liable. He did not appeal. The diocese had already removed him from public ministry on 4 December 2018 and reported the matter to prosecutors three days later, before the victims' own complaint was filed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were scout troop monitors under the parish's own scouting programme, within the pastoral authority the vicar held over parish youth activities.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eldiario.es/euskadi/cura-vizcaino-condenado-abusar-monitoras-scouts_1_10612356.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Diario (Euskadi): Un cura vizcaíno, condenado por abusar de dos monitoras de los 'scouts'.",
"body": "Report of the conviction, sentence, diocesan liability finding, and the diocese's own prior removal and 2018 report to prosecutors.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eldiario.es/euskadi/cura-vizcaino-condenado-abusar-monitoras-scouts_1_10612356.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "555f1e413c191589c7aa6646bce00dcbc0500068133edc85a1e3f2a0538869ad",
"final_url": "https://www.eldiario.es/euskadi/cura-vizcaino-condenado-abusar-monitoras-scouts_1_10612356.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9019,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "apelación (Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Castilla y León)",
"date": "2021",
"note": "TSJ Castilla y León confirmed the Audiencia Provincial de Valladolid's conviction."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, aged 13 to 16 during the offence, not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-valladolid-priest-cyber-abuse-castilla-y-leon-spain",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Valladolid, Castilla y León, Spain",
"lat": 41.6523,
"lng": -4.7245,
"title": "Spain: Valladolid priest's conviction for grooming and sexually abusing a minor parishioner confirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of Nuestra Señora de las Angustias parish, Valladolid"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish priest's pastoral relationship with a minor parishioner, exploited via private messaging"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Audiencia Provincial de Valladolid (trial), Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Castilla y León (appeal), Spain",
"stage": "conviction, confirmed on appeal",
"date": "2021-05-03",
"outcome": "A priest of the Nuestra Señora de las Angustias parish in Valladolid was convicted of cyber-harassment of a minor under sixteen and sexual abuse of a minor under sixteen, after he began sexually explicit WhatsApp conversations in December 2019 with a thirteen-year-old parishioner, continuing until she was sixteen. He was sentenced to three years' imprisonment and barred from approaching the victim within 500 metres. The Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Castilla y León confirmed the sentence on appeal; he served time and was released on parole after three-quarters of the sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a minor parishioner of the priest's own church, whose access to her arose from and was sustained through his pastoral role in her parish.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elespanol.com/castilla-y-leon/sociedad/20210503/confirmada-sentencia-condena-valladolid-carcel-sexual-ciberacoso/578443538_0.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Español (Castilla y León): Confirmada la sentencia que condena a un cura de Valladolid a tres años de cárcel por abuso sexual y ciberacoso a una menor.",
"body": "Report of the TSJ Castilla y León's confirmation of the sentence, the parish name, and the WhatsApp grooming timeline.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.eldiario.es/castilla-y-leon/justicia-confirma-pena-prision-tres-anos-carcel-cura-valladolid-abusar-ciberacosar-menor_1_7893189.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Diario (Castilla y León): La Justicia confirma la pena de tres años de cárcel a un cura de Valladolid por abusar y ciberacosar a una menor.",
"body": "Corroborating report of the confirmed sentence.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper",
"kind": "final-disposition-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "apelación (Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Castilla y León)",
"date": "2021",
"note": "TSJ Castilla y León confirmed the Audiencia Provincial de Valladolid's conviction."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elespanol.com/castilla-y-leon/sociedad/20210503/confirmada-sentencia-condena-valladolid-carcel-sexual-ciberacoso/578443538_0.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d11de4a32e37abd1af105afdb6c87c49bc9bda128f13ccacb7a5d74991240340",
"final_url": "https://www.elespanol.com/castilla-y-leon/sociedad/20210503/confirmada-sentencia-condena-valladolid-carcel-sexual-ciberacoso/578443538_0.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.eldiario.es/castilla-y-leon/justicia-confirma-pena-prision-tres-anos-carcel-cura-valladolid-abusar-ciberacosar-menor_1_7893189.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper; evidentiary role: final-disposition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6fce67061b12f2cba0114a8f74aa5f770bd2e3ca9bdfcce6012e346a810308e0",
"final_url": "https://www.eldiario.es/castilla-y-leon/justicia-confirma-pena-prision-tres-anos-carcel-cura-valladolid-abusar-ciberacosar-menor_1_7893189.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1054,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim not identified. Khan had a prior 2011 conviction (16 years, Stoke-on-Trent) for sexually assaulting two boys at another mosque; that is background, not a separate record. This entry concerns only the Bradford (Sunbridge Road) offences and conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mohammed-hanif-khan-bradford-uk",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Bradford, West Yorkshire, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.796,
"lng": -1.7594,
"title": "United Kingdom: Bradford imam jailed 13 years for repeatedly raping a boy at his mosque",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam at a mosque on Sunbridge Road, Bradford"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"grooming a child through his position as imam",
"religious-authority access to a child at the mosque"
],
"organizations": [
"mosque on Sunbridge Road, Bradford"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bradford Crown Court, United Kingdom",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2025-06-20",
"outcome": "Mohammed Hanif Khan, 57, admitted two counts of rape and one count of multiple rape committed against a boy in the 1990s while he was imam at a mosque on Sunbridge Road, Bradford. He was sentenced to 13 years' imprisonment with a 3-year extended licence period."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.westyorkshire.police.uk/news-appeals/man-jailed-non-recent-rapes-bradford",
"archive": "",
"citation": "West Yorkshire Police, 'Man jailed for non-recent rapes, Bradford' (June 2025).",
"body": "Official police release confirming Khan's role as imam at the Sunbridge Road mosque, the guilty pleas, and the 13-year sentence with extended licence.",
"tier": "police-press-release",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.itv.com/news/calendar/2025-06-23/imam-who-repeatedly-raped-boy-at-mosque-jailed",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ITV News Calendar, 'Former Bradford imam jailed for repeatedly raping boy at mosque' (23 June 2025).",
"body": "Broadcast news report corroborating the sentencing, Khan's role as imam, and reference to his earlier 2011 Stoke-on-Trent conviction for offences against two other boys.",
"tier": "national-broadcast-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Khan groomed and repeatedly raped a boy over several years using the access and trust his position as the mosque's imam gave him — the same mechanism a prior 2011 conviction at another mosque had already established as his pattern.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.westyorkshire.police.uk/news-appeals/man-jailed-non-recent-rapes-bradford",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: police-press-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.itv.com/news/calendar/2025-06-23/imam-who-repeatedly-raped-boy-at-mosque-jailed",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcast-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1055,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "All five victims (young Muslim girls, ages 8-18 across the offending period) are not identified. Iqbal was a private tutor engaged by families specifically for Quran instruction; the offending occurred during scheduled religious lessons in the victims' homes.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-umair-iqbal-rochdale-uk",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Rochdale, Greater Manchester, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.6097,
"lng": -2.1561,
"title": "United Kingdom: private Quran tutor jailed 14 years for a decade of assaults on five young Muslim girls",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"private Quran and maths tutor engaged by families"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-instruction access to children in their own homes",
"families' trust in a private Quran tutor",
"exploitation of community reputation to shield the offending"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Manchester Crown Court, United Kingdom",
"stage": "trial verdict and sentencing",
"date": "2025-08-07",
"outcome": "Following a four-week trial, Umair Iqbal was found guilty on 29 of 30 counts of sexual assault against five young Muslim girls and women, aged 8 to 18 across a ten-year period (2010-2020), committed while conducting scheduled private Quran and maths lessons in the victims' homes. He was sentenced to 14 years (11 in custody, 3 on extended licence), with an indefinite Sexual Harm Prevention Order and restraining orders."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gmp.police.uk/news/greater-manchester/news/news/2025/august/private-tutor-sentenced-to-14-years-for-sexual-assault-of-five-women-and-girls/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Greater Manchester Police, 'Private tutor sentenced to 14 years for sexual assault of five women and girls' (7 Aug. 2025).",
"body": "Official police release confirming Iqbal's role as the family's private Quran and maths tutor, the ten-year offending period, the guilty verdicts on 29 of 30 counts, and the sentence.",
"tier": "police-press-release",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.itv.com/news/granada/2025-08-08/private-tutor-who-sexually-assaulted-five-pupils-jailed-for-11-years",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ITV News Granada, 'Private tutor who sexually assaulted five pupils jailed for 11 years' (8 Aug. 2025).",
"body": "Broadcast report corroborating the Quran-tutoring context, victim count and sentence.",
"tier": "national-broadcast-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Iqbal was engaged by observant Muslim families specifically to deliver Quran instruction to their daughters in their own homes; that religious-instruction role, and the trust it carried in the community, is what gave him unsupervised access to each victim over a decade.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gmp.police.uk/news/greater-manchester/news/news/2025/august/private-tutor-sentenced-to-14-years-for-sexual-assault-of-five-women-and-girls/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: police-press-release; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.itv.com/news/granada/2025-08-08/private-tutor-who-sexually-assaulted-five-pupils-jailed-for-11-years",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcast-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1056,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Cassation, Kuwait",
"outcome": "The Court of Cassation affirmed the life sentence, making the conviction final."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Defendant's personal name not published in available reporting (identified only by nationality and role); victim, a non-Kuwaiti expatriate child, not identified. Multiple independent Kuwaiti and pan-Arab outlets corroborate the mosque-imam role, the luring of the child into the mosque, and the final Court of Cassation life sentence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-jahra-mosque-imam-kuwait",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Jahra Governorate, Kuwait",
"lat": 29.3375,
"lng": 47.6581,
"title": "Kuwait: Jahra mosque imam's life sentence for indecent assault on a child affirmed as final",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam at a mosque in Jahra Governorate"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"luring a child into the mosque under the imam's care",
"religious-authority access to a child on mosque premises"
],
"organizations": [
"mosque in Jahra Governorate"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Court, Second Penal Circuit, Kuwait",
"stage": "criminal conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "The court convicted the defendant, a Yemeni national serving as imam of a mosque in Jahra, of luring an expatriate child into the mosque and committing indecent assault against him, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. He was arrested attempting to flee via the Salmi border crossing after the child's family reported the assault to police."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Cassation, Kuwait",
"stage": "final criminal appeal",
"outcome": "The Court of Cassation affirmed the life sentence, rendering the conviction final."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://arabic.rt.com/society/1571907-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%83%D9%88%D9%8A%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%A8%D8%AF-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%A8%D8%AF-%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%89-%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%85%D8%B3%D8%AC%D8%AF-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AC%D9%87%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%A1-%D9%84%D9%80%D9%87%D8%AA%D9%83%D9%87-%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%B6-%D8%B7%D9%81%D9%84-%D9%88%D9%83%D8%B4%D9%81-%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%AA%D9%87/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RT Arabic, 'الكويت.. الحكم بالسجن المؤبد على إمام مسجد بالجهراء لهتكه عرض طفل وكشف جنسيته' [Kuwait: Life sentence for Jahra mosque imam for indecent assault on a child and disclosing his nationality].",
"body": "Reports the defendant's role as imam of a mosque in Jahra, luring an expatriate child into the mosque, indecent assault, life sentence, and his arrest fleeing via the Salmi border crossing.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://alqabas.com/article/5930604/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Al-Qabas, 'التمييز تحكم بالسجن المؤبد على إمام مسجد بالجهراء لهتكه عرض طفل' [Cassation affirms life sentence for Jahra mosque imam for indecent assault on a child].",
"body": "Kuwaiti newspaper of record reporting the Court of Cassation's affirmance of the life sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The imam used his position and the mosque itself to lure an expatriate child into his care before assaulting him — the mosque's religious function is what gave him unsupervised access to a child not his own.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Cassation, Kuwait",
"outcome": "The Court of Cassation affirmed the life sentence, making the conviction final."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://arabic.rt.com/society/1571907-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%83%D9%88%D9%8A%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%A8%D8%AF-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%A8%D8%AF-%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%89-%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%85%D8%B3%D8%AC%D8%AF-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AC%D9%87%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%A1-%D9%84%D9%80%D9%87%D8%AA%D9%83%D9%87-%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%B6-%D8%B7%D9%81%D9%84-%D9%88%D9%83%D8%B4%D9%81-%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%AA%D9%87/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "89402c99175ca2472f5196aab1a1bb7f028229fcbe8420940f11a5b157016830",
"final_url": "https://arabic.rt.com/society/1571907-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%83%D9%88%D9%8A%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%A8%D8%AF-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%A8%D8%AF-%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%89-%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%85%D8%B3%D8%AC%D8%AF-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AC%D9%87%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%A1-%D9%84%D9%80%D9%87%D8%AA%D9%83%D9%87-%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%B6-%D8%B7%D9%81%D9%84-%D9%88%D9%83%D8%B4%D9%81-%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%AA%D9%87/"
},
{
"source": "https://alqabas.com/article/5930604/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "383a263be6610ae1a38bf75305aef6d35c34566af04b5e2312e3ee7aadd3494c",
"final_url": "https://alqabas.com/article/5930604/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1057,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Imam's personal name not published in available Arabic-language reporting (identified only by role and location); victims (multiple boys aged 8-12) not identified. Sourced to Moroccan Arabic-language press reporting the appellate verdict.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-safi-mosque-imam-morocco",
"year": 2025,
"place": "El Maachate, Safi Province, Morocco",
"lat": 32.2833,
"lng": -9.2333,
"title": "Morocco: Safi mosque imam's 20-year sentence for abusing Quran-memorization students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam at a mosque in the Maâchate rural commune, Safi Province"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over children attending the mosque for Quran memorization",
"custodial access during Quran lessons"
],
"organizations": [
"mosque, Douar Ouled Taher, Maâchate rural commune, Safi Province"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Chamber, Court of Appeal, Safi, Morocco",
"stage": "appellate criminal conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-08-07",
"outcome": "The court sentenced the imam of a mosque in the Ouled Taher area, Maâchate commune, to 20 years' imprisonment after convicting him of indecent assault on minor children aged 8 to 12 who attended the mosque for Quran memorization. The investigation followed complaints from victims' families; the imam had been arrested in January of the same year and held in pretrial detention."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://marrakechpost.com/2025/08/07/20-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86%D9%8B%D8%A7-%D9%86%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%B0%D9%8B%D8%A7-%D9%84%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%85%D8%B3%D8%AC%D8%AF-%D8%AA%D9%88%D8%B1%D8%B7-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D9%87%D8%AA/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Marrakech Post, '20 سنة سجنًا نافذًا لإمام مسجد تورط في هتك عرض قاصرين بإقليم آسفي' [20-year firm sentence for mosque imam involved in indecent assault of minors in Safi Province] (7 Aug. 2025).",
"body": "Reports the Safi Court of Appeal's criminal chamber verdict of 20 years' imprisonment against the imam, the January arrest, and that the case involved children aged 8-12 who attended the mosque to memorize the Quran.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://kech24.com/20-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%A7-%D9%86%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%B0%D8%A7-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D8%AD%D9%82-%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%BA%D9%84-%D8%A3%D8%B7%D9%81%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%A7.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kech24, '20 سنة سجنا نافذا في حق إمام استغل أطفالا جنسيا' [20-year firm sentence against an imam who sexually exploited children].",
"body": "Independent Moroccan outlet corroborating the sentence, the mosque setting and the Quran-memorization context.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The children were delivered to the imam's religious care specifically to memorize the Quran at the mosque; that role is what gave him unsupervised access to abuse them.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://marrakechpost.com/2025/08/07/20-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86%D9%8B%D8%A7-%D9%86%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%B0%D9%8B%D8%A7-%D9%84%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%85%D8%B3%D8%AC%D8%AF-%D8%AA%D9%88%D8%B1%D8%B7-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D9%87%D8%AA/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "186147050f2f0497984cab2d72978ea70384a00c99d5971fa9e6d6a09e7e42f0",
"final_url": "https://marrakechpost.com/2025/08/07/20-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86%D9%8B%D8%A7-%D9%86%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%B0%D9%8B%D8%A7-%D9%84%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%85%D8%B3%D8%AC%D8%AF-%D8%AA%D9%88%D8%B1%D8%B7-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D9%87%D8%AA/"
},
{
"source": "https://kech24.com/20-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%A7-%D9%86%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%B0%D8%A7-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D8%AD%D9%82-%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%BA%D9%84-%D8%A3%D8%B7%D9%81%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%A7.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8c54ad6287d68901a90c7dc47c0e4c23d1e1ff1afdc85a9ce053b5ba86863106",
"final_url": "https://kech24.com/20-%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%B3%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%A7-%D9%86%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%B0%D8%A7-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D8%AD%D9%82-%D8%A5%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%85-%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%BA%D9%84-%D8%A3%D8%B7%D9%81%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%A7.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1058,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Imam's personal name not published in available reporting; victims (underage girls attending Quran lessons) not identified. The imam had previously been acquitted for insufficient evidence before new witnesses and victims led to this conviction.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-ouarzazate-mosque-imam-morocco",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Zaouiat Sidi Bilal, Ouarzazate Province, Morocco",
"lat": 30.9189,
"lng": -6.8934,
"title": "Morocco: Ouarzazate-area mosque imam convicted after confessing to abusing girls in Quran lessons",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam at a mosque in Zaouiat Sidi Bilal, near Ouarzazate"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over underage girls attending Quran lessons at the mosque",
"custodial access during religious instruction"
],
"organizations": [
"mosque, Zaouiat Sidi Bilal, near Ouarzazate"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal court, Ouarzazate Province, Morocco",
"stage": "criminal conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-02-21",
"outcome": "The imam of a mosque in Zaouiat Sidi Bilal confessed to all charges of sexually abusing underage girls who attended Quran lessons at the mosque and was sentenced to five years' imprisonment. He had previously been acquitted of similar allegations for insufficient evidence; new witnesses and victims, along with pornographic images found on his phone, led to this conviction."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nieuws.marokko.nl/100467/imam-in-ouarzazate-veroordeeld-tot-vijf-jaar-cel-voor-misbruik",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Marokko Nieuws, 'Imam in Ouarzazate veroordeeld tot vijf jaar cel voor misbruik' [Imam in Ouarzazate sentenced to five years for abuse] (21 Feb. 2025).",
"body": "Reports the mosque location, the imam's confession, the underage girls' attendance at Quran lessons, the five-year sentence, the prior acquittal, and the pornographic images found on his phone.",
"tier": "diaspora-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The girls attended the mosque specifically for Quran lessons under the imam's religious instruction; that role is what put them in his unsupervised care.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nieuws.marokko.nl/100467/imam-in-ouarzazate-veroordeeld-tot-vijf-jaar-cel-voor-misbruik",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: diaspora-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6c2a18db6c629a6c8c478a361abbe1f2ab66cb72c150c47bb4b9955cbbb2d2d6",
"final_url": "https://nieuws.marokko.nl/100467/imam-in-ouarzazate-veroordeeld-tot-vijf-jaar-cel-voor-misbruik"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1059,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim (8-year-old boy, 'Yaous' per AP reporting) identified only by first name/pseudonym in press. Sourced through the Associated Press investigative piece on Pakistani madrassa abuse, reproduced across multiple outlets (VOA, Dawn, Washington Times).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-qari-shamsuddin-mansehra-pakistan",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Mansehra, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan",
"lat": 34.3333,
"lng": 73.2,
"title": "Pakistan: Mansehra madrassa cleric sentenced to 16.5 years after DNA-confirmed rape of an 8-year-old",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"cleric/teacher at Madrassah-e-Taleem-ul-Quran, Mansehra"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over a student at his madrassa",
"community deference to a cleric shielding the allegation"
],
"organizations": [
"Madrassah-e-Taleem-ul-Quran, Mansehra"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "trial court, Mansehra, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan",
"stage": "criminal conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Qari Shamsuddin, a cleric at the Madrassah-e-Taleem-ul-Quran mosque in Mansehra, was arrested after DNA evidence matched samples recovered from an 8-year-old student, 'Yaous.' Fellow clerics and worshippers at the mosque disputed the charges, but he was convicted and sentenced to 16.5 years' imprisonment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dawn.com/news/1828006",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Associated Press, via Dawn, 'No country for children: the not-so-hidden horrors of child sexual abuse in Pakistan.'",
"body": "AP investigative report documenting the Mansehra case, the DNA match, community denial, and the eventual 16.5-year sentence, as part of a wider pattern of madrassa abuse in Pakistan.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-investigation",
"kind": "investigative-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.voanews.com/a/south-central-asia_child-sex-abuse-pakistans-religious-schools-endemic/6187436.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "VOA News, 'Child Sex Abuse in Pakistan's Religious Schools Endemic.'",
"body": "Independent syndication of the same AP investigation corroborating the Qari Shamsuddin case details and sentence.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-investigation",
"kind": "investigative-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Shamsuddin was a cleric with direct religious authority over his own madrassa student; that relationship gave him access, and the community's deference to his clerical status delayed accountability even after DNA evidence confirmed his guilt.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dawn.com/news/1828006",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-investigation; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fb864884afe5b6ba16683c0bbb2ddf533d783771e9d3d95cadb629011a98bbf5",
"final_url": "https://www.dawn.com/news/1828006"
},
{
"source": "https://www.voanews.com/a/south-central-asia_child-sex-abuse-pakistans-religious-schools-endemic/6187436.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-investigation; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2d60d257f793683e72c9fe3de2ea10c9c302ba10c76baedfdc02310234a7a5e0",
"final_url": "https://www.voanews.com/a/south-central-asia_child-sex-abuse-pakistans-religious-schools-endemic/6187436.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1060,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim (10-year-old girl) identified only by relation to complainant (Malik Usman's daughter) in press; full name not published.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-qari-abdul-aziz-bahawalpur-pakistan",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Bahawalpur, Punjab, Pakistan",
"lat": 29.3956,
"lng": 71.6836,
"title": "Pakistan: Bahawalpur madrassa teacher sentenced to 20 years for assaulting his Quran student",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Quran teacher (Qari) at a madrassah, Bahawalpur"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious authority over a student attending Quran lessons",
"private access to the student in his madrassa room"
],
"organizations": [
"madrassah, Bahawalpur"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Additional Sessions Court, Bahawalpur, Punjab, Pakistan",
"stage": "trial conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Qari Abdul Aziz, 60, was convicted under Section 377-B of the Pakistan Penal Code and sentenced to 20 years' rigorous imprisonment plus a fine of one million rupees, for the attempted rape of a 10-year-old girl who attended his madrassah to learn the Quran. He was caught in the act by the girl's father and others who entered his room after she failed to return home from the madrassah."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://thecurrent.pk/bahawalpur-madrassa-teacher-sentenced-to-20-years-for-attempted-rape-of-minor-girl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Current, 'Bahawalpur madrassa teacher sentenced to 20 years for attempted rape of minor girl.'",
"body": "Reports the Additional Sessions Court verdict, the Section 377-B charge, the 20-year sentence and fine, and the circumstances of the girl's father discovering the assault after she attended Quran lessons.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Aziz taught the girl the Quran in his own madrassa room; that religious-instruction role is what put her alone with him.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://thecurrent.pk/bahawalpur-madrassa-teacher-sentenced-to-20-years-for-attempted-rape-of-minor-girl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5ba5c05d91867b62d60ddf9ea47f2708c511ae8f2be6d5e502655214cabd0b46",
"final_url": "https://thecurrent.pk/bahawalpur-madrassa-teacher-sentenced-to-20-years-for-attempted-rape-of-minor-girl/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1061,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Lead victim identified as nine years old; two further girl students referenced but not individually named. Distinct from the corpus's existing Bangladesh madrasa records (different location, defendant, and tribunal).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-suayebur-rahman-chapainawabganj-bangladesh",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Kansat, Shibganj, Chapainawabganj, Bangladesh",
"lat": 24.6167,
"lng": 88.2167,
"title": "Bangladesh: madrasa teacher given life imprisonment for raping three girl students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"teacher at a madrasa, Kansat, Shibganj upazila"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teacher authority over girl students",
"custodial access during religious instruction"
],
"organizations": [
"madrasa, Kansat, Shibganj upazila, Chapainawabganj"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Chapainawabganj Women and Children Repression Prevention Tribunal, Bangladesh",
"stage": "trial conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-07-27",
"outcome": "Suayebur Rahman, 52, was convicted of raping three girl students under his instruction — one identified as nine years old — and sentenced to life imprisonment plus a 50,000-taka fine (with a further five years' imprisonment in default). The tribunal heard testimony from eleven witnesses. The first documented assault occurred 19 February 2022; the case was filed the next day by the victim's maternal uncle."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bssnews.net/district/138654",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Bangladesh Sangbad Sangstha (BSS), 'Madrasha teacher gets life-term for raping 3 students in C'nawabganj.'",
"body": "State news agency report of the tribunal's conviction, the three victims, the sentence, the fine, the witness testimony, and the case timeline from the February 2022 filing to the July 2023 verdict.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Rahman taught his three victims as their madrasa instructor; the school's religious-instruction structure is what gave him repeated private access to each girl.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bssnews.net/district/138654",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8cc1f29945f2d59af487a86543911be1fe4d0cc1e68c1e3947646e0b9721fc87",
"final_url": "https://www.bssnews.net/district/138654"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1062,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Defendant's full surname withheld in Turkish press reporting (referred to as 'Sığın'); victim (11-year-old boy resident at the dormitory) not identified. Distinct from the corpus's existing Turkey Islam records (Tarsus Quran course, Hiranur/İsmailağa, Uşşaki tarikat, Ağrı Quran course, Diyarbakır mufti) — a different institution, city and defendant.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-suleymanci-dormitory-imam-umraniye-turkey",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ümraniye, Istanbul, Turkey",
"lat": 41.0225,
"lng": 29.1244,
"title": "Turkey: Süleymancı boys' dormitory imam sentenced to 28 years for abusing an 11-year-old resident",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam/religious supervisor at a Süleymancı-affiliated boys' religious dormitory (yurt), Ümraniye"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"combined custodial and religious authority over a resident child",
"overnight supervisory access at the dormitory"
],
"organizations": [
"Özel Osmangazi Arifiye Ortaokul Erkek Öğrenci Yurdu (Süleymancı-affiliated boys' dormitory), Ümraniye, Istanbul"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "criminal court, Istanbul, Turkey",
"stage": "criminal conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-06-06",
"outcome": "The defendant, an imam who had worked at the Süleymancı-affiliated boys' religious dormitory for four to five years with responsibility for the children's overnight care and supervision, was convicted of aggravated sexual abuse of an 11-year-old resident and sentenced to 28 years' imprisonment without reduction."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/turkiye/suleymancilarin-yurdunda-cocuk-istismari-imam-28-yil-hapis-cezasi-aldi-2214587",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cumhuriyet, 'Süleymancıların yurdunda çocuk istismarı: İmam 28 yıl hapis cezası aldı' [Child abuse at the Süleymancı dormitory: imam gets 28-year prison sentence] (6 June 2024).",
"body": "Reports the dormitory's Süleymancı religious affiliation, the imam's four-to-five-year tenure with overnight custodial responsibility for the children, the 11-year-old victim, the aggravated sexual abuse conviction, and the 28-year sentence without reduction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "As the dormitory's imam, the defendant held both the religious authority of the Süleymancı order that ran the boys' residence and the custodial authority of overnight care — the combination is what left an 11-year-old resident alone with him.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/turkiye/suleymancilarin-yurdunda-cocuk-istismari-imam-28-yil-hapis-cezasi-aldi-2214587",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aa4c887169bc8406fee1e9b76e7d4d0689206eec55358685e9a50d4edf4e957a",
"final_url": "https://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/turkiye/suleymancilarin-yurdunda-cocuk-istismari-imam-28-yil-hapis-cezasi-aldi-2214587"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1063,
"aliases": [
"Ali S."
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The nine rape victims and roughly fifteen additional fraud victims are not individually identified; described in press as West African diaspora women aged 40-60. This record concerns only the rape convictions; the accompanying fraud convictions are noted for context but are not themselves the basis for inclusion.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-ali-sidibe-seine-saint-denis-france",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Seine-Saint-Denis, France",
"lat": 48.9356,
"lng": 2.3539,
"title": "France: self-styled marabout given the maximum 15 years for raping nine women under a jinn-healing pretext",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled marabout claiming healing and jinn-removal powers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed ability to heal sick children and remove djinns (evil spirits)",
"exploitation of victims' religious and spiritual beliefs",
"isolation of victims in a hotel room under the guise of ritual treatment",
"financial fraud accompanying the spiritual pretext"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Seine-Saint-Denis criminal court (cour criminelle), France",
"stage": "trial conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-05-06",
"outcome": "Ali Sidibé, a Malian migrant in his thirties who presented himself as a marabout able to heal sick children and remove djinns, was found guilty of raping nine women from the West African diaspora in the Paris region between 2018 and 2020, and of defrauding those and roughly fifteen further victims of tens of thousands of euros. He was sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment, the maximum available."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lematin.ch/story/france-un-marabout-violeur-en-serie-ecope-de-15-ans-de-prison-103099196",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Le Matin, 'France: un marabout violeur en série écope de 15 ans de prison' [France: serial-rapist marabout gets 15 years in prison] (6 May 2024).",
"body": "Reports Sidibé's claimed healing and djinn-removal powers, his exploitation of victims' religious beliefs to lure them to a hotel room, the nine rape convictions, the fraud convictions against roughly fifteen further victims, and the maximum 15-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fdesouche.com/2024/05/06/un-migrant-malien-violeur-en-serie-reconnu-coupable-de-viols-sur-9-femmes-en-lile-de-france-ce-marabout-qui-a-escroque-une-quinzaine-dautres-victimes-a-ecope-de-la-peine-maximale-encoure-so/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fdesouche, coverage of the Seine-Saint-Denis criminal-court verdict against 'Ali S.' (6 May 2024).",
"body": "Independent corroboration of the nine rape convictions, the fraud victims, and the maximum 15-year sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sidibé's claimed power to heal sick children and expel djinns is what led vulnerable women to seek him out and follow him into an isolated hotel room for ritual treatment — the spiritual-healing pretext was the entire mechanism of access.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lematin.ch/story/france-un-marabout-violeur-en-serie-ecope-de-15-ans-de-prison-103099196",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "eca79d93cdfb3aaf2030764de03fab8474efa573f0cc25483f4b14019c853bfb",
"final_url": "https://www.lematin.ch/story/france-un-marabout-violeur-en-serie-ecope-de-15-ans-de-prison-103099196"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fdesouche.com/2024/05/06/un-migrant-malien-violeur-en-serie-reconnu-coupable-de-viols-sur-9-femmes-en-lile-de-france-ce-marabout-qui-a-escroque-une-quinzaine-dautres-victimes-a-ecope-de-la-peine-maximale-encoure-so/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "94397d8d1ccfe1dab519b24d28be7271b42630e4f1812f2344f1acd906cae596",
"final_url": "https://www.fdesouche.com/2024/05/06/un-migrant-malien-violeur-en-serie-reconnu-coupable-de-viols-sur-9-femmes-en-lile-de-france-ce-marabout-qui-a-escroque-une-quinzaine-dautres-victimes-a-ecope-de-la-peine-maximale-encoure-so/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9101,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event record. This documents a federal government institution's own investigative findings across hundreds of schools and is not a single victim-perpetrator record; entered as recordClass institutional-event per this project's standing rule that national inquiry reports document an institution rather than a case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-us-federal-indian-boarding-school-initiative-report",
"year": 2024,
"place": "United States (national, 37 states and territories)",
"lat": 39.8283,
"lng": -98.5795,
"title": "United States: Interior Department's Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative finds 417 church-partnered schools and a federally funded assimilation system",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Federal Indian boarding school system operators, including religious denominations and orders contracted or partnered to run schools"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"compulsory removal of Native children from families under federal policy; residential control combined, at many schools, with a religious order's or denomination's own institutional authority over the children in its custody"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"U.S. Department of the Interior",
"Bureau of Indian Affairs",
"multiple Christian denominations and religious orders operating contract and mission boarding schools"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Department of the Interior, Washington, D.C., USA",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2022-05-11",
"outcome": "Volume 1 of the Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative investigative report, released 11 May 2022, documented that the federal government operated or supported 408 boarding schools across 37 states and territories (including Alaska and Hawaii) from 1819 to 1969, employing systematic militarized and identity-suppression methods, and identified marked or unmarked burial sites at approximately 53 schools, with the number expected to grow."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Department of the Interior, Washington, D.C., USA",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2024-07-30",
"outcome": "Volume 2, the initiative's final report, released 30 July 2024 after review of approximately 103 million pages of government records, updated the list to 417 institutions, documented at least 973 recorded student deaths and dozens more burial sites, detailed the participation of religious institutions and organizations in operating the system, and found the government appropriated more than $23.3 billion (FY23-adjusted) to fund the system and related assimilation policy between 1871 and 1969. The report issued policy recommendations to Congress and the Executive Branch for redress."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Many of the 417 documented institutions were run under contract or mission arrangements with Christian denominations and religious orders that held direct custodial and, in numerous instances, clerical or professed-religious authority over the Native children removed into their care; the report itself documents religious-institution participation in the system's operation and abuses.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bia.gov/sites/default/files/media_document/doi_federal_indian_boarding_school_initiative_investigative_report_vii_final_508_compliant.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of the Interior: Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative Investigative Report, Volume II (Final), 30 July 2024.",
"body": "The final volume documenting 417 institutions, recorded deaths, burial sites, religious-institution participation, and federal funding figures.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "federal-investigative-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/department-interior-releases-investigative-report-outlines-next-steps-federal-indian",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of the Interior: Department of the Interior Releases Investigative Report, Outlines Next Steps in Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative.",
"body": "Press release summarizing Volume 1 (11 May 2022) findings: 408 schools, 37 states/territories, burial sites at 53 schools.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "press-release"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bia.gov/sites/default/files/media_document/doi_federal_indian_boarding_school_initiative_investigative_report_vii_final_508_compliant.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: federal-investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "56fda4b84c89f0ebd203e8611b808f1f301302a4af42fb78676d22e19dce1b1c",
"final_url": "https://www.bia.gov/sites/default/files/media_document/doi_federal_indian_boarding_school_initiative_investigative_report_vii_final_508_compliant.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/department-interior-releases-investigative-report-outlines-next-steps-federal-indian",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: press-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fe4654b63490ad0f830f2186c3b7c90254f7672e61352470c8dbab1d71054d57",
"final_url": "https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/department-interior-releases-investigative-report-outlines-next-steps-federal-indian"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9102,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event record. Documents an official scoping inquiry's own aggregate findings across 308 schools and 24 religious orders; not a single victim-perpetrator record. Distinct from the closed Ryan Report (industrial and reformatory schools) — this inquiry covers ordinary day and boarding schools run by religious orders, a different institutional set.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-ireland-scoping-inquiry-day-boarding-schools-religious-orders",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Ireland (national, at least 22 counties)",
"lat": 53.1424,
"lng": -7.6921,
"title": "Ireland: Scoping Inquiry finds 2,395 allegations of historical sexual abuse across 308 schools run by 24 religious orders",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Members of 24 Catholic religious orders operating day and boarding schools across Ireland"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical and professed-religious office within schools the orders themselves ran, including boarding structures at special-education institutions where abuse was disproportionately concentrated"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Scoping Inquiry into Historical Sexual Abuse in Day and Boarding Schools Run by Religious Orders",
"Department of Education, Ireland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Scoping Inquiry (Government-appointed), submitted to the Minister for Education, Ireland",
"stage": "official-finding",
"date": "2024-09-03",
"outcome": "The Scoping Inquiry into Historical Sexual Abuse in Day and Boarding Schools Run by Religious Orders, submitted to the Minister for Education on 7 June 2024 and approved for publication by government on 3 September 2024, documented 2,395 allegations of historical sexual abuse at 308 schools run by religious orders, naming over 80 schools across at least 22 counties and involving 884 alleged abusers from 24 religious orders. The abuse was reported mainly between the early 1960s and early 1990s, peaking in the early-to-mid 1970s. A disproportionate concentration — 590 allegations across 17 institutions involving 190 alleged abusers — was found at special-education schools. The inquiry's principal recommendation was establishment of a statutory Commission of Investigation, alongside consideration of a survivor redress scheme funded in part by the religious orders themselves."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The alleged abusers held clerical or professed-religious office within schools their own orders operated and controlled, including boarding structures where children's day-to-day custody was inseparable from the order's institutional and religious authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.ie/en/education-scoping-inquiry/publications/scoping-inquiry-into-historical-sexual-abuse-in-schools-run-by-religious-orders/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Government of Ireland: Scoping Inquiry into Historical Sexual Abuse in Schools run by Religious Orders (publications page).",
"body": "Official publication of the Scoping Inquiry report and its findings.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "government-inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2024/0903/1468160-scoping-inquiry-schools/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RTE: 2,395 allegations of abuse at religious schools - inquiry.",
"body": "Report of the inquiry's key statistics on allegations, schools, orders and alleged abusers.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster",
"kind": "official-finding-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.ie/en/education-scoping-inquiry/publications/scoping-inquiry-into-historical-sexual-abuse-in-schools-run-by-religious-orders/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: government-inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2024/0903/1468160-scoping-inquiry-schools/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster; evidentiary role: official-finding-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0fa85ccdd38fe6b89d1d9b258f1faf2949795d83965b04bd2bbaea86810f36ab",
"final_url": "https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2024/0903/1468160-scoping-inquiry-schools/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9103,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims not individually named. Denomination and Catholic religious-order operation of the school (Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate) confirmed; Moran's own status is described in press coverage as a boy's supervisor who was, by the time of trial, living as a monk in a Saskatchewan monastery — entered on that basis as professed-religious status at the time of the offences is corroborated by his subsequent monastic life, though not explicitly stated for the offence period itself.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2004-gerald-moran-kamloops-st-marys-residential-schools-canada",
"year": 2004,
"place": "Kamloops and Mission, British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 50.6745,
"lng": -120.3273,
"title": "Canada: Kamloops and St. Mary's residential-school supervisor's conviction on twelve counts of sexual abuse",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Boys' supervisor at the Oblate-run Kamloops and St. Mary's Indian Residential Schools; subsequently resident of a Catholic monastery"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"residential custodial authority within a Catholic religious order's own institution, over children removed from their families into the order's care"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate",
"Kamloops Indian Residential School",
"St. Mary's Indian Residential School"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia, Canada",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2004-01-01",
"outcome": "Gerald Mathieu Moran, a boys' supervisor at the Oblate-run Kamloops and St. Mary's Indian Residential Schools during the 1950s and 1960s, was convicted on twelve counts of sexual abuse following a multi-year RCMP investigation. He was 78 years old at trial and was sentenced to three years' imprisonment; he had been living as a monk in a Saskatchewan monastery at the time of his arrest."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were Native children removed from their families into the custody of a Catholic religious order's own residential school, subject to the institutional authority the Oblates exercised over them as their custodians.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/four-year-hunt-ends-in-arrest/article713735/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Globe and Mail: Four-year hunt ends in arrest.",
"body": "Report of the RCMP investigation, Moran's identification as a supervisor at the Oblate-run schools, and his arrest.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "investigation-and-arrest-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamloops_Indian_Residential_School",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wikipedia: Kamloops Indian Residential School.",
"body": "Confirms the school's operation by the Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate and documents the Moran conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "reference-secondary",
"kind": "background-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/four-year-hunt-ends-in-arrest/article713735/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: investigation-and-arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "22009b19d571f01da7acbe17b8ed46f89db5d7c2cedbe0d5d6d23bccb71264c0",
"final_url": "https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/four-year-hunt-ends-in-arrest/article713735/"
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamloops_Indian_Residential_School",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: reference-secondary; evidentiary role: background-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c1287c83b24367f27da79d5c2db57f67a89e02ff1f453a012b4ecb02f0498124",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamloops_Indian_Residential_School"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9104,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Two teenage male victims, boarders at the school; not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-bede-hampton-marist-brother-st-josephs-college-masterton-new-zealand",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Masterton, Wairarapa, New Zealand",
"lat": -40.9556,
"lng": 175.658,
"title": "New Zealand: Marist Brother convicted of eleven historic sex offences against boarders at a Catholic boarding school",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Marist Brother teaching at St Joseph's College, a Catholic boarding school in Masterton"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-order brother's teaching office and access to boarders living under the school's residential authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Marist Brothers",
"St Joseph's College, Masterton"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court, Wellington, New Zealand",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2010-12-17",
"outcome": "Bede Hampton, a 62-year-old former Marist Brother, was found guilty by a jury on eleven charges (ten of indecent assault and one of committing an indecent act) relating to two teenage boys who were boarders at St Joseph's College, a Catholic boarding school in Masterton, in the early 1970s. He additionally pleaded guilty to two further charges of indecent assault against one of the boys; a third charge was dismissed. He was sentenced on 17 December 2010 to two and a half years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were teenage boarders at the Marist Brothers' own Catholic boarding school, living under the residential and religious authority the order's brothers held over them as both teachers and custodians.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/ex-marist-brother-guilty-of-sex-charges/WD3UN2NH553QEH5ONMJG7YMI4Y/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NZ Herald: Ex-Marist brother guilty of sex charges.",
"body": "Report of the jury verdict against Bede Hampton on charges relating to two boarders at St Joseph's College, Masterton.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/64414/former-marist-brother-jailed-for-sex-assaults-on-boys",
"archive": "",
"citation": "RNZ: Former Marist brother jailed for sex assaults on boys.",
"body": "Report of the sentencing to two and a half years' imprisonment on 17 December 2010.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/ex-marist-brother-guilty-of-sex-charges/WD3UN2NH553QEH5ONMJG7YMI4Y/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e493d35efd76903554e5be9f9653824b18e0f762ae2009cbfc696553fa95723a",
"final_url": "https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/ex-marist-brother-guilty-of-sex-charges/WD3UN2NH553QEH5ONMJG7YMI4Y/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/64414/former-marist-brother-jailed-for-sex-assaults-on-boys",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7aff345cf7dd032d2f075aed80182c875dc23fc408ed7489037b1f9f606b7e1a",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/all/64414/former-marist-brother-jailed-for-sex-assaults-on-boys"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9105,
"aliases": [
"Father David Pearce"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "sentence appeal",
"date": "2010-05-01",
"note": "Court of Appeal reduced the sentence from eight years to five years; the underlying conviction itself was not disturbed and stands."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Five minor victims, pupils of the school; not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2009-david-pearce-ealing-abbey-st-benedicts-school-uk",
"year": 2009,
"place": "Ealing, London, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.513,
"lng": -0.3037,
"title": "United Kingdom: Ealing Abbey Benedictine monk and former headteacher convicted of abusing five pupils over 36 years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Benedictine monk of Ealing Abbey; former headteacher of St Benedict's School"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic and headmasterly office within the abbey's own school, later maintained access to pupils even under restricted ministry"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Ealing Abbey",
"St Benedict's School",
"English Benedictine Congregation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Isleworth Crown Court, United Kingdom",
"stage": "conviction; sentence reduced on appeal, conviction stands",
"date": "2009-08-01",
"outcome": "David Pearce, a Benedictine monk of Ealing Abbey and former headteacher of St Benedict's School, pleaded guilty at Isleworth Crown Court to the sexual abuse of five pupils, with offences dating back to 1972 and continuing while he was under restricted ministry. He was sentenced in October 2009 to eight years' imprisonment; the Court of Appeal reduced the sentence to five years in May 2010 without disturbing the conviction. IICSA later found that since 2003, two monks (Pearce and Laurence Soper) and two lay teachers had been convicted of abusing over 20 children at the school between the 1970s and 2008."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were pupils of the abbey's own school, abused by a monk whose headmasterly authority and continuing access — including after he was placed under restricted ministry — arose directly from his monastic and clerical standing within the community that ran the school.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/english-benedictine-congregation-ealing-abbey/part-1-ealing-abbey-and-st-benedicts-school/executive-summary",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IICSA: Ealing Abbey and St Benedict's School Investigation Report, Executive Summary.",
"body": "Official inquiry summary confirming the convictions of Pearce and Soper and the scale of abuse at the school.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "statutory-inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "http://scepticalthoughts.blogspot.com/2010/05/father-david-pearces-appeal-against.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Confessions of a skeptic: Father David Pearce's appeal against sentence.",
"body": "Contemporary report of the May 2010 Court of Appeal sentence reduction from eight to five years.",
"tier": "specialist-commentary",
"kind": "appeal-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "sentence appeal",
"date": "2010-05-01",
"note": "Court of Appeal reduced the sentence from eight years to five years; the underlying conviction itself was not disturbed and stands."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/english-benedictine-congregation-ealing-abbey/part-1-ealing-abbey-and-st-benedicts-school/executive-summary",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: statutory-inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6d0d35332b5693ee9ddfe2bf6a516643d6af64b353c36b2391f8903f2eb4231e",
"final_url": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/english-benedictine-congregation-ealing-abbey/part-1-ealing-abbey-and-st-benedicts-school/executive-summary"
},
{
"source": "http://scepticalthoughts.blogspot.com/2010/05/father-david-pearces-appeal-against.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-commentary; evidentiary role: appeal-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "320b82d5e32e2a8eb116f826e3ab17ff4c41affe451c64c615e2ce53c5938e11",
"final_url": "http://scepticalthoughts.blogspot.com/2010/05/father-david-pearces-appeal-against.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9106,
"aliases": [
"Laurence Soper",
"Andrew Charles Kingston Soper"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victims, pupils of the school; not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-laurence-soper-abbot-ealing-abbey-st-benedicts-school-uk",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Ealing, London, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.513,
"lng": -0.3037,
"title": "United Kingdom: former Abbot of Ealing Abbey convicted after fleeing abroad for five years to avoid prosecution",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Former Abbot of Ealing Abbey, the Benedictine monastery adjoining St Benedict's School"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abbatial and monastic office over the abbey's own school, exploited to abuse pupils under the community's authority"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Ealing Abbey",
"St Benedict's School",
"English Benedictine Congregation"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "United Kingdom",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2017-01-01",
"outcome": "Laurence Soper, former Abbot of Ealing Abbey, was convicted in 2017 of sexually abusing pupils at St Benedict's School. He had fled the UK in 2011 while under investigation, withdrawing roughly £182,000 from a Vatican bank account and living abroad, including in Kosovo, before being extradited following his 2016 arrest to face trial."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were pupils of the abbey's own school, subject to the authority of a monastic community whose head — the Abbot himself — was the perpetrator, the highest expression of the community's religious authority turned against the children in its care.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tedteamsite.wordpress.com/2016/05/30/failed-bail-2011-now-2016-arrested-laurence-soper/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Failed Bail 2011 NOW 2016 Arrested – Andrew Charles Kingston Soper – Laurence aka Laurence Soper.",
"body": "Contemporary report of Soper's 2011 flight, Vatican bank withdrawal, Kosovo residence, and 2016 arrest and extradition.",
"tier": "specialist-commentary",
"kind": "arrest-and-extradition-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/english-benedictine-congregation-ealing-abbey/part-1-ealing-abbey-and-st-benedicts-school/executive-summary",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IICSA: Ealing Abbey and St Benedict's School Investigation Report, Executive Summary.",
"body": "Official inquiry summary confirming Soper's conviction as former Abbot alongside Pearce's.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-report",
"kind": "statutory-inquiry-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tedteamsite.wordpress.com/2016/05/30/failed-bail-2011-now-2016-arrested-laurence-soper/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-commentary; evidentiary role: arrest-and-extradition-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1c55a1a58f61684e11cef87771034dfa7ff7d510a7d83dcf154442a5a7fcf887",
"final_url": "https://tedteamsite.wordpress.com/2016/05/30/failed-bail-2011-now-2016-arrested-laurence-soper/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/english-benedictine-congregation-ealing-abbey/part-1-ealing-abbey-and-st-benedicts-school/executive-summary",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: statutory-inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6d0d35332b5693ee9ddfe2bf6a516643d6af64b353c36b2391f8903f2eb4231e",
"final_url": "https://www.iicsa.org.uk/reports-recommendations/publications/investigation/english-benedictine-congregation-ealing-abbey/part-1-ealing-abbey-and-st-benedicts-school/executive-summary"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9107,
"aliases": [
"Anthony William Peter Caruana",
"Fr Tony Caruana"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Twelve minor victims, students in his care; not identified. No appeal identified in available reporting; treated as standing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-anthony-caruana-chevalier-college-bowral-australia",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Burradoo (Bowral), New South Wales, Australia",
"lat": -34.478,
"lng": 150.4265,
"title": "Australia: Missionaries of the Sacred Heart priest jailed for fifteen years for abusing twelve boarding-school students",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Priest of the Missionaries of the Sacred Heart; dormitory manager, rugby coach and band teacher at Chevalier College"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly office combined with residential dormitory authority over boarding students at the order's own school"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Missionaries of the Sacred Heart (MSC)",
"Chevalier College"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New South Wales District Court, Australia",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2021-12-10",
"outcome": "Anthony William Peter Caruana, a priest of the Missionaries of the Sacred Heart who served as dormitory manager, rugby coach and band teacher at Chevalier College, a Catholic boarding school at Burradoo near Bowral, was found guilty by a jury of 23 charges (22 counts of indecent assault and four counts of sexual intercourse with a pupil) for abusing twelve students in his care between 1982 and 1988. On 10 December 2021 he was sentenced to fifteen years' imprisonment with a ten-year non-parole period, at age 80."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were boarding students under Caruana's own religious order's residential authority, abused by a priest whose dormitory-manager role was itself an assignment of his priestly office within the order's school.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://www.brokenrites.org.au/drupal/node/185",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Broken Rites Australia: A priest, aged 80, is jailed by a Sydney court for sexual crimes he committed against children at a Catholic boarding school many years ago.",
"body": "Report of the sentencing, order affiliation, charges, sentence and non-parole period.",
"tier": "specialist-advocacy-press",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.illawarramercury.com.au/story/7546384/twelve-ex-students-unite-to-bring-down-80-year-old-pedophile-priest-anthony-caruana/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Illawarra Mercury: Anthony Caruana jailed for 15 years for abusing 12 students at Chevalier College near Bowral.",
"body": "Regional report confirming the sentence and the twelve former students who brought the case.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://www.brokenrites.org.au/drupal/node/185",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-advocacy-press; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "50c96449a150b4f3f7dc464f9fc027cc724fa13d03b6bc35c17f182af54948f2",
"final_url": "http://www.brokenrites.org.au/drupal/node/185"
},
{
"source": "https://www.illawarramercury.com.au/story/7546384/twelve-ex-students-unite-to-bring-down-80-year-old-pedophile-priest-anthony-caruana/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a420a4458def8673147f015b7acce52c9b0d256624aac810564fbae2f268cbf5",
"final_url": "https://www.illawarramercury.com.au/story/7546384/12-ex-students-unite-to-expose-80-year-old-paedophile-priest-anthony-caruana/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1071,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Aladura-tradition (Cherubim and Seraphim, one of the classic Nigerian white-garment churches) prophet, though the offending congregation was a UK diaspora splinter he led rather than a mainline C&S assembly in Nigeria. At least 88 separate rape occasions were referenced at sentencing. Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-michael-oluronbi-cherubim-seraphim-birmingham-uk",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Birmingham, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.4862,
"lng": -1.8904,
"title": "UK: Cherubim and Seraphim prophet convicted of raping congregants during 'spiritual bathing' rituals",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled prophet and founder of a Cherubim and Seraphim splinter congregation, Edgbaston, Birmingham"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed prophetic power to 'cleanse' congregants of evil spirits and negative influences through ritual 'spiritual bathing'",
"authority over congregants' spiritual welfare used to isolate them for abuse over two decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"exorcism-deliverance",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Cherubim and Seraphim Church (Edgbaston, Birmingham; later a splinter congregation)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Birmingham Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-03-13",
"outcome": "Michael Oluronbi, a self-proclaimed Nigerian prophet and Cherubim and Seraphim church leader, was convicted of 15 counts of rape, 7 counts of indecent assault and 2 counts of sexual assault against six women and one man, most of them congregants, across two decades. He was sentenced to 34 years' imprisonment and placed on the sex offenders register for life. His wife, Juliana Oluronbi, was convicted of aiding and abetting rape by arranging abortions for victims he impregnated and was sentenced to 11 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Oluronbi held prophetic authority over his congregants as their spiritual leader and used the pretext of ritual 'spiritual bathing' to cleanse them of claimed evil spirits — the doctrinal mechanism the court heard placed victims alone and undressed with him, some from childhood.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2020/03/michael-oluronbi-uk-based-nigerian-pastor-raped-members-88-times/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vanguard (Nigeria), 'Michael Oluronbi: UK-based Nigerian pastor raped members 88 times' (16 March 2020).",
"body": "Reports the Birmingham Crown Court conviction, denomination, sentence, and the 'spiritual bathing' mechanism.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://guardian.ng/life/pastor-who-rapes-members-of-his-church-in-spiritual-baths-jailed-for-34-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Guardian (Nigeria), 'Pastor Who Rapes Members Of His Church In 'Spiritual Baths' Jailed For 34 Years' (2020).",
"body": "Confirms sentence, denomination, and wife's co-conviction for arranging abortions.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2020/03/michael-oluronbi-uk-based-nigerian-pastor-raped-members-88-times/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "be45a4b5104466118c1d55f623a3c82a832b6d892fd0483fe7faa7edf95208dc",
"final_url": "https://www.vanguardngr.com/2020/03/michael-oluronbi-uk-based-nigerian-pastor-raped-members-88-times/"
},
{
"source": "https://guardian.ng/life/pastor-who-rapes-members-of-his-church-in-spiritual-baths-jailed-for-34-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "084b8bf9956c1e843e914acf37c58397442742b4aa48c8fb0d6affa5063c9402",
"final_url": "https://guardian.ng/life/pastor-who-rapes-members-of-his-church-in-spiritual-baths-jailed-for-34-years/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1072,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The pastor is reported under two overlapping church names in different outlets ('African Faith Tabernacle Church' and 'Jesus Faith Tabernacle Church'); he told the court the latter was accurate. No appeal located. Minor victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-yaw-nkansah-jesus-faith-tabernacle-ghana",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Achiase, Eastern Region, Ghana",
"lat": 6.2333,
"lng": -0.9333,
"title": "Ghana: prayer-camp pastor jailed twenty years for raping five sisters, one drugged unconscious",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"head pastor, Jesus Faith Tabernacle Church prayer camp, Achiase"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed power to deliver a congregant from a curse ('prostitution spell') via a ritual bathing and prayer session",
"incapacitated a victim with powder before assaulting her"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"curse-witchcraft",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Jesus Faith Tabernacle Church, Achiase, Eastern Region"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Akyem Swedru Circuit Court, Eastern Region, Ghana",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2011-08-31",
"outcome": "Pastor Yaw Nkansah, head pastor of the Jesus Faith Tabernacle Church prayer camp at Achiase, pleaded guilty with explanation to defilement of a 15-year-old member of his congregation, the youngest of five sisters he was found to have raped. The court heard he told her the devil had cast a 'prostitution spell' on her, took her to a hill to be ritually bathed, then to his room where he poured a powder on her that caused her to lose consciousness before raping her. He was sentenced to 20 years' imprisonment with hard labour."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were brought to Nkansah's prayer camp as a pastor with claimed power to remove curses and deliver them from spirits; that claimed authority was the means by which he isolated and drugged at least one of them before raping her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.modernghana.com/news/348160/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-raping-5-sisters.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Modern Ghana, 'Pastor Jailed 20 Years For Raping 5 Sisters' (2011).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, sentence, court, judge's statement, and the 'prostitution spell' / ritual-bathing mechanism.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.myjoyonline.com/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-raping-five-sisters/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "MyJoyOnline, 'Pastor jailed 20 years for raping five sisters' (2011).",
"body": "Independent confirmation of the conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.modernghana.com/news/348160/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-raping-5-sisters.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "609d66b214a14b5e6f53c83357743665c8df575bbeeee4b53c030d34300913d0",
"final_url": "https://www.modernghana.com/news/348160/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-raping-5-sisters.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.myjoyonline.com/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-raping-five-sisters/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3f08bccd64d55c392824e1d1b1c99ed4e8aca9c6cedfbe95f93380b2ed922ec9",
"final_url": "https://www.myjoyonline.com/pastor-jailed-20-years-for-raping-five-sisters/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1073,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from the later, higher-profile Ishmael Chokurongerwa (Madzibaba Ishmael) Johane Masowe eChishanu conviction at Nyabira already in the corpus — different leader, different congregation, different decade. Minor victim not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-shepherd-matanda-johane-masowe-chitungwiza-zimbabwe",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Chitungwiza, Zimbabwe",
"lat": -17.9939,
"lng": 31.0575,
"title": "Zimbabwe: Johane Masowe sect leader convicted of statutory rape of a minor congregant lured to pick prayer pebbles",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leader (Madzibaba) of a Johane Masowe apostolic sect congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sect leader's authority over a minor congregant, used to summon her under a religious pretext (assisting with prayer pebbles) and isolate her"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [
"Johane Masowe apostolic sect, Chitungwiza"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Chitungwiza Regional Magistrates' Court, Zimbabwe",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2013-09-03",
"outcome": "Shepherd Matanda, a 41-year-old leader within the Johane Masowe apostolic sect who already had two wives aged 20 and 21, was convicted on two counts of statutory rape of a 15-year-old congregant, whom he had told he needed assistance picking pebbles used in prayer. He testified he intended to take her as a third wife. Magistrate Estere Chivasa sentenced him to three years' imprisonment, with one year conditionally suspended for five years, leaving two years to serve."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Matanda's authority as a Madzibaba (sect elder/prophet figure) within the Johane Masowe apostolic movement was the means by which he summoned the girl under religious pretext and secured access to her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://relzim.org/news/madzibaba-41-married-to-two-wives-aged-20-and-21-rapes-girl-15-gets-2-years-in-jail/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Religion in Zimbabwe, 'Madzibaba (41) married to two wives aged 20 and 21 rapes girl (15), gets 2 years in jail' (2013).",
"body": "Reports the conviction, sentence, court, and the pebble-picking pretext used to lure the victim.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thezimbabwean.co/2013/01/court-watch-7/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Zimbabwean, 'Court Watch' (2013).",
"body": "Zimbabwean court-reporting column corroborating apostolic-sect prosecutions from the same period.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting-roundup"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://relzim.org/news/madzibaba-41-married-to-two-wives-aged-20-and-21-rapes-girl-15-gets-2-years-in-jail/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0567cf7aa613128b0ef1c16c0a98b2ddd7545df90fbd78c949590e08b2845d7e",
"final_url": "https://relzim.org/news/madzibaba-41-married-to-two-wives-aged-20-and-21-rapes-girl-15-gets-2-years-in-jail/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thezimbabwean.co/2013/01/court-watch-7/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting-roundup.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "17a8aef187876e78767a9be05c064cc82a95d075cb6de48aedeac161b3ef4afa",
"final_url": "https://www.thezimbabwean.co/2013/01/court-watch-7/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1074,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL-EVENT class, not an individual-victim case record: this is a commission's systemic finding across a sector, most visibly the Neo-Pentecostal/prophetic-church space that overlaps with and adjoins the AIC/Zionist/prophet-healing tradition rather than naming a specific AIC by name. No named individual conviction attaches to this record; entered because the finding itself — official, at commission tier, addressing the same claimed-prophetic-authority mechanism this corpus otherwise documents case-by-case — is the class of record recordClass:institutional-event exists for. The regulatory recommendations were rejected; the underlying findings of documented practice were not.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-crl-rights-commission-commercialisation-religion-south-africa",
"year": 2017,
"place": "South Africa",
"lat": -28.4793,
"lng": 24.6727,
"title": "South Africa: CRL Rights Commission finds systemic commercialisation and abuse of belief in the unregulated prophetic-church sector",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-report",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled prophets, pastors and 'men of God' across South Africa's unregulated independent-church sector"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed prophetic and healing authority used to extract money from congregants and to compel dangerous or degrading acts (ingesting snakes, grass, insecticide, petrol; being driven over by a car) framed as tests or proofs of faith",
"structural absence of any peer-review or accountability mechanism for self-declared religious leaders"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"prophecy-divine-command",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"organizations": [
"CRL Rights Commission (Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities, South Africa)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "CRL Rights Commission, South Africa (Chapter 9 constitutional body)",
"stage": "official investigative hearings and report",
"date": "2017-08-01",
"outcome": "Following 2016 media reports of prophets in Neo-Pentecostal and independent prophetic churches instructing congregants to eat grass, snakes and insecticide-sprayed food and to drink petrol and detergent, and of leaders demanding large sums for prayer, blessings, and 'miracle' water or oil, the CRL Rights Commission held public hearings and published a report finding evidence of widespread commercialisation of religion and abuse of people's belief systems, and recommending licensing and peer-review regulation of religious practitioners and places of worship. The regulatory recommendations were publicly rejected by the responsible ministry (COGTA) in 2018 after sustained objection from religious-freedom advocates; the finding of documented abuse itself was not reversed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Commission's finding is that claimed prophetic and spiritual authority — not fraud alone — was the operative mechanism inducing congregants to pay exorbitant sums and to perform dangerous or degrading acts on the belief that doing so was spiritually efficacious.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201708/report-commecializationofreligionandabuseofpeoplesbelievesystems.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CRL Rights Commission, Report of the Hearings on the Commercialisation of Religion and Abuse of People's Belief Systems (August 2017).",
"body": "Primary official report: findings and recommendations on commercialisation of religion and abuse of belief systems in South Africa's unregulated religious sector.",
"tier": "official-finding",
"kind": "commission-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.forsa.org.za/articles/summary-of-the-current-status-on-the-crls-report-on-the-commercialisation-of-religion-and-the-abuse-of-peoples-belief-systems",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FOR SA, 'Summary of the Current Status on the CRL's Report on the Commercialisation of Religion and the Abuse of People's Belief Systems' (blog).",
"body": "Summarises the report's findings, the specific practices documented (exorbitant fees, dangerous ingestion practices), and the 2018 government rejection of the regulatory recommendations.",
"tier": "advocacy-org-summary",
"kind": "status-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/24693/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Parliamentary Monitoring Group, 'Commercialisation of Religion and Abuse of People's Belief Systems: CRL Rights Commission briefing' (committee meeting record).",
"body": "Official parliamentary committee record of the Commission's briefing on the report's findings and recommendations.",
"tier": "official-record",
"kind": "parliamentary-committee-record"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201708/report-commecializationofreligionandabuseofpeoplesbelievesystems.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding; evidentiary role: commission-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "667ad6b2866431d398590624679091bc50ff709abfe325cd1aee7a6a1d2047ab",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201708/report-commecializationofreligionandabuseofpeoplesbelievesystems.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.forsa.org.za/articles/summary-of-the-current-status-on-the-crls-report-on-the-commercialisation-of-religion-and-the-abuse-of-peoples-belief-systems",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-org-summary; evidentiary role: status-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/24693/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-record; evidentiary role: parliamentary-committee-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9dae5de56a84a4fab9b72b9d04bc05df8f68025f3a6f224c5bc80a485b06b024",
"final_url": "https://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/24693/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9001,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Perpetrator's name not published in the located Swedish reporting (Dagen, a national Christian daily, did not identify him). Victim was a 14-year-old congregation member, not a family member — explicitly distinguished from the family-abuse pattern that dominates Nordic Laestadian/free-church coverage. No appeal reported; the district court sentence appears final.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-linkoping-pentecostal-youth-leader-sweden",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Linköping, Östergötland, Sweden",
"lat": 58.4109,
"lng": 15.6216,
"title": "Sweden: Pentecostal youth-ministry leader convicted of raping a 14-year-old congregation member",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth-ministry leader (ungdomsledare) in a Pentecostal (Pingst) congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position of trust in the congregation's youth work, exploited directly against a minor member",
"access to church youth facilities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Pingströrelsen (Pentecostal Movement, Sweden) — local Östergötland congregation, unnamed in source"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Linköpings tingsrätt (Linköping District Court), Sweden",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2013-04-05",
"outcome": "A 42-year-old man engaged in youth ministry (ungdomsarbete) at a local Pentecostal congregation was convicted of raping a 14-year-old girl who attended the congregation's youth activities, at the church's own facilities. He was sentenced to four years' imprisonment. The court held that he had 'abused a position of trust in relation to the victim and subjected the victim to a serious violation' (missbrukat ett förtroende i förhållande till målsäganden och utsatt målsäganden för en allvarlig kränkning)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a minor member of the congregation whose access to the perpetrator ran entirely through his formal role in the church's youth ministry; the district court's own finding centered on his abuse of that position of trust rather than treating the case as generic acquaintance rape.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dagen.se/nyheter/fangelse-for-sexuella-overgrepp-i-pingstkyrka/3118725",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Fängelse för sexuella övergrepp i pingstkyrka', Dagen, 5 April 2013.",
"body": "Sweden's national Christian daily reporting the Linköping District Court conviction and sentence: 'tingsrätten [...] anser att mannen missbrukat ett förtroende i förhållande till målsäganden och utsatt målsäganden för en allvarlig kränkning' (the district court [...] finds the man abused a position of trust in relation to the victim and subjected the victim to a serious violation). English gloss inline above.",
"tier": "national-christian-daily",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dagen.se/nyheter/fangelse-for-sexuella-overgrepp-i-pingstkyrka/3118725",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-christian-daily; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2ca4603d8084d1e0c9cbeac3d39ce0f13049c2d6d9c2f082b49f5130f65390e9",
"final_url": "https://www.dagen.se/nyheter/fangelse-for-sexuella-overgrepp-i-pingstkyrka/3118725"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9002,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Perpetrator's name and specific congregation not published in the located Norwegian reporting (Vårt Land, the national Christian daily, and Romerikes Blad withheld identifying detail beyond 'menighetsleder'). Victim was a congregation member 37 years younger, not a family member. No appeal reported.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-romerike-congregation-leader-norway",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Romerike, Akershus, Norway",
"lat": 59.9558,
"lng": 11.0489,
"title": "Norway: congregation leader convicted of six-year sexual exploitation of a member who saw his words as God's word",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"menighetsleder (congregation leader) of several decades' standing"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"the victim regarded the leader's words as God's word; fear of God was cited by the court as part of why she felt compelled to endure the relationship",
"structural dependency relationship between leader and member"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"prophecy-divine-command"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Romerike og Glåmdal tingrett (Romerike and Glåmdal District Court), Norway",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-05-03",
"outcome": "A former congregation leader was convicted of repeated sexual abuse of a member 37 years his junior, whom he first met when she was a child; the court found the six-year sexual relationship (2012-2018) was obtained in a manner that excluded genuine voluntariness because of the dependent relationship. He was sentenced to one year and seven months' imprisonment and ordered to pay NOK 220,000 in compensation. The court noted the victim regarded the leader's words as God's word, and that fear of God was part of why she felt she had to endure the relationship."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court's own finding is the spiritual nexus: the victim experienced the congregation leader's authority as divinely sanctioned speech ('hans ord som Guds ord'), and fear of God — not merely personal deference — was identified as a specific reason she could not refuse or leave the relationship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.vl.no/nyheter/2023/05/03/menighetsleder-i-romerike-domt-for-seksuelle-overgrep-som-pagikk-over-seks-ar/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Menighetsleder i Romerike dømt for seksuelle overgrep som pågikk over seks år', Vårt Land, 3 May 2023.",
"body": "Norway's national Christian daily reporting the conviction; quotes the court's finding that the victim 'så hans ord som Guds ord, og gudsfrykt var en del av grunnen til at hun følte hun måtte holde ut forholdet' (saw his words as God's word, and fear of God was part of why she felt she had to endure the relationship). English gloss inline above.",
"tier": "national-christian-daily",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rb.no/kvinnen-var-barn-da-hun-motte-menighetslederen-sa-innledet-de-et-forhold-veldig-trist/s/5-43-2002847",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Kvinnen var barn da hun møtte menighetslederen. Så innledet de et forhold', Romerikes Blad.",
"body": "Regional Norwegian paper of record covering the Romerike og Glåmdal tingrett case, confirming the sentence (1 year 7 months) and that the woman was a child ('barn') when she first met the congregation leader.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.vl.no/nyheter/2023/05/03/menighetsleder-i-romerike-domt-for-seksuelle-overgrep-som-pagikk-over-seks-ar/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-christian-daily; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8ba44c57a393caea63c13d2b13f23055ce53b5ec23cec2424822289083df3928",
"final_url": "https://www.vl.no/nyheter/menighetsleder-i-romerike-domt-for-seksuelle-overgrep-som-pagikk-over-seks-ar/850622"
},
{
"source": "https://www.rb.no/kvinnen-var-barn-da-hun-motte-menighetslederen-sa-innledet-de-et-forhold-veldig-trist/s/5-43-2002847",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "406bd6630913e1afca97da6aa5f7212f0dee6d6d4264da1cccb372ca2c37fc00",
"final_url": "https://www.rb.no/kvinnen-var-barn-da-hun-motte-menighetslederen-sa-innledet-de-et-forhold-veldig-trist/s/5-43-2002847"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9003,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victim Steinunn Anna Radha spoke publicly and is named in Icelandic press; the perpetrator's name was not located in the sourced coverage. Abuse occurred in the months after he left his formal youth-leader post but grew directly out of the grooming relationship he built in that role; the congregation's own board chairman testified to the power imbalance. Criminal conviction confirmed by the victim's own account and corroborated by congregational testimony; specific court name and sentence not located in the available source and are omitted rather than guessed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-smarakirkja-youth-leader-iceland",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Kópavogur, Iceland",
"lat": 64.1039,
"lng": -21.9022,
"title": "Iceland: Smárakirkja youth leader convicted of sexually abusing a 15-year-old member he had groomed",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth leader (æskulýðsleiðtogi) at Smárakirkja (formerly Krossinn), an independent charismatic congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"grooming built through his formal youth-leadership role and age/status authority over a 15-year-old member",
"congregation-recognized power imbalance between adult leader and teenage member"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Smárakirkja (formerly Krossinn), Kópavogur, Iceland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Icelandic criminal court (specific court not identified in source)",
"stage": "conviction",
"outcome": "A youth leader at the Smárakirkja congregation (then called Krossinn) was criminally convicted of sexually abusing Steinunn Anna Radha, whom he had groomed from around age 15 through his position at the church. He worked at the church for roughly three months before being dismissed; the abuse, which the victim says continued for about a year, occurred after his dismissal but arose directly from the relationship of trust he had built as youth leader. The victim reported him and won the case at trial: 'Ég kærði hann, vann málið og hann var dæmdur' (I reported him, won the case, and he was convicted)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's access point to the perpetrator, and the trust that made the grooming possible, was entirely his formal role as the congregation's youth leader; the church's own board chairman testified at the civil/church review stage that the age and power gap between leader and teenage member could not be minimized ('engin sykurhúðun').",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.visir.is/g/20222232513d/smara-kirkja-hafnar-thvi-ad-vera-ser-truar-sofnudur",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Smárakirkja hafnar því að vera sértrúarsöfnuður', Vísir, 2022.",
"body": "Icelandic national news site reporting Steinunn Anna Radha's account of grooming and abuse by a Smárakirkja (then Krossinn) youth leader from age 15, her criminal complaint and conviction, and the church board chairman's testimony regarding the power imbalance. English gloss inline above.",
"tier": "national-online-newspaper",
"kind": "victim-account-and-verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.visir.is/g/20222232513d/smara-kirkja-hafnar-thvi-ad-vera-ser-truar-sofnudur",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-online-newspaper; evidentiary role: victim-account-and-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4f10938ad0a357b3bbe65e4a5c3e47a11b1d1b6f50a12a8641034fadec0be909",
"final_url": "https://www.visir.is/g/20222232513d/smara-kirkja-hafnar-thvi-ad-vera-ser-truar-sofnudur"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1078,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sentence quantum not confirmed beyond the reported statutory maximum; not asserted as the final figure.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2001-mokesh-prashad-gopal-temple-queens-usa",
"year": 2001,
"place": "Richmond Hill, Queens, New York, USA",
"lat": 40.6989,
"lng": -73.837,
"title": "United States: Hindu priest convicted of sexually abusing a parishioner who came to him for counseling",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest, Gopal Temple, Richmond Hill"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sought out as a spiritual counselor on her mother's suggestion",
"ritual pretext ('a reading') used to have her undress",
"assault at his home under the guise of a religious rite"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Gopal Temple, Richmond Hill, Queens"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "New York State Supreme Court, Queens County (Kew Gardens)",
"stage": "jury conviction",
"date": "2001-04-01",
"outcome": "Mokesh Narine Prashad, a priest at the Gopal Temple in Richmond Hill, was found guilty by a jury of two counts of sexual abuse. A 19-year-old congregant testified she went to his home for counseling at her mother's suggestion; he told her to remove her blouse so he could perform a religious 'reading', then had her lie on the floor and rubbed her with alcohol and salt before assaulting her. Judge Ronald Hollie scheduled sentencing for 20 April 2001, with Prashad facing up to seven years; the final sentence imposed is not confirmed in available reporting and is not asserted here. No reversal or appeal is documented."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim approached Prashad specifically in his capacity as priest, seeking spiritual counseling; he used a fabricated ritual ('a reading') as the pretext to isolate and assault her — the religious rite was the operative mechanism, not incidental to it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://qns.com/story/2001/04/04/hindu-priest-convicted-in-sex-abuse-of-teen",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Hindu priest convicted in sex abuse of teen', Queens Ledger/QNS (4 Apr. 2001).",
"body": "Contemporary trial report: verdict, victim's testimony about the counseling visit and the 'reading' pretext, and the scheduled sentencing exposure.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://qns.com/story/2001/04/04/hindu-priest-convicted-in-sex-abuse-of-teen",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d7cf4439b5c8bbcedff63e337506fa2e4d156867156bc6692ed3fd14200a5068",
"final_url": "https://qns.com/2001/04/hindu-priest-convicted-in-sex-abuse-of-teen/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1079,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim, not named. Exact sentencing date given as reported (year confirmed, precise day not located); not asserted beyond what is sourced.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-adhyatma-amithananda-tongaat-south-africa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "oThongathi (Tongaat), KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa",
"lat": -29.5667,
"lng": 31.1167,
"title": "South Africa: Hindu priest from Kerala sentenced to an effective life term for raping a 12-year-old girl he claimed to be healing",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Hindu priest and self-proclaimed spiritual teacher, invited from Kerala by local religious leaders"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed healing power over the girl's epilepsy",
"family's religious deference after meeting him at a temple discourse",
"grooming via promised cure before escalating to rape"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Verulam Regional Court, KwaZulu-Natal",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2016-01-01",
"outcome": "Adhyatma Amithananda, 57, a Hindu priest who arrived in South Africa from Kerala in March 2010 at the invitation of local religious leaders, was convicted before Regional Court Magistrate Jenny Pillay on six counts of rape, two of sexual grooming, and creating/publishing/possessing child pornography. The victim, a 12-year-old girl with epilepsy from oThongathi (Tongaat), was brought to him by her family — who had met him at a temple religious discourse — so he could pray over and cure her condition; he sexually abused her from June 2010 and raped her repeatedly from March 2011. Sentences ran concurrently for an effective 25 years, reported in South African press as a life term, with parole eligibility thereafter."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The family's approach to Amithananda was explicitly religious — a healer met through a temple discourse, entrusted with curing the child through prayer — and that entrustment is what delivered her into his sustained access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iol.co.za/news/swami-gets-life-for-raping-girl-1433792",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Swami gets life for raping girl', IOL News (South Africa).",
"body": "South African national press report on the conviction, sentence, and the healing pretext by which the victim's family brought her to him.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iol.co.za/news/swami-gets-life-for-raping-girl-1433792",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1080,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor victim at time of offending, not named. Exact sentencing date beyond 'sentenced in May' not confirmed; not asserted. The post-sentencing motion outcome is the most recent confirmed disposition — a full appellate outcome, if any, was not located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-cooper-reddy-chatsworth-south-africa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Chatsworth (Havenside), Durban, South Africa",
"lat": -29.9241,
"lng": 30.8991,
"title": "South Africa: Hindu priest jailed for raping a child devotee brought to him to be blessed",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Hindu priest, Chatsworth"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"child brought to him specifically to receive a religious blessing",
"repeated access over several years under that pretext"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Durban Magistrate's Court",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; post-trial application to reopen case for new evidence dismissed",
"outcome": "Cooper Reddy, 60, of Havenside, Chatsworth, was convicted on two counts of rape, one of indecent assault and one of sexual assault, and sentenced to 15 years in prison. The complainant, taken to Reddy to be blessed, was nine years old when the abuse began in 2006; it continued until 2010. After sentencing, Reddy's lawyer applied to the Durban Magistrate's Court to reopen the defence case to admit further evidence, arguing inadequate trial representation; the application was dismissed, the prosecution successfully arguing the statute was not intended to let the defence supplement evidence it had failed to lead at trial. The conviction stood at that stage; no further appellate outcome is confirmed in available reporting."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child was brought to Reddy specifically for a religious blessing — an act of parental religious deference that produced the sustained private access underlying a multi-year pattern of abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.iol.co.za/news/rapist-priests-court-bid-fails-1580709",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Rapist priest's court bid fails', IOL News (South Africa).",
"body": "Reports the original conviction and 15-year sentence, and the failed post-sentencing motion to reopen the case.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "post-trial-motion-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.iol.co.za/news/rapist-priests-court-bid-fails-1580709",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: post-trial-motion-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "skipped-robots",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9108,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sala Penal Tercera del Tribunal Departamental de Justicia de Cochabamba (Third Criminal Chamber, Cochabamba Departmental Court of Justice), Bolivia",
"stage": "appeal decided; sentence affirmed",
"date": "2026-05-29",
"outcome": "The Third Criminal Chamber rejected the defense appeals of both convicted former Jesuit provincials and confirmed the September 2025 first-instance sentence in full."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Companion record to the existing institutional-event record 2023-alfonso-pedrajas-jesuit-diary-cochabamba-bolivia, which explicitly notes that 'separate 2026 Bolivian court proceedings against Jesuit superiors addressed concealment of his abuse, not his own personal guilt, and are not the basis of this record.' This record is that separate proceeding: an individual criminal conviction of two named former Jesuit provincial superiors for covering up Alfonso Pedrajas's abuse, now affirmed on appeal. Filed as a core record (not institutional-event) because it is a named-defendant criminal conviction that stood through appellate review, distinct from the diary discovery itself and from the Sodalitium papal-suppression pattern. Dedup-checked against corpus: no existing record covers Alaix, Recolons, or the concealment conviction; only the diary-discovery record and the unrelated Spain Jesuit province report reference Pedrajas.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-alaix-recolons-jesuit-concealment-cochabamba-bolivia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Cochabamba, Bolivia",
"lat": -17.3895,
"lng": -66.1568,
"title": "Bolivia: two former Jesuit provincial superiors convicted of covering up Alfonso Pedrajas's abuse of boarding-school children, sentence affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Ramón Alaix, Spanish Jesuit priest, Provincial Superior of the Society of Jesus in Bolivia 1999-2007",
"Marcos Recolons, Spanish Jesuit priest, Provincial Superior of the Society of Jesus in Bolivia 1993-1999, later a senior Jesuit official in Rome"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"provincial superiors' institutional authority over the order's internal reporting channels, which they used to receive and suppress knowledge of a subordinate priest's abuse of children in the order's care",
"the underlying abuse itself was made possible by Pedrajas's own residential, teacher-priest authority over impoverished boarding-school boys at Jesuit institutions in Cochabamba; the concealment by his superiors extended that harm by protecting his continued access"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of Jesus, Bolivia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Departamental de Justicia de Cochabamba (Cochabamba Departmental Court of Justice), Bolivia",
"stage": "first-instance criminal sentence",
"date": "2025-09-01",
"outcome": "A Cochabamba criminal court convicted Ramón Alaix and Marcos Recolons, both former Provincial Superiors of the Society of Jesus in Bolivia, of covering up (encubrimiento de abuso sexual) the sexual abuse committed by priest Alfonso 'Pica' Pedrajas against children at the Jesuit-run Colegio Juan XXIII boarding school in Cochabamba. Each was sentenced to one year of imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Sala Penal Tercera del Tribunal Departamental de Justicia de Cochabamba (Third Criminal Chamber, Cochabamba Departmental Court of Justice), Bolivia",
"stage": "appeal decided; sentence affirmed",
"date": "2026-05-29",
"outcome": "The appellate chamber rejected the defense's appeal and confirmed the one-year sentences against both Alaix and Recolons, making the concealment conviction final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Alaix and Recolons held the Jesuit order's own internal authority over reports of clerical misconduct within the province; the court found they used that institutional position to receive knowledge of Pedrajas's abuse of boarding-school children and suppress it rather than report it, which is a distinct criminal wrong from Pedrajas's own abuse and one that stood through the full appellate process, unlike the underlying abuser's own prosecution, foreclosed by his 2009 death.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/justicia-ratifica-condena-exprovinciales-jesuitas-encubrir-abusos-pica/20260529111323991779.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Opinión (Cochabamba), 'Ratifican condena contra exprovinciales jesuitas por encubrir abusos de \"Pica\"' (29 May 2026).",
"body": "La Sala Penal Tercera del Tribunal Departamental de Justicia de Cochabamba rechazó la apelación presentada por la defensa de los exprovinciales jesuitas Marcos Recolons y Ramón Alaix, y ratificó la sentencia de septiembre de 2025 que los condenó a un año de prisión por el delito de encubrimiento de los abusos sexuales cometidos por el sacerdote Alfonso 'Pica' Pedrajas. Recolons fue provincial jesuita entre 1993 y 1999, y Alaix entre 1999 y 2007. // English gloss: The Third Criminal Chamber of the Cochabamba Departmental Court of Justice rejected the appeal filed by the defense of former Jesuit provincials Marcos Recolons and Ramón Alaix, and confirmed the September 2025 sentence that convicted them of one year in prison for the crime of covering up the sexual abuse committed by priest Alfonso 'Pica' Pedrajas. Recolons was Jesuit provincial from 1993 to 1999, and Alaix from 1999 to 2007.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lostiempos.com/actualidad/pais/20260529/ratifican-condena-contra-exlideres-jesuitas-encubrimiento-abusos-sexuales",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Los Tiempos (Cochabamba), 'Ratifican condena contra exlíderes jesuitas por encubrimiento de abusos sexuales' (29 May 2026).",
"body": "El tribunal de alzada confirmó la condena de un año de cárcel contra Ramón Alaix y Marcos Recolons, ambos exprovinciales de la Compañía de Jesús en Bolivia, por encubrir los abusos sexuales cometidos por el sacerdote Alfonso Pedrajas contra menores del internado Juan XXIII de Cochabamba. La Comunidad Boliviana de Sobrevivientes calcula que las víctimas de Pedrajas rondan las doscientas. // English gloss: The appellate court confirmed the one-year prison sentence against Ramón Alaix and Marcos Recolons, both former provincials of the Society of Jesus in Bolivia, for covering up the sexual abuse committed by priest Alfonso Pedrajas against children at the Juan XXIII boarding school in Cochabamba. The Bolivian Survivors Community estimates Pedrajas's victims number around two hundred.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sala Penal Tercera del Tribunal Departamental de Justicia de Cochabamba (Third Criminal Chamber, Cochabamba Departmental Court of Justice), Bolivia",
"stage": "appeal decided; sentence affirmed",
"date": "2026-05-29",
"outcome": "The Third Criminal Chamber rejected the defense appeals of both convicted former Jesuit provincials and confirmed the September 2025 first-instance sentence in full."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/justicia-ratifica-condena-exprovinciales-jesuitas-encubrir-abusos-pica/20260529111323991779.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e71ad62041a2e3893a19ae5a09364a555ed7556cf169c0c79ab2248128ad671b",
"final_url": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/justicia-ratifica-condena-exprovinciales-jesuitas-encubrir-abusos-pica/20260529111323991779.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lostiempos.com/actualidad/pais/20260529/ratifican-condena-contra-exlideres-jesuitas-encubrimiento-abusos-sexuales",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dad7249653439c2ca1b13001694cf7c51ed4e956072133d64812bd1a05e87187",
"final_url": "https://www.lostiempos.com/actualidad/pais/20260529/ratifican-condena-contra-exlideres-jesuitas-encubrimiento-abusos-sexuales"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9108,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Ishak's Oakland County conviction and sentence as reported by the Chaldean Diocese of St. Thomas the Apostle U.S.A. and contemporaneous press. Ishak was a subdeacon/sacristan, not an ordained priest; the record does not attribute his conduct to the Chaldean Catholic Church, Chaldean Americans, or Assyrian/Iraqi Christians generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-hurmiz-ishak-troy-michigan-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Troy, MI, USA",
"lat": 42.6064,
"lng": -83.1498,
"title": "Hurmiz Ishak: Chaldean Catholic subdeacon convicted of assaulting a teen altar boy at his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"subdeacon, St. Joseph Chaldean Catholic Church, Troy, Michigan",
"sacristan with church-opening and closing access since 1997"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"sacred liturgical role (subdeacon/sacristan) giving unsupervised access to a teen altar server",
"decades of trusted standing in the parish (served since 1997)",
"control of access to church spaces before and after services"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Joseph Chaldean Catholic Church, Troy, Michigan",
"Chaldean Diocese of St. Thomas the Apostle U.S.A."
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Oakland County Circuit Court, Michigan",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2019-09-27",
"outcome": "A jury convicted Ishak on August 29, 2019 of one count of third-degree criminal sexual conduct (acquitting on other counts). On September 27, 2019, the court sentenced him to 48 months to 15 years in prison, with parole eligibility after four years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ishak was a subdeacon and longtime sacristan at St. Joseph Chaldean Catholic Church, roles that gave him sacred liturgical standing and physical access to the church building and to a teen altar server, whom he assaulted between May 2017 and October 2018. The diocese's own statement and press reporting establish that his position — assisting at services and controlling access to the church — was the means of contact with the victim, not merely the setting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://chaldeanchurch.org/sentencing-of-chaldean-church-worker-found-guilty-of-child-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Chaldean Diocese of St. Thomas the Apostle U.S.A., 'Sentencing of Chaldean Church Worker Found Guilty of Child Sexual Abuse' (Sept. 2019).",
"body": "The diocese's own statement confirms the September 27, 2019 sentencing, the 48-month-to-15-year term, the Oakland County Circuit Court venue, and Ishak's role as sacristan since 1997.",
"tier": "official-diocesan-statement",
"kind": "institutional-disclosure"
},
{
"link": "https://legalnews.com/Home/Articles?DataId=1479558",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Legal News (Michigan), 'Former church worker sent to prison for assault' (Oct. 2019).",
"body": "Reports the sentence, parole eligibility after four years, and identifies the victim as a teen altar boy assaulted through Ishak's subdeacon and sacristan access to the church.",
"tier": "trade-legal-press",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/oakland-county/2018/11/01/troy-deacon-charged-sex-assaults-teen-boy/1843394002/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Detroit News, 'Troy sub-deacon charged with sex assaults on teen boy' (Nov. 1, 2018).",
"body": "Contemporaneous charging-stage reporting corroborating the church setting, dates of the alleged conduct (May 2017-October 2018), and Ishak's subdeacon role.",
"tier": "metro-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-charge-corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://chaldeanchurch.org/sentencing-of-chaldean-church-worker-found-guilty-of-child-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-diocesan-statement; evidentiary role: institutional-disclosure.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "394e4e537995761674dbd548800a65514095d5525b3fce05350fc7a1af0aa3e3",
"final_url": "https://chaldeanchurch.org/sentencing-of-chaldean-church-worker-found-guilty-of-child-sexual-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://legalnews.com/Home/Articles?DataId=1479558",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: trade-legal-press; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ab0b159f514a263e90308c7d55d65097de18cc7c3ad8cef2b41c72f4fe3b0763",
"final_url": "https://legalnews.com/Home/Articles?DataId=1479558"
},
{
"source": "https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/oakland-county/2018/11/01/troy-deacon-charged-sex-assaults-teen-boy/1843394002/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: metro-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-charge-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "03c6cc5ca7380e285db9f856fa03e696ea1843c40eff4fd0f0c2e55ee88fcd43",
"final_url": "https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/oakland-county/2018/11/01/troy-deacon-charged-sex-assaults-teen-boy/1843394002/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9109,
"aliases": [
"Fr. Philip Ferrara"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Ferrara's Susquehanna County no-contest plea and sentence. Ferrara was a member of the Melkite Greek-Catholic Eparchy of Newton operating a Roman Catholic diocese-permitted retreat house; the record does not attribute his conduct to the Melkite Greek Catholic Church, Eastern Catholics, or the Diocese of Scranton generally. He also appears in the 2018 Pennsylvania grand jury report, which otherwise excluded Eastern Catholic eparchies from its scope (see below).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-philip-ferrara-little-meadows-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Little Meadows, PA, USA",
"lat": 41.9679,
"lng": -75.9738,
"title": "Philip Ferrara: Melkite Greek Catholic priest convicted after using a retreat house to assault a boy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest, Melkite Greek-Catholic Eparchy of Newton",
"founder/director, Our Lady of Solitude retreat house, Little Meadows, Pennsylvania"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly authority exercised at a retreat house he founded and ran",
"isolation of the victim at the retreat property",
"religious framing (retreat setting) used to obtain physical contact under pretext of massage"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [
"Melkite Greek-Catholic Eparchy of Newton",
"Our Lady of Solitude retreat house / Society of the Annunciation of Our Lord"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Susquehanna County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania",
"stage": "no-contest plea and sentence",
"date": "2011-10-01",
"outcome": "Ferrara pleaded no contest to indecent assault and corruption of minors. In October 2011 the court sentenced him to six months to two years in state prison plus a fine."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ferrara, a Melkite priest, founded and ran a retreat house in rural Pennsylvania where he isolated a 14-year-old boy and, under the pretext of a religious retreat, directed the boy to give him oil massages during which the assaults occurred. His clerical status and control of the retreat property were what put the boy alone with him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://greekreporter.com/2011/10/21/melkite-greek-catholic-priest-charged-with-indecent-assault-and-corruption/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Greek Reporter, 'Melkite Greek Catholic Priest Charged with Indecent Assault and Corruption' (Oct. 21, 2011).",
"body": "Reports the charges, the retreat-house setting at Lake O'Meadows Road, the oil-massage pretext, and the priest's Melkite Greek Catholic affiliation.",
"tier": "press",
"kind": "criminal-charge-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.adamhorowitzlaw.com/blog/fr-philip-ferrara-diocese-of-scranton/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Horowitz Law, 'Fr. Philip Ferrara – Diocese of Scranton' (attorney case summary, citing Times-Tribune reporting).",
"body": "Summarizes Ferrara's Melkite Eparchy of Newton membership, his founding of the Society of the Annunciation of Our Lord retreat with Diocese of Scranton permission, the March 2011 arrest, no-contest plea, and 6-month-to-2-year sentence.",
"tier": "legal-case-summary",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/ferrara-philip-1990/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org, 'Fr. Philip Ferrara' accused-clergy database entry.",
"body": "Independent accountability-database corroboration of Ferrara's identity, Melkite affiliation, retreat house, charges and disposition, and his listing in the 2018 Pennsylvania 40th statewide grand jury report.",
"tier": "accountability-database",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://greekreporter.com/2011/10/21/melkite-greek-catholic-priest-charged-with-indecent-assault-and-corruption/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press; evidentiary role: criminal-charge-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ea72eb873ac327dd699f714661ec99fd1ee9b1b59a1d9e6f3b2c7d2e49b5bbc0",
"final_url": "https://greekreporter.com/2011/10/21/melkite-greek-catholic-priest-charged-with-indecent-assault-and-corruption/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.adamhorowitzlaw.com/blog/fr-philip-ferrara-diocese-of-scranton/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-case-summary; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "507fa4c0980c355f8bcebf69028dd18282826b1844fa416765930ee8778a9aef",
"final_url": "https://www.adamhorowitzlaw.com/blog/fr-philip-ferrara-diocese-of-scranton/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/ferrara-philip-1990/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: accountability-database; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8971c8cd446c9ef24d5f46919feabc7e16dbb062a96269a6c138caa29c591b36",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/ferrara-philip-1990/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9110,
"aliases": [
"Fr. Matthew Berko"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This record concerns Berko's 1985 Ontario guilty plea for the January 1984 assault of the parish youth-group president and the corroborating 1990 Ontario civil judgment. It does not address his later Connecticut probation term (a separate matter) or his subsequent unrelated pastoral assignment in Florida, noted here only for chronology.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1985-matthew-berko-mississauga-ontario-canada",
"year": 1985,
"place": "Mississauga, ON, Canada",
"lat": 43.589,
"lng": -79.6441,
"title": "Matthew Berko: Ukrainian Greek Catholic priest convicted of assaulting his parish youth-group president",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, St. Mary's Ukrainian Catholic Church, Mississauga, Ontario",
"youth-group spiritual director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a 14-year-old parishioner who led his own parish youth group",
"access to the church rectory as pastor",
"trust placed in him as spiritual leader of the youth group she headed"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Mary's Ukrainian Catholic Church, Mississauga, Ontario",
"Ukrainian Catholic Eparchy of Toronto and Eastern Canada"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario criminal court (Peel Region)",
"stage": "guilty plea",
"date": "1985-01-01",
"outcome": "Berko pleaded guilty in 1985 to sexually assaulting a 14-year-old parishioner, president of his parish youth group, at the church rectory on January 19, 1984."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario civil court",
"stage": "civil judgment",
"date": "1990-01-01",
"outcome": "An Ontario judge awarded the victim and her parents nearly $1 million in damages, finding Berko's conduct 'despicable and a flagrant breach of trust.' The judgment corroborates the criminal plea; it was never paid."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was president of the youth group at Berko's parish and was assaulted by her own pastor at the church rectory. The Ontario civil court that later awarded damages explicitly characterized his conduct as a breach of the trust his pastoral office carried, and the criminal guilty plea concerns the same underlying facts.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://bishop-accountability.org/news3/2002_04_10_Moore_ConvictedPriest_Matthew_Berko_1.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "St. Petersburg Times, 'Convicted Priest Removed from St. Petersburg Post' by Waveney Ann Moore (Apr. 10, 2002).",
"body": "Reports the January 19, 1984 assault of 14-year-old Alexandra Myhal, president of the parish youth group, at St. Mary's Ukrainian Catholic Church rectory in Mississauga; Berko's 1985 guilty plea; and the 1990 Ontario civil judgment of nearly $1 million for 'despicable' conduct and 'flagrant breach of trust.'",
"tier": "state-newspaper-investigative-report",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/catholic-church-sex-abuse-scandals",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Canadian Encyclopedia, 'Catholic Church Sex Abuse Scandals.'",
"body": "Independently corroborates Berko as a Ukrainian Catholic priest convicted of sexually assaulting a 14-year-old parishioner in Mississauga, Ontario, in 1985.",
"tier": "encyclopedic-reference",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/berko-matthew-1962/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org, 'Fr. Matthew Berko' accused-clergy database entry.",
"body": "Database entry collating the Ukrainian Catholic Diocese of St. Josaphat of Parma ordination record (1962), the Mississauga assault and 1985 guilty plea, the 1990 civil judgment, and his 2002 removal from a Florida Ukrainian Catholic parish when the assigning bishop learned of the history.",
"tier": "accountability-database",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://bishop-accountability.org/news3/2002_04_10_Moore_ConvictedPriest_Matthew_Berko_1.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newspaper-investigative-report; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f27c2f7c2d36bd10dbe934280395f37d0062f7a991ba32668c043af274c8c0f7",
"final_url": "https://bishop-accountability.org/news3/2002_04_10_Moore_ConvictedPriest_Matthew_Berko_1.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/catholic-church-sex-abuse-scandals",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: encyclopedic-reference; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/berko-matthew-1962/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: accountability-database; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bac480fd973fb08582d8baba9774423a2029f6f35b6550dc840bc97568224712",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/berko-matthew-1962/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9201,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Distinct defendant from the already-corpus Anna Wesley record (1999-anna-wesley-st-annes-fort-albany-canada) — same institution, same 1992-1998 OPP investigation, separate nun, separate conviction and sentence. Kakeychewan was a supervisor/dormitory nun, not the same person as Wesley. Do not merge.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-jane-kakeychewan-st-annes-fort-albany-canada",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Fort Albany, Ontario, Canada",
"lat": 52.1833,
"lng": -81.6833,
"title": "Canada: St Anne's residential-school nun convicted of assaulting female students",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"nun and supervisor of female students at a church-run residential school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"custodial and disciplinary authority over Indigenous children removed from their families",
"physical punishment inflicted under religious institutional cover"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St Anne's Indian Residential School",
"Grey Nuns of Montreal (Sisters of Charity)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario court, Canada",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "1998-01-01",
"outcome": "Jane Kakeychewan, an Ojibwe nun who had herself attended a residential school as a child and later served as a nun and supervisor at St Anne's Indian Residential School, was convicted in 1998 of three counts of assault causing bodily harm against female students in her care. She received a six-month conditional sentence. The conviction arose from a 1992-1998 Ontario Provincial Police investigation into abuse at St Anne's that interviewed roughly 700 victims and witnesses."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were Indigenous children removed into a church-run residential school where a nun's religious office and total custodial power over female students were the same authority; refusal or disclosure was not available to children held under that combined institutional and religious control.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/st-annes-nun-residential-school-charges-1.7001318",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former St. Anne's nun 8th person charged for alleged abuses at that residential school', CBC News.",
"body": "CBC News retrospective on the St Anne's investigation confirming Jane Kakaychawan's 1998 conviction on three counts of assault causing bodily harm and her six-month conditional sentence, distinct from Anna Wesley's separate 1999 conviction.",
"tier": "national-public-broadcaster",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Anne%27s_Indian_Residential_School",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'St. Anne's Indian Residential School', Wikipedia, citing the OPP investigation and prosecution outcomes.",
"body": "Summary of the OPP investigation (1992-1998, ~700 interviewed, 74 suspects, 7 charged, 5 convicted) and the individual dispositions including Kakeychewan's.",
"tier": "encyclopedia-secondary",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/st-annes-nun-residential-school-charges-1.7001318",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-public-broadcaster; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Anne%27s_Indian_Residential_School",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: encyclopedia-secondary; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1f96c17805cb697d88e39b6c3a19310657b2011968ae4861d4f550cbc6e7f012",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Anne%27s_Indian_Residential_School"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9202,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Three co-defendants (Buirds, McElhinney, Kane) tried together at Edinburgh Sheriff Court for offences at two separate Sisters of Nazareth children's homes (Lasswade and Kilmarnock); recorded as one proceeding covering all three. A retired lay support worker was also convicted in the same trial but is out of scope here (not a woman religious). Distinct proceeding from the separate Glasgow/Cardonald Sisters of Nazareth convictions (O'Gorman and McGuire) recorded separately below — different home, different victims, different court.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-nazareth-house-lasswade-kilmarnock-nuns-scotland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Lasswade and Kilmarnock, Scotland, UK (tried at Edinburgh Sheriff Court)",
"lat": 55.8814,
"lng": -3.1442,
"title": "Scotland: three former Sisters of Nazareth nuns convicted of cruel and unnatural treatment of children in their care",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"nuns of the Sisters of Nazareth holding custodial and religious authority over children resident at two of the order's children's homes"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial and religious authority over children with no outside contact",
"physical punishment presented as institutional discipline within a convent-run home"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Sisters of Nazareth (Poor Sisters of Nazareth)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Edinburgh Sheriff Court, Scotland",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-01-15",
"outcome": "Following a five-week trial, Carol Buirds (known in religion as Sister Carmel Rose), Eileen McElhinney (Sister Mary Eileen) and Dorothy Kane were found guilty of subjecting multiple child victims to cruel and unnatural treatment between 1972 and 1981 at Sisters of Nazareth children's homes in Lasswade and Kilmarnock. Buirds was convicted on 13 charges including assault to severe injury, including rubbing urine-soaked bedding on children, forcing food and soap into their mouths, and locking children in a cupboard and an unlit, waterless cellar; she was jailed for 15 months. McElhinney was convicted on 5 charges and given a 12-month Probation Order with 240 hours' unpaid work and a home curfew (4pm-midnight) for nine months. Kane was convicted on 2 charges of cruel and unnatural treatment and given 150 hours' unpaid work within nine months."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children committed to the Sisters of Nazareth's care were held under the total combined custodial and religious authority of the order; the convent setting and the nuns' religious office were what made the regime of punishment unrefusable and undisclosable to outside authority for over forty years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.copfs.gov.uk/about-copfs/news/nuns-convicted-of-non-recent-child-abuse-at-nazareth-house-children-s-home/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Nuns convicted of non-recent child abuse at Nazareth House children's home', Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS), 15 January 2026.",
"body": "Official Scottish prosecuting authority press release confirming the Edinburgh Sheriff Court convictions, charges and sentences for Buirds, McElhinney and Kane following the five-week trial.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.irishpost.com/news/former-nun-jailed-for-abuse-of-children-at-homes-in-scotland-run-by-catholic-order-the-sisters-of-nazareth-303382",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former nun jailed for abuse of children at homes in Scotland run by Catholic order, the Sisters of Nazareth', The Irish Post.",
"body": "Press coverage corroborating the sentences and identifying the two homes (Lasswade and Kilmarnock) and the abuse period (1972-1981).",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.copfs.gov.uk/about-copfs/news/nuns-convicted-of-non-recent-child-abuse-at-nazareth-house-children-s-home/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "08d271ee918e38312f55410b8ba548c6eefd6df2941370a7018983a92a226a9d",
"final_url": "https://www.copfs.gov.uk/about-copfs/news/nuns-convicted-of-non-recent-child-abuse-at-nazareth-house-children-s-home/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.irishpost.com/news/former-nun-jailed-for-abuse-of-children-at-homes-in-scotland-run-by-catholic-order-the-sisters-of-nazareth-303382",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7bc62f3c8e760171867c687e6b60f5ccccd4e59ea460c67932769b13ae70a037",
"final_url": "https://www.irishpost.com/news/former-nun-jailed-for-abuse-of-children-at-homes-in-scotland-run-by-catholic-order-the-sisters-of-nazareth-303382"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9203,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Separate proceeding from the Edinburgh Sheriff Court trio above — different home (Cardonald, Glasgow, not Lasswade/Kilmarnock), different court (Glasgow Sheriff Court), guilty pleas rather than trial verdict, and a distinct abuse period (1975-1981 at this home). Both are genuine, separately-sourced Sisters of Nazareth convictions and are recorded as two records.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-nazareth-house-cardonald-glasgow-nuns-scotland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Cardonald, Glasgow, Scotland, UK (tried at Glasgow Sheriff Court)",
"lat": 55.8404,
"lng": -4.3392,
"title": "Scotland: two former Sisters of Nazareth nuns plead guilty to abusing eight children at Nazareth House, Glasgow",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"nuns of the Sisters of Nazareth holding custodial and religious authority over children at Nazareth House, Cardonald"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial and religious authority over young children in a convent children's home",
"corporal punishment with implements and public humiliation used as institutional discipline"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Sisters of Nazareth (Poor Sisters of Nazareth)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Glasgow Sheriff Court, Scotland",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-03-25",
"outcome": "Marie O'Gorman (known in religion as Sister Mary Aelred) and Mary McGuire (Sister Maria Bernadette) pleaded guilty to multiple counts of child abuse involving physical violence and cruel mistreatment of eight victims, aged 3-12, at Nazareth House in the Cardonald area of Glasgow between 1975 and 1981. O'Gorman struck children with harnesses and slippers, forced a child into cold baths and made her wear a nappy publicly. McGuire used similar implements; one victim suffered an eye injury from a belt buckle. Both were sentenced to two years' probation supervision and ordered to pay GBP 1,000 compensation per victim; McGuire was additionally ordered to complete 225 hours' unpaid work within 12 months."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children placed in Nazareth House were under the combined custodial and religious authority of the resident Sisters; the convent's closed, faith-governed structure is what left children with no route to disclose or refuse punishment for years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.copfs.gov.uk/about-copfs/news/former-nazareth-house-nuns-and-retired-support-worker-guilty-of-non-recent-child-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Former Nazareth House nuns and retired support worker guilty of non-recent child abuse', Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS), 25 March 2026.",
"body": "Official Scottish prosecuting authority press release confirming the Glasgow Sheriff Court guilty pleas, charges, victim counts and sentences for O'Gorman and McGuire.",
"tier": "official-prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.copfs.gov.uk/about-copfs/news/former-nazareth-house-nuns-and-retired-support-worker-guilty-of-non-recent-child-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "40d6971003e8d470e67d28a07515d407a6edf201890e75c903536b4c0792a1f8",
"final_url": "https://www.copfs.gov.uk/about-copfs/news/former-nazareth-house-nuns-and-retired-support-worker-guilty-of-non-recent-child-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9204,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "One of a small number of individually-prosecuted US nun sexual-abuse cases (as opposed to institutional civil settlements). Giannini admitted to a 1996 church review board that she had molested at least four other boys including one in Chicago pre-transfer; those admissions are recorded as background allegation only, not as separately charged counts, since only the Milwaukee counts were prosecuted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-norma-giannini-st-patricks-milwaukee-usa",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA",
"lat": 43.0389,
"lng": -87.9065,
"title": "United States: Milwaukee nun convicted of sexually abusing two boys she taught as school principal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic nun (Religious Sisters of Mercy), eighth-grade teacher and school principal at St. Patrick's School"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as teacher and school principal over her own students",
"religious authority of a nun combined with direct educational custodial control"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Patrick's School, Milwaukee",
"Religious Sisters of Mercy"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Milwaukee County Circuit Court, Wisconsin, USA",
"stage": "no-contest plea, conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Sister Norma Giannini, who had engaged in dozens of sexual encounters with two boys beginning when they were 12 and 13 while she was their eighth-grade teacher and principal at St. Patrick's School (1964-1969), was charged in December 2006 and pleaded no contest just before trial. Judge M. Joseph Donald sentenced her to 10 years on two felony counts of indecent behavior with a child but stayed the prison sentence in favor of probation and one year's incarceration at a Milwaukee County jail facility, citing her age and health. Giannini had separately admitted to a church review board in 1996 that she had molested at least four other boys."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were her own pupils, and her access to them was inseparable from her combined role as their nun-teacher and school principal; the religious authority of the habit and the disciplinary authority of the principal's office were exercised as one over children who could not refuse a teacher who was also a Sister.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.andersonadvocates.com/news/nun-who-abused-boys-gets-one-year-in-jail-10-years-probation/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Nun who abused boys gets one year in jail, 10 years' probation', Jeff Anderson & Associates (victims' law firm case report).",
"body": "Case summary of the conviction, sentence, and the 1996 church-review-board admissions of additional victims.",
"tier": "law-firm-case-report",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.milwaukeemag.com/DevilinDisguise/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Devil in Disguise', Milwaukee Magazine.",
"body": "Investigative feature on the Giannini case, her role as teacher/principal, and the prosecution timeline.",
"tier": "regional-magazine-investigative",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.andersonadvocates.com/news/nun-who-abused-boys-gets-one-year-in-jail-10-years-probation/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: law-firm-case-report; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c0998e4a40cd07e86e227dee5e8e53a25bc3cbb4b02663ce861dde3ae6e68c64",
"final_url": "https://www.andersonadvocates.com/news/nun-who-abused-boys-gets-one-year-in-jail-10-years-probation/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.milwaukeemag.com/DevilinDisguise/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-magazine-investigative; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b267bcc4d2d3a6af45815e3f2979cac3d7b57d068f0beaa165d24835b3c1a8a8",
"final_url": "https://www.milwaukeemag.com/DevilinDisguise/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9205,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Confirmed by the Sala Penal, Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Entre Ríos, ~June 2021 (exact date not located in sourcing)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "N2 IS CLEARLY SATISFIED HERE, unlike the Magdalene laundries: Toledo's authority over Albarenque was her formal office as prioress (Mother Superior) of a Discalced Carmelite convent over a professed nun bound by vows of obedience and enclosure — the same authority shape as the corpus's existing 1869 Saurin v Starr record, but modern, criminal (not civil), and involving physical torture rather than confinement alone. The victim entered the convent voluntarily at 18 but the coercive confinement and violence began after profession, under the prioress's religious authority over her. First conviction of a Discalced Carmelite nun in Argentine history per the sourcing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-luisa-toledo-carmelite-convent-nogoya-argentina",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Nogoyá, Entre Ríos, Argentina",
"lat": -32.3667,
"lng": -59.7833,
"title": "Argentina: Carmelite prioress convicted of torturing and confining nuns under her authority",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"prioress (Madre Superiora) of the Discalced Carmelite convent of Nogoyá, with formal religious authority over professed nuns bound by vows of obedience"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"formal religious authority as prioress over nuns bound by vows of obedience and enclosure",
"prolonged isolation from family and outside contact",
"physical torture (whipping, gags, cilices/spiked belts, forced fasting) framed as religious discipline"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"organizations": [
"Convento de las Hermanas del Carmelo, Nogoyá (Discalced Carmelites)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Juicio y Apelaciones de Gualeguay, Entre Ríos, Argentina",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-07-01",
"outcome": "Luisa Ester Toledo (religious name Sor María Isabel de la Santísima Trinidad), prioress of the Discalced Carmelite convent of Nogoyá, was convicted of aggravated illegal deprivation of liberty against two nuns under her authority, Silvia Albarenque and Roxana Peña, and sentenced to 3 years' effective imprisonment. The court found she prevented the victims from leaving the convent for years and subjected them to violence, threats and torments including whipping, gags, cilices and beatings. Albarenque had entered the convent at 18 and endured roughly a decade of the abuse before her 2016 public complaint."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Sala Penal, Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Entre Ríos, Argentina",
"stage": "appeal",
"outcome": "The conviction and sentence were confirmed on appeal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were professed nuns under vows of obedience to their prioress; the same religious-authority relationship the corpus's 1869 Saurin v Starr record identifies is present here in a modern criminal case — enclosure, vowed obedience, and the prioress's formal spiritual office over the victims were what made refusal and disclosure impossible for years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.pagina12.com.ar/357841-sometida-a-14-anos-de-encierro-en-el-convento-y-torturas-sis/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sometida a 14 años de encierro en el convento y torturas sistemáticas, Silvia Albarenque cuenta como logró la primera condena a una monja por abuso de poder', Página/12.",
"body": "Argentine national daily's account of the case, the victim's 14 years under Toledo's authority, and confirmation this was the first Argentine conviction of a Discalced Carmelite nun for abuse of power within a convent.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "victim-account-and-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.religiondigital.org/america/Nogoya-Condenan-superiora-torturaba-monjas-penal-parana_0_2309469059.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a tres años de prisión a Luisa Toledo, la madre superiora que torturaba a las monjas de Nogoyá', Religión Digital.",
"body": "Coverage confirming the Tribunal de Juicio y Apelaciones de Gualeguay's 3-year sentence and the appellate confirmation by the Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Entre Ríos.",
"tier": "religion-specialist-press",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://viapais.com.ar/parana/ex-priora-del-convento-carmelita-de-nogoya-cumplio-condena-por-privacion-ilegitima-de-la-libertad/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex priora del convento Carmelita de Nogoyá cumplió condena por privación ilegítima de la libertad', Vía País.",
"body": "Regional press confirming Toledo's formal title as priora (prioress) and completion of sentence for the illegal-deprivation-of-liberty conviction.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Confirmed by the Sala Penal, Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Entre Ríos, ~June 2021 (exact date not located in sourcing)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.pagina12.com.ar/357841-sometida-a-14-anos-de-encierro-en-el-convento-y-torturas-sis/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: victim-account-and-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ef9e0d07292e209ff1b0a38d6b3d43655904bb447c84dd842898cbec695e0e1c",
"final_url": "https://www.pagina12.com.ar/357841-sometida-a-14-anos-de-encierro-en-el-convento-y-torturas-sis/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.religiondigital.org/america/Nogoya-Condenan-superiora-torturaba-monjas-penal-parana_0_2309469059.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religion-specialist-press; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f8faa1ec2cc0733ba5cd391533c8fc1a291fec74d4ad3df0be47dc2567d67a43",
"final_url": "https://www.religiondigital.org/america/Nogoya-Condenan-superiora-torturaba-monjas-penal-parana_0_2309469059.html"
},
{
"source": "https://viapais.com.ar/parana/ex-priora-del-convento-carmelita-de-nogoya-cumplio-condena-por-privacion-ilegitima-de-la-libertad/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2addb5f8ed5b743b20b0681fd1cabd11cfdabf06c80e2fedbb5b0010ac91df02",
"final_url": "https://viapais.com.ar/parana/ex-priora-del-convento-carmelita-de-nogoya-cumplio-condena-por-privacion-ilegitima-de-la-libertad/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9206,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Defense announced intent to appeal to the Tribunal de Casación Penal, Buenos Aires Province, as of the trial-court verdict (28 December 2023); no resolution of that appeal was located."
}
],
"scopeNote": "APPEAL STATUS UNRESOLVED — recorded per the standing rule that a trial-court conviction with a pending, unresolved appeal is not yet confirmed to have stood. Included because the underlying conviction, authority relationship and evidentiary tier are otherwise clean and well-sourced; flagged here rather than omitted so it is not silently dropped, but should be re-checked before being treated as fully settled. Do not upgrade evidenceStatus without confirming the Casación outcome.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-maria-tellez-fajardo-trinitarian-sisters-san-isidro-argentina",
"year": 2023,
"place": "San Isidro, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina",
"lat": -34.4708,
"lng": -58.5074,
"title": "Argentina: Trinitarian Sisters nun convicted of sexually abusing five adolescents at a children's home",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"nun of the Hermanas Trinitarias (Trinitarian Sisters) with residential custodial authority over girls at the order's children's home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"cohabitation authority as the resident religious figure in charge of the home",
"position of trust as caregiver combined with religious office",
"spiritual deflection of disclosure — a victim who reported the abuse to the home's director was told to 'wait for a divine sign'"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Hogar de las Hermanas Trinitarias de Boulogne, San Isidro"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal Oral en lo Criminal 1 de San Isidro, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-12-28",
"outcome": "María Téllez Fajardo (known as Sor Marina), a Colombian-born nun of the Hermanas Trinitarias, was convicted by majority vote of gravely outrageous sexual abuse aggravated by her position of entrusted care, her authority relationship, and the victims' consequent inability to freely consent. The court found systematic, non-isolated abuse of five girls aged 12-17 who cohabited with her at the order's children's home in Boulogne, San Isidro, between 2017 and 2021, exploiting her position of authority. She was sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment; the defense announced it would appeal to the Buenos Aires provincial Tribunal de Casación Penal."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were girls placed in the Trinitarian Sisters' residential care and living under Téllez Fajardo's direct religious and custodial authority as the resident nun in charge; when one victim tried to disclose, the home's own response invoked waiting for a 'divine sign' rather than intervention, illustrating how the institution's religious framing itself blocked escape from the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.perfil.com/noticias/judiciales/condenaron-a-10-anos-de-prision-a-una-monja-por-abuso-sexual-contra-5-adolescentes-en-un-hogar-de-san-isidro.phtml",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenaron a 10 años de prisión a una monja por abuso sexual contra 5 adolescentes en un hogar de San Isidro', Perfil.",
"body": "Report on the Tribunal Oral en lo Criminal 1 de San Isidro verdict, sentence, victim ages, abuse period, and the 'divine sign' detail regarding disclosure.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/sor-marina-culpable-condenaron-a-diez-anos-de-prision-a-una-monja-por-abusar-de-cinco-adolescentes-nid28122023/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sor Marina, culpable: condenaron a diez años de prisión a una monja por abusar de cinco adolescentes', La Nación, 28 December 2023.",
"body": "National paper of record confirming the verdict, the specific legal qualification of the offense (abuse of authority relationship, inability to consent), and the defense's stated intent to appeal to Casación.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Defense announced intent to appeal to the Tribunal de Casación Penal, Buenos Aires Province, as of the trial-court verdict (28 December 2023); no resolution of that appeal was located."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.perfil.com/noticias/judiciales/condenaron-a-10-anos-de-prision-a-una-monja-por-abuso-sexual-contra-5-adolescentes-en-un-hogar-de-san-isidro.phtml",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5a760bdc0a8443db201e8385afaca9fbcdda5b7dbb86d2e63cf2ae99b0f10302",
"final_url": "https://www.perfil.com/noticias/judiciales/condenaron-a-10-anos-de-prision-a-una-monja-por-abuso-sexual-contra-5-adolescentes-en-un-hogar-de-san-isidro.phtml"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/sor-marina-culpable-condenaron-a-diez-anos-de-prision-a-una-monja-por-abusar-de-cinco-adolescentes-nid28122023/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd8937b680b062ff7a4116298b211431cdcc8e32c4008d5dd9dfb09e10876cae",
"final_url": "https://www.lanacion.com.ar/seguridad/sor-marina-culpable-condenaron-a-diez-anos-de-prision-a-una-monja-por-abusar-de-cinco-adolescentes-nid28122023/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9207,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Confirmed by Court of Appeal of Milan, 19 March 2019; further confirmed as final by the Corte di Cassazione, December 2019."
}
],
"scopeNote": "The nun's own institutional role (educator at the parish oratory, 38 years old when the relationship with the then-15-year-old began) is the documented N2 mechanism; contemporary press describes the long relationship euphemistically as 'sentimental,' but the court convicted on the sexual-violence charge tied to the abuse of the oratory relationship and a specific coercive episode. Victim later died by suicide; that death is recorded as context, not as a separate charge (no homicide charge was brought or is implied).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-maria-angela-fare-oratorio-busto-arsizio-italy",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Busto Arsizio, Varese, Lombardy, Italy",
"lat": 45.6117,
"lng": 8.85,
"title": "Italy: nun convicted of sexually abusing a 15-year-old she groomed at her parish oratory",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"nun and educator (catechist/youth worker) at the Sant'Edoardo parish oratory"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as adult religious educator over a 15-year-old oratory member",
"prolonged grooming through hundreds of letters and declarations exploiting the victim's confusion about the nature of the relationship",
"physical restraint during the charged assault"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Oratorio Sant'Edoardo, Busto Arsizio",
"Figlie di Maria Ausiliatrice (Daughters of Mary Help of Christians)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunale di Busto Arsizio, Italy",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Maria Angela ('Mariangela') Farè, a nun then aged 38 serving as an educator at the Sant'Edoardo oratory, was convicted of sexual violence, private violence and stalking against Eva Sacconago, whom she had groomed from age 15 in a relationship that lasted roughly 13 years. The conviction centered on a specific episode weeks before Sacconago's 2011 death, during which the victim was restrained with ankle cuffs. The court of first instance sentenced Farè to 3 years and 6 months' imprisonment."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Corte d'Appello di Milano, Italy",
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2019-03-19",
"outcome": "The Court of Appeal of Milan confirmed the 3-year-6-month sentence and ordered the Figlie di Maria Ausiliatrice congregation to pay EUR 50,000 in compensation to Sacconago's parents."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Corte di Cassazione, Italy",
"stage": "final appeal",
"date": "2019-12-01",
"outcome": "The Court of Cassation definitively confirmed the conviction, making the sentence final."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The relationship began and was sustained entirely through Farè's position as an adult nun-educator at the parish oratory where the victim was a 15-year-old member; the grooming exploited the trust and authority inherent in that religious-educational role over a minor in her charge.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mondodiunalesbica.blogspot.com/2019/12/cassazione-condanna-definitiva-3-anni-e.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cassazione: condanna definitiva a 3 anni e mezzo per violenza sessuale a Maria Angela Farè', December 2019.",
"body": "Report confirming the Corte di Cassazione's final confirmation of the sentence.",
"tier": "italian-press-secondary",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/topnews/2019/03/19/ex-suora-condannata-per-abusi-in-appello_c6e193be-6b9e-468b-ba50-bdd774a5b459.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex suora condannata per abusi in appello', ANSA, 19 March 2019.",
"body": "Italy's national wire service confirming the Milan Court of Appeal's decision, sentence, and the EUR 50,000 compensation order against the congregation.",
"tier": "national-wire-service",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://retelabuso.org/2020/04/13/i-diari-di-eva-processo-fare/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'I diari di Eva, processo suor Mariangela Farè', Rete l'Abuso.",
"body": "Detailed reporting establishing Farè's role as oratory educator, the victim's age (15) at the relationship's start, and the nature of the grooming.",
"tier": "specialist-abuse-reporting-outlet",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Confirmed by Court of Appeal of Milan, 19 March 2019; further confirmed as final by the Corte di Cassazione, December 2019."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mondodiunalesbica.blogspot.com/2019/12/cassazione-condanna-definitiva-3-anni-e.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: italian-press-secondary; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1c8c85a15b0aaff9212972eef2f1e68cc403d12739cb890c1b169dd312994002",
"final_url": "https://mondodiunalesbica.blogspot.com/2019/12/cassazione-condanna-definitiva-3-anni-e.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/topnews/2019/03/19/ex-suora-condannata-per-abusi-in-appello_c6e193be-6b9e-468b-ba50-bdd774a5b459.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-wire-service; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "802a4dd77e0da469cf75903775af6d0dae40f4abd91b3593ff62d10f00bb30a4",
"final_url": "https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/topnews/2019/03/19/ex-suora-condannata-per-abusi-in-appello_c6e193be-6b9e-468b-ba50-bdd774a5b459.html"
},
{
"source": "https://retelabuso.org/2020/04/13/i-diari-di-eva-processo-fare/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-abuse-reporting-outlet; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4208d00e73a9f81b482e8e14d87660d80c34f34d971b9694237e01267eae20d8",
"final_url": "https://retelabuso.org/2020/04/13/i-diari-di-eva-processo-fare/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9208,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Warsaw appellate court increased the sentence to two years' unconditional imprisonment in 2011, confirming and strengthening the 2010 first-instance conviction."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Sister Bernadetta's conviction was for mistreatment and inciting/facilitating sexual abuse (by older residents, under her supervision and with her knowledge), not for personally committing the sexual assaults; recorded accordingly as physical-abuse/institutional-abuse rather than child-abuse. A co-defendant caregiver (Sister Franciszka) received a separate, lesser suspended sentence in the same proceeding and is noted for context but not given a separate record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-sister-bernadetta-zabrze-orphanage-poland",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Zabrze, Silesian Voivodeship, Poland",
"lat": 50.3249,
"lng": 18.7857,
"title": "Poland: nun convicted of mistreating children and enabling sexual abuse at a Zabrze care home",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"nun and facility director of a Congregation of Sisters of Mercy of St Charles Borromeo children's care home"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total institutional and religious authority as facility director over children with no outside contact",
"confession used as a control and silencing mechanism — a victim who told her about abuse received no response",
"physical punishment presented as religious discipline"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Kongregacja Sióstr Miłosierdzia św. Karola Boromeusza (Congregation of Sisters of Mercy of St Charles Borromeo)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sąd Okręgowy w Warszawie (Warsaw Regional Court), Poland",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2010-01-01",
"outcome": "Sister Bernadetta (Agnieszka F.), director of a Sisters of Mercy of St Charles Borromeo children's care home in Zabrze, was convicted of psychological and physical mistreatment of children in her care and of complicity in enabling sexual assaults committed by older residents under her supervision, dating from the 1970s onward. She was sentenced to two years' imprisonment, suspended."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Warsaw appellate court, Poland",
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2011-01-01",
"outcome": "The appellate court increased Sister Bernadetta's sentence to two years' unconditional imprisonment, finding the suspended sentence inadequate. Enforcement was delayed roughly three years on health and age grounds before she began serving the sentence in 2014."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Children in Sister Bernadetta's care were confined within a convent-run home under her total religious and institutional authority as director; when a victim disclosed sexual abuse to her directly, she gave no response, using her position as the sole authority the children could appeal to as itself a mechanism of silencing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://oko.press/500-tys-zl-wyrok-siostra-bernadetta-boromeuszki-z-zabrza",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sąd przyznał 500 tys. zł ofierze siostry Bernadetty, boromeuszki z Zabrza', OKO.press.",
"body": "Detailed case history including Sister Bernadetta's real name, congregation, the 2010 first-instance suspended sentence, the 2011 appellate increase to unconditional imprisonment, the delayed 2014 enforcement, and the later 2023 civil compensation ruling.",
"tier": "investigative-news-outlet",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.o2.pl/informacje/zakonnica-skazana-ofiara-siostry-bernadetty-dostane-odszkodowanie-6923308930534016a",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Zakonnica skazana. Ofiara siostry Bernadetty dostanie odszkodowanie', o2.pl.",
"body": "Polish national outlet confirming the conviction, the confession-silencing detail, and background from Justyna Kopińska's investigative reporting.",
"tier": "national-news-portal",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Warsaw appellate court increased the sentence to two years' unconditional imprisonment in 2011, confirming and strengthening the 2010 first-instance conviction."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://oko.press/500-tys-zl-wyrok-siostra-bernadetta-boromeuszki-z-zabrza",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: investigative-news-outlet; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e95623b653494e797f406e0a1722d5d8b3f8109a3a1de6c7bf2d649e4b509779",
"final_url": "https://oko.press/500-tys-zl-wyrok-siostra-bernadetta-boromeuszki-z-zabrza"
},
{
"source": "https://www.o2.pl/informacje/zakonnica-skazana-ofiara-siostry-bernadetty-dostane-odszkodowanie-6923308930534016a",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-news-portal; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9209,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL-EVENT, NOT CORE — per the plan's standing rule (repeated from the German diocesan-report lesson): this is a national commission of inquiry covering roughly 10,000 women across ten institutions and four religious orders over seven decades, not a single victim-perpetrator pair. Recorded as recordClass institutional-event/official-finding, matching the treatment already given to the corpus's Ryan Report Goldenbridge record. THE N2 QUESTION: the McAleese Report's own finding is that the State was the dominant referral pathway (courts, families, industrial-school transfers, state-run mother-and-baby-home transfers) for the roughly 2,500 women it could trace State involvement in sending to the laundries — meaning for a large share of women the operative coercive authority was parental, judicial or state-custodial, not the nuns' own spiritual authority, which fails N2 under this project's criterion even though the nuns ran the institutions. The report does NOT identify any individual nun convicted of a crime; no prosecutions of individual sisters arose from it. Where the record clearly documents the nuns' own religious authority as the operative mechanism — confession-based control, spiritual punishment, enforced penitential framing, loss-of-soul rhetoric used to prevent women leaving or resisting — the report's general findings do describe that (the sisters' 'save souls' framing and enforced silence/penance regime, as opposed to lawful detention), which is why this is recorded as an institutional-event core-adjacent record rather than excluded outright, consistent with how the Ryan and Goldenbridge institutional findings are handled elsewhere in the corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-mcaleese-report-magdalene-laundries-ireland",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Ireland (national — ten Magdalene Laundries operated by four religious orders)",
"lat": 53.3498,
"lng": -6.2603,
"title": "Ireland: McAleese Report finds State complicity in the Magdalene Laundry system; no individual nun ever criminally prosecuted",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious orders (Sisters of Mercy, Sisters of Charity, Sisters of the Good Shepherd, Sisters of Our Lady of Charity of Refuge) operating the ten Magdalene Laundries under combined custodial and spiritual authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"enforced silence and penitential framing presented as spiritual salvation ('to bring penitents to God')",
"denial of outside contact, renaming, and interception of correspondence",
"for the subset of women whose entry was parental, judicial or state-directed, the operative authority was custodial/state rather than spiritual (N2 caveat — see scopeNote)"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Sisters of Mercy",
"Religious Sisters of Charity",
"Sisters of the Good Shepherd",
"Sisters of Our Lady of Charity of Refuge",
"Government of Ireland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Inter-Departmental Committee to establish the facts of State involvement with the Magdalen Laundries (McAleese Committee), Ireland — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "official inquiry report",
"date": "2013-02-05",
"outcome": "After an 18-month investigation, the Committee found the Irish State was directly and fundamentally involved in the Magdalene Laundry system: roughly 2,500 of the traceable admissions were sent in directly by the State, the State awarded the laundries commercial contracts without Fair Wage or social-insurance compliance, and State factory inspectors oversaw a system of forced, unpaid labour without intervening. The report examined the four religious orders that ran the ten laundries and their treatment regimes but named no individual nun and resulted in no criminal prosecution of any sister. A formal State apology followed, and a redress scheme was subsequently established for survivors; the orders themselves declined to contribute to that scheme."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "For the women whose confinement was maintained by the nuns' own religious authority — the sisters' explicit framing of the laundries as instruments of spiritual salvation, enforced penance and loss-of-soul rhetoric used to prevent leaving or resisting, silence rules and confession as tools of institutional control — that authority meets this project's test; the report itself shows this was not uniform, since a large share of admissions were routed through the courts, the State, or families rather than through the nuns' own spiritual claim on the women, which is why this record is institutional-event rather than a set of individual core victim-perpetrator pairs.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2013_02_05_McAleese_Magdalen_Laundries/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Report of the Inter-Departmental Committee to Establish the Facts of State Involvement with the Magdalen Laundries (McAleese Report), 5 February 2013.",
"body": "Full statutory inquiry report documenting State referral pathways, State commercial and regulatory involvement, and the operating religious orders.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thejournal.ie/magdalene-laundries-report-finds-direct-state-involvement-783428-Feb2013/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Magdalene Laundries report finds direct State involvement', TheJournal.ie, February 2013.",
"body": "Irish national outlet summarizing the report's core finding of State complicity and the absence of any individual nun's prosecution.",
"tier": "national-newspaper",
"kind": "background"
},
{
"link": "https://womensenews.org/2013/05/nuns-claim-no-role-in-irish-laundry-scandal/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Nuns Claim No Role in Irish Laundry Scandal', Women's eNews, May 2013.",
"body": "Coverage of the religious orders' response to the report and their refusal to contribute to the survivor redress scheme.",
"tier": "specialist-news-outlet",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2013_02_05_McAleese_Magdalen_Laundries/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "92cf70263e24de1576ae1a3d3d1ad49b8ade095914b414f43fb85e597f777cfa",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2013_02_05_McAleese_Magdalen_Laundries/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thejournal.ie/magdalene-laundries-report-finds-direct-state-involvement-783428-Feb2013/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "930251c9a630e826a9d1d61db6a6b6dd4545a394b50126c140c9adc034460525",
"final_url": "https://www.thejournal.ie/magdalene-laundries-report-finds-direct-state-involvement-783428-Feb2013/"
},
{
"source": "https://womensenews.org/2013/05/nuns-claim-no-role-in-irish-laundry-scandal/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-news-outlet; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f4556a7d59b5e23ca0e00f634e13f8fcbe39f2a31da6d1229e8b96d01e8f6185",
"final_url": "https://womensenews.org/2013/05/nuns-claim-no-role-in-irish-laundry-scandal/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9210,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "INSTITUTIONAL-EVENT, NOT CORE — a statutory commission covering 18 institutions and tens of thousands of women and children over 76 years (1922-1998); not a single victim-perpetrator pair. Recorded at institutional scope, matching the McAleese Report record above and the corpus's existing Ryan/Goldenbridge treatment. The Commission's own final report was itself controversial for concluding there was insufficient evidence of systemic forced adoption or of the abuse many survivors testified to — recorded here as a finding of the report, not endorsed as settled fact by this corpus. No individual nun was criminally convicted arising from this Commission's findings; it is an official-finding record, not a set of convictions.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-mother-and-baby-homes-commission-ireland",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Ireland (national — 18 mother-and-baby and county-home institutions, 1922-1998)",
"lat": 53.3498,
"lng": -6.2603,
"title": "Ireland: Mother and Baby Homes Commission finds roughly 9,000 child deaths and a coercive, misogynistic institutional culture",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious orders operating mother-and-baby homes, including the Sisters of the Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary (Bessborough) and other congregations, under combined custodial, medical and spiritual authority over unmarried pregnant women"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"coercion, shame and family obligation used to deprive women of choice and agency, per the Commission's own finding",
"religious framing of unmarried motherhood as sin requiring institutional confinement and penance",
"denial of information about and access to children, later the basis of separate forced-adoption allegations the Commission found insufficient evidence to substantiate"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Sisters of the Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary (Bessborough, Cork)",
"Government of Ireland",
"Health Service Executive"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes and Certain Related Matters, Ireland — statutory inquiry",
"stage": "official inquiry final report",
"date": "2021-01-12",
"outcome": "The Commission, established in 2015, found that around 9,000 children — about one in seven of those born in the 18 institutions within its terms of reference — died in them between 1922 and 1998, roughly double the general infant-mortality rate. It described a 'stifling, oppressive and deeply misogynistic culture' reinforced by Church and State attitudes that directly and repeatedly deprived women of choice and agency through coercion, shame and family obligation. It named the Sisters of the Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary's Bessborough home as having a particularly high infant-mortality rate; the order apologised. The report was criticised by many survivors for concluding there was insufficient evidence of systemic forced adoption or abuse, despite contrary survivor testimony. No individual nun was criminally convicted as a result of this Commission's findings."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Women committed to mother-and-baby homes were confined under institutions whose religious orders framed unmarried pregnancy as sin requiring penance and spiritual correction; the Commission's own finding that coercion and shame — not simply state or family compulsion — deprived women of agency identifies the religious-moral framing itself as an operative mechanism, alongside the parallel state and family coercion the report also documents.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gov.ie/en/publication/d4b3d-final-report-of-the-commission-of-investigation-into-mother-and-baby-homes/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Final Report of the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes, Government of Ireland, 12 January 2021.",
"body": "Full statutory inquiry final report, including the child-mortality findings, institutional culture findings, and conclusions on forced adoption and abuse allegations.",
"tier": "official-statutory-inquiry-report",
"kind": "inquiry-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mother_and_Baby_Homes_Commission_of_Investigation",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Mother and Baby Homes Commission of Investigation', Wikipedia, summarizing the report and survivor criticism.",
"body": "Background on the Commission's establishment, scope, and the controversy over its conclusions regarding forced adoption and abuse evidence.",
"tier": "encyclopedia-secondary",
"kind": "background"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gov.ie/en/publication/d4b3d-final-report-of-the-commission-of-investigation-into-mother-and-baby-homes/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-statutory-inquiry-report; evidentiary role: inquiry-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mother_and_Baby_Homes_Commission_of_Investigation",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: encyclopedia-secondary; evidentiary role: background.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1e3c00f368589fefb0bc6ee14b1a7e8686d42d899ab1267c4304445174d8b2c4",
"final_url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mother_and_Baby_Homes_Commission_of_Investigation"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The wider FCI Dublin 'rape club' scandal produced convictions against the warden, several correctional officers, a cook supervisor and other custodial/administrative staff — all excluded from this corpus as custodial-authority abuse, not spiritual-authority abuse. Highhouse is the only chaplain among the FCI Dublin defendants and the only one who used religious office/scripture as the charged mechanism.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-james-highhouse-fci-dublin-california-usa",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Dublin, California, USA",
"lat": 37.7021,
"lng": -121.9358,
"title": "United States: FCI Dublin federal prison chaplain sentenced for sexually abusing an inmate he was counseling",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://oig.justice.gov/news/press-release/federal-prison-chaplain-sentenced-sexual-assault-and-lying-federal-agents",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, Office of the Inspector General (2022) 'Federal Prison Chaplain Sentenced for Sexual Assault and Lying to Federal Agents', Press Release, 31 August 2022.",
"body": "James Theodore Highhouse, a former chaplain with the Federal Bureau of Prisons, was sentenced in the Northern District of California to 84 months in prison followed by five years of supervised release for repeatedly sexually abusing an incarcerated female and lying to federal agents about his misconduct. Highhouse pleaded guilty on February 23, 2022, to two counts of sexual abuse of a ward, two counts of abusive sexual contact, and one count of false statements. From on or about May 15, 2018, through on or about February 9, 2019, Highhouse, while assigned to FCI Dublin, engaged in multiple sexual acts and sexual contact with an inmate he was counseling, despite receiving training on maintaining boundaries with inmates and attending yearly refreshers on sexual abuse and prevention. Once the FBI and the DOJ Office of the Inspector General opened a federal investigation, Highhouse lied to federal agents about his misconduct during a voluntary interview on February 21, 2019, and again on February 3, 2020, when he continued to deny engaging in sexual contact with the victim."
},
{
"link": "https://www.ktvu.com/news/this-is-rape-judge-sentences-dublin-prison-chaplain-to-7-years-for-sex-abuses",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KTVU FOX 2 (2022) \"'This is rape:' Judge sentences Dublin prison chaplain to 7 years for sex abuses\", 31 August 2022.",
"body": "U.S. District Court Judge Haywood S. Gilliam Jr. sentenced Highhouse in Oakland, California to seven years, calling the offense 'rape' and stating that sentencing guidelines (which called for under three years) 'seriously underestimate the seriousness' of his conduct. Victims described Highhouse telling them Bible stories to manipulate them into having sex, offering his chaplain office as a location for sexual encounters, and pressuring one woman into intercourse on Veterans Day by telling her she needed to 'serve her country' and on Thanksgiving by telling her to show gratitude. He warned victims that no one would believe them because 'you're an inmate, and I'm a chaplain.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/federal-prison-chaplain-pleads-guilty-sexually-assaulting-inmate-rcna17578",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NBC News (2022) 'Federal prison chaplain pleads guilty to sexually assaulting inmate', 24 February 2022.",
"body": "Highhouse is the first of five FCI Dublin employees charged in a widening sex-abuse scandal to be sentenced. Prosecutors said he engaged in predatory conduct with at least six women from 2014 to 2019, including one he counseled at a veterans hospital where he worked before joining the Bureau of Prisons."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Chaplain, Federal Bureau of Prisons, assigned to FCI Dublin (federal women's prison)",
"spiritual counselor to incarcerated women"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"invoked scripture and Bible parables to frame sexual contact as divinely sanctioned",
"used chaplain's office (behind a closed door) as the location for abuse",
"threatened that no one would believe an inmate's word against a chaplain's"
],
"organizations": [
"Federal Bureau of Prisons"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Northern District of California",
"stage": "sentencing",
"outcome": "guilty plea; sentenced to 84 months imprisonment plus 5 years supervised release",
"date": "2022-08-31"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Highhouse's authority as prison chaplain — the only source of spiritual guidance and pastoral counseling available to incarcerated women — was the operative instrument: he used Bible stories and scripture to reframe sexual contact as God's will, conducted the abuse inside his chapel counseling office, and used his religious standing itself (chaplain vs. inmate credibility) to silence disclosure. This is a religious-authority case, not a custodial one — he held no correctional/security role over the victims.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://oig.justice.gov/news/press-release/federal-prison-chaplain-sentenced-sexual-assault-and-lying-federal-agents",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7b24a8a07d500161bb66fc98cd62ea1f2c5f5db6d13394ab717943d5763eeba0",
"final_url": "https://oig.justice.gov/news/press-release/federal-prison-chaplain-sentenced-sexual-assault-and-lying-federal-agents"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ktvu.com/news/this-is-rape-judge-sentences-dublin-prison-chaplain-to-7-years-for-sex-abuses",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ac588ff7a7c00757fe84f09f9eca768ce3efeac987927b163f463d2c758e9cc7",
"final_url": "https://www.ktvu.com/news/this-is-rape-judge-sentences-dublin-prison-chaplain-to-7-years-for-sex-abuses"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/federal-prison-chaplain-pleads-guilty-sexually-assaulting-inmate-rcna17578",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4800b47b4455200a3a87e17c3fff3d9cdd148b82cd2cf5d5e5482efd3bf1bc85",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/federal-prison-chaplain-pleads-guilty-sexually-assaulting-inmate-rcna17578"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Distinguished from ordinary correctional-officer abuse because the charged mechanism was his religious counseling role and the program he personally created and ran, not his custodial authority (he held no security function).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-kenneth-dewitt-mcpherson-unit-arkansas-usa",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Newport, Arkansas, USA",
"lat": 35.6034,
"lng": -91.2793,
"title": "United States: Arkansas state prison chaplain sentenced for sexually assaulting inmate under guise of counseling and ministry",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.corrections1.com/arrests-and-sentencing/articles/ark-chaplain-sentenced-to-five-years-in-sexual-assault-case-ZhzypUI1IAm3CyvS/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Corrections1 (2016) 'Ark. chaplain sentenced to five years in sexual assault case', 8 August 2016.",
"body": "Kenneth Dewitt, 67, former chaplain at the Arkansas Department of Correction's McPherson Women's Unit in Newport, was sentenced to five years in prison after pleading guilty to three counts of third-degree sexual assault, down from an original 50 counts. Dewitt approached inmates individually while they participated in the faith-based 'Principles and Applications for Life' program he founded in 1998, asked about their feelings for him, and initiated sexual contact on multiple occasions, positioning victims so he could monitor for approaching guards. One victim was his subordinate in the chaplain's office; that relationship was acknowledged when he resigned in September 2014."
},
{
"link": "https://katv.com/news/local/victim-of-ex-arkansas-prison-chaplain-files-federal-suit",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KATV (2021) 'Victim of ex-Arkansas prison chaplain files federal suit'.",
"body": "Carolyn Arnett, the named victim, alleged Dewitt sexually abused her on a weekly basis for nearly four years under the guise of counseling and ministry work at the all-women McPherson Unit, and sued prison administrators for failing to act on knowledge of his conduct."
},
{
"link": "https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2016/nov/8/rape-victims-silenced-their-prison-cells/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Prison Legal News (2016) 'The Rape Victims Silenced by Their Prison Cells', 8 November 2016.",
"body": "Reports on the Dewitt prosecution as part of a wider pattern of chaplain and staff sexual abuse of prisoners silenced by fear of retaliation and disbelief; confirms the guilty plea and five-year sentence at the McPherson Women's Unit."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Chaplain, Arkansas Department of Correction, McPherson Women's Unit",
"founder and leader of in-prison faith-based ministry program"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"used his own faith-based counseling program as the point of individual access to victims",
"framed sexual contact as part of pastoral/spiritual relationship ('under the guise of counseling and ministry work')"
],
"organizations": [
"Arkansas Department of Correction"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Arkansas state court, Jackson County",
"stage": "sentencing",
"outcome": "guilty plea to 3 counts of third-degree sexual assault; sentenced to 5 years",
"date": "2016-08-08"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Dewitt was the prison's chaplain and the founder/leader of its faith-based rehabilitation ministry — the only avenue of spiritual and emotional support offered to women at the facility. He used that ministry program itself to select and isolate victims one-on-one, and the abuse was expressly conducted 'under the guise of counseling and ministry work,' not as an abuse of security/custodial power.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.corrections1.com/arrests-and-sentencing/articles/ark-chaplain-sentenced-to-five-years-in-sexual-assault-case-ZhzypUI1IAm3CyvS/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "155feb2490668a1379bca903b251cd578e93b9bc53d59c19a3c2b5fcac008e36",
"final_url": "https://www.corrections1.com/arrests-and-sentencing/articles/ark-chaplain-sentenced-to-five-years-in-sexual-assault-case-ZhzypUI1IAm3CyvS/"
},
{
"source": "https://katv.com/news/local/victim-of-ex-arkansas-prison-chaplain-files-federal-suit",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3c60ea993413628f03ba5b2da153ca8b76be45eeddaf3dd2930eda7fe151371d",
"final_url": "https://katv.com/news/local/victim-of-ex-arkansas-prison-chaplain-files-federal-suit"
},
{
"source": "https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2016/nov/8/rape-victims-silenced-their-prison-cells/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7c7b14d5637be5fba5251966063b876b8bd13f4fb12a1b1e0ffca948ad731552",
"final_url": "https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2016/nov/8/rape-victims-silenced-their-prison-cells/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit",
"outcome": "appeal denied, conviction affirmed",
"date": "2021-04-22"
}
],
"scopeNote": "Military-chaplain compound-authority case: rank and religious office reinforced each other. Conviction stood through appeal — Tenth Circuit denied relief in 2021.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-arthur-perrault-kirtland-air-force-base-new-mexico-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA",
"lat": 35.0844,
"lng": -106.6504,
"title": "United States: Air Force chaplain and priest convicted of sexually abusing an altar boy at Kirtland Air Force Base",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2019/04/12/former-air-force-chaplain-a-retired-colonel-found-guilty-of-sex-abuse-in-new-mexico/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Air Force Times (2019) 'Former Air Force chaplain, a retired colonel, found guilty of sex abuse in New Mexico', 12 April 2019.",
"body": "Arthur Perrault, a retired Air Force Reserve colonel who served as an Air Force chaplain and Roman Catholic priest, was found guilty by a jury of six counts of aggravated sexual abuse and one count of abusive sexual contact with a minor under 12. The victim, an altar boy Perrault took on excursions to amusement parks and other places, said Perrault touched him inappropriately as many as 100 times starting when he was 10, with abuse occurring at Kirtland Air Force Base in Albuquerque — where Perrault served as chaplain — and at Santa Fe National Cemetery. The abuse ended in 1992, the year Perrault fled to Morocco; he was located and arrested there in 2017 and extradited to New Mexico following indictment."
},
{
"link": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2019/09/15/retired-air-force-chaplain-a-fugitive-for-20-years-sentenced-in-kirtland-afb-sex-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Air Force Times (2019) 'Retired Air Force chaplain, a fugitive for 20 years, sentenced in Kirtland AFB sex abuse case', 15 September 2019.",
"body": "U.S. District Judge Martha Vazquez sentenced Perrault to 30 years in prison, stating it was the worst case of child sex abuse she had handled in 26 years on the bench."
},
{
"link": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2021/04/22/court-denies-former-kirtland-air-force-base-priests-appeal-in-new-mexico-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Air Force Times (2021) 'Court denies former Kirtland Air Force Base priest's appeal in New Mexico abuse case', 22 April 2021.",
"body": "Confirms the appellate court denied Perrault's appeal of his conviction, leaving the 2019 jury verdict and 30-year sentence in place."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Roman Catholic priest and U.S. Air Force chaplain, Kirtland Air Force Base",
"supervising priest of the victim as an altar server"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"used altar-server role to create private access and outings with the victim",
"compound authority of military chaplain rank plus priestly office over a child of the base community"
],
"organizations": [
"U.S. Air Force Chaplain Corps",
"Roman Catholic Archdiocese for the Military Services, USA"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, District of New Mexico",
"stage": "appeal denied",
"outcome": "jury convicted on 6 counts aggravated sexual abuse + 1 count abusive sexual contact; sentenced to 30 years; conviction affirmed on appeal",
"date": "2019-09-15"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Perrault held compound authority as both a Catholic priest and a commissioned Air Force chaplain (retired colonel), and the victim was his altar server — a child placed under his direct religious supervision at the base chapel community. The abuse occurred at Kirtland AFB, where he served as chaplain, and continued off-base on outings arranged through that pastoral role.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit",
"outcome": "appeal denied, conviction affirmed",
"date": "2021-04-22"
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2019/04/12/former-air-force-chaplain-a-retired-colonel-found-guilty-of-sex-abuse-in-new-mexico/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b0a4e8d99962bf8b5063b59b86660da205d98023344d4948364b5154a6a42dfc",
"final_url": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2019/04/12/former-air-force-chaplain-a-retired-colonel-found-guilty-of-sex-abuse-in-new-mexico/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2019/09/15/retired-air-force-chaplain-a-fugitive-for-20-years-sentenced-in-kirtland-afb-sex-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b3401cb8af00a04e8a7cce28885f316392a3d6ba4c058fca91f570a5a0abb13b",
"final_url": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2019/09/15/retired-air-force-chaplain-a-fugitive-for-20-years-sentenced-in-kirtland-afb-sex-abuse-case/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2021/04/22/court-denies-former-kirtland-air-force-base-priests-appeal-in-new-mexico-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "917a639e36ad46352c9dd954e58d387f4bf3cbc8d9ac64c0f0d672b0907e7346",
"final_url": "https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2021/04/22/court-denies-former-kirtland-air-force-base-priests-appeal-in-new-mexico-abuse-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Clean compound-authority military chaplain case: the operative mechanism was named by the perpetrator himself as his priestly role, not merely his rank.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2005-gregory-arflack-bamberg-germany",
"year": 2005,
"place": "Bamberg, Bavaria, Germany",
"lat": 49.8988,
"lng": 10.9027,
"title": "United States: Army chaplain court-martialed in Germany for forcible sodomy against enlisted men he was counseling",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wfmynews2.com/article/news/us-army-chaplain-sentenced-to-prison-for-sodomizing-troops/83-403607659",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WFMY News 2 / Associated Press (2005) 'US Army Chaplain Sentenced To Prison For Sodomizing Troops', 1 November 2005.",
"body": "Capt. Gregory Arflack, a 44-year-old Roman Catholic priest and Army chaplain, was sentenced to five years in prison after pleading guilty at a court-martial in Bamberg, Germany, to three counts of forcible sodomy against enlisted men. One of the victims, whom Arflack had been counseling about homesickness and family troubles, told the court about the abuse's impact. Arflack apologized during the court-martial, saying he was ashamed of what he had done as a priest and an officer."
},
{
"link": "https://www.9news.com/article/news/us-army-chaplain-convicted-of-forcible-sodomy-against-enlisted-men/73-344650072",
"archive": "",
"citation": "9News/AP (2005) 'U.S. Army chaplain convicted of forcible sodomy against enlisted men'.",
"body": "Confirms Arflack's guilty plea and court-martial conviction; assaults occurred in Doha, Qatar (21 June 2004) and in Bamberg, Germany (29-30 July 2004). Judge Col. R. Peter Masterton ordered Arflack dismissed from the Army with forfeiture of all benefits, in addition to the prison sentence."
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2005_07_12/2005_08_17_Liewer_BambergChaplain.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Stars and Stripes, republished by BishopAccountability.org (2005) 'Bamberg Chaplain Suspended during Sexual Assault Probe: Army Investigating Allegations Priest Forced Himself on Soldiers', 17 August 2005.",
"body": "Details the Army's suspension of Arflack pending investigation into allegations that he, as chaplain, forced himself sexually on soldiers under his pastoral care, including men who had come to him for confidential counseling."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Captain, U.S. Army Chaplain Corps",
"Roman Catholic priest providing pastoral counseling to enlisted soldiers"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"used one-on-one pastoral counseling sessions (for homesickness/family troubles) as point of access",
"compound authority of officer rank plus chaplain/confessor role over enlisted men"
],
"organizations": [
"U.S. Army Chaplain Corps"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Army court-martial, Bamberg, Germany",
"stage": "sentencing",
"outcome": "guilty plea to 3 counts forcible sodomy (plus indecent act, fraternization, conduct unbecoming); sentenced to 5 years, dismissed from Army",
"date": "2005-11-01"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Arflack abused enlisted men who came to him specifically for pastoral counseling — one victim was being counseled for homesickness and family troubles at the time. His authority was doubly asymmetric: officer rank over enlisted troops, and confessor/priest over men seeking spiritual and emotional support, which he himself named in his own apology ('ashamed of what he had done as a priest and an officer').",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wfmynews2.com/article/news/us-army-chaplain-sentenced-to-prison-for-sodomizing-troops/83-403607659",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.9news.com/article/news/us-army-chaplain-convicted-of-forcible-sodomy-against-enlisted-men/73-344650072",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2005_07_12/2005_08_17_Liewer_BambergChaplain.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "445048c6e89a4a8e1d8d1af77cc9f406454a650f88dc59a3d53f242bf4343988",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2005_07_12/2005_08_17_Liewer_BambergChaplain.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [
"John Thomas Matthew Lee"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from a purely custodial or command-authority case: victims sought him out specifically in his pastoral capacity, at a vulnerable disclosure moment his religious office created.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-john-thomas-lee-naval-academy-annapolis-usa",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Annapolis, Maryland, USA",
"lat": 38.9784,
"lng": -76.4922,
"title": "United States: Naval Academy chaplain court-martialed for forcibly sodomizing a midshipman and coercing men he was counseling",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/12/06/AR2007120601069.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Washington Post (2007) 'Navy Chaplain Pleads Guilty', 6 December 2007.",
"body": "Lt. Cmdr. John Thomas Lee, a Catholic priest and Navy chaplain assigned to the U.S. Naval Academy from September 2003 to October 2006, pleaded guilty at a court-martial at Quantico Marine Corps Base to 11 charges including forcible sodomy, aggravated assault, fraternization, conduct unbecoming an officer and wrongful use of a government computer. Investigators found Lee had sex or inappropriate contact with several men, including academy students who came to him for counseling after being identified as homosexual; he forced himself on a Naval Academy midshipman, coerced a Marine he was counseling to take nude photographs of him, and had unprotected sex with an Air Force officer without disclosing he was HIV-positive."
},
{
"link": "https://www.baltimoresun.com/2007/12/07/academy-ex-chaplain-sentenced-to-2-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Baltimore Sun (2007) 'Academy ex-chaplain sentenced to 2 years', 7 December 2007.",
"body": "Marine Corps Col. Steven Day sentenced Lee to 12 years' confinement, with 10 years suspended conditioned on compliance with the plea agreement, leaving 2 years to serve. Day also ordered Lee to disclose the names of all sexual partners since 2005, when Lee learned he was HIV-positive."
},
{
"link": "https://www.foxnews.com/story/hiv-positive-navy-chaplain-gets-2-years-for-sexually-assaulting-midshipman",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fox News (2007) 'HIV-Positive Navy Chaplain Gets 2 Years for Sexually Assaulting Midshipman'.",
"body": "Confirms the plea agreement and sentence; Lee had been relieved of chaplain duties in June 2007 when the allegations came forward."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Lieutenant Commander, U.S. Navy Chaplain Corps",
"Roman Catholic priest, Naval Academy chaplain, pastoral counselor to midshipmen"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"used pastoral counseling sessions offered to midshipmen questioning or identified as gay as the point of access",
"coerced a subordinate under his counsel into producing nude images",
"compound authority of officer rank over midshipmen plus confessor/chaplain role"
],
"organizations": [
"U.S. Navy Chaplain Corps",
"United States Naval Academy"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. Marine Corps court-martial, Quantico, Virginia",
"stage": "sentencing",
"outcome": "guilty plea to 11 charges including forcible sodomy and aggravated assault; sentenced to 12 years confinement, 10 suspended (2 years to serve)",
"date": "2007-12-06"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Lee specifically targeted midshipmen who came to him for pastoral counseling after being identified as gay — a moment of acute vulnerability where his role as confessor/chaplain was the only avenue open to them within the institution's constraints. He used that counseling relationship to coerce a Marine into producing nude photographs and to force himself on a midshipman.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/12/06/AR2007120601069.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.baltimoresun.com/2007/12/07/academy-ex-chaplain-sentenced-to-2-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "86f0f7a2d077d16c23934d913951ba5df0b72d07c27542ffa35ac703c529643c",
"final_url": "https://www.baltimoresun.com/2007/12/07/academy-ex-chaplain-sentenced-to-2-years/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.foxnews.com/story/hiv-positive-navy-chaplain-gets-2-years-for-sexually-assaulting-midshipman",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8fd303355a6474ad7a728cc813413a132708f8a565e3a2bdc1f4f065e2f57997",
"final_url": "https://www.foxnews.com/story/hiv-positive-navy-chaplain-gets-2-years-for-sexually-assaulting-midshipman"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [
"Father Angus McRae"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Canadian Forces court martial appeal",
"outcome": "sentence reduced from 4 years to 18 months; conviction itself not disturbed",
"date": ""
}
],
"scopeNote": "Military-chaplain compound-authority case with children of a captive on-base community as victims, distinguishing it from ordinary command-authority abuse of subordinate service members.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1980-angus-mcrae-cfb-edmonton-canada",
"year": 1980,
"place": "Edmonton, Alberta, Canada",
"lat": 53.5461,
"lng": -113.4938,
"title": "Canada: military base chaplain court-martialed for sexually assaulting children in the base chapel at CFB Edmonton",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.theinquiry.ca/wordpress/accused/charged/accused-m-to-z/mcrae-father-angus-mcrae/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sylvia's Site / The Inquiry (theinquiry.ca) 'McRae: Father Angus McRae'.",
"body": "Capt. Father Angus McRae, a Roman Catholic priest serving as a Canadian Forces chaplain, was arrested by military police at CFB Edmonton on June 28, 1980, following complaints from three youths aged 10 to 15 that McRae had sexually assaulted them in the base chapel. Charged with buggery, gross indecency and indecent assault, McRae pleaded guilty at his court martial and was sentenced to four years in the CFB Edmonton military prison, reduced on appeal to 18 months; he was released after serving 10 months and given a dishonorable discharge. In June 1980 he additionally admitted at an ecclesiastical court convened by his Catholic diocese to having sexually abused 'several minors' over the preceding years, resulting in mandatory counselling and five years' residency at a monastery."
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-class-action-lawsuit-military-child-abuse-1.7402756",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News (2026) 'Class-action lawsuit for children abused by military priest certified by Alberta court'.",
"body": "A class-action lawsuit seeking compensation for child victims of Capt. Angus McRae — who served as a chaplain at bases across Canada, sexually abusing children living on-base with military families, and died in 2011 — was certified by the Court of King's Bench of Alberta. The suit alleges the federal government allowed the abuse to continue across McRae's postings."
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2021/06/federal-government-faces-lawsuit-over-sexual-abuse-of-children-on-canadian-military-bases/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org (2021) 'Federal government faces lawsuit over sexual abuse of children on Canadian military bases'.",
"body": "Corroborates that McRae's abuse of children at Canadian Forces bases, where he served as chaplain to military families, extended across multiple postings and led to a 1989 further guilty plea in Toronto to fondling two boys aged 12 and 14, for which he was sentenced to three years' probation and banned from parish work for life."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Captain, Canadian Forces Chaplain Branch",
"Roman Catholic priest, base chaplain to military families at CFB Edmonton and other postings"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"used the base chapel — the physical seat of his religious authority over the base community — as the location of abuse",
"compound authority of military rank plus priestly office over children of the families under his pastoral charge"
],
"organizations": [
"Canadian Forces Chaplain Branch",
"Roman Catholic Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Canadian Forces court martial, CFB Edmonton",
"stage": "sentencing",
"outcome": "guilty plea to buggery, gross indecency and indecent assault; sentenced to 4 years (reduced on appeal to 18 months), dishonorably discharged",
"date": "1980-06-28"
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario provincial court, Toronto",
"stage": "sentencing",
"outcome": "guilty plea (1989) to sexual exploitation and sexual interference involving two further boys; 3 years' probation, banned from parish work for life"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "McRae was the sole chaplain serving the military-family community at CFB Edmonton; the assaults occurred inside the base chapel itself, the seat of his religious authority over children whose families were required by posting to live within his pastoral orbit. A subsequent ecclesiastical (Catholic diocesan) proceeding independently confirmed a pattern of abuse of minors, and a 2026 civil class action against the federal government for enabling his continued access across postings has been certified.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Canadian Forces court martial appeal",
"outcome": "sentence reduced from 4 years to 18 months; conviction itself not disturbed",
"date": ""
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.theinquiry.ca/wordpress/accused/charged/accused-m-to-z/mcrae-father-angus-mcrae/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-class-action-lawsuit-military-child-abuse-1.7402756",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2021/06/federal-government-faces-lawsuit-over-sexual-abuse-of-children-on-canadian-military-bases/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3c3ac8093e4fac3b7514bc43f30b4c19f4f0c2ccb79359f5f3945e396ae57f78",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2021/06/federal-government-faces-lawsuit-over-sexual-abuse-of-children-on-canadian-military-bases/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The clearest possible hospice instance of the criterion: the victim was maximally dependent (unconscious, days from death) and the chaplain's spiritual-care visit was the sole occasion of contact.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-arthur-apgar-hospice-chaplain-sacramento-california-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Sacramento County, California, USA",
"lat": 38.5816,
"lng": -121.4944,
"title": "United States: hospice chaplain sentenced for sexually assaulting an unconscious dying patient during a pastoral visit",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://sacda.org/2025/12/defendant-sentenced-for-sexual-battery-of-institutionalized-victim/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sacramento County District Attorney's Office (2025) 'Defendant Sentenced for Sexual Battery of Institutionalized Victim', 4 December 2025.",
"body": "Arthur Earl Apgar, a chaplain working for a hospice service, pleaded no contest to four felony counts of sexual battery on an institutionalized victim. On December 4, 2025, the Honorable Michael Sweet sentenced Apgar to 5 years in state prison. The victim was unconscious and receiving hospice care in an elder care facility in August 2024 when Apgar, who had visited to pray and sing with her, was recorded on a family-installed camera sexually assaulting her; she died four days later."
},
{
"link": "https://fox40.com/news/local-news/sacramento-county/hospice-chaplain-sentenced-to-5-years-behind-bars-after-assault-of-76-year-old-woman-allegations-victims-family-says/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FOX40 News (2025) 'Hospice chaplain sentenced to 5 years behind bars after assault of 76-year-old woman, victim's family says'.",
"body": "Reports the victim was a 76-year-old woman; her family had installed a camera after a prior fall, which captured Apgar's assault during what was presented as a pastoral visit. Apgar had been arrested August 8, 2024, following investigation by the Sacramento County Sheriff's Office Sexual and Elder Abuse Bureau."
},
{
"link": "https://www.abc10.com/article/news/crime/hospice-chaplain-accused-of-sexually-assaulting-elderly-woman-care-facility/103-079a6268-c437-4bc0-a1cf-f5f8e06fdeef",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ABC10 (2024) 'Hospice chaplain accused of sexually assaulting elderly woman at care facility'.",
"body": "Confirms the initial charge of four counts of sexual battery against a person who is seriously disabled or medically incapacitated, and that Apgar's role was chaplain for the hospice provider assigned to the victim's end-of-life care."
}
],
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Chaplain employed by a hospice care service, assigned to the victim's end-of-life spiritual care"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"entered the victim's room under the pretext of a pastoral visit (to 'pray and sing')",
"exploited total physical incapacitation (unconscious, dying) — the extreme case of a dependent, confined victim with no capacity to refuse or report"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sacramento County Superior Court, California",
"stage": "sentencing",
"outcome": "no-contest plea to 4 felony counts of sexual battery on an institutionalized victim; sentenced to 5 years state prison",
"date": "2025-12-04"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Apgar's only sanctioned reason for access to the victim's room and body was his religious office — he was there specifically to provide pastoral/spiritual care (prayer, singing) to a dying, unconscious patient. That pastoral pretext was the entire mechanism of access; there was no custodial or medical authority involved, only the chaplaincy role itself.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://sacda.org/2025/12/defendant-sentenced-for-sexual-battery-of-institutionalized-victim/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "90c4f86ce1a69e6a29c62eda17de09f98dd41f93feedad5fd295ef894d868d42",
"final_url": "https://sacda.org/2025/12/defendant-sentenced-for-sexual-battery-of-institutionalized-victim/"
},
{
"source": "https://fox40.com/news/local-news/sacramento-county/hospice-chaplain-sentenced-to-5-years-behind-bars-after-assault-of-76-year-old-woman-allegations-victims-family-says/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.abc10.com/article/news/crime/hospice-chaplain-accused-of-sexually-assaulting-elderly-woman-care-facility/103-079a6268-c437-4bc0-a1cf-f5f8e06fdeef",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1102,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Ruben founded and ran the camp on the strength of his standing in the church and was, with 'supreme irony', its own safeguarding lead; the sentencing judge and prosecution both framed his 'cloak of Christianity' as the access mechanism, distinguishing this from a custodial-only camp counsellor case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jon-ruben-stathern-lodge-leicestershire-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Stathern, Leicestershire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.8367,
"lng": -0.8425,
"title": "Jon Ruben: 23-year sentence for drugging and abusing boys at his own Christian summer camp",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"camp founder and leader",
"church safeguarding lead",
"veterinary professional trusted for medical authority"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"27-year church standing used to found and run the camp",
"self-appointed camp safeguarding-lead role",
"drugging via a 'sweet game' ritual at bedtime",
"isolation of the camp from parents for the residential period"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Stathern Lodge holiday camp"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Leicester Crown Court, England",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-06",
"outcome": "Ruben admitted wilful ill-treatment of eight children, sexual offences against two children, possession of indecent images of children and possession of a Class C drug; sentenced to 23 years 10 months in custody with an 8-year extended licence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ruben, then 76, ran a Christian holiday camp at Stathern Lodge that he founded on the back of his standing 'in the church' over at least 27 years, and prosecutors said he 'espoused Christianity' specifically to get into close proximity with boys. He was the camp's self-designated safeguarding lead, using that authority to isolate victims and administer drug-laced sweets during a nightly 'sweet game' before abusing them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/east-midlands/news/christian-summer-camp-leader-jailed-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crown Prosecution Service, 'Christian summer camp leader jailed for abuse' (Feb. 6, 2026).",
"body": "CPS press release confirming Ruben's guilty pleas, the Leicester Crown Court sentence of 23 years 10 months with an 8-year extended licence, and the prosecution's characterisation of his use of Christian standing to access victims.",
"tier": "official-prosecutorial-record",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timesandstar.co.uk/news/national/25832064.camp-leader-used-cloak-christianity-sexually-abuse-boys-court-told/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Times and Star, 'Camp leader used \"cloak of Christianity\" to sexually abuse boys, court told' (Feb. 6, 2026).",
"body": "National-wire court report on the Stathern Lodge camp, the 'sweet game' drugging method, Ruben's role as camp safeguarding lead, and the judge's remarks on the irony of that role.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.aol.com/articles/summer-camp-sex-offender-jailed-161609126.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "AOL/PA Media, 'Camp leader jailed for drugging and abusing boys' (Feb. 6, 2026).",
"body": "Wire-service corroboration of the sentence, the 27-year camp history, and Ruben's church standing as the route to access.",
"tier": "wire-service-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/east-midlands/news/christian-summer-camp-leader-jailed-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutorial-record; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d4736ca6391b1cc377e7bcbcca31a300e9863a12502f11fabf044f7533f5dfde",
"final_url": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/east-midlands/news/christian-summer-camp-leader-jailed-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timesandstar.co.uk/news/national/25832064.camp-leader-used-cloak-christianity-sexually-abuse-boys-court-told/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "92a6a5b4bc78c1fbb6cfdcaf8c5be5a9e407b0ad22b02b6a458284c8a37c6932",
"final_url": "https://www.timesandstar.co.uk/news/national/25832064.camp-leader-used-cloak-christianity-sexually-abuse-boys-court-told/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.aol.com/articles/summer-camp-sex-offender-jailed-161609126.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: wire-service-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3aa0a065655b7fd52692ddba0613dc9cb6add5ef4de659dbff878dffb6963662",
"final_url": "https://www.aol.com/articles/summer-camp-sex-offender-jailed-161609126.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1103,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The operative authority is Odiong's role as self-appointed spiritual director over adult women under his pastoral care, not a camp counsellor's custodial role — one relationship began after he offered to be a woman's spiritual adviser when he saw her weeping at Mass, and the abuse escalated inside that spiritual-direction relationship. Included in the retreat/spiritual-direction-for-adults arm of this lane.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-anthony-odiong-luling-waco-texas-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Luling and Waco, Texas, USA",
"lat": 29.6844,
"lng": -97.6494,
"title": "United States: priest Anthony Odiong given life for sexually assaulting women under his spiritual direction",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest",
"spiritual director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"self-appointment as spiritual director after a parishioner's public distress at Mass",
"framing of the relationship as spiritual direction and pastoral care",
"use of confession-adjacent one-on-one spiritual counsel to isolate victims"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Uyo, Nigeria (incardinating diocese)",
"unnamed Texas parishes"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court, Texas (Waco-area)",
"stage": "jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-02",
"outcome": "Convicted May 29, 2026 on one first-degree and two second-degree counts of sexual assault; sentenced June 2, 2026 to life imprisonment plus two consecutive 20-year terms and $30,000 in fines."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Odiong, a priest of the Diocese of Uyo, Nigeria who served in Texas parishes, offered to become a woman's spiritual adviser after seeing her weep during Mass; she testified she entered spiritual direction under him before the relationship was sexualized. A second victim's pastoral-care relationship with Odiong resulted in a child whose paternity DNA evidence confirmed at trial.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/priest-gets-life-prison-texas-sexual-abuse-women-under-his-spiritual-care",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Catholic Reporter, 'Priest gets life in prison in Texas for sexual abuse of women under his spiritual care' (June 2026).",
"body": "Reports the jury conviction, life sentence, two consecutive 20-year terms, $30,000 fine, and the spiritual-direction origin of the relationship including the weeping-at-Mass detail.",
"tier": "national-religious-press",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kwtx.com/2026/06/01/sexual-predator-wearing-priest-collar-anthony-odiong-gets-life-prison-sexual-assaults-parishioner/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KWTX, '\"A sexual predator wearing a priest collar\": Anthony Odiong gets life in prison for sexual assaults of parishioner' (June 1, 2026).",
"body": "Local television court reporting corroborating the life sentence and the spiritual-care relationship with the parishioner victims.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.osvnews.com/catholic-priest-found-guilty-of-sexually-abusing-women-under-his-spiritual-care-in-texas/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "OSV News, 'Catholic priest found guilty of sexually abusing women under his spiritual care in Texas' (May 2026).",
"body": "Confirms the May 29, 2026 jury verdict and describes the spiritual-direction relationship as the mechanism, plus DNA paternity evidence tying Odiong to a child born to one victim.",
"tier": "national-religious-press",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/priest-gets-life-prison-texas-sexual-abuse-women-under-his-spiritual-care",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-religious-press; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24a0418d89ae7b0ff49c71da089ba9281be8e7fc3472d16fcbffe4d25b062545",
"final_url": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/priest-gets-life-prison-texas-sexual-abuse-women-under-his-spiritual-care"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kwtx.com/2026/06/01/sexual-predator-wearing-priest-collar-anthony-odiong-gets-life-prison-sexual-assaults-parishioner/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "415766eff1ee18f9703cf4614fce20ddf550cc72d22e4f84fa0ea150ab2f704d",
"final_url": "https://www.kwtx.com/2026/06/01/sexual-predator-wearing-priest-collar-anthony-odiong-gets-life-prison-sexual-assaults-parishioner/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.osvnews.com/catholic-priest-found-guilty-of-sexually-abusing-women-under-his-spiritual-care-in-texas/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-religious-press; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "830043788183549fa2c0200d4e84b831fe353b9a2ad04ff3cc24bfcfab024ca6",
"final_url": "https://www.osvnews.com/catholic-priest-found-guilty-of-sexually-abusing-women-under-his-spiritual-care-in-texas/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1104,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Coleborn was the church's ordained minister, not a lay camp counsellor; the sentencing judge specifically found the offending was 'more than a mere slip' because of Coleborn's position as a leader in the church, satisfying the operative-religious-authority test rather than a custodial one.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-christopher-coleborn-cohuna-victoria-australia",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Cohuna and Burkes Bridge, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -35.8083,
"lng": 144.2226,
"title": "Australia: evangelical minister Christopher Coleborn jailed for abusing a boy at his own home during a church youth camp",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical church minister"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"minister's authority over a boy 'under his care, supervision or authority'",
"repeat access years apart, first as a child, then again as a young adult on a church youth camp",
"use of his own home as an extension of the camp"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Evangelical Presbyterian Church, Burkes Bridge (near Cohuna, Victoria)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Australia",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2023-11-10",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty to sexually abusing a boy under his care, supervision or authority, and indecent assault; sentenced to imprisonment for up to three years and eight months, with a minimum of 23 months before parole eligibility."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Coleborn was the ordained minister at the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, Burkes Bridge, when he first abused the boy at his own home in the late 1990s. Five years later he abused the same victim, by then 18, a second time while the victim was attending a church youth camp held at Coleborn's home — the camp setting and his ministerial authority over the victim were continuous across both offences.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8419142/evangelical-minister-jailed-for-child-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Canberra Times / AAP, 'Evangelical minister jailed for child sex abuse' (Nov. 10, 2023).",
"body": "Reports the County Court of Victoria sentence, the guilty plea, the church-camp setting of the second offence, and the judge's finding on Coleborn's position as a church leader.",
"tier": "national-newswire-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8354976/evangelical-church-minister-admits-to-child-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Canberra Times / AAP, 'Evangelical church minister admits to child sex abuse' (earlier plea report, 2023).",
"body": "Earlier wire report on the guilty plea and details of the church-camp offence and same-sex-attraction context the judge later addressed at sentencing.",
"tier": "national-newswire-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8419142/evangelical-minister-jailed-for-child-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newswire-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d79ec9545e8b5148e5d9cbcac04aa4dde2b240a41b9dbf5ca6666aa040493f47",
"final_url": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8419142/evangelical-minister-jailed-for-child-sex-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8354976/evangelical-church-minister-admits-to-child-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newswire-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "65f6d24a016128bd7ced356bb722c58727d6ac31579f464d3c23820bff9dac18",
"final_url": "https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8354976/evangelical-church-minister-admits-to-child-sex-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1105,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Never criminally charged; the record rests on a Maryland state-court civil jury verdict finding Krawatsky liable for assault and battery against two of three plaintiffs, arising directly from his role as a senior counselor with religious-community standing at an Orthodox Jewish camp. Krawatsky's own 2018 defamation suit against the accusers, which the countersuit responded to, failed on the malice standard.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-shmuel-krawatsky-camp-shoresh-maryland-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Baltimore and Frederick County, Maryland, USA",
"lat": 39.2904,
"lng": -76.6122,
"title": "United States: Baltimore rabbi Shmuel Krawatsky found civilly liable for abusing boys at Camp Shoresh",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"senior counselor, Camp Shoresh (Orthodox Jewish summer camp)",
"day-school and synagogue staff member"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"senior-counselor authority over 7- and 8-year-old campers",
"residential camp isolation from parents",
"religious-community standing that shaped how the allegations were received"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Camp Shoresh, Frederick County, Maryland",
"Beth Tfiloh Dahan Community School"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Maryland state court (Baltimore)",
"stage": "civil jury verdict on assault-and-battery countersuit",
"date": "2024-02-22",
"outcome": "Jury found Krawatsky liable to two of three plaintiffs for assault and battery, awarding $8,000 punitive and $1 compensatory damages to each of the two; did not find for the third plaintiff's family. No criminal charges were ever filed."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The three plaintiffs, aged 7 and 8 in 2015, attended Camp Shoresh, an Orthodox Jewish summer camp in Maryland, where Krawatsky was a senior counselor. He was fired from a Baltimore day school and a synagogue position after the allegations became public. The abuse occurred within the residential-camp authority structure rather than in a family or purely custodial context.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2024/02/26/united-states/baltimore-rabbi-found-liable-for-sexually-abusing-2-children-at-jewish-summer-camp",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 'Baltimore rabbi found liable for sexually abusing 2 children at Jewish summer camp' (Feb. 26, 2024).",
"body": "Reports the Feb. 22, 2024 jury verdict, the $8,000 punitive/$1 compensatory damages structure for two of three plaintiffs, Krawatsky's senior-counselor role at Camp Shoresh, and his firing from Beth Tfiloh Dahan and a synagogue post.",
"tier": "national-jewish-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "civil-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/baltimore-rabbi-found-liable-for-sexually-abusing-2-boys-at-summer-camp/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel, 'Baltimore rabbi found liable for sexually abusing 2 boys at summer camp' (Feb. 2024).",
"body": "Independent corroboration of the civil verdict, the camp setting, and background on the 2018 defamation suit Krawatsky filed against his accusers that preceded the countersuit.",
"tier": "national-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://forward.com/news/584553/rabbi-child-sexual-abuse-steven-krawatsky-baltimore/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Forward, 'Jury awards damages after Baltimore rabbi found liable for sexual abuse of children' (Feb. 2024).",
"body": "Further detail on the verdict breakdown across the three plaintiffs and the absence of any criminal charge against Krawatsky.",
"tier": "national-jewish-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2024/02/26/united-states/baltimore-rabbi-found-liable-for-sexually-abusing-2-children-at-jewish-summer-camp",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-jewish-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: civil-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3f06d0ecf0bf13ef389324f3250be2744d301085527e2814290c545b9db493b5",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2024/02/26/united-states/baltimore-rabbi-found-liable-for-sexually-abusing-2-children-at-jewish-summer-camp"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/baltimore-rabbi-found-liable-for-sexually-abusing-2-boys-at-summer-camp/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "53d394728d1d3b9094b5848685e33335da8732edea9dfa9540c4c1a5717a2f7e",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/baltimore-rabbi-found-liable-for-sexually-abusing-2-boys-at-summer-camp/"
},
{
"source": "https://forward.com/news/584553/rabbi-child-sexual-abuse-steven-krawatsky-baltimore/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-jewish-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3726522695bc30478bde117d18eefe67164b724cdc6d2572d8c96428df12a90b",
"final_url": "https://forward.com/news/584553/rabbi-child-sexual-abuse-steven-krawatsky-baltimore/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1106,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The counselor role at this Orthodox camp carried religious-community standing distinct from a purely secular custodial camp job — the camp serves Hasidic and Orthodox families specifically and Ben-Porath's access followed from that community position; included with an explicit flag that the source record documents the mechanism as counselor authority within a religious residential camp rather than describing an invoked doctrine, consistent with the criterion's institutional-obedience indicator.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-chisdai-ben-porath-camp-dora-golding-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Smithfield Township, Monroe County, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 41.0079,
"lng": -75.0335,
"title": "United States: Camp Dora Golding counselor Chisdai Ben-Porath pleads guilty to molesting a camper",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"camp counselor, Camp Dora Golding (Orthodox Jewish summer camp)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"counselor authority over young campers in a residential Orthodox camp",
"physical access to bunks at night",
"alleged camp cover-up (return bus ticket) that isolated the incident from parents and authorities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Camp Dora Golding, Smithfield Township, Pennsylvania"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Monroe County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2014-01-01",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty to molestation of a 12-year-old camper; sentenced to 5 to 23 months in Monroe County jail, ordered to register as a sex offender and attend counseling."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ben-Porath, then 20, was a counselor at Camp Dora Golding, which serves Orthodox Jewish children largely from Rockland and Orange Counties, New York. He was recorded on video molesting campers in their bunks in July 2013; a related civil suit alleged the camp owner sought to conceal the abuse by giving Ben-Porath a bus ticket home to Canada rather than reporting it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wfmz.com/news/former-monroe-county-camp-counselor-sentenced-for-molestation/article_4c3125db-0a96-5110-8572-4cb5d16bd6c7.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WFMZ, 'Former Monroe County camp counselor sentenced for molestation.'",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, the 5-to-23-month Monroe County jail sentence, sex-offender registration and counseling order.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/orthodox-camp-counselor-faces-molestation-charges/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Times of Israel, 'Counselor at Orthodox camp faces molestation charges.'",
"body": "Identifies Camp Dora Golding as an Orthodox Jewish summer camp, the July 2013 video evidence, and Ben-Porath's counselor role.",
"tier": "national-jewish-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.church.law/family-files-lawsuit-camp-counselor-alleging-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Church Law & Tax, 'Family Files Lawsuit Against Camp Counselor Alleging Sexual Abuse.'",
"body": "Reports the related civil suit alleging camp ownership concealed the abuse by sending Ben-Porath home rather than reporting it to authorities.",
"tier": "legal-trade-press",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wfmz.com/news/former-monroe-county-camp-counselor-sentenced-for-molestation/article_4c3125db-0a96-5110-8572-4cb5d16bd6c7.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6c7944ca13c5a443df74d863eef832a586d5e0fc4b874b7b72984c430f4d2d01",
"final_url": "https://www.wfmz.com/news/former-monroe-county-camp-counselor-sentenced-for-molestation/article_4c3125db-0a96-5110-8572-4cb5d16bd6c7.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/orthodox-camp-counselor-faces-molestation-charges/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-jewish-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6dedd7b09e71b7f30e0ccc88a99bc64fb0fec58cec9602c03b63505d792032f2",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/orthodox-camp-counselor-faces-molestation-charges/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.church.law/family-files-lawsuit-camp-counselor-alleging-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-trade-press; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bbdd8d1d252cfd4d9aa2b48b373329489f1c67b98c292c6a1724e6ff76b44892",
"final_url": "https://www.church.law/family-files-lawsuit-camp-counselor-alleging-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1107,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victim told investigators Cook 'persuaded him that the contact they had was acceptable ... because he was his EFY counselor' — the counselor's religious-program authority is recorded as the explicit operative mechanism the perpetrator invoked, not merely custodial access, which is why this is included over the plan's caution about camp counsellors generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-keldon-cook-especially-for-youth-utah-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Provo and Davis County, Utah, USA",
"lat": 40.2338,
"lng": -111.6585,
"title": "United States: Especially For Youth counselor Keldon Cook imprisoned for grooming a camper he told the abuse was acceptable",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"counselor, Especially For Youth (LDS Church youth conference program)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"counselor authority invoked directly to normalize the abuse ('acceptable ... because he was his EFY counselor')",
"continued contact and grooming after the residential program ended",
"trust extended by the church-affiliated program to families"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Especially For Youth (Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints youth conference program)",
"Brigham Young University (program host site)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Utah state court (Utah/Davis County)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2015-12-01",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty to one count of attempted sexual exploitation of a minor and three counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a 16- or 17-year-old; sentenced to four concurrent zero-to-five-year prison terms."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cook met the victim, then 14, as his assigned counselor at a weeklong Especially For Youth program hosted at Brigham Young University in 2012. Sexual contact occurred between March 2014 and March 2015; when the victim was 16, meeting again at a Davis County park, Cook told him the earlier contact was acceptable specifically because of his EFY counselor role — an explicit invocation of the program's religious authority as license.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.deseret.com/2015/12/1/20577867/ex-efy-counselor-sent-to-prison-for-sex-with-teen-boy/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Deseret News, 'Ex-EFY counselor sent to prison for sex with teen boy' (Dec. 1, 2015).",
"body": "Reports the sentencing to four concurrent zero-to-five-year terms and background on the guilty plea.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ksl.com/article/news/utah/former-efy-counselor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-contact-with-teen/37068987",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KSL.com, 'Former EFY counselor pleads guilty to sexual contact with teen.'",
"body": "Details the plea deal, the reduced charges, and the BYU-hosted EFY program setting where Cook and the victim met as counselor and camper.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.saltlakecriminaldefense.com/2015/12/sexual-abuse-lds-church-counselor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Salt Lake Criminal Defense Attorney case summary, 'Sexual Abuse by a LDS Church Counselor' (Dec. 2015).",
"body": "Legal-practice summary quoting the victim's statement that Cook told him the conduct was acceptable because of his EFY counselor status.",
"tier": "legal-commentary",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.deseret.com/2015/12/1/20577867/ex-efy-counselor-sent-to-prison-for-sex-with-teen-boy/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "852a20f470f6d518c75b919ea517ae8f6473162d2e4b0e5e519057d6828e4acc",
"final_url": "https://www.deseret.com/2015/12/1/20577867/ex-efy-counselor-sent-to-prison-for-sex-with-teen-boy/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ksl.com/article/news/utah/former-efy-counselor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-contact-with-teen/37068987",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fafc248c0d48d608ad7bf335d21fb81f3ff51fb4ad15683ccd8217e320926dc9",
"final_url": "https://www.ksl.com/article/news/utah/former-efy-counselor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-contact-with-teen/37068987"
},
{
"source": "https://www.saltlakecriminaldefense.com/2015/12/sexual-abuse-lds-church-counselor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-commentary; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1108,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Chihuahua state prosecutors expressly found the pastor 'used the trust inspired by his religious function' to commit the abuse specifically during spiritual retreats attended by his own disciple, matching the criterion's operative-authority test directly rather than a merely custodial relationship.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-esaul-lh-cuauhtemoc-chihuahua-mexico",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Cuauhtémoc, Chihuahua, Mexico",
"lat": 28.4064,
"lng": -106.8664,
"title": "Mexico: evangelical pastor sentenced to 53 years for abusing a disciple during spiritual retreats",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"evangelical pastor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"trust inspired by his position as religious pastor",
"isolation of the victim during residential spiritual retreats",
"repeated access across three documented retreat occasions"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"unnamed evangelical congregation, Cuauhtémoc, Chihuahua"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Chihuahua state court, Mexico",
"stage": "trial conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-07-18",
"outcome": "Convicted of sexual abuse of a minor across three retreat occasions in 2018 and 2020; sentenced to 53 years and 4 months' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The Fiscalía General del Estado de Chihuahua's own account states the pastor, identified as Esaul L.H., used the trust his position as a religious pastor inspired in Cuauhtémoc to gain access to the victim, and committed sexual offenses on three separate occasions when the victim attended spiritual retreats he led between 2018 and 2020.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.eldiariodechihuahua.mx/opinion/2023/jul/18/ejemplar-condena-de-53-anos-vs-pastor-498029.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "El Diario de Chihuahua, 'Ejemplar condena de 53 años vs pastor' (July 18, 2023).",
"body": "Reports the 53-year-4-month sentence and the spiritual-retreat setting of the three documented offenses.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://fiscalia.chihuahua.gob.mx/vinculan-a-proceso-penal-a-pastor-religioso-acusado-por-abuso-sexual-en-cuauhtemoc/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General del Estado de Chihuahua, 'Vinculan a proceso penal a pastor religioso acusado por abuso sexual en Cuauhtémoc' (official case notice).",
"body": "State prosecutor's official statement identifying the pastor's use of religious trust to access the victim during spiritual retreats, corroborating the mechanism found at trial.",
"tier": "official-prosecutorial-record",
"kind": "criminal-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.eldiariodechihuahua.mx/opinion/2023/jul/18/ejemplar-condena-de-53-anos-vs-pastor-498029.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "44612256f044f5b7c24f56510d114ef803b7b2860cc2a4528e2b81217539ab2e",
"final_url": "https://www.eldiariodechihuahua.mx/opinion/2023/jul/18/ejemplar-condena-de-53-anos-vs-pastor-498029.html"
},
{
"source": "https://fiscalia.chihuahua.gob.mx/vinculan-a-proceso-penal-a-pastor-religioso-acusado-por-abuso-sexual-en-cuauhtemoc/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutorial-record; evidentiary role: criminal-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1109,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Charged only, evidence tier accordingly capped at 'charged' — included as a live proceeding to track, not a stood conviction. Parago held both the pastoral title and the camp-director role simultaneously, so if the case proceeds to trial this record should be revisited for a stronger evidence tier rather than re-drafted as new.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-carson-parago-winnipeg-manitoba-canada",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada",
"lat": 49.8951,
"lng": -97.1384,
"title": "Canada: Winnipeg pastor and youth camp director charged with sexually exploiting a teenage counsellor",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "charged",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Centerpoint Church",
"youth camp director"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"dual pastoral and camp-director authority over a teenage staff member",
"grooming through private one-on-one meetings",
"distribution of sexually explicit material to isolate and normalize contact"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Centerpoint Church, Winnipeg"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Winnipeg Police Service / Manitoba provincial court",
"stage": "charged, released on Crown-authorized conditions",
"date": "2026-04-30",
"outcome": "Charged with sexual assault, sexual exploitation, luring a person under 18, and distributing sexually explicit material to a person under 18; arrested April 30, 2026 and released on conditions. Allegations not yet proven in court."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Police allege Parago, pastor and youth camp director at Centerpoint Church, groomed and gained the trust of a teenage youth-camp counsellor between August 2025 and March 2026, using his combined pastoral and camp-leadership authority to arrange private meetings and send sexually explicit material.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.winnipeg.ca/police/community/news-releases/2026-05-05-teen-sexually-assaulted-pastorcamp-director-custody-c26-60730",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Winnipeg Police Service, 'Teen sexually assaulted. Pastor/Camp Director in custody: C26-60730' (May 5, 2026).",
"body": "Official police release naming the charges, the arrest date, and Parago's dual pastor/camp-director role.",
"tier": "official-police-record",
"kind": "charging-record"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/youth-camp-pastor-charged-sexual-assault-9.7187931",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'No \"red flags\" around Winnipeg youth camp pastor now charged with sexually assaulting teen: lead pastor' (May 2026).",
"body": "Reports the grooming allegation timeline, Parago's role, and church leadership's response.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Charged with sexual assault, sexual exploitation, luring a person under 18, and distributing sexually explicit material to a person under 18; arrested April 30, 2026 and released on conditions. Allegations not yet proven in court.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.winnipeg.ca/police/community/news-releases/2026-05-05-teen-sexually-assaulted-pastorcamp-director-custody-c26-60730",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-police-record; evidentiary role: charging-record.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "156236a87ae007a4e072ad690135d2865527fdda6d175aecbb9fce6feec99b91",
"final_url": "https://www.winnipeg.ca/police/community/news-releases/2026-05-05-teen-sexually-assaulted-pastorcamp-director-custody-c26-60730"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/youth-camp-pastor-charged-sexual-assault-9.7187931",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1110,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This is a CIVIL finding, not a criminal conviction — grand-jury manslaughter indictments against the parents and Tosto were dismissed pre-trial in 1990 on Fourteenth Amendment fair-notice grounds under Minnesota's then-existing religious-exemption statute, and that dismissal was itself affirmed by the Minnesota Supreme Court (4-2). No criminal charge against anyone in this case ever reached a conviction. Entered specifically because Tosto and Lamb were engaged in a professional-religious capacity distinct from the parents' own parental authority, which is the shape this lane was tasked with finding; the evidence tier is civil-finding, not convicted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1995-lundman-v-mckown-christian-science-practitioner-minnesota-usa",
"year": 1995,
"place": "Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA",
"lat": 44.978,
"lng": -93.265,
"title": "Lundman v. McKown: Christian Science practitioner and nurse held civilly liable, in their professional capacity, for a child's death from withheld insulin",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "civil-judgment",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "civil-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Christian Science practitioner engaged to treat the patient",
"Christian Science nurse engaged to attend the patient"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal refusal of medical care",
"professional religious healing engagement substituted for medical treatment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"First Church of Christ, Scientist",
"Clifton House, Inc."
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Minnesota Court of Appeals",
"stage": "appeal — compensatory damages affirmed against the practitioner and nurse",
"date": "1995-04-04",
"outcome": "The Minnesota Court of Appeals affirmed a jury's compensatory-damages verdict against Christian Science practitioner Mario Tosto and Christian Science nurse Quinna Lamb (Giebelhaus), along with the child's mother and stepfather, for negligence in the 1989 death of 11-year-old Ian Lundman from untreated juvenile-onset diabetes. The court reversed the judgment against the First Church of Christ, Scientist itself and against Clifton House. The Minnesota Supreme Court denied further review on 1995-05-31, and the U.S. Supreme Court denied certiorari in 1996 (516 U.S. 1092)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Ian Lundman's mother, a Christian Scientist, engaged Mario Tosto — a Christian Science practitioner, a paid religious office-holder formally credentialed by the church to treat the sick through prayer — and Quinna Lamb, a Christian Science nurse, in place of conventional medical care for her son's diabetes symptoms. Both were retained in a professional capacity to treat the patient, not as family members or bystanders, and the jury found both independently negligent; the Court of Appeals affirmed that finding against them by name while relieving the church itself of liability.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/minnesota/court-of-appeals/1995/c1-94-891.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lundman v. McKown, 530 N.W.2d 807 (Minn. Ct. App. 1995), review denied (Minn. May 31, 1995), cert. denied, 516 U.S. 1092 (1996).",
"body": "The Minnesota Court of Appeals opinion affirms compensatory damages against Christian Science practitioner Mario Tosto and Christian Science nurse Quinna Lamb by name, alongside the child's mother and stepfather, while reversing the judgment against the church itself.",
"tier": "state-appellate-court",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/1989/10/28/3-christian-scientists-indicted-in-death-of-child-with-diabetes/3e3fdb67-cb9a-4a49-a3c9-1669e6e7e2df/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"3 Christian Scientists Indicted in Death of Child with Diabetes,\" The Washington Post, October 28, 1989.",
"body": "Contemporaneous press confirming the practitioner was charged alongside the parents in the underlying (later-dismissed) criminal case, establishing his direct treating role.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/minnesota/court-of-appeals/1995/c1-94-891.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-appellate-court; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/1989/10/28/3-christian-scientists-indicted-in-death-of-child-with-diabetes/3e3fdb67-cb9a-4a49-a3c9-1669e6e7e2df/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1111,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Qualifies through Stevens' own authority over the family and congregation, not merely the parents' paternal authority over their own child — the judge's finding that Stevens 'procured and aided' the killing by directing Jason Struhs is the operative fact distinguishing this from the paternal-nexus cases this lane mostly rejected. No reported appeal located as of this writing; entered as a trial-court conviction with sentence imposed, not yet confirmed final on appeal.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-elizabeth-struhs-the-saints-toowoomba-australia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Toowoomba, Queensland, Australia",
"lat": -27.5606,
"lng": 151.9539,
"title": "Elizabeth Struhs: 'The Saints' leader convicted of manslaughter for directing an 8-year-old's parents to stop her insulin",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-appointed leader of a home-based Christian sect ('The Saints') with authority over the victim's parents and household"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrinal refusal of medical care",
"leader's direct instruction to a parent to withhold prescribed treatment"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"The Saints"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Queensland",
"stage": "trial — convicted (judge-only trial)",
"date": "2025-01-29",
"outcome": "Justice Martin Burns found Brendan Luke Stevens — leader of the home-based Christian group 'The Saints' — and the child's father Jason Struhs guilty of manslaughter, along with 12 other congregation members including the child's mother and brother, in the January 2022 death of 8-year-old Elizabeth Struhs from six days without prescribed insulin for type-1 diabetes. All 14 defendants were convicted; Stevens and Jason Struhs were acquitted of the more serious charge of murder."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Queensland",
"stage": "sentencing",
"date": "2025-02-26",
"outcome": "Justice Burns sentenced Stevens to 13 years' imprisonment, describing him as 'a dangerous, highly manipulative individual' who 'procured and aided' the killing by encouraging Jason Struhs to stop providing his daughter's insulin. Other members received lengthy custodial sentences."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Stevens led 'The Saints,' a home-based sect built around belief in the healing power of God and rejection of conventional medicine, which some members described as 'witchcraft.' The sentencing judge expressly found that Stevens' authority over the group — not merely Jason Struhs' authority as a parent — was the operative means of Elizabeth's death: Stevens 'procured and aided' the killing by directing and encouraging the father to withhold insulin, and the court held the leader and congregation members criminally liable alongside the parents rather than treating the church context as incidental.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/religious-sect-members-convicted-death-diabetic-girl-elizabeth-struhs-australia/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"14 religious sect members convicted over diabetic girl's death in Australia,\" CBS News, January 29, 2025.",
"body": "Reports the judge-only trial verdict convicting all 14 defendants, including leader Brendan Stevens, of manslaughter.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "news-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2025/02/26/australia/elizabeth-struhs-sect-sentenced-intl-hnk/index.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "\"Australian sect members who believed God would save dying 8-year-old sentenced,\" CNN, February 26, 2025.",
"body": "Reports Stevens' 13-year sentence and the sentencing judge's finding that he 'procured and aided' the killing by directing the father to withhold insulin.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "news-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/religious-sect-members-convicted-death-diabetic-girl-elizabeth-struhs-australia/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6cb75bc4d3a3d2c85c0a70db1b050647c7e2d827cbdea24c99553a2c6694f190",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/religious-sect-members-convicted-death-diabetic-girl-elizabeth-struhs-australia/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2025/02/26/australia/elizabeth-struhs-sect-sentenced-intl-hnk/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: news-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ed5d6af1c77c884187ea77c7b3461808778c7020ca5d016d841eff5e291d5f3f",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2025/02/26/australia/elizabeth-struhs-sect-sentenced-intl-hnk/index.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1112,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainant, not identified. The exact sentence handed down after the deferred hearing in March 2011 was not confirmed in the reporting located; the conviction itself is the qualifying evidence event.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2011-surinder-singh-guru-nanak-sikh-temple-glasgow-scotland",
"year": 2011,
"place": "Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom",
"lat": 55.8721,
"lng": -4.2917,
"title": "Scotland: Sikh priest convicted of sexually assaulting a 12-year-old girl in his temple room in Glasgow",
"tradition": "sikhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-sikh",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Sikh priest (granthi) visiting from India, resident in the temple"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly standing at the Guru Nanak Sikh Temple",
"use of a private lesson (harmonium/classical music instruction) as the pretext to get the child alone in his room"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Guru Nanak Sikh Temple, Otago Street, Glasgow"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Glasgow Sheriff Court, Scotland (Sheriff Anthony Deutch)",
"stage": "conviction at trial",
"date": "2011-02-01",
"outcome": "Surinder Singh, 53, a Sikh priest visiting Scotland from India and resident at the Guru Nanak Sikh Temple, was found guilty after trial of sexually assaulting a 12-year-old girl in his room at the temple on 15 January. The girl had been invited to the room under the pretext of receiving classical harmonium instruction; Singh touched her hands, attempted to kiss her on the mouth, and placed food in her mouth. The sheriff stated he found the Crown witnesses credible and rejected the accused's evidence as incredible. Sentence was deferred to the following month."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainant was a child at a religious event at the temple where the defendant served as resident priest; his role and his private room inside the gurdwara were what let him isolate her under the pretext of religious/musical instruction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sikhnet.com/news/sikh-priest-convicted-glasgow-temple-sex-attack",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sikh priest convicted of Glasgow temple sex attack', SikhNet, 2011.",
"body": "Report of the Glasgow Sheriff Court trial, verdict, and the sheriff's stated reasons for finding the Crown witnesses credible.",
"tier": "community-outlet-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sikhnet.com/news/sikh-priest-convicted-glasgow-temple-sex-attack",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: community-outlet-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2f5523b10beb3e9d6de951cdffc650c4212f339f7e2ad672bcea4d90bf3726ec",
"final_url": "https://sikhnet.com/news/sikh-priest-convicted-glasgow-temple-sex-attack"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1113,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sentencing had not yet occurred as of the source located (pre-sentence hearing set for 2025-12-12); the conviction itself is the qualifying evidence event. This is a distinct perpetrator and proceeding from the corpus's existing Yeshivah College records (David Kramer, David Cyprys, and the Royal Commission Case Study 22 institutional record); Manny Waks, the complainant here, is the same survivor-advocate referenced in that broader Yeshivah Centre reporting history, but this conviction was not previously in the corpus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-velvel-serebryanski-chabad-yeshivah-centre-melbourne-australia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Melbourne, Victoria, Australia",
"lat": -37.8136,
"lng": 144.9631,
"title": "Australia: Chabad figure Velvel Serebryanski convicted of raping and molesting a child at Melbourne's Yeshivah Centre",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Adult figure within Melbourne's Chabad-Lubavitch Yeshivah Centre community, son of a prominent Chabad emissary rabbi"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing within the Yeshivah Centre's Chabad educational and religious community",
"isolating the child from a synagogue study session on the pretext of leaving to talk privately, then assaulting him in a restroom"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Yeshivah Centre, Melbourne (Chabad-Lubavitch)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "County Court of Victoria, Australia",
"stage": "conviction at trial",
"date": "2025-12-05",
"outcome": "Velvel Serebryanski, 61, was found guilty on all four counts — three charges of indecent assault and one of sexual penetration of a child aged 10-16 — over the molestation and rape of Manny Waks, who was 11-12 years old at the time, in the late 1980s in and around Melbourne's Yeshivah Centre and its affiliated synagogue. One incident occurred during a Shavuot study session when Serebryanski led the child from the synagogue to a restroom and assaulted him. Serebryanski had emigrated to New York and was extradited back to Australia in 2023 to face trial; he had separately confessed to the abuse during a 2017 televised exposé."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child inside the Yeshivah Centre's Chabad religious and educational community; the defendant's standing within that community, as the son of a leading Chabad emissary, gave him access to isolate the child from communal religious settings including a synagogue study session.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/son-of-chabad-rabbi-in-australia-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse-in-long-running-scandal/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Member of prominent Chabad family in Australia convicted of child sex abuse in long-running scandal', The Times of Israel, 2025.",
"body": "Report of the County Court of Victoria conviction on all four counts, the victim's identity and age, the 1980s Yeshivah Centre setting, and the defendant's 2023 extradition from New York.",
"tier": "international-jewish-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/son-of-chabad-rabbi-in-australia-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse-in-long-running-scandal/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-jewish-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c04711bf30a6903301c5f8d0c4fd5faf0be517f7f47ea9adecdd88e23ee8e6d0",
"final_url": "https://www.timesofisrael.com/son-of-chabad-rabbi-in-australia-convicted-of-child-sex-abuse-in-long-running-scandal/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1114,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Goodman was separately charged in 2018 in New Jersey with federal child-sex-trafficking offenses arising from a different, later period as executive director of a Chabad center in East Brunswick, NJ; that matter is a distinct proceeding and is not the basis of this record, which rests solely on the Pennsylvania conviction for the 2001 camp abuse.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-aryeh-goodman-chabad-camp-menachem-pike-county-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Lackawaxen Township, Pike County, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 41.427,
"lng": -75.0044,
"title": "United States: Chabad rabbi Aryeh Goodman sentenced for indecently assaulting a 12-year-old boy at a Chabad summer camp",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Chabad rabbi serving as a counselor at Camp Menachem"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rabbinic and counselor authority over a child at a religious summer camp"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Camp Menachem, Lackawaxen Township, Pennsylvania (Chabad-Lubavitch)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Common Pleas, Pike County, Pennsylvania, USA",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2015-10-01",
"outcome": "Rabbi Aryeh Goodman pleaded guilty to two counts of indecent assault of a person under 13 years of age, arising from incidents during the summer of 2001 when he was a counselor at Camp Menachem, a Chabad facility, and the victim was a 12-year-old boy. He was extradited from New Jersey in January 2013 to face the Pennsylvania charges. In October 2015 he was sentenced in Pike County to 11 to 23 months in prison, required to complete sex-offender counseling, and barred from contact with the victim or his family."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child at a Chabad-run religious summer camp; the defendant's authority as the camp's rabbi and counselor was what put him in unsupervised charge of the boy.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.jta.org/2018/02/20/ny/n-j-rabbi-again-faces-sex-charges",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'N.J. Rabbi Again Faces Sex Charges', Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 2018.",
"body": "JTA report recapping Goodman's 2013 extradition to Pennsylvania, his guilty plea to indecent assault of a child under 13, and his October 2015 sentence of 11 to 23 months, in the course of reporting his later 2018 New Jersey charges.",
"tier": "jewish-wire-service-court-reporting",
"kind": "background-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.jta.org/2018/02/20/ny/n-j-rabbi-again-faces-sex-charges",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: jewish-wire-service-court-reporting; evidentiary role: background-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a8c1dad8d3290cccf265d7aec2c17ca8a344f29305c17a11204bfddee1462456",
"final_url": "https://www.jta.org/2018/02/20/ny/n-j-rabbi-again-faces-sex-charges"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9211,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This conviction is separate from the Missouri Attorney General's September 2019 report naming 12 priests referred for prosecution (of which Frederick Lutz, already in the corpus, is the only one publicly confirmed charged); Lenczycki's Missouri sodomy charges arose independently through St. Louis County prosecutors and were sentenced in August 2019, one month before the AG report's release. Included because it is a St. Louis-area clergy conviction from the same investigative period and state, and because it corrects a gap: Missouri's AG-referral pipeline itself produced no further named individual convictions as of this research pass.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-follow-up",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-fred-lenczycki-st-louis-county-missouri-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "St. Louis County, Missouri, USA",
"lat": 38.7093,
"lng": -90.4029,
"title": "United States: priest Fred Lenczycki sentenced for sodomy of two boys in a north St. Louis County parish",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, parish assignment in north St. Louis County, Missouri"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish and pastoral access to children",
"prior interdiocesan transfer despite known abuse history in Illinois"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of St. Louis"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "St. Louis County, Missouri Circuit Court",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2019-08-16",
"outcome": "Fred Lenczycki pleaded guilty in May 2019 to two counts of sodomy against two boys, committed 1991-1994 while assigned to a north St. Louis County parish. Sentenced August 16, 2019 to two concurrent 10-year terms. This followed an earlier 2004 Illinois conviction (five years) for abusing three boys in Hinsdale, Illinois in the 1980s, after which Lenczycki became, in 2008, the first U.S. priest civilly committed as a sexually violent person under Illinois law. No appeal of the Missouri plea and sentence has been located."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Lenczycki abused the two Missouri victims using the access and trust granted by his position as parish priest; church officials had moved him between dioceses (Illinois to Missouri) despite an existing abuse history, extending his access to new children under clerical authority.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://cruxnow.com/church-in-the-usa/2019/08/priest-already-deemed-sexually-violent-sentenced-again",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crux, 'Priest already deemed sexually violent sentenced again' (Aug. 16, 2019).",
"body": "Reports the Aug. 16, 2019 sentencing to two concurrent 10-year terms for sodomy against two boys in St. Louis County 1991-1994, the May 2019 guilty plea, and Lenczycki's 2004 Illinois conviction and 2008 sexually-violent-person civil commitment.",
"tier": "national-catholic-press",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.recoveredmemory.org/legal-cases/illinois-v.-rev.-fred-lenczycki----",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Recovered Memory Project case file, 'Illinois v. Rev. Fred Lenczycki.'",
"body": "Background on Lenczycki's 2004 Illinois conviction and abuse history across Illinois, Missouri, and California, corroborating the interdiocesan-transfer pattern.",
"tier": "legal-case-archive",
"kind": "background-reference"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://cruxnow.com/church-in-the-usa/2019/08/priest-already-deemed-sexually-violent-sentenced-again",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-catholic-press; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "42f160c7b7cbd435c9268b895aace3f453f2a28bd5d838644066ce3b4ca312e3",
"final_url": "https://cruxnow.com/church-in-the-usa/2019/08/priest-already-deemed-sexually-violent-sentenced-again"
},
{
"source": "https://www.recoveredmemory.org/legal-cases/illinois-v.-rev.-fred-lenczycki----",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: legal-case-archive; evidentiary role: background-reference.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5e3c2bff259d8952f5657e273e5829d36cf8f5741d57888f30dfb7fa573d3c26",
"final_url": "https://www.recoveredmemory.org/legal-cases/illinois-v.-rev.-fred-lenczycki----"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9212,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Chavez appears on the Diocese of Brownsville's 2019 and 2025 clergy-disclosure lists (part of the 2019 coordinated Texas diocesan disclosure wave named in this research pass's target list). Exact plea and sentencing dates were not recoverable from available sources within this session's search budget; the year of arrest/prosecution (2014) is used and the proceedings date key is omitted rather than guessed. Sentence has not been reported as overturned; Chavez is confirmed still registered as a sex offender on parole as of March 2025, consistent with the sentence having stood.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-follow-up",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-ronaldo-chavez-diocese-brownsville-texas-usa",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Granjeno, Hidalgo County, Texas, USA",
"lat": 26.2334,
"lng": -98.4034,
"title": "United States: Diocese of Brownsville deacon Ronaldo Chavez pleads guilty to molesting an altar boy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic permanent deacon, mission church in Granjeno, Texas; also school principal"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical access to an altar boy through parish ministry duties"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Brownsville"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hidalgo County, Texas",
"stage": "arrest, guilty plea and sentencing",
"outcome": "Ronaldo Mitchell Chavez, a permanent deacon at a mission church in Granjeno and a school principal, was arrested January 17, 2014 on charges of molesting an altar boy over a two-year span (June 2010-August 2012). The diocese had already removed his diaconal faculties in 2012 when the allegation surfaced. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to seven years in prison; a civil suit followed on June 5, 2014. He was laicized in 2021 and remains registered as a sex offender, on parole, as of March 2025."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Chavez's access to the altar boy arose directly from his clerical duties as a permanent deacon assisting at Mass and parish ministry at the Granjeno mission.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/chavez-ronaldo-mitchell-2010/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org, accused-cleric profile: 'Deacon Ronaldo Mitchell Chavez.'",
"body": "Confirms arrest date, diocese, seven-year sentence, 2021 laicization, and sex-offender registration status as of March 2025, citing McAllen Monitor and Valley Central contemporaneous reporting.",
"tier": "clergy-abuse-database",
"kind": "case-profile-compilation"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2014/01_02/2014_01_20_Santella_MissionPd.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dan Santella, 'Mission PD: Granjeno church deacon molested altar boy over 2-year span,' The Monitor (Jan. 20, 2014).",
"body": "Contemporaneous report of the arrest and allegations naming Chavez as deacon and principal.",
"tier": "regional-daily-press",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/chavez-ronaldo-mitchell-2010/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: clergy-abuse-database; evidentiary role: case-profile-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fca6d12abfde3e1f8ed8e0246b18720f30e9f2b2458fba07c8bb2fbfebfdcbf6",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/accused/chavez-ronaldo-mitchell-2010/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2014/01_02/2014_01_20_Santella_MissionPd.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-daily-press; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d60185f0e16d57ff2b860e20e1e54596f3d72bfe63aea1f14a04f2967e18d0b2",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2014/01_02/2014_01_20_Santella_MissionPd.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9213,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Not a case named within the Maryland AG's April 2023 Archdiocese of Baltimore grand-jury report itself (that report's own criminal referral, of a lay wrestling coach, ended in a full acquittal - Neil Adleberg, checked and excluded, fails N1: he held no spiritual/pastoral authority over the victim). Guy's prosecution instead emerged independently in the same post-report Baltimore County wave (indicted 2025) and involves a distinct organization, Metro Maryland Youth for Christ, operating out of an Episcopal-affiliated church. Included because Guy held an ongoing pastoral/discipleship role over his identified victims, satisfying N1/N2, unlike Adleberg.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-follow-up",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-kevin-guy-metro-maryland-youth-for-christ-usa",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Catonsville and Reisterstown, Baltimore County, Maryland, USA",
"lat": 39.2721,
"lng": -76.7319,
"title": "United States: Youth for Christ leader Kevin Guy pleads guilty to sexually abusing teens in his youth group",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Youth ministry director/pastor, Metro Maryland Youth for Christ, based at Bishop Cummins Reformed Episcopal Church, Catonsville"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral and mentorship authority over youth-group members",
"one-on-one access through discipleship outings, his home, and his car"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Metro Maryland Youth for Christ",
"Bishop Cummins Reformed Episcopal Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Baltimore County, Maryland Circuit Court",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2025-09-16",
"outcome": "Kevin Guy, 32, a youth ministry director with Metro Maryland Youth for Christ, pleaded guilty September 16, 2025 to sexual abuse of a minor and third- and fourth-degree sex offenses, admitting abuse of five boys aged 13-17 between 2021 and 2024 at his home, his car, the church, and a nearby fast-food restaurant. Sentenced December 17, 2025 to 35 years with 28 suspended (7 years to serve) and lifetime sex-offender registration."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Guy used his role as youth-group leader and mentor, including one-on-one discipleship time built into the ministry's model, to isolate and abuse teenage members of the group he led.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thebanner.com/community/criminal-justice/kevin-guy-metro-maryland-youth-sex-abuse-KCZZQE6UE5AB7BB73E52HVQZ6Q/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Baltimore Banner, 'Former youth ministry director Kevin Guy pleads guilty to sex abuse' (Sept. 16, 2025).",
"body": "Reports the Sept. 16, 2025 guilty plea, the plea agreement's 35-years-with-28-suspended sentence recommendation, Dec. 17 sentencing date, and abuse details across 2021-2024.",
"tier": "regional-digital-newsroom",
"kind": "contemporaneous-reporting"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2025/09/former-baltimore-county-pastor-sentenced-for-abusing-boys-in-youth-group/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org, 'Former Baltimore County pastor sentenced for abusing boys in youth group' (Sept. 2025).",
"body": "Corroborates role, victim count, and church location (Bishop Cummins Reformed Episcopal Church, Catonsville).",
"tier": "clergy-abuse-database",
"kind": "case-summary-compilation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thebanner.com/community/criminal-justice/kevin-guy-metro-maryland-youth-sex-abuse-KCZZQE6UE5AB7BB73E52HVQZ6Q/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-digital-newsroom; evidentiary role: contemporaneous-reporting.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a4b768245132e6e598b53674f4344830409114c9098ac89b1829a218a6243308",
"final_url": "https://www.thebanner.com/community/criminal-justice/kevin-guy-metro-maryland-youth-sex-abuse-KCZZQE6UE5AB7BB73E52HVQZ6Q/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2025/09/former-baltimore-county-pastor-sentenced-for-abusing-boys-in-youth-group/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: clergy-abuse-database; evidentiary role: case-summary-compilation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f8c2890425bde1f64a1a37433bacbbc9ab4f529ee8b5238ef9e39a63d7d39ac7",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2025/09/former-baltimore-county-pastor-sentenced-for-abusing-boys-in-youth-group/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9001,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sourced from local Oregon TV/news coverage (KATU, KOIN, Patch, Valley Times) rather than a court-record repository; no appellate history located, and none expected given the guilty plea. Two named schools appear in reporting (Tigard business location; 'American Islamic Center for the Holy Qur'an'); both refer to the same religious-instruction operation.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-muhammad-laftah-hasan-tigard-oregon-usa",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Tigard, Oregon, USA",
"lat": 45.4312,
"lng": -122.7715,
"title": "Quran instructor Muhammad Laftah Hasan: guilty plea for sexually abusing two girl students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and instructor, American Islamic Center for the Holy Qur'an, Tigard, Oregon"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-instruction authority over young students in a private Quran class",
"one-on-one access to children built through the trust of religious teaching"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"American Islamic Center for the Holy Qur'an, Tigard, Oregon"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Washington County Circuit Court, Oregon",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2019-02-01",
"outcome": "Muhammad Laftah Hasan pleaded guilty to first-degree attempted sexual abuse and third-degree sexual abuse for abusing two girls who were students in his religious classes beginning in 2016, when both were under 14. He was sentenced to four years in prison, ten years' post-prison supervision, lifetime sex-offender registration, and over $5,000 in restitution, with no contact with minors other than his own daughter."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Hasan founded and ran the Quran-instruction center himself; the religious-teaching relationship with the two girls, built on his standing as their Quran instructor, was the access mechanism the investigation and reporting describe, not a role incidental to a secular institution.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://katu.com/news/local/quran-instructor-sentenced-to-four-years-in-prison-after-pleading-guilty-to-sexual-abuse",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KATU, 'Quran instructor sentenced to four years in prison after pleading guilty to sexual abuse' (2019).",
"body": "Reports Hasan's guilty plea to first-degree attempted sexual abuse and third-degree sexual abuse, the four-year sentence, ten years of post-prison supervision, lifetime sex-offender registration, and the restitution order.",
"tier": "local-news",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.koin.com/news/tigard-quran-instructor-indicted-for-sexually-abusing-girls/918050293/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KOIN 6, 'Tigard Quran instructor indicted for sexually abusing girls' (2017).",
"body": "Reports the initial indictment, describing Hasan as operator of the American Islamic Center for the Holy Qur'an in Tigard and the police investigation opened after a parent's report.",
"tier": "local-news",
"kind": "charging-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://katu.com/news/local/quran-instructor-sentenced-to-four-years-in-prison-after-pleading-guilty-to-sexual-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-news; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6a93caf1993d93df6178b403ea9531c0c038a52dfa900249ac146b1aa78756cd",
"final_url": "https://katu.com/news/local/quran-instructor-sentenced-to-four-years-in-prison-after-pleading-guilty-to-sexual-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://www.koin.com/news/tigard-quran-instructor-indicted-for-sexually-abusing-girls/918050293/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-news; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9003,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Keller had a prior, separate 1990s conviction in Israel for sexually abusing a child, disclosed here as context only; this record concerns solely the 2012 New York proceeding. Community-advocacy sources (Awareness Center, Jewish Community Watch commentary) are used alongside press reporting because Brooklyn Haredi-community abuse cases are frequently under-covered by mainstream outlets; both source types corroborate the same charges and sentence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-moshe-keller-crown-heights-brooklyn-new-york-usa",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Crown Heights, Brooklyn, New York, USA",
"lat": 40.6694,
"lng": -73.9422,
"title": "Chabad-Lubavitch rabbi Moshe Keller: guilty plea for endangering the welfare of a child after abusing a teenage boy",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Chabad-Lubavitch rabbi; ran an organization for at-risk Chabad youth in Crown Heights, Brooklyn"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rabbinic authority within the Chabad-Lubavitch community",
"trusted access to a vulnerable teenage boy through a youth-outreach role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Chabad-Lubavitch, Crown Heights, Brooklyn"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kings County Criminal Court, Brooklyn, New York",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2012-05-01",
"outcome": "Moshe Keller pleaded guilty to endangering the welfare of a child, arising from sexually assaulting a then-15-year-old boy in 2009, and was sentenced to three years' probation. Charges were brought in 2011 after a third accuser, Mordechai Feinstein, came forward; prior allegations dating back roughly two decades in Israel had not been disclosed to the New York community when Keller relocated."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Keller's standing as a Chabad rabbi running an outreach program for at-risk Chabad youth gave him the access and trust that placed the victim in his care; the abuse occurred within that religious-outreach relationship rather than a secular or family one.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/jewish-community-watch",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Rachel Silberstein, 'Watching the Jewish Community Watch and Its \"Wall of Shame\"', Tablet Magazine (2013).",
"body": "Discusses the Moshe Keller case as part of a wider account of the Jewish Community Watch's tracking of accused abusers in the Chabad-Lubavitch community, including the 2012 plea and sentence.",
"tier": "magazine-journalism",
"kind": "case-history"
},
{
"link": "https://www.mannywaks.com/blog/convicted-paedophile-moshe-keller-in-melbourne",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Manny Waks, 'Convicted paedophile Moshe Keller in Melbourne' (advocacy blog, n.d.).",
"body": "Survivor-advocate summary of Keller's conviction history, including the 2012 New York plea to endangering the welfare of a child and the earlier Israeli conviction, used here for corroboration of the New York disposition only.",
"tier": "survivor-advocacy",
"kind": "case-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/jewish-community-watch",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: magazine-journalism; evidentiary role: case-history.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.mannywaks.com/blog/convicted-paedophile-moshe-keller-in-melbourne",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: survivor-advocacy; evidentiary role: case-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "47bb78e9b5d36d9ab51dfda2ebde53ddbaf4b33b3f5e794fc974449780589385",
"final_url": "https://www.mannywaks.com/blog/convicted-paedophile-moshe-keller-in-melbourne"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9004,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Weiss avoided sex-offender registration as part of the plea agreement, which is stated here rather than omitted; this affects the visibility of the record, not the fact of conviction. Local Albany-area press (Times Union) is the sourcing tier; no appellate history located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-yaakov-weiss-colonie-albany-new-york-usa",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Colonie, New York, USA",
"lat": 42.7284,
"lng": -73.8298,
"title": "Rabbi Yaakov Weiss (Chabad of Colonie founder): guilty plea for endangering two boys, including contact in the synagogue's mikveh",
"tradition": "judaism",
"traditionDetailId": "judaism-hasidic-haredi",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and rabbi, Chabad of Colonie; founder, Chabad Hebrew School, Loudonville, New York"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rabbinic and Hebrew-school authority over congregation children",
"religious ritual setting (mikveh) used as the site of contact",
"instructing a victim to conceal the conduct from his mother and police"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Chabad of Colonie; Chabad Hebrew School, Loudonville, New York"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Albany County Court, New York",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2010-01-11",
"outcome": "Yaakov Weiss pleaded guilty to child endangerment for inappropriate physical contact with a 13-year-old boy at the synagogue's mikveh on Whitehall Road and a second 13-year-old boy later in 2007, including instructing one victim to deny the contact to police and his mother. The plea agreement did not require sex-offender registration."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Weiss founded and led both the Chabad of Colonie synagogue and its Hebrew school; the contact occurred through his rabbinic authority and in the synagogue's mikveh itself, placing the religious ritual setting and his clerical standing at the center of the access, not incidental to it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.clevelandjewishnews.com/news/local_news/rabbi-weiss-sentenced-to-six-months-in-prison/article_d80276f8-b6b0-11ed-b972-03fff2f6abcc.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cleveland Jewish News wire report, 'Rabbi Weiss sentenced to six months in prison' (2010).",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea to child endangerment, describes the mikveh location of one incident, and notes the instruction to one victim to conceal the conduct.",
"tier": "jewish-press-wire",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2010/01_02/2010_01_19_Gavin_GroupSays.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Robert Gavin, 'Group Says Rabbi No Longer Leader', Albany Times Union (19 Jan. 2010), archived via BishopAccountability.org.",
"body": "Reports Chabad's suspension of Weiss following the allegations and confirms his founding role at Chabad of Colonie and its Hebrew school.",
"tier": "local-news-archived",
"kind": "institutional-response-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.clevelandjewishnews.com/news/local_news/rabbi-weiss-sentenced-to-six-months-in-prison/article_d80276f8-b6b0-11ed-b972-03fff2f6abcc.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: jewish-press-wire; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "01646d04e0e1e2f94385bd091ed3d7cb45e9e4fb2a11ca6b33e296ed43233df4",
"final_url": "https://www.clevelandjewishnews.com/news/local_news/rabbi-weiss-sentenced-to-six-months-in-prison/article_d80276f8-b6b0-11ed-b972-03fff2f6abcc.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2010/01_02/2010_01_19_Gavin_GroupSays.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-news-archived; evidentiary role: institutional-response-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "83402ae2fb350d66bdd297f6992da1a32c8313cdc89269327adf2cb7baef01c9",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2010/01_02/2010_01_19_Gavin_GroupSays.htm"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9005,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Edwards was not serving as bishop at the time of the earlier (2006) incident but was bishop at the time of the 2012 incident for which he was convicted; both victims attended his congregation. 2024 civil lawsuits against the LDS Church over its response are noted as context, not adjudicated findings.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-todd-michael-edwards-menifee-california-usa",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Menifee, California, USA",
"lat": 33.6971,
"lng": -117.1859,
"title": "LDS bishop Todd Michael Edwards: guilty plea for molesting teenage girls in his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-latter-day-saint",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"bishop, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Menifee, California ward"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"bishop's pastoral and disciplinary authority over ward members",
"one-on-one pastoral-counseling access to teenage congregants"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Menifee, California ward"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Riverside County Superior Court, California",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2013-12-12",
"outcome": "Todd Michael Edwards was convicted via guilty plea to two felony counts of sexual battery and sexual penetration with a foreign object, for abusing two teenage girls in his congregation in 2006 and 2012. He was sentenced to two concurrent three-year prison terms and, at sentencing, classified by the court as a violent sexual predator."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Edwards held his victims' trust as their LDS bishop, the pastoral office responsible for spiritual counseling and discipline within the ward; his access to the second victim in particular arose from that office, held at the time of the offense.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2013/11_12/2013_12_12_Asbury_MormonBishop.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "John Asbury, 'Mormon Bishop Sentenced to Three Years for Sex Abuse', The Press-Enterprise (12 Dec. 2013), archived via bishop-accountability.org.",
"body": "Reports the guilty plea, the two concurrent three-year sentences, and the classification of Edwards as a violent sexual predator at sentencing.",
"tier": "local-news-archived",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://floodlit.org/a/a106/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FLOODLIT, 'Todd Mitchell Edwards Mormon sex abuse case' (database entry).",
"body": "Case-tracking entry corroborating Edwards's bishop role, the 2006 and 2012 offense dates, and the 2013 conviction and sentence.",
"tier": "advocacy-database",
"kind": "case-summary"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2013/11_12/2013_12_12_Asbury_MormonBishop.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-news-archived; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "af951b6992d6ff4143a2b42a6cd4155fa8c1576b9a40b6db4d7b4702249b2626",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2013/11_12/2013_12_12_Asbury_MormonBishop.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://floodlit.org/a/a106/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-database; evidentiary role: case-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a3bf37c40697d2c766455dd163f6e1c5cda5c6c3f2f86d01cc3aee613fc16107",
"final_url": "https://floodlit.org/a/a106/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9006,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"court": "Maine Supreme Judicial Court",
"date": "2025-08-19",
"outcome": "Vacated the separate unlawful-sexual-contact conviction on statute-of-limitations grounds; affirmed the gross-sexual-assault conviction; remanded for resentencing on the surviving count."
}
],
"scopeNote": "IMPORTANT — partial appellate reversal, not a clean conviction. Fyans was originally convicted on two counts (gross sexual assault, Class A; unlawful sexual contact, Class B) and sentenced to concurrent 20-year and 5-year terms. On 19 August 2025 the Maine Supreme Judicial Court (State v. Fyans, 2025 ME 78) vacated the unlawful-sexual-contact conviction because the statute of limitations in force in 1990-1992 should have barred it, while affirming the gross-sexual-assault conviction. Resentencing on the surviving count was pending as of the last source reviewed. This record is carried as convicted because the gross-sexual-assault conviction stands; the vacated count is stated for transparency, not concealed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-ernest-fyans-fort-kent-maine-usa",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Fort Kent, Maine, USA",
"lat": 47.2534,
"lng": -68.5905,
"title": "Jehovah's Witness elder Ernest Fyans: gross-sexual-assault conviction for abusing two Kingdom Hall children, affirmed on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder, Fort Kent Kingdom Hall, Jehovah's Witnesses"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"congregational elder authority over families within the Kingdom Hall",
"access to children of congregation members through that eldership standing"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Fort Kent Kingdom Hall, Jehovah's Witnesses"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Aroostook County Superior Court, Maine",
"stage": "jury verdict",
"date": "2023-09-01",
"outcome": "A jury found Ernest Fyans guilty of gross sexual assault (Class A) and unlawful sexual contact (Class B), arising from the sexual abuse of two children under 12 between 1990 and 1992 whose parents belonged to the Fort Kent Kingdom Hall."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Aroostook County Superior Court, Maine",
"stage": "sentence",
"date": "2024-02-01",
"outcome": "Fyans was sentenced to 20 years for gross sexual assault and a concurrent 5 years for unlawful sexual contact."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Maine Supreme Judicial Court",
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2025-08-19",
"outcome": "The court vacated the unlawful-sexual-contact conviction on statute-of-limitations grounds but affirmed the gross-sexual-assault conviction, remanding for resentencing on the surviving count."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Fyans's standing as a Kingdom Hall elder gave him standing within the families of the congregation; the victims were the children of fellow Jehovah's Witness parents at the same Kingdom Hall, and that congregational relationship is the access the prosecution's evidence and reporting describe.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/maine/supreme-court/2025/2025-me-78.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "State v. Fyans, 2025 ME 78, Maine Supreme Judicial Court (19 Aug. 2025).",
"body": "Appellate opinion affirming the gross-sexual-assault conviction, vacating the unlawful-sexual-contact conviction on statute-of-limitations grounds, and remanding for resentencing.",
"tier": "court-record",
"kind": "appellate-opinion"
},
{
"link": "https://thecounty.me/2023/10/02/news/former-jehovahs-witness-elder-found-guilty-of-sexually-assaulting-minors/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The County, 'Former Jehovah's Witness elder found guilty of sexually assaulting minors' (2 Oct. 2023).",
"body": "Reports the September 2023 jury verdict, describing Fyans as a Fort Kent Kingdom Hall elder and the victims as children of congregation members between 1990 and 1992.",
"tier": "local-news",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"court": "Maine Supreme Judicial Court",
"date": "2025-08-19",
"outcome": "Vacated the separate unlawful-sexual-contact conviction on statute-of-limitations grounds; affirmed the gross-sexual-assault conviction; remanded for resentencing on the surviving count."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/maine/supreme-court/2025/2025-me-78.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-record; evidentiary role: appellate-opinion.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://thecounty.me/2023/10/02/news/former-jehovahs-witness-elder-found-guilty-of-sexually-assaulting-minors/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-news; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a9d275da374af02235f266504a28509c656f059ee73bbf7230bec80297a31d9b",
"final_url": "https://thecounty.me/2023/10/02/news/former-jehovahs-witness-elder-found-guilty-of-sexually-assaulting-minors/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9007,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Part of Pennsylvania's 49th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury into Jehovah's Witnesses congregations, the same investigation that produced the corpus's existing Balosa and Aviles-Garriga records; this is a separate defendant and congregation. No appellate history located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-shaun-sheffer-zelienople-butler-county-pennsylvania-usa",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Butler County, Pennsylvania, USA",
"lat": 40.8612,
"lng": -79.8953,
"title": "Jehovah's Witness congregation member Shaun Sheffer: convicted of raping a child of a fellow congregant family over five years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"member, Zelienople congregation, Jehovah's Witnesses"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing as a trusted fellow congregant used to gain access to a child in the congregation",
"sustained access over years through the family's trust in his congregational status"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Zelienople congregation, Jehovah's Witnesses, Butler County, Pennsylvania"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Butler County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania",
"stage": "jury verdict and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-01",
"outcome": "A Butler County jury convicted Shaun Sheffer of three counts of rape, three counts of indecent assault, and one count of corruption of minors, for assaulting a child of a fellow congregation family between 1995 and 2000, beginning when the victim was seven years old. He was sentenced to 14 to 34 years in prison. The case arose from Pennsylvania's 49th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury into Jehovah's Witnesses congregations."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sheffer's access to the victim ran through his standing as a trusted member of the same Jehovah's Witness congregation as the victim's family; the grand jury's investigation frames the sustained access as a product of that congregational trust, consistent with the pattern in the corpus's other Pennsylvania Jehovah's Witness records.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/case-update-former-butler-county-jehovahs-witnesses-member-sentenced-up-to-34-years-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-young-child/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Pennsylvania Office of the Attorney General, 'Case Update: Former Butler County Jehovah's Witnesses Member Sentenced up to 34 Years in Prison for Sexually Assaulting Young Child' (2024).",
"body": "Official prosecuting-authority press release confirming the jury convictions on rape, indecent assault, and corruption-of-minors counts, the 14-to-34-year sentence, and the case's origin in the 49th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury into Jehovah's Witnesses congregations.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/news/butler-county-jehovah-witness-sexual-assault-conviction/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS News Pittsburgh, 'Former Butler County Jehovah's Witness member found guilty of sexually assaulting a child' (2024).",
"body": "Reports the jury verdict, identifies the Zelienople congregation, and describes the victim as a child of the congregation family Sheffer was close to.",
"tier": "local-news",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/case-update-former-butler-county-jehovahs-witnesses-member-sentenced-up-to-34-years-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-young-child/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9c010d1ba6641e14918c4c26cd3db728b83c12294ce83449c3f47e8e99e2768f",
"final_url": "https://www.attorneygeneral.gov/taking-action/case-update-former-butler-county-jehovahs-witnesses-member-sentenced-up-to-34-years-in-prison-for-sexually-assaulting-young-child/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/news/butler-county-jehovah-witness-sexual-assault-conviction/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-news; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7f324f8392bfb268a0bf21592629f38db357592cf3dfca7d41fdebbff8123f29",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/news/butler-county-jehovah-witness-sexual-assault-conviction/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1124,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Eddie was the longtime children's and administration pastor at Highland Park Baptist, arrested after church-owned-computer child pornography surfaced; during questioning he said he had abused so many children in his ministry he could not remember the number. Prosecutors offered a plea deal specifically to spare the identified victims from testifying, with every victim family's agreement.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jeffrey-dale-eddie-muscle-shoals-alabama-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Muscle Shoals, Alabama, USA",
"lat": 34.7448,
"lng": -87.6675,
"title": "United States: Alabama children's pastor sentenced for sodomizing boys in his ministry",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"associate pastor for children and church administration",
"children's ministry leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"26-year tenure and standing on church staff",
"unsupervised access to children through the children's ministry",
"plea bargain shaped around sparing child victims from testifying"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Highland Park Baptist Church, Muscle Shoals"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Circuit Court, Colbert County, Alabama",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-03-07",
"outcome": "Eddie pleaded guilty to 16 counts of sodomy, three counts of sexual abuse of a child under 12, and one count of possession of child pornography; sentenced to 30 years in prison."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Eddie spent 16 years on staff at Highland Park Baptist Church, most of it as the pastor with direct authority over the children's ministry, which gave him sanctioned, unsupervised access to the congregation's children over the same period he was abusing them.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/childrens-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Baptist Press, \"Children's pastor pleads guilty to sexual abuse\" (Mar. 2026).",
"body": "Denominational press report confirming Eddie's guilty pleas to 16 counts of sodomy, three counts of child sexual abuse and one count of child pornography, his 16-year tenure at Highland Park, and the 30-year sentence.",
"tier": "denominational-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://baptistnews.com/article/minister-sentenced-for-child-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Baptist News Global, \"Minister sentenced for child sex abuse.\"",
"body": "Coverage of Eddie's sentencing, his role as associate pastor for children and administration, and the plea arrangement negotiated with victim families to avoid trial testimony.",
"tier": "denominational-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.waff.com/story/24915091/former-childrens-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sex-charges/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WAFF, \"Former children's pastor pleads guilty to sex charges.\"",
"body": "Local Alabama television report on the plea and sentence, and Eddie's statement during initial police questioning about the scope of the abuse within his children's ministry.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/childrens-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: denominational-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fe199ff72ca1cb718ba2c237207c5841f1c38b9358abcf6fc8c1fb59a6e24220",
"final_url": "https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/childrens-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://baptistnews.com/article/minister-sentenced-for-child-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: denominational-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "061345f7aa766b0cb98b71337dee7f10f927f2b68b43480514a3e629f51b91c9",
"final_url": "https://baptistnews.com/article/minister-sentenced-for-child-sex-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.waff.com/story/24915091/former-childrens-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sex-charges/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b312e9a248846c83fe9f38c26b4c95773f39d43f66290f576fdc07c772f3aa7d",
"final_url": "https://www.waff.com/story/24915091/former-childrens-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sex-charges/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1125,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Turner invited a middle-school-aged boy to join a church youth group he ran; within months he began sexually abusing the child, generating nearly 12,700 text messages including sexually explicit content he solicited from the victim. The youth group itself was the access mechanism, not a secular or coaching relationship, so this clears the custodial-vs-religious line.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-marcus-turner-cobb-county-georgia-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Cobb County, Georgia, USA",
"lat": 33.9526,
"lng": -84.5499,
"title": "United States: Cobb County church leader sentenced to 25 years for grooming a teen through a new youth group",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"leadership role, Worship With Wonders Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"invitation into a newly formed church youth group as the access point",
"sustained one-on-one contact normalized through the youth-group role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Worship With Wonders Church, Cobb County"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Superior Court, Cherokee County, Georgia (Blue Ridge Judicial Circuit)",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-09",
"outcome": "Turner pleaded guilty to 11 counts including two counts of aggravated child molestation, two counts of child molestation, enticing a child, obscene internet contact with a child, four counts of sexual exploitation of children, and cruelty to children; sentenced to 25 years without parole plus lifetime probation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Turner used a leadership position at Worship With Wonders Church to found a new youth group, recruited the victim into it, and used the trust and access that role generated to groom and abuse him over several months.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.11alive.com/article/news/crime/da-former-church-director-sentenced-to-25-years-after-pleading-guilty-to-sex-crimes-involving-teen-boy/85-19d6f113-7f51-4afa-9c58-93028e276eee",
"archive": "",
"citation": "11Alive (WXIA), \"DA: Former Cobb Co. church director sentenced to 25 years after pleading guilty to sex crimes involving teen boy\" (Feb. 2026).",
"body": "District attorney's office statement, reported by 11Alive, confirming Turner's guilty plea to all 11 counts, the 25-year sentence without parole, and the youth-group grooming method.",
"tier": "local-television-da-statement",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cherokeecountyga.gov/District-Attorneys-Office/_resources/Press-Releases/2026-Pres-Releases/022026-Marcus-Turner-guilty-plea.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cherokee County District Attorney's Office, press release on Marcus Turner guilty plea (Feb. 2026).",
"body": "Official prosecutorial press release detailing the counts of conviction, sentence and case background.",
"tier": "official-prosecutorial-record",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fox5atlanta.com/news/i-trusted-pastors-mother-victim-speaks-out-after-church-leader-sentenced",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FOX 5 Atlanta, \"'I trusted the pastors': Mother of victim speaks out after church leader sentenced.\"",
"body": "Victim's family interview corroborating the church-youth-group access mechanism and the sentence imposed.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.11alive.com/article/news/crime/da-former-church-director-sentenced-to-25-years-after-pleading-guilty-to-sex-crimes-involving-teen-boy/85-19d6f113-7f51-4afa-9c58-93028e276eee",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-da-statement; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cherokeecountyga.gov/District-Attorneys-Office/_resources/Press-Releases/2026-Pres-Releases/022026-Marcus-Turner-guilty-plea.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutorial-record; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "72b9bd5008986b214e4cd889b277c093c70755c6a23f5540017676332fcbeb87",
"final_url": "https://www.cherokeecountyga.gov/District-Attorneys-Office/_resources/Press-Releases/2026-Pres-Releases/022026-Marcus-Turner-guilty-plea.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fox5atlanta.com/news/i-trusted-pastors-mother-victim-speaks-out-after-church-leader-sentenced",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b6a74c36a828df41583bb95f03ebf8fdded823322bb04b9bf69a25f0cd0a68ed",
"final_url": "https://www.fox5atlanta.com/news/i-trusted-pastors-mother-victim-speaks-out-after-church-leader-sentenced"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1126,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Shelton knew the victim and her family through their shared church and his own son before he became a pastor there in 2020; the abuse itself ran 2019-2020, meaning the church relationship — not a secular one — was the access channel the sentencing coverage explicitly framed as 'trust becomes access.'",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-silas-shelton-blanchester-ohio-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Blanchester, Clinton County, Ohio, USA",
"lat": 39.2925,
"lng": -83.9874,
"title": "United States: Ohio pastor sentenced after 'trust becomes access' abuse of a teenager he knew through his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Blanchester Community Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"family's pre-existing church relationship as the point of trust",
"nearly 30-year age gap exploited through a role later formalized as pastor"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Blanchester Community Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Common Pleas Court, Clinton County, Ohio",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-22",
"outcome": "Shelton pleaded guilty to three third-degree-felony counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor and one misdemeanor count of menacing by stalking; sentenced to three consecutive five-year terms (15 years total) plus a concurrent six-month jail term."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim and her family knew Shelton through Blanchester Community Church before he became its pastor in 2020; the church relationship was the trust channel the prosecution and coverage identified as what let a nearly-29-years-older man gain sustained access to a 14-year-old congregant's family.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.wnewsj.com/2026/06/22/trust-becomes-access-former-blanchester-pastor-gets-15-years-for-abusing-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wilmington News Journal, \"'Trust becomes access': Former Blanchester pastor gets 15 years for abusing minor\" (June 22, 2026).",
"body": "Sentencing report explicitly framing the case as trust-into-access via the church relationship, confirming the plea, counts and 15-year sentence.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wnewsj.com/2026/04/20/former-blanchester-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-conduct-with-a-minor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Wilmington News Journal, \"Former Blanchester pastor pleads guilty to sexual conduct with a minor\" (Apr. 20, 2026).",
"body": "Report on the guilty plea itself, with details on the church-family relationship pre-dating Shelton's formal pastorate.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.fox19.com/2026/04/21/ohio-pastor-pleads-guilty-child-sex-crimes-court-documents-say/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "FOX19 (WXIX), \"Ohio pastor pleads guilty to child sex crimes, court documents say.\"",
"body": "Regional television corroboration of the plea and case background drawn from court documents.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.wnewsj.com/2026/06/22/trust-becomes-access-former-blanchester-pastor-gets-15-years-for-abusing-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "74b47490d3ca80f7353c35feb3667f3065ed41277c306533128a6eb92b848741",
"final_url": "https://www.wnewsj.com/2026/06/22/trust-becomes-access-former-blanchester-pastor-gets-15-years-for-abusing-minor/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wnewsj.com/2026/04/20/former-blanchester-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-conduct-with-a-minor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ae7a4d70b339a694dda25158c0e3a2f29b1bdb9696d24276509d2dcae34f2be0",
"final_url": "https://www.wnewsj.com/2026/04/20/former-blanchester-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexual-conduct-with-a-minor/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fox19.com/2026/04/21/ohio-pastor-pleads-guilty-child-sex-crimes-court-documents-say/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "724ec034236ae6036557954ca3115599b104d881684a38bb438e18fd48081641",
"final_url": "https://www.fox19.com/2026/04/21/ohio-pastor-pleads-guilty-child-sex-crimes-court-documents-say/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1127,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Cunningham served as the student (youth) pastor at Turning Point Community Church from 2016 to 2020, a clerical role rather than a secular coaching or counseling position, and used that ministry access to assault a child he knew through the church in 2018.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-luke-cunningham-lubbock-texas-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Lubbock, Texas, USA",
"lat": 33.5779,
"lng": -101.8552,
"title": "United States: former Lubbock student pastor sentenced to 40 years for assaulting a child at his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"student pastor, Turning Point Community Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"youth-ministry role providing sanctioned unsupervised contact"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Turning Point Community Church, Lubbock"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "140th District Court, Lubbock County, Texas",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-03-30",
"outcome": "Cunningham pleaded guilty to two counts of sexual assault of a child (two of 16 original counts, the remainder dismissed under the plea); sentenced to 40 years on each count, with a lifetime protective order and lifetime sex-offender registration."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cunningham was the student pastor at Turning Point Community Church for four years, the ministry role that gave him access to the child he assaulted in 2018 while serving in that clerical capacity.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kcbd.com/2026/03/30/former-lubbock-youth-pastor-sentenced-40-years-child-sexual-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KCBD, \"Former Lubbock youth pastor sentenced to 40 years for child sexual assault\" (Mar. 30, 2026).",
"body": "Court report confirming the guilty plea to two counts of sexual assault of a child, the 40-year sentence, and Cunningham's role as student pastor at Turning Point Community Church.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kxan.com/news/ex-lubbock-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-40-years-in-prison-for-child-sex-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KXAN, \"Ex-Lubbock youth pastor sentenced to 40 years in prison for child sex assault.\"",
"body": "Regional corroboration of sentencing details, the dismissed counts, and lifetime registration and protective-order terms.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/03/former-lubbock-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-40-years-for-child-sexual-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org archive of Lubbock youth-pastor sentencing coverage (Mar. 2026).",
"body": "Archived aggregation of local reporting preserving case details and church affiliation.",
"tier": "watchdog-archive",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kcbd.com/2026/03/30/former-lubbock-youth-pastor-sentenced-40-years-child-sexual-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1c3d4a9db219ca68a8ca91c1a180962c1fcbc6ef9ff6f6adbaf5a98cde6cc0ec",
"final_url": "https://www.kcbd.com/2026/03/30/former-lubbock-youth-pastor-sentenced-40-years-child-sexual-assault/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kxan.com/news/ex-lubbock-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-40-years-in-prison-for-child-sex-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/03/former-lubbock-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-40-years-for-child-sexual-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: watchdog-archive; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "132afc6798a00ba0f4a72e92345cc97009f62e55d30ef116570e9ba2e6ed982a",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/03/former-lubbock-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-40-years-for-child-sexual-assault/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1128,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Allen was alone with a 24-year-old congregant specifically for spiritual counseling on her personal issues when he reached under her skirt and touched her; the setting itself (private pastoral counseling on spiritual matters) is the access mechanism, distinguishing this from a stranger or purely social assault.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-jason-lee-allen-flatwoods-west-virginia-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Flatwoods, Braxton County, West Virginia, USA",
"lat": 38.6779,
"lng": -80.639,
"title": "United States: West Virginia pastor found guilty of sexually-motivated battery against a congregant during spiritual counseling",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Victory Apostolic Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"one-on-one spiritual counseling session used to isolate the victim"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Victory Apostolic Church, Flatwoods"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Braxton County Magistrate Court, West Virginia",
"stage": "bench-trial guilty verdict; sentencing scheduled",
"date": "2026-05-08",
"outcome": "Found guilty after a two-day bench trial of sexually-motivated misdemeanor battery; sentencing set for May 27, 2026, with a maximum of one year in jail and a mandatory 10-year sex-offender registration due to the sexually-motivated finding."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Allen, pastor of Victory Apostolic Church, was alone with the victim specifically because she had come to him for spiritual counseling on personal matters; that pastoral-counseling context is what put them alone together and is the mechanism the prosecution built the sexually-motivated finding on.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://wvmetronews.com/2026/05/08/braxton-county-pastor-convicted-of-sexually-motivated-battery/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WV MetroNews, \"Braxton County pastor convicted of sexually motivated battery\" (May 8, 2026).",
"body": "Court report confirming the bench-trial guilty verdict, the spiritual-counseling context of the assault, and the sex-offender registration consequence.",
"tier": "state-newswire-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.kbtx.com/2026/05/13/pastor-found-guilty-after-reaching-up-skirt-church-member-seeking-spiritual-counseling/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KBTX, \"Pastor found guilty after reaching up skirt of church member seeking spiritual counseling\" (May 13, 2026).",
"body": "Wire-syndicated report naming the spiritual-counseling setting explicitly as the access context for the assault.",
"tier": "wire-service-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://wchstv.com/news/local/braxton-county-pastor-found-guilty-of-sexually-motivated-battery-prosecutors-say",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WCHS-TV, \"Braxton County pastor found guilty of 'sexually motivated' battery, prosecutors say.\"",
"body": "Local television corroboration of the guilty verdict and sentencing date.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://wvmetronews.com/2026/05/08/braxton-county-pastor-convicted-of-sexually-motivated-battery/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newswire-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c11aeeca5711ff349282889d923969ebc849074354c606a9cae2cec6c0b8b4c0",
"final_url": "https://wvmetronews.com/2026/05/08/braxton-county-pastor-convicted-of-sexually-motivated-battery/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.kbtx.com/2026/05/13/pastor-found-guilty-after-reaching-up-skirt-church-member-seeking-spiritual-counseling/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: wire-service-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f8863fb8552dd673f912407b73aaad6ef345d79b17f27b39928092232ad13609",
"final_url": "https://www.kbtx.com/2026/05/13/pastor-found-guilty-after-reaching-up-skirt-church-member-seeking-spiritual-counseling/"
},
{
"source": "https://wchstv.com/news/local/braxton-county-pastor-found-guilty-of-sexually-motivated-battery-prosecutors-say",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "18450ce5b98ab5738bd8cd64602b5d4fb1a3d8095b7b967ebcb6e4ad1b931e33",
"final_url": "https://wchstv.com/news/local/braxton-county-pastor-found-guilty-of-sexually-motivated-battery-prosecutors-say"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1129,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The victims were two sisters, aged 12 and 13 at the time, whose family attended the Livingston Church of God where Passmore was pastor; the church membership is what put him in their lives, not a family or custodial relationship — clearing the paternal-nexus line.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-terence-passmore-livingston-montana-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Livingston, Park County, Montana, USA",
"lat": 45.6621,
"lng": -110.5606,
"title": "United States: former Montana pastor sentenced to 30 years for raping two sisters from his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Livingston Church of God"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"family's church membership as the access relationship"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Livingston Church of God"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court, Park County, Montana",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-06",
"outcome": "Convicted of four felony sex crimes (one count of rape, three counts of sexual assault); sentenced to 34 years with five suspended for rape and 10 years with five suspended for each sexual-assault count, running concurrently, for an effective 30-year term."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Passmore was pastor of the Livingston Church of God, the congregation the victims' family attended; that church relationship was the access point for the abuse of the two sisters, then 12 and 13.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/montana/ex-pastor-gets-30-years-for-sex-crimes/article_a7e83c13-2b27-5240-9fbf-912344e5c7b8.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Billings Gazette, \"Ex-pastor gets 30 years for sex crimes.\"",
"body": "Court report naming Terence Passmore, confirming the four-count conviction, the 30-year effective sentence, and that the family attended the Livingston Church of God where he was pastor.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/montana/former-livingston-minister-accused-of-molestation-faces-criminal-charges/article_8a6cef37-6603-5cde-95bd-56fbff6641c2.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Billings Gazette, \"Former Livingston minister accused of molestation faces criminal charges.\"",
"body": "Earlier charging-stage report corroborating Passmore's identity and church role.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/montana/ex-pastor-gets-30-years-for-sex-crimes/article_a7e83c13-2b27-5240-9fbf-912344e5c7b8.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/montana/former-livingston-minister-accused-of-molestation-faces-criminal-charges/article_8a6cef37-6603-5cde-95bd-56fbff6641c2.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1130,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Lucero is consistently described in court and press reporting as a youth/young-adult pastor who oversaw the church's own youth group (ages 13-18) — a clerical, not a secular custodial or coaching, role — and used that oversight to groom and assault a congregant beginning when she was 15. His parents are the church's senior pastors, but the charge was framed around his own pastoral position of trust, not a family relationship to the victim.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-joshua-lucero-thornton-colorado-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Thornton, Colorado, USA",
"lat": 39.8681,
"lng": -104.9719,
"title": "United States: Colorado youth pastor convicted of assaulting a teen he oversaw in his church's youth ministry",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor, Word Alive Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"role overseeing juveniles aged 13-18 within the church's youth ministry",
"family standing as children of the church's senior pastors"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Word Alive Church, Thornton"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "17th Judicial District Court, Adams County, Colorado",
"stage": "jury conviction; sentencing pending",
"date": "2026-05-29",
"outcome": "Convicted by jury of one count of sexual assault on a child by one in a position of trust; faces a sentence of eight years to life."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Lucero was employed as a pastor at Word Alive Church and oversaw the congregation's youth group, ages 13 to 18; that pastoral oversight role — not merely being the senior pastors' son — is what the position-of-trust charge and conviction rest on.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://roysreport.com/former-colorado-youth-pastor-convicted-of-child-sexual-assault-faces-8-years-to-life/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Roys Report, \"Former Colorado youth pastor convicted of child sexual assault, faces 8 years to life.\"",
"body": "Report on the jury verdict, confirming Lucero's role overseeing the church's 13-18 youth ministry and the position-of-trust statute used to convict him.",
"tier": "religion-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.joemygod.com/2026/06/colorado-youth-pastor-convicted-of-child-sex-assault/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Joe.My.God., \"Colorado Youth Pastor Convicted Of Child Sex Assault\" (June 2026).",
"body": "Aggregated corroboration of the conviction, sentencing exposure, and the timeline of the abuse from 2018 to 2021.",
"tier": "news-aggregator",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://kdvr.com/news/local/youth-pastor-arrested-by-thornton-police-facing-charge-of-sexual-assault-on-a-child/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KDVR, \"Youth pastor arrested by Thornton police, facing charge of sexual assault on a child.\"",
"body": "Initial arrest report from Thornton Police Department confirming Lucero's employment as a pastor at Word Alive Church and his oversight role over the church youth group.",
"tier": "local-television-police-statement",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://roysreport.com/former-colorado-youth-pastor-convicted-of-child-sexual-assault-faces-8-years-to-life/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religion-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2c824549c16ca65cac87411830f0b2f5009cf603a64b497d02e15cc7aed3d1d0",
"final_url": "https://roysreport.com/former-colorado-youth-pastor-convicted-of-child-sexual-assault-faces-8-years-to-life/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.joemygod.com/2026/06/colorado-youth-pastor-convicted-of-child-sex-assault/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: news-aggregator; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1ada76338654c7dd7ea2fd92a829b09c40d29beb535857400bd7ff562318a5a1",
"final_url": "https://www.joemygod.com/2026/06/colorado-youth-pastor-convicted-of-child-sex-assault/"
},
{
"source": "https://kdvr.com/news/local/youth-pastor-arrested-by-thornton-police-facing-charge-of-sexual-assault-on-a-child/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-police-statement; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1131,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Camardo was executive pastor at The Chapel from 2012 and also coached girls' travel soccer; the church role is entered here as the qualifying nexus given his 14-year clerical standing and the church community as the shared context for both victims, while the soccer-coaching role is noted as an additional, non-qualifying access channel rather than the basis for inclusion.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-john-camardo-williamsville-new-york-usa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Williamsville, New York, USA",
"lat": 42.9645,
"lng": -78.7395,
"title": "United States: former executive pastor pleads guilty to raping two children he met through his church",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"executive pastor, The Chapel"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"14-year standing as executive pastor across a multi-campus church"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"The Chapel (Cheektowaga, Getzville, Lockport, Niagara Falls campuses)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Erie County Court, New York",
"stage": "guilty plea; sentencing scheduled",
"date": "2026-07-13",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty to one count of second-degree rape and one count of second-degree course of sexual conduct against a child, involving two victims under 15 and under 13; sentencing scheduled for September 10, 2026, with an expected six-to-eight-year determinate term."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Camardo served as executive pastor at The Chapel, a multi-campus church, for 14 years before his arrest; that clerical standing is the authority context reporting places him in relative to both child victims.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/buffalo/news/2026/07/13/the-chapel-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-abusing-children",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Spectrum News 1 Buffalo, \"Williamsville pastor pleads guilty to sexually abusing children\" (July 13, 2026).",
"body": "Court report confirming the guilty plea, both counts, the two-victim age ranges, and Camardo's 14-year tenure as The Chapel's executive pastor.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wkbw.com/news/local-news/williamsville-man-pleads-guilty-to-child-sexual-abuse-charges",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WKBW, \"Former executive pastor at The Chapel pleads guilty to child sexual abuse charges.\"",
"body": "Corroborating local report confirming the plea and Camardo's church role.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.wivb.com/news/crime/williamsville-man-admits-to-child-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "News 4 Buffalo (WIVB), \"Former pastor, soccer coach admits to child sexual abuse.\"",
"body": "Additional corroboration noting both the pastoral role and the soccer-coaching role, and the scheduled September 2026 sentencing.",
"tier": "local-television-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/buffalo/news/2026/07/13/the-chapel-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-abusing-children",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c394e1fa4d16a5617a46c5d3a372a1766cb3a7f9279b828519efbda99911a429",
"final_url": "https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/buffalo/news/2026/07/13/the-chapel-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-abusing-children"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wkbw.com/news/local-news/williamsville-man-pleads-guilty-to-child-sexual-abuse-charges",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f6e71fdf345a6223593f6cc976b1596b0daf58e730b18d3d7c90399b83f3b914",
"final_url": "https://www.wkbw.com/news/local-news/williamsville-man-pleads-guilty-to-child-sexual-abuse-charges"
},
{
"source": "https://www.wivb.com/news/crime/williamsville-man-admits-to-child-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-television-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1132,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Gallant abused an altar boy at St. Margaret's Parish in the late 1980s; the altar-server role is the classic sanctioned-proximity mechanism inside a Catholic parish and is squarely within the criterion.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-brendon-gallant-charlottetown-pei-canada",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, Canada",
"lat": 46.2382,
"lng": -63.1311,
"title": "Canada: retired Catholic priest sentenced for sexually abusing an altar boy in 1980s Prince Edward Island",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, St. Margaret's Parish"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"altar-server role providing sanctioned proximity to the priest"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Margaret's Parish, Prince Edward Island",
"Roman Catholic Diocese of Charlottetown"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Provincial Court, Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-04-07",
"outcome": "Gallant, who pleaded guilty in 2025 to a charge of sexual assault, was sentenced by Judge Nancy Orr to five years in a federal prison on a joint recommendation from the Crown and defence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Gallant was a Catholic priest at St. Margaret's Parish, and his victim served as an altar boy under him — a role that placed the child in close, church-sanctioned proximity to the priest and was the access mechanism for the 1980s abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/prince-edward-island/pei-retired-catholic-priest-sentenced-5-years-sexual-abuse-9.7154933",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, \"Retired Catholic priest in P.E.I. sentenced to 5 years in prison for 1980s child sexual abuse\" (Apr. 7, 2026).",
"body": "Court report confirming the 2025 guilty plea, the joint sentencing recommendation, the five-year sentence, and the altar-boy relationship at St. Margaret's Parish.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/04/retired-catholic-priest-in-p-e-i-sentenced-to-five-years-in-prison-for-1980s-child-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org, \"Retired Catholic priest in P.E.I. sentenced to five years in prison for 1980s child sexual abuse.\"",
"body": "Watchdog archive corroborating the sentencing and parish details.",
"tier": "watchdog-archive",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/prince-edward-island/pei-retired-priest-scheduled-sentencing-9.7138820",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, \"Retired P.E.I. Catholic priest again scheduled to be sentenced for 1980s sexual abuse.\"",
"body": "Earlier CBC report on the pending sentencing, confirming the guilty plea and altar-boy nexus.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/prince-edward-island/pei-retired-catholic-priest-sentenced-5-years-sexual-abuse-9.7154933",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2026/04/retired-catholic-priest-in-p-e-i-sentenced-to-five-years-in-prison-for-1980s-child-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: watchdog-archive; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/prince-edward-island/pei-retired-priest-scheduled-sentencing-9.7138820",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1133,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Jones was a trusted church volunteer whose access to the 10- and 11-year-old victim came entirely through her attendance at church-run after-school events, choir, band and kids' clubs; the church covered up the offending at the time rather than reporting it to police, an institutional-obedience aggravator distinct from and additional to the direct abuse.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-richard-jones-sutherland-shire-nsw-australia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Sutherland Shire, New South Wales, Australia",
"lat": -34.0333,
"lng": 151.0667,
"title": "Australia: 88-year-old church volunteer jailed decades later for abusing a girl at a Sydney congregation his own pastor covered up",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"volunteer, Christian Growth Centre (now Horizon Church)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"trusted-adult access through after-school church events, choir, band and kids' club",
"the church's own pastor declining to report the abuse to police at the time"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian Growth Centre / Horizon Church, Sutherland Shire"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court of New South Wales",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"outcome": "Jones pleaded guilty to two counts of indecent assault of a child under 16; sentenced to 16 months' imprisonment with parole eligibility after eight months. (Reported June 2026; exact plea/sentencing date not stated in available coverage.)"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Jones volunteered at the Christian Growth Centre (predecessor to Horizon Church) in Sydney's Sutherland Shire in the late 1980s and early 1990s, gaining access to his victim entirely through her participation in the church's after-school programs, choir, band and kids' clubs; the church's pastor did not report the abuse to police when it came to light at the time.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mychristiandaily.com/former-australian-youth-leader-jailed-for-sexually-assaulting-teen/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "My Christian Daily, \"Former Australian youth leader jailed for sexually assaulting teen.\"",
"body": "Report confirming Jones's guilty plea, the 16-month sentence, his age (88), and the Christian Growth Centre/Horizon Church setting.",
"tier": "religion-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cultnews101.com/2026/06/pentecostal-predator-had-lifetime-free.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cult News 101, \"Pentecostal predator had 'lifetime free of punishment' for Sydney child abuse\" (June 2026).",
"body": "Detailed account of the after-school events, choir, church band and kids' club access, and the church's contemporaneous failure to report the abuse to police.",
"tier": "specialist-watchdog-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mychristiandaily.com/former-australian-youth-leader-jailed-for-sexually-assaulting-teen/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religion-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cultnews101.com/2026/06/pentecostal-predator-had-lifetime-free.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: specialist-watchdog-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9ba37bc3f92a9cc653616469fce928d0615fb47854419366303272fdae970285",
"final_url": "https://www.cultnews101.com/2026/06/pentecostal-predator-had-lifetime-free.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1134,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Grant was a senior lay figure — deacon and youth-group leader — across two Baptist congregations and several affiliated north London youth groups over more than 40 years; his victims were four young men he accessed through those church and youth-group roles, and the abuse spanned 1970 to 2012.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-john-grant-north-london-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "North London, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.5906,
"lng": -0.1428,
"title": "United Kingdom: church deacon convicted of sexually abusing four young men over four decades",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"church deacon",
"youth group leader"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"deacon and senior youth-leadership standing across multiple congregations",
"targeting of 'vulnerable' young men through church youth groups"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Muswell Hill Baptist Church, north London",
"Billingham Baptist Church, Stockton-on-Tees"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Wood Green Crown Court, England",
"stage": "jury conviction",
"outcome": "Found guilty of three counts of sexual assault, six counts of indecent assault and two counts of causing another person to engage in non-penetrative sexual activity, against four victims between 1970 and 2012. (Reported 2026; exact verdict date not stated in available coverage.)"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Grant held deacon and youth-leadership roles at Muswell Hill Baptist Church and Billingham Baptist Church, plus several affiliated youth groups in north London, over a more-than-40-year span; those church offices gave him repeated access to the four young men he was convicted of abusing.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thestar.co.uk/news/crime/south-yorkshire-church-deacon-john-grant-8799404",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Star, \"Former church deacon sexually abused young men over four decades.\"",
"body": "Court report naming John Grant, his deacon and youth-leader roles at Muswell Hill and Billingham Baptist churches, and the jury's guilty verdicts on all counts.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://uk.news.yahoo.com/former-church-deacon-convicted-historic-165800808.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Yahoo News UK (Sky News), \"Former church deacon convicted of historical sexual offences against 'vulnerable' young men.\"",
"body": "Wire corroboration of the conviction, describing the victims as vulnerable young men targeted through Grant's church standing.",
"tier": "wire-service-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/ex-church-deacon-guilty-sexual-offences-young-men-5HjddXf_2/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "LBC, \"Ex-church deacon and youth group leader guilty of sexual offences on young men.\"",
"body": "Additional court corroboration of the guilty verdicts and Grant's youth-group leadership role.",
"tier": "national-radio-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thestar.co.uk/news/crime/south-yorkshire-church-deacon-john-grant-8799404",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "846562c885dd5b02f001e998e621d38b8809ca7a324de44b18f65653889e4bb6",
"final_url": "https://www.thestar.co.uk/news/crime/south-yorkshire-church-deacon-john-grant-8799404"
},
{
"source": "https://uk.news.yahoo.com/former-church-deacon-convicted-historic-165800808.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: wire-service-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dd396554b4e76564ce2d34e4cbc0ff19be19852742d9f91082b46a79cb2ed638",
"final_url": "https://uk.news.yahoo.com/former-church-deacon-convicted-historic-165800808.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/ex-church-deacon-guilty-sexual-offences-young-men-5HjddXf_2/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-radio-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "672ed9c72db35101579dc3f059d20e30e8ab42e2fa020ee7ea81450530406a70",
"final_url": "https://www.lbc.co.uk/article/ex-church-deacon-guilty-sexual-offences-young-men-5HjddXf_2/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1135,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Eke, founder of his own deliverance ministry, told the 25-year-old victim — a member of his own church — that his semen was holy and would deliver her from a 'marine spirit' troubling her, then drugged and raped her. This is a textbook direct spiritual-pretext mechanism (deliverance/exorcism framing used as the coercive instrument) and was the first prosecution under Imo State's Violence Against Persons Prohibition Act.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-desmond-eke-owerri-imo-nigeria",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Umuehieta Avu, Owerri West, Imo State, Nigeria",
"lat": 5.4527,
"lng": 6.9827,
"title": "Nigeria: pastor convicted of raping a church member's wife under a 'holy semen' deliverance pretext",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and pastor, Deliverance Ministry of the Good Shepherd"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claim that his semen was 'holy' and could deliver her from a 'marine spirit'",
"administration of a stupefying substance to weaken the victim",
"her existing status as a member of his congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"organizations": [
"Deliverance Ministry of the Good Shepherd, Umuehieta Avu"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Imo State High Court, Nigeria",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Convicted on three counts including rape and administering a stupefying substance; sentenced to eight years' imprisonment by Justice T. N. Nzeukwu, the first case prosecuted under the state's Violence Against Persons Prohibition Act. (Reported 2026; exact sentencing date not stated in available coverage.)"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Eke was the founder and pastor of his own deliverance ministry and the victim's own pastor; he invoked an explicit deliverance/exorcism pretext — that his semen was 'holy' and would free her from a 'marine spirit' — as the direct means of overcoming her refusal before drugging and raping her.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://punchng.com/pastor-jailed-eight-years-for-raping-members-wife-in-imo/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Punch (Nigeria), \"Pastor jailed eight years for raping member's wife in Imo.\"",
"body": "Court report naming Pastor Desmond Eke, his Deliverance Ministry of the Good Shepherd, the 'holy semen'/marine-spirit deliverance pretext, the stupefying-substance count, and the eight-year sentence as the first VAPP Act prosecution in the state.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.nairaland.com/8178564/pastor-jailed-eight-years-raping",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nairaland forum syndication of Punch report on Pastor Desmond Eke conviction.",
"body": "Syndicated corroboration preserving the same court details.",
"tier": "forum-syndication-of-national-press",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://punchng.com/pastor-jailed-eight-years-for-raping-members-wife-in-imo/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "24762b0139dcc62215a0eb53ce086b327bad79bda3fcebfa7da61bcbf188a752",
"final_url": "https://punchng.com/pastor-jailed-eight-years-for-raping-members-wife-in-imo/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nairaland.com/8178564/pastor-jailed-eight-years-raping",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: forum-syndication-of-national-press; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1136,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Mariti required girls aged 13-23 in his 'Team of Prophecy' to attend daily church sessions and frequent overnight prayer sleepovers at his home; during one such sanctioned overnight session he raped three of them in succession under the pretext of filming a TikTok video, then threatened to kill their families if they spoke. The prophetic-authority structure and mandated obedience to it is the coercive mechanism, not merely proximity.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-sabata-mariti-virginia-free-state-south-africa",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Virginia, Free State, South Africa",
"lat": -28.1183,
"lng": 26.8547,
"title": "South Africa: self-proclaimed pastor sentenced to 55 years for raping members of his own 'Team of Prophecy'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed pastor and prophet"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"membership in a mandatory prophetic-training group, 'Team of Prophecy'",
"daily church sessions and required overnight prayer sleepovers at his home",
"threats to kill victims' families if they disclosed"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"spiritual-consequence",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"\"Team of Prophecy\" prophetic ministry group"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Virginia Regional Court, Free State, South Africa",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-11-03",
"outcome": "Convicted of three counts of rape against congregation members aged 13 to 23; sentenced to 55 years' imprisonment. Mariti's claim of a political conspiracy against him was rejected by the court."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Mariti ran a prophetic-training group, 'Team of Prophecy', requiring young female congregants to attend daily services and sleep over at his home for prayer; he used that mandated obedience structure to isolate three girls during an overnight session and rape them, then threatened their families' lives to enforce silence.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/pastor-sentenced-55-years-raping-young-church-members",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Prosecuting Authority of South Africa, \"Pastor sentenced to 55 years for raping young church members\" (Nov. 2025).",
"body": "Official prosecutorial statement confirming Sabata Mariti's conviction on three counts of rape, the 55-year sentence, the 'Team of Prophecy' group structure, and the July 2022 overnight-session offence.",
"tier": "official-prosecutorial-record",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sowetan.co.za/news/2025-10-30-miracle-pastor-jailed-for-55-years-for-raping-three-girls/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sowetan, \"'Miracle' pastor jailed for 55 years for raping three girls.\"",
"body": "Court report detailing the TikTok pretext used to gather the victims, the successive rapes, the death threats against victims' families, and the prosecutor's characterisation of Mariti's exploitation of spiritual authority.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
},
{
"link": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child",
"archive": "",
"citation": "South African Government / Commission for Gender Equality media statement on pastor convictions including the Mariti case context.",
"body": "Government commission statement situating the conviction within a broader pattern of South African clergy sexual-abuse prosecutions.",
"tier": "official-government-statement",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/pastor-sentenced-55-years-raping-young-church-members",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutorial-record; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bda2a1a68c8d22c01c94351751e3f6608bd75457a3bba4543453b15078729b9f",
"final_url": "https://www.npa.gov.za/media/pastor-sentenced-55-years-raping-young-church-members"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sowetan.co.za/news/2025-10-30-miracle-pastor-jailed-for-55-years-for-raping-three-girls/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "e17a432eba48afad9739c591e4b46b9a03d58123fd04fe2eccf4149c8ea3b813",
"final_url": "https://www.sowetan.co.za/news/2025-10-30-miracle-pastor-jailed-for-55-years-for-raping-three-girls/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-statement; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "18007da2c7271b6f4b8cd4737abb4217880afccb68adec44d1a1febfda78abba",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-conviction-serial-rapist-pastor-child"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The federal jury verdict and 210-year sentence establish Geilenfeld's own adjudicated conduct as founder and director of St. Joseph's Home for Boys. This entry concerns his admitted-by-verdict abuse, not Haiti, Haitian orphan care, American missionary work generally, or the many uninvolved staff and donors connected to the home over three decades.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-michael-geilenfeld-st-josephs-home-haiti",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Port-au-Prince, Haiti",
"lat": 18.5944,
"lng": -72.3074,
"title": "Michael Geilenfeld: 210-year federal sentence for abuse of boys at the Haitian orphanage he founded",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"orphanage founder and director",
"self-presented lay religious figure and former Catholic brother"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"control of shelter, food and material survival of orphaned and abandoned children",
"founder's authority over an institution he built and ran for three decades",
"international travel access to children in his custody",
"religious framing of himself as a man of God, later described by survivors as false"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Joseph's Home for Boys (Haiti)",
"St. Joseph Family Homes"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida",
"stage": "federal jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2025-05-23",
"outcome": "A federal jury convicted Geilenfeld of one count of traveling in foreign commerce for illicit sexual conduct and six counts of engaging in illicit sexual conduct in a foreign place, involving boys at the Haitian orphanage he founded and ran between 2005 and 2010; U.S. District Judge David Leibowitz sentenced him to 210 years in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/founder-haitian-orphanage-sentenced-210-years-prison-sexually-abusing-boys-his-care",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs, 'Founder of Haitian Orphanage Sentenced to 210 Years in Prison for Sexually Abusing Boys in his Care' (May 2025).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records Geilenfeld's founding and operation of St. Joseph's Home for Boys in Haiti, the federal jury conviction on seven counts, the 2005-2010 abuse window, and the 210-year sentence.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.pressherald.com/2025/05/30/worst-of-the-worst-miami-judge-says-as-haiti-orphanage-founder-gets-210-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Portland Press Herald / Associated Press, ''Worst of the worst,' Miami judge says as Haiti orphanage founder gets 210 years' (May 30, 2025).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records survivor testimony describing Geilenfeld as initially perceived as 'a man of God' who used that perceived spiritual standing and control of the home to abuse boys in his care over three decades.",
"tier": "court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-context"
},
{
"link": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/american-founder-haitian-orphanage-sexually-abused-4-boys-prosecutor-s-rcna135996",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NBC News, 'American founder of Haitian orphanage sexually abused 4 boys, prosecutor says' (2024).",
"body": "Reports the federal charges and prosecutorial account of Geilenfeld's repeated travel to Haiti to abuse boys entrusted to his care at the orphanage he founded.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "trial-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Geilenfeld founded and directed a Haitian orphanage for impoverished and abandoned boys, presenting himself as a devout lay religious figure and former member of a Catholic order; survivors testified he was initially perceived as 'a man of God.' That perceived religious standing, combined with his sole founder's authority over the children's shelter, food, and survival, was the access and control mechanism his federal conviction establishes. The record is core because the religious self-presentation operated alongside, and was inseparable from, his material control of the home -- the founder role itself was constructed as a spiritual-guardian role, not merely a landlord or employer role.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/founder-haitian-orphanage-sentenced-210-years-prison-sexually-abusing-boys-his-care",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ead447ac633e8292c7a059ab4d8c741f96648590d83f2eef56af402942cfeffe",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/founder-haitian-orphanage-sentenced-210-years-prison-sexually-abusing-boys-his-care"
},
{
"source": "https://www.pressherald.com/2025/05/30/worst-of-the-worst-miami-judge-says-as-haiti-orphanage-founder-gets-210-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2f753ffd7154ae0185b22af05d5a30d1d189b48ac57081a7105395516a7f6bec",
"final_url": "https://www.pressherald.com/2025/05/30/worst-of-the-worst-miami-judge-says-as-haiti-orphanage-founder-gets-210-years/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/american-founder-haitian-orphanage-sexually-abused-4-boys-prosecutor-s-rcna135996",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: trial-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c71eb1fca6f036996337deddd02ec12da1ecc5d9d6654a8b273d5c2dce3f6e29",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/american-founder-haitian-orphanage-sexually-abused-4-boys-prosecutor-s-rcna135996"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 2,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The federal jury verdict and sentence establish Johnson's own adjudicated conduct as founder and operator of an unlicensed orphanage in Phnom Penh. This entry concerns his admitted-by-verdict abuse, not Cambodia, Cambodian orphan care, American missionary work generally, or the churches that funded the orphanage without knowledge of the abuse.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-daniel-johnson-hope-transitions-orphanage-cambodia",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Phnom Penh, Cambodia",
"lat": 11.5564,
"lng": 104.9282,
"title": "Daniel Stephen Johnson: life sentence for abuse of children at the Cambodian orphanage he ran as a Christian missionary",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"orphanage founder and operator",
"self-presented Christian missionary"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"control of shelter, food and material survival of orphaned children",
"founder's authority over an unlicensed orphanage he built and ran",
"missionary identity used, in the prosecutor's words, as 'the guise' for access to children",
"church funding and institutional legitimacy channeled through his missionary status"
],
"organizations": [
"Hope Transitions (Gladewater, Texas)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Phnom Penh Municipal Court, Cambodia",
"stage": "conviction (host-country)",
"date": "2014-05-01",
"outcome": "A Cambodian judge convicted Johnson of performing indecent acts on children at the orphanage and sentenced him to one year in prison."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon",
"stage": "federal jury conviction and sentence",
"date": "2018-05-16",
"outcome": "A federal jury convicted Johnson on six counts of engaging in illicit sexual conduct in a foreign place and one count each of travel with intent to engage in illicit sexual conduct and aggravated sexual abuse of children; he was sentenced to 30 years on each illicit-conduct and travel count and life imprisonment on the aggravated-sexual-abuse count."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/oregon-missionary-found-guilty-sexually-abusing-six-cambodian-children-orphanage",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs, 'Oregon Missionary Found Guilty of Sexually Abusing Six Cambodian Children at Orphanage' (May 2018).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records Johnson's identity as a Christian missionary operating under the nonprofit Hope Transitions, his founding and operation of the unlicensed orphanage in Phnom Penh, the jury verdict, and states 'the fact that this defendant abused children under the guise of being a missionary and orphanage operator is appalling.'",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/oregon-man-sentenced-life-prison-sexually-abusing-children-orphanage-cambodia",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs, 'Oregon Man Sentenced to Life in Prison for Sexually Abusing Children at Orphanage in Cambodia' (2018).",
"body": "Records the sentence, the 2005-2013 abuse window, the ten disclosed Cambodian victims aged seven to eighteen, and Johnson's prior one-year Cambodian conviction and sentence for the same conduct.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://churchleaders.com/news/343038-missionary-gets-life-in-prison-for-abusing-children-in-cambodia.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ChurchLeaders, ''Missionary' Gets Life in Prison for Abusing Children in Cambodia' (2018).",
"body": "Reports Johnson's self-presentation as a Christian missionary, the Hope Transitions nonprofit basis, and church funding support for the orphanage.",
"tier": "trade-press",
"kind": "sentencing-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Johnson presented himself as a Christian missionary and founded an unlicensed orphanage in Phnom Penh funded by church support, using that missionary identity and founder's authority to gain and maintain access to orphaned and abandoned children who depended on him for shelter and survival. The federal prosecutor's own statement frames the missionary and orphanage-operator identity as 'the guise' under which the abuse occurred. The record is core because Johnson's religious self-presentation was the instrument that secured church funding, community trust and unsupervised access to the children, not an incidental detail of an otherwise purely custodial relationship.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/oregon-missionary-found-guilty-sexually-abusing-six-cambodian-children-orphanage",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cdcf491c4d2c7563bda98fab718c53c34546394865ca08dae0e6b484fdc6a30c",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/oregon-missionary-found-guilty-sexually-abusing-six-cambodian-children-orphanage"
},
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/oregon-man-sentenced-life-prison-sexually-abusing-children-orphanage-cambodia",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7943b7424148a29a71669466e11de653fbd558e08beab304400d7b0e1c58c18b",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/oregon-man-sentenced-life-prison-sexually-abusing-children-orphanage-cambodia"
},
{
"source": "https://churchleaders.com/news/343038-missionary-gets-life-in-prison-for-abusing-children-in-cambodia.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: trade-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c7ba6ad627a85bf1b1976454d05af3552620728a82a1e0eb6f3dffcd749458ec",
"final_url": "https://churchleaders.com/news/343038-missionary-gets-life-in-prison-for-abusing-children-in-cambodia.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 3,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The guilty plea and federal sentence establish Tuininga's own adjudicated conduct as an Orthodox Presbyterian Church minister serving in Mbale, Uganda. This entry concerns his admitted conduct, not Uganda, Ugandan Christians, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church's doctrine, or its other missionaries.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-eric-tuininga-opc-mbale-uganda",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Mbale, Uganda",
"lat": 1.0827,
"lng": 34.1751,
"title": "Eric Tuininga: ten-year federal sentence for abusing a Ugandan girl in his pastoral care",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Orthodox Presbyterian Church minister and missionary"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a minor in his care",
"missionary's foreign-national status and standing within the local congregation",
"trusted position as a minister used to isolate and access the victim"
],
"organizations": [
"Orthodox Presbyterian Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Georgia",
"stage": "guilty plea",
"date": "2022-02-02",
"outcome": "Tuininga pleaded guilty to engaging in illicit sexual conduct in a foreign place, admitting sexual contact with a Ugandan girl who was fourteen in March 2019 while he served as an Orthodox Presbyterian Church minister in Mbale, Uganda."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Georgia",
"stage": "federal sentence",
"date": "2022-07-06",
"outcome": "Tuininga was sentenced to 120 months (10 years) in federal prison, lifetime supervised release, $20,000 restitution to the victim, and lifetime sex-offender registration."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mdga/pr/federal-judge-hands-down-ten-year-sentence-lifetime-supervised-release-former-georgia",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, Middle District of Georgia, 'Federal Judge Hands Down Ten-Year Sentence, Lifetime of Supervised Release to Former Georgia Pastor for Sexually Assaulting Ugandan Minor' (July 6, 2022).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records the ten-year sentence, restitution, lifetime supervised release and sex-offender registration, and states Tuininga 'used his trusted position as a pastor' to abuse a Ugandan girl in his care while serving as an OPC minister in Mbale, Uganda.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://ministrywatch.com/missionary-pastor-from-georgia-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-assaulting-a-minor-in-uganda/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "MinistryWatch, 'Missionary Pastor from Georgia Pleads Guilty to Sexually Assaulting a Minor in Uganda' (2022).",
"body": "Reports Tuininga's role as an Orthodox Presbyterian Church minister in Mbale, Uganda, the guilty plea, and that a U.S. citizen affiliated with the church reported him to the U.S. Embassy in Kampala.",
"tier": "trade-press",
"kind": "plea-context"
},
{
"link": "https://theaquilareport.com/former-georgia-opc-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-assaulting-a-ugandan-minor-on-missionary-trip/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Aquila Report, 'Former Georgia OPC Pastor Pleads Guilty to Sexually Assaulting a Ugandan Minor on Missionary Trip' (2022).",
"body": "Denominational press coverage confirming Tuininga's OPC affiliation and Uganda ministry post at the time of the offense.",
"tier": "denominational-press",
"kind": "plea-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Tuininga served as an Orthodox Presbyterian Church minister and missionary in Mbale, Uganda, and the federal prosecutor's own account states he 'used his trusted position as a pastor' to abuse a Ugandan girl described as being 'in his care.' The record is core because the operative access was his pastoral office and the trust extended to a foreign missionary-minister by the local congregation, not merely a private acquaintance who happened to be religious.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-reformed-presbyterian",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mdga/pr/federal-judge-hands-down-ten-year-sentence-lifetime-supervised-release-former-georgia",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "87eeab8012f21e2082d51be1fc60587e6b67f4be7e0f3385b7f76dc3a648985e",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mdga/pr/federal-judge-hands-down-ten-year-sentence-lifetime-supervised-release-former-georgia"
},
{
"source": "https://ministrywatch.com/missionary-pastor-from-georgia-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-assaulting-a-minor-in-uganda/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: trade-press; evidentiary role: plea-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3a31e3fd842803399fb5923b22c1ab98d3155cf27d0ce6f0b116fb1639d66263",
"final_url": "https://ministrywatch.com/missionary-pastor-from-georgia-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-assaulting-a-minor-in-uganda/"
},
{
"source": "https://theaquilareport.com/former-georgia-opc-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-assaulting-a-ugandan-minor-on-missionary-trip/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: denominational-press; evidentiary role: plea-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f7f9b4ed8bf3a9d0f92f81572a4248eaeb096776e872f35c9e570b0f95b587eb",
"final_url": "https://theaquilareport.com/former-georgia-opc-pastor-pleads-guilty-to-sexually-assaulting-a-ugandan-minor-on-missionary-trip/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 4,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The guilty plea and federal sentence establish Kennell's own adjudicated conduct as a New Tribes Mission missionary establishing a church among an isolated Amazon indigenous community. This entry concerns his admitted conduct, not Brazil, the tribe involved (not named in public reporting to protect the community), or New Tribes Mission's broader work.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2013-warren-kennell-new-tribes-mission-amazon-brazil",
"year": 2013,
"place": "Amazon region, Brazil",
"lat": -3.119,
"lng": -60.0217,
"title": "Warren Scott Kennell: 58-year federal sentence for abusing Amazon indigenous children while planting a church",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"New Tribes Mission missionary and church planter"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"missionary's role establishing a church among an isolated indigenous community",
"foreign-national status and outsider technological/material advantage over the community",
"position as the religious authority introducing Christianity to the tribe"
],
"organizations": [
"New Tribes Mission (now Ethnos360)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida",
"stage": "federal conviction and sentence",
"date": "2013-08-19",
"outcome": "Kennell was convicted and sentenced to 58 years in federal prison for producing child pornography involving two minor victims, members of an isolated Amazon indigenous community in Brazil where he was establishing a church as a New Tribes Mission missionary, between December 2008 and August 2011."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mdfl/pr/sanford-missionary-sentenced-58-years-production-child-pornography",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Attorney's Office, Middle District of Florida, 'Sanford Missionary Sentenced To 58 Years For Production Of Child Pornography' (2013).",
"body": "The prosecuting authority records Kennell's role as a New Tribes Mission missionary establishing a church among an isolated Amazon indigenous community in Brazil, the production of child-pornography images of two minor tribal members, and the 58-year sentence.",
"tier": "prosecuting-authority",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.scmp.com/news/world/article/1416823/us-missionary-jailed-58-years-abusing-amazon-children-brazil",
"archive": "",
"citation": "South China Morning Post, 'US missionary jailed for 58 years for abusing Amazon children in Brazil' (2013).",
"body": "Reports Kennell's identity as a New Tribes Mission missionary in Brazil and the discovery of over 940 child-pornography images on his devices at a U.S. airport search.",
"tier": "international-press",
"kind": "sentencing-context"
},
{
"link": "https://ictnews.org/archive/missionary-convicted-of-child-pornography-involving-indigenous/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Indian Country Today, 'Missionary Convicted of Child Pornography Involving Indigenous' children (2013).",
"body": "Corroborates Kennell's missionary role and the indigenous identity of the two child victims in the Brazilian Amazon.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Kennell was a New Tribes Mission missionary in the process of establishing a church among an isolated Amazon indigenous community when he produced child-sexual-abuse images of two children from that community. The record is core because his access to the children flowed directly from his role as the outside religious authority introducing Christianity to a newly contacted or recently contacted indigenous group -- a relationship in which the missionary's spiritual and material authority over the community was, by New Tribes Mission's own model of unreached-people-group evangelism, total and unmediated by any competing local institution.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mdfl/pr/sanford-missionary-sentenced-58-years-production-child-pornography",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecuting-authority; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "73f1af62f2b6c2de199ba9657fbbe6b6b611a1b329896fa1cb5e2a8de69146cb",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-mdfl/pr/sanford-missionary-sentenced-58-years-production-child-pornography"
},
{
"source": "https://www.scmp.com/news/world/article/1416823/us-missionary-jailed-58-years-abusing-amazon-children-brazil",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ed105552630ca8daef53f9f0577442d31234b182f5900f13acbc767a10e627b9",
"final_url": "https://www.scmp.com/news/world/article/1416823/us-missionary-jailed-58-years-abusing-amazon-children-brazil"
},
{
"source": "https://ictnews.org/archive/missionary-convicted-of-child-pornography-involving-indigenous/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d48cb806d0f78f1a3ad5a67dd8af2630841e3cc98db9b37d751014ca7b7948ad",
"final_url": "https://ictnews.org/archive/missionary-convicted-of-child-pornography-involving-indigenous/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 5,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The Kenyan magistrate's conviction establishes Scheller's own adjudicated conduct. This entry concerns his admitted conduct as an individual who posed as a church missionary, not Kenya, Kenyan churches, or German missionary work generally. The trial court's own language distinguishing genuine missionaries from Scheller's posing is preserved in the sourced record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-thomas-scheller-kisumu-kenya",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Kisumu, Kenya",
"lat": -0.0917,
"lng": 34.768,
"title": "Thomas Scheller: 81-year sentence for defiling boys after posing as a church missionary",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented church missionary"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"foreign-national status and posing as a Western church missionary",
"recruitment, transport and harboring of boys under the cover of missionary and charitable identity",
"material inducements (sweets, pornography) layered onto the missionary cover"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Kisumu Chief Magistrate's Court, Kenya",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-08-01",
"outcome": "A Kenyan magistrate convicted Scheller, a 74-year-old German national, on three counts of defiling minors (the youngest ten years old) and of recruiting, transporting and harboring boys for sexual exploitation, and sentenced him to 81 years in prison; the magistrate stated the court would not 'sit and watch helplessly while the Kenyan children are being abused by the affluent western and eastern visitors who hide their true selves in the church.'"
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://nation.africa/kenya/news/german-74-to-serve-81-years-for-defilement-child-pornography--4330346",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Daily Nation (Kenya), 'German 74, to serve 81 years for defilement, child pornography' (2023).",
"body": "Reports the magistrate's conviction of Scheller, the 81-year sentence, and quotes the court's finding that Scheller posed as a church missionary to access and abuse Kenyan boys.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://nairobinews.nation.africa/german-missionary-thomas-scheller-handed-eight-decade-jail-term/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Nairobi News, 'German 'missionary' Thomas Scheller handed eight-decade jail term' (2023).",
"body": "Corroborates the sentence and the missionary-posing framing used by both press and the trial court.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Scheller, a German national, posed as a church missionary to gain access to Kenyan boys, who he recruited, transported and harbored before defiling them. The trial court itself made the missionary-posing mechanism part of its finding, distinguishing Scheller's fraudulent religious cover from genuine missionary work. The record is core because the conviction record itself identifies the missionary pose -- not merely wealth or foreign-national status alone -- as the access mechanism the court found proven.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://nation.africa/kenya/news/german-74-to-serve-81-years-for-defilement-child-pornography--4330346",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://nairobinews.nation.africa/german-missionary-thomas-scheller-handed-eight-decade-jail-term/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 6,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This entry records the Christian and Missionary Alliance's own commissioned independent inquiry finding, not a criminal or civil court judgment -- no perpetrator named in the report has been criminally prosecuted, per available reporting. It concerns Mamou Alliance Academy specifically, not the Christian and Missionary Alliance's broader missionary work, other missionary boarding schools, or the many staff and alumni not named as abusers or enablers.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1998-mamou-alliance-academy-guinea",
"year": 1998,
"place": "Mamou, Guinea",
"lat": 10.3756,
"lng": -12.0913,
"title": "Mamou Alliance Academy: independent commission finds decades of physical, sexual and psychological abuse of missionaries' children",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"missionary boarding-school house parents and staff",
"Christian and Missionary Alliance-appointed school administration"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial control of missionaries' children boarded far from their parents on the mission field",
"religious framing of discipline and obedience within a Christian boarding institution",
"children's isolation from parents, who were themselves serving elsewhere in Guinea and West Africa under the same mission board"
],
"organizations": [
"Christian and Missionary Alliance",
"Mamou Alliance Academy"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Independent Commission of Inquiry (appointed by the Christian and Missionary Alliance)",
"stage": "official finding",
"date": "1998-10-01",
"outcome": "A two-year independent commission inquiry, appointed by the Christian and Missionary Alliance and drawing on interviews and written testimony from more than 70 alumni, missionary parents and former staff, found that seven former staff members and two former students physically, sexually or psychologically abused children at Mamou Alliance Academy between 1950 and 1971, and that a significant number of children were involved."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1998/10/26/children-of-us-missionaries-abused-at-african-school-report-says/d865b616-70a4-4250-9a63-39ca95a76a8e/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Washington Post, 'Children of U.S. Missionaries Abused at African School, Report Says' (October 26, 1998).",
"body": "Reports the independent commission's finding of physical, sexual and psychological abuse of missionaries' children at Mamou Alliance Academy in Guinea between 1950 and 1971, naming seven staff and two student abusers identified by the commission.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "institutional-finding-report"
},
{
"link": "https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/?date=19981110&slug=2782703",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Seattle Times, 'At School In Africa, The Children Of Missionaries Lived In A Secret Hell -- Independent Inquiry Documents Decades Of Physical, Sexual Abuse' (November 10, 1998).",
"body": "Corroborates the commission's findings and details specific incidents, including physical abuse by house parent Floyd Bowman.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "institutional-finding-context"
},
{
"link": "https://mksafetynet.org/content/mamou-final-report-independent-commission-inquiry/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "MK Safety Net, 'Mamou Final Report: Independent Commission of Inquiry' (hosted document, accessed 2026).",
"body": "Advocacy organization hosting the commission's final report and related investigation materials for the Mamou Alliance Academy inquiry.",
"tier": "advocacy-archive",
"kind": "primary-document-host"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Mamou Alliance Academy was a Christian and Missionary Alliance boarding school for the children of its own missionaries serving across West Africa, who were required to board there while parents worked the mission field. The commission's own finding is that house parents and staff -- installed by the mission board as custodians standing in loco parentis within an explicitly Christian institution -- physically, sexually and psychologically abused a significant number of children over two decades. The record is institutional-event rather than core because no criminal or civil court has adjudicated individual guilt; the commission's official finding is the highest evidence tier reached to date.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1998/10/26/children-of-us-missionaries-abused-at-african-school-report-says/d865b616-70a4-4250-9a63-39ca95a76a8e/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: institutional-finding-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/?date=19981110&slug=2782703",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: institutional-finding-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "89c43a95ec9eab6ee8953f6685526dc1ef8478c1268d9bc81b18addbf35efce2",
"final_url": "https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/19981110/2782703/at-school-in-africa-the-children-of-missionaries-lived-in-a-secret-hell----independent-inquiry-documents-decades-of-physical-sexual-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://mksafetynet.org/content/mamou-final-report-independent-commission-inquiry/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: advocacy-archive; evidentiary role: primary-document-host.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c13f8a97ea089a55d417b26359e21e3ec0332361fb55cc56c089a31a8938c919",
"final_url": "https://mksafetynet.org/content/mamou-final-report-independent-commission-inquiry/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 7,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "This entry records GRACE's independent investigative finding, not a criminal or civil court judgment -- per NBC News reporting, none of the individuals named in the GRACE report have been criminally prosecuted. It concerns the Fanda boarding school specifically, not New Tribes Mission/Ethnos360's broader work, other missionary boarding schools, or staff not named as abusers or enablers.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2010-fanda-eagles-new-tribes-mission-senegal",
"year": 2010,
"place": "Fanda, Senegal",
"lat": 12.5833,
"lng": -13.2,
"title": "Fanda: independent GRACE investigation finds more than 50 missionaries' children abused at New Tribes Mission boarding school",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"New Tribes Mission boarding-school dorm parents and staff",
"New Tribes Mission field leadership"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"total custodial control of missionaries' children boarded away from parents serving elsewhere in the mission field",
"religious framing of obedience and spiritual mentorship within an explicitly evangelical boarding institution",
"mission leadership's repeated failure to investigate or report complaints from the 1980s onward"
],
"organizations": [
"New Tribes Mission (now Ethnos360)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "GRACE (Godly Response to Abuse in the Christian Environment) -- independent investigation commissioned by New Tribes Mission",
"stage": "official finding",
"date": "2010-08-28",
"outcome": "GRACE's year-long independent investigation found that more than 50 missionaries' children had been physically, sexually or emotionally abused at the Fanda boarding school in Senegal, identified thirteen alleged offenders including seven named perpetrators of sexual abuse, and found five New Tribes Mission leaders culpable of failing to protect children after complaints beginning in the 1980s."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2010_08_28_GRACE_Fanda_Report.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "GRACE (Godly Response to Abuse in the Christian Environment), 'Amended Final Report on NTM Fanda' (August 28, 2010).",
"body": "The independent investigating body's own report, identifying named perpetrators including dorm parent David Brooks and detailing the scope of sexual, physical and emotional abuse at the Fanda boarding school and NTM leadership's failures to respond to complaints.",
"tier": "independent-investigator",
"kind": "final-investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/religion/ungodly-abuse-lasting-torment-new-tribes-missionary-kids-n967191",
"archive": "",
"citation": "NBC News, 'Ungodly abuse: The lasting torment of the New Tribes missionary kids' (2019).",
"body": "Reports the GRACE findings, names David Brooks as the most prolific identified perpetrator, and states that none of the individuals named in the report have been criminally prosecuted.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "institutional-finding-context"
},
{
"link": "https://wng.org/articles/fear-at-fanda-1617331599",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WORLD, 'Fear at Fanda' (2010).",
"body": "Contemporaneous religious-press coverage of the GRACE investigation's release and New Tribes Mission's response.",
"tier": "denominational-press",
"kind": "institutional-finding-context"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Fanda was a New Tribes Mission boarding school for the children of its own missionaries, serving isolated field postings across West Africa, who were required to board there apart from their parents. GRACE's independent investigation -- commissioned by NTM itself after alumni pressure, and conducted by an organization with recognized standing including former prosecutors and safeguarding specialists -- found dorm parents and staff, installed as custodians within an explicitly evangelical missionary institution, sexually and physically abused more than 50 children over decades, and that mission leadership repeatedly failed to act on complaints beginning in the 1980s. The record is institutional-event rather than core because no criminal or civil court has adjudicated individual guilt; GRACE's official finding is the highest evidence tier reached to date, and per NBC News reporting justice for the named perpetrators 'has failed.'",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2010_08_28_GRACE_Fanda_Report.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: independent-investigator; evidentiary role: final-investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "434df1ee248467918447494f8b20ba0ed60ae874c44aa70aadd3e2482b257b89",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/reports/2010_08_28_GRACE_Fanda_Report.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/religion/ungodly-abuse-lasting-torment-new-tribes-missionary-kids-n967191",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: institutional-finding-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3f1cb4954fb7748ff27e5f76609e8fdd38bae33c3173ed0d18ebb38ba721417b",
"final_url": "https://www.nbcnews.com/news/religion/ungodly-abuse-lasting-torment-new-tribes-missionary-kids-n967191"
},
{
"source": "https://wng.org/articles/fear-at-fanda-1617331599",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: denominational-press; evidentiary role: institutional-finding-context.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1144,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-bernardino-batista-dos-santos-belo-horizonte-minas-gerais-brazil",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Belo Horizonte, Minas Gerais, Brazil",
"lat": -19.9167,
"lng": -43.9345,
"title": "Brazil: former Catholic priest convicted of raping more than sixty children over decades in the Archdiocese of Belo Horizonte",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest of the Archdiocese of Belo Horizonte"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly authority over parish and catechism children",
"decades-long pattern normalizing contact within parish activities"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Archdiocese of Belo Horizonte, Minas Gerais"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Minas Gerais state court",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2026-07-01",
"outcome": "Bernardino Batista dos Santos, 78, a priest removed by the Archdiocese of Belo Horizonte in 2021 after dozens of accusations, was sentenced to 24 years and 9 months in prison for rape of a vulnerable person against more than 60 victims, minors aged 3 to 11 at the time, with offenses alleged to have occurred since 1975."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A parish priest used decades of catechetical and pastoral access to children under the Archdiocese's supervision to abuse more than sixty victims across generations.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.montevideo.com.uy/Noticias/Sacerdote-condenado-a-24-anos-de-carcel-por-abusar-de-ninos-Las-victimas-son-mas-de-60-uc949677",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote condenado a 24 años de cárcel por abusar de niños. Las víctimas son más de 60', Montevideo Portal, 2026.",
"body": "Regional Spanish-language wire report on the Minas Gerais sentencing, naming the priest, the archdiocese, and the 60-plus victim count.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-report",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.montevideo.com.uy/Noticias/Sacerdote-condenado-a-24-anos-de-carcel-por-abusar-de-ninos-Las-victimas-son-mas-de-60-uc949677",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-report; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7b30a1928f4d6b5fa51447878a63462d39591be24ed03862eb2f5d42169fd554",
"final_url": "https://www.montevideo.com.uy/Noticias/Sacerdote-condenado-a-24-anos-de-carcel-por-abusar-de-ninos-Las-victimas-son-mas-de-60-uc949677"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1145,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-diego-da-silva-correa-guaiba-rio-grande-do-sul-brazil",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Guaíba, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil",
"lat": -30.1136,
"lng": -51.3247,
"title": "Brazil: ex-priest convicted of raping a nine-year-old he approached under cover of 2024 flood relief at his parish",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest of Paróquia Nossa Senhora de Fátima, Guaíba"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical authority combined with disaster-relief trust",
"parish access used to isolate the child"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Paróquia Nossa Senhora de Fátima, Guaíba, Rio Grande do Sul"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "1ª Vara Criminal de Guaíba, Rio Grande do Sul",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2026-05-26",
"outcome": "Diego da Silva Correa, 44, a former priest of the Nossa Senhora de Fátima parish, was convicted by Judge Andreia da Silveira Machado of rape of a vulnerable person and possession of child sexual-abuse material, and sentenced to 18 years and 10 months in closed regime. The court found he used the trust generated by the May 2024 Rio Grande do Sul flood disaster, in which the parish provided aid, to approach and abuse a nine-year-old girl between May and August 2024."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A parish priest leveraged both his clerical office and the trust generated by his church's flood-relief role to isolate and abuse a child under his pastoral reach.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.reporterguaibense.com.br/noticia/homem-que-atuava-como-padre-em-guaiba-e-condenado-por-estupro-e-armazenamento-de-pornografia-infantil",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Ex-padre que atuou em Guaíba é condenado a 18 anos de prisão por estupro e pornografia infantil', Repórter Guaibense, 2026.",
"body": "Local court reporting naming the convicted priest, parish, judge, and sentence.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.metropoles.com/brasil/padre-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-durante-enchentes-no-rs",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Padre é condenado por estupro de vulnerável durante enchentes no RS', Metrópoles, 2026.",
"body": "National outlet corroboration of the flood-relief pretext and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-report",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.reporterguaibense.com.br/noticia/homem-que-atuava-como-padre-em-guaiba-e-condenado-por-estupro-e-armazenamento-de-pornografia-infantil",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4f58eea17b7168feaeb351d120cd7bb6bc7d7b45b9e61768cc0951ebfd3e0298",
"final_url": "https://www.reporterguaibense.com.br/noticia/homem-que-atuava-como-padre-em-guaiba-e-condenado-por-estupro-e-armazenamento-de-pornografia-infantil"
},
{
"source": "https://www.metropoles.com/brasil/padre-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-durante-enchentes-no-rs",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-report; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2dd9d4ac82c0aad7d7eafe22de6fb2b263b0d51874fa3c76eeb932052a83c7e8",
"final_url": "https://www.metropoles.com/brasil/padre-e-condenado-por-estupro-de-vulneravel-durante-enchentes-no-rs"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1146,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-victor-manuel-campos-alvarenga-sonsonate-el-salvador",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Sonsonate, El Salvador",
"lat": 13.7167,
"lng": -89.7247,
"title": "El Salvador: priest convicted of raping a parishioner over three years in the parish house — first Central American conviction from an adult clergy-abuse survivor",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest, Iglesia La Resurrección, Sonsonate"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"prevalimiento — abuse of clerical authority over an adult parishioner",
"control of access within the parish house"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Iglesia La Resurrección, Sonsonate",
"Diocese of Sonsonate"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Segundo Juzgado de Sentencia de Sonsonate, El Salvador",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2024-09-01",
"outcome": "Father Víctor Manuel Campos Alvarenga was convicted by the Second Sentencing Court of Sonsonate and sentenced to 12 years in prison for statutory rape by prevalimiento (abuse of authority) against a young woman he repeatedly raped over three years in the parish house of La Resurrección church. Bishop Constantino Barrera Morales had received the report in 2014 and took no action for a decade. Reporting frames the case as the first in Central America in which an adult victim of clergy abuse secured a conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A parish priest used his residence inside church property and his standing over a young congregant to commit repeated rape, with the diocesan bishop informed and inactive for ten years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://gatoencerrado.news/2025/04/10/obispo-de-sonsonate-supo-durante-una-decada-que-un-sacerdote-abusaba-adolescentes-y-no-hizo-nada/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Obispo de Sonsonate supo durante una década que un sacerdote abusaba adolescentes y no hizo nada', GatoEncerrado, 10 abr. 2025.",
"body": "Investigative Salvadoran outlet detailing the victim's account, the parish setting, and the decade of episcopal inaction.",
"tier": "investigative-journalism",
"kind": "investigative-report"
},
{
"link": "https://newsweekespanol.com/elsalvador/2024/09/14/sacerdote-condenado-a-12-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-contra-una-menor/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote condenado a 12 años de prisión por abuso contra una menor', Newsweek en Español, 14 sept. 2024.",
"body": "Court-outcome report confirming the 12-year sentence and the prevalimiento charge.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://gatoencerrado.news/2025/04/10/obispo-de-sonsonate-supo-durante-una-decada-que-un-sacerdote-abusaba-adolescentes-y-no-hizo-nada/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: investigative-journalism; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a7265e13fce2e4dffd9d32dd8ba531b61cc0ba6e07930bc270f23f3b4c068bb6",
"final_url": "https://gatoencerrado.news/2025/04/10/obispo-de-sonsonate-supo-durante-una-decada-que-un-sacerdote-abusaba-adolescentes-y-no-hizo-nada/"
},
{
"source": "https://newsweekespanol.com/elsalvador/2024/09/14/sacerdote-condenado-a-12-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-contra-una-menor/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1147,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-fernando-coronel-fanin-san-martin-mendoza-argentina",
"year": 2025,
"place": "San Martín, Mendoza, Argentina",
"lat": -33.0806,
"lng": -68.4694,
"title": "Argentina: evangelical pastor convicted of statutory rape aggravated by his position as minister of a congregation, against a 15-year-old member",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Centro de Vida church, San Martín, Mendoza"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral authority over a minor congregant",
"access during church activities and a church camping trip"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Centro de Vida, San Martín, Mendoza"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "San Martín, Mendoza, Argentina",
"stage": "conviction (abbreviated trial / juicio abreviado)",
"date": "2025-07-08",
"outcome": "Fernando Nehemías Coronel Fanin, 28, a pastor at the Centro de Vida evangelical church, was convicted under an abbreviated-trial agreement of statutory rape aggravated by being a minister of religion, in concurrence with a second aggravated count, after admitting to repeatedly abusing a 15-year-old member of the congregation between 2022 and 2023 at the church and during a church camping trip. He received a three-year suspended sentence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A congregation's own pastor used his position within the church, including church-organized activities, to repeatedly abuse a minor member; the aggravating factor charged and admitted was specifically his status as a minister of religion.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://mendozatoday.com.ar/2025/07/08/condenaron-a-un-pastor-acusado-de-abuso-sexual-de-una-adolescente-de-15-anos-en-san-martin/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenaron a un pastor acusado de abuso sexual de una adolescente de 15 años en San Martín', Mendoza Today, 8 jul. 2025.",
"body": "Local court report on the conviction, admission, and sentence.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/07/10/mendoza-un-pastor-evangelista-admitio-que-abuso-de-una-menor-pero-no-ira-preso/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Mendoza: un pastor evangelista admitió que abusó de una menor pero no irá preso', Infobae, 10 jul. 2025.",
"body": "National corroboration naming the aggravating 'minister of religion' charge and the suspended sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://mendozatoday.com.ar/2025/07/08/condenaron-a-un-pastor-acusado-de-abuso-sexual-de-una-adolescente-de-15-anos-en-san-martin/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a79797601cb5200e92d6b5039473d5d2ed28df1c6ad63e6b7822ecb35e2e6783",
"final_url": "https://mendozatoday.com.ar/2025/07/08/condenaron-a-un-pastor-acusado-de-abuso-sexual-de-una-adolescente-de-15-anos-en-san-martin/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/07/10/mendoza-un-pastor-evangelista-admitio-que-abuso-de-una-menor-pero-no-ira-preso/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f517e3bf762c0f185c3c8974507c61b8fe5274beaafcfaf45a0207d86e8d89a2",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/policiales/2025/07/10/mendoza-un-pastor-evangelista-admitio-que-abuso-de-una-menor-pero-no-ira-preso/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1148,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-gilberto-cardona-gomez-liborina-antioquia-colombia",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Liborina, Antioquia, Colombia",
"lat": 6.6797,
"lng": -75.8172,
"title": "Colombia: Antioquia parish priest convicted of abusing two children under cover of confession, thirteen years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, El Carmen de la Venta, Liborina, Antioquia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"confession used as pretext to summon victims alone",
"threats to keep children from telling their parents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"organizations": [
"Parroquia El Carmen de la Venta, Liborina, Antioquia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Juzgado Promiscuo del Circuito de Sopetrán, Antioquia",
"stage": "conviction",
"outcome": "Gilberto Cardona Gómez, parish priest of El Carmen de la Venta in Liborina, Antioquia, was convicted of aggravated abusive sexual acts, homogeneous and successive, against two children aged 8 and 13, and sentenced to 13 years in prison. The court found he repeatedly summoned the children to his room under the pretext of confession beginning in 2012, and intimidated them into silence. He was suspended by the Church in 2012 and laicized in 2017."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A parish priest used the sacrament of confession itself as the pretext to isolate child victims and used spiritual and personal intimidation to prevent disclosure.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://noticias.caracoltv.com/antioquia/sacerdote-de-liborina-pasara-14-anos-en-la-carcel-por-abusar-de-dos-menores",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Sacerdote de Liborina pasará 14 años en la cárcel por abusar de dos menores', Noticias Caracol.",
"body": "National broadcaster report on the sentence and the confession pretext.",
"tier": "national-broadcast-report",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.elcolombiano.com/antioquia/condenan-a-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-de-dos-menores-en-liborina-CJ1597532",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a sacerdote por abuso sexual de dos menores en Liborina', El Colombiano.",
"body": "Antioquia regional-paper coverage confirming the 13-year sentence, laicization date, and diocesan suspension.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://noticias.caracoltv.com/antioquia/sacerdote-de-liborina-pasara-14-anos-en-la-carcel-por-abusar-de-dos-menores",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcast-report; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "35fd75d83c268e323fe5df7e85f46ea9b2c8594fdf765521d54a1e0ad67844f3",
"final_url": "https://www.noticiascaracol.com/colombia/sacerdote-de-liborina-pasara-14-anos-en-la-carcel-por-abusar-de-dos-menores"
},
{
"source": "https://www.elcolombiano.com/antioquia/condenan-a-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-de-dos-menores-en-liborina-CJ1597532",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d6f608de409b9325d387801b42a53af589943c1d92263a4bdf71f8842b397458",
"final_url": "https://www.elcolombiano.com/antioquia/condenan-a-sacerdote-por-abuso-sexual-de-dos-menores-en-liborina-CJ1597532"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1149,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-ruben-guillen-altunar-centro-tabasco-mexico",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Centro, Tabasco, Mexico",
"lat": 17.9995,
"lng": -92.9475,
"title": "Mexico: Concilio Nacional de las Asambleas de Dios state leader convicted of raping an 11-year-old girl, thirty-two years",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"state-level leader, Concilio Nacional de las Asambleas de Dios, Tabasco"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"denominational leadership authority over a congregation family",
"access through his standing within the Assemblies of God structure"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Concilio Nacional de las Asambleas de Dios, Tabasco (roughly 400,000 members, 800 pastors statewide)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Juicio Oral, Poder Judicial del Estado de Tabasco",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2026-07-03",
"outcome": "Rubén Guillén Altunar, a state-level leader of the Concilio Nacional de las Asambleas de Dios in Tabasco, was found guilty on 26 June 2026 and sentenced on 3 July 2026 by Judge Alejandra Sánchez May to 32 years in prison for pederastia (statutory rape) against an 11-year-old girl, identified by initials B.R.E., in an incident at a home in the ranchería La Lima, municipality of Centro, in March 2015. The court also ordered a fine and victim restitution."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A denominational leader within Mexico's largest Pentecostal council used his standing inside the church structure to gain access to a child of the congregation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2026/7/14/condenan-a-32-anos-de-prision-a-lider-de-la-iglesia-asambleas-de-dios-por-pederastia-en-tabasco-376068.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Condenan a 32 años de prisión a líder de la iglesia \"Asambleas de Dios\" por pederastia en Tabasco', Proceso, 14 jul. 2026.",
"body": "National newsmagazine report naming the defendant, denominational role, judge, case number, and sentence.",
"tier": "national-newsmagazine-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://tsj-tabasco.gob.mx/resources/pdf/transparencia/b9d4a77173e51c063fe990fea1f4f9d2.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Poder Judicial del Estado de Tabasco, Tribunal Superior de Justicia, transparency bulletin listing case 157/2025-M.",
"body": "State judiciary's own transparency-portal listing corroborating the case number and outcome.",
"tier": "official-court-record",
"kind": "case-listing"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2026/7/14/condenan-a-32-anos-de-prision-a-lider-de-la-iglesia-asambleas-de-dios-por-pederastia-en-tabasco-376068.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newsmagazine-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bb02fe371eab13b570851863e6b8c92279b620d527c773f39cead4ff366406aa",
"final_url": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2026/7/14/condenan-a-32-anos-de-prision-a-lider-de-la-iglesia-asambleas-de-dios-por-pederastia-en-tabasco-376068.html"
},
{
"source": "https://tsj-tabasco.gob.mx/resources/pdf/transparencia/b9d4a77173e51c063fe990fea1f4f9d2.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-record; evidentiary role: case-listing.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "363d085d0147f646df9ee5cefdd5be70cbc6c8b8797a2c605025011add6dde43",
"final_url": "https://tsj-tabasco.gob.mx/resources/pdf/transparencia/b9d4a77173e51c063fe990fea1f4f9d2.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1150,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-mato-oaxaca-tuxtepec-mexico",
"year": 2022,
"place": "San Juan Bautista Tuxtepec, Oaxaca, Mexico",
"lat": 18.0872,
"lng": -96.1298,
"title": "Mexico: religious preacher convicted of aggravated sexual abuse of two children in Oaxaca's Cuenca region",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious preacher ('predicador religioso'), San Juan Bautista Tuxtepec"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"preacher's standing within the congregation used to access child victims"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Juzgado de Proceso, Fiscalía General del Estado de Oaxaca",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2022-01-22",
"outcome": "A religious preacher identified by the Oaxaca Attorney General's Office only by the initials M.A.T.O. was convicted by the Court of Proceedings of aggravated sexual abuse against two minors, committed in January 2019 in San Juan Bautista Tuxtepec, in Oaxaca's Cuenca region, and sentenced to six years in prison plus fines and damages exceeding 48,000 pesos. The defendant's full name was withheld by the prosecuting authority in its public reporting."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "A preacher used his religious standing within the community to gain access to child victims; the Oaxaca prosecutor's office withheld the defendant's full identity in its own release, so this record follows the official designation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.elimparcial.com/mexico/Predicador-religioso-es-condenado-a-seis-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-sexual-en-Oaxaca-20220122-0090.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Predicador religioso es condenado a seis años de prisión por abuso sexual en Oaxaca', El Imparcial, 22 ene. 2022.",
"body": "State wire report reproducing the Fiscalía General del Estado de Oaxaca press release verbatim, including the initials-only identification and sentence.",
"tier": "state-prosecutor-press-release-report",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://oaxaca.eluniversal.com.mx/municipios/por-abuso-sexual-contra-dos-menores-en-tuxtepec-oaxaca-condenan-religioso-seis-anos-de",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Por abuso sexual contra dos menores en Tuxtepec, Oaxaca, condenan a religioso a seis años de prisión', El Universal Oaxaca.",
"body": "Corroborating regional coverage of the same sentencing.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.elimparcial.com/mexico/Predicador-religioso-es-condenado-a-seis-anos-de-prision-por-abuso-sexual-en-Oaxaca-20220122-0090.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-prosecutor-press-release-report; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "981ae8b70914e829fe577efacb9c1b6074941afca10bb7416f9adc7f7f9b9959",
"final_url": "https://www.elimparcial.com/"
},
{
"source": "https://oaxaca.eluniversal.com.mx/municipios/por-abuso-sexual-contra-dos-menores-en-tuxtepec-oaxaca-condenan-religioso-seis-anos-de",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bb5305cc6476769326e737c302e92d10a18b88802537324ce9b12990c585b0fc",
"final_url": "https://oaxaca.eluniversal.com.mx/municipios/por-abuso-sexual-contra-dos-menores-en-tuxtepec-oaxaca-condenan-religioso-seis-anos-de/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"court": "British Columbia Court of Appeal",
"outcome": "Dismissed Emerson's appeal, holding there was no reversible error in the trial judge's assessment of consent and abuse of authority; conviction and sentence affirmed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-samuel-emerson-cloverdale-christian-fellowship-surrey-bc-canada",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Surrey, British Columbia, Canada",
"lat": 49.1913,
"lng": -122.849,
"title": "Canada: Cloverdale youth pastor convicted of sexual assault, conviction upheld on appeal for abuse of authority",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"youth pastor",
"Cloverdale Christian Fellowship Church, Surrey, B.C."
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"eight years' standing as youth pastor over congregants and youth-group members",
"access to victims through church youth events, including a church-run Bible camp",
"abuse of the pastoral position of trust, expressly named by the Court of Appeal in upholding the conviction"
],
"organizations": [
"Cloverdale Christian Fellowship Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Provincial Court of British Columbia, Surrey",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2019-11-01",
"outcome": "Convicted on one count of sexual assault; acquitted on the remaining charges (originally 13 counts of sexual assault, 11 counts of abuse of authority for sexual purposes and one count of sexual touching of a minor, reduced before trial). Sentenced to two years in jail with a 10-year firearm prohibition."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "British Columbia Court of Appeal",
"stage": "appeal",
"outcome": "Appeal dismissed; three-judge panel found no reversible error in the trial judge's treatment of consent and abuse of authority. Conviction and sentence stand."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/samuel-emerson-madelaine-emerson-surrey-sexual-assault-1.5359563",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Surrey pastor convicted of sexual assault, wife acquitted' (2019).",
"body": "Reports the conviction of Samuel Emerson, youth pastor of Cloverdale Christian Fellowship Church, on one count of sexual assault, with his wife acquitted on related charges.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "trial-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.surreynowleader.com/news/former-cloverdale-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-two-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault-2967974",
"archive": "https://web.archive.org/web/2020/https://www.surreynowleader.com/news/former-cloverdale-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-two-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault-2967974",
"citation": "Surrey Now-Leader, 'Former Cloverdale youth pastor sentenced to two years in jail for sexual assault' (2020).",
"body": "Reports the two-year sentence and 10-year firearm prohibition following Emerson's conviction.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://vocal.media/criminal/northside-foursquare-church-and-cloverdale-christian-fellowship-church-abuse-allegation-cases-dm9170bcg",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Vocal Media, 'Northside Foursquare Church and Cloverdale Christian Fellowship Church Abuse Allegation Cases' (compiled case history).",
"body": "Compiles the charge history, trial reduction from 13 to 5 sexual-assault counts, the November 2019 conviction, the two-year sentence, and the 2022 BC Court of Appeal dismissal affirming the trial judge's finding on abuse of authority.",
"tier": "secondary-compilation",
"kind": "case-history"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Emerson was youth pastor at Cloverdale Christian Fellowship Church for eight years, with pastoral authority over congregation youth and access to victims through church-organized youth events, including a church-affiliated Bible camp. The BC Court of Appeal, in affirming his conviction, specifically upheld the trial judge's finding on his abuse of that position of authority -- the core record is anchored on the appellate court naming the pastoral authority itself as the operative mechanism, not merely disclosure context.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"court": "British Columbia Court of Appeal",
"outcome": "Dismissed Emerson's appeal, holding there was no reversible error in the trial judge's assessment of consent and abuse of authority; conviction and sentence affirmed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/samuel-emerson-madelaine-emerson-surrey-sexual-assault-1.5359563",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: trial-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.surreynowleader.com/news/former-cloverdale-youth-pastor-sentenced-to-two-years-in-jail-for-sexual-assault-2967974",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2da23b1b3dd1f7cdaf13637a7341f714da440049568de869819d87a44616a777",
"final_url": "https://surreynowleader.com/category/news/"
},
{
"source": "https://vocal.media/criminal/northside-foursquare-church-and-cloverdale-christian-fellowship-church-abuse-allegation-cases-dm9170bcg",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-compilation; evidentiary role: case-history.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "080abcd1617d1d26cb09a23a0975b3c290a990c2e619dacc621b9704cd0c2a65",
"final_url": "https://vocal.media/criminal/northside-foursquare-church-and-cloverdale-christian-fellowship-church-abuse-allegation-cases-dm9170bcg"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 2,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-david-norton-anglican-priest-ontario-yukon-canada",
"year": 2018,
"place": "London, Ontario, Canada",
"lat": 42.9849,
"lng": -81.2453,
"title": "Canada: Anglican rector convicted of abusing First Nations altar boys in Ontario; second conviction for Yukon victims followed",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"rector, St. Andrew's Anglican Church (London, Ontario), 1977-1983",
"Anglican priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"rector's authority over altar boys serving at his church",
"access to children of the Chippewas of the Thames First Nation through his clerical role and the parish's ties to the community",
"grooming through attention, gifts, and outings that traded on his standing as a priest",
"later abuse of two more altar boys during a separate posting in the Yukon in the 1980s"
],
"organizations": [
"St. Andrew's Anglican Church, London, Ontario",
"Anglican Church of Canada"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ontario Court of Justice, London",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2018-11-01",
"outcome": "Found guilty of three counts of indecent assault and one count of sexual assault against four boys, then altar servers at St. Andrew's Anglican Church, from the Chippewas of the Thames First Nation, abused in the late 1970s and early 1980s. Sentenced to a total of 13 years."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Yukon Territorial Court, Whitehorse",
"stage": "trial conviction and sentence",
"date": "2023-11-06",
"outcome": "Found guilty after trial of six charges -- historic sexual assault, sexual interference and sexual assault against each of two more First Nations altar boys abused in the Yukon in the 1980s. Sentenced to three years on each Yukon count, served concurrently with each other but consecutively to the Ontario sentence, for a combined total of 16 years; added to the national sex offender registry for 10 years."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/david-norton-sentenced-1.5066273",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Former priest David Norton sentenced to 9 years for sexually abusing boys' (2019/2020 sentencing report).",
"body": "Reports Norton's role as rector of St. Andrew's Anglican Church from 1977-1983, the conviction on three counts of indecent assault and one count of sexual assault against four Chippewas of the Thames altar boys, and the resulting sentence.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/david-norton-yukon-sentenced-1.7021503",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBC News, 'Ex-Anglican priest who molested Yukon boys in the '80s to serve another 3 years in prison' (2023).",
"body": "Reports the November 6, 2023 Yukon Territorial Court sentencing, the six-count guilty finding for abuse of two First Nations altar boys, the three-year concurrent Yukon sentence served consecutively to the Ontario term, and the combined 16-year total.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://anglicanjournal.com/former-anglican-priest-sentenced-for-sexual-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Anglican Journal, 'Former Anglican priest sentenced for sexual abuse' (2019/2020).",
"body": "Denominational press confirms Norton's suspension of his priest's licence in 2016 following the laying of charges and his subsequent relinquishment of ministry.",
"tier": "denominational-press",
"kind": "institutional-response"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Norton was rector of St. Andrew's Anglican Church in London, Ontario from 1977 to 1983, and later held a clerical posting in the Yukon. Both sets of victims were altar boys -- children serving in his church under his direct clerical supervision -- and the first group were also members of the Chippewas of the Thames First Nation whom he accessed specifically through his parish's ties to that community. Two separate trials in two separate jurisdictions, a decade apart, both anchored the abuse in his role as their priest; the record covers both as a single perpetrator's authority-driven pattern across two dioceses.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/david-norton-sentenced-1.5066273",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/david-norton-yukon-sentenced-1.7021503",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://anglicanjournal.com/former-anglican-priest-sentenced-for-sexual-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: denominational-press; evidentiary role: institutional-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "67a66ec7646a1cf847cfe429f17f55071e649f887141ef11e25f4adad104c818",
"final_url": "https://anglicanjournal.com/former-anglican-priest-sentenced-for-sexual-abuse/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 3,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-samson-afoakwah-montreal-west-presbyterian-quebec-canada",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Salaberry-de-Valleyfield, Quebec, Canada",
"lat": 45.25,
"lng": -74.1281,
"title": "Quebec: Presbyterian minister jailed for sexually abusing the 13-year-old daughter of a congregation member",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Montreal West Presbyterian Church"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing with the victim's family as members of his congregation",
"access to the child through the family's church membership and the trust that role carried",
"abuse occurring in his home and car over several months while presenting as the family's pastor"
],
"organizations": [
"Montreal West Presbyterian Church",
"The Presbyterian College, Montreal"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Quebec, Salaberry-de-Valleyfield",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2024-01-19",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty to sexual assault of a minor -- the 13-year-old daughter of a member of his congregation -- and was sentenced to eight months in prison. The trial was held in Salaberry-de-Valleyfield because he lived nearby in Pointe-des-Cascades; the abuse itself occurred in the Montreal area over several months."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/montreal/article/montreal-pastor-sentenced-8-months-for-sexual-abuse-of-13-year-old-girl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CTV News Montreal, 'Montreal pastor sentenced 8 months for sexual abuse of 13-year-old girl' (Jan. 2024).",
"body": "Reports Samson Afoakwah's role as former pastor of Montreal West Presbyterian Church, the guilty plea, the victim's identity as the 13-year-old daughter of a congregation member, and the eight-month sentence.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2024/01/montreal-pastor-sentenced-8-months-for-sexual-abuse-of-13-year-old-girl/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org, 'Montreal pastor sentenced 8 months for sexual abuse of 13-year-old girl' (Jan. 2024), reproducing CTV News reporting.",
"body": "Corroborates the sentencing details and adds that the victim's father, a member of the congregation, noticed a change in his daughter's behaviour, which led to her disclosure and the police report.",
"tier": "secondary-compilation",
"kind": "case-archive"
},
{
"link": "https://presbyteriancollege.ca/2024/01/21/response-to-news-of-abuse-by-a-graduate-of-the-presbyterian-college/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Presbyterian College, Montreal, 'Response to news of abuse by a graduate of The Presbyterian College' (Jan. 21, 2024).",
"body": "Institutional response confirming Afoakwah as a graduate of the college and his standing as an ordained Presbyterian minister at the time of the offence.",
"tier": "denominational-press",
"kind": "institutional-response"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Afoakwah was the pastor of Montreal West Presbyterian Church and the victim was the 13-year-old daughter of a member of his own congregation. His pastoral standing with the family -- not merely proximity through some secular role -- is what gave him routine access to the child; the abuse took place in his home and car over a period of months while the family continued to trust him as their pastor. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-reformed-presbyterian",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/montreal/article/montreal-pastor-sentenced-8-months-for-sexual-abuse-of-13-year-old-girl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "37478d3871dcee995f576ac12109d406ad5d6e21b130e78bcb29b7d16a64ab8a",
"final_url": "https://www.ctvnews.ca/montreal/article/montreal-pastor-sentenced-8-months-for-sexual-abuse-of-13-year-old-girl/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2024/01/montreal-pastor-sentenced-8-months-for-sexual-abuse-of-13-year-old-girl/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: secondary-compilation; evidentiary role: case-archive.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2c374df1eacf3d2c20f76bab8ab40acb2f42555cd500f965d8c72baf07d1861b",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2024/01/montreal-pastor-sentenced-8-months-for-sexual-abuse-of-13-year-old-girl/"
},
{
"source": "https://presbyteriancollege.ca/2024/01/21/response-to-news-of-abuse-by-a-graduate-of-the-presbyterian-college/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: denominational-press; evidentiary role: institutional-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cdbb47dad92ea27c2b3b6e0e6496586a13309de1837aa611afce8a9d1d9e94b7",
"final_url": "https://presbyteriancollege.ca/2024/01/21/response-to-news-of-abuse-by-a-graduate-of-the-presbyterian-college/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1154,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Access mechanism was his embedded role at the mosque, not merely proximity to children in general — a victim described him as 'like a big brother,' language reflecting trust built specifically through the mosque community. Passes N2 as an institutional-obedience/trusted-insider case rather than a custodial-only figure.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-said-daauud-birmingham-mosque-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Birmingham, West Midlands, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.4862,
"lng": -1.8904,
"title": "United Kingdom: agency worker jailed 16 years for raping and abusing boys he groomed at a Birmingham mosque",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"IT support worker embedded inside the mosque",
"trusted adult figure ('like a big brother') to boys at the mosque"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"grooming with gifts (sweets, AirPods, computer games, phones) to build trust and secrecy",
"access to boys as young as nine secured through his role inside the mosque",
"exploitation of the mosque as a site presumed safe by parents"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Unnamed Birmingham mosque (name withheld for legal reasons)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Birmingham Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-02-06",
"outcome": "Found guilty of one count of rape, nine counts of sexual assault and seven counts of causing or inciting a child to engage in sexual activity. Sentenced to 16 years' imprisonment with a 5-year extended licence period."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Daauud worked as an agency IT support worker at a Birmingham mosque until February 2022, using that embedded position to identify and groom five boys as young as nine, abusing the trust the mosque community placed in him as an adult inside their place of worship.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.westmidlands.police.uk/news/west-midlands/news/news/2026/february/man-jailed-for-16-years-for-campaign-of-rape-and-sexual-abuse-against-children/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "West Midlands Police, 'Man jailed for 16 years for campaign of rape and sexual abuse against children' (Feb. 2026).",
"body": "Official police release confirming the Birmingham Crown Court sentence, offences, and mosque context.",
"tier": "official-police-record",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.expressandstar.com/news/2026/02/10/he-betrayed-my-truest-he-was-a-friend-like-a-big-brother-agency-worker-at-a-birmingham-mosque-who-sexually-abused-boys-is-jailed/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Express & Star, '\"He betrayed my truest — he was a friend, like a big brother\" — agency worker at a Birmingham mosque who sexually abused boys is jailed' (Feb. 10, 2026).",
"body": "Regional press report with victim impact statement and grooming detail (gifts, trust-building) confirming the mosque-embedded access mechanism.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "nexus-detail"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.westmidlands.police.uk/news/west-midlands/news/news/2026/february/man-jailed-for-16-years-for-campaign-of-rape-and-sexual-abuse-against-children/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-police-record; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.expressandstar.com/news/2026/02/10/he-betrayed-my-truest-he-was-a-friend-like-a-big-brother-agency-worker-at-a-birmingham-mosque-who-sexually-abused-boys-is-jailed/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: nexus-detail.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "7e8a195f38a527caff16d2c5d3c3370ddcccb5fb57d59775c976629e9399af29",
"final_url": "https://www.expressandstar.com/news/he-betrayed-my-truest-he-was-a-friend-like-a-big-brother-agency-worker-at-a-birmingham-mosque-who-sexually-abused-boys-is-jailed-5636592"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1155,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Church-elder standing plus an immigration-status threat is a double coercion mechanism — the plan's paternal/custodial traps do not apply since the victim was an adult congregant, not a dependent minor or family member, and the authority was explicitly religious-community standing.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-innocent-majoni-zaoga-leeds-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Leeds, West Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.8008,
"lng": -1.5491,
"title": "United Kingdom: ZAOGA church elder convicted of rape sentenced in absentia, fled before sentencing",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder, ZAOGA Forward in Faith Ministries International Leeds Assembly",
"director of a Leeds care company through which he met the victim"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"standing as a church elder used to build trust with a vulnerable woman",
"threat to report the victim to the Home Office for deportation unless she complied"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"ZAOGA Forward in Faith Ministries International, Leeds Assembly"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Leeds Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence (in absentia)",
"date": "2026-07-14",
"outcome": "Convicted at trial of three counts of rape and two counts of sexual assault. Sentenced in his absence to 13 years' imprisonment and a lifetime restraining order after he failed to attend sentencing and fled; police are searching for him."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Majoni, a prominent elder of the ZAOGA Leeds Assembly, used his standing in the church community and a separate business relationship to coerce a vulnerable Zimbabwean woman, threatening to report her immigration status to force compliance.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/news/crime/woman-fears-rapist-on-the-run-will-come-back-to-kill-her-8786141",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Yorkshire Evening Post, 'Woman fears Leeds rapist on the run will come back to kill her' (Jul. 2026).",
"body": "Local court reporting on Majoni's conviction, ZAOGA eldership, sentence, and flight before sentencing.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.zimeye.net/2026/07/14/zaoga-church-elder-named-among-leeds-most-dangerous-convicted-criminals-following-rape-sentence/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ZimEye, 'ZAOGA Church Elder Named Among Leeds' Most Dangerous Convicted Criminals Following Rape Sentence' (Jul. 14, 2026).",
"body": "Diaspora press corroboration naming Majoni's ZAOGA eldership and the immigration-status coercion detail.",
"tier": "diaspora-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/news/crime/woman-fears-rapist-on-the-run-will-come-back-to-kill-her-8786141",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c7f5798ea674bfd46f45f832402f4cf40a8c6011db2501831b8778f64cfe6de6",
"final_url": "https://www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/news/crime/woman-fears-rapist-on-the-run-will-come-back-to-kill-her-8786141"
},
{
"source": "https://www.zimeye.net/2026/07/14/zaoga-church-elder-named-among-leeds-most-dangerous-convicted-criminals-following-rape-sentence/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: diaspora-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2ca3d788a61d16db6d37b678fd62bf745b28ed41d162dc77cc8ba2186c62185d",
"final_url": "https://www.zimeye.net/2026/07/14/zaoga-church-elder-named-among-leeds-most-dangerous-convicted-criminals-following-rape-sentence/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1156,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Second sentencing round for a priest already serving time for parish abuse; both tranches rely on identical clerical-access mechanism, so this is treated as one nexus record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-david-leslie-crowley-yorkshire-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Bradford, Huddersfield and Settle, West Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.796,
"lng": -1.7594,
"title": "United Kingdom: priest already serving 18 years jailed a further 8.5 years for more parish sex offences against boys",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, St William's RC Church (Bradford), Our Lady of Lourdes (Huddersfield), St Mary's and St Michael's (Settle)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish-priest access to boys across three successive Yorkshire parishes",
"decades-long pattern spanning 1979-1993 across multiple postings"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St William's RC Church, Bradford",
"Our Lady of Lourdes, Huddersfield",
"St Mary's and St Michael's, Settle"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Leeds Crown Court, England",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-19",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty to a further 15 offences against boys; sentenced to an additional 8.5 years, extended by 2 years, consecutive to an existing 18-year sentence for 13 similar offences committed 1979-1985."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "David Leslie Crowley was a Catholic priest at three successive Yorkshire parishes between 1979 and 1993, using his position to abuse boys at each posting; the diocese moved him between parishes rather than removing him from ministry.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/sick-evil-huddersfield-priest-jailed-27162747",
"archive": "",
"citation": "YorkshireLive, 'Sick and evil Huddersfield priest jailed for even longer for sexually abusing kids' (Jun. 2026).",
"body": "Court report confirming the Leeds Crown Court guilty plea, additional 8.5-year sentence, and the three parishes involved.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/sick-evil-huddersfield-priest-jailed-27162747",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "dbe96fa49d7bf2d2646df1c1040989d536851b26041b9b246376a5f879f3038e",
"final_url": "https://www.examinerlive.co.uk/news/west-yorkshire-news/sick-evil-huddersfield-priest-jailed-27162747"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1157,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Date approximate — sentencing year not pinned in available press excerpts beyond confirmation the case reached Bradford Crown Court; offences occurred in the 1990s. Included as conviction-grade despite imprecise sentencing date per schema (date field omitted where not exact).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2000s-mohammed-hanif-khan-bradford-uk",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Bradford, West Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.796,
"lng": -1.7594,
"title": "United Kingdom: Bradford imam jailed 13 years for 1990s sexual offences committed while serving at the mosque",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam, mosque on Sunbridge Road, Bradford"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-teacher standing used to access victims connected to the mosque"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Mosque, Sunbridge Road, Bradford"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bradford Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Sentenced to 13 years' imprisonment with 3 years on extended licence for sexual offences committed in the 1990s while serving as imam at the mosque."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Mohammed Hanif Khan was an imam at a mosque on Sunbridge Road, Bradford, at the time of the offences, using that religious-teacher role to access and abuse victims connected to the mosque community.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.westyorkshire.police.uk/news-appeals/bradford-man-jailed-child-sexual-offences-1",
"archive": "",
"citation": "West Yorkshire Police, 'Bradford Man Jailed for Child Sexual Offences.'",
"body": "Official police release confirming Khan's role as imam at the Sunbridge Road mosque and the 13-year sentence with 3-year extended licence.",
"tier": "official-police-record",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.westyorkshire.police.uk/news-appeals/bradford-man-jailed-child-sexual-offences-1",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-police-record; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1158,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Targets met specifically 'through the Apostolic Faith Mission church' and his own founded church — congregational nexus explicit, not incidental proximity.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-walter-chahwanda-liverpool-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Liverpool, Merseyside, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.4084,
"lng": -2.9916,
"title": "United Kingdom: pastor who founded his own church convicted of sexual offences against children and young women met through his ministry",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Apostolic Faith Mission",
"founder and pastor, Sound of Dominion church, Liverpool"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing used to identify and target victims across the country through church networks",
"sending intimate images/videos to victims met through congregational contact"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Apostolic Faith Mission",
"Sound of Dominion, Liverpool"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Liverpool Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-03-20",
"outcome": "Found guilty on 17 of 22 counts by jury (verdict 2026-02-03) relating to nine victims; sentenced 2026-03-20 to 14 years, serving 9 years in custody with 5 years' extended licence."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Chahwanda was a pastor within the Apostolic Faith Mission before founding his own Liverpool church, Sound of Dominion; over roughly four years he targeted children and young women he met through those church networks, sexually assaulting a 14-year-old and sending sexual images to others.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/pastor-convicted-sexual-offences-against-children-and-young-women",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crown Prosecution Service, 'Pastor convicted of sexual offences against children and young women.'",
"body": "CPS release confirming the Liverpool Crown Court jury verdict, count breakdown, and church-network victim access.",
"tier": "official-prosecutorial-record",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/updated-sentence-pastor-convicted-sexual-offences-against-children",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crown Prosecution Service, 'Updated with sentence: Pastor convicted of sexual offences against children.'",
"body": "CPS follow-up release confirming the 14-year sentence with 9 years custody plus 5 years extended licence.",
"tier": "official-prosecutorial-record",
"kind": "sentencing-confirmation"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/pastor-convicted-sexual-offences-against-children-and-young-women",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutorial-record; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "600c6cf3cb5ff5f706eeb7587e13f405400179feccff03c20fdbe068406848a9",
"final_url": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/updated-sentence-pastor-convicted-sexual-offences-against-children"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/updated-sentence-pastor-convicted-sexual-offences-against-children",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutorial-record; evidentiary role: sentencing-confirmation.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "600c6cf3cb5ff5f706eeb7587e13f405400179feccff03c20fdbe068406848a9",
"final_url": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/updated-sentence-pastor-convicted-sexual-offences-against-children"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1159,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Vestry/convent access mechanism is explicitly clerical, not merely custodial.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-david-taylor-northumberland-uk",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Alnwick, Northumberland, England, United Kingdom (tried at Newcastle Crown Court, Tyne and Wear)",
"lat": 55.4147,
"lng": -1.7062,
"title": "United Kingdom: priest jailed for historic sex attacks on a boy in a church vestry and convent",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, ordained 1977"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"abuse committed inside a church vestry and an old convent, sites of unquestioned clerical access",
"abuse extended to a trip to a football tournament, showing access beyond church grounds via his priestly role"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Unnamed parish, Alnwick, Northumberland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Newcastle Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-12-13",
"outcome": "Sentenced for ten offences: five counts of indecency with a child, two counts of indecent assault, and three counts of indecent assault on a male person, committed against a boy from the priest's own parish beginning in the early stages of his priesthood."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Father David Taylor abused a boy in the church vestry, in an old convent, and on a football trip, using the unsupervised access his priesthood gave him inside religious buildings and church-organised activities dating back roughly 40 years before conviction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.itv.com/news/tyne-tees/2022-12-13/former-priest-jailed-for-sex-attacks-on-boy-in-church-vestry",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ITV News Tyne Tees, 'Former priest jailed for sex attacks on boy in church vestry' (Dec. 13, 2022).",
"body": "Regional broadcaster report confirming Newcastle Crown Court sentencing, the ten counts, and the vestry/convent/football-trip locations of abuse.",
"tier": "regional-broadcast-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.itv.com/news/tyne-tees/2022-12-13/former-priest-jailed-for-sex-attacks-on-boy-in-church-vestry",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcast-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1160,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Third conviction for the same offender; baptism-then-abuse pattern is explicit clerical-authority nexus, distinct from a generic caregiver case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-ifor-whittaker-sussex-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Sedlescombe, East Sussex, England, United Kingdom (tried at Hove Crown Court)",
"lat": 50.9186,
"lng": 0.5111,
"title": "United Kingdom: former Church of England priest jailed for life after raping a six-year-old boy he had baptised, in a church vestry",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Church of England priest (served under the name Colin Pritchard)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priest baptised the victim, then abused him in the church vestry using that pastoral relationship",
"prior convictions in 2008 and 2018 show a decades-long pattern of clerical access to child victims"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St John The Baptist Church, Sedlescombe, East Sussex",
"Diocese of Chichester"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hove Crown Court, England",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2024-11-19",
"outcome": "Admitted rape and gross indecency of a boy in the church vestry in the 1990s; sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 8 years. This is his third sentencing for child sex offences, following a 16-year sentence in 2018 and a 5-year sentence in 2008."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Whittaker, ministering under the name Colin Pritchard, baptised the six-year-old victim and then raped him in the vestry of St John The Baptist Church, using the trust his priestly office created with the boy's family to gain access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.gazetteherald.co.uk/news/national/24735829.former-vicar-jailed-life-raping-six-year-old-boy-church/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Gazette & Herald / national wire, 'Former vicar jailed for life after raping six-year-old boy in church' (Nov. 19, 2024).",
"body": "National court report confirming the Hove Crown Court life sentence, the baptism detail, and the prior 2018 and 2008 convictions.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.itv.com/news/meridian/2024-11-19/former-vicar-sentenced-for-third-time-for-child-sex-offences",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ITV News Meridian, 'Former Church of England vicar sentenced for third time for child sex offences' (Nov. 19, 2024).",
"body": "Regional broadcaster corroboration of the third sentencing and Diocese of Chichester affiliation.",
"tier": "regional-broadcast-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.gazetteherald.co.uk/news/national/24735829.former-vicar-jailed-life-raping-six-year-old-boy-church/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c576472d67d93dcc92248d1c3743e47b803711f3e560e5a8cc1e0725c89cf67a",
"final_url": "https://www.gazetteherald.co.uk/news/national/24735829.former-vicar-jailed-life-raping-six-year-old-boy-church/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.itv.com/news/meridian/2024-11-19/former-vicar-sentenced-for-third-time-for-child-sex-offences",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcast-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1161,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-obedience angle (diocese re-admitting a known offender) strengthens N2 beyond a single-incident clerical case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2021-david-beater-kent-uk",
"year": 2021,
"place": "Northfleet and Birchington, Kent, England, United Kingdom (tried at Maidstone Crown Court)",
"lat": 51.4407,
"lng": 0.3336,
"title": "United Kingdom: vicar jailed for second time for sexually abusing two boys, having been allowed back into ministry after an earlier conviction",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Church of England vicar, St Botolphs and St Marks Church, Northfleet; later St George's, Bickley"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"vicar's pastoral role gave access to boys in the 1980s",
"diocese allowed him to continue in ministry for roughly 25 years after an earlier indecency conviction, extending the access window"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St Botolphs and St Marks Church, Northfleet",
"St George's, Bickley",
"Diocese of Rochester"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Maidstone Crown Court, England",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2021-08-23",
"outcome": "Admitted five sex abuse charges against two boys committed in the 1980s; sentenced to 4.5 years' imprisonment. This followed an earlier indecency conviction after which the Diocese of Rochester permitted him to continue working in church settings for approximately 25 years."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Beater was vicar at St Botolphs and St Marks in Northfleet when he abused two boys in the 1980s; despite an earlier indecency conviction, the Diocese of Rochester allowed him to continue in parish ministry at St George's, Bickley, for around 25 years before this second prosecution.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/thanet/news/vicar-abused-child-but-was-allowed-to-return-to-church-252770/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KentOnline, 'Paedophile vicar David Beater, from Birchington, abused boy but was allowed to return to Northfleet church.'",
"body": "Local court report detailing the Maidstone Crown Court sentencing, the Diocese of Rochester's decision to reinstate him after an earlier conviction, and the Northfleet parish context.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/thanet/news/vicar-abused-child-but-was-allowed-to-return-to-church-252770/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ceaeeeaaab8c5610fded94e3bc137f079ed0d1a080a68aeac2088a52d670e727",
"final_url": "https://www.kentonline.co.uk/thanet/news/vicar-abused-child-but-was-allowed-to-return-to-church-252770/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1162,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Boarding-school-plus-clerical role satisfies N2 as institutional-obedience/clerical, not a bare teacher case.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-bournemouth-boys-school-priest-wessex-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Hooke, Dorset, England, United Kingdom (tried at Bournemouth Crown Court)",
"lat": 50.7963,
"lng": -2.6969,
"title": "United Kingdom: priest jailed for non-recent sexual abuse of boys at a Catholic boys' school",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest / staff member, St Francis School for boys, Hooke"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"clerical/school staff position used to access boarding pupils"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"St Francis School for boys, Hooke, Dorset"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bournemouth Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-12-17",
"outcome": "Found guilty on 12 December 2024 of five offences of indecent assault against boys at St Francis School, Hooke, committed between 1966 and 1967; sentenced 17 December 2024 to 6 years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The offender used his position at St Francis School, a Catholic boys' boarding school in Hooke, Dorset, to indecently assault pupils in the 1960s, exploiting the closed, faith-affiliated residential setting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/wessex/news/priest-jailed-non-recent-sexual-abuse-boys-school",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crown Prosecution Service, 'Priest jailed for non-recent sexual abuse at boys school.'",
"body": "CPS release confirming the Bournemouth Crown Court conviction, sentence, and the St Francis School, Hooke context.",
"tier": "official-prosecutorial-record",
"kind": "criminal-disposition"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/wessex/news/priest-jailed-non-recent-sexual-abuse-boys-school",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutorial-record; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "32fa210565e8f12a33c9487fd137e31efa514e8bd34411e675516be128d69207",
"final_url": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/wessex/news/priest-jailed-non-recent-sexual-abuse-boys-school"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1163,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Textbook N2 case — the perpetrator explicitly invented a doctrine ('Christian Domestic Discipline') to make the assaults spiritually unrefusable, distinguishing it cleanly from a secular abuse-of-position case. Two indicators present: prophecy/divine-command framing plus institutional-obedience (closed congregation under his sole leadership).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-howard-curtis-coulsdon-uk",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Coulsdon, London Borough of Croydon, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 51.3211,
"lng": -0.1367,
"title": "United Kingdom: pastor who ran a church as a 'cult' jailed for sexually assaulting women under a doctrine of 'Christian Domestic Discipline'",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and leader, Coulsdon Christian Fellowship"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"self-styled doctrine of 'Christian Domestic Discipline' used to frame sexual assault as spiritually sanctioned correction",
"spanking of naked congregants presented as scripturally grounded mental-health treatment",
"decades of controlling leadership over a closed congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"prophecy-divine-command",
"institutional-obedience",
"sacred-sex-purity"
],
"organizations": [
"Coulsdon Christian Fellowship"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Croydon Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2016-03-24",
"outcome": "Unanimously found guilty of six counts of sexual assault and two counts of child cruelty after a four-week trial; sentenced to 6 years' imprisonment (to serve half)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Curtis led the Coulsdon Christian Fellowship as a closed, cult-like congregation and invented a doctrine he called 'Christian Domestic Discipline,' under which he spanked naked female congregants, presenting the assaults as a spiritually sanctioned mental-health treatment rooted in his own biblical interpretation — making his religious authority the explicit operative mechanism of the abuse.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2016/05_06/2016_05_06_Tom_Matthews_PastorWho.htm",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Tom Matthews, Croydon Advertiser, 'Pastor Who Spanked Women in His Congregation for Sexual Pleasure Is Jailed' (May 6, 2016).",
"body": "Court report on the Croydon Crown Court trial, verdict, sentence, and the 'Christian Domestic Discipline' doctrine used to frame the assaults.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thisislocallondon.co.uk/news/14446626.spanking-pastor-sentencing-delayed-until-next-month/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "This Is Local London, 'Spanking pastor Howard Curtis, who led the Coulsdon Christian Fellowship (CCF) as a \"cult\", has sentencing delayed until next month.'",
"body": "Local report describing the congregation as run 'as a cult' and detailing the doctrine and trial.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2016/05_06/2016_05_06_Tom_Matthews_PastorWho.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8d1503c572dd86b19f7584cc0b05fab3fc4d760077c3bef1ea5f456133d15cbf",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2016/05_06/2016_05_06_Tom_Matthews_PastorWho.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thisislocallondon.co.uk/news/14446626.spanking-pastor-sentencing-delayed-until-next-month/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fa1cb10a173587a758ae0562940e65d344d76ecaa9289eb53393ee929e078096",
"final_url": "https://www.london-now.co.uk/news/14446626.spanking-pastor-sentencing-delayed-until-next-month/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1164,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Multi-parish serial pattern with a flight-to-Ireland element mirrors the transfer-pattern findings already logged for Irish institutional cases — parish-hopping as the Church's own containment failure.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-james-murphy-south-london-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Croydon, Streatham and Sydenham, London, United Kingdom (tried at Inner London Crown Court)",
"lat": 51.3762,
"lng": -0.0982,
"title": "United Kingdom: priest who abused at least 11 boys across four south London parishes before fleeing to Ireland jailed again",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest, Church of the Good Shepherd, Addington, Croydon",
"priest, Church of the English Martyrs, Streatham",
"priest, Our Lady and St Philip Neri, Sydenham",
"priest, St Gertrude's, South Croydon"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"successive parish postings across south London gave repeated fresh access to new victim pools",
"abrupt return to Cork, Ireland in 1990 evaded accountability for over three decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Church of the Good Shepherd, Addington",
"Church of the English Martyrs, Streatham",
"Our Lady and St Philip Neri, Sydenham",
"St Gertrude's, South Croydon"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Inner London Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-04-29",
"outcome": "Sentenced to 31 months' imprisonment for seven counts of abuse against four boys (part of a wider pattern against at least 11 boys aged 5-11 across 1975-1988)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Murphy moved through four south London parishes between 1975 and 1988, using his position as parish priest at each posting to abuse at least 11 boys aged 5 to 11, before abruptly returning to Cork, Ireland in 1990, evading justice for over 30 years.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thisislocallondon.co.uk/news/24286542.sydenham-priest-james-murphy-jailed-historic-sex-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "This Is Local London, 'Sydenham priest James Murphy jailed for historic sex abuse.'",
"body": "Court report confirming Inner London Crown Court sentencing, the four-parish pattern, and the flight to Cork in 1990.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.irishpost.com/news/former-priest-from-ireland-jailed-for-historical-abuse-of-young-boys-in-london-271796",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Irish Post, 'Former priest from Ireland jailed for historical abuse of young boys in London.'",
"body": "Corroborating diaspora press report confirming sentence length and cross-jurisdictional flight.",
"tier": "diaspora-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thisislocallondon.co.uk/news/24286542.sydenham-priest-james-murphy-jailed-historic-sex-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "66d482efdf4c604a4ceb9711a2e0412d2fd4b15d4a5d53ff52b8e4a3616256d7",
"final_url": "https://www.london-now.co.uk/news/24286542.sydenham-priest-james-murphy-jailed-historic-sex-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.irishpost.com/news/former-priest-from-ireland-jailed-for-historical-abuse-of-young-boys-in-london-271796",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: diaspora-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d8fa5ef1292b3d5f3a079f953660b9b16bab7c9920b5460d0f8dcdad00f928fc",
"final_url": "https://www.irishpost.com/news/former-priest-from-ireland-jailed-for-historical-abuse-of-young-boys-in-london-271796"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1165,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "The Nine O'Clock Service was already a subject of national controversy in the 1990s (its collapse was widely reported as a 'cult' scandal within the C of E) — this is the first criminal conviction resolving that history. Sentencing pending; evidenceStatus remains convicted since verdict is in.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-chris-brain-sheffield-nos-uk",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Sheffield, South Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom (tried at Inner London Crown Court)",
"lat": 53.3811,
"lng": -1.4701,
"title": "United Kingdom: leader of the Church of England's 'Nine O'Clock Service' convicted of indecent assaults on nine women",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ordained Church of England priest; founder/leader, the Nine O'Clock Service (NOS)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"founded and led an experimental church service that functioned as a closed, self-contained community",
"position as spiritual leader of NOS used to select and isolate victims from among his own congregation"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Nine O'Clock Service (NOS), Sheffield",
"Church of England"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Inner London Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction",
"date": "2025-08-20",
"outcome": "Found guilty of 17 counts of indecent assault against nine women committed in Sheffield in the 1980s-90s (acquitted on 15 further counts); jury discharged 2025-08-21. Sentencing date not yet reported in available sources."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Brain, an ordained Church of England priest, founded and led the Nine O'Clock Service, an unconventional nightclub-style congregation in Sheffield that gave him singular spiritual authority over a self-contained community of young worshippers, which he used to indecently assault nine women over more than a decade.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/former-vicar-convicted-sexual-assaults-connected-his-nightclub-nine-o-clock-service",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Crown Prosecution Service, 'Former vicar convicted for sexual assaults connected to his nightclub \"Nine O Clock service\".'",
"body": "CPS release confirming the Inner London Crown Court conviction on 17 counts, the NOS context, and the Sheffield location of the offending.",
"tier": "official-prosecutorial-record",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/former-vicar-convicted-sexual-assaults-connected-his-nightclub-nine-o-clock-service",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-prosecutorial-record; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "761e3b8ff1e1c93d0b76673ef9b35292edc4c659a1dc8a9c02c743f878f00d5e",
"final_url": "https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/former-vicar-convicted-sexual-assaults-connected-his-nightclub-nine-o-clock-service"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1166,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Went on to become bishop after these unreported offences — a career-advancement-through-cover pattern consistent with several already-logged Irish and English clergy records.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-anthony-pierce-swansea-wales-uk",
"year": 2025,
"place": "West Cross, Swansea, Wales, United Kingdom (tried at Swansea Crown Court)",
"lat": 51.6119,
"lng": -3.9683,
"title": "United Kingdom: former Bishop of Swansea and Brecon jailed for indecently assaulting a boy while a parish priest",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"parish priest, Holy Cross Church, West Cross (1985-1990 offences)",
"later Bishop of Swansea and Brecon, Church in Wales (1999-2008)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"parish-priest role used to gain access to a 14-year-old boy",
"subsequent rise to bishop within the same denomination compounded institutional protection"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Holy Cross Church, West Cross, Swansea",
"Church in Wales, Diocese of Swansea and Brecon"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Swansea Crown Court, Wales",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2025-03-12",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty on 7 February 2025 to five counts of indecent assault on a male child under 16, committed 1987-1989 while a parish priest at Holy Cross Church, West Cross; sentenced 12 March 2025 to 4 years 1 month. Three further historic reports were received after sentencing and remained under investigation."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Pierce indecently assaulted a 14-year-old boy while serving as parish priest at Holy Cross Church in West Cross, Swansea, in the late 1980s, later rising within the same Church in Wales structure to become Bishop of Swansea and Brecon before the offences came to light in 2023.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.itv.com/news/wales/2025-03-12/former-bishop-jailed-for-sexually-abusing-boy-at-swansea-church",
"archive": "",
"citation": "ITV News Wales, 'Former Bishop jailed for sexually abusing boy at Swansea church' (Mar. 12, 2025).",
"body": "Court report confirming the Swansea Crown Court guilty plea, sentence, and the parish-priest-to-bishop career arc.",
"tier": "regional-broadcast-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.churchinwales.org.uk/en/news-and-events/statement-on-anthony-pierce-sentence/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "The Church in Wales, 'Statement on Anthony Pierce sentence.'",
"body": "Official denominational statement confirming the sentence and the subsequent appeal for further victims to come forward.",
"tier": "institutional-statement",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.itv.com/news/wales/2025-03-12/former-bishop-jailed-for-sexually-abusing-boy-at-swansea-church",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcast-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.churchinwales.org.uk/en/news-and-events/statement-on-anthony-pierce-sentence/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-statement; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cfa8982ab946adc5a7747d97d1dd5fd1da9824b7a5a76e25dde3d24c6dac3d2b",
"final_url": "https://www.churchinwales.org.uk/en/news-and-events/statement-on-anthony-pierce-sentence/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1167,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Camp-organiser-plus-pastor combination mirrors the already-logged Jon Ruben (Stathern) pattern — this is a UK precedent for the same access mechanism (pastoral standing used to found and run a residential Christian camp).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-benjamin-david-thomas-criccieth-wales-uk",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Criccieth, Gwynedd, North Wales, United Kingdom (tried at Mold Crown Court)",
"lat": 52.9204,
"lng": -4.2352,
"title": "United Kingdom: North Wales pastor and former BBC presenter jailed over 10 years for abusing more than 30 boys and men at Christian camps",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-evangelical-pentecostal",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, Criccieth Family Church",
"organiser of Christian summer camps"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing used to organise Christian camps where victims slept in shared accommodation",
"abused victims mainly while they slept in sleeping bags, exploiting the residential-camp trust structure",
"covert filming of victims in showers at the same camps",
"public BBC-presenter profile added to his perceived trustworthiness"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Criccieth Family Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mold Crown Court, Wales",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"outcome": "Admitted 40 sexual offences against victims ranging from boys under 12 to men in their 30s, spanning locations in North Wales, England and overseas from the early 1990s onward; sentenced to a total of 10 years 4 months."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Thomas was pastor of the Criccieth Family Church and used that standing to found and run Christian camps at which he abused more than 30 boys and men over roughly three decades, exploiting both his pastoral authority and his public profile as a former BBC presenter to maintain access and trust.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.dailypost.co.uk/news/north-wales-news/predatory-pastor-hid-dark-secret-19036285",
"archive": "",
"citation": "North Wales Live, '\"Predatory\" pastor hid \"dark secret\" to abuse more than 30 boys and men over decades.'",
"body": "Court report on Thomas's guilty pleas at Mold Crown Court, the Christian-camp access mechanism, and the 10-year-4-month sentence.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://premierchristian.news/us/news/article/pastor-and-ex-bbc-presenter-convicted-on-child-sex-offences",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Premier Christian News, 'Pastor and ex-BBC presenter convicted on child sex offences.'",
"body": "Christian-press corroboration of the pastor role, Criccieth Family Church, and conviction details.",
"tier": "religious-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.dailypost.co.uk/news/north-wales-news/predatory-pastor-hid-dark-secret-19036285",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2e325e4e57fe3c75f8918f0cc07f23433f630839208d995d52562e9d7e48aac1",
"final_url": "https://www.dailypost.co.uk/news/north-wales-news/predatory-pastor-hid-dark-secret-19036285"
},
{
"source": "https://premierchristian.news/us/news/article/pastor-and-ex-bbc-presenter-convicted-on-child-sex-offences",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: religious-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d710d881636be77eaf33b9c6deecb3e1ce494a567f66582e17fad64723a4f8b2",
"final_url": "https://premierchristian.news/us/news/article/pastor-and-ex-bbc-presenter-convicted-on-child-sex-offences"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1168,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Non-custodial disposition, but a guilty plea satisfies N4 (conviction stood). Victims were themselves seminarians under his direct spiritual instruction — an unusually explicit N1/N2 fit.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-colman-mcgrath-blairs-college-aberdeen-scotland-uk",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Aberdeenshire, Scotland, United Kingdom (tried at Glasgow Sheriff Court)",
"lat": 57.202,
"lng": -2.431,
"title": "Scotland: priest convicted of indecently assaulting boys training for the priesthood at Blairs College seminary",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest and teacher, Blairs College seminary, Aberdeenshire (1963-1978)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"seminary teacher's authority over boys who were themselves training for the priesthood, doubling the spiritual-obedience dynamic"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Blairs College, Aberdeenshire (Catholic seminary)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Glasgow Sheriff Court, Scotland",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2015-07-01",
"outcome": "Admitted three charges of indecent assault against boys training for the priesthood, committed August 1972-September 1982; sentenced by Sheriff Kenneth Mitchell to a community payback order — 3 years' supervision and 200 hours unpaid work."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "McGrath taught at Blairs College, a Catholic seminary near Aberdeen, from 1963 to 1978, using his authority as priest-instructor over boys who were themselves training for the priesthood to indecently assault them — the victims' obedience was doubly bound, both as pupils and as aspirant clergy under his formation.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/news/aberdeen/626541/priest-avoids-jail-despite-abusing-young-boys-in-the-north-east/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Press and Journal, 'Priest who abused young north-east boys avoids jail' (Jul. 2015).",
"body": "Court report confirming the Glasgow Sheriff Court guilty plea, Blairs College seminary context, and the community payback sentence.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/news/aberdeen/626541/priest-avoids-jail-despite-abusing-young-boys-in-the-north-east/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1169,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Correctly routed to High Court of Justiciary per Scottish procedure note in the plan (High Court handles the most serious sexual offences, distinct from Sheriff Court).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-vincent-cassidy-greenock-scotland-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Greenock, Inverclyde, Scotland, United Kingdom (tried at High Court sitting in Paisley)",
"lat": 55.9506,
"lng": -4.7594,
"title": "Scotland: priest convicted of what the judge called 'crimes today classified as rape,' extradited from Australia after decades",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest, St Laurence's Church, Greenock"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly access to a 16-year-old boy at his own church",
"abuse continued off church grounds, at a caravan, showing the relationship of authority extended beyond the parish building",
"fled to Australia, evading justice for decades until extradition"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Laurence's Church, Greenock"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "High Court of Justiciary, sitting in Paisley, Scotland",
"stage": "conviction (extradited from Australia October 2024)",
"outcome": "Convicted by jury of indecently assaulting a 16-year-old male on multiple occasions 1973-1974 at St Laurence's Church, Greenock, and further occasions 1974-1977 at a caravan in Lossiemouth. Judge Sheena Fraser told him the crimes would today be classified as rape; sentencing deferred pending reports, with the offender placed on the sex offenders register and remanded."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Cassidy was a priest at St Laurence's Church, Greenock, when he began indecently assaulting a 16-year-old parishioner in 1973, continuing the abuse for years at a caravan in Lossiemouth before fleeing to Australia, from where he was extradited in 2024 to face trial.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irvinetimes.com/news/25944789.jury-find-former-priest-guilty-indecent-assaults/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Irvine Times, 'Former Greenock priest guilty of indecent assaults on boys.'",
"body": "Court report confirming the High Court/Paisley trial, the St Laurence's Church and Lossiemouth caravan locations, the extradition from Australia, and the judge's rape characterisation.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irvinetimes.com/news/25944789.jury-find-former-priest-guilty-indecent-assaults/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4d2749cf13685deecccecb3776bda5449a7a15948b24a6db60e70f4411efd094",
"final_url": "https://www.irvinetimes.com/news/25944789.jury-find-former-priest-guilty-indecent-assaults/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1170,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Cross-jurisdictional (Glasgow offending, Irish court, multi-country parish moves) — logged under UK/Ireland lane per the Glasgow nexus of the underlying abuse; church authorities' repeated failure to act despite complaints across three countries is a strong N2/institutional-obedience indicator.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-joseph-dunne-glasgow-scotland-ireland",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom (offences); tried at the Central Criminal Court, Dublin, Ireland",
"lat": 55.8642,
"lng": -4.2518,
"title": "Ireland/Scotland: priest jailed after Court of Appeal overturned a fully suspended sentence for sexually assaulting a vulnerable woman",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Catholic priest, active in parishes in Glasgow, Los Angeles and Ireland during the 1980s"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly authority used to target an 'extremely vulnerable' woman he had pastoral responsibility for",
"church authorities allowed him to move between parishes across three countries despite repeated complaints"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Catholic parishes, Glasgow, Los Angeles and Ireland"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Central Criminal Court, Dublin, Ireland",
"stage": "guilty plea and initial sentence",
"date": "2023-03-10",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty to five counts of indecently assaulting a vulnerable young woman between January and December 1989; sentenced to 4 years, wholly suspended."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeal, Ireland",
"stage": "appeal — sentence increased",
"date": "2023-12-18",
"outcome": "Prosecution appeal upheld; suspended sentence overturned, with 2 of the 4 years to be served in custody, taking into account the offender's age and family circumstances."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Dunne, a Catholic priest who served in parishes in Glasgow, Los Angeles and Ireland through the 1980s, sexually assaulted and harassed a string of young women and girls, targeting a vulnerable woman under his pastoral care in Glasgow in 1989; church authorities repeatedly failed to stop him despite complaints, simply allowing him to move to new parishes.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2023/12/18/ex-priests-fully-suspended-sentence-for-violent-sexual-assaults-of-vulnerable-woman-is-overturned/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Irish Times, 'Ex-priest's fully suspended sentence for violent sexual assaults of vulnerable woman is overturned' (Dec. 18, 2023).",
"body": "Report on the Court of Appeal decision overturning the suspended sentence, confirming the underlying Glasgow assaults and multi-parish pattern.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.sundaypost.com/fp/joseph-dunne-jailed/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Sunday Post, 'Shamed priest Joseph Dunne finally jailed for sexual abuse.'",
"body": "Scottish press coverage detailing Dunne's parish history in Glasgow, LA and Ireland and the pattern of church inaction on complaints.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2023/12/18/ex-priests-fully-suspended-sentence-for-violent-sexual-assaults-of-vulnerable-woman-is-overturned/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5563434cd005144bfa11f52065b6167bf505b8a0904769f762b0e83f26438f65",
"final_url": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2023/12/18/ex-priests-fully-suspended-sentence-for-violent-sexual-assaults-of-vulnerable-woman-is-overturned/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.sundaypost.com/fp/joseph-dunne-jailed/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1171,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Family-appointed private tutor rather than mosque-employed — the criterion is satisfied because the appointment and the access were explicitly religious-instructional (Quran tutor), not generic babysitting/tutoring.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-hafiz-pirzada-newham-uk",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Newham, London, United Kingdom (tried at Snaresbrook Crown Court)",
"lat": 51.5254,
"lng": 0.0215,
"title": "United Kingdom: imam appointed to tutor two sisters in the Quran jailed 8 years for sexually abusing them",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"imam appointed by the family as private Quran tutor to two sisters"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-instruction role secured unsupervised, recurring private access to the two girls",
"family's trust in his religious credentials as imam removed ordinary safeguarding scrutiny"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Private Quran tuition arrangement, Newham, London"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Snaresbrook Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2019-01-21",
"outcome": "Sentenced to 8 years' imprisonment for child abuse offences against two girls, aged 9-11 at the time, whom he taught the Quran between 2007 and 2009."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Pirzada was appointed by the victims' family specifically as an imam to teach the two sisters the Quran; that religious-instructor role, and the family's deference to it, gave him unsupervised private access during which he abused both girls between 2007 and 2009.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://pothwar.com/news/2019/01/23/london-hafiz-azizur-rehman-pirzada-aged-76-of-northolt-was-sentenced-to-a-total-of-eight-years-for-child-abuse/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Pothwar News, 'London; Hafiz Azizur Rehman Pirzada, aged 76 of Northolt was sentenced to a total of eight years for child abuse' (Jan. 23, 2019).",
"body": "Diaspora press report confirming the Snaresbrook Crown Court sentence, the Quran-tutor role, and the family-arranged nature of the tuition.",
"tier": "diaspora-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://www.newhamrecorder.co.uk/news/crime/21428996.imam-sexually-abused-two-young-girls-newham/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Newham Recorder, 'Imam sexually abused two young girls in Newham.'",
"body": "Local court report corroborating the imam role, the ages of the victims, and the offence period.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://pothwar.com/news/2019/01/23/london-hafiz-azizur-rehman-pirzada-aged-76-of-northolt-was-sentenced-to-a-total-of-eight-years-for-child-abuse/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: diaspora-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "512125d8060a754131e4f633483dc2cdafa6443f0af11f59be1df094f9ae5e74",
"final_url": "https://pothwar.com/news/2019/01/23/london-hafiz-azizur-rehman-pirzada-aged-76-of-northolt-was-sentenced-to-a-total-of-eight-years-for-child-abuse/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.newhamrecorder.co.uk/news/crime/21428996.imam-sexually-abused-two-young-girls-newham/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "671152c9d5441b649aea93e040a6b77677a38990f5194213912ab5cd65c9fd6d",
"final_url": "https://www.newhamrecorder.co.uk/news/crime/21428996.imam-sexually-abused-two-young-girls-newham/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1172,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Discovered when the child victims described the imam as 'creepy' during unrelated conversation — a disclosure pathway worth noting but not itself load-bearing for the criterion; the Quran-lesson access mechanism is what satisfies N2.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-shah-masukur-rashid-cheltenham-uk",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, England, United Kingdom (tried at Gloucester Crown Court)",
"lat": 51.9002,
"lng": -2.0783,
"title": "United Kingdom: volunteer imam jailed 6 years for sexually assaulting two young girls during Quran lessons",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"volunteer imam, mosque in Cheltenham"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"Quran-lesson setting gave repeated close, semi-private contact with young girls, exploited to touch them inappropriately during instruction"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Mosque, Cheltenham"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Gloucester Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-06-04",
"outcome": "Convicted of two counts of sexual assault against one girl and four counts against another, aged 5-7 at the time, committed October 2018-January 2019 during Quran lessons; sentenced to 6 years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Rashid volunteered as imam at a Cheltenham mosque and used the close, recurring contact of one-on-one Quran lessons to sexually assault two girls aged five to seven between 2018 and 2019.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.hellorayo.co.uk/greatest-hits/gloucestershire/news/imam-jailed-sexual-assault-children-quran-lessons-cheltenham",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Greatest Hits Radio Gloucestershire, 'Cheltenham imam who sexually assaulted young girls sentenced.'",
"body": "Court report confirming the Gloucester Crown Court conviction, six counts, victim ages, and Quran-lesson access mechanism.",
"tier": "regional-broadcast-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.hellorayo.co.uk/greatest-hits/gloucestershire/news/imam-jailed-sexual-assault-children-quran-lessons-cheltenham",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcast-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "87d76dd5e4d94c4daa5ff84600437a98456bb9a84a4a13fb8bd161f578752fb5",
"final_url": "https://www.hellorayo.co.uk/greatest-hits/gloucestershire/news/imam-jailed-sexual-assault-children-quran-lessons-cheltenham"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1173,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Elder-over-congregant is the standard Jehovah's Witness authority mechanism the plan flagged as a UK sub-vein to mine; four separate victims across an eight-year span shows a sustained pattern, not an isolated incident.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-mark-sewell-barry-wales-uk",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Barry, Vale of Glamorgan, Wales, United Kingdom (tried at Merthyr Tydfil Crown Court)",
"lat": 51.4045,
"lng": -3.2839,
"title": "United Kingdom: Jehovah's Witness elder jailed 14 years for raping and indecently assaulting women in his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder, Jehovah's Witness congregation, Barry"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"eldership standing within a tightly bound congregation used to access and silence women members"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witness congregation, Barry, South Wales"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Merthyr Tydfil Crown Court, Wales",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2014-06-30",
"outcome": "Convicted at trial of eight historic sex offences, including rape, against four female congregants committed 1987-1995; sentenced to 14 years' imprisonment. The judge said he showed 'not a thread of remorse.'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sewell was an elder in his Jehovah's Witness congregation in Barry, using that position of religious authority to rape and indecently assault four female members of the church between 1987 and 1995.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/jehovahs-witness-elder-mark-sewell-jailed-14-years-sex-crimes-1455020",
"archive": "",
"citation": "IBTimes UK, 'Jehovah's Witness Elder Mark Sewell Jailed for 14 years for Sex Crimes' (Jun. 2014).",
"body": "Court report confirming the Merthyr Tydfil Crown Court conviction, sentence, eldership role, and four congregant victims.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/jehovahs-witness-elder-mark-sewell-jailed-14-years-sex-crimes-1455020",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1a26aac5a155bc0ebb0f7b1f9cd1a1712d71d2298bf480845f1a9ba8c1f0c2c0",
"final_url": "https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/jehovahs-witness-elder-mark-sewell-jailed-14-years-sex-crimes-1455020"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1174,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Second UK Jehovah's Witness elder record in this sweep — the two together (Sewell, Winkle) begin to establish the pattern the plan flagged as a target sub-vein.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2015-john-winkle-stoke-uk",
"year": 2015,
"place": "Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53.0027,
"lng": -2.1794,
"title": "United Kingdom: former Jehovah's Witness elder jailed for indecently assaulting a schoolgirl in his congregation",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-jehovahs-witness",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"elder, Jehovah's Witness congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"eldership standing used to access a schoolgirl connected to the congregation over multiple occasions"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Jehovah's Witness congregation, Stoke-on-Trent"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Stoke-on-Trent Crown Court, England",
"stage": "guilty plea/conviction and sentence",
"date": "2015-11-22",
"outcome": "Admitted two charges of indecent assault and was convicted at trial of a third; sentenced to 4 years' imprisonment for indecently assaulting a schoolgirl on three occasions nearly 40 years earlier. Placed on the sex offenders register indefinitely."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Winkle was an elder in his Jehovah's Witness congregation when he indecently assaulted a schoolgirl connected to the church on three occasions in the late 1970s, using the trust his eldership commanded within the congregation to avoid scrutiny for decades.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://culteducation.com/group/1267-jehovah-s-witnesses/28993-ex-jehovah-s-witness-elder-jailed-for-sex-assaults-on-schoolgirl.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Cult Education Institute (reprint of local press), 'Ex-Jehovah's Witness elder jailed for sex assaults on schoolgirl.'",
"body": "Court report confirming Stoke-on-Trent Crown Court sentencing, the eldership role, and indefinite sex-offenders-register placement.",
"tier": "aggregated-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://culteducation.com/group/1267-jehovah-s-witnesses/28993-ex-jehovah-s-witness-elder-jailed-for-sex-assaults-on-schoolgirl.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: aggregated-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0e9acb5cb81d6c0172f72404b84190b8849384fc361659002120c721e49e027e",
"final_url": "https://culteducation.com/group/1267-jehovah-s-witnesses/28993-ex-jehovah-s-witness-elder-jailed-for-sex-assaults-on-schoolgirl.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1175,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Defendant name withheld in all press coverage to protect the child victim's identity, standard under Irish reporting restrictions in familial/known-relation sexual abuse cases; the record is titled and sourced without a perpetrator name, consistent with the underlying court record.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-dublin-pastor-83-anonymized-ireland",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Ireland (location withheld to protect victim identity; tried at the Central Criminal Court)",
"lat": 53.3498,
"lng": -6.2603,
"title": "Ireland: church pastor, 83, jailed 12.5 years for abusing a child in his congregation in the church bathroom",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, church congregation"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral standing over a congregant family used to isolate the victim in the church bathroom",
"victim's family had attended the church for years, embedding trust before the abuse began"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Unnamed congregation, Ireland (name withheld per Irish victim-anonymity law)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Central Criminal Court, Ireland",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-05-18",
"outcome": "Convicted of one count of attempted rape, one count of oral rape, and three counts of sexual abuse of a child committed December 2013-April 2018 (victim aged 8-11); headline sentence of 14 years with the final 18 months suspended, yielding 12.5 years in custody. Judge Kerida Naidoo said the pastor 'abused his position in the church to commit the offence.'"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The pastor abused a child from his own congregation, using the church itself — specifically its bathroom — as the site of assault, with the judge explicitly finding he 'abused his position in the church to commit the offence'; the victim, now an adult, told the court 'Church, a place of refuge, became a place of fear.'",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2026/05/18/church-pastor-83-jailed-for-12-years-for-sexual-abuse-of-a-child-in-his-congregation/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Irish Times, 'Church pastor (83) jailed for 12½ years for sexual abuse of a child in his congregation' (May 18, 2026).",
"body": "Court report on the Central Criminal Court sentencing, the judge's finding that he abused his church position, and the victim impact statement.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
},
{
"link": "https://dublinpeople.com/news/court/articles/2026/05/18/pastor-who-sexually-abused-child-in-his-congregations-jailed-for-12-5-years/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Dublin People, 'Pastor who sexually abused child in his congregations jailed for 12.5 years' (May 18, 2026).",
"body": "Corroborating national report confirming sentence structure (14-year headline, 18 months suspended).",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2026/05/18/church-pastor-83-jailed-for-12-years-for-sexual-abuse-of-a-child-in-his-congregation/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d09b45a6baa912faf70240a258a12c51846dc15bfa37a20d8523608fcfeb464a",
"final_url": "https://www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/courts/2026/05/18/church-pastor-83-jailed-for-12-years-for-sexual-abuse-of-a-child-in-his-congregation/"
},
{
"source": "https://dublinpeople.com/news/court/articles/2026/05/18/pastor-who-sexually-abused-child-in-his-congregations-jailed-for-12-5-years/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5bd9850fe08d595bfb8a4345fed515da5d643806f83eb50372f3e518f7c41699",
"final_url": "https://dublinpeople.com/news/court/articles/2026/05/18/pastor-who-sexually-abused-child-in-his-congregations-jailed-for-12-5-years/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1176,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Defendant name withheld in all available press coverage under Irish reporting restrictions protecting the victim's identity; recorded without a perpetrator name per the underlying court record, consistent with the Dublin pastor record above.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-limerick-priest-anonymized-ireland",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Diocese of Limerick, Ireland (location withheld; tried at Limerick Circuit Court)",
"lat": 52.6638,
"lng": -8.6267,
"title": "Ireland: priest jailed 3 years for sexually abusing a boy across several parishes in the Diocese of Limerick",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest, several parishes, Diocese of Limerick"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"priestly role across multiple parishes gave sustained access to the victim over several years",
"developed what the court called a 'most inappropriate and unhealthy' relationship with the child under cover of pastoral involvement"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Diocese of Limerick"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Limerick Circuit Court, Ireland",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2020-10-12",
"outcome": "Convicted by jury on nine charges of sexual abuse of a minor (touching and masturbating in the victim's presence on numerous occasions) committed September 1999-December 2002, victim aged 12-13 at onset; sentenced by Judge Sean O Donnabhain to 3 years' imprisonment."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The priest worked across several parishes within the Diocese of Limerick and developed sustained, unsupervised access to the child victim over three years, which the court characterised as a 'most inappropriate and unhealthy' relationship rooted in his pastoral role.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2020/10/limerick-priest-jailed-for-sexually-abusing-young-boy/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "BishopAccountability.org (reprint of Irish court press coverage), 'Limerick priest jailed for sexually abusing young boy' (Oct. 2020).",
"body": "Court report confirming the Limerick Circuit Court conviction on nine counts, the 3-year sentence, and the diocesan multi-parish context.",
"tier": "aggregated-court-reporting",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2020/10/limerick-priest-jailed-for-sexually-abusing-young-boy/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: aggregated-court-reporting; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cda520f1ca1a9a017333ea4b27c2bf4833317134cb91e9a565907b6bc49c9d92",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2020/10/limerick-priest-jailed-for-sexually-abusing-young-boy/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1177,
"aliases": [
"Steve Oh"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Court of Appeals, CA-G.R. CR-HC No. 09864, affirmed with modification on Feb. 10, 2021 (fine and damages increased); Supreme Court, Third Division, G.R. No. 262632, affirmed on June 5, 2024."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Victims not identified (AAA, BBB, CCC in court documents). All three were 15-17 at time of recruitment.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-si-young-oh-theology-school-pampanga-philippines",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Angeles City, Pampanga, Philippines",
"lat": 15.1449,
"lng": 120.5887,
"title": "Philippines: South Korean pastor's life sentence for trafficking minors recruited as unpaid theology students affirmed by the Supreme Court",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-reformed-presbyterian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor and head of an unlicensed theology school/seminary"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"recruitment through promise of free theological education and pastoral training",
"labor reframed as religious/spiritual training obligation",
"minors' belief that construction labor served a religious purpose"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Regional Trial Court, Branch 61, Angeles City, Pampanga, Philippines",
"stage": "trial conviction",
"date": "2017-07-07",
"outcome": "Si Young Oh a.k.a. 'Steve Oh', a South Korean pastor who headed an unlicensed theology school in Pampanga, was convicted of qualified trafficking in persons under RA 9208 for recruiting three minors with promises of a free Bachelor of Theology degree and pastoral training, then compelling them to perform unpaid construction labor from 8 a.m. to 3 a.m., justified to the victims as spiritual training. Sentenced to life imprisonment and a PHP 1,000,000 fine."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Court of Appeals, CA-G.R. CR-HC No. 09864, Philippines",
"stage": "appeal",
"date": "2021-02-10",
"outcome": "Affirmed the conviction with modification, increasing the fine to PHP 2,000,000 and awarding PHP 100,000 each in moral and exemplary damages to the victims."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of the Philippines, Third Division, G.R. No. 262632",
"stage": "final appeal",
"date": "2024-06-05",
"outcome": "Affirmed the conviction and life sentence in full, finding that Oh 'weaponized' the victims' religious beliefs and that no actual theology program existed at the unlicensed institution."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Three minors were recruited from South Korea's diaspora network in the Philippines with the promise of free theological education and a path to ordained ministry. Once inside the institution, they were subjected to grueling unpaid construction labor which Oh, as their pastor and the school's head, framed to them as spiritual training rather than exploitation — the promise of ordination and their belief in the religious legitimacy of the labor is what made refusal and disclosure difficult for minors far from home.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocs/1/69549",
"archive": "",
"citation": "People of the Philippines v. Si Young Oh a.k.a. 'Steve Oh', G.R. No. 262632, Supreme Court of the Philippines, Third Division (June 5, 2024).",
"body": "Full Supreme Court decision affirming the RTC conviction and CA modification, detailing the recruitment of three minors under promise of free theological education, the unlicensed nature of the 'seminary', the forced unpaid construction labor reframed as spiritual training, and the life sentence.",
"tier": "official-final-court-decision",
"kind": "supreme-court-decision"
},
{
"link": "https://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/sc-upholds-life-sentence-for-south-korean-pastor-convicted-of-trafficking-minors/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'SC Upholds Life Sentence for South Korean Pastor Convicted of Trafficking Minors', Supreme Court of the Philippines Public Information Office, 21 Oct. 2024.",
"body": "Official Supreme Court press release summarizing the affirmed conviction, the trafficking findings, and the exploitation of the victims' religious beliefs.",
"tier": "official-court-press-release",
"kind": "verdict-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1994898/supreme-court-affirms-pastors-life-sentence-for-trafficking-of-minors",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Supreme Court affirms pastor's life sentence for trafficking of minors', Philippine Daily Inquirer, 21 Oct. 2024.",
"body": "National press report of the Supreme Court decision, including the 2013 DSWD/NBI rescue operation and case timeline.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Court of Appeals, CA-G.R. CR-HC No. 09864, affirmed with modification on Feb. 10, 2021 (fine and damages increased); Supreme Court, Third Division, G.R. No. 262632, affirmed on June 5, 2024."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocs/1/69549",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-final-court-decision; evidentiary role: supreme-court-decision.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/sc-upholds-life-sentence-for-south-korean-pastor-convicted-of-trafficking-minors/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-court-press-release; evidentiary role: verdict-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1994898/supreme-court-affirms-pastors-life-sentence-for-trafficking-of-minors",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "418e5443b51726305079b3e064596b69c09183ed9c6685e97981ad52d129ec89",
"final_url": "https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1994898/supreme-court-affirms-pastors-life-sentence-for-trafficking-of-minors"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1178,
"aliases": [
"Govinda"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Second defendant Radhe (dholak/drum accompanist) convicted as co-principal, not merely an accomplice; both received identical sentences. Victim not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-govind-das-katha-kidnapping-sagar-madhya-pradesh-india",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Khurai, Sagar District, Madhya Pradesh, India",
"lat": 23.8397,
"lng": 78.3286,
"title": "India: itinerant religious preacher (kathavachak) sentenced to life for kidnapping and repeatedly raping a girl he met while conducting a temple storytelling event",
"tradition": "hinduism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-hindu",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"kathavachak (itinerant religious storyteller/preacher) conducting a katha (religious narrative) event"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious storytelling event used as the point of contact and manipulation",
"kidnapping and roughly two-to-three months' captivity following the religious event",
"repeated sexual assault during captivity"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Third Additional District and Sessions Court, Khurai, Sagar District, Madhya Pradesh, India",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2026-07-17",
"outcome": "Judge Sandhya Manoj Srivastava convicted kathavachak Govind Das (alias Govinda), of Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh, and his associate Radhe, of Tikamgarh, of kidnapping and repeatedly raping a 16-year-old girl the pair encountered at a religious katha event Das conducted in February 2025. The girl was held roughly two to three months from 13 February 2025. Both were sentenced to life imprisonment under Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Section 70(2) (gang rape) with a fine of ₹2,000 each, 20 years' rigorous imprisonment under POCSO Act Sections 5(l)/6 with a fine of ₹2,000 each, and 7 years' rigorous imprisonment under Section 96 (kidnapping) with a fine of ₹1,000 each, sentences to run concurrently."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim's family encountered Das in his capacity as a religious preacher conducting a katha (sacred-narrative recitation) event, a role that gave him standing and access within the community; he used that access as the point of manipulation before kidnapping the girl.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.amarujala.com/madhya-pradesh/sagar/khurai-court-sentences-preacher-partner-to-life-until-last-breath-for-assaulting-minor-sagar-news-c-1-1-noi1338-4510909-2026-07-17",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'कथावाचक और ढोलक वादक को अंतिम सांस तक जेल की सजा' [\"Preacher and drum accompanist sentenced to life\"], Amar Ujala, 17 Jul. 2026.",
"body": "Hindi-language report of the Khurai sessions court judgment, naming both defendants, the judge, the specific statutory sections and sentences, the February 2025 katha event as point of contact, and the roughly two-to-three-month captivity.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.amarujala.com/madhya-pradesh/sagar/khurai-court-sentences-preacher-partner-to-life-until-last-breath-for-assaulting-minor-sagar-news-c-1-1-noi1338-4510909-2026-07-17",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bc97d38a8fe6eaa4ca921f8c5f0f938540754d5ceddad815e30dd36cce581b4b",
"final_url": "https://www.amarujala.com/madhya-pradesh/sagar/khurai-court-sentences-preacher-partner-to-life-until-last-breath-for-assaulting-minor-sagar-news-c-1-1-noi1338-4510909-2026-07-17"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1179,
"aliases": [
"Brother Vincent"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Society of Saint Pius X is a traditionalist Catholic priestly society not in full communion with Rome; recorded under christian-catholic as the closest available detail id, consistent with corpus handling of Catholic-tradition splinter and traditionalist groups. Sentence was non-custodial (community work plus supervision); this is stated exactly and not represented as imprisonment.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-herbert-rustila-sspx-whanganui-new-zealand",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Whanganui, New Zealand",
"lat": -39.9301,
"lng": 175.0499,
"title": "New Zealand: Society of Saint Pius X religious brother convicted of sexually abusing an altar boy he supervised at a parish school",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"religious brother of the Society of Saint Pius X supervising altar servers at a parish school"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious brother's supervisory authority over an altar boy's church duties",
"normalization of physical affection during religious duties",
"enticement with treats during cleaning/mass-preparation tasks"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX)",
"Saint Anthony's School, Whanganui"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Whanganui District Court, New Zealand",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2025-04-01",
"outcome": "Herbert Simo Rustila, 38, a religious brother of the Society of Saint Pius X known as 'Brother Vincent', pleaded guilty in February 2025 to a representative charge of sexual conduct with a boy under 16 who served as an altar boy at Saint Anthony's School, Whanganui, over 2018-2022 starting when the boy was 12. Sentenced 1 April 2025 to 200 hours' community work and two years' intensive supervision with electronic monitoring, and prohibited from unsupervised contact with minors."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Rustila was a religious brother supervising the victim's altar-server duties, using cleaning and mass-preparation tasks as points of contact and enticing the boy with treats while normalizing physical affection as part of accepted conduct for a boy serving the church under a religious brother's direction.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2025/04/church-brother-guilty-of-sexual-conduct-with-altar-boy/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Church Brother Guilty of Sexual Conduct with Altar Boy', BishopAccountability.org, Apr. 2025 (citing New Zealand press).",
"body": "Report of the Whanganui District Court guilty plea and sentencing, naming Rustila/Brother Vincent, the SSPX affiliation, Saint Anthony's School, the offense period, and the community-work/supervision sentence.",
"tier": "national-press-repost",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2025/04/church-brother-guilty-of-sexual-conduct-with-altar-boy/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press-repost; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f70e224acafd1e3b17513910a2f4d58ae76661551e4a3395cb912f006bd58ac0",
"final_url": "https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2025/04/church-brother-guilty-of-sexual-conduct-with-altar-boy/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1180,
"aliases": [
"Rev. Kevin Rietveld"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Sentencing figures as reported: individual counts ranged six to twelve months producing a head sentence of four years two months; totality-principle and custody-time deductions of fourteen months produced a final term of three years. Both figures given exactly as reported rather than reconciled by this record. Victims not identified.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-kevin-rietveld-swim-mission-solomon-islands",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Solomon Islands",
"lat": -9.6457,
"lng": 160.1562,
"title": "Solomon Islands: Australian mission director and pastor jailed for indecently assaulting girls supported by his mission",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-reformed-presbyterian",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"pastor, reverend and Director of SWIM (Small Workshop in Mission), a mission of the Christian Reformed Churches of Australia"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"mission director's authority over girls whose families received the mission's financial support",
"pastoral/reverend standing within the mission community"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"SWIM (Small Workshop in Mission)",
"Christian Reformed Churches of Australia"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Magistrates' Court, Solomon Islands",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentence",
"date": "2019-08-01",
"outcome": "Principal Magistrate Felix Hollison sentenced Australian missionary Rev. Kevin Rietveld, 72, to a final term of three years' imprisonment after he pleaded guilty to seven counts of indecent assault against four underage local girls, committed between 2010 and 2012 while he was Director of SWIM, a pastor and reverend in the mission, and the girls' families were financially supported by the mission. Individual sentences of six to twelve months produced a head sentence of four years two months before deductions for the totality principle and time in custody."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Rietveld was the pastor and director of the mission that financially supported the victims' families, giving him standing and unsupervised access to the girls as a trusted religious authority within the small mission community; the allegations did not surface until after he left the country in 2012.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.solomonstarnews.com/missionary-jailed/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'MISSIONARY JAILED', Solomon Star News, 2019.",
"body": "Solomon Islands national press report of the Magistrates' Court sentencing, naming Rietveld, his SWIM directorship and pastoral role, the seven counts, the four victims financially supported by the mission, and the three-year final sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/395750/solomons-missionary-charged-with-indecently-assaulting-young-girls",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Solomons' missionary charged with indecently assaulting young girls', RNZ Pacific, 2019.",
"body": "Reports Rietveld's arrest and charging, his 1998-2012 tenure as SWIM director, and the Christian Reformed Churches of Australia affiliation.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "charging-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.solomonstarnews.com/missionary-jailed/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/395750/solomons-missionary-charged-with-indecently-assaulting-young-girls",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: charging-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "ec5500012505db066164e31ad4215caeaed044030f457f7385795aae7c0835da",
"final_url": "https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/395750/solomons-missionary-charged-with-indecently-assaulting-young-girls"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1181,
"aliases": [
"Mo. Ismail"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Bangladesh capital sentences of this kind are subject to mandatory High Court confirmation and connected appeals; no appellate disposition was located at time of writing. This record does not present the sentence as final. Distinct from the already-held 2025-riad-uddin-hifz-madrasa-lohagara-chattogram-bangladesh record: different teacher, different tribunal (Tribunal-5 vs Tribunal-2), different victim (12-year-old day student vs 9-year-old residential student), different sentence (death vs life).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mo-ismail-huffaz-madrasa-lohagara-chattogram-bangladesh",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Lohagara, Chattogram, Bangladesh",
"lat": 22.1667,
"lng": 92.05,
"title": "Bangladesh: madrasa Huffaz-department teacher sentenced to death for raping a twelve-year-old student",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"madrasa teacher, Huffaz (Quran-memorization) department"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious-school teacher's authority over a student at the madrasa"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Madrasa, Charambar area, Lohagara upazila, Chattogram"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Women and Child Repression Tribunal-5, Chattogram, Bangladesh",
"stage": "trial verdict",
"date": "2025-10-13",
"outcome": "Judge Saidur Rahman Gazi convicted Mo. Ismail, 46, a teacher in the Huffaz (Quran-memorization) department of a madrasa in Lohagara's Charambar area, of raping a 12-year-old student on 26 September 2022. Sentenced to death, plus a fine of one lakh taka (with a further year's imprisonment in default of payment). The madrasa administration surrendered the teacher to police after the assault came to light."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a student in the Huffaz section under the accused's direct religious-instructional authority at the madrasa where the assault occurred.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/district/x1ydmez5vp",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'শিশু ধর্ষণের মামলায় মাদ্রাসাশিক্ষকের মৃত্যুদণ্ডাদেশ' [\"Death sentence for madrasa teacher in child rape case\"], Prothom Alo, 13 Oct. 2025.",
"body": "Bangla-language report of the Tribunal-5 verdict, naming Ismail, his Huffaz-department teaching role, the 2022 assault date, and the death sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/district/x1ydmez5vp",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0e2b69ee0d75d53fd429f6992ae0830e3b9f18dd97118433886143965d13acde",
"final_url": "https://www.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/district/x1ydmez5vp"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1182,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "\"Mr Garnier\" IS A PSEUDONYM ASSIGNED BY THE COMMISSION, not the man's real name — footnote 23 to paragraph 195 states plainly \"This is a pseudonym.\" This record therefore documents a conviction that is established but an individual who is not publicly identified, and it should never be read as naming anyone. The Report states at Vol 2 Ch 3 para 195 that he \"was convicted of sexually abusing a 15-year-old boy from Ferryhouse Industrial School on a number of dates in the mid-1970s\", giving neither the court nor the sentence; paragraphs 196-207 describe the same man, a voluntary worker from Clonmel present through the 1970s who spoke to the Gardai about his involvement and who, at para 207, denied allegations of fondling and masturbation but admitted sexual contact with two boys. That admission is recorded in the Committee's evidentiary summary and is not explicitly stated to have been made in Garda interview. Resolves one of the two threads left open in the Ferryhouse chapter.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1970s-mr-garnier-ferryhouse-ryan-report-ireland",
"year": 1975,
"place": "Clonmel, County Tipperary, Ireland",
"lat": 52.3547,
"lng": -7.7009,
"title": "Ireland: Ryan Report records the conviction of a Ferryhouse volunteer worker, pseudonymised as 'Mr Garnier', for abusing a 15-year-old boy",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"long-serving voluntary worker embedded in the industrial school",
"outsider granted dormitory access via a Brother's personal friendship"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"years-long presence at the school built trust with staff and boys",
"friendship with the Brother managing 'C' Group secured unsupervised dormitory access",
"gifts, outings and treats used to draw boys into contact outside supervision"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"St Joseph's Industrial School, Ferryhouse (Rosminian Fathers)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Ireland (Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse / Ryan Report record)",
"stage": "conviction",
"outcome": "The Ryan Report states plainly: 'Mr Garnier was convicted of sexually abusing a 15-year-old boy from Ferryhouse Industrial School on a number of dates in the mid-1970s.' He separately admitted to the Gardai having had sexual contact with two boys at the school; the report does not give the court, sentence or exact date of the conviction."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Garnier was not a Brother but a lay volunteer who worked his way into years of trusted, unsupervised access to the boys of Ferryhouse industrial school through his friendship with Br Leone, who managed the dormitory group Garnier had 'particular contact with'. The Report frames this as the institution's own failure: 'There is an enormous difference between involvement by the community in the running of the Institution, and allowing outsiders to enter the boys' dormitories and to spend time there on a frequent basis' — but it was the Institution's religious authority structure, not Garnier's own office, that manufactured the access and the boys' inability to refuse or report him.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=13",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, Report (Ryan Report), Vol. 2, Ch. 3 (Ferryhouse), para. 195.",
"body": "States: 'Mr Garnier was convicted of sexually abusing a 15-year-old boy from Ferryhouse Industrial School on a number of dates in the mid-1970s.'",
"tier": "official-inquiry-record",
"kind": "conviction-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=14",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, Report (Ryan Report), Vol. 2, Ch. 3 (Ferryhouse), para. 196.",
"body": "Describes Garnier's role as a voluntary worker from Clonmel with 'free access everywhere in the Institution, even in the dormitories,' and his particular contact with the group managed by his friend Br Leone.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-record",
"kind": "institutional-access-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=14",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, Report (Ryan Report), Vol. 2, Ch. 3 (Ferryhouse), para. 238.",
"body": "Confirms Garnier admitted sexual contact with two boys and records the Report's finding that outsider access to the dormitories, as distinct from Brothers' own involvement, was an institutional failure.",
"tier": "official-inquiry-record",
"kind": "corroboration"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=13",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-record; evidentiary role: conviction-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "783253e2f75651d98c7f1fb990d278cbd64d3c9dbdcbd23d238aeb074f782a88",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=13"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=14",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-record; evidentiary role: institutional-access-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5100afbee3b2c00b69d7a458036215b65e9af977067a63a4811a965c08816802",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=14"
},
{
"source": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=14",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-inquiry-record; evidentiary role: corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "5100afbee3b2c00b69d7a458036215b65e9af977067a63a4811a965c08816802",
"final_url": "https://industrialmemories.ucd.ie/ryan-report/report/2-3?page=14"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9001,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event / official-finding record, not a criminal conviction. recordClass set to institutional-event because evidenceStatus is official-finding, not convicted.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2014-preston-down-trust-charity-commission-exclusive-brethren-uk",
"year": 2014,
"place": "Preston Down, Paignton, Devon, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 50.4333,
"lng": -3.5667,
"title": "UK Charity Commission finds Exclusive Brethren separation doctrine causes detriment to withdrawn members and children, conditions charitable registration on doctrinal change",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Exclusive Brethren (Plymouth Brethren Christian Church) elders and the community's doctrine of separation, exercised over members and their families"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"doctrine of 'separation from evil' mandating shunning ('withdrawal') of anyone excommunicated or who leaves",
"shunned members cut off from spouse, children, parents and all fellowship contact",
"restricted life opportunities and education for children raised inside the community",
"threat of total relational severance used to compel continued membership and compliance"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Preston Down Trust",
"Exclusive Brethren / Plymouth Brethren Christian Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Charity Commission for England and Wales",
"stage": "official-finding; registration decision",
"date": "2014-01-09",
"outcome": "The Charity Commission published its decision on the Preston Down Trust's application for charitable registration, first refused in 2012. The Commission's reasoning documented that the doctrine of separation, applied through shunning ('withdrawal') of excommunicated or departing members, caused serious harm to those cut off and limited the life opportunities of children raised in the community, and that this harm had to be weighed against and could outweigh any public benefit. The Trust was registered only after amending its governing trust deed to add express commitments to compassion, forgiveness and community engagement; the Commission stated the outcome was conditional on the PBCC addressing the identified harms through this doctrinal-document change, not a simple climb-down."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The finding is precisely on point: a state regulator examined the sect's own doctrine of separation and found, as an official matter of record, that the shunning it mandates operates as a mechanism of serious harm on members bound by it and their children — textbook isolation/dependency (I3) and supernatural-consequence leverage (I4) operating through the community's spiritual authority over its own membership, not a third party.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a74c214e5274a3cb2866f23/preston_down_trust_full_decision.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Charity Commission for England and Wales: Preston Down Trust, full decision, 9 January 2014.",
"body": "The Commission's full published decision on registration, including its findings on the doctrine of separation and detriment to withdrawn members and children.",
"tier": "government-regulatory-decision",
"kind": "official-finding"
},
{
"link": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/preston-down-trust/preston-down-trust-charity-commission-decision-brief-summary",
"archive": "",
"citation": "GOV.UK: Preston Down Trust — Charity Commission decision, brief summary.",
"body": "Official government summary of the registration decision and its conditions.",
"tier": "government-regulatory-decision",
"kind": "official-summary"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thirdsector.co.uk/preston-down-trust-decision-not-climb-down-says-charity-commission/governance/article/1229891",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Third Sector: 'Preston Down Trust decision was not a climb-down, says Charity Commission'.",
"body": "Sector press confirming the conditional nature of the registration and the doctrinal-harm reasoning behind it.",
"tier": "trade-press-court-reporting",
"kind": "context-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a74c214e5274a3cb2866f23/preston_down_trust_full_decision.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-regulatory-decision; evidentiary role: official-finding.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bfcd0b7ea06fc7a559d3ca1562cdc3e775465bf36ec9fbbf0c991d5c2c1dbc0a",
"final_url": "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a74c214e5274a3cb2866f23/preston_down_trust_full_decision.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/preston-down-trust/preston-down-trust-charity-commission-decision-brief-summary",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: government-regulatory-decision; evidentiary role: official-summary.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0d828e6154e82ca646431c5a185e63d9c33b5d8e09c19ab38332a5d7f9c3cebe",
"final_url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/preston-down-trust/preston-down-trust-charity-commission-decision-brief-summary"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thirdsector.co.uk/preston-down-trust-decision-not-climb-down-says-charity-commission/governance/article/1229891",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: trade-press-court-reporting; evidentiary role: context-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "cba824802fce91282f12846edbf5c9083c9301b734352d8b729f862df29b19c5",
"final_url": "https://www.thirdsector.co.uk/preston-down-trust-decision-not-climb-down-says-charity-commission/governance/article/1229891"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9002,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event / official-finding record covering the Jesus Fellowship (Jesus Army) Redress Scheme's independent final report, distinct from the individual criminal convictions of members recorded separately in this file.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-jesus-fellowship-redress-scheme-final-report-uk",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Bugbrooke, Northamptonshire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.2333,
"lng": -0.9833,
"title": "Jesus Fellowship (Jesus Army) Redress Scheme final report finds abuse endemic across community, names founder Noel Stanton among 539 accused",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "institutional-event",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"authorityRoles": [
"Jesus Fellowship Community Trust leadership, including founder and leader Noel Stanton (1926-2009), exercising doctrinal and communal authority over members living in shared households"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"communal-living structure placing members, including children, inside households controlled by church leaders and elders",
"doctrine binding members to the community and to leaders' spiritual authority, discouraging disclosure and outside reporting",
"founder's charismatic and doctrinal authority shielding him and other leaders from accountability for decades"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [
"Jesus Fellowship Community Trust",
"Jesus Army / Jesus Fellowship Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Jesus Fellowship Redress Scheme (independent scheme established after the church's 2019 dissolution)",
"stage": "official-finding; independent redress scheme final report",
"date": "2024-09-10",
"outcome": "The independently administered Redress Scheme published its final report on 10 September 2024 after processing 890 applications from 601 individuals and paying out approximately £7.761 million in compensation for abuse spanning the 1970s to the 2010s. The report identified 539 alleged abusers, with the Trust acknowledging responsibility for 264 of them, 61% of whom were former church leaders, and estimated that one in six children in the community were sexually abused. It recorded 31 separate incidents of abuse attributed to founder Noel Stanton and found that harm was not confined to a few leaders or a limited period but was systemic across the community's history."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "An independent scheme created specifically because the church's own communal-authority structure had produced and concealed abuse at scale; the report is an official finding that Stanton's and the leadership's spiritual authority over co-resident members, including children with no life outside the community, was the operative mechanism, not merely the setting.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://jesus.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Jesus-Fellowship-Redress-Scheme-Final-Report.pdf",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Jesus Fellowship Redress Scheme: Final Report, published 10 September 2024.",
"body": "The scheme's own final report: scale of applications, compensation paid, number of accused, and findings on Noel Stanton and systemic failure.",
"tier": "official-finding-primary-report",
"kind": "final-report"
},
{
"link": "https://premierchristian.news/en/news/article/jesus-army-pays-out-over-abuse-claims",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Premier Christian News: 'Jesus Army Redress Scheme pays out £7.7M over abuse claims'.",
"body": "News summary of the final report's headline findings and payout figures.",
"tier": "national-religious-press",
"kind": "context-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://jesus.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Jesus-Fellowship-Redress-Scheme-Final-Report.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-finding-primary-report; evidentiary role: final-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6d452227d5311be0be2ec9abb04ff3c7ccba69d2f72af57c15a6894fbe4e45e1",
"final_url": "https://jesus.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Jesus-Fellowship-Redress-Scheme-Final-Report.pdf"
},
{
"source": "https://premierchristian.news/en/news/article/jesus-army-pays-out-over-abuse-claims",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-religious-press; evidentiary role: context-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "589df26aa454e77ac21920c7f53abc63b52c877fb6e1b65cbfc8fe5c437b4071",
"final_url": "https://premierchristian.news/en/news/article/jesus-army-pays-out-over-abuse-claims"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9003,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Victims were the defendant's own goddaughters/wards under his welfare responsibility within the Brethren, not his biological children — paternal-nexus trap checked and does not apply. The Brethren's own investigation and shunning response is documented and central to spiritualNexus.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2007-lindsay-jensen-exclusive-brethren-albury-nsw-australia",
"year": 2007,
"place": "Albury, New South Wales, Australia",
"lat": -36.0737,
"lng": 146.9135,
"title": "Australia: Exclusive Brethren man convicted of sexually assaulting two girls he was responsible for under sect welfare arrangements",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Exclusive Brethren member entrusted with welfare responsibility for the victims within the sect's community structure"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position of trust and welfare responsibility over the girls assigned by the closed community",
"Brethren doctrine of separation isolating members from outside reporting channels and non-Brethren authorities",
"internal Brethren investigation that dismissed and sought to discredit the older victim's complaint, followed by temporary readmission of Jensen's family before disclosure reached non-Brethren school staff"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Exclusive Brethren"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Penrith District Court, New South Wales, Australia",
"stage": "conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2007-02-16",
"outcome": "Lindsay Ronald Jensen was convicted of four counts of indecent assault and one count of sexual intercourse without consent against a girl aged nine at the time of the offending, and later received an additional one-year sentence on 14 April 2007 for aggravated indecent assault against a second girl, aged twelve, also within the Brethren community. He was sentenced to a total of six years with a three-year non-parole period, becoming eligible for parole in December 2010."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victims were inside the closed community's own welfare and trust structure, assigned to Jensen's care by Brethren arrangement; when the older victim disclosed, the Brethren's internal process investigated and dismissed the complaint and temporarily readmitted his family, only escalating to outside authorities once non-Brethren school staff intervened — the isolation from external reporting channels (I3) that the doctrine of separation produces is what let the abuse continue and be handled internally rather than reported. The sect later applied its worldwide shunning policy to Jensen and his family.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://aussiesexoffenders.wordpress.com/2012/11/28/lindsay-ronald-jensen/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Aussie Sex Offenders registry entry: Lindsay Ronald Jensen, compiling Penrith District Court sentencing reports.",
"body": "Compiles the court dates, charges, sentence and the Brethren's internal handling of the initial complaint and subsequent shunning.",
"tier": "sex-offender-registry-court-compilation",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://aussiesexoffenders.wordpress.com/2012/11/28/lindsay-ronald-jensen/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: sex-offender-registry-court-compilation; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3d28b907f393e8201f6ffae6499527d1ac9e8bec4b4b0583e0cf9141da53f5d6",
"final_url": "https://aussiesexoffenders.wordpress.com/2012/11/28/lindsay-ronald-jensen/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9004,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Part of the Northamptonshire Police Operation Lifeboat investigation into the Jesus Fellowship / Jesus Army. Victim was a fellow community member's child within shared communal housing, not the defendant's own child.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-alan-carter-jesus-army-northampton-uk",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Northampton, Northamptonshire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.2405,
"lng": -0.9027,
"title": "United Kingdom: Jesus Army member convicted of indecent assault and buggery of a boy in the community during the 1990s",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Jesus Army community member sharing communal housing and doctrinal fellowship authority over a fellow member's child"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"communal-living structure placing children in shared households with adult members outside their parents' direct oversight",
"sect doctrine discouraging disclosure and outside reporting during the offending period"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jesus Army / Jesus Fellowship Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Northampton Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2018-04-18",
"outcome": "Alan Carter, then 57 and living in Swansea, was convicted at Northampton Crown Court, having faced seven charges of indecent assault against a male and a further charge of buggery, for offences against a boy committed in the early 1990s while both were members of the Jesus Army. He was sentenced to three years in prison as part of the Operation Lifeboat investigation into abuse within the sect."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The offending occurred inside the Jesus Army's communal households, where doctrine and shared fellowship placed children under the informal authority of adult members without their parents' direct oversight — the same communal structure the Redress Scheme's final report later identified as the systemic mechanism enabling abuse across the community.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.northamptonchron.co.uk/news/former-member-of-northamptonshires-jesus-army-member-jailed-for-historic-sex-offences-1035977",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Northampton Chronicle and Echo: 'Former member of Northamptonshire's Jesus Army member jailed for historic sex offences'.",
"body": "Local court report naming Carter, the charges and the three-year sentence.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.northamptonchron.co.uk/news/former-member-of-northamptonshires-jesus-army-member-jailed-for-historic-sex-offences-1035977",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "23999f0ede5b91642be8e7891290253201b23bdab2dc357e6ef94c43b156ae45",
"final_url": "https://www.northamptonchron.co.uk/news/former-member-of-northamptonshires-jesus-army-member-jailed-for-historic-sex-offences-1035977"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9005,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Part of the Operation Lifeboat investigation. Victims were fellow community members' children encountered during shared communal life (walks, shared dormitory), not the defendant's own children.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2017-nigel-perkins-jesus-army-northampton-uk",
"year": 2017,
"place": "Northampton, Northamptonshire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.2405,
"lng": -0.9027,
"title": "United Kingdom: Jesus Army 'transient member' convicted of indecent assault and gross indecency against boys sharing a communal dormitory",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Jesus Army community member sharing communal dormitory living with the child victims"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"shared dormitory and communal-living arrangements bringing adult and child members into unsupervised proximity",
"convinced victims not to disclose the abuse, causing long-lasting emotional damage per the sentencing court"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jesus Army / Jesus Fellowship Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Northampton Crown Court, England",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "2017-03-24",
"outcome": "Nigel Perkins, 56, of Penzance, Cornwall, pleaded guilty at Northampton Crown Court to three counts of indecent assault and two counts of gross indecency with a child under 14, committed over six years during the 1980s while he and his victims were members of the Jesus Army. He was sentenced to three years in prison and made subject to lifetime registration as a sex offender, arrested as part of the Northamptonshire Police Operation Lifeboat investigation into abuse within the sect."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The court heard the assaults happened opportunistically on walks or in the dormitory the boys shared with Perkins as fellow sect members — the communal structure of shared, unsupervised living the Jesus Army's doctrine mandated is what put the children in his reach and let him instruct them not to talk about it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.northamptonchron.co.uk/news/jesus-army-sex-offender-who-was-based-in-northamptonshire-sentenced-for-string-of-indecent-acts-directed-at-children-in-1980s-860901",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Northampton Chronicle and Echo: 'Jesus Army sex offender who was based in Northamptonshire sentenced for string of indecent acts directed at children in 1980s'.",
"body": "Local court report naming Perkins, the guilty plea, charges and sentence.",
"tier": "local-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.northamptonchron.co.uk/news/jesus-army-sex-offender-who-was-based-in-northamptonshire-sentenced-for-string-of-indecent-acts-directed-at-children-in-1980s-860901",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1bd9c4e04d11ef9cb72a306a24c62aa9da2e0d8a355e1958bb0c949fedf48f03",
"final_url": "https://www.northamptonchron.co.uk/news/jesus-army-sex-offender-who-was-based-in-northamptonshire-sentenced-for-string-of-indecent-acts-directed-at-children-in-1980s-860901"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9006,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Part of the Operation Lifeboat investigation. Both victims were unrelated children within Jesus Army communal houses, encountered as a fellow resident.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-clifford-brett-jesus-army-northampton-preston-uk",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Northampton, Northamptonshire, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 52.2405,
"lng": -0.9027,
"title": "United Kingdom: elderly Jesus Army member jailed for sexually abusing two boys at sect communal houses",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-other",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"Jesus Army community member resident in communal houses shared with the child victims"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"communal 'household' living arrangement placing an unrelated adult member in the same house as young children",
"targeted one boy while he slept and lured a second to a bedroom under pretext"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Jesus Army / Jesus Fellowship Church"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Northampton Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentencing",
"date": "2016-11-01",
"outcome": "Clifford Brett, 66, of Northampton, was jailed for five years total — four years for abusing one boy who was targeted as he slept at a Jesus Army house in Preston, and a further twelve months for luring a second boy, still of primary school age, to his bedroom. Both offences occurred at Jesus Army communal houses and were prosecuted as part of Operation Lifeboat."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Both victims were small children placed by their families' membership into the Jesus Army's shared communal households, where the sect's doctrine of common life put them in the same house as an unrelated adult member with no independent supervision — the mechanism the Redress Scheme later found systemic across the community.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.lep.co.uk/news/crime/oap-jailed-for-abusing-young-boys-at-jesus-army-homes-775725",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Lancashire Post: 'OAP jailed for abusing young boys at Jesus Army homes'.",
"body": "Court report naming Brett, describing both offences and the five-year total sentence.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.lep.co.uk/news/crime/oap-jailed-for-abusing-young-boys-at-jesus-army-homes-775725",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "41db9b1bb266ecbd8215eeb0f1ad9051b5cb6a5a53a849a44cf0172c6d3fcc7c",
"final_url": "https://www.lep.co.uk/news/crime/oap-jailed-for-abusing-young-boys-at-jesus-army-homes-775725"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1189,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2026-05-26",
"note": "Conviction and ten-year sentence upheld; appeal dismissed."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from the corpus's existing Thambuttegama chief-monk record (different hermitage, different victim, different court). Appellate-affirmed as of May 2026.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-uduwila-sujatha-balapitiya-sri-lanka",
"year": 2023,
"place": "Balapitiya, Galle District, Sri Lanka",
"lat": 6.25,
"lng": 80.0333,
"title": "Sri Lanka: forest-hermitage chief incumbent convicted of raping a nine-year-old boy resident at the temple",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"chief incumbent of a forest hermitage (Buddhist monk)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic authority over a child resident at the temple",
"status as the boy's spiritual guardian and de facto custodian within the hermitage"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Sri Lankan forest-hermitage monastic order (unnamed hermitage)"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Balapitiya High Court, Sri Lanka; Court of Appeal",
"stage": "conviction and sentence; appeal dismissed",
"date": "2023-08-01",
"outcome": "Rev. Uduwila Sujatha, chief incumbent of a forest hermitage, was convicted of grave sexual abuse of a nine-year-old boy who was living at the temple at the time. The offences occurred in 2009; the Attorney General filed indictments only in 2019, and the Balapitiya High Court convicted and sentenced him in August 2023 to ten years' rigorous imprisonment, a Rs 20,000 fine, and Rs 200,000 compensation to the victim. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal against conviction and sentence on 26 May 2026, finding the defence's claimed contradictions insufficient to undermine the prosecution's case."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim was a child resident of the hermitage under the chief incumbent's direct monastic care and authority; that custodial-spiritual position is what gave him unsupervised access.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newswire.lk/2026/05/27/monk-to-serve-10-years-as-court-dismisses-appeal-against-conviction/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Monk to serve 10 years as Court dismisses appeal against conviction', Newswire.lk (27 May 2026).",
"body": "Reporting the Court of Appeal's dismissal, restating the 2023 Balapitiya High Court conviction, sentence and fine.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/14248/court-upholds-10-year-prison-sentence-against-monk-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Court upholds 10-year prison sentence against monk in child sexual abuse case', Asian Mirror (2026).",
"body": "Corroborating report of the same appellate ruling and original 2023 sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-judgment-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"stage": "court-of-appeal",
"date": "2026-05-26",
"note": "Conviction and ten-year sentence upheld; appeal dismissed."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newswire.lk/2026/05/27/monk-to-serve-10-years-as-court-dismisses-appeal-against-conviction/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "54998b05c99858e03574e0103cac99966269496326edeb5a2af8f2139a8ca02a",
"final_url": "https://www.newswire.lk/2026/05/27/monk-to-serve-10-years-as-court-dismisses-appeal-against-conviction/"
},
{
"source": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/14248/court-upholds-10-year-prison-sentence-against-monk-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f7e82704d68bcedd58f460f1f2b5461da7286f8119361c6dcdeaff4f4dbcf038",
"final_url": "https://asianmirror.lk/news/court-upholds-10-year-prison-sentence-against-monk-in-child-sexual-abuse-case/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1190,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Japanese Pure Land tradition, not Tibetan/Vajrayana; included because the guru-teacher-authority mechanism and evidence tier (Crown Court conviction) are identical in kind to the lane's core thesis.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-koji-takeuchi-nottinghamshire-uk",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Nottinghamshire / Hove, England, United Kingdom",
"lat": 53,
"lng": -1.15,
"title": "United Kingdom: self-styled 'Buddha Maitreya' meditation-centre teacher convicted of indecently assaulting students' daughters",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"founder and teacher, Pure Land meditation centre (self-styled 'Buddha Maitreya')"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as the girls' family's spiritual teacher",
"access to students' children through the meditation centre and its associated Japanese garden retreat"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"organizations": [
"Pure Land meditation centre, Nottinghamshire"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hove Crown Court, England",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2022-09-22",
"outcome": "Koji Takeuchi, who styled himself 'Buddha Maitreya' and ran a Pure Land meditation centre and Japanese garden in Nottinghamshire, was sentenced at Hove Crown Court to a total of 24 months (14 months concurrent for two Brighton-area indecent assaults on two girls aged about 12, plus 10 months consecutive), following an earlier October 2020 conviction for abusing a separate girl from ages 3 to 9. Sentencing judge Jeremy Gold told him the families 'looked to you for spiritual guidance and you repaid them by carrying out' the abuse."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The judge's own sentencing remarks identify the mechanism directly: the victims' families trusted him as their spiritual teacher, and that trust — not mere proximity — is what he used.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.brightonandhovenews.org/2022/09/22/buddhist-monk-jailed-for-sex-attacks-on-girls/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Buddhist monk jailed for sex attacks on girls', Brighton and Hove News (22 Sept. 2022).",
"body": "Sentencing report at Hove Crown Court, including the judge's remarks on spiritual-guidance betrayal and the prior 2020 conviction.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.brightonandhovenews.org/2022/09/22/buddhist-monk-jailed-for-sex-attacks-on-girls/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "8a6c7dfa2e641b2de7744d56b291212b545ca29d6b2b8c0cf99b40317e37cb6f",
"final_url": "https://www.brightonandhovenews.org/2022/09/22/buddhist-monk-jailed-for-sex-attacks-on-girls/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 0,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"note": "Kansas Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and sentence in full, 1994-12-16 (256 Kan. 533)."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from 1999-st-petersburg-fl-usa (Shirley, Florida, 1999): same organizational mechanism (adult DeMolay chapter-advisor authority over the chapter's own teen members) but a different defendant, state, and decade (offense 1992, Kansas). Retained as a separate core record because it documents an independent conviction, not a retelling of the Florida case. Both records together establish that DeMolay's chapter-advisor structure — not Freemasonry generally — has produced more than one stood conviction under this mechanism.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record-added",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "1994-eric-sims-lawrence-ks-usa",
"year": 1992,
"place": "Lawrence, Douglas County, Kansas, USA",
"lat": 38.9717,
"lng": -95.2353,
"title": "US: DeMolay chapter advisor Eric Sims convicted, 70 years to life, for sodomizing and molesting chapter boys he groomed with gifts",
"tradition": "fraternal",
"traditionDetailId": "fraternal-orders",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"DeMolay chapter advisor"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"adult volunteer authority over a fraternal youth chapter",
"grooming through expensive gifts (including $700 suits) modeled on his own grandfather's grooming of him",
"sustained unsupervised access to chapter members over an extended period"
],
"organizations": [
"DeMolay International"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "District Court, Douglas County, Kansas",
"stage": "guilty plea and sentencing",
"date": "1992-12-10",
"outcome": "Pleaded guilty to 7 counts of aggravated criminal sodomy, 4 counts of indecent liberties with a child, and 2 counts of sexual battery (remaining counts dismissed under the plea agreement). Sentenced to 10 years to life on each of the 7 aggravated-sodomy counts, consecutive, plus concurrent lesser terms; controlling sentence 70 years to life."
},
{
"jurisdiction": "Supreme Court of Kansas",
"stage": "direct appeal of sentence",
"date": "1994-12-16",
"outcome": "Affirmed. The court found no reversible error in the trial court's handling of the motion to modify sentence, the record of the guilty-plea finding, or the admission of expert testimony at sentencing. 256 Kan. 533, 887 P.2d 72 (1994)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Sims was an adult volunteer chapter advisor for a local DeMolay chapter (a Masonic-affiliated youth fraternal order) with recognized authority over the boys' activities. The Kansas Supreme Court's opinion records that the abuse arose directly 'from the defendant's conduct while a chapter advisor for DeMolay,' and the State's sentencing-phase psychiatric witness testified that Sims's grooming of the boys 'to fit the image he liked' through his DeMolay role weighed against his treatability. That structural authority over his own chapter's members supplied the sustained, trusted access the record documents — not coincidental acquaintance.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/kansas/supreme-court/1994/70-186-3.html",
"archive": "http://web.archive.org/web/20250722233906/https://law.justia.com/cases/kansas/supreme-court/1994/70-186-3.html",
"citation": "State v. Sims, 256 Kan. 533, 887 P.2d 72 (Kan. 1994).",
"body": "'On August 26, 1992, Eric D. Sims was charged with 14 counts of aggravated criminal sodomy, 8 counts of indecent liberties with a child, 2 counts of sexual battery, and 3 counts of contributing to a child's misconduct or deprivation. The charges arose from the defendant's conduct while a chapter advisor for DeMolay, a youth organization of the Masons.' Sims pleaded guilty to 7 sodomy counts, 4 indecent-liberties counts, and 2 sexual-battery counts; the district court imposed a controlling sentence of 70 years to life. The State's forensic psychiatrist testified that 'the nature of the defendant's involvement with the boys in DeMolay, and his grooming of them to fit the image he liked, weighed against treatability.' The Kansas Supreme Court held: 'We find no reversible error and affirm.'",
"tier": "court-opinion",
"kind": "criminal-disposition-and-nexus"
}
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"other-spiritual-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"note": "Kansas Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and sentence in full, 1994-12-16 (256 Kan. 533)."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/kansas/supreme-court/1994/70-186-3.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: court-opinion; evidentiary role: criminal-disposition-and-nexus.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1192,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-mariusz-w-kielce-poland",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Kielce, Świętokrzyskie, Poland",
"lat": 50.8703,
"lng": 20.6291,
"title": "Poland: former priest Mariusz W. finally convicted of repeatedly abusing a 14-year-old",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"pastoral/spiritual authority over a minor parishioner",
"repeated abuse across multiple locations over a sustained period"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sąd Okręgowy w Kielcach (Regional Court, Kielce)",
"stage": "conviction; appeal upheld (final)",
"outcome": "Former priest Mariusz W. was convicted of sexually abusing a 14-year-old girl at least 15 times between spring and 14 August 2008, in Kielce, Sielpia and Murzasichle. Sentenced to three years' imprisonment, a ten-year ban on work involving the education, care or upbringing of minors, a ten-year no-contact order, and 30,000 złoty compensation to the victim. The regional court upheld the sentence on appeal; the verdict is final. Vatican laicization followed a year after the abuse; the criminal complaint was not filed until 2019, by a diocesan child-protection delegate."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The offender held the victim's trust and access as a Catholic priest at the time of the abuse; laicization preceded prosecution by a decade, illustrating the canonical/criminal gap this corpus tracks separately.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://tvn24.pl/polska/kielce-zapadl-wyrok-w-sprawie-mariusza-w-byly-ksiadz-co-najmniej-15-razy-wykorzystal-dziewczynke-st5733334",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TVN24, 'Kielce. Zapadł wyrok w sprawie Mariusza W. Były ksiądz co najmniej 15 razy wykorzystał dziewczynkę'.",
"body": "Reports the final regional-court verdict: three years' imprisonment, ten-year bans on work with minors and on contact with the victim, and 30,000 złoty compensation, for abuse occurring at least 15 times in 2008 against a girl then 14. Notes the decade-long gap between Vatican laicization and the criminal complaint, the latter filed in May 2019 by the Kielce diocese's child-protection delegate.",
"tier": "national-broadcast-press",
"kind": "conviction-report"
},
{
"link": "https://wiadomosci.wp.pl/swietokrzyskie-byly-ksiadz-skazany-za-pedofilie-wyrok-jest-prawomocny-6774824535714400a",
"archive": "",
"citation": "WP Wiadomości, 'Świętokrzyskie: Były ksiądz skazany za pedofilię. Wyrok jest prawomocny'.",
"body": "Confirms the sentence is final ('wyrok jest prawomocny') and repeats the sentencing detail.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "conviction-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://tvn24.pl/polska/kielce-zapadl-wyrok-w-sprawie-mariusza-w-byly-ksiadz-co-najmniej-15-razy-wykorzystal-dziewczynke-st5733334",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcast-press; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "a212dfbbf5f4fc8b59e3074846644f000287d68c294cbd8b867a797bc21aab85",
"final_url": "https://tvn24.pl/polska/kielce-zapadl-wyrok-w-sprawie-mariusza-w-byly-ksiadz-co-najmniej-15-razy-wykorzystal-dziewczynke-st5733334"
},
{
"source": "https://wiadomosci.wp.pl/swietokrzyskie-byly-ksiadz-skazany-za-pedofilie-wyrok-jest-prawomocny-6774824535714400a",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1193,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-karel-horak-kromeriz-czechia",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Kroměříž, Zlín Region, Czechia",
"lat": 49.2986,
"lng": 17.3933,
"title": "Czechia: priest Karel Hořák's suspended sentence for assaulting a child in the confessional upheld on appeal",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"priest (diocesan, Archdiocese of Olomouc)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"use of the sacrament of confession to gain physical proximity and privacy with the victim",
"clerical/pastoral authority over a child parishioner"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Krajský soud ve Zlíně (first instance); Vrchní soud v Olomouci (appeal)",
"stage": "conviction; appeal upheld (final)",
"date": "2026-03-18",
"outcome": "Priest Karel Hořák was convicted of sexually assaulting a ten-year-old girl in June 2020 inside the confessional of the Church of the Assumption of the Virgin Mary in Kroměříž, pulling at her shirt during confession. First-instance sentence (9 October 2025): three years' imprisonment suspended for a five-year probationary period, a seven-year ban on work with children, and 400,000 Czech crowns compensation to the victim; experts diagnosed a pedophilic disorder. The Olomouc High Court upheld the suspended sentence and the activity ban on appeal on 18 March 2026, adjusting the legal classification. Hořák denied guilt; he was suspended from pastoral duties in February 2021 and remains suspended."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The assault occurred inside the confessional itself during the sacrament of confession — the clerical authority and the physical setting it grants were the direct instrument of the assault, not incidental to it.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://kromerizsky.denik.cz/krimi/kromeriz-knez-zpovednice-utok-divka-podminka-2026.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kroměřížský deník, 'Soud potvrdil knězi z Kroměříže podmínku za útok na dívku ve zpovědnici' (2026).",
"body": "Reports the Olomouc High Court's 18 March 2026 confirmation of the suspended sentence, the seven-year ban on work with children under 15, and the 400,000 CZK compensation order, for the June 2020 assault on a ten-year-old in the confessional. Notes Hořák voluntarily underwent sexological treatment for three years and that his pastoral suspension (since February 2021) continues.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "conviction-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ado.cz/2025/10/09/vyjadreni-olomouckeho-arcibiskupstvi-k-rozsudku-nad-dieceznim-knezem/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Arcibiskupství olomoucké, 'Vyjádření olomouckého arcibiskupství k rozsudku nad diecézním knězem' (9 October 2025).",
"body": "The Archdiocese of Olomouc's own statement responding to the first-instance verdict, confirming the priest's identity, his suspension from ministry, and that the Vatican ordered an administrative penal process in parallel with the criminal case.",
"tier": "institutional-statement",
"kind": "institutional-response"
},
{
"link": "https://www.novinky.cz/clanek/krimi-za-sexualni-utok-na-10-letou-divku-ve-zpovednici-potvrdil-soud-knezi-podminku-40568526",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Novinky.cz, 'Za sexuální útok na 10letou dívku ve zpovědnici potvrdil soud knězi podmínku' (2026).",
"body": "National-press confirmation of the appellate ruling upholding the suspended sentence, activity ban, and compensation.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "conviction-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://kromerizsky.denik.cz/krimi/kromeriz-knez-zpovednice-utok-divka-podminka-2026.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "54eb6c1c9a11781143b6ceef67ba2ce2669147f5fc30513a59857f6a0404ea18",
"final_url": "https://kromerizsky.denik.cz/krimi/kromeriz-knez-zpovednice-utok-divka-podminka-2026/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ado.cz/2025/10/09/vyjadreni-olomouckeho-arcibiskupstvi-k-rozsudku-nad-dieceznim-knezem/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: institutional-statement; evidentiary role: institutional-response.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "864d2903cccb9557cdc29a3e39f5c73eaaa8cc959c6948475423c0254a30b631",
"final_url": "https://www.ado.cz/2025/10/09/vyjadreni-olomouckeho-arcibiskupstvi-k-rozsudku-nad-dieceznim-knezem/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.novinky.cz/clanek/krimi-za-sexualni-utok-na-10-letou-divku-ve-zpovednici-potvrdil-soud-knezi-podminku-40568526",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: conviction-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b22954595a6adc428b500fc9eee384503e47232e03592ed9f04027e61ff65ab5",
"final_url": "https://www.novinky.cz/clanek/krimi-za-sexualni-utok-na-10-letou-divku-ve-zpovednici-potvrdil-soud-knezi-podminku-40568526"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 1194,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Minor complainants, not identified. Indonesian-language sourcing, read in the original. Defendant's exact age reported inconsistently across outlets (60 vs 68); left out of the summary rather than guessed.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-secondary-source",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-lamongan-east-java-indonesia-tpq",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Deket, Lamongan, East Java, Indonesia",
"lat": -7.0797,
"lng": 112.2999,
"title": "Indonesia: Quran-school teacher sentenced to six years for abusing three students",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"TPQ (Taman Pendidikan Al-Qur'an) teacher and caretaker"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious instructional authority over children boarded at his Quran-education institution"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"guru-teacher-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"organizations": [
"Pondok TPQ, Deket, Lamongan"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Pengadilan Negeri Lamongan (Lamongan District Court), Indonesia",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2024-07-18",
"outcome": "A teacher (initials R, elderly) at a Taman Pendidikan Al-Qur'an (Quran study center/boarding house) in Deket, Lamongan, was convicted of sexually abusing three minor students in his care and sentenced to six years' imprisonment. The court cited the victims' fear and trauma as an aggravating factor and the defendant's age, courtroom demeanor, and a settlement reached with the victims' parents as mitigating factors."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The complainants were minor students boarding at the TPQ where the defendant taught Quran recitation, under his direct religious instructional authority; the abuse came to light when one victim reported pain, leading two more children to come forward.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7126111/diduga-cabuli-3-anak-pengasuh-pondok-tpq-di-lamongan-ditangkap",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Diduga Cabuli 3 Anak, Pengasuh Pondok TPQ di Lamongan Ditangkap', detikJatim, 5 Jan. 2024.",
"body": "Reports the arrest of a TPQ caretaker in Deket, Lamongan, on suspicion of abusing three minor students; the case surfaced after one victim complained of pain and two more children then disclosed similar abuse.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "arrest-report"
},
{
"link": "https://radarlamongan.jawapos.com/persidangan/2284881195/cabuli-tiga-anak-guru-tpq-divonis-enam-tahun",
"archive": "",
"citation": "'Cabuli Tiga Anak, Guru TPQ Divonis Enam Tahun', Radar Lamongan (Jawa Pos Group), 18 Jul. 2024.",
"body": "Reports the Lamongan District Court's six-year sentence for the TPQ teacher, three years below the prosecution's original demand, citing victim trauma as an aggravating factor and the defendant's age, conduct, and a parental settlement as mitigating.",
"tier": "regional-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "verdict-and-sentencing-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7126111/diduga-cabuli-3-anak-pengasuh-pondok-tpq-di-lamongan-ditangkap",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "33b679e020e19f80562a14fce15c4c0971ca958ad9f30f2e493c2756627f9d4d",
"final_url": "https://www.detik.com/jatim/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-7126111/diduga-cabuli-3-anak-pengasuh-pondok-tpq-di-lamongan-ditangkap"
},
{
"source": "https://radarlamongan.jawapos.com/persidangan/2284881195/cabuli-tiga-anak-guru-tpq-divonis-enam-tahun",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: verdict-and-sentencing-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "55899448f7b62d9d0f93b54037294c306697c1feb68f0cf1242ecca995c424f8",
"final_url": "https://radarlamongan.jawapos.com/persidangan/2407190013/cabuli-tiga-anak-guru-tpq-divonis-enam-tahun"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9214,
"aliases": [
"Hu Wan-lin"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Promoted from the private ledger by the Sections A/B resolution lane. The nexus rests on claimed supernatural power rather than ordinary medical fraud: the prosecution charged unlicensed practice, but the evidence describes healing by transmitted qi without contact. The charging decision does not narrow the criterion, which tracks the mechanism of harm rather than the prosecutor’s selection of offence.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "primary-press-verified",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2000-hu-wanlin-five-flavors-qigong-deaths-china",
"title": "China: self-styled 'divine doctor' Hu Wanlin, claiming non-contact qi healing, convicted after treatments linked to about 150 deaths",
"place": "Shangqiu, Henan, China",
"year": 2000,
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "death",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"other-spiritual-authority"
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://en.people.cn/english/200101/16/print20010116_60559.html",
"citation": "\"Fake Qigong Master Sentenced\", People’s Daily (English edition), 16 January 2001.",
"tier": "state-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "press",
"body": "Reports the Xinmi City court conviction and fifteen-year sentence of Hu Wanlin for practising medicine without a licence, in connection with deaths among patients who received his preparations."
},
{
"link": "https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2014-11/20/content_18947214.htm",
"citation": "China Daily, report on Hu Wanlin, 20 November 2014.",
"tier": "state-newspaper-reporting",
"kind": "press",
"body": "Retrospective account of the case, the claimed healing method and the sentence imposed."
},
{
"link": "https://www.scmp.com/news/china-insider/article/1339577/divine-doctor-kills-patient-with-toxic-soup-after-years-in-jail",
"citation": "South China Morning Post, “Divine doctor kills patient with toxic soup after years in jail”.",
"tier": "international-newspaper-reporting",
"kind": "press",
"body": "Independent reporting on the claimed supernatural healing power and a further death after release."
}
],
"lat": 34.4145,
"lng": 115.65,
"spiritualNexus": "Hu Wanlin presented himself as a qigong master able to heal by transmitting qi without physical contact, claimed a ninety per cent cure rate, and diagnosed patients in examinations lasting seconds. It was that claim to supernatural healing power, promoted through a book titled Qigong Master, rather than any claim of medical competence, that induced roughly 150 people to accept his sodium-sulphate preparations. The court charged the lesser offence of practising medicine without a licence; the mechanism of harm was the claimed spiritual power. Claimed supernatural healing power was the mechanism of harm, not incidental to it. Victims submitted to and continued a fatal treatment because Hu asserted spiritual power beyond medicine (non-contact qi transmission, mystical diagnosis) rather than ordinary medical competence. This distinguishes the case from ordinary unlicensed practice or medical fraud. The court charged the lesser offence of unlicensed medical practice; the corpus assesses nexus on the mechanism of harm, not on the prosecutor's charging choice.",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-proclaimed qigong master and healer"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed supernatural healing power",
"claimed ninety per cent cure rate",
"published guru persona"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Xinmi City People’s Court, Henan, China",
"stage": "conviction and sentence",
"date": "2000-10-01",
"outcome": "Hu Wanlin was convicted of practising medicine without a licence and sentenced to fifteen years imprisonment in connection with deaths among patients who took his preparations."
}
],
"status": "convicted",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://en.people.cn/english/200101/16/print20010116_60559.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: press.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4d5fe5ec4405dc199b93d5398e39714a8e8afb8e8f2633c5be89d68fb36da30d",
"final_url": "http://en.people.cn/english/200101/16/print20010116_60559.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2014-11/20/content_18947214.htm",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: state-newspaper-reporting; evidentiary role: press.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "342962a7da107b016f02f97d4a4e10b3d78bf360e441ecc80dd77cbedddfe6bd",
"final_url": "https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2014-11/20/content_18947214.htm"
},
{
"source": "https://www.scmp.com/news/china-insider/article/1339577/divine-doctor-kills-patient-with-toxic-soup-after-years-in-jail",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-newspaper-reporting; evidentiary role: press.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9215,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sala Penal de la Corte Provincial de Justicia de Chimborazo",
"date": "2026-03-23",
"outcome": "Appeal denied; trial conviction and 29-year-4-month sentence ratified."
}
],
"scopeNote": "Distinct from 2026-curandero-medicine-sessions-cuenca-ecuador (Cuenca/Azuay, defendant Juan Ismael J., offense at Nueve de Octubre market, appellate ruling 2026-05-07) and 2017-curandero-healing-threat-gualaceo-ecuador (Gualaceo/Azuay, defendant José C., ruling 2017-01-18). Confirmed via primary Ecuadorian press covering the Chimborazo Provincial Court proceeding; no Fiscalía General del Estado release was located for this specific case at the time of review (the Fiscalía release matching this search pattern concerns the Cuenca case only).",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2023-nestor-curandero-san-luis-riobamba-chimborazo-ecuador",
"year": 2023,
"place": "San Luis, Riobamba, Chimborazo, Ecuador",
"lat": -1.6635,
"lng": -78.6547,
"title": "Chimborazo curandero convicted of raping a 15-year-old during a claimed healing ritual; appeal denied",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"curandero, self-described traditional healer operating premises in the San Luis sector of Riobamba"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"traditional-healing setting and treatment trust",
"isolation of the victim in a darkened room framed as necessary to the cure",
"claimed ritual/therapeutic pretext for requiring the victim to disrobe"
],
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tribunal de Garantías Penales de Chimborazo (trial); Sala Penal de la Corte Provincial de Justicia de Chimborazo (appeal)",
"stage": "convicted at trial; conviction and sentence ratified on appeal",
"date": "2023-12-19",
"outcome": "Néstor D. B., a self-described curandero operating in the San Luis sector of Riobamba, was convicted of raping a 15-year-old girl who had come to his premises with her family seeking a 'curación.' The offense occurred on the night of 26 April 2023: the defendant took the victim to a darkened room, told her to undress, and assaulted her, claiming this was necessary to heal her. He was sentenced to 29 years and 4 months' imprisonment. He appealed; the Chimborazo Provincial Court's Criminal Chamber denied the appeal and ratified the sentence in full (reported 23 March 2026)."
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The defendant used his claimed status as a traditional healer (curandero) and the pretext of a healing ritual to isolate a minor and obtain sexual access, telling her the assault was part of the cure — the same doctrinal-pretext mechanism (traditional healing/curanderismo authority) already documented in the corpus's Cuenca and Gualaceo curandero records, but arising from an entirely separate proceeding, defendant, and province.",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.primicias.ec/noticias/sucesos/condena-curandero-riobamba-violacion/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Primicias, 'Tribunal condena a un curandero a 29 años de cárcel por violación en Riobamba' (2023).",
"body": "Reports the trial court conviction, the 26 April 2023 offense date, the victim's age (15), the darkened-room/disrobe pretext, and the 29-year-4-month sentence.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "court-verdict-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ecuavisa.com/seguridad/chimborazo-sentencia-violacion-ratificada-chunchi-interpol-detenido-estados-unidos-20260323-0088.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ecuavisa, report on the Chimborazo Provincial Court's Criminal Chamber denying the appeal and ratifying the 29-year-4-month sentence (23 March 2026).",
"body": "Confirms the appellate denial and ratification of the original sentence against Néstor D. B.",
"tier": "national-newspaper-court-reporting",
"kind": "appellate-ruling-report"
}
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Sala Penal de la Corte Provincial de Justicia de Chimborazo",
"date": "2026-03-23",
"outcome": "Appeal denied; trial conviction and 29-year-4-month sentence ratified."
}
],
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.primicias.ec/noticias/sucesos/condena-curandero-riobamba-violacion/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: court-verdict-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2974b02a47bc5554b9459a231b0cdc23598cc84203e84c6fdf717718c38d80d1",
"final_url": "https://www.primicias.ec/noticias/sucesos/condena-curandero-riobamba-violacion/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ecuavisa.com/seguridad/chimborazo-sentencia-violacion-ratificada-chunchi-interpol-detenido-estados-unidos-20260323-0088.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-newspaper-court-reporting; evidentiary role: appellate-ruling-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9216,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Moroccan court reporting identifies the healer only by the name/alias 'Mossaab' used in press coverage. This entry concerns this individual's adjudicated conduct, not Islam, Quranic recitation, Morocco, ruqya, or healers generally. Distinct from the corpus's existing Rabat, Berkane and Tangier raqi records -- different city, different defendant.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2019-casablanca-raqi-mossaab-morocco",
"year": 2019,
"place": "Casablanca, Morocco",
"lat": 33.5731,
"lng": -7.5898,
"title": "Casablanca raqi 'Mossaab': seven-year sentence for sexual assault during a claimed Quranic-healing session",
"tradition": "islam",
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented raqi (Quranic healer) known by the name 'Mossaab' operating a healing center"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"ruqya and Quranic-recitation healing-session claims",
"access to a client seeking treatment",
"inducing unconsciousness during the session",
"operation of a dedicated healing center used to isolate the victim"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Criminal Court (Chambre Correctionnelle) of Casablanca, Morocco",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"outcome": "The court convicted the defendant, known as 'Mossaab,' of sexually assaulting a client during a claimed Quranic-healing (ruqya) session after she lost consciousness, and sentenced him to seven years' imprisonment plus 80,000 Moroccan dirhams in compensation to the civil plaintiff. Police had earlier raided and sealed his healing center, seizing recording equipment."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.telemaroc.tv/jt/11456",
"archive": "",
"citation": "TeleMaroc, '7 سنوات لراق اغتصب احدى زبوناته' (contemporaneous court report; Arabic).",
"body": "Contemporaneous court reporting records the Casablanca Criminal Court's seven-year sentence, the 80,000 MAD compensation order, the ruqya-session pretext, and the loss-of-consciousness allegation.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-report"
},
{
"link": "https://kafapress.ma/85500.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Kafapress, coverage of the Casablanca Court of Appeal proceeding against the raqi 'Mossaab' (Arabic).",
"body": "Independent Moroccan outlet corroborates the defendant's alias, the healing-center raid, and the sexual-assault conviction.",
"tier": "local-court-reporting",
"kind": "judgment-corroboration"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies ruqya and Quranic-recitation healing claims, access to a client seeking treatment, and the operation of a dedicated healing center as the material spiritual authority, practice, and pretext connected to the documented sexual assault. The relevant authority role is self-presented raqi.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.telemaroc.tv/jt/11456",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "58319e73c50d8628aca1c7c370585cd1f8603e6f8080ab41e029c799463b2636",
"final_url": "https://www.telemaroc.tv/jt/11456"
},
{
"source": "https://kafapress.ma/85500.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: local-court-reporting; evidentiary role: judgment-corroboration.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "aabb8728468c511a628a2a00236a654069945417f1c11ebb21f06f22706c8dbd",
"final_url": "https://kafapress.ma/85500.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9217,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns this individual's adjudicated conduct as a self-presented Catholic lay spiritual guide (guía espiritual) delivering an unofficial formation course, not the Catholic Church, spiritual direction, or religious educators generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2018-jose-manuel-aguilar-garcia-aguascalientes-mexico",
"year": 2018,
"place": "Jesús María, Aguascalientes, Mexico",
"lat": 21.9611,
"lng": -102.3428,
"title": "Mexico: self-styled Catholic spiritual guide sentenced to 87 years for raping minors recruited through a formation course",
"tradition": "christian",
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"type": "child-abuse",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-presented Catholic 'guía espiritual' (spiritual guide) delivering formation courses within a Catholic organization"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"position as spiritual-guide instructor within a Catholic formation program",
"recruitment of minors under 18 enrolled in the course",
"deception used to lure victims to isolated locations",
"coercion of victims into reciprocal acts"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Mixed Court of First Instance, Fifth Judicial District, Jesús María, Aguascalientes, Mexico",
"stage": "criminal judgment and sentence",
"outcome": "The court sentenced José Manuel Aguilar García, 78, to 87 years in prison and a 67,593-peso fine for rape, sexual abuse and indecent assault against eight minors he recruited between 2006 and 2007 while delivering Catholic spiritual-guide formation courses. After the victims filed complaints, he relocated to Querétaro and worked as a theology professor until his arrest there in May 2014."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.fiscalia-aguascalientes.gob.mx/noticia/170/87-a%C3%B1os-de-c%C3%A1rcel-para-gu%C3%ADa-espiritual",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Fiscalía General del Estado de Aguascalientes, official notice, '87 años de cárcel para guía espiritual.'",
"body": "Official state-prosecutor release confirming the sentence, court, fine, and the spiritual-guide formation-course recruitment mechanism.",
"tier": "prosecutor-release",
"kind": "official-sentencing-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2018/7/16/guia-espiritual-es-sentenciado-87-anos-de-prision-por-violacion-abuso-sexual-en-aguascalientes-208749.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Proceso, '\"Guía espiritual\" es sentenciado a 87 años de prisión por violación y abuso sexual en Aguascalientes' (16 Jul 2018).",
"body": "Independent national-magazine corroboration of the sentence, the eight minor victims, the flight to Querétaro, and the 2014 arrest.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "press-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The cited record identifies the defendant's self-presented role as a Catholic spiritual-guide (guía espiritual) instructor, the Catholic formation-course setting used to recruit minors, and the trust attached to that spiritual-formation role as the material authority and pretext connected to the documented rapes. The relevant authority role is self-presented Catholic spiritual guide.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"guru-teacher-authority"
],
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.fiscalia-aguascalientes.gob.mx/noticia/170/87-a%C3%B1os-de-c%C3%A1rcel-para-gu%C3%ADa-espiritual",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: prosecutor-release; evidentiary role: official-sentencing-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "0bc9eaed2ce00862c25d63677787120ccd206cb1e58722076b812c428cd233e5",
"final_url": "https://www.fiscalia-aguascalientes.gob.mx/noticia/170/87-a%C3%B1os-de-c%C3%A1rcel-para-gu%C3%ADa-espiritual"
},
{
"source": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2018/7/16/guia-espiritual-es-sentenciado-87-anos-de-prision-por-violacion-abuso-sexual-en-aguascalientes-208749.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: press-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4b20eb315fb6ec47e566e67d2b273d0018ef0bcece1bbea074df8b4e2f767340",
"final_url": "https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/estados/2018/7/16/guia-espiritual-es-sentenciado-87-anos-de-prision-por-violacion-abuso-sexual-en-aguascalientes-208708.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9215,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns Kamoltep Chaisri's (Ajarn Suea Ban Fon) adjudicated/charged conduct toward his stepdaughter under claimed curse-removal ritual authority; not a general statement about sak yant tattooing or Thai spirit-medium practice.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-ajarn-suea-ban-fon-chiang-mai-thailand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Chiang Mai, Thailand",
"lat": 18.7883,
"lng": 98.9853,
"title": "Ajarn Suea Ban Fon: Chiang Mai sorcerer arrested for coercing stepdaughter under curse-removal ritual pretext",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled sorcerer, fortune-teller and ritual tattooist (sak yant)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed curse (bad-luck) affecting the victim",
"gold-leaf and incantation ritual staged as necessary treatment",
"firearm threats",
"threats to kill victim and her mother if disclosed"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Hang Dong Police Station, Chiang Mai, Thailand",
"stage": "arrest and charge",
"date": "2026-05-26",
"outcome": "Police arrested Kamoltep Chaisri, 43, known as Ajarn Suea Ban Fon, on rape charges after his stepdaughter's mother filed a complaint alleging he coerced the 18-year-old (from around January 2024) into sex approximately five times under the pretext that intercourse was required to remove a curse, using a gold-leaf ritual and threatening her with a firearm. Police seized six registered handguns, an unlicensed air rifle, ammunition and methamphetamine pills from his residence. He denied the allegations."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2935450",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thairath, 'บุกรวบ \"อาจารย์เสือ บ้านฟ่อน\" จอมขมังเวทคนดัง ลวงลูกเลี้ยงเข้าม่านรูด บังคับข่มขืน' (May 26, 2026).",
"body": "Thai-language original report of the arrest, allegations, and evidence seized at Ajarn Suea's residence.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
},
{
"link": "https://en.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2935450",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thairath English, 'Arrest of Ajarn Suea Ban Fon, Famous Sorcerer, for Forcing Stepdaughter into Prostitution and Rape' (2026).",
"body": "English translation confirming arrest, charge, and ritual pretext details.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The accused used his standing as a sorcerer performing curse-removal rituals (sadeaw karma) and sak yant practice to construct a pretext — a claimed curse requiring ritual sexual contact — through which he is alleged to have coerced his stepdaughter.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Police arrested Kamoltep Chaisri, 43, known as Ajarn Suea Ban Fon, on rape charges after his stepdaughter's mother filed a complaint alleging he coerced the 18-year-old (from around January 2024) into sex approximately five times under the pretext that intercourse was required to remove a curse, using a gold-leaf ritual and threatening her with a firearm. Police seized six registered handguns, an unlicensed air rifle, ammunition and methamphetamine pills from his residence. He denied the allegations.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2935450",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "2d48b36ecffe277cc3b88f26bdf07df76ba87dff3136005bb7b69199fb1138d0",
"final_url": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2935450"
},
{
"source": "https://en.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2935450",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "22d9cfc86c755653e52784d1ed2af30917aa655d275dcf2af3a8de50ebd8f673",
"final_url": "https://en.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2935450"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9216,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns a specific 2022 raqi's charged conduct in Berrechid; not a claim about ruqya practice generally in Morocco.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-berrechid-raqi-morocco",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Berrechid, Morocco",
"lat": 33.2655,
"lng": -7.5878,
"title": "Berrechid raqi jailed pending trial for raping woman who sought spiritual healing",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"raqi (Islamic spiritual healer)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual/healing authority",
"position of trust during ruqya sessions"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Berrechid public prosecutor / investigating judge, Settat Court of Appeal jurisdiction, Morocco",
"stage": "pretrial detention ordered",
"outcome": "A raqi (spiritual healer) in Berrechid was arrested in 2022 on charges of raping a 22-year-old woman, resulting in her pregnancy, along with adultery and drug-trafficking charges. The investigating judge ordered his detention in a rural prison pending further interrogation."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://journal24.ma/%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%AA%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82%D9%8A-%D8%AE%D8%AF%D8%B1-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A9-%D9%88%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%85-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%BA%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%87%D8%A7-%D9%85%D8%AA/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Journal24.ma, 'اعتقال راقي خدر شابة وقام باغتصابها متسببا في حملها' (Berrechid raqi arrest report, 2022).",
"body": "Arabic-language report of the arrest, rape and pregnancy allegation, and pretrial detention order.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The accused held the position of raqi (Islamic ruqya spiritual healer) and is alleged to have used the trust of a healing session to commit the rape.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"curse-witchcraft"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A raqi (spiritual healer) in Berrechid was arrested in 2022 on charges of raping a 22-year-old woman, resulting in her pregnancy, along with adultery and drug-trafficking charges. The investigating judge ordered his detention in a rural prison pending further interrogation.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://journal24.ma/%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%AA%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82%D9%8A-%D8%AE%D8%AF%D8%B1-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A9-%D9%88%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%85-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%BA%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%87%D8%A7-%D9%85%D8%AA/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "583c6e2144c566c7d89eb8be54cd2082d88f5d08e057f0dba301a2bd635f19dd",
"final_url": "https://journal24.ma/%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%AA%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82%D9%8A-%D8%AE%D8%AF%D8%B1-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A9-%D9%88%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%85-%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%BA%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%87%D8%A7-%D9%85%D8%AA/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9217,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns Phra Teeradech's (Theeradej Kachornsuk) documented arrest warrant and network prosecution at Wat San Pa Sak; not a claim about Thai Buddhist monasticism generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2016-phra-teeradech-chiang-mai-thailand",
"year": 2016,
"place": "Chiang Mai, Thailand",
"lat": 18.7883,
"lng": 98.9853,
"title": "Former Chiang Mai abbot Phra Teeradech: arrest warrant in network abusing boys at northern-Thailand temples",
"tradition": "buddhism",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"abbot, Wat San Pa Sak, Chiang Mai"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"monastic/clerical authority over boys at the temple",
"network recruitment using promises of money and support"
],
"organizations": [
"Wat San Pa Sak"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Chiang Mai Provincial Court, Thailand",
"stage": "arrest warrant issued",
"date": "2016-10-05",
"outcome": "Chiang Mai Provincial Court issued an arrest warrant for Phra Kru Silathada Theeradej Kachornsuk (also referenced as Phra Teeradech), then aged about 50, former abbot of Wat San Pa Sak, on charges of committing indecent acts against children under 15. He was named as part of a network of abbots at well-known northern-Thailand temples accused of luring boys with money then sexually exploiting them; eight victims, around age 14, had filed complaints with a child-protection center in November 2013 describing abuse occurring in mid-2013."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.khaosod.co.th/breaking-news/news_2700683",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Khaosod, 'จับคากุฏิ! อดีตเจ้าอาวาสวัดดังเชียงใหม่ ร่วมขบวนการพระ ลวงตุ๋ย 8 เด็กชาย' (Chiang Mai abbot-network abuse arrest report).",
"body": "Thai-language report detailing the network of abbots, the eight boy victims, and the arrest of the former Wat San Pa Sak abbot.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.matichon.co.th/region/news_4319483",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Matichon, 'ฉาวอีก! จับสึกเจ้าอาวาส วัดดังเชียงใหม่ ล่วงละเมิดเด็กไทใหญ่-สามเณร คากุฏิ นานหลายปี' (related Chiang Mai temple abuse coverage).",
"body": "Additional Thai-language coverage of Chiang Mai temple sexual-abuse network arrests context.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The accused held the office of Buddhist abbot at Wat San Pa Sak and is alleged to have used that clerical authority, together with a network of fellow abbots, to recruit and abuse boys at the temple.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "dharmic-buddhist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Chiang Mai Provincial Court issued an arrest warrant for Phra Kru Silathada Theeradej Kachornsuk (also referenced as Phra Teeradech), then aged about 50, former abbot of Wat San Pa Sak, on charges of committing indecent acts against children under 15. He was named as part of a network of abbots at well-known northern-Thailand temples accused of luring boys with money then sexually exploiting them; eight victims, around age 14, had filed complaints with a child-protection center in November 2013 describing abuse occurring in mid-2013.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.khaosod.co.th/breaking-news/news_2700683",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6308a164597efc1712d9979ddd21db06533f0ca648efe79fe7ee552a7a76a1c5",
"final_url": "https://www.khaosod.co.th/breaking-news/news_2700683"
},
{
"source": "https://www.matichon.co.th/region/news_4319483",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "12f83e8050a712258379bcfc3fe7e5fbd112712f7cc8413216c0a4bc895a05eb",
"final_url": "https://www.matichon.co.th/region/news_4319483"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9218,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns the specific fatal ruqya incident in Guelma and the prosecutor-announced arrest; not a claim about ruqya practice generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-primary-source",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-guelma-fatal-ruqya-algeria",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Guelma, Algeria",
"lat": 36.4611,
"lng": 7.4258,
"title": "Guelma: prosecutor announces arrest after 10-year-old girl dies during ruqya session",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "physical-abuse",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"ruqya practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed exorcism/healing authority",
"physical restraint/violence framed as ritual treatment"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Guelma public prosecutor's office, Algeria",
"stage": "arrest announced, investigation opened",
"outcome": "A 10-year-old girl in Guelma died after being subjected to physical abuse during a ruqya (Islamic healing/exorcism) session; the Guelma public prosecutor announced the arrest of the practitioner responsible."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.hespress.com/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Aggregated Arabic-language press reporting on the Guelma fatal-ruqya case and prosecutor's arrest announcement (search-result summary; primary article URL not yet isolated).",
"body": "Confirms death of a 10-year-old girl during a ruqya session in Guelma and the prosecutor's announcement of the practitioner's arrest.",
"tier": "press-aggregate-needs-primary",
"kind": "arrest-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The child died during a ruqya session conducted by the accused practitioner under claimed religious-healing authority.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"exorcism-deliverance"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A 10-year-old girl in Guelma died after being subjected to physical abuse during a ruqya (Islamic healing/exorcism) session; the Guelma public prosecutor announced the arrest of the practitioner responsible.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-20",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.hespress.com/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: press-aggregate-needs-primary; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "c6a048e1a301d4a679325c349d1f698400e2f96ade87aa69ae8a6ed988c84352",
"final_url": "https://www.hespress.com/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9219,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns the specific Sharqia/Zagazig 'jinn extraction' rape prosecution; not a claim about spiritual healing generally in Egypt.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-primary-source",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2022-hihya-sharqia-jinn-extraction-egypt",
"year": 2022,
"place": "Hihya, Sharqia, Egypt",
"lat": 30.6667,
"lng": 31.5833,
"title": "Sharqia 'jinn extraction' healer referred to trial for assaulting four women",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled spiritual healer claiming jinn-extraction ability"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed ability to extract jinn (possessing spirits)",
"recorded video used to threaten and blackmail victims"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Zagazig Criminal Court, Sharqia, Egypt",
"stage": "referred for prosecution",
"outcome": "A man and an accomplice in Hihya, Sharqia governorate, were accused of assaulting four women (2021-2022) after claiming ability to extract jinn the women were said to be possessed by; some victims became pregnant, and the accused threatened to expose them via recorded video. The case was referred to Zagazig Criminal Court for prosecution."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.mesr24.com/19692",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Masr24, 'حكاية \"دجال الشرقية\" اعتدى جنسيًا على 4 سيدات وينتظر حبل المشنقة' (Sharqia jinn-extraction assault case report).",
"body": "Arabic-language report detailing the jinn-extraction pretext, four victims, pregnancies, blackmail, and referral to the Zagazig Criminal Court.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "prosecution-referral-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The accused claimed a spiritual/exorcistic ability to extract jinn possessing the victims and used that claimed authority as the pretext for the assaults.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"exorcism-deliverance",
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A man and an accomplice in Hihya, Sharqia governorate, were accused of assaulting four women (2021-2022) after claiming ability to extract jinn the women were said to be possessed by; some victims became pregnant, and the accused threatened to expose them via recorded video. The case was referred to Zagazig Criminal Court for prosecution.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.mesr24.com/19692",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: prosecution-referral-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "af60f55675ef8685f2489081276df016d0b70a972686d8f217a699332b5b58e7",
"final_url": "https://www.mesr24.com/19692"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9220,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns the criminal proceedings against shaman Jose Manuel Pineda for the death of Kyle Nolan at the Shimbre Shamanic Center; not a claim about ayahuasca ceremonial practice generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-primary-source",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2012-kyle-nolan-ayahuasca-peru",
"year": 2012,
"place": "Near Pucallpa, Peru",
"lat": -8.3791,
"lng": -74.5539,
"title": "Kyle Nolan: American teen dies at ayahuasca retreat; shaman convicted of homicide and concealment",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "death",
"status": "conviction",
"recordClass": "core",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"authorityRoles": [
"ayahuasca-ceremony shaman, Shimbre Shamanic Center"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed shamanic authority over dosage and ceremonial safety",
"concealment of the death from the victim's family and authorities"
],
"organizations": [
"Shimbre Shamanic Center"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Peru (criminal courts, Ucayali region)",
"stage": "criminal conviction and sentence",
"outcome": "Kyle Josef Nolan, 18, of Sebastopol, California, died in late August 2012 during an ayahuasca ceremony at the Shimbre Shamanic Center in Peru. The retreat's shaman, Jose Manuel Pineda, concealed the death from Nolan's mother and buried the body before eventually confessing to police. Peruvian authorities convicted Pineda of homicide and of lying to authorities, sentencing him to five years in prison."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.cnn.com/2014/10/24/justice/ayahuasca-death-kyle-nolan-mother/index.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CNN, 'Teen's quest for Amazon \"medicine\" ends in tragedy' (Oct. 24, 2014).",
"body": "Reports the death, the shaman's concealment and burial of the body, arrest, and eventual conviction and five-year sentence for homicide and lying to authorities.",
"tier": "international-press",
"kind": "investigative-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/sebastopol-dad-says-sons-hallucinogen-death-in-peru-was-murder/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "CBS San Francisco, 'Sebastopol Dad Says Son's Hallucinogen Death In Peru Was Murder'.",
"body": "Additional coverage of the family's response and case background.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "follow-up-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The shaman held ceremonial authority over the ayahuasca ritual in which Nolan died, and used that position of trust to conceal the death rather than seek help.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"ritual-initiation"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.cnn.com/2014/10/24/justice/ayahuasca-death-kyle-nolan-mother/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-press; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "df01bc3b1b64d3abd8904d3460d085ac211a7a068562f66c430dd1d0c6cd9ec3",
"final_url": "https://www.cnn.com/2014/10/24/justice/ayahuasca-death-kyle-nolan-mother/index.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/sebastopol-dad-says-sons-hallucinogen-death-in-peru-was-murder/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: follow-up-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3fa8cb815cb82e549f73630bdfe9f6062890c15f7bb7e6fa965b2b0c05192dfe",
"final_url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/sebastopol-dad-says-sons-hallucinogen-death-in-peru-was-murder/"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9221,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns a specific self-styled TikTok ruqya-expert's charged conduct against a grieving victim; not a claim about ruqya or TikTok spiritual content generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-primary-source",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-mahdia-tiktok-raqi-tunisia",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Mahdia, Tunisia",
"lat": 35.5047,
"lng": 11.0622,
"title": "Tunisian TikTok 'healer' arrested for rape and blackmail of grieving victim",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-styled ruqya expert operating via TikTok"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed spiritual-healing expertise",
"psychological manipulation of a grieving victim",
"false promise of marriage",
"recorded footage used for blackmail"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tunisia (police investigation, Monastir/Mahdia area)",
"stage": "arrest, investigation opened",
"outcome": "A man presenting himself online as a ruqya (Islamic spiritual healing) expert was arrested after a university student in her 20s, grieving her father's death, reported that online sessions escalated to in-person meetings where he manipulated her psychologically, falsely promised marriage, and raped her, resulting in pregnancy; he filmed the encounters and used the footage to blackmail her. Investigators said the same tactics were used against multiple victims who were experiencing emotional distress."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://en.royanews.tv/news/59174/Tunisian-TikTok-%22healer%22-arrested-for-rape,-blackmail",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Roya News, 'Tunisian TikTok \"healer\" arrested for rape, blackmail' (2025).",
"body": "Reports the arrest, the ruqya-expert pretext, the grieving victim's account, the pregnancy, the blackmail via recorded footage, and the pattern of multiple victims.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The accused presented himself online as an expert in ruqya (Islamic spiritual healing) and used that claimed authority, combined with victims' grief and emotional vulnerability, to manipulate and assault them.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment",
"spiritual-consequence"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A man presenting himself online as a ruqya (Islamic spiritual healing) expert was arrested after a university student in her 20s, grieving her father's death, reported that online sessions escalated to in-person meetings where he manipulated her psychologically, falsely promised marriage, and raped her, resulting in pregnancy; he filmed the encounters and used the footage to blackmail her. Investigators said the same tactics were used against multiple victims who were experiencing emotional distress.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://en.royanews.tv/news/59174/Tunisian-TikTok-%22healer%22-arrested-for-rape,-blackmail",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "6231e0b8cb95d21d3f4b7db930ed3fdd18e99bd373158714e18a8cbdbe7f4707",
"final_url": "https://en.royanews.tv/news/59174/Tunisian-TikTok-%22healer%22-arrested-for-rape,-blackmail"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9222,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns the specific January 2026 Mohammedia death during a ruqya session and the raqi's detention for questioning; not a claim about ruqya practice generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-primary-source",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-mohammedia-ruqya-death-morocco",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Mohammedia, Morocco",
"lat": 33.6861,
"lng": -7.383,
"title": "Mohammedia: young man dies during ruqya session, raqi detained for questioning",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "death",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"raqi (Islamic ruqya practitioner)"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed healing authority over a medical condition (epilepsy) via ruqya"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Royal Gendarmerie / public prosecutor, Mohammedia, Morocco",
"stage": "detained for questioning, investigation opened",
"date": "2026-01-05",
"outcome": "A man in his thirties, who suffered from epilepsy, died in the Ben Yekhlef area of Mohammedia during a ruqya (Islamic religious healing) session at his family's home, after suffering a severe seizure that did not respond to emergency treatment. The Royal Gendarmerie detained the raqi and took him in for questioning under the supervision of the competent public prosecutor, and the body was sent for autopsy."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://maghrebtimes.ma/2026/01/07/%D9%88%D9%81%D8%A7%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8-%D8%AE%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%AD%D8%B5%D8%A9-%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%B1%D8%B9%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%AA%D8%B3%D8%AA%D9%86%D9%81%D8%B1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AF/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Maghreb Times, 'وفاة شاب خلال حصة رقية شرعية تستنفر الدرك الملكي بالمحمدية' (Jan. 7, 2026).",
"body": "Reports the death during the ruqya session and mobilization of the Royal Gendarmerie.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "death-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ariffino.net/%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%A9-%D9%88-%D9%85%D8%AC%D8%AA%D9%85%D8%B9/%D8%AC%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%A9-%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%AA%D9%86%D8%AA%D9%87%D9%8A-%D8%A8%D9%88%D9%81%D8%A7%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8-%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%AE%D9%84-%D9%85%D9%86%D8%B2%D9%84-%D8%A3%D8%B3%D8%B1",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Ariffino.net, 'جلسة رقية تنتهي بوفاة شاب داخل منزل أسرته بالمحمدية' (raqi detained for questioning confirmation).",
"body": "Confirms the raqi was detained and taken to the Royal Gendarmerie center for questioning in an official statement.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "follow-up-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim died during a ruqya healing session performed by the accused raqi under claimed religious-healing authority over his medical condition.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-ruqya-healing",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A man in his thirties, who suffered from epilepsy, died in the Ben Yekhlef area of Mohammedia during a ruqya (Islamic religious healing) session at his family's home, after suffering a severe seizure that did not respond to emergency treatment. The Royal Gendarmerie detained the raqi and took him in for questioning under the supervision of the competent public prosecutor, and the body was sent for autopsy.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://maghrebtimes.ma/2026/01/07/%D9%88%D9%81%D8%A7%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8-%D8%AE%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%AD%D8%B5%D8%A9-%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%B1%D8%B9%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%AA%D8%B3%D8%AA%D9%86%D9%81%D8%B1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AF/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: death-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "10da396fedf35850e18058fe1190786a3de9db138bbd17b402ba2e4b8f67f9c8",
"final_url": "https://maghrebtimes.ma/2026/01/07/%D9%88%D9%81%D8%A7%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8-%D8%AE%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%AD%D8%B5%D8%A9-%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%B1%D8%B9%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%AA%D8%B3%D8%AA%D9%86%D9%81%D8%B1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AF/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ariffino.net/%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%A9-%D9%88-%D9%85%D8%AC%D8%AA%D9%85%D8%B9/%D8%AC%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%A9-%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%AA%D9%86%D8%AA%D9%87%D9%8A-%D8%A8%D9%88%D9%81%D8%A7%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8-%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%AE%D9%84-%D9%85%D9%86%D8%B2%D9%84-%D8%A3%D8%B3%D8%B1",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: follow-up-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "982078ee1ec9ab77014c10455084990501bc9a9387eadaa22c5f082e710d776f",
"final_url": "https://www.ariffino.net/%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%A9-%D9%88-%D9%85%D8%AC%D8%AA%D9%85%D8%B9/%D8%AC%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%A9-%D8%B1%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%AA%D9%86%D8%AA%D9%87%D9%8A-%D8%A8%D9%88%D9%81%D8%A7%D8%A9-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%A8-%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%AE%D9%84-%D9%85%D9%86%D8%B2%D9%84-%D8%A3%D8%B3%D8%B1"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9223,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns Paisal Saenchai's charged conduct using a claimed past-life/karma-resolution pretext; not a claim about Thai fortune-telling generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-primary-source",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-paisal-sanchai-thailand",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Thailand",
"lat": 13.7563,
"lng": 100.5018,
"title": "Paisal Sanchai: 'karma-resolution' fortune teller arrested for rape and abduction of minors",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described past-life visionary and 'karma-resolution' (kae kam) practitioner"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed ability to perceive past lives and identify sources of victims' suffering",
"karma-cleansing ritual pretext",
"yearbook research used to fabricate convincing past-life narratives"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Thailand (Royal Thai Police, Crime Suppression Division)",
"stage": "arrest, charges filed",
"outcome": "Paisal Saenchai, 67, a well-known fortune teller claiming special spiritual abilities and past-life insight, was arrested on charges of rape and abduction of minors aged 15-18. Victims reported he lured them under the pretense of resolving their karma through ritual, then sexually assaulted them. Police seized approximately 198 items including school yearbooks that investigators found he used to fabricate plausible past-life details matching real names and addresses of victims and their families."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.thaipbs.or.th/news/content/506157",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thai PBS, 'ปิดฉาก \"ไพศาล\" นักแก้กรรม เปิดนิมิตพิศดาร ลวงอนาจาร \"เหยื่อ\"' (Paisal karma-resolution arrest and case closure report).",
"body": "Thai-language report on the arrest, the karma-resolution/past-life pretext, yearbook evidence, and charges.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster",
"kind": "arrest-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2934096",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Thairath, 'แถลงจับ \"อาจารย์ไพศาล\" อาจารย์แก้กรรม กระทำชำเราเหยื่อ คาดรู้ชื่อคนเยอะจากหนังสือรุ่น' (Paisal arrest press statement report).",
"body": "Confirms arrest, rape charges, and investigators' finding that yearbooks were used to identify and target victims.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "arrest-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The accused claimed visionary spiritual ability to perceive victims' past lives and the karmic sources of their suffering, and used karma-cleansing rituals as the pretext for the assaults.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"spiritual-consequence",
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Paisal Saenchai, 67, a well-known fortune teller claiming special spiritual abilities and past-life insight, was arrested on charges of rape and abduction of minors aged 15-18. Victims reported he lured them under the pretense of resolving their karma through ritual, then sexually assaulted them. Police seized approximately 198 items including school yearbooks that investigators found he used to fabricate plausible past-life details matching real names and addresses of victims and their families.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.thaipbs.or.th/news/content/506157",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "f78e5e4630c46ba4e0238c409eaf1ea7394eaffe3cfcf7d3c0b95e9e0b2044de",
"final_url": "https://www.thaipbs.or.th/news/content/506157"
},
{
"source": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2934096",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: arrest-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "813010ca0ff3f3b8a08cea77d1c07e64c178a2928f112141a959c6b5ac01b7b9",
"final_url": "https://www.thairath.co.th/news/crime/2934096"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9224,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns the specific Cabezas colony chemical-facilitated rape investigation opened Feb. 2024; part of a documented recurring pattern in Mennonite colonies (Manitoba 2019, Belice/Las Piedras 2022) but this record covers only the Cabezas, Bolivia investigation. Held as context rather than institutional-event: an ombudsman investigation was opened and two suspects jailed, but no institutional finding or verdict has been reached.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2024-cabezas-mennonite-colony-bolivia",
"year": 2024,
"place": "Cabezas, Santa Cruz, Bolivia",
"lat": -18.7833,
"lng": -63.2667,
"title": "Cabezas Mennonite colony: sedative-facilitated rape investigation opens after anonymous letter to child-protection office",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "sexual-abuse",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"male colony members exploiting the closed community's isolation and authority structures"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"chemical sedation (sleep-inducing spray) used to incapacitate victims",
"closed-colony isolation limiting victims' access to outside authorities"
],
"organizations": [
"Cabezas Mennonite colony"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Bolivian Ministerio Público, Santa Cruz department",
"stage": "investigation opened, two suspects jailed",
"date": "2024-02-02",
"outcome": "An anonymous letter to the Defensoria de la Ninez y Adolescencia of Cabezas, Santa Cruz, denouncing sexual assaults triggered a criminal investigation. One accused admitted that he and three other men used sedative sprays to incapacitate victims before raping them. Two suspects, Isaak M.P. (20) and Jacob D.W. (40), were jailed at Palmasola pending investigation on aggravated-rape charges; the Ministerio Publico said further victims and perpetrators are not ruled out. This is the third documented case of this pattern in Mennonite colonies, following Manitoba, Bolivia (2019, 151 victims) and the Belice/Las Piedras colonies (2022, at least 12 victims)."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/violacion-colonia-menonita-detenidos-sigue-investigacion/20240208000038936413.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Opinión (Bolivia), 'Violación en colonia menonita: hay dos detenidos y sigue investigación' (Feb. 8, 2024).",
"body": "Reports the anonymous complaint, the two detained suspects, the sedative-spray method, and the ongoing investigation.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "investigation-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/escena-del-crimen/terror-colonias-menonitas-siguen-violaciones-uso-spray-somnifero/20240218000020937319.html",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Opinión (Bolivia), 'El terror en las colonias menonitas: siguen las violaciones y el uso del spray somnífero' (Feb. 18, 2024).",
"body": "Places the Cabezas case in the context of the recurring sedative-spray rape pattern across Mennonite colonies in Bolivia.",
"tier": "national-press",
"kind": "investigative-followup"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The assaults occurred within a closed religious colony whose isolation from outside authority and internal social control structures are alleged to have facilitated the pattern of chemical-facilitated rape and delayed reporting.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"institutional-obedience",
"religious-marriage-family"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-mennonite-anabaptist",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "An anonymous letter to the Defensoria de la Ninez y Adolescencia of Cabezas, Santa Cruz, denouncing sexual assaults triggered a criminal investigation. One accused admitted that he and three other men used sedative sprays to incapacitate victims before raping them. Two suspects, Isaak M.P. (20) and Jacob D.W. (40), were jailed at Palmasola pending investigation on aggravated-rape charges; the Ministerio Publico said further victims and perpetrators are not ruled out. This is the third documented case of this pattern in Mennonite colonies, following Manitoba, Bolivia (2019, 151 victims) and the Belice/Las Piedras colonies (2022, at least 12 victims).",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/violacion-colonia-menonita-detenidos-sigue-investigacion/20240208000038936413.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: investigation-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d55870ce665ebb66b654422039f3b81ffc21188271df44865fad8cf4de59501b",
"final_url": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/policial/violacion-colonia-menonita-detenidos-sigue-investigacion/20240208000038936413.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/escena-del-crimen/terror-colonias-menonitas-siguen-violaciones-uso-spray-somnifero/20240218000020937319.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-press; evidentiary role: investigative-followup.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "20847d538ee8d1d4fb9dc94f6ed6d2e12d095e57469be9a18f8f13272c991662",
"final_url": "https://www.opinion.com.bo/articulo/escena-del-crimen/terror-colonias-menonitas-siguen-violaciones-uso-spray-somnifero/20240218000020937319.html"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9225,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns the specific July 2025 fatal 'baño de florecimiento' in Tambogrande, Piura; distinct from the 2023 Piura curandera conviction and the same-month Laguna Negra drowning, both separate incidents.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-piura-bano-florecimiento-death-peru",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Tambogrande, Piura, Peru",
"lat": -4.9564,
"lng": -80.3733,
"title": "Piura: woman dies of severe burns during 'blooming bath' ritual; healer flees",
"tradition": "spiritual-healing",
"type": "death",
"status": "investigation",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"curandera (traditional healer) performing 'baño de florecimiento'"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed healing authority over the victim's chronic leg pain"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Tambogrande police station / Peruvian prosecutors, Piura, Peru",
"stage": "preliminary investigation opened, suspect fugitive",
"date": "2025-07-07",
"outcome": "Marcelina Panta Zapata, 47, died after suffering third-degree burns over nearly her entire body during a 'baño de florecimiento' (blooming bath) ritual performed by healer Sandy Chozo in Tambogrande, Piura, which she had sought for chronic leg pain. Her family filed a police report; authorities opened a preliminary investigation for culpable homicide. Chozo fled and remained a fugitive as of the most recent reporting."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.infobae.com/peru/2025/07/09/mujer-muere-tras-bano-de-florecimiento-en-piura-sufrio-quemaduras-en-el-90-del-cuerpo-y-el-curandero-esta-profugo/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Infobae, 'Mujer muere tras baño de florecimiento en Piura: sufrió quemaduras en el 90% del cuerpo y el curandero está prófugo' (July 9, 2025).",
"body": "Reports the death, extent of burns, the healer's flight, and the opened investigation.",
"tier": "regional-press",
"kind": "death-report"
},
{
"link": "https://panamericana.pe/buenosdiasperu/nacionales/447830-mujer-pierde-vida-someterse-bano-florecimiento-piura",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Panamericana TV, 'Curandero implicado en muerte de mujer en Piura sigue prófugo'.",
"body": "Confirms the healer's continued fugitive status.",
"tier": "national-broadcaster",
"kind": "follow-up-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The victim died during a traditional ritual healing bath performed by the accused curandera under claimed spiritual/therapeutic authority over her medical complaint.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"healing-treatment"
],
"traditionDetailId": "healing-spiritual",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Marcelina Panta Zapata, 47, died after suffering third-degree burns over nearly her entire body during a 'baño de florecimiento' (blooming bath) ritual performed by healer Sandy Chozo in Tambogrande, Piura, which she had sought for chronic leg pain. Her family filed a police report; authorities opened a preliminary investigation for culpable homicide. Chozo fled and remained a fugitive as of the most recent reporting.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.infobae.com/peru/2025/07/09/mujer-muere-tras-bano-de-florecimiento-en-piura-sufrio-quemaduras-en-el-90-del-cuerpo-y-el-curandero-esta-profugo/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-press; evidentiary role: death-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9750586f68e442372d47581409506c5477ba838b8c95917e2d78c0b7f2789ef0",
"final_url": "https://www.infobae.com/peru/2025/07/09/mujer-muere-tras-bano-de-florecimiento-en-piura-sufrio-quemaduras-en-el-90-del-cuerpo-y-el-curandero-esta-profugo/"
},
{
"source": "https://panamericana.pe/buenosdiasperu/nacionales/447830-mujer-pierde-vida-someterse-bano-florecimiento-piura",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: national-broadcaster; evidentiary role: follow-up-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "fc03191d6b1a19b27a10c421fec8bc52194d69cb610807552371c304109fe5b0",
"final_url": "https://panamericana.pe/buenosdiasperu/nacionales/447830-mujer-pierde-vida-someterse-bano-florecimiento-piura"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9226,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Institutional-event record documenting the Sudanese government's own prosecutorial-reform pledge triggered by the BBC/ARIJ khalwa investigation; distinct from the two already-published individual khalwa-abuser conviction records (2020-gedaref-khalwa-imam-sudan; 2022-um-baru-khalwa-sheikh-sudan), which concern single perpetrators, not the systemic/aggregate finding. DOWNGRADED at ingest from official-finding to context: the finding rests on a BBC News Arabic / ARIJ undercover journalistic investigation, which this archive does not treat as an official evidence tier. It is retained as context because the investigation is substantial and prompted a government reform pledge, but no written government inquiry report has been located.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "needs-primary-source",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2020-sudan-khalwa-systemic-abuse-bbc-investigation",
"year": 2020,
"place": "Sudan (national)",
"lat": 12.8628,
"lng": 30.2176,
"title": "Sudan: BBC/ARIJ undercover investigation exposes systemic chaining, beating and sexual abuse in Quranic khalwas; government pledges prosecutions",
"tradition": "islam",
"type": "institutional-abuse",
"status": "official-finding",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "active-investigation",
"authorityRoles": [
"sheikhs operating khalwa Quranic schools across Sudan"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed Quranic-instruction authority",
"chaining and shackling of children for failure to memorize the Qur'an accurately",
"beating and starvation as discipline"
],
"organizations": [
"Sudan Ministry of Religious Affairs and Endowments"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Government of Sudan, Ministry of Religious Affairs (response to BBC News Arabic/Arab Reporters for Investigative Journalism investigation)",
"stage": "official-finding / government reform pledge",
"date": "2020-10-20",
"outcome": "A BBC News Arabic/ARIJ undercover investigation, filmed secretly across 23 khalwas over 18 months by reporter Fateh Al-Rahman Al-Hamdani (himself a former khalwa student), documented children as young as five being routinely chained, shackled, beaten and starved by sheikhs across Sudan's more than 30,000 khalwas, alongside evidence of sexual abuse by those running the schools and by older students. Following broadcast, Sudan's Minister for Religious Affairs, Nasreddine Mufreh, publicly pledged there would be no more beating, torture or rights violations in khalwas and said the government would prosecute the schools filmed by the BBC. A December 2020 BBC follow-up found implementation had been slow."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/sudan-widespread-abuse-islamic-schools-khalwa",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Middle East Eye, 'Sudan's religious schools accused of routinely abusing students'.",
"body": "Reports the BBC/ARIJ investigation's findings of chaining, beating, starvation and sexual abuse across Sudanese khalwas.",
"tier": "international-press",
"kind": "investigative-report"
},
{
"link": "https://gijn.org/stories/undercover-in-the-sudanese-schools-that-chain-boys/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Global Investigative Journalism Network, 'Undercover in the Sudanese Schools That Chain Boys'.",
"body": "Details the 18-month undercover methodology and the government's public response pledging prosecutions.",
"tier": "trade-press",
"kind": "methodology-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "The abuse was carried out by sheikhs under their claimed religious authority as Quranic instructors, using children's obligation to memorize the Qur'an as the pretext for chaining and beating.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"pastoral-clerical-authority",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "islam-quranic-school",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "A BBC News Arabic/ARIJ undercover investigation, filmed secretly across 23 khalwas over 18 months by reporter Fateh Al-Rahman Al-Hamdani (himself a former khalwa student), documented children as young as five being routinely chained, shackled, beaten and starved by sheikhs across Sudan's more than 30,000 khalwas, alongside evidence of sexual abuse by those running the schools and by older students. Following broadcast, Sudan's Minister for Religious Affairs, Nasreddine Mufreh, publicly pledged there would be no more beating, torture or rights violations in khalwas and said the government would prosecute the schools filmed by the BBC. A December 2020 BBC follow-up found implementation had been slow.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/sudan-widespread-abuse-islamic-schools-khalwa",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: international-press; evidentiary role: investigative-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9cbf13fc04c76fd7cb88296db230845d76cc7939e289ffc117c5ca2c5caaba0d",
"final_url": "https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/sudan-widespread-abuse-islamic-schools-khalwa"
},
{
"source": "https://gijn.org/stories/undercover-in-the-sudanese-schools-that-chain-boys/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: trade-press; evidentiary role: methodology-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9227,
"aliases": [],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns the formal Argentine criminal charges against Opus Dei's South American auxiliary vicar and other leaders for trafficking/labor exploitation of numerary assistants; not a claim about Opus Dei membership or Catholic religious life generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2025-argentina-opus-dei-trafficking",
"year": 2025,
"place": "Argentina",
"lat": -34.6037,
"lng": -58.3816,
"title": "Argentina: Opus Dei auxiliary vicar and leaders charged with trafficking and labor exploitation of 43 women",
"tradition": "christian",
"type": "trafficking",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"Opus Dei auxiliary vicar and regional leadership, South America"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"religious vocation framing of unpaid domestic labor",
"recruitment via promises of education and training",
"strict internal control over 'numerary assistants'"
],
"organizations": [
"Opus Dei"
],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "Argentine federal prosecutors",
"stage": "charges filed",
"date": "2025-07-06",
"outcome": "Argentine federal prosecutors charged Opus Dei's auxiliary vicar for South America, Monsignor Mariano Fazio, along with other leaders, with human trafficking and labor exploitation of at least 43-44 women recruited between 1983 and 2015 as 'numerary assistants.' Prosecutors allege the women were recruited with promises of education and training, then forced into unpaid, roughly 12-hour domestic-labor workdays under strict organizational control. Opus Dei has published a formal denial characterizing the allegations as taking the women's freely chosen vocation and formation out of context."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2025/07/06/auxiliary-vicar-of-opus-dei-charged-with-human-trafficking-and-labor-exploitation/",
"archive": "",
"citation": "Catholic World Report, 'Auxiliary vicar of Opus Dei charged with human trafficking and labor exploitation' (July 6, 2025).",
"body": "Reports the formal charges against Msgr. Mariano Fazio and other Opus Dei leaders.",
"tier": "trade-press",
"kind": "charge-report"
},
{
"link": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/argentine-prosecutors-accuse-opus-dei-leaders-south-america-trafficking-and-labor-exploitation",
"archive": "",
"citation": "National Catholic Reporter, 'Argentine prosecutors accuse Opus Dei leaders in South America of trafficking and labor exploitation'.",
"body": "Details the 43-44 alleged victims, the 1983-2015 timeframe, and the trafficking/exploitation theory of the case.",
"tier": "trade-press",
"kind": "charge-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Opus Dei leadership is alleged to have used the religious framing of vocation and formation to recruit and control numerary assistants in conditions of unpaid domestic servitude.",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"religious-marriage-family",
"institutional-obedience"
],
"traditionDetailId": "christian-catholic",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Argentine federal prosecutors charged Opus Dei's auxiliary vicar for South America, Monsignor Mariano Fazio, along with other leaders, with human trafficking and labor exploitation of at least 43-44 women recruited between 1983 and 2015 as 'numerary assistants.' Prosecutors allege the women were recruited with promises of education and training, then forced into unpaid, roughly 12-hour domestic-labor workdays under strict organizational control. Opus Dei has published a formal denial characterizing the allegations as taking the women's freely chosen vocation and formation out of context.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2025/07/06/auxiliary-vicar-of-opus-dei-charged-with-human-trafficking-and-labor-exploitation/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: trade-press; evidentiary role: charge-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "527066f70d585e65d271f99920f3eb90a2c371fc0b7c874a243c95eb432abb6f",
"final_url": "https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2025/07/06/auxiliary-vicar-of-opus-dei-charged-with-human-trafficking-and-labor-exploitation/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/argentine-prosecutors-accuse-opus-dei-leaders-south-america-trafficking-and-labor-exploitation",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: trade-press; evidentiary role: charge-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4aa5705c27d330cca86ae159700a098f5c67007af5b8d8b8ba9819017cd907ed",
"final_url": "https://www.ncronline.org/news/argentine-prosecutors-accuse-opus-dei-leaders-south-america-trafficking-and-labor-exploitation"
}
]
},
{
"additionIndex": 9228,
"aliases": [
"Jolene Travis"
],
"organizationIds": [],
"clusterIds": [],
"appellateHistory": [],
"scopeNote": "Concerns the specific federal wire/mail-fraud indictment of Bridgette Evans and Vinnie Uwanawich for a curse-cleansing psychic-fraud scheme; not a claim about psychic or spiritual-consultant services generally.",
"sourceAuditStatus": "source-of-record",
"legacyRecord": false,
"slug": "2026-evans-uwanawich-psychic-fraud-washington",
"year": 2026,
"place": "Frisco, Texas / Seattle-area, Washington, USA",
"lat": 33.1507,
"lng": -96.8236,
"title": "Texas couple federally indicted for $2.5M 'curse cleansing' psychic-fraud scheme targeting grieving victims",
"tradition": "new-age",
"type": "fraud",
"status": "charges",
"recordClass": "context",
"evidenceStatus": "charged",
"authorityRoles": [
"self-described psychic ('Jolene Travis')"
],
"coercionMechanisms": [
"claimed psychic ability to diagnose a curse on the victim's money/possessions",
"instruction to liquidate assets and surrender cash/gold for 'cleansing'"
],
"organizations": [],
"proceedings": [
{
"jurisdiction": "U.S. District Court, Western District of Washington",
"stage": "federal indictment",
"outcome": "Bridgette Doreen Evans, using the name Jolene Travis, and her partner Vinnie John Uwanawich, of Frisco, Texas, were indicted on conspiracy to commit wire and mail fraud plus multiple counts of wire and mail fraud, for stealing at least $2.5 million from at least three victims between April 2021 and July 2024. Evans advertised psychic services on social media targeting people experiencing divorce, bereavement or isolation, telling them their money was cursed and the only remedy was to liquidate holdings and surrender gold coins or cash for her to 'cleanse.' Uwanawich managed bank accounts receiving the funds, sold the gold coins, and vouched for Evans with victims. Both made an initial federal court appearance in June 2026 in the Eastern District of Texas; each fraud/conspiracy count carries up to 20 years."
}
],
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdwa/pr/texas-couple-indicted-psychic-fraud-scheme-allegedly-stealing-millions-vulnerable",
"archive": "",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, Western District of Washington, 'Texas couple indicted for psychic fraud scheme allegedly stealing millions from vulnerable people' (2026).",
"body": "Official DOJ press release detailing the indictment, the curse-cleansing scheme, and the charges.",
"tier": "official-government-release",
"kind": "indictment-press-release"
},
{
"link": "https://www.king5.com/article/news/local/king-county-victim-sent-2-million-attempt-to-remove-alleged-curse-fortune-teller-fraud/281-e3923db0-cc8e-4757-b986-c83c393c056d",
"archive": "",
"citation": "KING 5 News, 'King County victim sent $2 million in attempt to remove alleged curse in fortune teller fraud, DOJ says'.",
"body": "Details a specific King County, Washington victim who sent over $2 million.",
"tier": "regional-broadcaster",
"kind": "follow-up-report"
}
],
"spiritualNexus": "Evans presented herself as a psychic able to diagnose a curse afflicting victims' money, and used that claimed spiritual authority to induce them to surrender their assets for 'cleansing.'",
"pretextCategoryIds": [
"curse-witchcraft",
"prosperity-divination"
],
"traditionDetailId": "nrm-new-age",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": "Bridgette Doreen Evans, using the name Jolene Travis, and her partner Vinnie John Uwanawich, of Frisco, Texas, were indicted on conspiracy to commit wire and mail fraud plus multiple counts of wire and mail fraud, for stealing at least $2.5 million from at least three victims between April 2021 and July 2024. Evans advertised psychic services on social media targeting people experiencing divorce, bereavement or isolation, telling them their money was cursed and the only remedy was to liquidate holdings and surrender gold coins or cash for her to 'cleanse.' Uwanawich managed bank accounts receiving the funds, sold the gold coins, and vouched for Evans with victims. Both made an initial federal court appearance in June 2026 in the Eastern District of Texas; each fraud/conspiracy count carries up to 20 years.",
"disposition_last_checked": "2026-07-27",
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdwa/pr/texas-couple-indicted-psychic-fraud-scheme-allegedly-stealing-millions-vulnerable",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: official-government-release; evidentiary role: indictment-press-release.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "b00a632f8371f6a3f5b37c409cf97ef39ca152fe73e8a57308a57e9d2ff6ba25",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdwa/pr/texas-couple-indicted-psychic-fraud-scheme-allegedly-stealing-millions-vulnerable"
},
{
"source": "https://www.king5.com/article/news/local/king-county-victim-sent-2-million-attempt-to-remove-alleged-curse-fortune-teller-fraud/281-e3923db0-cc8e-4757-b986-c83c393c056d",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Corpus classification: regional-broadcaster; evidentiary role: follow-up-report.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
}
],
"historicalCases": [
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/07/26/the-german-experiment-that-placed-foster-children-with-pedophiles",
"citation": "The New Yorker, “The German Experiment That Placed Foster Children with Pedophiles” (July 26, 2021).",
"body": "The report synthesizes the Berlin-commissioned findings and surviving records. The dossier is classified as historical context, outside the modern core map."
}
],
"slug": "kentler-experiment-west-berlin",
"year": 1969,
"title": "The Kentler experiment: foster placements with known pedophiles in West Berlin",
"place": "Berlin, Germany",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"tradition": "context",
"summary": "Berlin-commissioned research documented a decades-long public-welfare failure in which vulnerable boys were placed with known pedophiles. Its relationship to spiritual-abuse history is contextual and concerns ideology, authority, and institutional legitimization rather than religion.",
"lng": 13.405,
"lat": 52.52,
"coordinateProvenance": "Gazetteer point for the place named in this record (\"Berlin, Germany\"). The record's own stated location; no location inferred beyond it.",
"status": "Official finding",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/07/26/the-german-experiment-that-placed-foster-children-with-pedophiles",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "9efdd80432da92203fc14f7197e4ba70788c0d15bc82aecc84de6cd6bfbaa0fd",
"final_url": "https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/07/26/the-german-experiment-that-placed-foster-children-with-pedophiles"
}
]
},
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "http://www.rogermwilcox.com/Reich/index.html",
"citation": "Roger M. Wilcox, Reich research index.",
"body": "This collection is used as a lead index. Its summaries are not treated as adjudicated findings without the underlying record."
}
],
"slug": "reich-orgonomy-child-programs",
"year": 1940,
"title": "Wilhelm Reich, orgonomy, and child-focused experimental programs",
"place": "United States",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"tradition": "context",
"summary": "Historical research dossier separating federal litigation over orgone devices from claims about Reich’s child-focused programs. Publication requires source-level corroboration for each harm claim.",
"status": "Official finding",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "http://www.rogermwilcox.com/Reich/index.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "19d42d4bdbfff91b4255c117cfaca89090e4a811d20dfe78bb193801b2404033",
"final_url": "http://www.rogermwilcox.com/Reich/index.html"
}
]
},
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/CPRT-96HPRT44542O",
"citation": "U.S. House Committee on Foreign Affairs, The Assassination of Representative Leo J. Ryan and the Jonestown, Guyana Tragedy (May 15, 1979).",
"body": "The congressional staff investigation reconstructs Representative Ryan's inquiry, the Port Kaituma attack and the Jonestown deaths and reviews the official response and warning record."
},
{
"link": "https://www.fbi.gov/history/cases-and-criminals/jonestown",
"citation": "Federal Bureau of Investigation, 'Jonestown.'",
"body": "The FBI history records reports of beatings, forced labor, imprisonment, drug-based control and rehearsed mass suicide; it describes the airstrip murders, the deaths of more than 900 people including more than 200 children, and Larry Layton's later federal conviction."
},
{
"link": "https://jonestown.sdsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/GuyanaInquest.pdf",
"citation": "Coroner's Inquest into the Jonestown deaths, Guyana (Dec. 1978), archival reproduction.",
"body": "The reproduced official inquest record contains survivor and official testimony. The jury returned a verdict that 910 people were murdered by Jim Jones while separately classifying the deaths of named inner-circle members."
}
],
"slug": "jonestown-peoples-temple-guyana",
"year": 1978,
"title": "Jonestown and Peoples Temple: coercive control, official investigations and mass deaths",
"place": "North West District, Guyana",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"tradition": "nrm",
"summary": "Official and archival records document forced labor, beatings, confinement, drug-based control, rehearsals for collective death, the murder of Representative Leo Ryan and more than 900 deaths. A Guyanese coroner's jury classified 910 deaths as murders attributed to Jim Jones. The dossier preserves the distinction between those findings and the separately recorded suicides of named inner-circle members rather than describing every death as voluntary.",
"lng": -59.9667,
"lat": 7.65,
"coordinateProvenance": "Gazetteer point for the place named in this record (\"North West District, Guyana\"). The record's own stated location; no location inferred beyond it.",
"status": "Official finding",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/CPRT-96HPRT44542O",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "52fe37555cd3f19bf7ed34537841ddb67f0c11d14ae29a8cb3dc83b5613610c3",
"final_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/CPRT-96HPRT44542O"
},
{
"source": "https://www.fbi.gov/history/cases-and-criminals/jonestown",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "69c790e46892ee705bb3fedc883d367eeacf904c516046da9538578c6b1db225",
"final_url": "https://www.fbi.gov/history/cases-and-criminals/jonestown"
},
{
"source": "https://jonestown.sdsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/GuyanaInquest.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "96d371ab96fecdd6062750985c738850cf514c9fa04f83b610362ff6ed9f94d2",
"final_url": "https://jonestown.sdsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/GuyanaInquest.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/61/102.html",
"citation": "People v. Manson, 61 Cal. App. 3d 102 (Cal. Ct. App. 1976).",
"body": "The appellate opinion affirms Manson's Tate-LaBianca convictions and documents his unquestioned authority, followers' belief that he was a 'God man' or Christ, the apocalyptic prophecy used to motivate the conspiracy, and evidence of sexual coercion admitted to establish his control."
},
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/71/1.html",
"citation": "People v. Manson, 71 Cal. App. 3d 1 (Cal. Ct. App. 1977).",
"body": "The second appellate opinion affirms Manson's life sentences for the Hinman and Shea murders and conspiracy, identifies him as the Family's leader and finds overwhelming evidence supporting the Hinman murder verdict."
}
],
"slug": "charles-manson-family-california",
"year": 1969,
"title": "Charles Manson and the Family: convictions tied to apocalyptic authority and coercive control",
"place": "Los Angeles County, California, USA",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"tradition": "nrm",
"summary": "California appellate opinions affirm Manson's murder and conspiracy convictions and document his near-total authority over the Family. The court record describes followers who regarded him as a divine or Christ figure, an apocalyptic Helter Skelter prophecy used as the conspiracy's motive, sexual coercion used to demonstrate control, and orders that culminated in killings. No relationship to Solar Lodge O.T.O. or other occult organizations is inferred.",
"lng": -118.2437,
"lat": 34.0522,
"coordinateProvenance": "Gazetteer point for the place named in this record (\"Los Angeles County, California, USA\"). The record's own stated location; no location inferred beyond it.",
"status": "Conviction",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/61/102.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
},
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/3d/71/1.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.sdsheriff.gov/bureaus/media-relations/common-questions/heaven-s-gate-case",
"citation": "San Diego County Sheriff's Office, 'Heaven's Gate Case.'",
"body": "The investigating agency records the discovery of 39 members in Rancho Santa Fe and its determination that all participated in a mass suicide over several days."
}
],
"slug": "heavens-gate-rancho-santa-fe",
"year": 1997,
"title": "Heaven's Gate: official investigation determines 39 members participated in collective suicide",
"place": "Rancho Santa Fe, California, USA",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"tradition": "nrm",
"summary": "The San Diego County Sheriff's Office determined that all 39 members found dead in March 1997 participated in a mass suicide over several days. The deaths were inseparable from Heaven's Gate's departure belief, but the official record cited here does not establish homicide, physical compulsion or a criminal finding against Marshall Applewhite. The dossier therefore records belief-directed collective death without converting group membership into proof of coercion.",
"lng": -117.2028,
"lat": 33.0203,
"coordinateProvenance": "Gazetteer point for the place named in this record (\"Rancho Santa Fe, California, USA\"). The record's own stated location; no location inferred beyond it.",
"status": "Official finding",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.sdsheriff.gov/bureaus/media-relations/common-questions/heaven-s-gate-case",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.rsi.ch/info/svizzera/Trent%E2%80%99anni-fa-la-tragedia-dell%E2%80%99Ordine-del-Tempio-Solare--2268745.html",
"citation": "Radiotelevisione svizzera, 'Trent'anni fa la tragedia dell'Ordine del Tempio Solare' (Oct. 5, 2024).",
"body": "The Swiss public broadcaster's retrospective, drawing on the official investigation, records the 48 Swiss deaths, identifies Jouret and Di Mambro as spiritual leaders, and states that 20 of the 23 people at Cheiry were killed by gunfire."
},
{
"link": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/ita/ordine-del-tempio-solare-il-dramma-di-20-anni-fa/40807902",
"citation": "SWI swissinfo.ch / Keystone-ATS, 'Ordine del tempio solare: il dramma di 20 anni fa' (Sept. 30, 2014).",
"body": "The Swiss public-service report records 74 deaths in Switzerland, Canada and France and states that investigations were closed without prosecution after the alleged instigators were found dead."
},
{
"link": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/fre/vivre-vieillir/michel-tabachnik-relax%C3%A9-en-appel/1053324",
"citation": "SWI swissinfo.ch, 'Michel Tabachnik relaxé en appel' (Dec. 20, 2006).",
"body": "The report records Tabachnik's acquittal by the Grenoble Court of Appeal after an earlier trial acquittal. It states that the appellate court found proof of his responsibility for the deaths was lacking."
}
],
"slug": "order-solar-temple-murders-suicides",
"year": 1994,
"title": "Order of the Solar Temple: investigations distinguish murders, suicides and an acquitted defendant",
"place": "Switzerland, Canada and France",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"summary": "Seventy-four deaths occurred in linked episodes from 1994 through 1997. Swiss reporting based on the investigations records that 20 of the 23 people at Cheiry were shot, while other deaths involved poisoning, fire or suicide; the principal instigators, Joseph Di Mambro and Luc Jouret, were among the dead. Michel Tabachnik was acquitted at trial and again on appeal because proof of responsibility was lacking. This dossier does not treat every death as voluntary or transfer culpability to an acquitted person, survivors, esoteric orders generally or modern Templar groups.",
"status": "Official finding",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.rsi.ch/info/svizzera/Trent%E2%80%99anni-fa-la-tragedia-dell%E2%80%99Ordine-del-Tempio-Solare--2268745.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "bd5a6b7251e07ce0b335e9a267b32c59884d3b79c800419f50695fa311bd5ffc",
"final_url": "https://www.rsi.ch/info/svizzera/Trent%E2%80%99anni-fa-la-tragedia-dell%E2%80%99Ordine-del-Tempio-Solare--2268745.html"
},
{
"source": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/ita/ordine-del-tempio-solare-il-dramma-di-20-anni-fa/40807902",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "4149964337a4ac46a5dbba15f1f21ae95fa2bf203bd1ac0d6a4d8ff95eca5852",
"final_url": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/ita/ordine-del-tempio-solare-il-dramma-di-20-anni-fa/40807902"
},
{
"source": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/fre/vivre-vieillir/michel-tabachnik-relax%C3%A9-en-appel/1053324",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "1c0cb0ee830ba41dc7ae8d8e9c3151590a45e804194f177d1df9d132df95dc53",
"final_url": "https://www.swissinfo.ch/fre/demographie/michel-tabachnik-relax%c3%a9-en-appel/1053324"
}
]
},
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/publications/waco/report-deputy-attorney-general-events-waco-texas-child-abuse",
"citation": "U.S. Department of Justice, Report to the Deputy Attorney General on the Events at Waco, Texas: Child Abuse (1993).",
"body": "The Justice Department report says historical evidence suggested long-running physical and sexual abuse by Koresh but was insufficient for indictment or conviction, and it expressly finds no direct evidence of abuse during the standoff."
},
{
"link": "https://www.congress.gov/104/crpt/hrpt749/CRPT-104hrpt749.pdf",
"citation": "U.S. House of Representatives, Investigation into the Activities of Federal Law Enforcement Agencies Toward the Branch Davidians, H. Rept. 104-749 (1996).",
"body": "The congressional report records the warrants, raid, negotiations, fire, autopsy findings and later convictions. Its majority and dissenting sections disagree on important questions of government responsibility, which this dossier does not collapse into a single uncontested account."
}
],
"slug": "branch-davidians-waco-official-record",
"year": 1993,
"title": "Branch Davidians at Waco: official findings on authority, abuse evidence, siege and deaths",
"place": "Mount Carmel, near Waco, Texas, USA",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "official-finding",
"tradition": "christian",
"summary": "The Justice Department found historical evidence suggesting that David Koresh used religious authority in physical and sexual abuse before the 1993 standoff, while stressing that the evidence did not meet indictment or conviction standards and that no direct evidence established abuse during the siege. Congressional findings documented the fatal fire, close-range gunshot deaths inside the compound, criminal convictions of surviving Branch Davidians and serious federal planning failures. This dossier preserves the disputes within the official record rather than using the deaths to validate every allegation against Koresh or every defense of federal conduct.",
"lng": -96.9861,
"lat": 31.5993,
"coordinateProvenance": "Gazetteer point for the place named in this record (\"Mount Carmel, near Waco, Texas, USA\"). The record's own stated location; no location inferred beyond it.",
"status": "Official finding",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/publications/waco/report-deputy-attorney-general-events-waco-texas-child-abuse",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3c3443acb86fd462b3cd58a84292a013a9b6ecd2be1ca0364f9e06d1a5e4937b",
"final_url": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/publications/waco/report-deputy-attorney-general-events-waco-texas-child-abuse"
},
{
"source": "https://www.congress.gov/104/crpt/hrpt749/CRPT-104hrpt749.pdf",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "3aa1081d520c4038fe72e8418ab537b48f2a457fdef4164a7a8cf943cb0045d8",
"final_url": "https://www.congress.gov/104/crpt/hrpt749/CRPT-104hrpt749.pdf"
}
]
},
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/518/512/2128591/",
"citation": "Velle Transcendental Research Association v. Sanders, 518 F. Supp. 512 (C.D. Cal. 1981).",
"body": "The federal opinion recounts the Boy in the Box incident and resulting dispositions: four felony child-abuse convictions, three misdemeanor convictions, Jean Brayton's no-contest plea to felony child abuse, three years of probation and a $500 fine. It also identifies Velle as the corporate name used by principal members of the group described as Solar Lodge."
}
],
"slug": "solar-lodge-oto-boy-in-box",
"year": 1969,
"title": "Solar Lodge (OTO standing contested): child-abuse convictions and Jean Brayton's no-contest plea",
"place": "Vidal and Blythe, California, USA",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"tradition": "western-occult",
"summary": "A later federal opinion records that a six-year-old child was chained in a packing crate as punishment at Solar Lodge's desert ranch, that four members received felony child-abuse convictions and three received misdemeanor convictions, and that group leader Jean Brayton later pleaded no contest to felony child abuse and received probation and a fine. The same opinion describes claims that Manson may have visited the group only as allegations in a disputed book; no Manson-Solar Lodge relationship is entered in this corpus.",
"lng": -114.5602,
"lat": 34.1786,
"coordinateProvenance": "Gazetteer point for the place named in this record (\"Vidal and Blythe, California, USA\"). The record's own stated location; no location inferred beyond it.",
"scopeNote": "SUPERSEDED DUPLICATE. This record and 1969-solar-lodge-boy-in-the-box-blythe-california-usa document the same 1969 event from the same single source, the federal opinion in Velle Transcendental Research Ass'n v. Sanders, 518 F. Supp. 512 (C.D. Cal. 1981). The other record is the record of reference: it pins precisely what the opinion supports and declines the widely circulated 56-day confinement claim. This entry is retained rather than deleted so the duplication is visible rather than silently removed, and because its summary carries the corpus's refusal of the alleged Manson connection. ON THE GROUP'S RELATIONSHIP TO THE ORDO TEMPLI ORIENTIS, WHICH THIS CORPUS DOES NOT RESOLVE: Solar Lodge's standing is contested and was never adjudicated. Phyllis Seckler, an Agape Lodge initiate, stated that Solar Lodge \"was an O.T.O. Lodge\". Against that, Ray Burlingame, who initiated Georgina \"Jean\" Brayton in 1962, held no charter to found lodges or initiate; a participant account states the group had no written charter from any Grand Master; Karl Germer had closed Agape Lodge in 1953 and never recognised Solar Lodge; and Grady McMurtry, reviving the OTO in 1969, could have recognised its initiations retroactively and did not. The claim of standing therefore rests on participant recollection rather than any institutional or judicial finding, and this record asserts neither regularity nor irregularity. The distinction is not merely historical: if the leaders' authority was chartered, the initiatory mechanism over members was materially stronger than if the group was self-constituted.",
"status": "Conviction",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp/518/512/2128591/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-27",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "failed",
"content_sha256": null,
"final_url": null
}
]
},
{
"publicationStatus": "published",
"sources": [
{
"link": "https://maryboro.ca/story/cult-leader-roch-theriault-on-trial/",
"citation": "Maryboro Lodge Museum / Kawartha Virtual Museum, 'Cult Leader Roch Theriault on Trial' (archival excerpts from the Lindsay Daily Post, 1989-1993).",
"body": "The local museum reproduces contemporaneous court reports recording the guilty pleas, the twelve-year assault sentence, the later second-degree-murder plea and life sentence, and Thériault's authority as the commune's self-styled 'Moses.'"
},
{
"link": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1989-10-12-mn-328-story.html",
"citation": "Reuters / Los Angeles Times, 'Canadian Cult's Leader Sentenced in Maiming Case' (Oct. 12, 1989).",
"body": "Contemporaneous international reporting records Thériault's and three followers' guilty pleas to assault charges and his twelve-year sentence."
},
{
"link": "https://globalnews.ca/news/219182/man-gets-25-years-for-killing-cult-leader-roch-theriault-in-prison-fight/",
"citation": "The Canadian Press / Global News, 'Man gets 25 years for killing cult leader Roch Theriault in prison fight' (Mar. 5, 2012).",
"body": "The Canadian Press retrospective records that Thériault was serving a life sentence imposed in 1993 for the murder of a commune member."
}
],
"slug": "roch-theriault-ant-hill-kids",
"year": 1993,
"title": "Roch Thériault and the Ant Hill Kids: murder and aggravated-assault convictions",
"place": "Burnt River and Coboconk, Ontario, Canada",
"recordClass": "historical",
"evidenceStatus": "convicted",
"tradition": "nrm",
"summary": "Contemporaneous court reporting records Roch Thériault's 1989 guilty pleas to aggravated assault and unlawfully causing bodily harm, a twelve-year sentence, and his 1993 guilty plea to second-degree murder with a life sentence. The Ant Hill Kids were an isolated apocalyptic commune in which Thériault styled himself as 'Moses' and exercised religious and communal authority. This dossier avoids unnecessary graphic detail, distinguishes the separately convicted followers, and does not attribute the group's conduct to the Seventh-day Adventist Church or apocalyptic Christianity generally.",
"lng": -78.9333,
"lat": 44.65,
"coordinateProvenance": "Gazetteer point for the place named in this record (\"Burnt River and Coboconk, Ontario, Canada\"). The record's own stated location; no location inferred beyond it.",
"status": "Conviction",
"acquittals": null,
"appellate_history": null,
"non_admission": null,
"favorable_findings": null,
"subject_response": null,
"disposition_status": null,
"disposition_last_checked": null,
"figure_status": "unknown",
"provenance": [
{
"source": "https://maryboro.ca/story/cult-leader-roch-theriault-on-trial/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "67b1f4042890c3fde4e4304af76ea0ef453e7384e8bde2309cf344f08fc27264",
"final_url": "https://maryboro.ca/story/cult-leader-roch-theriault-on-trial/"
},
{
"source": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1989-10-12-mn-328-story.html",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "252e6ad869223462c91f418229ee2f0b696a084993402b1c5631a29c2a2be588",
"final_url": "https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1989-10-12-mn-328-story.html"
},
{
"source": "https://globalnews.ca/news/219182/man-gets-25-years-for-killing-cult-leader-roch-theriault-in-prison-fight/",
"accessed_date": "2026-07-20",
"verifier": "Bound by Fear automated source-preservation ledger",
"tier_basis": "Legacy citation preserved without a normalized source tier or evidentiary-role code.",
"verification_scope": "retrieval-and-integrity",
"retrieval_status": "saved",
"content_sha256": "d6ab94aad7bfe7f61f78299c35d094577c84a5316da415f76bbc535fa62bbb64",
"final_url": "https://globalnews.ca/news/219182/man-gets-25-years-for-killing-cult-leader-roch-theriault-in-prison-fight/"
}
]
}
]
}